podcasts / Politics Unpacked / episode
Politics Unpacked cover art
podcast
📅 2026-11-13 ⏱ 26 min episode · ~2 min read 📝 Transcript · 6,772 words

Burnham's Brussels 'Win-Win'

Politics Unpacked · · Transcript & summary by WhipScribe

Two columnists argue over whether Andy Burnham's EU reset and welfare plans can work, then move on to AI, Nvidia and sticky toffee pudding.

Read the transcript Episode page ↗
In this episodeAndy BurnhamDavid CameronAlan MilburnStarmerPat McFaddenRachel ReevesJohn HealyTrumpPutinNvidiaJohn HarrisonLos Angeles Times

▸Chapters

Tap a chapter to play it from that moment in the show's own player; the transcript opens there too.

Transcribe your links. Paste a YouTube, Google Drive or podcast link and WhipScribe gives you the transcript. Transcribe a link →

▸Notable quotes

“I just think that that's completely illiterate.” Alice · at 2:23 — ▶ hear it from here

▸What this episode covers

Andy Burnham wants a win-win deal with Brussels, but the panel doubts closer EU ties can fix Britain's economy alone. Alice rejects the idea that Brexit explains weak growth, pointing to slower-growing EU countries and to borrowing, welfare spending and the pensions triple lock. Michael sees the bigger problem as politics, since the Conservatives negotiated Brexit and now face Liberal Democrats in southern seats. The reset is small, covering youth mobility, emissions trading and food standards, worth about 0.4% of GDP.

The bigger test is welfare. Burnham plans to reform benefits and tackle youth unemployment, with the Milburn review due next week, and the panel doubts Labour MPs will accept anything that looks like cuts. Alice says one in four people claiming disability benefit is too many and that the bill, set to rise by about £40 billion over five years, needs cuts up front. The panel also argues that recent employment rules make hiring young people far costlier, so public-sector jobs for under-25s would be dependency rather than a fix.

The lighter end covers AI and culture. The panel expects AI to be transformative and welcomes the push for data centres, though local opposition and weak grid connections could slow them. A scandal involving Nvidia's chief executive wiped billions off the company's value, and the panel thinks the firm will recover. They close on John Harrison becoming the oldest Booker Prize winner at 81 and on whether sticky toffee pudding is finally cracking America.

▸Burnham's Brussels 'Win-Win' on Politics Unpacked: the answers

What did Alice say about Brexit?

Alice said it was completely illiterate to blame Britain's low growth since Brexit on leaving the EU, because many other EU countries are growing far less strongly than Britain. She argued that the bigger drags are borrowing, welfare spending and entrenched spending ratchets, so a pragmatic trading relationship with Europe cannot solve Britain's problems alone.

“I just think that that's completely illiterate.”Alice · 2:23

What did Alice say about David Cameron?

Alice said David Cameron was right when he told Bloomberg that Britain's growth problems come from borrowing too much, spending too much on welfare and keeping too many entrenched spending ratchets. She pointed to the pensions triple lock as one of those ratchets.

“I think David Cameron was right when he told Bloomberg that actually Britain's growth problems are down to borrowing too much”Alice · 2:23

What did Alice say about disability benefits?

Alice said it is not right that one in four people are claiming some kind of disability benefit, and that the system encourages people to get signed off with a disability. She said the bill is set to balloon by about £40 billion over the next five years, so Andy Burnham needs to make cuts up front.

“I don't think it's grasping the fact that currently one in four people are claiming some kind of disability benefit.”Alice · 8:52

What did Michael say about Conservatives?

Michael said Andy Burnham's Brexit stance puts the Conservatives in a difficult position, because they negotiated Brexit and now have to own its results. He argued that revisiting Brexit opens a hole in British politics rather than closing the argument, and he pointed to the rise of Reform and the schism Brexit caused.

“I think it's opening a hole, not just a can of worms, like a drawer of knives.”Michael · 3:36

What did the panel conclude about Andy Burnham's Brussels reset on Politics Unpacked?

The panel described Andy Burnham's Brussels reset as modest, covering youth mobility, emissions trading and food standards, worth about 0.4% of GDP. They said it is worth pursuing but will not fix growth on its own, while the welfare reforms due with the Milburn review are the harder test and will need cuts up front.

Mentioned in this episode

Episode facts

Released
November 13, 2026
Length
26 minutes

▸Key takeaways

01Andy Burnham's Brussels reset covers just three areas, youth mobility, emissions trading and food standards, worth about 0.4% of GDP.
02The Milburn review, due Tuesday, frames welfare changes as extra upfront support that saves money later, avoiding the word cuts.
03Spending on disability benefits is set to rise by about £40 billion over five years, which the panel says shows the welfare bill is out of control.
04The panel says employing a young person costs about £5,000 a year more than before Labour took office, so public-sector jobs will not fix it.
05The panel expects Andy Burnham to pass welfare reform despite Labour backbench anger, but says he must explain his vision, not just cut.

