Politics Unpacked · · Transcript & summary by WhipScribe
Three commentators tear into Andy Burnham's travel-heavy start, the Milburn youth benefits review and a Welsh Senate ban on a Reform UK member in one brisk episode.
Tap a chapter to play it from that moment in the show's own player; the transcript opens there too.
“a complete act of madness that I think will down the line also have a massive political cost for those who are pushing it.” Juliet Samuel · at 17:37 — ▶ hear it from here
“unless you're inciting violence in a way that is illegal, that there should be very few limitations.” Juliet Samuel · at 29:28 — ▶ hear it from here
The hosts open with Andy Burnham's dash through three countries in one day, from COP31 in Turkey to the European political community in Dublin. Matthew Syed calls it a distraction from domestic problems, while Juliet Samuel says the European forum is Britain's main seat at the table since Brexit. On climate, a new special representative for climate security signals a shift toward treating energy as national security, and the panel reads a Treasury push to take control of energy policy as a retreat from net zero. Both favour nuclear power and more North Sea gas for cheaper, reliable electricity.
On technology, Juliet Samuel argues Britain should stockpile AI chips, because one Taiwanese factory, a Dutch lithography machine and one American designer form a fragile supply chain. Matthew Syed doubts Britain can build frontier AI models with expensive power, but sees room for leverage in chip design. On Europe, David Cameron's warning against rejoining the EU wins backing, since Juliet Samuel calls another decade of debate a self-inflicted wound.
The welfare segment centres on Alan Milburn's youth unemployment review, due Tuesday, which he says should rebuild a benefits system that currently pushes young people toward inactivity. Juliet Samuel finds the plan less radical than headlines suggest, since savings take a decade, and sees it as a test of Andy Burnham's authority after Keir Starmer failed to pass about £5 billion of welfare cuts. Matthew Syed praises a London school's discipline model. The show ends on Reform UK's Senate ban in Wales and a debate over Russell Brand's politics.
Juliet Samuel said David Cameron is right to warn against rejoining the EU, because Britain should not spend another five to ten years arguing about whether it is in or out. She called reopening that debate a complete act of madness that would distract from the economy's real problems.
“a complete act of madness that I think will down the line also have a massive political cost for those who are pushing it.”Juliet Samuel · 17:37
Matthew Syed said he visited the Michaelis School near Wembley Park and was impressed by its approach of combining discipline and praise with consequences for bad behaviour. He said the school has the highest value added of any school in the country and beats many prestigious private schools.
“giving young people discipline and praise and reward when they do good things, but also punishment when they do bad things”Matthew Syed · 12:48
Juliet Samuel said Keir Starmer's government could not get even a small package of welfare cuts through, and that it could not even reduce the plan to £2 or £3 billion. She said this episode badly damaged his authority and will be the next major test for Andy Burnham.
“couldn't get just £5 billion worth of cuts to welfare through.”Juliet Samuel · 14:11
Matthew Syed said Russell Brand's politics acted as a shield, with people on the left defending him when he was aligned with them and people on the MAGA right defending him after the verdict. He said Brand's views were consistent but simplistic, and that it surprised him anyone took them seriously.
“how being identified with one or the other side can often be something of a shield for somebody who's doing something wrong.”Matthew Syed · 30:18
Juliet Samuel said Nvidia, run by Jensen Huang, is the only company able to design the most advanced chips used for AI. She argued that this concentration, combined with a fragile supply chain, is why Britain should stockpile chips.
“They're the only company who can design the most advanced chips used for AI.”Juliet Samuel · 23:09
The panel of Juliet Samuel and Matthew Syed questioned whether Andy Burnham's three-country day of meetings was worthwhile, with Syed arguing Britain's problems are mainly domestic and Samuel saying the European political community is the main forum where Britain is represented since leaving the EU. Both saw the new climate security envoy as a sign that the government is moving energy policy away from net zero.
Juliet Samuel said David Cameron is right to warn against rejoining the EU, since Britain does not want another five to ten years of argument over whether it should be in or out. She called reopening that debate a complete self-destruction that would distract from fixing the economy. She also argued the facts about EU trade-offs have not changed enough to justify rerunning a settled democratic vote.
Matthew Syed said Britain will not build its own frontier AI models or data centres any time soon, because it is a long way behind and its electricity is very expensive. He suggested a narrower goal: finding a way to design a certain type of chip, or to hold some leverage over the physical AI supply chain that Taiwan Semiconductor and Nvidia dominate. He warned that countries which missed earlier technology curves, such as steam and electricity, have found it hard to catch up.
