podcasts / Newscast / episode
Newscast cover art
podcast
📅 2026-11-13 ⏱ 39 min episode · ~2 min read 📝 Transcript · 8,281 words

The Week: Welfare Plans and EU Deals

Newscast · · Transcript & summary by WhipScribe

A week of Newscast covering a possible welfare overhaul for under-25s, a Brexit reset and the US midterms, with reporters close to each story.

In this episodeAlan MilburnKeir StarmerAndy BurnhamStuart InghamGary O'DonoghueDonald TrumpJ.D. VanceMarco RubioUrsula von der LeyenDame Meg HillierThe TimesJackdaw gas field

▸Chapters

Tap a chapter to open that moment in the transcript; the link to it is copied for you.

Transcribe your links. Paste a YouTube, Google Drive or podcast link and WhipScribe gives you the transcript. Transcribe a link →

▸Notable quotes

“I believe there is a good deal to be done that could be a win-win for Britain and Europe.” Andy Burnham · at 35:02 — open in the transcript →
“the whole thing happened in the blink of an eye” Chris Mason · at 5:55 — open in the transcript →

▸What this episode covers

Alan Milburn's review into young people not in education, employment or training is the week's main story, and early interviews suggest a sharp break for under-25s. The Times reported that the health element of Universal Credit and PIP would be replaced with an additional cost allowance for that age group, while people with profound disabilities who cannot work would get a higher-level benefit. The hosts say Labour MPs sound calmer than during the earlier rebellion against Keir Starmer, largely because the plan is being briefed in advance with job and mental health support attached, though the meaning of 'profound' remains open.

Abroad, Andy Burnham attended the European political community summit in Dublin and pressed for mini deals with Brussels next week, which he says could look more like the Brexit voters expected in 2016. The hosts warned that openly floating rejoining could weaken his bargaining position, since Brussels might stop offering bespoke arrangements. On climate, the government approved the Jackdaw gas field while the Rosebank decision is still pending, so the Prime Minister's brief COP31 appearance in Turkey has to be read against that record.

In the US, Gary O'Donoghue reported that Democrats' Texas Senate win followed Hispanic voters turning against Republicans over immigration enforcement, while rural voters angry about fuel prices stayed home. The hosts noted that more than $570 million was spent on advertising for one seat and that Donald Trump has been surprisingly muted in defeat.

▸The Week: Welfare Plans and EU Deals on Newscast: the answers

What did Gary O'Donoghue say about Donald Trump?

Gary O'Donoghue, reporting from Washington, said Donald Trump's standing with Hispanic voters in the Rio Grande Valley split in two. They backed his border security but turned against the detention and deportation drive, which pulled in relatives and people who were not criminals. He argued that this, and rural anger over petrol and diesel prices, helped drive the Democrats' midterm wins in Texas.

“So they like border security. So they love Trump for that.”Gary O'Donoghue · 22:46

What did Chris Mason say about Keir Starmer?

Chris Mason said Keir Starmer's earlier attempt at cutting young people's benefits came together so quickly that many Labour MPs saw it as crude cost-cutting. That is why Alan Milburn's review is being previewed in advance this time, to avoid a similar Labour revolt.

“the whole thing happened in the blink of an eye”Chris Mason · 5:55

What did Andy Burnham say about European Union?

Andy Burnham said Britain and the EU were both putting requests on the table for a new set of mini deals, which he believes could be win-win. He argued the outcome could be closer to the Brexit people voted for in 2016 than the harder one that arrived in 2019. The deals were due to be discussed at an EU summit in Brussels the following week.

“I believe there is a good deal to be done that could be a win-win for Britain and Europe.”Andy Burnham · 35:02

What did Newscast say about Alan Milburn's welfare review for under-25s?

The Newscast hosts said Alan Milburn's review, previewed in The Times, would replace the health element of Universal Credit and PIP for under-25s with an additional cost allowance, and that the change would also affect existing claimants. The report was due to be handed to government the following Tuesday, with the government expected to respond the same day.

Mentioned in this episode

Episode facts

Released
November 13, 2026
Length
39 minutes

▸Key takeaways

01Alan Milburn's welfare review would strip the health element of Universal Credit and PIP from under-25s, including existing claimants.
02Under Alan Milburn's plan in Britain, under-25s would get an additional cost allowance, while those who cannot work get a higher-level benefit.
03The Conservatives' youth welfare plan, unveiled weeks earlier, targets about £36 billion of savings from the welfare bill.
04Labour MPs revolted against Keir Starmer's first attempt at these cuts, so Milburn's plan is being briefed in advance to avoid a repeat.
05Andy Burnham says a win-win deal at next week's Brussels EU summit could look closer to the Brexit voters expected in 2016.

▸Questions this episode answers

Q1What did Alan Milburn say about under-25s and welfare benefits?

In interviews with The Times previewing his review, Alan Milburn indicated that under-25s would no longer receive the health element of Universal Credit or PIP. Instead they would get an additional cost allowance for day-to-day costs. People with profound disabilities who cannot work would get a new higher-level benefit. The Newscast hosts said the change would also apply to existing claimants, so some young people would lose benefits they currently receive.

Q2What did Andy Burnham say about EU deals and a better Brexit?

Andy Burnham said at the European political community summit in Dublin that a good deal with the EU could be a win-win for Britain and Europe. He argued it could look closer to the Brexit people voted for in 2016 than the harder one that took effect at the end of 2019. The hosts noted his position had shifted from wanting to rejoin in his lifetime to treating rejoining as only one option.

