podcasts / The Political Scene | The New Yorker / episode
The Political Scene | The New Yorker cover art
podcast
📅 2026-11-14 ⏱ 41 min episode · ~2 min read 📝 Transcript · 7,147 words 🎙 Jonathan Blitzer

Jonathan Blitzer: The Political Scene transcript and summary

The Political Scene | The New Yorker · · Transcript & summary by WhipScribe

A New Yorker panel with reporter Jonathan Blitzer explains why loyalty-first fighters like Stephen Miller and Jim Jordan now steer Republicans after a midterm rout.

Read the transcript
In this episodeStephen MillerJim JordanDonald TrumpSusie WilesKevin McCarthySteve BannonChristian NielsenHouse Freedom CaucusJonathan BlitzerRaphael Warnock

▸Chapters

Tap a chapter to play it from that moment in the show's own player; the transcript opens there too.

Transcribe your links. Paste a YouTube, Google Drive or podcast link and WhipScribe gives you the transcript. Transcribe a link →

▸Notable quotes

“two bodyguards that Trump has picked, one to represent the Republicans in the House and the other, his chief of staff in the White House.” Jane Mayer · at 4:32 — ▶ hear it from here
“MAGA was always a kind of supernova that burned bright, but was likely to expire with Trump's presidency.” Susan Glasser · at 39:08 — ▶ hear it from here

▸What this episode covers

After a heavy midterm defeat for the governing party, Donald Trump answered by removing White House chief of staff Susie Wiles and promoting Stephen Miller, a combative loyalist. New Yorker staff writer Jonathan Blitzer, who has profiled Miller, traces his climb from a fringe figure ridiculed inside his own party to one of the most powerful aides in government. Blitzer credits a patient strategy: Miller stayed close to the president, presented himself as the person who understood Trump's wishes, and spent Trump's first term learning how to maneuver the federal bureaucracy. When his policies backfired, he often let someone else take the blame.

In the House, Republicans picked Jim Jordan as minority leader, and Jane Mayer describes the pair as bodyguards Trump installed, one for Congress and one for the White House. Blitzer traces how the Freedom Caucus moved from threatening to shut down government to the party's mainstream. A 2018 defeat in the leadership race led Kevin McCarthy to give Jordan the Oversight gavel, which gave him real influence. Blitzer notes that no bill Jordan proposed in nearly 20 years in Congress has become law. Trump awarded him the Presidential Medal of Freedom less than a week after January 6th, for his push to delay certification of the 2020 election.

The panel's verdict is that both men thrive in opposition and suit a party built around fighting Democrats, yet may be poorly equipped to govern. Susan Glasser argues that MAGA was a supernova likely to fade with Trump's presidency, and expects the final two years to be volatile. Blitzer worries that immigration and foreign policy, where a president has wide latitude, will become harsher even though voters already rejected those policies. The hosts doubt that this playbook can handle the everyday work of lowering costs and making government feel responsive.

▸Jonathan Blitzer on The Political Scene: the answers

Who is Jonathan Blitzer?

Jonathan Blitzer

Jonathan Blitzer is a New Yorker staff writer who has profiled both Stephen Miller and Jim Jordan. He joins the hosts in the middle of the episode to explain the two men's new roles.

What did Jonathan Blitzer say about Stephen Miller?

Jonathan Blitzer says Stephen Miller's career is the story of a white nationalist ideologue whose fringe views were once mocked, but who has now systematically taken over much of the federal government. He says Miller's rise to White House chief of staff was the culmination of a trajectory that was visible to anyone following closely.

“The Stephen Miller story is the story of a white nationalist ideologue with a thoroughly unadulterated vision”Jonathan Blitzer · 5:18

What did Jonathan Blitzer say about Freedom Caucus?

Jonathan Blitzer says members of the House Freedom Caucus were written off by Republican House leadership, who called them lemmings with suicide vests and legislative terrorists. He argues their real aim was to maximize their political relevance, even when that meant shutting down the government or ousting their own leaders.

“members of the House Freedom Caucus were written off by Republican House leadership”Jonathan Blitzer · 20:36

What did Susan Glasser say about MAGA?

Susan Glasser says MAGA was always a kind of supernova that burned bright but was likely to fade once Trump's presidency ended. She argues that neither Stephen Miller nor Jim Jordan represents the future of the Republican Party, and that the next two years will be a volatile final stretch.

“MAGA was always a kind of supernova that burned bright, but was likely to expire with Trump's presidency.”Susan Glasser · 39:08

What did Jane Mayer say about Jim Jordan?

Jane Mayer describes Jim Jordan and Stephen Miller as two bodyguards Donald Trump has picked, Jordan to represent House Republicans and Miller as White House chief of staff. She says both men are known for fighting and for being willing to use brass knuckles.

“two bodyguards that Trump has picked”Jane Mayer · 4:32

What was decided about Stephen Miller and Jim Jordan on The Political Scene?

Trump removed White House chief of staff Susie Wiles and promoted Stephen Miller to the job after the midterm defeat. House Republicans picked Jim Jordan as their new minority leader, and the panel argues both men signal a doubling down on ideology.

