Test Match Special · · Transcript & summary by WhipScribe
A former Ashes-winning captain breaks down the sandpaper row and England's Perth collapse in the same episode, so you get both the scandal and the cricket.
Tap a chapter to open that moment in the transcript; the link to it is copied for you.
“There was no master plan around using illegal methods.” Pat Cummins · at 6:18 — open in the transcript →
“I thought the penalties were far greater than the crime that they committed.” Michael Vaughan · at 3:21 — open in the transcript →
The episode opens with the sandpaper fallout that has overshadowed Australian cricket this week. Test captain Pat Cummins faced 69 minutes of questions in Sydney and rejected the idea of a master plan, saying he did not know sandpaper was going onto the field during the 2018 Cape Town Test. Michael Vaughan, a former England captain and Ashes winner, calls the public row sad for a sport built on togetherness, and argues that the three players punished at the time already paid more than their crime deserved. David Warner, one of those three, backed Usman Khawaja's book and said Cummins had thrown Khawaja under the bus.
The harder question is what anyone actually knew. Vaughan notes that ball-tampering has a long history in the game, which makes the line Australia crossed with sandpaper a grey area, and he doubts that only three players were aware. Warner's answers suggested sandpaper had been used earlier, and Khawaja's book places it in Durban in the same series. Vaughan believes the full truth may never come out without a recording or a confession, and he sees no point in restarting an investigation eight years later.
Then the cricket. England were bowled out for 131 in Perth after slumping to 65 for 8, and Australia won the first one-day international of the three-match series. Harry Brook blamed execution rather than preparation, while Vaughan said England have struggled in Perth for years and need to adapt to the bounce of the pitch. He also argued that Adil Rashid should be in the white-ball side, and questioned the constant changes in England's coaching set-up.
Michael Vaughan is a former England captain who won the Ashes as captain. He is working on the Test Match Special broadcast in Perth for this episode.
Pat Cummins told a Sydney press conference that there was no master plan around using illegal methods during the 2018 Cape Town Test. He said he did not know sandpaper was going onto the field, and that he does not remember any team meeting about collective responsibility.
“There was no master plan around using illegal methods.”Pat Cummins · 6:18
David Warner told Fox Cricket that he still stands by Usman Khawaja and what he wrote in his book, which he called the truth. He said Pat Cummins had thrown Khawaja under the bus at the press conference, and that Warner has spoken to Cummins about the issue only in passing.
“I've played golf with Pat Cummins a couple of times.”David Warner · 9:02
Michael Vaughan said England have had no rewards in Perth, a ground where the pitch has bounce and big drives often do not come off. He said he thinks it is now time England stopped playing Test cricket in Perth.
“I've been coming to Perth a long time and England have had no rewards.”Michael Vaughan · 21:48
Harry Brook said England's preparation for the Perth one-day international was outstanding, and that the problem was execution rather than preparation. He said Australia's attack put the ball in the right areas for 30-odd overs and that England must adapt quicker before Adelaide.
“I think just the execution, really, probably.”Harry Brook · 19:05
Michael Vaughan said he has a huge amount of admiration for Usman Khawaja for exposing that more people knew about the sandpaper. He also said the three players punished in 2018 received penalties far greater than the crime they committed.
“I thought the penalties were far greater than the crime that they committed.”Michael Vaughan · 3:21
Michael Vaughan argues that the sandpaper row should be allowed to move on, because the three players punished in 2018 have already paid far more than their crime deserved. He also says England must learn to adapt to Perth's conditions and one-day tempo before the World Cup.
At a Sydney press conference lasting 69 minutes, Pat Cummins said he did not know sandpaper was going onto the field during the 2018 Cape Town Test. He called the claim that he and others were architects of a sandpaper scheme complete nonsense, and said he did not remember any team meeting about collective responsibility for using illegal methods.
David Warner told Fox Cricket that he still stands by Usman Khawaja's book, which he said is the truth. He felt that Pat Cummins had thrown Khawaja under the bus in the press conference, and said he and the other two reprimanded players have paid a heavy price for the 2018 scandal.
Michael Vaughan said the three players punished in 2018 received penalties far greater than their crime, and that their lives and mentalities have been changed. He said he personally does not see how more bans or another investigation would help, and that he hopes the country can move on.
