Deadline: White House · · Transcript & summary by WhipScribe
Live coverage of a rare nationwide ground stop shows what was known, what was not, and why vague official answers left travelers and reporters guessing.
Tap a chapter to play it from that moment in the show's own player; the transcript opens there too.
“But this is not a crisis, really. It's more of an embarrassment than anything.” Alan Deal · at 27:32 — ▶ hear it from here
A nationwide ground stop from the Federal Aviation Administration held US flights on the ground while communication problems hit several air route traffic control centers. More than 7,800 flights were delayed and about 350 cancelled, and the stop landed just two weeks before Thanksgiving, one of the busiest travel days of the year. Reporters at airports described boards that were not updating, passengers with no announcements, and travelers choosing between waiting, renting cars or rebooking.
Official explanations were thin and sometimes contradictory. The Homeland Security secretary called it a telecommunications outage, said there was no reason for the public to be afraid, and refused to rule out a cyber attack. Justice Department sources told reporters they were not tracking a terror link, and a Bloomberg report citing a single source said investigators were examining whether a software update caused it. Congressional staff said neither the White House nor the Pentagon knew the cause, and the company behind a Transportation Department AI routing tool denied any role.
The broadcast kept returning to why the system failed. Air route centers that hand off high-altitude traffic were affected, while airport towers were not, and aircraft already in the air were continuing to their destinations. Commentators described decades-old equipment still running on copper wire, a modernization effort still underway, and a shortage of about 1,500 controllers. Aviation consultant Alan Deal called the episode more an embarrassment than a crisis, but argued the system is vulnerable and needs cyber experts involved in air traffic control.
Alan Deal is an aviation safety consultant who, as the broadcast introduces him, has worked with the NTSB, the Federal Aviation Administration and the U.S. Air Force. He joined the show by phone to comment on the ground stop.
Alan Deal called the nationwide FAA ground stop more of an embarrassment than a real crisis. He said the air traffic system is antiquated, that the FAA is short 1,500 controllers, and that the government needs cyber experts involved in air traffic control.
“But this is not a crisis, really. It's more of an embarrassment than anything.”Alan Deal · 27:32
Paula Reid reported, citing Justice Department sources, that there was no law enforcement terror connection being tracked in the ground stop. Those sources described the problem as a frequency issue.
“DOJ sources tell me there's no law enforcement terror connection.”Paula Reid · 14:30
Mark Santia reported from Jacksonville International Airport that passengers were confused because there were no answers. The departure boards were not being updated, and many flights still showed on time even as delays and cancellations built up.
“there's a lot of confusion here at Jacksonville's International Airport”Mark Santia · 2:17
Eugene Daniels, stuck on a plane at Los Angeles International Airport, said his captain was getting information from American Airlines corporate headquarters and not from the FAA. Pilots were not hearing much from federal officials either.
“The captain that was on my plane, he told me that he was getting his information from corporate headquarters at American Airlines.”Eugene Daniels · 30:23
The FAA issued a nationwide ground stop after communication issues affected multiple air route traffic control centers, and officials did not confirm the cause during the broadcast. The show reported that Justice Department sources saw no terror link and that a single-source Bloomberg report pointed to a possible software update, with no timeline for restoring flights.
Alan Deal, an aviation safety consultant who has worked with the NTSB, called the nationwide ground stop more of an embarrassment than a real crisis. He said the air traffic system is antiquated, that the government needs cyber experts working on air traffic control, and that the FAA is short 1,500 controllers, which leaves little room for extra stress on the system.
The FAA's statement blamed communication issues affecting multiple air route traffic control centers, and said technicians were working on the problem. The Homeland Security secretary called it a telecommunications outage and would not rule anything out. A Bloomberg report citing a single source said the FBI did not believe a cyber attack or criminal activity caused it, and that investigators were looking at whether a software update was the cause.
In a briefing, the Homeland Security secretary described the ground stop as a telecommunications outage and said there was no reason for the public to be afraid. He said the government was not ruling anything out, including a cyber attack, and that the event was not another 9-11. He declined to give a timeframe for restoring operations and said it would take some time to get flights running again.
Reporter Paula Reid said Justice Department sources told her there was no law enforcement terror connection being tracked, and that the problem was described as a frequency issue. Officials stressed that the ground stop was not a repeat of September 11, 2001, though reporters noted that the last nationwide ground stop came after those attacks. A cyber attack was not confirmed either way during the broadcast.
A ground stop halts new departures so the system can empty out, so planes already in the air kept flying to their destinations. United Airlines said its aircraft were continuing to their destinations rather than diverting. A senior transportation reporter said the outage hit the air route traffic control centers that manage aircraft at cruising altitude, not airport control towers or takeoffs and landings.
The episode does not establish when flights resumed. Pilots passing information to reporters suggested the stop could last about seven hours, but the Homeland Security secretary said no timeframe had been discussed and that getting flights going again would take time. Reporter Eugene Daniels, on the ground at Los Angeles, said pilots he spoke with thought the delays could run for hours.
A senior transportation reporter said much of the equipment at the air route centers is decades old and in some cases runs on copper wire, and that Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy often uses the floppy disk as his example. The reporter said the government has been replacing copper with fiber optic cables under a modernization effort, but the FAA statement did not say whether the outage was related to that work.
The Department of Transportation has an AI tool called SMART that is designed to optimize routes around weather and cut delays. The software company that produced it tweeted that it had nothing to do with the ground stop, and a senior transportation reporter said the hardware sits at DOT headquarters in Washington rather than at the FAA facilities said to be affected.
Our own transcript of the public episode, with a timestamp about every 90 seconds. Tap a timestamp to play the episode from there in the show's own player; the link button on a paragraph copies a link that opens this page there.
0:00Call Her Daddy is brought to you by SoFi, the everything app for smarter money. If your money is scattered across five different apps you never open, you're not in control. Your money should move you forward. With SoFi, you get award-winning banking, investing, borrowing, and more all in one app. So you finally know where your money is. Make your first move with SoFi checking and savings, competitive APY, no account fees, a bonus when you join with eligible direct deposit, terms apply, SoFi Bank and a member FDIC when you're ready to invest or pay off that debt. Everything you need is right there. As a SoFi member, you get access to SoFi Wealth's world-class financial planners to help you know what to do next.
