podcasts / The Story / episode
The Story cover art
podcast
📅 2026-11-14 ⏱ 30 min episode · ~2 min read 📝 Transcript · 5,065 words

Convicted fraudster Elizabeth Holmes says she wasn’t lying: do her victims believe her? – The Saturday Story

The Story · · Transcript & summary by WhipScribe

It is a rare look at how a convicted fraudster presented herself on camera, weighed against the former employees who lived through the collapse.

Read the transcript Episode page ↗
In this episodeElizabeth HolmesTheranosNathan FielderLance OppenheimA24You Can See EverythingBilly EvansGeorge ShultzLarry EllisonJohn Carreyrou

▸Chapters

Tap a chapter to play it from that moment in the show's own player; the transcript opens there too.

Transcribe your links. Paste a YouTube, Google Drive or podcast link and WhipScribe gives you the transcript. Transcribe a link →

▸Notable quotes

“I don't think it came across as a documentary.” Roisin Kelly · at 30:44 — ▶ hear it from here

▸What this episode covers

Elizabeth Holmes built Theranos on a promise that one finger prick of blood could support hundreds of medical tests. Powerful backers, including former US Secretary of State George Shultz and Oracle co-founder Larry Ellison, helped make her a Silicon Valley star, with magazine covers and a Walgreens deal. The claims did not hold up. Investors lost millions, the company collapsed, and Holmes was convicted of fraud and sentenced to more than 11 years in prison.

The documentary You Can See Everything, made by Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim, follows Holmes through the 34 days before she reported to prison, with her partner and two young children at home. The Times and Sunday Times reporter Roisin Kelly, based in New York, describes a film that has drawn large crowds. Former employees responded very differently. Scientists mostly refused to talk, and some said the film reopened old trauma. Staff from branding and marketing were more willing to speak, and some described how exciting the job once felt.

Viewers and former staff remain split on what they saw. Some read the film as Holmes playing another character, while others see a publicity exercise or a sign of a planned comeback. Kelly does not think Holmes is naive about how the film would look, and she does not see a redemption story. She does think some of the tears may be real, and she suggests watching with a pinch of salt.

▸Convicted fraudster Elizabeth Holmes says she wasn’t lying: do her victims believe her? – The Saturday Story on The Story: the answers

What did Roisin Kelly say about You Can See Everything?

Roisin Kelly, the Times and Sunday Times US correspondent based in New York, said she does not think the film came across as a documentary and that calling it one is a slight misrepresentation. She suggested it is probably a publicity exercise, possibly setting up publicity for something else.

“I don't think it came across as a documentary.”Roisin Kelly · 30:44

What did Roisin Kelly say about Elizabeth Holmes?

Roisin Kelly said she does not personally believe Elizabeth Holmes is stupid and does not think Holmes would be unaware of how the film could come across. She said she cannot see the film as a redemption arc and advised viewers to take it with a pinch of salt, while still calling it worth seeing.

“I would definitely take it with a pinch of salt if you're watching it.”Roisin Kelly · 31:33

What did Patrick O'Neill say about Theranos?

Patrick O'Neill, chief creative officer at Theranos from 2014 until 2017, said working there was exciting and that many of his colleagues were jealous of the job. He said the staff felt they were part of a bigger picture that came from Elizabeth Holmes's focus on her mission.

“A lot of my colleagues, contemporaries, were so jealous too.”Patrick O'Neill · 10:39

What did Roisin Kelly conclude about Elizabeth Holmes's documentary You Can See Everything?

Roisin Kelly concluded that the film is probably a publicity effort rather than a documentary or a redemption story. She said Holmes is unlikely to be naive about how it would come across, though some of her tears may be real. She advised viewers to watch it with a pinch of salt.

Mentioned in this episode

Episode facts

Released
November 14, 2026
Length
30 minutes

▸Key takeaways

01Nathan Fielder's documentary You Can See Everything follows Elizabeth Holmes for the 34 days before she entered prison for fraud.
02Theranos claimed its Edison device could run hundreds of medical tests from one finger prick of blood, and the company was once valued at $9 billion.
03When Theranos collapsed, investors lost millions and more than 800 staff lost their jobs; Holmes was sentenced to more than 11 years in prison.
04Former Theranos staff told the Sunday Times the documentary re-traumatised them, while branding and marketing workers spoke more openly about the company.
05Times correspondent Roisin Kelly doubts the film is a true documentary or a redemption story, and calls it probably a publicity effort.