Mentioned in this episode

Episode facts

Released
November 14, 2026
Length
41 minutes

▸Key takeaways

01Trump replaced White House chief of staff Susie Wiles with Stephen Miller two days after last week's midterm defeat, a sharp move toward combative politics.
02Stephen Miller rose from a party pariah to the most powerful White House job by staying close to Trump and claiming to speak for him.
03According to Jonathan Blitzer, no bill Jim Jordan has proposed in nearly 20 years in Congress has become law, and Jordan treats that record as a badge of honor.
04Trump gave Jim Jordan the Presidential Medal of Freedom less than a week after January 6th, for his push to delay certification of the 2020 election.
05Susan Glasser says the MAGA era will be a detour, and the next two years will be a volatile final stretch of Trump's movement.

▸Questions this episode answers

Q1What did Jonathan Blitzer say about Stephen Miller's rise to chief of staff?

Jonathan Blitzer, a New Yorker staff writer who profiled Stephen Miller, says Miller went from the political margins to one of the most powerful jobs in the government. Blitzer credits a savvy strategy: Miller stayed close to Donald Trump, implied he understood Trump's wishes, and used Trump's first term to learn how to work the federal bureaucracy.

Q2Why did Trump pick Stephen Miller to replace Susie Wiles as chief of staff?

Susan Glasser said Trump's response to the midterm defeat was to punch back harder, so two days after the vote he removed White House chief of staff Susie Wiles and promoted Stephen Miller. The hosts describe Miller as the most combative and divisive version of Trump's politics, and the only adviser left from 2015.

Q3What did Jim Jordan achieve in Congress according to Jonathan Blitzer?

Jonathan Blitzer says Jim Jordan has been in Congress for nearly 20 years and is often ranked among the least effective legislators, with no bill he proposed becoming law. Jordan has said he did not come to Congress to pass laws, and Blitzer says he treats that record as a badge of honor and builds his political success on fighting other people.

Q4How did Jim Jordan rise from Freedom Caucus founder to House Republican leader?

Jonathan Blitzer says Jim Jordan founded the House Freedom Caucus, a group Republican leadership wrote off, and moved into the party's center by attacking conservatives he considered inauthentic. A 2018 loss to Kevin McCarthy for minority leader led McCarthy to give Jordan the ranking seat on House Oversight, which gave Jordan influence he had not had before.

Q5Why did Trump give Jim Jordan the Presidential Medal of Freedom?

The hosts say Trump gave Jim Jordan the Presidential Medal of Freedom less than a week after January 6th, because Jordan whipped votes on the House floor hours after the insurrection to delay and block certification of the 2020 election. Trump called Jordan a warrior for him, and the hosts say the award shows how close their relationship is.

Q6What did Susan Glasser say about the future of MAGA?

Susan Glasser argues that MAGA was always a kind of supernova that would burn out with Trump's presidency. She says neither Stephen Miller nor Jim Jordan represents the future of the Republican Party, and that the movement is an incredible detour into a cult of personality, with a volatile final two years ahead.

Q7What does Jane Mayer say about Stephen Miller and Jim Jordan as Trump's bodyguards?

Jane Mayer says Trump has picked two bodyguards: Jim Jordan to represent House Republicans and Stephen Miller as his White House chief of staff. She says both men are known for fighting and using brass knuckles, and that they are alike in wanting to win any way they can.

▸Transcript

Our own transcript of the public episode, with a timestamp about every 90 seconds. Tap a timestamp to play the episode from there in the show's own player; the link button on a paragraph copies a link that opens this page there.

0:00Hello, political scene listeners. Before we start, a reminder that we're doing a live show in Washington, D.C. next week. It'll be Wednesday, November 18th at 6th and I at 7 p.m. And we'll be joined by a very special guest, Senator Reverend Raphael Warnock of Georgia. So join us in person or stream online. Tickets are at sixthandI.org. And the ticket link is also in our show notes. Hope to see you there. And now on to the show. You know, let's just be honest. How can you be the CEO of the most valuable AI company in the world and have that much time for extracurricular activities. I can't get all my work done. I think ruthless time management. I have a homebrew theory, which is that he actually began

0:57to probably valorize his subterfuge in the same way that he would celebrate his business success, that like pulling that off, you know. By the way, you just used the word valorize very successfully in a sentence. Really good. And subterfuge too. I do think it was probably the first time valorize was used to describe anything involving Jensen Huang's illicit, terrible behavior. But. illicit, terrible behavior. Welcome to the political scene from The New Yorker, a weekly conversation about the big questions in American politics. I'm Evan Osnos, and I'm joined as ever by my colleagues, Jane Mayer and Susan Glasser. Hi, Jane. And hi, Susan. Hey, Evan. Hey, there. So great to be with you guys. Well, last week, as we all know, voters delivered one of the worst midterm defeats of a governing party in modern American history.

2:00And now we are getting a very clear sense of how the Republican Party plans to respond to that. So what do all these changes tell us about the Republicans' agenda for the next two years? Where does the party go from here? Susan, let's start with Trump at the very top here and how he and the White House have responded to this midterm thumping. Well, message not received, I think you could say. You know, Trump's response is what Trump's response is always. When you're punched, you punch back harder. And I think it's a personal life motto for him. It's certainly a political motto. And there you had two days after the midterm thumping, getting rid of Susie Wiles, his White House chief of staff, and promoting Stephen Miller.