Juliet Samuel argues stockpiling AI chips is basic due diligence because the supply chain is fragile. Nvidia in America designs the most advanced AI chips, they are made only in factories in Taiwan, and those factories depend on a lithography machine that can only be made in the Netherlands. She notes the Taiwan factories sit on an island aligned with the US but claimed by China, so a cutoff is more likely than people hope.
Alan Milburn told The Times the entire benefits system for young people needs to be rebuilt from scratch. The hosts take his point to be that the current system encourages inactivity when it should push young people back into work. Juliet Samuel reports that he expects savings to take about a decade, with no upfront cost saving, and that his youth unemployment review was due to be published on Tuesday.
Juliet Samuel said she doubts Labour has the stomach to pass the Milburn welfare changes, which she sees as the next major test of Andy Burnham's authority. She pointed to Keir Starmer's failure to get about £5 billion of welfare cuts through, and said even a minor immigration reform under Shabana Mahmood proved hard to pass despite Labour's large majority.
Matthew Syed said he visited the Michaelis School near Wembley Park and was impressed by its model of discipline, praise and reward, with consequences for bad behaviour. He said the school has the highest value added of any school in the country and beats many prestigious private schools. He argued that welfare incentives drifted away from this approach, and that giving people an incentive not to work is bad for them as well as for society.
Our own transcript of the public episode, with a timestamp about every 90 seconds. Tap a timestamp to play the episode from there in the show's own player; the link button on a paragraph copies a link that opens this page there.
0:00Dominic O'Connell and Hannah Prevett here from The Business Podcast. Join us for a special episode with President of the British Chambers of Commerce and former Chief Economist at the Bank of England, Andy Haldane, and PwC's UK tax leader, Clare Blackburn, as we look ahead to John Healy's first budget. We'll discuss the challenge he faces trying to get the economy growing with an uncertain geopolitical backdrop and a party that's not keen on making cuts to public spending. We'll also ask what businesses are looking for, whether the government will be in a position to deliver or if more tax squeezes are on the way. Listen to The Business wherever you get your podcasts. This episode of Politics Unpacked is sponsored by Lloyd's Banking Group.
0:45Financial empowerment belongs to all of us. It means having the confidence and control to make more informed decisions about money, from building a financial buffer to managing credit or starting to invest. Those everyday decisions could add up to something bigger. Modelling commissioned by Lloyd's Banking Group suggests that making digital financial tools more accessible at scale could unlock up to £100 billion for Britain's economy by 2036. Search Lloyds Banking Group Financial Empowerment to learn more. This episode is sponsored by Google. Tradespeople are the backbone of the British economy. But for many who run their own businesses, time-consuming admin takes them away from the work that really requires their skills and craft.
1:28Google's AI Works for Britain program is helping tradespeople learn AI skills so they can save time and grow their business. Because Google believes when all sectors of the economy have the right AI tools, everyone will benefit. Visit grow.google.com to learn more about AI and find the right training resources for you. Hello, I'm Hugo Rifkind, and now we're going to be unpacking the politics of the day, from Annie Burnham's diplomatic dash to a new deal for NEETs, and we'll discuss calls for a grown-up drug policy as users get older and older. And with me today, to make sense of it all, clear-headed as anything, it's Times columnist Juliet Samuel. Hello, Juliet. Good morning. Good morning. And Matthew Side. Hello,
2:09Matthew. Hello, Hugo. Great to connect. Let's talk first about Andy Burnham. He is rattling around the world. He's arrived in Turkey for meetings at COP31, the annual summit about the minor issue of whether planet Earth is going to boil away into a puff of steam. And after that, he's going to his second summit of the day, which is a meeting of the European political community in Dublin, meaning three countries in the space of a day, suggesting that on the global stage, he is very keen to be present. So look, yeah, two meetings in one day, three countries, five and a half hours on an aeroplane. Matthew, I'll come to you first on this. Is this diligent or is this a bit mad? I think a bit of a waste of time, Hugo. I think almost all of
2:45Britain's problems are domestic. And most people around the world are not that bothered by what we think. Our power in world affairs is very severely diminished. And if we can sort out our economy, it actually did okay today. There's some good numbers. But we have massive latent potential. And I remember when Keir Starmer said he was leaving office, and I went to read the Times, obviously, first and foremost, but then I started looking at some of the global newspapers. The Wall Street Journal didn't have the news story on its homepage. And for a moment, I was a bit bemused. I thought, you know, has the website not updated? Is there a power cut on the Avenue of the Americas? And then I realised that it had been buried in world news.
