World Business Report · · Transcript & summary by WhipScribe
A short, sharp briefing on what Jensen Huang's exit means for Nvidia's share price, the US-China chip race and how a founder-led giant plans for succession.
Tap a chapter to open that moment in the transcript; the link to it is copied for you.
“but I think Jensen's been a unique leader, and it won't be easy to replace him.” Chris Miller · at 14:21 — open in the transcript →
Nvidia chief executive Jensen Huang has resigned and left the board after reports about his personal relationships, including one with a woman US authorities suspect of spying for China. The company's long-serving finance chief, Colette Kress, has taken over on an interim basis, and Nvidia has appointed a board chair for the first time. Shares fell as much as 14% during the session before closing down 5.4%, and they remain roughly 30% below the all-time high set a little over a month earlier. Investors appear to be betting that Nvidia's dominant market position and deep cash reserves will carry it through, but analysts say the deeper worry is losing the figure who made the company central to the AI boom.
The programme also looks at why one person mattered so much. Chris Miller, author of Chip Wars, notes that Huang ran the company for 33 years and bet heavily on AI years before most people thought it would yield a commercially viable product, and that Nvidia has no obvious internal successor. A Yale leadership professor argues that founder-led firms, including Tesla and Meta, often surround their leader with loyalists rather than outside figures who can challenge them. He contrasts this with Michael Dell, who put experienced outside chief executives on his board early on. Both views suggest the next chief will face a hard job whatever happens to the chip roadmap.
The political fallout could matter as much as the boardroom. Nvidia has argued that selling chips to China is acceptable because they serve commercial customers, but that case is harder to make after reports that a Southeast Asian customer providing computing power to China was run by a Chinese intelligence asset. Miller expects Congress to push the Trump administration for tighter limits, and notes that Chinese firms such as Alibaba and ByteDance still depend heavily on Nvidia hardware, much of it in overseas data centres.
Chris Miller, author of Chip Wars, said Jensen Huang deserves credit for building Nvidia into one of the world's leading chip makers, and for betting heavily on AI more than a decade ago, when most people thought it would never produce a commercially viable product. He said it will not be easy to replace Huang as chief executive.
“but I think Jensen's been a unique leader, and it won't be easy to replace him.”Chris Miller · 14:21
Chris Miller said Nvidia's defence of selling chips to China has been that they are used only for commercial purposes. He said that argument is harder to make after reports that a key customer in Southeast Asia, which provided computing power to China, was run by a Chinese intelligence asset.
“NVIDIA's argument has been that it's OK to sell chips to China because they're only used for commercial purposes.”Chris Miller · 12:56
Chris Miller said he expects Congress, alongside Nvidia's board, to launch a series of investigations, above all into how an alleged Chinese agent could get so close to the leader of such an important company. He warned that these probes would take up a lot of time for Nvidia's senior leadership, making it harder to keep competing.
“there are going to be a series of investigations that will take up a lot of time of NVIDIA's senior leadership”Chris Miller · 11:39
Susanna Streeter, chief investment strategist at Wealth Club, said Nvidia shares fell as much as 14% during the session before closing down 5.4%. She said a lot of bargain hunting by retail investors helped the stock recover after an aggressive sell-off, though shares were still down 30% from their all-time high set a little over a month earlier.
“I think there was a lot of bargain hunting going on, particularly by retail investors after that really aggressive sell-off.”Susanna Streeter · 7:10
Lily Jamali, the BBC's North America technology reporter, said Colette Kress is the new interim chief executive of Nvidia and a familiar name to people who follow the company. She noted that Kress has been the chief financial officer for the last 13 years and is seen as a steady hand, though her finance background would be a knock against her for a permanent technology role.
“She's the chief financial officer, has been for the last 13 years.”Lily Jamali · 4:07
Jensen Huang resigned as Nvidia chief executive and left its board after reports about his personal relationships, including one with a woman suspected of spying for China. Colette Kress, the finance chief, was named interim CEO, the company appointed its first board chair, and a search for a permanent successor, inside and outside the company, is under way.
