podcasts / Politics Unpacked / episode
Politics Unpacked cover art
podcast
📅 2026-11-16 ⏱ 35 min episode · ~2 min read 📝 Transcript · 8,197 words

Burnham Restarts The Brexit Wars

Politics Unpacked · · Transcript & summary by WhipScribe

Three sharp commentators argue about whether Andy Burnham can really take Britain back toward Europe and what the next election might look like.

Read the transcript Episode page ↗
In this episodeAndy BurnhamNigel FarageBoris JohnsonDavid CameronRussell BrandDavid WalliamsClactonRosebankReform UKVogueThe TimesThe Telegraph

▸Chapters

Tap a chapter to play it from that moment in the show's own player; the transcript opens there too.

Transcribe your links. Paste a YouTube, Google Drive or podcast link and WhipScribe gives you the transcript. Transcribe a link →

▸Notable quotes

“he has now got the perfect narrative for the rest of his life” Seb Payne · at 26:19 — ▶ hear it from here

▸What this episode covers

Seb Payne reads Andy Burnham as wanting the UK back in the EU and building support through a national conversation, while ministers around him disagree. Libby Purvis expects heavy resistance, a return to the gridlock of the Theresa May years, and prefers small deals on specific issues. Both question whether Labour's manifesto red lines leave room for more than side arrangements, and whether the debate should be settled by an explicit choice between staying out and going fully back in.

The second thread is legal pressure around celebrities. Libby Purvis argues that non-disclosure agreements, once a sensible way to protect company secrets, are now used to cover personal behaviour, and that lawyers should question the practice. Seb Payne links this to press investigations, recalling legal letters sent to a 17-year-old during the David Walliams reporting. The panel also rejects a staggered age of consent, doubting that the law can draw a workable line.

The shorter items cover Nigel Farage's standards investigation, which Seb Payne expects to produce a finding that could lead to a Clacton by-election, a Labour revolt over the Rosebank oil field, a rise in adult baptisms in the Church of England, and a Prosecco-and-ChatGPT story about using AI to draft political speeches.

▸Burnham Restarts The Brexit Wars on Politics Unpacked: the answers

What did Andy Burnham say about Brexit?

Andy Burnham said in May that he was not proposing that the UK rejoin the EU and that he respected the 2016 referendum result. The panel noted that he has since said Britain lost more than it gained by leaving, and that it should embrace the club of democracies on its doorstep.

“I'm not proposing that the UK considers rejoining the EU.”Andy Burnham · 2:18

What did Libby Purvis say about NDAs?

Libby Purvis said non-disclosure agreements are actually quite sensible when a company wants to keep its secrets or a payout confidential. Her objection is to their use over famous people's personal behaviour, which she called not decent or humane.

“NDAs are actually quite sensible.”Libby Purvis · 10:30

What did Seb Payne say about Rosebank?

Seb Payne said the Rosebank North Sea oil field is the big issue for Labour rebels, because the last budget included costings that assumed it would be approved. He reported that 75, maybe 100 Labour MPs were preparing a public letter expressing concern about it.

“75, maybe 100 Labour MPs are going to do one of these public letters”Seb Payne · 21:00

What did Seb Payne say about Nigel Farage?

Seb Payne said Nigel Farage is still under investigation by Parliament's standards committee and that MPs widely expect him to be found guilty of breaching the rules. He also said a longstanding friend of Farage thinks Farage now has a ready-made narrative that the establishment came to get him.

“he has now got the perfect narrative for the rest of his life”Seb Payne · 26:19

What did the Politics Unpacked panel decide about Andy Burnham's Brexit push?

The panel did not decide anything formal, but Seb Payne and Libby Purvis agreed that Andy Burnham is pushing toward a fuller return to the EU and should seek a mandate in the next Labour manifesto rather than spend years debating options. Libby Purvis expects the push to meet strong opposition and to end in a deal that does not go far.

Mentioned in this episode

Episode facts

Released
November 16, 2026
Length
35 minutes

▸Key takeaways

01Andy Burnham says he isn't proposing rejoining the EU before an election, yet he argues Britain has lost more than it gained by leaving.
02Labour's manifesto red lines rule out the single market, a customs union and free movement, so Burnham's EU plan would rely on side deals.
03Seb Payne says 75, maybe 100 Labour MPs were preparing a public letter opposing the Rosebank North Sea oil field approval.
04Nigel Farage faces a Commons standards finding, and a suspension longer than nine days could trigger a recall petition needing 10% of Clacton voters.
05Libby Purvis calls adult baptisms a genuine conviction rather than a lifestyle trend, while Seb Payne warns against converting just for Instagram.

▸Questions this episode answers

Q1What did Andy Burnham say about rejoining the EU on Politics Unpacked?

Andy Burnham said in May that he was not proposing that the UK rejoin the EU and respected the 2016 referendum result. Later he said Britain had lost more than it gained by leaving and that it should embrace the club of democracies on its doorstep. Seb Payne argues he wants the UK back in and is holding a national conversation to win people round, but that it is unclear whether his government and the Labour Party would follow him.

Q2What did Seb Payne say about Nigel Farage's standards investigation?

