Test Match Special · · Transcript & summary by WhipScribe
A pointed pre-series press conference in Perth, where Mitchell Marsh would not say whether he knew about the sandpaper, followed by England captain Harry Brook's first thoughts on the tour.
Tap a chapter to open that moment in the transcript; the link to it is copied for you.
“I'm walking out tomorrow to captain my country in a really exciting series against England in a World Cup year.” Mitchell Marsh · at 1:56 — open in the transcript →
“more from your mistakes than you do from always winning or doing really well.” Harry Brook · at 14:32 — open in the transcript →
Australia's white-ball captain Mitchell Marsh faced hostile questioning at his pre-match press conference in Perth, ahead of the one-day series against England. Asked whether he knew sandpaper had been used to tamper with balls in the 2018 South Africa Test, he said he respected others telling their stories but was not sharing his own, and that his focus was on the next day's game. The commentators described a long, awkward quarter-hour of non-answers, and noted that Marsh was standing in for Pat Cummins, who was due to speak in Sydney the following day.
The bigger story is Usman Khawaja's book, which has reopened the Cape Town episode and the questions Cricket Australia's investigation left unanswered. The commentators argued that the bowlers' 2021 statement, saying they knew nothing, now looks doubtful. They said Khawaja's account of anger felt by him and David Warner spreads the blame, and that this pulls in players who had no involvement, widening the scrutiny of the whole 2018 team. They also noted that Steve Smith and David Warner bore the harshest penalties, which is why many expected Warner to speak first.
On the England side, captain Harry Brook said the Tri-Series in Pakistan was a useful learning experience and that he had not read the book, with England having no idea what happened in that dressing room. The commentators rated Adil Rashid as England's best ever white-ball player and argued England will struggle at the back end of the next World Cup without him. They saw Brook as more mature after a difficult year. Their verdict was that the sandpaper row will keep bubbling along until Australian fans feel the right people have been held to account.
Harry Brook is England's captain for the one-day series against Australia, speaking on the eve of the first match in Perth. He reflects on the Tri-Series in Pakistan and what England has learned from a difficult year.
Mitchell Marsh said at his Perth press conference that he was focused on captaining Australia against England in the one-day series, and he would not go back over his recollections of the 2018 South Africa Test. The hosts said he spent much of the session avoiding the questions put to him.
“I'm walking out tomorrow to captain my country in a really exciting series against England in a World Cup year.”Mitchell Marsh · 1:56
Harry Brook said England did not get the results they wanted in the Tri-Series in Pakistan, but he called it a very good series for learning. He said players often learn more from their mistakes than from always winning or doing well.
“more from your mistakes than you do from always winning or doing really well.”Harry Brook · 14:32
Asked about Adil Rashid's role going forward, Harry Brook said it depends on conditions. He said everybody knows how good Rashid is, and that he is a magician with the ball who can tear through sides.
“Everybody knows how good Rash is. He's a magician with the ball.”Harry Brook · 15:13
Harry Brook said he had not personally seen any of Usman Khawaja's book, though he had heard some conversations about it. He said England were not in that dressing room and have no idea what happened, so the team is focused on its own challenge in Australia.
“we weren't in that dressing room. We have no idea what happened.”Harry Brook · 16:36
Harry Brook argued that England's recent Tri-Series losses in Pakistan taught the team valuable lessons, because players learn more from mistakes than from winning. He said England are focused on their own challenge against Australia and have no idea what happened in the dressing room described in Usman Khawaja's book.
At his pre-match press conference in Perth, Mitchell Marsh said he respected that others had told their stories but was not sharing his own, and that his focus was on the next day's one-day game against England. Asked whether he knew sandpaper was used to tamper with balls in the 2018 South Africa Test, he said he would not go back over his recollections of South Africa. The commentators said he spent most of the session avoiding the questions he was asked.
The commentators said Usman Khawaja's book describes the anger he and David Warner felt when the bowlers' 2021 statement came out, with no one willing to take responsibility and others seemingly comfortable letting Warner and the banned players carry the blame. They argued that by spreading the blame, the book ties players who had no involvement into the row and adds to scrutiny of the whole 2018 Australian team.