Chris Miller, author of Chip Wars, said much of Nvidia's success depends on Jensen Huang, who ran the company for 33 years and bet heavily on AI more than a decade before most people thought it would produce a commercially viable product. He said Nvidia now faces a real dilemma because it has no obvious internal successor, and an outside hire would struggle to lead a company so used to one person at the top.
Susanna Streeter, chief investment strategist at Wealth Club, said Nvidia shares fell as much as 14% after Jensen Huang resigned before closing down 5.4%. She said retail investors bought the dip, and that the share price remained about 30% below its all-time high set a little over a month earlier. She described the reaction as disappointment that Huang, the AI revolution's poster boy, had left a central position.
Donald Trump suggested that Tim Cook should take over at Nvidia after Jensen Huang's resignation. A Yale leadership professor said he would agree with the President, calling Cook a tech titan with little ego who manages people well, has a good relationship with the Chinese, and has grown Apple far beyond what Steve Jobs left. He added that CFO Colette Kress is excellent but that Cook is the better choice for this moment.
Chris Miller said Nvidia has argued it is acceptable to sell chips to China because they are used only for commercial purposes. That argument is harder to make now that a key customer in Southeast Asia, which provided computing power to China, was reportedly run by a Chinese intelligence asset. Miller expects Congress to push the Trump administration to crack down on chips flowing directly to China and on those rented onward from Southeast Asian data centres.
A Yale leadership professor argued that Nvidia was built so that Jensen Huang faced no real threats, with about 60 direct reports and no management committee. He said its board contains few former chief executives with independent standing, so their legitimacy flows back to the founder, a pattern he compared to Elon Musk's Tesla board. He contrasted this with Michael Dell, who started his company at 19 in a college dorm room and filled his board with experienced outside leaders.
Colette Kress is Nvidia's chief financial officer, a role she has held for 13 years, and she has been put in charge of the company temporarily after Jensen Huang's resignation. The BBC's Lily Jamali described her as a familiar face and a steady hand. The board has also appointed a chair for the first time, which signals more oversight of whoever comes next. Nvidia is searching inside and outside the company for a permanent chief executive.
Our own transcript of the public episode, with a timestamp about every 90 seconds. Tap a timestamp or the link button on a paragraph to copy a link that opens this page there.
0:00This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK. online broker and get started. See what adding futures can do for you at cmegroup.com forward slash podcast. Derivatives are not suitable for all investors and involve the risk of losing more than the amount originally deposited and any profit you might have made. This is not a recommendation or offer to buy, sell, or attain any specific investment or service. Big news! Wayfair's Black Friday sale is here, early! Right now at Wayfair, get up to 70% off everything you need for the season ahead. Save on kitchen and dining, bedroom furniture and mattresses, holiday decor, and way more. Now is the time to score big, from seasonal finds to favorites you'll use all year long.
0:59Plus, with Wayfair, enjoy fast and easy shipping, with delivery in time for the holidays. Save up to 70% off early Black Friday deals. Shop now at Wayfair.com. Wayfair, every style, every home. The man who built a $4 trillion technology giant is out. It's extremely disappointing that Jensen has got himself into these situations. The company faces a real dilemma when it looks at its next CEO. It's World Business Report from the BBC World Service. I'm Leanna Byrne. Jensen Huang's dramatic departure has rocked one of the world's most valuable companies. Could his exit change the balance of power in the technology race between the US and China? And Donald Trump has weighed in on who should replace him.