Seb Payne said Nigel Farage is still under investigation by the parliamentary standards committee and that widespread expectation among MPs is that he will be found guilty of breaching Parliament's rules. A suspension of more than nine days could trigger a recall petition, and if 10% of Clacton's constituents sign it, a by-election follows. Payne also said the rules were broken over a five million pound gift from a crypto tycoon.

Q3What did Seb Payne say about the Labour rebellion over Rosebank?

Seb Payne said the Rosebank North Sea oil field is the next big fight for Labour rebels. The last budget costed in its approval, and Payne reported that 75, maybe 100 Labour MPs were preparing a public letter of concern. He said the rebels feel emboldened because the Energy Secretary is widely believed to oppose the project but is being strong-armed by Downing Street and the Treasury.

Q4What did Libby Purvis say about celebrity NDAs?

Libby Purvis said non-disclosure agreements are sensible when they protect company secrets, as IBM and Microsoft used them in the digital era, or stop someone revealing a payout. She argues that using them to cover famous people's personal behaviour is not decent or humane, and that lawyers who threaten people even when they have signed nothing should look at themselves. Her point is that the law follows money.

Q5Does Libby Purvis think there should be a staggered age of consent?

No. Libby Purvis said she does not think a staggered age of consent would work, since it would require drawing arbitrary lines between ages such as 31 and 37. She thinks the age of consent should stay as it is and that the protection comes from empowering young women to speak out, plus social pressure from families, neighbours and public opinion. Seb Payne was uneasy about a one-sided law in which the adult would commit an offence and the 16-year-old would not.

Q6What did the panel say about adult baptisms in the Church of England?

The panel discussed a Times report that overall baptisms are falling while adult baptisms are rising, with 2025 possibly the highest on record. Libby Purvis said adult conversions are something to be glad of, a genuine choice made through people's intellect and observation of holy individuals, not a lifestyle trend. Seb Payne said his wife was baptised in the Church of England in her early 20s, and that people deciding for themselves is a good thing, though identity can play a part.

▸Transcript

Our own transcript of the public episode, with a timestamp about every 90 seconds. Tap a timestamp to play the episode from there in the show's own player; the link button on a paragraph copies a link that opens this page there.

0:00Cash Now, More Later from Opendoor gives you cash up front for your home, plus all the profit later. That's no chaos now, no cash left behind later. Skip the showings now, pocket extra profit later. This is so simple now, this is so awesome later. Or sell fast now and pop the champagne later. Cash Now, More Later, now available nationwide. Start your offer at opendoor.com slash ACAST. Profits calculated after fees and costs, eligibility and offer price may vary. This episode of Politics Unpacked is sponsored by Lloyd's Banking Group. Financial empowerment belongs to all of us. It means having the confidence and control to make more informed decisions about money, from building a financial buffer to managing credit or starting to invest.

0:48Those everyday decisions could add up to something bigger. Modelling commissioned by Lloyds Banking Group suggests that making digital financial tools more accessible at scale could unlock up to £100 billion for Britain's economy by 2036. Search Lloyds Banking Group Financial Empowerment to learn more. This episode is sponsored by Google. Tradespeople are the backbone of the British economy, but for many who run their own businesses, time-consuming admin takes them away from the work that really requires their skills and craft. Google's AI Works for Britain programme is helping tradespeople learn AI skills so they can save time and grow their business. Because Google believes when all sectors of the economy have the right AI tools, everyone will benefit.

1:33Visit grow.google.com to learn more about AI and find the right training resources for you. Hello, hello. I'm Hugo Rifkind. And now we're going to be unpacking the politics of the day. From Andy Burnham reigniting the Brexit wars, to whether the sweary Chief Whip can keep control of Labour MPs, to whether it's ever a good idea to sit Prosecco on the train while using chat GPT to write a speech for the Prime Minister. And my columnists today certainly don't ask AI to give them their opinions, but whether there is Prosecco involved or not, I cannot be sure. They are Libby Purvis. Hello, Libby. Hello. Cheers. And Seb Payne. Hello, Seb. Hello, Hugo. I think more of an English sparkling man on the train than Prosecco, but we did

2:18have a leader in the Times last week about how popular Prosecco is. So, you know, it's on the upper panel, even if you're not working for the prime minister we will come back to prosecco later but it is my long-held and belligerent opinion that all sparkling wines taste the same you can you can get your objections to that in place and we'll talk about it in a moment first though let's talk about brexit because andy burnham still really does want to talk about bre. Just to remind you, this is what he said in May. I'm not proposing that the UK considers rejoining the EU. I respect the decision that was made at the referendum, and it's going to undermine everything I've said about strengthening democracy if we don't respect that vote.

