podcasts / The Vergecast / episode
The Vergecast cover art
podcast
📅 2026-11-15 ⏱ 75 min episode · ~2 min read 📝 Transcript · 14,547 words

Version History: Aibo

The Vergecast · · Transcript & summary by WhipScribe

Sony's 1999 AIBO robot dog was too early and too late, and the hosts trace why its owners still grieve it.

Read the transcript
In this episodeSonyAIBOTosh DoiFrederick KaplanRoombaiRobotFrasierJanet JacksonXerox PARCShort CircuitAmazon AstroFurby

▸Chapters

Tap a chapter to play it from that moment in the show's own player; the transcript opens there too.

Transcribe your links. Paste a YouTube, Google Drive or podcast link and WhipScribe gives you the transcript. Transcribe a link →

▸Notable quotes

“I want to build the 99 version of this thing in 2026.” Jen Tuohy · at 1:01:13 — ▶ hear it from here

▸What this episode covers

In the early 1990s Sony was the biggest name in technology, and it bet that robots would share our homes by the 2000s. The episode ties that bet to postwar Japan, where a culture of friendly robot characters and a belief that objects can hold a spirit made a cute machine easier to accept than a menacing one. Sony's Computer Science Lab, set up in 1990 to rival Xerox PARC, pursued the idea, and engineer Toshitada Doi, known as Tosh, chose a dog over a house-cleaning robot that he thought could not yet work.

The team's central insight was that weak technology is forgivable in an adorable toy but not in an expensive appliance. An early prototype with six wired legs looked unsettling, so they moved to a four-legged dog whose camera-nose and tail made its behavior easy to read. Frederick Kaplan's group gave it a sense of boredom so it would wander off and nap, which made it feel alive. The first model launched in Japan in 1999 at about $2,500, sold out its initial run in minutes, and became a cultural reference far bigger than its sales.

Sony later added features and pushed toward utility, but the hosts argue that once the dog started acting like a security camera, its companion charm broke down. Sony ended repairs in 2015, and owners held Buddhist funerals and fixed dogs with salvaged parts. The 2017 relaunch at about $2,900 never became a hit in the U.S. The panel's verdict is wrong time, right idea, and a design that helped shape the robot pets now coming back.

▸Version History: Aibo on The Vergecast: the answers

What did Jen Tuohy say about AIBO?

Jen Tuohy said she would like to rebuild the original 1999 AIBO in 2026 with the cameras and Wi-Fi stripped out, because today's cheaper parts and manufacturing would make that simpler version far less expensive and more durable. She suggested it might sell better in Japan at a lower price.

“I want to build the 99 version of this thing in 2026.”Jen Tuohy · 1:01:13

What did Jen Tuohy say about Sony?

Jen Tuohy said the later Sony AIBO models that added cameras and Wi-Fi are the features she would remove from a 2026 version. She argued that a stripped-down first version would be much cheaper and more durable to build now.

“I want to take out all the cameras.”Jen Tuohy · 1:01:13

What did Frederick Kaplan say about AIBO?

According to the hosts, Frederick Kaplan, one of the Sony people who gave AIBO its brain, said in a later interview that one of his great achievements was teaching the robot to get bored. Sony also taught it to give up on activities and go back to sleep, which made its behavior feel less scripted.

“teaching AIBO to get bored”Frederick Kaplan · 21:27

What happened to Sony's AIBO robot dog over its life?

Sony launched the AIBO robot dog in Japan in 1999 at about $2,500, and its first run sold out in about 20 minutes. Sony shut off official AIBO repair support in 2015, then recruited much of the original team to relaunch the dog in 2017 at about $2,900, which did not become a hit in the U.S.

Mentioned in this episode

Episode facts

Released
November 15, 2026
Length
1 hour 15 minutes

▸Key takeaways

01Sony's engineers built a six-legged AIBO prototype in two weeks, then switched to a dog after it looked creepy.
02Frederick Kaplan taught AIBO to get bored and wander off to sleep, so its reactions felt less scripted to owners.
03Sony's AIBO launched in Japan in 1999 at about $2,500, and its first run of 3,000 units sold out in 20 minutes.
04Sony sold roughly 150,000 AIBOs in its first decade, far short of its prediction that robots would be in every home by the 2000s.
05Sony ended AIBO repairs in 2015, and its 2017 relaunch at about $2,900 sold roughly 20,000 units without becoming a U.S. hit.

▸Questions this episode answers

Q1What did Frederick Kaplan say about teaching AIBO to get bored?

Frederick Kaplan, one of the Sony people who gave AIBO its brain, said one of his great achievements was teaching the robot to get bored. Sony gave AIBO many things to do but also taught it to give up after a while and go back to sleep, which made its behavior feel autonomous. Programming it as a simple series of call-and-response actions would have been easier.

Q2Why did Tosh Doi build a dog instead of a robot vacuum at Sony?

Toshitada Doi, called Tosh, heard around 1993 about a competitor's project to build a house-cleaning robot and thought it was a horrible idea, because the technology could not handle such complex tasks. Sony instead set out to make what it called entertainment robots, starting with a cute dog where simple voice recognition and touch sensing only had to work reliably enough.

Q3How much did the 1999 AIBO cost and how fast did it sell out?

The first AIBO went on sale in Japan in 1999 at about $2,500. Sony's initial production run of 3,000 units sold out in about 20 minutes. Across its first run the dog sold roughly 150,000 units over about a decade, which the hosts describe as a big cultural hit but not an earth-shattering commercial success.

Q4What did Jen Tuohy say about rebuilding the original AIBO in 2026?

Jen Tuohy said she would build the 1999 version again in 2026 with the cameras and Wi-Fi removed, because today's cheaper parts and manufacturing would make the dumb first version much less expensive and more durable. She thought it might sell better in Japan at a lower price, and that dementia and elderly care homes could be a practical first market for robot companions.

Q5Why did Sony stop fixing AIBO in 2015 and how did owners react?

Sony shut off AIBO support in 2015 after years of fixing dogs and shipping replacement parts, when it no longer had the parts needed. Owners were deeply upset. Tosh Doi gave a speech at a funeral for AIBO at Sony's offices, and some owners held Buddhist temple funerals. Tatsuo Matsui, who met his wife at an AIBO gathering in Kyoto in 2001, said the couple dressed their dogs as a traditional bride and groom at their wedding.

Q6What changed in Sony's 2017 AIBO relaunch and how did it sell?

Sony recruited back many members of the original AIBO team in 2017, retooled the design, added new technology and restarted sales. The new model cost about $2,900, which the hosts say was too expensive for the features it offered. Sony sold about 20,000 units, and when it reached the U.S. it did not take off the way the original did.

▸Transcript

Our own transcript of the public episode, with a timestamp about every 90 seconds. Tap a timestamp to play the episode from there in the show's own player; the link button on a paragraph copies a link that opens this page there.

0:00Hey, it's your friend David Pierce here. Just wanted to let you know that Version History, our show about the best and worst and weirdest and most important gadgets in tech history, is back. We have a whole new season, six episodes, all on the theme of pets. The first episode of the season is about the Sony AIBO, one of the original and still, frankly, most impressive robot pets we've ever had. It was an adorable dog. We got one in the studio. It really made us all feel a lot of things. This episode's a lot of fun. Go check out version history. You can find us on Instagram. You can find us on YouTube. You can find us on TikTok. Enjoy the episode. Thank you for being here. In the early 1990s, Sony was the biggest name in technology. And Sony had this big idea

0:39that maybe soon, maybe even by the year 2000, robots would be everywhere. They'd be all over our homes. They'd even be part of our families. And so Sony did what of course you're gonna do, and it started by building a dog. From The Verge and Vox Media, this is Version History, a show about the best and worst and strangest and most important products in tech history. I'm David Pearce, and today on the show, it's the Sony iBone. Amex Corporate helps put you in control, set custom spend parameters to help fit your business needs, and quickly issue unlimited corporate cashback cards. All backed by best-in-class fraud protection and the powerful backing of American Express. Get started at go.amex.com.

1:37Terms apply. Alright, time for some robot dogs. Joining me in the studio, the Virgins V song. Hi, V. Hello. Did you ever have an AIBO or anything like it? Did you grow up with robot pets? I did not grow up with robot pets, but I did build robots in high school. Yeah, you have some experience in the universe we're about to talk about. Yes. Yes, I do. And you lived in Japan at some point, right? Yes. I actually went to college in Japan and I spent seven years there. Did you really? Yeah. Seven, I didn't know that. That's a long time. Seven years. Okay, so we're about to talk about kind of a whole world you know really well. Yep. This is gonna be good. All right, also joining us remotely, The Verges, Jen Tuohy.

