The Politics Show · · Transcript & summary by WhipScribe
A weekly roundup that turns the Nvidia CEO's affair into a lesson on AI valuations, then tests the same skepticism on civil service fraud, wealth limits and a bank holiday.
Tap a chapter to play it from that moment in the show's own player; the transcript opens there too.
“all systems working as intended by Tories and Labour” Dominic Cummings · at 15:49 — ▶ hear it from here
“I owe my family and all of you an apology. I was unfaithful to my wife.” Jensen Huang · at 2:26 — ▶ hear it from here
Jensen Huang has stepped down as chief executive of Nvidia after confirming, in a company-wide email, a New York Times report of an affair. The hosts focus on one relationship: a woman reportedly recruited by Chinese security services and now believed to be in Beijing. Nvidia, which they say makes about 80% of the chips used to build AI, lost roughly $380 billion in value on the first day after the revelation.
The larger question is whether Nvidia's lead survives. Its chips began as gaming hardware, were pushed into crypto and then AI, and the hosts say the company was early enough to hand OpenAI a specially built card in 2016. Chinese AI models are often open source, and a cheaper Chinese rival, DeepSeek, once wiped about a trillion dollars from tech valuations in a single day. Financing loops between Nvidia and OpenAI add to the fragility.
The rest of the roundup sets the affair against other stories: a UK civil servant who held overlapping public jobs and a Spanish water official who stayed home for years, both raising productivity questions. Michael Portillo's train-talk tour shows politicians chasing national-treasure status on television. The show closes with an LSE project to define an 'extreme wealth line' and campaigners seeking a one-off bank holiday for King Athelstan's 1,100th anniversary.
Jensen Huang confirmed the New York Times report of an affair in a company-wide email, days after stepping down as chief executive of Nvidia. In the email he apologised to his family and staff and said there was no excuse for what he did. The hosts note that the woman involved is suspected of having been recruited by Chinese security services.
“I owe my family and all of you an apology. I was unfaithful to my wife.”Jensen Huang · 2:26
Dominic Cummings replied to a colleague who asked his view of a civil servant who held eight overlapping public sector roles between 2020 and 2023 and earned more than £284,000 of taxpayers' money. He said the case showed that the system was working as intended by the Conservatives and Labour, a line the hosts found a great quote.
“all systems working as intended by Tories and Labour”Dominic Cummings · 15:49
Ed Davey, the Liberal Democrat leader, has urged the government to create a one-off bank holiday to mark the 1,100th anniversary of King Athelstan becoming the first king of a unified England. The hosts note that the site of Athelstan's coronation lies within Davey's constituency. Lisa Nandy has not backed the idea.
“Lib Dem leader Ed Davey has urged the government to create the holiday.”Ed Davey · 37:54
Jensen Huang stepped down as chief executive of Nvidia after confirming an affair, and the hosts say a woman linked to him is suspected of having been recruited by Chinese security services. The hosts argue the affair has hurt Nvidia's share price and the wider AI market, and that the company's valuation depends on a technological lead that could be threatened.
Jensen Huang confirmed the New York Times report of an affair in a company-wide email after stepping down as Nvidia's chief executive. He wrote that he owed his family and staff an apology, admitted he had been unfaithful to his wife, and said his actions had hurt her and their children. The hosts note that the woman involved is suspected of having been recruited by Chinese security services, a claim whose full details were not yet known.
Nvidia's market value dropped by roughly $380 billion on the first day after the affair was revealed, according to the hosts of The Sketch. The hosts argue that AI chipmakers' valuations rest on a lead that rivals cannot match, so any sign that Chinese actors gained access to the company's technology threatens that lead. They point to DeepSeek, a cheaper Chinese model, which wiped about a trillion dollars off tech valuations in one day.
Nvidia gave OpenAI financing of about $105 billion to build data center capacity, and OpenAI committed to spend that money on Nvidia's chips. The hosts describe such deals as legal and possibly necessary for building AI quickly, but also as a structure that could be how a bubble is constructed. They warn that if one major component of the AI boom suddenly deflates, the whole structure of the boom and its finance looks less certain.
