podcasts / The Politics Show / episode
The Politics Show cover art
podcast
📅 2026-11-12 ⏱ 46 min episode · ~2 min read 📝 Transcript · 8,745 words

How green is Burnham’s government?

The Politics Show · · Transcript & summary by WhipScribe

A panel of New Statesman journalists tests whether Andy Burnham's government is really putting cost of living ahead of climate, with the Rosebank decision as the test case.

Read the transcript Episode page ↗
In this episodeAndy BurnhamKeir StarmerRosebankJackdawRussell BrandDavid WalliamsEd MilibandLisa NandyStuart InghamLouise HaigKemi BadenochMore in Common

▸Chapters

Tap a chapter to play it from that moment in the show's own player; the transcript opens there too.

Transcribe your links. Paste a YouTube, Google Drive or podcast link and WhipScribe gives you the transcript. Transcribe a link →

▸Notable quotes

“they think that the problem with your Starmer's government was anytime it looks difficult” Alva · at 19:37 — ▶ hear it from here
“Andy Burnham has brought back Green voters and Lib Dem voters who had drifted away under Keir Starmer.” Alva · at 24:14 — ▶ hear it from here

▸What this episode covers

The episode opens with the week's biggest story: Russell Brand's sentencing and newly published allegations against David Walliams, which Walliams denies. The panel uses a New Statesman cover piece asking whether Britain's Me Too moment has finally arrived to examine Westminster. Their view is mixed. They credit the journalists and victims who pursued these cases, but they see the same patterns of power, NDAs and women quietly leaving politics, and they note Louise Haig's campaign to restrict NDAs in media.

The central question is whether Andy Burnham's government ranks climate below cost of living. Alva Ray's column reports that at least 50 Labour MPs are privately warning the Prime Minister against approving the Rosebank oil field, a decision the energy secretary must reach herself. Recent moves, including a £700 million cut to carbon capture and hydrogen and the Jackdaw gas approval, suggest a shift in emphasis. Insiders argue the two goals can align, but the panel warns of a green backlash among voters Burnham has won back from the Greens and Lib Dems.

On Europe, Stuart Ingham's essay argues that Labour contains many rejoiners but is not yet a rejoiner party, and that the risks of the EU reset are underestimated. The panel notes the government is still negotiating a youth mobility scheme and a food standards deal while Burnham floats bigger ideas such as freedom of movement, which has divided cabinet. They conclude that every step toward the EU brings trade-offs, and that British governments have long tried to have their cake and eat it.

▸How green is Burnham’s government? on The Politics Show: the answers

What did Tom McTague say about Andy Burnham?

Tom McTague said Andy Burnham has made cost of living the absolute priority of his government, which he argued creates a real tension with re-industrialising Britain and with green policy. He pointed to the Alva Ray column as showing how many decisions now lean that way.

“Andy Burnham has made this cost of living the absolute priority.”Tom McTague · 21:56

What did Lisa Nandy say about European Union?

Lisa Nandy told the media round she did not believe anybody wanted to repeat circular arguments about in or out. Asked whether she would want to go back into the European Union, she said she did not know whether that was a choice Britain had, which the panel read as a clear signal she does not want to rejoin.

“I don't know if that's a choice we have.”Lisa Nandy · 38:51

What did Stuart Ingham say about EU reset deal?

Stuart Ingham, a former close adviser to Keir Starmer, wrote in the New Statesman that Labour is a party with rejoiners in it rather than a rejoiner party. He argues the risks of the EU reset deal are underestimated in Britain, and that cabinet ministers protecting their departments can pull policy away from the collective position.

“Labour for now is a party with rejoiners in it rather than a rejoiner party.”Stuart Ingham · 34:56

What did Alva Ray say about More in Common?

Alva Ray said More in Common polling matches her own reporting: Andy Burnham has brought back Green and Lib Dem voters who drifted away under Keir Starmer. She said that a Rosebank approval could alienate those voters even though a narrow public majority supports it.

“Andy Burnham has brought back Green voters and Lib Dem voters who had drifted away under Keir Starmer.”Alva Ray · 24:14

What is the main argument on The Politics Show about Andy Burnham's climate record?

The panel argues Andy Burnham has made cost of living the top priority, which has shifted his government's emphasis away from climate goals. Evidence cited includes a £700 million cut from carbon capture and hydrogen and the approval of the Jackdaw gas field, while the Rosebank oil field decision remains open and is facing opposition from at least 50 Labour MPs.

Mentioned in this episode

Episode facts

Released
November 12, 2026
Length
46 minutes

▸Key takeaways

01Andy Burnham flew to COP31 in Turkey promising climate leadership while his budget cut £700 million from carbon capture and hydrogen.
02At least 50 Labour MPs privately warned Burnham against approving Rosebank, a quasi-judicial decision the energy secretary must make herself.
03More in Common polling shows Burnham won back Green and Lib Dem voters, a gain that a Rosebank approval could quickly lose.
04Ed Conway argued in the New Statesman that re-industrialising Britain clashes with decades of prioritising cheap consumer prices.
05Stuart Ingham, a former Starmer adviser, warns Labour is a party with rejoiners in it rather than a rejoiner party, and says EU reset risks are underestimated.

▸Questions this episode answers

Q1What did Alva Ray say about the Rosebank decision and Labour MPs?

Alva Ray reported that at least 50 Labour MPs were coordinating a private letter to Andy Burnham warning that approving the Rosebank oil field would permanently damage Labour's climate credentials. The panel said the decision is quasi-judicial, so the energy secretary must reach it herself, and that Burnham appeared unsure which way to lean.

