podcasts / The Vergecast / episode
The Vergecast cover art
podcast
📅 2026-11-13 ⏱ 120 min episode · ~2 min read 📝 Transcript · 24,051 words 👁 1 views

What's really at stake in the Jensen Huang saga

The Vergecast · · Transcript & summary by WhipScribe

A sourced read on why the Jensen Huang scandal could reach Congress and the chip trade, followed by a fast tour of streaming and Hollywood.

Read the transcript
In this episodeNVIDIAJensen HuangMegaspeedColette KressMarco RubioHoward LutnickElizabeth WarrenSam AltmanTim CookBillboardOcarina of TimeBrendan Carr

▸Chapters

Tap a chapter to play it from that moment in the show's own player; the transcript opens there too.

Transcribe your links. Paste a YouTube, Google Drive or podcast link and WhipScribe gives you the transcript. Transcribe a link →

▸Notable quotes

“The biggest problem for all of the circular financing has always been the stupidest tech question of all time.” Nilay Patel · at 24:06 — ▶ hear it from here

▸What this episode covers

Hosts David Pierce and Nilay Patel open with NVIDIA CEO Jensen Huang, who stepped down within days of reports about affairs, one reportedly involving an executive who was alleged to be a Chinese spy. They argue the affairs are the smaller story. The bigger issue is Megaspeed, a company with offices that appear empty and chip shipments suspected of reaching China, and a U.S. government that reportedly knew for a long time while enforcement stalled. For the hosts, Huang's departure is the start of a fight over corruption, export controls and national security.

On the business side, they say Huang's real skill was financial engineering: circular deals that financed AI cloud companies to buy NVIDIA chips, with those same chips serving as loan collateral even though new chip generations quickly lower their value. They doubt his finance chief can carry that role, and they note that his public image rests on NVIDIA's wealth more than on the consumer products people use. They contrast the case with the Sam Altman ouster at OpenAI, arguing there is no employee revolt or dual-class structure to bring Huang back.

The second half turns to streaming and media. The hosts describe a race to copy TikTok with vertical video feeds, including Disney Plus's Verts tab, while free clips posted by teenagers and clip farms undercut paid services. They also cover micro-dramas monetized like mobile games, a change in how YouTube data feeds Billboard's charts, a Hype Desk segment on the Ocarina of Time remake, a DC Films shake-up, and a nominee's confirmation hearing at the FCC.

▸What's really at stake in the Jensen Huang saga on The Vergecast: the answers

What did Nilay Patel say about NVIDIA?

Nilay Patel argues that NVIDIA's circular financing is the core weakness in the company's model. NVIDIA lends money to companies that buy its chips, and those chips also serve as loan collateral, even though each new chip generation lowers their value.

“The biggest problem for all of the circular financing has always been the stupidest tech question of all time.”Nilay Patel · 24:06

What did Nilay Patel say about Megaspeed?

Nilay Patel says Megaspeed's data centers in Southeast Asia serving Chinese customers are not illegal in themselves. The illegal risk is shipping chips from those sites into China, and he says the evidence is not conclusive but shows a lot of smoke.

“It's not great if you're America and you want to maintain the American hegemony in AI, but it's not illegal.”Nilay Patel · 11:53

What did Nilay Patel say about Sam Altman?

Nilay Patel says the Jensen Huang exit is not like the Sam Altman ouster at OpenAI. Huang resigned after a public pressure campaign in which he misled shareholders, the public and his board, so he has no route back.

“There's no coming back from that.”Nilay Patel · 35:43

What did Nilay Patel say about Disney Plus?

Nilay Patel describes the Verts tab in Disney Plus as a vertical clip feed of shows on the service that feels like a stream of ads. He says the feed sits right in the app's tab bar, so viewers see it at once.

“It's right there in the tab bar of the app when you open it.”Nilay Patel · 46:03

What did Nilay Patel say about Billboard charts?

Nilay Patel says YouTube draws an enormous amount of traffic from free viewers, which Billboard's paid-stream weighting undervalues. The hosts discuss how YouTube's return of its data to Billboard could shift which music appears on the charts.

“YouTube obviously has an enormous amount of traffic from free viewers.”Nilay Patel · 1:30:10

What did the hosts say was decided about Jensen Huang's NVIDIA exit?

NVIDIA announced on a Thursday that Jensen Huang was out, with Colette Kress acting as CEO, and the announcement included no quote from Huang saying he resigned. The hosts argue the affair is the smaller part of a larger problem involving Megaspeed, chip exports to China and possible corruption.

Mentioned in this episode

Episode facts

Released
November 13, 2026
Length
2 hours 0 minutes

▸Key takeaways

01NVIDIA CEO Jensen Huang stepped down within days of affair reports, after the company first called a Megaspeed executive tie a normal business relationship.
02Megaspeed, a company claiming Southeast Asian data centers, is suspected of sending NVIDIA chips to China, and its listed office was reportedly a shopping mall.
03A research firm with an axe to grind claimed about 20% of NVIDIA's chip revenue traces to illegal China sales, a figure the hosts call unproven but dangerous.
04NVIDIA's financing model used its own chips as loan collateral, so each new chip generation could erode the value behind neocloud deals.
05Hosts David Pierce and Nilay Patel expect congressional probes to keep going and say no heroic comeback is likely, unlike Sam Altman's return at OpenAI.

▸Questions this episode answers

Q1What did the Verge Cast say about Jensen Huang's resignation from NVIDIA?

David Pierce and Nilay Patel argue Jensen Huang's exit is the start of a bigger problem, not the end of the story. They say NVIDIA first called his tie to a Megaspeed executive a normal business relationship, then reversed after Huang admitted an affair and apologized. The company announced his departure on a Thursday, about a day after a board meeting. The hosts say the real stakes are national security and corruption, not the affair itself.

Q2Why do the Verge Cast hosts say Megaspeed matters so much in the Jensen Huang story?

The hosts say Megaspeed is the most important part of the story. It claims data centers in Southeast Asia that serve Chinese companies, which is legal on its own, but they say the evidence suggests it may have shipped NVIDIA chips to China, which would be illegal. They point to offices with no one in them, a listed office that turned out to be a shopping mall, and Bloomberg reporting on discrepancies in how chips were allocated.

Q3What do the Verge Cast hosts say about NVIDIA's circular financing risk?

The hosts argue Jensen Huang's real skill was financial engineering rather than chip design. NVIDIA financed neocloud companies that bought its chips, and those chips were also the collateral for the loans. Because NVIDIA keeps releasing new chips that cut the value of older ones, the hosts say the deals depend on a confident leader who can keep investors from asking hard questions.

Q4Who could replace Jensen Huang as NVIDIA CEO, according to the hosts?

The hosts think Colette Kress, NVIDIA's long-time CFO who is currently acting CEO, is the most likely long-term pick, because the job is mostly financial engineering. Donald Trump has said Tim Cook should be CEO, which the hosts doubt will happen. They do not expect anyone to take the job until the scandal burns out, and they expect NVIDIA to hire a cautious outside executive to steady the company first.

Q5How do the hosts compare the Jensen Huang exit with the Sam Altman ouster at OpenAI?

The hosts say the two situations do not rhyme. Sam Altman returned to OpenAI after an employee revolt and a Microsoft offer to hire staff. Huang resigned after a public pressure campaign in which, the hosts say, he misled shareholders, the public and his board. Huang holds only about 3% of NVIDIA and there is no dual-class stock structure, so there is no equivalent route back, and they expect shareholder litigation to grow.

Q6What do the hosts think streaming services get wrong about vertical video feeds?

The hosts say streaming services are racing to copy TikTok by adding vertical clip feeds, such as the Verts tab in Disney Plus. The problem is that those feeds compete with free clips posted by teenagers and clip farms, which pay nothing for content. The hosts say the Disney feed feels like a stream of ads because the studio cares too much about polished, full-screen content in a way clip farms do not.

▸Transcript

Our own transcript of the public episode, with a timestamp about every 90 seconds. Tap a timestamp to play the episode from there in the show's own player; the link button on a paragraph copies a link that opens this page there.

0:00Support for the show comes from Jira by Atlassian. You may think you already know Jira, but if you take a closer look, I think you'll be surprised at its evolution. Later in this episode, you're going to hear a Hypedest segment about Jira that delves into some of its amazing new tools, like the Atlassian Teamwork Graph, which is designed to give you visibility into all the scattered threads of information that are crucial for understanding a project's context. Stick around for that segment. Learn more at Jira.com. That's J-I-R-A.com. Hey, David Pierce here. Before we get started, I just wanted to let you know, we record our episodes for Fridays on Thursday afternoons. Usually that's fine. The gap between

0:40when we record and when we publish does not allow for that much time or news chaos. In this case, with Jensen Wong, it sure does. For instance, there's been allegations of a third affair from Jensen Wong just since we stopped recording the episode for today. So just wanted to let you know, all of this is accurate as of Thursday afternoon. All the stuff we talk about still holds. There might be little things that have changed. We'll get to those soon, too. Enjoy the show. Hello and welcome to The Verge Cast, the flagship podcast of interim CEOs. I'm your friend David Pierce. Nilay Patel is here. Hey, buddy. How's it going, man? Have you ever been an interim anything? I was the interim managing editor of Vox.com.

1:21Oh, yeah, you were. I remember that. That was a time. That was the time Nilay spent most of his life on Trance is my main memory of you during that time. I went back and forth to DC to hang out with Ezra Klein and Matt Iglesias and Melissa Bell, the three founders, while they were standing at Vox.com. And the theory was that we had just started The Verge, so I knew what I was doing. And I will tell you, the only thing that I did for that team in the several months that I worked there was at every meeting, I would say, what's going to be on the homepage on the day we launch? And they would panic because they were so deep in their own heads about all the stuff they were going to do that they had not written stories for the first day.

1:56And I was like, OK, that'll just be my job. I'll just I'll just assign some stories for the first day. And that was like what I did for that. Not the worst analogy in the world for a lot of what we're about to talk about. So we have a lot to do today. There's a lot of streaming news. I want to kind of galaxy brain our way through some streaming wars stuff going on. Brendan remains up to stuff. So do AI companies. Muse still out there musing. But we have to start with Jensen Wong. We emergency podcasted a little bit yesterday. But the story of the week, maybe the story of the year, is what has been going on with Jensen Wong over the course of this week. Should we just recount kind of where this has gone over the course of the last seven days?

2:35Is that a useful place to start? Yeah, I think there's so many elements that are so sticky and juicy because it is a bunch of affairs and there's endless memes. And everybody in the memes is like 15 to 20 percent hotter than they are in real life. so sticky and juicy because it is a bunch of affairs and there's endless memes and everybody in the memes is like 15 to 20 percent hotter than they are in real life i'm just pointing that out that's a real thing deepfake technology is doing to the story a lot of like jensen wong memes where he like has abs and is lying on a yacht with with a hot girlfriend and it's it's it's a time this is what people do actually my favorite like c story of all this is Vanity Fair has developed a pretty good side reporting line just putting photos of Jensen through SynthID detectors and being like, he didn't actually wear this jacket.

3:14No way. It's very good. SynthID, it's working, but only in the hands of Vanity Fair editors. Nowhere else on the internet is deepfake working in any way, shape or form. But the editors at Vanity Fair have figured out that in fact, AI imagery is often watermarked and you can tell people that the jacket is fake. So there's like a lot of that, like a lot of literally like sexy stuff to look at. And then the facts I think have been subsumed and the import, the gravity of the facts are actually really important. Yeah. So I think in an interesting way, I have really my vision of what matters here has gotten bigger and bigger and bigger over time. But let's just so very quickly just to walk through the last five days, essentially. Right. So Sunday, big story comes out

4:01saying that Jensen Wong, the CEO of NVIDIA, has been in a relationship with this woman named Alice Wang. No relation. Who is an executive at a company called Megaspeed. And we should talk a lot about Megaspeed because I think actually the most important part of this entire story is about Megaspeed. But she may have also been a spy for the Chinese government. And that in fact the U.S. government believes her to be a spy for the Chinese government. That comes out on Sunday. Lots of tumult. Jensen Wang admits to the affair, but denies giving up any kind of secrets. Well, no, hold on. This is again, the problems keep escalating. First, there was denial, on the record denial from NVIDIA spokespeople saying everything

4:44was fine and there was nothing wrong. This was a normal business relationship. Maybe for Jensen it was. Yeah. Which has led to Liz Lopato on our team just running around going, who else was he fucking? All week. That's all Liz has said. All week. So you just have problem one. Yeah. Which is Jensen is approving statements that are lies. Yes. And potentially he is lying to his own board of directors. He's certainly lying to shareholders. And he's lying to the public. Yes. So you just got your first problem right there. The news comes out that the United States, and every time we post about this, you know, the audience, the comments are like, what proof do we have? The answer is we don't have a lot of proof.

5:20We have the United States intelligence apparatus issuing memos for a year saying this is true. Right. Fine. Like that's as much as you need to say alleged spy, I think. But this is a huge part of the problem. And then you have the NVIDIA's first response is a lie. Yes. Right. This is a normal business relationship. Nothing happened. So then in the course of 24 hours, that goes away. Jensen Wong admits to NVIDIA and to the public that he had an affair, apologizes to his wife and his family in a letter to shareholders. It's all very weird, but says, I had this affair and he and the company are saying, no secrets were leaked about NVIDIA or the government or anything. Everybody is up in arms. An internal investigation is launched.

6:06This becomes a whole thing. And then on Wednesday, another story comes out from, I believe, the New York Times again, saying that Jensen Wang actually had a second relationship, this time with someone who worked for him on his team. She was like a VP of health at NVIDIA. And they, by some accounts inside of the company, had a long-term affair that was sort of an open secret inside of NVIDIA, that a lot of people believe this. There was video evidence of them together that had been sort of passed around inside of the company. The video evidence piece is another just blinking red light, because the person who took the video, according to the reporting in the New York Times, was immediately approached by NVIDIA security and presented with an NDA.