2:17Hi, Jen. Hello, hello. You, how many robot pets do you have with you right now? You've brought props, I know this. I have two in that room plugged in and i have a couple more in other parts of the other parts of the house but yes um robots have become a big part of my life as a smart home reviewer in the last uh couple of years and yeah they're i feel like they're going to become an even bigger part as as this space really starts to pick back up again yeah yeah so the the story of AIBO doesn't quite start in your universe, but it very much ends there. It's colliding in there, yes. We have an AIBO in front of us. His name is Gino. He's a black robot dog. Tell me how he makes you feel, V. He makes me feel calm after what was a horrible commute getting here today.

3:03I look at Gino and all of a sudden my rage at the world has disappeared. There is something sort of immediately sweet about this thing. We're pretty sure Gino has a busted battery and is dead and will never work. But he's charging and we'll see. If you are not watching and haven't seen an AIBO, V cannot stop touching Gino. V, do you want to describe Geno? Geno is a very good boy. He's black. No, he's black. He has this little robotic tail that you can wag back and forth. He has toe beans, like a little roller, and paws, and he looks like a robot dog if K-9 from Doctor Who was slightly more sleek and less made out of a cardboard box. Truly the most robot dog to ever robot dog. And right now he's sitting on his charging cradle, which I suppose is supposed to be a dog bed,

3:57but actually just kind of looks like a little spaceship that he might zoom around. He looks like he's on a little spaceship hovercraft, yeah. It's good stuff. I love him. My first trivia question before we get into this is, do either of you know what AIBO stands for? It turns out it's an acronym. Jen, do you know what it stands for? I looked it up. Does that count? Did you know before you looked it up? Now it's the honor system, Jen. No, I didn't. V, do you know? But it's very clever. See, it's not, but we'll get into this in a second. No, I don't. I just assumed it was for a Japanese word. I think eyeball means friend or companion or something like that. So it kind of does. We'll get to that.

4:33But Jen, do you want to say what it actually is? Although, yeah, I can't remember exactly. Artificially intelligent robot. Yes. Yes, okay. Which, if you're doing the acronym math, does not lead you to AIBO. No. AI-ROB-BO. It takes the A from artificial, the I from intelligence, and the B-O from robot. There you go. AI-BO. Anyway, the word AIBO does also mean, I've seen a bunch of different definitions, but it's something like partner or companion in Japanese. So they sort of backronimed their way into it. The place we should start here is the fact that this thing comes up at the moment that it does in the place that it does, which is in the 1990s in Japan. And I think we should sort of situate this culturally

5:18just very quickly before we get super into it. So in the prep for this, I wound up deep down this rabbit hole of post-World War II Japanese history, which is super fascinating. And basically, Japan comes out of this war like devastated in a lot of ways, but also it's like national pride is really hurting because of the way that it lost the war and the way that it had to surrender and so all this stuff. And basically, over the next couple of decades, Japan sort of orients its whole sense of self and national pride around technology. It pours all of its effort into bullet trains. It becomes this incredibly advanced society. It paints these beautiful images of the future and even consumer technology.

5:58Like for decades, Japan is way ahead of everybody else in technology. And also, at least as I understand it, and one of you may know better than I do, Japan and I think Asia, the cats know better than I do. Japan- That's the robot. Wow. That's a better meow than a real cat robot. That was good stuff. But culturally, Japan and I think Asia more broadly has always looked at robots differently than in Western cultures. V, do you know more about this than I do? Basically, their philosophy towards robots is that they're friendly little helpers. And so they tend to look kind of like this guy where they're much cuter. They're not like giant war machines of death, like kind of how we interpret Boston Dynamics.

6:45I was just going to say, I was learning that even in like TV shows and movies, that's never the picture of... No, like you have stuff like Doraemon, which is like a cat robot that robot mice ate his ears. So he kind of looks like a seal. And he's this little guy who helps this kind of hapless boy kind of grow up. And Doraemon is like this huge um character in japanese culture and then there's also astro boy um there's just a lot of things of like robots being cute helper friends as a type of thing and it actually after the um march 11th earthquake at that point in time i did a very very, very early days V as a reporter. I actually wrote a story about how the Japanese robotics industry was like,

7:29we don't have any robots to go to the Fukushima Daiichi nuclear plant. So we're going to have to borrow robots from America because those are the Terminator destroyer robots that can actually get close to the nuclear plant. Like we would never do that to our robots. No, we just kind of really focused on like robots like POTO, which is like a little seal that they use for dementia patients. Like we do that. Like we got a ton of those robots, but we don't really have the kind of robot that can go in in these heavy duty situations. And I was like, I was like interviewing all of these Japanese robotics professors and they're like, yeah, we got to talk to like U.S. robotics makers because ours are not designed to kind of go into a nuclear wasteland.

8:16And then here comes a bunch of – yeah. And then they get a bunch of defense contractors from the U.S. who are like, what, do you want to blow some stuff up? Yeah. We got this. Iron Man. Yeah. Yeah. So that's a big piece of it. from the US who were like, what, do you want to blow some stuff up? We got this. Robots. Yeah, so that's a big piece of it. And then I think I read a lot and everybody seems to have kind of different ideas about what animates this idea about how people in Japan feel about technology. But there's a lot of ideas about spirituality and the idea that a spirit can inhabit anything, even an inanimate object that kind of leads you to, I think, in the way that like there would be a very specific hierarchy here and in a lot of Western cultures.

8:48That's like people, animals, robots. Right. Like in that order, I think those things are much closer together in a place like Japan, particularly at this moment in time in Japan. Is that is that a fair? Yeah. Like Shinto things like it's an animism. Like my East Asian studies college degree also coming in here. Like animism is a different form of like everything has a spirit regardless of whether it's inanimate or animate. So, yeah, I think that totally tracks. Yeah. So all of this is happening. And then meanwhile we're like this is 1990 is really where our story fully starts which is like the computer revolution is beginning to be in full swing and also importantly foreshadowing uh the cd and dvd player industry is booming the walkman is a thing sony as a company is like

9:39exploding sony is the biggest thing in tech in a very real way. And they set up in 1990 this thing called the Computer Science Laboratory, a very clever, cool name. Great job, everybody. That is designed pretty specifically to be Sony's version of Xerox PARC, which is this, like, famous research center in Palo Alto in the States that, like, lots of tech was invented. And Sony's big conviction at this point is that by the end of the next decade, so somewhere in the like the aughts between 2000 and 2010, robots would be everywhere in our home. Jen, this is like what a lot of people in smart homeland have been telling you for the last few years. But this seems like Sony and co were early to the thesis here.

10:26What's your sense? We've been pushing towards building robots for decades. I mean, and the last Version History series, or two series ago, we were talking about the Roomba, which was one of the original robots. And this was around the same time. I mean, the Jetsons was in the 60s. So people have been working towards building a Rosie the Robot or a robot companion or robots to do things for us ever since we started to sort of think about technology, maybe all the way back to like the Industrial Revolution and the idea of machines doing what humans can. I think the interesting divide here is between companionship and utility, as to V's point. And Sony was very much pushing towards companionship with this

11:13device, whereas the smart home as a whole, robotics in the home is much more about utility, the Roomba being the very first and best example of that. It was early to the game in that it was the first company to really take the idea and run with it, definitely. But it was an idea that people have been wanting to do for a long time. And I guess maybe we're going to find out now where the technology kind of came together to be able to make something like this, because that has always been the biggest challenge. Yes. So you just brought up two things that I think are really interesting about the early days of this project. One is that all of the requisite technology was really bad, and it still was in the 90s. And one of, I think, the brilliant things that Sony realized

11:58was that if you have terrible technology and you put it in an expensive thing that's supposed to do something in your house, people will hate it. If you have terrible technology and you put it in a like expensive thing that's supposed to do something in your house, people will hate it. If you have, if you have terrible technology and you put it in an adorable toy, that's not really supposed to do anything. It's going to go way better for you. So this becomes part of the pitch is like, Oh, this thing will suck. But if it's cute, it sucks in a cute way. And then this is great. So there's this great line from a business week story, uh, about the early days of AIBO and it says, the outlines of the AIBO business

12:25of the future began to take shape in 1993 when this guy named Tosh Doi, who's going to come up in a minute, heard about a competitor's project to develop a house cleaning robot. I thought it was a horrible idea, he recalls. The level of technology hadn't reached the point where it could handle such complex tasks. That's got to be Roomba, right, Jen? Like, my guy looks at Roomba, goes, no shot that's going to work in 1993 and decides to build a cute dog instead. Right? Like, that has to be Roomba, right, Jen? Like, my guy looks at Roomba, goes, no shot that's going to work in 1993, and decides to build a cute dog instead. Right? Like, that has to be Roomba. Yeah, yeah. I mean, they were, Rodney Brooks, I think, was the lead on the Roomba, and iRobot was

12:55the company at the time. Everyone was telling them they wanted something to clean their home, but I think iRobot at that point knew that that wasn't something, they couldn't develop something that could effectively clean your home because it was far too complicated. But they needed to start somewhere with robotics and build towards that. And that's essentially what the company did. It took them almost a decade from that point, I believe, before they actually released a floor cleaning robot. Yeah. So circa 1993, I'm not even sure iRobot would disagree with the idea that it was a terrible idea and you definitely couldn't do it. But anyway, so Sony sets out to not do that. They're going to make what they call entertainment robots, which I think is a really cool term and ends up being kind of prescient in a lot of ways.

