Wake Up to Money · · Transcript & summary by WhipScribe
A BBC panel connects a sudden corporate scandal at the world's most valuable chipmaker to the wider UK economy, Poundland and the Grand Theft Auto 6 launch in one hour.
Tap a chapter to open that moment in the transcript; the link to it is copied for you.
“I think he does because this company, NVIDIA, cannot survive without him and the vision that he's putting out there.” Ray Wang · at 6:31 — open in the transcript →
“The board is better than we thought.” Douglas McNeill · at 15:04 — open in the transcript →
Jensen Huang has stepped down as chief executive of Nvidia after more than three decades leading the chipmaker. He admitted an extramarital affair with a woman the US administration reportedly suspects of being a Chinese spy, which China has dismissed as a smear. Further reports named affairs with employees who reported to him. Nvidia's value fell by about half a trillion dollars in a single day, though shares recovered to close only about 5 or 6 percent lower, and the company is still worth roughly four trillion dollars. Finance chief Colette Kress is interim boss while the board searches for a permanent replacement. Congressional committees have summoned Huang over how advanced chips reached China despite export controls.
The panel debated whether one person holding so much influence is a weakness. Byron Dixon, who runs the Leicester biotech Microfresh, argued that British founders plan succession early, while US tech firms often let one person run everything. Douglas McNeill, a former economic adviser to Rishi Sunak, judged that the board acted quickly, a silver lining. Maya Bandari of Neuberger Berman said the firm had not changed its view of Nvidia's earnings power but expected more headline and regulatory risk. Jeff Herbst, a former Nvidia vice-president, said products appear sold out for 18 to 24 months.
The same week brought other stories. Poundland, bought for a pound by Gordon Brothers last year, is up for sale again and risks being broken up across its roughly 600 shops. UK growth beat forecasts at 0.7 percent, which the panel saw as resilient but a possible reason for further rate rises. Grand Theft Auto 6 arrives next week with a 212 gigabyte download, and Sir Ian Livingstone argued that Britain's blockbuster games remain foreign-owned.
Jeff Herbst spent 20 years as Nvidia's vice-president of business development and is now managing partner of GFT Ventures. He says he worked closely with Jensen Huang and Colette Kress.
Sir Ian Livingstone is a British gaming entrepreneur and executive who launched the Tomb Raider series around the time Grand Theft Auto first came out.
Douglas McNeill said Nvidia's board acted quickly once Jensen Huang's position became untenable, which he counted as a silver lining in a difficult week. He said critics had feared the board was too close to Huang, but it had turned against him.
“The board is better than we thought.”Douglas McNeill · 15:04
Ray Wang, founder of Constellation Research, said when the affair news first broke that he expected Jensen Huang to survive, because Nvidia could not survive without him and the vision he was setting out. Events moved faster than that, and Huang was removed as boss within days.
“I think he does because this company, NVIDIA, cannot survive without him and the vision that he's putting out there.”Ray Wang · 6:31
Byron Dixon, founder and chief executive of the Leicester biotech Microfresh, said Nvidia's problems showed the risk of one person holding too much control. He said he plans early for the chief executive being removed, because the business has to survive without its founder.
“So we plan very early for what happens if the person at the top, something goes wrong.”Byron Dixon · 12:15
Sir Ian Livingstone said Grand Theft Auto 6 is a great British success story with enormous cultural impact. He noted that Grand Theft Auto 5 made a billion dollars in its first three days of sales, and estimated the new game cost over a billion dollars to make and could earn more than $5 billion in its first week.
“It's a great British success story.”Sir Ian Livingstone · 47:49
Nvidia's board removed Jensen Huang as chief executive after his affair with a woman suspected of being a Chinese spy, and after further reports of affairs with employees. Finance chief Colette Kress became interim chief executive, and the board said it is looking inside and outside the company for a permanent replacement.
Jensen Huang resigned as Nvidia chief executive after admitting an extramarital affair with a woman the US administration reportedly suspects of being a Chinese spy. China has dismissed that as a smear campaign. Further reports named affairs with employees who reported to him, and the board concluded it had no choice but to remove him or accept his resignation.
Byron Dixon, founder and chief executive of the Leicester biotech Microfresh, said that in the US it is normal for one person to run a tech company, citing Bill Gates, Mark Zuckerberg and Elon Musk. He said British businesses are more conservative and build governance and a succession plan from the start, so the business survives if the founder leaves. He said the share price fell sharply at Nvidia because the company was centred on one person.
Jeff Herbst, who spent 20 years as Nvidia's vice-president of business development, said Nvidia's products appear sold out for the next 18 to 24 months. He called Colette Kress a safe pair of hands who needs to stabilise the company and explain its roadmap. He expects blowout earnings when Nvidia reports next week, because Huang had already given investors a forecast for the next 12 to 18 months before he left.
Colette Kress was Nvidia's chief financial officer for 13 years and is now its interim chief executive, after Jensen Huang's resignation. The BBC's Lily Jamali described her as a familiar face to Silicon Valley analysts who follow the company's earnings calls. The board says it is looking inside and outside the company for a permanent replacement, and the panel noted that Kress lacks Huang's technology background.
Poundland, the discount chain with about 600 shops and around 11,000 employees, was bought by the US restructuring specialist Gordon Brothers for a pound last year and is now up for sale again. Several bidders are interested in the whole chain, but their approaches have so far been rejected, raising fears of a piecemeal break-up. A court gave the business more time to find a buyer, and Liam Byrne, chair of the Business and Trade Select Committee, said protection would likely be extended by a couple of weeks.
Sir Ian Livingstone, the British gaming entrepreneur who launched the Tomb Raider series, said Grand Theft Auto 6 will be one of the biggest entertainment releases of all time. He noted that Grand Theft Auto 5 generated a billion dollars in its first three days of sales, and that the new game cost over a billion dollars to make and could exceed $5 billion in its first week. He argued that most of Britain's blockbuster games are foreign-owned, so the country needs more scale-up capital to keep their value at home.