A project at the London School of Economics aims to find an 'extreme wealth line', the level of wealth at which riches become harmful to society, in the same way the World Bank sets an international poverty line. The academics argue that great wealth can harm the environment or democracy, for example by buying an election. They have not yet set a figure. An earlier UK study found the public did not name any level of wealth as too much.
Dominic Cummings replied to a New Statesman colleague who asked his view of the case that it was 'all systems working as intended by Tories and Labour'. The case concerns a civil servant convicted of fraud who held eight overlapping full-time public sector roles between 2020 and 2023 and earned more than £284,000 of taxpayers' money. The hosts say the story is being used by critics of the civil service.
The hosts describe Michael Portillo's train documentaries and a live evening at Cadogan Hall in Chelsea as part of a route politicians take toward national-treasure status on television. They trace his career from Thatcher-era Eurosceptic to defence secretary and say he once launched a failed leadership coup from Lord North Street. They also say some of his after-dinner jokes were well worn, including an aircraft-carrier anecdote with a long history.
Our own transcript of the public episode, with a timestamp about every 90 seconds. Tap a timestamp to play the episode from there in the show's own player; the link button on a paragraph copies a link that opens this page there.
0:00As a fitness coach, my active psoriatic arthritis can slow me down. With Sky Rizzi, Rizzen Kizumab Rizze, I'm treating my skin and joint symptoms so I can keep moving. Sky Rizzi, a prescription-only injection for adults, helps me move with less joint pain, stiffness, swelling, and fatigue. And for those who have plaque psoriasis, 90% clearer skin is possible. With Sky Rizzi, there's no daily dosing. It's just four doses a year after two starter doses. Serious allergic reactions, increased infections, or lower ability to fight them may occur. Before treatment, get checked for infections and tuberculosis. Tell your doctor about any flu-like symptoms or vaccines. Thanks to Sky Rizzy, there's nothing like clearer skin
0:42and better movement. And that means everything. Because nothing is everything. Ask your doctor about Sky Rizzy. Visit SkyRizzy.com or call 1-866-SKY-RIZZY to learn more. Most women have been there. Something feels off. You don't feel like yourself. Yet your doctor says everything looks fine. Spoiler, it's your hormones. MIDI is a virtual care platform built for women by women and offers specialized hormone care from trained clinicians. Plus, it's covered by most major insurances. Getting started is easy. You can book your first visit with a clinician right away. It's not you. It's your hormones. Visit joinmidi.com to book your first visit. That's joinmidi.com. Insurance coverage varies. Check with your plan for coverage.
1:38I'm Anoush Shakelian, and you're listening to The Sketch from The New Statesman. And I'm here with my colleague Will Dunn for our usual weekly roundup. Hi Will. Hello. So our first category this week is when the chips are down of the week and I think it's pretty obvious what the story is. Yeah whose chips are down this week whose chips are down furthest? Yeah. So the person whose chips are down the furthest this week is of course jensen huang the ceo or until today he was the ceo we're recording this from thursday and he's literally just stepped down as ceo of nvidia which was kind of jostling for first place in the table of world's most valuable companies for much of this year with uh with apple it's the
2:26biggest uh hardware manufacturer in the the ai boom and the maker of all the chips i think it has about an 80 share of the chips used in the in the ai infrastructure build out. So this enormously valuable company and he has admitted that he has been having an affair, possibly two affairs, but one of them in particular of interest to the wider world and the Trump administration and others because the woman with whom he had an affair is suspected of having been recruited by the Chinese security services, which we don't know the full details on that yet. She is believed to currently be in Beijing. And yeah, but it's not been great for the stock price and for the wider AI market. Yeah. And he confirmed the reporting, which was in the New York Times, in a company-wide email, which was, I owe my family and all of you an apology. I was unfaithful to my wife. My actions hurt her and our children. There is no excuse for what I did. I'm deeply sorry. Do you think he confirmed to his wife before he confirmed the company-wide email?