▸Questions this episode answers

Q1What did Alice say about Andy Burnham's Brussels reset and Brexit growth?

Alice, opinions and features editor at City AM, said it was completely illiterate to blame Britain's low growth since Brexit on leaving the EU, because many other EU countries are growing more slowly. She argued that borrowing too much, spending too much on welfare and entrenched spending ratchets such as the pensions triple lock are the real problems, and that a pragmatic trading relationship with Europe will not solve them alone.

Q2What does Andy Burnham's Brussels reset include and how big is it?

The panel said Andy Burnham's Brussels reset covers three things: youth mobility, linking up emissions trading and a deal on food standards. They put its value at about 0.4% of GDP, a modest figure that many would still call significant, though far from the percentage points on growth Burnham has suggested.

Q3What is the Milburn review and why does it matter for Andy Burnham?

The Milburn review, written by Labour grandee Alan Milburn, is due to be published on Tuesday and sets out how Andy Burnham can reform welfare and tackle youth unemployment. It is a test of whether Labour MPs will back the reforms, after earlier plans drew objections because they were presented as cuts.

Q4Why do critics object to doubling under-25s in the civil service?

The Milburn review is expected to recommend doubling the proportion of under-25s working in the civil service. Alice called it welfare dependency of another kind and said it is absurd to subsidise jobs when government policy has made them expensive to create, while the panel argued that the right people belong in the right jobs rather than in a quota.

Q5What did the panel say about the UK's data centre push and AI?

The panel said the UK's push for data centres could give Britain an edge, since they have become highly politicised in the US while Britain has been more welcoming. They expect AI to be transformative, but warned that NIMBY opposition and a lack of grid connections could slow the build-out, and that communities will need payback such as lower energy bills.

Q6What did the panel say about the Nvidia chief executive scandal?

The panel discussed a scandal involving Nvidia's chief executive, which they called a very human failing, and said it wiped billions off the company's market value. They expect the company to recover and survive, but note it was largely one man's company, so the episode raised questions about how much it depends on one person.

Q7What did Michael say about Ukraine peace talks and Europe's role?

Michael said Russia has refused to open the talks to outsiders and sees Trump as its last hope for a deal on Moscow's terms, while Europe has finally persuaded the administration it must have a voice. Alice was sceptical, saying Russia's territorial claims have not changed, but argued that Europe has to be involved because the security of the continent is at stake.

Q8What did the panel say about John Harrison winning the Booker Prize at 81?

John Harrison, 81, became the oldest Booker Prize winner this week after more than 50 years as a writer, and Queen Camilla told him age is no barrier to success. The panel agreed that experience can deepen work and that some writers keep getting better with age, while others simply stop with nothing more to say.

▸Transcript

Our own transcript of the public episode, with a timestamp about every 90 seconds. Tap a timestamp to play the episode from there in the show's own player; the link button on a paragraph copies a link that opens this page there.

0:0098 of the top 100 U.S. accounting firms trust Bill to handle bill pay processes. Why? Because our tools are built on over a trillion dollars of secure payments. We're not just moving money. We're powering financial workflows for half a million customers. That's a level of expertise you just can't fake. Ready to talk with an expert? Visit bill.com slash proven to get started. And grab a $150 gift card as a thank you. Terms and conditions apply. See offer page for details. This episode of Politics Unpacked is sponsored by Lloyd's Banking Group. Financial empowerment belongs to all of us. It means having the confidence and control to make more informed decisions about money, from building a financial buffer to managing credit or starting to invest.

0:48Those everyday decisions could add up to something bigger. Modelling commissioned by Lloyds Banking Group suggests that making digital financial tools more accessible at scale could unlock up to £100 billion for Britain's economy by 2036. Search Lloyds Banking Group Financial Empowerment to learn more. Works for Britain programme is helping tradespeople learn AI skills so they can save time and grow their business. Because Google believes when all sectors of the economy have the right AI tools, everyone will benefit. Visit grow.google.com to learn more about AI and find the right training resources for you. I'm Lara Spirit and we're going to be unpacking the politics of the day from Burnham's major tests on Europe and welfare.