Our own transcript of the public episode, with a timestamp about every 90 seconds. Tap a timestamp or the link button on a paragraph to copy a link that opens this page there.
0:00This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK. online broker and get started. See what adding futures can do for you at cmegroup.com forward slash podcast. Derivatives are not suitable for all investors and involve the risk of losing more than the amount originally deposited and any profit you might have made. This is not a recommendation or offer to buy, sell, or attain any specific investment or service. Big news! Wayfair's Black Friday sale is here, early! Right now at Wayfair, get up to 70% off everything you need for the season ahead. on kitchen and dining bedroom furniture and mattresses holiday decor and way more now is the time to score big from seasonal finds to favorites you'll use all year long plus with Wayfair enjoy
0:56fast and easy shipping with delivery in time for the holidays save up to 70% off early Black Friday deals shop now at wayfair.com. Wayfair, every style, every home. BBC Sounds, music, radio, podcasts. Wake Up To Money from BBC Five Live. Hello and welcome to Wake Up To Money. NVIDIA's flying over with Jensen Wang stepping down after more than three decades in charge of the tech giant. What's next for the company he runs? It's still worth trillions, but its stock market value has dropped by more than half a trillion dollars in just five days. Another big tech firm, Microsoft, is having problems today too. It's struggling to fix a major global outage of its Teams, Outlook and artificial intelligence software Copilot.
1:47Also on the programme, as the UK comfortably beats growth expectations, we look at what's keeping the economy resilient at the moment in an unstable world. And a lot of people are rather excited about this. Oh, it is so on now. Grand Theft Auto 6. Coming November 19th. Rated M for Mature. Well, Grand Theft Auto 6 gets its full release next Thursday. Some are calling it the biggest entertainment launch ever. Wake Up To Money from BBC Radio 5 Live. This is more Good Morning, Good Morning. It is Wake Up To Money on 5 Live on Friday the 13th of November. It's just after five o'clock. I'm Theo Leggett with you for the next hour or so. And it has been another week of drama in the tech sector, hasn't it?
2:34The downfall of the NVIDIA boss, Jensen Huang, following days of revelations about his personal life, allegations of spying. It's like something out of a John le Carre novel. Huge amount to talk about. Microsoft also in the news this morning. It's still working to resolve issues with its 365 service, affecting things like email, Outlook, Teams and Copilot. The Poundland saga has been rumbling on. The company was itself bought for a pound last year. It now has won a few more days to secure its future. And we've had some surprisingly upbeat economic news as well this week. All told, plenty for our Friday panel to get their teeth into, so let's meet them one by one. And with me this morning, Byron Dixon, who's founder and chief executive of the Leicester-based biotech
3:19company Microfresh. Good morning, Byron. Good morning, Theo. How are you doing? Very well indeed. I hope you are too. And Theo, how are you doing? Very well indeed, I hope you are too. And how's business at the moment? It's been a while since we last spoke to you. It has been a while, yeah business is good. We have, as I said before a few months ago, we have a lot of levers to pull in our business so we are growing, we are international, so right now I can't complain. It's always good to hear. Also on the programme today is Maya Bandari, who's Chief Investment Officer for for Multi Asset at Neuberger Berman. Good morning, Maya. Good morning. What's been catching your eye this week? Well, I think you touched on some of the things that have been catching my eye this week.
3:58I mean, huge volatility in NVIDIA and the broader AI ecosystem, strong numbers out of the UK economy, and of course, earning season, which is in full flow. You must be exhausted. You must be glad it's Friday. I'm always glad it's Friday, Theo. And completing our Friday panel this morning is Douglas McNeill. He was Chief Economic Advisor to Rishi Sunak when he was prime minister. Good morning, Douglas. Good morning, Theo. And I guess those economic figures earlier in the week, they were big news for you. And they were kind of unexpected, weren't they, as well? They were. They showed that economic growth was above 0.5% for the third month, the third quarter, I should say, in a row. That's the first time we've had a run of three quarters of 0.5% or above since 2022. So that's definitely a positive. But it could be
4:53a double-edged sword, of course, because it suggests that the economy is strong enough to withstand further interest rate increases. And so the Bank of England will be viewing it in that light. All told, plenty for us to talk about later in the programme. You can get in touch on text 85058, on WhatsApp 08085909693. And if you are listening to us on BBC Sounds or on the podcast, use the hashtag wakeuptomoney on social media. Now, let's get into the story about NVIDIA, because after more than 30 years leading the company, Jensen Huang, the chief executive, has resigned. With his trademark all-black outfits, leather jackets and mischievous charm, he did have something of a rock star appeal in a tech-sector-y sort of way.
5:39His star shot up in recent years with the AI boom and was only going in one direction until very recently. Here was Huang giving advice to British founders at an event in London only last month. There's a strange general behaviour in the UK. First of all, from the outside looking in, you have superpowers in intellect, you have superpowers in some of the best universities in the world, you have superpowers in just a great culture. Nobody in the world could drink on the streets than you can. And so the fact of the matter is you have smart people, you have a great culture, you have young people, and the energy is vibrant. But for some reason, if there was a million ways to win, you find the one reason not to do it.
