Newscast · · Transcript & summary by WhipScribe
A BBC Newscast preview of Alan Milburn's youth employment review explains why hiring young people has become costly and what the government could do about it.
Tap a chapter to open that moment in the transcript; the link to it is copied for you.
“But I think most businesses would say that a closer relationship with our biggest, nearest market would be a good thing.” Simon Jack · at 22:43 — open in the transcript →
Alan Milburn's review into young people who are not in work, education or training is due on Tuesday, and the Newscast hosts treat it as a rollout the government has been staging in pieces for weeks. Each preview has added a layer, from an offer to young jobseekers, to a rebuilt benefits system, to incentives for employers. The hosts expect ministers to lean on the report as both a guide and a way to bring Labour MPs along, while warning that it is a decade-long plan whose savings arrive late.
The hardest barrier is the cost of hiring a young person. Employer National Insurance rose in April 2025 and its threshold fell sharply, minimum wages for 18 to 20 year olds have climbed faster than inflation, and new day-one employment rights add risk. Milburn suggests cutting employer taxes on younger workers' pay gradually, but only when the economy allows, and pausing the planned convergence of youth and adult minimum wages. The hosts point out that the national insurance changes cover only retail and hospitality, leaving a Nottingham hairdresser who cannot afford apprentices out of reach.
The episode then turns to Brussels, where the prime minister is due at a summit on Friday and has set out three golden rules for EU dealings: consistency with Labour's manifesto red lines, an improved Brexit deal closer to what voters expected in 2016, and visible gains in everyday life. Business groups see closer EU ties as a growth boost. Finally, a message from Russell Brand, relayed by his wife Laura Brand, prompted Downing Street to say it was appalled and to look into possible breaches of prison rules.
Simon Jack said employer National Insurance rose from 13.8% to 15% in April 2025, and that the threshold was lowered from £9,100 to £5,000, which hit employers hard. He said Alan Milburn accepts these changes did not create the NEETs crisis but made a bad situation worse, and that Milburn wants to reverse them gradually.
“Employers' national insurance not only went up from 13.8% to 15% effective April 2025”Simon Jack · 6:15
Simon Jack said the national living wage for people aged 21 and over, and the minimum wage for 18 to 20 year olds, have risen far faster than inflation. He said that, combined with new employment rights from day one, younger people have become more expensive and riskier to hire, which is why Milburn wants the planned convergence of the two rates paused.
“the cocktail is that younger people are more expensive and they're riskier to hire”Simon Jack · 9:11
Simon Jack said most businesses would argue that Brexit has cost more than it has gained, citing the paperwork, costs and red tape of exporting to the EU, and that 25% of smaller exporters gave up exporting to the EU entirely. He said most businesses would welcome a closer relationship with their biggest, nearest market.
“But I think most businesses would say that a closer relationship with our biggest, nearest market would be a good thing.”Simon Jack · 22:43
The hosts previewed Alan Milburn's review, due on Tuesday, as a ten-year plan to move young people who are not in work, education or training into jobs, with incentives for employers and gradual cuts in employer taxes on younger workers when the economy allows. They expect little fiscal saving until years nine or ten.
Alan Milburn's review, due to be published on Tuesday, sets out a ten-year plan to reduce the number of young people who are not in employment, education or training. The Newscast hosts describe it as a roadmap built in three parts: an offer of support to young people, a change to the benefits system, and incentives for employers to hire them.
The hosts say employers face a combined cost. Employer National Insurance rose from 13.8% to 15% in April 2025, and the threshold at which it becomes payable fell from £9,100 to £5,000. Minimum wages for 18 to 20 year olds have also risen far faster than inflation, and new employment rights from day one add to the perceived risk of hiring.
Simon Jack said most businesses would argue that the costs, paperwork and red tape of leaving the EU outweigh the gains, and that a quarter of smaller exporters gave up exporting to the EU altogether. He said most businesses would welcome a closer relationship with their biggest, nearest market, and noted a Bank of England estimate of around 0.4% extra GDP growth in a short time.