Q2What did Tom McTague say about Andy Burnham's cost of living priority?

Tom McTague argued that Andy Burnham has made cost of living the absolute priority, which sits in tension with re-industrialising Britain. He said the choice is between importing wind turbines and solar panels cheaply from China to meet green targets faster, or making them domestically at higher prices.

Q3What does Stuart Ingham say about rejoining the EU?

Stuart Ingham, a former close adviser to Keir Starmer, wrote in the New Statesman that Labour is a party with rejoiners in it rather than a rejoiner party. He says he would vote to rejoin in another referendum, and argues that the risks of the EU reset deal are underestimated in Britain, with departmental self-interest pulling some ministers towards a more Eurosceptic position than the cabinet as a whole.

Q4What did Lisa Nandy say about rejoining the EU?

Lisa Nandy said on the media round that she did not believe anybody wanted to repeat circular arguments about in or out. Asked whether she would want to go back into the EU, she replied that she did not know whether that was a choice we have, which the panel read as a clear sign she does not want to rejoin.

Q5What did Ed Conway argue about re-industrialising Britain and cost of living?

Ed Conway, whose essay ran in the New Statesman a few weeks before this episode, argued there is a fundamental tension between re-industrialising Britain and cost of living. Decades of economic strategy have prioritised the cheapest consumer prices, so making steel products or wind turbines at home means paying more, and may require tariffs on imports.

Q6What does More in Common polling say about Andy Burnham and Green voters?

Alva Ray said More in Common polling shows Andy Burnham has won back Green and Lib Dem voters who drifted away under Keir Starmer, and that reuniting the progressive coalition is a big part of his strategy. A majority of the public narrowly supports approving Rosebank, but the panel warned that Green-leaning voter groups could be alienated by it.

▸Transcript

Our own transcript of the public episode, with a timestamp about every 90 seconds. Tap a timestamp to play the episode from there in the show's own player; the link button on a paragraph copies a link that opens this page there.

0:00Do you snore? Did somebody hand you a CPAP and did you quietly stop using it? The mask that never quite seals? The hose tugging at you every time you roll over? A machine sitting abandoned in a closet? Excite OSA works a different way. It treats a root cause instead of managing the noise, and you use it while you're awake. 20 minutes a day, while the coffee brews, while you set your fantasy lineup. An FDA-cleared prescription device for primary snoring and mild obstructive sleep apnea. Then you go to bed like a person, nothing strapped on, nothing plugged in. In clinical studies, 90% of patients saw a reduction in snoring. No sleep study required. Prescribed online, shipped to your door. Excite OSA at springsleep.com slash sleep20. Code sleep20 for

0:5620% off. Excite OSA is an FDA-cleared prescription-only device for primary snoring and mild obstructive sleep apnea. Not for everyone. Individual results vary. Risks and benefits The holidays bring brand new gadgets, bigger spending, and even more on your to-do list. Good thing Verizon gives you more than just a great network. We give you a whole lineup of products and services. Like a protection plan for your family's home tech that covers everyday mishaps. A credit card that rewards holiday shopping with real savings. And a smart watch built specifically for keeping up with your kids. Take the stress out of the season. Pick what works for you at verizon.com slash extras. The New Statesman.

1:56Andy Burnham flew to COP31 in Turkey this week, promising a new era of British leadership on climate and announcing £12bn of private investment in offshore wind. But he left behind a budget that cut £700 million from carbon capture and hydrogen, the end of green levies on energy bills, a looming decision on the Rosebank oil field after the Jackdaw gas field had been approved, and reports that the electric car target may be softened. Downing Street insists cost of living comes first, no exceptions. But with at least 50 Labour MPs privately warning the Prime Minister against Rosebank and pollsters cautioning of a green lash on Labour's left, just how green is Andy Burnham's government really?

2:36I'm Anousheh Kellyan and this is The Politics Show from The New Statesman. I'm joined today by Alva Ray and Tom McTague. Hello. Hello. Now, first of all, before we start chatting about that topic, we should touch on the biggest story this week. Russell Brand's sentencing to 10 and a half years for rape and sexual assault and the newly published allegations against David Walliams, which he denies. We've got a brilliant cover story on that this week by Ros Irwin, Rosamund Irwin, one of the journalists behind the brand investigation at the Sunday Times. And it's a great piece. She argues that the Me Too movement in Britain in the original sort of Me Too wave was only ever half-baked. And she actually, she sort of takes us back to that time. And I found it really instructive to

3:19sort of think back to that time because she said the main scalps here were sort of unknown politicians, really. Michael Fallon resigning as Defence Secretary and Anthony Lester leaving the Lords over harassment allegations that he denied. And that it never really came to being in the way that we now think of Me Too as a wave in the US. And she hopes, you know, through her reporting and the stories that we've had this week, that perhaps this time will be different and this will be Britain's Me Too moment. I mean, Tom, you commissioned that piece and we were talking about it sort of right up to the wire, weren't we, on press day, the day before we're recording this podcast. Why did you go for that story and what did you make of Roz's thesis?

