podcasts / Newscast / episode
Newscast cover art
podcast
📅 2026-11-12 ⏱ 30 min episode · ~2 min read 📝 Transcript · 5,888 words

Are Under-25s About to Lose Sickness Benefits?

Newscast · · Transcript & summary by WhipScribe

It explains a controversial plan to change sickness benefits for under-25s, plus a surprise growth figure and a CEO's sudden exit, in a short briefing.

In this episodeAlan MilburnKeir StarmerJensen HuangNVIDIARachel ReevesPat McFaddenAndrew BaileyHarriet HarmanFrank FieldAndy BurnhamThe TimesOffice for Budget Responsibility

▸Chapters

Tap a chapter to open that moment in the transcript; the link to it is copied for you.

Transcribe your links. Paste a YouTube, Google Drive or podcast link and WhipScribe gives you the transcript. Transcribe a link →

▸Notable quotes

“six in ten young people who are neat today have never had a job and that's up from four in ten in 2005” Chris · at 8:56 — open in the transcript →

▸What this episode covers

Former Labour minister Alan Milburn's review covers the roughly one million 18-to-24-year-olds not in work, education or training, and six in ten of them have never had a job. Times briefings previewed his most contentious idea: under-25s would lose the health element of universal credit and find personal independence payments harder to claim, with the savings redirected into job support over about a decade. Milburn accepts that existing claimants could end up with less, a politically tough point after an earlier benefits shake-up collapsed under Labour MPs' opposition.

Earlier, NVIDIA chief Jensen Huang resigned after an overnight board meeting, following reports of a potential affair with a direct report. NVIDIA shares fell about 13% at the open, a loss of roughly half a trillion dollars, which the hosts treat as a reminder that the AI chip supply chain rested on one man's stewardship.

The economic segment reports that UK growth for July to September hit 0.7%, against a forecast near 0.2%. The hosts still flag warning signs: the Office for Budget Responsibility expects weaker growth and inflation near 5% next year, construction is weak, and energy bills rise in January after the Iran war. Bank of England governor Andrew Bailey has said that without the war he would be cutting rates rather than raising them.

▸Are Under-25s About to Lose Sickness Benefits? on Newscast: the answers

What did Alan Milburn say about NEETs?

Newscast reports that Alan Milburn's interim report, published in May, found that six in ten young people who are NEET have never had a job. That was up from four in ten in 2005, and the UK has slipped further down European comparisons, with only Romania showing a more pronounced problem.

“six in ten young people who are neat today have never had a job and that's up from four in ten in 2005”Chris · 8:56

What did Jensen Huang say about NVIDIA?

Newscast reports that NVIDIA chief Jensen Huang resigned after an overnight board meeting, following reports of a potential affair involving a direct report of the CEO. The hosts note that NVIDIA shares opened down 13% in New York, a loss of about half a trillion dollars in value.

“There was a board meeting overnight, some speculation that this was to come.”Faisal · 4:24

What did Jensen Huang say about Donald Trump?

The hosts describe Jensen Huang as a wandering diplomat over three decades at NVIDIA, someone who could walk into the White House and speak to Donald Trump. One of his answers in an interview appeared to give the private thoughts of both Donald Trump and Xi Jinping, which the reporter found credible because of his personal access.

“He became a kind of wandering diplomat, the sort of person that could walk into the White House, speak to Donald Trump”Faisal · 6:52

What did the government decide about under-25s and sickness benefits on Newscast?

Newscast reports that the government had not yet decided on changes to benefits for under-25s, but said it would publish its response alongside Alan Milburn's independent review next Tuesday. It also said it would set out a detailed policy plan in the new year and introduce legislation the following year, with Times briefings previewing proposals to take under-25s off the health element of universal credit.

Mentioned in this episode

Episode facts

Released
November 12, 2026
Length
30 minutes

▸Key takeaways

01Former Labour minister Alan Milburn's review covers nearly one million 18-to-24-year-olds who are not in work, education or training.
02Milburn's plan would deny under-25s the health element of universal credit and make personal independence payments harder to claim.
03Six in ten young people who are NEET have never had a job, up from four in ten in 2005, according to Milburn's interim report.
04Milburn accepts existing 22-year-old claimants could end up with less, which makes his plan politically harder than changing only new claims.
05Growth of 0.7% in July to September beat a 0.2% forecast, but the OBR expects weaker growth and inflation near 5% next year.