1:50Whether the solution to the NEETs problem is to give all the young people jobs in the public sector and how the sticky toffee pudding finally cracked America. Joining me in the studio, the Times leader writer Michael Binion. Hello. Hello, good morning. Morning, good morning. And opinions and features editor at City AM, Alice Denby. Hello. Thank you for having me. How are you? Very happy to be here. Very happy to have you both. We're going to start with Europe, not sticky toffee puddings. That joy is yet to come. Andy Burnham says Britain can strike a win-win deal with Brussels, bringing down costs and boosting growth. He's been meeting European leaders in Dublin ahead of next week's big UK-EU

2:23summit. But history suggests negotiating with the EU is rarely as straightforward as it sounds. Yeah, look, I think obviously having closer ties with our nearest neighbour and good diplomatic relationships is important. What did disturb me about what he was saying was that he said that he thinks that all of Britain's low growth since Brexit is down to leaving the EU. I just think that that's completely illiterate. I mean, many other EU countries are growing way less strongly than we are. I think David Cameron was right when he told Bloomberg that actually Britain's growth problems are down to borrowing too much, spending too much on welfare, and having too many entrenched spending ratchets in our economy, like the pensions triple lock. Sure, we can have a pragmatic trading relationship

3:03with Europe, but that is not going to solve all our problems unless we can really grip our own public finances. Michael, taking what Alice has into account that perhaps actually on the merits of what he's suggesting, it might not necessarily be the most accurate case. What do you think about the politics of this? Is it a good bet from Andy Burnham? Because I think it does put the Conservatives in a slightly difficult position. We know they're facing Liberal Democrats in the South. That is one of their absolute key battlegrounds come the next election. Many of those remain voting constituencies and they're in a position where they're saying, you know, we're gonna have to reverse even this very modest Brexit reset. And I just wonder whether you think for Andy

3:36Burnham, it seems to be slightly easier politics. Well, I think it's a brave stance. And I think it's the right stance. I agree with Alice that, you know, saying let's go straight back in right now is probably unwise and will simply cause mayhem within the party. In fact, within the entire British political establishment. But yes, it does put the Conservatives in a difficult position. After all, they were the ones who negotiated Brexit. To some extent, they've got to own it. And they've got to show that it's done great wonders for this country, which it clearly hasn't. It's had exactly the opposite effect. I think the politics of this are baffling to me. I think it's opening a hole, not just a can of worms, like a drawer of knives.

4:12I think it's bizarre to look at what's happened in subsequent Brexit elections, the rise of reform. You know, the serious schism that Brexit caused in this country. You think, oh, well, the thing we need to do is to revisit it. I think we need to move on, both within the Labour Party and in politics generally. Well, we need to move on, but we need steady progress. What we've got to do, and in fact, what Burnham is doing, which I think is sensible, is re-knitting all those smaller links that have been broken. In other words, agreements on police cooperation and agreements particularly on common standards over food, hygiene, and what he's trying to negotiate now, youth exchanges, all that, that's a very good idea. And the more of those we get, the better,

4:55so that we are almost virtually a member, but not quite. I mean, what I think the general public would welcome is the end of these dreadful border controls, having to put, you know, fingerprints and face things, all that. I mean, that people would really appreciate. And they do associate all that with Brexit because it's because of Brexit. We've got these wretched controls on tourism. Sure, but by the same token, I think if aligning with food standards means we have to not have ketchup sachets and we need to rename marmalade and, you know, those things will do affect those tiny... Well, those are minor things. But those things are tangible to people and they annoy them. Well, yes, but I mean, all that talk even before Brexit of, you know, those things are tangible to people and they annoy them.

5:26Well, yes. But I mean, all that talk even before Brexit of, you know, bananas have to be straight and various other things have to look like this. And you can't have knobbly radish. Well, I don't know, radishes. Whichever it was, it used to annoy people. I don't think that matters. I mean, much more important is that farmers can export. I mean, funnily enough, one of the big exports for British food is cheese, which is a great export, but it's so fraught with bureaucracy now, papers and things you've got to fill in. If you can get all that cleared away, that certainly will help. making that irrespective of whether or not the british people might maybe perhaps want closer relations with the eu that actually the politics of this is extremely difficult with europe and

6:09if you're looking at this reset for example this is only containing three things right youth mobility linking up emissions trading and a deal on spf so exactly that you say that many people think be beneficial for removing border checks although as alice says at some cost of perhaps sovereignty that in itself has been unbelievably complicated to negotiate they're still not there it's taken years it's very modest it's 0.4 percent uh to gdp now many people would say that's significant but when you think that andy burnham says he wants percentage points on growth you're looking at actually a much more torturous process of negotiation and i think quite a lot my my personal sense is that quite a lot of