0:41Get started today at SoFi.com slash call her daddy. SoFi, get your money right. This is a paid advertisement by SoFi Technologies and is not intended to be financial advice. If you're a parent and want to help set up your child for success, then iXcel is right for your family. As an effective and affordable online learning program, iXcel covers math, language arts, science, and social studies using interactive practice problems for kids from pre-K to 12th grade. Listeners can get an exclusive 20% off iXcel membership when they sign up today at iXcel.com slash 20. Visit iXcel.com slash 20 to get the most effective learning program out there at the best price. Hi there, everyone. It's now 5 p.m. in New York. If you're just joining us,
1:34we are covering the breaking news of a nationwide ground stop issued by the Federal Aviation Administration. It's only the second time this has happened in our country's history since 9-11. In a statement, the FAA says the ground stop was issued following, quote, communication issues impacting multiple air route traffic control centers, and that technicians are working on the issue. According to flight tracking site FlightAware, there are now more than 7,800 flights delayed in the U.S. and about 350 cancellations. Nationwide ground stops are incredibly rare. As we said, the last one was on January 11th, 2023. It lasted about 90 minutes after an aviation warning system went down. The one before that was issued in the wake of the terror attack on September 11th.
2:17The source tells our colleague David Rode that they have been told that FAA systems are the issue. Congress is at the moment in the dark. The top ranking Democrat on the House Intelligence Committee says he has not been told of any national security nexus. I want to go back to MSNOW reporter Mark Santia at the Jacksonville airport who found a passenger who had more information than we've received from the government. That passenger was told by a pilot that this would go on for seven hours. Mark Santia, what else are you hearing from passengers there? Yeah, Nicole, there's a lot of confusion here at Jacksonville's International Airport. There's a lot of confusion because there just aren't answers.
2:56Even looking at the board, Nicole, that we looked at when I first joined you a short time ago, you can see it's not being updated, right? So you're still looking at delays. There's a cancellation, but still there are a lot of flights that say on time. We know that 445 flight, it's not on time. It's a five o'clock. That was 15 minutes ago. So the boards aren't being updated here. There's not a lot of communication and talking to people across the country. This is, sounds like what's happening at other airports. People just don't know. I want to walk you down the terminal here. You can see a large group of people as people are just waiting to see what happens next, how long this is going to last.
3:34The most popular place in the airport right now, Nicole, it's the restaurants, the bars, the grills, people grabbing some food because no one really knows how long it's going to take. Mark, let me do this. Just because you are there with people who have questions, we may be getting the latest that is knowable. This is a briefing underway from Mark Wayne Mullen, the Secretary of the Department of Homeland Security. Let's listen. Those are separate issues. Yes. Just to be clear, can you definitively rule out that this is not a cyber attack? And how long do you expect this outage to last? What is the cause? So we're working with Secretary Duffy on this. We're not ruling out anything at this point.
4:14The first thing is the safety of everybody that's flying. We are assured that everybody is safe. Everybody that's going to be in the air that's currently on a plane, loved ones, as I said, we're going to get you on the ground and we're doing it in a safe manner. To say that we can rule out anything, that's not what we do at this point. The first thing we want to do is make sure everybody is safe and we restore operations. Yes. Can you talk about the specific system that is being affected right now? And we have seen some planes land at specific airports. Is that going to be the case at all airports? Any flights in the air will be allowed to land? The flights that are currently in the air, we have a ground stoppage. We still got to get the
4:54flights out, right? And so we're going to be dealing with those case by case. I think you said specific. It's a telecommunication outage. I'm not going to get ahead of FAA. That's their lane to talk about. We were wanting to assure all the American people this isn't a safety to the American people or another 9-11. I think that's what a lot of people are trying to make the comparison to. And that's not the case. And in briefing the president, what kind of all of government response is being assembled right now? Who's involved? We're throwing everyone that has a stake in this. Everybody's involved right now. So this is a this is unprecedented when we when you see something like this and we're going to
5:36continue to throw the assets we need at it to make sure that one as not to repeat myself, but that we get the flights down and then we get the normal operations back up. But there was several of us that was involved in it. Yes. Back here, back here. Blue tie. Sorry. Thank you, Mr. Secretary. So is it currently the communications is down as we speak right now? Yes. And then secondly, there is, Let me explain. We are able to communicate at certain levels, but it's overwhelmed some of the systems we have. Once again, Sean Duffy, Secretary Duffy, is on this. He was on the phone earlier with the president and several of us, and they're doing a phenomenal job in a crisis mode. So is it days or weeks?
6:25That's too early to tell. There are reports that they last about seven hours right now that pilots are telling these people. Is that the time frame you're looking at? We have not discussed any time frame. I'll just think about this as a whole. If I have a loved one at the airport, just to get everybody started back up and the flights going again, it's going to take some time. And so this isn't going to just be resolved and turned around within the hour. This is going to take some time. But once again, everybody is safe, the flights are accounted for, and there should be no fear to the public at all. And this one. Yes. Can you explain, just the president has been briefed, you've talked to him?
7:12Yes. And then- Well, I wasn't the only person in the room, obviously. And then there are thoughts that, you know, this could be an AI related error or issue. We call it SI. Ronnie, remember? Sure. SI. You know, you just can't rule out anything at this point. We're going through that process, and we're going to find out what happened. And when we do, we'll take the appropriate actions to make sure it doesn't happen again. While you are investigating, are there any extra precautions that are going on for the president to keep him safe while you are still investigating? Well, there's no fear to the public. I want to make sure we say this again. There's no reason for the public to be afraid or scared for your loved ones.
7:59This isn't another 9-11. I just can't repeat that enough. People are making that assumption because that's the last time we had a nationwide ground stoppage. This is a telecommunication outage. This is much different. And just following up on Caitlin's question, there are reports that the FAA was rolling out a new AI traffic control system today. Has there been any link between that? We're looking at that. That's part of something that obviously through CISA at DHS, we're taking a look. We're working with our counterparts throughout all agencies. Are there plans in the air that FAA isn't able to communicate with right now? No, no. It's just at a different level. The clarity is my understanding. So I'm not trying
8:49to get ahead of myself on this one. My understanding is that we can still communicate. It's just that it's at different levels and the clarity that we can get to. But there's redundancy in most communications. So as you can see, there's still planes landing. And so there's still communications going on. We add an abundant of caution is the reason why we decided to ground everything. Thank you, sir. This is a ground stop for the United States. Yes. Is this affecting other countries as well? Not that we're aware of. There's two areas that we know that are not affected. I don't think I'm at the ability to share those right now. But there's two areas inside the United States that are still able to communicate just fine.