4:02I went for the story because it's the most important story of the week. And I thought it was important that we sort of reflected that. And actually, you and I spent quite a bit of time talking about it because you've written a fantastic piece this week that we're going to talk about in future podcasts. So it wasn't, you know, we'd planned to go with your piece, but it was so important that we reflected this story on the front. And actually, I tried to reflect a bit of this in the editor's note, the way that you and I were talking, the way we were talking with other colleagues in the newsroom. It was quite sort of a reflective moment yesterday, because we were saying a lot of female colleagues at the

4:47new statesman were sort of saying i'm not sure this is going to be our me too moment i'm i'm i'm skeptical you know it felt like we were going to have a moment 10 years ago we were talking about 10 years it's amazing you know nine years ago a decade. And I was really struck by that, that sense that, you know, people were, you know, posting stories of abuse and everything that had happened 10 years ago, and they feel watching what's happening has anything improved. And so that there's a skepticism about whether it is going to get better. And actually, that was reflected in the headline on the cover. It's a question mark. It's not a statement that's saying, this is Me Too, or we aren't finally having it. It's a question,

5:40is it going to be? And I think that's what Rosamund is arguing as well in the piece. She's saying, I hope that this is a proper moment. So there is a fantastic piece. Obviously, she's a fantastic journalist who did an amazing thing. And so we were quite proud to have her in the magazine as well. So yeah, it's a story we're going to have to come back to, unfortunately, again and again. But I think it was important to put it on the cover this week. And I was one of those people in our meeting on Monday saying, I'm not sure this is a Me Too moment in the UK. In that these feel like two really important stories that have taken an enormous amount of work from you know the victims raking over their experiences dating back decades and journalists putting in

6:34in some cases like years of their time into reporting these stories so it's a you know a form of accountability and reporting even though you know, David Williams denies all the allegations against him. So does Russell Brand. But the, you know, these feel like two quite isolated moments that took a lot of work. And I think, I mean, Ros Irwin and her colleagues have just done amazing work on this. And all the victims who testified in the Russell Brand case put themselves through a lot to get justice. So I think I feel almost a tiny bit jaded about the whole thing that it takes so much work to get to that point. I mean, if you look at the Noel Clark case and, you know, Shirin Khaled, the Guardian and her colleagues did everything right um and ended

7:25up being taken to court for their reporting on his sexual misconduct and ended up spending like years of their lives defending their reporting and it ended up being completely vindicated but it was actually an awful process for them to go through I thought Ros just made an interesting point about how um insofar as we've had a moment like that, it's been in Westminster, which is obviously where I work every day. Yeah, that's what I was going to ask you about, actually. Yeah, so go ahead. there's been an open secrets about certain individuals in Westminster, you know, during that first wave of Me Too, but also, you know, before that and in the time since. How has this story landed this week? You know, how is it? What are the conversations like in

8:14Westminster about it this week? And do you feel like the culture is ever going to shift in Westminster? I guess there's not been one uniform response. I mean, I think everyone just feels like this is a huge moment. You know, feminist achievement, I'm, you know, in the wrong. I think a lot of women in Westminster feel like there's just so far to go. You know, having had a sort of lukewarm me too moment in Westminster, still there is just so much misogyny all the time. And so many like rumors and half-baked allegations. I mean, things that reach a criminal threshold do get reported up and escalated often political parties still hand them a handle them appallingly and the women affected just leave politics you know that's still happening and I just think

9:17actually in the time I've been working in Westminster where all of this has been rumbling on I think I've become sort of sadder about it rather than confident you know I think if if you get an overwhelming number of allegations and a particular journalist is prepared to put in years of work into something and the victims are prepared to do something at quite a quite big personal cost to pursue justice and accountability then you maybe get something over the line but just feels like sometimes quite a lot of the time people you know it's the the men who continue and not the yeah and that just the women end up moving on with their lives and going going to leave politics and doing other things so um it's like a kind of upbeat moment i think in in the

10:02uk in terms of feeling like they've got accountability on two big stars but I'm actually not sure if it feels that way in Westminster yeah yeah it's interesting I think I think the reactions that I've had from from friends and colleagues and and contacts has been mixed as well some people feel you know inspired by the fact that these journalists you know were so persistent and finally justice seems to be being done on the other hand you know I've heard people saying like I just feel really low like you know these were so persistent. And finally, justice seems to be being done. On the other hand, you know, I've heard people saying, like, I just feel really low. Like, you know, these were people

10:28who were sort of icons of my teenage years. And it's just sort of like, tarnished, you know, my memory of growing up that these men were doing these things sort of almost in plain sight of in showbiz and the media and things like that. So yeah, I feel sort of a mix of those two things. Yeah, and I think you can probably tell that that's sort of how I feel about it because I work in a world where there's proximity to power and you can see its dynamics all the time and you can see that power routinely being abused, even if it's not necessarily always in a criminal way. But I also think just working in the media, there's so many dreadful stories, NDAs being widely used, people who sort of, you know, there's sexual misconduct,

11:07they are quietly moved out of a job, they, you know, do some big legal settlement, there's an NDA, and then they just sort of pop up somewhere else. And women warn each other about them, but nothing really happens. That's kind of the reality. And actually, bringing it back to politics, because this is a politics show, Louise Haig, now the second most powerful person in the government, the first Secretary of State, and Andy Burnham's right-hand woman, went after she had to resign from Keir Starmer's cabinet. She used all of her time on the back benches campaigning to restrict the use of NDAs in the media because she knows lots of journalists, is well aware about the abuse of NDAs in the media because she knows lots of journalists is well aware about the abuse of ndas

11:46in the media world and i just think you know fair play so obviously no one in politics is mentioning that and i think she would find it crass to point that out because i you know you know that's not the main story credit for things yeah but i actually your work yeah i think she's really vindicated and highlighting that and just and actually for speaking to lots of mps this week i think that's something they want to pick up again and there's obviously a role for parliament in other ways around the use of injunctions parliamentary privilege there there are more things that can be done in this space i think not not wanting to take credit by the way is something that is interesting a lot of the women who have been involved in these stories the journalists um at the guardian itv

12:32channel four sunday times yeah they often actually when we've been in touch have not wanted to claim credit so i think you know it we should give them credit yeah absolutely yeah okay let's take a quick break here. We'll be back in a bit. The holidays bring brand new gadgets, bigger spending, and even more on your to-do list. Good thing Verizon gives you more than just a great network. We give you a whole lineup of products and services, like a protection plan for your family's home tech that covers everyday mishaps, a credit card that rewards holiday shopping with real savings, and a smartwatch built specifically for keeping up with your kids. Take the stress out of the season. Pick what works for you at verizon.com slash extras.