6:49Yeah. It is unclear if this person signed the NDA. John Gruber wrote, it's unclear if NVIDIA security has a packet of NDAs like meter maids have parking tickets. Like, is that just what we're doing? This made me think of, do you remember when that story was going around about Derek Jeter and how he would sleep with women and then make them sign NDAs that moment, everyone knew he would be out. story happens very quickly, right? So right after that time story drops, like kind of right after the Wall Street Journal posts a story saying that the NVIDIA board is meeting as soon as tonight, which was Wednesday night, to discuss Jensen Wong's future. He's probably out. And at that point, just everything catches on fire. And then Thursday morning, the company announces that he's out. So within within,

8:05I would say, 24 hours, the general consensus went from this is weird. Big investigation to Jensen Wong is out. It's important to say that he quote unquote resigned. There's no quote from him in the the announcement that he resigned, which is a thing that would normally happen when a person resigns willingly and not is forced out of the company that they co-founded and have been the only CEO of ever for 30 plus years. Like he was obviously told to a sense that this is the whole story, right? That dude has scandal, dude pays for scandal, story over, scandal over, right? Like guy had relationship he shouldn't have, guy is fired. This is actually a thing that happens in tech and business a lot.

8:58Yeah. And then everybody kind of moves on. The more I think about this and the more I talk to people about it and the more I read the reporting on this, the more it seems actually this is the very beginning of a problem that is going to get much, much, much bigger for every single party involved. NVIDIA, the government, Jensen Wang, China, the AI industry like this is all in the middle of continuing to explode and in no way will stop with Jensen Wong out at NVIDIA. Right. Especially because you have a group of very empowered Democrats coming into power in Congress, poised to launch investigation after investigation because they believe they have a mandate to investigate corruption. And here, this is why I keep bringing it back to the Trump administration.

9:39What you have is pretty naked evidence of corruption that threatened national security. And in the middle of the timeline you just laid out, you have Marco Rubio, who is somehow also serving as the director of national security while being the secretary of state. Like they all have 10 jobs. It's like a well-run administration. I mean, there's only eight people that Trump trusts. And so they all just do things. That's what it is. This is why Trump is like Tim Cook should be the CEO because he only knows five people. You know, he's like, whatever, a guy. Yeah. Anyhow, so somewhere in the middle of this timeline, Marco Rubio oversees a memo saying Alice Wong is a spy and Megaspeed is a problem. That memo gets to Trump. Trump does nothing about it. Somewhere in the middle of

10:17this, you have the Commerce Department trying to do an investigation of these dealings and Howard Wutnick basically stopping it. You have the FBI taking over that investigation because NVIDIA executives have called directly and traded on their direct relationships with Trump in some way. That is naked corruption. Somewhere in there, you have a heated meeting in the Situation Room where Howard Lutnick is basically told, impose the export controls, and he tries to stall implementation until he, I think someone calls his bluff and he's told to call Trump directly. And Trump calls Elon, who's like, do it. This is all of them in the middle of this, knowing that there's a national security issue, knowing that Jensen is doing things with Megaspeed, which as you pointed out,

11:05is pretty obviously like a shady shell company at this point. We can talk about that reporting as well. And you have Trump being like, don't do anything. The entire economy depends on AI and this guy. If that falls, right? If the circular financing house of cards starts to tip over here, I think you're absolutely correct. This story just spirals to some gigantic conclusion. It's unclear if that will happen, but I think once you start poking at the house of cards, things are going to start getting real shaky. Yeah. And I think what you just said about the belief that everything depends on AI and this guy explains so much of this, that Jensen Wang and NVIDIA may have been in some ways allowed to get away with absolutely anything and everything

11:53because it was too important for this company to keep winning, that you just forgive everything that they're doing along the way, right? So the Megaspeed part of this, as I have come to understand it, is the sort of central allegation against Megaspeed is that it was a company claiming to have data centers in Southeast Asia that served Chinese companies, which is not illegal. It's not great if you're America and you want to maintain the American hegemony in AI, but it's not illegal. You can run a data center in Singapore that serves a company in China. But the American government is capable of saying you can't sell chips to that company because they have Chinese customers. This is a real thing the American government can and

12:32should do. And directly have not. They have been presented with the opportunity to say you can't sell to Megaspeed and they have not. But what you can't do if you're one of those companies in Southeast Asia is ship those chips to China. And I would say the evidence that Megaspeed has been doing that at some scale is it's not conclusive, but there is a lot of smoke, I would say, if that makes sense. Yeah, there's a lot of offices with no one in them. Right. These are all the things that you would do if you were going to be illegally smuggling chips to China are all the things that Megaspeed has done. Nobody can find real offices or real executives of this place. The company that owns Megaspeed listed its office is something that turned out to be like a shopping mall.

13:18It's just it's a it's a mess. There have been discrepancies. Bloomberg has been doing really great reporting on this company for a long time, finding discrepancies in how the chips are being allocated. It's all really messy, right? And one of the big questions in chips right now is like, who is actually responsible for litigating this, right? Is it NVIDIA's job to make sure that none of its chips are going to China? Is it the government's job? Is it somebody else's job along the chain? It actually turns out nobody really knows. And so what seems to have been happening is everyone has decided from NVIDIA on down that the easiest thing to do is just turn a blind eye. You just you make sure they write down this is not going to China. And then you don't worry there was a Foxy spy whispering in your ear. and Nvidia and made a bunch of noise about it. And their central thesis was that, I think it was 20% of Nvidia's chip revenue

14:27is coming as a direct result of illegal stuff going on in China. And so that, if that's true, and this is the results of some really interesting research that they did. This is a company with a real like axe to grind. They want you to be anti-Nvidia. Right, so it's like- Culprit research. Yes, culprit research. So you can see where they're coming from. But if that number is even close to true, and you have a government that actually wants to enforce its rules, it just tanks NVIDIA in a very real way. Elizabeth Warren, chair of the Senate Banking Committee, saying monopolies are a problem, unchecked corporate power is a problem. I'm going to put NVIDIA on the stand and say, is 20% of your revenue illegal? Right. And then maybe that it's not going to be this justice

15:11department that prosecutes it, but you, because this justice department is nakedly corrupt, but there might be enough pressure to get this justice department to begin an investigation. And at the very least, it's going to be enough to spook the hell out of the rest of the AI industry, which like, it's so important. This is why I come back to the thing you said about Trump saying the AI industry and this guy like Donald Trump absolutely unequivocally believes that Jensen Wong is so crucially important to the economy that he should essentially be allowed to do whatever he wants. Yeah, that is abundantly clear. And and so all of this happens up to and including the man may have gotten a briefing

15:46saying, Jensen Huang is sleeping with a Chinese spy. And he goes, ah, don't worry about it. Bring him onto the plane. We're going to China. Like this stuff is crazy. So, you know, I was on cable news. I was on Stephanie Ruhl's show on MSNOW and she said the Chinese spy thing. And I was like, yeah, Donald Trump just bangs Russian spies. And I saw like the cable news organization, like immediately react to the fact that I'm used to just shooting my mouth off on this show. Yeah. Later stuff is like, to be clear, we have no proof that Donald Trump has ever banged our heads. Several lawyers like passed out as soon as they heard you say that. Yeah, I get it. Anyhow. Brendan Carr showed up at somebody's house as soon as you said that.

16:24Yeah. They're like, this whole thing has gone down because, you know, I made the dumbest joke in the world. Um, look, that piece of the puzzle where Trump always excuses bad behavior, particularly about powerful men, he excuses his own bad behavior. Jeffrey Epstein, it's all there, right? It's, there's some swirl of that. I don't want to see this. I don't want to know it. In fact, in many cases, I support it is like part and parcel of the Trump vibe and administration. Jensen Wong, also a huge Trump donor, gave twenty five million dollars to the ballroom like the man went way out of his way to ingratiate himself into those kinds of treatments. And that is your corruption. And so there's a national security element. There's the mandate to stop corruption that the Democrats feel it is only the beginning. And we've already seen powerful Democrats start to call for investigations and hearings. There's a little bit of reporting in CNBC that says Jensen Wong has agreed already that he will appear before Congress in some form or fashion. Interesting. So when you say it's only the beginning, it really is only the beginning and the spiral is going to get way bigger than NVIDIA really fast. Yeah. Because all of the

17:29companies that are financed by NVIDIA are looking at a company that might not only take a 20% haircut on its revenue, but might get further punished for having 20% of its revenue be illegally funneled by China. Right. Is it surprising to you that all of this stuff is happening right as the same people at the same time are yelling publicly to anyone who will listen about how winning the AI race with China is existentially important and we're all going to die if China gets to AI before we do? And then you have people up to and including the CEO of NVIDIA and the president of the United States enabling China's access to that very technology. Like, I understand that saying isn't the cognitive dissonance of this bad is ridiculous to do

18:13with the Trump administration because like the two facedness is the point. But I'm so struck by this. Like all anyone talks about is how we have to win the AI race with China. And then there are a lot of people in positions of power who are very happily enabling China in that race. I think this all comes down to where the story came from, which is the intelligence community knew this for a long time and no one listened to them. And in some cases, potentially in the case of Howard Lutnick in the Commerce Department, it actively impeded them. And so I do think you have a Marco Rubio, who is a China hawk, being like, this needs to be known. There's something happening there that you can really understand that, okay, they hit the brick wall enough times, the information

18:58got out. In this last episode of Coder Raid, Kyle Chan, who studies China and its relationship with the United States at the Brookings Institution, And he basically was like, this probably backfired for China, right? Instead of having the open flow of chips and aligned to the president through Jensen because of their spy, now they're going to be faced with a bunch of China hawks and an absolute restriction on imports of any chips. Whereas Jensen's own business interests dictated that he wanted the flow of chips to China and he was succeeding in that way. So I do think we're about to see a big swirl over what winning is. The other point he made to me, which is really interesting, is that the Chinese AI industry does not care about AGI in the way that the United States AI

19:41industry does. They care about applying the AI to their industrial capabilities. And we here, we're just like, we're going to make Jesus or like whatever these guys think they're doing. And that the economic realities might mean that good enough models and good enough chips actually still gives China the damage. Yeah. Which has been the desperate fear of the US tech industry for some time, right? That if DeepSeek's almost as good and much cheaper model ends up being good enough for most uses, what is the point of what the rest of these companies are spending all of this money on? Right. The United States AI market has really landed on what we're going to do is make AGI and then AGI will tell us how to be cool. And China

20:19is much more like we're going to make useful AI and like deploy it into our manufacturing and industrial capacity and that will make us more productive and efficient. And it's like, those are different ideas and they have different goals and different requirements. Yeah, I agree. So, okay. So I wrote down a bunch of questions that I have about what's going on right now at NVIDIA and I'm just gonna throw them all at you and see if you have any answers. Question number one, who do you think is the next CEO of NVIDIA? Obviously right now it's Colette Crest is acting as the CEO. She's been the CFO for a very long time. I would say even just in the hours since this was announced, the momentum for Colette Cress to be the long term solution here has grown, which is really interesting. But she for now is the, uh, Donald Trump, like you mentioned earlier,

21:05believes it should be Tim Cook. That's a real thing. He said on truth social, um, with all the weight, uh, I've also seen, uh, names like Johnny Shruji who runs hardware at Apple. And as of not that long ago was reportedly threatening to leave Apple for some other bigger job. Uh, is there anyone else out there floating around who might be the obvious? Because this person is also de facto maybe the most important person in AI. And you need somebody, at least the theory goes, who can do all the Jensen things. Does that person exist? I'm actually curious what the Jensen things are. I've done some org chart reporting on this day because I couldn't help myself. I think it has to be Colette Crest. I think it has to be the CFO.

21:50I think the most important thing Jensen has been doing is financial engineering, not hardware engineering, not chip design, not any of that stuff, not set the roadmaps. It is open, overt financial engineering. We are going to do circular financing to stand up NeoClouds and build the AI industry and make sure all of it is hopelessly dependent on NVIDIA chips and NVIDIA technology like CUDA. And if you listen to the way he talks about China, it is basically a monopoly argument. Sure. Right, he's like, I will have a monopoly over AI chips and AI accelerators and through our ecosystem that will prevent China from getting ahead because no one will be able to outperform us. Yeah, it's let us do it so Huawei can't is the argument here as it has been. It was the same argument with 5G, right? Like we've done this already. Huawei is the big bad and we can't let Huawei win. So we have to. Yeah. And there's some part about that where it's like, sure, then the Chinese AI industry will be hopelessly dependent on American chips.

22:47And then what? You're going to kill switches built into all the switches? He's never made the rest of the argument. Right. Right. And who knows? Like, maybe that's in the United States' long-term interest to sell all the chips to its greatest geopolitical rival. But why? Like, I always understood why don't let Huawei control the 5G networks was in our national interest, because I'm pretty sure the Chinese government would install surveillance equipment and kill switches and that stuff. Like, it's the networks. Sure. The bare metal chips is like a whole different thing. So who knows, right? This is already a whole stack of problems there. If you put in a hardware person and they are not familiar with

23:25how the financial engineering works, right? How the structure of Neo cloud financing works, and you don't have the ability to be the new CEO and go in front of wall street and say, everything's going to be okay because I understand this technology better than you do. I built this system and it's going to be fine. Then I think that whole thing starts to fall apart. Like people start to look at CoreWeave's financials much more closely to say, is this going to work? Are your customers making more money because they're spending money with you than they would have otherwise? Or is all of AI deployment kind of smoke and mirrors and eventually this circus comes to an end and we're just going to take our money back out now.