9:37Mr. Secretary, I don't understand that. What does that mean? Can you describe who is helping in investigating the root cause of it, as far as what agencies? Every agency that has an asset that is involved in this, from the communications side, FFA, DOW, State Department, we're all working together. But that's what we do, right? And I don't want to say that this is a crisis, but it is because we're down. You know, we had to do a nationwide ground stoppage. It's what the government works well at. That's what we're here for. And so we are well positioned and communicating very well. The president took a lead in this immediately, and he gave us the assets and the communication to move forward in a fast way.
10:30That's what leaders do, and President Trump's the best at leading us. I haven't got you. Go ahead. You say this is not a 9-11-style event, but if it is a widespread telecommunications issue, could that in theory be a cyber attack related to some sort of terror, a version of terror, but the modern day cyber version? This isn't the same comparison to 9-11. That's a road I won't go down. But people are making that assumption because it's a stoppage. Do we know what has caused it yet? No, we're going to go through it. But I'm not going to make assumptions. As I've said multiple times, it's very difficult to make assumptions. We want to always deal with facts. And we're going to deal with facts.
11:15And as we get them, we'll roll them out to you guys. All right? Thank you, guys. Appreciate it. Call Her Daddy is brought to you by SoFi, the everything app for smarter money. If your money is scattered across five different apps you never open, you're not in control. Your money should move you forward. With SoFi, you get award-winning banking, investing, borrowing, and more all in one app. So you finally know where your money is. Make your first move with SoFi checking and savings, competitive APY, no account fees, a bonus when you join with eligible direct deposit, terms apply, SoFi Bank and a member FDIC when you're ready to invest or pay off that debt. Everything you need is right there. As a SoFi
11:57member, you get access to SoFi Wealth's world-class financial planners to help you know what to do next. Get started today at SoFi.com slash call her daddy. SoFi, get your money right. This is a paid advertisement by SoFi Technologies and is not intended to be financial advice. Every day, someone sits in this chair convinced healthy, strong hair has to come with a luxury price tag. But you know what really surprises them? How simple the solution can be. The secret isn't some long, expensive salon treatment. It's actually Pantene. Pantene Daily Moisture Renewal Shampoo and Conditioner has a vitamin-rich lather that leaves hair looking vibrant and hydrated after every wash, with results lasting over 72 hours. And for an extra boost, use Pantene's Miracle Rescue 10-in-1
12:46multitasking spray. Oh, here comes a new client. Time to share the secret. For salon quality hair repair, it's actually Pantene. If you're a parent and want to help set up your child for success, then iXcel is right for your family. As an effective and affordable online learning program, IXL covers math, language arts, science, and social studies using interactive practice problems for kids from pre-K to 12th grade. Listeners can get an exclusive 20% off IXL membership when they sign up today at iXL.com slash 20. Visit iXL.com slash 20 to get the most effective learning program out there at the best price. So that was the secretary of the Department of Homeland Security, Mark Wayne Mullen. A few interesting things there, David, that we learned. He seemed to undercut the timeline that the pilots have offered by saying this,
13:45quote, we have not discussed any timeframe. It's going to take some time to get this all up again. So it's, I think we're looking at two scenarios here. One is that some very serious natural security incident has occurred and that's why such a drastic step was taken. Like a cyber. Yes. I mean, that was the line of questioning from the journalist there at the end that actually precipitated the end of the conversation. And he seemed to be really spending a lot of time suggesting that the coverage was making a parallel to 9-11. I don't, I'm not obviously able to watch any of the coverage. I think the historical reference point is that there's only one time since that day when there's been a nationwide ground stop. But I couldn't tell if he was conflating the reasons or if he was simply
14:30saying that there's no threat, which, of course, we've been reporting. Our own Paula Reid reported that over an hour ago, that, quote, DOJ sources tell me there's no law enforcement terror connection. They're tracking it this time. They said it's a frequency issue. So it's two scenarios. Maybe there was a threat and it was the right thing to do the ground stop. And I don't want to, that's still a possibility. This might have been the responsible thing to do. The way he communicated there, though, and what we're hearing from all these sources, and I have one more thing to share. It's not very clear the administration is handling this very well. And so either way, either there's a very serious national security threat, and that is very concerning the American public, or this administration,
15:08you know, enacted a shutdown nationwide, terrifying people across the country. And it's not clear if that was necessary. And just in terms of the chaos, this is a congressional official. They told me, we both talked, we talked to both the White House and the DOD earlier, and neither of them knew why this is happening. And but again, they're hearing that it's an FAA problem, an FAA system problem. So the positive side there is that's another source. This is a person with some knowledge in terms of congressional oversight and the intelligence committees that the White House and the DOD is not telling them this is national security related. We also heard him invoke CISA. What is left of CISA? So CISA is the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency. It was gutted by the Trump
15:56administration when he came in for his second term. One of the things he used to do was to warn when there was foreign interference in elections. So it came in and I think Musk was involved, but it's, oh, this is propaganda. You're, you know, they were, they were, they're actually shutting off free speech. What, that's not what CISA does. CISA secures election systems and water systems and power systems across the country. I'm not sure of their role in terms of aviation, but then I'll just say, lastly, again, maybe there was there's a serious threat here. And the right thing to do was to to announce this massive ground stoppage the way they've handled this for the last hour and a half. They will have
16:34a crisis if there was not a national security issue, that they shut down every flight in the country, had no communications for an hour. And he wasn't exactly clear. He was clearly trying to reassure the American people, and that was right. But I'm still confused about what's happening. The Secretary of Homeland Security saying this, there is no fear for the public, no risk for your loved ones. It is a telecommunications outage. We have been joined by a friend of the program, John Heilman. Hi. Hi. Flying anywhere today? No, thank God. Think about the people who are up in the air right now. Yeah, me too. It's not the people who are on the ground. Being on the ground is, you know, panning out. Being on the ground,
17:21it looks like, I mean, our own colleague, Eugene Daniels, was on the ground in L.A. I think he's since got off the plane. And it sounds like from our reporter, Mark Santia, who's in Jacksonville, a lot of people are coming off airplanes. It sounds like they're getting people off planes that were on the ground to take off. But, yeah, if you're up in the sky, it's a really scary day. Yeah. And I think even if you're not up in the sky, because of the lack of clarity that David and you have both been talking about, and I'm very strongly in favor of lack of speculation in these situations, just of not taking comfort from things that are said that are unclear or panicking over things that are said that are unclear. It is a fact that we live in a new technological world
18:07that almost nobody understands, which is the world of AI. I am not an AI expert, but I saw my friend Josh Tarantino, who has just written a book about AI, was on Pablo Torre's show yesterday and was talking about the possibility of AI-enabled mischief going to critical infrastructure that doesn't qualify, maybe would not qualify as foreign terrorism, wouldn't meet the standards for a lot of the way we talk about these things. It's not really a category for it. It would certainly cause a cyber attack. But you could see from Mullen there that his, I just feel like they really know what's going on. Well, Mr. Mullen actually corrected, there was a question about SI and he said, quote, you mean SI. Yes. Well, I thought that was asinine. But beyond that, I think there is,
18:57we are, these kinds of disruptions that are going to happen unquestionably in the next 18 to 24 months. Just unquestionably in the next 18 to 24 months. Just unquestionably. There's going to be disruptions of things. Some may be severe, some relatively small. But it's not clear without- It's a great point that it's another line of questioning. Right. The first reporting we have is that it's not tracking as a terror case. But your point, and the journalists who were just questioning, the Secretary of Homeland Security asked it as well, is there any evidence that it's an AI issue? Yes. And I think that to say that there's not evidence that it's an AI issue? Yes. And I think that to say that there's not evidence of it is not conclusive even then. Right. Because you're
19:30dealing with a series of systems that are, there is no precedent for such things. It's not that in general, when we see things like this and the taxonomies that the government uses to characterize things are based on precedent. The systems that they monitor are based on precedent. But we hear about giant communications, telecommunications outage of this critical infrastructure. It raises questions about not whether people are not being candid, but about the degree of actual comprehension that the government that monitors these systems has over totally novel technology that's now at loose in the world. Which completely marries into the reporting that you have from your sources. I don't want to be more blunt than you just were on television and said no one knows what the hell is going on.