England captain Harry Brook said the Tri-Series in Pakistan did not go England's way, but he called it a very good series for learning. He said players often learn more from their mistakes than from always winning. He added that one-day cricket is not only about taking wickets and being aggressive, and that there are periods where a team needs to hold back for a while.
One of the commentators argued that Adil Rashid is England's best ever white-ball player, saying he is in a class of one and has been since returning to the team 12 years ago, with nearly 250 one-day international wickets. He said England have not come close to finding someone who can do what Rashid does, and that if England are to be competitive at the back end of the next World Cup, Rashid has to be in the team.
Harry Brook said he had personally not seen any of Usman Khawaja's book, though he had heard some conversations about it. He said England were not in that dressing room and have no idea what happened. He said England's focus is on the challenge against Australia in their own backyard.
Pat Cummins was due to speak in Sydney the day after the Perth press conference, and the commentators saw it as the line in the sand for the row. Rory Dollard said he hoped Cummins would speak with enough clarity to move the story on, and that the nation needs one set of facts rather than competing recollections. The commentators expected Cummins to choose his words very carefully, and expected Cricket Australia to want the matter settled before the Test series.
Our own transcript of the public episode, with a timestamp about every 90 seconds. Tap a timestamp or the link button on a paragraph to copy a link that opens this page there.
0:00This BBC podcast is supported't just about the grid. That same racing mindset, the obsession with engineering, the pursuit of perfection, lives in the Cadillac V-Series lineup, giving you the chance to experience the precision and performance of the grid on the open road. Cadillac V-Series, distinctive luxury performance, engineered to thrill. Discover the V-Series lineup at Cadillac.com. Host Thanksgiving with industry-leading quality standards from Whole Foods Market. There are no antibiotics in their meat department ever, so carve up turkey and spiral-cut ham with peace of mind. Shop organic sides like stuffing mix and cranberry sauce from 365 Brand. And guess what? All their delectable pies are made with no high fructose corn syrup.
1:06Gourmet Thanksgiving flavors with the quality you want. Only at Whole Foods Market. You're listening to the TMS Podcast from BBC Radio 5 Live. Hello, I'm Henry Moran and welcome to the Test Match Special Podcast from Perth on the eve of the ODI series between Australia and England. Don't forget, you'll hear every ball of the series on Test Match Special across BBC Sport and BBC Sounds. To come, we'll be hearing from the England captain Harry Brooke. But where else can we possibly start than the biggest story in town? Sandpaper very much front and centre of the conversation on front pages and back right across Australia. And I think it's fair to say that the Aussie captain Mitchell Marsh was facing some fairly hostile deliveries from the media
1:56in his pre-match press conference. Mitch Marsh, did you know that sandpaper was being used to tampon cricket balls in South Africa? He just hit a six off the first ball there, mate. Well done. Look, there's obviously been a lot of noise around this week. And I respect that certain people have told their stories, but I'm not here to share mine today. I know that might sound weird, but it's a big week for us and it's an important time for this one-day group. And my sole focus has been on preparing for tomorrow. You're walking out to captain Australia tomorrow. Why can't you give the Australian people a yes or no? That's exactly it. I'm walking out tomorrow to captain my country in a really exciting series against England in a World Cup year.
2:41My focus has been on that this week. It's about more than just tomorrow's game though, isn't it? Do people deserve to know if you've been keeping that to yourself for eight years? Yeah, for me, tomorrow is really important. So that's where my focus has been. Can you say yes or no? Did you know that sandpaper was being used to tamper with balls in the 2018 South Africa Test? Yeah, as I said, I'm not here to go back on my recollections of South Africa. But McLaren says that the entire team know, you, including yourself. He says that players like yourselves let others take the fall for that. Is that accurate or is he lying? Look, as I've already stated, I really respect that Uzi's told his story.
3:23He's written his book and my focus is really on tomorrow. But is Uzi lying or is he lying? As I said, I'm not here to go back on my recollections of South Africa. I'm solely focused on tomorrow mate and you've asked the same question. Why will you not go through it and why can you not confront that head on? My honest answer is because I've personally moved on. I respect that others probably haven't, but I have, and I hope that's respected. And at the start of the summer for me, it's a really important one for us. We've got a great summer coming up, and it's my responsibility now, in this moment, to lead this group of a pretty inexperienced side. Did you know that sandpaper was being used at Port Elizabeth before Cape Town?