24:06This is a real problem for the core use of the world. Yeah, I think it's possible that's going to happen no matter what. Like for the same thing you said with China, where this has really sort of Streisand affected, a thing that everyone involved would rather no one be thinking about. I think this question of, isn't NVIDIA just giving a lot of people money to give back to NVIDIA? And isn't that maybe not great business for anyone involved other than NVIDIA? Is a question that's going to be asked a lot more now than it has been. The biggest problem for all of the circular financing has always been the stupidest tech question of all time. If you take out a loan to buy NVIDIA chips and your collateral for that loan is the NVIDIA chips, right? Like this is the thing that's

24:53happening. The problem is that NVIDIA will make new chips and radically depreciate the value of the chips that you just bought with their money. And so NVIDIA never had incentives to make better chips. They were destroying their incentives to make better chips. And Jensen, singular figure, would be like, I would never do that. Right. Full speed ahead. Anyone else in the chair is like, wait, why are we making products that obsolete our own collateral? This is like, if you buy a car, the car appreciates, and everyone's like, you just leased the car. Like, everyone understands that buying a car is a dumb financial decision yes uh building billion dollar neocloud hyperscaler competitors on loans financed by depreciating assets when you

25:37don't know what their turns will be has always been chaos like this is the argument for the bubble right and jensen has just managed to be like, I am very loud and you're a fucking loser if you disagree with me. And that has won. Now, is his CFO going to be able to play that game? Probably not. Will they be able to be the CFO who architected that whole system with Jensen and say, look, it's all the same. Nothing has changed materially here. It's just that guy's gone, but i built this system as a cfo it's going to be fine yeah don't worry about the hardware engineering because actually if that slows down the core problem with this whole scheme is actually kind of like mitigated and also that's

26:15the thing nvidia is probably most resiliently good at like jensen wong for all of his a bit like as you like to talk about on decoder all the time, the CEOs are very rarely the ones doing the things. And the people who are doing the things will continue to do the things. There's a real longer term NVIDIA brain drain possibility that I think increases pretty aggressively without Jensen Wong there. But that's not a, like, today problem. Yeah, especially if the stock doesn't rebound, right? The opportunity to sell your stock, get out and do something better is there. And Jensen famously has somewhere between 35 and 60 direct reports. The number fluctuates a lot depending on what podcast he's on.

26:56Unclear how that actually works. He also claims that he reads 1,000 emails a day. Yeah. I'm just saying. He does a lot of myth-making. Yeah. I'm just saying, like, there's, he does a lot of myth-making. Yep. So, there's a lot of myth-making, but I did make some calls and ask some questions about the 60 Direct Reports thing, and the way NVIDIA works is, it's very similar to other tech companies. Most other type companies have a thing called directly responsible individuals, where like one person is in charge of a whole thing, and that person can get yelled at or fired. In NVIDIA, those people are called pilots in command. Sure. PICs. PICs, not DRIs. They're PICs. Not DRIs. At Amazon, it's single-threaded owners, STOs.

27:37No, single-threaded leaders, STLs, STOs. It's one of those. It's a whole thing. The whole tech industry has these characters in them. At NVIDIA, it's pilots in command, and they own the whole project. So they have those people, and they are empowered to just run a project end-to-end. So it appears that if you can just keep them all going, whatever projects you have now will be completed. Whatever projects you might wish to do in the future seems like a bit more of an argument yeah but at least for now in the short term nvidia i think will keep executing but that does make it sound like jensen set himself up in a certain way to be a figurehead right that like functionally if you are the person overseeing all of those PICs. You don't have that much to do

28:25except be the big person in the room, be the Jensen Wong, right? Wear the leather jacket, go to the sphere and tell everybody how amazing AI is. Like that actually becomes the job in that case. And I do wonder, and this is the next question on my list, is does the AI world need, like does that person need to exist in the AI industry as it exists right now? And if it's not Jensen, because it's obviously not Jensen anymore, who is it? Like Mark Zuckerberg can't just go out there and have that kind of like power and credibility in this industry. Can I ask you a question though? Yeah. Why was it Jensen Wong? I think because NVIDIA made the chips. Like, I think it was the only... But who cares? They don't make the technology.

29:09They don't make the models. They don't make the products. I mean, they make some of the products. Well, no, they don't make the products like you're talking about, but they make some of the most important infrastructure. And I also think they make some of the only universally acknowledged best products in their class in this way but they're they're enterprise product their data center accelerated processing like more broadly like why why is why has jensen broken out of ceo circles and become like an honest to god celebrity in his way right and it's the leather jacket it's the fact that he will tell you you're a fucking loser if you dare cross him uh it's he's brash he made this big bet on gpus and he was right but he isn't the person who sells the technology that is actually

29:50disrupting the business world or consumer world or any of it sure right he's the infrastructure this would very much be like if the ceo of siemens was a rock star yeah and you're like all the cell networks running my chips. I'm the iPhone. Yeah. What? Are you talking? Who are you? Yeah. Like how many people can name the CEO of Qualcomm? Too many people who listen to the show. Well, yeah, that's fair. That guy wants to be a cool guy too. Sorry, Cristiano. I love you. You can come on to Coder whenever you want. We all know what it's like. There's just a weirdness there. And I think it's because he was making all the dollars. It was his wealth that made him a celebrity. Yeah. Right? And your average Jensen keynote,

30:33you know, they're all very long. We've been listening to them for years. And they are just machine gunfire tech specs delivered with confidence that hypnotizes you into believing that he's absolutely right about everything. Yes. Which is a very useful skill. Don't get me wrong, super useful skill. But the question is who will be the new face of AI? That person almost certainly has to be from a model company or a product company that is making actual change. And I think by default, if you just look at that set of characters, you're going to pick Jensen instead. Right? Sure. You're like, Dario, you're the new face of AI. And it's like, you just back into that bush, buddy. Homer Simpson style.

31:13It's not Dario. All Dario wants to do is like sadly tell you about how the world might end. It's not Sam Altman, who is messy and has a pretty low confidence rating on his own. It's not Mark Zuckerberg. Same reasons. It's not Elon. rating on his own. It's not Mark Zuckerberg. Same reasons. It's not Elon. It's not Sundar. He just doesn't seem to have the sort of force of personality in that same way. It's not Satya Nadella, who I think actually has some of that same force of personality, but doesn't seem to... He doesn't have any products. and he doesn't seem to be interested in pointing his energy in that direction. Like Satya does not strike me as somebody who is desperately trying to be more famous.

31:50Oh, interesting. Which I think is frankly largely to his credit as a CEO. And I think he just doesn't have any products. I think in that brief moment when Bing was going to rival Google, the glimmer was in his eye. Yeah. I mean, yes, he did one very good decoder episode. I agree with you on that. No, I'm just saying, I was on the other side and he was like, but then he didn't do that. Instead, he tried to bang Kevin Roos. Sure. It's not... By the way, can I just say, I keep making that joke. I've made that joke for years. It's a whole chapter of Kevin's book. Oh, yeah. I don't feel bad about this joke at all anymore. No. I asked Kevin about this on both of our shows, or on the Verge cast, and you asked him about it on Decoder,

32:27and he's just like, well, I had to. What do you mean? This is who I am now. But that was the high point of Nadella's ability to be a famous speaker. You're totally right. But so I think it's none of those people who's left. Like there is no heir apparent that is obvious to me in this way, which I think is really fascinating. And I actually think in a lot of ways, having that person, whether it's to be the person most successfully in Trump's ear, whether it's the person able to most successfully make the whole AI industry and Wall Street feel better about itself. I think the AI industry needs that person. I think the thing Jensen did broadly in public for the AI industry was really important for the AI industry. And I think it's the house of cards looks a lot more fragile

33:11without him there. Yeah. I think the only thing I'm pointing out is he wasn't making the products. He was making the infrastructure. And the money. You're absolutely right. Like, it's not nothing that NVIDIAIA his fame rose as NVIDIA became the most valuable company in the world. Right. And the thing he was saying was I'm taking my money and I'm making a bet on all these other companies and therefore you should trust me. Right. But I'm just going to close the loop. He never said because these products are great. But they were. Right. Like the things he was making were great. NVIDIA's products are great but the products affecting your life and disrupting your work and all that stuff. It's a bunch of weird Justin Bieber slop like a deep fake slop.

33:53Which is sort of funny because nobody nobody pinned the problems of AI on Jensen Wong, which is a thing he had never really thought about until now, but is really true. Like he was far enough back in the equation that people who were mad about data centers weren't mad at jensen wong about data center oh some of them were some of them were but it wasn't it was not nearly pointed the people were mad at meta for building data centers and kevin o'leary for building data centers they weren't mad at jensen wong for filling them with his chips in nearly the same way he he got the the defensibility of being slightly removed from the products that people don't like and all of the ways in which those products are built that people don't like.

34:29But all of the upside of being able to be so closely associated with all of the AI things. Like he set himself up sort of perfectly. Because he also makes a consumer product that people love because he makes gaming GPUs. Sure. Yeah. I'm just coming back around. That's true. gaming GPUs. Sure. Yeah. I'm just coming back around. There are no great consumer AI products and if you have a great consumer product, you get to get away with a lot, including being Jensen Wang and banging an alleged Chinese spy until the second domino falls and the Trump administration tears itself apart in recriminations and blame and then you have to resign. Yeah. Okay. Two more questions for you. And this one's actually for you specifically. there's been a lot of comparison between this and the sam altman

35:10open ai ordeal do you think these two things rhyme with each other at all no not even a little bit you know it's interesting we just had helen toner on decoder i think that episode's coming out soon uh she was on the board she's one of the people who pulled the trigger with along with elias discover and the rest to fire Sam Altman. Right. And I asked her, would you do it again? She goes, of course I would do it again. Interesting. And I was like, talk more. And she's like, lawyers. And then that was the end of that conversation. Look, they, I think all the people involved in that will happily tell you they did a bad job of executing that decision, but they think they made the right decision.

35:43And no one involved in that decision works at OpenAI anymore. Sure. Yeah. Right? Mira Marotti, Elias Huskover, Helen Turner, they're all gone. And they probably should have communicated the reasons they did that more loudly and more openly. I think they will also tell you that that was a mistake. In this case, he resigned. He resigned after a very public pressure campaign in which he openly lied to shareholders, the public, and potentially the government and his board. There's no coming back from that. Right? There's no Steve Jobs in the wilderness coming back from that. It's like you lied to shareholders. The amount of shareholder litigation that will result as of today is going to be through the roof.

36:22Yes. So you can't just swing on back in. This is a big public company. It's been around for a long time. It's made a lot of people a lot of money. He only has 3%. There's no dual class stock structure. He's not in control of the thing. There's not, at least as far as we can tell, an employee revolt or a mutiny, which is really what brought Sam back. Yep. This company will end or Microsoft. You remember this? Microsoft was going to hire everybody. Oh yeah. And put them in a Microsoft division. They'd ordered the laptops, which is my favorite little detail from that moment in time, which is really funny because they probably just like circular ordered their own surface laptops. Like finally a customer. There's just

36:58none of that happening here. And then that's, that's just the structure of it. And then you, there were, there were no congressional investigations into all the principles there is no howard lutnick might have to go to jail involved in the sam altman debacle so i i don't i think this one it's only going to get worse for everyone there's no heroic return yeah i think that's right and to that you you just brought up my last question which is what what do you think is the next turn here? I do think Jensen resigning ends one part of this story, and it feels like all the next stuff might take a minute in that, you know, like you said, there's going to be a lot of people hauled in front of Congress.

37:36There's going to be a lot of investigations. That stuff takes time. That stuff often leads to a lot of yelling and nothing else. Is it obvious? What do you think the next thing is? You have shareholder lawsuits. You have additional investigations. You have, I don't know, empowered attorneys general. Colette Kress, you are the CFO of NVIDIA. Did you know Megaspeed consisted of a bunch of shell office buildings that might've just been freight forwarding NVIDIA chips to China legally? There's a question you could ask of the new CEO. Yeah. Yeah. Who would know? Presumably would know. Yeah. Who at NVIDIA knew that this man was constantly in the company of these women? Were alarms raised? Who in the government knew these things?

38:16There's just no way that a bunch of very interested parties, some of which have the power to put you in jail, are not going to ask those questions. In fact, they have every incentive to make a name for themselves by asking those questions ever more loudly of every single person. Yeah, I think you're right. And for that reason, I do not think Tim Cook will take the job. I do not think Johnny Struge wants this job. Like, you got to let this thing burn out before you can involve anyone else in this role. This does seem in a funny way like a massively undesirable job, at least for the relatively near future. Yeah, you need it. They're going to if it's not the CFO, they will hire the most anodyne McKinsey type in the entire world to stabilize and operationalize this company before you bring someone else in.

39:04And that job will be to sit in front of Congress and say anodyne things. world to stabilize and operationalize this company before you bring someone else in. And that job will be to sit in front of Congress and say anodyne things. Yep. I wasn't here. Based on what we know. I agree. Everyone else should go to jail. But he already resigned. Yeah. I'll give you Jason's number. I never knew the man. You should do it. If you're interested, now's the time. Yeah, a number of security cameras have detected the hamburger running through our halls. Like, whatever you need me to say, dog. Wasn't me. Like, Shaggy is out there just like, wasn't you? That's pretty good. All right, well, I suspect we are going to be talking about this roughly every week forever.

39:44So let's pause there for now and take a break. But God help us, this will keep happening. We're going to come back. We're going to talk about TikTok and streaming because it's the first cast and that's what we do. We'll be right back. Support for the show comes from Jira by Atlassian. AI is only as useful as the context it has to work from. But when that context is scattered across tools, threads, and DMs, that means your team and your AI agents end up flying blind. That's the problem Jira solves. What's the gold tie to your project? What got decided last week in Slack DMs? Atlassian's Teamwork Graph pulls all the pieces together from Jira, Confluence, GitHub, Slack, and more, so nothing falls through the cracks. With Jira, you can actually share the context

40:26with agents you already use, like Claude, Cursor, and GitHub Copilot. Assign them work directly or connect your agents through Atlassian MCP. Spend less time digging through endless links and DMs, less time chasing down what got decided and by who, and more time actually shipping with Jira. Learn more at Jira.com. That's J-I-R-A dot com. All right, we're back. So, Nilay, there's been a bunch of, I would say, small-ish news stories this week coming out of streaming companies. We're in earnings season, so all these companies are declaring their values to investors as they want to do from time to time. And it turns out everybody is pointed at the same thing, which is what we keep talking about, which is that literally nobody has any idea what they're doing.