20:14I want to bring into our coverage our senior transportation reporter, Josh Einiger. Josh, what do you know? So, Nicole, I just feel like it's important to level set and just talk about what they have said and what it means, just what the definitions are here. So the air route traffic control centers, which is what the FAA statement said, are having this problem. That's a center and that's the backbone of the national airspace. There are like 20 to 24 of these facilities. There are office buildings all across the country. And these are the centers that manage flights that are at altitude. So when you're at 30,000 feet cruising at altitude, your pilots will be handled by Indianapolis Center. And then at some point, you'll move on to the next one as you cross the country.
21:04And there's what they have described as some sort of technical issue involving those facilities. It doesn't involve control towers at the airport level. It doesn't involve planes taking off or landing. This is simply planes. And I don't want to say simply. This is the backbone of the network. But it's the planes that are at altitude, right? It's that component of the system. According to the FAA, that has had this problem. Now, importantly, there are lots, you look at that image now, that's, I believe, someone correct me if I'm wrong, that's a live image of FlightAware. There are a lot of planes in the sky right now. United Airlines just put out a statement saying that its aircraft are continuing to their destination. So they're not being forced to divert somewhere, which indicates
21:50that they are in communication in some way with air traffic control and they're able to continue their flights. What the FAA is talking about is a ground stop, which means their systems in some way are overloaded or degraded in some way, and that they don't want to add more flights into the system. They want to basically let the system empty out as they figure out what's going on here. So I just wanted to add that little bit of context. It's scary to talk about these concepts, to talk about people who are in the air right now. You know, I think it's safe to assume that if there were a critical communication issue that meant planes could not talk to towers or control centers, I should say, that they would be diverting. And I would also add, Nicole, like we've talked a lot,
22:38for example, about failures in the Newark area over the last year and a half or so, when there's a problem communicating between a flight deck and air traffic control, there are a lot of redundancies in the system. There are other ways that pilots can communicate, whether it's with their own airline's dispatch or other channels, you know, like frequencies that they can use that enable them to communicate, not just with the controllers, but also with other planes near them. So, you know, I think from just a pure sort of fear factor, I think, you know, the fact that there are a lot of planes still in the sky and that they're continuing to their destinations indicates that, you know, this is clearly a major outage and a major
23:22failure at some level, maybe at many levels. But when it comes to an immediate acute safety issue, I think that it would indicate that, you know, people in the sky might worry a little bit less. And so for the people in the sky who are normally, or when everything is working, handed off, your example was if you're above Indianapolis, you are dealing with someone from the air route traffic control center in Indianapolis. And as you head west, you maybe get handed off to, I is a temporary, quote, there's a temporary telecommunications outage to these centers. Who would be communicating with who in the place of that system, Josh? So what we don't know, Nicole, is are these centers not able to communicate with one another, right?
24:21But they can communicate with the planes. We don't know what that means, because it's important to be precise here. And that statement is not exactly precise in terms of what exactly has failed. There are so many different communication sort of channels involved here. If the centers can communicate with one another, but they can communicate with planes, I mean, that means they need to work together to coordinate routing, but it doesn't necessarily involve whether the airplane can fly through the airspace. So, and that's just a hypothetical, but I think the point here is they've been very, very vague as you guys have been talking about. And even, you know, I've been, it's been very difficult to get answers
25:02at just a basic level about what's going on right now. I do want to add something else because, you know, I've been, it's been very difficult to get answers at just a basic level about what's going on right now. I do want to add something else because, you know, there's been a lot of talk over the last, you know, couple of years about the, you know, the antiquated nature of the national airspace. And this is something that is not in dispute. This is the systems in many cases that are running on, you know, copper wire. Secretary of Transportation Sean Duffy likes to use the floppy disk example. There's equipment up there all across the country that's decades old. And they're not running on fiber optics the one big, beautiful bill that is modernizing the whole system.
25:51So one question to be asked, and that one statement from FAA doesn't come close to answering it, is this in some way related to the modernization. They have replaced a lot of equipment at these centers, a lot of copper wire with fiber optic cables. They've replaced a lot of systems. Could this be something to do with the modernization effort, or could this be a failure of antiquated equipment that is in the pipeline to be modernized, or is it something totally different? But those are the, you know, at the end, you know, when you look at what's going on in the national airspace right now, those are the issues I think that really come to mind. And then, of course, there's this question that obviously the Homeland Security Secretary
26:37is trying to tamp down, and, you know, all our sources, all our reporters are outsourcing this question of could this be some sort of malicious incident. And that so far doesn't appear to be the case, which is a great thing. But there are a lot of buckets that could cause something like this. At the end of the day, we're more than an hour into this and it's still very, very vague about what it is that's at the root cause of this. Stay with us. Let me bring into our conversation by phone aviation safety consultant Alan Deal, who has worked with the NTSB, the Federal Aviation Administration, and the U.S. Air Force. Alan, tell us what you see when you see all these really dots of information. Well, of course, we're kind of overwhelmed with theories right now.
