Newscast · · Transcript & summary by WhipScribe
Newscast unpacks a live row between Chris Philp and Zia Youssef and previews Alan Milburn's plan to move a million young people into work, with the political stakes spelled out.
Tap a chapter to open that moment in the transcript; the link to it is copied for you.
“Gentlemen, I just basically thank you both.” Tim McNally · at 9:26 — open in the transcript →
The episode centres on a public confrontation in Piddington, an Oxfordshire village of about 400 people, where Chris Philp for the Conservatives and Reform UK's Zia Youssef traded accusations over a fast-tracked plan to hold more than 1,200 single male asylum seekers at a former military site. The hosts treat the scene as a live example of the fight on the right between the Conservatives and Reform. They also note that the local Lib Dem MP has led opposition to the plan, so the concern is not limited to one side of politics.
Most of the episode previews Alan Milburn's review on youth unemployment, which targets roughly a million people under 25 who are not in work, education or training. Milburn argues the welfare system has tilted too far toward paying benefits and away from helping people into jobs, and he puts the cost of unemployment support for young people at about £22 billion a year. The hosts test what a legal opportunity guarantee would mean in practice, and whether the plan would reach existing claimants, which the government says it will not do for people with severe disabilities.
The discussion keeps returning to Labour's internal politics. A former adviser to Liz Kendall recalls how an earlier welfare push collapsed under backbench pressure and leaks about PIP cuts, and argues the mood has shifted since Andy Burnham took over. The guests see the review as a possible big idea for Burnham, comparable to a pensions deal, while agreeing that deeds, not words, will decide whether it works.
Alan Milburn is a former Labour minister whose review on young people who are not in work, education or training is due to be unveiled on the following Tuesday. The episode describes him as a veteran, seasoned Labour figure and one of the last true Blairites.
Alex was Liz Kendall's adviser when she was Work and Pensions Secretary, before Pat McFadden. He is a Labour insider who speaks on the earlier welfare push and the current plans.
In an interview in Liverpool, Alan Milburn put the cost of unemployment support for people under 25 at about £22 billion a year. He said the welfare system has tilted too far toward paying benefits rather than helping people into work, and that the ratio should move from about £25 to £1 down toward £2 to £1.
“this pendulum has spun far too far from the one to the other”Alan Milburn · 20:00
Alex, who advised Liz Kendall when she was Work and Pensions Secretary, said the earlier welfare cut was pulled back by Keir Starmer in the face of opposition from Labour backbenchers. Alex said the team never got the chance to make the argument that people would be supported into work first.
“Keir Starmer pulled it back down in the face of opposition from backbenchers to welfare cuts.”Alex · 17:07
Alex said a legal entitlement for young people to a job, apprenticeship, training place or support would be framed as a duty on government, which is being called the opportunity guarantee. Alex compared it to councils' existing legal duties to house homeless people or accommodate children in care, and said it would need conditionality in practice.
“We're calling it the opportunity guarantee.”Alex · 26:16
The episode presents Alan Milburn's review as aimed at about a million young people under 25 who are not in employment, education or training, known as NEETs. The hosts describe the NEET rate as having barely been below 10% in 25 years, and say it carries a large benefits cost as well as lost opportunity.
“that represents around a million young people who live in this country under 25”Newscast · 15:00
The Home Office said a final decision to proceed with the Piddington asylum accommodation site had not yet been taken, though planning consent was pushed through that week so the government could do it. Alan Milburn's review on young people not in work, education or training was due to be unveiled the following Tuesday, with proposals to shift spending from benefits toward employment support.
In an interview in Liverpool, Alan Milburn put the cost of unemployment support for under-25s at about £22 billion a year. He argues the welfare pendulum has swung too far from helping people into work toward paying benefits, and he wants the ratio shifted from about £25 to £1 down to around £2 to £1, meaning less spent on benefits and more on employment support.
The episode reports that the hosts and a former Labour adviser see existing claimants as part of the savings, because the benefits bill is rising and fiscal pressure is real. The government and Milburn say they are not targeting people with severe disabilities or serious illness, but the changes could reach people who currently receive some benefits for conditions such as ADHD or mild depression or anxiety.
At an impromptu press conference in Piddington, Oxfordshire, Chris Philp and Zia Youssef clashed over the proposed asylum accommodation centre. Youssef pressed Philp to apologise to the British people and the villagers for not using his majority to secure the borders, while Philp argued the Conservatives had changed under new leadership and that Labour was responsible for the situation.
The hosts describe the proposed Piddington site, former military accommodation for more than 1,200 single male asylum seekers, as easy politics for both the Conservatives and Reform. The Home Office says a final decision has not been taken, although planning consent was pushed through that week so the government could proceed. The village has about 400 people and no shop, pub or doctor's surgery, according to residents.