41:20And like we've heard from, let's see, we heard from Paramount Skydance this week, David Ellison and his giant new conglomerate. We've heard from what Disney's up to. Peacock has new stuff. Tubi has new stuff. Ronnie Mull on our team wrote a great thing called Streaming is Still Trying to Be TikTok, which I think is as good a summation of the story as any. But in particular, I wanna know your thoughts, Nili, about this deep obsession that all of these streaming companies have developed with. We have to have a feed of vertical videos in our app. And I put it that way because no one has a more sophisticated take than that. Some do. Some have different ideas about what that means, but everybody is aligned on if you want to be a streaming service, the most important thing to

41:59have is a scrollable feed of vertical videos. Full stop. The future of Hollywood is you paying $500 a month. That's where we're going. I'm just calling it out. They're headed towards $500 a month in total streaming subscription costs to watch something on TV while you have that same services app open on your phone, scrolling clips of that thing. Okay. And I say this because right now everyone's doing effectively that for way cheaper. They open Netflix and then they open TikTok. Right. And there's a statistical chance that you will encounter clips of the thing that you are watching on Netflix while you are scrolling TikTok. And they know this and this has to be driving them bananas. I had, this was a few weeks ago now,

42:48but I had one of the most incredible deja vu moments of my life watching the show Tires on Netflix. It's Shane Gillis' show. It's very funny. I actually really recommend it. The only thing I know about the show is that's where the, it's the song about the breakers quote comes from, that little audio. Oh, yeah. That's not even their best song. It's the one about, it's that show, right? Yes. That's the only thing I know about that show, but I'm like, that's a good quote. It's delightful. I enjoyed it very much. But I had a moment where exactly the thing that you just described happened, where I'm watching Tires and a scene that I had watched, I'm not kidding, four minutes earlier, came up on my TikTok feed.

43:24And it was really like a jump scare when this appeared on my phone. And it is the most convinced I've ever been that my phone is listening to me and directly feeding algorithmic stuff towards me. But they know this because if you just think about the economic reality of that experience that you had, you paid them money to watch tires. Yes. You did not pay anyone any money to watch that same click on TikTok. Correct. And so this is their nightmare, is they have to market the stuff to you on TikTok by turning a blind eye to the rampant clip piracy that is happening. And in some cases, they are paying their own clipping agencies to promote the shows. In many cases, in fact, they are paying to promote the shows by posting the content to TikTok for free in the vain hope that this will cause you to spend ever more money per month on a subscription to their TV app, which you are still not realize, one, I'm not actually watching these shows. I don't need to subscribe to them. And then two, they're going to realize they bought

44:29Samsung frame TVs because they prefer how they look when they're off to when they're on because they don't watch the TV and they just, they prioritize how it looks when it's off and they will get rid of the TV entirely and replace it with some actual goddamn art. The way I know we've been doing this for too long is literally the minute you started talking four minutes ago, I knew this is where you were going. I'm just saying, the army of teenagers working for free is an economic disaster on the supply side, right? Because your competitors are teenagers who do not need money to make infinite content. And then on the demand side, you're stuck with, oh, I'm just watching my phone anyway. And in many cases, I'm watching clips of the show that you posted in the futile hope that I will now pay $32 a month for Hulu without ads, which is what the number just went up to.

45:16Insane. And I'm stuck because of Bluey. Yeah. All right. That's all I got for you. Recently, I switched off the ESPN part of the bundle to get the no ads on Hulu and Disney Plus part of the bundle. And it was the most, like, I am sacrificing my needs for my child's needs thing that I think I've ever done in my entire life. It's like, goodbye sports. Hello, fewer ads during movies. I used to justify this with NFL Primetime, which is still the single best football show ever. uh but then we had a second child yeah and now who has time for that nope yeah nfl i don't even know what that is anymore okay but but i think what's funny about this to me is i think you're you're completely right that it's futile and also if you are one of these companies it's

46:03probably the right thing to do. Yes, without question. And this is the challenge, right? Where I think, like I opened up the Disney Plus version of this, and it's called Verts. It's right there in the tab bar of the app when you open it. It's very obvious they're trying to put this in front of you. And scrolling through it, I mean, it's exactly what you would think. It's vertical clips from stuff that's on Disney Plus. And it feels like I'm scrolling through a bunch of ads in a way that seeing even the same clips in TikTok would not feel like ads. And I spent a long time trying to figure out, okay, if you're Disney, how do you dress this up in a way that doesn't just make it feel like I'm scrolling through a bunch of trailers,

46:41even though functionally that's what it is. And I'm fine with it when it's on TikTok, but it feels bad when I'm on Disney Plus. And they're all talking about, you know, how do we how do we do stuff with creators? This is Paramount's idea. This is Disney's idea. They're all talking about, you know, Disney is even like working with TikTok and doing some integrations there. Like, I think if you're these companies, you have to do this. There just is no other move at this moment in time. But I just I have such a hard time imagining it working. Right. Because, again, on the supply side, they're competing with those platforms which have perfect cost structures. They don't pay for the content because of the army of teenagers working

47:17for free. And then on the demand side, consumers have overwhelmingly picked those experiences. Yeah. So what are we going to do? So you have to participate. You have to compete in some way. And I think the reason that, you know, the Disney feed or any other feeds feel like ads is because they care too much about their content in a way that the clip farms do not. I do think that's right. It's all very glossy and like fills the whole screen. Yeah. I mean, it's like, give me the thing that only takes up a third of the middle of the screen and is just a weirdly cut off version of the trailer. Just do the lines. Make it look like piracy. Yeah, yeah. Just do it. Just like let the AI go through it, cutting randomly in the middle of things, dropping you in the middle of sentences.

47:57Make it feel like the thing you're actually losing to. Yeah. And maybe that will work. Or maybe develop some other integration with some of these platforms. Or if you do encounter some of their IP, it lets you drop into a full experience in a way that's actually economically valuable. But I don't think these platforms want to do that. They don't want to take you out of their app. And you know what's funny is Instagram is doing this in reverse, right, with their long-form video. Where they're like, we'll show you clips of a podcast and then we'll get you to go watch the long form video, a product that we've never had before social platforms. All the social platforms are saying, no, actually what we want is high touch, highly produced, longer stuff that we can run mid-roll

48:50ads in and put on your television. And that's just streaming services. Like these two sides are just absolutely running at each other's actual, you know, best features all at once. And I think correctly, every streaming service is terrified that youtube will be them before they are able to be youtube or tiktok or instagram like do you think youtube's uh do you think youtube shorts works i guess depends on how you define works like do i watch it by accident sometimes absolutely yeah do i get irritated what's in the search results what i don't i don't think i was actually thinking about this the other day, that like when we talk about vertical videos, we talk about Instagram Reels and TikTok.

49:30And then like one out of 10 times you go, oh, like, oh, and YouTube Shorts. But it is such a distant third in terms of how we perceive the platforms. But it doesn't really matter. Like YouTube's thing is YouTube. Shorts is a useful discovery mechanism for YouTube. This is what they want. Right. This is what HBO Max would love. If their discovery mechanism was you open this app, you flip through some shorts, and then you are like, I'd love to see more from this creator. And then you go watch a bunch of long form on your TV. Yeah. YouTube has figured that out. Right? In some way, they have figured that out. Whether or not it's actually the end goal that everybody wants, up for debate, right? Like, is YouTube Shorts a cultural phenomenon the way that Instagram Reels has turned itself into a cultural phenomenon?

50:14Like, I don't, you're never going to get Fleetwood Mac going viral again because of YouTube Shorts. It's just not going to happen. Yeah. That's the thing. TikTok is just like horsepower into existence whenever it wanted to. But in terms of that discovery mechanism where you watch a short and you land on a podcast or a creator and the long form is there and that's very native, it is the closest anyone has gotten. Yeah, I agree with that. And I think the thing that all of these social platforms have going for them is just raw quantity of content. I remember talking to the folks at Real Good, which is one of those like data combining services that pulls all the all the streaming services together and tries to help you

50:51find stuff to watch. They're also a provider for a lot of like, search engines that you might use elsewhere on the internet. But anyway, they're like universal search for streaming services. And one of the things that they said is they're like, actually, Netflix could have the perfect algorithm to know exactly what you want. And it only matters if they have the perfect algorithm to know exactly what you want. And it only matters if they have the perfect piece of content to put in front of you. And they only have a few thousand pieces of content. So the just library of stuff to give you at the end of the algorithm is much smaller. And their pitch was, well, we can do a better job because we can combine all the streaming services.

51:25YouTube is like several orders of magnitude larger in terms of the content it has available to it to put into your feed. So even if Disney knows exactly what I want to watch, TikTok probably has more of it than Disney does. It's actually TikTok is full of that same content pirated from Disney. It has all those clips and everything else. And because Disney is paying its own marketing agencies to post those clips. Yeah. This is a nightmare death spiral for this industry. Yes. I think I've gotten all the way to Hollywood is in an unrecoverable death spiral. And maybe it's because the Ellison takeover of Warner is complete and now they own so much stuff. And Ross and Ashley are going to come on in a bit.

52:05I'm confident we'll end up talking about James Gunn in DC. But like that only ends one way. Like buying Warner Brothers only ends one way. And then everyone else has this like massive economic problem that is unsolvable until you break people's relationship with their phones. This is the best argument for the iPhone duo. If you wanted to save Hollywood, you would give everyone in America an iPhone Duo because watching vertical video in an iPhone Duo is not fun. Landscape video is going to be back because you have to open your phone. You open your phone and you settle into a prestige drama. So, okay. To that point, I don't know if you've noticed this, but also everyone is desperately in on micro dramas. Micro dramas, people should know, are a real like hobby horse of Neely's.

52:48I watch a lot of really weird AI created micro dramas and then I send them to Addie Robertson and she's like, weird, these do have the extremely bizarre psychosexual problems that you've been describing to me in Slack at work. The ones I see are the ones where there's always like a flood coming and it's people running towards a shelter that they have in the ground. They go right and they close it right as the flood comes it's all very strange I mean all the microdrama the AI microdrama companies in particular have just like raided the fan fix sites and like AO3 which they in fact do have bizarre psychosexual problems and like all of the work that are created like uh so we have talked about that

53:26verge for ages just like that whole community and how important it is and like that's that's where a lot of books come from anyway uh to see like ai recreations of that stuff as in microdrama form in many ways is the only verge story that has ever existed fair communities formed on the internet and then robots got really confused about what people wanted. A billion dollar industry was born. Yes. But the thing is, micro dramas, every time we write about micro dramas, people just flood our comments with the word quibby. And I think if again, this is this is one of those things that I'm like, I don't think it's going to work, but I also don't know how you don't try. If you are one of these companies, if you are Netflix or Disney or whoever else, of course you are going to run down this road and land at,

54:11what if we made vertical content, but better? And that's a way to drag people back into the Disney Plus app to watch the Pixar micro drama that we have made for our platform. You're shaking your head. Why won't this work? Because the micro drama monetization model has nothing to do with paying for content. It has everything to do with loot boxes and video games. What do you mean? So the way the big micro drama apps are monetized is you get one for free. They all end with cliffhangers and it's like, are the hot people going to bang? Like this is what they're all like. And then you have to buy coins to get more. And then they cliffhanger you again. And you got to buy more coins. And sometimes you get a good coin.

54:52And all of that free-to-play mechanic is stolen from video games and has nothing to do with Disney doing recurring revenue. Like, Disney is too proud to actually do microdramas the way that the Chinese micro drama companies care nothing for like the American economic security. But you can just you can see the problem. Yeah. And if there's a really good story in the in the times about micro drama production and want the line that really stuck out to me was they don't care about the content behind the paywall. All of the production effort, all of the lighting, all of the care is in the two content behind the paywall. All of the production effort, all of the lighting, all of the care is in the two episodes before

55:30the paywall to get you hooked to make you pay the money. Once you've paid, they don't care anymore. They don't care. And it's like, they just like turn off the lights to save on like power. Yeah. You know, they're like, well, this person's less hot than the previous person. Like whatever it is they're paying for. And there's something about the economics of micro dramas where, yep, Quibi might have had an idea, but they did not have the other idea, which was to basically use free to play mechanics from video games to monetize video content. Do you think it's possible to use those things as essentially loss leaders to get people into your system? Because again, the other thing that all these companies agree on is that they need a free tier. Netflix has been talking about

56:10it. Disney has been talking about it. This idea that we need to put some stuff in front of the paywall to hook people into our ecosystem a little bit. Whether it's a selection of content or you get to watch a certain amount of stuff before you hit the paywall or whatever, there are a million different ideas about how to do this. But the idea that somebody needs to be able to land on our app and do something before we ask them for money is, I think, just absolutely coming for all of these services, especially as they ramp up their ads business. Can you stick those two ideas together and say, well, what if the thing that you come for is the Pixar micro drama in the verts tab? And then you get to the end and we say, do you want to go watch Monsters, Inc.?