▸Questions this episode answers

Q1What did Roisin Kelly say about Elizabeth Holmes's documentary You Can See Everything?

Roisin Kelly, the Times and Sunday Times US correspondent in New York, said the film did not feel like a true documentary to her and was probably a publicity effort. She does not think Holmes is stupid or unaware of how the film would come across, and she does not see it as a redemption story. She did think some of the tears may be real. Her advice was to watch it with a pinch of salt, while agreeing it is worth seeing.

Q2How did former Theranos employees react to the Elizabeth Holmes documentary?

Roisin Kelly reported that former Theranos staff reacted very differently to the documentary. People who worked on the science side were hesitant to speak at all, and some said the film re-traumatised them. People from the creative, branding and marketing side were more open. Patrick O'Neill, chief creative officer from 2014 to 2017, said working at Theranos was exciting and that colleagues were jealous of the job.

Q3Why did Elizabeth Holmes let a film crew into her home before prison?

According to Roisin Kelly, the filmmakers say Elizabeth Holmes approached A24, the production company behind You Can See Everything. Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim then arranged a meeting with her. The general view is that Holmes made the first approach because she wanted to tell her own story, after several documentaries and podcasts, including The Dropout, had told it for her. Fielder was given around-the-clock access to her home in the 34 days before she went to jail.

Q4How did Theranos collapse and what happened to Elizabeth Holmes?

Scientists inside Theranos had raised concerns that the equipment did not work and that failures and forged results were being overlooked. Whistleblowers spoke to John Carreyrou, a Wall Street Journal reporter, who revealed the technology did not work. The company collapsed and more than 800 staff lost their jobs. In 2021 Holmes was tried for wire fraud and conspiracy to commit wire fraud, and she was sentenced to more than 11 years in prison, later reduced by one year. She is now held in Texas.

Q5What did former Theranos staff say about Elizabeth Holmes's motives?

Former staff described Elizabeth Holmes as obsessed with the company's mission, and said every decision was meant to make it happen. Some staff remembered her using scientific terms loosely, such as confusing the Fibonacci series with a logo based on the seed of life. Others said she often talked about The Alchemist, a book about wanting something badly enough for it to happen. Kelly says most people think Holmes either convinced herself the technology would work or believed she was destined for something great.

▸Transcript

Our own transcript of the public episode, with a timestamp about every 90 seconds. Tap a timestamp to play the episode from there in the show's own player; the link button on a paragraph copies a link that opens this page there.

0:00At PwC, we optimize the systems that put your data to work, so you can scale your AI from proof of concept to competitive edge, and accelerate your tech evolution so you can redefine what's possible. From blueprint to breakthrough, we take you further with tech, so you can outthink, outpace, and outperform. PwC. So you can. PwC refers to the PwC network and or one or more of its member firms each of which is a separate legal entity cash now more later from opendoor gives you cash up front for your home plus all the profit later that's no chaos now no cash left behind later skip the showings now pocket extra profit profit later. This is so simple now. This is so awesome later. Or sell fast now and pop the champagne later.

0:51Cash now, more later. Now available nationwide. Start your offer at opendoor.com slash ACAST. Profits calculated after fees and costs, eligibility and offer price may vary. From the Times and the Sunday Times, this is the story on Saturday. I'm Manveen Rana. Over the last few weeks, a new film has taken America by storm. Some are calling it the wildest thing they've ever seen. What did I just see? I am a full-throated evangelist for this movie. I am so won over by it. It is definitely my film of the year. I've seen it twice already. It made $15 million at the box office this weekend, the second highest opening for a documentary ever. It feels unignorable as a force that the Oscars are going to have to contend with.

1:46The film You Can See Everything opens in the UK this week. It follows the disgraced American entrepreneur and former Silicon Valley whiz kid Elizabeth Holmes in the 34 days before she began her prison sentence for fraud. I'm not that person. I can promise you that. I don't have anything to deceive you on. Of course I'm not deceiving you. Elizabeth Holmes rose to fame after founding a company that promised to diagnose hundreds of medical conditions from just one drop of blood. At its height, it was valued at $9 billion, but it turned out to be a lie. The technology didn't work and the company collapsed. Investors lost millions, hundreds lost their jobs, and Holmes was sentenced to 11 years in prison.

