Deadline: White House · · Transcript & summary by WhipScribe
It connects a possible espionage lapse at the center of the AI boom to a Senate upset in Mississippi and a taxpayer-cost story, all explained by reporters who worked the sources.
Tap a chapter to play it from that moment in the show's own player; the transcript opens there too.
“I am pretty shocked, but not surprised.” Jim Himes · at 4:30 — ▶ hear it from here
“Like all Americans, I got to read about this when it was broken in the press.” Jim Himes · at 7:15 — ▶ hear it from here
The New York Times reported that President Donald Trump was warned at least twice that Nvidia chief executive Jensen Huang was in a relationship with a woman U.S. intelligence judged to be a Chinese asset. The first warning reportedly came aboard Air Force One en route to China, delivered by Marco Rubio. Trump told reporters in the Oval Office that Huang had no idea the woman was a spy. Around the same time, Huang was lobbying for looser export controls on advanced AI chips to China, and Beijing has called the allegations a smear campaign. Connecticut Congressman Jim Himes, set to chair the House Intelligence Committee, said the FBI needed to open a counterintelligence investigation and that Congress was never told.
The conversation widened to why Washington and Silicon Valley are protecting Huang. Nvidia sits at the center of the AI boom and has no clear successor, so a collapse of confidence in him could hit its stock and its investments across the industry. Charlie Worzel argues that the same fear of China driving the AI race is pushing officials to brush past an apparent security lapse. Both guests described the episode as a sign of a broader failure of oversight that Democrats are likely to pursue in the next Congress.
Two other stories rounded out the hour. Washington Post flight records showed Secretary of State Marco Rubio flew to Gators football games to see his son, with personal trips costing taxpayers more than $1.2 million. In Mississippi, Democrat Scott Colombe pulled further ahead of Republican Senator Cindy Hyde-Smith as affidavit and mail ballots were counted, and the AP then called the race for him.
Connecticut Congressman who is set to be the next chair of the House Intelligence Committee. He joined the show to discuss the Nvidia CEO spy reporting.
Author of the newsletter Galaxy Brain, who writes about AI and technology for the show's panel.
Democratic strategist who served as battleground director for the Harris-Walz campaign.
Spokesperson for Home of the Brave and a former deputy White House press secretary during Trump's first term.
Jim Himes said he was pretty shocked, but not surprised, that President Trump was reportedly warned about Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang and still did not act. He said he was chuckling at Trump's claim that Huang did not know the woman was a spy, since telling the people you spy on that you are a spy is not part of the job.
“I am pretty shocked, but not surprised.”Jim Himes · 4:30
Jim Himes said that as a member of Congress he should have been told about the intelligence on Jensen Huang, because a breach like this must be reported to the intelligence committees. He said he learned of it only when it was reported in the press, like other Americans.
“Like all Americans, I got to read about this when it was broken in the press.”Jim Himes · 7:15
Charlie Worzel said Jensen Huang built Nvidia into the company that powers the AI boom and has no clear successor, so many people fear that if he stepped down the company's share price could fall. He compared Nvidia to a Jenga brick whose removal could bring down the whole tower.
“It is the Jenga brick that if you pull it out, the whole tower comes down, potentially.”Charlie Worzel · 13:26
Dan Cannon said Scott Colombe was in good shape to win Mississippi's Senate race against Cindy Hyde-Smith. He said Colombe's lead had grown from about 1,500 votes to well over 5,000 as affidavit and mail ballots were counted, and that the remaining ballots from Democratic strongholds would keep widening it.
“I think we're in good shape for Scott Colombe.”Dan Cannon · 31:14
Marco Rubio said he would continue to attend events important to him and his family, including his son's games, after the Washington Post found he had flown to at least 10 Gators football games since taking office. The State Department confirmed the trips but declined to say how much Rubio had reimbursed the government.
“I have and will continue to try and make it to as many events that are important to me personally”Marco Rubio · 23:11
The show reported that the New York Times said President Trump was warned at least twice that Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang was in a relationship with a woman U.S. intelligence determined was a Chinese asset. Trump denied being told, and guests said the FBI and Congress needed to find out whether a counterintelligence investigation was ever opened.
Connecticut Congressman Jim Himes said he does not know whether the FBI opened a counterintelligence investigation into the woman linked to Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang. He said that if the FBI did not launch one, it would be a shocking breach. He said it is the FBI's job, not the CIA's or the NSA's, to determine what information may have passed between Huang and the woman, and that he intends to get that answer, hopefully without subpoenaing FBI Director Kash Patel.
Donald Trump said in the Oval Office that Jensen Huang had no idea the woman was a spy. The New York Times reported Trump had been warned at least twice that Huang was in a relationship with a woman U.S. intelligence determined was a Chinese asset. According to the Times, the first warning came aboard Air Force One in May en route to China, delivered by Marco Rubio, and Trump was not particularly moved. The State Department and White House declined to comment.
Charlie Worzel argues that Jensen Huang pivoted Nvidia to AI in the 2010s and helped create the conditions for the AI boom, making the company a central piece of the global economy. Because Huang has no clear successor and makes key chip allocation decisions, Worzel says many people fear that if he were forced to step down, Nvidia's share price and its investments across the AI ecosystem could fall and trigger a crash.
Marco Rubio, serving as Secretary of State and national security adviser, delivered the intelligence about Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang and a woman believed to be a Chinese spy to President Trump aboard Air Force One in May. He later disseminated the information around the executive branch. Congressman Jim Himes asked whether Rubio got the FBI to start an investigation and whether he made the case to the president that Trump should not be spending time with Huang.