1:42But is his pick a realistic one? What a day. This time yesterday on World Business Report, we were telling you that Jensen Huang, the man who co-founded NVIDIA more than 30 years ago and turned it into a $4 trillion giant, could be forced out of the company. Well, now he's gone. Wang has resigned as chief executive, following reports about his personal relationships, including one with a woman suspected by US authorities of spying for China. He's also leaving NVIDIA's board. The company's long-serving finance chief, Colette Kress, has been put in charge temporarily. That's been quite the ride today. So let's speak quite the ride today. So let's speak to the BBC's North America technology reporter,
2:31Lily Jamali, who is in Santa Clara, California, outside the headquarters of NVIDIA. Hello, Lily. Hello. So how is it there? What's the offices like even? Yeah, well, you know, you have the usual workers coming and going for lunch and whatnot. But there has also been a steady trickle of interested parties, of onlookers wanting to just be here on this really big day for a really important company in Silicon Valley. A couple of them have dropped off mementos, flowers. It's almost like they're mourning something. I spoke to a couple of them and that does kind of capture it for at least a couple of these folks. They feel like Jensen Wong and NVIDIA have made such a contribution to their lives. One of the people I spoke to was a
3:17longtime gamer who was very in the weeds with all of the, you know, the history that NVIDIA has first as a maker of chips for gaming systems before they pivoted to AI. And, you know, we're really surrounded by people very familiar with the culture who wanted to just see the building today. Yeah, it's just such a huge moment in the industry and just in the economy in general, really. So can you just recap for us everything that has happened today? So today we saw Jensen Wang, of course, resign. And that would have been unthinkable just five days ago. But here we are in the interim. We have had this revelation that he had an affair with somebody who is alleged to have been a Chinese spy. We now have more information about
4:07extramarital affairs that he had inside with executives at his own company. And so the board met last night. He turned in his resignation today. The new interim CEO is Colette Kress, a familiar name to people who follow this company. She's the chief financial officer, has been for the last 13 years. We hear her quarter after quarter on earnings calls. She'll be on another one this coming Tuesday. I bet there's going to be a lot more people tuning in to that one. And they have also appointed a chairperson of the board for the very first time. So Jensen Wang also resigning his position there. And they have, I think the message there is that they're going to have a little more oversight of whoever
4:51comes next than they had over Jensen Wang when he was at the helm. And Colette Kress, she's going to be leading the company temporarily. Is there a search for a permanent replacement? There is a search. They're looking inside and outside the company. She is, again, a familiar face, seen as a steady hand. But if she's not somebody with a technology background, she has a finance background. And so I do think there's a lot of speculation, obviously, including from President Trump about who will take over. But that would be one knock against Chirp. Yeah, I think he was mentioning Tim Cook. We'll have to see how that goes. Lily Jamali in Santa Clara, California, outside the headquarters of NVIDIA.
5:36Thank you so much for joining us. So how are investors reacting? Stephen Yu is chief investment officer of Blue Whale Growth Fund, which holds more than $300 million worth of NVIDIA shares. He gave his reaction to my colleague, Luke Wilson. So firstly, it's extremely disappointing that Jensen has got himself into these situations, given that he has been an instrumental part of NVIDIA's success in the last, I would say, 30 years, especially in the last, I would say, five years. And what questions are you asking yourself now as an investor in NVIDIA? One is whether the new leadership is going to continue the strategy. Obviously, in terms of the search for a new CEO is still ongoing. So it might take some weeks or months for that to settle
6:23down. So that is something as an investor, we need to assess whether the new person is going to be doing a better job than Jensen going forward. And secondly, I think it's important to separate Jensen's issue versus what the company has achieved so far in terms of its competitive positioning, in terms of its product, and also in terms of all these relationships they have with suppliers and customers. And with Stephen Yu, Chief Investment Officer of Blue Whale Growth Fund. Well, the uncertainty has certainly been felt on Wall Street. NVIDIA has been one of the biggest winners from the artificial intelligence boom, and its extraordinary rise has helped drive the wider US stock market higher. So let's talk to Susanna Streeter, Chief Investment Strategist at Wealth Club.
