World Business Report · · Transcript & summary by WhipScribe
It rounds up a nationwide flight halt, a global Microsoft outage and NVIDIA's leadership crisis in one short episode, with stranded travellers and bankers describing what it cost them.
Tap a chapter to open that moment in the transcript; the link to it is copied for you.
“We are completely in the dark, Leanna.” Ed Butler · at 11:13 — open in the transcript →
“The problem is those remaining servers then report that they're not healthy when they have these so-called health checks.” Alan Woodward · at 16:16 — open in the transcript →
On a Friday afternoon the Federal Aviation Administration halted all departing US flights, citing extraordinary circumstances and safety, after a communications problem hit its regional air traffic control centres. Travel journalist Simon Calder said more than a million people were due to depart in the following hours, and inbound transatlantic jets risked being stranded overnight. Aviation spokesman Mike Arnott counted at least 11,000 scheduled departures, 481 cancellations and 603 diverted flights, and said an idle plane can cost upwards of $100 a minute. BBC travel reporter Ed Butler, stuck at Orlando airport, described crowded corridors and almost no announcements.
A separate Microsoft 365 outage disrupted businesses and public services in more than 70 countries, though Microsoft said it was not a cyber attack. Alan Woodward of the Surrey Centre for Cyber Security traced it to a failed health check that pulled servers offline and overloaded the rest in a cascade. Irene Sumter, a banker in Kenya, said lost email instructions stalled client work and that switching to personal email opened fraud and data-protection risks. Investors largely treated the outage as a glitch.
The week's other big story was NVIDIA, whose chief executive Jensen Huang resigned on Thursday after a scandal involving a woman suspected of working for Chinese intelligence. The stock has fallen 24% over 30 days, partly because Huang had about 60 direct reports and no clear successor. The US Treasury Secretary blamed the Commerce Department for delaying a blacklist of Singapore-based Megaspeed, a firm suspected of smuggling AI chips into China, and congressional committees are demanding testimony.
Travel journalist who explained how many travellers were stranded by the FAA's halt and how it compares with past shutdowns.
Spokesman for an aviation analytics firm who counted the affected flights and passengers and the cost of idle planes.
Professor at the Surrey Centre for Cyber Security who explained how a health-check failure may have cascaded through Microsoft's servers.
Assistant general manager in business development who works in banking in Kenya and described lost client email instructions.
Portfolio manager at Exchange Capital Resources in Chicago who reported on airline, Microsoft and NVIDIA shares.
BBC North America business correspondent who covered the NVIDIA scandal and the debate over AI chip export controls.
Simon Calder said the last time the United States grounded flights on this scale was the aftermath of 9/11, when aircraft were used as weapons and air traffic was shut down across the UK for several days. He said the current halt is extraordinary, though the US Homeland Security Secretary stressed there was no nefarious attack and the cause appeared to be a telecommunications problem.
“Well, you have to go back 25 years to the dark days of 9-11, when, of course, aircraft were being used as guided missiles”Simon Calder · 4:25
Alan Woodward said Microsoft runs health checks that poll its many servers in large data centres around the world to ask whether they are alive. He believed something went wrong with that process for some servers, which were then pulled offline and had their work passed to the rest. Those remaining servers then reported themselves unhealthy and shut down, which produced a cascade of failures.
“The problem is those remaining servers then report that they're not healthy when they have these so-called health checks.”Alan Woodward · 16:16
Ed Butler, a BBC presenter who was himself stranded, reported from Orlando airport that it was packed with people standing in corridors and sitting at gates. He said there were almost no announcements over the loudspeakers, his flight was about two hours delayed, and passengers had no information from their airlines about rebooking or accommodation.
“We are completely in the dark, Leanna.”Ed Butler · 11:13
Susan Smith said NVIDIA's share price had stabilised but was down 24% over the previous 30 days after chief executive Jensen Huang stepped down. She explained that Huang had about 60 people reporting directly to him in a very flat structure, with no clear successor, so investors were waiting for a name to lead the company forward.