4:15As I said, I'm not going back to South Africa. Have you read any book? No, I haven't, no. Not a big reader. Have you spoken to Uzi Collider since it came out? Not since it came out, but I have spoken to Uzi. Which kind of scars were you upset with the allegations he made? It's a private phone call, but I played with Uzi for a long time. I respect him and respect that he's told his story and that's all. Tom Wildey from the ABC based here in Perth was in the press conference. That was lively. Yes, you couldey from the ABC based here in Perth was in the press conference. That was lively. Yes, you could say that Mitch was under the gun in that press conference. Obviously, he was in the Australian team in 2018.
4:53He bowled with the ball that was tampered with. And he's one of the, who's now the captain of the Australian white ball team. So he's in a position of authority. And he really refused to engage with questions about St Papagate. He's one of the players that he's sticking to the line of wanting to move on, which is not something that a lot of the Australian cricket public want to do. Usman Khawaja's book has reopened old wounds that haven't healed and has allowed people to re-litigate the events of Cape Town eight years ago. Is there a sense across Australia that actually answers are required? Definitely. The Bowler's statement from 2021 that they didn't know and had no involvement in it now just appears to be, like the allegations in Quage's book make that seem what everyone
5:42suspected to be untrue. And it makes Cricket Australia's investigation feel like a box-ticking exercise. They just wanted to bury it and move on. What it's done is just bring light to the questions that weren't answered in the aftermath. If you go back and watch David Warner's press conference from 2018, the questions he doesn't answer are the ones now that have been answered in Quijs' book. You get the sense that CA had an opportunity eight years ago to deal with this and leave it in the past. They didn't, and people have been waiting for someone to answer the questions that weren't answered then. We thought it would be David Warner. Absolutely, yeah. It always felt like it was going to be David Warner
6:30because he's the one that bore the harshest penalty. He was banned for a year along with Steve Smith, but then banned from all captaincy for all time until that was lifted. It's somewhat surprising that it was McQuaggia. He was always very respected within Australian cricket. But you get the sense that he's been carrying this for a long time. A lot of the criticism of him has been, why now, why not, eight years ago? And I don't think they're the right questions. He was in the Australian team, he had a career, and the backlash that we're seeing now against him from some corners sort of explains why he couldn't have done it when he was playing um it is also a little bit unsurprising that it's
7:15Kawaja in that one of his best friends is David Warner someone who really bore the brunt of it he describes in the book these the anger that uh him and Warner felt when the bowl statement came out that no one was willing to take responsibility and seemed pretty comfortable with bancroft smith and and warner wearing that wearing it and this seems like his way of you know um redistributing some of the blame the problem is that by redistributing the blame even those who weren't involved are tied with that brush now and that just adds to the speculation and the intense scrutiny of of the Australian cricket set up as a whole and the Australian cricket team from 2018. Just finally how does this play out what next? Next I think
7:55is David Warner's book I think he's just signed a deal and that's the book everyone will be waiting for because he's the player that paid the biggest price. But in the immediacy, I mean, Pat Cummins speaks in Sydney tomorrow. Yeah, I think it was someone from the BBC who wrote that, the sandpaper cost the captaincy and the science mate cost another one. I'm not sure that's the case. I think Cummins will choose his words very carefully tomorrow, like Mitchell Stark did. I think this will be a case of Cricket Australia being keen to get it out of the way before the Test Series. But until the Australian cricketing public is satisfied that the right people have been held to account, this is something that will just bubble along for a long time.
8:37Thank you so much for your time. The TMS Podcast from BBC Radio 5 Live. PNC Bank brings you Call of the Wild Money Moves. You hear that? YOLO! That's an internet troll telling you to put all your money into a single investment. YOLO! YOLO, YOLO! He wants you to liquidate your emergency fund. YOLO! And buy a digital racehorse named Silicon Steve. YOLO, YOLO. He wants you to liquidate your emergency fund. YOLO. And buy a digital racehorse named Silicon Steve. YOLO. Stay vigilant. He's very persistent. YOLO. Guard against wild money moves with PNC Bank. Brilliantly boring since 1865. Host Thanksgiving with industry-leading quality standards from Whole Foods Market. There are no antibiotics in their meat department ever.