56:54Pay Disney Plus. say do you want to go watch monsters inc pay disney plus what do you think i don't i don't hate that oh yes the pixar micro drop on the verts tab i don't know the words man i mean i think i think a lot about this so like one of the things in the disney app that you get is a lot of uh ancillary content that I didn't know existed. Like there are five Toy Story movies and then there are like 12 Toy Story shorts just sort of floating around in the Disney Plus app. And for me, it's like, well, what if you're Disney, just shove the Toy Story stuff that isn't the movies in front of the paywall and let kids watch those and learn who the Toy Story characters are and then say, hey, for $9.99 a month

57:28or whatever, however many thousands of dollars Disney ends up charging, you can come watch the Toy Story movies. That could work. Then you're saying the only thing these studios should be saying, which is we're going to win with great content, right? This is what we were saying about Netflix not that long ago, that Netflix forgot that it was in the business of making things people actually want to watch. And then it started to wane and is now rebooting the whole company to get back in the business of making stuff people want to watch. And so for me, it's like, maybe you can borrow a little bit of the TikTok mechanic and a little bit of the vertical scrolling stuff and still be in the business

58:03of making stuff people want to watch. And there's something there. The problem is there is absolutely no evidence ever, anywhere, ever, and still be in the business of making stuff people want to watch. And there's something there. The problem is there is absolutely no evidence ever, anywhere, ever, that what I just said is true. No. It feels true. No, it's not true. I mean, like, look, if we, you know, we just published a story on the culture of private torrent trackers. Yeah. By the Yakka Rockers. Great story. Everybody should go read the story. And there's like this furious argument in the comments about why people do piracy and all this stuff and a dynamic that is just hard to wrap your head around is the economics of film and tv are such

58:36that you rarely watch anything twice right there's some i know you're like a sicko and you turn on the office when you're like walking around your house um and like there's some of that comfort food in the world but the hollywood previously was built on selling things multiple times there's like a great ben affleck speech about dvds that you can go watch right he's like the collapse of the dvd killed hollywood it's matt damon just it's matt damon it's i understand that they're essentially the same person but it's a good speech it's very good ben affleck has a good ai speech he does about training models so they're in it. Anyway, you can just go watch it. It's basically the argument, which is you used to make a TV show and NBC would put Friends out on air and

59:16collect a bunch of advertising revenue because it was the one everyone wants to watch. Then they would run it in reruns and make a bunch of advertising revenue again in the summer. And then they would syndicate it to 10 different cable channels. At the same time, they were selling it internationally. And then they would sell it to you as different cable channels. At the same time, they were selling it internationally. And then they would sell it to you as a DVD box set. And this is like 50 different ways to make your money. And that let the cost of production be high. Right? Because you have this pathway to recoup your losses everywhere. Now it's like Netflix makes a show and they're like, did it drive subscribers?

59:42Right. Will season two drive subscribers? It won't. Goodbye show. Yeah. And that's just, they got one shot and the shot is to get more subscribers. Will season two drive subscribers? It won't. Goodbye, show. And that's just, they got one shot and the shot is to get more subscribers. And if it can't do that, they'll let you go. I think with all of these things that you're describing, we'll have a free tier. We'll have an ad supported tier. We'll license shows to one another. Apple will be here with free movies for some reason. They are redeveloping all of these different little content windows and monetization strategies. I have no idea which ones will work, but unless Hollywood just like stares right at the supply and demand problems. Yeah. We compete with free content in a format

1:00:18that people like better. And what you have is the verts tab and Disney plus like they're gun. They have to do something else to make that work and i think probably what they should do is stand up one combined discovery feed full of content from all of the studios to have the volume you're talking about and then and then kick you back out to whatever but they they can't compete on the volume of the supply side against any of the social platforms and they certainly are not competing on the user experience side of the apps. So what are you going to do? That's interesting. I like the idea of a sort of Movies Anywhere type collaboration. It's already dead. We've killed it already. I had this idea 30 seconds ago,

1:00:56and you murdered it in its cradle. What you're describing is an app called Hollywood in which all the studios work together, and that is best of luck. It's a lot of people who are famously easy to work with all working together on this, on this idea. Well, they all had the same problem. So maybe, maybe this time. Yeah. Um, I do think the other thing, and just the, I mentioned to be in Peacock, the other thing that keeps coming up as you see what these companies are up to is, uh, this broad discovery problem, uh, to be launched this really interesting thing called mixtapes, where you can basically make public playlists of stuff on to be and share them with people. And that's, it's just like a very simple, clever discovery tool. Peacock is doing conversational

1:01:36AI search. So you can tell it what you want to find other streaming services have this already, but you can just see that what these companies are discovering is that it's very hard to find things to watch. And actually, what's really easy is to just open TikTok and watch what's on there. So this is the other part of that experience that all these companies are so threatened by is. And this is where I actually think Netflix kind of got too big for its britches is Netflix reached a point where they were like, we are just a default app. You will open and look for something to watch. And overwhelmingly, people said, no, thank you. which is Netflix reached a point where they were like, we are just a default app. You will open and look for something to watch.

1:02:09And overwhelmingly people said, no, thank you. I will go to you when there is something to watch that I will go find. And all of these services are awful at discovery. It's just giant windows full of tiles of movie posters, which turns out to not be as compelling a system as I tapped the TikTok icon. And now that all these things are on my TV with recommendation systems and never ending feeds, you can just see these streaming services flailing to figure out how do we put stuff in front of you faster? Netflix should launch an app called Netflix What to Watch. And it's just chaotic AI driven cuts of all of its movies. And whenever you like one, you like press the star button and then you open Netflix and it

1:02:48just drops you in the middle of that movie and you can rewind if you want, or you can just keep watching. And this would actually solve their problem. They will never do this because they, they have, I don't know, copyright licensing deals. The actors will get mad. Like they care too much, but that's actually the product they need to make. That's a really good idea. Like, genuinely, that might be the best product idea you've ever had on the first cast. Yeah, but you have to take the entire Netflix catalog and be like, robots are going to chaotically cut this into nonsense. And that will be a better discovery mechanic than any other system that we ever have because it's the discovery mechanic that is already winning.

1:03:23Every single guild in Hollywood just started writing their response letter to that idea. The first cast email is going to be a mess. Yeah. So you're really of the mind now that Hollywood is sort of doomed. That unless something giant changes and quickly, it is spiraling towards death. I think we're about to see David Ellison run this particular version of the experiment to the finish line. Because his posture is everyone is stupid except for me yep and so he's going to do all the things he said no one else could do he's going to bundle Paramount and HBO Max it's like some news that he has he's going to add a free tier in micro dramas he's going to build some technology to make discovery he's going to do everything and he's going to realize that the next Matt Reeves,

1:04:08Batman movie is still more expensive than a Batman cosplay video on Tik Tok. Yeah. And people are going to pick the cosplay video and there's nothing you can do about that. Right. Well, except the, the good news on the Hollywood side is that movie theaters are back like super duper back sure and the idea of like collective movie going experiences are are cool and exciting and people want them what's funny is this comes kind of one whole generation after all of these services decided to stop doing great movies and to start betting on long discursive television shows yep uh and and either they're going to pivot back to event-based programming in a big way or i think they are headed exactly the way you're describing it's it'll definitely david olsen in particular is

1:04:57like all mission impossible movies the problem with movie theaters being back is okay you're going to make the big spectacle you're going to make avengers Doomsday and then you have to sell it five more times. Right. And there still isn't that. You don't have that thing. There's not, not all the way down. This is my, my, I've always thought that we should review movies based on a screen scale. Like what screen is this movie worth? And you start at a movie theater and you end at Delta Seatback for free. Right. And like, this is worth the Delta Seatback. They don't have those sales. There's no screens in the middle. There's, we made a lot of money and there's nothing. I'm not ready to call it. I just think

1:05:34we're going to see Alison speed run to the conclusion, which is you have to do something else. You can't just be everyone else's stupid except for me. Yeah, I agree. All right. We, we, we can leave that there. We've got a lot of streaming stuff left to talk about. All right, it's time now for the Hype Desk where our friends Ross Miller and Ashley Esqueda come and tell us cool things. Ross and Ashley, welcome back. Hello. Hello. Long time no see. I know. It's been a minute. I went on parental leave. I haven't seen either of you in like 100 years. It's very nice to have you back. What do you guys have for us this week? What do you want to talk about? I think we got to talk about Ocarina of Time. Right, Ross?

1:06:13Let's talk Ocarina of Time. You've been playing, I've been playing or rather my wife's been playing and I've been supporting her and helping her where I can. I have been told Ocarina of Time is a really good spectator sport that like it's actually unusually fun to watch someone else play this game i am experiencing it right now through my son's eyes oh it's very good he's seven uh but watching him this has been like kind of the joy of for me like the joy of parenting as like a gamer has been like watching him play things that I experienced when I was younger, like through his eyes and how he thinks about puzzles and stuff, man, that it's so good. It's so beautiful. It's so like, it's the way that I thought it looked in my head when I originally played it. Like, it's like,

1:07:02it's so cool to like see it realized like it's. It's everything my imagination thought it would be. That's actually, A, a huge deal. And B, it seems to be kind of the consensus that a whole generation of people who grew up playing a pixelated version of this game, people are like, this is it. They did it. They finished the thing that I have been imagining all this time. Which is such an unbelievably high bar for re-imagining this like incredibly important nostalgic game. Here's what I remember at Ocarina of Time when I played it. For first of all, this is like a CRT game, right? Yes, 64. So I think what people are remembering is those graphics, but then if you play them in an emulator, they look bad on

1:07:42LCDs and OLEDs, right? So they like fuzzed them up and up-resed them the right way. I'm just telling you, this is like a real thing. This is the way I remember it looking as a real technology element to it. Oh, yeah. I also just remember being like, I've got to play this flute a lot and that was very controller dependent. How did they solve that for the Switch? Well, first off, it is an ocarina. The name of the game is Ocarina of Time. No, no, no, no. It's the flute of time. It really is. It's the flute of time. Yeah, the flute of minutes. Chrono flute. Chrono flute adventures. Nilay plays the time flute is a Twitch show just waiting to happen. You can play it the same way you did before where you just go into Ocarina mode and you just hit the buttons and all that.

1:08:27And it does match the right notes and the staff. But you can also, if you have a microphone, Ashley. Or if you have a Switch 2, you can literally use the microphone and sing to it. You can do the... It's awesome. It's so cool. Could you do that for us now, Ashley? No, absolutely not. No? Okay. You know why? Because I care about licensing. and I don't want you to get in trouble. That's smart. But it's really spectacular how they incorporated that. It's really fun. So this seems to be one of the themes with this game, actually, is that Nintendo and even players have found a bunch of weird, cool things to do with this game. I've heard a bunch of people talk about how if you use the, I think it's the Nintendo app,

1:09:10there's all kinds of cool stuff you can do inside of the game. If you play it next to it and Ross, you're saying people are like finding weird, wild external Zelda experiences to have too. Yes. This gets into the little more of like the, the nebulous area of like hacking and ROMs and all that. But like in with any game that comes out, you see it very quickly get ported to PC and people can start playing around doing what they want with it uh it's partially an AI story but we'll skip that part in record time I think within less than a week uh the Switch 1 and Switch 2 kind of hacking community managed to get this ported on PC and then really start just playing around with it in ways that you know you're going to see but like not in this amount of time like 21 by 9 widescreen PC support uh I've seen it played

1:09:51on an iPhone 18 airplay to a TV iPhone Duo with like a custom UI in the map on the second part of the screen the one that blows me away is um there was it's the same user who did the Legend of Zelda, the Tears of the Kingdom recomp, did multiplayer. Yes. So you can Ocarina of Time in multiplayer. Multiplayer. Which is pretty wild. So everyone's just swinging at different Switch 2s. I guess so, yeah. It's so wild to me that it's like, oh, yeah, we just added some online multiplayer mod to this. No big deal. Well, so inside of me are two wolves, right? It's like the nerd in me is like, that's really cool. But then also the person who likes having a job in the industry is like, I hate that. Like, I don't want that.

1:10:37Turn it off. Turn it all off. I think a lot of people are having that exact feeling right now. Right now, Nintendo's fine. They are selling more time flutes than ever before. Five, what is it? Five, over five million units in the first four days. That's crazy. That is incredible. What do you make of the fact that it's all nostalgia? Like, actually, I'm curious about this. Like, Zelda-wise, right? Like, Breath of the Wild and Tears of the Kingdom are masterpieces. They went backwards, not forwards. The incentives to go backwards are always quite high. Well, yes and no. So, I mean, like, we are long in the era of, like, reboots, remakes, and remasters, right? On some economic level, it's like, look, these are the safest IPs.

1:11:15But unlike a movie where you can just go watch an old movie and it works just fine, like, if you go back to the original Ocarina of Time, which you can because it's in the Switch Classics app, there's no jump button. It's a little clunkier. And to your point, it just doesn't look the same, doesn't have the same kind of save function that people expect. There's a lot of reasons where you can't capture that same memory with the same level of patience that you had in the Nintendo 64 era. So it almost becomes a necessity to kind of move this up. And again, to your point, Nintendo sold five and a half million of these, but you see it again and again. There's been so many remakes, particularly during weird economic times

1:11:51where people are scared of making risks. Taking risks, yeah. Yeah, very scared of taking risks. Ocarina of Time was guaranteed to sell, so they had time to like, we can do this right, we can modernize it. And if it does well, turns out the same kind of game, Back Engine, works with Majora's Mask, the other really big Zelda game from that era. So there's rumors that's coming out. They've denied it. Who knows? I feel like it's more of a matter of time at this point than anything. All right. You guys also brought one other thing to us, which is a bit of news we all need to briefly have some feelings about. Ross, what's going on? Yeah, of course. It's the biggest leadership change in Tekken Entertainment this week if you stopped reading the news on Tuesday.

1:12:25Yeah, totally. If you stop on Tuesday. Yeah, totally. If you stop on Tuesday. Yeah, nothing else happened. But no, after four years running DC Films, James Gunn and Peter Safran, who reportedly had this big 10-year plan, kind of becoming DC's Kevin Feige, they're out. They're out early. David Elson has summarily dismissed them, and he's replaced them with Jeremy Latcham, who used to be, quote, the right-hand man of Kevin Feige, left Marvel for a while. He's got producer credit from Iron Man through, like, Age of Ultron. And he's got a lot of big ideas. You know, he says he wants to make superhero movies that grandmas can watch. So this changes quite a bit of the Gunn-Saffron timeline. Yeah.