27:32Thank God that at least DOJ and Homeland Security says this doesn't look like a 9-11 situation. To use an old, overworn political cliche, it's the economy stupid. Well, I think it's the system stupid. As other guests have pointed out, it's very antiquated. They're getting around replacing copper wires and floppy disks. whether or not this is related to the overhaul that's underway, we don't know. But this is not a crisis, really. It's more of an embarrassment than anything. And I'm certainly glad that Secretary Duffy, out of an abundance of caution, issues the ground hold. You know, they're short 1,500 controllers. The system can't handle a lot of unnecessary stress. So everybody's safe. They're holding the flights on the ground.
28:36The people that are in the air are obviously going to be able to continue to their destiny. So this is more of an embarrassment than a real threat of any kind. So the system is working. Electronically, it's broken down. Software, it's probably broken down. But everything looks like it's still safe right now. And hopefully it will return to normal in the next several hours, I guess they're saying. Alan, what does it say to the world in terms of people who now know with their own eyes, anyone consuming our coverage, just how vulnerable our system really is? Well, as others have pointed out, the system is growing probably more vulnerable. And clearly, the cyber experts that work for the government certainly need to get involved with things like air traffic control.
29:34They've looked at infrastructure like power plants and water systems, but air traffic control should be on our radar right now. And I do think that the administration will probably need to fund that in the very near future. And, of course, the modernization needs to continue. And certainly they need to continue hiring controllers so that they can make the system work even when the mechanical electronic aspects break down. I want to bring into, Alan, stay with us. I want to bring back into our coverage, senior Washington correspondent, Eugene Daniels. He's at LAX where he has gotten off the plane. Is that right, Eugene? And in front of a camera for us. Yeah, that's right. We were disembarked from the plane.
30:23What the pilot said when he came on was that our plane needed to move because they had to bring on other planes so the other folks could deplane. So it seems like a kind of mass deplaning situation happening at LAX at this point. is the lack of information that the pilots themselves are getting. The captain that was on my plane, he told me that he was getting his information from corporate headquarters at American Airlines. He wasn't hearing anything from the FAA, and they weren't really hearing anything from the FAA. He also said that his wife is a pilot at United, and so they were trying to share information with each other. And as I've walked and talked to people who recognize us from MS, what they would say to me was they are shocked that they have not heard from the president in
31:11front of the camera. Obviously, we heard from DHS Secretary Mark Wayne Mullen, but folks are looking to hear more information from the leader of the free world as this is shaking out. One person told me that they were disturbed that there wasn't a lot of information coming from this administration. I've tried to kind of foil those fears because we just don't know what's going on. I think that's more concerning. A lot of folks, as they've kind of been sitting and getting out their pungent, as you can see, I'm trying to move out of the way here, folks who are sitting around, many of them think that they might be getting on their plane soon, right? That they weren't getting a lot of information.
31:46So they're anticipating that this might just be kind of a normal delay situation that you deal with. But, you know, you deplane, you get back on after an hour or so. And yet what we know is, and what we've been hearing from pilots over and over, including my pilot, that this could be hours and hours. The pilot that Captain I talked to said that he had also heard on the 1030 Eastern that that was when we would have some time to leave. And so that was information that he had gleaned from his different conversations from folks at American Airlines, folks at his work at United, who's also a pilot, and not getting any information from the FAA. So I'm going to be here talking to folks as long as we're stuck here, Nicole.
32:27But at the end of the day, people are concerned they're not getting any information. Well, Eugene, I would add that Mark Wayne Mullen, the secretary of Homeland Security, said this, quote, it's going to take some time to get this up and running again. So even for the scant information, we do have some acknowledgement from the Secretary of Homeland Security that it's going to take some time to turn everything back on. And the pilot that I talked to, he said his next step in the questions that we have, and I heard Josh talk about this a little bit, is like, is this going to be everybody gets on the plane at some point and goes to their destination, the destination they were scheduled to? Or is this some kind of
33:09mass diverting event? And the mass diverting event, he said, would be for him, you know, the worst case scenario once we got back in the air, because you kind of may not end up where you were going. And it will cause even more issues and more importantly, more delays and cancellations for people at the're trying to get home. So at the end of the day, still a lot of information that we don't know. A lot of speculation here that I won't share with folks. But what I will say is that folks seem to be getting kind of hit to the idea that they may be in for much longer than they anticipated. Eugene, we're so sorry that you're impacted by this, but we're grateful to have your reporting and your eyes and ears and your great accounts from what you're going through.
33:51And I think some comfort for people who are sitting on airplanes and watching this coverage on planes that according to the Secretary of Homeland Security, quote, there is no risk to the public, no risk to your loved ones. What is being described as a telecommunications outage that has ushered in really the second only national ground stop in more than 20 years in this country. We're going to sneak in a break. No one's going anywhere. I don't know that they knew that when they agreed to help us through these two hours, but that is the case. We will all be right back. But the foam density is only 1.8 pounds per cubic foot. No one does more research than parents. 3,000 people reviewed this sippy cup?
35:08Shh, I'm reading. With the possible exception of the specialists at Stanford Medicine Children's Health, who lead the way in research, innovation, and new protocols, all in the pursuit of the best possible outcomes. So, what's the verdict on the cup? I'm making a spreadsheet. Ask me later. Stanford Medicine Children's Health. Access to excellence. You know, recommendations can be great. Maybe someone recommended this podcast, and here you are. But home projects are different. If a podcast isn't your thing, you lose a few minutes. If you hire your cousin's neighbor to mount your TV, you might end up with a lopsided screen and wall damage. Maybe I Know A Guy just isn't enough for your home. That's why Thumbtack works.