13:21Hi, this is Mark Bittman from the podcast Food with Mark Bittman. I've been writing about food and restaurants for almost 50 years. My whole career, really. And what I know is that the good restaurants all have something in common. They're busy. Genuinely, chaotically busy. And somehow, in the last few years, the best of them have begun to make it look easy. And do you know why? Because they're running on Toast's technology. Toast is built for restaurant owners who understand that Toast's tools keep the line moving and keep their customers happy, with fewer mistakes and hiccups in ordering and paying. For owners, that turns busy into business. To learn more, head to toasttab.com. That's T-O-A-S-T-T-A-B, toasttab.com.

14:12Toast, built for busy. Welcome back. Alva, among all of the conversations that you've been having about various stories this week, your column has been making waves. Kemi Badenoch mentioned it at PMQs on the day that you've been having about various stories this week, your column has been making waves. Kemi Badenoch mentioned it at PMQs on the day that we're recording. The big revelation in your column, and we're going to talk about the whole theme of the piece in this discussion, is that at least 50 Labour MPs are coordinating a private letter to the Prime Minister, warning him that approval of Rosebank, this oil field which we've spoken about many times on the podcast before, would permanently damage Labour's climate credentials.

14:48Yes, 50 MPs and counting because Andy Burnham, I don't think has received this letter yet. They are still, I mean, he now knows it's coming. He can start writing his response. But they, yeah, it's 50 and counting um i you know with with letters in politics in general often they are sort of designed to be leaked um but i think insofar as it's possible to know with these things i really don't think this one was given the way i found out about it um i think that this has really been intended to be completely private in the hope that MPs have the confidence to just share their private candid view with the prime minister. I think that, you know, they're hoping to get, you know, a huge number of names to just privately express concern about Rosebank.

15:40And, you know, no decision has been made on that. Also, the prime Minister doesn't make the decision it is Miata van Bullen so they might need to cc the letter to her um but um is she not one of the signatures we'll come on to that but um I yeah I think that's interesting because we're still so early on in the Andy Burnham premiership. And there's that whole wider question, which I guess we'll come on to, of just, you know, how green is he? How good are his climate credentials as he heads off to COP? But Rosebank is, I think, shaping up to be quite a difficult issue for him. The debate on it at Prime Minister's Questions was, I think, one of his weaker performances against Camille Badenoch partly because it's a

16:26famously quasi judicial decision which means other politicians can't be seen to be prejudging it's like you know Miata Fambola is meant to get all the information and make a make a view reach a decision on her own um so i think he's partly bound by that and not being able to say much but it also just felt he didn't know which way to lean with the politics knowing that the people behind him are so divided on this because i mentioned you know this growing caucus of mps wanting to say to him that they're really worried about it there's also a debate as we're recording in westminster hall right now where government pps's are expressing their concerns about rose bank which is a bit unusual um but

17:10they're also um like labor mps on the other side of the argument being really quite vocal about their support for mps like henry toughnell um and john healy is yeah yeah yeah yeah exactly yeah i was gonna say exactly like members of the cabinet including john healy literally the chancellor And John Healy is. in your column because you sort of detail all of these things that may have slipped under the radar for a lot of our readers and you know even journalists as well but because you lay them all out one after the other it does really to me when I was reading it seemed like a shift in emphasis at least in strategy you know at most of this government since the Keir Starmer administration into putting sort of affordability and the cost of living

18:05above sort of green considerations. And you lay out so many different examples of this. I think I said in the intro about moving all of that money from carbon capture and hydrogen into the defence investment plan. And you've had the approval of Jackdaw and the potential approval of Rosebank, but we don't know what they're going to decide. So it does feel as if the emphasis is changing. And I feel like the people that you speak to in government when you put this to them, they don't deny it, do they? They say, well, we want to make sure that everyone knows what this government is about. And this government is about the cost of living. Yeah, I mean, I guess there is context on all of those that's worth adding um if we come if we come on

18:46to those because some of some of them haven't had decisions made on them so the vibes that we're getting might end up changing but yes i think especially with the budget and with some other real changes in technical things that the government has done so far and with approving Jackdaw the mood music is quite different and yes from the very top of government I think maybe the most interesting thing is that they're kind of leaning into it um I kind of devoted the last sort of the last column of the column as it were like the last 300 words just to this view from inside government is that you know from someone really quite senior at the top of government that this is sort of necessary like they would say there are lots of times when green considerations and

19:37affordability are mutually inclusive like you can have both that's a win-win. And I think people in government don't want us to forget about that. But when there is a trade-off about these policy things that Andy Burnham's just come in and said affordability is his number one priority, and they think that the problem with your Starmer's government was anytime it looks difficult, they would sort of forget what their top priority was and you would end up sort of thinking where which way is he going to go and so I think they think even if this is going to be difficult for some Labour MPs and you know I think probably a lot of people you know quite a few people of the people listening who read the New Statesman I think some of this vibe shift is a bit difficult.