“It's an unusual structure and there isn't a clear successor in place.”Susan Smith · 23:26
Michelle Flurry said the White House was divided over whether to sell some advanced AI chips to China, and that the NVIDIA scandal gives more weight to those calling for tougher controls. She said one proposal being discussed is the AI Overwatch Act, and that the investigations into the affair are still at a very early stage.
“This now gives, I guess, more credence to those who say no, tougher controls are needed.”Michelle Flurry · 26:26
The Federal Aviation Administration halted all departing flights in the United States on a Friday afternoon, citing extraordinary circumstances and safety, after a communications issue affected its regional air traffic control centres. The FAA did not explain the cause in detail, and flights heading to the US from overseas were also unable to take off.
Simon Calder, a travel journalist, said the FAA's halt took effect around 4 p.m. on the East Coast, at the peak of the week, with more than a million people booked to depart from US airports over the next few hours. He said inbound transatlantic jets were due to fly back that night but it was unclear whether any would, leaving tens of thousands of foreign travellers unsure how to get home. He compared it with the shutdown after 9/11 and said a nationwide halt on this scale is extraordinary.
Alan Woodward of the Surrey Centre for Cyber Security said Microsoft's servers, spread across large server farms worldwide, are regularly polled with health checks that ask whether each one is alive. He believed something went wrong with that process for some servers, which were pulled offline and had their work passed to the remaining servers. Those servers then reported themselves unhealthy and shut down, producing a cascade of failures. Microsoft said the outage was not a cyber attack.
Mike Arnott, an aviation analytics spokesman, said every minute a plane sits at the gate can cost upwards of $100, from burned fuel, crew pay and food on board. Reaccommodating passengers and crew in hotels adds to that, so costs mount very quickly. He also said at least 11,000 flights were still scheduled to depart after 4 p.m. Eastern time, with 481 cancellations so far, about 1.8% of the day's departures.
Susan Smith, a portfolio manager at Exchange Capital Resources in Chicago, said NVIDIA's share price had stabilised but was down 24% over the previous 30 days. She said investors were reacting to a series of news items after Jensen Huang stepped down as chief executive. The company had a very flat structure, with about 60 people reporting directly to Huang, and no clear successor, so investors were waiting for a name.
The US Treasury Secretary accused the Commerce Department, led by Howard Lutnick, of failing to blacklist Singapore-based Megaspeed, a company suspected of smuggling advanced American AI chips into China. In an interview on CNBC he said the responsibility lay with the Commerce Department, which had chosen to delay. Megaspeed has links to a woman suspected of working for Chinese intelligence who had an affair with NVIDIA's former boss, Jensen Huang.
Michelle Flurry, the BBC's North America business correspondent, said the scandal gives more weight to people who want tougher controls on advanced AI chip exports to China. She said the White House was already divided, with some officials favouring selling some of these advanced chips to China. She said one proposal being discussed is the AI Overwatch Act, and that other rules and regulations are likely to follow, though the investigations are still at an early stage.
Our own transcript of the public episode, with a timestamp about every 90 seconds. Tap a timestamp or the link button on a paragraph to copy a link that opens this page there.
0:00This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK. online broker and get started. See what adding futures can do for you at cmegroup.com forward slash podcast. Derivatives are not suitable for all investors and involve the risk of losing more than the amount originally deposited and any profit you might have made. This is not a recommendation or offer to buy, sell, or attain any specific investment or service. Big news! Wayfair's Black Friday sale is here, early! Right now at Wayfair, get up to 70% off everything you need for the season ahead. Save on kitchen and dining, bedroom furniture and mattresses, holiday decor, and way more. Now is the time to score big, from seasonal finds to favorites you'll use all year long.
0:59Plus, with Wayfair, enjoy fast and easy shipping, with delivery in time for the holidays. Save up to 70% off early Black Friday deals. Shop now at Wayfair.com. Wayfair, every style, every home. When Microsoft goes down, the world feels it. The outage really hit us hard. We're really in a fix right now. Are we heavily relying on Microsoft on this? Should we start thinking of what would be the plan B in case it happens again. It's World Business Report from the BBC World Service. I'm Liana Byrne. A major Microsoft outage has disrupted businesses in more than 70 countries. We'll hear from a banker in Kenya who's counting the cost. And a breaking story, flights are grounded across the US due to an air traffic control communications issue.