6:31Shooting from the hip as ever. That was just a fortnight ago. But despite the skyrocketing value of his company, now one of the biggest in the world, it has all come crashing down in stunning fashion after the New York Times first reported him having an affair with a woman suspected of being a Chinese spy. Now, many were expecting Huang to survive the scandal. Here's what Ray Wang, founder of Constellation Research and formerly a senior product manager at Oracle, had to say when the news first broke. I think he does because this company, NVIDIA, cannot survive without him and the vision that he's putting out there. But things then unraveled further still, and yesterday came the news that he was no longer the boss of Nvidia. With him gone, shares in the company dropped rapidly. They
7:16did recover later, so they ended the day only down about 5 or 6 percent. But from when the affair first emerged, Nvidia has had a total fall in value of about a trillion dollars, a quarter of its value, but still worth four trillion or so. Ouch. Shortly before we came on air, I spoke with our North America technology correspondent, Lily Jamali, who spent most of yesterday outside NVIDIA's headquarters in California. It all started on Sunday with news that he had admitted to an extramarital affair. That affair was with an alleged Chinese spy. And then over the course of the week, we've had more revelations about other affairs, including those with people inside of his companies, executives who report to him. So it was getting to the point where the board really
8:06didn't have any choice but to either remove him or have Mr. Wang go ahead and submit his resignation of his own volition. Well, now he's gone. We've lost one of the rock stars of the tech industry. I think that's fair to say. He's been replaced by Colette Kress. Now she's the finance director of the company. This looks like safety first. Safety first. She's a familiar face and she's been there for a long time. She's been the chief financial officer for 13 years. So she's the interim CEO. And she's somebody who's very familiar to people in Silicon Valley, anybody who listens to their earnings calls, as many of us here on the reporting staff at the BBC do every quarter. You'll know her. And so I think that familiarity is really important at a moment when there's so much uncertainty.
8:59But they are looking for a replacement, a permanent replacement. It could be her, but she doesn't have the technology background that Jensen Wang brought to bear. And, you know, they say that the board said that they're looking both inside the company as well as externally for a potential replacement. But big shoes to fill. Well, absolutely. I mean, you're looking at that kind of charisma in a leader is pretty difficult to find, isn't it? It is. But I think one of the things I'm noticing in some of the language from the board, and it's really changed from just a couple of days ago when they issued this statement basically saying they had no reason to believe anything had gone wrong in terms of trade secrets being revealed or national security issues cropping up. Now they're being
9:45much more circumspect, saying, for example, they're appointing a chairperson of the board for the very first time. That's a clear signal. They want people to know there's going to be more oversight of whoever ends up in that top seat once they determine who that will be. And with Colette Crest, they get somebody who knows the company well, is very familiar with the company's customers. But she may end up being a bridge to a new chapter in this company's history. So steady as she goes for now at NVIDIA. But what about Jensen Huang himself? He's going to be testifying before congress i think well at this point what we have confirmed is that the chairs of three congressional committees that handle u.s national security
10:31they say they need to know the full extent to which that national security was placed at risk and so they have summoned um mr wong they've also uh summoned secretary of Commerce Howard Lutnick and one of his key officials in that department. They want to know what they knew and when and how was it that clearly some of these advanced AI chips designed by NVIDIA made it into China, clearly flouting US export controls. So they have until tomorrow evening, at least Mr. Wang does, to get back to them. Otherwise, they're threatening to issue subpoenas. It's so hard to keep up. I'm running out of breath, Lily. But in the meantime, problems at NVIDIA. But we've also had some problems over the past 24 hours at another tech titan, Microsoft.
11:22Yes, there's been this Microsoft outage. I can't say I was immune from it. It's very interesting reporting on the biggest story of the year without any access to email. But that was what many of us were faced with today. The company saying they are trying to restore access to its software, which also touched Teams, the Slack competitor in some cases. So that's an ongoing situation. I can tell you personally, I still don't have access to my email, but they're continuing to work on getting these servers back up because so many people are having this issue. And that was Lily Jamali, our correspondent in California. Well, take a breath. Byron, Byron Dixon, let's start with you. What's your reaction to everything that's been going on at NVIDIA over the past week?
12:15Is this what happens when one man has too much control, too much influence in a company? Yeah, well, I mean, it's a culture thing. So listening to Gentleman Huang in London, I mean, what he said was very true. But the culture is here when we grow a business, what you're taught quite early on is to build in resilience, building governance and building a succession plan. So we plan very early for what happens if the person at the top, something goes wrong. And in the US, in the tech industry, it's quite normal to have one person running everything. If you think of Bill Gates, Mark Zuckerberg, even Elon Musk. Whereas over here, we are conservative is one way of putting it, but we do build that in.
12:56And we're doing that in my business as well, because I may decide to go off and do something which I think is a bit more fun, and then the business has to survive and is to protect the business. I mean, you look at NVIDIA and on the one hand, it is still, even after everything that's happened, a $4 trillion company. It's absolutely huge, having grown massively over the past five years. But in some respects, it's still almost a family business, isn't it? You know, you had Jensen Huang at the top. You had some of his children in senior roles. That's right. Yeah. I mean, hey, far far from i to tell nvidia how to run their business they're slightly bigger than us um but uh what what i've been taught is the founder should be an asset not a
13:34single point of failure but as i say it does lead to quicker growth and the numbers that you see in the us are huge but uh yeah it's a culture thing. And when something goes wrong, it can be catastrophic, especially when, as we've seen with Nvidia, the share price dropped dramatically because it was all centred around one person. Douglas McNeill, I want to bring you in here because you've had experience talking to senior politicians, looking at what happens when things go wrong. Drawing on your experiences, how do you diagnose when a scandal is survivable? And what do you do when you're in a situation like NVIDIA's facing at the moment? Well, I think Mr. Huang's position in this case had certainly become untenable
14:17because one of the responsibilities of people in that sort of position and in that sector in the US these days is to operate at the interface of the relationship between the US and China. That is very much part of the future of the AI sector here. It affects debates around export controls on chips from the US, for example. And clearly, Mr. Wang's position in the US-China debate had been fatally compromised by the affair. And that being the case, I think it was incumbent on the board to act quickly. That's what you've got to do. You've got to act quickly and take the initiative. And it's been a good week for the NVIDIA board, I think. At the start of the week, people were complaining, rather, as Byron says,
15:04that there was a corporate finance problem here, that the board wasn't strong enough, that the people there were too close to Jensen Wang. They would never turn against him and so on. In fact, they have done so. They have acted quite quickly. And so in what's obviously been a difficult week for NVIDIA, that is one silver lining. The board is better than we thought. OK, so NVIDIA has reacted, in your opinion, quite well to this. But, you know, there's another side to the story as well, isn't there? There's the US government side. They suspect that one of the women Jensen Wang was having an affair with was a Chinese spy. How worrying is it for the US administration and indeed other administrations around the world that this kind of apparent infiltration can happen?