2:45And, you know, look, we're 10 years into this. Just the name Stephen Miller is kind of shorthand for the most combative, divisive, extreme version of Donald Trump. You know, he's not just Donald Trump's prime minister, as he's been called. He's Donald Trump's id. You know, he's famous, I would suggest, for a couple things. One is you can run down a list of the most divisive extreme policies of Trump's two terms. And Stephen Miller's name is written all over them, mass deportations and family separation. And then the second thing is extremism in defense of Trump and extremism in service to Trump as his most loyal advisor. He's the only survivor left from 2015 and the early days of Donald Trump. He's over the top, slavish,

3:36cartoonish, number one suck up of the Trump era. Yeah, he's pure, unadulterated Trump. So that's what we're going to have over at one end of Pennsylvania Avenue, replacing Susie Wiles, very different culture and tone. So, Jane, then what's now happening on the Hill? How are Republicans there doubling down on Trump? All right. Well, the House Republicans have picked Jim Jordan as their new minority leader. And everything Susan said about Stephen Miller, extreme, combative, known for loyalty, id, way outside the mainstream. He's most famous for having been a wrestler in college who has taken wrestling to the political arena. He said that they're completely alike. All he wants to do is win any way he can. And he's picked for his loyalty. I mean, in a way, I think what you've

4:32got right now is two bodyguards that Trump has picked, one to represent the Republicans in the House and the other, his chief of staff in the White House. And both these guys are known for fighting and using brass knuckles. Well, we're joined this week, fortunately, by our colleague, New Yorker staff writer Jonathan Blitzer, who over the years has profiled both Stephen Miller and Jim Jordan. We'll have to find out what he did to get those assignments. John, welcome to the show. Thank you. This is the most dubious distinction I've ever received. Thank you. We're going to go in order here. We want to talk first about Stephen Miller and his new role as chief of staff in the White House. You've spent a lot of time plumbing the depths,

5:18shall we say, of Stephen Miller's motives, his ideology. What did you come to believe is the important story about Stephen Miller, who is now stepping into this role as chief of staff? Yeah. The Stephen Miller story is the story of a white nationalist ideologue with a thoroughly unadulterated vision for what, you know, immigration policies should look like in America, how political combat should be waged in America, spent most of the first part of his career in the political wilderness, largely deride it as an unserious extremist who no one could stand. And in the span of almost literally a decade, went from the margins of his own party to perhaps the most powerful position in the side in presidential

6:06administration. And so his story is the story of how a truly fringe ideology that had made him a pariah for most of his career, including among members of his own party, has managed really, in some ways, single-handedly. I mean, with Trump's help as a kind of sort of public face, but he has really orchestrated this kind of systematic takeover of the federal government. And now some of the things that he thought that Republicans laughed at in 2015 or 2014 are now considered political orthodoxy, policy orthodoxy. And so in some ways, when the news broke that he was tapped to be the chief of staff, policy orthodoxy. And so in some ways, when the news broke that he was tapped to be the chief of staff, obviously I was shocked. It is a shocking bit of news in its own

6:50right. But in many ways, it felt inevitable because that's what this trajectory would have culminated in. And to anyone paying close attention, you could see him kind of on this ascent. And it's an ascent, I'll just say lastly, that, you know, there are political consequences. Like, I think it's widely understood that the midterm route that we just witnessed had a lot to do with Miller's vision and how unpopular that vision is nationally. And yet he's not someone who's going to calibrate his positions. That's not how he got where he is now. And so there's no reason to expect him to moderate now that he's there. So, Jonathan, I totally remember him when he was considered something of a joke on the margins of things and pestering reporters to get attention.

7:36And how do you explain his rise to this point? You know, I was just thinking last night in anticipation of coming on, you know, it's very hard to survive in Trump's orbit. I mean, that's to put it mildly. And here is someone who has been with him, kind of orient himself vis-a-vis Trump such that his unpopular opinions that would alienate most people have been kind of aligned with Trump's political rise. And so when he speaks, and this has been widely reported as well, even inside the administration now, when he speaks, it's generally assumed that what he is saying is what Trump wants. And he plays off of that, of his proximity to power. And so I think the explanation, really, for how he went from the fringes to the sort of apex of American political life is an extremely savvy and well-thought-out plan for how to elevate himself in this Trumpian moment. And he's also,

8:47he's extremely smart. I mean, it's easy, I myself was guilty of this as I kind of dug deeper into his record and some of his policy positions. It's very easy to write him off as ridiculous because of the things he says in public. But I think that bluster belies actually how smart he is and how systematically he's studied the levers of power. And so that would be the second. My second answer to your question is, you know, in the first Trump administration, you could really watch him learning as a tactician different ways of maneuvering the federal bureaucracy to achieve his aims. He had this one issue of immigration in the first Trump administration that was his be-all and end-all. And so he was able to just work relentlessly and systematically figuring out how to maneuver inside the bureaucracy to outlast people. were, I think, the kind of final stage of his training for the present moment,