3:31You know, Britain changes prime ministers a lot. It isn't the strongest country in the world. And I think I would like to see our prime ministers rigorously and ruthlessly focused on what they can do back here in the UK. Juliet, do you agree? Or do you think actually, we need to be present on the world stage? It's deeply connected with everything else. You probably have to show up to some of these things, particularly the European political community, because that's really the only forum since we left the EU where Britain is properly represented. And discussion about security matters is pretty important across the continent of Europe right now. I do think the COP summits are really an utter waste of time and energy
4:10and just a kind of lobbying circus. And, you know, so I would probably say we should drop that. But, you know, the prime minister has to do some of this stuff. I think with Starmer, the suspicion was that he was doing so much because he couldn't face doing anything at home. The problems were just too difficult. And, you know, he'd spent his whole career in international human rights forums. But, you know, Burnham is not like that. He's probably only showing up to the ones he feels he has to, whether that's for political or real reasons, it's hard to tell. Well done you for knowing there was a European political community. I must admit it rather sneaked up on me. Matthew, you know all about the European political community,
4:52right? I helped found it and designed the opening charter. It was founded in 2022, basically as a response to the war in Ukraine. And Juliet's right, it is our big forum for speaking to Europe since we left the EU. Of course, it includes many countries that aren't in the EU, such as Ukraine as well. Look, on the climate side of things, Burnham, he's also announced Dame Madeleine Alessandri as our first special representative for climate security. Matthew, what do you reckon one of those is? Is it like a SAR, do you think? In a very special way, represent the British interest in that sphere. I don't really know Hugo. I mean, energy is obviously very important. I mean, this is about climate change.
5:33Is it more than energy, this representative? Well, this is what's interesting about it. She is the special representative for climate security. She was the former head of the Joint Intelligence Committee. So it does seem to be a bit of a change of direction to think of climate principally in a kind of national security way rather than an economic way or even a kind of moral way. What do you think about that? Juliet, sorry. I think they've tried all the words in different orders, haven't they? So they've tried energy and climate change. Then they tried energy security and net zero. And now they're having a go at climate security just to mix it up. But I mean, more seriously, I just think this is one of those things where you want to appoint someone so that you, for political purposes, not for any practical purpose,
6:18so that you have someone who makes it look like you're doing things. You've got someone you can send to meetings, especially at the same time. And this is actually one of the more interesting things that has happened with this government so far, if not the most interesting thing, as you're pivoting away from net zero policy and actually prioritising cheap bills. And there's actually a major turf war going on at the moment between the Treasury and the Energy Department, involving essentially the Clean Power 2030 target that was Ed Miliband's thing to basically decarbonise all electricity supply by 2030, which is not a practical target. And the Treasury is basically seizing that control of energy policy. And this is a major change, you know, more than
7:03a decade, it's really been run by people focused on climate. So what this appointment probably is, is a stop to the Energy Secretary to say, I know we're taking your policy area away from you. But look, you have a new, a new czar, you can send out into the world to show how important you are. But Matthew, I mean, climate is a security issue, isn't it? I mean, because, you know, it is sort of climate considerations that mean we have? I mean, because, you know, it is sort of climate considerations that mean we have to rely on, I don't know, unreliable partners for all our gas and oil. It leads to sort of land grabs of disputed regions, perhaps in the Atlantic. Changing global temperatures lead to huge waves of immigration and may lead to more. This is
7:40a security issue. Isn't that the right way to think about it? Yeah, massive. It's a massive issue. And the question is how much control we have over it in this country. I mean, the amount of power we can, it's a very great paradox that the amount of power, political power we're able to project in order to get the kinds of policies we wish on climate change or anything else, it depends on the strength of our economy and military. But the strength of our economy and military depends on having cheap electricity, which often means having a policy here at home which doesn't tally with this global agenda. So this is the deep tension at the heart of our species at the moment. We have these collective problems at a global level which require resolution with individual nation states whose
8:25power is determined in no small part by their willingness to breach the global accords. It's exactly the same with AI. My own view, for what it's worth, is I'd like to see free democratic societies get to super intelligence first and control it effectively. On climate, I just don't think that we've had a sufficiently robust global accord so it makes sense for a country like ours that is a very small percentage of global emissions to act in the national self-interest so friends of the earth say that a british authority on tackling climate change is crumbling at the start of cop 31 julia are they are they right or was it always in fact pretty crumbly and we just could have ourselves otherwise well i i just think the entire concept of climate thought leadership has been really
9:11bankrupted by the fact that we have the most expensive industrial energy costs in the developed world and if you're trying to show leadership and why the energy transition is a good idea, you probably need to demonstrate that it is at least compatible, if not encouraging, of a thriving economy with abundant energy. So I think the entire approach that probably friends of the Earth would have adopted to the concept of climate leadership is not one that I think was ever going to be effective. What would be a better approach, Juliette? A better approach would be to invest in technology, mainly, I think, in nuclear power, where we used to have an incredibly strong, thriving industry. And I don't see a reason why we can't again.
