Deadline: White House · · Transcript & summary by WhipScribe
A same-day breakdown of Mississippi's historic Senate win, with the panel arguing it could change how Democrats campaign across the South.
Tap a chapter to play it from that moment in the show's own player; the transcript opens there too.
“we've got a mandate to make life more affordable for Americans.” Scott Colom · at 7:36 — ▶ hear it from here
“The war in Iran has been terrible for everybody.” Scott Colom · at 6:53 — ▶ hear it from here
Scott Colom won Mississippi's Senate race, becoming the first Democrat sent to the Senate from the state since 1882 and its first Black senator since Reconstruction. The panel reads the result as a coalition story: Black voters angry about policies aimed at their communities, voters squeezed by prices, and some Republicans uneasy with Senator Cindy Hyde-Smith's loyalty to Donald Trump. Trump had carried the state by 23 points in 2024, and the race tightened late. Colom's pitch centred on affordability and corruption, and he framed his goal as getting Congress to take back power from the executive branch.
The larger argument is about strategy. Simone Sanders Townsend and Michelle Norris say the result undercuts the idea that a handful of battleground states decide national elections, since a party that competes in roughly 40 states has to show up everywhere. They credit grassroots work: apartment-complex meetings, town halls, and a digital ad team, with former Obama political director Patrick Gaspard advising the campaign. Their warning is that Democrats must deliver on the cost of living after winning, or the voters they gained will drift away before 2027 and 2028.
The episode also covers two stories beyond the election. A rookie ICE officer, David Brouillette, was cleared through a fast-tracked vetting process, and the New York Times reports that he had expressed deep hatred of immigrants and had a history of domestic violence claims and PTSD. Separately, families of sailors aboard the USS George H.W. Bush confronted Navy leaders at a town hall over shortages, extended deployments and the lack of a clear mission in the war with Iran.
Scott Colom told Simone Sanders Townsend that he has been a big opponent of Trump's tariffs, which he says have hurt farmers and consumers in Mississippi. He said Congress needs to take back power over tariffs so that low tariffs can be set.
“They've been terrible for Mississippi.”Scott Colom · 6:53
Michelle Norris said some people at the table are older than the Voting Rights Act itself, and she recalled the tactics used in Mississippi to keep Black residents from voting, including poll taxes and violence. She said it was striking that a Black senator could win in the state where that history happened.
“Poll taxes, people were beaten.”Michelle Norris · 9:40
Al Sharpton said the Rainbow Coalition of the 1980s, which Jesse Jackson built with farmers and urban residents, got lost in the 1990s when Democrats started acting like the right wing. He argued the Mississippi result came from foot soldiers doing ground-level organizing, and that Democrats must rebuild that coalition.
“the foot soldiers, they call them in the movement, are the ones that make the movement.”Al Sharpton · 27:46
Katie Benner, a New York Times investigative correspondent, said she went to David Brouillette's house in Maine to ask him to speak with her, and a sheriff warned her she would be arrested if she returned. She said Brouillette claimed in October that he was under protective custody and that DHS was taking care of him, though she had no evidence he was still working.
“I did go to his house in Maine to try to see if he would speak with me.”Katie Benner · 35:46
Scott Colom won Mississippi's Senate seat, the first Democrat sent to the Senate from the state since 1882 and the first Black senator from Mississippi since Reconstruction. The panel argues the result shows Democrats cannot rely on a few battleground states and must deliver on affordability after winning.
Scott Colom told Simone Sanders Townsend he has opposed Trump's tariffs because they hurt Mississippi farmers and consumers, and he called the war in Iran a terrible foreign policy decision. He said Congress must take back power over tariffs and the war. His first proposed bill would end federal income tax for anyone earning under $75,000 a year, and he said the cost would be worked out later.
Michelle Norris and Simone Sanders Townsend argued that the Mississippi result shows Democrats can no longer pick a few battleground states, because a party competing in about 40 states has to show up everywhere. They said voters want candidates who address the cost of living, health care and the future of their children. They warned that Democrats must deliver after the win, or the voters who turned out will drift away by 2028.
Michelle Norris said that some people at the table are older than the Voting Rights Act itself, and she described the lengths Mississippi went to in order to keep Black residents from voting. She listed poll taxes, beatings, and people sent to Parchman prison. She said it was powerful that a Black senator could win in the state where that history happened, and that he had been robbed of a clean election-night celebration.
Katie Benner, a New York Times investigative correspondent, reported that David Brouillette, a rookie ICE officer who fatally shot a Colombian migrant in Biddeford, Maine, was offered a job on December 1st after a fast-tracked vetting process. Benner said an outside contractor ran a background check, but ICE was so backlogged that no one inside the agency evaluated the findings. Her reporting cites claims of domestic violence, job instability and PTSD.
Al Sharpton said the Mississippi win came from foot soldiers rather than high-profile figures, pointing to the apartment-complex meetings, town halls and summer brigades his National Action Network ran. He argued that organizing must continue between elections, not just in the 30 days before one. He said the Democrats must not repeat the mistake of the 1990s and must rebuild the Rainbow Coalition that Jesse Jackson built in the 1980s.
