podcasts / The Politics Show / episode
The Politics Show cover art
podcast
📅 2026-11-16 ⏱ 32 min episode · ~2 min read 📝 Transcript · 6,335 words 🎙 Anoush

Britain’s violence-obsessed adolescents — Anoush, The Politics Show transcript

The Politics Show · · Transcript & summary by WhipScribe

It explains a new government category for violence-obsessed teenagers that most people have never heard of, using a rare first-person account and polling that has never been done before.

Read the transcript Episode page ↗
In this episodeSouthportPreventLeanne LucasYouth Endowment FundPalestine ActionHome OfficeOnline Safety ActNew StatesmanTom McTagueTaylor Swift

▸Chapters

Tap a chapter to play it from that moment in the show's own player; the transcript opens there too.

Transcribe your links. Paste a YouTube, Google Drive or podcast link and WhipScribe gives you the transcript. Transcribe a link →

▸Notable quotes

“the generation that for their entire lives have had access to this kind of violent material” Tom McTague · at 18:07 — ▶ hear it from here
“I think this might actually be a sort of sticking plaster measure.” Anoush · at 27:37 — ▶ hear it from here

▸What this episode covers

Anoush, a New Statesman writer, explains Whitehall's new label for young people obsessed with violence but without a clear political cause. The Southport attack shows the gap: the attacker had Al-Qaeda material and Nazi interests, was referred to Prevent three times, and was judged to lack a single ideology, so he was never classed as a terrorist. That affects what victims can access, and it raises the question of whether attacks on girls are misogyny, political violence, or both.

The episode follows a young man the piece calls Billy, who fantasised about killing after being bullied at school, was hospitalised and given antipsychotics, and has since recovered. Official figures are hard to compare because a new Prevent category began in 2024, but 818 referrals, including 566 children, were logged in the year to September 2025. A Youth Endowment Fund poll found one in five 13-to-17-year-olds in England and Wales had sought violent material or fantasised about harming others in the past year.

Experts link the problem to a generation that has graphic footage a tap away, where violence can work like an addiction and online forums reward escalation. Critics on the left worry about overreach against ordinary Muslim children, and critics on the right say Prevent has been captured by a politically correct brigade. Leanne Lucas, a survivor of the Southport attack, calls the new category a false sense of security. The piece concludes that no one agrees on the right path.

▸Anoush on The Politics Show: the answers

Who is Anoush?

Anoush

Anoush is a New Statesman writer who wrote the magazine feature on violence-fixated young people in Britain. She joins Tom McTague on this episode to walk through her reporting.

What did Anoush say about Prevent?

Anoush explained that Prevent is the government's early prevention counter-extremism system, which was built around a specific ideology. She said that people obsessed with violence without a clear political cause can fall through it, because they do not fit that ideology test.

“PREVENT, which is the early prevention counter-extremism system that the government has.”Anoush · 3:21

What did Anoush say about Southport murders?

Anoush cited the Southport murders as the most obvious example of a high-profile crime in the UK where the perpetrator had shown an obsession with violence beforehand. She said this kind of behaviour can include researching school shootings online or watching graphic footage of real violence.

“the Southport murders is the most obvious example”Anoush · 2:43

What did Anoush say about Youth Endowment Fund?

Anoush said the Youth Endowment Fund gave her polling that it had never published before, the first time children who feel this way have been polled. It found one in five children aged 13 to 17 in England and Wales had sought violent material or fantasised about harming others at least once in the past year.

“some polling that I was given exclusively by the Youth Endowment Fund”Anoush · 13:54

What did Anoush say about Online Safety Act?

Anoush said most of the experts she interviewed barely mentioned the Online Safety Act or the social media ban coming next year. She said they felt that children who wanted to seek out this material would still be able to find it, which she found worrying.

“they barely mentioned the online safety act and the coming social media ban”Anoush · 34:31

What is Anoush's main argument on The Politics Show about violence-fixated teenagers?

Anoush argues that Whitehall has created a new category, violence fixated individuals, for young people obsessed with violence who fall outside the ideology-based counter-extremism system. She says the existing framework is not built to catch them, and that the government's response is still unclear, with no one agreeing on the right path.