1:13:08If you look at what Gunn and Saffron did, they're quirky, they're experimental, they really want to play with the art form. They're filmmakers, not tours. Whereas Latcham, and I think more importantly, by extension, David Ellison, he wants general audience movies, right? Clayface doesn't make sense. He makes Mission Impossible. He wants... So from what I have heard from a few people who work in the industry around superhero content, what I have heard is that Ellison is very interested in like the Justice League. This is like the thing. So it's like I want like this sort of high concept popcorn Justice Justice League, grandma can watch stuff. Wait, those words don't go together. I agree. But also what the thing is, is like,

1:13:53I think he feels like he can accomplish that because like he was part of the studio that built the MCU. But even Marvel isn't capable of that anymore. Even they're struggling right now. Yeah, like everybody, the superhero genre, I think is like, it's all struggling. But even Marvel isn't capable of that anymore. Even they're struggling right now. Yeah. Like everybody, the superhero genre, I think is like, it's all struggling. Yeah. With rare exception. Like Spider-Man is like still doing crazy numbers. Yeah. Right. Like Sony's superhero stuff is doing fine. Because everyone forgot about them. Only if it's Spider-Man. Yeah. Spider-Man, Sony's one property, is doing fine. What? He studied with my grandmother in the forest.

1:14:31But even DC, like, even DC under Gunn and Safran, struggled. Everything struggled except for Superman. And so, like, that was the only real breakout hit. And if what you want is the Justice League, you're like, well, the last time you tried that. It failed. Grandma did not like that. Nobody liked that. Neither did anybody else. I mean, look, AT&T liked it so much they made a 4-3 grayscale Justice League. I mean, this is again, my argument is everyone who buys Time Warner ends in a fiery death. And like, here you are. Like, you're staring at fiery death because you bought Warner and you think you can fix it. And actually, this IP will kill you. Yeah. So, yeah, we're hearing, I think, Matt Bellany of Puck reported this week.

1:15:19It's a full reboot mode again. It's exactly that. They're not trying to keep things of the 10-year plan that Gunn and Saffron had. It feels like, yeah, it feels like safe. But here's the thing I do think is different. I think Gunn and Safran came in to be a Kevin Feige. And I do not think Lasham is being set up to be a Kevin Feige figure at all. He's an executive. Whereas Gunn and Safran and Kevin Feige, they report to the top guy, right? He's reporting to Dana Goldberg and Josh Greenstein, the co-presidents of Skydance Motion Picture. Their budget, their decisions are in line with every other film that Skydance is going to make. Like, this is just part of the slate. I don't think we're going to see the same kind of,

1:15:56like, they want to get to Justice League, but I don't think we're going to see, like, the Comic-Con 10-film slate the same way we would with a Feige figure. This is just now a movie studio figuring out what it wants to be. Movie after movie after movie. Re out what it wants to be. Movie after movie after movie. Reboot after reboot after reboot. This is like the DC Studios story is just continual like insane cycles of disaster. Yeah, reset. We should keep moving. Ross, Ashley, you guys have a sponsored segment to do. Neil and I will see you guys on the other side for the lightning round. Take us away, guys. On today's Hype Desk, Ross, we are talking about Jira. I've heard some rumors for a while now

1:16:35that Jira is working on something really big. Yes, because so many people from so many different fields rely on Jira to get their work done. Atlassian could see that crucial information was getting siloed in different apps and platforms. So they spent years mapping out how people actually work and figuring out how to connect the different pieces to have a unified data layer and context engine. And they call that Teamwork Graph. It brings together data from Jira, Confluence, and the other apps and tools your teams already connect to. Then it maps how all of it is related. And it surfaces signals about how you work, like who you collaborate with and what you're working on, to make the right connections more visible.

1:17:15And this is the crucial part. The AI tools you use can now tap into that context too. So they can find information, answer questions, and even take action, all while respecting who's allowed to see what. Honestly, if I was running a production, this sounds like it would be a total home run for my team's productivity. Learn more at Jira.com. Support for the show comes from Jira by Atlassian. AI is only as useful as the context it has to work from. But when that context is scattered across tools, threads, and DMs, that means your team and your AI agents end up flying blind. That's the problem Jira solves. What's the gold tie to your project? What got decided last week in Slack DMs? Atlassian's teamwork graph pulls all the pieces together from Jira, Confluence, GitHub, Slack, and more.

1:18:06So nothing falls through the cracks. With Jira, you can actually share the context with agents you already use, like Claude, Cursor, and GitHub Copilot. Assign them work directly or connect your agents through Atlassian MCP. Spend less time digging through endless links and DMs, less time chasing down what got decided and by who, and more time actually shipping with Jira. Learn more at Jira.com. That's J-I-R-A.com. All right, we're back. Neal, is it time? Do we have to do this again? Oh, it's time. This is like a sequel. It's like very Hollywood. Oh, okay, good. Back with a vengeance. We're extending the IP. Brendan to Electric Boogaloo. It is time once again for America's favorite podcast in their podcast, Brendan Carr is a Dummy.

1:19:04Every once in a while, we got to play the classic intro. Viola de Goombia, shout out. Pretty good. What did Brendan do this week, Neal? So, like I said, we're extending the franchise. We have a new character. We have a- A new dummy? We have a new dummy. Oh, that's so exciting. We've got a Brendan Jr. Oh, no. It's good stuff, man. So, even though you're not supposed to know anything about the FCC, if you're a regular citizen of America, or many of our international listeners who send us emails about how much they know about Brendan Carnow, which is not great, you might know that the FCC has not been fully staffed for quite some time. It's supposed to have three of the majority party and two of the minority party. We only have one Democrat, and then we have two Republicans. We

1:19:45have Brendan, and Olivia Trustee, and we have Ana Gomez. That's the whole FCC right now. Ana Gomez, who continually cannot believe she's not been fired. Well, it's coming. Oh, no. Okay. So you need to have at least three. So this is the right to pass a vote. You need to have a quorum of three out of what is supposed to be five. Anyhow, so in this lame duck session of Congress, President Trump decided to put forth another FCC nominee. Oh boy. Her name is Danielle Thuman-Severs. She's Brendan Carr's senior counsel. Are you serious? So it's Brendan too. Again, we're expanding the franchise. We're going to spin her off. She's going to fight crime in Boston or something. It's going to be great. This is the

1:20:26Chicago med. Do you see what I'm saying? To's gonna be great. This is the Chicago Med... Do you see what I'm saying? ...to Brendan's Chicago Fire. She's gonna have her own adventures. If this all goes to plan, the VCU... This podcast is gonna get longer. The VCCU, I guess it would be. It's gonna keep expanding. Anyway, so we have our conference. hearing. And I do continually point out that Brandon Carr is a dummy, creates strange bedfellows in America. Most notably me and Ted Cruz. And Rupert Murdoch. And Rupert, yeah. The big three, I call you. Rupi Murda and me, we get down. So she has her nomination. Baron Soka, who runs Tech Freedom, point out that he's been covering confirmation hearings for a long time, and Republicans just did not show up to this one. They did not want to talk to the Republican

1:21:12nominee for FCC commissioner because they did not want to be anywhere near the free speech questions. Ted Cruz, to his credit, showed up and asked some questions. And I just want to compare and contrast how Danielle Thuman answered Ted Cruz's questions about free speech with how she answered Democratic questions about free speech. So we have some clips. So here's Ted Cruz basically being like, are you a dummy? Oh, God. In 2018, Senate Democrats urged the FCC to investigate Sinclair's news coverage and questioned its fitness to retain broadcast licenses. In 2023, left-wing activists sought to pressure the FCC to deny renewal of a Philadelphia station's Fox broadcast license. And this year, the FCC ordered eight ABC-owned stations to file

1:22:07early renewal applications as part of the commission's unlawful discrimination investigation, which ABC argues is actually in retaliation for the network's programming. I'm not asking you to prejudge that case. If you are confirmed, will you commit to basing licensing decisions on the law and the record and to not using the FCC's authority to pressure or punish a broadcaster for protected speech? Thank you, Chairman, for the question. Yes. That's it. That's it. No. That is not what I expected to happen. See what I'm saying? It's a long windup. The Democrats do it too. Do you commit to it, right? Right? Oh, that was great. Yes. She's like, yeah. All right. So we move on in this hearing. And I appreciate Senator Cruz's question.

1:23:09The least excited Ted Cruz has ever been to ask a question on television. He did not want to do this. No. Okay. So then Ed Markey, who's a Democrat, who's been on Decoder many times, comes on, asks some questions about E-rate, which is a program he did to put broadband in schools. Whatever. He gets to the free speech question. Listen to this response. Oh, no. Which is, by the to the free speech question. Listen to this response, which is, by the way, the same question. Do you believe it was appropriate for Chairman Carr to use his regulatory authority to pressure broadcasters to take a comedian off of the air? Thank you for the question. Those were his words. They were not my words, and I have not advised him or worked with the chairman on these particular issues.

1:23:50I can say that if I were to be confirmed as commissioner, I would make all of my decisions in the facts and the law and the record. I'm not asking whether you agree with Jimmy Kimmel or not. I'm asking whether the FCC chairman should use the power of his office to pressure broadcasters over protected speech. Again, I can't speak to the intent behind his words. Those were his words. They were not my words. Well, again, the FCC is supposed to protect free speech, not intimidate broadcasters into silencing voices that the president doesn't like. Will you commit to publicly opposing threats like these even when they come from Chairman Carr? I commit to making all of my decisions based on the record and the facts and the law and in the event that there was

1:24:41an enforcement investigation in front of me I would base my decision in the record that forms as a result of that investigation. Again, you are continuing to evade, and anyone seeking a seat on the Federal Communications Commission must be willing to stand up to such threats and to defend the First Amendment, and you are not willing to do so here in your confirmation hearing. Okay, I just want to stop. She's his lawyer. I've never met Brendan Carr in my life. She's counsel in his office. What are we doing? You said his name is Brandon? All right. So then we keep going. Ben Ray Luan asked another series of questions. Straightforwardly the same questions. Let's run this one. Do you support Chairman Carr's illegal campaign to remove Jimmy Kimmel from Nations Airways?

1:25:33Again, I have advised the chairman on issues before three of the bureaus. I have not worked with the chairman on any media-related issues, and I'm not familiar with all of the details regarding the investigation of ABC or the early license renewal of their licenses. And I haven't been involved in any of those conversations regarding any of their practices or regarding Jimmy Himmel. Since you've been advising Chairman Carr, did he make an announcement that differs from your advisement to him? In the nearly five years or little more than five years that i've worked at the agency i have provided a lot of counsel to now chairman carr then commissioner carr sometimes he takes my advice sometimes he does not

1:26:24is there anything you disagreed with chairman car? I'm sure that there have been issues where we have disagreed over the amount of time that I have worked with him. Yes. Can you name one over those five years? I don't think that it would be appropriate for me to be identifying places where I have disagreed with him on policy matters. You've been chief counsel at the FCC. You're here before us to be an FCC commissioner. You will be responsible for making decisions. I'm simply asking if you disagree with any of the decisions that Chairman Carr has made because he would be a colleague of yours and you'd be an equal to him. You're not able to answer that? I'm just pointing out, her response to Ted Cruz was yes.

1:27:03Yes. And all the other ones, she's like, what? I've never... Jimmy Kimmel, is he a... I've only been chief counsel of Ren and Carr. I've never heard him talk about Jimmy Kimmel before in my life. I couldn't possibly tell you. Yeah, I'm familiar with all the details. Against my will, I am familiar with all of the details of the Jimmy Kimmel thing. It's very good. She will, we'll see if she gets confirmed in this lame duck. It seems more than likely that it will get pushed through in a lame duck as these things do. But if she gets confirmed, Anna Gomez, her term is up and she's just on. And so Trump will probably let that expire and then we'll have three Republicans, both of whom are essentially

1:27:45lackeys to Brandon Carr. Including Danielle Thuman, who does not know what is going on. Straightforwardly, it's like, who? Yeah, she's like, sorry, guys, I don't really come to work very often. I'm not, I have no idea who you're talking about. Anyway, so the Brendan Carr's dummy universe is expanding. I would point out that you are about to have a big, empowered Democratic Congress. And I think you're going to see opportunities for the Ted Cruz's of the world to take a big stand on free speech and mention their bipartisan bills about FCC jawboning, whatever they want to do. That's coming. It's coming for Brendan. And the reason that I keep saying that he's a dummy and he's not some Machiavellian genius is that he played himself 100% into this situation.

1:28:34Yep. He arrived at a place where the United States Congress can point to him as a threat to free speech, and I think they're going to. And I'm not sure his confused, acting, ignorant lackeys will be there to help him when that time comes. Anyway, Brendan, Danielle, Olivia, do any of you want to show up Avengers style and try to defend yourself against very obvious questions without claiming that you've never spoken to one another before in your lives? Even as you served as chief counsel, you're more than welcome to be on this show, on Decoder. We're doing live shows in the future. You can show up on stage. Happy to have you. And yeah, that's been Brandon Carr is a Dummy, America's favorite podcast on the podcast.

1:29:19Brandon Carr is a dummy. I just want you to know, Ne-Li, that I'm now imagining you, Rupert Murdoch, and Ted Cruz against the three FCC commissioners in like a WWE-style cage match. I think we could make a lot of money pay-per-viewing our way through. We probably could. All right, I have a lightning round item for you that I suspect we are both going to be very excited to talk about, maybe for very different reasons, which is the billboard charts, the charts that measure the most popular music will now once again include YouTube streaming data. These companies have been at odds for some time. It used to factor in YouTube streaming. The billboard charts are a very complicated thing. It's not as straightforward as add up all the streams and whoever wins, wins.