15:50Yeah, they will certainly be concerned. And it's pretty surprising to put it mildly that Jensen Huang didn't see the risk of that happening as well. He would obviously have been a great subject of interest to the Chinese state, to Chinese intelligence services for many years, I imagine. And the fact that he's gone is also a problem in the sense that he was one of the few people who commanded the confidence, commanded the ear of people at the very top in both Washington and Beijing. And now that he's gone, you know, one useful channel of communication between those two governments is gone. So that's a pity. My bad diary. NVIDIA has made itself an indispensable part of the AI ecosystem. And it is this sort of circular economy with the AI companies, isn't it? They invest in one another,
16:34they lend to one another. We've seen AI stocks hit at the end of the last week by the US midterms. Now we've got this. Is there a risk that this is a tipping factor now for the sector? Well, I mean, I'd perhaps just take a step back and say, you know, as far as NVIDIA is concerned, we describe it as a really unfortunate day in that, you know, NVIDIA's future is just not as clear as it was without Huang at the helm. As you've been discussing, I think at the minimum, we'll have a period of heightened uncertainty. And certainly from our perspective at Neuberger, while we haven't shifted our assessment of NVIDIA's fundamental earnings power, the distribution of outcomes around the stock have clearly changed.
17:24And there's going to be, we suspect, substantially more headline volatility and indeed a more regulatory and perhaps legal risk. Now, I think there are a couple of key questions. One is, you know, what is the potential impact on the broader AI ecosystem? And, you know, there's a direct angle to this and an indirect angle, you know, directly. To your point, Theo, you know, NVIDIA had pledged, I think, $10 billion to buy Anthropic shares as part of the private placement concurrent with its upcoming IPO. Its earnings are also released in just four days. The indirect impact, of course, is it surrounds some of the softer stuff, you know, Jensen's ability to steer the whole AI ecosystem, which is, you know, arguably irreplaceable.
18:21And of course, you know, some of the problems at NVIDIA have raised the probability of tighter chip export controls being incorporated, which is, of course, a live debate, but could be quite problematic. And I'd say for the AI space more broadly, for our listeners, you know, we're sort of moving from belief to proof for investors. I mean, we've seen eye-watering levels of CapEx in the US. You know, CapEx on AI is akin to the railroads in the 1800s. I mean, that's the sort of numbers we're talking about. And now folk want to see the returns, and especially with a more uncertain policy setting post the midterms. So, yes, a real area of focus. And I should say it was notable that the UK is up on days like yesterday.
19:16You know, very different mix of companies and a very different price point. But it is extraordinary, isn't it, that one man's love life can have economic and market repercussions around the world. It is. It is. We live in extraordinary times and we'll have more on video later in the programme. But I do want to get the panel talking about some of the other stories we've had this week because there have been plenty of them. And to begin with, let's home in on Poundland. Now, Poundland, in the days before the likes of Aldi and Lidl started to dominate discount retailing, there was Poundland. It was a source of cheap goods through the year and desperate last minute stocking fillers at Christmas. Maya, have you been there? I have indeed. Yes.
19:55The desperation in December. Well, it's since fallen on hard times. And last year it was sold to the US restructuring specialist Gordon Brothers, inevitably for a pound. But now it's up for sale again. And while there are several bidders interested in the whole chain, their approaches have so far been rejected. And this has sparked concerns the business could end up being broken up and sold off piecemeal. And this matters because it's the future of a business with about 600 shops and around 11,000 employees. Their future is in doubt. This week, a court gave the business more time to find a buyer and politicians have also waded in. Yesterday, there was a private meeting between Poundland, Gordon Brothers and MPs on the Business and Trade Select Committee.
20:38Chair Liam Byrne had this to say afterwards. My own sense is that the protection that Poundland currently has applied for will get extended by another couple of weeks. That provides a really crucial bit of breathing space in order to get a deal done to save the business. But if that plan is to work, then Gordon Brothers needs to make sure that Poundland has got full and unfettered access to its own funds in order to cash flow a busy trading period in the run-up to Christmas. So it looks like Poundland is safe from collapse for another couple of weeks or so, and the BBC understands that Gordon Brothers has agreed to release a further £9 million from company accounts and funding, on top of an already agreed £10 million,
21:18which should be enough to tide the company over for a further 10 days or so to find a buyer, if there is a will to find a buyer. Byron, let me bring you in here. What do you make of all of this? I think it's a classic illustration, Theo, of how brutal low margin retail can be. When the costs that we all know about, wages rising, energy and supply costs all rise together, there's just not enough margin. So the investors will look at what return they're getting. And if the numbers don't match up, they will pull out. And if they think they can make more money from breaking the business up, that's what they're going to do, isn't it? Absolutely. I mean, there's a saying, I mean, I talked to some investors. I don't have any
21:58investment in my business as of yet. But investors say to me, Byron, we don't come with tea and biscuits. We come to make a margin. And it is a fact. So although low margin retail is very tough, when the numbers don't add up, the investors will pull out. And the real tragedy is that when a major shop like Poundland disappears, you don't just lose the shop, you lose jobs, you lose business, but also footfall, especially in city centres. And the high street is struggling with footfall right now, as everybody knows. Douglas, the consequences of a store chain going down are obvious and nasty for those who are involved. But it is kind of the law of the jungle on the high street, isn't it? Well, that's right. And clearly there is a problem here.