6:44remainers would look at this and perhaps think perhaps they voted remain but they think it's of negotiation. And I think quite a lot, my personal sense is that quite a lot of Remainers would look at this and perhaps think, perhaps they voted Remain, but they think it's going to be utterly painful. And they have sympathy with what Cameron is saying, which is perhaps we should focus our energies on improving other aspects of our politics that haven't been worked out. Well, of course, it's going to be painful. I remember, you know, see, I can remember back, you know, in the early 60s, I can remember the negotiations that Harold Macmillan tried and the de Gaulle veto and all the row over that. That was very torturous. And then when Ted

7:11Heath took up the baton again, there were tremendously detailed discussions, particularly what to do about New Zealand lamb and what to do about Commonwealth preferences and all that sort of thing. Yes, it's very slow and it's very difficult. Mind you, in those days, there's goodwill on both sides. So they did get it done, even though it's very technical. Now, I think the danger is there's not necessarily goodwill from Europe because they're going to say, well, listen, guys, you know, you decided to leave. You're very capricious. How do we know you're not going to leave again? I mean, can we be sure you're genuine this time? I think the point is something being torturous doesn't necessarily mean it's not worth doing.

7:46But what it does mean is that it takes resources away from other things. And if we're talking about percentage points on growth, I think there are many other things that would be better to expend resources on fixing our public services, making things more productive, embracing the benefits of AI, which, frankly, we can only do because of Brexit. Those things, I think, would contribute more to growth than having civil servants spend decades arguing with the EU. Well, I hope we could do both. I mean, maybe. Well, there we are. There we are. We're going to have to wrap up this particular discussion. Now, next week, Burnham will face one of the biggest tests of his premiership yet with plans to reform the welfare system and to tackle youth unemployment release.

8:20The Milburn Review is due to be published on Tuesday. Will Burnham succeed where Starmer failed and get Labour MPs to back the reforms? Last time, of course, MPs objected to the ways that the government presented these plans as cuts themselves. Alice, the strategy they're taking here is obviously not to present them as cuts and to talk kind of slightly Delphically about the fact that there might be savings a little further down the line. Yes, I think he will get these through because I think he's going to frame it as actually extra support upfront in order to long term bring the welfare bill down. Fine, if that gets it through. I just don't think it really grasps the urgency of the situation.

8:52I don't think it's grasping the fact that currently one in four people are claiming some kind of disability benefit. I just think that that cannot be correct. I think that there must be some people who are abusing the system. And I think that's an insult to those people who actually genuinely do need extra money to get on with their lives. So I think he there must be some people who are abusing the system. And I think that's an insult to those people who actually genuinely do need extra money to get on with their lives. So I think he needs to tackle that. He needs to tackle the fact that the system actually incentivises people to get themselves signed off with a disability. And I think he needs to make cuts up front because this bill is set to balloon.

9:17What is it? It's going to be 40 billion more we're going to be spending on disability benefits over the next five years, something like that. So I do not think this grasps the urgency of the situation. I think if he can get some reforms through his backbench is fine. I just don't think it's good enough. Michael, I mean, they have to be careful here, Labour, don't they? Because they're in the invidious position of both pledging possibly multiple billions of pounds towards support for young people looking at the models in the Netherlands and elsewhere. It looks like it is pretty expensive to do that money that, of course, some people would say the UK government, owing to the recent budget, does not have.

9:47While, on the other hand, being told, actually, we are going to cut benefits in some form. We've already had that interview with Alan Milburn, Labour grandee with The Times earlier this week, where he revealed that, of course, some young people will be coming off those benefits, will be entitled to less. And that's going to be quite uncomfortable for a number of Labour backbenchers. So either way you look here, it's going to be pretty uncomfortable for Andy Burnham, perhaps the next week. Well, we knew this right from the start. And Burnham obviously knew that this is a big challenge, even as he came into the job. And he's been very cautious, and I think sensibly so. And I think it is a clever approach to say, well,

10:22actually, we've got to change the system. That's what we're trying to do. We've got to make it a system that helps people work rather than hinders people working. And this is the right approach. But as Alice says, and I absolutely agree, it's urgent. You've got to get on with it now. And if it's going to cost a bit more upfront, where's that money coming from? You've got to make some cuts, real cuts straight away in the benefits bill, because it's out of control. I mean, we've already talked and many people have talked about the triple lock on pensions. Well, that's going to go not completely, but that's going to be phased out. That's quite right. But the cuts got to be really deep. And Burnham's just got to show the backbenchers,

11:01sorry, you don't like it. Shut up. Otherwise, I withdraw the whip. I also think there's the other side of the youth unemployment problem, which is that government's own policies have made it far more expensive and far riskier to employ young people. It's putting up the minimum wage, it's workers' rights legislation, it's national insurance. All of that means it's cost something like £5,000 a year more to employ a young person than it did before Labour came in. They have no plans to change that. It's no good saying we're going to employ everybody in the public sector because you've made it impossible to employ a young person than it did before Labour came in. They have no plans to change that.