Mentioned in this episode

Episode facts

Released
November 16, 2026
Length
32 minutes

▸Key takeaways

01Whitehall's new violence fixated category put 818 people, including 566 children, into Prevent referrals in the year ending September 2025.
02Teenagers who seek out gore or violent footage without a political ideology fall outside Prevent's test, so they can slip through the counter-extremism system.
03Youth Endowment Fund polling found one in five 13-to-17-year-olds in England and Wales sought violent material or fantasised about harming others last year.
04Leanne Lucas, a Southport dance teacher who survived the attack, argues the new category is a false sense of security that misses misogyny.
05Anoush concludes no one has a clear answer on the right path, and the experts she interviewed barely mentioned the Online Safety Act or the coming social media ban.

▸Questions this episode answers

Q1What did Anoush say about violence fixated individuals on The Politics Show?

Anoush explained that Whitehall has adopted the term violence fixated individuals, or VFIs, for people who show an obsession with violence without a clear political cause. She said the category covers people who research school shootings or watch graphic footage of real violence, and that existing counter-extremism rules were built to catch ideology rather than obsession.

Q2What did Anoush say about Prevent and the Southport attacker's ideology?

Anoush said the Southport attacker had an Al-Qaeda manual, an interest in Nazi Germany and Hitler, and a tablet full of material on Rwanda, the Balkans and other violence. He was referred to Prevent three times but was judged to have no specific ideology. She said a judge at sentencing called the attack akin to terrorism, though it was not classed that way.

Q3What did Anoush say about the Youth Endowment Fund polling on teenage violence?

Anoush reported polling given to her exclusively by the Youth Endowment Fund, the first time children who feel this way have been polled. One in five children aged 13 to 17 in England and Wales sought violent material or fantasised about harming others in the past year, one in 10 thought about a specific act of violence against a person or group, and one in 20 engaged in these behaviours weekly. She said the polling cannot show a rise because no earlier data exists.

Q4What did Leanne Lucas say about the new violence fixation category?

Leanne Lucas, a dance teacher who survived the Southport attack, was sceptical of the new violence fixation category. Anoush said Lucas argued the attacker had multiple ideologies, had Nazi material as well as Al-Qaeda manuals, and clearly hated girls, so the attack was misogynistic. Lucas called the new category a false sense of security and a sticking plaster measure.

Q5Why does Anoush say online violent footage affects today's teenagers differently?

Anoush said today's teenagers are the first generation to have grown up with access to extreme violent material on the internet, from Syria and ISIS beheadings to footage from Gaza and Ukraine. A psychologist she interviewed told her that violence fixation can work like an addiction, with each video giving a buzz that pushes viewers toward more extreme material. The psychologist also said AI now lets users create violent content themselves.

Q6What did Anoush say about criticism of Prevent from the left and right?

Anoush said criticism of Prevent comes from both sides. Critics on the left worry that referrals about Islamist terrorism sweep up ordinary Muslim children and create division in communities. Critics on the right argue that Prevent has been taken over by a politically correct brigade that hides the continuing threat from Islamist terrorism. Anoush said the two lines of criticism converge on concern that too many people are being scooped into the system.

Q7Did Anoush say the Online Safety Act addresses teenagers seeking violent material?

Anoush said most of the experts she spoke to barely mentioned the Online Safety Act or the social media ban coming next year. Their view was that children who want to seek out this material will still be able to find it. She said this worried her and that the country has not grappled with children being able to view whatever they like online from the age they first use a smartphone.

▸Transcript

Our own transcript of the public episode, with a timestamp about every 90 seconds. Tap a timestamp to play the episode from there in the show's own player; the link button on a paragraph copies a link that opens this page there.

0:00Do you snore? Did somebody hand you a CPAP and did you quietly stop using it? The mask that never quite seals? The hose tugging at you every time you roll over? A machine sitting abandoned in a closet? Excite OSA works a different way. It treats a root cause instead of managing the noise, and you use it while you're awake. 20 minutes a day, while the coffee brews, while you set your fantasy lineup. An FDA-cleared prescription device for primary snoring and mild obstructive sleep apnea. Then you go to bed like a person, nothing strapped on, nothing plugged in. In clinical studies, 90% of patients saw a reduction in snoring. No sleep study required. Prescribed online, shipped to your door. Excite OSA at springsleep.com slash sleep20. Code sleep20 for

0:5620% off. Excite OSA is an FDA-cleared prescription-only device for primary snoring and mild obstructive sleep apnea. Not for everyone. Individual results vary. Risks and benefits This message is brought to you by today's sponsor, Walden University. Set a course for change. Now is the time to make a real change in your life, career, and community. At Walden University, we give you the support and flexibility to get the W. Walden's online programs are designed for working professionals like you. You'll gain hands-on skills to take on real-world challenges and succeed. Your future is waiting and Walden is here to help you achieve it. Take the first step to make your impact. Visit waldenu.edu. Walden University.