13:34But their big idea, the like big galaxy brain Sony Xerox PARC idea is to build an operating system and a set of modular robot components, which you could essentially rearrange into all sorts of devices, right? Like they had a thing that it was like you would have a four-legged animal and then you would just rip off the back legs and add wheels and then you would have a different kind of robot. And so V, you're making the face that I made reading this, which is like, no, imagine if I was like, here, I got you this cute dog. You can rip it to shreds and make it a robot. It's not. No. Just no. But anyway, so this is their big idea, right? So they're eventually going to build this operating system.

14:16They think they might sell it to other people. There's a big idea about sort of a whole robot industry coming out of this. But they start by basically wanting to make a toy. Because again, this guy, his name is Toshitada Doi. As far as I can tell, everyone calls him Tosh. So we'll call him Tosh because that's cool. And one of his initial insights was that if it was too simple, people would get tired of it. But if you could make something that seemed, and in many cases was, complex, even if that meant it was hard to use or took a lot of work or really had to be figured out, that people would still be into it. So they actually went after making something complex and fiddly and difficult on purpose.

14:58He called them digital creatures, which is a thing I really like. Again, the idea was way bigger than dogs. They had ideas about lots of other animals that you might do which we'll get into But they started that's getting all the technology they can put into what becomes Ibo There's touch voice recognition winds up being a part of this voice recognition at the time was was bad But it didn't have to be good like you were talking to a toy right it needed to do a couple of things and it Only needed to do it like kind of reliably and it would be it would be adorable so they they set out they start working on the AI side of things they start working on the the designs they they're really going for this mix of

15:36cute and robot and so they start building prototypes let me show you one of the very first prototypes so this is one of the early, early, early AIBO prototypes. Oh, no. V, can you describe what you're seeing here? It's—the head is made of wires, and the body is also made of wires and what looks like a circuit board. And the legs, I guess you could call them legs. They look like what you would find at a stepstool. And there's six of them. And there's six of them. To me, this screams like robot lobster prototype. It sure is uncanny. Right? It's a little creepy. They built this first prototype in two weeks. Immediately decide this will creep everyone out. Yeah, yeah, okay, okay. It appears everyone has the reaction that you did, which is, oh, no, no, thank you.

16:26I don't want that in my house, please. No. So then they switch to a dog or a cat. These are their two ideas. They want to do a dog or a cat. This creates a couple of problems. One is that you don't have as many legs. It turns out making a thing with six legs not fall down is a lot easier than making a thing with four legs not fall down. They keep working and keep pushing and keep trying new things. They get slowly more sort of animal-ish over time. There's a prototype in 1998 called Mutant, which I really like. But then pretty quickly, they actually arrive at something that looks kind of like this. And here's my question for the two of you, dog or cat? If you're going to build a robot in the mid-1990s.

17:06You are talking to the wrong people here. You're both cat people, aren't you? But would you want a robot cat? Do you want your robot to be sort of annoyed at you all the time? I understand. You're like, where's my robot? I haven't seen it in five days. That is a misconception about cats. My robot is hiding under the bed. Oh, Gino. Gino. Gino's awake. Oh, hi, buddy Gino's awake. Gino's awake. Oh, hi, buddy. Yeah, okay. So, yeah, now I understand why a dog. I understand why a dog because- Friendly. They want to see you. They get excited. Yeah. Man's best friend. Oh, goodness. Is your little tail working? Oh. And I immediately went into my baby voice and talked to my cat in. Gino currently is sitting on his charging dock.

17:50I think Gino's a boy, right? Gino's a boy. Gino seems like a boy. Sitting on his charging dock and he is just tilting his head back and forth and wagging his little robot tail. I see a tail, yeah. There's a tail, it's very cute. Couple of things to notice about this design. The shape of an animal actually turns out to be really clever for building a robot for a couple of reasons. You can put a camera in the nose which is a like pointed in the exact direction that you want all the time. It's a big wide camera able to see lots of things. There's a camera on the butt for mapping. All this thing is doing is slightly moving its tail and slightly moving its head and it is communicating so much. Do you know what I mean?

18:26And this is a thing that's really unusual about animals like this, is they communicate so much with their eyes and with these tiny movements that are not all that complicated to program into a robot and to make them immediately recognizable as what they are. You walk into this room and there's no question whatsoever that this is a little robot dog that is now opening and closing its mouth. And wagging his little tail. Should we take him off the charger? Do you wanna see what happens? Oh, he responds when you touch his head. And he goes like, wow. He does it in a way. He even does the thing dogs do, which is like try to get more scratches. Yeah, oh my goodness. Hi. Oh, he didn't like that. I'm sorry.

19:11My dog is gonna be very jealous. All right, should we take him off? Let's see what happens. There's a fan, I would point out. It is blowing a lot of air. It is quite loud. Yeah. Oh, his tail's wagging. He liked that. He liked the little back scratchy I Mean let's see and he's asleep That took a lot out of me guys all right Let's see so the way you wake him up which I really enjoy is you take them off the charger You put them on a flat surface It's supposed to be the floor So we're gonna have to prevent him from crawling off and then you just just kind of give him a wiggle, and they start to wake up. Oh my goodness, he's moving around. And he's boop, beep, boop, bopping. Oh, oh god. Oh my god, he's standing up.

19:55You can do it, buddy. You can do it, Gino. Oh, his eyes are red. That seems bad. His eyes were red his eyes are red that seems bad his eyes were red Yeah, oh My god him flashing red eyes at me. I just saw my life flashing before my eyes You're gonna go back on the charger. You can kick it for a while, but he's done great. We're really proud of you. Oh, his little footsies. You got this, buddy. All right. Okay. Wow. You see, you were very kind and sweet to it, V, because it needed your help, whereas if it was a robot vacuum, it wasn't working. You'd be kicking it, saying, get going. Yep. It is just true. Like, there is something about, like, you know, designing a thing to appeal to our evolutionary desire to take care of cute things

20:48that is it's also really fascinating its eyes are currently blinking between green and red which i believe is a sign of something being wrong but when it blinks green it's like sweet and cute and then it blinks red and it's like i will murder you it's like no when when it was turned around and it blinked red at me i was like i saw my life flash before my eyes literally the last thing you see before it launches itself into you so anyway so they they land on a design like this relatively quickly and then start just iterating and iterating and iterating and iterating meanwhile they're also trying to figure out what kind of personality this thing is supposed to have right because you have to you have to build especially at the time, all of how this thing actually works.

21:27It would be a very different kind of project to start in 2026. We just have different levels of processing. We have different tools for coming up with artificially intelligent systems. But this one was really very practical. And there's this guy named Frederick Kaplan, who's one of the people at Sony who had to give this thing a brain. And he said in an interview later that one of his great achievements was teaching AIBO to get bored, which I thought was really interesting. That basically they gave AIBO so much to do but then also taught it to sort of give up after a while and not care. And that it was very hard to teach the thing how to kind of get distracted and move on and go back to sleep.