10:00We just, it will take a very long time. You know, it will take five to 10 years to get back the skills base that enable you to build nuclear at an affordable rate. And at the same time as that, I would support massively more exploiting the North Sea, which is piped gas where the infrastructure is already there. We know the environmental standards involved in extracting it are some of the highest in the world. And, you know, as much as possible, reduce our dependence on external sources. And I think if you could get to a point where energy prices were lower, and you had reliable baseload power at the same time as being one of the lower emissions countries in the world, then, you know, that would really be an example other countries might want to follow. Matthew?
10:46I think that's exactly right. I mean, it's one of the great tragedies, really, that nuclear fission in particular, you know, it really got scuppered by Three Mile Island. And when you look at the statistics, there weren't that many deaths related either to that incident itself or afterwards. And then, of course, Chernobyl and Fukushima. In actual fact, this is a clean technology that the green movement turned against, that Germany turned against, we did. Juliet said you need to have skills and tacit knowledge. But South Korea are building these very effectively. If we could get on that learning curve now, I think we could drive the price down, have abundant and clean energy. Energy is at the center of all economic activity and all life. And I think there's been a blind spot in theoretical economics for a long time.
11:28The energy is front and center of how we should be thinking about all of the things that are important for civilization. And then, of course, technology can not just improve the way that we get the energy from splitting, from fission, but also from fusion. I know this has been on the horizon for a while, but my sense is that this could be imminent. And then if we're at the beginning of that revolution, that'd be fantastic. I want to talk about the Milburn Review into youth unemployment. It's almost here. It's going to be published on Tuesday. And so Mr. Milburn, Alan, to his friends, has been speaking to The Times, and he says the entire system of benefits for the young needs to be rebuilt from scratch. Matthew, his point seems to be that at the moment it is geared towards
12:08keeping people inactive, when actually it should be doing the exact opposite. He's right, isn't he? Sounds logical to me, Hugo. It does raise the question, how on earth could we have got to a point where a welfare system was doing the opposite of what it should have been doing, which is giving people the chance when they lose employment or if they're in a period of genuine need to have that safety net, but then to have the encouragement to get back into work, which is so incredibly important. I spent a day this week, I don't know if you've been to the Michaelis School near Wembley Park Tube? I know of it. I have not been there, no. Honestly, Hugo, I thought I knew the school because I'd read all the reports and had been impressed with the head teacher. You go to that
12:48school and I was just completely blown away by the fact that giving young people discipline and praise and reward when they do good things, but also punishment when they do bad things, creating incentives to actually go out there and do the stuff that makes them better rather than to plead victimhood. They've had incredible results and most of the kids have thrived there. They've got the highest value added of any school in the country. They beat the socks off many of the most prestigious private schools. I do think that a bit of, I don't want this to sound like a kind of a cultural point, but a bit of progressivism infiltrated our welfare system and didn't realise that when you give people an incentive not to work
13:31it's not just bad for the society but it's bad for them too. Juliet, the headline on the front of the Times about this today is probably exactly what Andy Burnham wouldn't want. It reads, Milburn cuts sick benefits to force young into work. And Milburn himself says that this is not going to be pain-free for people on benefits at the moment. And look, whatever the motive, cutting benefits is cutting benefits. Does Labour have the stomach to get this through? I doubt it. Although I do think from the interview, there were some indications that it may not actually be as major a change as we might have been led to believe. Because he said things like it's going to take a decade to get any savings
14:11out of this. There's no upfront cost saving to be made here. You know, there were examples of people who would still need job support, included those with mild ADHD and mild anxiety. So those things did not read to me like a very revolutionary change to the whole system. But obviously, we don't know what's in the report and even any minor change, as we saw with Shabana Mahmood's immigration reforms, impossible to get through even the very substantial majority Labour has. So yeah, it's probably going to be a major struggle. And this is one of the things that fell the Keir Starmer government that really shot his authority when he couldn't get just £5 billion worth of cuts to welfare through. He couldn't even get it down to £2 or £3 billion