A Washington Post analysis of flight records found Secretary of State Marco Rubio has flown to at least 10 Gators football games since taking office last year. He traveled to Gainesville on government aircraft at least 23 times, including 15 trips the department characterized as solely personal, costing the government more than $1.2 million. Rubio must reimburse the equivalent of an economy fare, but neither he nor the State Department would say how much he has repaid.
The AP projected that Democrat Scott Colombe will be the next U.S. senator from Mississippi, defeating Republican incumbent Cindy Hyde-Smith. His lead grew as affidavit and mail ballots were counted, reaching 4,645 votes in one count. He is the first Democrat to hold the seat in a long time and would be the first Black U.S. senator from Mississippi since Reconstruction. Panelists credited his campaign and years of organizing by Black voters in the state.
Democratic strategist Dan Cannon said Cindy Hyde-Smith had no realistic path to victory based on the remaining ballots. He said Colombe's lead had grown from about 1,500 votes to well over 5,000 as counting continued, with Hinds County running strongly for him and even Rankin County's mail and absentee ballots favoring him. He said Colombe's campaign was urging Hyde-Smith to acknowledge the math and concede.
Our own transcript of the public episode, with a timestamp about every 90 seconds. Tap a timestamp to play the episode from there in the show's own player; the link button on a paragraph copies a link that opens this page there.
0:00Welcome to The Circle. In this game, you never meet the other players. Your goal is simple, become the most popular. But should you play as yourself or Catfish as someone else? With the new host, celebrity contestants, and this time, audience voting will influence the game. You decide who has what it takes to win. Watch the Hulu original series, The Circle, on November 17th. Streaming on Hulu and Hulu on Disney Plus for bundle subscribers. Terms apply. This holiday, all plans, even unlimited, are just $15 a month. A holiday deal this good obviously deserves an enormously expensive holiday song, like All I Want. Right. Okay, we can afford that. You know what? Forget the music budget. We're going to stick with whatever's in the public domain.
0:44Give it a try at mintmobile.com slash switch. Upfront payment of $45 for three months, $90 for six months, or $180 for a 12-month plan required. $15 per month equivalent. Taxes and fees extra. New customer offer for initial plan term only. Greater than 50 gigabytes. May slow when network is busy. See terms. When you went to China earlier this year in May, did you know about these alleged ties with the Chinese spy then? No, I didn't hear about it then. But a lot of people have heard about it. And Jensen totally denies that. I asked him today because I did speak to him today just to see if he's feeling all right, how you doing. And I asked him about that. I asked him today, because I did speak to him today, just to see if he's feeling all right, how you're doing. And I asked him about that. And he said he had absolutely no idea that the person in question was a spy. Hi again, everyone. I'm Alicia Menendez in for Nicole Wallace.
1:39That was Donald Trump in the Oval Office yesterday denying that he had been informed that one of his closest allies and largest donors who manufactures one of America's most sensitive technologies had been compromised by an alleged Chinese spy. Shocking new reporting from The New York Times finds that Trump had, in fact, been warned multiple times about the fact that NVIDIA's CEO, Jensen Huang, was engaged in a romantic relationship with a woman who U.S. intelligence has determined was a Chinese asset. From that time's reporting, quote, President Trump was told aboard Air Force One in May en route to China that the United States had obtained sensitive intelligence showing that NVIDIA's chief executive was in a relationship with a woman believed to be
2:21a Chinese spy, people with knowledge of the matter said. The message was delivered by Marco Rubio, his Secretary of State and National Security Advisor, shortly before the NVIDIA leader, Johnson Huang, joined the presidential trip to Beijing at Mr. Trump's invitation. It marked at least the second time in seven months that the president had been told of intelligence about Mr. Huang's involvement with the woman. The Times reports that, quote, Mr. Trump was not particularly moved by what he heard from his national security advisor and continued with the plan to pick up Mr. Wang for the trip to China, the people with knowledge of the event said. The State Department and the White House all declined the Times' request for comment, and China has claimed the allegations are a smear campaign.
3:03Even as Trump was being warned about Wang's relationship with the alleged Chinese asset, Huang was effectively lobbying Trump to loosen the Biden-era export controls on highly sensitive AI chips to China. As the Washington Post reports, quote, Throughout his second term, Trump has repeatedly warned that the United States cannot afford to fall behind China in the race for artificial intelligence, invoking the threat from Beijing to justify opposition to regulation of the rapidly advancing technology. Yet he has approved the sale of advanced technology to China that Hawks, in his administration, argued could help Beijing close the technological gap with the United States. And when allegations emerged that Chinese intelligence had successfully targeted Jensen Huang, one of the most influential executives in the technology
3:50industry and a man with close ties to the president, Trump appears to have taken little action. The looming questions around why Donald Trump allowed one of America's most sensitive technologies to be exported to China at the behest of a man he knew to be compromised is where we begin this hour. With Democratic Congressman Jim Himes of Connecticut, he is set to be the next chair of the House Intelligence Committee. Congressman, thank you so much for joining us. Your reaction to learning that the president of the United States was informed of this national security threat at least twice, not only took no action, but loosened chip export controls and then lied in the Oval Office about being informed of said threat.
