podcasts / Wake Up to Money / episode
Wake Up to Money cover art
podcast
📅 2026-11-12 ⏱ 52 min episode · ~2 min read 📝 Transcript · 10,909 words

The Jensen Huang affairs

Wake Up to Money · · Transcript & summary by WhipScribe

It is a fast, practical read on how a chipmaker's leadership crisis, UK growth and rising business costs connect, with named analysts giving concrete numbers.

In this episodeNvidiaJensen HuangKimberly PowellRay WongAnna McDonaldEmma Heathcote-JamesPoundlandGordon BrothersHeathrow AirportPaul Batts

▸Chapters

Tap a chapter to open that moment in the transcript; the link to it is copied for you.

Transcribe your links. Paste a YouTube, Google Drive or podcast link and WhipScribe gives you the transcript. Transcribe a link →

▸Notable quotes

“Jensen only has 3.7% of the shares.” Ray Wong · at 7:22 — open in the transcript →
“AI is not the only thing that's going to be driving the number of jobs in the future.” Tara Alice · at 27:23 — open in the transcript →

▸What this episode covers

The Nvidia leadership crisis dominates this Wake Up to Money episode. Nvidia's board says it is investigating a second affair by chief executive Jensen Huang, and the New York Times reports it involves a senior executive. Analyst Ray Wong argues the board must weigh governance, the chance that more relationships come to light, and a congressional hearing. The panel agrees it is hard to picture Nvidia without Huang, whose personal relationships and long bet on AI have shaped the firm.

The second theme is the UK economy and AI. Anna McDonald expects third-quarter growth of about 1.8 to 1.9 percent, helped by business investment, though household budgets remain squeezed. Tara Alice says growth is concentrated in AI-linked business services while consumer sectors such as hospitality stay muted. Jaeger, from the legal-tech firm Luminance, describes contract review that once took a year now taking minutes, and argues that clients are beginning to question whether they need contracts at all. Emma Heathcote-James, who runs a soap company, says rising costs from every direction mean sales growth does not automatically mean profit.

The last segments turn to costs in everyday businesses. Poundland's creditor protection and rescue deadline are discussed alongside the high street damage done when large chains leave, with Paul Batts arguing that independent shops need reasons to draw people into town. An airline industry group warns that air passenger duty, jet fuel prices and possible Heathrow expansion charges could push travellers toward Paris. The programme closes with a government change ending the double levy on glass for hospitality venues from April 2027.

▸The Jensen Huang affairs on Wake Up to Money: the answers

Who is Ray Wong?

Ray Wong

Ray Wong is the principal analyst and founder of Constellation Research and a veteran Silicon Valley tech analyst. He was on the programme to analyse the Nvidia leadership situation.

Who is Anna McDonald?

Anna McDonald

Anna McDonald is investment strategy director at Hargreaves Lansdowne and was a regular panel voice on the economy and markets.

Who is Emma Heathcote-James?

Emma Heathcote-James

Emma Heathcote-James is the founder and owner of The Little Soap Company, a British manufacturer speaking about business costs.

Who is Tara Alice?

Tara Alice

Tara Alice is an honorary professor at the Productivity Institute at Manchester University and a regular Friday guest on the programme.

Who is Paul Batts?

Paul Batts

Paul Batts owns an outdoors and active independent shop in Weston-super-Mare and chairs the town's business improvement district.

What did Ray Wong say about Nvidia?

Ray Wong said Nvidia does not have a dual-class share structure and that Jensen Huang holds only a small stake, so the board must decide whether Huang keeps his position. He argued the board has to look at governance carefully, given a second affair and a congressional hearing coming up.

“Jensen only has 3.7% of the shares.”Ray Wong · 7:22

What did Tara Alice say about AI and UK jobs?

Tara Alice said AI is one factor among several shaping UK job numbers, alongside an ageing population that needs more healthcare and social care. She expects some jobs to disappear and others to grow, and on balance thinks there will be more jobs, with a big shift in where they are.

“AI is not the only thing that's going to be driving the number of jobs in the future.”Tara Alice · 27:23

What did Anna McDonald say about Jensen Huang?

Anna McDonald said investors become concerned when a chief executive has a relationship with a subordinate, because it can look like an abuse of power and conflicts with good governance. She also linked Huang to conflicts of interest, since his influence on US rules on chip exports to China is a concern for investors.

“there are problems with having subordinate, a relationship with a subordinate that can be seen as an abuse of power”Anna McDonald · 10:36

What did Paul Batts say about Poundland?

Paul Batts said Poundland took on the old Woolworths building at the centre of Weston-super-Mare's high street. He said big empty units are hard to fill with independent shops because rents and rates are too high, which makes losing a big name such as Poundland a real problem for the town.

“the rent and rates are just too high”Paul Batts · 33:18

What is the main news on the Jensen Huang affairs episode of Wake Up to Money?

Nvidia's board said it was investigating a second affair by CEO Jensen Huang, this time with an executive the company had not known about, which the New York Times identified as Kimberly Powell. The Wall Street Journal reported the board was preparing to oust Huang, and the company declined to comment on his future.

Mentioned in this episode

Episode facts

Released
November 12, 2026
Length
52 minutes

▸Key takeaways

01Nvidia's board is investigating a second affair by CEO Jensen Huang, reported by the New York Times as involving vice president Kimberly Powell.
02Jensen Huang owns only 3.7% of Nvidia's shares and the company has no dual-class structure, so the board, not his stake, decides his future.
03Nvidia shares fell well over 5% on Wednesday, and futures pointed to a drop of more than 8% before the next market open.
04Ray Wong says Nvidia has no clear succession plan, naming CUDA architect Ian Buck and CFO Colette Kress as the likeliest internal interim candidates.
05Anna McDonald of Hargreaves Lansdowne says Huang's influence over US rules on chip sales to China raises conflict-of-interest concerns for investors.

▸Questions this episode answers

Q1What did Ray Wong say about Jensen Huang's future at Nvidia?

Ray Wong, principal analyst at Constellation Research, said the Nvidia board must weigh a second extramarital affair by Jensen Huang, whether more relationships could surface, and a coming congressional hearing. He noted that Huang owns only 3.7% of the shares and that Nvidia has no dual-class structure, so the key question is whether long-time backers still support him.

Q2Who could replace Jensen Huang as Nvidia CEO?

Ray Wong named two internal candidates for an interim role: Ian Buck, vice president of hyperscale and high-performance computing and the architect of CUDA, and Colette Kress, the chief financial officer. He also named two outside options, Rene Haas of Arm, a proven chip-market CEO who once worked at Nvidia, and Lisa Su of AMD, a wild card if Nvidia bought AMD.

Q3Why did Nvidia's shares fall after the Jensen Huang affair reports?

Nvidia shares fell well over 5% on Wednesday, and futures pointed to a drop of more than 8% before the next open. The fall followed the board's statement that it was investigating a second affair by Huang, this time with someone inside the company the board had not known about. The New York Times reported that the executive was Kimberly Powell, the company's vice president of healthcare, and that the board was preparing to oust Huang.