2:47Elizabeth Holmes, who famously dropped out of college to revolutionise blood testing once compared to Steve Jobs, now found guilty of four counts of criminal fraud. Elizabeth Holmes has always maintained her innocence, but for many of her employees, the fallout from the collapse of her company was traumatic. My life was deeply affected. I went through a period of extreme anger and anguish. It kind of took two years out of my career in a way. I don't actually show any of the work that we did. So what do the people whose lives were ruined by her company make of the fact that Elizabeth Holmes invited a film crew to document her day-to-day life and her reflections before going to prison? The Sunday Times decided to ask them.

3:39I was afraid to see it a little bit. The thing that kind of made me want to jump out of my seat was just, there's no way she didn't know she was lying. She's never acknowledged her wrongdoing. The story today, is the Elizabeth Holmes documentary, Just Another Lie? It came out in America last month, so people have been talking about it here for weeks. There's billboards everywhere, you know, Times Square, just kind of Elizabeth Holmes' eyes are looking down at you. Everyone in the office, in coffee shops, is asking, have you seen it? Have you seen it yet? Roisin Kelly is US correspondent for The Times and The Sunday Times, based in New York, where it seems the whole city can't stop talking about You Can See Everything.

4:41I went a few weeks ago on a Tuesday night. There was a screening every hour, but they were all full. I managed to get one seat that was left right at the front of the cinema. And then coming out of the cinema afterwards, going down the escalators, everyone was discussing it. So it's been a huge point of conversation here. And Roisin, it is doing surprisingly well at the cinemas, as you say. You know, it's like a Hollywood blockbuster release rather than a documentary film. All of this comes down to the story of Elizabeth Holmes. Just remind us, stepping back, who is she? Yeah, so Elizabeth Holmes became known as a Stanford University dropout and crafted this amazing Silicon Valley success story. Age 19 she founded a company called Theranos and she pitched

5:37this revolutionary blood testing device. It was called the Edison and it claimed that with a single finger prick so with a single drop of blood from a finger prick it could run this comprehensive medical testing that could find all kinds of different conditions or give you different diagnoses just with this one test. We'd like to see a world in which every person gets access to this type of basic testing and the types of tests that are done are ones that provide insight into the onset of disease in time to do something about it. At the time this was really revolutionary because it was really accessible. In 2013 Theranos even did a deal with Walgreens which is this this huge American pharmacy chain, to be able to roll out the blood testing device there.

6:30And it became this sensation in the tech world. You know, Elizabeth Holmes became this kind of star, really. You know, the media were chomping at the bit for her. A health care pioneer is being compared to visionaries like Bill Gates and Steve Jobs. Elizabeth, you're doing something that's so profound. Inspiring so many young women with your presence and your intelligence and your belief that young women can grow up and be just like you. Elizabeth Holmes is part of the new Time 100 list just out. She was on the cover of magazines. She became known for, she had a deep voice. We see a world in which no one has to go through the pain of traditional phlebotomy. She wore a black turtleneck in the style of Steve Jobs

7:19and red lipstick. And, you know, it was this kind of platinum blonde success story of this young woman who had dropped out of university but actually made it and, you know, was dominating the world of tech and Silicon Valley. We actually did an episode about her and about her company a few years back and we'll put a link to that in the description of this podcast. So do go back and have a listen a few years back. And we'll put a link to that in the description of this podcast. So do go back and have a listen if you want more. But, you know, she clearly had a huge vision for what this blood test would be able to do. It was rolling out to the military. It was rolling out across the country. And as a result, she was able to convince

8:01quite a lot of very powerful people to back her. I mean, just run us through some of the people who were investing in her or were on her board. She had major investors, major board members. These weren't stupid people who were throwing money at something. She had George Shultz. He was the former U.S. Secretary of State. He was one of her biggest backers. And also, famously, anyone who's followed this story will know that he sided with Holmes over his own grandson, Tyler Schultz, who is the famous Theranos whistleblower. I had a personal relationship with Elizabeth. She was close to my family and I felt like she was deceiving my family and the public. She had Henry Kissinger on board, another former US Secretary of State.