9:45insofar as he spent those years in exile, so to say, preparing for what a second Trump term would look like, so that on day one, they could hit the ground running. And that's exactly what's happened. You know, it's interesting, Jonathan, that you identify that almost frantic need to stay inside the orbit of Donald Trump and to focus on him personally. You know, it reminds me of my one and only encounter with Stephen Miller in the first term. I received a phone call after reporting correctly that Donald Trump on his first visit to NATO had deleted at the last minute the one sentence that everybody wanted to hear from him, which is to say, yes, I remain committed to Article 5 mutual defense. And I don't even believe Miller

10:32was named in this story, but I received a phone call from him and he started shouting, it was off the record, I don't even remember the details of what he said anyway, so I didn't publish what he said. But I will tell you that the takeaway from this was the impression and the feeling that this was a man who was deeply panicked, almost hysterical at the idea that he knew what Donald Trump wanted and was going to give it to him. And I didn't know and my sources didn't, and nobody knew about Donald Trump except for him. And he was the guy in the room. And it was that, this just almost powerful feeling after, you know, decades in Washington. I've never had a conversation like that with anyone else. So it was really just amazing moment. And the reason I bring it up is

11:20I'm curious, like, you know, you say he's evolved over the 10 years. Like, that was a deeply immature and insecure person that I heard. And a lot of the sort of fight club atmospherics of the Trump presidency is a bunch of very insecure men, it seems to me, kind of shouting at us, right? How much will that figure into a role that, you know, this is the most important role in the presidency with an 80-year-old guy who's, you know, wandering off and talking about marble all the time? No, what you describe is fascinating because this is the dynamic, really, that anyone who's tried to understand Miller has encountered in some fashion, which is he walks this very fine line because, you know if you fly too close to the sun in the trump administration and you claim outright credit

12:09for something you become competitive with the president himself and he clips your wings and you know i remember the first trump administration the steve bannon story loomed large for miller i mean you know you put steve bannon's face on the cover of time magazine and that's you know your political death now exactly miller got that he understood that. And yet he had to trade on this idea that, you know, he wanted to maximize his power. And the only way he could do that without seeming to overshadow his principle was to claim this kind of, I mean, it's like, as you say, it's sort of an argument of proximity, but almost like a kind of psychic proximity that I'm so close to Trump. I alone know what he's thinking.

12:50Telepathically. Exactly. He's a telepathic president. Exactly. I agree. And it's fascinating because, you know, when I interviewed people during the first Trump administration, almost to a person, they would say that he was explicit about making that point. You know, that I spoke to the president. This is what the president wants. I'm speaking for the president, almost as though he were shoring up that credential in conversation. Now, as chief of staff, he's in a kind of different orbit altogether. But in the second term, he's had a lot more power than he did in the first term. And the idea that he speaks for Trump and that he represents Trump's way of thinking now no longer needs that constant explicit ballast that he did in the first Trump administration.

13:28It's kind of fascinating to see. So, Jonathan, I was just thinking, though, he's in a pretty odd position in some ways as speaking for Trump in that he was a defender of the Iran war. Trump's evidently reportedly planning to put him in this position to wind down the Iran war. He's known as the face of the hardcore anti-immigrant movement. And Trump's out there talking about how he feels sorry for certain immigrants who are hardworking and just nice people. And, you know, this is not the sound of Stephen Miller. Yet he's there to be the voice of Trump. How is he going to now operate if it requires flipping on a couple of the positions he's taken before? Yeah, it's a really good question. I have to say, I mean, the big, to my mind, one of the most interesting plots of Miller's political career is how he has managed to survive some of the most overwhelmingly unpopular policies that have had a real blowback for the president.

14:32I mean, the Iran war is the most recent example. Operation Metro Surge in Minnesota is another, you know, very, very striking example. And I'm thinking from the first term, the travel ban and family separation. Those, you know, these were Miller plans that blew up in the face of the administration. The president, uncharacteristically at the time, had to retreat. And Miller somehow sidesteps any blame for what happened. Now, some of that involved a very particular choreography where he kind of nudges someone else forward to take the blame. So, you know, at the press conference where someone from the administration had to explain what had happened with family separation, he's nowhere to be found.

15:08It's Christian Nielsen, the then Secretary of Homeland Security, who's caught holding the bag and becomes the literal face of family separation. And so a number of people I've spoken to over the years have kind of made this point that he's actually quite adept at finding his way out of some of the trouble he creates. And that doesn't mean that he's in any way become convinced that he's had to moderate his positions. It's just purely a kind of tactical matter of surviving to fight another day, which leads us to the overwhelming question of, okay, well, so now you have a president who ostensibly cares about being somewhat popular and a chief of staff who is so ideologically driven that, you know, it's almost certain that he's going to go in a direction far

15:50more extreme than any kind of middle-of-the-road American wants. And I think, I mean, in my point of view, what's allowed Miller to square that circle has been the degree to which he is a fighter for Trump. That is what Trump chiefly sees in him, so that I think he can kind of continue in the president's eyes to seem like he's fighting the good fight, even while he's pushing things that are incredibly extreme. He's also now, by the way, set up his kind of reins on power inside the federal bureaucracy such that he's got people carrying out some of his sort of ideological agenda items. So, you know, inside the Department of Homeland Security, inside the Department of Justice, he now has cadres of people who are executing his plan.