3:47Yeah. I mean, you'd hope he's just sent her a quick text. Just about to update the company. Here's what I've been up to. He probably got ChatGPT to do it. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, probably. Use those chips. Yeah. But he's interesting. I think he's a very, very respected CEO who has embodied being in the right place at the right time, which is the kind of mixture of luck and foresight that really helps people succeed. So for a long time, NVIDIA nvidia i think was founded in 1993 and for about two decades they basically made graphics cards for gaming pcs so um outside of the video games industry not particularly well known so actually when i was a tech reporter, I would go to technology trade shows and there would be Jensen Huang on a little stage in front of about 30 people, you know, probably half of them trade press writing about the latest GeForce graphics card and what it would mean for your gaming PC. gaming pc um but the thing about graphics chips is basically as screens get bigger and as computer
5:08games get more advanced you need something that can basically draw more triangles at once um so the bit of maths that it has to do isn't particularly complex but it has to do lots and lots of those sums at once so in a computer you would have the the cpu the main processing unit and then you would have the gpu which is what nvidia were making do make and that would do yeah if you think about processing as basically maths it's not doing the hardest sums but it's doing lots and lots and lots of sums all at once parallel computing for a long time that just involved just drawing things on a screen but then fairly early on jensen huang was trying to broaden what his technology they were making could be used for and other stuff came along
6:00so the the first thing was the crypto boom. So that basically that kind of parallel processing is also useful for crypto mining, which is also basically doing loads of little calculations for effectively no reason. And then along comes AI. And he was very, very early to recognize the potential of his technology for that. So he started going to AI companies. I think he delivered this specially made graphics card to OpenAI by hand himself, took it to them in 2016. So ChatsGPT didn't come out until 2022. So he was very, very early to recognize that that was going to be potentially a use for his technology yeah and then 2022 chat gpt happens and there's this enormous gold rush and in a gold rush the people
6:53who actually get rich are the people selling the shovels and nvidia like i said 80 of the gpus used for ai are made by them so it's it's almost the only shovel company in town so like some of the very very best ceos he sort of cornered the market for something before that market existed yeah um and that has been absolutely phenomenal for nvidia they were the first company to be valued over five trillion dollars um but obviously his his departure has um shaved a fair bit off that um i think in the first day after the affair was revealed nvidia's market cap dropped by about 380 billion something like that i mean obviously when they're worth so much the valuations can fluctuate by enormous amounts but there are two schools of thought
7:46now about what this is going to mean for the company and for AI companies with these enormous valuations. So on the one hand, some people have pointed out that quite often when a CEO is caught having an affair, the stock dips and then it goes back up again and actually it'll end up higher yeah i've read about this so that happened with amazon microsoft and alphabet yeah after affairs by their yeah leaders so i mean arguably a recipe for success but the really important thing is the question of to what extent the affair was with somebody who was... A Chinese spy. Yeah, a Chinese spy. Because if the valuations of these companies rely on the idea that they are years and years ahead of the competition
8:35in something that is incredibly difficult to do, if the intellectual property you've created starts turning up in a Chinese company, and in China, AI models tend to be open source, electrical property you've created starts turning up in a chinese company and chinese in china ai models tend to be open source um so that then your your economic moat evaporates like you and that's why we saw when um china unveiled this much cheaper um more efficient ai model uh deep seek there was a trillion dollars was wiped off the valuations of tech companies in a single day um and that was because of you know if china can do it more efficiently or you know more cheaply then um that that radically alters the the value proposition
