podcasts / The Story / episode
The Story cover art
podcast
📅 2026-11-16 ⏱ 27 min episode · ~2 min read 📝 Transcript · 5,860 words 🎙 Josh Glancy

Josh Glancy: The Story transcript and summary

The Story · · Transcript & summary by WhipScribe

It explains why about a million young Britons are out of work and study, and what a radical welfare overhaul would cost and change.

Read the transcript Episode page ↗
In this episodeAlan MilburnRachel ReevesKeir StarmerStephen TimmsAndy BurnhamJames ReidGreat YarmouthBirkenheadNetherlandsUniversal CreditLouise HaigSunday Times

▸Chapters

Tap a chapter to play it from that moment in the show's own player; the transcript opens there too.

Transcribe your links. Paste a YouTube, Google Drive or podcast link and WhipScribe gives you the transcript. Transcribe a link →

▸Notable quotes

“I think for this generation of young people they feel like they are putting in effort and the contract's broken.” Josh Glancy · at 19:05 — ▶ hear it from here
“Milburn likes to use this phrase, we need a whole system reset.” Josh Glancy · at 26:13 — ▶ hear it from here

▸What this episode covers

Britain has roughly one million young people classed as NEET, meaning not in education, employment or training, and youth unemployment has rarely dropped below 10% this century. It now sits around 14 to 15%. Former minister Alan Milburn calls this a moral crisis rather than a fiscal one. He argues the labour market is the main driver: there are about 1.6 million fewer low- and medium-skilled jobs than 25 years ago, and automation and the collapse of entry-level work have removed the first rung of the ladder. Employers using AI screening also leave applicants feeling ignored.

Josh Glancy, associate editor of the Sunday Times, spent time with young people in Great Yarmouth and Birkenhead, where one job seeker, Connor, had sent 172 applications since January 2025 and found that half got a reply and most then went silent. Mental health diagnoses, including ADHD and autism, have risen sharply, and Milburn says the system is too quick to ask what people cannot do. Glancy found many of the young people passive and unsure how to act, rather than unwilling to work.

Milburn's proposal merges Universal Credit and PIP for young people into a single youth allowance. Most claimants would receive a means-tested payment linked to job searching, while those with serious disabilities would get an unconditional top-up. He draws on the Netherlands, which cut its own NEET rate sharply after treating the problem as an emergency. Glancy thinks the plan is radical and likely to be adopted, but it costs money before any savings arrive, and it may still face resistance from Labour MPs.

▸Josh Glancy on The Story: the answers

Who is Josh Glancy?

Josh Glancy

Josh Glancy is associate editor of the Sunday Times. He spent time with Alan Milburn and young people in Great Yarmouth and Birkenhead while reporting on the NEET issue.

What did Alan Milburn say about NEET?

Alan Milburn told Josh Glancy that the NEET problem, meaning about a million young people not in education, employment or training, is a moral crisis rather than a fiscal one. He argues the answer is to enhance young people's opportunities rather than simply cut their benefits.

“It's not about a fiscal crisis, it's a moral crisis.”Alan Milburn · 5:30

What did Alan Milburn say about youth allowance?

Alan Milburn proposes replacing the separate health and disability benefits for young people with a single youth allowance, so young people would no longer be split between Universal Credit and Personal Independence Payment. Most claimants would receive a means-tested payment linked to searching for work, while people with serious disabilities would get an additional allowance that is not tied to job searching.

“So basically, everyone's going to have this youth allowance.”Josh Glancy · 19:46

What did Josh Glancy say about AI?

Josh Glancy said that, based on his conversations, AI is not yet replacing jobs in large numbers, but companies are changing how they recruit and becoming more selective at the entry level. He reported that James Reid of Reid Recruitment claims graduate jobs have dropped by about 75%, partly due to AI.

“AI isn't replacing jobs in large numbers at the moment, but companies are changing their recruitment patterns.”Josh Glancy · 11:37

What did Josh Glancy say about Netherlands?

Josh Glancy said the Netherlands faced a NEET rate similar to Britain's 15 years ago and brought it down hugely. The Dutch treated it as an emergency because losing a generation of young people was at stake, and they put work ahead of welfare.