16:34And so he doesn't even need, I mean, the level of micromanaging during Trump 1 was astonishing. Even during parts of Trump 2 for Miller. I mean, policies that affect hundreds of thousands of people that are incredibly fine-grained. I mean, things that I had to sort of study up and talk to experts to understand, you know, recalibrating regulations that no one ever really paid much attention to that were buried in laws from decades before. Miller is fine-tuning these things. So I wonder partly, given the kind of docket of new responsibilities he'll have, if he can micromanage to the same degree, because that's been one of the reasons for his success, that he is so hard driving and so tireless that, you know, when most people rest on their laurels or kind of let go a little bit, he's always pushing ahead.

17:19But I think eventually he frames this as his fighting for Trump and that that's his political answer to your question. We're going to take a quick break. And when we come back, Stephen Miller isn't the only one with a new job in Washington this week. We're going to turn to Capitol Hill. More with Jonathan Blitzer after this. The political scene from The New Yorker will be right back. If you've been enjoying the show, please leave us a rating and a review on the podcast platform of your choice. And while you're there, don't forget to hit the follow button so you never miss an episode. Thank you so much for listening. From Vanity Fair, I'm Mark Aduchi, and I want to tell you about our new show, Fair Game.

18:05On every episode of Fair Game, I'll sit down with a leading character in our culture, from the worlds of Hollywood, politics, style, Silicon Valley, and beyond. Fair Game is a deep dive into some of the personalities that shape our world and the stories that you need to hear. Think everyone and everything that you'd read about in the pages of Vanity Fair. So join me, Mark Aduchie, on YouTube, VanityFair.com, and wherever you listen to podcasts. It's all fair game. One day last year, police entered a mansion in L.A. County and discovered the couple that lived there had almost two dozen children. Nearly every one of them born through surrogates. But those surrogates had been deceived. I started crying. I was like, what the heck did I just get myself into?

18:57I'm Ava Kaufman. The Journey is a new series from In the Dark and The New Yorker. Find it now in the In the Dark podcast feed. Hi, I'm Nicole Phelps, Global Fashion News and Features Director at Vogue and co-host of the Run Through podcast. Each week on the show, our listeners get an all-access pass into the world of Vogue. On Tuesdays, join me as I interview influential designers like Calvin Klein, Rachel Scott, and Simone Bellotti. On Thursdays, join Chloe Mao, head of editorial content at Vogue US, and Choma Nadi, British Vogue's head of editorial content, as they explore fashion through the lens of culture with guests like Doja Cat and Margot Robbie. Listen and watch The Run-Through with Vogue wherever you get your podcasts and Vogue's YouTube channel.

19:52All right. Well, you've helped us very well, I think, fill out the toolbox that Miller brings to this job. Let's turn now to the Hill, John, where House Republicans have put another of your profile subjects, Jim Jordan, one of the party's most hardline figures, into the role of minority leader. Having spent time talking to everybody about Jordan, filling out an understanding of him, what do you think Jordan brings to this job? This is a fascinating one. I mean, you guys know certainly more than I do about just the kind of incredible story of how the House Freedom Caucus went from being this insurrectionary force to the Republican establishment. But that essentially is how I see the story of Jim Jordan. And in kind of a strange

20:36way, there are certain parallels to the inevitability of Miller's rise in the sense that, you know, you go back a decade, I mean, almost literally a decade again. I mean, the parallels are very, very striking in this regard. And members of the House Freedom Caucus were written off by Republican House leadership. There are very colorful phrases. Lemmings with suicide vests was one description of these guys. Legislative terrorists was another. And these were scarcely exaggerations. I mean, these guys were willing to blow it all up, to shut down the government, to oust their own leaders, to kind of ostensibly to advance an ideological agenda of reducing the federal debt, for instance, and things like that.

21:17But I think more frankly, to maximize their political relevance. That was always the bottom line for them. And Jordan went from the founder of that group and someone who was at constant odds with Republican leadership and who was seen as a conspiracy theorist and a kind of ridiculous figure to someone who, year after year, through the kind of political combat that you might associate with Miller of being willing to go after, you know, very conservative figures inside the party and challenge them and challenge their kind of authenticity as conservative figures, managed to inch and elbow his way into the political center. And so one thing that came up a lot in my conversations when I was writing about Jordan

21:54back in 2023 was that an inflection point came in 2018 when Jordan challenged Kevin McCarthy for the role of minority leader in the House and lost, lost badly. And McCarthy, who was savvy and clever in his own right, invited Jordan into leadership as a kind of way of trying to shore up his own right flank. And so he had asked Jordan to be the ranking member on House Oversight, which for these guys was the kind of be-all, end-all type position at the time. And Jordan took the job. And what a number of people said to me was, that was a real turning point in his thinking, because prior to that moment, it was seen among House Freedom Caucus members as apostasy to make any deal with leadership. And here, he hadn't had to concede anything.