22:41I mean, Gordon Brothers are getting a lot of criticism. It does look as if they are perhaps a little bit blind to the human aspect of all of this. But nevertheless, if they thought that the business had a bright future, then they wouldn't be in this position. They wouldn't be withholding cash if they feel that the cash is just going to be wasted propping up a business that isn't viable, then you can see why they are reluctant to release some of it. And there may be bidders around, but we don't know what sort of price they are willing to pay. So clearly there is that problem. Maya, do you think politicians are right to get involved in all of this? I mean, it is the economy in action, isn't it?
23:31Yes, I mean, you know, I suppose reflecting some of the comments that Byron made a moment ago, you know, this is really, Poundland is in the middle of an insolvency crisis. And, you know, there are, I think, perhaps valid concerns of contagion in other discount retailers and a pretty fragile UK high street when it comes to retail. You know, footfall has been a concern and there are, of course, impacts on pound land directly, but also the broader impacts on the sector. You know, I think we can sort of contrast, if you will, what we're seeing in pound land with what we're seeing, for example, in another firm like Metro Bank, which is, of course, a really good recovery story in many ways. And it's, of course, exploring a sale to which the stock responded really quite nicely in the last couple of days. And we'll be discussing Metro Bank later in the programme. But your
24:26experience of Poundland, do you think it still has a place on the British high street? Or is it just a question that others are doing the same thing better? Well, I mean, I think it's a slightly tricky question to answer. I mean, and again, reflecting on what Byron said a moment ago, for low margin firms like Poundland, really, the competition is intense. And clearly, Poundland struggled to keep up with that. I mean, you go into the stores, as we were discussing earlier, and you have quite a different experience with some of the more modern discount stores that are also on the high street. So there is a challenge set up for Poundland here, I think. Byron, do you think there's still a place for Poundland on the high street?
25:16My personal view is I think the high street in general is struggling. So if it was my money, I've got to say I wouldn't want to invest in Poundland because more to the point of where they are more than what they do. OK, let's move on to the other big story of the week, which is those economic figures we had. Better than expected growth in the three months to the end of September of 0.7%. That's the fastest rate of growth for two years. The average prediction just months ago for this period was 0.1%. And I've been covering the growth figures through the year. And every time we see the forecasts that it's going to be at a certain level, we get the reaction that growth is resilient, but we're told it's going to tail off in the second half of the year. And so far,
26:01that hasn't happened. Douglas, you're an economist, what do you make of all of this? Well, resilience is certainly one of the main words that one reaches for here, because we are doing a lot better than we thought we would at the start of the year. And that's good, given that a war in the Gulf has broken out along the way. And we're going to do better this year, probably than the Eurozone, which will come in about 1%. I think what we've seen this week doesn't change the bigger picture, which is that for the year as a whole, we'll probably see growth here of around 1.3%. So that is better than we expected earlier in the year. But it doesn't take us back to the old normal, so to speak. If you look at the half decade or so
26:43before the COVID pandemic broke out, we used to be used to growth of around about 2% on average. So we're still falling a little bit short of that. And we're in a rising interest rate environment as well, aren't we? That's right. So that is one of the headwinds that we face next year. The Bank of England has already raised interest rates once. It may well do so again at its next meeting, which is in December, and maybe then again at the meeting after that in February. There was a speech this week by one of the key Bank of England Monetary Policy Committee members suggesting that that is definitely a policy that is under consideration, an option that's under consideration. And it's also true that the full impact of the fuel price increases originating out of the Gulf has not come through as yet.
27:30There's still a bit more of that to come. So we may find that the first part of next year is harder. And Maya, how's this been impacting the markets? Well, I mean, I think, you know, as far as the UK is concerned, I think, you know, we are at, we think we are at or pretty close to peak growth economically. And I think that's something we can say more broadly. Just to say that, you know, I think as far as the, just reflecting on the comments earlier, you know, clearly markets in the UK, but also globally have moved to price in a series of interest rate hikes from the Bank of England, but also the Federal Reserve and the ECB. And at Nürburgring, we'd question some of that because, you know, when we fold in the energy prices, for example, and the impact that's likely
28:18to have on consumer spending, it's not clear to us that the economy indeed needs higher interest rates. Now, when we're talking about markets, you know, it's worth reminding ourselves that UK equities actually have very little to do with the UK economy. You know, I think 75% or so of the revenues for the FTSE 100 come from overseas. But as we discussed earlier on, when we touched on NVIDIA, you know, the UK has tended to benefit at times when AI as a theme has come under pressure. And yesterday was one example of that. And I think supporting UK equities are a few things. I think first that the sectoral mix, which is very different from the US and also Europe. And second, the valuation or the price you pay for exposure to UK equities. You know,
29:13when you look at it by sector or overall in its own context, these valuations are pretty attractive. And of course, there's sterling. Sterling has been trading in a range, if you will, of sort of for most of this year. And we'd expect it to sort of stay in that broad range. Thank you. suitable for all investors and involve the risk of losing more than the amount originally deposited and any profit you might have made. This is not a recommendation or offer to buy, sell or attain any specific investment or service. With Geico, 15 minutes could save you 15% or more. Now sure, there are plenty of ways to spend 15 minutes in San Francisco. Like looking for parking. Not finding it, but looking. Networking with someone who's wearing the exact same vest as you.
30:25Nice one. Or walking three blocks that somehow have four hills. And apparently hearing that cable car bell quite a bit. 15 minutes goes a long way in San Francisco and could save you 15% with Geico. Wake Up To Money from BBC Radio 5 Live. And welcome back to Wake Up To Money from BBC Radio 5 Live. And welcome back to Wake Up To Money. Theo Leggett with you for the next half hour. Coming up later, it's going to smash game sales records, or at least that's what we're told, and some of you are likely to be downloading it right now. Yes, Grand Theft Auto 6, the most hotly anticipated computer game for a long time, is almost here. We want to know what was the last new game you were excited about.