One host suggested Milburn's youth plan could give Andy Burnham the big concrete proposal he has been criticised for lacking, after a lot of rhetoric about a ten-year plan. The comparison drawn was with Burnham's pensions deal, which trades some planned increases for a national care service. The hosts said the decisions that follow, not the speeches, will determine whether it counts.
A former adviser to Liz Kendall said the earlier welfare cut was rushed by a Treasury-set deadline, so the team never got to make the case that people would be helped into work first. Keir Starmer pulled it back in the face of opposition from Labour backbenchers, a climb-down the adviser accepted as a political humiliation.
NEET stands for young people who are not in employment, education or training. The hosts say Alan Milburn's review focuses on around a million people under 25 in this group, a problem they call socially damaging and costly to the economy through lost tax contribution and a large benefits bill.
Our own transcript of the public episode, with a timestamp about every 90 seconds. Tap a timestamp or the link button on a paragraph to copy a link that opens this page there.
0:00This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK. The ripped carpet by the basement door snags my shoe. Do I rip out all the carpet or just replace that section? What do I... Wait. What if I just use Thumbtack? I can find top-rated pros for over 500 home categories and projects. Easily compare prices and read reviews on Thumbtack. Download the app today. Opportunities should be about more than opening doors. At Year Up United, it's about opening the world so everyone can find their way. Here, you can learn in-demand skills while earning a weekly stipend working with industry-leading companies. Companies that are looking for someone like you. And with an opportunity like that, there's nowhere to go but up.
1:02Learn more at yearup.org. Right, that's enough of the very important conversation about whether when you are watching The Washing Machine, your border terrier also watches The Washing Machine with you. Because there is a much more interesting conversation that we are going to talk about on this Saturday's newscast. Is there not? Yes, it is. It is the verbal and visual realisation of the fight for the right. And it's huge in this context. We've been going on for a long time on newscasts about the interesting politics between reform and the Conservatives, the upstart challengers to the Tories and the Tories trying to chisel support back from Nigel Farage. And on our TV screens, on our phones yesterday,
1:45in real life, that confrontation over an asylum centre potentially coming to a tiny village in Oxfordshire was played out for the nation and for all to see. The only way we are going to solve this problem, Chris, is by... The only way we are going to solve this problem... by... You are in a hole, buddy. You are in a hole. Stop digging. The only way we are going to solve this problem... I don't think I've ever heard the word buddy used in quite such a passive-aggressive way. That's from the mouth of Chris Philp, Shadow Home Secretary, and Zia Youssef, Reform UK's Home Affairs spokesperson. So we're going to get into that on today's newscast and we have an important preview of what's going to be a massive political moment next week
2:24when Alan Milburn, the former Labour Minister, comes forward with his ideas of trying to help a lost generation of a million young people who don't have anything to do. All on Saturday's Newscast. Newscast. Newscast from the BBC. Humanity's next great voyage begins. I don't know who the Prime Minister is, Mike. I'm Andy and I'm not looking at my best right now. I see that he was, I guess, the mayor of a town. Everyone assumes that you must be a traitor. And what will you do? Stare at a wall. Do we play music now or what do we do? Hello, it's Paddy in the studio. And it's Laura in the studio. And before we get into the battle for Piddington, it's worth remembering, I think, the context of this.
3:05Labour came to power with a promise to get rid of asylum hotels in lots of towns and cities around the country. In recent years, the government had been paying for accommodation in hotels where people who just arrived in this country without permission often were being housed. There was a series of all sorts of political stripe demonstrations at the hotel that became famous, the Bell in Epping in Essex, that many people listening will remember. But as a result of closing asylum hotels, which is what people voted for and said they wanted, the government's then been on the hunt for other places to house asylum seekers when they arrive in the UK. And the heart of the row, to accept the invitation to go.
4:07And the villagers of Piddington, some of whom I've met, were very pleased that Chris Philp went and they were very pleased that Zia Youssef went. However, Chris Philp and Zia Youssef were not pleased, it seemed, that each other went. Certainly not. So before we get into that extraordinary exchange, Piddington is a tiny village in Oxfordshire. The government has fast-tracked planning permission. Angela Rayner was accused of sort of sneaking it out in the dead of night this week for there to be a pretty sizable asylum accommodation centre on the edge of the village. It's former military accommodation and the government is proposing that more than a thousand asylum seekers are held there on that site. They would be allowed to come and go. It's not like a camp
4:51where they'd be barricaded in, but it's been very controversial. And Paddy, you've been there, you've spoken to villagers there. People might remember people voted in a referendum, which was kind of metaphorical to leave the country rather than allow this to happen. But give us a flavour of what it's like. Well, I mean, you've put your finger on all the important bits of it. And there's one thing people don't often point out, which is that there is a prison very close to the village as well. And the difference between the prison and the proposed migrant accommodation is the open door. The prison has a door that is shut. The military camp that was proposed as a site for 1,200 single male migrants
5:31will not. The village is not 400 people. So it's three to one. And people say there's no shop, there's no pub, there's no doctor surgery. It's the wrong site, the wrong plan is what they say, the people who live there. And what kind of place is it? I mean, you know, it's a gorgeous Oxfordshire village, beautiful houses that you could almost imagine doing a jigsaw with. I went to the village hall. There's a sign up in the village hall that said Tortoise Found. It's a small community. I walked around with a mum who was looking forward to going on holiday with their motorhome, which they park in the drive outside. It's a part, a slice of rural England, which is a dream for many of the people who moved into it.
