podcasts / Newscast / episode
Newscast cover art
podcast
📅 2026-11-15 ⏱ 33 min episode · ~2 min read 📝 Transcript · 7,312 words 🎙 Rosamund Irwin

Rosamund Irwin: Newscast transcript and summary

Newscast · · Transcript & summary by WhipScribe

A Sunday Times reporter who spent seven years on the Russell Brand story explains why a complainant came forward and whether the age of consent should change.

In this episodeRussell BrandMiaGiselle PelicotLouise HaigPat McFaddenAlex ChalkAlan MilburnAndy BurnhamKeir StarmerRachel ReevesSunday TimesFlorida

▸Chapters

Tap a chapter to open that moment in the transcript; the link to it is copied for you.

Transcribe your links. Paste a YouTube, Google Drive or podcast link and WhipScribe gives you the transcript. Transcribe a link →

▸Notable quotes

“I don't want to criminalise teenagers from having sex with each other.” Mia · at 6:32 — open in the transcript →
“I don't think anyone sitting in that courtroom felt the cross-examination of the women by the defence was polite.” Rosamund Irwin · at 16:02 — open in the transcript →

▸What this episode covers

Rosamund Irwin of the Sunday Times, who spent seven years on the Russell Brand investigation, joins BBC Newscast to explain why one complainant, previously identified as Alice, has now given her name as Mia. Mia says she wants the law to change so teenagers today are better protected. She describes a relationship that began when she was 16 and Brand was about 30 and becoming famous. Irwin adds that the defence suggested some accounts might have been invented, which she says was untrue, and that the complainants' own messages were used against them in court while Brand's phone was never handed over.

The panel then turns to whether the age of consent should be staggered, so that teenagers can have relationships with each other up to 18 while adults are barred from relationships with under-18s. They note that the age of consent for heterosexual relations was raised from 13 to 16 in the 1880s, and that Florida sets 18 with an exception for partners aged 23 or under. Louise Haig, described on the programme as Andy Burnham's deputy, called a change a massive step that deserves proper scrutiny, while Pat McFadden said only that the question will be discussed. Former Conservative justice minister Alex Chalk favoured standardising at 18, though he acknowledged that 16-year-olds can already vote and join the armed forces with parental consent.

The programme also previews Alan Milburn's review of young people who are not in education, employment or training. Its proposals include ending GP fit notes and warning against raising employer costs, and it is expected to take about a decade to break even. The hosts see that timeline as the main political fault line, and as a test of whether Burnham can hold his Labour MPs together.

▸Rosamund Irwin on Newscast: the answers

Who is Rosamund Irwin?

Rosamund Irwin

A journalist at the Sunday Times who spent seven years on the Russell Brand investigation. She is the guest on this Newscast episode.

What did Rosamund Irwin say about Russell Brand?

Rosamund Irwin said the defence's cross-examination of the women in the Russell Brand trial was not polite, unlike the prosecutor's questioning of Brand and his wife. She argued that the complainants' text messages were used against them in court, while the disparity in how complainants and defendants were treated was a serious problem.

“I don't think anyone sitting in that courtroom felt the cross-examination of the women by the defence was polite.”Rosamund Irwin · 16:02

What did Mia say about the age of consent?

Mia said it would be reasonable to ask for a staggered age of consent, so that 16 to 18-year-olds can have relationships with each other. She said adults in their 30s, 40s and 50s who have relationships with under-18s should face a criminal offence.

“I don't want to criminalise teenagers from having sex with each other.”Mia · 6:32

What did Pat McFadden say about the age of consent?

Pat McFadden, a senior minister, said a staggered age of consent is a question that has been raised and will be discussed. He said he could not tell listeners what the conclusion would be, and the hosts felt he was not committing the government to change.

“I think it's certainly a question that has been raised and will be discussed.”Pat McFadden · 10:39

What did Alan Milburn say about GP fit notes?

Alan Milburn said he no longer thinks doctors should be able to sign people off sick and onto benefits. He argued that about 93% of fit note applications are signed off automatically, which makes the fit note a route into the welfare system that he says is not right.

“I think GPs themselves would say that that's not their primary purpose.”Alan Milburn · 23:15

What is Rosamund Irwin's main argument on Newscast?

Rosamund Irwin argues that the Russell Brand case has raised a serious question about whether the age of consent should be staggered, and that complainants were not treated fairly in the criminal process. She describes the complainant Mia's decision to waive anonymity as a courageous step to push for change.

Mentioned in this episode

Episode facts

Released
November 15, 2026
Length
33 minutes

▸Key takeaways

01Mia, previously identified as Alice in the Sunday Times reporting, waived her anonymity to push for a change in the age of consent.
02Louise Haig called changing the age of consent a massive step that deserves proper scrutiny, which hosts said is not yet a government commitment.
03The age of consent for heterosexual relations was raised from 13 to 16 in the 1880s, while Florida sets it at 18 unless the partner is 23 or under.
04Alan Milburn's welfare review says it will take about 10 years before savings break even, a timeline Conservatives will attack as spending keeps rising.
05Rosamund Irwin says complainants were not treated correctly, since women's texts were read out in court while Brand's phone was never handed over.