Before a Brussels summit on Friday, the prime minister set out three rules for dealings with the EU. Any arrangement must be consistent with Labour's manifesto and government red lines, which rule out the customs union, the single market and free movement. It must improve the Brexit deal toward what people thought they were voting for in 2016, and it must deliver real, tangible improvements in people's everyday lives.
Laura Brand, Russell Brand's wife, posted a video on YouTube relaying a message from him in prison, in which he confirmed he was held in a Cambridgeshire prison and said he was not guilty. Downing Street said it was appalled that he could effectively broadcast a claim of innocence from behind bars, and said it is looking into whether prison rules were breached.
Milburn proposes lowering the taxes employers pay on younger people's wages gradually over time, because cutting them all at once would be too expensive. The Treasury would only do this when economic conditions are low, which makes it a political judgment about when to start reducing employer National Insurance on young people.
The hosts say the Milburn plan is a ten-year strategy with no quick wins, and that overall fiscal savings to government are unlikely to appear until late in the period, perhaps years nine or ten. They expect a political argument over what counts as benefit spending and what counts as wider support spending, since the package spends more in the short term.
Our own transcript of the public episode, with a timestamp about every 90 seconds. Tap a timestamp or the link button on a paragraph to copy a link that opens this page there.
0:00This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK. It's why we've been ranked number one in innovation for more than a decade. Your future is worth preparing for, and you don't have to prepare alone. Become future ready. Explore more than 400 programs at asuonline.asu.edu. That's a degree better. What does the history of nuclear weapons tell us about what could happen with AI? I'm Asma Khalid, co-host of the Global Story podcast from the BBC. Coming up, we kick off a special week of episodes that digs into the backstory and global ramifications of the most earth-shattering technology the world has seen in decades. We'll speak to the history podcaster Dan Carlin about how the rise of AI compares to the dawn of the nuclear age. For more,
1:01listen to the Global Story on bbc.com or wherever you get your podcasts. Hello. It's been heavily discussed in the media for, well, years now. There have been loads of rumours. There have actually been some quite big hints from the people themselves. And now Robert Pattinson has finally been announced as the new James Bond after years of speculation. He will be the seventh official James Bond, but the eighth person to play the role if you include david nevin in that weird non-official james bond film of casino royale which no one's ever seen now what does that remind me of what what how's that process played out exactly the same but in politics oh yeah the alan milburn review which has gone through the same
1:40rigmarole is finally being published on tuesday And we've had some more heavy hints about what's going to be in it. So we will discuss that, even though the new James Bond is my out-of-work passion, on this episode of Cast Newscast. Newscast. Newscast from the BBC. Humanity's next great voyage begins. I don't know who the Prime Minister is, Mike. I'm Andy and I'm not looking at my best right now. I see that he was, I guess, the mayor of a town. Everyone assumes that you must be a traitor. And what will you do? Stare at a wall. Do we play music now or what do we do? Hello, it's Adam in the Newscast studio. And it's Chris at Westminster. And Simon Jack is here too. Hello, Simon. Hello, Adam. Right, I'm trying to think of a name for what we could call today
2:20because it's the day before the publication of Alan Milburn's review into the Neats. I can tell you what somebody in government called it. What? They called it Milburn Eve to me. That's not the original. Not wildly original, but it tells you something about the kind of countdown that they've been going through in terms of what we've seen and heard of Alan Milburn in the last handful of days and then the wider argument they've been making in the last couple of weeks and months. So, yeah, not original but a sense of the mentality if you like around the significance of well not just tomorrow but the whole if you like, setting out of this argument which we've been in the in the throes of for quite a while now.