Q4Do investors care about a CEO's private life? What did Anna McDonald say?

Anna McDonald, investment strategy director at Hargreaves Lansdowne, said investors care when a chief executive has a relationship with a subordinate, because it can look like an abuse of power and conflicts with governance. She also flagged that the first story potentially involves a Chinese spy, and that Jensen Huang has influenced US government decisions to allow less advanced chips to be sold to China, which raises conflicts of interest.

Q5How does Tara Alice say AI is affecting UK jobs and growth?

Tara Alice, honorary professor at the Productivity Institute at Manchester University, said recent UK growth has been driven by business investment and by sectors involved in AI, especially business services, while consumer-driven sectors such as hospitality have been more muted. She said the labour market is cooling mainly through slower hiring rather than firing, and expects AI to create some jobs and remove others, with more jobs overall.

Q6What did Paul Batts say about high streets and independent shops?

Paul Batts, owner of an outdoors and active shop in Weston-super-Mare and chairman of the town's business improvement district, said Poundland took over the old Woolworths building in the middle of the high street. He argued that when big names leave, their large units are hard to fill with independents because rents and rates are too high, and that shoppers need a reason to come into town.

Q7What did Emma Heathcote-James say about rising costs for small British businesses?

Emma Heathcote-James, founder of The Little Soap Company, said her business is being squeezed from every direction, including ingredients, energy, transport, packaging, employment and regulation. She said growing sales and growing profits are very different things at the moment. She still said she is optimistic and that the company is investing in infrastructure.

▸Transcript

Our own transcript of the public episode, with a timestamp about every 90 seconds. Tap a timestamp or the link button on a paragraph to copy a link that opens this page there.

0:00This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK. online broker and get started. See what adding futures can do for you at cmegroup.com forward slash podcast. Derivatives are not suitable for all investors and involve the risk of losing more than the amount originally deposited and any profit you might have made. This is not a recommendation or offer to buy, sell, or attain any specific investment or service. Day or night, VerboCare is here 24-7 to help make every part of your stay seamless. If anything comes up or you simply need a little guidance, support is ready whenever you reach out. From the moment you book to the moment you head home, we're here to help things run smoothly. Because a great trip starts with the

1:00right support. And hey, a good playlist doesn't hurt either. sharply again yesterday after reports that Mr Wang had another affair and that his board was moving to Austin. We'll have the very latest. Also on the programme today, Heathrow Airport could lose business to European rivals like Paris because it's too expensive to operate there. That's according to the industry group that represents the biggest airlines in America. And also on the programme today, we'll be taking a look at glass. Well, the rules around packaging taxes and how much businesses have to pay for processing it. Wake Up To Money with Will Bain. Morning. Welcome to Wake Up To Money on Thursday, the 12th of November. Will with you this morning, a little startled, as is our guest, Anna McDonald,

1:59by the glass smashing sound effects at four minutes past five in the morning. It certainly woke us all up. Welcome to the programme. Anna, I think I've said this lots of times recently, but it feels like we're going to have a very, very busy programme. Yeah, absolutely. The news just keeps on coming. It does. Anna MacDonald, the Investment Strategy Director at Hargoofs Lansdowne, is here in the studio with me this morning and going to be with us for the full hour, alongside Anna for the next hour as well. Emma Heathcote-James is with us. Emma is the founder and owner of The Little Soap Company. Morning, Emma. How are you? Good morning, Will. I'm fine, thank you. Hopefully no glass smashing around you at home, Geordie, just down the line.

2:33No glass here. Good. How's business going at the moment? Business is really good. It's certainly challenging, of course. It's never a dull day. Yeah, we've just had our King's Award for Enterprise presentation a couple of weeks ago. We had a big barn dance in the Cotswolds with the team and suppliers. So, yeah, everyone's in good spirit. That seems a good way to celebrate. So we were talking about this a little bit on the programme yesterday. So what is that? A bit of consumer confidence that you're seeing? Consumer confidence, yes. But equally, like so many other independent British manufacturers, we're totally facing rising costs from every single direction ingredients, energy, transport, packaging, employment

3:10and increasingly regulation so it is becoming, it's really quite painful Well that's going to be a big part of the conversation we're going to have in about 15 minutes or so we're going to be joined as well by some more guests to chat through we've got GDP numbers today they're for the third quarter of the year it's seven o'clock from the ONS so we're going to dig into a load of that. And Emma's going to be well placed, as you can hear already, to kind of give us a sense of what's going on, whether the momentum that we've had or the resilience, I guess, it's been, hasn't it, Anna, through the summer, whether that sticks with us. So we've got big news on the UK economy we're going to dig into. We're going to hear about that warning

3:41from Airlines for America. Chris Sununu, quite a big name in US politics as well, been over here in London for a conference. He's warning about costs that he throw, the cost of that extra runway. We'll hear from him in the second half of the programme too. And we will also be checking in on Poundland, of course, because we've been telling you all week about that sort of crunch meeting with the Business Select Committee. Of course, the deadline today, this sort of moratorium that Poundland has had with its creditors, the sort of payment freeze window with its creditors, that expires today, sounding like, from what our business editor Simon Jack was hearing overnight, that there will be an extension both to that and in the time to try and find a rescue deal for Poundland.

4:23We will be digging into all of that today. So as I say, on a really busy program, we'd love to know your thoughts as we move through it. 85058 is the text number to get in touch. 08085 99693 is the WhatsApp. But we have to start once again with the chipmaker, Nvidia. Stocks falling really sharply. They were down well over 5% again yesterday. And looking at the futures markets this morning, down more than 8% in terms of anticipation for when that market opens again. It's because the NVIDIA board says it's now investigating a second affair by the chief executive, Jensen Huang. This one, it sounds like, with someone inside the company that the company wasn't aware of. The Wall Street Journal reported that the NVIDIA board is preparing to oust the NVIDIA chief executive

5:10and meeting. Well, as we speak, still ongoing, obviously, about 9pm in Silicon Valley at the moment. Our correspondent there, Lily Jamali, brought us the latest. We don't exactly know, but it doesn't look good for Jensen Wang at this point. I've been in touch with NVIDIA throughout this evening. At this point, they are telling me they are not commenting on Mr. Wang's future. But according to our partners at CBS, the board of NVIDIA is meeting reportedly and is potentially going to oust Mr. Wang from the position that he has held for the last 30 plus years. He's a co-founder of NVIDIA and has been at the top for all these many decades. The news of this second affair reported by the New York Times seems to be what has precipitated

5:58this latest move. That also, again, coming from another outlet, but I have been speaking with sources inside the company who have said that there were questions about a potential relationship between Mr. Wang and this particular executive way back to 2017. And that executive, according to the New York Times, is Kimberly Powell, the chipmaker's vice president of healthcare. Not looking good for Jensen Huang, Anna. Not looking good. Lily and I recorded a podcast last night at 6 p.m. our time, what everybody needed to know on the World Service about NVIDIA. It's not looking very good for that podcast. No, I think it's probably dated it. We're going to be recording that at some point today. Ray Wong is back with us.