8:48And then in terms of investors, there was Tim Draper, billionaire venture capitalist, who wrote one of the first $1 million checks for Elizabeth Holmes. Larry Ellison, the co-founder of Oracle, gave her money, backed her. And it had this domino effect because you had these big names, these respectable, successful people who were not just giving her money for what she was doing, but they were telling everyone, you know, this amazing young woman, look at what she's creating. This is going to be incredible. You want your name on this. More and more people started to back Theranos and to buy into Elizabeth Holmes. I mean, she was able to create this phenomenal legend around herself. For the people who worked with her, who saw her day in, day out,

9:51and saw what was happening inside the company, what did they make of this? Because I know you've been speaking to some of them more recently. I mean, firstly, how easy was it to persuade them to talk? Were they desperate to talk about what they'd seen? Honestly, it was a mixed bag. And what I found was anyone who was involved in the actual science side of things was really hesitant to speak to me. And a lot of them wouldn't. Some people would speak off record, but a lot of people just were kind of traumatized by by what happened at Theranos and were actually kind of re-traumatized by this documentary coming out whereas the people who worked on the carpeted side as they called it so you know in publicity in creative direction in branding in marketing

10:39they were much more open to speaking because I think while they were burnt by what big takeaway from You Can See Everything, which is that she has these different sides. She's been accused of being manipulative. And I think that came across in speaking to people. So, for example, Patrick O'Neill, chief creative officer at Theranos from 2014 until 2017, you know, he kind of said how it was exciting to work there. A lot of my colleagues, contemporaries, were so jealous too. Like, you really got the best job in the industry. I hear this. And I was like, yeah, it was great. It was so full of promise. We were all bursting at the seams, you know? Yeah, yeah, yeah. They was so full of promise. We were all bursting at the seams, you know. Yeah, yeah, yeah.

11:45They thought they were doing something. They thought there was like a bigger picture that they were working towards. And that all came from Elizabeth Holmes. You know, people said that she was obsessed with the mission, as she called it. The mission was everything. The mission was what she talked about. The mission is what she believed in. And every decision was leading to making that mission come true. Roisin Sitsu, there's a real sense of mission. They all feel like they're working for a visionary, even if they're helping to create that image on the front cover of all the big magazines. Were there people who weren't entirely convinced or who could see that perhaps she wasn't all she was cracked up to be.

12:33Yeah, and to varying degrees. Brad Arrington, for example, was a lawyer in-house at Theranos for five years. He kind of spoke of a high-pressure environment. In a high-pressure environment, you know, it was an extremely stressful time. I couldn't sleep. And something he couldn't quite put his finger on at the time, but this feeling that things weren't quite above board. There were just things that made me really uneasy. And it just felt like, you know, the shoe was going to drop. Gage Cleck, for example, who was creative director until 2016, kind of describes how Elizabeth Holmes would use language that she'd heard probably in meetings with all of these big important men she was working with

13:19that were on her board, or maybe she'd picked it up by overhearing a scientist speaking to another scientist but maybe maybe she would mispronounce them or she might use them in slightly the wrong context i think that her understanding of science is actually really rudimentary like our logo or at least one of the logos was based on this seed of life kind of image. And that is not the same thing as the Fibonacci series, but she would get those two things confused and talk about them interchangeably all the time. And it kind of made me also think that she just was saying things and not really understanding them, which is obviously a big part of what she did. Something lots of people said, which I think is an important point,

14:05is that in hindsight, it's easy to kind of say, oh, how did you not realize that Elizabeth Holmes was a bit weird or a bit strange? But what a lot of people say is when you're working in Silicon Valley, you know, most tech founders are a bit kooky. Like, how did you ever work for someone that's so weird? Why didn't she know she was off? I'm like, I got to tell you, when you're working with her on a day-to-day basis and you're aligned on a mission, she isn't so weird. Hey, don't you think Elon's a little weird? These two jobs, a little bit weird. So at the time, they didn't really think anything of it. But then you have people who naturally you would perhaps expect to be more sceptical of her. So read Catherine, for example, this is a lawyer who represented some Theranos investors and successfully sued Holmes and Theranos in 2016 on behalf of the investors. He was sceptical from the beginning. But he, when he

15:06met her, he spoke of how she would do these kind of doe eyes as a way of trying to kind of throw someone off. She dropped some documents in front of me. So I bent over to help pick them up. And when I started to stand up, she looked at me straight on with those dull eyes. Just like you're the only person in the room. Oh, thank you. And I had to say, wait a second, she's a fraud. Even he, a lawyer, had to remind himself for a second not to buy into it. The whole company eventually fell apart. Just remind us how that happened. How did Elizabeth Holmes meet her downfall? In 2014, Forbes named Elizabeth Holmes the youngest self-made female billionaire ever. Everyone was talking about this company.