“they decided it was a crisis it's emergency if you're going to lose a generation of young people”Josh Glancy · 21:42

What is Josh Glancy's main argument on The Story?

Josh Glancy argues that Britain's NEET crisis is driven as much by a shrinking supply of entry-level jobs as by young people's skills, and that Alan Milburn's plan to merge youth benefits into one allowance, paired with more employment support, could work if the upfront cost is accepted. He says the Netherlands shows the problem can be largely reversed.

Mentioned in this episode

Episode facts

Released
November 16, 2026
Length
27 minutes

▸Key takeaways

01Britain has about one million young people classed as NEET, and former minister Alan Milburn has spent a year reviewing how to fix the welfare system for them.
02Milburn wants one youth allowance replacing Universal Credit and PIP for young people, with a job-search condition attached for most claimants.
03Milburn says every £25 spent on welfare support buys just £1 of employment opportunities, a ratio he wants to flip toward jobs and apprenticeships.
04Milburn's plan costs money up front, with about £6 billion floated, before long-term savings reach the welfare bill in Britain.
05Josh Glancy thinks Milburn's plan can work, pointing to the Netherlands, which cut its NEET rate sharply after treating it as an emergency.

▸Questions this episode answers

Q1What did Alan Milburn say about the NEET crisis being a moral crisis?

Alan Milburn told Josh Glancy that the NEET problem is a moral crisis rather than a fiscal one, because Britain does not offer enough opportunities to young people. He argues the response should focus on enhancing their opportunities instead of simply cutting their benefits. He also says the NEET label hides a million different lives and stories.

Q2What is Alan Milburn's youth allowance proposal for young people on benefits?

Alan Milburn proposes abolishing the existing health and disability benefits for young people and replacing them with a single youth allowance, so there is no separate Universal Credit and PIP for them. Most young people would receive a means-tested allowance linked to searching for work, with a stick alongside the carrot. People with significant disabilities would get an additional cost allowance that is not means-tested and not tied to job searching.

Q3How radical is Alan Milburn's plan for the NEET crisis, according to Josh Glancy?

Josh Glancy said he thinks Milburn's plan is quite radical and that Milburn will see much of it implemented, because it is a ready-made policy agenda for a government that lacks oven-ready plans. Glancy said the plan needs upfront spending, with a figure of about £6 billion floated, before any long-term savings. He described Milburn's approach as a whole system reset that reaches into the Department for Education and the NHS.

Q4What did Josh Glancy say about AI and entry-level jobs for young people?

Josh Glancy said AI is not replacing jobs in large numbers yet, but companies are thinning their intake and being more selective at the entry level. He reported that James Reid, of Reid Recruitment, claimed about a 75% drop in graduate jobs, partly due to AI. Glancy said young applicants often send AI-generated applications that are rejected by AI screening software, leaving them feeling ghosted.

Q5How many job applications did Connor send, and what happened to them?

Connor, a young man Josh Glancy met in Great Yarmouth at an employment readiness school, had applied for 172 jobs since January 2025. Half of those applications got a response, but most of the others simply ghosted him. Connor was studying for a car mechanic course and was facing difficult family circumstances, neurodivergence and social struggles, according to Glancy.

Q6How did the Netherlands bring down its NEET rate, according to Milburn and Josh Glancy?

Josh Glancy said the Netherlands had a NEET rate similar to Britain's a decade or 15 years ago and brought it down hugely. According to Glancy, the Dutch government treated it as an emergency, since losing a generation of young people was at stake, and it put work first, ahead of welfare. Milburn spent time there and looks to the Dutch model as the gold standard for reducing NEET numbers.

▸Transcript

Our own transcript of the public episode, with a timestamp about every 90 seconds. Tap a timestamp to play the episode from there in the show's own player; the link button on a paragraph copies a link that opens this page there.

0:00Hey, we're Nick and Jack, hosts of The Best One Yet. Behind every episode, there's research, email, spreadsheets, and our shared Google Doc, the headline hammer. With Google Workspace with Gemini, Google's AI is built right into the premium versions of tools we already use, like Gmail, Docs, and Sheets. No new tools or extra logins, just personalized AI for the way we work. That means less time on the work, around the work, and more time finding the stories worth talking about. Get AI tools for work. Upgrade to Google Workspace with Gemini at goo.gle slash workspace with Gemini. That's goo.gle slash workspace with Gemini. Cash now more later from Opendoor gives you cash up front for your home plus all the profit later. That's no chaos now, no cash left behind later. Skip the showings now. Pocket extra profit later.