Q3What did Gary O'Donoghue say about Democrats winning Texas in the midterms?

Gary O'Donoghue, reporting from Washington, said Democrats' Texas Senate win came after Donald Trump lost ground with Hispanic voters in the Rio Grande Valley, who disliked the enforcement of detentions and deportations. Rural Republicans angry about petrol and diesel prices also stayed home or voted Democrat. He said advertising alone for that one Senate race cost more than $570 million, about four and a half times the total spend on the UK general election.

Q4Why did Labour MPs rebel against Keir Starmer's welfare cuts?

Chris Mason said many Labour MPs felt Keir Starmer's first attempt at these welfare changes looked like crude cost-cutting rather than a moral mission to get young people into work. That rebellion was hugely damaging to Starmer. This time, Alan Milburn's plan is being previewed in interviews and comes with extra support, so Labour MPs are less hostile. Dame Meg Hillier, one of the ringleaders last time, is now on side, though some opposition remains on the left of the party.

Q5How much would the Conservatives' youth welfare plan save from the welfare bill?

The hosts said the Conservatives' newly unveiled youth welfare policy, announced a few weeks before this episode, aims to save in the region of £36 billion from the welfare bill. It includes a lower rate of welfare for under-25s, sending young people to the job centre to learn interview skills, and a back-to-work card that can only be spent on certain things after a period out of work.

Q6What did Gary O'Donoghue say about Donald Trump's reaction to the midterms?

Gary O'Donoghue said Donald Trump has been less of a sore loser than expected after the midterms. Before the vote there had been talk of lawyers, federal monitors and the Insurrection Act, but little happened because elections are run by the states. Trump said he could work with Democrats, then later blamed voting machines. O'Donoghue said Republicans in Congress showed little appetite to fight the result, and that Trump is governing largely by executive order.

▸Transcript

Our own transcript of the public episode, with a timestamp about every 90 seconds. Tap a timestamp or the link button on a paragraph to copy a link that opens this page there.

0:00This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK. from a dedicated advisor. That's full-service wealth management. Mix, match, and change your mind whenever you want. Because at Schwab, you can invest your way. No matter your goals or appetite for investing, Schwab has everything you need all in one place. Visit schwab.com to learn more. GLP-1s are changing weight loss. My sister had amazing... The ideal treatment is... Seems like everyone's a GLP-1 expert these days. But when it comes to your health, it pays to listen to someone who actually is. Orderly Meds makes it easy to get started with personalized support along the way. And with your first month's order, we're giving you the second month free.

0:55Visit orderlymeds.com. Bringing orders to the chaos of GLP-1s. Individual results may vary. Eligibility and prescription required. Not medical advice. Visit orderlymeds.com for details. Compounded medications are not FDA approved. Chris is here. Hello. Alex is here. Hi. And Gary O'Donoghue has joined us from Washington, D.C. Hello, Gary. Hello. We've had a message from Catherine who says, Hi, Newscast. Enjoying a cultural visit to London today, I was lucky enough to see Chris Mason near College Green in Westminster and I gave him a thumbs up to declare my loyalty as a newscaster. I enjoyed our little conversation. Yes. Catherine commends you for your cheery smile. And then she says, Laura Kay once read out

1:38one of my questions on newscasts, so I'm halfway towards my collection of the original Brexit cast team. I shall wait patiently to get Adam and Katja. Oh, well, I'm always waiting for people to come up and ask me questions, especially about Brexit. You need to hang out on College Green a bit more. Yeah, exactly. Catherine, what's taking you so long? What I loved about the conversation with Catherine, as I always do when newscasters say hello, is not only did she stop and say, I like listening to newscasts, she described herself as a newscaster. So using that kind of, you know, the word that we always use. A proper stand. Yeah, and those listening. So it's great. I was on the train the other day

2:12and the guard working on the train was a big newscast fan. Oh. Yeah, mentioned it. And he downloads it every week to watch. Fantastic. There you go. Good. Well, let's give newscast listeners and newscasters and newscast stans such a terrible phrase. More things to talk about by recording a new episode of Newscast that they can mention when they see us in any format or location. Newscast. Newscast from the BBC. Humanity's next great voyage begins. I don't know the Prime Minister is, mate, do you? I'm Andy and I'm not looking my best right now. I see that he was, I guess, the mayor of a town. Ooh la la. Thinking about it like a panto helped. And what will you do? Stare at a wall. Do we play music now or what do we do?

2:54Hello, it's Adam in the Newscast studio. And it's Chris in the studio. And it's Alex also in the studio. And I'm delighted to be here. It's Gary. Gary, thank you for joining us from Washington DC. You've come a long way. Is it a totally different city now in the wake of the midterms? Oh, deep, deep blue, obviously, as the whole country seems to be. Even Mississippi, even Mississippi, which hasn't elected a Democrat for goodness knows how long, I don't know, 100 years or something, it's going blue. So one Senate seat to go and they could have a 56-44 majority in the Senate, which hasn't been heard of for years. And we'll discuss some more American politics in a second. But Alex, the big thing me and Chris were discussing on today's episode of Newscast, the podcast, was Alan Milburn's interview he gave to The Times previewing his big report into what to do about the NEETs, young people not in employment, education or training.