1:42Also, the NVIDIA scandal causes a rouse in the White House. Our top story, we're going to start with the news that all flights in the United States have been grounded until further notice due to extraordinary circumstances and for reasons of safety. That's according to a statement from the Federal Aviation Administration. It's understood the shutdown followed a communications issue affecting all the FAA's regional air traffic control centers. Here's how it's been reported in the United States. 4.15 is a major breaking news. All flights are now being grounded across the nation. Now to more breaking news. The Federal Aviation Administration says that it was halting all departing flights due to extraordinary circumstances
2:32and for reasons of safety. There you go. Now, as it stands, no flights due to land in the United States can take off. But let's get some more information from our travel journalist, Simon Calder. Simon, thanks for joining us. Well, I am so, so sorry that this is happening. It is an absolutely desperate situation for more than a million people. Those are the people who are booked to depart from US airports over the next few hours. This has happened at the absolute peak time of the week, Friday afternoon. It basically came into effect at US time about 4 p.m. in on the East Coast, 1 p.m. on the West Coast. You've got the world's busiest airport, of course, Atlanta, Chicago, extremely busy. And everywhere else, there are planes all ready to go, many people with connections.
3:29And while, of course, as with any time in the US, there were plenty of aircraft in the air, those appear to be landing fairly normally. I was watching a British Airways flight coming into New York. JFK made a perfectly ordinary landing and taxied to the gate. Everybody's safe, of course. But anybody who has got a transfer flight will not be making their connection. And crucially, of course, all these inbound transatlantic jets are supposed to be going back tonight. And it's not at all clear if any of them will be, which creates huge problems for tens of thousands of foreigners who perhaps finished a business trip, a vacation in the US and are now wondering how they might possibly get home. Absolutely huge Huge problems, very unfortunate,
4:25but it's also extremely extraordinary, isn't it, Simon? I mean, when was the last time the United States grounded flights on this scale? Well, you have to go back 25 years to the dark days of 9-11, when, of course, aircraft were being used as guided missiles and all air traffic was shut down across the UK for several days. Now, in the past few minutes, the Homeland Security Secretary Markway Mullen has been talking to reporters and absolutely stressing that this is not something that there appears to be a, that there is no quotes nefarious attack against us um but it appears to be a telecommunications problem which is not unknown in air traffic control you go back three years the entire british air traffic control system came to a halt because of technical problems
5:21um so it's it's yes air traffic control keeps people safe by keeping aircraft apart. Those and the natural thing to do if the system isn't working is just to stop people flying. So it's just an absolute mess. And when things do get back to normal, planes, pilots, cabin crew, passengers will be scattered all over the place. And it's going to take a great deal of time to get people where they need to be. Well, we've also got Mike Arnott, a spokesman for Serium Aviation Analytics. And Mike, thanks for joining us. I believe you have the numbers, how many planes, how many passengers are affected? Right. Well, there's at least 11,000 flights that are still scheduled to depart after 4 p.m. Eastern time, which is around 9 p.m. in the
6:15UK. That's going to impact at least, as Simon said, a million passengers. And it's probably a million passengers and it's probably upwards of 1.5 million passengers who will be stranded at the airport or you know unsure when their flight might depart. What we do know is that some 481 flights have been cancelled so far which is around 1.8 percent of the total departures today. The other thing is that there are planes that are in the air now, and there are flights that are going to divert from their intended destination. So now what we know is that there are 603 flights that were already in the air today that diverted to a different airport than they had originally intended. Most of them are returning to their origin airport.