▸Questions this episode answers

Q1What did Rosamund Irwin say about the Russell Brand case on Newscast?

Rosamund Irwin, a Sunday Times journalist who spent seven years on the Russell Brand investigation, told BBC Newscast that one complainant, previously identified as Alice, has now waived her anonymity as Mia. Irwin said complainants were not treated correctly in court, arguing that the women's text messages were read out and used against them while Brand's relevant phone was never handed over. She also said the defence's suggestion that some accounts were invented was untrue.

Q2Why did Mia give up her anonymity in the Russell Brand case?

Mia, previously identified as Alice, waived her right to anonymity because she wants change for teenagers today. She says she began a relationship with Russell Brand at 16 when he was about 30, and she describes it as emotionally abusive. She has withdrawn from the criminal process after five years, partly to focus on her young child, and she is speaking about the age of consent so that other young people do not face what she did.

Q3Should the age of consent in the UK be staggered, according to Newscast?

Newscast guests discussed a staggered age of consent, under which 16 to 18-year-olds could have relationships with each other while adults would be criminal for relationships with under-18s. Mia said this would be reasonable, and former Conservative justice minister Alex Chalk said he favours standardising at 18, though he noted that 16-year-olds can vote and join the armed forces with parental consent. The hosts said there is a tangle of consent rules in the UK and that a teacher in a position of trust is already restricted.

Q4What is Louise Haig's position on changing the age of consent?

Louise Haig, described on Newscast as Andy Burnham's deputy, told Rosamund Irwin that changing the age of consent would be a massive step but that it deserves proper consideration and scrutiny. The hosts said this was not a commitment to legislation, but it was a commitment by the government to engage in the discussion.

Q5What did Pat McFadden say about a staggered age of consent?

Pat McFadden, a senior minister, said the question of a staggered age of consent had been raised by the newspaper story and would be discussed, but he could not say what the conclusion would be. He said the last week had put the issue in lights. The hosts said his answer seemed more concrete than the usual government response, but they doubted the government knew how the debate would be structured.

Q6What did Alan Milburn propose about young people who are not in work?

Alan Milburn, reviewing the people who are not in education, employment or training, is expected to propose on Tuesday that GPs should no longer write fit notes, since about 93% of fit note applications are signed off automatically. He also urged the government not to raise wages or employer national insurance in ways that make it more expensive for businesses to hire young people. He said the plan would take 10 years to reach a break-even point.

Q7Is the welfare reform plan a test of Andy Burnham's authority over Labour?

The Newscast hosts argued that the Milburn welfare plan is a first big test of Andy Burnham's authority over the parliamentary Labour Party and of whether his rhetoric about rewiring the country is real. They noted that the government has one of the biggest majorities in British political history, though Burnham did not win that majority on a welfare platform. They also said the last welfare rebellion, led by Louise Haig and a fellow Labour MP, marked a turning point for Keir Starmer's authority.

▸Transcript

Our own transcript of the public episode, with a timestamp about every 90 seconds. Tap a timestamp or the link button on a paragraph to copy a link that opens this page there.

0:00This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK. Schwab knows that when it comes to your finances, choice matters. No matter your goals, investing style, life stage or experience, Schwab has everything you need, all in one place, so you can invest your way. Visit schwab.com to learn more. Heroes don't always wear capes. Sometimes they carry a backpack. Work a shift. Help their family. Mom, I'm home. And still show up for class. At Cal State East Bay, change your future and what's possible for everyone who comes after you. Cal State East Bay. Becoming a pioneer starts here. Apply or learn more at cssueastbay.edu slash start. Sunday's newscast has invited a guest who has made a lot of news by her hard work and reporting.

1:13Exactly. We are joined today by Rosamund Irwin for the Sunday Times, who's been working on the Russell Brand story for seven years, which is a very good reminder sometimes that very important journalism takes a lot of hard work and a long time and some of that journalism has resulted now in a big national conversation. About the age of consent whether it should be staggered also about the bravery of victims of sexual assault coming forward in this case it's an alleged victim as we'll get to nonetheless women who waive their right of anonymity and in fact men who do so in these cases deserve a lot of attention when it happens and that's what's happening today. We'll discuss it. And because of that, I should warn you

1:52there will be issues discussed of rape and sexual assault on Sunday's Newscast. Newscast. Newscast from the BBC. Humanity's next great voyage begins. I don't know who the Prime Minister is, Mike. I'm Andy and I'm not looking at my best right now. I see that he was, I guess, the mayor of a town. Everyone assumes that you must be a traitor. And what will you do? Stare at a wall. Do we play music now or what do we do? Hello, it's Laura in the studio. Hello, it's Paddy in the studio. Hello, it's Henry at home. And with us. Hi, I'm Rosamund Irwin. Very good to have you with us. Now, people who have been following this story for a long time through your journalism will know that one of the people making allegations was named Alice,