3:43What was your take on what Alan Milburn's got planned? So a couple of things. First thing is, aren't they managing this carefully? Because we knew and have known that this has been coming for some time and everyone's been talking about what will or won't be in the Milburn review. And when the government's asked about welfare, all young people, it points to this Milburn review. And now even before the review's being published properly, we are getting very carefully planned interviews where Alan Milburn is giving away some details about what's coming. You know, the phrase is pitch rolling. So aren't they being cautious about the way that they are letting it be known what the plans are around this

4:17so they can try and manage the way that it's landing, if you like? That was the first thing. The second thing is actually this looks to be quite radical because in broad terms, what Alan milburn has told the times which we understand to be broadly accurate about what's going to be in the review is that for people who are under 25 there'd be a big big change to the way that they currently can access benefits so the suggestion is they would no longer be able to get the health related element of universal credit or personal independent payments, which are for people with long term health and disabilities that they need extra support with living costs, for example. They would go and instead the under 25s would get an allowance for an additional cost allowance to help with their day to day costs and the like.

5:11And then people with profound disabilities or those that could not work could get a new benefit, which would be at a high level on top of that. But it would be a fundamental change. And to be blunt, what he's saying is it would mean that some young people would lose the benefits they currently get. And also that isn't just for future claimants, but for existing claimants. And Chris, what's your sense of where the Labour MPs are on this? Because of course, they're the ones that scuppered this when Keir Starmer tried to do this the first time round. Yeah, exactly that. So from taking the temperature today, and they are not just basing their analysis on what they've read in the Times, because, picking up on Alex's point, the pitch rolling, to use the Westminster phrase, has been going on seemingly forever,

5:55because it was the big lesson learned from the lack of it last time round, where the whole thing happened in the blink of an eye, and looked like, through the perspective of of many Labour MPs perspective on it they felt like it was a crude cost cutting exercise rather than making an argument about a moral mission to get younger folk into work or into education or whatever. From the conversations I've had today there's a totally different mood. That's not to say there aren't opponents, there are opponents but they tend to be from the left of the Labour Party, whereas last time it was a much broader sweep of Labour MPs. A key voice in all of this is Dame Meg Hillier, long-standing Labour MP.

6:33She was seen as one of the ringleaders last time around the rebellion that was hugely damaging to Keir Starmer. She is on camera and on side and flattering Alan Milburn for his work. And is that because it's much less focused on Pip than it was before? Because Pip was always a really sensitive... I think so. And I think as well, just a sense, Gary, that Labour MPs feel like they've been taken seriously. They've been listened to, they've been called in. There's elements of it, as Alex was fleshing out there, where there's crucial detail we don't yet know. So there's talk of extra support for the quote, profoundly disabled. What is profound? I think that's open to some discussion. Does that end up looking a bit like the criteria

7:18for PIP now, which could then encompass a lot of people living with a lot of conditions? Or is it very narrowly drawn like the top end of PIP right now? Completely. So both that and in some of the other elements, and these are just the elements we've heard of today, there is still scope for discussion. And the implication being that they're at least hearing out the concerns of Labour MPs about where you draw those lines. I think there's a recognition as well that the scale of the challenge that they face, not just around the question we've regularly discussed, the uptick in the benefits bill in an era where you want to spend a load more on defence, but also that kind of moral sense of a million people who are neat. And the argument I've heard from some is,

8:06if a Labour government cannot tackle a problem like that, what is the point of it? Yeah, and it's also really important to note that from an Alan Milburn perspective, and I think part of the reason that Labour MPs at this stage in the main don't seem to be raising huge concerns, let's see, but at this stage they don't, is because the way that he is presenting it and the way that the government is attempting to present this is it isn't about cuts to the benefit bill alone. It's coming with lots of extra support that would be advocated to try and support people into work. And if you contrast that to what the Keir Starmer government attempted to do, which was largely seen as just making cost-cutting

8:41as opposed to trying to support people back into work with this kind of notion of it being a sort of moral cause. But still conditionality because... Yes. Even Blair, you know, think the unthinkable, was what Blair told his people to do and he couldn't get it done with an enormous majority, if you remember. Quite. I just think you talk to people in this space trying to get young people back into work after they've been unemployed or not in education and once you hit six months of not being in a job and not being in the workforce it is virtually impossible to get somebody ready and happy and confident enough to go back to work and so if lots of young people will already have had that six months and we're

9:22talking about a 10-year plan to introduce this. And the other side of it is there does have to be jobs available, suitable jobs that are available for young people. And we know because it's well documented, some of the problems in the labour market, not just with what you might call sort of entry-level jobs or, you know, first jobs, but also longer-term jobs. You know, like the graduate market at the moment is actually really challenging for people, not least because of AI. So that's the other flip side of it. And then, of course, there is this issue about mental health support as well, which we know is under huge pressure. So, you know, is the government going to approach that side of it as well? Because

9:52there are lots of people on long waiting lists to try and get support with their mental health. Is that going to be part of the broader package? And so I think while the very early soundings from Labour MPs about what they've been briefed on so far internally, or what they've read the Times from Alan Milburn whatever else you know I think they're sort of that they're not kicking off at this point in large part but it still feels to me there's a lot of detail to be fleshed out and a lot of I know like politicians always say this right but genuinely it feels like on this one because of how significant this issue is to Labour Party but much more broadly I think the phrase the devil in the detail was going to do a lot of work on this.

10:25This is going to take so long. So you get Milburn doing his, Milburn, as if we're in private school, Milburn, hand in your report now on Tuesday. And then we know the government's going to respond in some way on Tuesday. Because John Healey, the chancellor, was talking to Faisal today and said the government will respond on Tuesday and not just in a, oh, thanks for doing that. We'll get back to you next year thing. Then there'll be a white paper, which is that sort of first stage of passing new legislation. Then they'll have to draft a bill, which you'll have to get through both houses of parliament. And it will be controversial. And there'll be all sorts of case studies of people popping up saying, oh, this would be the consequences on me or on my child.