7:10Chicago O'Hare, for example, has 28 flights that took off that were in the air and are now back on their way or are landing in Chicago. So it's quite disruptive for the industry and for passengers. And I'm sure there's knock-on effects already for airlines around the world as well. It's not just inbound flights or flights in the US. Well, most of the flights that are coming from places like Asia or from Europe have already landed for the day. They're being groomed and turned around to be ready to return back to Europe. So the time that this actually happened was fortunate in that situation in the sense that most of these planes will have already been on the ground in places like New York, JFK or Chicago. But that doesn't
8:02really provide much comfort to passengers who aren't entirely sure if they're going to get out tonight, particularly on a Friday. Absolutely. And Simon, I mean, I'm sure we learned from the UK's story a couple of years ago, even if flights are allowed to resume in the next few hours, maybe tomorrow, presumably it's not as simple as flicking a switch and getting everything moving again. Absolutely not. I mean, let us hope that things will actually, and listening to the Homeland Security Secretary, sounded as though there were possibly optimistic sounds. But let's suppose just within the next hour they allow aircraft to leave again. There is going to be an almighty backlog. There will need to be,
8:47of course, all kinds of issues in terms of the aircraft that are coming in trying to find gates. Aviation is this incredibly complicated game of three-dimensional chess that requires everything to be working exactly as it should be. And when you have a shutdown like this, well, it can, I'm afraid, reverberate not just for hours, but for many days. Yeah. And Mike, I'm sure it's impossible to put a figure on this, but when an entire country's aviation system, and sorry, I mean, it's the global top economy in the world. It effectively grinds to a halt. How quickly do the costs of that start mounting? Well, they start mounting immediately because every minute that a plane is sitting at the gate waiting
9:34can cost upwards of 100 US dollars. It's sitting there burning fuel. The crew need to be paid. The costs of the food on board, all of that, plus then reaccommodating passengers at hotels, crew at hotels, etc. It can mount very, very quickly. Okay, Mike Arnott, spokesman for Serium Aviation Analytics and travel journalist Simon Calder. Thank you both for joining us. Well, listeners to World Business Report will be familiar with the voice of Ed Butler. He's often in this chair where I am today. But today he's one of the hundreds of thousands of passengers who's been affected. And he joins us from Orlando Airport. Hello, Ed. How are you? Hi, I'm well, not too bad. Thank you, Leanna. At the minute, I mean, I'm one of the one, one and a half million people that Mike and Simon were referring to there.
10:29And we are all sitting actually remarkably well behaved in Orlando Airport. It seems at the moment no one seems to be getting too kind of raucous or angry yet. But boy, it is rammed here. I am surrounded by people standing in corridors you know people keep seeming to arrive whilst others are standing at sitting at departure gates looking at their mobile phones uh me among them and uh uh there's the other striking thing is there's almost no noise coming from the loudspeakers we're not being given any announcements at all everything is being pushed back my flight's like two hours delayed at the minute, but I guess that's just a holding position until they delay it more. So yeah, it's frustrating.
11:13So you're just in the airport. Has your airline offered you any alternative arrangements, accommodation? Are they saying you might need to rebook? Or are you just in the dark a little bit at the moment? We are completely in the dark, Leanna. And what's striking is, I mean, curiously, my previous flight was already cancelled, so I'm on a different airline anyway. But what's really striking is I just don't, I think, I get the feeling because of the lack of news that all of the airlines don't quite know what to say. You know, we could be flying, I guess, in two or three hours if this thing is called off or suspended, this security issue or safety issue that's been described. But who knows? You see, it could be till the morning. And then I honestly don't think even a place like Orlando
11:57is going to have enough hotel beds to put up everybody because there are so many people here, you can imagine. And if every single flight is delayed and there's tens of thousands just in this one airport, where are they all going to go? I guess we're just sleeping in seats or in corridors. Oh, God, Ed, we don't want that for you. And you're a great talker. I'm sure you've been speaking to people, other passengers. What are you hearing from other passengers? Do they have any other stories, places they need to be? Yeah, there are people. Listen, I've been hearing voices in Chinese, voices in Spanish. As you know, it's a very international place here. They've got a lot of people have been talking about buses,
12:36about getting higher cars. Some of them, of course, are just going to like a city three or 400 miles away. They're kind of thinking, I can still get there, you know, some other way. But to be fair, it's just, like I say, they're well behaved. I think people are patient because they know how hard things are. And they're reading online what's going on and how this is a blanket thing. It's not their airline who can be blamed. But it's still incredibly disruptive. And you're just looking at people scratching their heads, particularly those with kids. Wow, I feel for them. And what were you doing, Orlando, anyway? Disneyland. Thank you, Leanna, for asking. Disney World. You're quite right. Sorry.