7:10Susanna, hello. Hello. So what happened to the share price today? Well, as expected, because indications were certainly in pre-market trading that there was going to be a big slide. And that indeed happened for a few hours. But actually, then the shares recovered somewhat, falling in the end down 5.4%. They did drop as much as 14% earlier in the session. But I think there was a lot of bargain hunting going on, particularly by retail investors after that really aggressive sell-off. Because shares are down 30% since the all-time high a little over a month ago. But there are plenty of investors who are still betting that given Nvidia's highly dominant position, its competitive advantages and deep cash pockets,
7:55it has space to weather the storm, and they feel that its established customer relationships will survive this leadership transition. Yeah, by the dip, as the kids say these days, as retail investors. But what's this tell us about how investors valued Huang as a leader? Well, I think the very fact that we've seen the stock slide so dramatically down by around a third, it really does show that there's huge disappointment that he has left this absolutely central position. He was really at the heart of the AI revolution, the poster boy for all of these AI advances, given just how NVIDIA had become something of a central bank for the AI trade, not just supplying the scarce resource needed to build and run AI. It's been financing the build out, partly by taking
8:43equity stakes in its customers and developing hugely complex financial arrangements. So it's really at the heart of it. And I think that's why you've seen the share price fall dramatically. And there is this real feeling that NVIDIA has lost a visionary. We'll have to see what happens. I mean, Colette, certainly the CFO, Colette Kress, she's been at the company for 13 years. She's seen as a safe pair of hands. I think that's why the share price did steady. But they are going to have to find a new longer term CEO to really lead the company, because it's got to be at the real edge of the AI frontier to make sure it's still staying ahead of the competition. Yeah, and its earnings are due next week. How important will they be?
9:31I think they're going to be extremely important given just how fragile sentiment has been around the company. We have become used to NVIDIA always beating expectations. And I think the market is going to want to see a really big beat again. And of course, it comes at a time when there's a lot of uncertainty evolving after the midterms about potential slowdown, the build out of data centres, which of course would have repercussions for NVIDIA as well as other AI giants. So we're riding on those results. Absolutely. Well, Susanna, you stay right there because even without Jensen Huang, NVIDIA remains a company with enormous power over the global technology industry. The company's been around for over three decades. Its chips are in huge demand. Its order books are full
10:19and rival companies, they're still struggling to compete. And in fact, it controls 80% of market share. And earlier, I spoke to Chris Miller, the author of the book Chip Wars, and one of the leading historians of the industry. And he told me how much of NVIDIA's success has been down to Jensen Huang personally. Well, Jensen has run the company for 33 years. And so much of the success does depend on him. He deserves credit for building the company into one of the success does depend on him. He deserves credit for building the company into one of the world's leading chip makers. And perhaps more importantly than that, in over a decade ago, betting heavily on AI at a time when most people thought it would never
10:55produce a commercially viable product. And so the company faces a real dilemma when it looks at its next CEO. There's no obvious internal successor, but it's also hard to imagine someone coming from the outside and leading a company that has been so used to a single person atop it for so long. And it's dominated the market for AI chips. So does his departure create an opportunity perhaps for competitors like AMD and Broadcom? Or is NVIDIA simply too far ahead at this point? Well, I think a lot depends on how much of a distraction this will be for NVIDIA. It seems to me that it could create a fair amount of chaos, not just the CEO resigning, but Congress is going to investigate a broad array of issues,
11:39above all how an alleged Chinese agent could get so close to the leader of such an important company. And so I would expect that in Congress, as well as the board, there are going to be a series of investigations that will take up a lot of time of NVIDIA's senior leadership, which will make it difficult for the company to keep competing in such a competitive market. Yeah, and the company, it's not just selling chips to AI companies, it's also investing billions in some of those very businesses themselves. You know, so how important is NVIDIA to the wider AI ecosystem? companies, it's also investing billions in some of those very businesses themselves. You know, so how important is NVIDIA to the wider AI ecosystem?
12:16NVIDIA's invested extensively in many of the newer companies that have emerged around AI, not just OpenAI and Anthropic, but an array of other providers of cloud services or open source models. And if NVIDIA pulls back on those investments, it'll have a big impact across the AI ecosystem. Yeah, and we've seen such enormous sums of money pouring into artificial intelligence, much of it ending up with NVIDIA. So are we seeing investors reassessing the foundations of that AI boom? I think investors are certainly asking tough questions of NVIDIA itself. And one of the concerns is that it loses market share to its competitors that are now able to race ahead as NVIDIA faces weeks or months of confusion.