2:58Well, now he says he isn't proposing rejoining this side of an election, but he also says we have lost more than we gained by leaving the EU and that we must embrace the club of democracies on our doorstep that shares this country's values and so many of its interests. Meanwhile, Boris Johnson, remember him, has been writing in the Telegraph that Britain would vote again to stay out and that Burnham is making a mistake and will impale himself and his party on the issue, which inevitably brings to mind the spectre of being impaled by Boris Johnson, which is a horrific fate already suffered by so many. Seb, what is this really all about? Never mind if it's a good idea or a bad idea. What's Burnham up to? Is he rolling the pitch for

3:34something? Does he want to distract his critics? What's the game plan here? Well, I think if we start from the basis, what does Andy Burnham want? He wants the UK to rejoin the EU. He's made that pretty clear from before he was prime minister and has only kind of paid lip service the idea that he accepted the 2016 referendum results. I think that is the starting point. But what the prime minister seems to be doing is having a kind of big national conversation to try and win around other people to this idea. So on the one hand, you've got him and like Wes Streeting, the defence secretary, who are very much in favour of fully rejoining. But then you've got all these other people around Andy Burnham

4:12who are not so certain. So John Healy, the chancellor, just after the budget, he said that 2016 was the decision and it's done. You've heard from Lisa Nandy, the culture secretary. She has a similar view as well. So the problem with what Andy Burnham is doing is he's conducting this big conversation where we know where he wants to be. But we don't know. Can he take his government with him? Can he take the Labour Party with him, which will be kind of split on this issue? And then on the other side of it, you've got pro-Brexit conservatives sort of leaning into what they did in 2016, saying we don't need to kind of go back on this. But, you know, we've got this summit coming later this week. I'm very

4:50certain there is going to be a deal, you know, to take us back to those glorious years of 2016 to 2019. You know, he's setting out three tests that have to be met before he signs any deal. And I don't know about you, Hugo, but I somehow feel those tests are going to be met. Otherwise, he wouldn't be going to a summit in Brussels to sign a deal. Libby, I seem to be finding myself in a situation where my views are that, on the one hand, I absolutely agree with Andy Burnham that we've lost more than we gained and the situation should be improved. But on the other hand, I agree with his critics, though, with a view of generally, oh, God, let's not do all that again, which seems to me to be a deeply unsatisfactory position

5:25just simply for me, let alone for the country. What do you think? Yes, I've been, ever since Rod Liddell's memorial service the other day, I've been rereading various books of his, including The Great Betrayal, his book about Brexit. And it's very interesting to read that analysis of the people who voted for Brexit and how they were received by the sort of the left leftish liberati and and you know arts community and so on um i think what will happen i'm afraid my prediction is he is trying for a complete reunion and i think there will be more stiff opposition uh not necessarily very rational opposition, but there'll be a lot of it. And it just feels like going back into a hideous mess of the Theresa May period, you know,

6:13when nothing could be got past Parliament. I mean, it's sad because, I mean, I agree about the values and interests of Europe. I agree with the idea of heavy duty cooperation on defence and on trade as well. But I just think the EU authorities, the EU Parliament, you know, the European Commission have just not convinced enough people quite yet. But then what's the alternative, Libby? Is it leaving a problem unsolved while admitting that it's a problem? Because that doesn't sound like responsible politics. I think it's a lot of sort of small scale deals on small scale matters, you know, which some of the some countries seem to be seem to be managing to do some of the Scandinavian countries, I think. But it's not ideal. None of it is ideal. And if the EU had

6:56been better run in the first place, and we haven't had to leave, that would have been wonderful. Seb, Burnham seems to sort of come in from criticism from two directions. On the the one hand some people say he's kind of trying to take us back into the EU by stealth on the other hand I'm sure he would say there's nothing stealthy about it I'm saying it kind of I'm saying it quite openly he promised not to do this when he ran in Makerfield does that matter? Well he talked about the Makerfield test didn't he which was his idea about what his government doing would it be on the side of his new constituents. And given that make-a-field is a pretty still strongly pro-Brexit constituency, this does seem to break it.

7:33What I can't quite get my head around, Hugo, is the fact that he's clearly on the trajectory, as Libby said, that he does want to take us all back in with the pros and cons that's come. But Mr Burnham has also said he's not going to breach the red lines in Labour's manifesto, which said no single market and no customs union, no free movement of people. So all that rules out any kind of significantly closer relationship. Instead, all that's going to mean is that we're sort of, you know, that we can do some side deals and be a little bit closer here and there. It feels like what he might be doing is pitrolling the next Labour manifesto. And I'm not going to get into another conversation about when the

8:08election is going to be, because I think we talk about that every week. But this does feel as if he's going to do some bits now and then spend the next couple of years trying to say to people, look, we've done a bit, but we need to go further and we need a mandate for that in the next election. I'm going to advocate full rejoin or wherever it is he lands as well. But the debate we're seeing now is just going to continue on and on. And I do agree with David Cameron on this point, that is this really the best way of spending our time at the moment when we look at the problems facing the country that you can say Brexit was a good thing or bad thing? I don't think David Cameron would say it's a particularly good thing

8:43given it ended his political career. But the fact is, by spending all this time debating the different options, it doesn't feel particularly good to me. And it feels the better thing to say is, do we want to stay out? And what does that look like? Or do we go all the way back in and try and cut out all the middle options? Because all of them, I think, are pretty unsatisfactory. Well, so you're saying he should just be much more gung-ho in his desire to rejoin, if that's what he thinks? Well, I think he is pretty gung-ho. Like, I mean, he's giving the Mansion House speech where he'll put on his white tie-in theory tonight. And I think it doesn't take much to read between the lines of him saying that he does want to rejoin.