▸Questions this episode answers

Q1What did Alan Milburn propose for under-25s on sickness benefits?

Alan Milburn, a former Labour cabinet minister, is leading an independent review of the roughly one million 18-to-24-year-olds not in work, education or training. According to Times briefings before his final report, under-25s would no longer be able to claim the health element of universal credit and would be less likely to get personal independence payments. The money would be redirected into job support and small business subsidies, with savings expected over about a decade.

Q2Would Alan Milburn's benefit plan affect people already claiming?

Milburn has said the change should apply to existing recipients as well as new ones, because changing it only for newcomers would be unfair. Under that approach a 22-year-old already receiving these benefits could eventually get less than they do now, which the hosts describe as politically tricky. The exact phase-in timing and eligibility cut-offs were not yet known.

Q3Why did Jensen Huang resign as NVIDIA CEO?

NVIDIA chief Jensen Huang resigned after an overnight board meeting. The move came after reports of another potential affair involving a direct report of the CEO. NVIDIA shares fell about 13% at the New York open, a loss of roughly half a trillion dollars in value, before recovering a little.

Q4How strong was UK economic growth in July to September?

UK growth for July to September came in at 0.7%, well above a consensus forecast of about 0.2% and a June city economist forecast of 0.1%. The hosts say it ended a run of sluggish growth since the pandemic, with support from ordinary companies investing in productivity and consumer confidence that was better than expected over the summer.

Q5What warning signs does the Office for Budget Responsibility see for UK growth?

The Office for Budget Responsibility, in its blue book published with the budget a couple of weeks earlier, predicts much weaker growth next year and inflation possibly around 5%. The hosts also point to weak construction data and to energy bills that rise in January because of the Iran war, which has already weighed on consumer confidence.

Q6What did Andrew Bailey say about the Iran war and interest rates?

Bank of England governor Andrew Bailey has said that without the Iran war he would have expected to be cutting interest rates right now rather than raising them. The hosts link that to the growth figures and to the idea that a settlement of the Middle East conflict would help inflation fall and lower government borrowing costs.

▸Transcript

Our own transcript of the public episode, with a timestamp about every 90 seconds. Tap a timestamp or the link button on a paragraph to copy a link that opens this page there.

0:00This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK. in Washington right now. Host Mike Townsend, Charles Schwab's Managing Director for Legislative and Regulatory Affairs, takes a non-partisan look at the stories that matter most to investors, including policy initiatives for retirement savings, taxes and trade, inflation concerns, the Federal Reserve, and how regulatory developments can affect companies, sectors, and even the entire market. Mike and his guests offer their perspective on how policy changes could affect what you do with your portfolio. Download the latest episode and follow at schwab.com slash Washington Wise, or wherever you listen. Whoop. Sleep better, train smarter, recover faster, and feel healthier.

1:03Understand and optimize your sleep. Get coaching and insights for every age, stage, and cycle. Track over 140 habits. Get a 360 view of your training and workouts. Never miss a second of that with a wireless and waterproof charger. Expect all new features all the time. Hello, Chris. Hi. We've already met today because we were on Five Live together this morning. That was quite something. You know, you and me on the radio together, live. I was thinking this is... What could go wrong? Well, exactly. It felt quite novel in a nice way. The benefit of being on Five Live for a few days, though, is that I'm well briefed on all the big sports stories, like Michael Carrick finally being fired as the head coach of Manchester United,

1:53which means I'm fully briefed to speak down the line to Faisal. Hello. What's your take on the big HR news from Manchester United? Well, I was trying to work out if maybe this is the secret reason why there's been all this merry-go-round in the tech world. Maybe someone, they've had to go much higher in order to get someone to manage my football club. But Pochettino is not good. Pochettino from Team USA is not good enough. Listen to you, Adam. No, no. It's Jenson, isn't it? All the way. No, I'm just joking. Listen, it's not... People call United fans glory boys, but no one could accuse United fans of being glory boys given the past 13 years. And I think the basic problem is we're too romantic.