2:34which was not her real name, until the last 24 hours. And she has waived her right to anonymity. We now know that she is Mia Latter. And just, I suppose, talk us through, why has she taken that very courageous decision to show the world that she is Mia Latter and just I suppose talk us through why has she taken that very courageous decision to show the world who she is? Well she wants to fight for things to change for other people she wants what happened to her not to happen to the teenagers of today so that's why she's talking about the age of consent so she had a relationship with Russell Brand when she was just 16 years old. He was 30. He was becoming famous at that stage. He was becoming a household name really at that stage.

3:11And so there's two power differentials there that are quite obvious. There's obviously a massive age gap. You know, most of us see a 16-year-old as a child still and treat them as such. They obviously, you know, 16-year-olds like to push boundaries, don't they, themselves. You know, they often think they're more worldly than they are. I certainly did at 16. And then there's also obviously the power differential of somebody who is famous and somebody, you know, who doesn't have that profile. And I think the other issue here is that we had a lot in the trial that, you know, the women are reporting were all anonymous, which, by the way, wasn't wasn't true. We did actually name one of the women in the original 2023 investigation.

3:54And then the defense barrister at one on a number of occasions suggested they may have been quotes made up. You know, he said, we don't even know if they're real. And I think she wants to put out that, you know he said we don't even know if they're real um and i think she wants to put out that you know address that i mean that was actually said at one point to one of the complainants um in winter the defense barrister said oh you know they were all just actresses in this documentary well they well they weren't i mean mia went on camera herself to tell her story obviously in silhouetted but um you know it's a corrective of well you know she's a person this had cost a very long shadow over her life which is now you know she has a corrective of well you know she's a person this had cast a very long

4:25shadow over her life which is now you know she has a lovely life now she's happily married this is a positive story this is a woman who has you know been through terrible things and turned them into power actually and i saw that one of the things she said to you in your interview was was quoting giselle pelico the french woman whose mantra really became that the shame wasn't hers. The shame belonged to her husband who had done terrible things to her for such a long time. So it was like she was taking her power back. But Ros, before we go on, can you just then remind us what does she allege happened? Because we should be clear what she alleges happened was not part of the criminal case. Yeah, so I should also be clear that obviously she has talked to the police

5:08and the Crown Prosecution Service decided not to put her in the trial that she's gone, but police officers did want her to be part of a potential future trial. And obviously she's waiving her right to anonymity, but also withdrawing from the criminal process because this has now been five years of her life. And, you know, she's got a young child that she would like to focus on. And, you know, it's hard, this process. It's very, very grueling for people. So there's a lot of... So she had a relationship with Ross Brown. I should just make clear that he totally accepts that point back in 2006. And she was 16. And she alleges that relationship was very abusive emotionally. I mean, that he was cruel to her

5:50and that on one occasion he orally raped her. Now, in our original reporting, because she described what happened to her sexual assault, we described it in the same way. Obviously, I was aware when she was telling me this that this was actually rape, but we're very careful in our reporting to reflect how alleged victims describe things. And so we described it in the way that she had. Obviously, she is now aware what the law is, partly because this case has drawn attention to that. I should note that one of the complainants, I think, wasn't aware originally that what had happened to her was counted in the law as rape as well. People don't necessarily know where the line is between sexual assault and rape.

6:32We can hear from Mia Latta talking to Rosamund now. I think it would be reasonable to ask for a staggered age of consent. I don't want to criminalise teenagers from having sex with each other. If you're between the ages of 16 and 18, that seems fair and reasonable that you can have relationships with each other and they're always going to. But I think it should be capped at the age of 18. And if you're over the, you know, if you're in your 30s, 40s and 50s and you're trying to have a relationship with someone under the age of 18, it's a criminal offence. And your interviewing and her waiving of her right to anonymity, which is granted to all victims of sexual assault, this happens to be an alleged victim of sexual assault

7:12and rape now. Henry, it's triggered this conversation about a staggered age of consent, and I was looking into this for Radio 4 this morning, and the age of consent for heterosexual relations was raised from 13 to 16 back in the 1880s and it does seem as though government ministers are understanding they have to respond to a call to have a staggered age of consent a new conversation in 2026 well any story as huge as this becomes political because it's at the center of the national conversation so that's why we spent most of Newscast this time last week talking about it, although not talking specifically about the age of consent. One of the really significant things in Rosamund's reporting today is that she's spoken to Louise Haig, who's the first Secretary of State,

7:59essentially Andy Burnham's deputy, who says that while it would be a, in her words, massive step to change the age of consent laws, it deserves proper consideration and scrutiny. I think that's a very big moment. That's not a commitment to the government doing certain things, but it is a commitment to the government engaging in this discussion. Laura spoke to Helen Waitley, the Conservative Shadow Cabinet Minister on her programme. She said that she was sympathetic to the idea. In fact, she basically embraced it, speaking as the mother of teenage daughters, although she said as a sort of Conservative, she was more in the space of let's have this discussion. But I think this is something we're going to hear more and more about. Absolutely.