2:57So I was going to say I would call it Milburn's night. Milburn's night that's better. Oh that's quite good, yeah that's good. But that's the night of the thing rather than the day before. I just have to say, Chris, this is quite an odd report, isn't it? In the sense that it is ostensibly recommendations from an independent person. And yet it has been stage managed and delivered with some skill, I have to say, by the DWP on a daily basis. We've been fed it piecemeal. Yeah, the Department for Work and Pensions are absolutely sort of in the thick of all of this. And what we're seeing is, yes, someone at least semi-detached from government as the, you know, the principal author and driver of this in Alan Milburn,
3:43but also absolutely the government and indeed Mr Milburn, because he'd like to see the ideas that he's fleshing out become reality, try to take, well, the country in the broad sense, and then in particular Labour MPs with him step by step so that no element of it is surprising, so that they feel like they are involved in the conversation privately and publicly and in the formulation of the policy, which obviously does not end on Tuesday when this thing is published. And I think they felt that they learnt politically Labour as a party from Keir Starmer's attempts at changing the benefits system 18 months ago was basically didn't do anywhere near enough of all of those things. And so, yes, they will argue this or not they're going to back this,
4:47is absolutely central to this. And they've been very kind of deft and thoughtful in how they've gone about approaching that. And I think we've had three phases of this, of this never-ending preview. So phase one was what can the government do? What's the offer to young people who are not in employment, education or training? Phase two was, how do they change the benefit systems to basically create a new parallel benefit system for 125s? And I feel we got phase three today in some of the newspapers, Simon, which is what incentives will be given to business to employ a young person that they might not otherwise have employed? Yeah, yes. And the DWP have been very clear that they think that the ones that you talked about, stages one and two,
5:27were, if you like, the supply side. How do you create a supply of employable young people with skills that you need and get them out of benefits into some kind of productive educational training? They see today's measures as the demand side of it. So Alan Milburn will say to you, there's no point in creating and giving skills to these people, to young people, if there are no jobs for them to go and fill. So this is an offer to employers, a recommendation to try and reduce the cost of hiring younger people by gradually lowering the taxes employers pay on younger people's wages. Now, this is an awkward one for the government because one of the big problems that business leaders and employers will tell you
6:15is that quite the opposite has been happening over the last couple of years. Because that's employers' national insurance. Employers' national insurance not only went up from 13.8% to 15% effective April 2025 from the July 2024 budget, from the November 2024 budget, I beg your pardon. But also, and the big oof moment for employers was lowering the threshold from £9,100 to £5,000, at which point that tax becomes payable. And so, now, Alan Milburn was saying that these changes didn't create the NEETs crisis. It has been a long burning thing, but it has gone up in the last couple of years. And I think it's a tacit acknowledgement that government policy in the last couple of years has made a bad
6:56situation worse. And he's looking to reverse it, not in its entirety, that's going to be too expensive. But over time, gradually lowering the tax burden on employers, he hopes will make it, you know, will make them keener to hire. And also, Chris, this seems to come with a big caveat, which is the Treasury will be able to only do this when economic conditions are low. In other words, there would be a political judgment about when to start ratcheting employer nicks on young people, start ratcheting it down. Indeed so. And this is where it collides, isn't it, with a whole other slew of competing demands or things beyond the government's immediate control in terms of the wider economic picture.