2:30We want our old players. We want our old players to win and to kind of come to fruition as great managers. Well, it was more like it was Oli Gunnar Solskjaer, now it's Carrick. We'd love the idea of someone who played for us, managing us well, and it doesn't work. And I think we've now realised this and we've gone for a proper manager. Do you know what Pochettino likes to have in his office to absorb negative energy? Oh, I heard about this. Oh, no, I don't know. I don't know. I think it's a box of lemons, isn't it? Yes, a bowl of lemons. How do they absorb any energy at all? I feel it may not be based in real science. But if it makes him feel good, then if there's a placebo effect, then who am I to quibble?

3:14You could bite into them and wake up. That's the only thing I can think of. Don't worry, Faisal, next time you're in the Newscast studio, we're going to have a bowl of lemons prepared for you so that everything goes very, very smoothly. Excellent. Not bitter at all. No lemons, though, on this episode of Newscast Studio, we're going to have a bowl of lemons prepared for you so that everything goes very, very smoothly. Excellent. Not bitter at all. No lemons, though, on this episode of Newscast, although there are many, many news stories for us to chew over. Newscast. Newscast from the BBC. Humanity's next great voyage begins. I don't know who the Prime Minister is, Mike, do you? I'm Andy and I'm not looking at my best right now.

3:40I see that he was, I guess, the mayor of a town. Ooh la la. Thinking about it like a panto helped. And what will you do? Stare at a wall. Do we play music now or what do we do? Hello, it's Adam in the Newscast Studio. And it is Chris at Westminster. And it's Faisal in Oxfordshire. And there's lots of news stories to get through, so I hope everyone is very pithy. Very good. That's a lemon joke, in case you didn't get it. Anyway, so actually, Faisal, should we start with the big breaking news that happened just as we were sitting down to record this episode of Newscast at 2.42 on Thursday afternoon, which is that Jensen Wang, the CEO of NVIDIA, the world's richest company, because it makes all the chips that power the AI models, is now the ex-CEO.

4:24Yes, he has. There was a board meeting overnight, some speculation that this was to come. It came after reporting of another potential affair of an employee, a direct report of the CEO, Chen Zunwang, and he has now resigned. And as we go on air, the shares have opened in New York and they're down 13% at opening. They've recovered a little bit, but that is a half, am I going to get this right? Yes, half trillion dollar loss in value. I was going to say half billion because that sounded more natural. But then I had to check myself and think, hang on. Yes, that's right. Astonishing that for everything that we've talked about in terms of the tech boom, that this is the cause of this most significant loss of value

5:21and concerns that stretch well beyond the stewardship of this extremely important company. Although, Faisal, on that note, it is interesting because actually the different categories of concerns people have had about tech and AI, one of them is safety. One of them is it just is massively inflated in terms of the American stock market, which means there'll be a bust, which will affect everybody. But actually, there has been a bit of personnel stuff, like are the guys guys and they're all guys who are shepherding this technology the right people to be doing it so suppose this kind of fits into that category yes yes it does i mean in actual fact there was a bit of distance between jensen huang and nvidia and some of the much publicized potential harms, the harms to jobs,

6:05the harms to via social media, the harms potentially wiping out humanity. All of that was slightly downstream. So what NVIDIA did, as you say, was created the chips and the most cutting edge chips that enabled the creation of the large language models, the frontier models like ChatGPT or Anthropics Cloud or Gemini's um uh so google's gemini model so they were essential to the creation of those but often like when what when i talked to jensen wang he would create a bit of a distance you know he just creates the tools that fuel the gold boom but like it's up to the people to decide what they do with them. But I guess I'd put it like this, Pithily. So important was the supply chain and the supply of what NVIDIA created