8:37So I discussed this with the former Conservative Justice Minister, Alex Chalk, because at the age of 16, you soon will be able to vote in a national UK election. Hello, listeners in Scotland who do vote at 16. And you can, with parental consent, join the armed forces. And so the interesting thing for him is, should we actually standardise everything at 18? You're a child until you're 18, he says. Thus, he's in favour of staggered age of consent, but says there are going to be complications for teenagers who are told, oh, you can do this at 16. We can't possibly do that at 16. Well, it's already like that, isn't it? If they're bringing down the voting age to 16 for everybody, but you can't buy a pint.

9:17So this is a tangle. There is, I think, a tangle in the UK over consent for all sorts of different things. Yeah, and we do already have some restrictions in that you wouldn't be able to have a sexual relationship with someone in power, so i.e. a teacher, for example. Positions of trust. Positions of trust, exactly. So someone who has power over you, basically. So we have already built something in that says that we don't treat 16 and 17-year-olds in quite the same way in regards to sexual relationships, and that's already in there. It's interesting, though, this does exist in a way in some places so in Florida for example Alex Chalk I think said to you something I didn't I didn't know that in Florida the age of consent is 18 unless the

9:54other person is 23 or under so there is that sense if you had two 17 year olds perfectly happily together you know boyfriends girlfriends whatever would you want to criminalize them for having what many people would be seem to be a normal relationship for teenagers for for late on teenagers but it was interesting i thought when we asked pat mcfadden about this this morning he was carefully saying yes maybe we should have a think but i didn't necessarily get from him that he was saying, yeah, let's go ahead with this. Because sometimes what happens, a massive story like yours, excellent reporting around a terrible situation, then there's a rush to discuss legislation. Sometimes somehow that would make all our problems go away.

10:39So let's just have a careful listen to how Pat McFadden, the senior minister, handled it this morning. Last week has been appalling in some of the stories that we've read and I think this abuse of power by powerful men has struck the whole country and this question of a staggered age of consent has been raised by a story in the newspapers today. I think it's certainly a question that has been raised and will be discussed. I can't tell you what the conclusion of that would be, but the last week has certainly put that up in lights. I think sometimes when you hear a government minister answering a question like that in response to an issue of massive public concern, it's clear that they are just saying yeah yeah yeah we'll look at that but actually they don't mean it i think in this case

11:30it feels more concrete to me especially given the seniority of louise haig having uh engaged in it with ros rosamund i mean i don't know going forwards, though, and I suspect the government doesn't know the structure of this conversation. This is the sort of issue where you'd probably be talking public consultations. You'd be talking a piece of legislation which I suspect the people with the breadth of experience in the House of Lords would spend a very long time on. So I don't think we should anticipate that if the government does decide changes are needed here, that it's going to happen quickly. But I do think we should anticipate that they do keep looking at this rather than this being the last we've heard of this.

12:14Yeah, I'm sure that's right. And there are prominent MPs too, who are highly likely, I think, to make sure that they are pushing not just on this issue but also around the issue of NDAs and so called slaps which are a form of legal mechanism that people can use to try and control a story or control a narrative around them. Ros I just wonder I mean what's it been like working on this for such a long time? Well I had two children in the time it took for this investigation to come into the world. So, yeah, like my life has changed radically over this period. And I look back on 2019 me and I, you know, it's sort of, you know, the past is another country type feeling. I mean, I went into this. One of the things I always find vaguely amusing is that we actually listed this story in its second week, which now sounds absolutely insane to me just for newscasters what does that mean if you're not in our business

13:09sorry we have a news list of the stories for the weekend and i've been working on it for one week full week at this stage and and we put it up for the second week um because i'd come across somebody with an immensely powerful story and she didn't end up taking part in our investigation but she did end up taking part in the criminal process and so um you know uh look i stuck at it because what she told me was so horrendous i mean i had a lot of dark nights over the soul of the soul thinking i know this um and you know it it should be in the world and i obviously didn't have people's um at that stage enough people's permission to do the story. But or legal, you know, I didn't have the legal. And the other thing for newscasters, you know, just there is such a difference in being able in hearing allegations and then the journey that you have to go through to actually get something in print.