9:17But if he wants to do that, then he should get a mandate for it and put it in the next Labour manifesto and not have to spend the next couple of years debating various options, which is what he seems to be wanting to do at the same time. One more question on this before we move on. When will the next election be? Oh, again, you ask me this every single week, Hugo. I think it feels as if we passed the window for an election being this year, despite all the fevered speculation. I still think it's going to go long. I still think it's going to be may 29 of this basis because next year is going to be pretty difficult economically in terms of inflation energy costs they're not going to be very good and if you're andy burnham when you

9:54want as much time as possible to try and turn things around here as much economic growth then just sit then just sort of curtailing your time down the street earlier it's really sweet that you answered that question properly when i literally only asked it to annoy you. Libby, you've been writing about the celebrity habit of silencing people via NDAs, non-disclosure agreements, and other forms of legal threats. And you point out these are often, if not exclusively, targeted at women. Explain the point you make in your column to us, because as ever, it's a stormingly good one. Well, it's about the willingness of lawyers, which rather rather shocks me to go in for this sort of genteel pinstriped coercive control

10:30and facilitate the drawing up of quite dodgy ndas about famous people's personal lives and personal behavior um and then a willingness to terrify people with threats even if they haven't signed anything as shillings did in in one recent case um I just, I think, I think I'd want to have a good look at myself if I was in the legal profession and say, you know, how justifiable are these? Because NDAs are actually quite sensible. If you're a company and somebody's leaving, you know, you want them not to spill your secrets all over the place. That's reasonable. If you want them not to give away how much you paid them to go away, I think that's also quite reasonable. And they have a history, they have a hundred year history. You know, they came up big in the sort of,

11:12in the days of digital advances, you know, IBM and Microsoft and so on brought in the first lot of terrific NDAs because they didn't want stuff to leak. But this business of using them for personal behaviour of, you know, the idea, this extraordinary website I found, a very senior and important legal firm explaining how good it was when you were doing a prenup always to sort of fold an NDA into it, and how you should do this at the beginning of the relationship and not at the end, because they say, very, very wise lawyers, it may be more difficult to get people to sign at the end of it except damn well will won't it so i just wanted to talk about these lawyers and the fact that it doesn't seem to me a very sensible or humane or decent use of the law yeah no i

11:56understand that look it's obviously not very romantic and it's quite anti-human as well but at the same time libby if you're a super famous person starting a relationship with somebody who you don't know very well because you're just starting the relationship you do obviously want to protect yourself don't you i think it would be better simply to behave in a decent way towards that person i mean i know this is a very pretty radical thing you're a bloke you know and you may feel that actually one has a right to be a complete pig all the time. I don't think you do think that, but you could. No, I just think it is not decent. It is not humane. And publish and be damned. My favourite sentence in the whole of the English language is publish and be damned.

12:39You know, you can then pop up and say, well, actually, the woman was appalling and this is what she did. You know, do that if you must. But don't try and protect yourself with expensive lawyers because you've got more money. You can then pop up and say, well, actually, the woman was appalling and this is what she did. You know, do that if you must. But don't try and protect yourself with expensive lawyers because you've got more money than the other person. That's what's so tacky about it. The fact that money follows, the law follows money only. Yeah, I mean, speaking as a man who's been with his wife since they met almost 30 years ago, I think the horse has long since bolted for me trying to get her to sign an NDA, which is a bit of a shame. Seb, there's a whole legal industry

13:07here which tries to protect celebrities through menaces. I used to get frequent threats when I was a gossip diarist, including, in fact, from people acting for David Walliams, as I talked about last week. And I think a lot of the public don't realise quite the level of legal warfare that goes on with the press. But on the other side, on the other side of the equation, attitudes about this stuff do swing like a pendulum. Does the media have some culpability here for the growth of this, for our insatiable appetite for kiss and tails, which sometimes are exposing foul behaviour, but sometimes are just titillation? I think, look, the job of investigative journalists is becoming much, much harder because of this

13:44whole industry that exists there i mean one of the things that i found so uh shocking in for the david walliams and the reporting in the times was legal letters being sent to a 17 year old victim by one of these firms threatening her um and i mean that's a 17 year old you know and and that just feels if you work in that industry i know that there's not maybe a huge amount of scruples but you would think someone would think hang on a minute is this the right thing should we really be doing this do we really want to take this guy's money to be trying to silence a 17 year old in this kind of situation and the answer is obviously in many cases they say yes they do they're happy to take that kind of money but i do think it is very troubling and

14:24you know you you don't see as much of this in the world that I know most, which is the political world. But I think I was very taken in your column, Libby, about your point about technology and where NDA started at the kind of the start of the personal computer revolution in the kind of 70s and 80s when there was so much fraught innovation. And this was all about corporate espionage. And that, to me me seems completely reasonable but it seems to have extended so much into personal behavior there does feel like there needs to be a reset i'm a little bit uncomfortable politicians talking about this that bridget phillipson who is the minister for equality she's been out saying we need to legislate to stop all ndas that feels a bit too draconian to me, but on the other hand,

15:05I'm not quite sure how you sort of change a culture or how you have a reset. Because as you said, Libby, it would be great if men just behaved better. But again, if we could flick a switch to do that, it would solve a lot of the world's problems. We were just talking about celebrities silencing people they've had relationships with via non-disclosure agreements. Linked to that, the cases of Russell Brand and also of David Walliams have prompted a conversation about a staggered age of consent. The idea that while 16-year-olds are old enough to consent to sex with each other, it should be illegal for adults over a certain age to have sex with 16 and 17-year-olds. Libby, what do you think about this?