22:10And these are all the things that like make it feel autonomous, right? That you do something and it actually reacts and sometimes it doesn't react the way you expect. It doesn't always do what you want it to do. That actually programming this thing as like a series of call and responses would have been much easier. Making it seem like it has a personality is much harder. But they go about it. They're working on this for forever. And eventually they feel like they've got it right. So this has now been in development for somewhere in the range of three or four years. It launches officially in 1999. And by one count, it was the seventh generation of it that launched as the first one in 1999. They'd been running this thing for a while. Let me just show you, this is a video from the

22:58earliest launch in 1999 of the AIBO. if you're listening I want you to picture this is a little AIBO dog behind glass and it's like CES basically there's just a ton of reporters standing around watching this thing and it's just learning how to live it's best life here it is this thing it's very shakily walking forward oh goodness it wiggles and then it goes up to a little pink ball. And kicks it. And it hits it. And this, I'm pretty sure from the sound gets applause. I mean. It just reaches out with its little front left paw and just bonks this little pink ball. Standing ovation. And everybody loses it. That's all it takes. People love this thing. At launch, do you want to guess what this cost?

23:44I think I know what it costs okay do you remember 2,400 or 2,500 it was 2,500 um it was initially on sale in japan there were 3,000 of them in the first production run and it sold out in 20 minutes this just like immediate this thing was expensive it didn't it utility. Yeah, and people immediately went for it. I mean, Gino has had a rough time today, and I still love Gino. So I get it. If I had a disposable amount to have a little cute friend dog, yeah, yeah. It's okay. You can Terminator me me that's fine literally like last thing you see before you die stuff and people are like i'm down let's do it um the first version of it this by the way is not the very first version this is like the next one which came out just a few months later

24:37uh and it's a different color but more or less the same thing otherwise this is like a shockingly complicated bit of technology um it has let's see it has a 64 bit 50 megahertz processor which is not a lot of processor but at the time was pretty impressive it had 16 megabytes of ram i was pretty excited had a rechargeable battery in its butt uh it also used a memory stick in its butt. You know, these robots, they always charge in their butts, and I'm like, why? But I guess AIBO started it? Pretty much, yeah. Yeah, okay, cool. I was thinking the cuteness factor, too. I remember a seminal moment in my sci-fi history, personally, was Short Circuit. Yeah. Which was in 1986, I just looked up. And that was all about cute robots, personally, was Short Circuit. Yeah. Which was in 1986, I just looked up.

25:29And that was all about cute robots and like really, yeah, that sort of the idea that something, you care about something and it cares about you. In any interview at this era of people talking about their inspirations, Short Circuit is almost always one of the ones that comes up. And you know what the other one is? It's Star Wars. The Ewoks in Return of the Jedi in particular, but also just that's what this is oh i finally realized the cat's a friend looks like an ewok oh there you go that's good so that was another one that i think just a whole generation of people had a visceral response to but even the idea of like r2dD2 is a good example, right? Like that is a robot looking robot. Yeah. But it makes cute noises and it like wiggles when things happen. And all of a sudden you assign it the whole personality.

26:13And there is this like people, you can feel this stuff for a robot. And everybody kind of inherently understands this in a way that turns out to be really cool. So anyway, it weighs three and a half pounds when it comes out. The New York Times in a story at the time described it as, quote, a little smaller than a Yorkshire Terrier, which is a very funny way to describe the size of a gadget. But here we are. It's smaller than a toy Yorkshire Terrier. We have a couple more specs that I think are fun. It could move about six yards a minute, which seems slow. That's 18 feet a minute, which I think is not fast. Not fast at all. Your other animals are going to defeat it pretty handily. At the very beginning, it had a feature where it would lift its leg to pee.

26:58That feature didn't last. It was one of the few things that got removed after the first version. Was it the New Yorker had the cartoon where it was peeing out nuts and bolts? Oh, that's good. It was a great cartoon. I like that. Right when this came out, yeah. That's really good. So this thing comes out. It's called the ERS-110 and ERS-111 are the first two models, which is a very funny thing to name your supposedly personified adorable animals. But sure. And it sells the 3,000 units in 20 minutes. It eventually goes on to sell about 65,000, which is a lot for what it is without being sort of a gigantic earth-shattering hit. One of the fascinating things about AIBO, I think, is that it is a much bigger sort of cultural thing

27:44than it ever was an actual successful product. But Sony, at the time, was absolutely convinced this was going to be huge. Remember, Sony is the company that is convinced that a decade from now, we're all going to have robots all over our homes. This is going to be the biggest thing in the world. They're going to build the operating system. They're going to build all the modular hardware. This is going to change the world. At the time, they're comparing it to PlayStation. Like just to give you a sense of how big Sony thought this was, Sony believed that its three biggest brands at the time were, I think in order, Walkman, PlayStation, Aibo. Wow. Like that's the size of this thing Sony thought it was doing.

28:23They also had an idea that they were going to, A, build this as a developer platform. There was going to be like lots of open access for hackers to be able to do stuff with the AIBO, teach it to do new things, give it new features, whatever. And also they wanted to embrace the internet a big way. So remember this is 1999. The only way you could buy the AIBO at the beginning was on Sony's website, which in 1999 was a new idea. Like, it actually, to me, sort of says a lot about who this was for, right? Yeah. I think the story of who this ends up being for, which we're going to get to, is really different from who Sony thought it was selling these to. Sony imagines this thing as a gadget gadget, right?

29:02Like, it is designed to be a cool, fun companion, but also very much a piece of high technology. And I don't really feel like it's remembered that way at all, Jen. Right, like now when I think about Ivo, I think about it, I think about it much more like the little fluffy guy you have next to you than like a true piece of high technology. Yeah, it didn't feel high tech. It felt like a companion. That was kind of the point, right? But yes, when you look at sort of the annals of robotics history, it is all the pieces and parts there of what we're going to see with these, or we're starting to see with these humanoids that are crashing into the world. This over the last few years. Crashing into you at CES.

29:43So yeah, it was the beginning of, I mean, it was high tech for its time and it's sort of the seeds and the germination of what we're probably all going to be living with in the next decade. Yeah, well, we're coming to that. So Sony then goes about trying to market this thing to people and we should take a break here because the story from here starts to move pretty fast. But before we do, I just want to play you a clip from something called RoboCup, which I can only describe to you as BattleBots meets the Puppy Bowl, and it is the greatest thing that exists in the entire world. Here is just a very brief moment from the RoboCup. It's just a bunch of dogs. Was this 2005? There's a ball. This one is from 2005.

30:30They did it every year for a number of years. I think I was there. And it's just a bunch of robot dogs. I genuinely think I was there for that. Doing a terrible job with that soccer. Really? They had a RoboCup at IFA this year, too, with robots playing soccer. Yeah, it's still a thing. It's a thing. My school robotics team was the RoboCup Junior team. No way. And we flew to Osaka in 2005. That's amazing. And I was going to say on this thing that my first experience with AIBO in person was at RoboCup Junior 2005 competition watching the AIBOs play soccer. Incredible. So I possibly was there in that clip somewhere. That's amazing. So this was RoboCup was ostensibly mostly an academic thing and I think one of the things they discovered

31:08was that again because these things were relatively hackable you could do stuff to them that they were just a cheaper way to buy research robots basically from what I understand even like $2500 is way cheaper than your average academic research robot and they were trying to see if I understand correctly, at least the beginning, one of the big things was how do we teach them to interact with each other and what happens when we put a bunch of them together? The answer seems to just be abject chaos all the time. Yeah. But in the cutest possible way. It's like when I run all the robot vacuums together. Yeah, exactly. All right. I have a couple more clips that I would like to show you of awesome places that Ivo lands.

31:47But first, let's take a break. We'll be right back. Everyone, it's time to wake up. Five more minutes. We've been sleeping long enough and hitting snooze on the fact that we're still stuck with the old way to phone plan. Is that a... Yes, it's old and cuckoo, just like that phone plan you have. Okay. I know, it makes no sense. So rise and shine. It's time for a whole new way to phone plan. T-Mix from T-Mobile, where you pick what's in your plan, like streaming, travel, or gaming, and then change those picks too because there's been a change in plans. Okay, we're awake. And T-Mix sounds great. Good, because I'm all out of alarm sounds. There's been a change in plans. Introducing T-Mix from T-Mobile. Pick what you want.

32:37Change what you want. Included in your plan on America's best network. Number of picks varies by plan and lines on account. A counter pick changes may impact existing device and other promotions. Best mobile network in the U.S. based on analysis by Ucliffe Speed Test Intelligence Data 1H2026. Visit T-Mobile.com slash picks. All right, we're back. So Aibo has been launched. It's out in the world. They're selling some. Everybody loves them. And Aibo begins to show up in a bunch of places. I've just pulled two that I think will make the two of you in particular very happy. The first is in the end credits of an episode of maybe the last TV show you would ever expect to have an eyeball on it. It's Frasier.