22:46Just by the sheer force of his opposition to McCarthy, he was able to convince McCarthy that it was just easier for McCarthy's own life to make Jordan a ranking member of the Oversight Committee than not to, and then to have to deal with Jordan lobbing grenades at him all the while. And so he started to taste what this kind of influence and power looked like. And during the Biden years, he obviously graduates into being the chairman of the Judiciary Committee with a huge budget, a staff of 60-plus people. He could prosecute all of his conspiracy theories from the highest perch inside the party. So in some ways, he's a natural fit for a Republican Party that's unmoored by their midterm losses, and that, like Miller,

23:31are basically seeing their only path into the political future as fighting with the Democrats. That moment is actually very instructive, isn't it? Because he's now being given even more power. But if past his prologue, he didn't moderate once he had the power. He used the power to be a demagogue, really. And so it seems like that would be maybe what to expect at this point. I mean, and, you know, one of the things that he's famous for, having been in Congress for nearly 20 years, is he falls to the bottom of many studies about effective legislators in Congress. He's often the least effective legislator, in fact. I think not a single bill that he's ever proposed has become law. And he has said sort of infamously, well, I didn't come to Congress to pass laws.

24:26What exactly did he come to Congress to do then? It's incredibly striking. I remember that fact while working on this profile that, OK, he's never actually successfully passed a bill or sponsored a bill that passed. And then you look to see, OK, is there an apology? Is there an explanation? Is there some self-consciousness about the fact that he doesn't have any actual legislative credential? And it's the opposite. It's a badge of honor for him. You know, I think he sees his own political success has been derived entirely from his fighting with other people. For years, it was the Democrats. But he actually realized that what really catapulted his brand was going after Republicans for being insufficiently conservative. And it's very befuddling because,

25:12you know, when I started to write about him, I had to look up all of these plots of sort of, you know, deep state conspiracies that I consider myself like fairly up on the news. And, you know, 90% of the things he's talking about, I had never even heard of. And then you go on to conservative media, and of know, 90% of the things he's talking about, I had never even heard of. And then you go on to conservative media, and of course, he's setting the tone there. His kind of witch hunts are the principal story there. So I think his world is such a restricted circle. It is, he is speaking only to a Republican base. I mean, he's, in a way, he's a perfect figure for while the Republicans are in the opposition

25:45because he's just going to be fighting. He doesn't actually have to advance anything. He doesn't have to make compromises. He doesn't have to think about the unity of the conference. This is the easiest time to be in Republican leadership because, you know, they're trying to claw their way back to power and everything is going to be against the Democrats here. And so he, in that sense, I think, embodies just that raging id of the party. Can I ask you about his relationship with Donald Trump? You know, in many respects, what was so striking about how the Freedom Caucus sort of ate the rest of the Republican conference in Trump's first term is by undercutting their own leadership and sort of doing the bidding

26:26of the president. What role did Jordan play in that turning over the Republican conference in the House to President Trump? Does he have a close personal relationship with him? I mean, I know he was adept at the kind of speaking to the audience of one on Fox, but what's the connection going to be like now that they're all sort of on their back heels and fighting Democrats? You know what's crazy, and I'd forgotten just in the kind of tumult of the last couple of years, after January 6th, less than a week after January 6th, Trump gave Jim Jordan the Presidential Medal of Freedom. Like, obviously, I experienced that vividly at the time. But like in the years since, it's all been so chaotic. I kind of forgot that fact.

27:14And that is an incredible symbol of their relationship because the reason Trump gave it to him was his efforts to fight certification of the 2020 election. And he was whipping votes right off of the floor of the House hours after the insurrection. And whipping votes to delay certification, to block certification. And so he, I think, as this conspiracy theorist, saw election theft as a kind of political cash cow for him. I think he believes it. I mean, that's the thing that I ultimately find kind of disturbing about this, is that this is not just purely a political calculation. I think he actually genuinely has some of these deep-seated beliefs about a deep state conspiracy and insurgency. But his relationship with Trump has always been, he was, you know, one of the early backers

28:08of Trump. And I think, you know, he and other members of the Freedom Caucus, you make a good point. So here they are so allergic to their own party's leadership in the chamber in which they serve. And yet they roll over for the figurehead of their party, the ultimate leader of their party in Trump. But I think there was a key overlap in the sense of aggrievement that Trump stoked. You know, when Trump says, I am your retribution on the 2024 campaign, there is a way in which members of the House Freedom Caucus can identify with that cause too. These are guys who felt neglected, who felt overlooked, who felt derided by members of their own party. And Trump saw them as, you know, loyal foot soldiers and so

28:51lavished attention on them. And so as far as I can tell, that relationship hasn't cooled at all. And I think it's probably we're going to see more of. I mean, I think you're going to see now this kind of dyad of, you know, Miller and Jordan as Trump's fighters. And I actually think, I can't remember, I actually wrote it down in anticipation of seeing you guys. When Trump gave Jordan the Presidential Medal of Freedom, he called him a, quote, warrior for me. There you go. Everything, right? Right there. Yeah. You know, I was just thinking in terms of his relationship with Trump, Trump's such a stickler for people looking like they're from central casting and they have to always be dressed the right way. I wonder how Trump feels about the Jordan look, which is the