11:28You know, so it's no good saying we're going to employ everybody in the public sector because you've made it impossible to employ them in the private sector. Well, you're absolutely right. And also, I think this idea of helping people into work is a bit vague. I mean, what sort of help? Are you going to say, let's offer you, here's a spreadsheet of all the possible jobs you could do? It would take forever. I mean, you can't be sure that they'll get a job. And also, are there any jobs around? I mean, that's part of the problem, that for a younger generation now, the dearth of jobs is looking ever more difficult and ever more frightening. AI is a sort of threat many people see on the horizon. So where are these jobs coming from?

11:59I just think it's absurd to try and subsidise jobs when your own policies have destroyed them. It's madness. And it's difficult politically for Burnham because, of course, the welfare rebelling that we saw under Sakhir Starmer was in part a protest vote at the way that Starmer had run the party. So in that sense, we shouldn't read too much into what it says about the propensity of Labour MPs to back welfare reform. But they were extremely uncomfortable with these cuts. And Andy Burnham, when he came in, made a massive virtue of different party governance. So when when you say we'll remove the whip from all of them that's just not something that he's going to do because he came in and said basically

12:32everyone's been too heavy-handed people haven't been listened to enough in the parliamentary party we're going to be doing it differently and so I just find it really hard politically to see how they'll get it through look I think Burnham's really popular in the Labour Party and I think the Labour Party recognises that he's the best asset they've got, and that they should stick with him and stay behind him. But I think you're right that they will try their best to water certain things down. For example, trying to do this retrospectively, I think that they could probably try and block that. The people kind of currently on benefits. That's one of the more controversial elements. Yeah, I mean, I can see them making a big fuss about that saying that we support the overall

13:03package, but people currently on benefits need to stay. And then, you know, then that's just another generation written off. Of course, I mean, that was one of the centre to take the tough decisions and persuade his party and the whole country to go along with it. I mean, he's just got to do it. That's what everybody's saying. Just do it. That's not only in welfare, but almost everything. Just get the country moving. I mean, one of the big points is i guess in his favor there's two actually one is that you know he's governing a party now with a number of people at the helm of it who were very influential in that initial welfare rebellion but who are now very predisposed towards helping him try to get these uh reforms through and that as we've said

13:58before labour mps caricatured as being completely averse to cuts when actually they were very very upset with kiss armor and felt that it wasn't done properly. They've also got a big lead in the pot, not a big lead, they've got a modest lead in the pot, Labour, a modest enough lead to think that perhaps this is a good time to take difficult decisions. Yes, I'm optimistic, as I say, that he will get this through. But I think leadership is all about saying why you're doing things. You're absolutely right, he needs to just do these things. But if he wants to take his party with them, he needs to explain why he needs to explain what his vision is and i'm a bit worried that it's just a bit like well we know we need to change welfare we know we need to get the welfare

14:31bill down but we're going to do it in the most palatable possible way rather than actually do it in a labor way which is what they're so fond of saying essentially it means well my my reading of it is that essentially it means we're not going to explicitly use the language of cuts we're going to talk about support and and you will hear you hear this from pat mcfadden the work and pension secretary you hear this from alan milburn the author of this report and you hear this from uh the prime minister himself which is essentially we've let down a generation of young workers it is not a labor thing to do to allow them to language at home many of them would like a job we owe it to them to support them and it's very difficult for them in these current

15:02circumstances and that's why some people will lose out on their entitlements and i think that that's the kind of way that they will try and pitch this as opposed to under kirstama we basically need to find some money and we're going to take we're going to take this pot away here and and to that too many labour and peace that was just a total anathema it was sort of well we're just doing this arbitrarily and we're not doing it to a particular end the burnham is a much better communicator but ultimately i think a labour way means more people being dependent on the state i don't think it has you know i don't think it's in its dna to have people sort of having taking personal responsibility and standing on

15:32their own two feet and not being on benefits and i think that's what you're going to see with this milburn report saying that we want many more people young people to be employed in the public sector so well fine you're just like you're just subsidizing their job i was going to ask you about that so this is that the review will record a recommendation to double the proportion of under 25s working in the civil service. How do you feel about the NEETs running the government for us? I do not feel good about that at all. Again, I just think this is pure socialism to say, oh, okay, there aren't enough jobs out there for them. So let's just employ them by that. Let's have the state employ them. And who is subsidising that? It's the tiny dwindling proportion of taxpayers in the private sector