Our own transcript of the public episode, with a timestamp about every 90 seconds. Tap a timestamp to play the episode from there in the show's own player; the link button on a paragraph copies a link that opens this page there.
0:00With Amazon, you can deliver joy to everyone on your list. Like your Uncle Ricky, who made your wedding photos unforgettable because his fly was open. Get him some new underpants he'll love. And save up to 45% off top brands with Amazon Black Friday week starting November 19th. Three o'clock, kids are home. Your to-do list isn't done. New Kraft Mac and Cheese Power Mac was made for days like this. Kraft Mac and Cheese Power Mac packs the same irresistible creamy, cheesy flavor you love, now with 17 grams of protein and 6 grams of fiber. Fuels you up, keeps you going, because your day doesn't stop. Kraft Mac and Cheese Power Mac. Find it at your favorite retailer. The best thing ever keeps getting better.
0:52I want to know how you guys feel right now. Ah, great! Fantastic! I feel hopeful. I feel hopeful. I just feel really excited. It almost feels surreal. I'm just so exuberant about the pride I've seen. So many people work so hard to make this happen. Lots of words right now, but to have a black senator for Mississippi, one for everybody, that's what I want to say. It's not just because he's black, but this is a man that's for everybody. Both of my parents picked cotton, and my great-grandmother was sold here as a slave from Virginia to here, so I am so excited to be on this side of history. Watch an hour of that. Hi again, everybody. It's now five o'clock in New York. Like a big, bold exclamation point at the tail end of a campaign week already so vividly defined
1:41by shock and transformation and American renewal, the results of that Senate race in Mississippi are nothing short of superlative, perhaps the most shocking, the most transformative, the most radiant example of the way that ordinary people, voters, are driving, are the single driver of an age of American renewal. Because as of today, you could now address Scott Cologne as Senator-elect. Scott Cologne, the first Democrat sent to the United States Senate from Mississippi since the year 1882, and the first Black Senator from that state since Reconstruction. Here's what he had to say last night. But I want to have a final word to every Mississippian, the ones that voted for me, the ones that didn't vote for me, and the ones that didn't vote.
2:30My commitment to you, each and every one of you, is that first, I'm going to treat your children like I want my children to be treated. I'm going to treat your parents the way I want my parents to be treated. I'm going to treat your parents the way I want my parents to be treated. I'm going to treat your future the way I want my future to be. We did it. We did it. Ladies and gentlemen, Century Lake Scott Colon and the Colon family. God bless you. God bless you. God bless you. It is a remarkable result. One few would have dared to predict with a few notable exceptions two months ago, let alone two years ago. But such is the moment. One that has Mississippi voters feeling like this. So many of us have great dreams and hopes for our children.
3:34And for a lot of us, that means that maybe you hope sort of that your kids leave and that they find a better place to be where there isn't the hatred. I think Scott will be a leader that reverses the brain drain in Mississippi. And he makes Mississippi a place where mamas can be thrilled for their babies to come back home to. Wow. Voters in Mississippi making their own choices for their own reasons. But as we mentioned, that choice fits snugly when consider the broader shift underway across America. From the New York Times reporting, quote, Colom's victory was powered by a diverse coalition that included black voters angered by policies that targeted their communities and their voting power,
4:12while voters frustrated with high prices in the Trump administration's agenda and some Republicans dissatisfied by Senator Cindy Hyde-Smith's loyalty to the president and his policies. For much of this year, Hyde Smith had been heavily favored to defeat Cologne, a district attorney, and win a second term. Trump carried Mississippi by 23 percentage points in 2024, and Republicans have long dominated statewide elections. But the race appeared to tighten toward the end. Cologne, who barreled across the state to homecoming celebrations, city halls, and college campuses, worked to introduce himself and capitalize on frustrations with Mr. Trump and his Republican allies. Now, his victory ensures that Democrats will have at least 55 seats in the U.S. Senate
4:56at the start of the new term, with a final result in the state of Alaska still unknown today. For the purposes of our conversation, it should be enough to recognize and to raise up the voters of Mississippi and their history, making choice for Senate. That is where we begin today with my colleague, Simone Sanders Townsend in Columbus, Mississippi. She spoke with Senator-elect Coulombe earlier today. With me at the table, host of Politics Nation and founder of the National Action Network, the Reverend Al Sharpton, and senior contributing editor Michelle Norris is here. Simone, you and I talked about this race on the podcast weeks ago. You have been thinking about this and covering this and talking about
5:37this longer than anyone I know. What did you see? What did you know? And how do you feel today? Well, it feels great to Nicole to be here with you and to be here in Mississippi. I'm actually sitting in the auditorium in Columbus, Mississippi, at Columbus High School. And this is the high school that Senator-elect Scott Colombe attended. And when I spoke to him today, we actually spoke in the gym that he used to play basketball in. So a true full circle moment. What did I see? I saw the people of Mississippi doing the work here on the ground. And I saw a candidate that was right for the moment. And I talked to Senator Alec Cologne about all of that. We talked about the agenda the Democrats should have.