13:20I don't have that much sympathy for you now, actually. No, Disney World and a little bit of Florida's very extraordinary, exotic backwaters up in the north. And it was glorious. We had a lovely time, but not so lovely now. No, well, we'll try and get you back. I'm sure there's a few shifts here that you need to fill. So, Ed Butler. I'll be with you next week, guys. Excellent, excellent stuff. Ed Butler from World Business Report. Thanks so much for joining us. We wish you all the best. And there's more on this story on the BBC World Service. Just keep tuning in and you can keep up to date at bbc.com where there is a live page on this issue right now. With us is Susan Smith, Portfolio Manager
14:00at Exchange Capital Resources in Chicago. Susan, any update on airline shares? Any effects because of what's going on? Nothing substantive yet. It's Friday after market close when this happened. And so there's very limited trading happening in these shares. We're seeing them down one to two percent. This is where it's impacting all of the airlines. It's really unclear how much this is going to impact profitability. But investors take this as a one-time issue. And it will be hopefully just a blip for this quarter and they'll be back to normal operations soon. Let's hope so. All right, you're with World Business Report from the BBC World Service. Well, we thought this was going to be our lead story today,
14:47but it wasn't. Wherever you are in the world, if you went to start your working day and you couldn't get access to your email, you weren't alone. I'm a nurse in a clinic within a hospital. We use Teams to communicate with pharmacy, and that's not working. Since morning until now, it's been like, you know, more of a handicap. Teams was working, but Microsoft 365 Office Outlook was all down. I am a university professor and the outage really hit us hard because we're right in the midst of the second phase of exams. So we're really in a fix right now. Here in Zambia, everyone's kind of happy of this outage and because of the heat, we just want to go and rest and go somewhere cool and have a drink.
15:32So businesses, governments, public services in more than 70 countries have been hit by an outage affecting Microsoft's 365 software, which has more than 430 million paid accounts. Microsoft says it's not a cyber attack and that services are stabilising but not everyone is back online. Professor Alan Woodward from the Surrey Centre for Cyber Security gave us his assessment of what might have gone wrong. I think what happened was that they have lots and lots of servers obviously in their big server farms all around the world and they have a thing called a health check whereas these servers are polled. They send a little message saying, are you alive? Can you talk? Et cetera. And I think something went wrong with that process for some of the servers. And when that happens,
16:16those servers are pulled offline. And a load of what they're doing is passed on to the remaining servers. The problem is those remaining servers then report that they're not healthy when they have these so-called health checks. And they then shut down and you get this sort of snowball happens and you get this cascade of failures. So here's the thing, Microsoft, Amazon and Google control more than 60% of the global cloud computing market. So when one of these tech giants goes down, that's a high cost to businesses. Across the globe, people are counting that cost, like Irene Sumter, an assistant general manager in business development who works in banking in Kenya. We receive a lot of instructions on email from our customers.
16:57Then it means we're not able to receive some of the daily instructions that we'd be getting from clients. Owing to the fact that there was no notice of the outage, then it becomes a bit chaotic in terms of what is the plan B for you to be able to service your customers as expected. Because, of course, there's also the overall body that regulates the industry, making it a bit difficult to give, for example, my personal email to receive such instructions, then it means work comes to a standstill. And so are there transactions that may have happened today but now won't happen until this is all fixed? Yes, correct. We have alternate banking channels where maybe customers would be able to do the transactions by themselves, which is the online platform.