6:12And this, they would argue, is their version of a nightmare. Now, of course, it is the same sort of situation that people living in big towns in the north of England have had. They've had HMOs, houses in multiple occupation. And they're not popular either. And there is an argument, and it was voiced by senior Labour people, that rich people in the south should suck it up. That's right. And Andy Burnham himself has said that. Essentially, this is about people taking a fair share. But as you have explained so evocatively, this is something that has gone down like a cup of cold sick in a small community, a very small community with a proposal to have significantly more people right on their doorstep, arriving from a different place. So you can see why both the Conservatives
7:01and reform think for them politically, this is easy politics. We should also mention that the local Lib Dem MP has been leading the campaign against it. So this is not just concern that's being expressed by people on the right. But let's just have a listen and have a watch if you're watching on YouTube or iPlayer, let's just replay what was. I can't remember, actually, such a sort of, not fisticuffs, but such a sort of metaphorical fisticuffs between politicians out in the wild, out in real life. And if you're listening, not watching, behind them is standing the chairman of the parish council, Tim McNally, who I think you spoke to and you met. Yeah, he drove me round the village. And other local people in Pennington
7:47are sort of crowded around this impromptu press conference. But it wasn't really just like a press conference. It was very nearly a punch-up. But I hope today, rather than engage in point scoring, we can stand in solidarity. We can stand in solidarity with the residents. It's a very important point, though. We can stand in solidarity with the residents. It's a very important point, though. It's a very important point, Chris. It's a very important point. Read the room. Listen to the people clapping. Listen to the people clapping and read the room. It is important that we hold everybody accountable for this situation accountable. That's why I came into politics, right? The notion that you had no involvement,
8:20you know that that's not true. You were heavily involved in immigration and borders policy for the Conservative Party. And yes, it is true. One thing you did say that was correct. One thing that you did say which was correct. Hold on, Chris. Hold on. Hold on. Hold on. This is not cheap politics. The only way, the only way, the only way, the only way we are going to solve this problem, the only way we are going to solve this problem, Chris, is by, Chris, the only way, the only way we are going to solve this problem. The only way we are going to solve this problem, Chris, is by being honest about how we arrived in this situation. When the Tories had a walloping majority, having promised the British people in four
8:54consecutive elections they would secure our borders, you refused to do it. Had we given, had we given, had we given, the hole that this village is in, Chris, the reason why we are in this situation is because we don't have a secure border. You have misjudged the situation. Do yourself a favour and calm down. Chris you should apologise to the British people and to the people of Piddington who would not be in this mess if you had used your majority to secure our borders and stop the boats. Would you like to apologise? That's the last thing I'm going to say on this matter. I've just explained the young men being put here are recent arrivals under the Labour government, and just listen to the public here.
9:26They do not want to hear your cheap party points. They want to hear solidarity and unity. I think there's a lot of people in the country who want to hold the Conservative Party accountable for their records. Gentlemen, I just basically thank you both. That's Tim McNally. Tim McNally, the parish councillor, he's sort of like a referee, and you can see him sort of all throughout that clip wondering what's going of like a referee. And you can see him sort of all throughout that clip, wondering what's going on in his mind. At one point, he's sort of nervously picking his cuticles, thinking, oh, my God, what's happening here? And I really valued watching the expressions of the people watching on.