6:16I asked some very pointed questions about Chuck Schumer. We talked about the history and the weight of this moment. And we talked about his amazing wife, Nadia, who literally was the power behind this campaign. But, Nicole, I do have a bite for you. It is specifically a conversation Senator-elect Cologne and I were having about voting rights and about the need to pass some type of voting rights legislation, given what is happening across the South and gerrymandering and given how people had stood up. And so I asked him, I said, oh, do you think that Democrats, that is the first bill that they should put forward? And if they do so, are you the one that is going to author it? And this is actually the response that he had for me.
6:53I'm going to play it for you and we'll talk on the other side. Well, I think that the first thing we got to do is focus on affordability. We also got to focus on delivering for people that are really suffering. I mean, for example, I've been a big opponent of the tariffs. They've been terrible for Mississippi. They've hurt farmers. They've hurt consumers. The war in Iran has been terrible for everybody. And so what I say is let's take our power back. The executive branch was never meant to have all this power. We need balance and we got to get the power back on tariffs so we can get low tariffs. We got to get out of war in Iran as quickly as possible because that's been a terrible foreign policy decision and it's not going to get better. If anything in history from
7:36the Iraq war to the Afghanistan war teaches us anything, it doesn't get better. So, you know, we need to be smart about that and we need to get costs down because we've got a mandate to make life more affordable for Americans. What could you do in the United States Senate? What's a bill you can pass that could actually lower costs for people in this state and across the country? Well, the first bill I would propose, and I think we might get a chance to get some Republicans to support it, and a chance that President Trump will sign it, is no federal income tax for anybody making under $75,000 a year. And how will you pay for that? Listen, we'll figure it out. We'll find ways to pay for wars.
8:12Senator-elect Scott Colon, Nicole, relentlessly on message just as he was during his campaign. But he, I mean, literally, the affordability, the gas and the groceries, it definitely came up a lot during this interview. Well, he sounds a little bit like anyone that won, right? Like everyone that won had this relentless focus on one or both of the top issues that people said they went to the polls to vote on, which were corruption and affordability. I mean, to say they have a mandate is almost an understatement. Absolutely. The voters made that clear. Simone, let me bring Michelle in. The voters made that clear. And when watching Simone, I'm so glad that she was able to sit down with him because, you know, normally when senators come to Washington, they're asked to sort
9:02of be a little quiet the first year, you know, in their freshman year. And I hope that that's not the case with him because he clearly has so much to offer this party. And I hope they find a way to use him. The voters spoke, and I just have to say that this happened in Mississippi. Can we just take a moment and marinate in that fact that this is happening in Mississippi? You know, I am, some of us at this table are older than the Voting Rights Act itself. You know, when we talk about voting rights, we really have to talk about voter suppression and the lengths to which they went in Mississippi to make sure that people never, ever had this kind of power and the violence that was used and the extreme measures that people
9:40went through to make sure that young people could never vote, that old people could never vote. Poll taxes, people were beaten. People were sent to Parchman, you know, a place that you would expect to see in Siberia or someplace like that. And so for him to have a moment like this and that he was robbed of the opportunity in some ways to enjoy the victory on election night, because it's been clear for days that she was not going to be able to do this. But as the old folks say, when it's right, it's right on time. You know that this happens in his own moment, in his own way. And he sort of clapped into victory. And that the fact that it happens in Mississippi and that he'll go to Washington with a strong message of balancing affordability and also holding people accountable because they have to do both. It was also striking to me that we talk a lot about what happened in Mississippi during the fight for civil rights.
10:33Goodman, Cheney, and Swerner, two Jews and a black, killed for exactly this voting rights protest. You talk about Viola Louisa. And then now you see the grandchildren of them, black and white, united to elect a black U.S. senator. When I was going to Mississippi during the late summer, early fall, when the Noel, Nolan Wells case and I did the funeral and all, I started hearing from young people then about him, which is why we started putting him on our show a couple of times when people didn't think it was a contest. But there was something about him energizing young people of all races in Mississippi that they didn't see coming because they don't look at what's really in front of their eyes in terms of their own constituents.
11:26And I think and I text him a couple of times this week back and forth. He tapped into something that he really believed in. And you can feel you can't fake people's belief. People can feel if you just talk or if you believe that. And the other thing I think that he did that was very smart, he always reached out to Republicans and he honored those that were of the generation that made him possible. He went to Medgeber's house. That last closing out. And he showed that where many of the younger politicians talk about new generation, he went and exalted the people that laid the path for him, which makes the older people even want to vote for him more. A brilliant move. And, you know, Patrick Gaspard, who I respect more than most, was very critical of his campaign.
12:13He said, you're going to be surprised about him, Ralph, months ago. And I'm talking about Ambassador Patrick Gaspard, who was political director for Obama. And he was right. This was a candidate that I don't know anyone else could have done it the way he did. Can I just say something to that also that he did, is that he also went places where they didn't think that a black man could win. You know, his father was a Republican. Yes, he is a Republican. I talked to his father. You know, for Reagan. Right. And so he he campaigned across the state. And that's a strong message to Democrats, because, you know, that old saying you lose every shot you don't take. He went everywhere. He went across that state and he made the case.