16:08But behind the scenes, things were starting to bubble over. A lot of the scientists had been raising concerns because they felt that the equipment didn't actually work and they had been encouraged to overlook certain failures in it. There were accusations of results being forged and so under the surface you had a lot of people getting frustrated and eventually that led to whistleblowers speaking to John Carreyrou. He was a journalist at the Wall Street Journal and he blew the lid on the fact that actually this technology didn't work at all and people had been investing millions of dollars for something that actually was essentially a lie. When all of that blows up, what happens to Elizabeth Holmes?

17:06She held on till the very end in terms of Theranos. You know, the company essentially completely collapsed. I think it was over 800 people. The entire workforce ended up losing their jobs. You know, Elizabeth Holmes maintained her innocence. But in 2021, there was a criminal trial where Elizabeth Holmes was accused of defrauding investors. She was accused of wire fraud and of conspiracy to commit wire fraud. And eventually, after this very public trial, she's sentenced to more than 11 years in prison. That has actually since been reduced by a year. And she's now in jail in Texas. During that time of the criminal proceedings she met a man called Billy Evans. His parents are very successful hotel entrepreneurs.

17:54He himself claims to be a tech founder. They entered into a relationship and had two children. Some people say that that was intentional because it delayed Holmes going to jail. Whether that's true or not, you know, we don't know. But that's kind of speculation. When the company collapsed, she obviously went through a very difficult legal process. During that time, she did meet and fall in love with somebody and have children. So there have been redeeming moments over the last few years for her. What about for her employees? What was that moment like for them when the company they'd all been dedicated to suddenly came crumbling down? It was awful. A lot of them are still very traumatized. I went through a period of extreme anger and anguish. I left Theranos.

18:45I resigned from Theranos without a job. And I didn't work again for a year and nine months. Part of it was that I couldn't get a job. Some people saw it coming and got out just before it happened. So Patrick and Gage, for example, their creative directors and chief creative officer, they'd kind of jumped ship already. In advertising, it's kind of like you're only as good as your last ad. And it kind of took two years out of my career in a way. You know, I don't actually show any of the work that we did. Others, you know, lost their job. And I think, again, for the people working on the lab side and the science side, it was a much bigger problem because their reputations were completely at risk there. They had worked for a company that had lied and defrauded people and pretended to

19:43have this revolutionary technology that actually didn't work. And also, I think when you work in that kind of area, when you are a scientist working towards changing healthcare forever, you're personally deeply hurt to have fallen for that or to have been a part of that. At the time, it was awful for people because I think even though a lot of them knew it was coming, they really worried about their part in this and not just their reputation, but also that, you know, they could be called up as witnesses or having to give evidence and explain their part in what had happened. Coming up, Elizabeth Holmes invites a film crew into her home, presumably to tell her side of the story. But does it work?

20:44That's in just a moment. At PwC, we optimize the systems that put your data to work so you can scale your AI from proof of concept to competitive edge and accelerate your tech evolution so you can redefine what's possible. From blueprint to breakthrough, we take you further with tech so you can outthink, outpace, and outperform. PwC, so you can. PWC refers to the PWC network and or one or more of its member firms, each of which is a separate legal entity. Mod.com is changing the way people battle excessive fatigue. Ever hit a wall in the middle of the day and a third coffee just doesn't do it anymore? Here's what's actually happening. Coffee only briefly blocks adenosine, the chemical that tires you out. When it stops working, your system is flooded and you crash.