12:56So what will this do to the US-China chip race? Because Jensen Huang, he's been very influential for arguing for continued sales of American chips to China. And without him, could we see Washington maybe take a much tougher approach to restricting China's access to that AI technology? Well, NVIDIA's argument has been that it's OK to sell chips to China because they're only used for commercial purposes. But that's a harder argument to make now that we know one of the key customers in Southeast Asia that was in turn providing compute to China was actually run by a Chinese intelligence asset. And I think that's going to drive Congress to push the Trump administration to crack down on some of the chips that are flowing directly to China,
13:41as well as some of the chips that are ending up in data centers in countries like those in Southeast Asia that are then in turn rented onwards to Chinese customers. And if that happens, does it strengthen America's position in the global AI race? Well, it probably does, because for many Chinese technology companies like Alibaba or ByteDance, they rely very heavily on NVIDIA chips still. They can get some quantities smuggled physically into China, but a lot of the computing power those firms access is actually outside of China in data centers that are full of NVIDIA chips. Chris, if NVIDIA's technology remains the industry leader, does it really matter who's running the company? Well, I think that's a big if,
14:21and we'll see if NVIDIA's next leader can keep it at the technology frontier. NVIDIA's employees and its investors are certainly hoping so, but I think Jensen's been a unique leader, and it won't be easy to replace him. That was Chris Miller, the author of the book Chip Wars. Well, there's another big question hanging all over this. How did a company worth trillions of dollars become so closely tied to the fortunes of one man? Jensen Huang founded NVIDIA back in 1993, and he's been at the helm ever since, helping to turn it from a relatively small graphics chip business into one of the most influential companies in the world. But his departure has raised difficult questions about the role of NVIDIA's board and whether it was properly prepared for life after
15:05its founder. I've been speaking to Dr. Jeffrey Sonfeld, a professor in leadership studies at Yale University, and I asked him if recent events are the result of a company being too dependent on Huang. Clearly the case, and he designed it that way, to have no threats. These monarchs, they create the brand around themselves. They have a mission, which is a truly immortal mission in their mind, that their longevity depends on their work as a net contributor to society. That's what it was. And he started to believe in his own greatness. But this is the guy who really created the CUDA software, which drives AI, and the GPUs, which some argue are perhaps overused or oversold. But these highly valuable chips are something that he designed and helped to promote.
15:58That's had a transformational effect on an industry that was 50 years old. And maybe I'm being naive here, Geoffrey, but how is it that such a company of that size, the biggest chip company in the world, could find itself in an uncertain position over succession? I mean, NVIDIA had three decades to prepare for life after Jensen Huang. These monarchs believe that there is on earth one person indispensable, and they know who that is. And they, again, only leave office by dying in office or a palace revolt. They don't leave office willingly. They love their jobs. And they create a management team that's not a threat. To have 60 direct reports and no actual management committee is not an accident.
16:41He doesn't have to worry about anybody rising up as a threat in his management lieutenant team. And then also on his board, there's nobody there that's run a public company that has spoken to outside constituencies and has an external following. So their legitimacy is almost like through a filial piety back to him. This is a similar kind of thing that Elon Musk has on his board. It's not chock full of former CEOs that have independent standing and authority. It's people that are there that are beholden to him. And that's the same thing as Elon Musk and the Tesla board. Well, that's a good point because there's so many founder-led technology companies out there. You've got Tesla, SpaceX, Meta, Anthropic, the list goes on.
17:27So is this a bit of a warning for those companies now? There's a clear fork in the road. There's a choice. By contrast, you can look at Michael Dell, who started his company at age 19 in his college dorm room. And he put a board together immediately filled with highly experienced senior leaders, including CEOs of other companies. Even right now, CEOs of airlines, chemical companies, things with different models that would churn the water and cause them to think. And Michael Dell is very self-critical. He doesn't have the ego, of course, of these other people we're talking about, but he has the courage. He's really visionary. He's challenging his own business by working on on-premises computing. Nobody else
18:09does that if you have the kind of religious zealotry, perhaps, of Musk or of Justin Wong, whereas Michael Dell looks to try to keep changing what they're doing. If you can build a board that provides some degree of self-criticism and a good mirror to hold yourself accountable. Well, I have one last question for you. US President Donald Trump has weighed in. He suggested that Tim Cook should take over. So what do you make of that suggestion? Well, it certainly would make things a lot easier for President Trump to no longer get tongue-tied and accidentally, as he did a few times, call him Tim Apple. That will seem a little stranger now. And I don't think that he'd be able to stumble his way into Tim NVIDIA. That really would be a stretch. So this will be good for everybody's
18:56nomenclature and identity crisis. But I actually, putting all pathetic humor aside, is that Tim Cook is fantastic. He's another one of these tech titans with precious little ego. He knows how to manage people with egos. He obviously knew how to circumvent the ire of President Trump, but he also has a remarkably good relationship with the Chinese. He's had a reassuring effect on regulators. Technologists have liked working with him. But what happened under Tim Cook, this company has grown 30 times beyond what Steve Jobs left us, his legacy, as brilliant as it was. That's amazing. So that he can take somebody else's creation and take it light years forward with very little ego. So he would do a remarkably great job.