Harry Brook told reporters after the first one-day international in Perth that England's preparation was outstanding, and that the problem was execution. He said Australia's attack put the ball in the right areas for 30-odd overs, and that England need to bank the experience and adapt quicker before the Adelaide match.
Michael Vaughan said a modern one-day side needs to score quickly and dominate, but that England failed to read the conditions in Perth. He argued that a total of 260 to 280 can win on Perth's big outfield, and that the repeated talk of adaptability is a problem if the team does not change how it plays.
Michael Vaughan said David Warner's answers suggested sandpaper was used before Cape Town. He noted that Usman Khawaja's book says it was used in Durban in the same series, and that Pat Cummins could not say 100 per cent that nothing happened during the 2017-18 Ashes. Vaughan called the issue a massive grey area.
Our own transcript of the public episode, with a timestamp about every 90 seconds. Tap a timestamp or the link button on a paragraph to copy a link that opens this page there.
0:00This BBC podcast is supported't just about the grid. That same racing mindset, the obsession with engineering, the pursuit of perfection, lives in the Cadillac V-Series lineup, giving you the chance to experience the precision and performance of the grid on the open road. Cadillac V-Series, distinctive luxury performance, engineered to thrill. Discover the V-Series lineup at Cadillac.com. Host Thanksgiving with industry-leading quality standards from Whole Foods Market. There are no antibiotics in their meat department ever, so carve up turkey and spiral-cut ham with peace of mind. Shop organic sides like stuffing mix and cranberry sauce from 365 Brand. And guess what? All their delectable pies are made with no high fructose corn syrup.
1:06Gourmet Thanksgiving flavors with the quality you want. Only at Whole Foods Market. You're listening to the TMS Podcast from BBC Radio 5 Live. Hello, this is Henry Moran. Welcome to the Test Match Special podcast from Perth, where England have been thrashed in the first one-day international of this three-match series against Australia. We'll be dissecting what went wrong in the company of Ashes winning captain Michael Vaughan, and there was plenty from England's point of view. But before that, we have to start with the extraordinary day that we've seen in the continuation of the sad paper story. In Sydney, first thing this morning, Test Captain Pat Cummins, one of the bowlers who played during the infamous test in South Africa eight years ago,
1:57faced the media for 69 minutes worth of grilling. We'll hear some of that shortly. But first, Michael, it has been a bleak week for Australian cricket off the field. Yeah, it has. I mean, I arrived Saturday morning and it was the day that parts of Usman's book were in the media and I thought, well, this is going to be interesting. You know, then there was obviously Mitchell Stark did a bit of media. There's been some Instagram posts from David Warner, 100% backing up what Usman has put in his book. And then this morning, Pat Cummins, 69 minutes, he was in that press conference, answered every question. I thought he did a sterling job in terms of answering questions. Now, I've got to be totally honest that, you know, we, as English people,
2:38we should be absolutely reveling in the fact that Australia are going through this kind of turmoil, this off-field bitching of one another. I find it desperately sad. You know, the Baggy Green, when I was growing up in the 90s, was something that all you ever heard about, the Baggy Green, this kind of togetherness, this culture that they've created here in Australia, playing against them from, what, 2001 to 2006-07. Again, that same kind of feeling amongst their group. I've worked here for 10 years and I've always felt that the baggy green was everything. This kind of togetherness, this culture, the pillars of strength that they always talk about here in Australia cricket. To see them arguing publicly like they have done over the course of the last few days
3:21has been, as I said, it should be a moment where all those English cricket fans and ex-players are going, yeah, look at them. I find it really sad. To air your dirty washing so publicly, Usman's absolutely in his right to write a book. I have a huge amount of admiration for Usman in terms of exposing that more people knew. That doesn't surprise me. I think we've all been around cricket long enough to suggest that the three that got the punishment and the crime that they did, I thought the penalties were far greater than the crime that they committed. Those three players have had to bear the brunt of what happened eight years ago. And I felt that's wrong. So that didn't surprise me in terms of more people knew.