21:53Modafinil is a prescription treatment that works in a completely different way. Modafinil works by stimulating multiple receptors in the brain associated with wakefulness, including dopamine, serotonin, norepinephrine, histamine, glutamate, and orexin. It's a more complete solution that gives you 10 to 12 hours of steady focus and energy. To learn more, go to mod.com. Fill out your intake form, meet with a licensed provider, and if approved, ModAlert ships straight to your door. Go to mod.com to get started. That's M-O-D dot com. Harvard Business School Executive Education delivers a world-class learning experience that energizes aspiring and established changemakers. Prepare for the next elevation

22:41for your organization and for yourself. Learn more at hbs.me slash breakthrough. That's hbs.me slash breakthrough. Roisin, you've been describing how the collapse of Theranos affected many of its employees, a really traumatic time. There was a legal process. Elizabeth Holmes was found guilty. She is now behind bars. How does this documentary about her come about? So it's actually, it's slightly unclear, but the filmmakers say that she had approached A24, the production company who have made You Can See Everything. And Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim the directors kind of caught wind of this and wanted to get in on it and so they then managed to schedule a meeting with her but the consensus seems to be that it was her who

24:00approached A24 and I think the line kind of from her side of things is that she's never, you know, everyone else has told her story. She wanted to tell her own story. There had been a lot of documentaries and podcast series in the meantime about the collapse of Theranos. Yeah, there had. I mean, most famously, The Dropout with Amanda Seyfried, which was based on a podcast. And that was, you know, a very before Elizabeth Holmes goes to jail and show the real her. And it is a completely different image than we've seen before. You know, there's no black turtleneck. There's no red lipstick. This is a kind of cashmere jumper, jeans wearing mum doting on a toddler and a baby constantly crying in the film,

25:04which some people are buying into, but a lot of people aren't. You mentioned the makers of this film, Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim. They're not so well known in the UK, certainly haven't been up until now. Just tell us a bit about them and their reputation. Nathan Fielder is a Canadian filmmaker and a comedian. His whole thing is completely deadpan humour. He's quite known over here in America for Nathan For You, which is this kind of docu-reality comedy series. And then you've got Lance Oppenheim. He makes documentaries, but he also makes feature films. So recently, you might have seen everyone talking about Primetime with Robert Pattinson, which is based on real events and a real TV show that used to be on here in America. He worked on The Whale, again, kind of award winning film. People have found it quite crazy that Nathan Fielder got access to Elizabeth Holmes just because the work he's known for is satire. You know, it's not like Louis Theroux going in there kind of thing.

26:05So that was kind of an element of surprise that people over here in America seem to have had around this film. And without giving away any big spoilers, just tell us what this film covers. What is it about? You Can See Everything is the 34 days before Elizabeth Holmes goes to jail and Nathan Fielder's given 24-7 access to her at home with her partner and her two very young children. There's lots of kind of unfiltered looks at her life from making scrambled eggs to being on the phone, being prepared for what to expect in jail. Fielder does attempt to ask her about what happened at Theranos and whether she regrets it. But I would say if anyone's expecting a kind of sobbing confession or apology, that is not what happens.

26:57Wow. I mean, it's been a huge commercial success in the US so far. It seems to be doing, you know, filling cinemas. It's doing really well. What did the people you'd spoken to, the people who'd worked for her, what did they say about it? I think there's been different perceptions of it, which again is why it's interesting. Everyone has a different view. Everyone's taken different things from it. You know, Patrick O'Neill, who worked at Theranos, who I spoke to, he'd seen it on opening night and then he was going to see it for a second time with someone else because he wanted to kind of watch it again to take more from it. We were, you know, befuddled, but also part of me was excited that the world was

27:37experiencing Elizabeth in that way that I did, and understanding her ability to persuade and her ability to kind of connect as odd as it is. They thought that this was Elizabeth Holmes creating another character. So the Elizabeth Holmes at Theranos was very much a character, they think, and this is now another character. The person that's in that movie is not at all the person that i knew yeah it is a new it's a new character some other people think it's a bit distasteful because there were people you know deeply traumatized and affected by what happened i thought they were just gonna or she was just gonna go quietly to prison and then wouldn't hear anything about her for a long time. But she chose otherwise. I think that's telling.