0:46This is so simple now. This is so awesome later. Or sell fast now and pop the champagne later. Cash now more later. Now available nationwide. Start your offer at opendoor.com slash ACAST. Profits calculated after fees and costs, eligibility and offer price may vary. From the Times and the Sunday Times, this is The Story. I'm Luke Jones. For our nation's young and unemployed, even getting a no is a faff. I've applied to countless places, I got one response, and then I got turned down, but I had to reach out to be told, oh yeah, we've be turned you down without telling you. You're making people feel like, why am I bothering from an inn? This guy is one of the one million young people the government have put in a bucket called

1:36NEET. N-E-E-T. Not in education, employment or training. I feel like people don't really read your CV anymore. It's just like the AI things that just go through a huge site and pass it off. You don't really get the sponsors back. It kind of makes you feel like there was no point even trying to get on it. Who is going to sort this out? Well, in the bowels of government, an urgent plan is coming any minute. This cohort of young people, what strikes me more than anything is their potential, their creativity, their aspirations to succeed. And I hate the fact that that's somehow capped. And what we're doing is we're ruining their life chances. Former Minister Alan Milburn will tomorrow publish his year-long review of the issue and what should change to fix it.

2:26Welfare changes are potentially afoot, coupled with more job support. So yes, there will be less money being spent on benefits, and there'll be more money being spent on opportunities and support. That support should be a guaranteed entitlement in law. Associate editor of the Sunday Times, Josh Glancy, has been out and about with Milburn and some of those he's trying to help. I guess the easy assumption is, oh, it's a snowflake generation and they just want to live on benefits and they are all on their phones all day. But most of the kids I met do quite want to work. They do want to do something perhaps with their life. They can't see a path there. The story today, why aren't young Britons working?

3:23We are talking NEETs today, people who are not in education, employment or training. And Alan Milburn, he is gainfully employed. What's he up to? Alan Milburn actually hates the acronym NEET. Does he? Yeah, because I think it's become a kind of ubiquitous label in politics. But actually, obviously, there's a million people classified as NEET. But actually, that obscures, obviously, a million different lives and stories and lots of different things within them. So I, for this sort of piece of journalism, really wanted to actually go and spend some time with young people who obviously all have different stories and different perspectives. Because this has become one of the big focal points of our politics really in the last year. So if you wind back to the summer of 2025, Rachel Reeves and Keir Starmer attempted

4:05to cut the benefits bill by five billion, which is a lot, but also not that much in the context of the benefits bill. And it goes catastrophically wrong. There's a backbench rebellion in the Labour Party. The bill is watered down to insignificance. And it's a huge political defeat for the government. And at that point, they have a decision to to make because everyone knows that something needs to be done about the benefits bill but also about this growing amount of young people who are just not in the system and not gainfully active in any way so what they do at that point is they appoint two well-known old labour war horses shall we say uh stephen timms who's doing a review of the PIP, the Personal Independence Payment System.

4:49And then Alan Milburn, who's looking at the whole welfare system for young people, root and branch. How can we change it, make it more effective, both cost effective, but also more effective for young people? So he has spent the last year a bit more going to massive detail about this. And as you say, it's something that has hoved into a particular political view in the last year or two. It's a problem that's slowly been getting worse ever since, I don't know, would we go back to COVID? Would we go back to the financial crash? You can go back to the 1970s, really, if you want, because it's the de-industrialisation of Britain and the arrival of Thatcherism and the kind of remodelling of Britain's economy.