4:30Yeah, I guess it's the answer to the question of so many things related to Donald Trump. I am pretty shocked, but not surprised. I was sort of chuckling at the way the president described his conversation with the CEO of NVIDIA. He said, well, he didn't know he was a spy. Well, of course he didn't know. It turns out a pretty critical description of your job as a spy is to not tell the people you are spying on that you are a spy, right? But to be more serious about this, I don't have a lot of insight into what the president was told or when. What I can tell you is I don't know in this moment whether in the spring, when, as I understand it, the intelligence community provided this information to Marco Rubio, the secretary of
5:11state, and Marco Rubio then disseminated that information around the executive branch. What I don't know is whether the FBI did what it is its job to do, which is to launch a counterintelligence investigation to find out exactly is Alice Wang actually a sort of operating agent of the Chinese service? Is she an unwitting agent? We don't have answers to these questions. And therefore, we don't have answers to the critical questions of what information may have made its way from the CEO to Alice Wang, how she may have influenced him, how she may have said something that then he used to influence the president. So the question in my mind right now, which shouldn't be easy to answer, is whether the FBI undertook the intensive counterintelligence investigation that would
5:54be called for in this case. Well, to that end, to the question about the role of the FBI, do you plan to subpoena FBI Director Kash Patel on his role in all of this? Well, I certainly intend to get the answer to that question. And again, I mean, the American people need to know right now what because if the FBI did not launch an investigation, that would be a shocking breach. And the question would be, well, why didn't the FBI launch an investigation? I don't want to go too far down this path because I don't have the facts. But, you know, I have not been yet told of any such investigation. And without that investigation, remember, it's FBI that has this mission. It's not the CIA or the NSA or the
6:34National Security Council or whatever. It is FBI's job to figure out exactly what Alice Wang's relationship was with the Chinese and what information may have flown back and forth or might have flown, gotten back and forth between Mr. Huang and Alice Wang. So, yes, of course, I'm going to get that answer. And hopefully it doesn't require a subpoena to the director of the FBI. And further to that point, Secretary Rubio, what questions do you have about his involvement here? He was apparently the one who briefed the president. He also then wrote that secondary intelligence memo. Was there more that he could have done when it became clear that the president was going to ignore his guidance? Yeah, well, I mean, a couple of things to say there.
7:15Question number one is, as a member of Congress, why the hell didn't you tell us? Right. This is if this is as bad as it looks, this would be a major, major intelligence brief. And under the law, a breach, I should say, under the law, the executives are required to report that to the intelligence committees of the Congress. That did not happen. Like all Americans, I got to read about this when it was broken in the press. That's question number one. Question number two is, well, Marco, you're also the national security advisor. The national security advisors is the president's primary advisor on on on questions of national security advisor. The national security advisors is the president's primary advisor on
7:45questions of national security. So did you get the FBI to start an investigation? Did you make the case to the president that maybe he shouldn't be hanging around with Jensen Huang in, you know, either before or during or after a trip to China? You know, we focus on these chips, right? But foreign intelligence services are interested in all kinds of stuff that makes us very vulnerable. If Jensen Huang had conveyed the president's schedule in China to Alice Wong and that got conveyed to the Chinese, that's a massive security liability. And again, I'm putting that in the hypothetical because we don't know exactly what the nature of that relationship was. And the not knowing is a part of the problem until Sunday. I think it was notable
8:25that NVIDIA, Mr. Wong, they denied the allegations about Mr. Wong's affair. They've only just agreed to hold an internal investigation. I was speaking yesterday with former director of the CIA, John Brennan, and he said, listen, that internal investigation is not sufficient. This is going to absolutely require congressional investigation. Do you agree? Yeah, of course I agree. I mean, why is NVIDIA doing an investigation? This has cast a massive reputational problem. This has created a massive reputational problem for the board of directors and for the company, and that's been reflected in its stock price performance. And if I were on the board of NVIDIA, I would be all over that. But what NVIDIA's board is not
9:04going to do, not have the tools or the access to do, is to determine whether there was a serious breach of our national security. That's the FBI's job. That's Congress's job. And yes, we're going to get those answers. Congresswoman, just real quick, do you feel that your Republican colleagues have expressed a commensurate level of concern given the national security risk that could be detailed here? So to now they have. And again, it always surprises me when this Congress wakes up under a Republican majority and actually does its oversight job. But yes, three Republican chairmen of the national security committees have written, along with we Democrats, have written to Mr. Huang to say you will appear before and author of the newsletter Galaxy Brain, Charlie Worzel. David, I got to say, you've
10:08been the one internally who has been ringing the alarm about this and making sure that we all understand what it is that is at stake here. I have the benefit of sitting with you on set as I was interviewing the congressman and I watched you taking a series of notes. What stood out to you? I'll just be, look, on the positive side, it's great that three Republican chairmen are part of this. This is an incredibly serious thing. And I was thrilled that he talked about the broader problem here. It's not just like chips we're talking about that. That's incredibly important. But, you know, what President Trump said to Jensen Wang in sort of casual conversation, I mean, they were at all these dinners together and all these things like that
10:42is of immense value to Chinese intelligence. President Trump's views of China, President Trump's views on tariffs towards China, President Trump's views of whether there needs to be AI regulation or not, that is of immense value to Chinese intelligence. And I'm most worried about Jensen Huang's devices. We all know what's on our phones. You know, this was a protracted affair allegedly but you know was she able to get access to his phone at some point i mean i'm sorry to be you know they were meeting in hotels and he falls asleep and i'm sure the phone is locked or encrypted but there's technologies and other things like that so that's what really concerns me about how this went on and then there has to be accountability here for Kash Patel. How did the FBI respond? Why did this go on for so long? And also to Marco Rubio.