31:08You can get in touch on text 85058, on WhatsApp 08085909693, and if you're listening to us on BBC Sounds or on the podcast, use the hashtag WakeUpToMoney on social media. Now, let's get back to NVIDIA. Top story of the day and undoubtedly of the week as well. We've been talking about Jensen Wang, the boss of the chip making giant who resigned yesterday from the company he co-founded more than 30 years ago. He's admitted to having an extramarital affair, but the key point is who he had it with. Reports in the US say the administration there think the woman in question, tech executive Alice Wang, no relation, may be a Chinese spy. China has dismissed that as a smear campaign. It's also alleged Mr Wang had affairs with two NVIDIA
31:57employees. He's now agreed to appear before the US Congress for questioning, according to the BBC's US media partner CBS News. Well, when markets opened yesterday, we saw half a trillion dollars fall off the chipmaker's market value. That's on top of losses accumulated throughout the week, and although it did recover some ground, it's still lost nearly a quarter of its market value since Monday. It is hard to overstate how central NVIDIA's place is in the global AI boom. The company's at the heart of a whole network of deals and investments across the artificial intelligence ecosystem. And now, Mr Wang's former chief financing officer, Colette Kress, will be taking over the $4 trillion operation. Well, someone who's known Jensen and Colette well was Jeff Herbst, who spent 20 years
32:43as NVIDIA's Vice President of Business Development and is now Managing Partner of GFT Ventures. Welcome to the program, Jeff. Yeah, thanks for having me, Theo. Well, you've been on the inside and you know the key characters. Tell us about your time working at NVIDIA was an AI company, we were a computer graphics company. And Jensen is such a visionary. When I joined the company, I talked to him and we talked about building NVIDIA into a high performance computing company and that GPUs were going to be used for more than gaming and graphics. And basically through his vision, through his hard work, through his relentless investment in this over time, NVIDIA became central to the modern AI revolution.
33:47And was this an inspired decision or was it luck? Because you look at NVIDIA's history and it grew fairly slowly for many, many years and then obviously surfed the wave of the AI boom since around 2020. So, you know, inspirational luck? You know, it's like everything else. It's probably some of both. I believe that, you know, Jensen used to say, if you build it, they will come. And NVIDIA knew that these GPUs could be used for high performance computing. There were a lot of smaller applications for that, like crash testing of cars, fluid dynamics, scientific applications. I mean, we thought about AI, but really the only way for AI to grow was first to build the platform and then for AI to start utilizing the platform. So, you know, luck is
34:42where opportunity meets preparation, right? So we were prepared and we created the conditions or the platform for which these amazing AI researchers and scientists could build the first foundation models. And look, the industry's grown dramatically from there. OK, so all of this has happened and a driving force behind it has been the personality of Jensen Wang. Now he's gone. Colette Kress is in place. She's the safe pair of hands, I guess. What does she have to do now? Well, I think she needs to stabilise the ship. So you asked me, do I think this would have happened, you have happened on its own without Jensen? Actually, of course not, because Jensen was willing to make these huge investments in high-performance computing and CUDA well before there was any indication of any revenues.
35:47So that's where Jensen really shined and would have continued to shine. The good news right now is that NVIDIA's products appear to be sold out for the foreseeable future, 18 to 24 months. So I think the company has been through a lot of disruption. Colette is a safe pair of hands. I believe she's above reproach and, you know, definitely probably not involved in any of these so-called scandals. And, you know, she needs to right the ship, calm everybody down and execute on all of the orders and the products that have been ordered so far. And obviously, over the long run, they have to keep innovating and building products. But I think order of the day number one is to stabilize the ship, calm down investors, explain the roadmap, explain what they're going to do,
36:41explain the process. And she's going to have a great opportunity next week when NVIDIA announces their earnings. And I am almost 100% confident they're going to be blowout earnings. And the reason I know that is because Jensen, before he left, basically told investors what the financial forecast was for the next 12 to 18 months. But we've seen time and time again, haven't we, how the influence of these alpha characters, the Steve Jobs of this world, they're absolutely central to the fortunes of the companies they leave. In his absence, is there a risk that NVIDIA's rivals could gain ground? There is, but it won't happen immediately because NVIDIA is so embedded into the ecosystem and they've locked up so much of the fabrication
37:34supply and the chip supply and the memory supply that for the foreseeable future, I don't see any risk. I think the longer term risk is what are the next products NVIDIA is going to build? What are the next markets they're going to go into? And I think they've got a little bit of breathing room now to do that. I mean, as tragic as it is, and as much as we're all going to miss having Jensen and NVIDIA, I mean, even though I'm not at the company, we work with him. A lot of my startups work with him. He's incredibly responsive. The good news is he's leaving at a time when the company is firing on all cylinders. You know, the product roadmap for the foreseeable future has been laid out. So it would be much more
38:19dramatic in my view if NVIDIA was not doing so well and he left the company. So we have a great opportunity here. NVIDIA has a great opportunity to really right the ship, get their act together and figure out who's going to be the next long-term CEO and move from there. But allegations of spying, that's really hard to move on from, isn't it? Do you think that NVIDIA and other AI companies are going to face increased regulation and oversight in future? Most likely, and you're right. I mean, those allegations are hard to move on from, but that's most likely why Jensen had to resign from the company. I'm sure he feels terribly about what happened. Having worked with him for many years, I know him as someone
39:06that admits his mistakes and does not deny and figures out how to fix it. So he probably had to fall on his sword here in order to protect the company that he built. Jeff, thank you very much indeed. That was Jeff Herbst, who spent 20 years as NVIDIA's Vice President of Business Development and knew many of the cast of characters we're talking about today. Byron Dixon, you're still there. What do you think of all of this? Where does NVIDIA go from here? Well, I think what they will have learned is that that won't happen again, I guess. The board and the governance will get a lot stronger. They'll be prepared for anything like that happening again. So it seems with Colette at the helm, they can only go from strength to strength.