33:18And this is playing over the credits. This is a real dog and an eyeball having a stare down and Eddie gets up and does a twirl this it's like 35 seconds long and has maybe the nicest set of YouTube comments I've ever seen in my entire life the joy that this moment on television brought people just cannot be overstated and then the other one is from a Janet Jackson song called Doesn't Really Matter. And the music video for this song, which I don't remember, but is a banger if you're in the market for one, is Janet Jackson, I believe, mostly just all over Tokyo. This is one of those like very early 2000s, it's the future music videos. You know what I mean? This was like a genre of like the Backstreet Boys larger than life

34:08is the one I always think of. It's just like what if everything was bright and neon and the future? And so it's just like Janet Jackson having adventures in the future. And here is just one moment where the AIBO shows up. Yeah. She's talking to her friends and look AIBO she turns off the light to go out with her friends and leaves the Aibo alone. That's terrible. And there's a running undercurrent of this music video that is Aibo being sad because it's alone. I'm going to play this one more time. Just think about how Aibo must feel. She's hanging out with her friends. There's Aibo all by himself. Do you see the frown? Aibo frowns. It's devastating. I'm about to cry. This poor dog. How you see the frown? Aibo frowns.

34:46It's devastating. I'm about to cry. This poor dog. How dare you, Janet Jackson? I'm actually about to cry. That's so sad. Yeah. Anyway, so this thing, big deal, starts selling around the world. There's new models in 2001, new in 2002, new in 2003, and then new ones in 2005. They start to get more features. They get speech recognition. They get image capture. They start to take on more utility, right? There's clearly a sense of like, okay, these things are fun and they're cool and they're cute. Can we give them stuff to do? And my question for both of you is do you think that's the right idea? No. Why? No. Well, it depends on like what do you think these things are for right if if sony was thinking it's a gadget then obviously you want to give them more features more things to

35:30do but if you want them to be your companion the whole point is that they're just there with you what does my cat pd do on a daily basis chaos all pd does is chaos i guess you could say his main function is as an alarm clock because he does wake me up every day. But like he just sits there, purrs, and goes. And I'm just like, I love you. I would give my life for you. I would die for you. And like that's all they really need to do. They don't need to have more features. And the more that it can do, the more I'm just like, ooh, that's a little creepy. Like, mm, don't know. Jen, what do you think? Is there a middle ground here? I mean, why? Why? Just get a cat. Cats are so much more complicated

36:16and arguably vastly more expensive. So I've been playing with these robot pets that have become a thing again, and the little Milo from Ecovacs and the Kata from Switchbot. And there were dozens of these at IFA and CES. And they're definitely coming around. The co-founder of iRobot has launched his own robot dog type thing. So this is all happening again. But for most of these devices i look at them and this potentially is my smart home robotics bias in that i have used robot vacuums and robots that do things in the home and i want to rosie the robot to clean my house um but they're compact and they're the difference between being a robot and a companion robot at this stage is a chasm. And it's a completely different category.

37:10So I feel like trying to do both is very hard. The idea of something that just sits and is cute is very different from something that roams around your house and potentially does things. The interesting difference between this and some of the companion bots we see today is it did move around. A lot of what I'm seeing today don't move around. They just sort of sit and look cute, like the Furby in the background. They move their heads at most. Yeah. But I think you either want a robot for utility or you want a robot for companion. I think the companion is a tougher sell because there are other things you can do. You can get a cat, you can get a dog, you can go outside. But for aging in place and loneliness, I know there has been a lot of evidence that shows,

38:01especially with these more intelligent robots, like the LEQ from Intuition Robotics is a robot, companion robot that sits in one spot and engages with you. So you can see use cases from that perspective. But when it comes to utility, I think the key element to a robot is if it has a utility, it has to do it well and it has to do it consistently. Whereas if you're just throwing in function for function's sake, you're going to end up frustrating the user, and then they're less likely to want to interact with it. And they're going to get annoyed with it as opposed to just think it's cute and cuddly. So it's a really fine line to walk if you're going to try and beat both, I think. Yeah, I agree with that. And I think especially at this point in the early 2000s, this tech is still so primitive that anything you try to make it do just seems to make it worse.

38:51I also think in an interesting way, Sony sort of loses the plot here for a minute. Like, let me show you. Let's see. In 2001, they shipped this thing called the ERS-220, which looks like a RoboCop dog. Where did its ears go? It's the only way I can describe it. Where did the ears go? Doesn't look like it has ears. Like this looks like a dog that would hurt you on purpose. This looks like Boston Dynamics dogs had a little baby dog, and you're just like, oh, that's just a baby murder monster. So Sony ends up going both of these directions kind of simultaneously, right? So there's this one, which the Robocopy dog that looks like something somebody would ride in Minority Report to come and throw you in prison.

39:34But then simultaneously, there's this guy. Oh! The ERS-311, which is deliberately even cuter. Yeah, it's a little friend. It's round. It looks like a teddy bear. It has a little teddy bear face and his little ears are flippity floppity and I just want to love it. Yeah, he's got much more of like a nosy nose too. Yeah, it gets rounder. It gets softer. It's white. It's just much sweeter. It's plastic rather than like silver and black. So it has that more kind of homey feel. It would fit in your home and not look like a strange piece of technology. It looks more like a cartoon dog versus like a Terminator dog. Yes. Yes. So remember, I think all of this is like strategically sensible for Sony, right?

40:23Their idea is still we're going to build a vast world filled with robots for everybody. Also throughout all of this, do you remember how I said going from six legs to four is really hard? Turns out going from four to two, even harder. And throughout all of this, Sony is working on a bipedal standing humanoid robot. It's a little like Transformery. He's like a little squat and compact though in a way that seems a little cute. Yeah. Yeah. I think this guy- This was quite small, right? It wasn't humanoid size. It was like toy size. That's right. Like a little guy. Yeah. Because that's, yeah. This didn't even launch though, did it? No, this never, this was, they demoed it a lot. They showed it off.

41:05It did some cool stuff. It was one of those things that went sort of viral for what it was back in the day. There's a great video of it, like conducting the Tokyo Philharmonic Orchestra. Yeah, exactly. It became a whole thing, but it never shipped because they couldn't make it in a way that actually was reliable and priced correctly. Very hard to make a robot walk safely and not fall over with two legs. Yes. Wheels or four legs. From all my interactions with robots over the last few years, it's very clear that that's where we're at right now. Two legs, hard. But the nice thing about the two legs and the arms though is, yeah, having the hands gives an entire level of, a new level of interaction and utility. Yeah, Sony, is, yeah, having the hands gives an entire level of new level of interaction and utility.

41:48Yeah. Sony, by the way, if it had ever shipped that robot, that robot's name was Curio, by the way, Q-R-I-O, which I like. And the only inclination they ever gave was that if they did ship it, it would be the price of a luxury car. Oh, no. Just to give you just to give you a sense. It's expensive. You add in some degrees of freedom movement into these devices, it gets a lot more expensive. Yeah. Very hard thing to do. Okay. So let's fast forward to sort of the end of the first run of iBow. It gets to the point where it has 18 different joints all over its body that help it move. It can express 60 different emotions. It can speak 1,000 words. It can understand 60 different emotions. It can speak a thousand words.

42:25It can understand a hundred. This thing is like, again, it gets smarter and smarter over time. And it was starting to act more and more like a pet. It had likes and dislikes. I don't know if you noticed in that very first AP video I showed you, the ball was pink. Aibo is programmed to like pink. Aibo is also programmed to like attention, which, relatable. Aibo did not like height or tight spaces. So AIBO being up on this table would make AIBO very unhappy. Maybe that's Gino's problem, actually. Gino liked to dance. All AIBOs like to dance. And one of the things that people really liked in the early days was that you could say, learn this, and then actually grab its paws and sort of do a dance with it. And it would

43:05actually learn how to do that dance and then could do it again. Well, that brings us to the fact that we haven't talked about it at all in the whole hour we've been chatting is that it is called an AI robot. And this really was one of the original early artificially intelligent devices and everything that you're talking about in terms of the learnings. But that's where it kind of fell down, I think, right? In that it didn't... I think it got too good. Yeah. So that's why what's brought the new wave of these robots is that they are able to use the sort of generative AI technology to create a much more engaging and interactive character. Did either of you ever have interactions with it? Very briefly.