20:30But, you know, inside number 10, they think there's a benefit to be had from a leader who's strong enough to just set priorities and go with them. And actually, if you know that the public supports it overall, if Labour MPs have the confidence that actually their leader is getting the politics right, they may be more likely to row in behind it. Yeah. I mean, Tom, there's certain prime ministers that we've had where you sort of know that climate is a sincerely held thing for them. Boris Johnson was an example. I mean, under Keir Starmer, because he had Ed Miliband as his energy secretary, there was that commitment to sort of clean energy. And it's very hard to imagine that we would be debating on the podcast whether or not they were going to go ahead with rosebank under

21:09that pair you know what did what impression did you get from your interviews with andy burnham about how he feels about climate and sort of where in his list of priorities it sits um i'm not sure whether we could give that Boris Johnson believes in anything sincerely. Oh, really? Do you think? Apart from himself. I thought what Alva was saying about Keir Starmer and the lack of a hierarchy of objectives or principles is completely true. And you can see that with the missions and how they fell into different sort of different things and you weren't quite sure which one sits on top, you know, and what's your theory about how they fit in together, you know, which is the kind of the thing that is absolutely core for all the others, you know.

21:56And I think what you can see with Ed Miliband is he does have a kind of theory, doesn't he? He has a theory of where he thinks the economy needs to be and the country needs to be in the long run. And he would argue that they're mutually, well, that they work together, right? So you can, in the long run, if you invest in green technology, you will be able to have cheap energy in the long run, but you're going to have to get there over the long run. I think what Alva was writing about in her column this week is so striking, as you say, when you list it, is that Andy Burnham has made this cost of living the absolute priority. But I think there is a really fundamental tension, not just on individual

22:37choices, but when we ran the essay by Ed Conway in the magazine a few weeks ago, he made the argument, which I thought was pretty persuasive, that there is a fundamental tension between re-industrializing the country and cost of living, in that we have ran an economic strategy for decades now, which is prioritized consumer prices. So what is the cheapest way to get consumer goods into the country and therefore for consumers? And that has been the overarching goal. And if you want to re-industrialize the country, you're going to have to prioritize more expensive things, steel products. And you're going to have to place potentially tariffs on things coming in. That tension runs through the green agenda as well.

23:24How do you bring in wind turbines, solar panels, et cetera, et cetera, et cetera? Is it a re-industrialization strategy where those things are made in Britain on the, you know, up the east coast of Britain, say? Or do you get them in cheaply from China or somewhere else so that you can more quickly reach your green target. So these aren't sort of small trade-offs, but absolutely fundamental. And so if we are reaching into a point where Andy Burnham is absolutely serious that that is the purpose of his government, it's really quite radical once you start taking it down through all of the decisions. And I guess we're going to see that play out over the months and the years ahead. Like, will he stick the course on these things? Because they have radical implications.

24:14Yeah. And just lastly, on the politics of this, Alva, you speak to Luke Trill, who runs More in Common, which is kind the the organization that tells us what the public thinks about various various subjects and he warns that there could be a green lash on on labor's left because part of the burden bounce has been picking up voters who had drifted to the greens and lib dems on and for for a number of reasons but partly because of their commitment to the environment and the planet. Yeah, Luke Trill's polling is so interesting as ever, because what he has found independently matches every bit of sourcing I have. So basically parts of Luke Trill's polling back up the number 10 approach and other parts of Luke Trill's polling back up the concerns of Labour rebels. It's all true. Andy Burnham has brought back Green voters and Lib Dem voters who had drifted away under Keir Starmer.

25:28And it's sort of seen, I think it's widely accepted now that a big part of the Burnham strategy is reuniting that progressive coalition. But that's potentially a bit fragile. So, Rosebank in particular is quite a totemic issue. And even though, according to Luke Trill's polling, a majority of the public actually support approving Rosebank narrowly, but in a few key voter groups. Because they divide them into these demographics, don't they? Yeah, into these seven different voter demographics, which I won't get into, but basically into the key demographics. There is such a sharp drop in Burnham's, green lash of these voters that have been brought back being alienated again by a move like that, even if the public overall are okay with it. I haven't discussed it with people in government, so it might be unfair. But one quite perceptive MP posited a theory to me that they think Burnham, they were like, I think Burnham thinks that you can have climate or you'd be good on Gaza to keep the left behind you.

27:00But you don't have to do both. And we actually have just seen quite neatly Ed Miliband move from kind of flying the green flag to foreign policy, foreign secretary, where he's still doing global climate leadership. He's at COP today. He's in the world leaders' photo. The real leader. Pretending to be prime minister. Delighted with himself. But he has really shifted British foreign policy on Israel and Gaza. And, you know, so I think that the government feels like they're in a good place on that. But at the same time, the vibes on climate have really shifted. And maybe not just the vibes, climate have really shifted and maybe not just the vibe certainly the rhetoric but the way you meant the the list of things you mentioned in the piece um just in particular

27:53that massive cut in the budget to fund the defensive essence plan so carbon capture and storage and hydrogen projects 700 million pounds has been cut from that. Well-placed people now just don't really understand how the UK can meet its climate targets, if that's the case. And I've checked with people in government and they say that they can make it up elsewhere, that Burnham's committed to it. The government has never missed a carbon budget it's always it has always met its targets and there are things because they're devolving a bit more um where i think that you know they make a case that they can work mayors to make up the difference but it obviously doesn't look good um and uh then there are all these decisions to come. But yes, it's worth, you know, because Rosebank in particular is quasi-judicial,