29:37rolled up sleeves and, you know, Mr. Tough Guy. I don't know. It doesn't seem to bother him. There was a moment in the first Trump administration when it must have been one of the first times Jordan went to the Trump White House to give it to the president. Trump couldn't stay focused on the topic at hand and stopped and started peppering Jordan with questions about his wrestling career because he was this very distinguished college wrestler and said to Jordan something like, I mean, there's a verbatim quote circulating out there somewhere. I'm going to mess it up a little bit, but something like, tell us, you were the best wrestler in the country, right? And Jordan kind of diverts because it's just awkward. Here they

30:22are to talk about the budget. And Trump says, come on, come on, you know, don't be modest. Like, tell us. You are the best, right? You're the best. You're the fiercest. And so Trump has always latched onto that. So in a way, the kind of like, you know, the shirt sleeves, the fighter, the kind of, you know, the tie knot that's a little askew, I think that comports with Trump's idea of this wrestler who's kind of like going, quite literally going to the mat for him. John, you've helped us visualize what are these two figures who clearly operate by what Stephen Miller famously called the iron laws of the universe. Essentially, it's not about law. It's about strength. It's about bullying your way through.

31:02So the question is, as we wind down here, John, is, OK, maybe that may serve Trump's purposes. He wants a warrior for me, as he said in the case of giving Jim Jordan this award. But what does that actually do for the Republican Party? I mean, if you pitch this forward, what is the next two years? Donald Trump cannot run for president again. So if your primary mission is to fortify, enable, and flatter Donald Trump, does that actually serve the Republican Party's prospects in 2028 well, or does that actually disadvantage them? I mean, it seems to my mind to pretty clearly disadvantage them as a party. I myself do not know, you know, how Republicans, how congressional Republicans get out of their present bind, because here they have

31:51a very clear message, as clear as you could possibly imagine from the electorate, repudiating Trump, his agenda, them, the whole thing. And yet, these congressional Republicans still have to win primaries. So on the one hand, you know, their eyes are now wide open about the unpopularity of their platform and association with Trump. And on the other, if they still want to be in the game, they still have to contend with the most fervent Trump loyalists who control the base and are going to be their gateway, you know, into and through a Republican primary. So the truth is, I just don't know how they threw this particular conundrum. But it seems to me very clear that if all of the things that we've seen in the last two years have alienated people, what we're about to see is going to

32:37alienate them further. Just in terms of, you know, and I worry most specifically, I have to say, about immigration policy, I think it's going to get extremely ugly and painful. Foreign policy is another thing as well. I mean, these areas where the president has particularly wide latitude in setting policy, irrespective of Congress. And so, to your point, I mean, here, these guys are going to maximize Trump's power in these two areas. But these are precisely the areas that the public has reputed the president on. So I do not know where this leads us. I have to say, as our reigning Jordan and Miller expert, John, you're going to have your hands full. We're going to be reading you with great interest, and we look forward to talking to you again. Thanks so much for coming

33:20on today. Oh, thanks for having me, guys. The political scene from The New Yorker will be back in just a moment. From Vanity Fair, I'm Mark Aduchi, and I want to tell you about our new show, Fair Game. On every episode of Fair Game, I'll sit down with a leading character in our culture, from the worlds of Hollywood, politics, style, Silicon Valley, Fair Game. On every episode of Fair Game, I'll sit down with a leading character in our culture from the worlds of Hollywood, politics, style, Silicon Valley, and beyond. Fair Game is a deep dive into some of the personalities that shape our world and the stories that you need to hear. Think everyone and everything that you'd read about in the pages of Vanity Fair.

33:59So join me, Mark Aduchi, on YouTube, VanityFair.com, and wherever you listen to podcasts. It's all fair game. Hi, my name is Zach Barron. I'm the Senior Special Projects Editor at GQ, and I am pleased to introduce one more question to GQ's new weekly interview show. Over the years in the magazine, I've written dozens of cover stories and traveled the world to talk to and write about some of the most the years in the magazine, I've written dozens of cover stories and traveled the world to talk to and write about some of the most interesting people in the GQ universe. From Martin Scorsese to George Clooney and Brad Pitt to outcast Andre 3000. And now I'll be doing it weekly. I'm going to sit down with some of the most interesting people

34:38in the world and figure out what makes them, well, them. New episodes of One More Question will be available each week wherever you get your podcasts, or on YouTube if seeing people in chairs is more your thing. I'm Vincent Cunningham. I'm Nomi Frye. I'm Alex Schwartz, and we host Critics at Large from The New Yorker. Each week, we pick a starting point. The new novel you can't stop thinking about, the movie everybody's seeing this weekend, and we kind of go galaxy brand with it. Right. We take the ideas at the center of these things and trace them across history, across mediums, all to get to the bottom of why this particular text is important right now in politics and culture and also in your everyday life.