12:57And he said, if people aren't going to vote for me, it's not because they don't know me. Right. It's not because they don't know who I stand for. And that showed. I mean, Simone, he also had, just as a political craft, some incredibly instinctive clapbacks to someone who was essentially a Trump puppet. I mean, she said, well, change your proteins if you can't afford your groceries. And he said, well, okay, or you could change your senator. I mean, he just never seemed to lose a political debate. Very much so. Look, I think that and to the point that Reverend Sharpton just made, it was Ambassador Patrick Gaspard, who was, again, very instrumental in this race. And Senator Colombe will be the first person to say, as he has told me on a number of occasions—he said it again last night at his victory rally—that it was Patrick that said, you really have
13:48to capitalize on those comments that she made, and gave him the idea for that ad. And then it was the young digital director guru, a young man named Ryan, from Mississippi, that created that ad, shot that ad and wrote it, and obviously is one of the political ads of the season. Yes, Senator Colom had amazing instincts, right? He was ready and ripe for the moment. And he spoke about this in our interview about that, speaking to all voters. And it took him all the way back to when he first was elected DA at 32. And that folks in a majority white district in Mississippi trusted him to be the top law enforcement officer. And that's something he never forgot. But he also talked about the bench and the organizing and the Mississippians that really made this moment possible.
14:35And I spoke to Benny Thompson, the dean of the Democrats congressional delegation here last night. And he made the point to me that Scott Colombe was the first was in the first class of the Mississippi Black Leadership Institute. And it was an institute that they started here. When Benny Thompson looked around and said, there is no bench, we got to create a bench. Scott Colombe was one of the first folks in that class. And look at him now. You know, the other thing I keep thinking of is how amazing it is that Democrats are now going to have sort of under their tent Scott Cologne. They're going to have James Tallarico. They're going to have, you know, all these red state senators. It's an incredibly powerful statement to the entire country.
15:19Senator from Kansas. Senator from Iowa. Senator from Texas. Senator from Mississippi. It's extraordinary. And Senator from Kansas. Yeah. And challenging because they all have different agendas and, you know, they will have to figure out how to make sure that everybody is heard in a big tent. But this is a moment of opportunity. And the word hope keeps coming up over and over and over again. That's a word that we just haven't heard bandied about enough in recent years. Well, for like exactly what, 12? But I think that we should give credit, if we're going to be honest, to one of the key organizers of different people coming together, different views, different backgrounds. And that is the real strategist that helped us was Donald J. Trump.
16:03He united the country. For sure, finally. we couldn't unite ourselves. With his greed, with his bigotry and self-serving. And I mean, all of the things that I grew up as a kid being told, this is what people fought for, voting rights, civil rights, women's rights, abortion rights. And then when I got my teen years, joined that all of that, he has revoked or attempted to this Supreme Court's decision. The careless decision was really wiping out what Medgar was died for. I mean, this is literally the president that was going to undo the civil rights movement, undo women's rights, and in some ways, parts of the New Deal. And I think that people that weren't talking, they didn't necessarily dislike each other, but they weren't talking,
16:57found out we better start talking because this guy has just taken out Section 2 of the Supreme Court. I mean, Section 2 of the Kalis decision took that out of the Voting Rights Act. He's done this. He's done that. He's got a warrant charge and tariff. He's telling us that don't worry about the fact gas is going up. We got to go through this to deal with some fantasy he's given. And everybody starts saying, you know what, maybe you're not that bad. I don't agree with you on two things, but I agree with you on eight. We need to come together. And I think that happened. That was part of the climate that made all the races that you're talking about happen. And then they would put people up. Who has the accusations? Who has the amount of scandals that
17:41you see with Donald Trump and go and run somebody like Paxton in Texas. So it's almost like you have no shame. Have you no shame? Yeah. Or the other way, like such a bad boyfriend that everyone got together and said, it doesn't have to be this way. This is the opportunity for, excuse me, but for Democrats. Right. Because there are people who voted for the Democrats enthusiastically. Right. Because there are people who voted for the Democrats enthusiastically. Right. And there are people who voted basically against Donald Trump. That's right. And now it's the Democrats' chance. And some didn't vote at all. And some stayed at home. Which is what he addressed. But for the people who voted against Trump, which meant they were in the Democratic category,
18:18the opportunity for the Democrats now is to show their stuff and to keep them and to show them. Because a lot of people vote out of habit, you know, to show, you know, this is now that you've walked across the street, get comfortable because we have something to offer you. That's why the Democrats have to deliver. Otherwise, we'll be sitting here two years from now saying and they kick back on them. They have to deliver all of this about who ought to lead this. Talk about what you're going to lead us toward. And out of the program will come who's best equipped and who can rally the votes to get those things through Congress. We cannot reduce this to a personality contest. It must be who can deliver what the people felt they wanted
18:58when they voted. I love that conversation on the other side of a break. That's really important. Much more to come on the history made last night in Mississippi. Scott Colon becoming the state's first black senator since Reconstruction. As Democrats pad their already very substantial Senate majority also ahead. New reporting on the alarming background of an ICE agent involved in a deadly shooting in Maine. The journalist who unearthed his history of racism and anti-immigrant hatred will join us later in the hour. And there is growing frustration again among the family members of Navy sailors whose loved ones won't be home for the holidays. Those family members now confronting Navy leaders over dwindling food