11:00MPs will then start getting emails that they haven't been getting yet because people don't know what's happening. Then there'll be a legal challenge. You can imagine a charity saying, hang on, this is ageist. This is age discrimination to have a different system for people under 25. And the government might win that legal challenge, but they won't be able to implement it while it's happening. And then the years just mount up and up and up and up. But the Tories will have to vote for this, right? I mean, he'll get Tory votes. Well, it'd be interesting to see how... So hearing Camille Badenoch today making an argument where she was saying... So, I mean, the classic, as you know, Gary, the classic tool is that of an opposition party,

11:36what's the best way to make a government feel awkward? Say that you'll back them. Yeah. Particularly if there's a load of pressure on their own side. Absolutely. Their argument, or Camille Badenoch's argument right now, is to say, not to short, throwing a load of money at government schemes is necessarily a good use of money. Surely you've got to get the bill down. And of course, what is the bill? Because you could see an argument where Labour, if they get to the point where this is a few steps down the track, can say that the benefits bill is perhaps beginning to tick down or not rise at an increasing rate, but the overall cost remains about the same because you're putting the money into support.

12:16And Alan Milburn's arguing that this set of measures wouldn't be saving money in the round for the best part of 10 years. So I think from Kelly Badenock's perspective, I think she's likely to acknowledge, because it's almost impossible not to, that there's a problem that needs addressing here. But precisely where the solutions come and whether she's willing to be sort of more robust in trying to get that headline number down quicker, I think is where we'll be. And also the Tories unveiled a new policy on young people's welfare a few weeks ago, which has actually got quite a few of these elements in it. So a lower rate of welfare if you're under 25 and marching you to the job centre to learn how to do job interviews

13:00or get ready for the world of work. So it's sort of a tougher sounding version. Yeah, and also things like, you know, not giving after a certain period of time out of work, putting on a back to work card that you can only spend on certain things. There was quite a lot in there that they've set out and their total savings that they want to make from the welfare bill is in the region of £36 billion, which is... Eye-watering. Extensive. Now, Chris, as we're talking, a whole panoply of European leaders, so not just the EU, but the EU plus, plus, plus are in Dublin. This meeting of the European political community. Yes. Thrilling branding for a group of people. I mean, I'd love to be there, but that's just how I'm going to do it.

13:34The prime minister is on his second international shindig of the day. Yeah. Having woken up. Turkey for breakfast. which is a geographical rather than the menu It's a bit early for Turkey at any time of day really isn't it So Turkey for the Sorry I've really distracted you with that You could hear me slowing down Breakfast in Turkey Processing that imagery So yeah the climate change the COP summit of which you're a veteran, aren't you, Adam? When it was in Glasgow, when it was in my hometown. Congress of the Parties, is that right? Conference of the Parties. All right, there you go. And the thing about COP is... Come on, Mason, if we go by surnames. There's multiple conferences with multiple different parties

14:20to different agreements all happening simultaneously. What do the numbers mean? Just the number of the conference. It's that simple. What I love about that is that the United Nations has their own years. So it's like, we're like, oh, it's 2026. Well, it's COP31. When was COP26? Oh, five years ago. Anyway. Forget about COP26. EPC. Then he went on to the European political community. As you described it, I think, earlier in the week, sort of EU++, plus, plus. So it's a bigger club by numbers than the European Union. And it's a much looser kind of collection that get together, acknowledging that Europe extends beyond the borders of the European Union. So it's a useful vehicle for a post-Brexit British prime minister to turn up at.

15:02And plenty of them have in recent years. And I think useful from the Prime Minister's perspective on two things. One, a conversation about Ukraine going on. As we record, I think we're going to hear from the Prime Minister this evening. And then secondly, he has been seeing, amongst others, Ursula von der Leyen of the European Commission ahead of that summit in Brussels in a week's time. Where they will ink, as the tabloids would say, the deals that were started to be negotiated by Keir Starmer. So things like the plant and animal health thing, youth experience, maybe, emissions trading. Gary, going back to COP and the climate change conference in Turkey, so Donald Trump is pulling out of the Paris climate change agreement

15:42and that whole UN architecture which makes people think maybe it's all just a busted flush now if the world's biggest economy is not in there. But I hear lots of American politicians are still going though. So the Democrats are sort of going under their own steam. Yes, although I think the State Department has refused to pay for a CODEL as they call it, a Congressional delegation. So they're presumably having to pay for themselves. And I think as they call it, a Congressional delegation. So they're presumably having to pay for themselves. And I think Al Gore's going, isn't he? So they are trying to signal, or some of them are trying to signal that, you know, just hang on guys. You know, if things turn out

16:16differently in 2028, maybe we'll be back in. So I imagine that's what that's all about. And Alex, in terms of what the Prime Minister was saying when he was having breakfast in Turkey, not turkey for breakfast. Well, he might have had turkey for breakfast. I mean, it'd be a bit of a weird choice, as Chris was saying. Everyone eats turkey all day in America, I'm afraid. Do they? Yeah. So have you had turkey for breakfast, have you, Gary? Yeah, they have turkey sausage, would you believe? Yes. It's very pale. It looks very pale. It's sort of like undercooked. You're not selling it. Yeah, you don't really. Also, I have to say, American sandwiches just look so good. And they're so thick. The size of a house.