35:26We go highbrow, we go lowbrow, we go everything in between. Food culture to meme culture, Charlie XCX to Toni Morrison. K-pop to the Kennedys. From horror movies to heated rivalry. From the Oscars to the Met Gala. The Golden Bachelor to Wuthering Heights, great expectations to desperate housewives. That's what we're talking about over here. We're having fun. It's Critics at Large from The New Yorker, every Thursday, wherever you get your podcasts. Well, I feel like we have been, thanks to John, which was, he was absolutely brilliant on the subject of what makes these guys tick. What do of the combative outsider, the insurgent, the aggrieved extremist, you know, having an ideologue in the position of White House chief of staff,

36:36or for that matter, as House minority leader, as Jim Jordan. You know, this is a dangerous experiment for Republicans, and history suggests it's not going to go that well. The White House chief of staff is not supposed to be arguably the most extreme radical person in America. You know, it's supposed to be somebody who can help the president become a successful chief executive. It's somebody whose job it is to provide honest, open counsel, including difficult truths when there's no one else to provide them to the president. It's somebody whose pragmatism and deal-making skills may ultimately define the success or failure of the presidency. And not a single one of those is an attribute that we've heard in any respect connected with Stephen Miller.

37:27I mean, my takeaway was just in some ways I think both of these gentlemen and the president, they're at home being at war. And I think what this is suggesting to me is we're entering a phase of a real war. And the question is, who is it against? And I think it's going to be against a great proportion of the American political world. I think they're going to be at war with the Democrats and defining a lot of the people in the country as the enemy. And I think then to tie it back to really the moment we're in now, what does that mean actually for addressing the things that got Republicans into such trouble in this election? It's hard to see how that playbook really goes about doing the mundane work of getting

38:17costs down, of getting people to feel as if government is responding to their practical everyday needs. In some ways, Miller and Jordan may have been perfectly suited to get themselves into the jobs they're in now and may be utterly unsuited to actually do them. Well, I think, you know, the other thing that I took away from listening to Jonathan was just don't write off Stephen Miller as a dunce. He is smart and cunning and has studied the government for the entire interregnum between Trump terms. And they've got plans and he gets into the fine print. So it's certainly not a peace offering after the midterms. Susan, we're winding down here. Where does this leave you now, having spent some time? You've spent a lot of time over your career working on what chiefs

39:08of staff do, on how you covered the Hill. How do you see this era unfolding? Interestingly, our conversation today has underscored for me that I don't think they have a way forward. MAGA was always a kind of supernova that burned bright, but was likely to expire with Trump's presidency. And I think that my guess is that neither one of them represents the future of the Republican Party so much as this incredible detour that it's taken into the MAGA cult of personality, we are in a very volatile final two years of that explosion. Brace yourselves. Well said. Well, terrific to see you guys here and looking forward to seeing you in person next week. We have a live show coming up. Absolutely. It should be great. So wonderful, wonderful to catch up with

40:05you guys. Can't wait. This has been the political scene from The New Yorker. I'm Evan Osnos. We had research assistance today from Alex D'Elia, editing by Rhiannon Corby. Our producer is Nora Ritchie, mixing by Mike Kutchman. Stephen Valentino is our executive producer. Our theme music is by Alison Leighton Brown. And reminder, we're doing a live show in D.C. next Wednesday, November 18th at 7 p.m. at Sixth and I, with special guest Senator Reverend Raphael Warnock of Georgia. Join us in person or stream online. Tickets are at sixthandI.org, and the ticket link is also in our show notes. See you there, and thank you so much for listening. Craving flavor-packed food to help keep your day moving?

41:07Look in the freezer. Jimmy Dean bowls and sandwiches are ready when you are made with the signature sausage america loves no prep no assembly just tasty meals that fit right into busy mornings and non-stop days food that shows up when you need it and keeps pace with whatever is next jim Dean brand, breakfast that's done right. Tap the banner to shop now. One day last year, police entered a mansion in L.A. County and discovered the couple that lived there had almost two dozen children, nearly every one of them born through surrogates. But those surrogates had been deceived. I started crying. I was like, what the heck did I just get myself into? I'm Ava Kaufman. The Journey is a new series from In the Dark and The New Yorker.

41:54Find it now in the In the Dark podcast feed. Wired has always put a microscope on the people, power, and forces shaping our world. Uncanny Valley brings that same fearless reporting straight to your feed. Is Doge finally over? Will AI actually democratize American healthcare? Each week, Wired journalists from across the newsroom are going to unpack where politics, technology, and Silicon Valley collide. From conversations with tech leaders across Silicon Valley, internet fandom investigations, Thank you. you up at night and helps make sense of the future taking shape right now. Listen to new episodes every Thursday, wherever you get your podcasts.

▸More episode summaries

The Political Scene | The New Yorker cover art
The Political Scene | The New YorkerA.I. Loses the Popular Vote2026-11-12 · 46 min
The Political Scene | The New Yorker cover art
The Political Scene | The New YorkerHistorian Timothy Garton Ash on the World After Trump2026-11-16 · 36 min
Transcribe your links. Paste a YouTube, Google Drive or podcast link and WhipScribe gives you the transcript. Transcribe a link →
New The Political Scene | The New Yorker transcripts by email
One email per new episode, unsubscribe in every message. Not shared with the publisher.