19:36and supplies, a lack of adequate health care, and a mission with no clear end in sight. Deadline White House continues after a quick break. Don't go anywhere. T's and C's apply. Ever notice how every new AI tool asks you to explain your business to it all over again? Google Workspace with Gemini skips that. You get Google's AI built right into the premium versions of Gmail, Docs, Sheets, and more. No new tools. No extra logins. Just one subscription that gives you personalized AI right inside your actual workflow. Make work less work. Try Google Workspace with Gemini at goo.gle. If you like YouTube, you'll love YouTube Premium. It's destroying athlete, creator, and YouTube maxer. YouTube Premium enhances how I use YouTube with awesome features like offline downloads
21:00so I can download my favorite training videos before I hit the gym. So no Wi-Fi doesn't turn leg day into loading day. Plus, I get ad-free videos, background play, and so much more. YouTube Premium, it's like YouTube got some extra gains. Try YouTube Premium for two months free at youtube.com slash premium. Trial eligibility varies. Terms apply. Cancel any time. We organized an apartment dwelling community. We started early. We started in January, but especially in April, March, we went to each apartment dwelling community. We had education meetings. We talked to people. We brought people from Jackson to talk to people. We brought people from the NAACP from One Voice, and we kept going. And then we started having town hall meetings, and we had meetings where we broke out into groups and said, what are you going to do between now and election day? You got 30 days,
21:48you got 28 days, you got five days, you got 24 hours. What's going to happen on election day? We ground zero at Zion Chapel High and Revels Church on election day. We're back with Simone, Reverend Al and Michelle. So, Simone, I've watched that twice. I love her. But I think that people are still processing the scale of the wins and have not begun to process what It means you have to show up. It means you have to ask her, is there a way? Is there a way? It means Texas cannot be slept. It is now, it's hard for me to say this out loud. It is a blue, I said purple twice. It was written blue in the teleprompter. I can't say blue. It is a blue state right now. Now, does it go blue in the next presidential?
22:39That is a fate that is unknown, but it could go either way if people can bend this moment, this moment in politics, this opportunity. I mean, Ohio was a battleground. You're baby. I'm old enough to remember when all the bus tours were zipping back and forth so often all over the same roads that we would pass the carry bus twice in one day on bus tours. I mean, Ohio is a battleground. Kansas is a battleground. Iowa is a battleground. Texas is a battleground. And Mississippi is a potential presidential battleground. How weird is that, Simone? It is. It's weird, but also not surprising. Frankly, Nicole, I think the strategist people need to just clip this clip and the Republicans need to play it for the strategists. The Democrats need to play it for the strategists. The DSA needs to play your clip for all their would-be strategists, because that is, in fact, the key.
23:31I feel like last week, time is a flat circle. When I was still in New York, I was one morning, Joe, and I was speaking with Joe in the break. And he said that, oh, what was happening in Mississippi reminds him of Reverend Jackson going through the South in the 1986 midterm elections and what grew out of that. And little babies like me forget, because I wasn't even born in 1986, that what happened is that there were five new senators that the South elected, that black people in the South organized, that because they showed up and came to the polls, they elected those Democratic senators. And when Robert Bork, the Supreme Court nominee, came before the Senate Judiciary Committee, he was rejected.
24:08And part of that rejection was those—some of those five senators that were elected from the South. He had a terrible civil rights record, by the way, Robert Bork. So I say that to say that this is not the first time, and it won't be the last, that people pay attention and continue to organize. We haven't talked about Louisiana yet, but for years, Louisiana had a Democratic governor. So why is the feeling that Louisiana and Mississippi and Florida are so out of reach for Democrats, yet Kansas and Alaska and Texas seemed like sure things? So I do think that the strategists and the would-be elected officials have to ask themselves and check themselves about what they think is possible. So going into 2027, next year, there are elections everywhere. There's
24:48elections right here in Mississippi. The governor, the state legislature, and America's policy is, in fact, made in state legislatures across the country. But then come 2028, well, next year, people will start organizing and going across the South and candidates. I mean, we might have somebody announced before the end of the year, Nicole. You have to rethink the strategy and you have to. I know. Right. You got to rethink the strategy. And I think that there are multiple paths, frankly, to a nomination and to the presidency now, just as I thought there were multiple paths, frankly, to a Senate majority for Democrats this cycle. I totally agree. And I think the gift that the voters gave the country is to put out of business all those strategies. It's craven and dark and
25:30twisted to have the whole thing determined by six states. I mean, I think, Michelle, the most healthy thing, it is impossible to carve up the country into travelable, ad-buyable, direct mailable pockets when you're competing in 40 states, which is what now appears to be viable. I mean, in Florida, where no national money was sent or spent, those races were determined by two, three, four points. That is absolutely a battleground. In Ohio, the Democrats won. In Mississippi, they won. In Louisiana, it's winnable. In Ohio, Democrats won again. In Kansas, in Iowa, in, I mean, it's so, it might be the healthiest plot twist in our politics in modern history that every state is potentially winnable.