16:50Yeah, that's what I'm getting at. Anyway, Alex, back to COP. Enough turkey chat. Yeah, so I was projecting five live breakfast on Thursday morning, and we took the Prime Minister's whole speech live. And I thought, well, how long is this? It's going to take about half an hour of this programme. And it ended up being four minutes. So it was not very long. And what was interesting for me was, oh, he said, Britain is going to go back to being a leader on climate change, which I thought was interesting, because, well, hang on, you've just approved a new gas field off the coast of Scotland, which might not quite, I mean, you can make an argument for why it's compatible with the climate change targets, but didn't scream green.

17:26No, he's trying to walk a bit of a tricky line on this one. And I think in some ways, part of the reason he did go to COP, even though he had to fly to Turkey and then to Dublin and only gave a short speech when he was there, because he wanted it to be a symbol of his commitment to the climate change agenda and also net zero and that target of reaching net zero by 2050 because at the same time his government is taking decisions which some environmentalists have a real problem with. So yeah they approved the Jackdaw gas field. There is also speculation and reports that they might change the targets for the sale of electric vehicles, water them down a bit where there's been pressure from some quarters in the industry for them to do that but still there are people

18:05that would say hang on is that really compatible with you saying you're a climate leader? And then, of course, what is still pending is that really big, significant political decision about whether to give the go ahead for the Rosebank, mainly oil field. So Andy Burnham is trying to say, and of course, when they gave the approval for Jackdaw, they were trying to make the argument that, look, come on, this is better than shipping in liquefied natural gas from overseas. This is more carbon friendly than doing that. We're going to have oil and gas in the mix for years to come. Why not use our own? There's tax revenue. We'll put that into renewables. We're still committed to the renewables agenda. But there were plenty of people that said, hang about. In terms of a signal,

18:40in terms of a symbol, this is approving more drilling. And that question hangs over them to an even greater extent when it comes to Rosebank, which is why it's kind of a difficult argument for the Prime Minister to make simultaneously at the same time. But I think that is in part the reason that he was determined to be at the COP summit, despite the fact it involved a pretty long plane ride. And lean into the point that he's the only G7 leader who's there. Yeah, because the rest of them didn't go. Which also chimes with the economic message today about the UK leading the G7 when it comes to economic growth, I suppose. Yeah, and there's quite a few smiles in government at the moment about these economic numbers.

19:18I mean, granted, by any sort of historical sweep, it's not exactly gangbusters territory, but given where things have been and given where things were projected to be not that long ago, there's been quite a bit now of points on the graph that are more upbeat, more optimistic than some thought. Right, let's go back to American politics. And Gary, this is where it slightly gets like an episode of This Is Your Life, if people remember that TV show. Because here is one of Gary's greatest hits from the midterms last week when the Democrats had a sensational victory in Texas, a place where they hadn't had many victories for a while. Democrats have taken back or projected to take back Texas in the shape of James Tallarico.

20:02Sounded quite loud that, Gary. You're having to properly shout. Even American political journalism is louder than it is in British history. It's so big. Yeah. What was actually happening at that point? So the crowd had just seen on the screen, so there's a venue in Austin where Tallarico was having his thing. And he just won the Senate seat. And he just won the, or he'd just been, they'd just learned he'd won the Senate seat and they went just won the Senate, or he'd just been, they'd just learned he'd won the Senate seat, and they went bananas, of course, and we were there. And, you know, it was kind of, there was a lot of expectation that he probably would. The polls were in his favour for some time,

20:35but, of course, the polls had been wrong on several occasions in the past, and they never quite believed them, and they're not sure. And Texas has been going blue for generations. I remember doing it in 2014 when it was about to go blue and, of course, it never happened. But not just him, but up and down the ticket they won. They won the governor's race, which no one expected. But they won a whole bunch of other statewide races as well. And I spoke to the head of the Young Republicans the day before and he said, I'm going to have a red wave party. I said, really? OK. And then the day after, he's like in total shock, like total shock. So it wasn't very... It's not what turned up to his party.

21:15No, certainly not. And it certainly didn't turn... I mean, I said to him, so Texas is purple now? He said, to me, it looks pretty blue. Purple meaning it's a mixture of Democrat and Republican. Red and blue. Yeah, yeah. And you mentioned James Tallarico. I mean, here in Britain, we sort of see just sort of a sense of him, sort of that we feel his aura across the Atlantic rather than actually seeing the detail of what he does and how he performs. What's your take on him? Untested at the moment, I'd say. You know, he's been in the Texas State House. He was a teacher before that. I mean, you get tested during these campaigns and he stood up pretty well to that. But, you know, if he's going to run for

21:5320 years... The money is the thing that still shocks me. I mean, they spent, on advertising alone, more than half... I mean, 570-odd million. I think I worked out it was like four and a half times... That one race was more than four and a half times the entire spend on the UK general election. Wow. Just for one Senate seat. It's extraordinary. And that's just the advertising. That doesn't account for the field work and on the ground and the staffing costs and all that kind of thing. Musk put in 200 million into Texas alone. And what do you think, Gary, was the key in Texas specifically in terms of why the outcome was how it was? Two big things. One is that Trump had done really, really well

22:46with Hispanics down in the Rio Grande Valley. Because there's this thing that, you know, we think immigration and border security are lumped together. They're not. You know, Hispanics living by the river don't like hundreds of thousands of people crossing from Mexico and running through their back gardens and, you know, causing havoc. They don't like it. So they like border security. So they love Trump for that. But what they didn't love was the enforcement of detention and deportation. So, you know, auntie and uncle, brother and sister getting pulled over. And of course, because of the pressure they're under to do the numbers meant they weren't just going after the criminals and the drug dealers as