5:30And ever since then, you've really had a problem with youth unemployment. The word NEET doesn't arrive until the 21st century because we love our Whitehall acronyms. In the 21st century, the NEET rate has never been below 10%, really. Spikes massively after the financial crisis. Comes down again, but has now gone up, yes, since COVID. And it's now at about 14, 15%. And as Alan Milburn told me when we spoke, this is actually a moral crisis, because there's just not enough opportunities for young people. I think we've got to look at it through an entirely different lens. It's not about a fiscal crisis, it's a moral crisis. Yeah. And it's got to be all about how are we enhancing young people's opportunities

6:11rather than, you know, simply cutting their benefits. And to try and meet some of those young people, you went to two places in particular, Great Yarmouth and Merseyside. Why those places and what did you find there? Both of those places, in a way, are emblematic of what I'm just talking about. A kind of hollowed out, desiccated economic model where, you know, Birkenhead, once part of the, you know, Liverpool being the New York of Europe and the great shipbuilding and the dockyards and all of that. Those jobs haven't all gone, but a lot of them obviously have. Great Yarmouth was once the sort of herring and tourism capital of britain there's a great sort of victorian seaside town both places

6:51now that are you know in really poor economic shape and have been for a long time and so you have this kind of almost intergenerational poverty and intergenerational dependence on welfare so so i was looking at that really tell us about connor on welfare, so I was looking at that, really. Tell us about Connor. So Connor is someone I met in Great Yarmouth. I went to a place called ACE, which is a kind of training and employment readiness sort of school that gets funding from the government, and he was a young guy doing car mechanic course. I came here because I wanted to express my interest in cars, potentially maybe for a good paid job as a mechanic, maybe one day. At the moment, I'm trying to think of what I want to do.

7:37OK. But there isn't many good options and not enough support in this generation anymore. I was quite taken aback, but you sort of have these ideas in your head and you read the articles, and I hope people will read the article I've written and listen to this podcast, but actually when you actually sit with someone and you listen to the amount of different challenges he was facing, both in terms of really difficult family situation, wide array of neurodivergencies, and just clearly like just physically and socially like struggling. I'm on university quit and PIP. I've actually applied for 172 jobs since January 2025. And Conor of those 172 applications like how many? Half of them got back yeah half of them got back yeah and then most of them just ghosted me.

8:26That makes me feel it was horrible. It was horrible. The, I guess, easy assumption is, oh, it's a snowflake generation and they can't be bothered to work and they just want to live on benefits and they are all on their phones all day. And, you know, you might find elements of truth in that. You might find that in lots of generations, to be honest. But most of the kids I met do quite want to work. They do want to do something perhaps with their life. They can't see a path there. That's what really troubled me about some of these younger people I met. A sense of passivity, but also of low agency. They couldn't quite see how they would be able to make things happen in the world for themselves it just felt very fuzzy to them and to some extent i

9:11don't know if you remember being 20 luke or even 18 but like to some extent all young people feel like that but yes the picture for them felt very blurred and on the point of jobs it is clear isn't it that these this cohort of young people are entering a very different jobs market from previous generations. What has changed and how much is just a symptom of the fact that our economy is struggling somewhat? So quite a lot has changed. So I think when you think about NEETs, you have to think about supply and demand. So supply is how are the young people equipped to flourish in the workplace? But the demand is, are there the jobs there and the opportunities for equipped to flourish in the workplace, but the demand is, are there the jobs there

9:46and the opportunities for them to flourish in? Alan Milburn told me that there are 1.6 million fewer low- or medium-skilled jobs in the economy today compared to 25 years ago. I think the fallacy in public policy for 40 years has been if you can fix the young person, make them more employable, make them more skilled, took them the benefits, then that'll solve the problem. And unless you get the labour market side of it right, which is the biggest driver of this, then it'll count for nothing. Jobs that used to not require a degree now require a degree. And then there's just the elimination of jobs that get alternated and so on. So 1.6 million fewer low or medium skilled jobs in the economy today

10:25compared to 25 years ago. And those would largely, or a lot of them, would be entry-level jobs that would have gone to EMP. So that's a whole change. It's not just about economic decline. It's actually also about things like automation. It's about the collapse of the high street, even the newspaper round, that sort of thing. The kind of thing that you would do as your first job, not be very well paid for. Those jobs aren't there in the same kind of numbers. So that is a real issue because what you tend to find with young people is once you've had a job and you've experienced getting paid and what you can do with the money and the independence that gives you, it can create a virtuous cycle quite quickly.