16:08that are actually making any money to pay for all of this. I think it's just welfare dependency of another kind. And it's also, it comes at a time when everyone's saying civil service is too big and too bloated and people are there not pulling their weight. And if you were just going to add those who by definition are inexperienced and will need a bit more time to get into it. On the other hand, there are certain areas in government, not necessarily civil service, that are desperately short of people, people who need to actually answer phone calls and give direct help to people, people who could be answering queries that are simply going unanswered. I mean, all that sort of thing. They do need more people in certain sectors,

16:46but just to bring them in and say, right, here's a pen, sit there. It's just typical. It's like, oh, we're going to have a target for 11% of employees in the department need to be under 25. I mean, it's just tractor production numbers. Oh, that's ridiculous. You can't have targets like that. You've got to have the right people in the right jobs. Of course. Many young people are extremely capable, and of course they should be employed in the civil service, but to have a target is just ridiculous. I think it definitely goes against, I think, the grain of what many people have been saying about the civil service for some time. In an interview, we should now go to John Healy with The Times. The Chancellor says AI could transform the economy.

17:18The economy grew at its fastest rate for two and a half years in the third quarter this year, celebrated, of course, by Rachel Reeves, previous Chancellor, with growth in the tech sector largely behind it. This debate about AI, it's always that it's growth, but it's only felt by a small number of people. How credible do you think that is? No, I think AI is going to be transformative. And I think it's going to produce huge amounts of growth. And I'm encouraged that John Healy is talking about the need for data centres. For example, I think this is an area where the UK could have a real advantage because data centres have been highly politicised in the US, whereas here we're actually being much more welcoming to them. And that is that compute

17:53that will be needed to realise the benefits of AI. Is that in part, do you think, because we haven't really seen very many data centres? Yes, partly. I'd love to be as optimistic as you, but I just think the NIMBY strain in the British psyche might take hold they are not going to be popular, they do hum but the main thing I wanted to talk about in AI is this amazing Jensen Wang situation, mainly because I have so many Wang puns that I really wanted to share we got a great one, tell me because we did get a great one in the comments which I'll read so it's Gotadama Wang for the AI sector, he's the Don Wang of AI he's run NVIDIA as a date her centre Damar Wang for the AI sector. He's the Don Wang of AI.

18:28He's run NVIDIA as a date-her centre. I could get... Yeah, not bad, not bad. Well, I could think of a few, but maybe not on air. He's been whining out to dry. Yes, he has, yes. We got Libido Killed the NVIDIA Czar. Love it. By Steve, so thanks very much for that. So maybe keep yours coming in on that. But yeah, presumably you've been enjoying this. Oh my God, this is a, you know, when a business story is fun, that's your catnip at City AM. But also I do think that there's something quite sort of novelistic about how it was something very, a very extremely human failing that has brought down, you know, the mastermind of the AI revolution. It was like, you know, you can have all the microchips in the world,

19:01but he cannot resist a Chinese spy. I just think. And also he's clearly an amazing guy. He went straight out from university and built this company from scratch. This company is him. And without him, can it survive? It's so central to the entire nexus of America's AI boom. So it actually could be quite threatening to America's prosperity. But at the moment, let's just enjoy the gossipy aspect of it. Look at the drop in shares. I mean, shareholders are not going to be pleased. The most expensive affair in history. I mean, at the drop in shares. I mean, shareholders are not going to be pleased. The most expensive affair in history. I mean, billions wiped off the market. I mean, extraordinary.

19:29I think it's going to recover. And I think the company will find a way of, you know, keeping itself together. But you're right. It was one man's company. And it's extraordinary that one single person can have such command and control of such an important industry. I don't think that will be the case here. And I don't think it's going to be on the same scale here. And that's why I think you're right about data centres. They're not going to be as big as the size that people in America didn't like. And the fact that they hoovered up huge amounts of, well, not hoover, but just, you know, used water and electricity on a vast scale. They're going to try and put them somewhere where there is adequate supplies of energy and water to keep them going. So I think the resistance to these things is going

20:12to be less here, but it's not going to be companies run to the same degree by one charismatic individual. John Healy is right to say that for communities to accept data centres, there need to be some payback. So I think he wants to see data centres perhaps putting back into people's energy bills or so on. And I think that's the exact right way to do them. The one risk is, as you say, the kind of NIMBY instinct in the British public, but also we just simply don't have the grid connections. We really don't have the infrastructure to actually like plug in the data centres. Even if we wanted to. So that is a problem. But, you know, I think he's saying the right sort of things here. Yeah, that is fair.