9:26So carve up turkey and spiral cut ham with peace of mind. Shop organic sides like stuffing mix and cranberry sauce from 365 Brand. And guess what? All their delectable pies are made with no high fructose corn syrup. Gourmet Thanksgiving flavors with the quality you want. Only at Whole Foods Market. Big news! Wayfair's Black Friday sale is here early. Right now at Wayfair, get up to 70% off everything you need for the season ahead. Save on kitchen and dining, bedroom furniture and mattresses, holiday decor, and way more. Now is the time to score big from seasonal finds to favorites you'll use all year long. Plus, with Wayfair, enjoy fast and easy shipping. With delivery in time for the holidays.
10:12Save up to 70% off early Black Friday deals. Shop now at Wayfair.com. Wayfair, every style, every home. Well, that was the thoughts of ABC broadcaster Tom Wiley, based here in Perth. And we've now come upstairs to the Test Match special commentary box, where once again, joined by the Press Association's Rory Dollard. Now, Rory, we weren't planning on doing a podcast today, but you were in that press conference with Mitchell Marsh. I mean, that was remarkable, wasn't it? It's the most unusual press conference I've been to in Perth since we sat and watched Steve Smith talk about Monty Panesar's appearance on Mastermind a year ago before the ashes test. There's something about that room, Henry.
10:57I know. It sends people a bit for a loop. It was combative. There was some fairly terse exchanges. There was that idea where if you ask a question a dozen times, you might get a different answer the more you ask. Mitch Marsh didn't want to play that game. But yeah, we know that Pat Cummins is due to speak on this tomorrow. That's probably the line in the sand, really. And it was a bit of a hospital pass for Mitch Marsh because I suppose he's standing in for Pat Cummins as white ball captain this week. He was standing in for Pat Cummins at a press conference that Pat Cummins would have been giving, all things but equal. But he knows that Pat Cummins, who is his senior, is due to speak tomorrow.
11:40So he spent the best part of 15 minutes trying not to answer the questions he was being given. It was both the quickest and longest 15 minutes of a press conference I can ever remember. It was long in the sense it was quite awkward at times. And what's interesting is the Australian press can sometimes be accused of being a little bit sycophantic towards the Australian team. But when they are going at it, it is pretty brutal stuff. Yeah, my experience is that they're going hard at someone usually. So if it's not England, it's their own. Yeah. Their default setting is that they want to have a go at somebody. And at the moment, it's their own team to some extent. Listen, one thing I would say, Henry, and I really hope Pat Cummins
12:24speaks with enough clarity that we move past this, is we're hearing a lot about people sharing their stories and their recollections. We're getting very, very close to alternative facts, aren't we? There isn't their stories and their recollections. There's one story, there's one fact about what's happened here, and we could do with hearing about it pretty soon. Not, I'll tell you my story and you tell me yours then we'll measure them and see whose story is bigger yeah i mean it feels like it's getting out of hand now yeah we there's only so often that we can have a day like we've had today with mitch marsh sort of staring down and desperately trying to sell it as a story about great news for Western Australia, having five players in the team.
13:05And he didn't get any traction on that. He didn't, no. It's a sandpaper story. And we need Pat Cummins to do the whole nation a favour and move it on. Well, it does feel a bit like that, doesn't it? And it was interesting. And why Mitch Marsh is so relevant to this is that he was playing in that series in South Africa, took a couple of wickets with the infamous ball. Swung the ball a bit from recollection, Mitch Marsh, which he hasn't always done over the course of his career. So yeah, that's interesting. We'll wait and see how it all plays out. But it is continuing to grow and grow. And each press conference feels like it's becoming sort of more box office viewing by the day. Let's hear from the England camp then.