39:53They have a great product. They have a great image. And hopefully the share price will start going back up and they'll start to reap rewards for the investors. Is there a moral to this story? Yes. I think the moral is act as though you may never be there, which is something that every business should do. In my business, my team and the board around me are saying, let's run this business as though Byron is not there. Absolutely. I want to move on to some of the other stories that we've got today. And obviously, all of this has had quite a big effect on the financial markets we've seen fluctuations in tech share prices not just because of nvidia but also reaction to the midterms last week and so on so it's been pretty turbulent um but maya you were talking to me
40:41earlier you were saying that stock market valuations, we've seen stock market records set this year. There's still been this wave of interest in AI, hasn't there? And we shouldn't detract from that. Yes, I mean, absolutely. I mean, I think AI is a transformative theme for us. And I think, you know, I think when we think about both companies, but also economies and our day-to-day lives, I think, you know, the impact on productivity, we think in due course will be really quite significant. And earnings have been good, haven't they? And earnings have been exceptionally strong. And not only have the earnings been exceptionally strong, but the price that we're paying for those earnings, which is valuations in financial market jargon, have compressed significantly.
41:39I mean, global technology stocks have fallen by 20% in valuation terms. And that's what, again, quote unquote, folk call a bear market. And so you do get access to this stream of really quite attractive earnings at a very reasonable price. So, yes, strong earnings and valuations going down. That's a buying opportunity, isn't it? It certainly can be. And I think within AI, what we think we're likely to see in the next sort of 12 to 18 months is a bit more differentiation. I mean, you know, reflecting what I said a bit earlier on on the show, I think, you know, the focus from investors has sort of shifted from supporting a huge boom in GapX and now wanting to see the return on that investment. And I think whether we're talking about the profitability
42:36or the models or indeed the impact of some of the politics like the midterms on these companies, we think we're going to see increasing diversification within the group of AI. So some of the hyperscalers that have very strong balance sheets, for example, that have fallen quite significantly, look quite attractive to us. By contrast, some of the neocloud companies, you know, the core weaves, for example, that folk on the show on the show may have heard of may be more challenged because they have less clear revenue streams. That's where it all comes down to, isn't it? It's earnings. And it sounds as though you think some of these companies will have sustained high earnings, but others won't. Essentially, yes.
43:20OK, well, let's move on to one of the other stories that we've been looking at. MetroBank, you mentioned it earlier on in the day. It's put itself up for sale after embarking on a significant turnaround effort in the years after its rescue by Colombia's richest man a few years ago, Jaime Galinsky. Remind us of the background to all of this. MetroBank, not so long ago, was in trouble. Yes, I mean, you know, Metro Bank, I'd say, is broadly a good recovery story in many ways. And the contrast with someone like Poundland, I don't think is lost on our listeners. It is a good recovery story. It's exploring a sale, although it's been, you know, quite clear that, you know, it's not a required sale. It's an exploratory sale. And I think the market response to that news yesterday
44:14was revealing. I mean, the stock was up about 10% or so following that announcement. So good news for the Challenger Bank. Another business with a successful turnaround story to tell, the luxury brand Burberry, an impressive 6% increase in revenue and its half year results, better than expected sales. Yes, you know, I think Burberry is again, a genuine turnaround story. And I think it's really interesting because, you know, when we look at luxury more broadly, which is of course,, the sector that Burberry sits in, you know, China demand, we look at how valuations across the sector have moved, they've moved to, I think, the cheapest levels in over a decade, more broadly. And so Burberry's success in that context is really one of the bigger positive surprises. It's bucked the China
45:21trend. And when I last looked last night, you know, it's, I think, one of the best performers in its sector over both one month, but also three months. So, yeah, a really good story. It always surprises me with premium brands. You know, you go into the shops, they're so upmarket, the prices are high, all the standards are really, really refined. But it's actually a cutthroat business, isn't it? Yeah, it certainly is, as we've seen from other companies in the sector. And it's not just a cutthroat business or sector, but it's also one that is intensely exposed to the state of the Chinese economy, given the proportion of Chinese demand in that sector. OK, now we're going to change tack a little bit,
46:08because leaving the markets news aside, it's not long now until gamers will be able to play one of the most hotly anticipated video games ever. Oh, it is so on now. Grand Theft Auto 6. Coming November 19th. Rated M for Mature. Well, after a long wait for fans, Grand Theft Auto 6 is out next Thursday. That's 13 years and two months since the release of the massively successful Grand Theft Auto 5. It's in line to be the biggest entertainment release of all time and is expected to smash game sales records. And these sales go into the billions. Fans who've pre-ordered the game have been able to download it but not play it yet since yesterday. And that is causing some issues for internet service providers
47:05because it's a massive 212 gigabyte download. It's reportedly been slowing down some of the internet. So what will happen when millions more people download the game next week and beyond? Sir Ian Livingstone is a British gaming entrepreneur and executive who launched the Tomb Raider series around the same time as Grand Theft Auto first came out. You probably remember that. So, Ian, so much hype around this game. Do you agree with that assessment that this is going to be one of the biggest of all time? Absolutely. I mean, it's an extraordinary cultural, social and economic impact on the world. I mean, Grand Theft Auto 5, as you said, launched 13 years ago. It generated a billion dollars in its first three days of sales.
47:49It's a great British success story. And it's, you know, the cultural impact is absolutely enormous. And it's estimated that it cost over a billion dollars to make, and it'll probably generate revenues exceeding $5 billion in its first week. I mean, these are extraordinary numbers. You can't argue that it's not the biggest entertainment release of all time in any media. Well, as you say, those figures are absolutely extraordinary. A billion dollars to make. Investors are expecting returns of at least $2 billion. PlayStation and Xbox have announced it's the most pre-ordered game in history. How does something get to be as big as this? I mean, at the end of the day, it's a computer game, yet thousands of people working on it.