23:23Trump had promised. Again, it was a broken promise thing. They just went after anyone as and the drug dealers as Trump had promised. Again, it was a broken promise thing. They just went after anyone, as someone put it to me, with a brown skin. And so that turned the big Hispanic vote in the valley against him. And then also the rural Republicans. And I'd spoken to a bunch of those a few weeks before up in the sort of rural counties further north. They were just they were so annoyed about gas prices, petrol, diesel. They were so annoyed about it, you know, and the fact that Trump kept denying it and kept telling them, oh, it's just short term and what are you worrying about? And they, you know, they didn't allow themselves to be gaslighted.

24:01And a lot of them stayed at home. But, you know, there were significant numbers that actually voted Democrat. And that was quite astonishing. So you can combine that nationwide with, you know, actually the youth vote turning against Republicans as well, which Trump had done pretty well with in 24. And, you know, it was a bigger, it was a sort of 50-year type wave, 50-year long, right? You know, huge. Anyone remember how to spell Mississippi? a bigger, it was a sort of 50 year type wave. 50 year long road. Huge. Anyone remember how to spell Mississippi? Mrs M, Mrs I, Mrs Ssi, Mrs Ssi, PPI. This is unbelievable. Was that Rafa Notorious Alex Versailles? Do that again. Here we go. Drum roll please.

24:41Okay, got it then. Ready? Mrs M, Mrs I, Mrs Ssi, Mrs Ssi, PPI. Yes. That on then. Ready? Mrs M, Mrs I, Mrs SSI, Mrs SSIPPI. Yes, correct. That's correct, right? A meme was born. Double S's, double P's. Yeah, okay. Well, that's a pithier way of doing it. I can't even remember your round. Where did you... Was that a school thing? Actually, no idea. Yeah, I guess so. Or was it self-panned? Yes, I wrote that brilliant rhyme myself. I mean, Gary, why is M-I-s-s-i everyone's talking about that this week because it took them a while to count the votes yes it did and it was very close and there's a lot of what they call provisional ballots in in places in the south in particular what these are people turning up with the wrong info and they say and they sort of take an affidavit

25:21from them and they say yeah yeah honestly i can I can. Honestly, I am allowed to. And then they check it afterwards. Particularly a big deal amongst African-Americans. And they finally sort of done that. And they have to report it by tomorrow. What we still don't know is Alaska, which has this weird kind of, I mean, this sort of redistributing of second votes and things like that. It's one of those few states with a very weird system. And they have another couple of weeks to count. But the Democrat, Paul Tullo, she's slightly ahead there at the moment. So at the moment, it's 55-44 with one seat to go. In the Democrats' favour. Yeah, but it's still, you know, don't forget you need 60 votes in the Senate to get legislation through to avoid filibusters.

26:04So they're still short of a, you know, we can get stuff done without getting Republican support. And if you want to do impeachments, you know, that's two thirds, that's 67 senators. So they may still, even if they get 56, they would still need to get 11 Republicans to come along with them if they want to impeach people like Pete Heg said. Alex, you've got a rap for Alaska. Sadly not. It's very easy. I know. I probably could come up with one. I don't think it's going to take me a long time. It doesn you've got a rap for Alaska. Sadly not. It's very easy. I know. It's all about the fish. I don't think it's going to take you a long time. It doesn't need a whole rap to itself. Hey, Gary, I heard a fact.

26:31Can you tell me if it's true? Oh, my goodness. That the Democrats won in Kansas for the first time since Judy Garland was filming The Wizard of Oz. So is that 1932? That sounds about right, doesn't it? There you go. That was my best US midterms. Yeah. For this podcast. A load of useless information. We're on fire for this podcast. We've had useless information. We've had conference of the parties. We've had Miss whatever it was. Go on, Chris, try it. Judy Garland. It's unbelievable. Except, though, Chris, isn't it interesting that the big knock-on effect of the midterms initially was actually all this rhetoric from the Democrats about clamping down on AI, whether the development of the technology

27:06or opposing data centers being built, that then has a massive knock-on effect on the American stock market, which has a knock-on effect on the global economy. And so the ripples of that is felt in the UK. And because British politicians are quite hooked on what happens in America, you can see maybe some of those themes will be imported here as well. Yeah, all of that. And I think it'd be fascinating to see on one of those specifics where the data centre's argument goes in UK politics. It's already heating up. There's already some local examples of where that is. Because you haven't got... I mean, there isn't the space, is there? I mean, America's got space for this stuff. I mean, miles and miles of it.