15:02and get that through. So it will be, you know, the next major test of BAMM's authority. Yeah, I mean, as Juliet says, we don't yet know what's in it. But it seems to me to be that the idea, who knows to what extent, is to take money away from benefits and put it into things like employment support and careers advice, which itself slightly worries me, Matthew, because I know you're all over this kind of stuff. But I'm not sure I necessarily trust careers advisors to know at the moment what they should be advising young people to do as careers. The world is changing so much. AI is changing so much. Is it possible to say for a government-appointed careers advisor to tell people what kind of jobs
15:38are going to be thriving in the next decade, except perhaps for careers advisors, of which we're going to need a lot more? Yeah. I'm just thinking back to when I was in what was back in the old currency fifth form. And we had to go and see careers advisors in the evening. And I told them that I wanted to be a professional table tennis player. I won't try and describe the facial expression that came on that poor person's- Were you holding your paddle at the time, Matthew? That's a very Americanism there, Hugo. Bat, we like to call it. Paddle is what they call it in America. Answer the question. I feel, I guess, like many people listening at the moment, that we need a fundamental change. And Juliet's obviously read this in some detail.
16:25I really do hope Milburn doesn't bottle it, that this is a whole scale change, a complete rewiring of our welfare state as part of a bigger mission to really change the way that the state operates. The state is too big. The welfare state has grown. It's enormous. Debt has grown at the same time. And unless there's incremental change know, incremental change with no savings for 10 years, that hints of pushing it down the road. And I wonder, you know, Milburn Burns, I think, was a really impressive minister in a very, very good government. I'm a big admirer, particularly of the first Tony Blair term, wish we could get back to that level of common sense in our economic and social policy. But if the Labour backbenchers have got to him,
17:05or Burnham's people have said, look, this is just not going to get through, what a tragedy that would be for the country, and also for future generations. It's obviously too early to write off the Millburn Review just yet. Fingers crossed, it's going to do what everybody hopes. Let's move on. I want to talk about the EU a bit. David Cameron has warned in an interview with Bloomberg that rejoining the EU is a bad idea, telling Andy Burnham, we don't want another decade long debate about whether we should be in or out. Juliette, do you feel he has a point or do you feel he might just be a bit bitter because he so badly ballsed up the last 10 year long debate about whether we should be in or out?
17:37I'm sure it's both, but bitterness does not erase the point. He's obviously right that the notion that we are going to spend another five to ten years arguing about precisely what this aspect of our constitutional arrangements should be rather than actually solving fundamental problems in the economy seems to me a complete act of madness that I think will down the line also have a massive political cost for those who are pushing it. It's as if they've learned nothing from the Brexit wars, from years of trying to overturn a democratic vote. And, you know, because there's a shift in the poll ratings, they're going back to kind of chew on the old bone of the fight that they lost, you know, the moment when it was revealed that the country had really changed and that the worldview of the fight that they lost, you know, the moment when it was revealed that the country had really
18:25changed and that the worldview of the last generation was probably had reached its zenith and was now in decline. So I, yeah, I think he's entirely right. And I think that it would be, you know, it would be a complete self-destruction to re-enter this whole debate in that way again. I mean, it's been 10 years, Juliette. Don't all democratic votes overturn the last democratic vote? Well, not referendums every 10 years on something as fundamental as this. I mean, you know, the Scottish referendum, for example, was said to be, you know, once in a generation opportunity. And I also don't think that you can really argue that many of the facts on the ground, you know, have massively changed in terms of what we know
19:13about the trade-offs of the EU membership. So this is not like just changing the people who are running your government. This is a big change to the way your government is run and where different powers are vested and how you relate to the world. And no, I don't think you can just go back over that every 10 years. One of the major problems we have is that we're constantly flip-flopping on policies when, you know, success comes from long-term planning. And this is the opposite of that in every way. I'm interested in how this debate sort of feels at the moment, because at the moment, the debate doesn't really seem to be whether we continue with the status quo, or whether we rejoin the EU. The debate seems to be whether we slightly surreptitiously