7:34I think what's interesting both on this point and more widely is an argument that we will hear from Alan Milburn, which the government seems to be acknowledging, which is that what previously might have been an argument about equalising, if you like, rights, terms and conditions for younger workers versus older ones because of a sense of an age discrimination, is that there's a wider argument now that acknowledges or is seeking to emphasise that someone sort of straight out of college or straight out of university or straight out of education in a job is not likely to offer as much value added as somebody five, six, seven, eight years older. In other words, someone who is still young, still the right side of 30, for instance, but has vastly more experience than the person who has just arrived. And that
8:25rather than an instinct to say that there shouldn't be, if you like, anything that acknowledges that reality, in other words, you're trying to close gaps, whether it be around pay or tax, that actually, particularly given the scale of the problem, you don't want to have additional kind of government ideas, however well-intentioned, making a difficult situation even trickier. Simon, I don't hang around with a lot of business people. It's your entire job to hang around with business people. How much is the cost of employing a young person the barrier to employing the young person? Because part of me thinks tweaking the national insurance rate or threshold is quite marginal. There are three components to it in a way. One is the national insurance, which we've
9:11talked about. The other one is we've seen very hefty increases in the national living wage for people 21 and over, the national minimum wage for people aged 18 to 20, far exceeding the rate of inflation. So that has also been part of it. The third part of it has been a slew of new employment rights from day one around sick pay, what have you. Also about unfair dismissal, bringing the threshold of when you can start to apply for that from two years to six months. You add all of that together and the cocktail is that younger people are more expensive and they're riskier to hire, which going back to Chris's point, which is that why would I take a risk on someone who's 19 when I can get someone who's 27
9:53and actually I'm not getting much of a discount or not getting the discount I used to on hiring a younger person, which is why John Healy in his budget and Alan Milburn will endorse this in his report saying that this convergence between the minimum wages for 18 to 20 year olds and 21 plus, that convergence, which was part of Labour manifesto, or Labour policy, should be put on pause, because Milburn recognises that you do still need that discount. So you're right, the National Insurance is one lever to tweak. There are other ones. And we have seen some pre-tweaking of that, both in the budget. And Simon, there's a quite interesting case study on the BBC News website of a hairdresser called Colette in Nottingham,
10:37who's been talking about the cost of taking on young people. She used to have 21 staff, but that's now halved. She used to employ eight apprentices a year she now can't afford to take on any and she says it costs around 60 000 pounds to train an apprenticeship and then she says before we can actually start allowing them onto any customer's heads and what's interesting about that is that um i've seen some of those seen some of colette's comments and she actually amazingly said she's had parents coming up to her offering to pay the wages of their children in order for them to get trained because they're so desperate to get their kids into some kind of profession. I get around, I'd say about 50 to 55 CVs a week, messages on Facebook, Instagram, all of the social media.
11:21We have parents offering to pay their wages. So we'll take them. We have parents offering to pay their wages, so we'll take them. We have apprentices offering to work for free. But as an, obviously, ethical employer, I can't do that. The desperation is palpable, but it's also the other side, the heartache that I can't take these people. What's interesting about the Milburn review and the things we've just talked about just now is that these changes to national insurance which are the headline stuff today will only apply to retail and hospitality. That will not include that, you know, hairdressers for example. Because retail and hospitality are seen as the big employers of younger people. So these tweaks to
12:00national insurance won't affect Colette. Other measures in the overall package may, but these ones in particular will not. And actually, I'm just thinking of reading some of the reports in the newspapers this morning. So the Times, for example, which was picking up on the national insurance cut, they were also talking about there being financial incentives for businesses when they take somebody on. So maybe you'll get a few thousand pounds if you hire and eat. So maybe collect could benefit from that. And that's why I think that, and Chris may want to come in on this, why opposition parties have said it's a bit perverse that you're basically, you know, you've raised taxes on employers to take people on and now you're subsidising people
12:41to be taken on by employers. And what their line is. I think it was Helen Waitley, Shadow Work and Pensions Secretary, said the answer is just stop the taxing was her line. Yeah, completely. And it's interesting, isn't it? Because that gets to the big picture principle of the, you know, how much state intervention is useful, state intervention. What about the argument that amounts to if the government's instincts have been to get out of the way in the first place, you might not have created some of these contributory factors that made the cost of employing younger people so much the higher. I think the argument we're going to hear from government in the next couple of days is conscious that they are, that they've got to land a message broadly, but also with their own side, that means that some current recipients of some benefits will get less in the future
13:32because of the desire to channel money in the direction of wider support in terms of employment support, education support, leaning into and emphasising exactly that, that employment and education support, as a way of persuading those who otherwise might find that benefit cut kind of politically hard to swallow. And Alan Milburn's final report will be published on Tuesday morning, at last. Although I feel there's not going to be any surprises in there. It's well trailed. I'm just keen to know to what status this report will actually have. Because, you know, I've seen big reports before. And this is a big one. It's 250, 300 pages long. And sometimes these reports, you know, become the kind of, you know, North Star for policy.