1:44Set a course for change. Certified to operate by Chev. The New Statesman. Hello, I'm Tom McTague and you're listening to The Politics Show from The New Statesman. Anoush is here with me, but she's not in the hosting chair today because I wanted to talk to her about an amazing report that she's got in the magazine this week on Britain's new adolescent nightmare, we call it. So just, you know, an uplifting story that you've been spending two weeks looking into. Let's start with the fundamentals of the story that you've been looking into. Whitehall, you write, has produced a new acronym. It's a fairly depressing one, but it's called VFIs, which is violence fixated individuals. Can you tell us what these people are? I mean, in one sense, it's kind of obvious, but why is this

2:43a new category and why should we sort of be worried about it? Yeah. So, I mean, if one sense, it's kind of obvious, but why is this a new category and why should we sort of be worried about it? Yeah. So, I mean, if you look at some high profile crimes that sadly have sort of blighted the UK in recent years, the Southport murders is the most obvious example, but there are many others that I list in the piece. Often it turns out that the perpetrator of these crimes has been someone who has shown beforehand, before committing the crime, an obsession with violence. So whether that's researching school shootings online or watching very, very explicit graphic footage of real life violence, they've displayed that.

3:21And it's becoming something that's worrying Whitehall so much that they've come up with this, that they're looking into this new acronym. I'm not sure if the acronym was actually coined in Whitehall, but they're using it there now. And also this acronym NIEV, which is non ideological extreme violence. So there's this sort of gap that these people are falling through in the system, which is if you are obsessed with, you know, if you've got Al-Qaeda manuals and you're obsessed with watching ISIS beheading videos, then you could be referred to PREVENT, which is the early prevention counter-extremism system that the government has. But it's an obvious ideology, and you have that on the far right as well. But an obsession

4:06with violence doesn't necessarily manifest as a sort of political ideology or something that you'd naturally sort of categorize as a terrorist leaning. And therefore, they're not really being picked up under our current counter extremism framework. And so there's work going on in Whitehall to try and make sure that they catch these individuals as part of that framework or even in a whole new system itself. We don't know what they're actually going to come up with as a long term plan. But that's what the Southport Inquiry, which has now entered its second phase, is now looking into as well. Right. So there's a lot to unpick there, isn't there? So PREVENT is the sort of anti-extremism yeah um program yeah and and it was and it emerged uh in the early 2000s after 9-11 and it was a it

4:53was a sort of focus then on is the missed ideology particularly and since then as the threats have grown and changed or you know uh developed it has taken in other threats like you mentioned right-wing extremism extreme right-wing radicalization um and now it's moving into this new thing which is people who are just non-ideological they might not they might have multiple ideologies but they don't have one specific thing. It seems almost like, are we talking about sort of definitions here? Like, you know, what is terrorism? Does it have to be in pursuit of a political agenda? Because most people, I think, would assume something like Southport. Well, of course, that's terrorism. That is terrorizing the public, whether it's in pursuit of a political goal or not. the perpetrator in the Southport murders. He was found to have an Al-Qaeda manual, but also to have an obsession with Nazi Germany and Hitler and this tablet that he had in his room,

6:11full of everything from Rwanda to the Balkans, ethnic cleansing, videos of all sorts of different types of violence from all sorts of political standpoints. He was deemed by, you know, he was referred to prevent three times, but it was deemed that he didn't have a specific ideology. Some would argue that he just had multiple ideologies and that, you know, this is a sort of case of terrorism. He sought out to kill women and girls in particular. And I think the judge at his sentencing remarks did say this is akin to an act of terrorism. It's just not classed that way. And there are many problems with why it's not classed that way. First of all, if his kind of behavior that he displayed before committing the crime had been classed in that category, then he may have been picked up and on the route to being de-radicalized. But also, it manifests in all sorts of other ways. So,

7:05Leanne Lucas, one of the teachers who survived that attack, she told me that because it wasn't classed as terrorism, she can't access certain help that the government provides to victims of terror attacks. And it's just sort of described as a mass event. And she felt that sort of undermined it slightly. And that, you know, because he was targeting women and girls, that's an act of misogyny. It's an act against a specific group. And what's the difference between an act against a specific group of people who happen to be women and girls and those of a minority group where it would count as a political crime? Yeah. Or we've seen, haven't we, you know, controversy in recent months about Palestine action.