19:43And I don't want to diminish the CFO who stepped in. I think Colette Kress is excellent. And there are many times where a CFO actually can take their business light years forward. But this is on one of those occasions where I would agree with President Trump. That was Dr. Jeffrey Sonnefeld, Professor in Leadership Studies at Yale University. You're with World Business Report from the BBC World Service. Balance your trading strategy by adding futures. CME Group helps you manage risk and capture opportunities in all market environments. Capitalize on around-the-clock access to highly liquid global futures and options markets across all major asset classes. Visit your online broker and get started.
20:22See what adding futures can do for you at cmegroup.com forward slash podcast. Derivatives are not suitable for all investors and involve the risk of losing more than the amount originally deposited and any profit you might have made. This is not a recommendation or offer to buy, sell, or attain any specific investment or service. The ocean delights us as playful otters restore coastal kelp forests. The ocean teaches us how our choices impact even the deepest places. The ocean connects us. Visit montereybayaquarium.org slash connects. The UK luxury retailer Burberry's latest results are in, and its sales rose 4% in the three months to September this year. That's booking a trend in the luxury sector.
21:06Susanna Streeter is still with us. Doing well, it seems. Doing very well. Returning to profit. And what it is, is a back to basic strategy that is driving strong sales of the British brand's coats, jackets and handbags. And this was really evident over the summer. We've heard from Joshua Shulman, the chief executive, and he said that the luxury brand really has outperformed in a challenging luxury market. Because of course, due to the war with Iran, sales actually fell 1% in Europe and the Middle East. Not surprising, given how so many flights have been grounded and malls have been emptied. However, sales rose 15% in China and 14% in the Americas. So certainly where Burberry was able to attract custom, its styles were working.
21:57And also it's been focusing on this pyramid of pricing, ranging, putting out items, more affordable items, starting from quite low, really, to less than $100, to top-tier bags and coats, which can cost more than $9,000. And then more broadly, the UK economy actually grew by 0.7% in the third quarter, quickest pace since 2024. Was it an economy all around, maybe? Yeah, again, the UK economy has confounded expectations. Interestingly, the whole programme's been about AI and the big sums being poured into artificial intelligence are actually starting to be felt across the wider economy because you look at what it's contributing towards growth. It seems small, 0.15 percentage points to overall GDP growth,
22:45but certain sectors like computer programming, consultancy, jumping 4.4%, so it's having that real effect. All right, Susanna Streeter, Chief Investment Strategist at Wealth Club, thank you so much for joining us. Now, Manchester United are facing another hefty bill after sacking manager Michael Carrick less than six months after appointing him. Club seems set to bring in Maurizio Pochettino, who's currently in charge of the US men's national team. But with the United struggling near the bottom of the English Premier League and the club's owners already under pressure over their cost-cutting measures, how much could this latest managerial shake-up cost? Ciarán Maguire is a football finance expert
23:26and he's crunched the numbers for us. I think we take a look at the costs. First of all, you're going to have to pay Michael Carrick compensation. Now, Manchester United have spent around about $120 million since Sir Alex Ferguson retired in 2013. This will probably be a single million dollars because he only had a two-year contract. And if Mauricio Pochettino is, as is predicted, the new person to become Manchester United manager, I think he has a release clause of around about $8 million in his contract. But to put that in context, relegation from the Premier League could hit Manchester United to somewhere in the region of $300 million of lost revenue. So I think you have to put it in some form of context.