6:52under Jensen Huang's watch over three decades, that he wasn't just a guy running a company. He became a kind of wandering diplomat, the sort of person that could walk into the White House, speak to Donald Trump, walk in and speak to Xi Jinping. And then when I spoke to him, really, I was really thinking about just how to get across how astonishing his role was, not just in tech, but in the world. You know, he gave an answer to one of my questions where he appeared to tell me the private thoughts of both Donald Trump and Xi Jinping. And I thought, this guy is the only guy in the world who could say something like that. And I could credibly believe that what he said was rooted in reality and personal conversations

7:36with both those leaders. And it probably was. And the person you've been speaking to in Oxford, and the reason you're there today is the Chancellor John Healey, who's responding to some very positive news about growth in the economy. we will talk about that in a second but I suppose Chris the story you're working on today is a bit related to that because Alan Milburn who's doing this independent review into the NEETs the nearly 1 million 18 to 24 year olds who are not in employment education or training it's coming out next week but he's doing a whole load of sort of trailers for it like it's a big blockbuster film Yeah, and the trailers are part of the, if you like the communication strategy

8:12but also just the overall strategy as far as the government's approach this time round as far as benefits changes are concerned because newscasters might recall about 18 months ago, Keir Starmer's government had a go at a bit of a shake-up of the benefits system and it kind of blew up in their face because plenty of Labour MPs just weren't comfortable with it and the government had to retreat. It was a big kick to the then Prime Minister's authority. So what happened off the back of that is that Alan Milburn, former Labour Cabinet Minister, was tasked with having a look at the whole issue, particularly around younger people, not in education, employment or training. One in eight young people currently classified as

8:56NEET. And as Mr. Milburn said in his interim report, which was back in May, which was the kind of diagnosis stage before the if you like solutions or proposed solution stage in this report uh next week six in ten young people who are neat today have never had a job and that's up from four in ten in 2005 so that sense that the problem has been getting worse in the uk and also by international comparisons or European comparisons, the UK has been slipping further and further down the, if you like, the league table around this whole issue. I think only Romania with a more pronounced problem. So what they're doing, both Mr. Milburn, but also government ministers, Pat McFadden, the working pension secretary, prime minister and others, they have been trying to take Labour MPs by the hand and

9:47persuade and talk them through it and listen to their concerns and accept there might be elements where they want to kick the tyres of things or set parameters about what might happen. But then also never surprise. So talk about things publicly, regularly. And now we're in the handful of days before it formally is published next tuesday uh the kind of rollout of various elements of what alan milburn is suggesting starting today with an interview is given in the times and the idea at the heart of that is that younger people 18 to 24 year, coming off the main sickness and disability benefits and effectively a different benefit system being created for younger people. The idea being that in the end,

10:34but it could take a decade to get there, it can save the state money. But in the meantime, the money is prioritised in terms of getting people work ready, getting people into work, as opposed to effectively paying people as much as is currently paid for them not to work. But Chris the detail on the benefit changes that Alan Milburn was giving us all via the Times newspaper is that people under 25 would not be able to claim the health element of universal credit and would be less likely to be able to claim personal independence payments to help with their daily living costs if they're living with a condition compared to older people. Exactly that. Exactly that. Now, precisely the breadth of it, we don't know. So,

11:18you know, where would the exact line be drawn? In addition to that, Mr Milburn talks about those with the most profound disabilities getting a new benefit paid at a higher rate, but how is profound defined? And speaking to some Labour MPs today, they're keen to hear, obviously, those specifics down the track. But you've got Mr Milburn making argument where he accepts that this is difficult. This is politically really difficult because in his view, it wouldn't be right to change the system for new recipients only. The fair thing in his view to do is for it to apply across the piece. And that could mean if you right now are a 22-year-old recipient of some of these benefits and then the process works its

12:05way through let's assume the government adopts uh the these ideas which i think is a reasonable assumption in the round and then they change the law in order to make it happen etc etc that person uh could down the track be receiving less than they're currently receiving now and obviously politically that is trickier than telling somebody who was at the beginning of a kind of, if you like, journey through the system that they're getting less than they would have done if they'd been signing up for it six months previously. And Faisal, what was your gut reaction to this interview from Alan Milburn? Well, I thought it was interesting and tactical to get, if you like, what might be considered for them personally, politically,

12:46the bad news out of the way at the beginning. In other words, the benefit cuts. Yeah, exactly. That's going to be tricky. And obviously, ultimately, you could argue what kind of undermine fatally, eventually, his predecessor's authority within the party. As soon as you can't get your policies through, people start to ask all sorts of questions about absolutely everything. So they're allowing Alan Milburn to think the unthinkable. He's now come out with the most controversial part of that to, I think, just get it out into the ether. Actually, in a funny way, the argument I think that they're going to try to prosecute is that these young people, the under 25s, are effectively still getting the same amount of money.