9:17in the market these companies that's why all the the money is sort of fleeing from nvidia um as as we speak um it might be the case that you know she didn't have that much access and still they'll be back yeah there's a huge amount riding on it because also in terms of ai companies nvidia is kind of at the center of this like web of financing so that ai bros like to talk about self-recursive self-improvement, which is this idea that models start to improve themselves and get more and more advanced. But the industry is also recursively self-financing. So the companies give money to each other to buy their own products and that kind of thing. So, for example so nvidia gave open ai financing of i think it's 105 billion dollars to build out data center capacity and then open
10:14ai basically committed to spend that on nvidia's chips so you know it's they're giving them money to say well but you'll. Which is all very legal. And there are lots of these kinds of deals, which on the one hand, you could say that's just sort of necessary for the industry to all work together and build this stuff as quickly as possible. On the other hand, you could say, this is how a bubble is constructed. And you could see it as a web. You could see it as a, you know, more of a pyramid shape. I don't know. It depends how you choose to look at it but the whole structure of the ai boom and its finance starts to look less certain if one of the major components suddenly deflates so that's not a story that's going to stop with one 62 year old
11:03man in a leather jacket having an affair. Well, let's talk a bit about this, Will, because as if this poor man hasn't had a difficult enough week, in the piece that you've written about this whole thing, there's a drive-by about his wardrobe describing him as wearing the overpriced leather jackets of a recently divorced dad since the early 2010s. I mean, Will, I would would say to this how else would honey traps know how to identify their targets well surely yeah it's a man so insecure in his masculinity that he has to buy expensive animal hide as a version of hunter gathering i mean that's your target come on girls we've got it it does the the whole leather jacket thing yeah i mean and you see other tech ceos
11:47wearing yeah you do yeah so you see musk in a leather or a shearling sometimes uh bezos has definitely been seen in a fair bit of leather um as in the the like the weird new bezos not the not the previous like relatively normal he looks like a businessman in a suit Bezos I mean the kind of weird like Jim Bro yeah yeah space Bezos so yeah there is there is something about that kind of leather jacket on a man that age because all of these guys are uh I think Jensen Wang's 62 Be Bezos' early 60s, right? I think Musk is late 50s. There is something about a man that age in a very, very expensive leather jacket just absolutely reeks of a very advanced form of midlife crisis, a very, very expensive midlife crisis.
12:39Yeah, and I just have to feel for these women really because I hope they haven't been left disappointed if he could only get a semi-conductor. And if you're a trillionaire tech CEO with erectile dysfunction, do let us know in the comments. Let's take a quick break here. We'll be back in a bit. 75% of women who seek menopause care don't receive it. The lying awake at 3 a.m., wondering what's happening to your body ends now. Midi is virtual care built for women in perimenopause and menopause with clinicians who specialize in women's health. Plus, it's covered by most major insurances. Getting started is easy. You can book your first visit with a clinician right away. Midlife needs Midi. Visit joinmidi.com to book your first visit today. I love days like these at the pool,
13:38but my moderate to severe plaque psoriasis can sometimes take me out of the moment. I'm ready to make a splash with clearer skin thanks to Sky Rizzi, Rizankizumab Rizza. Sky Rizzy is a prescription-only injection for adults who are candidates for systemic or phototherapy. At four months, most people saw 90% clearer skin when measured from head to toe, and many were even 100% plaque-free. People also saw significant improvement in psoriasis symptoms of pain, redness, itching, and burning. Don't use if allergic to Sky Rizzi. Serious allergic reactions, increased infections, or lower ability to fight them may occur. Before treatment, get checked for infections and tuberculosis. Tell your doctor about any flu-like symptoms or vaccines.
14:15Now there's nothing on my skin, thanks to Sky Rizzi. And that means everything. Ask your doctor about Sky Rizzi, the number one dermatologist prescribed biologic and psoriasis. Visit SkyRizzi.com or call 1-866-SKY-RIZZI to learn more. Welcome back. We're on to our next category, which is nice work if you can get it, of the week. So, Will, I have been looking, oh, well, I've been reading about this civil servant, Kashim Chowdhury, who between 2020 and 2023 had eight full-time public sector roles that overlapped and earned him 350 grand in total. And at one point, he was working five jobs that overlapped at the same time in the spring of 2023 when he was contracted to work 183 hours per week.