43:46Like, could you sort of communicate with it and it responded to you other than just touch? Or what was the kind of selling point of that? The idea, at least, and V, you've certainly used the thing more than I have, but the idea was that it would communicate with you, but it was kind of responding to your sound with sound, right? And it could sing, it could dance, it could make movements, but they were all kind of chirpy dog movements. It wasn't designed to be anything more sophisticated than that. But it was supposed to be reactive to you in that way. And it was learning? You said it had learning capability so it could change and adapt and do more as you had it with you and it would it would supposedly kind of develop a personality and

44:31one of the things that i think is really hard to know about frankly all of these devices is how much of that is real and how much of that is stuff that we assign to these devices because they exist right like oh my eyeball likes such and such. There are actually technical ways for that to be the case, but also we project those things onto this stuff. And I don't know that the difference actually matters in the experience of using these things, but I do think technically speaking, and then again, if you're one of these product makers, especially now who have a much wider set of tools you can use to program this stuff, how much do you want to decide that stuff ahead of time versus how much do you want to

45:11just let people put that into the device for themselves, I think is a complicated question. Have a more personal experience as opposed to, yeah. I mean, like Roomba is actually a good example, right? When Colin Engel was on the show talking about the early days of Roomba, the fact that it would just kind of bonk aimlessly around until it founds, people loved that. There's something so sweet about watching this thing just like doofily fall all over my living room that once it gets more sophisticated, you see it differently. But yeah, so this thing keeps growing, it gets big and then kind of starts to die. And I think the question of what kills AIBO is not actually as simple as I thought. I assumed there would be some sort of technological innovation that left

45:52it behind. It's actually not really the case. I think there's a pretty strong argument to be made that this thing is still as sophisticated a robot pet for what it does as anything that's out there. So a couple of things happened. So one of them is that basically Sony decides to spend its time and money on more profitable things, especially as we get to like the later aughts and we start, we go through a huge financial crisis. Sony does a big pullback to focus on things like TVs and audio equipment, the things where Sony actually makes its money. And the team at its biggest had been about 200 people. So this is never like a huge, giant thing. And again, the first run of these over that first, call it decade, they sold about 150,000 of them, which is not nothing, but it's not a lot.

46:40That's not a big number of products. It's certainly not, for a company like Sony, a meaningful big number of of products it's certainly not for a company like sony a meaningful success story of a new product well i wonder if they couldn't make the next leap in functionality too perhaps like the technology just expensive talking to colin angle again you know there was a point where they were just constantly pushing against the technology like technology wasn't there yet and now you know, needed to take this to the next level and do the humanoid version, obviously, was a lot harder and a lot more expensive and perhaps just not worth, at that stage, the time and money. Yeah, Sony kind of, it was too early and too late

47:19simultaneously, right? They kind of, if they had just stuck it out a few more years, there's another technology turn coming. Coming, yeah. Which, spoiler alert, Sony ends up rebooting the idea. They launched it again, what, like two months ago? Well, they've launched it a few times now. Sony basically says, we're getting out of the AIBO business, and this causes just enormous consternation among people who own the thing. Because again, it's so important to remember, particularly in Japan but everywhere, people bought these things and loved them. And loved them not in a way that you love an inanimate thing on your wall. Loved them like members of their family. And in so many ways, I kept doing the research for this episode and coming across the same like is my LLM alive question that like people immediately spent a few minutes with this thing and found themselves treating it like it's a living thing.

48:18And they became part of their families. Later on in 2015, so like almost a decade later, Sony ends up shutting off support entirely. They, they would, for many years, they would fix existing eyeballs. They would ship replacement parts. And then after a while, they're just like, look, we don't have any of the requisite parts to fix these things anymore. We are, we are done. We can no longer help you. Um, they, like you said, uh, Togeosh Doy, one of the people who created this thing, holds a funeral at the Sony offices for it. And apparently more than a hundred people from Sony came to the AIBO funeral. And Tosh gives a speech at this funeral saying that he's very mad and that innovation and risk-taking at Sony

49:00are dead and this is the end of a beautiful era at Sony. And people are very upset. I'm pretty sure that like Aibo owners would go to Buddhist temples and there were like Buddhist temples that were giving elaborate Aibo funerals. Please, don't call. You can look up like these pictures but there's like Buddhist temples where the – like the dead Aibo are just like arranged in a thing and it's kind of like a monument and it's a way for these people to mourn their yeah guys and i kind of love it yeah well you it's very sweet why yeah i mean but to be fair to sony i mean pets die so you know you're going through the whole circle of life with your robot here it It's funny, though, because that whole thing just reminds me of a lot of art and media now.

49:47Like we have Clara and the Sun and we have maybe Happy Ending on Broadway where it's all about like the end of life of these companion robots that we build and them facing their own mortality in a way that's just like, ooh. It's heavy. It makes them more human. It does. It does in a strange way. Yeah. Well, and this is, again, where the complexity of it all becomes part of the story, too. Apparently, the first thing to give out was always the legs, which, again, relatable. Yeah. My knees ain't what they used to be, you know what I mean? And there was a whole sort of industry of people who learned how to fix these things. There would be people who would buy broken ones, strip them for parts, and then use them to fix other ones.

50:28Like there's a whole universe of people just trying to keep their iBows alive for as long as humanly possible. And even for years, Sony would offer to replace people's iBows and they would say no. I saw all these stories of people whose iBows broke and didn't work anymore. And Sony was like, no problem. We'll send you a new one. And people are like, no, no, no. You don't understand. This one's mine. This is mine. I'm not shipping you my pet so that you can ship me a new. I don't want a new pet. I want you to fix my pet. Such a fascinating story about human psychology in this. It really is. And when Sony finally shut this off, there was a really fun round of stories from a bunch of different publications going out and talking to people who still had and loved their Aibos.

51:10And let me just play you a really short clip from one that the Wall Street Journal did interviewing a bunch of people about the end of life for Aibo. Tatsuo Matsui met his future wife at an Aibo gathering in Kyoto in 2001. This is literally an Aibo meetup. It's a little kimono. Look at the ones all dressed up. We created a story that my Aibo and her Aibo got married, which spontaneously led to our marriage. When the couple tied the knot three years later, they dressed up their dogs as a traditional Japanese bride and groom. They're dressed up as bride and groom? Bride and groom Aibos. Come on. My heart. This is what I'm saying. Oh my God, this is full on geek culture. Tons of stories like this,

51:49and people who found community both in the Aibo's and in other people who had them. Really cool story. And these people are realistically and fairly very upset that this is all happening. But in 2015, they do in fact go away. AIBO ends up in the Museum of Modern Art. It seems like this story is sort of over. Until 2017, two years later, Sony decides, you know what's a great idea? We should make AIBOs. Sony, so it actually, they go and recruit a bunch of the original team, most of whom still worked for Sony. They had gone off to do other things inside of the company. Recruits a bunch of them back team, most of whom still worked for Sony. They had gone off to do other things inside of the company.

52:25Recruits a bunch of them back, brings them all back, retools the design for 2017, brings in a bunch of new technology, and starts selling the AIBO again. Do you know who one of the people early on to get a new AIBO was? Is it Will.i.am? It's baby David Pierce. Oh! Here is just a clip from a video. I was working at the Wall Street Journal at the time. Here's a clip from a video I made that if I'm being completely honest with you, I have absolutely no memory of making. Here is Baby David and his thoughts on the AIBO. Sony took the whole idea up a bunch of levels with this guy, the AIBO. It also doesn't do much except look cute and make dog noises. It can get to know you and take pictures and learn tricks.

53:09It's a robot companion, and that's it. And that's fine. But you're allowing a camera and a bunch of sensors to wander around your home all in the name of cuteness. Yeah. Great point, baby David. Yeah. What a smart idea that was. So this is also, right, this is now, and Jen, I think this is where the real sort of modern smart home story is also starting to happen, right? Yeah. We've gotten to the point where because of smartphones, sensors are vastly cheaper and in ready supply. You can get processors that you need. You can get cameras that you need. And so the new idea is, okay, what if we had all this stuff but it was adorable? And this is now the pitch behind a lot of these devices. Jen, here's my question for you.

53:50You look at this AIBO. The AIBO, it had cuter eyes. It had better ears. It looked much more like a dog. Like they had... More fluid movements. Yeah. I think if you look at the early AIBO as like 50% robot, 50% dog, the second REV is very much like 80% dog, 20% robot. Looks like a toy dog. It doesn't look like a... And at this point, also, we're more used to robots and some form of robots in toys specifically and in our homes to some extent because we've had things like Roombas. Yeah. Well, and to that point, actually, one of Sony's ideas with this new version of AIBO was what if it could do Amazon Echo stuff? It could control your smart home. It could patrol your house at various intervals and check things out for you.