35:47It matches you with top-rated local pros with photos, reviews, and credentials all in one place. For your next home project, try Thumbtack. Hire the right pro today. Southwest 2179, just a heads up. We went into a national ground stop all aircraft with update unknown. We are back with the breaking news that the FAA has issued a national ground stop for all flights. Details, as we've been discussing, are very scarce right now, but here is what we do know. It is only the third such time in recent history in our country. The last nationwide ground stop was in 2023. The one before that was after the 9-11 terror attacks. Moments ago, the Secretary of the Department of Homeland Security, Mark Wayne Mullen, described it this way
36:38as a, quote, telecommunications outage and sought to reassure the country by saying that your loved ones have nothing to fear. The outage comes just two weeks before Thanksgiving, which is traditionally one of the busiest travel days of the year. Let's go back to MSNOW reporter Mark Santia, who was on the ground at the Jacksonville airport for us. Mark, what are you hearing? Yeah, Nicole, we're not hearing much. And that's a frustration with a lot of passengers here who are sort of trying to figure out that next step. Talk to some people who just booked a car. They said they're driving back to New York because they don't know when flights are going to take off again. We've heard different time zones. There are times, rather, for flights to take off. But I want to show you what we're
37:17starting to see at the gates, Nicole, and that's lines of passengers. Now, these passengers aren't boarding, but they're asking for help. They're also trying to figure out how to get their luggage. What happens with luggage? Because now you take a look at the boards over here, Nicole, they've all been updated. You can see all the delays, the cancellations, still some showing on time. We know that's not going to happen, especially with a 529 flight on time. That's not happening. Now, across the way here, this is a flight from Detroit that just landed. So you're seeing people walk off. I talked to a couple of passengers who just disembarked. They said they were in the air. Pilot gave them no warning. They landed, no issues.
37:56But they said now they don't know how it's going to be when they go back home. They don't know when flights will resume. And that's why you're taking a look. The restaurants here are starting to pack out. A lot of people filtering out. And Nicole, what we're seeing and hearing from people is they're figuring out and they're planning their next move. And again, some people are renting cars and saying, that's it. I'd rather take my chances on 95, on 75 and drive back north or drive where I have to go because at least I know I can get moving. So are you waiting for a flight? Are you flying? What's the latest? What have they told you? I'm just waiting on the flight. There's something going on. There's a ground stop, a nationwide ground stop. Yeah. Where are you
38:34heading back to? I'm heading to Michigan. Heading back to Michigan. Yeah. All right. So yeah, all flights to Michigan, it's a ground stop and there's no, what time was your flight supposed to take off? It was supposed to take off at 7 o'clock. And you've gotten no word from the airlines, no word. You've heard nothing until now. Nothing, just till now. Yeah. Oh, wow. And that's sort of, thank you, sir. I appreciate it. We'll be back. Yeah, I'll brief you up in a bit. And that's sort of the issue, Nicole. It's just this lack of communication. We've not heard anything come over the intercom here. There've been no announcements. A lot of people heading to the gate, people talking to different airport employees you see there, just trying to get any word on when they
39:16might be able to get home, get on their vacation. We had one couple heading to a wedding in Mexico and you're starting to see, this is a portion of the terminal here that's starting to empty out because people are, again, just trying to figure out their way home. Are you heading to Chicago? I will always talk to a Packers fan, especially a smiling Packers fan. I'm well, thank you. Talk to me. What's going through your mind now? You're heading to Chicago. Have you gotten any word about when you're taking off? Just initially they said kind of weather, but then they said communication problems. But not much detail on that. It's just a lack of, I understood maybe they can hear and communicate, but maybe the security part of it.
39:59So what's your plan? You need to get back. I have to go back to Indiana somehow. Extend this vacation. It's a lot warmer down here in Florida than Indiana. I don't blame you. So some passengers sort of glass. You do this as well. Glass is half full, definitely. But this is another line, Nicole, you can see here. People just wondering if they should get their luggage, what they should do. Because again, it's the communication that's really sort of lacking at this point. This is, no one's boarding here, Nicole, but you see these passengers are just in line to try to either figure out a next step to try to get their luggage. This is everybody in line here waiting to get to just talk to someone
40:44and figure out the next move. This is a flight heading to Denver, a United flight heading to Denver here. And you see no one is boarding the plane, but people are just looking to get info and looking to see what that next step is. Frustrating for a lot of people here who are just sort of left to wonder. Nicole? Thank you so much for all that reporting. I feel, as a frequent traveler, I feel so bad for everybody trying to figure out how to get their bags and what to do and where to go. I want to bring in someone who knows this all too well. Joining us now, Jim Olson. He's a former United senior spokesperson, a longtime aviation employee, now himself stuck at Washington National Airport. What should people do in the
41:32situation that Mark Santia's interview subjects are finding themselves in? Yeah, well, look, I've always been on the other side of the table here. But for this situation, I think that passengers should follow the same rules that pilots use when they're confronted by a unique circumstance, which is aviate, navigateiate. Basically, stabilize your situation. Make sure you're getting the information you need from your airline. Then navigate, figure out what your plan B is. Do you need a hotel? Do you need to go back home? And then third, then worry about sharing what's going on, the drama of this with your family and on your social networks. Social media and your communicate should be the last thing you focus on, just like pilots. Well, what information is there to aviate right now? What do
42:27you know? Well, I'll tell you, as a communications person, I don't work for an airline anymore, but this has been a very confusing situation. From the initial statement that came out from the FAA, this was an extraordinary safety situation that that creates a lot of drama and unfortunately speculation on people's parts. Was this another 9-11? Obviously that, and thankfully that's not the situation now, but you want your communication to be as clear as possible out of the gate. And so there's just a lot swirling around right now. So that did not help the situation. Well, I think that the allusions to 9-11 that I have heard are simply the historical fact that one of the last two times in the last 25 years that this has happened was after 9-11.
43:13And I think people are just trying to understand if this happens often, if there are, I mean, the Wi-Fi goes out in my house all the time. Is this like a Wi-Fi outage or is this something bigger? And what are your questions about how something this massive could happen? Yeah, a nationwide ground stop is very, very rare. I think the last time this happened was 9-11. There have been regional ground stops before, but I think this is the first nationwide ground stop. This is not a rerouting of flights. Most flights are actually, I think, continuing on to their uh destination but all outgoing flights are grounded right now um this is creating a huge amount of complexity and confusion for people um but that's just the nature of the situation safety always comes first so
43:54i think everyone's doing the right thing here but communications really is the key the airlines need to be doing a better job of communicating what's going on. I'm flying United right now. I love United on the record, but they haven't really explained what's been going on. I'm getting all my information from news and the other passengers that I've been sitting next to have been saying the same thing. They're getting delay information, but no information about what's actually causing these delays. So I think the airlines can do a better job of communicating what's going on and what the next steps are. And I think the administration and the FAA can do a better job of communicating what's going on.