15:08There aren't 183 hours in a week. And he fraudulently earned more than £284,000 of taxpayers' money. And he's been convicted of fraud. And he used sick notes and remote working to juggle jobs. And I think one of his bosses said that he used white face paint to try and make himself look ill. It's an absolutely amazing story that involves a lot of major government departments, the Department of Health, the Home Office, Department for Business and Trade, the Food Standards Agency, DEFRA, and obviously is being used by critics of the civil service to suggest that they're, you know, everything that they believe about the way that civil servants work, and the way that Whitehall is run is correct. And actually,
15:49our colleague, Megan Kenyon has written a good piece about this. And she messaged Dominic Cummings to say, what do you think of this story? And he just replied, all systems working as intended by Tories and Labour, which I thought was a great quote. I mean, arguably not that intentional. But I mean, surely if this guy wanted 350 grand of ill-gotten gains, then he should have just done six months running HS2. Nice. I was going to say, do you feel sympathy for this man as someone who works as the new statesman's sketch writer, business editor and podcast host? no i've been rumbled i've been rumbled well on the one hand the first thing i thought when i read this story for the first time i thought about joaquin garcia um who worked or rather didn't work for the cadiz
16:40water authority um this is a spanish civil servant um so it's public water authority who the he was caught because they were going to give him a plaque commemorating his 20 years of service and then people started saying well who is this guy and they realized he hadn't been in the office for at least six years and possibly as much as 14 years he'd been at home um and he said when he was reporters caught up with him he said he'd been reading philosophy at home good use of his time well done Joaquin but I don't I don't think it's particularly I understand why people jump on this as an example of you know the civil service not being as efficient as it could be but i don't think i think the language used around this story is a bit misleading so
17:31even the bbc news reporting they're saying oh he was doing five jobs and the the bbc used the phrase that he earned these amounts but he wasn't doing these jobs he was just malingering um you know and that people were obviously trying to get this guy to do work you know they were getting him to turn up to these like interviews of which she you know performance review type yeah yeah and they were trying to get him to explain why he was having all this time off and i assume there were other people who had to pick up all the work that he wasn't doing because he was busy committing fraud. And I think this does happen in the private sector, but you wouldn't hear about it because it would take place in a less public manner.
18:22And it's not taxpayers' money that's being fraudulently earned. Well, exactly, yeah. But I do also understand, yeah, it's our taxes, but also public sector productivity, I think, is the real reason why people get really annoyed by a story like this, because the productivity growth of the public sector is just absolutely dire in the UK. So from 1997 to 2019, the output relative to spending from the public sector dropped by about 0.3% per year. So that's just the public sector consistently offering less value for money year after year after year. And then it got loads worse during covid and you know so like productivity growth is terrible when in terms of what the taxpayer gets for their money and we see that everywhere and it's easy to say that a case like this illustrates that
19:20but i think there's obviously you know this obviously isn't happening loads we would know and actually this is what happens it's interesting because this has come in the week of the head of the civil service antonio robio talking about the uk civil service being no longer the sort of rolls royce that it was purported to be and it's it's not considered to be the best in the world anymore she said And she wants to do some new performance management that would incentivize and reward brilliant delivery, valuable expertise and sticking it out to get the job done, therefore implying that's not what's going on at the moment. And so it's interesting that that's come in the same week as this. And it's clear that she's trying to tee up the civil service for efficiency, which basically means making savings by cutting jobs and yeah um you know freezing hiring and all of that and actually the the consequence of doing
20:10that is that you might get a situation where someone is doing two or three jobs right yeah yeah i mean you i mean i think well i'm not sure you can say, oh, well, we would, you know, you always just have to just look out for fraudsters and prosecute them, really. But yeah, I mean, at the same time, whenever you go to, as both of us do, like conferences about local government and things like that, there's always talk about, oh, the problem we have is what we can't get the best people to come work in in local government and that's because yeah because they don't necessarily have the best incentives um for you know you you'll always see headlines about people who are overpaid in local government and
20:56some people in local government certainly are you never see headlines about the much larger group of people in local government who aren't necessarily paid all that well and do a lot of thankless work that is quite difficult and kind of is kind of propping up yeah exactly yeah what's your nice work if you can get it of the week so my nice work if you can get it this week is saying fun stuff about trains on stage to an audience full of people um who've watched maybe 22 series of you talking about trains and being a self-deprecating cabinet minister former cabinet minister sorry so i have i have chosen i've chosen my own sketch from this week's magazine in a crass as is your right self-serving piece of self-promotion.
22:07But it is a brilliant sketch. It's really funny. So this is Michael Portillo. It's interesting that he's sort of still doing the rounds. I mean, this is kind of the theme of your sketch, the thesis of your sketch,. And it's basically half of the event seems to be him talking about trains, as he's been doing in his documentaries for how many years? 20 years? Oh, yeah, a long time now. Yeah. I mean, he's an interesting character because he is, I mean, he described himself as applying for a position as a national treasure. Probably actually explicitly said that. Yeah. He sees himself as being on the way to Attenborough status or something in that area. And he makes lovely programs about trains.