17:45But I wouldn't say that we've transitioned to 100% into the online platforms in Kenya or in the developing countries. So there's still heavy reliance on instructions that would be sent on email. I wonder, does an outage like this create opportunities for fraud? Because within financial and banking sectors, all of those transactions and those communications, they're usually quite secure. So if you're having to do them in other ways, does that become risky? It can easily open up window for fraud. Just a good example, in the spirit of trying to be agile and serve your customers as fast as possible, even in moments of crisis, within the industry, it is very easy for somebody to give a proposal of,
18:33for example, send instructions through my personal email. How will I be able to verify that this is coming from the correct channel? Or better still, if my email is hacked, my personal email is hacked, and then the information falls into the wrong hands, then we can easily also be sued on data protection issues because then it means the customer's in... Balance your trading strategy by adding futures. CME Group helps you manage risk and capture opportunities in all market environments. Capitalize on around-the-clock access to highly liquid global futures and options markets Thank you. involve the risk of losing more than the amount originally deposited and any profit you might have made. This is not a recommendation or offer to buy, sell, or attain any specific investment or service. The ocean moves us, surfing a wave or savoring the view. The ocean delights us as
19:35playful otters restore coastal kelp forests. The ocean connects us. Visit montereybayaquarium.org slash connects. Information has been exposed to a third party owing to using the wrong channel of communication or the channel of communication that was not agreeable from the onset. So much as it would be in good faith, then you can end up getting exposed as an institution. I wonder, has this prompted any conversations at work that perhaps you might be too reliant on Microsoft or there needs to be a backup system because of those reasons? Oh yeah, for sure. I can tell you that has sparked some discussions here and there. And this is all across the industry because I'm looking at financial industry within Kenya and maybe within
20:23developing countries for the people who are affected. So the question is, are we heavily relying on Microsoft on this? Should we start thinking of what would be the plan B in case this incident persists or in case it happens again? So of course, those discussions have been spurred. Nothing concrete at this moment, but definitely people have started thinking on what would be plan B in case of such occurrences. And is your business losing money as this goes on? Let me give an example. For instance, day one, it would be considered as a crisis. But if this persists, I look at it from even man hours that might not be compensated. There's the actual loss of business owing to not receiving instructions that should be processed.
21:12But there's also the other aspect of you have man hours, you have people at work who are not working because they're not able to dispense their duties as expected. So maybe for work that was meant to be done within an hour, somebody might end up doing it for two hours because you're trying to see what would be the alternate channel of communication. That was Irene Satuma, an Assistant General Manager in Business Development who works in banking in Kenya. Susan Schmidt is still with us. Any effect on the Microsoft share price on any of this? Shacklingly, not a very big impact on the Microsoft stock price. And so I think investors took this as truly a glitch. We've seen this before in other companies where something's happened and caused great disruption,
21:58where it was an upgrade a year ago, two years ago from another company that caused a glitch and everyone's system went down. We've seen other technical things happen in the airline stocks even, not just a ground stop from the FAA, but something compromising booking capabilities. Microsoft stock down a fraction of a percent on the day and investors really looking past this, recognizing that Microsoft is entrenched in this Office 360 product. It's something that everyone uses. And now the investors will be looking towards the future to see how many of them would give up their Office Outlook, etc., and switch to a different system based on this one-day outage. There you go. I feel like, Susan, the story of the week is NVIDIA,
22:42isn't it? Where's the share price at there today? Yes, and perhaps that's why investors aren't paying attention to Microsoft because NVIDIA is so much more exciting for them. So NVIDIA's share price seems to have stabilized a bit, but that's down 24% in the last 30 days. So it's had quite the fall. Investors have been looking at this with another news item dropping on it almost every day this week. So obviously, we've all heard the announcement, CEO Jensen Wang is going to step down. He stepped down from his position yesterday. Another person in management has been elevated and investors are really looking at this saying, well, who's going to lead the company forward? It was a very flat structure.