44:31I think that's I think that's the universal sentiment. We have one more question for you while we have you. If everything were suddenly repaired and any communications or technology issues were resolved, how long would it take to reverse a ground stop? Oh, again, I'm just speculating here, but I think for myself and others, I don't think many of us are going to be actually getting on flights until tomorrow morning, especially if you're flying internationally. If you're abroad, your flight is supposed to be, that might have been departing night, is not going to be departing. And so I think there'll be a lot of people either sleeping on floors in the airports or at nearby hotels. Tim Wilson, thank you for your expertise and for using your time there at the airport to
45:17help us understand what's happening. We're grateful to you. It was a nice, thank you. It was a nice diversion from the chaos going on here. Call back anytime. Call back. We'll tell you what we know. You tell us what you know. David wrote, I mean, this is the theme from the earliest reporting you brought us, that senior, senior congressional folks not able to find out anything more than passengers sitting at airports waiting to get on flights. Yeah, we're not hearing that. There's one more piece of news. This is a Bloomberg report. It's just from one source. But the FBI does not believe the communication issue that caused this was due to a cyber attack or criminal activity. One area of inquiry, again, Bloomberg, just from a single source, that they're looking at is whether the
46:00outage was caused by a software update. Extraordinary. It took down the entire nation's aviation system. As I said, either way, this is bad. I mean, again, thank you. Who knows? Again, that's why I don't update my phone, but I'm not in control of anybody else. I mean, that is, I mean, to me, of course, the safety of our fellow citizens is the first and the last part of what everybody cares about. And it is also a issue of national security that our system has now known the world over to be this vulnerable and decrepit. Yes, it's a warning sign for all of us. It's a moment of leadership for people in the government to address this. How could this have not been addressed in the past? And let's say
46:43it, I know, I don't believe it either. I think I understand. I agree with John that like, could it be AI or something like that? And they just haven't made it public. But let's say it is a software update. Again, the communications issue, just the fear that is felt by families across this country right now and the people in the air, it's extraordinary. We've heard, I'm sorry, you said it already, but it's extraordinary we've heard so little from the White House. I think the, you know, compounding the just everyone's perplexness about this is the Microsoft outage from just yesterday, which according to the reporting, to go to what David just said, according to the reporting on that as of now,
47:24what is believed is that that was not a cyber attack. And that was another, a network upgrade gone wrong. Where that's the, this is what they are, what they're currently saying is that the Microsoft leading explanation is that it was a botched network infrastructure upgrade compounded by a subsequent network configuration change. I have the last thing in the world is I would challenge something like that. So I'm not challenging it. But if the two things have happened in two days, massive national, one's in the private sector, one's in the public sector, and they both have affected millions of people in two straight days, it would be really extraordinary if it were true that both of those events were caused by, essentially, by infrastructure upgrades. I'm not casting doubt
48:11on it. I'm just saying, wow, that would be an incredible coincidence. And you could imagine why people would question that coincidence and would wonder if it was more without spreading conspiracy theories. It, just an incredible coincidence if a coincidence. You can't not note that that would be an incredible coincidence. And a huge political failure of our government. I mean, these are critical systems, poor communications, you know, flight systems. It's extraordinary. Is Vaughn Hilliard still with us? I am. Vaughn, are you hearing anything from your administration sources or White House sources? Yeah, I'm in contact with the White House, and they're checking on a couple lines of inquiry here for me here.
48:51And I wish that we had more things firmed up. I think that I'm sure what David is hearing, Josh is hearing, are a lot of one-sourced information. And for the transparency of our reporting process, before we report anything, we want to ensure that we are entirely confident with what our sources are passing along to us. So we're getting a couple lines and a couple threads here that we're working on. We know that there are communications between Nicole, the FAA, and members of Congress up on Capitol Hill. Of course, we heard there Secretary Mullen indicate that there was a meeting in the Oval Office, though he didn't go into detail exactly about who was in the room. You did hear, and I'm not going to get into
49:28details here, but we did hear him be asked directly about the AI, the new technology that was set to be implemented across the 22 different air traffic control centers in the U.S. here this week. Again, we do not have reporting that that was what impacted this, but we know that this week that they were planning to institute that despite lawmakers having had expressed concerns over the last weeks about its preparedness. Again, there's a lot of questions and the administration is not doing much to provide the answers here. And so while we are working through this, I think it was quite notable to hear him mention, and David was getting at this, you guys were talking about CISA and, of course, the extent to which they have gutted major pieces of
50:16infrastructure and personnel inside of CISA in the wake of the Trump administration coming into power here. So I think that there is a lot of hesitancy in a way that we're not used to, potentially, to be clear, from the White House in terms of their public messaging. And we're used to, frankly, getting something from the president of the United States himself on True Social or by calling in to Fox. And so far, that has not happened here. And so for the sake of transparency, we're working on reporting and trying to get a couple of things hopefully confirmed here, as I'm sure it sounds like the administration is trying to better identify themselves about what caused this. Vaughn, excuse my ignorance on this, but is there a White House press secretary?
50:59There is currently a White House press secretary. Stephen Chung is the communications director for the White House. There have been, of course, several departures here over the last week, Susie Wiles among them. We know that Stephen Miller is now in this position. There's one deputy chief of staff that has left the ranks. We are — there is a press shop that is still in place. We are working with this White House and we have open lines of communication with them. And so we're hoping, Nicole, to get some pieces of information from them. Well, I guess one of the one other part I want to get to is that the Marco Rubio, again, is also still the national security adviser as well. And again, when we talk about sort of the way in which this cabinet is structured, it is notable that Rubio stands in this position here in the midst of
51:53wars and negotiations on multiple fronts here. I guess my questions are along those lines. So Stephen Miller has been the White House chief of staff, I don't know, since Tuesday or Monday. So he's three days on the job. There is no White House press secretary. And the national security advisor is also the nation's secretary of state at a time when the country is at war. And I believe today Trump talked about another war. So he's busy. Who is in charge of responding to this? Let's take all of their statements of Katie Zachariah, it was a concern, the clear lack of domestic and foreign knowledge that she had to fill into the role. And it's more than just giving a briefing. But for the purposes of this type of a situation, the reporters are able to go and gut check.
52:58Right. We have one. Again, this is sort of the inside of the reporting that we do. Right. We have one source that tells us, you know, that we have heard something from an FAA administrator. And part of this is being able to go to the White House and have that open line of communication and cross-check some reporting here. There are public servants that are serving inside of the press office as we speak, but there is nobody that is serving in the press secretary role here at this point of time that we could expect to come from the podium. That is why I know when I was talking with your control room, we got word that in two minutes, Secretary Mullen, the Homeland Security Secretary, was going to be coming out.