13:36We're taking it from cash payments for health and disability and we're repurposing it into job support, subsidies for small businesses, health support, all this sort of stuff. And that is better, not just for the individuals, but also better for the economy, better for the taxpayer longer term, albeit, as Chris says, over what we think is nine to 10 years. By the way, we don't have the detail. It all depends on the detail. How quickly might they phase in the application of this to existing claimants as well as new claimants? All of this, you know, what is the precise cutoff? All of this hugely matters. But even in the reports we had in the Times, you know, I'm already, I find my socials full of people

14:20who say that they're affected or representing disability charities that are affected, saying, well, you know, this is not on. And they're already, no doubt, emailing Labour MPs. And remember, we'll get the Milburn report next week. Will we get some sort of response? We're waiting for a different report called the Tims report into PIP, which reflects more closely what happened with the U-turn under Rachel Reeves and Keir Starmer. But they have slightly different aims. And I don't think the Tim's report is going to talk about cuts to welfare, for example, and it has been, quote-unquote, co-produced with disability charities. This report by Milburn has not been co-produced with disability charities.

15:02So, you know, but we haven't got the whole picture yet, is I think what I would say. But it's a very interesting, potentially bold set of policies. And we're still waiting for how the government would actually respond to it as well. And Chris, that phrase Faisal used, think the unthinkable, that is a callback to the Blair era, 1997, 1998, when Harriet Harman was the Work and Pension Secretary, although that wasn't the name of the job at the time. And her deputy was Frank Field, who was tasked with thinking the unthinkable about the welfare system. Yeah, and then lost his job. And had a massive falling out with Harriet Harman, and she lost her job too. Well, yeah. Old newscast alert. Yeah, yeah.

15:40No, exactly. That is a proper vintage reference. Department of Social Security, I think it was at the time, isn't it? Yeah. And that speaks to the sort of generational long, probably longer than that, difficulties for any government, but particularly Labour governments when it comes to having a crack at changing the benefit system. I think we'll see the argument made by Alan Milburn in the next few days and indeed by the government off the back of it, trying to ground it as a moral people-focused argument as opposed to a fiscal bottom line argument, not least because we expect that fiscal bottom line argument to be an acknowledgement that you only make savings into the medium term, you know, 10 years roughly ahead, but also trying to persuade those Labour MPs who perhaps felt that

16:33last time around, in fact, not perhaps, they did feel that last time around, the emphasis was all on saving money. And they just felt quite uncomfortable about that, the emphasis upon that, that this time, the framing is rather different. Certainly, as things stand, hearing from Labour MPs, granted, they haven't necessarily seen all of the detail yet, you know, exactly how does the government in time legislate around all of this? What are some of the, you know, as far as I was saying, what are some of the specifics that we don't know yet? What do they turn out to be? Obviously, that will shape an element of the reaction. However, the early indications point to the Parliamentary Labour Party

17:10being in a substantially different position around much of this. They feel like they're being listened to. They feel like they're being consulted. Yes, there's a core of those on the left of the Parliamentary Labour Party who will remain sceptical. I've spoken to a couple of them including on camera uh today they're quite happy to say it publicly and attach their name to it there was bell ribiro adi on the today program on thursday morning uh i've just been talking to brian leishman another labour backbencher but quite a few of the others who were who joined them 18 months ago in being sceptical are no longer sceptical. A few of them, by the way, are in government. And then others are, yeah, I just think that this time round