7:41Yeah. And you would say, and that is classed as terrorism because it is violent political activity in pursuit of a goal. But it could be violence against a property or material things rather than against people. And so you have this curious situation. People would find it almost perverse that you have something like Palestine action described or classified in this way but uh the south port attacks which i think clearly emotionally to to to a large part of the country has terrorized us you know it is it's a it's a terrifying thing and it has radicalized some people as we saw in the riots in the aftermath yeah i i why don don't we go back into your piece? Because you start talking about an individual

8:29who was one of these people who was violence obsessed without a kind of a particular motivation, whether it's, you know, sort of in pursuit of a goal. It was just the sense of vengeful violence, which seemed to sort of capture him. You talk about him as Billy, you say in the piece, you changed his name to protect his identity so that he could speak to you freely. And now that he's older, he's at university and he's kind of, he's sort of moved past that phase. But it was quite chilling in a sense to sort of be, to read his description of himself as a teenager and how he got sort of dragged into this world. Yeah, it was really chilling speaking to him. And I am very grateful that he did speak to me because this is not something that many young people want to admit or to talk about.

9:20He he became obsessed with thoughts of violence and fantasized about killing people because he was bullied at school and he felt like he was being bullied by the teachers as well as one pupil in particular and this is a common characteristic of teenagers who are fixated on violence I've spoken to a psychologist who works specifically with these people in the piece and she says often it will be someone who's a bit isolated, bullied at school and develops a sort of fantasy world where they beat the bullies. And that can, in a minority of cases, lead to fixations on killing people or school shootings and that kind of thing. And he described that he just got obsessed with this idea and it was taking up all of his headspace.

10:03He couldn't get the thoughts out of his head to the extent that he described it as homicidal ideation. So some of our listeners will know the phrase suicidal ideation because that's sort of when you have thoughts of harming yourself. And it's something that a mental health professional will ask anyone who comes in seeking help for anxiety or depression. Do you have suicidal ideation? He described it as that. So it sort of was these thoughts dogging him. He never did harm anyone, but he did get to the point where he was worried that he might. And in the end, he was hospitalized and given antipsychotics. And he's sort of been on a path of recovery since then. But it was interesting speaking to him because I think, you know, the most of most teenagers,

10:40and there's some polling that we'll get into that shows that it's quite an extraordinary proportion of teenagers who display some of these behaviors in the UK, won't go on to actually harm anyone else. But they are harming themselves by looking at all this footage and obsessing about these stories. And he said that he got into a period of watching gore videos. And this is actually a sort of genre online now of extreme mutilation. And you can just sort of type in gore and you'll get all of this stuff and that's so terrible for you know your own well-being but also your he said it really affected his self-esteem feeling this way can we i mean some people listening to this or watching this might think you know this has always happened you've always had sort of depressed um teenagers loners who feel isolated

11:28or being bullied who are you know they don't have friends or whatever it might be they and they have this sense of uh alienation from the world you know going all the way back it's a kind of teenage trope right and it's and it's very real. And we've always had violence as part of our, you know, humanity and of life. This is something, you know, we see obviously in the States all the time. We've seen it for a long time. The thing that struck me in your piece is that you're describing something that is clearly rising. It's not just something that people are concerned about, you know, that, oh, you know, I'm worried about teenagers or the state of modern youth, you know, a kind of lament from a, you know, our generation.