26:14And decency won and democracy won. I mean, last week we were talking about, yes, that we were talking about an ailing democracy. Well, democracy got up off the gurney. Correct. You know, I'm here, I'm back, and I'm strong. I love that clip from that woman who spelled out how she organized. And Simone is right. People do need to study that and understand if you go to the gym, you know, sometimes there's a poster and it says, summer bodies are earned in the winter. I always see that and keep walking to the snack bar. So I've heard that that poster exists. But the point is that you keep going, that there's no off season in terms of organization. That I bet that that woman who talked about 30 days,
27:0014 days, 24 hours, she is a no waste. We got to find her. Simone, we got to find her and have her on. You know, she's going to be at the senior center. We're going to be at the next apartment complex. And that's the way you win, is you don't just like plug the system in 30 days before an election. You keep it going. And it doesn't come from Washington. It comes from the ground. It comes from people's neighbors and friends. It comes bottom up. You know, Simone mentioned Reverend Jackson, who, you know, was a mentor to me. And this is what the Rainbow Coalition was in the 80s. We got lost. That's why I'm saying the Democrats cannot allow that to happen, because somewhere in the 90s and all, they started acting like the right wing and started, you know, things
27:46like the Omnibus Crime Bill and all that. But Jesse had farmers and people in the urban areas coming together. I was there. I was a younger man. So this can happen. But we've got to believe in it. And people that believe in it will work. When I toured around with National Action Network this summer, forming summer brigades after the march, people were there night and day. And it is those, the foot soldiers, they call them in the movement, are the ones that make the movement. They're not those of us that are high profile. They say, we need y'all to be the neon signs. We need that. But it doesn't end there because you're not lighting up anything if you don't have those troops on the ground that believe like that woman.
28:30That's who elected Scott Collin. That's who saved the country from from the threat of democracy ending. I mean, when Trump won a second time, the law firms fell over each other to capitulate one faster than the other. The universities bended under threat of cuts to their funding. Celebrities absent, a small handful who we've lifted up and celebrated here were AWOL, wouldn't even post on social media or say a word about politics. Athletes were afraid. Business leaders were all in league with the White House. I mean, I just hope that this people-powered result stays there. And I wonder how you think we make sure that's the case. I think it's going to be an interesting season of atonement. I think a number of people who
29:09silenced their voices, who capitulated to Donald Trump, who changed their policies, who got rid of diversity programs. I mean, this is one of the things that this election showed. Diversity has always been our strength, always been our strength. And one of the reasons that they tried to divide us was because they wanted us to forget that. And in the South, in particular, one of the reasons that they wanted to keep, they never wanted kids to compete against each other or to play with each other because they were afraid if they saw each other, they would see something that they liked and that they would develop collective power. And that's what we see now. And agency. And you've got to show them
29:40that Willie Barrow was one of the leaders in a movement that helped train us, said self-interest is the key to organizing. You've got to serve people's interests. Yeah. Simone Sanders Townsend, we'll be watching your interview tonight. Cannot wait to see the whole thing on the weeknight. Come back when you're back in town to the table. Rep, thank you for starting us off today. Michelle sticks around for the rest of the hour. When we come back, the disturbing story we told you about of a rookie ICE agent who shot and killed a Colombian immigrant last summer in Maine. New reporting on Earth that ICE agent's troubling history of anti-immigrant hatred. The journalist who broke the story will join us after a very short break. and more. No new tools, no extra logins, just one subscription that gives you personalized AI
30:46right inside your actual workflow. Make work less work. Try Google Workspace with Gemini at goo.gle slash workspace with Gemini. If you like YouTube, you'll love YouTube Premium. Hi, I'm Sean Evans from Hot Ones, and I want to tell you about YouTube Premium. It has offline downloads, so you can watch without Wi-Fi. Background play, so you can lock your phone, and it still plays, baby. Oh, and it is completely ad-free. Yes, I said it, ad-free. Try YouTube Premium for two months free at youtube.com slash premium. Trial eligibility varies, terms apply, cancel any time. This holiday, all plans, even unlimited, are just $15 a month. A holiday deal this good obviously deserves an enormously expensive holiday song like
31:33All I Want. Right. Okay, we can't afford that. You know what? Forget the music budget. We're going to stick with whatever's in the public domain. Give it a try at mintmobile.com slash switch. Upfront payment of $45 for three months, $90 for six months, or $180 for a 12-month plan required. $15 per month equivalent. Taxes and fees extra. New customer offer for initial plan term only. Greater than 50 gigabytes. May slow when network is busy. See terms. When I heard about my brother's actions on July 13th, I was devastated and immediately recalled his messages. I'm confused how somebody could offer him a federal enforcement role and provide him with a weapon and the authority to use it. That doesn't make any sense to me, given his history. And I would like some answers about that.