17:54it's been much better handled and is a much more palatable, from their perspective, kind of prospectus. But let's see, because, you know, we've got to see the whole thing and then crucially beyond that, see on the specifics what the government decides to do and when and across what kind of timeframe, et cetera, et cetera. And let's bear all of that in mind as we listen to what John Healy, the Chancellor, was saying about this to Faisal when he spoke to him earlier on Thursday. We have a moral duty, in my view, to avoid the situation that we've seen in recent years where a million youngsters not in work or in training are simply written off. Alan Milburn will produce his report and the government

18:33will set out our response alongside it. And then I've said people will expect to see then a detailed government policy plan in the new year, legislation next year. It's interesting, Adam and Chris, actually, that he has confirmed there that the government is going to set out its response alongside the publication of the report next Tuesday. I'm interested in that because they're not going to wait for the TIMS report to come out two weeks later. But it's just a point of slight processology. And then they're already saying that they're going to have detailed government policy plan and in the new year legislation. So I think they probably do already know where they're going. And you heard that phrase,

19:14moral duty as well. And then, you know, I think the Chancellor, when he hears, of course, he's probably a regular newscast avid listener, will feel somewhat relieved by Chris's characterisation of where the backbench Labour MPs are. But interesting that we'll get a response next week. You know, I didn't know necessarily know that. Yeah. Chris, how extensive will that response be? Or will it be more of a sort of taking note response and giving some pointers as opposed to a fully worked out plan? I think it'll be more than taking notes because this isn't going to come as a surprise to them. They had originally said that they would sort of formally respond before Christmas. I think it's possible that they still do do that

19:55ahead of kind of setting out the kind of legislative plan, changing the law plan into the new year. But I think, Faisal, you're right. It is noteworthy that they are seeking and advertising that they will be seeking to inject themselves into all of this in a relatively substantial way off the back of the publication next Tuesday, rather than waiting for the Tim's report, which will be about a fortnight further down the track. And I think Tryon kind of sees the kind of political momentum around all the conversations that Mr. Milburn's been having with Labour MPs, that Pat McFadden, the Working Pension Secretary, has been having with Labour MPs to try and, well, basically, as they would see it, crack

20:34on with it pretty quickly. And Faisal, the reason you were there chatting to John Healy about a whole load of things was because he wanted to talk about the good economic news that came from the Office for National Statistics on Thursday morning. Yeah, and another day where we started a Man United manager and a CEO of NVIDIA. This would be a significant piece of news. It is a significant piece of news. And why I say that is we now have had a pattern of the entire of 2026, every single quarter, growth exceeding by some margin what was forecast only a month or two before. So I'll just take you back a few weeks. And the consensus for this quarter to the third quarter, that's between July and September, was 0.2-ish percent.

21:17In June, city economists thought it would be 0.1%. Well, we've just had to figure, as you say, 0.7%, which in long-term historical perspective, say pre-financial crisis two decades ago, would have been like normal growth. In current history of sluggish growth, we had this once two years ago, then absent the pandemic, you have to go back to the end of 2017 to get a growth of about 0.7%. It's really cool. And what you get from Westminster, so it's a couple of things here, is I am struck moving between the worlds that I move through, how kind of default doom-mongery everything is in Westminster. And that's a product of politics. Labour do it when they're in opposition as well. But the economy was showing some signs of life all the way

22:02through this year. And I think in the significance of the summer quarter is for the past four years it's been pretty miserable we've had cruel summers since the pandemic where there's any growth momentum has been wiped out not the case this month 0.7 is acceleration this year and as i said decent enough and the uk is now growing pretty much the same just a slightly bit less than the US and far more significantly than the rest of Europe. And there are interesting reasons for that in AI investments, not the big data centers, the big controversial data centers, but things like ordinary companies just trying to up their game and up their productivity. But also, and this is interesting politically, we've talked about consumer confidence before, which had been doing better over summer.

22:46You know, the vibes are better than you would have expected, particularly given the Iran war. Yeah, two flies in the ointment, though, that I've been thinking about since these numbers came out. The Office of Budget Responsibility, in its blue book that came out with the budget a couple of weeks ago, predicts a much less good year for economic growth next year, also predicts much higher inflation, maybe 5% next year. And also, if you look at the data today from the ONS, it shows that the building sector has not been great. And you build things because you're investing in the future. So I just wondered if there were some little kind of warning signs. Definitely. I'm going to be paying warning signs.