9:58There's one man who's very carefully looking at his shoes. There's two women on the right of the shot, both in their, you know, autumn puffergy lays, sort of looking at each other, thinking, oh oh my God, what is going to happen here? And yes, this is primarily, of course, in that moment about what's happening in this one community. But you can also see there, you know, literally, this is the fight on the right. You have a prominent reform politician who's making his point in a very forceful kind of of finger-pointing, jabbing way, trying to say, apologise, apologise, landing the problems of immigration in this country squarely at the Conservative Party. Then you've got the Conservative spokesman, Chris Phelps,
10:36who, yes, let's not forget, was a Home Office minister in that administration, saying, look, we've changed, we've changed, we're not the same, we're under new leadership, look, we've changed. We've changed. We're not the same. We're under new leadership. Things are Labour's fault. And by the way, people don't really like the cut of your jib. And that's what you can see going on between the Conservatives and reform. Kemi Badenoch has been sort of saying, we don't want anything to do with those people. We're not going to do a deal. We don't want anything to do with them. It's ugly politics. We're not going to do a deal. We don't want anything to do with them. It's ugly politics. We're not going to get pulled into it. Prominent reformers like Zia Yusuf think,
11:10no, no, they need not just to stick to that kind of politics, but actually to double down, to keep going, to push harder, to be more sort of vitriolic sometimes in how they're using language and to be completely relentless in trying to pin the country's problems on the Tories. It's fascinating. I mean, it's interesting to hear you, who I would call a seasoned observer. I mean, I'm old. Joe Pike's not even here and I've already been accused of being old. No, seasoned. Seasoned. It's interesting to see you say you can't remember it. It revokes in me a memory of Alistair Campbell and Adam Bolton on Sky News, a clip from a long time ago. Blimey, yes. mighty fight for the left, as evidenced by the deposing of the prime minister by Andy Burnham in a plot that was hatched over one year.
12:10There has been a demonstrable fight for the left. Yes, there has been a massive fight for the left. But isn't it a mark of Andy Burnham's political ability that he staged a coup in plain sight and came out of it more or less with most people thinking, oh, he looks like a really nice guy. Now, people would say that, but people close to Andy Byrne would say he's a genuinely very nice, empathetic, good man. But yes, also, when it comes to politics, he's prepared to be incredibly ruthless. But this is a Laura Koonsberg point. I feel confident in making you agree with it. So we've basically got the fight for the right. We won't go back over. We've just seen it. The fight for the left. And it's got this shaping up to be
12:55the next election has got to be things like welfare. Where do you stand on welfare or work? And where do you stand on how tough to be on people who've landed in the country? Those sorts of issues are shaping up. Yeah, absolutely. I think we can see those tram lines really clearly already. There is, though, still, and we'll talk about welfare just in a second, because there is going to be a fight on the left about welfare and there is a fight on the left between the Greens and Labour, for sure. And yes, Zach Polanski's had some problems in the last couple of months, but there is a fight on the left about welfare. There is a fight on the left about spending levels. There is a fight on the left about the European Union
13:30and all of those things. But I'm really glad that we've taken the time to look at that clip today and talk about it because it is a real-life explainer. We couldn't have described that better ourselves. This is both a metaphor and the actual reality of the real tussle for support of voters on the right in this country. And it's really interesting in that context. It is a really important moment, not least just, and we should say this in terms of what happens next to Piddington. So the Home Office is still saying that a final decision to proceed is yet to be taken, but the planning consent has been pushed through this week so the government could do it if they wanted to. Well, and the people in Piddington have told me
14:16that they expect this to get into Donald Trump's field of vision. Oh, that's fascinating. Yeah, well, maybe it's got an Elon Musk X-Fest written all over it, hasn't it? That lies in the future. Let's talk about something in the more immediate future then, shall we? Tuesday, I believe it is. You've been speaking to the Labour panjandrum, who is going to be suggesting what to do with a million people under 25, well, between 18 and 25, I suppose, who aren't in work, education or training? Panjandrum. That's a tremendous word. It's one of the reasons I like doing our podcast so much because I learn a new word from you every week. Yes, you refer to Alan Milburn, the veteran, seasoned Labour former minister,
15:00one of the last true Blairites standing, who is unveiling his long awaited full tome, full of proposals to end what is one of the ugliest sounding problems in our country of NEETs, which is not just a horrible acronym, but that represents around a million young people who live in this country under 25, who don't have a job, who aren't training for a job, who don't have apprenticeship and they're not studying. And it's a terrible problem from a social point of view. Think of all that lost opportunity and all this stress and upset for young people who can't get work if they want it. But also it's a huge cost to the economy because the bill for benefits is massive. And also there's that lost opportunity.
15:46If people aren't working, then they're not contributing to the economy in a way that they might want to. So let's discuss it now with Alex Zappman, who was Liz Kendall's advisor when she was work and pension secretary before Pat McFadden. Hello, Alex. Hello, Laura. Hello, Paddy. Hello, thank you for coming. It's great to have you with us. Now, should we do a little pre-see of what happened when you and Liz Kendall Hello, Laura. Hello, Paddy. Hello, thank you for coming. Thank you for coming. It's great to have you with us. Now, should we do a little pre-see of what happened when you and Liz Kendall were trying to sort all of this out? If we can invite you to go over something that might be rather painful, maybe not at great length.