20:45And there was a lot on artificial intelligence in the budget that perhaps didn't get as wide a mention as some people would hope, in part because perhaps a lot of it is actually quite confusing. But even so, it does feel like John Healy is wanting to grasp this as an issue now. So I'm sure we'll hear lots more about it. This episode is sponsored by Google. Trades people are vital for building economic growth in the UK, but they face serious time pressures that often take them away from the work that requires their craft and expertise. Google's AI Works for Britain program offers training to help them discover the AI tools already in their pockets that can help them save up to eight hours a week,

21:30helping to boost productivity and grow their business. Visit grow.google.com to learn more about AI and find the right training resources for you. 98 of the top 100 US accounting firms trust Bill to handle bill pay processes. Why? Because our tools are built on over a trillion dollars of secure payments. We're not just moving money. We're powering financial workflows for half a million customers. That's a level of expertise you just can't fake. Ready to talk with an expert? Visit bill.com slash proven to get started and grab a $150 gift card as a thank you. Terms and conditions apply. See offer page for details. Let's talk a bit about Ukraine because Trump's envoys, President Trump's envoys have

22:23been talking to Putin in Moscow and Zelensky in Dublin and now say that European representatives could join the next round of peace talks. Michael, why has it taken so long for Europe to get a proper place in these negotiations, given the war is happening literally on its doorstep? Because the Russians have been so obstinate and they simply said no, they've not opened the door for any outsider to come in. They were reluctant even to negotiate with the Americans. But they now see Trump as the last possible hope for getting a deal on their terms, which Trump seems absolutely committed to just throwing Zelensky to the wolves and saying, you know, he's no good. He lost the chance. He he's more or less saying he started it and only he can end it by just

23:05saying, let's do the deal. But the Europeans have finally persuaded the administration, I think. They must have a voice. They do have a voice. It's good that they're all meeting together. It's good that they're pretty much entirely unified. And all of the main players in Europe, I mean, Germany, Italy, France, Britain, are at one with the smaller countries. It's interesting that Dublin is hosting this meeting. You know, Ireland is not a big country, and it's not even a member of NATO. So it wouldn't be involved in any possible security enforcement. I mean, those are guaranteeing an agreement. I think the Europeans have felt very angry at being left out. They're angry at being basically sidelined by Trump by being denounced. Now's their chance to make their

23:52voice heard. But whether the Russians will listen, I'm very sceptical at. Alice, what do you think? Do you think it's a genuine change in the government's approach here and the US's approach here in trying to involve the Europeans? Or do you think it's just asking them to agree to things that they've already decided? I just don't know. I think that the main thing is that it doesn't look like US's approach here in trying to involve the Europeans? Or do you think it's just asking them to agree to things that they've already decided? Yeah, I just don't know. I think that the main thing is that it doesn't look like Russia's approach has changed. I think Russia still maintains the same territorial claims.

24:13So I can't really see where we're going to get any movement. But absolutely, Europe has to be involved in these discussions. This is our continent. This is our security. For America, it's just a game. But for us, this is existential. And I would love to speak more about ukraine but we do have to speak about this this particular issue which is on the booker prize because m john harrison 81 became the oldest winner of the booker prize this week after more than 50 years as a writer queen camilla told him that age is no barrier to success do we think creativity improves with age? Oh, definitely. I've got two weeks in which to write my book and to qualify. After that, I could be the older one, you know, have a year on him.

24:53But yes, I think, well, what comes from age is, I hope, experience and a certain world vision or at least experience of the world doesn't necessarily work. I mean, you can simply end up with a jumbled mess of everything. And it's interesting that he is rather angry about being put into categories. He spent a lot of time denouncing the way that publishing defines people by categories because, you know, he's had so long of an experience of the world. Is it science fiction? Is it romance? Well, not romance, but, you know, whatever it is. But good for him. And I think if you can keep a grip on what you're trying to say, then age shouldn't be a barrier. And do you think, I mean, there is a case that we're just quite obsessed often

25:38with celebrating younger talent. I think it's wonderful to see Michael's generation succeeding. And I think it was lovely that this was to see the michael's generation succeeding and i think it was lovely that this was a comment from the queen because of course she's a woman who came into the top job later in life uh and is doing it and is doing it brilliantly um literary talent is a funny thing i know martin amos used to talk a lot about the death of talent um he because obviously he was you know very famous very early on he had that kind of energy and he said that you know as you get older kind of all you want really is just a martini and a medal. But I think that some of the most impressive creative people,

26:12some of the most impressive artists are those who've kind of never stopped thinking and never lost the curiosity. If you think about like Matisse doing his paper cutouts when he couldn't paint anymore because his eyes were failing, but he'd still find a way to be creative. I think that's one of the most inspiring things out there. Yes, and some writers just get better and better. I mean, W.E. Yeats, I mean, his poems in his final years were just so much better than his very early rather dreamy stuff. At least that's my opinion. But it's true that some people get better. Some simply stop. They just have nothing more to say and then there's a long silence. And before I let you guys go, we do have to talk about the sticky toffee pudding.