22:39But at the same time, he also has this political past. He wasn't a cuddly politician he was the face of the new right then he was thatcher's presumed heir at one point he was you know hesseltine was the sort of the old wets and he was the new harder right he emerged from this group of ideologists at Peterhouse College in Cambridge where he studied and then, you know, became one of these early sort of harder Eurosceptics and did so at a young age and was extremely ambitious, was defence secretary and all these kinds of things and um yeah and and launched a failed coup actually from the same house in lord north street from which boris johnson later launched his successful coup against teresa may and i think they were 24 years apart but yeah i think he is he's an
23:40interesting character um but also i think he embodies this thing that politicians seem to want now which is to be on be on tv you know you see michael gove who actually wrote portillo's autobiography doing the um pretending to be prime minister on the reality show that we oh yes yeah this is a bugbear of mine as politicians trying to rehabilitate their reputations by going on reality tv and yeah cuddly programs and trying to turn themselves from you know grubby politician into national treasure yeah i mean ed ball's doing his dancing you know every politician now politics has almost become a route to a podcast or doing a nice show where you wander through some cobbled streets and talk to a local historian it's it's like as you know even like andy burnham is still
24:33prime minister and he's been on goggle box i mean it's just become a stepping stone to the better job on tv yeah yeah and and tell me a bit about who actually goes to watch, apart from Will Dunn, who goes to go and watch An Evening with Michael Portillo in Chelsea? Well, it's, I guess, the sort of audience you might expect in Cadogan Hall in Chelsea on a Monday night seeing a retired Tory cabinet minister. Very, very, very, very posh. Excruciatingly posh. So in the piece, there were two guys behind me who were literally having a conversation about shooting. Yes, I enjoyed that. downstairs behind me um an older lady um who was actually she she looked kind of dressed for shooting in a way very sort of tweedy uh and some very sturdy looking boots and um she was saying
25:35she was talking about all the international train journeys they'd been on like a serious hardcore portillo fan obviously and she was saying oh, next we're going to Uzbekistan to go on the trains there. I was thinking, wow, these people are, you know, there is a serious community of people who go on nice train journeys. That is core Portillo. Core Tillo. But I do, yeah, I go to a lot of these an evening with things um as do politicians so they start off doing them while they're in politics because it's a very common way to bring together fundraisers so often you will have um you have dinners or you and the person for whom the funds are being raised will give a speech or like a party bigwig will go to a fundraiser for another MP.
26:29And then that leads into, you know, you'll go to your local conservative association and give a speech. I mean, you know, it's part of meeting people, but also that gives them a natural sort of affinity for just getting up in front of groups of people and doing a bit of after dinner style speaking uh i did feel i have to say that portillo's um speaking some of his jokes were i mean to say they were well worn i think they wouldn't have been accepted by a charity shop they were i mean one of his jokes was so old and so well used. I literally looked it up and it literally has its own Wikipedia page, this anecdote, as it's been used by so many people in so many different contexts. But he delivered them with great aplomb
27:16in a very avuncular, very Boris Johnson-y way that the audience lapped it up. What's that joke? What's the old joke? Can you tell it? Can you become a footnote in the Wikipedia page? It's another man who has told this joke. So Portillo's version, he was saying that he was on the bridge of an aircraft carrier when he was Defence Secretary and he was stood next to this mustachioed rear admiral who barked an an order that and they were looking at the radar and they saw a blip come up and he barked an order into the things telling the blip to get out of the way and the reply comes back no you must change your course and he said no repeat order you must change your course. And then the person said, no, you must change your course.