6:39If you were with us earlier in the week, you know that Ray is the principal analyst and founder of Constellation Research, a veteran Silicon Valley tech analyst. Morning, Ray. Good morning. Oh, my God. Yeah, quite, quite. Life comes at you fast, I think is the cliche, right? Yes, it does. What was it, even 24 hours ago, 48 hours ago, that you and I were talking here and you thought he might just about survive. It doesn't look good now. It does not look good. And part of the reason is the second extramarital affair. But it's also the question is, are there any more? And I think with that and a congressional hearing coming down, the board members have to look at governance very carefully. And when you look at

7:22this, this company does not have a dual class structure. Jensen only has 3.7% of the shares. And so the question is, will the longtime backers, Mark Stevens and Tench Cox, you know, that support NVIDIA still be around to help them out? And will Stephen Neal at Cooley also be there for him? And so this is a question is, does he have the votes or does he not have the votes? And then what are the succession candidates as a number of those names have been floating around right now? Yeah, I mean, it's interesting, isn't it, that we don't hear much about those succession plans ahead of time, because, you know, it could be for several reasons that a CEO actually has to suddenly depart. So the fact

7:59that there's not one set up is quite strange and shows that, I mean, despite his small shareholding, his impact has just been pretty enormous. And maybe it hasn't been possible to even imagine a sort of post-Wang world, which is one that we're definitely, well, it sounds like we're going to be facing. Ray, has that been something of a problem here? I mean, we had Stephen Witt, one of the biographers of Jensen Wang and the Rise of Nvidia on the programme a little earlier in the week. And I kind of put it to Stephen, you know, is there anybody in the company who can say no to Jensen? Is there anybody he listens to when he says, I think you might be going down the wrong path here? And Stephen answered in one word, no. Is that your experience of it too? And how much of an issue is that when

8:37you come to, I guess, a crossroads like this? Look, it's the founder CEO models we talk about. And the answer is no, I completely agree. But there are two individuals, if they have to do interim, they'll probably put them in charge in that way, should Jensen really be removed. One of them is Ian Buck. He's the VP of hyperscale and high-performance computing. He's the one that was the architect for CUDA. That's the software that sits on top of the chips, and that's the biggest innovation in NVIDIA that was part of it. The second one is Colette Kress. She is the CFO. She's been responsible for managing the earnings ship and keeping the company in line. And so she would be the second internal candidate.

9:17But we also think there are two other candidates. One is Rene Haas at ARM. He had worked at NVIDIA before, and he's a proven CEO in the chip market. And of course, it would be interesting if NVIDIA bought AMD and brought Dr. Lisa Su on board. And so that's the wild card in the space. Really, really interesting. Emma, as our kind of business leader, our business owner here, all of our business panelists this week, kind of bosses in your role on the program, have kind of talked about their shock. And obviously, because it's the second largest company in the world, none of you run a company that's as big as that. But all of you shocked at the kind of lack of governance structures, rules, I guess.

9:56Why is it so important? Because we've seen, particularly when relationships happen inside companies that boards don't know about, we've seen it here in the UK, haven't we, that chief executives have gone, that boards have thought that's the final straw. Why is that trust, I suppose, so important at the top of a company, do you think? I think trust is imperative, isn't it? And I think that's where being a challenger brand, we have that benefit that we're so agile and we can we can you know we've got we've got that ability to kind of bend and flex which bigger companies don't the bigger the bigger the company gets that there's no responsibility is there Anna we've had a couple of texts in about

10:36over the week as well when we've covered this story and I'd love to get an investor's perspective who cares you know what he does in his private life is up to him. Do investors care what he gets up to in his private life? When they care, I think is when there are, I mean, there are problems with having subordinate, a relationship with a subordinate that can be seen as an abuse of power, which is not a sort of, it's not something that someone hot on governance and hot on wanting to keep the ethics of a company intact. That's not something you want to see. And remember, the first story is potentially involving a Chinese spy. Now, that is a very significant impact because Jensen Wang has been key

11:17in influencing the U.S. government to allow the chips that aren't at the very forefront, that aren't at the bleeding edge, allowing those to be imported to China. So it does bring up various conflicts of interest. And it's just, you know, NVIDIA has been the market leader. It is a significant weighting of the index, even now. It's something crazy, isn't it? If you have £100 in the S&P 500, what is it? £6 or £7 will be in Nvidia. But remember what's been happening over the last few days is that stocks always move. They're part of a whole index. We've seen otherwise a recovery in lots of the AI names. We've seen some of the competitors such as AMD, which is a direct competitor, Broadcom and Alphabet, who've been developing alternatives,

12:12these TPUs, they're called, processing units. There are AI specialists. Remember, NVIDIA started off as video gaming chips that turned out to be very good for training large language models. So there are other shifts happening in the index and in those big companies in that index. So where you might lose from NVIDIA, you will be gaining from other stocks. So the companies don't move just in isolation. Ray, Anna used that phrase, influence, of that kind of list that you gave us, really kind of useful primary of who may be next as we as it looks closer and closer doesn't it to jensen wang being out the door is your concern as someone who kind of invests in the sector and knows the sector so well

12:55that the next person through the door just can't possibly have the same influences as jensen wang has had at a time where you know government and regulation has been the thing, as Anna was just touching on, that's kind of been moving markets a lot. It will be very different if someone else were to take in charge. And I think that's part of the challenge with the key person, key man risk here that's going on with NVIDIA because Jensen's personal relationships have driven this. His passion for AI, his passion for investing in those startups while they were early, all across the board. And that's really what's driven this, his passion for AI, his passion for investing in those startups while they were early, all across the board.

13:27And that's really what's driven this. It's a singular vision of where AI is supposed to go. And that's very hard to replicate. But the good news is like when Steve Jobs had left and passed away, I mean, the roadmap is there. The team can execute on it, but it's not at the same level. It won't be at the same relationships. And I think that's what the board is going to have to weigh is, will we still be effective as a company without Jensen? Can NVIDIA exist without Jensen? And are the charges against him, those charges severe enough to remove him from the company? Anna mentioned perhaps some other winners on the US stock market, but Ray, is the only real winner, someone you mentioned, I think, in your very first answer to us earlier in the week, anybody involved in AI in China?

14:11It is, unfortunately. If we slow down our race versus China, it is a race between the US and China. That could be the big issue in terms of slowing down US's capability and the Western world's capability to develop AI with our Western values and our sense of what is right and wrong. Ray, really appreciate you staying up for us again. And glad that your shock was as much as ours for these latest developments as well. And hopefully, we'll have you back on again soon. Perhaps running us through one of those people you had on the list for the next boss. Thank you. The story keeps on giving. It certainly does. Ray Wagner, Principal Analyst and Founder of Constellation Research and a veteran Silicon Valley tech analyst. 85058, what do you reckon are the latest with all of that?