15:41Because, I mean, on a moral level moral level i think i expect most of us would agree that this is contemptible should it be in law as well i don't really think that a staggered age thing would work it just seems very odd you have what three years is it three years is it four years is it what is it you know should you then sort of stagger between sort of 31 and 37 um i i don't i don't think so i I think we have an age of consent, which is perfectly reasonable and probably should be the same as the marriage age, though that's been now disconnected. But I don't think it works. I think the only things which will work on this are empowering young women to know that this is not a good idea and that they have a right to speak out

16:27and for men to know that these women will have an unfettered right to speak out and could do them a lot of damage if they misbehave. And also, I think a certain amount of social pressure, you know, just ordinary pressure. But the idea of legislating a rather complicated, staggered age, I can't see it working. And I don't think we should mess around with things that we don't think are really going to work. But I mean, a man in his 40s, say, sort of grooming and then sleeping with a 16-year-old, that does sort of feel like something the law should be involved in, doesn't it, Libby? I don't know. The feel that the law should be involved in it, I think families should be involved in it. I think neighbours should be involved in it. I think opinion should be involved in it.

17:10But, you know, 40 and 16, that's quite a big gap. But, you know, I think there are things that the law shouldn't complicate, frankly. I think that's more of a problem to me, that the law would simply complicate frankly you know i think that that's that's more that's more of a problem to me that the law the law would simply complicate it and it would it would it would be very hard to draw the correct line at the correct at the correct place so what do you think i mean i do think this whole thing is obviously getting into you know i was when i was looking at this it made me think about the votes at 16 question, which in theory is still, I believe, going through Parliament at the moment, although I think

17:49there's been some soundings from the government that they might actually particularly delay this as well, because it kind of depends on what we think as a society about where is the kind of particular age of consent and the age that you participate in society? And 18 has kind of been the clear level for some times. And this vote at 16 was brought forward pretty much because I think the government could see some electoral advantage to this, which it may or may not have anymore as well. But it does sort of feel to me as if, I don't know, it feels like we've got to be careful to rushing into these things. And I think when it came to voting age, that certainly rushed into which why it's been paused.

18:28And I tend to agree with Libby as well, that going into this as well feels like it's trying to respond to one thing, which we've seen with the horrific Russell Brand and David Williams, with a sort of slightly different issue. Yeah, yeah, I think I agree with you. I'm just sort of, I don't know, I guess what bothers me more about it is the idea of a sort of a one-sided law that the 40-year-old in this circumstance would be committing an offence while the 16-year-old wouldn't be, which is obviously morally how it would have to work. I don't know, it's complicated. I'm sure this is one we'll come back to. Let's move on. Let's talk about the Chief Whip, Annalise Midgley. She's given an interview

19:02to Vogue magazine, which is quite difficult to discuss in an Ofcom compliant way, because apparently the rules for cabinet ministers speaking to Vogue are quite a lot less strict than they are when you're a presenter speaking on the radio. Nonetheless, in this interview, she shows off her collection of actual whips, which I think she inherited from previous whips. And she says people don't talk enough about kindness in politics so far so good. But then she says right right at the end, obviously all that stuff I said before about team building, that's absolutely right. But, like, I'm not going to take any S word, and I don't F word about. We'll come to the comments themselves in a moment. But Libby,

19:35why do MPs want to be profiled by Vogue? It seems a bit needy. Should they do this stuff? Well, I suppose some voters do read Vogue, don't they, if they can afford it these days. Yeah, I don't see why she shouldn't do that. I quite like a bit of a sweary minister lot of threats over them, like, you're going to lose your job if we lose the election. I think that I'm quite in favour of her, actually. I mean, not necessarily the Vogue thing, but the idea of being a bit tough as a whip is what whips are for, I think. Seb, how rebellious are Labour rebels feeling right now? Because there's a lot for them to rebel about from a variety of directions, Europe, North Sea oil and gas, military spending, Gaza, and so on. Where's her work going

20:28to be? Where's she going to have her work most cut out? So the big thing coming up is Rosebank, which is the North Sea oil field, because obviously Jackdaw, which was the gas field, was approved reluctantly by some parts of the government that went through. And the last budget did include costings that included Rosebank being approved. And this is pretty controversial among some parts of the government that went through. And the last budget did include costings that included Rosebank being approved. And this is pretty controversial among some parts of the Labour Party because it results in more CO2 emissions than Jack Dorr. And there's a lot of Labour MPs who feel unhappy about this. And we had reports in the Sunday Times

21:00over the weekend that 75, maybe 100 Labour MPs are going to do one of these public letters and try and express their concern about it. And the reason they feel emboldened is that there's this widely held view that Miata Fanbula, who is the Energy Secretary, is not in favour of this and is being strong-armed by Downing Street and the Treasury. And this is the problem with these rebellions, is when you think you've got sympathy within the cabinet, it therefore means you feel like you can do this with a wink and a nudge from behind. And that is what Annalise Midgley has to deal with. I found the interview sort of quite interesting and bracing, actually, because chief whips normally don't sort of do these things in public.