27:44Yeah, yeah, whereas by definition, data centres are just going to be closer to people in the UK? I mean, America's got space for this stuff. I mean, miles and miles of it. Yeah, yeah, well it's by definition there's just going to be closer to people in the UK, aren't they, relatively speaking. And then I think the other thing which we've seen over and over again in the last week or so, and we saw instantly from the Prime Minister and the Foreign Secretary at the Commonwealth Summit that I was at last week, is latching on to the critique of, in response to the midterms that a significant proportion of it was about the cost of living and in particular the cost of fuel. And that, if you like, turbocharging the public argument you hear from the Prime Minister and others

28:19about sort out the Middle East because that's the single biggest contributor to easing the cost of living and leaning into the argument that plenty of senior Republicans acknowledge, not least the president now, around how big a contributory factor that that was. And also this, I mean, it makes it easier here with the more general argument we talked about earlier about energy security and having your own ability ability to to you know generate your own electricity as much as you can and no one can do it completely but that is a big deal i think and that's certainly something that the was a big factor in america you know despite being the world's biggest exporter of of gas particularly it's still

29:03you know still the prices went up, you know, double, triple, you know, for diesel in particular. So you can have as much of your own stuff as you like, but you're still susceptible to the world market. And that's an interesting point because I guess what the other thing, the flip side of the argument around the cost of living is that the US midterm results were perhaps a reminder, if they needed it, which they probably didn't, to Andy Burnham that when governments promise to take action on the cost of living and then don't or can't, they get punished for it. And clearly Andy Burnham has put the cost of living front and centre of his own premiership and at the same time acknowledges there are limited levers he can pull

29:36given what's happening globally. So, you know, it's the kind of political jeopardy of that. And how voters quite often, the way they feel in their pockets is just massively important. Voters are really rational yeah you know i mean of course they're gonna say if they feel if they feel less well off i mean that's the immediate problem for them and they they behave like economic units they they do and it's i mean i'm surprised that people are you know politicians are surprised right yeah right um gary it seems to me that donald trump is being less of a sore loser than you might have expected in this scenario. Well, I mean, there was so much kind of sort of war gaming beforehand about what might happen and team thousands of lawyers and, you know, Insurrection Act and all sorts of, you know, they were sending out federal monitors, whereas, you know, elections are run by the states.

30:24And pretty much nothing happened at all. And, you know, the day after he... Well, actually, the day before he was saying, yeah, I could work with Democrats, you know, that's not a problem at all. And then we all thought it was gone. And then suddenly, randomly, a couple of days ago, there was, oh, it was the voting machines, of course. They were all kind of... So he had started playing some old tunes again. In a very half-hearted way. It is definitely a dog that hasn't really barked this time around. Is that because of how significant the Democrat win in the round was? Yeah, I think so. And I think there just isn't the appetite for it among Republicans. You know, the MAGA elements just don't seem to have the appetite for it.

31:04And he doesn't seem to have the appetite for it at the moment. I mean, you know, he's into this lame duck period, which he seems to have accepted. You know, he doesn't really care that much about Congress anyway. He's governed through executive order largely. I mean, one or two big pieces of legislation. But the interesting thing will be how he uses executive power over the next two years. What does he suddenly feel about legacy and, you know, what might he do? Particularly now he's got Stephen Miller who is, you know, the hard liners hard liner as his chief of staff now. You know, the architect of the immigration policy, which was so unpopular amongst voters in the midterms, but he's there and we'll see what their agenda is.

31:48But, you know, everyone's kind of guessing about how far he might go. But he has promised to try and work with the Democrats. So we'll see. The strategic question for Democrats is a really interesting one because, you know, you can kick up a lot of sand in the next two years. You can launch inquiries because you know you can kick up a lot of sand in the next two years you can launch inquiries because you control the committees in congress you can try and impeach left right and center is that the right thing to do you know do the punters actually want that or do they want to see you trying to do something about the cost of living even if the president vetoes it i was just going to say that because clearly it was a really great result for the

32:23democrats clearly but then is there also a question about a what they do with it but b where they go if the president vetoes it. I was just going to say that, because clearly it was a really great result for the Democrats, clearly. But then is there also a question about, A, what they do with it, but B, where they go from here? Because now they've got this quite wide range of people representing the Democrat Party. At the same time, they're trying to work out their direction ahead of the next presidential election, right? Does that make it in some ways a bit of a harder internal conversation? It means, you know, if you get Al-Sayed winning in Michigan, you know, kind of on the, very much on the left of the party,

32:48but you get sort of moderates. I mean, like, the only way you win in Texas is by being a conservative, whether you're a Democrat or a Republican, right? So you've got Tallarico, you know, who's a small C conservative. And so you've got the successes on both wings of the party in these elections, which means neither can claim the higher ground. Now, can they work out a platform that encompasses a pretty broad church and find someone to unify behind in this next two years? Because, you know, the firing pistol has started, you know, it's been the trigger has been pulled on them already. And then on the Republican side, where what we've seen in the last month or so leaves J.D. Vance, where it leaves Marco Rubio,

33:36where it leaves anyone else. Yeah. I mean, Vance obviously came out straight away, distanced himself from the war. Rubio has said virtually nothing about it at all, which again is a strategy of some kind. And then you've got people like DeSantis, of course, in Florida, who's clearly going to be a contender again this time around. And it's just the, you know, is there a continuity candidate? Can you inherit Trumpism? Is your best play to be something different? But if you distinguish yourself too much too early, then he can still destroy you because he has a stranglehold on the party. The calculations are numerous. I mean, you know, there will be people pouring over all sorts of strategies right across the country wondering

34:21at what point, I mean, there's talk about Rubio at some point, maybe just, you know, resigning, walking away, because, you know, J.D. Vance will have a huge fundraising advantage as the vice president. And at some point, you know, if Rubio wants it, which we pretty much think he does, he's got to find a way of breaking loose from the circle and making a different pitch. But it's going to be on both sides. It's going to be, I mean, it's genuinely open on both sides, I think, at the moment about what kind of candidate they choose to nominate. And while we've been recording this episode of Newscast, Andy Burnham has been talking to the media in Dublin at this summit with other European leaders.