14:56Let's turn away then from international, well, is it business news, international espionage news, international scandal, international tabloid news, I guess, to an extent as well, and turn to matters close to home, because it's seven o'clock this morning, we're going to get the latest GDP figures. So that sort of temperature test really on the health of the UK economy, how we are growing the government's complete and utter obsession, isn't it? And this one, a key kind of figure, Anna, because it's also the third quarter, the three months from July to September. So people seem to tend to zoom in on this one a bit more. Yeah, absolutely. And actually the first half, growth has been pretty good.

15:29And I think that the third quarter is anticipated to actually be around 1.8%, 1.9% on an annualised basis. So that is pretty good. It puts us towards the top of the G7 countries. And it'll be something that all market participants will be watching. The Bank of England will also be watching. They raised rates last week, we know, for the first time in three years. Their next decision is mid-December. So what markets really watch for is something, you kind of want a Goldilocks number, you don't want something too strong, too hot, because then maybe there's future interest rate rises to come. You don't want anything too cold, because then that shows that the market, our economy is starting to stumble. What I think is good is that in the last couple of years,

16:21we saw quite strong first half, weaker second half of the year because of worries about the budget and the impacts and things like that. This year, we might buck that trend. And maybe that's because the rumors of the budget were very much kept quite close to the – there weren't very many rumors that didn't seem to have too much of an impact on consumer confidence. But we know that the Office of Budget Responsibility that checks the Treasury's homework has taken their GDP growth for next year from 1.6% to 1%. And that's entirely down to the Middle East crisis. They see those higher costs that we're all having to bear directly squeezing out our ability to spend on other things. So if we see a Middle East resolution

17:12and we see everything start to return a bit to normal, perhaps that growth will actually also come in through next year, which would be obviously good. Well, alongside Anna and Emma to chat through this in a bit more detail, we're also joined by one of our Friday regulars here on Wake Up to Money, Tara Alice, Honorary Professor at the Productivity Institute Research Organisation at Manchester University, and Jaeger Glacina. Jaeger is the Chief Staff at Luminance AI, one of our whole programme guests here on the programme, tech firm that works in the legal sector. And we thought Jaeger's input might be really interesting here because we know that AI has been one of the things, Anna, hasn't it,

17:46that they've been flagging the ONS that has already been having an impact around growth because of what it's doing to productivity and things like that as well. Emma, why don't you reset the table for us as well then as a business leader here. So what are you seeing? What did you see through the summer? Because these are obviously backward looking. And what are you seeing? Anna makes a good point, doesn't she? Simon French loves to talk about this every time he's on the program the sort of fast first half of the year and the slow second so what are you seeing in the sort of looking ahead to the final um three months of the year of course the UK economy you know it may be showing resilience but that doesn't necessarily translate into profitability for us so we're being squeezed

18:23in absolutely every single direction and the cost of everything is going up and up and up. So for us, growing sales and growing profits, you know, it's two very, very different things. And in terms of those costs, is it primarily the energy that Anna's talking about? Is it other things? Is it policy, as we've talked about a lot in the programme? It's everything. It's rising energy costs, it's inflation, higher interest rates, household budget pressure. You know, we've got about a lot in the programme? It's everything. It's rising energy costs, it's inflation, higher interest rates, household budget pressure. You know, we've got the cost of living, we've got regulatory costs, we've got obviously we deal with the supermarkets,

18:57so there's price pressure coming from them as well. It's absolutely everything. Tara, morning. Great to have you back on the programme. Good morning. Anything you'd add then in terms of Anna's kind of set up of what you'd be looking at today and perhaps folding in a little bit of what Emma was telling us about what she's seeing out there? Yeah, so I think I too expect continued momentum from the GDP numbers, but we'll have to see. I think the thing to watch out for is the composition of those numbers. So it's the first half of the year and I expect the third quarter to be similar. SEAPs have been very driven by business investments and by those sectors in the economy that are involved in AI in some way or another.

19:36So particularly business services, whereas the consumer side of things and sectors such as hospitality, which are more driven by consumer demand, have been more muted. And I would expect that sort of bifurcation to continue in these third quarter figures. And then we're just all watching, aren't we, around that business investment figure, whether it continues to grow. It grew by 5.2% to the second quarter. Is it going to continue to be that robust? Because if it is, then that's excellent news for productivity going forward. And it is also good news for that kind of resilience that we heard about. I think the cost of living pressures will continue to put real squeeze on consumer spending. Unfortunately, we saw in the last inflation print that while

20:27average inflation was 3.5%, the inflation essentials, the things that people actually have to buy, was about 4.8%. And so that means that, you know, there just isn't all that extra discretionary money to spend on, whether it be goods and services in our households. Well, I'll get Emma's thoughts on both of those in just a moment. But I'll say morning to Jager as well. How are you? Hi. Good, thank you. Thanks for having me, Will. So I know when you've been in the studio with us, the sort of take up and appetite, I guess, for products like yours has been, you know, crazy when you've kind of talked us through the numbers. So I guess no surprise to you that that seems to be part of the story, as Anna and Tara are saying.

21:07Not surprising to me. I think what's interesting is where the growth is coming from. So I think we should look at it as short-term and long-term growth. A lot of the short-term growth is coming from actually the building of the AI infrastructure. So companies spending billions of dollars on AI infrastructure like the data center, the chips, the developing of the models. They're really, I think, the bigger and the longer-term gains. They haven't necessarily completely arrived yet. I think we're starting to see the beginnings of what is possible. And those come from the businesses actually using the AI to make themselves more productive. And we saw the same with the internet. The investment came first and productivity followed.

21:44Would you want to break that down for people? Because we're kind of talking in abstracts a little bit here, aren't we? And sort of big terms about growth. When you break it down, when someone uses you guys' products within the legal sector, what are they benefiting from? What are they not having to do? What are they not wasting time doing? Yeah, absolutely. So one of the best things in terms of the productivity that you can get from labour productivity is breaking it down really simply. AI is allowing people and workers to complete tasks faster, automate repetitive activities and make better decisions. So when you're applying that to the legal profession, think about what lawyers deal with every single day.