11:05It's when you've never had a job and you get used to living off benefits, you can get a vicious cycle quite quickly. So it can go one of two ways quite quickly for young people. And what about AI in all of this? It's already, we know, getting rid of some of those sort of entry-level, bottom rung of the ladder jobs. Is that actually really happening or is that just a fear? Yeah, it's really interesting. James Reid recently said that AI is literally eating jobs. Is that actually really happening or is that just a fear? Yeah it's really interesting James Reid recently said that AI is literally eating jobs and on his platform Reid Recruitment he reckons there's about a 75% drop in graduate jobs in no small part due to AI. The best I can

11:37understand talking to a bunch of people about this is that what is happening is that AI isn't replacing jobs in large numbers at the moment, but companies are changing their recruitment patterns. They might be thinning their intake. They might be being a bit more selective about who they take and what jobs they fill. So actually, it's really at that entry-level point where things are really difficult. People are almost spamming companies and firms with applications that are AI-generated, and they're getting battered back by those companies, AI, HR, software, and it's really the robots talking to the robots. And the young people are often left very alienated and quite confused by this process.

12:14They feel quite sort of ghosted by the system. And this issue of people not getting feedback just came up again and again and again. And did you, in terms of the young people that you spoke to, I mean, were any particularly and specifically concerned about AI and that eating the job that they might be going for? Yeah, so I met a lovely young guy called Bradley, who's 21, at the Youth Hub in Great Yarmouth. What he really wanted to do was design and computing and gaming. And he was really into it, quite passionate about it. But he was quite, also quite, almost quite wistful. And so he was actually having to rethink in real time what he wanted to do in life it was quite challenging one of the big hurdles in the moment there is like ai

12:52yeah we've generated ai being like a really big thing yeah right now lots of people are going oh why don't we just get a computer to do that So you're worried that some of those jobs or tasks won't be there? Yeah, that's pretty much what I'm saying. Luckily, as the murders, what they are, you can always look closely and be like, that person's got six fingers sort of thing. Right, yeah. There's a bit more of lenience at the moment, but as it's getting more and more developed, Yeah. that's going to be rough be what I've studied for, or could be what I've studied for, in the bin. So we know AI is an issue. We know the stagnating, sluggish economy is an issue. But then we also have this recurring theme in the reporting around this. And I assume in also the conversations you had with people about this issue on mental health

13:50and this increasingly becoming a barrier to people getting into work they may wish otherwise be in. So mental health as a reason for being on benefits as a young person has absolutely rocketed. The mental health, that's a very broad umbrella. We're talking about a wide range of issues here. We're talking about depression and anxiety, which rocketed during the pandemic. We're also talking about neurodivergence and diagnoses of ADHD and autism, which have also gone up astronomically. I mean, this was a stat that just amazed me. So there was a recent report by the psychoanalyst Peter Foneghi about a diagnosis of neurodivergence. He found that ADHD prevalence among 12 to 17-year-olds in England

14:33between 2000 and 2025, so since the millennium, has gone up by 1,392%. Wow. So we're in a completely different world when it comes to that kind of neurodivergence. So the system hasn't caught up, basically. The system says, okay, well, if you've got ADHD, like, here are your benefit options. It's too easy, is Milburn's argument, to get an ADHD diagnosis, which might be a perfectly valid thing, but the jump from there to you're on benefits and you might well be staying on benefits because once people get on, we know it can be a treadmill, is very quick. And we'll get into what Milburn is proposing in a moment. So are you agreeing with, I think what sounds like his point, which is the system is inadvertently writing young people off?

15:18I do agree with that, actually. I think the way Milburn puts it is we're too quick to say what can't you do, not what could you do. And you need to reframe that in a much more positive way. And I do agree with that, not least because, you know, to go back to that statistic, I mean, we are talking huge, huge numbers who have neurodivergence. It doesn't necessarily stop you working. It might make you more suited to some work than others. And I think we've got to think all that through. But the idea that we can write off, frankly, millions of people from the workplace as a result of that is just not feasible or advisable or in fact beneficial to those people. Coming up then how radical are Alan