28:50I think that's just a, that's a really interesting one. It's come back up today. There's loads of reporting about Miata van Buller, Rosebank, because of COP and because this is a difficult thing for the Labour Party to grapple with. We discussed it on the podcast at the time that Burnham had intended to give the Energy Secretary job to Lisa Nandy. And everyone in Westminster is acting like they hadn't heard that before. Lara Spirit put it in the Sunday Times the weekend after it happened and then we talked about it on the podcast. I had it in my own reporting. But she got the scoop on it. But everyone in Westminster is acting like they've only discovered that today. And they're using that to shed light on the decision,

29:37on the sort of strategy on energy with Lisa Nandy. If you think Lisa Nandy is the person who should this if you think in the hypothetical sort of if you think it should be Lisa Nandy making these decisions on Rosebank and Jack Dole you can see more clearly what the vibes were that maybe Burnham wanted to achieve it's also been I think quite heavily implied by parts of government that Burnham gave Miata Fambula the job. I think she was intended to be in cabinet anyway. He gave her the energy secretary job on the understanding that she would approve Jack Dahl and Rosebank. So that's been rumbling on for months. At the point in the summer when climate, after the wildfires, when climate concern was really, really high, they kind of rode back from suggesting that.

30:31But now there is a little bit of an expectation again that maybe Burnham wants to approve Rosebank. Obviously, lots of people in the cabinet want to. There's a sort of perception that Miata fanbola is being pressured into it john healy's joke did not help uh or john healy's slip in the budget really didn't help on that um but i just wonder where he said she opposed it rather than approved it yeah um which is just so awkward given the well-known difference it's a classic freudian flip isn't it such a good one but it really actually annoyed labor mps in loads of different directions because I think this perception, rightly or wrongly, that people might be trying to influence Miata Fambula's decision is really

31:16annoying some of them. And so I actually just wonder, this is just me speaking hypothetically, but I just wonder if maybe Miata Fbola what it was you know had it heavily implied to her affordability and jobs is our priority wink wink and she was given the job on the sort of understanding that she would approve rose bank but now she's been in the job a few months she you know she's you know well within her rights to actually um block it you know maybe maybe she's leading that way and she's sort of well aware that she's within her rights too because it's ultimately her decision and so after all of these sort of vibes not being great having written everything i wrote i still wonder if after this big wobble on the green

32:07vibes for the Burnham government, if some of these big decisions might actually end up pointing in a different direction. We're going to take a quick break now. Remember, you can listen to the New Statesman podcast ad free by downloading the New Statesman app. It's available on iOS and Android. Links are in the show notes. Gift a New Statesman subscription for only £2 this festive season. Visit newstatesman.com forward slash Christmas26 to subscribe. Staying locked in is. AlphaBrain is Onnit's daily nootropic formula for cognitive support, designed to support memory, focus, attention, and mental clarity. Its formula with science-driven ingredients include theanine and huperzine A to support focus and memory, and it's caffeine-free.

32:57So when you're deep in the work, AlphaBrain helps support enhanced productivity and tune out distractions. Get focused on what matters. Shop AlphaBrain now at onnit.com. Do you snore? Did somebody hand you a CPAP and did you quietly stop using it? The mask that never quite seals? The hose tugging at you every time you roll over? A machine sitting abandoned in a closet? Excite OSA works a different way. It treats a root cause instead of managing the noise, and you use it while you're awake. 20 minutes a day, while the coffee brews, while you set your fantasy lineup. An FDA-cleared prescription device for primary snoring and mild obstructive sleep apnea. Then you go to bed like a person, nothing strapped on, nothing plugged in. Thank you. springsleep.com slash sleep20. Code sleep20 for 20% off. Excite OSA is an FDA-cleared

34:09prescription-only device for primary snoring and mild obstructive sleep apnea. Not for everyone. Individual results vary. Risks and benefits at springsleep.com. Welcome back. Let's talk about another piece that we've run in the magazine this week. It's by Stuart Ingham, formerly a close advisor to Keir Starmer in government. And it's an interesting piece. He's warning about the sort of hard road ahead to rejoining the EU, but also warning about the risks of the EU reset deal. He says that the risks are underestimated in Britain. And he draws from his own experience working in government very recently on this. He describes the phenomenon of departmental nimbyism when it comes to cabinet ministers

34:56wanting, so saying, you know, oh yeah, we definitely agree with this path, but then wanting to sort of jealously protect their budgets and their freedoms to regulate their areas and their stakeholders when it comes down to actually the meat and drink of whatever deal you're signing with the EU. And he also warns that Labour for now is a party with rejoiners in it rather than a rejoiner party. I mean, he does himself come out and say like he would vote to go back in if there was another referendum. And that's of a piece with some of the old guard who have come out and said things like Rachel Reeves came out for rejoin recently. Her former chief of staff, Ben Nunn, has gone into Number 10 to advise on the EU.

35:38What's going on here, Tom? What does this intervention from one of these sort of old guard mean for Andy Burnham? God, I think Alva's better placed to say what's going on, but I can give you a sense that I was going to talk about the NIMBYism thing, because I thought that was such an interesting phrase, and also kind of plays into what we have just been discussing. You know, the sense that you have Andy Burnham, John Healy and Lou Haig setting a, you know, a strategy, but you also have ministers in positions with real authority and power over other parts of, you know a strategy but you also have ministers in positions with real authority and power over other parts of you know government decisions whether it's miata on rosebank or um

36:13or on questions of europe where he talks about sort of uh being um pro-european in theory and kind of in practice being a little bit skeptical because you're protecting your area. And you sort of, it might be a question of say that somebody said to me that John Healy in defense was quite burnt by that experience of negotiating with the European Union over something called SAFE, which is an acronym, I forget what it actually means, but it's a kind of coming together of European procurement on defense contracts in support of Ukraine. And the cost to Britain of entering that was something like 10% of the entire MOD budget. And so the British government's mission was, you know, we want to be a part of that, but we can't possibly justify that so you end up taking a position which keeps you outside of a of a of a