23:26No. with some little kind of warning signs. Definitely. I'm going to be paying warning signs. So the first thing is that the Iran war impact may just be a sort of delayed reaction. And we've sort of staved it off because of things like the energy cap. It is coming and people are going to feel it on their bills. And that has already weighed down consumer confidence as we enter these last two or three months of the year. However, I would have probably presumed that that would have happened in the third quarter too, and it didn't. So let's see where that goes. Construction is a problem, but you think about it. You've had higher inflation. You've had higher borrowing costs, both for government, for businesses,

23:56and in the mortgage sector. You have seen an impact of that in housing, and they've tried to kind of stimulate that with their new version of help to buy subsidies for mortgages. Nobody's calling this a boom. I think the point is that the doom, I think we can now say was overdone. There are still challenges. So much of this, and it's, you know, I don't want to sort of say the blindingly obvious, but so much of this is obviously down to what's happened with the Iran war, which, again, we're trying to judge the tea leaves from what's happened in the midterms. But you can, in fact, John Healy, later in the interview, told me that. He said it was quite an interesting concept. The best economic policy for Britain would be a settlement

24:41of the conflict in the Middle East, which is like, okay, that's not really an economic policy, But you can see that they really want to invest in that. Because what do you get with that? You get the momentum that we can see in the figures continue, number one. Number two, you get inflation down, so the cost of living crisis can taper off, even though the bills are going to go up in January. But you also get government borrowing costs down. You get mortgage rates down. I can just imagine them doing whatever they do to kind of just basically make the Gulf conflict kind of somehow go away if they can do it, because that is now the critical potential turning point for them economically. They've got some other stuff to work with.

25:22You know, there's some good signs. However, that doesn't mean we're sort of totally outwards and it's there's such a consistency in the framing of that particular argument fights because when i was at the commonwealth thing in the uh caribbean last week both the foreign secretary and the prime minister responding as they were then to the uh midterm results were latching straight onto that i suppose it it throws open that thought, doesn't it, as to where economic growth would be now or could be soon if, and obviously it's a huge if, but if there was a resolution in the Middle East. It absolutely does. And indeed, the Bank of England governor, Andrew Bailey, was pretty clear about this. Had there been no Iran war,

26:02he would have expected to be cutting interest rates right now rather than raising them. So listen, there are all sorts of pressures. I don't think anybody's getting carried away. But I think it is very interesting. There's all sorts of questions that arise from this. So for example, you just take the AI growth, AI-fueled growth. What does that do to any sort of incipient voice on the back benches, what you know, what some cabinet ministers I've spoken to have called America brain. They see what happened in the midterms, they saw the backlash against data centres, and they've started calling now some, you know, essentially left-wing Labour MPs for a moratorium on data centres. You know, this now asks some real questions

26:38of Prime Minister Burnham. Is he going to go full throttle for UK and AI, given what it's done for growth? It raises questions, I think. We're going to be talking a lot i think over the next week about brexit and the reset and the summit that chris is going to go off to okay is that part of the the vibe that the uk may have settled more more closer relations with the european union or does it just inject a whole lot of uncertainty at a time when growth has done better than many people expected? There are big judgments to be made on the back of this, but it isn't just in the growth figures. As I reported last week, Sterling against the basket of currencies reached last week the highest level since

27:20after the referendum. And a penny for Rachel Reeves' thoughts right now. Well, no, we don't need to because she's posted them on LinkedIn. Oh, no, exactly. Well, I've overpaid by a penny, haven't I, for those thoughts. Unless you've got LinkedIn Premium, which I think is about 50 quid a month. They were available for three. Well, okay, sorry. I haven't read that post, but like, yeah. Well, praise me what she said, but I imagine she's thinking, I did all the hard work and I never got to, I never got, and I did all the gardening. She says, I'm delighted with the figures. This shows just how great a turnaround we achieved. She says, we said we would have the fastest growth in the G7 and now it looks like that will be the case