15:58Milburn's plans and just how likely is it that they'll actually be implemented? More from Josh in a, Docs, and Sheets. No new tools or extra logins, just personalized AI for the way we work. That means less time on the work, around the work, and more time finding the stories worth talking about. Get AI tools for work. Upgrade to Google Workspace with Gemini at goo.gle.com. That's goo.gle.com. That's workspace.gle.com. your competitor. That's why over 90,000 companies choose Quo, the business phone built for busy teams. Smart call routing sends calls to the right person. Shared numbers let your team cover for each other. And an AI agent picks up when nobody can, capturing every lead so nothing falls through

17:16the cracks. Money is on the line. Always say hello with Quo. Try Quo for free. Plus, get 20% off your first six months when you go to Quo.com slash tech. That's Q-U-O dot com slash tech. 500 orders a month was manageable. 5,000 is madness. Embrace intelligent order fulfillment with ShipStation, the only platform combining order management, warehouse workflows, inventory, returns, and analytics in one place. What used to take five separate tools, ShipStation does in one. Automate fulfillment and rate shopping to ship up to 15 times more with up to 90% savings. Go to ShipStation.com and use code AUDIO to try ShipStation free for 60 days. Josh, you've been thinking about the issues that our welfare state is currently dealing with with regards to how to get many of our young people who are not in work or training

18:24or education or the rest actually into those things and Alan Milburn as you said is the man put up by actually not even this prime minister the previous prime minister to look into this what exactly is he proposing and how radical do you think it is I think it's quite radical I think that Milburn will see a lot of his stuff implemented because it's a ready-made policy agenda for a government that has a lot of long-term plans but not necessarily anything oven-baked and ready to go and as he told me Milburn really does see this as a moral crusade. Look I tell you the most energising thing the most energising thing is spending time with young people and it really pisses me off I mean genuinely when I hear this frankly bullshit about oh they're sort of lethargic, they don't

19:05care, the snowflake generation and then you go and meet them you know, the young lad there is full of beans and I think for this generation of young people they feel like they are putting in effort and the contract's broken. And it's worth noting that the Prime Minister Andy Burnham is very exercised by this issue too, he sat on a NEETs commission a couple of years ago when he was Mayor of Manchester. So he really cares about this too. So I do think we're going to see a lot of movement. There will be money he'll have to be made available. So the big thing that Milburn wants to do is really overhaul the system. So basically abolish the existing health and disability benefits and come up with a new system.

19:46For young people. For young people specifically. So basically, everyone's going to have this youth allowance. So it sort of simplifies the system. You won't have universal credit on the one hand, personal independence payments on the other. You just get a youth allowance. And Milburn's view is that there are people who really aren't going to be able to work easily for most of their lives, whether it's whatever disability they have, whatever issues they face. And those people need our support. And that's what we do as a caring society. But that is actually a relatively small proportion of the group that we call needs. Yeah. And for those people, he's suggesting you sort of they have a kind of additional cost allowance that is not means tested

20:25or linked to whether they're searching for work. I mean, it'd be nice if they found jobs, but you're sort of helping them either way. But everyone else would be on a youth allowance, which, you know, is means tested and is linked to them searching for work and does have what you might call a stick attached along with the carrot. So the idea is you almost create a funnel for the majority of people that leads them towards a job and towards employment. And then for everyone else, you have much more of a, I guess, a net, a safety net for them. And the overarching thing, which he's talked about quite a lot, is there should be a lot more effort put into helping people finding work as opposed to just

20:59paying them while they're... Yeah, so the stat he loves to quote is that for every £25 we invest in welfare support, just £1 is invested in providing employment opportunities. I mean, that ratio, you don't have to be, I've spent a year researching this to realise that is not a good ratio. He wants to basically flip that on its head and put loads more money into employment that's creating apprenticeship roles. That's going to be a big part of it. It's partnerships with business, perhaps even paying people to work and do work experience and that sort of thing. And he's looking very closely at the model they have in the Netherlands, which has been the sort of gold standard for this, in that they had a very similar niche rate to us a decade or 15 years ago

21:42and have really brought it down hugely. So he spent a lot of time over there 15 years ago holland was in a very similar position to us yeah and they did basically they did two or three things one they decided it was a crisis it's emergency if you're going to lose a generation of young people two they elevated the primacy of work yeah work comes first work beats welfare. And in terms of the thing you just mentioned there, the shifting young people onto a youth allowance as opposed to the sort of main universal credit system where they are at the moment, the controversial thing about that as pre-trail, the head of his report actually being released, is that this would apply to everybody. This wouldn't be for new claimants