37:08core piece of european integration which we want to be a part of in theory so they're all of these questions and you add them up over uh you know from each department and the argument that stewart's making is sometimes you end up in a sort of more Eurosceptic position than the collective, which on the whole wants to rejoin or to move closer to the European Union. and say to ministers, I'm afraid that you might not like the consequences in this particular area, but it is in the benefit of the country overall to move in this direction. And I thought the other part of Stuart's argument, which was fascinating, and I'd be interested to know how it sort of plays out in Labour Party politics, is this sense of if you move too fast if you move

38:07towards rejoin too quickly he has that metaphor at the beginning that you kind of you lose sight of of the the necessary steps in on the way and you sort of fall into the hole and you don't get to where you want to get to um and i just think that it's it's um it's a piece that sort of talks, I think, about some of the conflict that is happening within the party. And even within individual cabinet ministers, I think that sense that they may be pro-European, but they're a bit unsure how to get there because they're concerned about what freedom of movement might do as an argument in their patch of the next election, or they're concerned about reopening the debate, that kind of thing. Well, yeah, you saw Lisa Nandy, actually, didn't you, recently on the media round,

38:51basically saying she didn't want to rejoin and looking sort of very uncomfortable about having to have this whole argument all over again. She actually said, I don't believe anybody wants to repeat circular arguments about in or out, leave or remain. And then when she was asked, would you want to go back in? She replied, I don't know if that's a choice we have. So clearly just not wanting. And that's a neighbouring constituency. And that's also not what circular arguments mean. That killed me. But that's a neighbouring constituency to Andy Burnham. Yeah, I know. And she's meant to be an ally of his. I mean, it's so interesting because there are, I guess, two different conversations about us and europe happening at the same time

39:27there's the kind of big sexy one that andy burnham kicked off um about this is what counts as sexy it's all relative you know there's the kind of big brushstrokes, you know, let's have a big conversation about our direction on Europe, sort of hinting about, you know, maybe even having rejoin on the, you know, on the ballot at the next election, talking about freedom of movement. Like big, bold, oh my goodness, after Labour's red lines and saying we're not reopening the Brexit debate. Does Andy Burnham seriously just actually want to bring this all back up again um some people delighted by that some people horrified by it and i mean i guess we can talk a bit more about that but the but the the less sexy one is

40:17just the more immediate one which is the uk eu summit yes coming up and so these are happening at the same time where these are negotiations that were begun under Keir Starmer he was clear that he wanted a closer relationship to the EU but that involves some give and take the negotiations have only got harder with the change of government because I gather that you like to put their the you know the other side through their paces so the the asks have got more difficult and so a youth mobility scheme basically allowing young people from the eu and britain to to move freely and travel and study um the numbers involved there are getting higher and higher um yeah and so it could be you know it could end up in six figures you know like a hundred thousand

41:06um you eu young people allowed in the uk every year or something like that that we don't know what the fine print on that looks like but that negotiation is happening at the moment and then there's also just the unsexy stuff of an sps deal stuff about you know ketchup sachets and being banned or smoky bacon crisps and you know there's there's the immediate negotiation which is really really difficult and then this massive blue sky thinking on the other hand they're happening at the same time and I think it's the blue sky thinking that is freaking people out i mean i thought that maybe a cabinet this week it was political cabinet which means some extra people get to go and the civil servants

41:55aren't there i thought a political cabinet given there has been so much kind of tense briefing around things like rosebank evs cabinet ministers trying to bounce each other into difficult things, very, very obviously all across the media. I thought they might have it out on green stuff at cabinet. And I was told, no, green, like the environment, climate, like none of that came up. It was all on Europe. And I think it was quite, I don't know if it was heated, but quite developed discussion on that. And there are kind of deep cabinet splits on what they want to do in terms of that blue sky thinking. And actually, even among quite senior people, I think there's a little bit of confusion about what Andy Burnham intended to do with those remarks on freedom of movement.

42:47There's been a lot of suggestion, is it just kite flying? He wants to see what the public reaction is. Support for rejoining, according to polling, has slightly ticked up since he said it, which is really interesting. Was he just testing an idea? What was the point of it? Where does it go from here and so speaking to some of his allies i think what they are all agreed on which is ultimately literally no different to kira starmer but better executed is they just want to keep reminding people that brexit hasn't worked out you know they want that to stay in the conversation and just keep keep it there um but beyond that i think some people who are burning want to shift more to talking about trade-offs

43:33you know the economy versus immigration and they also want a bit of sort of structure and order to the conversation i think that's part of why ben nunn who you know who you know for for non-ical people, it's really actually quite extraordinary him going into work for Andy Burnham, given he's been so close to Keir Starmer. whole way through opposition then worked for rachel reeves but you know he was there on dining street in the last day now he's working for the man who who ousted him um and um i think then none has been brought in to add a kind of sense of there being staging posts and structure and how you would do the eu relationship step by step so that it doesn't get too big and scary.