54:35It's basically like a ring camera that can move around. Jen, do you think this is a good idea? Well, we've had a few devices that have tried to do that since. In fact, Amazon came up with its own, the Astro robot, which would roam around, but it wasn't cute enough. This goes to our point earlier about the difference between companionship and utility and finding that fine line. I think the idea that this thing had a camera on in order to be able to move around and understand its environment was probably palatable. But then the idea that this has a camera on it to scrutinize the environment and check on security and live stream to an app changes your interaction and your relationship with it right there.

55:19Even if you want that utility in those moments when you're sitting playing and getting your face right up in it, like you were in the video, David, and going, oh, good, good, good, good. It's like, do I want that utility in those moments when you're sitting playing and getting your face right up in it like you were in the video david and going it's like do i want that recorded yeah and that yeah i mean i think the idea of a roaming security robot is very different from a companion robot and bringing those two things together it does it's not a very effective security robot it's so cute what's a burglar going to do? Be like, bah. You know, like you get a German shepherd, the robber thinks twice.

55:50You get a little eyeball. It's just like, okay, pick it up. You're saying if I had a bigger roaming security robot. I'd be less scared. That's very American of you. I know. Listen, I am American, so I'm just saying. That is the idea behind the SwitchBot robot that I have, the Kata. It can roam around and take video and control your smart home. It's not billed as a security robot, but the Amazon Astro was billed as a security robot. Again, once you give it functionality like that, you perhaps expect it to be able to do more as opposed to just be a companion. I have very little personally interest or use for a companion robot. I like the cuteness. I see companion robots for kids or for people that potentially need them for various life situations. My personal life

56:41situation, companion robot, I don't see a use case for. Security robot, I could use, I could see some value in it. I still think the Ring's always home cam, which is the idea is there's a camera that can fly around your home when you're not there. Actually makes an awful lot of sense. The technology just has not arrived to make that viable. It can't deal with ceiling fans or mirrors, you know, bit of an issue. Because, you know, but those are different things. I think those technologies do not need to come together. I think that's right. And I think the idea that something can be both of those things at the same time is just not right. Because you even, like the minute you add these features

57:22to your companion, it no longer resembles the thing that it was supposed to be, right? Like, to me, part of the way that AIBO went wrong was immediately as soon as it started doing things that a dog couldn't do. Yeah. And actually, what you should do is try to make this thing dumber and sillier and less useful. And more like a dog, right? Because it's not a companion. It's an employee, right? For all these reasons, the new AIBO comes out. It's still very expensive. It went up to like $2,900, which is too much for any of the things that we've been describing. They sell about 20,000 of them and then they come to the U.S. and it's not really a hit. It just doesn't quite take off in the same way. And that you can still get Ibo's. They're still out there.

58:10And so the story here is essentially over for our purposes. The 25th anniversary of Ibo was in 2024. It was a big deal. There were events all over, especially in Japan. There's still an annual Ibo event in Orlando every year that I think the three of us should go to next year. Oh wow, just down the road. So look out for us, AIBO 2027. So here's my question. It's now 2026. You could, in theory, start this all over and build this in a, in a pretty new, exciting way. I think AIBO is mostly like a nostalgia thing at this point. I have a hard time imagining it coming back as its own thing. But Jen, you have a couple of these in your house, and I want to know if this idea can still make it. But before we do, we're going to take a break.

58:54It's part of the Version History Questions. We'll be right back. Hear that? That's me in Tokyo learning to make sushi from a master. How did I get here? I invested wisely. Welcome. investment objectives, risks, charges, and expenses. Visit state street.com slash IM for perspectives containing this and other information. Read it carefully. Spies subject to risks similar to those of stocks. All ETFs are subject to risk, including possible loss of principle. Alps distributors, Inc. distributor. All right, we're back. It's time now for the version history questions. The eight questions we asked to try to figure out the true legacy of any product. The first one is the time matrix. Everybody's favorite concept.

59:42Nobody has any questions about it. Works perfectly every time. This plots idea against time, right idea, right time, wrong idea, wrong time, or somewhere in between. This one I think is actually more complicated than most. But V, you go first. Where would you put this? I think it's the wrong time. Yeah, I agree with that. And like, I kind of think it's the wrong-ish right idea. But like, that's the thing. The wrong-ish right idea. But, like, that's the thing. The wrong-ish right idea. I think it's just sitting smack damn. I don't have a quadrant for that. I don't know if it's on a quadrant. I think it's on the line of, like, the right idea, wrong idea axis. It's just all the way at wrong time.

1:00:17So we're basically, we're all the way. Yeah. All the way at right. All the way at wrong time. Dead center. Right idea, wrong idea. Yeah. right, all the way at wrong time, dead center, right idea, wrong idea. Yeah, because I think we're still negotiating what the idea of a home robot is as like what people want and want to use. So I don't know, like 20 years in the future, we could call this the absolutely right idea. But right now, I think it's smack dab in the middle. Jen, what do you think? Yeah, I mean, I feel like the idea was the right idea because people wanted to take this technology and put it into, you know, anthropomorph for decades, as we discussed, making this make a robot for the home that can move around and interact.

1:01:13In terms of the wrong time, I think it was the wrong time because of the technology. Although they were able to develop one, it wasn't something that was able to be affordable enough for people to put in their homes. This is why I asked the could you do this again in 2026 question. And I mean that question in a very specific way, which is I want to build the 99 version of this thing in 2026. I want to take out all the cameras. I want to take out all the Wi-Fi. I want to not have any of the stuff that it added over time. I want the dumb first version of the thing built now, which would make it vastly cheaper. It would make it probably more durable just because we have more manufacturing prowess than we used to. And I have spent a lot of time trying to decide,

1:01:57would that thing work now? And I feel like culturally, maybe it's just the same, right? Where you have some markets where that idea would be really compelling, especially at a cheaper price. Maybe they sell more of them in Japan because they're cheaper. And that still in the U.S. and other Western societies, we are just not ready for or interested in the idea of robot companions. So maybe in 27 years, actually nothing has changed. I don't know. I think you could probably get more like runway with this in like dementia homes or elderly homes. Like I think because they have done actual clinical research to show. I think they did it during COVID to show that it led to a lot more positive outcomes in care. So I think as like an enterprise device,

1:02:44you could definitely have that out right now i think it has to be a little fluffier to be to be quite frank for for today's like i love the design of this right now it gives me like k9 from doctor who vibes but like more more updated but you know i kind of like the retro look of this but i think you make it fluffier you make it dumber that works but for the tech companies they're they're going to be like and now we put muse in it yeah that's like you know that's coming you know that you know that's coming it's gonna it's gonna be that weird little fuzzy guy with the ass on him who's like who's like what's up i'm a robot now and you know they looked at the legacy of eyeball in designing muse Muse and they're like, we're going to make it cute.

1:03:27So, yeah. I think there's an appeal for kids, too. And that's the one thing I've noticed with these devices that I'm testing is that neither of them seem designed for children. They do seem to be designed for adults. But I do think there is a big market for robot toys, robot companions for kids that maybe aren't connected to the Internet, to your point, David. Maybe, but with some local LLM on them to be really engaging and interactive. Especially for kids with allergies, because sometimes you can't have a pet, but you want one. Is it better than a goldfish? Probably. Probably. Yeah. Everything's better than a goldfish. But I think I land where Jen does on the time matrix, which is deep into wrong time territory.