11:32How rattled is the national security community by the lapses in what happened here? I think deeply rattled. I mean, I've talked to former FBI officials who did these exact investigations. And I was told by his name is Alan Kohler. He's the former director of counterintelligence at the FBI. He ran the division that should have investigated this. He doesn't know the facts of this case, but the moment there was any evidence that Ms. Huang, the Chinese woman, was linked to the Chinese Ministry of State Security, their CIA, the moment the FBI gets evidence of that, they launch a counterintelligence investigation. And they should give Huang a defensive briefing. They should warn Huang and other big questionnaires, why wasn't he told this woman
12:18was potentially a spy? And that responsibility falls to FBI Director Patel? It would be, yes. I was told by other former officials that, yes to FBI Director Patel? nonpolitical FBI director. You need nonpolitical investigations of these incredibly important cases because you don't want political interference. Another official told me, does the president really want it to get out that this guy who's so close to him, Jensen Huang, who's on the plane and visiting with him, you know, is sleeping with a potential Chinese spy? You have, Charlie, the administration being oddly defensive, but you also have the tech industry being defensive in their posture regarding Wong. Can you help me understand what is motivating that? believed to be and is to some degree this visionary who pivoted the company on artificial
13:26intelligence way back in the 2010s, who basically saw the power of these chips to fuel the training of neural networks. He largely has created the conditions for the AI boom to happen. And NVIDIA is one way to think about the company is that it's just sandwiched in the center of the global economy. It is the Jenga brick that if you pull it out, the whole tower comes down, potentially. And so a lot of people, I think, are very afraid. Wang is someone who doesn't really have a clear successor. He is the company. He makes a lot of these decisions about chip allocation, et cetera, et cetera. And there is a feeling that if someone like Wang is forced to step down, if this becomes a huge problem,
14:10if an internal investigation or a congressional investigation reveals some terrible details, that the price of NVIDIA can fall. And also the investments that NVIDIA has made throughout the AI ecosystem could fall and it could just trigger this crash. So I think that there is so much economically riding on NVIDIA and on Wong. And that's also a reason that President Trump loves Wong, that he has cozied up to him because he is someone who he who Trump thinks can bolster the entire economy amid a war and the tariffs. I, one, appreciate the fact that you use the Jenga reference for my very analog senior millennial brain. Thank you so much. That actually did, in fact, help me understand it. I also think you are making a point that is bigger than NVIDIA and bigger than Wong and
15:00really sort of commentary on this moment that we are living in. This is some of your own reporting. The scandal holds an irony that's especially befitting of the AI moment. Huang seemingly has cozied up to his industry's number one foe, China, the boogeyman that, by the professed logic of Silicon Valley's AI executive, is forcing many of his peers to build a product that they fear. Instead of denouncing him, Washington and Silicon Valley are motivated to circle the wagons around Huang, in part because doing so keeps the system moving and the money flowing. The build-at-all-cost rationale that dictates treating China's AI prowess as an existential threat is also driving the same people to brush past an egregious dalliance with that enemy. If nothing else,
15:42Huang is a useful example to understand what happens when the fortunes of countries and many of its most powerful citizens are all tied up in one progressively intricate technological and financial bet. You know, on Tuesday, the American people sent a message about corruption in Washington, and I think that it is very easy to read that in sort of a singular way, right, which is the corruption of this administration without widening it out to say the system itself has been corrupted. The system itself is not asking bigger questions about the pursuit of profits at all costs, about the way in which this administration has cozied up to tech oligarchs or has remade the image of this country and even gambled its national security on some future
16:26promise of prosperity? Is there actually an opportunity in this sort of unwinding of all of this, whether it is the congressional investigations we were just talking about, Charlie, with Congressman Himes, or whether it is, God forbid, some type of deep introspection on the part of these tech executives about what is actually being put at risk by putting the possibility of prosperity and profit above all else? I think the one thing that we can see about this AI boom is that it causes a lot of people to behave very irrationally, right? You see that logic that I was writing about that you just read there. You have a bunch of people basically wanting to defend a guy who's cozied up to the number one
17:12enemy that's doing this thing that's forcing them to build this technology that a lot of them are afraid of because we have to beat China, right? It doesn't make a lot of sense. People are saying the same thing about the stock market, about the economy, about our politics, that there's kind of a break in the logic. We've kind of worked ourselves into a pretzel. And a lot of that is because of either corruption or putting profits over people or prioritizing scale and growth and development and number go up over the basic tenants and things that we want as a society. I think that this is a great example of the pretzel we've worked ourselves into. You know, it's up to lawmakers. It's up to the media. It's up to a lot of people to do that investigating and to figure out what that means
17:57going forward. But it is an opportunity to look at some of these things and to see the position that we've put ourselves in as a society, as a politics. Just to put a final point on it right before I let you go, which is you have the president pointing to China as a threat in a very theoretical sense, but then when there is actually an opportunity for action, refusing to take it. He blinks. I mean, he's always blinked with China. And I just want to say this is an opportunity. Charlie's amazing, and I agree. This is an opportunity for newly elected Democrats to take a leading role about this, because one of the broad themes here is just the inability of government to sort of regulate or even understand the digital age and tech.
18:34I mean, it was a problem with sort of, you know, X and social media. This is a more serious version, but it's an opportunity. And let private industry do it. I'm not saying the government should control it, but some guardrails. What do we as a society and a government want from AI? You need great translators like Charlie Worzel who can explain it all to you in the form of 90s childhood games. David Rode, Charlie Worzel, thank you both so much for spending some time with us today. When we return, there are new questions today about the use of taxpayer dollars by another high-profile member of the Trump administration. Why Secretary of State Marco Rubio is on defense today for his use of private jets to watch the University of Florida football team play.
19:15That's next. Also ahead is becoming a rather noticeable pattern. The double standard inside the Trump White House. We're going to dig into why women are frequently made the scapegoats while their male counterparts get off scot-free. And a turning point in the ballot counting in the Alaska Senate race. And it could signal good things ahead for the Democrats. Deadline White House continues after a quick break. Stay with us. Hey, what's up, guys? It's Haley Bailey. Okay, I need to tell you about something. I just got YouTube Premium. It's got tons of awesome features like offline downloads, so I can download my favorite videos before I travel and watch them whenever I don't have Wi-Fi. Because we all know airplane Wi-Fi is the worst.