44:26That's interesting. But it has really thrown people in the Labour Party. It's kind of fun if you're a political journalist. There's almost a sense of mystery, even among senior people, about what Andy Burnham is up to and what the intention of it is. And, you know, someone said to me, you know, if your intention is to bring the Labour Party together, why would you bring this back up? Because there are so many divisions, including around his top table. And I think those were really in evidence at Cabinet this week. Yeah, it's interesting what you say that people just were thrown into confusion, because I remember when he became Prime Minister, speaking to someone in the Cabinet Office involved in the existing EU negotiations who were like,

45:09suddenly we have to apply the make a field test to everything. But they hadn't been told that, they were just sort of starting to do it themselves and couldn't work out. Even then, you know, with the EU reset, the sort of incremental sector by sector negotiating, how they could sort of match the make a field test onto that. And now you get, like you say, this kind of talking about freedom of movement and rejoin. I suppose, you know, talking about what these prime ministers sincerely hold to him, I suppose he sincerely just thinks it would be better to be back in. Didn't he say something to you in one of your interviews where he said he just likes unions? He likes the idea of unions. He likes unions, trade unions, the United Kingdom, the European Union. Yeah. Yeah. the united kingdom the european union yeah uh yeah i mean i suppose lots of us do right but

45:46this is um incredibly um dangerous i think in so many ways um to stewart ingham's p uh point uh and what you know alva's been saying it's it's like every step of the way is dangerous for a labor party and complicated because even say like take the spPS deal on you know food and farming you can apply and I presume they will do this they'll say this is cost of living this is a cost of living measure this will lower the cost of bringing goods in you know ridiculous barriers between Britain and the European Union that make it harder for supermarkets to bring things in. That would be a clear argument. But there are also trade-offs, right? So we are going to become a rule-taker on these questions.

46:33And any deal where we get close to the European Union, the fundamental reality is we become a rule-taker. So we will be following EU rules. Not if we rejoined, I guess. Not if we rejoined. Yeah, if we rejoined, and that's kind of the argument from these voices. Exactly. And it's total clear logic. So once you start down this process, there is a logical endpoint, which is if you don't want to be a rule taker, rejoin and have some say over the rules that are going to apply to you. And a lot of people are sort of looking at that and saying, that's clearly where we're going here. I mean, there's another way of thinking about this. We've always been here, Britain. And Andy Burnham is an example of this.

47:14He applies the Makersfield test to himself in many ways and sort of argues he was a reluctant Remainer because he was concerned about the impact of immigration onto schools in his area, particularly Roman Catholic schools. And he talks about that. And then, you know, but that is part of free movement of people, right? You know, this is something that you manage as a member and lots of member states do that. Every step that you enter into this process all the way through to rejoining comes with trade-offs. And perhaps that is a grown-up beginning of this conversation that he is starting here where he is going to talk about that. Trade-offs. Trade-offs of freedom of movement and the economy and prices and control control the rules that affect you all of these

48:05things it is it is fundamentally true but i'd say you know we'll go back all the way to harold wilson this is what labor prime ministers and tory prime ministers have been doing we want like we want our cake and eat it the whole way through yeah and there and there is just this irony of having the big discussion about possibly rejoining or the big ambitious one when in reality we're locked in a really torturous negotiation over an sps deal exactly about sausages yeah a really live reminder of how difficult it is to negotiate with the european union who have their own interests as well and a i mean i i think it just has not entered the political conversation enough in the UK that the EU would need to have a say on all of this.

48:51You know, it's not like we can just decide to rejoin and it's just for us. You know, it would be about entering into negotiation where the exact destination is not necessarily decided. That would be decided in the negotiating room. We have such a weird way of talking about it where we set our red lines and where we want to get in the negotiation publicly in a British public debate before we go into the negotiating room, which is not how anyone reasonable ever negotiates. No, you're showing your hand before you enter into the negotiation. But they're also just more powerful than us yeah this you know this is something that is also just not being digested very um obviously in britain which is they tend to set the terms of of the debate because we tend to be the

49:38demander in this relationship you know we are asking for a closer relationship they're not coming to us and say we really really want you to have an SPS deal. They're quite comfortable. You know, they are doing the checks on the border. We found it incredibly difficult to do the checks on the border coming into our country. And we should also just put this sort of just throw this out there as well. The European Union are completely aware that there is a major political divide here. You know, so the Labour Party is looking to negotiate a closer relationship. Some people are talking about rejoin. The country as a whole, as Alva said, has shifted towards, you know, a clear position on this, although it seems to be, you know,

50:18how hard that is, who knows. But the Conservative Party want to move us further away from Europe. So they want to leave the ECHR as do reform with enormous consequences, you know, for the Good Friday Agreement, other things. Like there is not a clear set of the direction of travel in British politics. And they're aware of that. They don't want to enter a negotiation, which then they have to sort of enter another one in two years' time or three years' time. And if there is a conservative-led or a reform-led government, that is also playing out in this discussion. You've been listening to The Politics Show from The New Statesman with me, Anoush Shakelian, and my colleagues Alvar A. and Tom McTague.

50:59This episode was produced by Rob Lemaire. Your daily supplement routine doesn't need to be managing a handful of different bottles. Onnit's Total Human brings key research-based vitamins, minerals, herbs, and amino acids together in convenient day and night packs. One all-in-one product designed to make supplementation easier. The day pack supports cognition, focus, and cellular energy production. At night, the Nightpack helps you wind down and supports a calm, relaxed state. Less time managing your supplements, more support for your day and night. Shop Total Human now at onnit.com.

▸More episode summaries

The Politics Show cover art
The Politics ShowThe Jensen Huang affair2026-11-14 · 35 min
The Politics Show cover art
The Politics ShowBritain’s violence-obsessed adolescents2026-11-16 · 32 min
Transcribe your links. Paste a YouTube, Google Drive or podcast link and WhipScribe gives you the transcript. Transcribe a link →
New The Politics Show transcripts by email
One email per new episode, unsubscribe in every message. Not shared with the publisher.