23:2660 people reported to Jensen Wong. Who else is going to manage some 60 direct reports? It's an unusual structure and there isn't a clear successor in place. That's what investors are focusing on and what's pressuring the share price. So people are waiting for a name, essentially. Yeah, absolutely. All right. Susan Schmidt, Portfolio Manager at Exchange Capital Resources in Chicago. Thank you so much for joining us. Now, let's talk about NVIDIA. It was a scandal that brought down the boss of the chip-making giant and is now exposing divisions at the very top of U.S. President Donald Trump's administration. U.S. Treasury Secretary Scott Besant has accused the Commerce Department, led by Howard Lutnick,
24:08of failing to blacklist a company suspected of smuggling advanced American AI chips into China. That company, Singapore-based Megaspeed, has links to a woman suspected of working for Chinese intelligence and who had an affair with NVIDIA's former boss, Jensen Huang. Huang resigned on Thursday. I've been speaking to the BBC's North America business correspondent, Michelle Flurry. Look, I think one way to think about all of this is, obviously it started with a sex scandal, but the reason everyone is still talking about this has more to do with the heart of the AI boom, the fact that NVIDIA is kind of in many ways, not just a key player, but also a central bank in it, financing a lot of it. Then there's the national security aspect of this, and the geopolitics. And it's the national
24:57security element of all of this that has taken centre stage, I think, in the last 24 hours, with people wondering how close was Jensen Huang to Donald Trump? How far up did this go through the administration? And so you're starting to see that blame game, that sort of separation. So Scott Besson, the US Treasury Secretary, came out in an interview on CNBC, making it clear that from his perspective, from the Department of War, from State Department, there was a sense that stronger export controls were needed. In other words, stronger controls on what advanced AI chips could be sold to China. His criticism is that it really all was on the kind of shoulders, the responsibility lay with the Commerce Department, and they chose to delay. So making it very clear, nothing to do with me.
25:42He was talking about that company Megaspeed, wasn't he? And he was questioning why it wasn't blacklisted sooner. Do we know why that was the case? I think that is going to be very much the focus of congressional oversight. You've got the Senate Banking Committee pushing for testimony from Jensen Huang, but also from Howard Lutnick, who is the Secretary of the Commerce Department. You've also got other committees, those chaired by soon to be the kind of ranking member Elizabeth Warren. Come January, after these midterm elections, she will be in charge of one of the committees. She also has been pushing for the administration to keep hold of documents relating to conversations between NVIDIA and the White House over exactly this
26:26question about export controls blacklist. So the investigations have begun. I think this is very early days still in this whole affair. I guess stepping back, could this scandal lead to tougher restrictions on American chip exports to China? You know, there was a division, it's fair to say, within the White House. Some favoured selling some of these advanced chips to China, arguing given that these AI chips can power everything from nuclear missiles to biotech weapons. And so there was a division. This now gives, I guess, more credence to those who say no, tougher controls are needed. And so you can expect to see a legislative push. One of the things people are talking about is the AI Overwatch Act, but there will no doubt be other
27:23rules and regulations that will be discussed. And Michelle, today's Business Daily is all about this topic, isn't it? There's been no escaping this topic. And in fact, if you want to find out much more about what it all means on that national security front, what it means for policy, we talk about it, Will Bain, Rahul, Tandon and I, on our Power Players podcast, which you can find on our website. There you go. Have a listen. That was BBC's North America business correspondent, Michelle Flurry. And a reminder of our top story, flights across the United States have been grounded until further notice following an extraordinary order from the Federal Aviation Administration. The FAA says the decision has been taken for safety reasons, but has not explained what's prompted it. Fights heading to the United States from overseas are
28:09also affected, with aircraft due to land there unable to take off. There's continuing coverage on the BBC World Service, of course, and at bbc.com. And that's it from World Business Report. I'm Leanna Byrne. Thanks for listening. the guests work out a planning so you can spend less time searching and more time packing. Book your next day now with Vrbo. With Geico, 15 minutes could save you 15% or more. Now sure, there are plenty of ways to spend 15 minutes in San Francisco. Like looking for parking. Not finding it, but looking. Networking with someone who's wearing the exact same vest as you. Nice one. Or walking three blocks that somehow have four hills. And apparently hearing that cable car bell quite a bit.
29:1115 minutes goes a long way in San Francisco and could save you 15% with GEICO.