28:05And then the admiral said, I'm Sir Admiral Sir Anthony Michael Clutterbuck. And I'm telling you, I'm on the HMS Art Royal. I'm telling you, you must change your course. And the reply comes back. Well, I am the lighthouse keeper of the so-and-so lighthouse. And I'm telling you, you must change your course. And it's quite it's a quite a good yarn and it's one that's been used again and again um apparently it happened in the u.s navy uh the first time around but it never actually did it's just it's a shaggy dog story that gets told at you know military events i guess which is probably where he heard it well i bet that went down really well with that audience who loved it as you note when they hear the phrase senior rail card a few of them actually cheer which is a great deal yeah
28:51the one one nice thing about going to these things is um uh even a middle-aged man like me can feel you know comfortably one of the comfortably one of the youngest people in the room i feel very gen z going to events like this. We're going to take a quick break now. Remember, you can listen to the New Statesman podcast ad-free by downloading the New Statesman app. It's available on iOS and Android. Links are in the show notes. Gift a New Statesman subscription for only £2 this festive season. Visit newstatesman.com forward slash Christmas26 to subscribe. and remarkably fast. What's this? Garland? A wreath? Essentials to host? Good thing she celebrates way longer than most. As her cart filled with magic
29:49and decor from the heart, Merry Christmas to all. Get your Wayfair head start. For holiday decor you can count on year after year, Wayfair delivers. Do you snore? Did somebody hand you a CPAP and did you quietly stop using it? The mask that never quite seals? The hose tugging at you every time you roll over? A machine sitting abandoned in a closet? Excite OSA works a different way. It treats a root cause instead of managing the noise, and you use it while you're awake. 20 minutes a day, while the coffee brews, while you set your fantasy lineup. An FDA-cleared prescription device for primary snoring and mild obstructive sleep apnea. Then you go to bed like a person, nothing strapped on, nothing plugged in. In
30:39clinical studies, 90% of patients saw a reduction in snoring. No sleep study required. Prescribed online, shipped to your door. Excite OSA at springsleep.com slash sleep20. Code sleep20 for 20% off. Excite OSA is an FDA-cleared prescription-only device for primary snoring and mild obstructive sleep apnea. Not for everyone. Individual results vary. Risks and benefits at springsleep.com. Welcome back. We're on to our last category, which is money can't buy happiness of the week. So, Will, I've been looking into this new project at the LSE where some academics are trying to draw what they call an extreme wealth line. So this, everyone knows the idea of a poverty line or the bread line, that there is a level of poor which is too poor,
31:39where you can't sort of meet your basic needs. And that's been measured since sort of the Victorian philanthropists of sort of the turn of the 20th century. The World Bank measures a sort of international poverty line and calculates the absolute bare minimum that a human can live on. And they want to work out what the line is to do the same thing for extreme wealth. So how rich is too rich and i thought this was really interesting because they have tried to do this before there was a study in the uk um back in 2020 that i covered um where they basically tried to work out whether or not the british public feels that there is a a level of wealth or income that is too much and they did that by by presenting these different brackets
32:25of kind of lifestyle markers to the people who they were consulting for the study. And basically, there was no level of wealth where the public could really say that's too much. They started feeling a bit more negative at the wealthy level. So there's five levels. And in this level, you have a housekeeper, five holidays a year, privately educated children. You own a horse and pay for stabling. You have a personal Pilates instructor and pedigree pets as opposed to just run-of-the-mill pets. So that was where a few negative comments started to come in. But overall, none of the public who they consulted on this idea of a riches line said that they think that there is a level of rich that is too rich, which I think is really interesting sort of insight into the British psyche.