48:35I can't really get my head around it. Well, it's just epic in its scale and ambition and incredible in its realisation. I mean, the realism, the immersion, this kind of world that you can just immerse yourself in forever and unlike film, which is a linear experience where the director controls the action, the players control the action in a game of this epic scale. So it's like being in a different world completely and it's no surprise it's the most wanted game. And it's likely to get extraordinary scores because it's that amazing. I mean, 13 years in development, a billion dollars, thousands of people working on it. You know, Sam Howser, the president of Rockstar, is just an extraordinary creative genius.
49:22And he's got an incredible team producing the game, Rob Nelson and a cast of thousands, as it were. Personally, I struggle to see how one computer game can be so much better than another, but that's just me. I'm not a gamer, I have to admit. But there is a downside as well, isn't there? And that's the size of this game in terms of the amount of memory it takes up. It's a huge download, 212 gigabytes. We've had one internet service provider, Ufiber, saying it's struggling to meet demands. Do you think the internet infrastructure will hold up when many more people start downloading over the next week? Well, nobody knows yet. I mean, it depends how many people actually do download it on the day as well. I mean, everybody's pre-loading it, as you say, in advance.
50:10And the ISPs are aware of what's going on. Maybe they need even more data centers built than is being built at the moment. But I think the other consideration is the speed it'll run at because there's a bit of a trade-off between the graphic fidelity and the speed it'll run depending where you are and who your ISP is. But you'll get a minimum of 30 frames per second and everyone will expect 60 frames per second ultimately. So it will be like being in your own movie. And I think they'll sort it out quite quickly. And how much credit can Britain claim for this? Because Rockstar North in Edinburgh is the lead development team on the game, so it's made here, but Rockstar Games is a US company. It is. I mean, that's kind of indicative of the great British creative industries.
50:57I mean, look at our film, our fashion, our music, our publishing, and of course our games, architecture. It's celebrated around the world. It gives an edge as a nation, but we don't always see the value in some of the great creative things that we've made in this country. Like you quite rightly say, Grand Theft Auto, created by Rockstar in Edinburgh. Tomb Raider was created in the UK, Football Manager. And the common denominator of these blockbuster titles is that they're all foreign-owned. So we need to get kind of more scale-up capital around some of our creative interests, particularly the games industry, so we can realise the value for the creators, but also for the inland revenue, be able to tax the intellectual property
51:39that resides and owned in the country rather than being taxed overseas. How to puncture the bubble of optimism, start talking about tax. Sir Ian, thank you very much indeed. That was Sir Ian Livingstone, British gaming entrepreneur. Byron, let me bring you back in here. Are you a gamer? I'm not, but I used to be. And do you know what? I did used to love Grand Theft Auto. It's a fantastic game. Ironically, I stopped gaming when the business started to get busy. So I used to play FIFA, I used to play Grand Theft Auto. The violence is a little bit questionable, but no, I love it. And it brings happiness and satisfaction to loads of people, people that sometimes find it difficult to leave the home.
52:24So I think it's a great thing. And the numbers are fantastic. It's a British thing. So I'm all for it. But as an entrepreneur, you've got to put your time into the business. You can't afford to be distracted by this kind of thing. Absolutely. And in the evenings and weekends, I'd spend time away from the screen. So that put an end to all my gaming about 15 years ago. Does it disappoint you that this is made in Britain, but or developed in Britain, but we don't have ownership of it? Yeah, it does. And I mean, the scale up capital question, that's a whole nother show. But yeah, I think we should advertise the fact that it's British, although it's a subsidiary, but it does disappoint me because I think the UK has some fantastic
53:00innovative businesses, and we don't shout about them enough, and they're not known enough in the world. Maya, let me bring you back in here, because it is quite hard for innovative businesses, and we don't shout about them enough, and they're not known enough in the world. Maya, let me bring you back in here, because it is quite hard for British businesses, up-and-coming British businesses, to raise the money they need, isn't it? So that's why they often end up in foreign hands. Yes, I mean, I think that is the case. And again, I'd sort of come back to the point I made earlier on, which is when we look at broad UK stock market indices like the FTSE 100, you know, three quarters of the revenues also come from overseas. So not only are companies
53:35owned, a lot of the companies, particularly the smaller companies, are owned overseas. But when we look at some of the larger companies, a lot of their revenues come from overseas. So there is a very intimate link, if you will, between UK stocks and the global setting. It sounds like what we're really good at is people in sheds and garages developing things, but we just don't seem to have the ability to scale them up, which is a bit disappointing. But then we don't have the US stock market behind us either, do we? Yeah. Okay. Well, that brings us, unfortunately, to the end of this episode of Wake Up to Money. It's been absolutely fantastic today. I've loved talking to my guests. So to Byron and to Maya
54:16and to Douglas as well, thank you very much indeed. Wake Up to Money from BBC 5 Live. For more than a decade, British boxing has been shaped by two men. Two completely different personalities, two extraordinary careers, and one fight that just won't go away. There's never been a fight like this in the history of British boxing. Never. This is the story of how we got here. And how the AJ Fury rivalry redefined boxing forever. This will split the country. Half Fury fans, half AJ fans. Five Live Boxing, Fury v Joshua. Listen on BBC Sounds. With Geico, 15 minutes could save you 15% or more. Now sure, there are plenty of ways to spend 15 minutes in San Francisco. Like looking for parking. Not finding it, but looking.
55:35Networking with someone who's wearing the exact same vest as you. Nice one. Or walking three blocks that somehow have four hills. And apparently hearing that cable car bell quite a bit. 15 minutes goes a long way in San Franciscoisco and could save you 15 with geico dewalt nailers are now at lowes for a limited time save on everything you need for your next job like the new dewalt 20 volt max 18 gauge nailer stop by lowes or visit lowes.com today while supplies last selection varies by store