14:03Yeah. How would you describe that process? Well, it's the magnitude of the allegation. So I had done a number of Me Too stories before that point. They were mostly in workplaces and so they were witnesses to things and they were more straightforward than this. And I think that's perhaps why I now feel that 2019 me was a bit naive about how long it would take. So, look, the work that goes into this i don't even i mean i yeah i have never had to talk to more sources i mean i always my advice to young journalists is always call five people more than anyone else can be bothered to on a story um and i think that's what's you know helped but on this one i i mean i we spoke to hundreds of people what um do you have you come to a conclusion?

14:45Have we treat complainants correctly in our court system? Well, I don't feel they were treated correctly in this case, no. One of the things also in the criminal process that I think is really important is that these women handed over huge amounts of data about themselves. So obviously on their phones, emails, all those types of things. And Russell Brand has never handed over the phone that exists that is relevant to this case and I think there's this huge disparity the text messages that women handed over in this case were then used by the defense against them and sort of cherry-picked so for example I mean a common thing in these stories is women would always say to you I mean every single woman I ever spoke to

15:24said this to me oh my story's not that bad and then you hear the story and i think it's a coping mechanism i think we all do it about trauma we say oh what happened to me isn't as bad as what happened to other people and then you hear their story and it's horrific frankly and you you know you feel physically sick listening to um the story and then they say it's not that bad as a way to make it seem sort of a manageable thing in their life yeah and so the fact that a woman had said that you know oh um i don't know that i you know i don't know that i've really got a story and she said to a friend that had put me in touch with her that was then used against her and you know obviously she got she got a conviction she's the

16:02fifth complainant she got a conviction for what happened to her. So the jury clearly realized that that was why people might do that. But I think one of the things I'd really like to make clear, more of my text messages, because I was in touch with two of the complainants before they went to the police, were in this case than Russell Brand's. And I just think there's this massive disparity between how complainants are treated and defendants. And that carried over into the court process because the prosecutor, Riel Calme-Jones, was very sensitive. She was utterly forensic, but she was in her approach to Russell Brand and his wife. She cross-examined them in a way that was polite. And I don't think anyone sitting in that courtroom felt the cross-examination of the women by the defence was polite.

16:46Let's just underline what you said there. More of your text messages as the journalist who uncovered and revealed the extent of what was going on were read out in court than Russell Brand, who's now convicted and in jail. No, more of my text messages are in the evidence for this case, yeah. And it was more a discussion, actually. It was sort of worse than that. You know, it came up that obviously all journalists use disappearing messages and they don't didn't come in until partway through the story. I think WhatsApp brought them in in 2020. So at some point, obviously, you would have switched them on as a journalist because and that's because, you know, you're not thinking at this stage about criminal processes.

17:25You're thinking obviously about civil cases. It's a very normal thing in investigative journalism to use deleting messages. I actually use them as a default also because I have too many messages otherwise around my phone as it gets bogged down. Mostly with pictures of my children, but also other things. But so, you know, things like that came up in court and you're sort of sitting there thinking, well, that is sort of normal practice. It's not like a big deal. But yeah, so that gets discussed. And we'll close this conversation with the fact that you are receiving abuse on social media. So whatever anyone wants to say about the law on staggered age of consent, there are people in the country who feel the right way to use all the technology at their at their fingertips on this

18:05case is to abuse you online well i've got a pretty thick skin about this stuff that's what's actually happening uh well yes but i'm much more worried about the women in this case and you know this came up repeatedly from the complainants in the case that they were concerned and actually we had that in their um victim impact statements at the end during sentence ahead of sentencing that you, they're really scared about their identities being known and then and then being trolled. And and I just say that, you know, there's never a perfect enough victim for these people. You know, they go through people's social media and, you know, Mia is very conscious of the fact that people will criticize her.

18:41And obviously she's had a huge amount of praise. And I was really grateful to Bridget Philipson for being really kind in what she said and saying how brave it was. And obviously the Women and Equalities Minister. But she knows that she's going to get criticism and that, I would just say, makes it an even braver thing to do. It underlines her courage. Yeah. Ros, thank you so much for coming in today and also talking about your courageous reporting. And I think people are really interested to know not just what happened, but also how these things work and what it entails bringing a story like that into the public domain. Thank you for coming in. Premier hosts on Vrbo deliver quality vacation rental stays with fast responses and clear instructions.

19:21So you don't have to worry about surprises. I asked our host a question about the house last night, and he got back to me super quick. See, that's the premier host move right there. I wish I had a premier group chat. I asked them where we should have dinner last night, and they left me on read. I know you saw it. It says it. Classic group chat move. Don't walk into a surprise. Book a top-rated Verbo stay with a premier host. If you know, you Verbo. Imagine buying a toy for your kid, but it doesn't come with batteries. That sucks. But honestly, it's even worse when you buy business software. You end up with fragmented, disconnected systems that cost a fortune and don't talk to each other. Odoo completely changes that. Odoo comes fully