16:18Not at great length, but, and obviously it was painful. But, look, we wanted to do what is happening now. And they have done a fantastic job in laying the groundwork that we never got a chance to do. And, you know, I don't need to go into the details of that. We all kind of know what happened there. There was a period of a few months where the Treasury said, you're going to do this. And then we were on a deadline to do it. What we didn't get to do was put out the narrative that actually we're going to help people. We're going to support people first. This time they've got a really good hook, which is the Milburn Review. And they are using that as a fantastic opportunity because it's not just fiscally the right thing to do,
17:07it is morally the right thing to do. So that's really interesting. So you go straight there to the importance of making the argument. Totally. What you and Liz Kendall were trying to do was, yes, save a lot of money from the benefits bill. That came out the tube, as it were. The Labour Party went bananas. Keir Starmer pulled it back down in the face of opposition from backbenchers to welfare cuts. And you never had the chance to say, but of course we'll make these cuts, but we'll help people get into work. And that's what we always wanted to do. The first and foremost, certainly from my previous boss Liz's point of view, it was always about, it's always people first. But you were called cruel by people
17:43from the same political party as her. You're always going to have some people who do that. But that's how high the stakes were. I just wonder, in terms of the moral and fiscal thing, would you think that the benefit bill should be cut from people who are already claiming? Do you understand if Mr Milburn is going to say that as opposed to future claimants? Because that would be different fiscally and morally, wouldn't it? Well, I kind of look at the bill as it is at the moment. I don't want to dwell too much on the fiscal element because that's not what's going to convince Labour MPs. But it is obviously incredibly important. Look at the bill at the moment and it is going up. It's not slowing down, it's going up.
18:21And so if you want to seriously make a dent in that and try and spend that money on other public services, try and get our borrowing costs down, you are going to have to look at existing claimants. I don't see any way around it. And that's what number 10 says at the moment. Privately, that is also what Alan Milburn is going to say, that you have to start taking benefits in some cases from people who already get them and you have to make very big changes. Before we dive into this I think it's important to say though that Milburn does absolutely make plain as does the government they are not talking about taking benefits away from people who have severe disabilities who have serious illness they are though talking in the
19:04margins about people who might have ADHD currently and be in receipt of some benefits or people who might have what might be determined as mild depression or anxiety. They are talking about things that are mental health conditions potentially, but they are not talking about taking benefits from people with serious disabilities. So we did an interview this week with Alan Milburn in Liverpool, which has one of the highest youth unemployment problems in the country. He puts figures, just to give you a flavour of it, at about £22 billion a year for the cost of unemployment support for people under 25. And his overall thing that I really took from the interview is he believes there's got to be a very dramatic swing of the pendulum from the money that goes on benefits currently, which dwarfs the amount that's spent helping people get into work, to basically what would be 25 to 1 all the way down to 2 to 1.
20:00And this is the first short clip of what we're going to hear from him today. So look, the welfare system's got two purposes, doesn't it it it's got a purpose to help people when they fall on hard times that should always be there if you've got a disability you should be helped for example but it's also got a purpose to help people into employment to get off welfare and into work and this pendulum has spun far too far from the one to the other, £25 to one, and we can take it, we think, to £2 to one. To do that, we've got to invest less in benefits, so we've got to be paying out less in benefits, let's be clear, spending less money on benefits and spending more money on employment support and creating opportunities for young people.
20:41And when people talk about the benefits bill, the only way of getting it down sustainably is to ensure that young people can get into work. And to get into work, they need more support and more opportunity to do so. Let's just take that in turn then, because if you want to get that ratio from 25 to 1 to 2 to 1, that implies two things. It implies extra cash for support and training, but also implies significant cuts to benefits. So where are the cuts going to fall? And can you say to us plainly today, there are going to be a lot of young people who are going to lose out? So there will be some young people who lose out, of course. But what we'll do is we'll make sure that the support is there and the opportunity is there for young people.
21:26So it's not a question about whether we spend money. It's how we spend it. I knew about investing, but I really didn't know how to go about it. Meet Corey, a Wealthfront client. With Wealthfront, I could put money in and it would automatically distribute it into a diversified portfolio. Then it starts to compound. The compounding compounds on the compounding. Just let it run and it's great. Over 1 million clients trust Wealthfront. We'll be right back. of the strategy used. Past performance does not guarantee future results. At Vrbo, we understand that even the best of plans sometimes need a little support. So we plan for the plot twists. Every booking is automatically backed by our Vrbo Care Guarantee,
22:13giving you confidence from the very start. Whenever you need help, it's ready. Before your stay, through the moments in between, and after your trip. Because a great trip starts with peace of mind and maybe a good playlist. But we trip starts with peace of mind and maybe a good playlist. But we've got the peace of mind part covered. Spend it. Alex, just give us some context. I mean, that is a huge change, isn't it? Yeah, it really could be. I think the thing about support and employment support is that, I mean, it's clearly not working so well, right? We can see that in the numbers because the turnout is just that that outturns, as it were. It's just it's clearly not working. And all these programs think Alan just referred to things like in the past, YTS, whatever.