28:33Or just investors who are annoyed because they put loads of money into it and, you know, and didn't get anything back out. And now that they've gone back and watched this documentary, they've sort of been reconfronted by this character who, you know, at first can be quite mesmerizing, who they'd sort of thought was a visionary. Were they able to look at her independently? Were they able to assess whether they think she was dishonest or whether she genuinely believed her own hype. She genuinely believed she would somehow come up with a piece of technology that she didn't quite have, but it was on the way. Honestly, most people think that she either convinced that she can make that technology work

29:19or convinced that she is destined to do something great, that that's her motivation. So even read Catherine, the lawyer who represented investors and sued Holmes and Theranos, he doesn't believe that she intentionally went out to defraud people. She truly believed, as a lot of fraudsters do, that at some point you're going to get there. If only I have enough time, if only I have enough money, you know, I'll just lie a little until we get there. If only I have enough time, if only I have enough money, you know, I'll just lie a little until we get there. I mean, she really, really pushed people to make this thing work. And if it didn't work, you know, go to plan B, go to plan C. To put it the best kind of way, Gage Clegg,

29:57the former Theranos creative director, said how her favorite book is The Alchemist. And she used to talk about that book all the time. And basically that the entire book is about how if you just want something bad enough it will happen and I think that kind of has has been you know the the through line of her entire life where it's like she just wants this bad enough so it'll happen. It may be medically impossible and scientifically impossible but she has convinced herself that that she can do it. I think when people watch the film, that will come across to them too, because without getting riled up or emotional or aggravated by Nathan Fielder, she so calmly just keeps reasserting that the technology was going to work. It could work.

30:44Roisin, what about you? I mean, you've seen this documentary. What did you make of her? What did you make of the documentary? I don't think it came across as a documentary. I think when it's being called that, it's a slight misrepresentation. I think that this film is probably a publicity thing. I personally don't believe that Elizabeth Holmes is stupid and I don't think that she would be completely unaware of how this film could come across. I mean, I don't think it's a redemption arc story. If it is, I think it's seriously failed. That said, there are points that anyone can perhaps not feel sorry for her but simple like I I don't think I don't believe that she's fake crying the entire time about

31:33leaving a baby while she goes to jail for 11 years you know I'm sure some of those tears are real but personally I can't quite especially if she sought this out I can't quite, especially if she sought this out, I can't quite get my head around why you would do that if you were sorry and you wanted to kind of disappear into the shadows. I think this is perhaps setting up to get some publicity for something else. This is why it's such an interesting film, is because there's so much debate even around the type of film that it is, and it's very, very unique. I would definitely take it with a pinch of salt if you're watching it. I think people will have strong opinions, but I think it's 100% worth seeing,

32:20not only if you followed the whole Theranos story, but just if you're interested in film, I think it's worth seeing. And I'd be very interested to see what Elizabeth Holmes and Billy Evans are going to go. Sound designer today was Michaela Arneson. The executive producer was Edward Drummond. And theme composition was by Mal Aseto. Have you seen the film or are you planning to? Do send us your views to thestoryatthetimes.com. Thanks for listening. We'll be back tomorrow. Thank you. so you can scale your AI from proof of concept to competitive edge and accelerate your tech evolution so you can redefine what's possible.

33:52From blueprint to breakthrough, we take you further with tech so you can outthink, outpace, and outperform. PwC, so you can. PwC refers to the PwC network and or one or more of its member firms, each of which is a separate legal entity. Do you think today's world needs more bold ideas? So do we. The University of Chicago Booth School of Business can help you unlock your potential. With world-class campuses in Chicago, London, and Hong Kong, Chicago Booth is where bold ideas come to life. If you're ready to expand your thinking and push your ideas further, then it's time to go Booth. Visit chicagobooth.edu to learn more.

▸More episode summaries

The Story cover art
The StoryBrand and Walliams - are we finally believing women?2026-11-13 · 27 min
The Story cover art
The StoryCould Pete Hegseth be tried for war crimes?2026-11-12 · 30 min
The Story cover art
The StoryI'm Alice | The Trial of Russell Brand - The Sunday Story2026-11-15 · 52 min
The Story cover art
The Story‘I’ve applied for 172 jobs, most of them ghosted me’: can Britain fix its NEET crisis?2026-11-16 · 27 min
Transcribe your links. Paste a YouTube, Google Drive or podcast link and WhipScribe gives you the transcript. Transcribe a link →
New The Story transcripts by email
One email per new episode, unsubscribe in every message. Not shared with the publisher.