14:16And sometimes they end up collecting dust in the bottom of some civil servant's drawer. Andrew Dilnot's reforms for social care, they become both. Yes. For 20 years. What's your sense, Chris, about, you know, is Andy Burnham wedded to this report in all its glory? My hunch, and as I utter this sentence, I'm conscious that this is one that gets wheeled out and played back in May of next year on a newscast with me looking like a fool. My hunch would be that this will be closer to the North Star than the dusty thing at the bottom of the filing cabinet I think the government will embrace much of this now it's fair to say there'll be a lot of the detail that will still be key in terms of how this is legislated
15:00for what the time frames look like how you get the timelines right as many MPs would see it, so that support is there before potentially a benefit kicks in. You know, where are those potential cliff edges, thresholds between those who are, for instance, described as profoundly disabled and those who aren't. Lots and lots of details that will matter. But I think the government will lean on this and use Alan milburn's report as both a crutch in terms of them saying look this is what milburn says we ought to do so we ought to do it um and then but also as a kind of way marker for for what they think is uh what they think is necessary so what a crutch shoved into the ground by the side of the road pointing that
15:44way and a battering ram through the uh back benches maybe as well So what, a crutch shoved into the ground by the side of the road, pointing their way? And a battering ram through the back benches maybe as well. Wow, so a crutch that you put into the ground to show the direction and then you hit your enemies with. It's worth saying also that there's no costings really around this. All we do know is that this is going to be a 10-year plan and I expect the report to say that you will not see the benefit fiscally in terms of overall bringing down the cost to government of all this stuff until very late in that period, maybe years nine or even 10. So this is a long term strategy where there's no quick wins here, I don't think.
16:18And so you'll see, and we've started seeing this already, quite a loud public argument about what benefit spending is actually defined as. Because if we allow ourselves to imagine that this sort of tram track down the next handful of years runs as Alan Milburn would like it to, you'll get into a discussion, I would have thought, fairly quickly about, yeah, what are we counting as benefit spending and what are we counting as that wider support spending? Now now as alan milburn makes clear this is a this is a best part of a decade before uh there's any overall fiscal saving but you can see there being a political argument that some would see as useful from their perspective where you say ah the benefits bill is shrinking granted we're spending as much and perhaps more in the
17:01short term on the wider package uh but that, as they would see it, has wider societal benefits. So, yeah, I think we'll start to see that argument bubbling away if the government presses ahead with the kind of roadmap that Alan Milburn's setting out. And here's my mini prediction, in that from lunchtime on Tuesday, this stops being kind of one man's crusade, and it can all be handily bundled together in a thing called the Milburn Report. And it becomes a much more diffuse thing that involves the Treasury at the next budget, a bit of legislation here, some tweaks to some regulations there, some incentives for businesses, some new programmes to be set up, some trial schemes. It stops becoming one big thing that everyone can see and talk about and make podcasts about and just becomes some more bits of daily government policy tweaking.