23:00There has to be a better way of doing it and you have thousands of job centre plus staff across the country who are doing their best in a system that kind of pushes people towards health and disability benefits it's clearly not working for people and we've got a million people you know 18-25 I think it's 16-25 who are not in employment, education, training. Not all of them will be going back, will have the opportunity to go back to work. As you rightly said, there will be people who need to be fundamentally protected for the rest of their lives. But there has to be a strong, there has to be a significant cohort of people who can get specific help that they need to get back to work. And if you rebalance it to more kind of specialised or for each person having their own specific plan,
23:54it has to make a difference. That's expensive though, isn't it? At least in one of the controversial things that the opposition parties are likely to hammer Alan Milburn on next week as saying it might cost more in the short term when the benefits bill is already up here. And by the way, it might not make that much difference for years on end. It might not, but these things do take time. You know, the kind of results for some of these work programmes are kind of varied. Some of them are excellent, some of them are less good. But I must say, the state that the benefits bill and the department was left in from political opposition leaves a lot to be desired. So I'm really not sure they've got much room to be to be criticising. At least we are, at least Alan and Andy and the team and Pat are trying to make something new happen. The system that they left the Labour government is not working.
24:47Let's then talk about one of the other things that we know he is going to suggest, which is this notion that young people will have a legal entitlement, either to a job or to an apprenticeship or to the support, perhaps it might be mental health treatment, that would allow them and enable them to be ready to go to work. The NEET rate in our country has barely been below 10% in 25 years. Now, it's a lot higher than now. One of the reasons is that we've never had the permanence and the entitlements to say to a young person, if you put in effort, we will guarantee you an opportunity, an apprenticeship, a pre-apprenticeship, a college place, a job and we'll give you the support that you need to get there, some mental health support, some job coaching. But the deal is a very
25:34straightforward one. If there's more opportunities for young people, there's got to be more obligations on their part to take up that opportunity. What we can't have is a generation living on benefits a disaster for them and it's a disaster for the taxpayer let's just take those in turn though so if you give young people a legal right to a job an apprenticeship a training place or the support they need to get into work does that mean then you're going to give a whole generation essentially the right to sue the government or their council if the opportunities aren't there for them. Isn't that a minefield? We're not going to avoid that elephant trap. Believe me. But you can put it in law. But we are going to have a duty on government to provide
26:16opportunities. We're calling it the opportunity guarantee. So there should be a guarantee for a young person because at the moment the only guarantee they've got is to a very simple thing, to get a benefit. What sort of a right life is that? I mean, seriously? So it sounds like a much tastier carrot, but a much sharper stick. I mean, this legal entitlement, and it was explained to me, it might be a bit like councils have a legal responsibility to accommodate children in care or to try and give advice or accommodation to a homeless person. So it will not, as I wondered, be, you know, a 17-year-old can phone up the government and say, I'm taking you to court because I didn't get a job being a supermodel.
26:54But it does sound, Alex, to my ear at least, a bit like the kind of thing that politicians quite like announcing. But in practice, it might be more problematic. What do you think of that idea? Well, look, we'll see. is quite like announcing, but in practice it might be more problematic. What do you think of that idea? Well, look, we'll see. We'll see on that when the rubber hits the road. But I think fundamentally there has to be a greater element of conditionality in the system. I mean, it's there. It's always existed. It's always going to exist. And that means you've got to do this or you don't get your cash. Or if you've got cash and you don't go and find a job, you lose the money. That would be my approach.
27:30And I wonder what you make of some of the opposition, because here is Nadia Whittam, the Labour MP. Cutting health and disability support will not create new jobs or help young people into work. And it would be disingenuous to pretend otherwise. Look, the thing is that, for me, the Labour Party is about rights and responsibilities. Yes, we will give people... I mean, Alan, I'm not we, obviously. Alan can... He'll be spiritually on his side. No, totally, spiritually on Alan's side, 100%. They will say, you've got to do this. You're going to get the right, this legal obligation, you're going to get this right to take to an opportunity. But you do have to take the responsibility. My worry is that some people are a bit squeamish about this
28:26and a bit like, well, we'll accept the rights, but not the responsibilities bit. And that is, for me, the most important thing. There has to be that contract between government and the people. There has to be. But here is the big question. The last time that you and Liz Kendall and Keir Starmer tried to do this, you ran into trouble. As you said, we weren't able to make the argument because you didn't have time. But it ended up being a massively humiliating political climb down. It did. Now the gamble for Alan Milburn and Andy Burnham is that the political climate is now different. There's a Prime Minister that appears to be doing better in the polls. The PLP, the Parliamentary Labour Party,
29:05the backbenchers are pretty happy. Pat McFadden's been rolling the pitch. Pat McFadden has been spending all this time, it seems like, trying to talk to MPs and get them in what he would think is the right place in order to support this. But as a Labour insider, to what extent do you think the mood has changed? And as and when we start seeing specific proposals, you know, Joe Bloggs would lose £20 a week. Yeah. How many people are going to be behind it then? We'll see. Look, what you described there was the kind of moment that basically ended it for us. I think there was a couple of leaks, as there are inevitably in Whitehall. Yeah, sorry about that. Yeah, usually I can't... Usually to Laura Koonsman.