19:55I get ad-free, I get background play, and there's like a ton more in there. You should try it. If you like YouTube, you'll love YouTube Premium. Try it now for two months free at youtube.com slash premium. Trial eligibility varies. Terms apply. Cancel anytime. That's a mouthful. Welcome to the circle. In this game, you never meet the other players. Your goal is simple, become the most popular. But should you play as yourself or catfish as someone else? With the new host, celebrity contestants, and this time, audience voting will influence the game. You decide who has what it takes to win. Watch the Hulu original series, The Circle, on November 17th, streaming on Hulu and Hulu on Disney+, for bundle subscribers.
20:40Terms apply. This holiday, all plans, even unlimited, are just $15 a month. A holiday deal this good obviously deserves an enormously expensive holiday song like All I Want. Right. Okay, we can't afford that. You know what? Forget the music budget. We're going to stick with whatever's in the public domain. Give it a try at mintmobile.com slash switch. Upfront payment of $45 for three months, $90 for six months, or $180 for a 12-month plan required. $15 per month equivalent. Taxes and fees extra. New customer offer for initial plan term only greater than 50 gigabytes may slow when network is busy. See terms. There's more hope for tomorrow. More change within reach. Moments like this remind us what's at stake.
21:29We will be counted. And how it feels to be part of something bigger. We're going to rise and stand strong together. We're lucky in the United States to be able to vote. We just need change. Oh, wait, there it is. There's more of us. The crowd here is celebrating. More of us getting involved. There's immense emotion here. The vibes are strong. This is a seismic change in Washington. That's democracy in action. And now there's more that connects us. Join us. For an administration whose brand is corruption, this next story might not be the biggest or the most egregious. But today, Secretary of State Marco Rubio is facing questions about an eyebrow-raising number of personal trips he took to watch his son play football in Florida.
22:31Washington Post's analysis of flight records found that since taking office last year, Marco Rubio has flown to at least 10 Gators football games, which the department, State Department, confirmed, and traveled to Gainesville aboard government aircraft at least 23 times, including 15 trips the department characterized as solely personal, costing the government more than $1.2 million. According to the reporting, Rubio is barred from flying commercially for security reasons and is required, when traveling for personal reasons, to reimburse the government the equivalent of an economy fair ticket. But both Rubio and the State Department declined to say how much she has reimbursed the government, with Rubio saying,
23:11quote, I have and will continue to try and make it to as many events that are important to me personally and to my family as possible. I want to bring in at the table host of the Fast Politics podcast, contributor here at MSNOW, Molly Zhang Fass, and the Washington Post journalist bylined on that reporting. Rick Mace. Rick, this is your reporting. Talk us through it. Yeah, it's an interesting story, and I think it's kind of nuanced. You know, there's a handful of top government officials that are called required use passengers, and they have to fly on military aircraft. They need, you know, certain kinds of safety measures in place. They need certain kind of comms available to them at all times.
23:51So Marco Rubio doesn't actually have the option of flying commercial if he wants to see his son playing football. Now, what that means to the taxpayer is they're footing the bill. Marco Rubio reimburses the government for the equivalent of a single seat on an airplane. But the gap between that and what actually costs for these planes to leave a military base is thousands and thousands of dollars. And in fact, it adds up to $1.2 million since Rubio took the Secretary of State position last year. Can you give me a sense, Rick, of how the cost of Rubio's personal travel compares to that of his predecessors? Yeah, we spoke with several people from past administrations, and obviously we hear about transportation issues involving
24:29cabinet officials, you know, every couple years. So, you know, there's a lot of scrutiny on this kind of travel. But we heard that, you know, when Anthony Blinken was in office, he did far less travel, you know, than only a couple times a year. And, you know, it's kind of unusual to have a Secretary of State who has a son, you know, not just in college, but, you know, only a couple times a year. And, you know, it's kind of unusual to have a Secretary of State who has a son, you know, not just in college, but, you know, playing college football. And Marco Rubio has made it clear it is a priority for him to go be there for his son, support his son, and attend these games. He is making zero apologies about it.