17:50And so it's less easy to sort of see what's being done. And so it would feel maybe a bit less like a very obvious mission. But yet we'll still have the big headline badge of the Milburn Report as a, you know, to give it a sort of imprimatur of sort of, you know, thought out, credible, coherent, joined up thinking. Almost like a kite mark. Correct. Right. If you thought the Milburn Report was a long running saga, let me remind you of Brexit. So actually, Simon, remind me, the Lord mayor's banquets in the city right yes like there's the there's the banking one that the chancellor does yeah what's that what is that the lord that's the professional services dinner basically which have the lord mayor and you have
18:35the chancellor there yeah but then chris the one tonight is the other lord mayor's banquet where they talk about and it's the prime minister and they talk about foreign and it's the Prime Minister, and they talk about foreign policy. Yeah, they get their posh clobber out and they talk about foreign policy. And usually it's a sort of cast around the UK's place in the world and the Prime Minister's take on various things going on geopolitically around the world. And there will be that tonight. But obviously the timing of it this year is that it's, what, four days shy of this summit in Brussels on Friday. And so a fair chunk of it, certainly, I think, in terms of the bit that catches the eyes of folk like me, and newscasters is the whole business of what he's
19:17saying on the European Union. And what was striking is that normally prior to these speeches, because often the speech that the Prime Minister gives at this event isn't necessarily wildly newsmaking. And so they might tell us in advance a little bit of what they're going to say, a couple of paragraphs, if that, maybe literally a paragraph. Last night, you can tell I'm waffling a bit because I'm scrolling through my emails at the same time trying to find it. Last night, they sent out an absolutely whopping trail. Now, number of words is not necessarily always the same as stuff within a trail. But yeah, they are keen, again, to lean into the broader argument that the Prime Minister is making. It's one that newscasters will be
19:56familiar with his view that Brexit hasn't worked as was sold. And then him setting out his stall for what he hopes to achieve on Friday. then an element of his longer-term stuff. And he's got three new golden rules for his dealings with the EU. He has. He has, although I don't think these are wildly earth-shattering. These are that it must be consistent with the manifesto and the government's red lines. That's the whole business about the customs union, the single market and no free movement. It must improve the Brexit deal, of course, improve is in the eye of the beholder, and bring it closer to what people thought they were voting for in 2016. Rather, as he puts it, than the hard Brexit that
20:36no one seriously argued for in the referendum. That's his argument. And third, and this is interesting that he's coming back to this, it must pass the make a field test by delivering real tangible improvements in people's everyday lives. And he wrote a piece in the Daily Mirror this morning focusing on that. And it was intriguing on Friday, quite a few of us were made aware by friends of the prime minister of a by-election result for a council seat in his constituency in make a field in which Labour won a seat that had been held by an independent for years and years and years and the argument that his friends were making was that you know if people thought that there was any kind of Brexit backlash in a leave voting seat
21:16to the Prime Minister's rather pro European tone of the last few months then so their argument went this by-election proved otherwise. Now I'm sure there were 101 other things that might have motivated the voters of that corner of the makefield constituency as well as what the prime minister is saying about the eu but nonetheless it shows you an extent to which they are aware of that argument that either says look what the prime minister said when he was a by-election candidate versus what he's saying as prime minister in other words he's sounding a lot more pro-eu or that sense that here's a prime minister who who represents a seat that was solidly for leave who's now sounding pretty uh pretty pro-eu so that you know it shows the extent to which they
21:56are aware of taking the country with them step by step yeah um simon i know you've got to go do you want to have a parting words on eu relations? I think that most businesses would say that, would agree with Andy Bellum's assessment, which is he said, I think we've lost more than we've won. Because clearly in the negative column are the processes, the costs, the red tape, the forms you've got to fill in. And we know that 25% of smaller exporters just gave up entirely of exporting to the EU. And we know that, for example, that on food and things like shellfish and whatever, those were very important markets. In the positive column, they'll point to things like the India trade deal, what started