12:17That's not it. You're saying quite clearly in here that the government has categorized this as something that they are particularly concerned about. It's a new category and it has large numbers of people that are being referred to Prevent program. So where Prevent was once dealing with far-right ideology and Islamist ideology, it is now dealing with this and the numbers are striking. Yeah, they are striking. And it is quite hard to put a very specific number on the rise because they added this new category in 2024. So it's hard to compare like for like with, you know, the prevent figures from 2023 compared to 2024, 25. But it's still a large number of individuals. So 818, including 566 children

13:08were referred in this category. The category is called fascination with extreme violence or mass casualty attacks in the year ending September 2025. And if you compare that to the sort of in old money, the old categories that might have covered this before they brought that new one in, one of them was school massacre, which is sort of fixation on school massacres. The other one was high counterterrorism risk, but no ideology. That was just 164 referrals back in 2022, 23. So it could be that there is a rising awareness among public servants who refer people to prevent and parents, you know, anyone who engages in the system. There is obviously Southport really made the awareness in the general public rise about this

13:54issue. So it could be that just more people are aware of it and more people are therefore reporting it. But I don't think that we should dismiss the extent in society with which these behaviours are manifesting. So some polling that I was given exclusively by the Youth Endowment Fund, which is the only organisation that has, for the first time, polled people, children who feel this way. One in five children aged 13 to 17 in England and Wales sought out violent material or fantasised about harming others at least once in the past year. One in 10 thought about committing a specific act of violence against a person or a group. One in 20 engages in these behaviors weekly. So that includes fantasizing about this, researching real world

14:36violence and spending time in online hate communities where they discuss doing things like this. And one in 40, that's nearly one in every classroom, engage in these behaviours every day. So we can't say that that's a rise because we haven't had that polling before. It's the first time we've ever done the polling. But it's so widespread that you do have this new task force that's been set up in the Home Office to deal with it. You do have the first major change to our counter-terrorism framework in 15 years to add this category into the prevent system. So whether or not it's an uptick in reports or an uptick in real life cases, it's clearly a problem that we have to deal with that hasn't been as intense before. We're going to take a quick break now. Remember, you can listen

15:21to the New Statesman podcast ad free by downloading the New Statesman app. It's available on iOS and Android. Links are in the show notes. Gift a New Statesman subscription for only £2 this festive season. Visit newstatesman.com forward slash Christmas26 to subscribe. Do you snore? Did somebody hand you a CPAP and did you quietly stop using it? The mask that never quite seals? The hose tugging at you every time you roll over? A machine sitting abandoned in a closet? Excite OSA works a different way. It treats a root cause instead of managing the noise, and you use it while you're awake. 20 minutes a day, while the coffee brews, while you set your fantasy lineup. An FDA-cleared prescription device for primary snoring and mild obstructive sleep apnea.

16:16Then you go to bed like a person, nothing strapped on, nothing plugged in. In clinical studies, 90% of patients saw a reduction in snoring. No sleep study required. Prescribed online, shipped to your door. Excite OSA at springsleep.com slash sleep20. Code sleep20 for 20% off. Excite OSA is an FDA-cleared, prescription-only device for primary snoring and mild obstructive sleep apnea. Not for everyone. Individual results vary. Risks and benefits at springsleep.com. This message is brought to you by today's sponsor, Walden University. Set a course for change. Now is the time to make a real change in your life, career, and community. At Walden University, we give you the support and flexibility to get the W.

17:09Walden's online programs are designed for working professionals like you. You'll gain hands-on skills to take on real-world challenges and succeed. Your future is waiting, and Walden is here to help you achieve it. Take the first step to make your impact. Visit waldenu.edu. Walden University. Set a course for change. Certified to operate by Chev. The thing that you and I talked about when I was reading the piece before it was published, talking about the sense that even if it's hard to measure year by year by year, because going back to these sort of questions of definition and categorization and how you ask a question or whether you ask a question, you know, in surveys or, you know, measuring the number of referrals to a certain, you know, government program or not.

18:07What we're seeing here is specific government action changes the first in 15 years you put in the piece to deal with something that the government believes is serious enough. To me, the thing that's really hard not to address is the fact that these people, these young, usually male teenagers who are obsessed with violence, are the generation that for their entire lives have had access to this kind of violent material. Obviously, previous generation, people would have watched movies that were inappropriate or seen violence in their lives, whether at home or around them. But this is something of a different order which I think is unique in in human experience right these are adolescents who were brought up on a on a sort of an internet that

19:16is different to the one even now that exists that is becoming more regulated where scenes of violence are of the worst kind imaginable. We're talking about scenes from Syria, ISIS, from Iraq of beheadings and burnings and rapes and the atrocities now that we see all the time when we open up social media from Gaza or deaths on the battlefield in Ukraine, that I open up Twitter now and I can almost immediately, there will be a video of a drone going in and killing a Russian soldier. That's just sort of part of my new life that I watch somebody die when I open up my mobile phone. And so then you have to be careful about, well, okay, so clearly my son can't open up. I can't let him look at my phone because what happens if he clicks on an app that is a perfectly reasonable app?