22:24as some of the changes to the benefit system are usually introduced as, to basically stop people having their money cut where previously they had maybe more. Yeah, and this is where you might start to see some resistance from Labour MPs. It is always hard to change someone's circumstances. I think the argument he is making, which will resonate with a lot of people, is A, we need to start getting the bill down. And although this overall package won't do that anytime soon, long term, the hope is that it will. But also, I think almost more importantly, from his perspective, at least, is this isn't a good deal for the people themselves. You know, and you keep coming back to this, like, obviously,

23:08if someone is dependent on welfare to, you know, feed their kids and all that sort of thing, you know, you don't want to be ripping stuff away from people. But in the long term, it isn't helpful to have a lot of people who are able to work, would benefit from working and may want to work, sort of trapped in a system where they're on they're on dependency so you need in order to get them off you sort of do need to kind of restructure the system and that does require some changes and that and that will probably create some political turbulence as there was as you've already mentioned political turbulence when rachel reese and kirsten alma tried to um reform welfare do you think that has changed we've already seen

23:42some noises off on the airways from the Labour benches pre-criticising this. It's a really good question. I was talking to a lot of people about this over the last few days in Westminster. A few things are different. First of all, the people that organised that rebellion are now almost all anti-Burnham's key lieutenants in government. So people like Louise Haig and Annelies Midgley. So they're not going to be at it again. Second of all, that rebellion really broke Starmer and Reeves's agenda in Parliament. It broke their kind of authority. The Labour Party doesn't want to do that to their Prime Minister again. They've had that coup. You know, they defenestrated their PM. They know they can't do it again. They know

24:19they're fighting the next election with Andy Burnham at the helm. So there is a kind of ceiling on their revolutionary ambitions, if you like. And also, you talk to people in Parliament, they're much happier now. And I feel like Andy Burnham gets them and he talks to them and he speaks their language, represents their values. But also there is, if all of this sort of pre-briefing is to be believed, there's going to be more money that's needed to be put into this system before there is any kind of future savings. So, I mean, that sort of also makes it even more difficult, doesn't it? That is something that Milburn has been explicit about, and John Healy and Andy Brander have now acknowledged too, which is, yeah, it's going

24:54to cost up front. I do sort of buy the idea that if you actually are going to change the system without ruining lots of people's lives, a bit of money up front for long-term benefit, I do sort of buy that. I've seen the figure six billion floated around. But then you also look at the welfare bill just not being sustainable in the short term. Yes, exactly. Both fiscally and politically. And if they're going to go and fight the next election since, I don't know, May 2028, whenever, I do think they're going to have to show that they are willing to make cuts. And if the cuts aren't going to come from the Milburn project, then you look at the Stephen Timms personal independence payments report, which is also coming out soon.

25:31And that actually is where they might have to be a bit tougher if they want to show that they can make cuts and that they are serious about the country's fiscal prospects. As we've, I think, made clear, this is an enormous problem that needs dealing with. And obviously, an enormous part of that is reforms that might need to be done to the welfare system and how these people are supported. Do you worry, though, that actually the issue might be a bit more broad? It does obviously go to the jobs market, as you explained there, but also does it go to education? I mean, is this a societal issue that needs to be reckoned with as opposed to just have we reformed universal credit as best as we might?

26:13Yeah, it is. Milburn likes to use this phrase, we need a whole system reset. So he wants to talk to the Department for Education about how can you integrate work experience into schooling much earlier. Talk about the Department for Health. Could we have someone from the NHS, you know, integrated into some of these youth hubs so that you're not separating the medical diagnosis from the kind of job hunt? But, you know, government has its limitations, we know, both financially and in terms of capacity. You know, part of it is this kind of slightly hollowed out economic model in places like birkenhead um and great yarmouth and there is a frankly a limit to how much you can do about that in the short term but beyond that i do think that this is a challenge you know a lot of