20:03complete, with all your business apps perfectly integrated and working together seamlessly. It's everything your business needs in one place, saving you time, headaches, and serious money. Stop paying for missing pieces. Go to odoo.com. That's O-D-O-O dot com to learn more. Sometimes we all need an extra help in hand, especially with a tricky business problem you've been putting off. to learn more. a folder or scattered notes into a report and it does the work and hands back something finished that you can open and edit. Claude can now draft a doc or deck right in front of you and Claude design now lives right inside Claude. Describe the website or prototype you're picturing, attach your design system and it comes back in your own design language ready to edit right on the canvas. It

21:02works with your files and the tools you already use, like Gmail and Slack. And whether you're debugging code at midnight, building a financial model, or strategizing your next business move, Claude extends your thinking to tackle the problems that matter. For problems worth solving, get started with Claude at claude.ai slash solve. That's claude.ai slash solve. And check out Claude Pro, which includes access to all of the features mentioned in today's episode. Claude.ai slash solve. Big news! Wayfair's Black Friday sale is here, early! Right now at Wayfair, get up to 70% off everything you need for the season ahead. Save on kitchen and dining, bedroom furniture and mattresses, holiday decor, and way way more now is the time to score

21:46big from seasonal finds to favorites you'll use all year long plus with wayfair enjoy fast and easy shipping with delivery in time for the holidays save up to 70 off early black friday deals shop now at wayfair.com wayfair every style every home So we move on to the Alan Milburn review on the people who are not in education, employment or training. With this rather nasty acronym NEAT and the work that the government wants to do over 10 years. Have we learnt anything new today that you didn't bring us yesterday? Yeah, lots. So we've got another whole list of things that Alan Milburn is going to propose on Tuesday. And we will play you some of the clips. But just to give you the headlines, he says GPs should no longer write fit notes,

22:32which basically can sign people off and then on to the sick. He had quite a caution, I think, for government in terms of putting wages up again or implicitly, I think, raising national insurance for employers. Essentially, he's saying don't make it more expensive for businesses to hire young people. He also said, let's be candid. This is going to be 10 years, which I think is going to be the biggest political fault line this week, that there's this big plan to get benefits down and get young people into work. But it's going to take a decade before you get to something like a break eveneven point um and well that's probably enough to be going on with isn't it should we listen to a couple of them here he is saying very clearly he no longer thinks that

23:15doctors should be able to sign people on the sick and onto benefits i don't think it should be a gp really no i don't think it should be a gp I think GPs themselves would say that that's not their primary purpose. About 93% of applications for FitNotes are signed off automatically. So FitNote is a route into the welfare system. And that's not right. And we've got to make sure that the starting point is not this question. What can't you do? The starting point should be be what could you do henry i've taken uh listening to alan millburn in this way that he's using data a lot these are very emotive arguments we told laura about the ratio of benefit spending to training spending he said it was 25 to 1 he's then saying 93 of sick notes are approved and i think that because

24:03this is so emotive for Labour, I've taken the interest for me has been in how much he's trying to rely on facts and data to get this difficult argument to Labour MPs. And it is an argument, and I think that's the big difference from last time the Labour Party had a go at welfare reform or welfare cuts, depending on how you viewed it. Last year, by the way, it was still only last year that Keir Starmer and Rachel Reeves suffered their welfare rebellion, extraordinary as that is to say, given all that's happened since. And what Alan Milburn, I think, is trying to do is make it so that when Tuesday rolls around and he finally publishes this report, and let's remember this isn't yet government policy,

24:48though it was pretty clear from what Pat McFadden said and pretty clear from things that Andy Burnham has said that it is going in bulk to become government policy. But what I think Alan Milburn is trying to do is, once he's published this report on Tuesday, no one's going to be particularly shocked by what is in it. He's been making versions of this argument for the past year since he was commissioned to do this report, when Keir Starmer was still the Prime Minister. And I'm sure there will be new things. He said interesting new things to Laura today. But essentially, everybody knows what he's going to say, and it's not going to be a shock. And I think just to take people behind the substance of what he's saying,

25:24I think that is the political management technique which he has sought to use in a way that partly because it was a more urgent matter as they saw it. albeit over a much faster time frame and ended up, I think we can say with the benefit of a bit of distance I think that was probably the beginning of the end of Keir Starmer's government. I think that's completely right. I think that's the moment his authority took an absolute hammering and it never recovered because here he is with this enormous majority and he couldn't get something through. But I think that the fascinating thing is going to be not so much this week where as you say, Henry I think the government's response is going to be not so much this week, where, as you say, Henry, I think the government's response is going to be very warm. But when we get to the point of any actual numbers being put on this for any actual young people in the real world. So if, and we touched a bit on this yesterday, at what point something becomes real, where a real human being stands to lose a real amount of money, it becomes much more troublesome from a point of view of political management.