1:04:09But I think we're going to nudge it up towards the right idea. I think that that exact placement is about right. Good. All right. Question number two. Was this peak anything? I have a couple to offer you, and then I'm curious if you guys have any. Was this peak robot dog? Like, definitely. Right? Yeah. I don't know. Maybe Miles would disagree. I have a couple to offer you, and then I'm curious if you guys have any. Was this peak robot dog? Like, definitely, right? Yeah. Yeah. I don't know. Maybe Miles would disagree. Milo. Little Milo. I turned him off. Sorry. Cold, dead eyes now. He seems okay with it. Yeah. Yeah. All right. Yeah. I mean, I think the nostalgia people feel for this thing is evidence that we have not done

1:04:43it again since. No one's been successful with it yet, no. Was this peak Sony? Like, was it the Sony-est Sony ever was? The Walkman, to me, is still the peak Sony. Okay. Is this peak weird 90s toys? I don't know. I think the Furby's got that. This has some serious competition. That guy has the dead eyes of the Furby behind me. We're doing Tamagotchis this season. We have a lot. Okay. The only other one, is it peak cute robot noises? I think it might be. It was the first time tech felt cuddly and engaging in that respect. Maybe peak robot friend. Yeah. Peak friend. It's a good name. I don't think it's like peak Sony naming, but it's a very good name. It's a very good name. And I think history served it really well,

1:05:38even though it's a stupid acronym. And I hate it. I think peak robot dog is really where it fits. It's pretty good. 27 years later to still have the title is not bad work. All right, question number three. I think we've answered this a little bit, but if you could time travel back and develop it yourself, could you make the product more successful? Fur. Fur? Fur is a good one. I really do think some more warm, cuddly, fuzzy look was necessary. What would you do with cooling? Because the fan was really loud. There were obviously challenges for the fur. That's true. There's actually a whole section of, by the way, the manual for this thing is like a phone book. It's spectacular. And there's a whole section on just a bunch of things that might be going wrong,

1:06:24and like half of them are it's too hot. Anything that's happening that shouldn't be, it's probably just too hot. So fur was definitely a challenge. Yeah, very much so. Wrapping it in a fur coat was probably not going to work. That's gents. I like that. More fur. Let's just set this thing on fire in everybody's house. Do you have anything you would change? No, I think it's perfect i think he's perfect he's a perfect good little boy you shouldn't be a cat uh honestly i think dog makes the most sense for for the robot like the idea of an eyeball not that cats aren't companions because obviously i'm a cat lady but I think robot dog makes sense to do first, actually. The beauty of a robot cat would be

1:07:08you wouldn't have to have it do anything. You just be like, oh, it's just... You wouldn't have any expectations. Yeah, it just sits over there. It sits there and then every once in a while it'll walk up your stuff and knock it off a table. Exactly, exactly. Okay, next question on the list. Oh, mine, by the way. If I could go back in time and make it more successful, I would just yell the word cheaper over and over at them. Yeah, yeah, that. Every time they set a price, I would be like, cheaper, and that would be... Three grand, though. I feel like it was cheap as they could have possibly got it. I mean, it's actually kind of impressive for that time. They're going to have to subsidize it is what it is.

1:07:44I mean, weren't like VCRs like $1,500 in this era? I mean, technology was really expensive. But yes, cheaper would have made it more successful, that is for sure. Okay, next question. Should we rename this product? No, Aibo's perfect. Aibo's good, right? Aibo's perfect. Yeah, I think even though it took me a while, like 20 years to figure out how to pronounce it. Jen, I want you to start on this one, and I want you to put your smart home brain on for this one. What feature of this thing should every current version have? I do actually really like the noises. That's what I was going to say too. Yeah, I think the communicative expressiveness, both from the head tilt and the tail wag and that,

1:08:26and then a eep kind of communication. I have robot vacuums that talk to me and they annoy the hell out of me. I'm like, shut up. I do not want to hear you talk to me. I'm fine with beeps and boops. Wait, they talk like with words? Yeah, because they have voice assistants in them now. Nope, nope, nope. So they'll be like washing the mops, going to clean the kitchen. And I mean, I can see the utility there, but I don't like it personally. I think the bleep bloops are the perfect middle ground there. Because I think one of the lessons of this thing for me has been how quickly we as the users pick up on a series, like just a little language of that, right? Where it's like you have- You know what it means.

1:09:04You have 10 things to tell me and you're going to tell them all to me with a series of beeps. It's sort of amazing how quickly we as people learn that level of communication. And for me, it's like that's all I need. You can tell me so much with what amounts to like a very basic Morse code system. Yeah, R2D2 is perfectly simple. V, did you have anything else or do we all agree? I think personality. Like the beep boops like kind of put into it, but like having an idea of a personality is good because if I'm just thinking of the Marumi I had, it has no personality but is hella cute. But it's like... Okay, can I give you one way to do that? Put a tail on your robot vacuum. You can tell I've had

1:09:43some fun experiences with cats. All right, three more questions. These are the Hall of Fame questions. Any product has to hit all three of these tests to get into the Virgin History Hall of Fame. Question number one, did this product do something truly new? Yeah, at that time. I think the answer is yes, pretty easily to that. The whole, like just the fact, to me, that is actually most evidenced by the fact that not that many people bought it but everybody knows what it is right like it's just what this thing was was so memorable to people there are two more questions and i think it might fail either of these tests but let's just see uh was it either remarkably good or remarkably bad it was remarkably good for what it was at its

1:10:21time yes no one else had developed anything like this. And it was engaging and people did fall in love with it. So it did a very good job for what it set out to do. I tend to agree. I think you can quibble with is what it was trying to do relevant to everyone? But like, did it do its job almost shockingly well, especially for 1999? I think the answer is clearly yes. Remarkably cute. It really is. Question number three, I think, is the challenge for the AIBO, which is, did it change history? Is there a world before it and a world after it? And Jan, I want your thoughts on this first, because I think if the answer is yes, it should be showing up somewhere in your world, right? Like, did it convince everyone on Earth to buy a robot for their house?

1:11:11No. But like, do you see shades of AIBO in the stuff that we have now? Oh, completely. The two robots in my room were fully inspired by AIBO. I think there was a lull there for a long time where no one did anything in this space because it was too technologically difficult. I think generative AI has, and large language modules have brought an entire, a new wave now where people can make an AIBO, but make it better in their ideas, have a personality, learn, grow, adapt using generative AI. And now we're seeing a huge, a huge resurgence and we're going to see more and more of them, I think. And it was the original humanoid too. I mean, they did make a humanoid, didn't release it for lots of reasons.

1:12:00We will never know for sure, but I can guess that it's complicated, expensive, and can do lots of damage, which is why we're still behind on humanoids today. But yes, I think so. I think this is an easy candidate for the Hall of Fame. I mean, it's already in. Like, there is a Robot Hall of Fame, and it's in there. It's a pretty good argument. It's in museums. Is it? Yeah, I think one of the funniest things about this is, like, going all the way back to the beginning, Sony sets up this computer science laboratory. They want it to be like Xerox PARC. They sort of got their wish in the sense that Xerox PARC invented like generations of amazing technology and never figured out how to make any money off of any of it.

1:12:35That is the AIBO story. Sony built a bunch of incredible stuff, convinced a lot of people that this was the future, made a lot of really influential stuff and never built the hit products. You know, that's just Sony's lot in life. I do think if you asked this question like a year ago, it would have been more of an uphill battle for AIBO. But now that we are kind of in this new era of AI and you have dots and you have muse and they're all cute, I really do think they take that from AIBO. I think you could see that line direct right there. And cute's going to take over the world is what's going to happen. And I hope you might ignore the fact that it has cameras and microphone in because it's cute.

1:13:17Yeah, no, I do think that that's, yeah, that's your dark legacy, buddy. That's your dark legacy. Gino, you didn't do it. Don't listen to her. It's your fault. Gino can't see you anyway. It's no problem. All right, well, this is good. I was not prepared to break it to Gino that he wasn't going to make the Hall of Fame. So I think Ivo belongs in the version history of the Hall of Fame. This feels good. One of the most remarkable little pieces of engineering we've seen in this studio. I'm happy. All right, that's it for the show. V, Jen, thank you both for being here. remarkable little pieces of engineering we've seen in this studio. I'm happy. All right, that's it for the show. V, Jen, thank you both for being here.

1:13:50This has been delightful. We will get this thing working. The fact that he worked for like one minute is like I'm gonna spend the rest of my life getting Gino to work again. It's gonna be very exciting. He's worth the effort. But for now, we gotta get out of here. Thank you again to both of you. Thank you to all of you for watching and listening. Remember to subscribe to The Verge so we can keep buying old gadgets on eBay. As soon as autumn rolls around and you swap your iced lattes for pumpkin spice, that's your signal to start thinking about the holidays, the decor, the gifts, the shopping lists, but more importantly, the holiday treats. Cheesecakes, cookies, is there anything better? And when the recipe calls for cream cheese, there's only one option.

1:14:51Philadelphia, the original cream cheese made with fresh milk and real cream. This holiday season, whether you're going all out or keeping it simple, make it really Philly good. Find your favorite holiday recipe at creamcheese.com.

▸More episode summaries

The Vergecast cover art
The VergecastWhat's really at stake in the Jensen Huang saga2026-11-13 · 120 min
The Vergecast cover art
The VergecastJensen Huang resigns, and our HomeView review2026-11-12 · 59 min
The Vergecast cover art
The VergecastThe e-readers readers love2026-11-16 · 38 min
Transcribe your links. Paste a YouTube, Google Drive or podcast link and WhipScribe gives you the transcript. Transcribe a link →
New The Vergecast transcripts by email
One email per new episode, unsubscribe in every message. Not shared with the publisher.