26:56my friends have young kids and you know parenting's got really hard around a lot of these issues talking about neurodivergence screen addiction isolation you know all these things that came up with a lot of the young people i was talkingdivergence, screen addiction, isolation, you know, all these things that came up with a lot of the young people I was talking about. There are no easy fixes to that. Milburn, for example, is very supportive of smartphone bans in schools, social media bans for under-16s. These are all kind of live issues in our politics. I do think it all does sort of fit together, but there's no one lever you can pull, right? I hope that's coming across. It is a lot of different factors

27:25are contributing to this thing i do think if you fix the benefit system and get employers really thinking about this as well and engage with it that gets you probably quite a lot of the way there i think some of the deeper problems are more intractable but the point that really came home to me is that also we don't want it you know we don't want this for our young kids I spoke to this lovely young guy called Leyland he was about 18 19 and I found it really moving because he you know I remember being 18 19 I didn't really know what I wanted to do with myself so you know that is a common problem in life but he was just sort of saying well you know hopefully I find someone who loves me and something to do and I just really want you know want to find something

28:04that will pay me and just so I can sort of get out there and work. Leyland, what about you? When you think about the future, do you feel hopeful, anxious? It's kind of, but I'm more anxious in a way because I've been thinking about my future, about my future personally. I'll do any job. I don't care about the money as long as I get paid. A job's a job. Work's work. You work, you get paid, you're fine. But one of those days, I don't know if I find someone who'll love me or I'd be alone somewhere living how I want to live. But then I don't know how I want to live. I think for most people it's just a very, what is already a difficult time of life and a challenging and confusing moment is just really, really hard to navigate when you can't

29:03sort of see the pathways forward. But I do think they want to navigate when you can't you can't sort of see the pathways forward but i do think they want to i think that if you keep that at the sort of core of your assessment of this whole thing then that that's quite encouraging right because kids don't want to work jobs can be found benefit systems can be changed we can adapt to this kind of issue of screens and social media and isolation and all that we've had this huge rise in neurodivergence but again we can adapt to that and so I don't think it's a hopeless catastrophe I think it's really good that Melbourne's done this big piece of work and that the government will get behind it I do think they're going to need to save some money

29:39on welfare in the short term but long term I do think that we are seeing a serious engagement with this issue. And I do think, you know, the Netherlands have broadly resolved their problem with it to a great degree. And I do think we can do the same. That was Josh Glancy, Associate Editor of the Sunday Times. The story at thetimes.com is our email address. Should you have a view, let us know. That is it from us today. Today's producers were Paige Reynolds and Robin Simon. The executive producer was Harry Stott. Sound design was by Dave Creasy. And theme composition was by Mal Assetto. I'm Luke Jones. See you soon. Hey, we're Nick and Jack, hosts of The Best One Yet. Behind every episode, there's research, email, spreadsheets,

30:46and our shared Google Doc, the headline hammer. With Google Workspace with Gemini, Google's AI is built right into the premium versions of tools we already use, like Gmail, Docs, and Sheets. No new tools or extra logins, just personalized AI for the way we work. That means less time on the work, around the work, and more time finding the stories worth talking about. Get AI tools for work. Upgrade to Google Workspace with Gemini at goo.gle slash workspace with Gemini. That's goo.gle slash workspace with Gemini. Cash now, more later from Opendoor gives you cash upfront for your home, plus all the profit later. That's no chaos now, no cash left behind later. Skip the showings now, pocket extra profit later.

31:27This is so simple now, this is so awesome later. Or sell fast now and pop the champagne later. Cash now, more later. Now available nationwide. Start your offer at opendoor.com slash ACAST. Profits calculated after fees and costs, eligibility and offer price may vary.

▸More episode summaries

The Story cover art
The StoryConvicted fraudster Elizabeth Holmes says she wasn’t lying: do her victims believe her? – The Saturday Story2026-11-14 · 30 min
The Story cover art
The StoryBrand and Walliams - are we finally believing women?2026-11-13 · 27 min
The Story cover art
The StoryCould Pete Hegseth be tried for war crimes?2026-11-12 · 30 min
The Story cover art
The StoryI'm Alice | The Trial of Russell Brand - The Sunday Story2026-11-15 · 52 min
Transcribe your links. Paste a YouTube, Google Drive or podcast link and WhipScribe gives you the transcript. Transcribe a link →
New The Story transcripts by email
One email per new episode, unsubscribe in every message. Not shared with the publisher.