26:26But it also just makes me wonder, you know, Andy Burnham has got very big, expansive rhetoric about being the biggest change in four decades, about completely rewiring the country. How vigorously he's really willing to take this on might be the first big test of whether that rhetoric actually is real. But also, I think the first big test of his authority over the parliamentary Labour Party. Yeah, you're saying it much better than that. I think that's right. Well, no, no. I mean, I think it's both, because the speed at which he embraces some of the most controversial elements of this or the extent to which he embraces some of the most controversial elements of this will tell us what he thinks about the level of his authority over

27:06the parliamentary Labour Party. And as you reminded us, this government does have one of the biggest majorities in British political history. So you would typically in the past have said they can do whatever they like. Obviously, it's slightly complicated by the fact that Andy Burnham didn't win that majority and welfare wasn't a big part of that campaign or that platform. But yes, I think it's going to be really fascinating. I think there are some early signs that this is going to play out very differently to the last welfare row. Yes, there is an element of what Alan Milburn proposes, which would mean some people end up receiving less money than they currently do, existing claimants. And that was one

27:46of the most controversial elements of the Starmer Reeves package. But I think the fact that it is being sold overall as a long-term solution to the issue of young people out of work, rather than what the Starmer Reeves package was, which was quite openly an attempt to save several billion pounds this year as quickly as possible to make the sums add up in a fiscal event. I think that is dealing with a lot of the pain. And then you've also got to remember on a much more mundane level, who were the ringleaders of the last rebellion? Louise Haig and Annalise Midgley. They are now the deputy prime minister equivalent and the chief whip. So they're inside the house. And Meg Hillier was another rebel, wasn't she?

28:26And she was on the radio last week giving lukewarm sort of support, it seemed. Other countries do this better. That's another fact. I think it's really interesting to look at other countries. We should do that more. And I think there's a real prize as well for a political party, I don't know which one, that wants to take the side of young people, people under 20, and speak up for them. I do think that this business of focusing on all the negatives is not really what people are so used to it who are under 20. They're always slagged off in our national conversation. And I think if you could come up with anything as a government that gave a break to people of 18, you might possibly get votes. You might possibly get votes. And this, in a way, is the massive challenge for the government and Alan Milburn in how they manage these arguments.

29:16These messages. Does it get away from them and just become a fight about benefit cuts with the sort of hostility to young people that you refer to and the implication that is a sort of well-worn accusation that they're sitting around, they're snowflakes, they're on benefits because they can't be bothered to do anything and therefore they deserve to lose that money they didn't really need in the first place? Or can the government craft a story around this really that is much more hopeful, which is what I think Downing Street wants to do with it is to say the deal that young people have is pretty raw we are going to come up with a whole new way of helping that manage that moment where you sort of jump off the edge of the

29:58cliff at 17 18 19 20 if you're not going into one of the professions, if you've not got a super comfortable background and parents who can help you out and all the rest, we're going to help you manage that moment with a guarantee of some kind of opportunity, money spent on that. And oh, by the way, that means that some people are going to have a little bit less cash, but we promise it's going to mean a better deal and a better life for you in future. That's the tightrope that they're trying to walk. Complicated, of course, because they've got voters on different sides. So if you're looking in some places, the argument that young people are sitting on their butts and their snowflakes and they should all be sent out to work, that goes down

30:39well in some quarters and it goes down appallingly in other quarters. So try to stitch that story together is a really interesting challenge. And that will, in the end, someone, I was talking to a lot of people about this in the last few weeks, and someone said to me, that is going to have to be led by Andy Burnham. He's the one that has to do it to keep the party kind of in the tent and to try to get that across to the public. And Henry, can I characterise the Conservative position as the official opposition, as they're behind Alan Milburn's direction of travel but would like it to be earlier, would like it all to happen earlier, not to be a 10-year break-even? I think they're impressed by some of what Alan Milburn says

31:21and some of his thinking and certainly his willingness to be radical in terms of moving young people into a new benefit system with new benefits and so on. But I would expect come Tuesday them to be pretty fierce in their criticism of a system in which the government spends, or government spending on welfare continues to rise for a decade before there starts to be savings. I mean, the Conservatives, of course, you know, would also argue that there is a moral crisis or whatever of young people being out of work and that that's terrible for them and their life chances and so on. But at the core of the reason that Camille Badenock has prioritised this issue is that she believes the country can't afford the amount it's spending.