35:02And he was asked about the prospects of doing these mini deals with the EU at his next EU summit in Brussels next week. Requests are coming from the European side. We are putting our requests on the table too. I believe there is a good deal to be done that could be a win-win for Britain and Europe. I think it actually could be more like the Brexit that people thought they were voting for in 2016. I don't think people thought they were going to get a Brexit as hard as the one that finally came through at the end of 2019. It was much harder than Theresa May's deal when she was trying to come up with an arrangement. So let's see where we get to in the next seven days. But I think in the end, what we get could be good for

35:45Britain, but also closer to what people voted for at the referendum. Now, to me, that sounds like somebody who has gone from two years ago saying, I would like to rejoin the EU in my lifetime, to a few weeks ago at Labour Party conference saying, well, we need to look at all the options and rejoining should be one of the options, but it might not be the best one. So now like, oh, the deal I'm getting with Brussels next week might be good enough and everyone will be happy with that. Let's end the debate here. A better Brexit as he would see it. I mean, even... I wonder if all of this stuff is done now. We were thinking we were going to have 10 more years of it. Even hearing that formulation just for the first time there

36:22sounded a bit like he was trying to cast at least at least until we heard the end of the sentence a bit beyond purely what we're likely to get next week and what might also be achievable say within this parliament before the general general election gives you some sense of how much he's trying to uh freight what we'll get next week. And others make it sound really good. Well, yeah, and significant and quite weighty, even though plenty of it was pretty much sort of signed off before, when he was the mayor of Greater Manchester. But then also, as we were discussing, Adam, the other day on Newscast, with Stuart Ingham, the former number 10 advisor. How does he seek next week to weight in his argument

37:09the significance of, as he sees it, the wins there with that longer term stuff? He's let the longer term stuff run and run quite far for quite a while, for the last five, six weeks. Does he seek to? He'll certainly get questions about the longer-term future next week in Brussels. I might ask one myself. But how much does he try and constantly pull it back to look at these actual, as he sees it, wins that can make a difference, that can make an economic difference, etc., etc.? In other words, as you say, that sort of sense of a better Brexit. How risky is this? I mean is how risky is this i mean how risky is it well gary there is an episode of newscast available now on bbc science that we recorded on wednesday yeah with stuart ingham as chris was referring to who was in the policy unit

37:55in downing street for kirsten and has spent a lot of time looking at eu related issues and he was here in the studio for about 40 minutes just listing all the risks and the dangers domestically, internationally, within the Labour Party, within public opinion, about the course that Andy Burnham looked like he was pursuing. And I wonder if Andy Burnham, I'm not suggesting he was listening to Newscast. He never knows. I mean, stranger things have happened. Over his turkey at breakfast. But I do wonder if Andy Burnham's been advised about all those things that Stuart Ingham was saying to us. And he's now going for a much more minimalist approach than the quite maximalist approach. I mean, there is an answer for presenting it as incremental, isn't there?

38:33But there's also the other side of that, the risk factor, is Brussels, is the EU itself. So there is a risk that if you're constantly... We sort of always forget that. Yeah, I mean, they're quite important aspects and elements of all of this. Because there is a risk, of course, that if you're constantly talking about or floating the possibility of rejoining, what does that do to the conversations about what you're trying to achieve now? Why would Brussels try and come up with bespoke arrangements on phytosanity food standards or whatever it is, if their door is open to rejoining, they think you're serious about it? And also the other risk is that by constantly looking ahead to the longer term,

39:05do you undermine what you're trying to achieve now or at least undermine the weight of what you're trying to achieve now? Because it almost by definition looks sort of piffling compared with an argument that says the whole hog of going back in. Also, like Theresa May is going to be playing the Alanis Morissette. Isn't it ironic? At 11 tonight in her house she hears that, doesn't she? I don't know if she's the Alanis Morissette. Isn't it ironic? At 11 tonight in her house, she hears that, doesn't she? I don't know if she's an Alanis Morissette fan, but I think she is. Who isn't? Yeah, exactly. Right. Gary, lovely to see you on this side of the Atlantic. Lovely to be here as always. Alex, great to catch up.

39:37Pleasure as ever. And Chris, good to see you again. And you. And that's all for this episode of Newscast. We will be back with another one very soon. Newscast. Newscast from the BBC. From one newscaster to another, thank you so much for making it to the end of this episode. You clearly do, in the words of Chris Mason, ooze stamina. Can I also gently encourage you to subscribe to us on BBC Sounds. Tell everyone you know, and don't forget you can email us anytime at newscast at bbc.co.uk. Or if you're that way inclined, send us a WhatsApp on plus 440 330 123 9480. Be assured, I promise, we listen to everyone. Wake up to Monterey Bay views this holiday. When you book direct with Chaminade Resort and Spa,

40:40you unlock our best available rate and two welcome cocktails or craft mocktails on us. Plan your stay at Chaminade.com.

▸More episode summaries

Newscast cover art
NewscastAre Under-25s About to Lose Sickness Benefits?2026-11-12 · 30 min
Newscast cover art
NewscastA Very Public Row On The Right2026-11-14 · 38 min
Newscast cover art
NewscastCould The Russell Brand Case Change The Age Of Consent?2026-11-15 · 33 min
Newscast cover art
NewscastThe Name's Milburn...Alan Milburn2026-11-16 · 31 min
Transcribe your links. Paste a YouTube, Google Drive or podcast link and WhipScribe gives you the transcript. Transcribe a link →
New Newscast transcripts by email
One email per new episode, unsubscribe in every message. Not shared with the publisher.