1:30:10There's a very complicated formula. And basically, Billboard has always considered paid subscription streams to be more valuable than free streams. And the ratio has fluctuated over time. But basically, it got to the point where, let's see, the New York Times had a story that said it was set to 2,500 free streams was the equivalent of 1,000 paid streams. So the idea is that a paid stream is two and a half times more valuable than a free stream. YouTube obviously has an enormous amount of traffic from free viewers. YouTube didn't like that ratio, said it didn't accurately represent the power of YouTube or the experience of people using YouTube. They've been fighting about this. Now that ratio is 1500

1:30:52to 1000. So 1.5 to 1. YouTube still thinks it should be equal parity, but at least seems to be happy enough that it is giving its data back to Billboard to factor into the charts. I feel like I need to pause you here. And we need to do a disclosure. Oh, we do. We now work at the company. I forgot about this. Or we work at a company that's in a joint venture with the company that owns Billboard. Yep. And I know the Billboard people. They're wonderful. And the company that powers the Billboard charts, which is called Luminate. Right. Which is a whole ass enterprise data business. Yeah. Like a big, powerful Luminate. Like, you can go look at it. It's just a big data provider to the entertainment industry.

1:31:34They're there. They power the billboard charts. I've just met the people. Sure. In some convoluted way, we are sister publications. I did not negotiate the YouTube rates. Yeah. But anyway, okay. I think this is fascinating for a reason, but I suspect you also think this is fascinating for a very different reason. Tell me why you're interested in the billboard charts and YouTube. It's my ongoing theory that all of American society has been torn asunder by the fact that no one knows how to measure anything at any time. No one knows how to measure anything at any time. It goes right back to if you stop testing, COVID will go away. That sentence explains more about America than literally anything. If we just stop measuring or we change the terms of measurement,

1:32:20we can tweet a different number and then reality will bend to our will. All of America is explained in this. So in this case, a very specific thing that happened was YouTube disengaged from the data collection that powers the billboard charts. They stopped giving their data because they have to participate. Right. Like Nielsen, Lumina, all these companies they have to go, they have to make, the companies have to send them data affirmatively. So YouTube disconnects and rap music goes away from the Billboard charts or it goes down because there's some difference in how people listen and you can PhD thesis in that specific phenomenon. And a bunch of people get very confused and we have a whole conversation

1:33:05about how rap is dead in America and country music. It is ascendant and there's a cultural vibe shift. And it's like, nope, they're still listening to music on YouTube. And because we disconnected the data and a bunch of young people who don't pay for music services are on YouTube listening to music. There aren't being counted. We are now confused about the nature of reality. Yep. And then we'll see what happens and i plug the data back in obviously the stream ratio is different we'll see but i i suspect that we are now going to discover that rap music has been popular the whole time i think you're exactly right and there's actually been some really interesting data basically because youtube has

1:33:44its own charts uh which i think are also not a perfect representation of anything, but are much more accurate to what's going on on YouTube. And people have been tracking the difference between the two charts. And basically since the data went away, things like K-pop and things like hip hop have become vastly underrepresented for all the reasons you just said. And think like old people music has become vastly overrepresented. It's real. And like Choose in Texas has been this giant hit on the Billboard charts, not necessarily because it is the most popular song in the world, but because it is the most popular song where things are being measured. I think it's fascinating for a different reason,

1:34:18which is I want to rewind a couple of years to when YouTube first started showing up on the Nielsen charts. So what Billboard is to music, Nielsen is to TV and movies, right? It is a it attempts to be a relatively even measure of what is popular and what people are watching. It's not a perfect system, but it's the best one we've got. Kind of like the Billboard charts. And YouTube spent a long time lobbying to be on those charts based on the theory that a lot of people are watching on TV. We are competing on the same wavelengths as a lot of these other companies. Like YouTube really desperately wanted to be on the Nielsen chart because it would give YouTube a lot of credibility to be next to the other streaming services. And they wanted to be seen as like a prestige

1:35:00streaming service. But anyway, so YouTube gets on the chart, immediately jumps to the top of it. And I think has absolutely been that that chart shift became a huge part of the panic about YouTube in Hollywood, because everybody looked at it and said, Oh, my God, however popular we thought we were, YouTube is kicking our ass at our own game. And you can see it on the Nielsen charts. And now our advertisers and our business partners and our content partners, and everybody looks at this and says, Oh, YouTube is more popular. And now the measure always is, you know, Netflix and Disney and whoever else are all together almost as popular as YouTube. And it has made them look worse in an even comparison

1:35:38and it has been ugly and it has been bad. I think Billboard is going to do the same thing to music. YouTube is so popular as a music service. It is it has been the music platform for so long. Do you remember a long time ago, Susan Wojcicki, the then CEO of YouTube, so data pilled, she would run around saying YouTube is fundamentally music service. Yes. Because by any any sane look at the data, the only thing that's happening on YouTube is people watching music videos. Yeah, and I think the billboard charts are obviously slightly different in that they don't perfectly, like they don't show you which service is showing you which things. So it won't be as blindingly obvious that most of what matters is coming from YouTube,

1:36:22but to people paying attention, it will. And all of a sudden you will realize that the place to go to be popular and to go up the billboard charts and to seem very popular is to win on YouTube, not to win paying attention, it will. And all of a sudden, you will realize that the place to go to be popular and to go up the Billboard charts and to seem very popular is to win on YouTube, not to win on Spotify, not to win on Apple Music. You can screw all of those platforms. Just go win on YouTube because that's where the volume is. And I think this one change has the potential to upend the music industry in YouTube's favor in the exact same way that just being measured on the Nielsen chart does for YouTube.

1:36:49Maybe. I'm going to throw you a maybe. Okay. So I think that's true in terms of like catalog, right? Fleetwood Mac and The Clash, they're on YouTube, right? Like Jay-Z's catalog is doing great on YouTube. No one's discovering- I'm glad you picked current billboard charting artists like Fleetwood Mac and The Clash. Well, I'm thinking about big catalogs, like big catalogs that transact for billions of dollars. The reason that that, like private equity is buying music because the catalog lives forever on these platforms and they can sell advertising. Like that's what I mean by catalog. That's why it's always classic rock that transacts for these numbers. You're a new artist, right? If you're Olivia Rodrigo, your discovery is still happening on Instagram and TikTok.

1:37:36And then maybe people are going to YouTube. But all new discovery happens there. Yes. But the hope has been to funnel that to Spotify. That has been the hope, yeah. And it has made people like the people who program New Music Friday. Like, that's a very powerful thing in the music industry because it guarantees you a certain amount of streams, it guarantees you a certain amount of popularity, and if you can just woo this small handful of people inside Spotify, you can basically win your way up the charts with a relatively small amount of work. YouTube is just going to turn that on its head because you can say, oh, all we have to do is have a massively viral music video and we're going to win in the

1:38:17exact same way. That actually we get the control back from the people who are making the playlists on Spotify. They are no longer in charge. We're just going to go program our YouTube channel and win that way. But again, I think all that discovery happens first on those other platforms. Maybe. This might be a really good argument for YouTube Shorts. Oh, God. I'm serious. This maybe gives YouTube incentive to push harder to be that kind of discovery mechanism because now it can win through the entire stack. I think Hollywood and music are just like different industries. They face different pressures. They are. entire stack. I think Hollywood and music are just like different industries. They face different pressures. But to me, the thing about music is that its discovery is really hard. But once you

1:38:53get through the catalog, the catalog lasts forever. Yeah, that's probably true in a way that is not true for TV and movies. Yes. And YouTube is just a catalog play. I think like to hear a new song. I don't know if that's happening on YouTube in that way. I think that's still I think like to hear a new song, I don't know if that's happening on YouTube in that way. I think that's still, I think those Spotify playlists are still very powerful and the social platforms are still very powerful. And somewhere in there, we're going to see, again, the whole point of it, the whole point that I think where we are agreeing is that like the way you measure things changes people in like big, important ways.

1:39:25And this is a measurement change and we should pay attention to it. This is what I'm saying is I think you're wrong. And I think we're about to find out how wrong you are. Interesting. We'll see. Like, I think it's going to be very fun to see. It'll be interesting to see how they roll this out because there's a world in which the chart just flips on its head overnight the minute they start ingesting YouTube data. And it will be fascinating to see what that looks like. The rap music is back. As always, if we're going to talk about measurement, I got to end this part of this by saying James Vincent, former Verge reporter, wrote an incredible book about the politics of measurement called Beyond Measure. And I just can't recommend it enough.

1:40:00It's very good. I totally agree. All right. What's your next lightning round item? We got to talk about Mark Zuckerberg and smoking meats. Again? Again. It's like eight-year-berg and smoking meats. Again? Again. It's like eight year old story. He keeps bringing it back. He wants this to happen for him. So the news here is that they added a feature to Muse where it can make little apps for you. Oh yeah they call it like spaces or something. Spaces. And this is like one of those things where they had to find a phrase for this. Like you know like Anthropic has artifacts and they are very careful that they didn't call them apps. Right. Like they use the word artifact for a reason artifacts and they are very careful that they didn't call them apps. Right.

1:40:29Like they use the word artifact for a reason because it's like it's a little self-contained blah, blah, blah. It's not an app. It's not a whole thing. It's just a, it's an artifact. Well, you call it an app and then Phil Schiller comes and beats down your door and demands a lot of money from you. There's that as well. But yeah, so Muse now has spaces where I can write a little widget for you and you can look at a widget. So Mark Zuckerberg goes on Threads and he is smoking meats. And he wrote, I'm using our new Spaces feature on Muse to build a tool for my smoker. Give Muse a prompt and it can help build whatever you want to keep track of. The Pit Viper's vent controller has Bluetooth now. So Muse tracks the temp for me throughout the day.

1:41:10There's so many things I don't like about that. I'm going to unpack a lot of sentences here. Okay, please. So if you have smoked meats and I have smoked many meats, you basically, the entire job is keeping your smoker at a temperature for some long amount of time. Yes. And there are people who can do this by feel. They don't even use a thermometer and they're, they're like, they're very cool. And you go to the barbecue restaurants in the South and they kind of growl at you and it's the best food you've ever had in your life. And then you try to do it and you're like, well, I burned everything to ash. I should add computers to this. And then you spend three years of the pandemic Instagramming pictures of graphs.

1:41:49I'm not saying I had this experience. This is all purely hypothetical, of course. But so you got two ways to do this. You can control your fuel, which is what Traegers do, right? They add fuel, wood pellets, or you can control your air, like the two key components of a fire. Okay. And that's what a pit viper is. A pit viper is a fan. And all of these fans, a shit you not, are basically just computer fans that you stick on to like the hole at the bottom of your grill. Sick. And they just blow air into your grill. So now you've got to control the fan. And there's infinite ways to control the fan. Right? You put a thermometer in the thing and then there's a thing called a fireboard. And there's, I have a ThermoWorks billows.

1:42:27Like there's infinite ways to control a fan to right it's like the fire is getting too hot i'm gonna stop the fan the fire is getting cold i'm gonna blow some air on the fire to make it hot again like you have a little computer that controls the fan the fact that you know the brand of your billows makes me hate you in a way i can't possibly describe. ThermoWorks is a hot company, and I should get them on the code. They're incredible. Like, if you've built an empire of just thermometers, like, I want to know everything about you. Anyhow, so I've just come back to Mark. The Pit Viper's vent controller has Bluetooth now, so Muse tracks the temp for me throughout the day. Let me just pull this apart.

1:43:05The Pit Viper does not have Bluetooth. The Pit Viper is just a fan. You have to plug it in to a vent controller, the thing. And I'm guessing if you're Mark Zuckerberg, you have the fanciest one that not only turns the fan on and off, but also controls how open and closed the vent is. So you have more precise temperature control because it's the only thing that you're attempting to do. Okay. So he just wanted to say Pit Viper, which is not the thing that has Bluetooth. He probably has a controller that has Bluetooth to connect to an app that's on his phone. Right. Right? That's why it would have Bluetooth. Yeah. And the logic for that controller is almost certainly embedded in a controller already.

1:43:45Right? Because you don't want it to stop working when your phone goes out of bluetooth range right yeah so it wouldn't make any sense to do any other thing yeah so why did you make a muse app that breaks when you're out of bluetooth range to replace the app that is almost certainly already on your phone. See what I'm saying? Because Muse is not controlling the temperature. The control logic is local on the hardware of the controller, which, by the way, is still not the Pit Viper, which is just the fan. Like, I read this sentence and my brain exploded. Like, it's very cool that Muse can make little apps for you. Yeah. But this specific example is disconnected from reality is any flight booking example. You bought all this stuff. You set up a

1:44:37fan, you set up a controller, your fancy one, you want to be the smoke and meat sky. All you're really doing is setting the controller to 250. 275 but now instead of opening the app that someone built specifically to do that i have to open muse go to the correct space and then use the worst app and i add asked muse to like do a bunch of bluetooth stuff right does muse have bluetooth access it paired to this controller is it actually reading the controller do you see what i'm saying like i do have questions about this. It's a lot of questions, actually. Yeah. This thing is like, why would you do this? I assume there's like a headless Muse system all around Zuck's house that we can't even begin to imagine.

1:45:20He's got like a Muse gadget sitting next to his controller. Like, if you look at this screenshot, it says vent opening and that says Muse auto, which all but implies that Muse is actually in control. Like if you look at this, this screenshot, it says vent opening and that says Muse auto, which all but implies that Muse is actually in control. Yep. But where does Muse run the logic? Like where is Muse running the temperature controller logic? Is it in its little Linux computer in the cloud? So now you've taken your vent controller, which used to be a piece of hardware, like embedded, like an inexpensive piece of hardware that just monitored a temperature and spun a fan to I've now Bluetooth into my phone.