26:48Because I'm reading here that it's finely cracked America. And the LA Times has been giving Californians recommendations on the best places to get one. I'm quite surprised given how sweet and calorific and over the top a sticky toffee pudding is that it's only just finished America. The curious thing is Americans don't understand the word toffee. I remember when I lived there, they simply, it's something completely taffy. That's different. But I remember saying to somebody, oh, he can't act for toffee. And they said, what? What does that mean? I mean, this is English type toffee that we're talking about. I think they'll love it. And they do note that it's from Britain. They've sort of said, oh, the British are all over the place.

27:30I mean, I think it's the Los Angeles Times that had a big thing on this with all the different variants. But of course, being America, there are all kinds of absolutely crackpot ways of serving it. Some want to serve it with fish sauce. I saw this because typical Americans are just getting it wrong. They're putting dates in it. That's not right. Is that not right? So I did look this up. Nigella puts dates in hers. Well, then it's the right thing to do. I've never had a sticky toffee pudding with dates in it. But I think they should get into the full panoply of British puddings. I'd love to see an American order a spotted dick with a straight face. Again, another one that you could see cracking in America. I'd love to see an American order a spotted dick with a straight face. Again, another one

28:06that you could see cracking at Mary. I just find it surprising. Yes, possibly. Game pie, but yes. Apparently polls show that sticky toffee pudding is our favourite, our nation's favourite. Well, I can understand why. Aren't we going to get some when we've all finished here? I like an eaten mess. In all seasons, though, because I think sticky toffee pudding Much better for the winter Where's your favourite sticky toffee pudding from? Oh, Rules In Covent Garden, the oldest restaurant In Britain has the best That is an amazingly specific one Any high street recommendations For those who won't make it there? Oh god no, not that I can think of I mean your local pub probably does a great one And you can probably buy quite good ones Pre-packaged, ready made up for those who won't make it there. Oh, God, no, not that I can think of. I mean, your local pub probably does a great one.

28:47Yes, and you can probably buy quite good ones, pre-packaged, you know, ready made up. I mean, it's not the same as doing it all yourself and pouring the sauce over it and whatever. But yeah, it is becoming the favourite dessert and I can see why. I mean, it's reasonably fattening. It's certainly very indulgent and people can sort of have it and then say oh gosh i i have to now diet ice cream or clotted cream uh clotted cream with a bit of treacle tart with clotted oh that's different yes that's a different thing that's equally good the americans get that as well treacle tart yes amazing okay well we have to leave it there sadly because i feel like we could talk quite stiff to we believed for ages.

29:25But thank you so much, Alice Embry and Michael Vinyan, for joining me today, our columnists here at The Times. This episode is sponsored by Google. While many people use AI, few are truly unlocking its full benefit. Google's AI Works for Britain program has set out to help Britain's tradespeople unlock this potential and give their businesses an AI-powered productivity boost. AI tools have the potential to be a game changer for builders, plumbers, electricians, and other trades by unlocking new ways of working that can help them save time, increase productivity, and grow their business. Visit grow.google.com to learn more about AI and find the right training resources for you. With almost half a million customers and

30:19over a trillion dollars of secure payments, Bill isn't new to intelligent finance. It's the proven way to simplify bill pay and maximize cash flow. Want to learn more? Visit bill.com slash proven for a special offer. Hi, this is Robert Mays from The Athletic Football Show. In the market to buy a new car, you're not alone. Navy Federal Credit Union members have a helping hand. Technically, a helping globe. A mission assistant whose mission is guiding you through your car buying journey, offering low rates that can save you more. Your mission assistant helps you budget, estimate your payment and understand your terms so you roll into dealership ready to negotiate on your terms. Mission assist. Everything you need to buy a car all rolled into one. Navy Federal Credit Union. Our members are the mission. Navy Federal is insured by NCUA.

31:07Credit and collateral subject to approval.

▸More episode summaries

Politics Unpacked cover art
Politics UnpackedBurnham's Diplomatic Dash2026-11-12 · 32 min
Politics Unpacked cover art
Politics UnpackedBurnham Restarts The Brexit Wars2026-11-16 · 35 min
Transcribe your links. Paste a YouTube, Google Drive or podcast link and WhipScribe gives you the transcript. Transcribe a link →
New Politics Unpacked transcripts by email
One email per new episode, unsubscribe in every message. Not shared with the publisher.