21:38The last one, I think, was Gavin Williamson, Sir Gavin Williamson, who was interviewed with his pet tarantula, Cronus, who I think has sadly passed away quite recently. But he was the last chief whip to kind of cultivate some sort of public image because normally chief whips are not seen and not heard in the public domain. But she is one of the kind of key people behind the Andy Burnham project. So it is very interesting to hear from her. And it does make me think that maybe she's got her aspirations on higher jobs than just being a backroom functionary as francis urquhart famously described that job so how do you know that this tarantula has passed away were you whatsapp friends with the tarantula uh i i wasn't whatsapp friends with the tarantula since i think uh his tentacles

22:21would struggle to get onto a keyboard and Gavin Williamson posted this on his WhatsApp, on his Instagram, Hugo, and it was then reported in the Times Diary. So I don't know why you were not reading our paper insidiously enough. That's a fair criticism, but at least I know spiders don't have tentacles. Let's move on. Seb, we're going to talk about something you've written. Something you've written for the Times now, which is, of course, good news for Jacob Rees-Mogg. Well, I actually agree with what Sebastian Payne wrote in The Times recently. He might. I don't know. You wrote last week about the potential of another by-election in Clacton. Remind us why we might have to do all that again. I know. Try not to make listeners' hearts sink so early in the week.

23:00So, lest it be forgotten through all the kind of chaos of reform and the money and the age leaving and the undercover stings and all that stuff is the fact Nigel Farage is still being investigated by the parliamentary standards. And I wrote in the Times last week that this is about to come to a head very soon. And there's a widespread expectation amongst the MPs that I've spoken to that Nigel Farage is going to be found guilty of breaching Parliament's rules. So if he is found guilty, it's obviously not preordained, but the sense is that he will. He will then get a punishment. And if you remember the joyous end of the Boris Johnson era, we'll have the Committee on Standards who have to decide how long that punishment will be

23:40in the form of a suspension. If it's nine days or less, then he is not allowed to attend the House of Commons for nine days, which in Nigel Farage's case probably doesn't make much difference anyway. But if it's more than nine days, then it can trigger what's called a recall petition. And that then means if 10% of your constituents sign that, it's a by-election. There would be 10% of Clacton constituents because of the Labour plus the Conservative vote plus whatever else there. So I think we could well be heading to another by-election. And once again, Nigel Farage will try and pitch this as this is the establishment. They're coming for me. They're trying to stop me. But I think it'll be very damaging

24:17because A, 10% of his constituents will have endorsed this. So it's not the establishment. It's the people of Clacton who want this by-election. And B, it's confirmed that he'd broken the rules on this five million pound gift from crypto tycoon christopher harbourn but also um get help in kind from george cotter or post george the convicted fraudster and what i kind of posed in the column is this farage paradox which is all these parties he's had ukip the, the Brexit party, reform, they cannot exist without him at the top, yet they cannot thrive with him at the top, because they've all gone in exactly the same direction, which is to have a huge well of support and look as if they're going to change British politics forever. And then they end up in scandal through donations or bad

25:03conduct, or you name it, and then they fall and collapse again and it does feel as if reform is just another instance of this and it's not going to go any it's not going to recover from the kind of trough that they're in at the moment but yeah if you're in clapped and i would imagine early in the new year you can imagine me going to the polls yet again libby to have one by election over your referendum looks unfortunate, but when you have two, it starts to look like carelessness. Voters would not be kind, I think. He does risk looking like a bit of a joke, doesn't he? Yes, and I mean, already the ratings are very down. What interests me is that just anecdotally and locally among people I know to be reform supporters

25:40or instinctive reform supporters, how uneasy they've been about the big money about five million um you know that that has bothered them much more than i thought people think oh the money thing doesn't cut through you know it's all the policies but actually i think the money thing does cut through the sense that you might be you know dealing with somebody a bit dodgy here so i'll be very interested to see what happens uh Seb, do you think he might just pack it in? There are some people in reform who think that that is the case, particularly if it raises a question about the money and whether any of it has to go back. You know, I spoke for the column to a longstanding friend of Mr Farage, who's robbed him for many years,

26:19and they said to me, he has now got the perfect narrative for the rest of his life that he said, I could have been prime minister. I was going to be prime minister now got the perfect narrative for the rest of his life that he said i could have been prime minister i was going to be prime minister but the establishment they came to get me and that's a great narrative he can use on fox news gb news all the rest of it whereas if he sticks around he's got fighting of the by-election and you know one would assume he'd possibly win that but what i would watch carefully is Restore Britain, which is Rupert Lowe's insurgent to the insurgent party, because Clacton is prime territory for Restore Britain. And I could see them getting 10, 15% of the vote there.

26:55Plus, if there's a repressed reform vote, you could see a world where the Tories do come through. And if he looks at all that and thinks there's never going to end, you can see him just saying, you know what? I'm not doing this anymore. I'm walking away. And then let Robert Jenrick and Zia Yusuf bicker among themselves about which one of them is best placed to take reform forwards, or in their case, probably backwards. This episode is sponsored by Google. Tradespeople are vital for building economic growth in the UK, but they face serious time pressures that often take them away from the work that requires their craft and expertise. Google's AI Works for Britain program offers training to help them discover

27:38the AI tools already in their pockets that can help them save up to eight hours a week, helping to boost productivity and grow their business. Visit grow.google.com to learn more about AI and find the right training resources for you. 500 orders a month was manageable. 5,000 is madness. Embrace intelligent order fulfillment with ShipStation, the only platform combining order management, warehouse workflows, inventory, returns, and analytics in one place. What used to take five separate tools, ShipStation does in one. Automate fulfillment and rate shopping to ship up to 15 times more with up to 90% savings. Go to ShipStation.com and use code AUDIO to try ShipStation free for 60 days. Hello, Hugo Rifkin here, currently unpacking the politics of the day with Libby Purvis and Seb Payne.