22:25It's a huge amount of words and documentation. And that is just the reality. In the past, you had people spending their time reading every word and highlighting them. Today, AI can do that. It speeds far greater than what we can achieve as human beings. And it can do something that humans can't do altogether, and that is break words down into almost numbers and maths and use that to see patterns, trends, and anomalies and to make connections across words far better than any human was ever capable of doing. So it's quite exciting, really. I can give some examples of how our customers are actually using this because today we actually don't really service the law firms. We're servicing the departments within businesses who interact with contracts. So that actually goes well beyond legal

23:16departments today. We're talking about every single department in a business interacting with a contract and they do. And we recently signed a a multimillion dollar deal with a large FMCG business. They were trialing our software for free and they tested it out on a big audit task, which is highly, highly manual as they typically are. They'd worked on it the previous year with an older system that wasn't utilizing AI, more of a traditional software as a service product. And that audit task took them a year with that non-AI product. And with our Luminance product, which is an AI product, of course, it took them a year with that non-AI product. And with our Luminance product, which is an AI product, of course, it took less than five minutes. So you can't argue

23:50with results like that. I think the real test is always whether the work is getting done faster and better. And with the businesses that we're seeing in the industries that we're working with, it really is. Jager, I wanted to ask you about this. Does this mean actually that whilst I can see the enormous productivity benefits, that actually just more work ends up being created? Someone creates, who can now afford to access your service and others, creates more work and then that's more work for the other company to come back with. And it kind of builds upon itself. And suddenly you just find that there's even more legal work to be responded to all the time. And it just sort of, it creates a monster of its own. I've been thinking about

24:36this a lot over the years. I think at one point in time, I thought that is undoubtedly what's going to happen. But actually what I'm seeing now is a shift in what type of work is created. And I'm starting to see a lot of strategic thinking about better ways of doing things. And so I don't think we're just seeing an adding of the workload as more, as there's more responsiveness and more access to information and to things like justice. What we're starting to see is our customers actually start to question whether they need contracts at all. And so I'm interested to see where that goes. And for people who've not heard Jager on the program before, I should say you've got a legal background and you and all the team have as well, Jager, haven't you too?

25:18I do. Tara, the balance in there, I'm always kind of interested in this because obviously lots of those games are volume games, aren't they? How much work can you get through quickly? And evidently products like Jaeger's can do it quicker than a human being can. But when we look at the overall impact that that has on the UK economy, presumably there are people who are not being hired or contracted, particularly I'm thinking kind of smaller firms or whatever, they are the ones, right, who are most likely to turn to an AI product because it's much cheaper than hiring, you know, an in-house lawyer or paying for, you know, a firm to do it or a consultant to do some of the work in a different field.

25:57I just wonder when that's balanced out in the round, the sort of impact of job loss of people not working, not inputting into the economy for periods of time. Have we got a sense of what that balance is, what that means for the wider economy yet? Well, we don't really know in the long run what might happen there, because multiple scenarios are very possible. Right at the moment, I think what we're seeing is a kind of slight cooling of the labour market, which is showing itself up not in firing, but a slower sense of hiring. So there's a slight slowing down of the kind of churn in the labour market, but not necessarily fewer jobs as such. And the important thing to know about AI is, as we've just heard, if it makes things a lot faster, it also makes

26:42things a lot cheaper. That means there might be a lot more demand for those goods and services, which might mean that even if it's more productive, you actually need more people. So we are seeing that, for example, in the AI space itself and for software engineers, there's been worries that there won't be enough jobs for them because their jobs are now 100, 200 times more productive than they were. But actually, it's a very hot occupation to be in. And so I expect there to be some occupations where demand actually grows and some others, call center operators, for example, where indeed there's not going to be a need for a human person or that many human people anymore in the future. And the broad outcome is likely that there's going

27:23to be more jobs. Because one final thing to note is that AI is not the only thing that's going to be driving the number of jobs in the future. There's the aging population, that means more healthcare, that means more social care. There's the fact that we're all going to be a little bit more affluent. So we're going to want to spend money on experiences. And a lot of those are based on human touch human uh interactions so i think on balance there's probably going to be more jobs but there's that there's going to be a big shift in where those jobs are and emma we're right up against the news but i just want to bring us back to a couple of things that tara talked about in her first answer there because you're

27:59i think probably best placed of everybody on the panel to chat us through and so so in terms of investment business investment, what's your kind of outlook for how confident you're feeling about, you know, investing in expanding, growing, you know, new products, new people, new places. And similarly, Tara talking about the cost of living and the impact it could have on, you know, consumer facing products like yours. What are you seeing at the moment as well? I think despite all the challenges, I'm really, really optimistic. We're investing. We're spending a lot on infrastructure at the moment. We're growing. We just need to kind of like tough it out. You know, I think that's always the case for British business, isn't it?

28:37I think we've got extraordinary innovation going on, creativity. And, you know, the UK is a really determined nation. We just need the environment that gives us a little bit of breathing space and it allows those businesses to thrive. Well, we'll be interested to see what those numbers tell us at seven o'clock. I'm sure I'll be on Five Live Breakfast with Rachel a little bit later on to chat you through what they show us. Tara, always appreciate your time. Thanks so much for it again this morning. Tara Alice there, Honorary Professor at the Productivity Institute Research Organization at Manchester University. And Jager, thanks for explaining all of that for us as well. Really appreciate it.

29:11No problem. Thank you. And that's Jager Glacina, the Chief of Staff at Luminance AI. Balance your trading strategy by adding futures. CME Group helps you manage risk and capture opportunities in all market environments. Capitalize on around-the-clock access to highly liquid global futures and options markets Thank you. all investors and involve the risk of losing more than the amount originally deposited and any profit you might have made. This is not a recommendation or offer to buy, sell, or attain any specific investment or service. Big news! Wayfair's Black Friday sale is here early. Right now at Wayfair, get up to 70% off everything you need for the season ahead. Save on kitchen and dining, bedroom furniture and mattresses, holiday decor, and way more. Now is the time to score big

30:04from seasonal finds to favorites you'll use all year long. Plus, with Wayfair, enjoy fast and easy shipping. With delivery in time for the holidays. Save up to 70% off early Black Friday deals. Shop now at wayfair.com. Wayfair, every style, every home. Wake Up To Money with Will Bain. Morning, welcome back to wake up to money on thursday the 12th of november our panel this morning anna mcdonald investment strategy director at hargreaves lansdowne here in the studio with me and emma heathcote james founder and owner of the little soap company do keep your questions uh and comments coming in on 85058 on the text or 08085 909693 is the WhatsApp. We've got a couple that we'll weave into our conversations through the second half of the program,

30:49where we're going to talk about airlines, in particular the cost of landing at Heathrow and that cost of building that third airport. And we're also going to talk now about something we've talked about every day this week, I think, because it's been one of those crunch weeks, hasn't it, for Poundland, the discount retailer, and still its future appears to hang in the balance this is what Liam Byrne the chair of the business select committee in the House of Commons had to say yesterday after meeting with Poundland's American owners Gordon Brothers. My own sense is that the protection that Poundland currently has applied for will get extended by another couple of weeks. That provides a really crucial bit of breathing space in order to get a deal done to save the business.

31:31But if that plan is to work, then Gordon Brothers needs to make sure that Poundland has got full and unfettered access to its own funds in order to cash flow a busy trading period in the run-up to Christmas. Now, that latter bit doesn't seem like it's the case still. We talked about earlier in the week, didn't we, that 50 million had been frozen. 10 million, it sounds like, was initially released and then a further nine on top of it from those accounts to try and keep things going. Thursday, as a number of Poundland suppliers have told us through the week here on Wake Up To Money, a bit of a D-Day because it's protection from creditors there for them, but also that Friday was when a lot of them were due to be paid again.