32:30So that is the sister of a man named David Brouillette. You may remember David Brouillette is the rookie ICE officer who fatally shot and killed a Colombian migrant in Biddeford, Maine, over the summer. The shooting of Johan Sebastian Duran Guerrero, a 25-year-old husband and father, remains under state and federal investigation. But brand new emails obtained by the New York Times provided by Brouillette's sister show that he held a clear and stated deep-seated hatred of immigrants years before joining ICE. He expressed anger toward his sister's partner, who was born in Colombia and now lives in the United States legally. Roulette writing, quote, he does not emulate what it means to be an American, end quote. That is, quote, bloodline knows nothing about what it
33:15takes to earn and then cherish the freedom America offers. The new reporting underscores the lenient vetting process for ICE officers under Trump's administration while hiring thousands of new ICE officers. New York Times adds that Brouillette was cleared to start at ICE after being fast-tracked through a preliminary vetting process. That's according to a person with knowledge of his hiring. The Department of Homeland Security saying that, quote, any claims of substandard training and betting are false. And Brouillette declined to comment to The New York Times. But in a text message to The Times, Brouillette's mother said this, quote, he is dangerous and should not have weapons. Believe his victims, not him. And when his first wife, Ashley Brouillette, found out that he was
34:01joining ICE, she recalled asking him how he continued to get jobs with guns. Quote, he laughed, she said. I want to bring in the New York Times investigative correspondent bylined on that reporting, our contributor, Katie Benner. Michelle is still here. Katie, I read this with my jaw on the ground, and then I watched your video on the Times website on the story. It's extraordinary. Just take us through what you're reporting. Yeah. So this story began because my colleague, Ali Berzan, and I were trying to better understand what happened when, after ICE decided to fast track people into the force to, by all accounts from whistleblowers, lower standards and do less vetting, and whether there were the dire
34:44consequences that whistleblowers had warned us of. And one of the agents who was squarely hired within that period and using those criteria was David Brouillette. It was fascinating. You know, he was offered the job, he applied for the job last fall and was offered the job on December 1st. And in that time, you would think that they would have caught some of these things in his background, including claims of domestic violence, a difficult time holding a job, his own record of PTSD. He collects veterans benefits, mental health issues that his mother told us about. Yet they didn't. And we couldn that indeed a background check had been done by an outside contractor, but ICE was so backlogged during this surge that nobody within ICE had had the chance to actually evaluate what was in that report and decide whether or not he should be on the force or out on the streets. accounts from his mother, from his sister, quotes from his ex-wife. Were you able to ascertain
35:46whether or not he's still on the streets with a gun working for ICE? You know, from what I can tell from reporting, I did go to his house in Maine to try to see if he would speak with me. You know, he had a sheriff come warn me that I'd be arrested if I came back after I'd left the property. And I then Freedom of Information Acted the property. And then Freedom of Information acted that report. And one of the things that he told the sheriff, interestingly, was that he was under protective custody, or what he calls protective custody, and that DHS was taking care of him. So he at least asserted at that time in October that he was still at DHS an employee. And we have no reason to believe at this time that he has been let go. But it doesn't seem that he was still at DHS an employee. And we have no reason to believe at this time
36:25that he has been let go, but it doesn't seem that he's actually at work. It's in this category of shocking, not surprising, Michonne. Well, it reminds me of what happened in Minneapolis. You know, we don't know where Jonathan Ross is, you know, the person who shot Rene Good. We're not sure where he is. The two people who were involved in the shooting of Alex Preddy, we're not sure if they've been placed on administrative leave, if they have been punished in any way. But as to the fast tracking, I mean, we should remember that Customs Enforcement in general is now the largest law enforcement entity in the entire country. And that happened very quickly. And the only way that that can happen quickly,
37:05just if you look at how police officers and law enforcement officers are changed, is if you make adjustments in the way people are vetted and hired. And it reminds me, I don't know if you remember that Mother Jones report, I believe it was Mother Jones magazine, where the reporter applied for a job and got one, went undercover and got one. And even though her drug report hadn't come back, even though she hadn't had the interviews, and so it was a clear example of how someone had been fast-tracked. I remember being at a dinner with Senator Durbin at the end of last year, and he was concerned about this happening. And he said, God help us all if they start hiring people this quickly, because it means that you're throwing standards out the window.
37:41And it appears that that might be what has actually happened to lead to tragedies like this. It's an incredible piece of reporting. Katie Benner, thank you so much for doing the reporting and for joining us to talk about it. When we come back, exclusive new reporting on the growing frustration among Navy families whose loved ones on board the USS George Bush won't be home for the holidays and are facing more shortages in supplies, food and health care. We'll have that new report after a short break. We have a call to make in a governor's race in a traditionally red state. The Associated Press projects that Democratic candidate Cindy Holzer will be the next governor of Kansas, defeating Republican candidate Ty Masterson.
38:33This is a hold for the Democrats. Michelle, the winds keep rolling in. And this is a state that had elected. She replaces a Democrat. But this is a state that notably is sending a Democrat to the U.S. Senate as well. And a state that had been seen as a red stronghold for a very long time. I don't think anyone would be smart to make that kind of projection going into 2028. Clearly, affordability was an issue here, but I think this Kansas is a state where the displeasure with Donald Trump really made a difference in the state. And some are saying that small things like we have to remember the Algerians set up their base camp in Kansas during the World Cup. It was a moment of solidarity with people seeing another culture kind of opened up things.