24:58And, you know, we talked to watchdog groups, and they seem to understand. They don't expect someone to assume these positions and, you know, decide they're not going to be there for their family. They're just there's just a cost to it. And the tax payer is bearing the brunt of that. I am 100 percent all for public officials making time for their children, going to support them at their sporting games, at their theater and dance recitals. Here is what is particularly notable to me, aside from the cost, which you and I will talk about in the wake of an election where voters are very upset about the way in which their financial reality is not matching the financial reality of this administration. Back in 2023, Rubio called for a review of military jets used by Biden's
25:39transportation secretary, Pete Hegseth, and the watchdog had found that Buttigieg complied with federal rules. So to me, there is an irony there. Yeah, I actually that was what I was thinking, too. But also, you know, look, this administration has a sort of let them eat cake vibe, right? Donald Trump run up to the midterm the day before the midterm. What does he do? He does a press conference on the reflecting pool. And if the American voter had a dollar for every time Donald Trump talked about the reflecting pool, they would have a lot more dollars. And so I do think the problem for this administration is that everything looks bad at this point, right? They've sort of crossed the Rubicon. You have so many issues with the
26:26president's son-in-law, who was not elected and who has not had congressional approval, negotiating high-level peace with countries that he may or may not take money from in the form of his venture fund. I mean, these are things that are just, like, norm crushing. And so they set a tone where everything else looks suspect. Again, to the point about the irony, Rick, you included what Rubio said about Buttigieg at the time that, quote, American taxpayers deserve assurances that their tax dollars are not wasted by the government's highest officials. Your report, if Rubio had made reimbursements, it wouldn't necessarily be made public. But what do we know about those reimbursements? Yeah, we asked State Department. And while they did confirm a lot of these flights that the
27:13secretary has taken, they did not want to tell us what he's reimbursed. They have said that he will be reimbursing, you know, the government for the cost of these flights. We just don't know. And a lot of the watchdog groups say that's actually part of the problem is that we don't know. And there's not a lot of transparency behind this. And it's the same whether it's the FBI director, Kash Patel, whether it's, you know, Buttigieg, it took an IG investigation to bring out some of the numbers. But they're not voluntarily telling us how they're using the tax dollars when it comes to these flights. Right. I mean, it is the duality, right? The corruption, the people not feeling that their economic reality is matching what they're hearing from this administration. And then an administration
27:51that says it is the most transparent in American history, but actually it's very difficult to get answers from them. Yeah. And they're about to have a very big Congress filled with Democrats who know that the primary thing they can do in this 120th Congress is oversight. And so they are going to do hearings on everything. You know, there's a lot to talk about. And the idea that oversight actually works for, you know, ending tariffs and making things more affordable is real. And so you're going to see more and more of this. And this scrutiny has to go everywhere. All right. Rick Mace, thank you so much for bringing us your reporting today, Molly. I'm going to ask you to stick with us when we return.
28:34We're going to get back to our top story, the Senate race in Mississippi, now characterized as leaning to the Democrats. Scott Colombe, we've got the latest on that race next. And on this busy day of breaking news, we're also keeping an eye on a building collapse in New York City. Local news outlets report that four workers were injured in that collapse in the borough of Brooklyn. That is according to the New York Fire Department. We're going to continue to monitor that breaking news here in New York. Let's sneak in another break. We'll be right back. Hey, what's up guys? It's Haley Bailey. Okay. I need to tell you about something. I just got YouTube premium. It's got tons of awesome features like offline downloads.
29:14So I can download my favorite videos before I travel and watch them whenever I don't have wifi because we all know airplane wifi is the worst. I get ad free. I get background play and there's like a ton more in there. You should try it. If you like YouTube, you'll love YouTube Premium. Try it now for two months free at youtube.com slash premium. Trial eligibility varies, terms apply, cancel anytime. That's a mouthful. Welcome to the circle. In this game, you never meet the other players. Your goal is simple, become the most popular. But should you play as yourself or catfish as someone else? With the new host, celebrity contestants, and this time, audience voting will influence the game. You decide who has what it takes to win.
29:56Watch the Hulu original series, The Circle, on November 17th, streaming on Hulu and Hulu on Disney Plus for bundle subscribers. Terms apply. This holiday, all plans, even unlimited, are just $15 a month. A holiday deal this good obviously deserves an enormously expensive holiday song, like All I Want. Right. Okay, we can afford that. You know what? Forget the music budget. We're going to stick with whatever's in the public domain. Give it a try at mintmobile.com slash switch. Upfront payment of $45 for three months, $90 for six months, or $180 for a 12-month plan required. $15 per month equivalent. Taxes and fees extra. New customer offer for initial plan term only. Greater than 50 gigabytes may slow
30:33when network is busy. See terms. Now returning to our top story, that razor-thin Senate race in Mississippi, which we can now characterize as leaning toward the Democrat Scott Colombe. Colombe, on the verge of a historic victory, will be the first Black senator from Mississippi since Reconstruction. I want to bring in Sarah Matthews. She's a spokesperson for Home of the Brave and was a former deputy White House press secretary during Trump's first term. Also joining our conversation, Democratic strategist Dan Cannon. He served as battleground director for the Harris-Walls campaign. Molly is still with me. Dan, listen, this is the type of math I need to crack out my TI-83 calculator for, but you have been very helpful
31:14at talking through these numbers with me. Talk to me about what we already have, what is still outstanding, and the likely timeline this is all going to play out on. Yeah, great questions, Alicia. I think we're in good shape for Scott Colombe. Just a few minutes ago, I saw a memo issued from their campaign manager, which outlined the non-existent path to victory for Cindy Hyde-Smith. And that's really based upon just basic math. We've known for a few days now that Scott Colombe's lead, as expected, has been increasing as they keep counting these affidavit ballots and mail-in ballots. And he's been winning them pretty consistently, both based on the type of vote that they are and also where they're coming from.
31:57There's two counties really remaining, Hines County and Rankin County. Hines County is a Democratic stronghold. It's been 80-20 for Scott Colombe. And even Rankin County, although a more Republican county, he's been winning those ballots because of the type of votes that are coming in, often vote by mail ballots and absentee ballots. And so day by day, as they've counted these, he's gone from, you know, a 1,500 vote lead to a 2,000 vote lead to a 3,000 vote lead, now well over 5,000 vote lead. And what is left are really from these counties that we know are strongholds for Democrats and a type of ballot that will continue to increase his lead. And even if you math out everything in the utmost favor to
32:38Cindy Hyde-Smith, she cannot get there. And the campaign as of this hour, Scott Clum's campaign, is urging her to acknowledge that reality and to concede. The lead that we are able to report is 4,645 votes. Sarah Matthews, are there any Republicans in the state who legitimately believe that Cindy Hyatt Smith has a path to victory here? No, I think that this is a case of when a Republican politician gets lazy and doesn't do the work and doesn't campaign. And so I think that this is a case of when a Republican politician gets lazy and doesn't do the work and doesn't campaign. And so I think that Republicans in the state see the writing on the wall when you look across the national landscape, that this was a blue tsunami for Democrats.