28:46Moving on, we learned from the Times today that overall numbers of baptisms are down and fewer people are baptising their babies, but more people are getting baptised as adults. According to somebody from the Church of England's data team, there's a workplace sitcom waiting to happen, it may well be the case that the number of adult baptisms in 2025 was higher than it has ever been. Libby, we've discussed this sort of thing before. We can't know exactly the motives for any adults who are getting baptised, but we've talked before about Christianity as a kind of sort of adult lifestyle trend, and you're not keen. Well, not if it's just thought of as a lifestyle trend, but I think adult conversions, as a Christian myself, I think they're something to be glad of. Sense of

29:25people looking around using their intellect and also their feeling and their observation of those who follow that religion. By their fruits shall ye know them. Some people baptised as Catholics or Anglicans now find themselves drawn towards the good works and decent people in non-conformist churches. And that's interesting to watch too. I think nothing is more likely to convert you than a visibly and manifestly holy individual who is setting an example of what religion gives to him or her. So I don't think it's a bad idea at all. I don't think it's a trend. I think it is something that's quite genuine. I mean, loath as I am to utter his name in this context, one looks at the recent conversion of, for example, Russell Brand, baptised in a river by Bear Grylls, and there has been a

30:11sort of a move towards, I don't know how to put this, but the sort of the yoga wellness side of things has gone through spirituality and often seems to have come out looking and sounding and talking and identifying quite strongly as Christianity. Come on, Hugo, you can't legislate against there being a load of idiots around in the world. I mean, there really are idiots and followers and trendsetters. But as I say, anecdotally, I have noticed rather more people moving towards the severity, good works, charity, and general moral decency of non-conformist churches. I think that's very interesting. I actually, I mean, I know a decent number of people who've found religion. I was going to say later in life,

30:50that makes it sound much later than I mean. Low church or high church? I mean, kind of both, to be honest. I mean, well, both Catholics and evangelicals. And it does seem to make them extremely happy. Seb, what do you think about this? Well, my wife actually got baptized much later in life, in her early 20s. So I've kind of got first-hand experience of this. She was brought up in a kind of agnostic background that was probably culturally Christian. But when she was attending university in London, she began attending church and found herself not only obviously a believer, but also the atmosphere around that. And yes, she got baptised, I think, when she was 21 or 22 into the Church of England.

31:34And six months ago, tomorrow, we got married in the Church of England church. And it's something that she actively embraced because of how she felt, I think, about faith and being a believer, but also that kind of sort of side of the community and of the church as well. And I think it's a good thing that you've got people actively making this choice, that I was brought up in a Catholic background where both sides of my family were Catholic. And a lot of people, I went to Catholic secondary school and Catholic primary school. And I think when people are passed on to it, some people don't make a conscious decision to decide, you know, do I feel I believe in this or am I just doing it because it's always kind of been there?

32:12So I like the idea people are deciding for themselves and feeling they actually want to engage with Christianity. Is there an element, just before we move on from this, Seb, is there an element of identity politics here, though? Is people just trying to clarify their identity? I'm not saying that's necessarily bad, but people trying to clarify their identity in their own in their own minds as society is increasingly siloed people want to be able to sort of look at themselves and think i'm one of those i think that's definitely the case and i think as well it's you know it's for some people it's about engaging with an institution as well you know be the catholic church or the Church of England.

32:46And I think, you know, when you saw quite a lot of people who moved from the Church of England to Catholicism in the 90s due to female priests being ordained, you know, that was, again, people actively wanting to engage with the Catholic Church as an institution because its beliefs aligned closely with their beliefs as well um i mean obviously i kind of as as someone who is a christian i do think you should not do it just because it looks good on your instagram or you like the look of the church you know it's what you do because you actually believe in religion and in god as well but there is clearly an identity part of it i think that's right hugo okay look now all rise all rise it's time to open the court because it is time now for judge

33:31libby where libby purvis ably assisted both by her entirely fictional and inaccurate gavel and also by seb will give her verdict on some of the key dilemmas of the day the first case before the court the middle classes apparently are in shock at the news that the posh Molden sea salt brand isn't what it seems. The company's packaging says it's selling gourmet sea salt harvested in the UK town of Molden in Essex, but apparently it has also included some rock salt dug out of the ground in Germany. Libby, does it matter if the salt is below the salt? I'm really enjoying the angst of people worrying about the shape of their salt crystals when they should be having a pinch of good old Saxon putting the money into the local food bank, frankly.

34:11I say bar humbug, but also I love the fact that the idea of a mellow taste in sea salt is important to some gourmets and also enjoyed very much the Malden claim that rock salt is actually its ancient sea salt, because once upon a time, the mountains might have been under the sea. In other words, as someone says in the Times, BP sells seafood because its oil is made of ancient fossils. No, it's a wonderful bit of nonsense. And I quite like the pretty crystals. And I quite like getting salt from special places like some salt flats in Croatia. saw. I bought that sort of salt from there. I was really excited by fleur de sel, but it tastes just the same. We got given some very posh pink Himalayan salt the other day.