33:16So if you own a horse and you don't pay for stapling, you just let it run around. You own a stolen horse. But I mean, being insanely rich does make people a bit mad, doesn't it? I mean, it's not necessarily good for people to be insanely rich, is it? Well, I'm glad you said that because that's exactly what these academics who are trying to come up with the new measure are arguing. They're basically saying there is a level where you have too much wealth because it starts to harm society. So whether that's the environment or whether it's democracy, you might earn enough money to be able to buy, not earn, but you might have enough money to buy an election. And they were saying that you can actually measure sort of how much money, they haven't come up with a figure yet
34:02because they've just started the work on it, but they said you can actually measure how much money they haven't come up with a figure yet because they've just started the work on it but they said you can actually measure how much money becomes sort of uh unconscionably harmful to society i think this is a really interesting argument it is yeah limitarianism isn't it as sometimes described but i guess the practical issue that you come up against is people who are insanely rich, effectively all of their assets are financial assets. And in the case of somebody like Elon Musk, that's all concentrated in the companies that he owns yeah runs so how do you do you actually limit the wealth of that person
34:48a bit above a certain level i mean if if you just say well you know two billions enough for you and we'll take like how are you going to expropriate of them of you know what 950 billion or whatever else he's going to have left and how are you going to stop that from just crashing the value of those companies leading them to you know i mean like it becomes on a practical level i think like the yeah the you have to start from point of saying well it would be better if these people were never able to get that rich but then like financial markets would have to work in a very different way wouldn't they and that might have implications for you know the whole retirement savings thing that everyone relies on and stuff like that yeah i think the idea is less to say
35:35okay we've drawn this line and now you're not allowed to have above it it's more to create a popular and international consensus that there is such a thing as having too much um which they think would you know eventually help change attitudes towards inequality and wealth. Because at the moment, in Britain at least, in all of the studies that I've read on this, we have a very, very strong ingrained meritocratic narrative. So we think that people on the whole who are rich have got there because they deserve it. And the people who believe in that meritocratic narrative the most are the people who earn the most money. Surprise, surprise. And so that's really hard to shift. It is ingrained. Even having reported on these
36:16kind of studies for a while, I'm sure that I have that impulse somewhere in my brain where I think someone sort of deserves it. So that's hard to shift. And also you have the aspirational thing. So people don't really like hearing about wealth taxes and higher tax bands and things and mansion taxes, even if they don't have that much money themselves, because they like to imagine that in future one day they will and they would want to keep that for themselves. So that's a very, very strong, at least in Britain, impulse as well. well but again i guess in a world in which financial markets are by far and away the fastest and easiest way to get very very rich then yeah that becomes more of a you know a wealth that accelerates in a more a less sort of tangible way i guess and yeah
37:01i i agree like i mean in your brilliant reporting on the return of the ASBO last week, you know, you were talking about this idea, recurring idea of the undeserving poor. Yeah. But we don't have in society an idea of the undeserving rich. Yeah, exactly. Yeah. I like that phrase. What have you chosen for your money can't buy you happiness? So just one extremely wealthy person who we might soon feel thankful for, King Athelstan. We don't speak about King Athelstan enough on the podcast, do we? We don't. I think that potentially for podcast fans who want to hear more about King Athelstan, there might be other podcasts that can scratch that itch. We don't know. Never heard of it. So next year, he will have been dead for about 11,
37:54for exactly 1100 years. Apparently, it was cause for celebration. Campaigners, including Tom Holland, the historian, I feel like he's been on a podcast. But they want a one-off bank holiday in England on Monday, the 12th of July next year to mark the 1100th anniversary of Athelstan becoming the first king of a unified England. Now, if you were going to choose a politician who would opportunistically jump on a people-pleasing measure and would never have to put up with the consequences of implementing it, who would you choose? Can I shock you? Lib Dem leader Ed Davey has urged the government to create the holiday. Loves urging the government, does Ed. He loves to urge. Yeah, but he does. He's just a populist, isn't he, Ed Davey?
38:54Yes. But actually, he does have a bit of a claim to Athelstan because the site of Athelstan's coronation is within his constituency uh but yeah lisa nandy has not backed the idea um because bank holidays cost the economy money and you're not going to keep up your fragile economic growth if you let everyone take the day off work even if you know there's civil servants doing five five days worth of malingering in one. But she has said, you know, we're going to do something to have a fitting commemoration of Athelstan. So I look forward to that. Great, great. I love that even the campaign from the people who love Athelstan the most and are most excited about this anniversary of a unified England,
39:41it's only for a one-off bank holiday. I mean, how English is that? Yeah, we don't want to make a fuss. They riot in France, but this is our revolution. Just the one. That'll be plenty. Athy tubes. We're making it happen. You've been listening to The Sketch from The New Statesman with me, Anoush Shakelian, and my colleague, Will Dunn. The podcast will be back on Monday. Do you think today's world needs more bold ideas? So do we. The University of Chicago Booth School of Business can help you unlock your potential. With world-class campuses in Chicago, London, and Hong Kong, Chicago Booth is where bold ideas come to life. If you're ready to expand your thinking and push your ideas further, then it's time to go Booth. Thank you.