32:09And Liam Byrne went on to tell colleagues that he was deeply concerned that Gordon Brothers' behaviour may have jeopardised thousands of jobs. And he was also concerned that Gordon Brothers has been behaving much like the wolf on Wall Street of the British High Street. Well, Paul Batts joins us. Paul's the owner of an independent shop in Western Supermare, outdoors and active, and the chairman of the British High Street. Well, Paul Batts joins us. Paul's the owner of an independent shop in Western Supermare Outdoors and Active and the chairman of the town's Business Improvement District. Morning, Paul. Good morning. And we've heard of lots of people kind of really directly involved, you know, suppliers and

32:35former owners and staff at Poundland. But we thought it'd be interesting to kind of get a bit of an insight, I guess, to their importance as a company in our high streets, in our shopping centres. And I know they've been a big part of your town centre. Yeah, absolutely. They took on the old Woolworths building, which is very central to the high street here in Western Supermare. So it's a, you know, it's a very central point right in the middle of the high street. And of course, it's, you know, we've opposite them is an empty Marks and Spencer's building as well. So it's very difficult for high streets because, you know, a lot of these big names that are pulling out and leaving big gaps. And of course,

33:18those big buildings will not be filled by, you know, local independent shops because the rent and rates are just too high so we the last thing we need is another empty space in the high street and the importance of just something a reason for people to come into city centres full stop in the first place even if you're not a retailer right the way you're sort of dragging people in are potentially things like power or i need to nip in and get x, or I might as well, you know, pop to the pub or grab a coffee or something afterwards. Absolutely. You know, it's, as you said, you need an excuse to bring people into the town. And then the other independent shops like myself and lots of others, you know, then benefit from that sort of footfall from the high street. And what we've seen over the years is that, you know,

34:06the larger retailers that are starting to pull out, a lot of these things are quite cyclical, of course, because all high streets started with independent shops and then the bigger guys have sort of muscled people out. But, of course, when those big guys disappear, you know, you see it a lot on social media and stuff that people are, you know, trying to find an excuse to come into town. And if you lose those cornerstone shops, it decreases the footfall and that has an effect on the, you know, the cafes and all the other independent shops around it. Just going to bring our panel in, Paul, as well. Emma is someone obviously very exposed to kind of the retail space, what have you made of the Poundland story, kind of watching on from

34:49the outside? I think it's the whole question of is the high street dying? And I think our argument would be the high streets evolving rather than dying. We know consumer habits have changed enormously. And the challenge we've got is whether traditional retailers can adapt quickly enough. Now, a conversation we had in our team meeting yesterday took it a step further. So we sell into all the supermarkets. And the question is, is the supermarket going to die? You know, which is, you know, that that's massive for us. We know that people are completely changing the way they shop. You know, when I grew up, mum would do once a week, massive big shop in the supermarket with the trolley piled high.

35:27And we know people aren't shopping like that anymore. And the fact that, you know, I think it's 8.6 million people in the UK actually live alone. So people are doing little and often shops rather than these great big shops. So it's really fascinating. And I think what we need to do is adapt. You know, we've got to, well, yeah, online shopping didn't exist when we started in 2008. You know, no one would have bought online. It wasn't possible. And now everybody does that, you know. Anna, from the wider kind of perspective, Will Walker-Arnett, another of our guests who's often in your chair there as one of our investors on the program, saw Will on BBC TV earlier in the week kind of saying this seems to him a kind of fine line between clever business deal, sort of get in for something when it's very cheap, that presumably is quite unhealthy, actually,

36:26for us as a country to have those sorts of doubts about, you know, the morality, I suppose, of investment. It doesn't seem a very healthy thing to have when we're trying to talk about growth that we were talking about in the first half of the programme. Yeah, I mean, I don't want to apportion blame. Gordon Brothers says it's pursuing all these different avenues and then the suppliers, they were feeling under huge amounts of pressure in terms of are they going to get paid and there does seem to be some kind of tension between underlying, the trading is actually improving, so why are we in this situation and one's thoughts have to be with the employees. There are 11,000 employees running up to Christmas

37:08not knowing what's going to happen. There'll be lots of people, won't there? I mean, seeing what happened to what's now TG Jones, what was WH Smith as well, asking about the role of private equity in our high streets in particular. Yeah. And we've seen it lots with the casual dining kind of restaurant sector too right um yeah i mean i don't think it it's it i don't think that you can't necessarily say that that that all private equity behaves like this um and um in in if if these companies were on listed and and on the say the uk stock market they'd still be facing extraordinary pressure. And so I don't think that it's not, that's not whatever the opposite of a magic bullet is. Yeah, and there's still the kind of question then as well

37:53about whether you can have sustainable businesses in lots of these places, smaller places around the country like where Paul's speaking to. Remember that these, and as Emma's been saying, you know, the high street is super tough. You've got high costs, you've got high wages, employer national insurance changes. There's rates are extremely tough. And we know that, as I was saying earlier, it's really tough on the consumer having our household budget squeezed by higher energy costs. So it is a difficult place, whether you're listed or not, whether you're independent or not, whether you're a private equity owner or not. I should say as well, Gordon Brothers call themselves a distressed investor.

38:28And actually, we do need lots of those out there because the only people who come and do any of these rescues when companies do get into a pickle, like Poundland found itself in the first time, are companies like that. So they go pop sooner as well. I know a lot of people are putting the blame at their door there, but we wouldn't have Poundland from last year, would we, if this company hadn't come in at this point. Paul, more broadly then, what is the kind of answer to the kind of high street fight back, do you think? Well, we've noticed that over the last probably year or so, we're starting to see more people who are grateful for a specialist little independent like we are because it's about having conversations. who are grateful for, you know, for a specialist little independent like we are,

39:07because it's about having conversations. You know, one of the things that we noticed, certainly through COVID, is as was mentioned just now, there's a lot of people living alone, whether they're young or old, you know, and their trip into the town centre was traditionally, you know, that conversation, we're lucky enough to have a butcher's and a baker's just up the road still. And so a lot of these people that live alone, you know, their only trip into town and their only real conversation with someone is that face-to-face conversation. And we've had more, it's been very noticeable that more and more people have said, oh, how great it is to find a shop where we can have a conversation with someone

39:43because everything's becoming this kind of self-service world. You know, we've seen this with the supermarkets, which was, you know, where you would normally go, all right, you select all your stuff, but you would sometimes have a quick conversation with the cashier as, you know, at the end of that. But now you're literally, you know, rushed through with no conversation. And there's a lot of people that just, you know, don't like that kind of self-service, you know, un through with no conversation. And there's a lot of people that just, you know, don't like that kind of self-service, you know, unhelpful world. And it's difficult because, you know, it's the cost thing. We're lucky enough here in Weston to have a sort of 100-year-old family,

40:18high street sort of department store that has had to evolve and, you know, change the way it works but the you know the less you're seeing and of course over the years it was all made very easy for people to go out of town with free parking and then you know costs in in towns most places still suffer you know not suffer from but still have parking charges so it was another excuse to just drive to an out of town park for free go in a few shops and then go home it as as was said that you know the high street needs to evolve it needs to be that place of a mix of things whether it is leisure space and certainly in my sector, you know, retail, you know, it is harder and harder because of the costs for an independent. But you need to provide that experience,

41:11because it's just disappearing everywhere. You know, we're going to end up with this sort of sterile, either online or self-service world, where people just aren't, you know, conversing and having those experiences. Yeah, a really interesting thought from Paul. We were talking about this in relation to ASDA yesterday on the programme, weren't we? I wonder what you make of it. 85058 is the text number. Have we kind of reached peak online and self-service? As they're saying, they're putting the tills back in. Paul talking about people wanting to have that face-to-face conversation. Is that how you feel? 0808599693 is the WhatsApp if you want to get in touch with us. Paul, really appreciate your time this morning. Thanks so much for coming on.