22:43out as being a better deal with the US and kind of ended up in the same place as the rest of the EU, frankly, and also the TCPCC, or I'm not sure I've got the right C's and P's in there, and sort of saying that those things wouldn't have been possible without it. But I think most businesses would say that a closer relationship with our biggest, nearest market would be a good thing. And he has been, Andy Byrne has been very keen to jump on comments by the Bank of England and others to say that there might be 0.4% of extra GDP growth in pretty short order. And if you're faced with something like that and growth is one of your top priorities, then you've got to grab that with both hands. And I think it's going to be interesting,
23:24this dance he's going to have to do around what happens to the existing things we've done since then. And it's been some areas of divergence on things like gene-edited tomatoes and all that kind of stuff. So there's stuff to work through for sure, but stopping short of saying, you know, of membership of the EU, membership of the single market, membership of the customs union. Simon, thank you very much. Thank you, Adam. Yeah, Chris, just in terms of the single market, membership of the customs union. Simon, thank you very much. Thank you, Adam. Yeah, Chris, just in terms of the sequencing here, because is Andy Burnham talking about what's going to happen on Friday at this summit? Because, I mean, Labour's general election manifesto red lines don't come into these
23:56mini deals that Keir Starmer started negotiating. And the make a field test, well, is the make a field test going to be applied to these mini deals on Friday? And maybe Andy Burnham will say, oh, no, I don't want to do them after all. I'm just a bit confused about what these three rules are for. Yeah, I'm not sure we should attach a wild amount of significance to the three rules. Not because they're not significant, but just because, broadly speaking, we either knew about them, i.e. the red lines, or, you know, it's an argument about, as the Prime Minister put it, delivering real tangible improvements as he sees them. Well, I mean, of course, he would make that argument about changes he's making at any level and with anyone,
24:33let alone in this kind of context. And then the second one is, you know, this idea that the Brexit deal, you know, isn't anywhere near what most people thought they were going to get as he puts it, which again is an argument we've sort of heard before. But I think it gets to the essence, Adam, of the tricky thing that number 10 has to navigate here, which is they've got the stuff on Friday, a lot of which they're inheriting from Keir Starmer, which they'll go along and there'll be the moments on Friday in a news conference and we'll hear the counter-arg argument from Nigel Farage and the Conservatives and others, etc, etc. And then there's the wider stuff that the Prime Minister started talking about.
25:12And from his perspective, the slightly tricky thing, and we were reflecting on this, weren't we, in our conversation with Stuart Ingham, the former Downing Street advisor last week, that you then, you're only one sentence away. One minute you're talking about smoky bacon crisps. The next minute you're talking about rejoining the EU. And how does Downing Street manage that conversation so that there isn't necessarily a race immediately to that second point? Not least because we're seeing the campaign groups on the other side of the argument, if you like, the Brexit side of the argument popping up and making their arguments, that sense that, oh, here we go again. Perhaps the fundamentals of Brexit
25:55need to be argued about once again. So the prime minister, in talking principally about friday is also framing that wider argument about the longer term and then we'll have to see because we were promised that he would talk much more about the longer term around the summit well it's not going to happen prior to it so at what point afterwards and in what forum does he talk about the wider stuff and And to what extent after Friday, as journalists are always thinking of the next thing, aren't we? To what extent after Friday does he continue leaning into his sort of, for want of a neater way of putting it, his pro-European positioning that we've seen a lot of in the last couple of months? Or does he just rein it back a bit?
26:41I don't mean by that changing his mind or adopting a different stance, but almost an issue around prominence and frequency. Does that just dial back a bit in order to create space for him to talk about other stuff? Because that's a decision. That's a decision that's up to him to an extent. Just thinking back to those three rules, which, yes, you very diplomatically said not to fixate on, but I'm sort of now ignoring you and fixating on them. It's just another reminder of Andy Burnham starting to sound a bit like Theresa May, because this is the sort of thing she used to do. And she was a remainer having to rebrand herself as a Brexiteer. Andy Burnham is a rejoiner who for the meantime has to rebrand
27:22himself as a Brexiteer because his initial objective is to make the Brexit deal work better because as you said, he doesn't want to get drawn fully into the whole rejoin argument. So he's got to say things like, oh, we've got to stick to not joining the single market and it's got to work for the British people is to achieve that purpose. Completely. And that's not just for an audience back home who might be sceptical about the reopening of the whole Brexit question, irrespective of their original view on Brexit 10 years ago, but also with the ongoing conversation with the European Union. Because if you're trying to extract as much as you can from a UK perspective out of the current arrangement