19:59change our relationship with the EU to be one that is more sort of close and integrated, or whether we do it out loud while admitting that's what we're doing. Those seem to be the two sides, aren't they? I'll disagree with that. No, I don't think we should be moving closer to the EU at this point at all. I think every time we reopen a negotiation, we lose more ground. How many times do we want to do it? I think if you look particularly at two policy areas that are absolutely fundamental to the future, energy and AI, I think the EU is going very rapidly in completely the wrong direction. And therefore, you know, moving closer, tying ourselves into things without any clear strategy about what this means for the economy would be a major mistake. On the EU, I voted remain, like you,
20:46Hugo, if I remember correctly, and I thought that it was a mistake to leave the European Union. But I do think the world has moved on quite significantly. And what worries me the most, by a very long way, is that we get distracted again. I would just love to see a government come in and make a series of major reforms that I think are doable to drive growth, maybe a great reform act to change planning so that we can build houses and energy infrastructure, probably the most important single thing, along with reform to welfare and some other things that I've written about in my columns. Is the EU going to make a difference on that? I'm not sure it would. And having a debate about it would suck our bandwidth
21:24for such a very long time. But I do worry as well about the AI regulation in the EU. So maybe for one of the very rare occasions in his career, David Cameron is right. This episode is sponsored by Google. Trades people are vital for building economic growth in the UK, but they face serious time pressures that often take them away from the work that requires their craft and expertise. Google's AI Works for Britain program offers training to help them discover the AI tools already in their pockets that can help them save up to eight hours a week, helping to boost productivity and grow their business. Visit grow.google.com to learn more about AI and find the right training resources for you. Dominic O'Connell and Hannah Privet here from the Business Podcast.
22:18Join us for a special episode with President of the British Chambers of Commerce and former Chief Economist at the Bank of England, Andy Haldane, and PwC's UK tax leader, Claire Blackburn, as we look ahead to John Healy's first budget. We'll discuss the challenge he faces trying to get the economy growing, with an uncertain geopolitical backdrop and a party that's not keen on making cuts to public spending. We'll also ask what businesses are looking for, whether the government will be in a position to deliver or if more tax squeezes are on the way. Listen to The Business wherever you get your podcasts. um juliette you've been writing about the the huang huang bang bang the scandal of jensen
23:09huang head of nvidia and his uh affair with an alleged chinese spy but you're less interested in the salacious details boo than you are in the geopolitics of chips the ai boom is all about chips and you think britain should be stockpiling Oh yeah, we definitely should be because it's just this whole scandal highlights what an unbelievably fragile and incredibly complicated supply chain these things have. So, you know, the world economy relies on a flow of billions of these things. They are designed in America by this company run by Jensen Huang, NVIDIA. They're the only company who can design the most advanced chips used for AI. They're made in Taiwan in the only factories that can make these chips.
24:10The factories use a machine that can only be made in the Netherlands that was developed over decades. It's a lithography machine that can kind of enable you to print the nanoscale circuits onto the chip in order to, they're made basically with light exposure. And, you know, then you have the geopolitical backdrop to that, which is that, you know, obviously the US and China are entering this age of major superpower rivalry and the factory making all these chips is on an island aligned with the US but claimed by China. You could not make this up as a plot for a major thriller or almost a disaster movie. So I think, yes, stockpiling chips would be an act of very basic due diligence in a situation where the chances that they get cut off for a period or
24:46something very bad happens seem, you know, much higher than you would ever hope was possible. Matthew, Julia also thinks that the UK should, of course, be producing giants in the field of working with AI, not just creating it. And I don't know, you might be interested in this. I had an epiphany the other day about maybe why it is that Britain is so bad at tech when we are so good at science. I suddenly realised they're different things. The UK is good at science because science is academic, whereas the US is brilliant at tech because tech is commercial. Do we need to become more of a tech country and less of a science country? That's definitely been an issue, I think, in cultural terms for a long
25:22time. Governments have tried to deal with that. But it isn't easy to shift that kind of cultural psychology in America. It's about monetizing any advance and making sure that consumers want to buy it. I think there is something in there. And then on AI, it's a tricky one for us. I don't think we're ever going to get strategic autonomy in terms of building our own frontier models and having the data centers to run them, certainly not anytime soon. We're a long way behind and our electricity is so expensive. But I do wonder about trying to find a way in the physical basis of AI, having some kind of a chokehold over the supply chain, if you like, in the way that the Taiwan semiconductor company