27:59for the first nine months of the year. Now let's keep up the pace. I think it's quite close, actually. I think America just pips us, actually. But yeah, we're there or thereabouts. Well, let's keep up the pace. I think America just pips us, actually. But yeah, we're there or thereabouts. Well, okay, there we go. I've overpaid by a penny. I demand a refund. Anytime. And that mirrors, doesn't it, the language we had from Stuart Ingham on Newscast the other day, the former Keir Starmer advisor who'd worked in Downing Street and that sense, in his view, that from his former boss and indeed the Chancellor next door that as they see it they'd done the hard yards which collectively and indeed their

28:33successes in government are now the as they would see it the beneficiaries of. I just want to ask Chris a quick question which is like how do you tactically deal with this situation as an opposition party because you're like you can see it like and you saw it with labor in the reverse situation there's opposition you're you're sort of bought into the negative you can be bought into the negative to the doom where does it leave where does it leave you when the numbers kind of outperform what do you like do you i'm i'm intrigued by your yeah i i think it's it's a fascinating strategic conundrum isn't it and i think it particularly is when as cammy bosenoch has done for more than a year now she has consciously pitched the thrust

29:19of her political argument uh around the economy and economic growth, trying to, you know, kind of reclaim the mantle of being seen as credible on the economy. There were some opinion poll ratings more than a year ago that suggested that was a door the Conservatives ought to push at, and they did. They've consciously, we saw it in Kevin Bailie-Knox's conference speech this year, not talk to the same degree as they might have done in the past around issues such as legal or illegal migration, but again, to focus on economic growth. So how do you then continue to make that argument and do so in a politically expedient way from their perspective, when the numbers are looking better particularly when you

30:06have Andy Burnham when he's making his wider EU related arguments and as Stuart was telling us the other day that doesn't come without risk within the Labour Party and within the broader electorate but a big part of the argument we'll hear from the Prime Minister around that summit at the back end of next week in brussels is one about these changes both in the short term and then potentially into the longer term having the potential for further economic growth as kind of their underpinning logic so that economic tussle that we'll see in the coming months between labour and the conservatives in particular but obviously the parties involved too, will be fascinating to observe. Because as you say, Faisal, the tram tracks on which that debate is happening

30:50appear to be shifting a bit. Right, we have squeezed a lot out of a very juicy news day. So that is all for this episode of Newscast. Thank you very much for joining us from Oxford, Faisal. Thank you. Chris, good to speak to you in Westminster. Ta. And Chris and I will be reconvening on Thursday night on BBC One after question time for our look back at the week's news and what we've learnt and what we might have missed at the time, which you will be able to hear as a podcast in your newscast feeds from Friday. Speak to you then. Bye-bye. Newscast. Newscast from the BBC. From one newscaster to another, thank you so much for making it to the end of this episode. You clearly do, in the words of Chris Mason, ooze stamina.

31:31Can I also gently encourage you to subscribe to us on BBC Sounds. Tell everyone you know. And don't forget, you can email us anytime at newscast at bbc.co.uk, or if you're that way inclined, send us a WhatsApp on plus 44 0 3 3 0 1 2 3 9 4 8 0. Be assured, I promise, we listen to everyone. Thank you. You can even get help from a dedicated advisor. That's full-service wealth management. Mix, match, and change your mind whenever you want. Because at Schwab, you can invest your way. No matter your goals or appetite for investing, Schwab has everything you need all in one place. Visit schwab.com to learn more.

▸More episode summaries

Newscast cover art
NewscastThe Week: Welfare Plans and EU Deals2026-11-13 · 39 min
Newscast cover art
NewscastA Very Public Row On The Right2026-11-14 · 38 min
Newscast cover art
NewscastCould The Russell Brand Case Change The Age Of Consent?2026-11-15 · 33 min
Newscast cover art
NewscastThe Name's Milburn...Alan Milburn2026-11-16 · 31 min
Transcribe your links. Paste a YouTube, Google Drive or podcast link and WhipScribe gives you the transcript. Transcribe a link →
New Newscast transcripts by email
One email per new episode, unsubscribe in every message. Not shared with the publisher.