1:46:03I'm sending temperatures to my Linux computer in the cloud, which is then sending commands back to my phone to Bluetooth to a fan. All of this is cool. When I first saw this, I was like, oh, that's really cool. I really hate this app on my phone from whatever smoker controller I have. all of this is cool like the that when i first saw this i was like oh that's really cool i really hate this app on my phone from whatever smoker controller i have and then i thought what what like how does any of this work i would love to know i would love to know maybe there are good answers to all this but this just struck me as a sort of like i can write software to control anything demo that just like hits in the AI industry.

1:46:29And the second you try to apply it to the real world where people who are actually good at smoking meat like laugh at the imposition of computers to their barbecue grills. Well, and this is a particularly fun run because the other thing about smoking meat is you do it for a super duper long time. And so the idea that is going to be there for 14 hours. Do I have to stay within Bluetooth range of my of my smoker for 14 hours? Interesting. I just have a lot of questions about this. I think it's very cool that you can make little apps or stuff. I love all the you everyone's vibe coding their own TV launchers. Yep. I think that's really cool. I have also completely come around on building apps to replace my apps because it turns out

1:47:04like most apps are really bad. And all I want is an app that just makes me press one button. Like I'm looking at Zuck's thing and like my dude wants a temperature button where he can press plus or minus and then he wants a power button. And I bet whatever app comes with this smoker is vastly more complicated than that. And I sort of appreciate being like, I just want this thing to give me three buttons and I'm going to vibe code the three buttons to solve all of my problems. I'm in on that as a vibe coding solution. Maybe. When it works. Having used most of these apps, there's not more to them than that. You know what I mean? What you actually want is an alarm when you have a runaway. Anyway, I don't mean to talk about Smoky Meats,

1:47:43although if anybody in the comments wants to discuss Smoky Meats, we can do it i was gonna say you you super do one of my favorite episodes of decoder was the ceo of traeger by the way i highly recommend that one um we had the big green egg guy like every now and again we we we do it i'm just pointing out this demo it like it looks really cool because you made a little app to do a thing and you're like what did we accomplish right and like by any logical step through what i'm just looking at here we've actually just made the thing vastly more complicated than needs to be with the power of technology i was gonna say that's that's what we do here in the tech industry i think zuck just wanted to use the phrase pit

1:48:22fiber anyways if you want to just come on and only talk about your meat smoking setup, I will agree to that. I feel that I can ask many, many, many pressing questions only in the context of smoking meats. I can get to a lot of stuff, even if I agree to only limit my conversation to smoking meats. So when you're smoking meat, are you thinking about child safety on your platforms? See what I'm saying? Yeah, that's pretty good. Whose job is it to make sure the smokers are safe, Mark? What do governments think about the age at which you should be able to smoke your own meat? All right, I have one more for you, which is a product called Reddit Reviews. We've talked a lot about Reddit trying pretty hard to figure out what it wants to be and wants to be about over the last few months as it reckons with what AI is and what reckons with Google Zero.

1:49:13Reddit is trying a bunch of things. And I actually think a lot of them are really interesting. But Reddit is in this constant position of the very thing that it has, which is a huge set of users who love it and use it a lot for everything all the time, is both its greatest asset and its biggest risk. And the example from this week is this thing called Reddit reviews, where you can now go to Reddit and they've had a thing where you can do AI search and get something like an AI overview for a while. You can just sort of see the general consensus of Reddit on any question that you have, and then it'll let you, you know, dive into specific conversations and stuff like that. This one is very much about products. So you go to Reddit and you say, what does Reddit think about

1:49:57the new Sony headphones or like the iPhone Duo or whatever? And it will actually synthesize and give you something that looks like a product listing in a semi-professional looking review. It's like if you went to the Wirecutter and looked up reviews, they try to sort of ape that format and give you ways to buy stuff and give you the consensus feelings about stuff. Sure. On the one hand, interesting, smart idea, right? People want to know what Reddit thinks about something and rather than farm that out to Google, which is not sending any traffic back to Reddit, Reddit is saying, we're going to do this inside of the app. Redditors hate this. Hate it. Because what it does is it does all the things that they hate

1:50:35that everyone else is doing with their stuff, which is take all of the things that they're making, all the conversations that they're having, and instead of directing people back to them in those communities, just abstracting it all into something that doesn't even acknowledge those communities at all. It just says like, people generally like these headphones. This is the same argument that the New York Times cooking app integration of AI has come into. So the New York Times added AI features to the cooking app where you can ask about substitutions and how to have them double recipes. And by all accounts, it works quite well. Jen Tuohy wrote about it for us. But all that information comes out of the comments.

1:51:11It comes out of the community under the recipes on the cooking app. And so all the substitution conversation is there. Got it. Because every New York Times recipe has some crazy ingredient. Everyone's talking about how to substitute it. Yeah. And there's always 1,500 comments from people being like, I use rosemary instead of olive oil and it tastes bad. And everybody's like, what are you talking about? And so like the promise is like the app is utility and you should just be able to like ask a question and get this thing. But it comes from this community that is obviously not being compensated. And so you've created no incentive to go participate in the community or validate that that community exists.

1:51:46We'll see what happens in the context of cooking. Who knows what will happen. Some people just want to talk about cooking. Who knows? In the context of Reddit, across every category, much dicier. Because all of those communities have different dynamics, have different reasons to participate, have different cultures. This is going to be a mess. Yeah, I agree. And I think it's just a fascinating thing in that I think Reddit is gamely and I think correctly trying to figure out how do we give people useful stuff on top of this incredible community that we have. should only support the community and being like lift the wisdom out of the community they should find ways to support that like how many times have you read a reddit thread where people are like

1:52:31this question has been asked and answered 500 times oh every single day yeah right it's like reddit should solve that problem in a way that makes the community feel great about itself yeah i think that's i think that's fair i think that is much harder to do when you're a public company who has to constantly show user growth, right? But how do you make Redditors love Reddit? And how do you bring new people to Reddit are just completely different things in so many ways, or at least Reddit, as a company has decided those are totally different things. And I think is really struggling to figure out how to do right by both sides of that equation. And so Reddit reviews is like, you look at it and you use it.

1:53:08And it's like, oh, this is actually, this makes a lot of sense. This is a genuinely useful product. And if I were a person who had ever written one word on Reddit about that pair of Sony headphones, I'd be furious. It's tough. And I, yeah, I don't, I don't know how Reddit navigates through those things, but I hope it does because Reddit is really genuinely kind of the last version of a very important thing on the Internet. Everything Reddit does should be how do we use AI to encourage you to participate? Yeah. Not encourage you to consume. Yeah, agreed. And if they take too much value out, people, the incentive to participate will go down and the value of Reddit goes down. Yeah, I think that's right.

1:53:43All right, you get one more. What's your last one? This is the most lightning round of all lightning round items. David, the Cybertruck has been discontinued. Oh no, how awful. Elon announced it in a tweet that Tesla would be winding down production to make room for CyberCab. Then he kind of walked it back and said they were going to fulfill orders throughout the year because you got to do some things for love. Is that really what he said? Yes. He said production will continue through summer 2027 to work through the backlog of orders, the staggering number of orders that I'm sure there are. And he said, you have to have room for sentimentality, which is basically like he's going to play. I will remember you while making the last five

1:54:24cyber trucks that anyone ever ordered, you know. And just ceremonially push them off a cliff because no one wants them. That's going to be great. I will remind you, the Cybertruck was supposed to revolutionize the auto industry. He said he would sell a quarter million a year. The most popular cars in America are full-size trucks. He was supposed to go after the F-150 in a Silverado, and he did not. In fact, the Cybertruck mostly became a symbol for all that was wrong with Doge. Yeah, well, so, okay, this is actually, at the risk of opening a rabbit hole that we don't have time for, a thing I have found myself wondering is, was it the truck itself or was it the Elon of it all? Because this truck did come out

1:55:07right as Elon's popularity just absolutely tanked. But also it's a stupid, dumb, bad truck. Okay. By some accounts, there are some parts of it that are great. I just want to, I will say this. The wiper is huge. I'm not going to say it's the wiper. But like the steer by wire is supposed to be great. Like there's some parts of it that are like maybe legitimately great. But yeah, Elon going full mega, putting on a pickup pickup truck and then it not being a good pickup truck right and it like this could in another world this was his opportunity to get a bunch of truck guys to buy a truck yes an ev and be like you have a kick-ass ev truck that can smoke every other truck off the line and he made a bunch of promises about range and towing capacity.

1:55:50Do you remember when he was like, I'm towing a train and an F-150 or whatever nonsense he was doing? And, like, winning a race with a supercar. Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah. He was like, he had a Porsche on the thing and he beat a Porsche, right? He could have done all this stuff. And the truck, in many ways, the Cybertruck did not deliver on any of these claims. There's, like, a lawsuit. Some guy kept trying to use Wade mode, like, breaking his truck by driving into water. This is all very good, right? The wiper was extremely dumb and got recalled a bunch of times. He designed the wrong product for the thing he was trying to do. If he had just designed a pickup truck that was compatible with pickup trucks and what that market wanted out of pickup trucks. And so this is legitimately better at some things.

1:56:30He might've sold a bunch of trucks to those guys. Instead, he designed like a walking eyesore that was not as good at being a pickup truck is a 10 year old Ram 1500. Yeah. What are you going to do? And so like, you're not going to get a bunch of left-wing people in the Doge era being like, I've always wanted a pickup truck. Like Ford is going to get a bunch of left-wing people in the Doge era being like, I've always wanted a pickup truck. Like, Ford is going to sell a million Ford Fathoms. The slate truck is going to fly off the shelves. Toyota just announced K-trucks, like little K-trucks for fleets. I think this, who knows? Who knows if any of this stuff is going to work? But, like, they're good at being trucks.

1:57:04Like, straightforwardly, they're made to be good at at being trucks and they're going to do fine at being trucks this thing was like I'm an asshole that's it that's what I'm good at I will never ever forget the cyber truck that I saw driving with the I bought this before Elon went crazy bumper sticker and it's just like my guide you did it's statistically impossible that you did that like linear time suggests that you did not do that. It's rough out there. Well, RIP to the Cybertruck. By the way, if you haven't seen the Toyota K truck announcement, go check it out. They look rad. The tiny truck comeback is a thing that I am personally excited about. Even though they brought back the Scion brand

1:57:44for it, which is just stupid. K trucks are going to be sick. All right. I was right about that wiper the entire time. Both your fascination and your evaluation of it, I think, were proven out. All right. We need to get out of here. We are way over, as we are wont to do. Blame Jensen Wong. Blame China. It's a whole thing. Neil, who's on Decoder next week? I'm pretty sure it's New Jersey Governor Mikey Sherrill, who is great. Okay. That's exciting. And if it's New Jersey Governor Mikey Sherrill, who was great. Okay. That's exciting. And if it's not, it'll be somebody else. We talked about abolishing the Electoral College and she's like, what a great idea. We're all over the place. This is blue way of Ne-Li

1:58:19just throwing out insane political ideas. Let's see what happens. It was like the last question and she's like, I'm so happy you asked me this question. That's awesome. We also have a new season of Version History starting this Sunday. We actually have a new season of Version History starting this Sunday. We actually have a trailer. Let me play a trailer for you. Version History is back. I'm David Pierce. He's Neelay Patel. Hello, sir. It's pet season here on Version History. We have six episodes. I have all six gadgets in front of us. Your job is to explain what is pet-ish about all six things. Ready? Go. All right. The AIBO is obviously a dog. Nailed it. Tamagotchi, obviously a digital pet. All right, the AIBO is obviously a dog. Nailed it.

1:58:48Tamagotchi, obviously a digital pet. Yep. The Commodore pet is a pet. It was the most cheating of all of the episodes. I will just level with that. That one I got. The GoPro, you can attach to a pet. Nailed it. And the iPad is like the kitty cat of gadgets. You know who loves pawing at fish on an iPad? Sure, okay. It's cats, yeah. There's one more. There's laser pointers. This might be the easiest one on the board. Oh, pets love laser pointers. They do it. All six of those things, virgin history, it's pet season. See you there. The kitty cat of gadgets. The iPad's a real reach. Looking back on it, it's a lot. The iPad also, very fun episode. All these episodes are very fun. AIBO is the first one coming up this weekend.

1:59:38We had one in studio and it made people feel a lot of feelings. Check it out. It's a good one. And if you want to get all of our podcasts ad-free, plus all of our exclusive newsletters, all of our coverage of everything, honestly, at this point, you should subscribe to The Verge just to hear Liz Lopato get really mad at Jensen Wong, apparently several times a day for the rest of all of our lives. Theverge.com slash subscribe. It's the best way to support everything we're up to. If you want to get in touch, if you have thoughts, questions, if you are a spy from China and would like to tell us about it, get at us. The VergeCast hotline is 866-VERGE11. The email is VergeCast at TheVerge.com. We love hearing from you about anything and everything.

2:00:13The VergeCast is a Verge production and part of the Vox Media Podcast Network. The show is produced by Josh Cajas, Eric Gomez, Brandon Kiefer, and Travis Larchuk. We will see you next week. Eli, rock and roll. Support for the show comes from Jira by Atlassian. No matter where you work, you're likely running into a version of the same problem. Your critical information is siloed. We all have these different apps and tools, but there's no centralized source of truth. Hopefully after hearing the hype desk's take in today's episode, it's clear how Jira solves that problem. Jira is where your team and your agents work from the same context. The result, less token waste, better agent output, and more time moving work forward.

2:00:54This is how work gets done. Learn more at Jira.com. That's J-I-R-A dot com.

▸More episode summaries

The Vergecast cover art
The VergecastJensen Huang resigns, and our HomeView review2026-11-12 · 59 min
The Vergecast cover art
The VergecastVersion History: Aibo2026-11-15 · 75 min
The Vergecast cover art
The VergecastThe e-readers readers love2026-11-16 · 38 min
Transcribe your links. Paste a YouTube, Google Drive or podcast link and WhipScribe gives you the transcript. Transcribe a link →
New The Vergecast transcripts by email
One email per new episode, unsubscribe in every message. Not shared with the publisher.