33:16So even though it would have been hard to believe the idea of Mississippi flipping blue in this election, I think it's quite possible, especially when you have such a strong candidate and someone like Scott Colombe. This is someone who did the work. And I think he ran the best campaign ad of this cycle. When you look at that ad of pick another protein, I'd rather pick another senator. And for him being able to capitalize on that and make it into an ad and just be a charismatic guy, then yeah, it's kind of easy to believe, I think, for even Republicans in the state of Mississippi that a guy like him could be a lazy politician like Cindy Hyde-Smith. You know, Molly, this is undoubtedly a race where candidate quality on both sides made a big
34:00difference. But there is also years of investing on the part of Black organizers inside the state that fundamentally shifted the ground underneath the Colombs race. That's right. I mean, this is the work of the people, you know, these people, these organizers in Mississippi. And look, Zendaya Smith wasn't just a lazy candidate. She's a bad candidate, right? She's not like... Yeah, her 2020 numbers are not that strong during a presidential year. Right. I mean, this is like Roger Marshall and Kansas, right? This is just not a good candidate. And Scott Colom is a really good candidate who represents the lion's share of the people of Mississippi. And this is what real multiracial democracy looks like, is that the people of Mississippi get to elect someone who is from Mississippi, who is, you know, and I do think this happens because of like this, you know, Stacey Abrams in Georgia, you know, people in the South from the South getting voters of the South to be able to elect candidates who come from their states. And it's very exciting.
35:06You know, he's the first Black senator since Reconstruction in the state of Mississippi. He will be if he wins. He will be if he wins. And this is the future of the South, right, is to have people from the South who are, you know, of the South, who are representing the South. And it's incredibly exciting. And it is what we were hoping for is what a multiracial democracy looks like. Dan, feel free to pick up the ways in which this begins to change the map for Democrats. But also, you know, you and I watched returns on election nights. There were there are a lot of races where there was 70 percent of the vote in, 65 percent of the vote in. But the candidate who had lost their race knew, based on watching where
35:47those votes were coming in from, that they had lost. And they had advisors around them who said, listen, Governor Abbott, there's no path to victory here. It's time to pick up the phone and call Gina Hinojosa and congratulate her on a fight well run. Why are we not seeing that yet from Cindy Hyde-Smith? And I get that Republicans lost the majority by much more than they ever anticipated. And so each of these seats becomes additionally precious. There is a Democratic argument for making sure that each vote is counted and counted correctly. Do you believe, though, that she believes that there is a path to victory? And once this race is officially called, do you think it is possible that Republicans are prepared
36:32to set up for ongoing relitigation of this campaign? Great questions. I don't know Cindy Hyde-Smith and how she may react to this personally and whether she understands the math and whether she's being stubborn or recalcitrant or truly trying to get every vote counted, which would be fine. And a normal part of the process when a race is very, very close. I do think in the South in particular, there is just this history of using tactics to intimidate voters into not participating. And we talked about this, you know, the other day with the affidavit ballots where they use Experian credit data to put people on an inactive list. Would the idea being that when you show up and then you're a black voter,
37:15you think you're active, you're on the wrong list, then maybe you go home because it seems not worth it to do an affidavit ballot. And everything from Todd Blanch's saber rattling to I think the elongation of this kind of a, of a long drawn out process when it's clear who the winner is, is part of the at least the instinct, if not the strategy to to put up barriers, cast doubt on the validity of elections and ultimately keep folks at home and not participate in these elections. We knew in the 08 Obama campaign, coming out of the primaries and into that general election, that something was happening with Southern Black voters and Barack Obama. And it put North Carolina in play. He won it that year in 2008,
37:54well before it became kind of a conventional battleground state. And there were organizers in the general election for Barack Obama in Georgia and in Mississippi because of the large black vote there and the idea that if the participation was high enough, you could see, if not a win, a very, very close election. And I think Republicans know that about the South, that if they keep participation down, then they can hold onto these seats no matter what. But if folks show up, and I think the really danger part of Republicans here is it's kind of evident that in many parts of the country, from the Rio Grande Valley to the South, when folks show up, the math changes, and especially when you're so unpopular and disconnected from the American people.