29:54No, not these days. It's normally her fault. Yes, we've got so much in it. And there was that moment where people could see the specifics of how, you know, Joe Bloggs is going to lose, is on PIP and he's going to lose £20. And you're always going to have kind of nuances in the system where you have, I remember specifically there was a case of somebody who said their constituent couldn't kind of wash themselves but was liable to lose PIP. And obviously you have to be extremely careful about this. You do. But I think I take a step back and look at the big picture as Andy's brought a kind of new... Energy. Energy to the... A new kind of energy to the PLP and Labour politics more generally. But taking a step back,
30:48I don't think it's acceptable for us to go into another election having not done something quite significant on welfare because the Conservative Party and the Reform Party will come for us. And on the left, obviously the Green Party will come for us on it. But, you know, that's a Party will come for us on it. But, you know, that's a whole different argument about their viability. So in other words, you can handle noises off from some left-wing Labour MPs who've already been teasing at that, and there will certainly be a few of them, and you can handle noises off from the Greens, and maybe the SNP in Scotland, who might make this a campaigning issue, maybe. But the more important thing, in your view,
31:27is to get this done. Partly to face down Tories and reform, but also because you believe it's the right thing to do. It's the right thing to do, to speak to the country and say, we have done this, we have dealt with this. And we don't have, you know... Look, by the time of the next election, obviously it's not going to have made a massive impact. Well, that's what I was going to say, because can you say we've dealt with it, it's not going to have made a massive impact. Well, that's what I was going to say, because can you say we've dealt with if it's going to take 10 years? I think you can say that progress has been made. Well, I wonder how progress will be made in two different areas. For instance, it might be harder, I think this was in the Tim's review, to cut PIP payments. It might be harder to do that in this parliament.
32:02And I'm not making the case to cut PIP payments. I interviewed a man who was going to lose disability payments under your scheme, and he was very upset about it. So I'm not making a point. I'm just saying, is it going to be harder to deliver PIP reductions than a sort of unemployment benefit? I mean... Jobseeker's allowance. I can speak from my experience of being part of that team that did try to reduce Pip it's really difficult, it's really really hard but that's the point of politics it is hard doing hard things, that's the point of being in power so good luck to them, no honestly I don't mean that in any cynical way. Good luck to them because they go with my full support because it's such a critical issue and we have to get this right. We can't duck it again.
33:03It's another interesting thing. I got the impression from speaking to Alan Milburn at some length about all of this. And our interview will be on the show in the morning. And there's a flavour of it out on the news today. He clearly sees this as something for right across the government. As you said, this is not just about DWP, Department for Work and Pensions. It's about the health system and the education system as well as the welfare system and goodness knows all the systems. But I just wondered also if this might come at a very helpful moment for Andy Barnum. There are lots of political dangers, as you've alluded to, but there's also a sense he's meant to have this big 10-year plan. He's had a lot of big rhetoric, not so many big concrete plans. You know, if Alan Milburn plays his cards right, could this actually rather conveniently turn up as being Andy Burnham's big vision for what he really wants to do? suggested to me actually he's done his sort of triple lock moment which was about a new deal a different settlement for the older generation where you might lose a bit of the planned
34:10increases in pensions but you get a better deal because you'll get a national care service this is the equivalent sort of mirror image for the younger generation so benefits will be harder to get yes and they might be lower than they were going to be, but you get a better deal in terms of your life chances. And I just thought that was quite an interesting thing. You know, if Andy Barham's scratching around for a big idea, maybe this is the one. I think it's a really interesting way of putting it. It's probably the right one. But there's also, you know, the welfare system is not just out of work benefits and it's not just PIP. It's also the pension system. That is obviously the most expensive part of the system
34:51and he's already started to tackle that. It'll come down by billions and billions of pounds over the next 20, 30 years. Now's the time to do it on this particular issue. And they're doing it the right way because going through young people is pretty much the only way you're going to be able to get this through. Because there's so many arguments in favour of it. And yet it's going to be hard. Because aren't there also quite a lot of arguments against it? Not least from people who were delighted to see Andy Burnham come back thinking, oh, he's properly of the left. He's not like some terrible playwright like Alan Milburn, an expensive nipmire who's going to come and say it's all about the market.