20:18And then suddenly he might see somebody being murdered or killed. This is kind of something i think completely new and it's surely playing into this that this is what the government is having to deal whether we think and we can turn to this in a bit whether we think the government is acting appropriately reasonably effectively yeah or anything this is the reality that we're all living with now yeah i think that's right I think, and that is what the psychologist who works with these people, these young people described to me. She said the access is so much easier, even sort of, she said, compared to 10 years ago or something. It's just so much easier with the click of a button to find the most appalling footage

20:59that you can imagine from any parts of the world and watch it. And then she said, if you do sort of develop a fixation or or an obsession with it then it almost works as if it's an addiction so you watch one thing it gives you a sort of she said that some of the children that she works with said that they get a buzz from it yeah gives you a buzz and then you have to seek out something even more extreme next time to feel that same feeling and so you go down this rabbit hole maybe you've watched a stabbing that happened on the streets of the city where you live and you found it a bit exciting. Then you seek out something even more extreme, something more extreme. Then you get down to some very, very dark material that she said to me, I didn't put this in the piece, but she said,

21:38there's not really a such thing as a dark web anymore. It just is the web. So a bit like what you were saying, just opening a mainstream app app like twitter you might end up looking at something that you really weren't expecting that was not the case and it was 10 years ago no that's what she was saying um and she said what's even what's amplified it now is the ai which is now you know it's just open to sort of mass users anyone can use it will allow you to create some of this content yourself as well so to sort of invent it in your head and make it play out on a screen and you can use that for your own sort of indulging your own fixation or you can use it which is probably the case for most teenagers

22:15who do this to get sort of clout online and get clicks and get people to come to your page it's like the pornification of violence yeah exactly, exactly. Yeah. And there is an addiction. It becomes ever more whoever playing a video game, there's probably going to be, you know, there's so many games where violence is involved. And so that's a part of the issue as well. And then you have these online forums. If you're someone lonely, who's had a few, you know, moments where they fantasized about harming people in their lives, who they feel have done them wrong, you might end up on a forum with other people who are sort of validating that worldview and and sort of telling you that you're right and

23:08and sort of pushing you into more and more extreme behaviors so which you see in all sorts of ways right so you see it in um eating disorders to self-harm to anything yeah you know it's almost like you will find your community exactly you'll Well, I guess it comes back to that point about, you know, previously you might feel miserable and alienated and angry and vengeful and all the rest. But you wouldn't have access to communities who will tell you to go to the most extreme degree to seek out that revenge or whatever it may be. You can find some sense of community. Yeah, no, exactly. And she described that, the psychologist. She said you may be lonely in real life, but you find this so-called community online,

23:56but it is obviously not in your best interest. Yeah. You spoke to a woman called Leanne Lucas, who I think you mentioned earlier, who was one of the dance teachers at the Southport dance class when Axel Rudiger Barna committed that atrocity. And I thought this section of your piece was really challenging to read. I mean, it must have been incredibly challenging to report on because in a sense, you know, you would have expected in a sort of normal flow of a piece like this, you would have expected to reach her account and she would sort of say something like, I'm glad the government is finally recognizing the threat posed by these kind of violence fixated individuals who are radicalized online seemingly without some you know overarching cause but can cause this

24:53this level of terror you know thank god something is changing but her account was actually quite skeptical of what was going on. And, you know, came across as a bit offended by the notion that these are non-ideological, almost that they're just kind of nihilistic, not terrorists. They're sort of, they're just lone wolves out there, sort of, you know, doing bad things things doing terrible things um and she was saying well doesn't this miss the fact that no they had multiple ideologies he was looking at nazi material as well as al-qaeda uh manuals um and he clearly hated girls so he targeted girls you know it was a taylor swift dance class and he so it was it was a Taylor Swift dance class. And he so it was it was misogynistic.