41:49Paul Batts there, owner of an independent store in Western Superman, outdoors and active, and he's the chairman of the town's business improvement district. Let's turn to the world of aviation then. Big conference here in London this week with lots of the top names in the industry appearing. The chief executive of Heathrow, Thomas Waldby, one of them, and he was welcoming Chancellor John Healey's confirmation yesterday that the government is, quote, behind a third runway at Heathrow Airport. But a group that represents the nine biggest US airlines says the airport is in danger of losing business to rivals like Charles de Gaulle Airport in Paris because of the cost of landing at Heathrow. We've been speaking to Chris Sununu, chief executive of Airlines for America, told us that

42:30charges like air passenger duty combined with higher jet fuel prices and potential increased fees levied to fund any third runway could see US carriers and passengers choosing to avoid London altogether. We want the UK to be strong. We want Heathrow to be strong. You know, it is a gateway to the entire European market. The US loves it. But when you look at the cost, just the cost per passenger, even an economy passenger, it's over £100 of tax just to land at Heathrow. I think it might be the most expensive airport to land in terms of your passenger fees. So this is air passenger duty we're talking about. Yes, yes, that's right. Is it the ADP, is that what you call it? APD, yeah. Well, in the United States, we have choices, right?

43:10And so maybe we start moving more to Paris or we start moving more to Melbourne. I was going to say, you're going to Paris, for example, tomorrow. Is that the type of conversation? Is that where we are now? Absolutely. These hubs are kind of competing against each other now. Absolutely. For people like you who don't have the, where their end journey isn't necessarily the UK or France or Frankfurt or whatever. That's right. If the end journey isn't here in London, then we're going to have other options potentially. And the international market is a strong area of growth for the major airlines in the US. And so they're going to look at those costs and those choices when there's already so many other cost pressures.

43:42Which is keeping your members up at night the most? Is it what's going on with jet fuel? Is it regulations? Right now it's jet fuel. It's jet fuel. And that goes, I think, for everybody all across the world, because, you know, you just can't pass all of that cost onto the customer. You want to stay competitive and it's an incredibly competitive industry. So the industry as a whole is eating about 50 percent or more of the increase in jet fuel. And I remind folks, it's not the price of oil, right? Price of oil might go up 30, 40, even 50 percent. Jet fuel is at 250 percent because what we call the crack spread is so drastic. And so when you look at about the cost of putting an airplane in the sky, about 28 percent of your ticket is just in jet fuel. So when that goes

44:20up 250 percent, that's a massive cost on an industry, at least in the US. In the US, our profit margin is about 4% to 5% as an industry, right? So it's not like over here you have other airlines that make a much higher profit margin. We don't. We are incredibly competitive over there. So there's less room, there's less give on the financial side. And so therefore, that's the big driver of why this is on folks' minds. So kind of adjacent to where passenger duty in that debate is, of course, the debate around capacity. And Heathrow being the big focus, obviously, in the third runway there, but also new runways at Gatwick and expanding others. Well, because Heathrow is such a center point for the entire continent,

44:56you know, in New York, for example, we have JFK, we have LaGuardia, we have Newark, we have three options if you want to go to New York. Here, you basically have Heathrow on the international side. People are choosing Dublin a little bit more. There's a couple of additional flights going into Dublin and Paris. Now, Paris has its own political strife today, but long term, I think the US market still very much believes in Paris as a potential hub. But at the end of the day, we need Heathrow to be strong. So we would love to see those upgrades happen. But boy, the cut, what, 45 billion? I don't even know what the latest number is in terms of adding that. I'm being charged to your members. Oh, yeah. Not my members, my passengers. Right. I mean, it all flows down to the customer.

45:31What is the sort of outcome? What is the end outcome? The end outcome is probably less carbon trading. Yeah. If those costs increase to become unbearable, the American consumer is going to make a different choice. That's just it. A $5, $10, $25 difference in ticket, they're taking the difference and they're making other plans because it's so easy to do that. It's so easy to change your flight now, right? Just the concept of being able to buy and manage your own travel so easily with technology, you don't have to go through a travel agent and all that stuff or get on the phone every time. It allows people to make more choice. It gives them more flexibility and they are learning to use that. The use of AI, where people will go on now and almost treat AI not just as a travel agent,

46:09where should I go? But a travel agent, how best do I design my cheap, my most affordable vacation? I'm not going to London anymore. I'm going to go to Eastern Europe. We're going to vacation in Croatia. Or we're going to go down to Italy. And now more airlines are going to start doing more direct to Barcelona or Italy or whatever it is. So we're not coming through Heathrow anymore. Well, that really affects your economy, affects jobs, it affects opportunity. We don't want to see that. We love opportunity in terms of the options for the customer. But because London and England are so important to us from a US standpoint, we don't want you guys to price yourselves out of the market. That would

46:43be bad for everybody. Anna, that debate runs and runs. Yes, absolutely. And I think key at the moment, as he was saying, is that jet fuel is just really expensive. It's gone up so much. And that's even if the Middle East crisis resolves, we do still have that damage to those refineries there that were making that jet fuel and exporting it. So high prices will cure high prices. I say that frequently, and that's because other refineries will step in and start supplying. I mean, supply is not actually the issue at the moment. It's just the pricing. But we will see that take a while to recover, I think. And until then, it's possible that flight prices will remain quite high. Emma, do you have a view, particularly on the cost to us as a country

47:32or potentially as passengers, even if you're on a UC throne, frequently about the expansion? Or is it just something that we've debated for so long now we should just get on with? No, apart from holidays, let's move on. Yeah, absolutely. Well, let's move on. Yeah, absolutely. Well, let us know what you think. I can see a couple of texts here that we'll try and weave in in a moment as well on Heathrow. Coming up to seven minutes to six here on Five Live, we don't often get to do a deep dive into the British glass industry, but after a government intervention yesterday, here's our opportunity. Wake Up To Money's Josh Corber-Hoffman has been trying to explain what's going on. Here's what changed for the glass industry yesterday in under a minute.