13:48I spoke to the captain, Harry Brook, on the eve of the series at a venue that he has some memories of. We're very happy to be out here. We've had a very good training block over the last week or so and we're all really raring to go tomorrow. Optus, which was where the Ashes started as well and it's an amazing place to play cricket. The atmosphere when we played here was unbelievable so we're hoping for a bit more tomorrow. Brendan McCollum said that you would have grown a lot as a captain from the experience in the Tri Series. What does he mean by that? What have you learned? The Tri Series was... I know the results didn't go our way, but I think it was a very good series for us in terms of learning. A lot of the time you learn
14:32more from your mistakes than you do from always winning or doing really well. So I think that series, there's a lot of things that we can look back on and bank them experiences, especially if we find ourselves in a similar position. In one-day cricket, it's not necessarily all about taking wickets and trying to be really aggressive. There might be periods where you need to just hold for a while and that could be various different skills. That's one example, but there's plenty of things that we can take away from the series. It's going to be a slightly different squad, but it's a squad missing Jacob Bethel, which is a real frustration. What can you tell us about how he's going and how he is?
15:13Yeah, he's all right. I've spoken to him. I had breakfast with him this morning and yeah, he's obviously very disappointed, as all of us are. We know how much hard work he's put in over the last few months to try and get back. I remember hearing him say that he was batting at Loughborough and hitting the ball everywhere and saying, that's six at Optus. He was really looking forward to getting out here and playing. I'm devastated for him, but hopefully he'll be back as soon as possible. Adil Rashid didn't play a huge role during the tri-series. What is his role going forward for this England side? It's all conditions dependent, really. Everybody knows how good Rash is. He's a magician with the ball.
15:55He can tear through sides, and the skill that he possesses is unbelievable. So it's awesome to have him in and around the squad. But Liam Dawson did an exceptional job in Pakistan and he did the role very well. He had a lot of clarity at the top of his mark. He knew exactly what he needed to do and he performed well. Any concerns over middle-overs, wickets and finding the right combinations with your bowling line-up to ensure you continue as a threat throughout the 50-0s? Yeah, if you look at the best teams in the world, that's the key areas that they're dominating at the minute. And that's something that we've spoken about a lot over the last week or so. We want to try and control that middle overs with bat and ball a little bit better than
16:36what we have. And that could be being boring for a little period of time or deciding to accelerate at some point. So we've just got to read and adapt to them conditions and the situation's a little bit better than what we have done. But we're still a work in progress, as every team always is. And we're looking forward to trying to put that into practice this week. There's been a lot of conversation around Australian cricket over Usman Khawaja's book. How much have you lot been talking about it? I personally haven't actually seen any of it. I've obviously heard some conversations and, yeah, look, we weren't in that dressing room. We have no idea what happened. We're out here now. We've got a good challenge against Australia
17:19in their own backyard and that's all that we should be focusing on now. Can you accept it's not a great look for cricket at the moment again we weren't there we we have no idea what happened we're just trying to focus on ourselves well that was harry brook chatting to me there and uh rory dollard of the press association still alongside me he um i think it's fair to say he's probably rather enjoying sitting on the sidelines and all the attention for the series, being able to, you know, just actually focus on his team in this building. Well, yeah, I actually, in the open press conference, I asked him first up about the little photo opportunity that he had with Mitch Marsh, where they shared a little afternoon tea set.
18:00Nothing clichéd about that. Nothing clichéd about that, giving the Yorkshiremen some tea. But I actually thought, gosh, how different must it feel for Harry Brooke when they arrived here in Australia and here in Perth 12 months ago. They were public enemy number one. They were all over the back pages for being cocky. Cocky captain. I mean, Ben Stokes absolutely copped it out here when he arrived. And Harry Brooke's been offered a cup of tea on arrival. It's a very different experience for England. They're out of the crosshairs for sure. There aside, coming to this off the back of negative results in Pakistan, but he's quite keen there to emphasise the positives that came from that series. I mean, there are positives for England.