28:00within the manifesto tram tracks that have been set out. There's talk about other things that might be discussed about in the next year. For instance, the whole question of the EU's Made in Europe idea, this idea about trying to offer some sort of protection to the EU from China flooding products onto the world market at below cost, dumping onto the world market? Well, the UK is outside of the EU, so it could potentially find itself in a tricky position there. But can it negotiate being part of that deal? In other words, there's other things that will be part of the short-term negotiation with the EU within the broad tram tracks of the current relationship. Now, how much you can extract from the current relationship,
28:45at least to a degree, will be determined by the extent to which Europe thinks you're committed to that relationship for a reasonable period into the future. So, you know, it cuts that way as well. And as you say, it's why it's another reminder of the awkwardness of trying to occupy multiple positions at the same time around all of this stuff, which, you know, we were very used to, weren't we, in the Theresa May era? Less so in the era where either there was the kind of we've got to get out and we've got to get out pretty quickly, which is the Boris Johnson pitch in 2019, or the let's not talk about it because we're all a bit fed up of it, which was most people until pretty recently. And maybe some newscasters will be fed up of us talking about this much already, but
29:26plenty more this week. And in fact, we'll get some stuff in black and white on Friday when hopefully we'll see some, not necessarily the legal text of the deals, but at least we'll get that political declaration jointly signed by the UK and the EU, which will provide us a bit of a roadmap with some pointers about what's going to happen in the next year or two. So we'll be significant. And we'll be recording an episode of Newscast on friday lunchtime rounding up all the events in brussels as chris goes to my old stomping ground you can tell me which bars are still open although it'll be quite early to go for a beer although never too early in brussels um right chris in other news this weekend laura brand the wife of Russell Brand posted a video on YouTube where she relays
30:06a message she's received from him in prison and he talks about the prison staff being strong and kind and dedicated and he confirms that he's being held in HMP Little Hay in Cambridgeshire and then he sort of does a play on words on the name of the prison and then Laura Brand quotes this and this is a direct quote he says says, I don't know which other men are not guilty. Now, how's the government responded to Laura Brand posting that video with the message from her husband? Downing Street have said they are appalled. It was clearly appalling, as Downing Street put it, that he was able to effectively broadcast a claim of innocence for his offences whilst behind bars. And there's a wider argument about the extent to which you can or should be able to stop that.
30:54Now, clearly, in a previous era, without social media and means for people to effectively broadcast themselves, getting a message like that to a wider, if you like, national or international audience would have been pretty much impossible. But in this era, that's not the case, and hence that message getting out there. And Downing Street have reacted to it, and it sounds like they're looking into it because they, from reading between the lines, they think maybe some prison rules have been breached here. Yes, so they say they're looking into it um because they say it shouldn't be possible that a prisoner should be able to re-traumatize their victims by effectively broadcasting via an intermediary from from
31:39prison um so yeah let's see what if anything they're able to do in that situation because it's quite tricky isn't it when something has been passed on to a third party I mean in this instance his wife but passed on to someone who obviously does have the means of broadcasting something unlike him but the message itself is then is then out there And that is all for this episode of Newscast Chris let's preview the next one actually no we've been doing that for the last three months because it is Alan Milburn's final report will be landing mid-morning on Tuesday. And so Chris and I will be reassembling on Tuesday afternoon and we'll be joined by BBC education editor Bramwyn Jeffries. And at last, we will have the full Milburn in black and white.
32:19Talk to you tomorrow. Bye-bye. Newscast. Newscast from the BBC. From one newscaster to another, thank you so much for making it to the end of this episode. You clearly do, in the words of Chris Mason, ooze stamina. Can I also gently encourage you to subscribe to us on BBC Sounds? Tell everyone you know. And don't forget, you can email us anytime at newscast at bbc.co.uk or, if you're that way inclined, send us a WhatsApp on plus 44 0 3 3 0 1 2 3 9 4 8 0. Be assured, I promise, we listen to everyone. We'll be right back. from the very start. Whenever you need help, it's ready. Before your stay, through the moments in between, and after your trip. Because a great trip starts with peace of mind
33:30and maybe a good playlist. But we've got the peace of mind part covered.