38:34And I just want to very quickly shout out, speaking of Black organizers and those in the South, my business partner, Jonay Wartell, who ran the runoffs for John Ossoff and Raphael Warnock and worked for Stacey Abrams, did work in Mississippi this cycle. She is down in Jackson this week doing some of the affidavit ballots and some of the cure work. And it's folks like that that have put this place back in play and hopefully for the future. All right. No one is going anywhere. We need to fit in a short break. We're going to pull in our reporter, Nnamdi Gwanwu, who is standing by for us in Jackson, Mississippi. He has brand new reporting on the Senate race that is coming up on the other side. We continue to cover the Senate race in
39:18Mississippi. MSNOW characterizing it as leaning towards Democrat Scott Cologne. And since then, his lead over Republican incumbent Senator Cindy Hyde-Smith has grown. I want to go back to MSNL reporter Nnamdi Iguonwu in Jackson. Sarah, Dan, Molly are still with us. Nnamdi, what can you tell us at this hour? We're starting to get a steady drip of additional affidavit ballot counts in counties that are smaller than Hyde, but still important, the latest being Forest County and Copiah County, both of those increased Scott Colom's margin once those ballots were processed. So there's been a lot of focus here on Hines County just because of its size. It's one of the largest in the state. And that's why Scott Colom has been putting so
39:59much of his focus on seeing what those affidavit ballots would yield. But the reason why our characterization has shifted to lean Democratic because what we're seeing across this state is that in counties with large Democratic strongholds, Scott Colom is getting the bulk of those affidavit ballots and in counties that lean Republican, he's either cutting into Cindy Heisman's gains or still in some cases, pulling out more affidavit ballots, even in counties Republicans still are successful in. The other thing worthy of a flag here is the Secretary of State actually just put out the latest numbers from the statewide election management system. Right now, he says 19,218 affidavit ballots have been processed, with roughly 74 percent
40:36of them being accepted. But the thing that really matters here, 25 out of 82 counties have not uploaded those official results. Those numbers, the deadline for that is Friday. But you have roughly a quarter of the counties, if not more, almost a third of the quarters of the counties here uploading those official numbers. And 77 out of 82 counties have uploaded their unofficial results. So essentially what that means is we're getting updated numbers. And the more and more numbers we get here, the more Scott Colum's lead so far has grown. So the question remains, where will Cindy Hyde-Smith find the votes that can narrow the margin in this race? It's hard to see it from my perspective because, again, even in those conservative-leaning areas,
41:14Scott Colom still seems to be overperforming the typical Democratic performance in those regions. So, Dan, Nnamdi and I understand these numbers as best we can. As journalists, I want you to talk as the operative at journalists. I want you to talk as the operative at the table about how you would interpret those numbers. Nnamdi did a great job of that. I think that, again, the two distinctions are there are counties that are Democratic or Republican, you know, and the first thing you look at is where the vote's coming from. And as he said, Hines County, very Democratic. You're expecting those to be a lot of Scott Colon votes as they come in. But the point, which I'll just underscore, is in those Republican
41:49counties where Cindy Hyde-Smith would have to not just win, but really win, really increase her margin because she's behind. She's got to catch up. Even in those places, Scott Cologne is cutting further into her advantage and creating a bigger advantage for himself because of the type of ballots. They're often affidavit ballots, which may be more his voters that had challenges and had to file those affidavit ballots than with her. And so if she's not gaining ground on her turf and she's losing ground pretty massively on his turf, it's not hard to look at what's left and say there's just no path. Sarah, I wonder, as someone who spent a good part of your life in Republican politics, what you think the message is that voters in Mississippi
42:31are sending to the Republican Party? Because yes, part of this is about the economy and discontent with the economy and discontent with this administration. But part of what we are watching specifically in Mississippi is a lot of anger about the ways in which Republicans tried to mess with people's right to vote. Do you think that that message can be metabolized by today's Republican Party? Yeah, I think that voters in Mississippi clearly were sending a message and they were making their voices loud and heard and let it be known that they were angry because no state is a solid red state and Mississippi is proving that. When you have a great candidate and you're able to recruit someone who can run on a compelling
43:16message and if they have the resources, which Scott Glom didn't have many, and I think that there's a lot of Democrats within the party who realize maybe they need to be investing more resources in the South and some of these states could be in play moving forward. But I think that these voters were also sending a shot to the Republican Party saying, hey, we're not just going to stick with you just because you assume that we're always going to be there. And so they were making their anger known. And I think that when you see the Republican Party, that you would think that this would be a wake-up call for them. But when you see them appoint someone like Jim Jordan to be the minority leader in the House, or Trump appointing
43:57Stephen Miller to be his new White House chief of staff, clearly they haven't learned anything from the midterms because voters made it clear that they want to change. And this is just more of the same from Republicans when you make decisions like that. All right. Namdi Iguon, we said you would be on standby and you have, in fact, answered the call. Thank you so much for joining us once again. Dan Cannon and Molly Jean Fast, Sarah Matthews, thank you all so much for your time. We're going to take another quick break. We'll be right back. Nicole's guest on this week's episode of the Best People podcast is our friend over at the Bulwark, Tim Miller. He and Nicole talked about Donald Trump's corruption, how it impacted the midterms.
44:44I want you to take a listen to where they think he went wrong. He's rubbing it in people's faces. Yes. You know, it's different if it was like, oh, Mar-a-Lago and Bedminster are getting renovations and he's going back there every weekend to go do golfing. You know, like he could have got away with that. I got to my line that I keep using with the mega folks when I go argue with them. It it's like had he went in there and just golfed just golfed i completely agree he could have done all that he could have still done the arch even if you want you know what i mean like they're funny that he just had he just golfed and like flown there every weekend you know the late night comedians would have made
45:18fun of them we would have made fun of them uh you know he probably would have lost some altitude a little bit from his peak in 2025. But like, basically, they would have been done all right. They probably would still have the Senate right now, you know. And instead of doing that, it was just the most ostentatious corruption imaginable. And I guess that shouldn't be surprising from Trump, one of the most ostentatious and corrupt people in the history of American public life. But he really, you know, kind of let it all hang out like this time. If you want to listen to the full episode, you can go ahead and scan the QR code on your screen or you can download it wherever you get your podcasts. I'm going to
45:56speak in one more break. Be right back. We can now call the Senate race in Mississippi. The AP is projecting Scott Colombe will be the next U.S. Senator from the great state of Mississippi. He is the first Democrat to hold that seat in a very long time and the first black U.S. Senator since Reconstruction. A big night of breaking news. This holiday, all plans, even unlimited, are just $15 a month. A holiday deal this good obviously deserves an enormously expensive holiday song like All I Want. Right. Okay, we can afford that. You know what? Forget the music budget. We're going to stick with whatever's in the public domain. Give it a try at mintmobile.com slash switch. Upfront payment of $45 for three months, $90 for six months, domain. Give it a try at mintmobile.com slash switch.