24:16So it's a financial burden they almost have to take on in a way. That's right. And it's part of the way that football operates. We've seen Chelsea regularly put through some very high charges. The cost of dismissing Ruben Amorim earlier this year, that ended up around about $10 million for Manchester United. And I think the biggest one that they had to pay out was Jose Mourinho. And that was around about $25 million. If you sign people to a long-term contract, you get the benefit in the sense that they can't go elsewhere. But if the club chooses to terminate, then they have to go and pay up a large section of the contract. The interesting thing is, though, Sir Jim Ratcliffe has overseen major cost cutting,
24:59including job losses at the club, and he's spending so much on managers. So how difficult is that to justify? Well, I think there is a case for being patient in football. If you take a look at other very successful managers, ironically, Sir Alex Ferguson himself, he didn't win a single trophy for four years. It took him six years to win the Premier League. And then he created the dynasty that we've seen at Manchester United. It took the current Premier League champions Arsenal. Mikel Arteta was there for six years before he won that trophy. Another high profile manager, Jurgen Klopp. It took him five years to turn things around at Liverpool. So the revolving door strategy, which has been employed by Ineos and Jim Ratcliffe's predecessors over the course of the last decade, and then Jim Ratcliffe himself, does appear to be a very short-sighted one.
25:56You've got to give managers the time to turn around the supertanker, which is a club of the stature of Manchester United. Yeah, so do you think that's raising questions about how the Glazers and Ineos are ultimately running Man United? And is there anybody being held accountable for these expensive decisions, apart from the manager themselves, who keep going out the door? Well, it does seem to me that the manager is a convenient fall guy, because if you take a look at any business, and I teach at a business school, you focus on business success. And it comes down to three elements. First of all, resources. Now Manchester United have the biggest stadium in the Premier League. They have the biggest fan base.
26:37They are certainly the most popular team in terms of social media engagement and popularity with sponsors. They're very much up there. So they've got an A-plus when it comes to that metric. You then look at the opportunities that the business can generate. Manchester United's in the Premier League. It's in the Champions League as well. So you get nothing better. The Premier League is the most valuable domestic competition. The Champions League is the most valuable domestic competition. The Champions League is the most valuable international competition. And then it comes down to senior management and their decision making. Why is Apple a success? And we don't talk about BlackBerrys anymore because Apple got those decisions right.
27:19And I think it could be questioned as to whether Ginios and Jim Ratcliffe have been getting those decisions right since they acquired the club a couple of years ago. Yeah, and despite everything, lots of billionaires would love to own Man United, wouldn't they? They would, and I'm sure if the club was up for sale, and for all we know at this present moment in time, there could be discreet inquiries made. That's the nature of the football business and everything can be negotiated if the price is right. Manchester United's a stellar brand as far as global sports are concerned and there's no doubt that it will be attractive. At the same time, the egos of the current incumbents are such that they want to be seen
28:00to be the people that have brought success and that's why they might want to stick around for a bit longer. That was football finance expert Ciarán Maguire. And that is it from World Business Report from the BBC World Service. If you want to listen back, just subscribe to us. Wherever you get your podcasts, just search for World Business Report. I'm Leanna Byrne. Have a great day. Thanks for listening. The The The The You know, the Global Tech Company is Ohio's newest business. With so many tech companies investing in Ohio, it's become the Silicon Heartland. Hmm, I guess I need to check out Ohio. Ohio has it all. You can find out more at successinohio.com. Yep, successinohio.com. This is the story of the one.
29:02The shipping manager who's there before the first truck backs in and the first pallet is loaded, coordinating schedules, clearing bottlenecks, keeping freight moving. He counts on Grainger for the industrial-grade products he needs to stay ready, from shipping supplies to PPE to hand tools, so when the doors roll up, he's ready to roll. Call 1-800-GRAINGER, clickgrainger.com, or just stop by. Granger, for the ones who get it done.