32:07And so I would expect her to say, well, look, this is a recipe for taxes going up, for borrowing continuing to rise for at least a decade. And Pat McFadden this morning, when we asked him what would happen to the cost of working age benefits before the election, wouldn't say. So I think that's, as you say, that's the political fault line. It's right there. We know exactly how these political arguments are likely to run. Who wins them? Of course, we don't know that yet. Now then, it's going to be a busy old political week. Tomorrow night, Henry, what's the Prime Minister doing? The Prime Minister is giving the speech at the Lord Mayor's banquet. That's always a foreign policy focused speech. But given that Andy Burnham has a rather important item of foreign policy coming up this week, but also where he is leaning into a pretty new position, pretty new posture, i.e. Britain's relationship with the European Union, I expect us to be watching very carefully what he

33:05says about Europe in that speech. I think he will say something. And, you know, that will help us frame or have a sense of the frame through which he is viewing this sort of period of summitry that is going on when it comes to Britain's relationship with the EU. Yes. I mean, I would advise the political class who don't take advice from me to do what I did yesterday and go back to Ted Heath in 1961, talking about a closer relationship with Europe. And then Harold Wilson in the 1970s saying that the referendum put to bed this issue. We could stop arguing about Europe. That was in the 1970s. I just cannot believe that we have been going on about this, arguing about it since 1960, when the French said no,

33:54these British, we can't have them in our club. de Gaulle said no. Where is the, where is the, where is the, how is it still possible to be having this argument? Because it's sitting 20 miles across the channel. It's 70 years. 70 years, Henry. Even you weren't born. No, it's even you weren't born, Paddy. I knew he was going for that. Well, look, there's a brilliant book somewhere on the shelves behind me by Tom Octavius with The New Statesman, a sort of history of Britain's political arguments over its role with Europe in the period, in the run up to 2016, which is a extensive reminder that this did not start in 2016. And you read that and you realise, yeah, and it was never going to stop in January 2020 when Britain did eventually leave the European Union. We had a referendum in the 1970s.

34:45When we then had another referendum 10 years ago, 10 years of my life has been spent arguing about this now. When we had another referendum, people then called for a second referendum. They did. But that was actually the third because people had mysteriously just forgotten the first referendum in the 1970s like it didn't exist. And what is the matter with the country? How can you just forget a referendum which confirmed our entry into the EEC? How can you forget the Norman Conquest in 1066 if one might argue it was the first big problem with our continent? What would Wellington have said? I mean, how did we let journalists get away with calling for a second referendum when it would have been the third?

35:21How did we... Oh, I see what you're... I was going to say it wasn't journalists calling for a second referendum, it was have been the third? How did we... Well, oh, I see. I was going to say, it wasn't journalists calling for a second referendum, it was the... No, but it was campaigners and politicians calling for a second referendum. That would have been a third. Oh, it was the second Brexit referendum. Yes, alright. Or a never-end-em. So, anyway, that's Henry's look-ahead. And then there's a summit, Henry, itself. On Friday is the second annual UK-EU summit in Brussels. Last year it was in the UK where Andy Burnham will sign, we think, although he's claiming there's still a few long nights of negotiations to go, agreements on various areas like sanitary, like emissions trading, but I think most importantly on the youth mobility and experience scheme as it is being called and we

36:05will learn how many young people with what criteria are going to be able to come from the EU to the UK and from the UK to the EU each year. This was mostly going to happen under Keir Starmer. What is significant about Friday is the language and the tone around it from Andy Burnham and from the Presidents of the European Commission and the European Council it from Andy Burnham and from the presence of the European Commission and the European Council about where things might go next. And not many people might notice because they might all be busy playing the new Grand Theft Auto 6, which comes out on Thursday. But we will notice and we will watch and we will be back next weekend, no doubt, to bang on about Europe more,

36:39because I know how much that makes you happy, Paddy, as you have just neatly illustrated. I shall bring, armed, I shall bring've just neatly illustrated I shall bring next week I shall bring a sound montage from the 1960s to now I shall bring that with me next week okay well I will look forward to that newscasts will be agog and we will look forward to seeing you there there was a hint of irony in the use of the word agog no no never goodbye and thank you for listening goodbye newscast from the BBC thank you so much for making it to. Goodbye. Newscast. Newscast from the BBC. Thank you so much for making it to the end of Newscast. You clearly, copyright Chris Mason, ooze stamina. Can I gently encourage you to subscribe to us on BBC Sounds?

37:16Don't forget, you can email us anytime. It's newscast at bbc.co.uk. And if you would like to join our Discord community to talk about everything Newscast related, there is a link in the description of this podcast. And don't be scared. It's super easy to click on it and then get set up. Or you can WhatsApp us on 0 3 3 0 1 2 3 9 4 8 0. And I promise you we read and listen to every single message. Thanks for listening to this podcast.

▸More episode summaries

Newscast cover art
NewscastThe Week: Welfare Plans and EU Deals2026-11-13 · 39 min
Newscast cover art
NewscastAre Under-25s About to Lose Sickness Benefits?2026-11-12 · 30 min
Newscast cover art
NewscastA Very Public Row On The Right2026-11-14 · 38 min
Newscast cover art
NewscastThe Name's Milburn...Alan Milburn2026-11-16 · 31 min
Transcribe your links. Paste a YouTube, Google Drive or podcast link and WhipScribe gives you the transcript. Transcribe a link →
New Newscast transcripts by email
One email per new episode, unsubscribe in every message. Not shared with the publisher.