26:02does, the company in the Netherlands that were mentioned by Juliet, NVIDIA, of course, in America, if we can try and think strategically about how to find a way of designing a certain type of chip, that might give us a certain degree of leverage. But this is such a transformational period. And if we're too far behind the curve, like those countries who didn't get onto the curve when it came to the steam engine and electricity, then it will be difficult ever to catch up. Yeah. Let's turn to some politics. There's some fresh madness from the Senate in Cardiff after a Reform UK member, Joe Martin, was banned from the Senate for saying that white people are being replaced. That might seem extreme from the Senate. Do recall that just a few months ago,
26:43they also banned the use of the word blanket, which I can explain in a moment if I have to. The leader of Reform Wales, Helen Jenner, spoke yesterday. We feel this is down to undue pressure applied by the governing party who don't like to hear what we have to say. It's infringement on freedom of speech and quite frankly nothing would have happened to Jo had he said these things out on the street. So why should he be silenced in the parliament here in wales as such we have decided to make a stand and our stand is this if you silence one of us you silence us all matthew i'm not a fan of people saying that white people are being replaced it strikes me as being both racist and frankly a lie but i'm also i don't think a
27:20fan of democratic bodies banning people whatever they they say. What do you think? I'm quite stunned by this. So this reformed person isn't allowed to go to Parliament because he said something that they found objectionable but that was legal. Yes, and I believe didn't even say it in Parliament, said it on the BBC. Well, that is quite remarkable. I mean, it's the Parliament that is there to debate questions of what is and is not acceptable speech in a free society for a parliament to be banned for saying something legal outside the parliament building i i'm frankly i'm almost speechless with with this story i'm blown away by it i think it's unjustifiable even though i didn't necessarily agree with the comment that was made juliet you're
28:04a well-known pinko liberal hand waver. Presumably you'll have a completely different view. I think that it's, you know, it doesn't speak very well of the Senate that when they hear something they disagree with vehemently. They don't seem to understand this is a debating chamber and the whole basis of our constitution is that we believe in testing ideas in a forum of debate. So I don't think it helps them to be running scared of a debate of this kind. But as you said, they're those, you know, hiding under their blanket, if that's allowed, if that terminology is allowed. I think that was a debate about the speed limit, wasn't it? Yes, it's been running for years. I think it just shows it's not a serious forum, is it?
28:50I mean, nothing real is happening there. You know, a bit of speed limits, a bit of annoyance for the people of Wales. But if this were a serious chamber, this is not the approach they would be taking to ideas they don't like. The blanket thing, just to explain, they got very cross in the Senate. People kept describing the 20 miles per hour speed limit as a blanket ban. And for some reason, this led to them banning the describing of it as a blanket ban. Julia, is there any line you think here? Should people be able to say anything? I mean, if they're in the Senate, are there views that should bar people from being in a democratic chamber if they express them? Or is that just simply not how chamber ought to work?
29:28I think short of incitement, honestly, you know, you should probably just go by what is legal speech. And I do think actually what is legal speech is sort of creepingly becoming less free. You know, you have misuse, for example, of the Public Order Act to enforce de facto blasphemy laws. So I do think that's a concern across the country at large. But no, we specifically have in the Westminster Parliament a protection whereby, you know, you can even libel someone and not be liable for it, because we recognise that this is where ideas are threshed out. So I think, you know, unless you're inciting violence in a way that is illegal, that there should be very few limitations. Matthew, you've been writing about Russell Brand and about how his politics protected him.
30:18Explain your argument. Yeah, obviously, appalling, terrible, terrible story. And I was struck by how a political perspective in a very polarized society, how being identified with one or the other side can often be something of a shield for somebody who's doing something wrong. And I was struck by the fact that in Russell Brown, in his phase, when he was a bit on the left, a lot of people on the left came out to defend him. And now that he's more associated with the right, it's very striking how many people, particularly on the MAGA right, even since the verdict, by the way, have come out to defend him. Because they're ideologically aligned with Brand, they feel that he obviously couldn't have done anything wrong.