48:11Since October last year, producers of glass bottles were paying a tax, called Extended Producer Responsibility Fees, based on the amount of glass they were selling to customers. The idea was to collect money for councils to pay for glass disposal. But some of those glassmakers passed the cost on to the buyers of those glass bottles, including pubs and restaurants, and some of them then passed it on to consumers. Hospitality venues were particularly unhappy because they were effectively paying a tax on glass disposal twice, once when buying from the glassmakers, and then again to get their glass disposed of at their premises. So yesterday, the government announced that from April 2027, glass producers

48:51would no longer be charged the levy when selling directly to hospitality venues. Anna and I left shaking at the multiple smashes of glass on a roundel. I'd be in a Greek wedding there, wouldn't I? Charlotte Harrington joins us on the programme. Charlotte's the Chief Executive at Bellewater. Morning. Good morning. So the changes then, what do they mean for you guys? So, I mean, we're very hopeful that the government has started to address, I guess, some of the unintended consequences of this scheme. We sit in a slightly interesting intersection, I guess, between glass, hospitality, but also social enterprise. And I think the hospitality pays twice issue has been one that we have been highlighting in the

49:35lobbying that we've been doing all of this year, alongside the fact that it felt as if glass was being unfairly penalised. And what we are hoping is that this obviously is the start of a dialogue and that we can really get some clarity from the government around the way in which social enterprises within the scheme are recognised. Right, so it's not don't do this, it's just that the way it was going to be done, you're not sure it would have worked. Yeah, the intention behind EPR is right. So, you know, we support the ambition to ensure that businesses play a role in funding the recycling infrastructure and incentivising a circular economy. But I think the way in which it was implemented was very much one size fits all.

50:16And there are lots of different business models within the industry. And that's, you know, that's hospitality, but it's also social enterprises and they operate in a very different way to say a retail organization i just wonder emma and anna i'd be interested in your thoughts on this as well after after charlotte we we talked about this charlotte a little bit earlier in the week just in terms of messaging as we were talking about the zev mandate actually earlier in the week with the charging industry so that's this target for um for for electric vehicles that have to be on the roads. And Melanie from one of the charging companies is making this point that it's just the kind of noise, the mood music around it that like even to be seen to be flip-flopping in inverted commas on environmental policies kind of messages to people, to the public, to us, that it doesn't really matter, that we don't need to take this too seriously that it's

51:05not kind of a pressing thing to do i just wondered do you think that's a kind of danger here a little bit a hundred percent it's a danger here in terms of the flip-flopping nobody really knows whether they're coming or going um you know we absolutely support the principle of epr but again it's got to be proportionate it's got to be fair and it's got to have a genuine incentive um you know we have to think about the environment you know this it's it doesn't necessarily mean it's sustainable and we're doing our best as a business to be doing the right thing and we just feel like we're being penalized left right and center for doing things well emma you were going to come in sorry sorry that was me.

51:45Oh, sorry, Emma. Charlotte, go. That's all. No, I mean, I would agree with what Emma said. I think, you know, for us, understanding and having transparency of where the funding was going was also part of the questions, I guess, that we had. So I think if it was going to fund better infrastructure for recycling that would mean that we had better recycled content that we could put back into our packaging, we would 100% be supportive of that. But again, it needs to be implemented in a way that is proportionate and recognises the different recyclability of materials, but also the fact that some parts of the industry already pay to get this waste recycled. And what you were saying, I guess, both of you around, I mean, is sustainability still,

52:32five, ten years ago, it would have been all we talked about on this programme, right? Sustainability goals. Has that slipped full stop for consumers, do you think, Emma? It hasn't. No, not for consumers. Consumers are still really, really conscious about what they're buying. And they're very, very conscious that they want sustainable products. The challenge that we have is they want them at a low price. And that's what's really, really difficult. Charlotte, that balancing. Yeah, I mean, for us as a business, it's still core. You know, it's a core part of our purpose. So for us, you know, sustainability is, you know, the first core part of our of our purpose so for us you know sustainability is is you know

53:06the first thing we think about and so that has to be front and center but you're right in terms of the cost of living and the way that this levy has been um has been charged on does mean ultimately the consumers will be paying more because there is nowhere else that it can go given all of the other costs that hospitality and businesses like Baloo are having to absorb. Well we will talk you through hopefully with less glass smashing any future plans of how that is modified in the future and hopefully we'll have Charlotte back on to chat to us about any of those as well. Thanks so much for your time this morning. Great thanks for having me. Charlotte Harrington the chief executive of Baloo Water there thanks

53:41for your texts coming in. One person Anna clearly not happy with the idea of more chatting at tills. Paul, Elaine and Ralph, they all apparently texted it together. Last thing we need is people chatting at checkouts when there are very few and queues are building up. Oh, well, I mean, I suppose so. But maybe we, well, I don't want to tell supermarkets to do, but maybe we need more people at checkouts. Perhaps you can have a chatting checkout. chatting checkout a slow I mean they do do some supermarkets do offer sort of quiet mornings or slower mornings for people who who are who want to go and take it not been a quiet morning here appreciate your time this morning thanks so much Anna Macdonald

54:19investment strategy director at Hargreaves Lansdowne Emma Heathcote James as well founder and owner of Little Soap Company and big thanks to all of you of course for listening to Wake Up To Money this morning Wake Up To Money with Will Bain For more than a decade, British boxing has been shaped by two men Two completely different personalities. Two extraordinary careers. And one fight that just won't go away. There's never been a fight like this in the history of British boxing. Never. This is the story of how we got here. And how the AJ Fury rivalry redefined boxing forever. This will split the country. Half Fury fans, half AJ fans. Five Live Boxing, Fury v Joshua. Listen on BBC Sounds. With Geico, 15 minutes could save you 15% or more.

55:22Now sure, there are plenty of ways to spend 15 minutes in San Francisco. Like looking for parking. Not finding it, but looking. Networking with someone who's wearing the exact same vest as you. Nice one. Or walking three blocks that somehow have four hills. And apparently hearing that cable car bell quite a bit. 15 minutes goes a long way in San Francisco and could save you 15% with GEICO. Book a loved by guest property with Verbo and you get a top rated vacation rental that's loved for all the right reasons. Like being in a great location or having great amenities. Oh, I love my Verbo for the view. Good reason. Ooh, and the sauna. Sweet. Another good reason. And that it's one of those good saunas with the hot rock thing.

56:03Oh, love a good hot rock thing. Fancy. That's also a reason. Don't worry about surprises. Book a Verbo you'll love with the Love by Guest filter. If you know, you Verbo.

▸More episode summaries

Wake Up to Money cover art
Wake Up to MoneyNvidia's Huangover2026-11-13 · 53 min
Wake Up to Money cover art
Wake Up to MoneyOpening doors?2026-11-16 · 51 min
Transcribe your links. Paste a YouTube, Google Drive or podcast link and WhipScribe gives you the transcript. Transcribe a link →
New Wake Up to Money transcripts by email
One email per new episode, unsubscribe in every message. Not shared with the publisher.