25:48And she was sort of saying to us, why aren't you looking in the face of what's going on here? These are young men who often hate women. And lots of other people have talked about this, haven't they, that there is a connection between that and, say, things like domestic violence or other expressions of misogyny. And so I thought what was so interesting is, and I'd love to hear your opinion, is that it kind of feeds into the meta-criticism of Prevent. Yes. prevent yes which is prevent started off with a you know a clear objective and it has since just ballooned into this thing where it is trying to deal with everything including non-ideological stuff and effectively it's not very effective you know and and this is going to be another example of this where you're going to deal with lots of disaffected teenagers who will get referred into this thing.

26:52They'll be looking at far too many people and they're sort of missing the wood for the trees. That there are violent, extreme young men who often hate women, who are addicted to violent images and extreme ideologies and and it's quite clear who they are and we're pretending that's not the case yeah exactly um and i think that i'm glad that the interview came across that way because she was one of the last people that i spoke to for the piece not on purpose i didn't leave her to the end on purpose but it just turned out that way and i had long, long conversation with her over the phone and it did completely almost turn the piece on its head because she didn't say what, like you said, I expected her to say something similar. She was quite sceptical and she's heard this expression,

27:37violence fixation, because it's part of the inquiry. And she was just saying, you know, I think this might actually be a sort of sticking plaster measure. You know, we're almost comforting ourselves by creating this new category of person. And they're likely to slip through the cracks too, because we're not, you know, that's not necessarily what they are. You know, she said they have multiple ideologies and it often crosses over with hatred of women and girls. I mean, if you think of any, you know, anyone sort of from an Islamist to a far right sympathizer, they probably does cross over with hatred of women and girls. And she spoke, I thought, very powerfully about that and was basically saying, you know, you're all comforting yourselves.

28:17I think she called it a false sense of security by creating this new sort of definition. It's almost like a semantic thing. Yeah. All encompassing yeah exactly without looking in the eye what is actually motivating these people and i thought that was a really powerful point from someone who had never had to think about this before she was attacked you know she doesn't want to be an expert in this um but you know from having to go over what happened to her and those girls on the day and think about sort of why he was missed as this extreme individual, she has come to this conclusion. And I think it's a really important voice to have in the piece because there's a lot of people in politics who do think that our counterterrorism framework is wrong. In fact, someone that I spoke to very high up in counter extremism

29:05in government warned me a while back that the counterterrorism framework that we have is not fit for purpose because so many of these people could almost be classed as sort of not on one side or the other. So they told me about incels. They'd been looking into incels and they said it's not that they're all far right actually or far left really. They all have one thing in common, which is they are totally fixated on the concept of violence, violence against women and girls in that case. You probably weren't thinking about retirement when you met the love of your life, or when you realised they actually weren't, or when you swapped the family home for a cosy cottage for one. Or when you decided to start a business in your 50s.

29:51And Rex the rescue puppy became the new love of your life. For the life we live. Standard Life. Phoenix Life Limited. Trading at Standard Life. For full details, visit standardlife.co.uk. Do you snore? Did somebody hand you a CPAP and did you quietly stop using it? The mask that never quite seals? The hose tugging at you every time you roll over? A machine sitting abandoned in a closet? Excite OSA works a different way. It treats a root cause instead of managing the noise, and you use it while you're awake. 20 minutes a day, while the coffee brews, while you set your fantasy lineup. An FDA-cleared prescription device for primary snoring and mild obstructive sleep apnea. Then you go to bed like a person, nothing strapped on, nothing plugged in.

30:45In clinical studies, 90% of patients saw a reduction in snoring. No sleep study required. Prescribed online, shipped to your door. ExciteOSA at springsleep.com slash sleep20. Code sleep20 for 20% off. Excite OSA is an FDA cleared prescription only device for primary snoring and mild obstructive sleep apnea. Not for everyone. Individual results vary. Risks and benefits at springsleep.com. When we were looking into this for the piece, what was interesting was to see the criticism of Prevent, the government's program, comes from across the political spectrum. Yeah, it does, yeah. So generally speaking, as you put it in the piece, on the left there this this completely legitimate concern that you know concern

31:48about Islamist terrorism can lead to lots of people in positions of authority whether it's in schools or hospitals or social care or social work or any of these professions referring ordinary Muslim children who are not extremists and then creating a sense of sort of division and tension within communities. So there is that side of the group, kind of also like a civil liberty side, that this is kind of mass overreach and that the government is trying to sort of scoop up more and more people into a sense that they are a threat. And when a lot of them will not be and they could be treated in a kind of health setting in many ways or in a social care setting or whatever it may be. And then there is the criticism from the right, which is more ideological.