31:00And it's quite interesting psychologically, and that's what I was trying to get across in the column. I find it sort of fascinating that anyone, either on the left or the right, wants to embrace Russell Brand and ever did. I always think his politics were remarkably consistent. He was always a conspiracy theory. He always had these views about a malign establishment keeping people down. He always said that he called for a revolution while boasting about not voting. I always thought it was just sort of simple and daft and populist nonsense. And it didn't surprise me that it moved from the left to the right. But it does surprise me that anyone took it seriously at all. Juliet, what do you think? Yeah, I guess that's just the power of celebrity, isn't it? I always found him quite
31:36grotesque, because you could sort of see what he was up to in a way from the way he projected a kind of, the sexual charisma he was trying to project was a kind of one related to power in a way that I was found quite disgusting even on the screen. But I do think that Matthew's article in this question of morality speaks to how we've really moved away from, you know, probably 100 years ago, morality was really judged by habits and behavior and, you know, the way in which you embodied the expectations of the society around you. And I guess probably because of technology and then, you know, demographic, fast demographic change probably adds onto it. Our culture has fractured so that we're left with really
32:28the other main understanding of morality, which is just, you know, what you say and what you believe and the causes you align with. And in the process, we've slightly jettisoned, probably to too high a degree, the judge of someone's character just through how they behave and not what they say they believe. Gosh, that's wise. Look, while I've got you both, I want to play you a clip. This is from the United States. This is the US Defence Secretary, Pete Hegseth, and a group he was with were reprimanded at the Tomb of the Unknown Soldier at Arlington National Cemetery on Wednesday by a soldier who was on guard duty. Listen to this. All visitors will maintain atmospheric silence and respect at all times.
33:18Just to be clear, what that is, that is a sentry in the US Army hollering at the US Defence Secretary for being disrespectful at a memorial tomb. Matthew, I think that's sort of deeply impressive on all kinds of levels. I couldn't agree more, Hugo. What courage to do what he did. What a sense of conviction of the people who had died, shed their blood for the Republic. i don't know hugo i'm struck all the time when i go to america by their martial tradition you know every sports event you go to nfl basketball i was there last week in new york watching football and basketball and um american football you know they pause before the beginning of the match and they ask somebody from the military or
34:03one of their vets to come out and they stand and they applaud with sincerity at the schools they do the same even when i was boarding the plane to come home you know pre-boarding for families with children it was like are there any vets are there any vets and i think there's something tremendously culturally powerful about that and hegseth and his crowd there that were laughing i've been to that cemetery it's a very solemn place very somber and i admire the the century who did what he did yeah I mean Julia I suppose it's always possible he didn't quite know who he was shouting at but we have to hope we have to hope that he'd have to hope that that he did it is um I I like Matthew always find it both uh
34:39sort of humbling and a bit chastening the reverence America has for their armed forces. Yeah, I think in a way it relates to what I was just saying. I think actually the military is one of the few places where you do have this culture left of strict behavioural codes. And when you find yourself in a sphere where those are suddenly enforced, it's actually quite shocking. You notice how much we go about our business in places where those norms have completely broken down. So I think there's a reason it strikes you when you encounter it, which is that it's just so noticeably absent in the rest of our lives. Yeah, I think that's absolutely right. Look, I'm afraid that's all we have time for, which means we have no time to talk about my column in the paper today
35:26about why it's going to be old people who make us want to legalise drugs. And alas, we can't talk about Matthew's column on football. Nonetheless, Matthew Syed, Juliet Samuel, thank you very much indeed. I've been Hugo Rifkin. This episode is sponsored by Google. While many people use AI, few are truly unlocking its full benefit. Google's AI Works for Britain programme has set out to help Britain's tradespeople unlock this potential and give their businesses an AI-powered productivity boost. AI tools have the potential to be a game changer for builders, plumbers, electricians, and other trades by unlocking new ways of working that can help them save time, increase productivity, and grow their business. Visit grow.google.com
36:16to learn more about AI and find the right training resources for you. Dominic O'Connell and Hannah Prevett here from The Business Podcast. Join us for a special episode with President of the British Chambers of Commerce and former Chief Economist at the Bank of England, Andy Haldane, and PwC's UK tax leader, Claire Blackburn, as we look ahead to John Healy's first budget. We'll discuss the challenge he faces trying to get the economy growing with an uncertain geopolitical backdrop and a party that's not keen on making cuts to public spending. We'll also ask what businesses are looking for, whether the government will be in a position to deliver or if more tax squeezes are on the way. Listen to The Business wherever you get your podcasts.
37:00This is the story of The One. As a shipping manager, he's running the dock stocking supplies and making sure every order goes out on time and granger helps him stay prepared from shipping supplies to ppe to hand tools he counts on granger to keep products moving and trucks rolling so his operation runs smoothly no matter the shift call 1-800-GRANGER, click granger.com, or just stop by. Granger, for the ones who get it done.