34:53It hasn't half jammed up our grinder. Seb, what do you think about this? I mean, I was reading the statements from Maldon about this, and there is some fantastic PR work going on here as well, that the planning agent for Morden Salt is saying the manufacturing process has remained essentially unchanged for 130 years. So that means it has changed. And there was another statement as well. You know, they've the fact they've updated all this as well by saying, you know, the ancient salt is added for extra minerals. So I find it very very funny i mean i think we have some modern salt in the kitchen as well and it's obviously quite nice it's obviously expensive and at the end of the day people buy it because it tastes good and is on their cooking i'm

35:34not bothered exactly where it comes from but uh the fact they've had to change all their statements suggests that our reporting was very much on the money i should point out i love i love the minerals it reminds me of the old sort of 60s joke of, you know, you're short of iron, go lick a bicycle. I should point out that, as my wife very often reminds me, there are important environmental ethical concerns about precisely where your salt comes from. Unfortunately, I can't quite remember what they are. Look, finally, an advisor to Andy Burnham has been photographed on a train sipping Prosecco while using chat GPT to give advice on a speech. There's a lot to unpack here, Libby, as is our way. But should you use AI to write a speech for the Prime Minister?

36:09Should you drink Prosecco on the train? And should you take photos of other people when they're doing things on the train? What are your views on any and all of that? It's very, very, very important and very, very tense because Prosecco, as we know, is a sort of chat GPT ai version of champagne and too many people are just messing about like that and i think that between drinking prosecco and being on chat gpt at the same time does not inspire the sort of confidence one requires in a prime minister the judge says here yeah i mean said would it be better if they if this person had been i don't know drinking stout and using gemini i mean i mean in Andy Burnham's, they should have been like a bottle of Newcastle

36:49Brown Ale or something like that. I mean, the Prosecco on a train, I don't mind that at all. I think drinking on trains is one of our great national pastimes. It feels almost obligatory. In terms of using the AI to check speeches, I mean, if they were using it to write it, that is a problem. You know, I'm in the middle of writing a book at check speeches, I mean, if they were using it to write it, that is a problem. You know, I'm in the middle of writing a book at the moment and there's very strict conditions about using AI. Using it to fact check or research, I don't have a problem with that at all. But I do feel a bit sorry for this person. They're on a train. They're trying to do their business, enjoy their sad little bottle of Prosecco.

37:21And they're getting photographed by someone for just, you know, having a good time on a train let them get on with it you're ai fact checking you're fact checking your book on ai no no i'm not fact checking my book on ai i'm saying that checking it here you can't have that no no i'm fact checking i'm saying you cannot use ai at all for writing or checking anything in terms of writing a book i'm saying people do use ai for fact checking to be very clear there, Libby. Here, here. I think anyone who uses AI for writing needs to ask themselves the very pertinent question, why am I alive? Because I don't think there's necessarily an answer if that's what you're talking about. I thought we were going to talk about

37:55young people drinking port. We were. We didn't have time. We'll have to do that next week, Libby, I promise. Drinking port. It's excellent stuff. Okay, fine. We'll explain what that means next time, I promise. Libby Purvis, Seb Payne, thankby, I promise. Drinking port. It's excellent stuff. Okay, fine. Well, we will explain what that means next time, I promise. Libby Purvis, Seb Payne, thank you very much indeed. You've been listening to Politics Unpacked, unpacking the politics of the day with the brightest brains from The Times and The Sunday Times. If you enjoyed this conversation, and you must have done if you made it this far, make sure to hit the follow or subscribe button wherever you're listening right now

38:22so you never miss any episode. And while you're doing that, leave us a review on Apple Podcasts or on Spotify to help new listeners find us. Thanks for listening. This episode is sponsored by Google. While many people use AI, few are truly unlocking its full benefit. Google's AI Works for Britain program has set out to help Britain's tradespeople unlock this potential and give their businesses an AI-powered productivity boost. AI tools have the potential to be a game-changer for builders, plumbers, electricians, and other trades by unlocking new ways of working that can help them save time, increase productivity, and grow their business. Visit grow.google.com to learn more about AI and find the right training resources for you. up front for your home, plus all the profit later. That's no chaos now, no cash left behind later.

39:26Skip the showings now, pocket extra profit later. This is so simple now, this is so awesome later. Or sell fast now and pop the champagne later. Cash now, more later. Now available nationwide. Start your offer at opendoor.com slash ACAST. Profits calculated after fees and costs, eligibility and offer price may vary. 500 orders a month was manageable. 5,000 is madness. Embrace intelligent order fulfillment with ShipStation. The only platform combining order management, warehouse workflows, inventory, returns, and analytics in one place. What used to take five separate tools, ShipStation does in one. We'll see you next time.

▸More episode summaries

Politics Unpacked cover art
Politics UnpackedBurnham's Brussels 'Win-Win'2026-11-13 · 26 min
Politics Unpacked cover art
Politics UnpackedBurnham's Diplomatic Dash2026-11-12 · 32 min
Transcribe your links. Paste a YouTube, Google Drive or podcast link and WhipScribe gives you the transcript. Transcribe a link →
New Politics Unpacked transcripts by email
One email per new episode, unsubscribe in every message. Not shared with the publisher.