32:47It's a kind of criticism that essentially, you know, Prevent has been taken over by a politically correct brigade who are kind of trying to mask the fact that, you know, there is still a threat from Islamist terrorism. So that's the criticism on the right. But I thought what was so fascinating about this is there's a sense to me at least that there was almost like a confluence happening here from the criticism from the left and the right. A sort of concern that maybe everything is happening at once here where lots and lots and lots of people are being scooped into this categorization and we're not being honest. And there's sort of the two things are coming together and producing something that, you know, is this going to protect us?

33:41You know, one in 40 children. Evidently it's not sustainable if one in 40 children are on a sort of prevent program. Is that a realistic start? I just thought that in one sense the piece starts with a worrying trend, a concern about what's happening, facts that the government is changing, of course, all this kind of revelatory stuff. And as you get through it, you kind of get to this like, hang on, is this, are we heading in the right direction as a country? Yeah, and I don't know the answer. And, you know, I think I say somewhere in the piece, all the people I spoke to spoke so well on this, but they almost contradicted each other. It's almost like no one really knows what the right path is and we'll see out of Southport and out of this task force that I've written about

34:31in the piece, whether or not they come up with a new plan that can sort of in some way successfully deal with these individuals. It's not obvious what to do. But what did become obvious was that we have not caught up with this thing with this uh this thing about people being able to view whatever they like online from the moment that they can tap their finger on a smartphone and it was interesting because most of the conversations i had i spoke to a lot of experts for this piece they barely mentioned the online safety act and the coming social media ban, which is coming in next year, because they just felt that, you know, if there are children who want to go and seek out this material, they're going to be able to do it. And so that was quite worrying. And I don't think

35:15we've really grappled with that. And the only real antidote to the culture of children turning inwards and just looking at things online and becoming obsessed is that they have a sort of robust network in real life where they can express themselves. And that's something that's been sort of degraded over the past 20 years as well. When you look at sort of, we write about this a lot in the New Statesman, Tom, about the decline of public services in the public realm. And, you know, that feeling of belonging to a community has been degraded via various government decisions over the years, as well as sort of natural changes in the way that we consume our media, even in the way that we do our shopping and, you know talking about you know st james's clubs we're talking about like you know a church a football club you know exactly anything you know most

36:11people just don't yeah they you know a library you know yeah you order your stuff online you speak to people online you don't even go supermarket shopping yeah it's delivered by somebody else um and that sense of just um modernity in a sense is a drift towards a kind of alienated individualistic um place yeah and that's one thing that the psychologist i spoke to said some of her most successful interventions for these young men is to prescribe them uh sort of social prescribing so you know there was a young guy she told me about who only liked gaming and he was obsessed with violence. And luckily there was a gaming club in the school holidays that happened to be in a kickboxing gym near him. And he would never have

36:54gone to a gym, but they got him to go and go to the gaming club because he liked gaming. And then he started doing the kickboxing from there. And she said, he's got this community around him now, he's made friends. And, you know, that sounds a bit like a sort of, I know this stuff sounds really woolly, you know, when I write about it, but it is kind of, you know, if you think about specific cases, and these cases are so rare, but if you look at the sort of the history of the person who may be a perpetrator in one of these atrocities, then there is so much, what if that had just happened? If only this had been there, if only that had been there in place. And she, I think the way that she spoke about,

37:29you know, helping her patients was quite compelling, even though it's very difficult to think of how that could possibly be a sort of widespread antidote to a problem that's essentially dictated by sort of tech firms and media companies that are beyond the government's control. Anoush, thanks so much for the piece. It's really, really powerful. And please do go and read it. Thank you so much, Tom. As it hits here. Thanks. You've been listening to The Politics Show from The New Statesman with me, Tom McTague, and my colleague, Anoush Shikhalian. You can read Anoush's full feature online via the link in the show notes.

▸More episode summaries

The Politics Show cover art
The Politics ShowThe Jensen Huang affair2026-11-14 · 35 min
The Politics Show cover art
The Politics ShowHow green is Burnham’s government?2026-11-12 · 46 min
Transcribe your links. Paste a YouTube, Google Drive or podcast link and WhipScribe gives you the transcript. Transcribe a link →
New The Politics Show transcripts by email
One email per new episode, unsubscribe in every message. Not shared with the publisher.