39:26But this is another example of a blue wave that just keeps rolling. And it's sort of hearkening back to our conversation at the beginning of the hour. It's so good for the country and for our politics that no one can ignore any corner of our country anymore. You know, they had tried to make that argument. Remember in the first Obama administration, they were saying we're going to compete everywhere. And then they sort of pulled back from that in more recent elections and Hillary Clinton with Joe Biden. I think it's, again, we're going to see that this year. Yeah. And it will mean that you have to maybe spend more resources. But I would argue that it's harder to target. This is what you were saying earlier.
39:58It's harder to target these markets. And we shouldn't have targeted. Hopscotch over states. Correct. People all over the country should kick the tires on their politicians and people should have to say the same thing no matter where they are. I think it really kind of ends the era of niche targeting and niche negative ads. And I mean, I think Elon Musk continues to be the biggest loser. Well, exactly. The money didn't make a difference in a lot of these races. Many of the candidates who won were outspent significantly. Correct. And so it's not that you can make the argument with money. What people are looking is for candidates who will improve the material conditions of their lives, who will speak to the cost of living, who will speak to their worries about health care,
40:41and who will also speak to the worry about leading their children with the world that they deserve. Exactly. And that's where it comes down to decency again. Exactly. I'm so happy we're having this conversation. One of the big issues for voters is the war in Iran and the condition of the men and women of the military who are fighting in that war. We have some brand new exclusive reporting on that that will bring you on the other side of a very short break. Don't go anywhere. Turning now to the war in Iran, it remains deeply unpopular with a majority of the American people and devastating to our economy. And at this point, where it goes next is completely unpredictable, not just day by day, but hour by hour.
41:27Trump declared this morning that now the U.S. does not need to deal with Iran. That is the opposite of what Donald Trump said on Monday. All the while, thousands of human beings, U.S. service members, find themselves two weeks before Thanksgiving without basic necessities and the news that they will not be home with their families and loved ones for the holidays. Our Pentagon reporter Priya Shridhar reviewed exclusive audio of hundreds of family members berating the Navy leaders over horrific conditions for sailors on board the USS George H.W. Bush carrier strike group. One spouse said her husband, quote, saw an apple for the first time after three months and almost cried on the phone. Another said, quote, my husband has wanted to try to kill himself four
42:11times while on the bush and nobody gave him help. The spouse of a sailor later told MSNOW that the family's learned service members on board were told on Tuesday that their deployment was extended again and to plan for a worst-case scenario of 12 months on the ship. Let's bring in our Pentagon reporter, Priya Sridhar. Priya, I am wondering, one, how they're doing, and two, with Democratic control of the Congress, is there anything they can do to improve the conditions for the men and women on board? Yeah, well, I guess we're going to have to wait and see until January, right, Nicole? But these 7,000 service members all left Norfolk, Virginia on March 31st and headed straight to the Middle East to be involved in combat operations with this war
42:57in Iran. And they faced much of the similar conditions that I've been talking to you about with the USS Abraham Lincoln. They had nowhere safe to stop in the region for so for 187 straight days. They went without a port call and it wasn't until early October that they were finally able to stop in Thailand. But I think what was the most interesting thing about this town hall to me, Nicole, was the fact that there were so many military families that were just so skeptical of what they were hearing from the Navy's top brass. They asked the same questions that I've heard repeatedly. What is the mission? What are we trying to accomplish over there that is going to bring our loved ones back home? And the acting secretary of the Navy, Hung Kau, said that they were,
43:40in fact, enforcing this naval blockade. And they were also defending vessels that were trying to go through the Strait of Hormuz that are still to this day being peppered by Iranian drones. And so the family said, listen, this is unsustainable. It's unaffordable. Are we just going to keep this naval blockade going for another 10 years? And the response from the Navy leaders was we're trying to build unmanned fleet of vessels that can at least reduce the military footprint in the region from two carrier strike groups down to one. But it was incredibly telling given the fact that, as you just said, this administration keeps trying to tell the American public that this war is over while simultaneously extending these deployments.
44:23And the Navy leaders who are planning for this war are basically preparing for a very long-term blockade on Iran. This ship is obviously named after an American president whose son is also a former American president and still alive. Has he had any comment on the conditions of the men and women of the military aboard this ship named after his father? I haven't heard anything about that, but we know that the former president is also a Navy veteran himself. So I'm sure that this issue is very close to his heart. You know, this war is primarily being fought right now by the Navy and they're simply running out of aircraft carriers. These deployments are only supposed to be six to seven months. We're simply running out of aircraft carriers. These deployments are only supposed
45:05to be six to seven months. We're doubling the length of these deployments because we simply are running out of deployable aircraft carriers and people. And I think this is going to have a really chilling effect when it comes to retention of service members, because a lot of family members are thinking, I can't single parent my kids for much longer with these unpredictable timelines. Priya, you've been on the front line of all this reporting. Thank you again for breaking more news on this front. Michelle, thank you for spending the whole hour with me here at the table. It's a pleasure. Quick break for us. We'll be right back. Thank you so much for letting us in your homes tonight.