35:30Who, by the way, ironically, is actually suggesting a very big expansion of the state. That's one of the real, if you're a Sado like me, from a philosophical point of view, it's really interesting. Alan Milburn, who used to be all about markets and getting the private sector into the NHS, is actually suggesting a really big expansion of the state. But do you think that for some of Andy Barnum's supporters, if he really goes for this in a full-throated way, they're going to be like, hang on, I thought you were a lefty. The Tories would say, oh, he's a traditional socialist. Well, I think there's two things there. Number one is that you might call might call it a big expansion of the state. I think for, I think actually it's reforming the state. And that is, you know, what Tony did really very well. And they have done a very good job in laying the groundwork for this. No one should be surprised by what will come on Tuesday and what will come in the Timbs review, really.
36:28That's very candidly where you began. It's really appreciated that you should own up to some, what you said was a big mistake by the team you were part of, effectively. Not in the principle, but in the delivery. You said you didn't get it right. I wouldn't accept that we made the mistake. It was the Treasury. I'm not going to say any more. It was the Treasury. I'm not going to say any more. It was the Treasury. I'm not going to say any more. Soap with your eyes. That's all your best line, isn't it? Or you say you're saying it with your eyes. But the thing is, what we can say, you say they've done a good job, they've got Keir Starmer's majority and they've got Rachel Reeves' growth. So what Laura's getting at, and I'm her translator on these matters,
37:04is when are we going to see Burnham Burnham? He does an awful lot of chatting about what's coming up. My 10-year plan. You called him Al-Inqara a couple of weeks ago. I said there's a risk of being seen as chatting. You called him Al-Inqara. After the next election, after the next election. And so I think this is it. This is the rubber hitting the road on Tuesday. It's a big moment. There's no doubt about it. And the government has been building up to this for a long, long time. Well, you know, before, obviously before Andy came in and it was something that started under Keir. But I think you have seen the authentic Andy, actually. I mean, the conference speech, going back to that, I was speaking to people from inside Number 10 in the hours afterwards
37:43and they were saying to me, that was him. And whether, you know, you have to respect that somebody's going to go out there and say, this is what I believe. Andrew Neil, who's not a natural Andy Burnham supporter, called that one of the most consequential conference leaders' speech he has seen. And he's even more seasoned than you. But that's the, I think that's the authentic answer. Look, I don't know, Andy. It's going to be deeds. Deeds. Well, that's the thing. It's deeds not words. And I think you're right. I think that speech and Barnum, he is what you see, really. He is that politician, but he loves chatting and he loves chatting about things happening in the medium to long term. But the actual decisions he's going to make
38:23in response to this are the things that might really, really count. But wouldn't it be ironic if Keir Starmer, who he deposed, has actually left Andy Burnham something that he can grab onto and create a sense of political momentum and actually see his big rhetoric be matched by big change? And on chat, the editor has put down his hip flask and asked that we reluctantly bring this to a close. But I was trying to thank you earlier, and then you started saying I'd misquoted you. So let me just thank you this time for coming in on a Saturday. You're very welcome. It's very nice of you to come in and give us some insight and also a feeling of what it must be like inside government when you're trying to do these big and hard things,
39:01because they are big, hard things. And sometimes as journalists, we can maybe be a little bit snarky. Skepticism. Skepticism is correct. Snark, maybe not. What are you doing tomorrow? So I am doing more on the weather. It's a weather bomb. OK. And also I'm looking at why some chief executives get into trouble. They're very lionised, like Jensen Huang, but they have their invincibility is also their vulnerability it's explained by. It's lionising what they call it these days. Yes. Lionising. We will have Milburn on the programme tomorrow and Pat McFadden the Welfare Secretary who is Dobb it will be to respond specifically to what Alan Milburn has to say and Alan Milburn has very helpfully said
39:44on tape there's nothing in this report that they don't know is coming. So Pat McFadden will not be able to say on the red chair tomorrow morning, we'll have to wait and see for the proposals on full on Tuesday. Which is what some MPs are saying. It is what some MPs are saying. So we will be reunited tomorrow. We'll look forward to seeing you then. But I think that is it. Thank you very much indeed to Alex for coming and talking to us today. Goodbye for now. Newscast. Newscast from the BBC. Well, thank you for making it to the end of another newscast. You clearly ooze stamina. Can I gently encourage you to subscribe to us on BBC Sounds? And then, without having to do anything else, our meandering chats will miraculously make its way to your phone.
40:36In Our Time is a world-class seminar every week. Why was Jeremy a lonely snail? What were lions doing in York in the third century? I'm Misha Glenny and every week I'm joined by expert guests to explore the ideas that shape our world. It's one of the first times really that you consistently see someone painting teeth. I know that sounds bonkers. If I was going to define mathematics, I would say it's the study of structure. In our time, listen on bbc.com or wherever you get your podcasts. Tea or coffee? Love a cup of tea.