18:40I mean, big runs, standout performances. It's not all doom and gloom. No, I think because the World Cup is going to take place in Africa, in South Africa and Southern Africa in particular, I think they're fairly able to sweep it to one side that they lost a few games in Pakistan. Then the conditions aren't awfully comparable. They won't be certainly playing games in the same rhythms that they were out there. So I think they were quite happy to get a few games under the belt, get a few guys, maybe batters into a bit of form. But probably the thing they are looking for is just to sharpen up the bowling and probably they will think they let a couple of opportunities slip in that series. And if they've got any sort of wishes and wants for the next couple of games out here,
19:23they'll be looking for a pretty steady bowling performance and a couple of these seem as probably to stand up and and tighten up interesting what he said about the focus on those middle overs both with bat and ball and the Adil Rashid factor he didn't play much of a role just the one game in that tri-series and yeah a lot of question marks is he still the bowl he once was but it was quite clear from Brooke's answer there the magician one thing or another they do still rate him and how couldn't you given his record? I am of the opinion that Adil Rashidi is England's best ever white ball player player? Absolutely definitely. We hear that's Joss Butler. I think Joss Butler is England's best white ball batter but I think we
20:06over the last decade or whatever have had batters who could more easily replicate what Joss Butler does than we've had bowlers who could do what Rashid does Rashid is in a class of one and has been since he came back into the team 12 years ago nearly nearly 250 ODI wickets yeah and we haven't come close and has been since he came back into the team 12 years ago nearly. Nearly 250 ODI wickets. Yeah, and we haven't come close to having a stand-in. When Josh Butler is injured right now and he's fantastic, phenomenal, pretty much a peerless player, but we have players up the top of the order getting the runs. When Rashid doesn't do what he does, it's a massive glaring vacuum. I think he's England's best ever white ball player.
20:46And to see him not in the team by choice in Pakistan was really unusual. And I would go further and say, if England are going to be competitive in the back end of the World Cup next year, either Rashid better be in the team and take him with it, or it probably won't happen. You'd go as far as to say that a year from now, even when he's approaching 40, he's still going to be that value? I think he has to be. I think if he isn't in the team, England have a much steeper challenge on their hands than if he is. Yeah. Harry Brook is somebody who has, over the years, I think, become a better speaker and more authoritative as a leader. Interesting what Brendan McCollum's had to say about Brook as a captain
21:27and having grown a lot, particularly over the course of that Tri Series. I'm just partly quite impressed with Harry Brook. As an individual, he seems to have matured quite a lot. Yeah, and I wouldn't be at all surprised if the negative stuff that happened to Harry Brook over the last year has been part of that usually we do find that you know pressure forges diamonds or something you know that's one of the the phrase is it people don't tend to grow until they've had a bit of something to rub up against and harry brooke burst onto the international scene and had it all his own way for a little bit. Then things got pretty tricky for him. And probably he's looked, realised there are things he could
22:10and should have done better. And he appears to have come out in charge right now of quite a professional and focused set-up. And that comes partially from seeing some own gaps, probably, in what he was doing and filling them. And England will probably think that if they've got a leader who's learned from some mistakes, that's a good place to be. Well, it'll be interesting to see how the series goes and what his leadership will bring this England side across the three matches played here in Perth at the Optus Stadium, then over to Adelaide Oval, and then concluding in Hobart before those five T20 internationals. You'll hear them all every single game of this tour that is becoming increasingly noisy
22:53and well away from any of the cricket, but it is a fascinating place to be. Rory, thank you very much indeed. All of the matches available on BBC Sounds. And don't forget to subscribe to this here podcast. Wherever you get your pods, you'll make sure that you'll never miss an episode. The Test Match Special podcast bringing you all the analysis and reaction to this series as we go through it. It promises to be a really entertaining, thrilling few weeks. For more than a decade, British boxing has been shaped by two men. Two completely different personalities, two extraordinary careers, and one fight that just won't go away. There's never been a fight like this in the history of British boxing.
23:45Never. This is the story of how we got here. And how the AJ Fury rivalry redefined boxing forever. This will split the country. Half Fury fans, half AJ fans. Five Live Boxing, Fury v. Joshua. Listen on BBC Sounds. Book a loved-by-guest property with Verbo, and you get a top-rated vacation rental that's loved for all the right reasons, like being in a great location or having great amenities. Oh, I love my Verbo for the view. Good reason. Ooh, and the sauna. Sweet. Another good reason. And that it's one of those good saunas with the hot rock thing. Oh, love a good hot rock thing. Fancy. That's also a reason. In a world full of distractions, presence is power. Meet the new Kindle Scribe, a digital notebook that feels like paper.
24:46No tabs, no notifications. Just focus. Plus, built-in AI to organize, summarize, and move your ideas forward faster. Because the most impressive person in the room is the one who's fully in it. What are you working on? The new Kindle Scribe.