53:35And what you heard there from him was more questions than almost any answer that he provided. The one answer he provided was to try to assure Americans that this was not a 9-11 event, that planes would not be flying into any U.S. pieces of infrastructure. But that's a far cry from providing Americans assurance that there was no cyberattack or being able to identify exactly what the White House was engaged in inside of the Oval Office about the extent to which there was a threat to critical infrastructure, for instance. And that is what has left a lot of people to be questioning this administration. And Stephen Miller is trying to streamline. We have been reporting here this week, streamline operations, open up so the cabinet secretaries have direct line of communication with him as well as with the president.
54:29And so this is part of the storyline of Donald Trump's next two years, understanding that we expect more individuals to depart this White House and questions about who is going to fill in these roles in these capacities here and the extent to which the American public gets clear messaging about what is currently evolving and what could very well be a national crisis. I'm not saying that is what this is, but it is an example of some of the conversations that were around about Caroline Leavitt's departure and understanding that there was plenty of scrutiny on the role that she played as press secretary, but understanding that there was at least a public-facing figure that was able to effectively communicate in real-time information to the public
55:12in a situation like this. Since you've been talking, Ron, we saw a plane take off from LAX, so it's not clear if the tweet from Sean Duffy, who's the country's transportation secretary, is still operative. I want to go back to our senior transportation reporter, Josh Einiger. What do you know? So not only did one plane take off, but you see there that live picture, that's a United plane right now. And I'm actually looking at a flight tracking app right now. That's a flight bound for Shanghai. And the plane that you were referencing a little while ago was a cargo jet that was also bound for China. So I would hesitate. I mean, look, there's no information coming out at all. They're not really saying what's going on and why certain things are happening and certain things aren't.
56:02You could surmise that because it's westbound from the continental United States, away from the network of air traffic centers that they say are impacted by this outage, that they are allowing a small number of international flights to take off if they're not going to be in the national airspace, which is impacted by this. But we're not supposed to speculate, and I'm sorry, Nicole, that's exactly what I just did. I don't actually have an answer for that. I can just tell you that's why those two planes that we just saw take off were bound for China, out of the country, away from what they call the NAS, the National Airspace. And so that's one potential explanation for this. But look at all those other planes that are lined up here.
56:45And they're just sitting there on the tarmac. Now, they haven't gone back to the gate. The FAA requires airlines to go back to the gate after three hours. They get fined a tremendous amount of money if people are stuck on an airplane for more than three hours. So the fact that this has been going on now for, what, maybe, I don't know, Nicole, about two hours. Two hours, yeah. Right. So, I mean, maybe controllers at LAX have given those particular pilots some degree of hope that maybe they'll get a slot and they'll be able to take off at some point. Eventually, they're going to go, you know, what they say, DOT-3. I think that's landing. That looks like a plane that's landing. So again, the flights are continuing to their destinations.
57:31You know, one thing that Mark was pointing out at where he is at Jacksonville, Mark Santia, is that, you know, there's so little information. I've spoken to airline officials at a number of airlines. I've spoken to people in the industry. There's just a lot of bafflement about what exactly is happening. I will say one last thing. The DOT has rolled out an AI tool that they call SMART, which is something that is designed to optimize routes around weather and try to cut time off of the flight path that people have to endure on a plane and reduce delays. The developer, the software company that produced SMART has tweeted, they have nothing to do with this. And that particular software is not, it's at DOT headquarters.
58:17The actual hardware is at DOT headquarters in Washington and is not at any of the facilities that the FAA says are impacted here. So, you know, they're the data point for you as well. Well, it's a denial in a moment where for two hours, while the entire country's airspace has been grounded to a stop for the second time in 26 years, we don't have any information from the government, but we do have a denial from one of the AI companies in business with the government. David wrote, it may encapsulate the last two hours of our lives. Again, we were sort of gesturing each other about the company saying, we had nothing to do with this. We have nothing to do with this. Neither do I for that matter. I'll be very clear,
59:00not my software. We don't have any sort of fresh reporting here coming in. But again, it's just it's look, let's make sure everyone's safe. But it's back to the issue of communications and not and getting more information here. And sorry, we do. Paula Reed, our colleague, has from a Justice Department official that there's no there's no law enforcement or terror connection that they're tracking at this time. So it continues to be that reporting. I think we're back to, was there some kind of cyber thing, and the government hasn't announced it yet remains a question. But the entire country is on edge right now. Every American, I would argue, just how frequently we all fly. Well, and it is an immense relief that they're not tracking a single terror thread, which I think is the specific
59:54language of Paula's reporting, and that there is no known cyber attack that they believe is causing any of this. We have a denial from an AI company that they caused it either. If this was someone leaning into the wall and turning off the switch by accident, it is still of grave economic and national security danger that the world knows how vulnerable our system is. Absolutely. Look, and I'm half speculating here, and I said this earlier, but I just feel like our government, the federal government, has not done a good job of regulating in the digital age. People complain about that, about sort of social media being this completely unregulated space and hate speech and other terrible things happen.
1:00:38This is far more serious about the failure of our government, our paralyzed government, to address these new technologies. Drones, if you remember when all the drones were flying around New Jersey and everyone was afraid of them. So this is just maybe the biggest example yet of how we have to address these new technologies as a society and as a political system. And to your point, I mean, it really is, whatever this ends up being, the state of paralysis we're in is exposing kind of vulnerability that is not helpful. And the last thing, to see me to Vaughn's point, you know, we kind of all laugh and think that Trump's kind of an idiot when he does this joking about, hey, I'll make Dana White the press secretary.
1:01:20We could use a White House press secretary. This is why you need a White House chief of staff. And it's not a joke. It's not a joke. There are some days when we don't miss the White House press secretary. This is why you need a White House chief of staff. And it's not a joke. There are some days when we don't miss the White House press briefing. But on a day like this, there are a lot of people who would like to have someone who could stand up and answer questions on behalf of the White House so we could ask them. And vilifying government experts and election clerks and FBI agents. I've been thinking of Michael Lewis for two hours and his great book, The Blockers. It has been an extraordinary day of news, and we could not have gotten through 10 minutes of it without all of my colleagues who you've seen on the air over the last two hours.
1:01:56Josh Einiger, Mark Santia, Eugene Daniels, Vaughn Hilliard, David Rhode, and John Helman, who had totally different plans for the last 120 minutes. But they spent these two hours with us and I thank them all I want to thank all of you for being here with us on this really extraordinary news day Peter Alexander is going to pick up our breaking news coverage from Washington DC if your kid has a serious diagnosis you'd travel to the ends of the earth to get them the best outcome but you don't have to because Stanford Medicine Children's Health has some of the best pediatric specialists in the world, right here in the Bay Area. Stanford Medicine Children's Health.