4:07A huge amount of admiration for Usman speaking out about those three. But the way it's played out so publicly, I felt quite put back by because fundamentally, what are people hoping is going to happen? You're talking about human beings. They all made mistakes back in 2018. I think those within the game and those that have been around cricket or sport will know that there was always going to be more than three that knew about what was going on. Now, what do people really want from here on in? Because it's a he said, she said kind of situation from eight years ago. And I hear cries of, you know, they want people banned. You know, they want to go through another thorough investigation. I just don't see why we need to go all the way back and start again.
4:54I think it's happened. I think it's been a really poor look for Australian cricket. I think they're going to find it hard to kind of put that togetherness of what Australian cricket is very soon. I don't think it's going to be done overnight. But fundamentally, you're kind of looking at, you know, a lot of human beings that I would say two or three that were involved eight years ago that were on the side of being penalised strongly. I think they'd be more than happy for it to go away. I think their lives have been changed. I think their mentality has been completely questioned. I know two of them personally have gone through some really dark times. And I think somewhere, somehow, people have got to understand that we've got to move on.
5:32I know a lot of people out there will be saying, oh, no, you can't move on. Australia cheated. We've got to go back over it. We've got to see more penalties. We want to see more people banned. I personally don't see how that's going to help the cause. Well, let's hear a little bit of Pat Cummins' press conference. I think it's fair to say he came out swinging. When he says we all knew, if by that he means that we knew sandpaper was going out in the field, he's 100% wrong. I've said that consistently for the last eight years. I did not know that was happening. He says that I and others were architects of a scheme to ball tamper with sandpaper. That's complete and utter nonsense. Usman's a friend, but friends aren't casual with each other's lives and reputations.
6:18In his book, Usi has been casual with my lives and the lives of many others, and I think Australian cricket. I support his right to tell a story, 100%. I'm really glad that he feels like he can, but we have to be accountable for the things that we say and do. There was no master plan around using illegal methods. I think that's maybe something that hasn't been spoken about enough. People assume you've gone from very illegal methods to suddenly taking sandpaper, and there must have been some huge master plan like the truth just that is not the case i don't remember any conversation around collective responsibility i don't remember any team meeting where he stood up and said that's why i own this as a team um so then you know to the following no i've got no idea who those two
7:03people would be because i don't remember ever being asked or having a conversation about it. Michael was working today alongside David Warner, one of the three men reprimanded and held responsible for the sandpaper conspiracy. And he gave his reaction to both Michael and Adam Gilchrist on Fox Cricket and KO. Yeah, look, you know, Pat Cummins was very well prepared this morning. And, you know, I still stick by Uzi and what he's written in that book. It is the truth. And I really, really support him. I actually feel for him at the moment. I actually feel that the captain today actually threw Uzi under the bus. And I'm very, very disappointed about that. All three of us have played a big price in this.
7:43And, you know, I hadn't spoken about it in eight years but at the end of the day we've got to live with these consequences daily and you know we've we've been served a life punishment so when other people talk about it's been affected by it there's no there's no nothing worse for for me Steve and Cameron who have to walk out there every single day and you know we cop abuse yes we accepted it but at the end of the day my wife and I as well pay the greatest price we lost a baby during that time and that's why it really hurts me the most until the truth is accepted because the way that it was handled in the first place it was hard for us to go back and actually you know give more evidence it was literally as I said it was I feel
8:21like it was a botched investigation it was a quick one to get it over and done with. Some of the questions were quite challenging in a way that it was being planted on us and we had to move on and just accept responsibility for three of us. And we ultimately did. We don't have that opportunity to go there and speak again. You know, Todd Greenberg squashed that the other day. So there are probably going to be conversations behind the scenes probably after all this. Dave, have you ever had any contact with Usman or maybe Cam Bancroft through this period? Yeah, I've spoken to both of them. They're quite upset about this all as well. And I think the main part about this is in that eight years, not one of those people that were in that changing besides those three
9:02have spoken to us about that. And I think that's the mateship that we talk about, the honesty that you have with each other, that there's been no contact or questions about it. And we're all adults and we're open to conversation. We're open to that. But I've played golf with Pat Cummins a couple of times. I've been in the changing room since then and played and won some World Cups. And it's just never been questioned or asked about it. So, yeah, look, at the end of the day, you know, Pat's not going to agree with me, I'm not going to agree with him. He's obviously spoken about what he thinks about Uzi's book, but I stand by Uzi and his comments. You know, for me, it's about accepting the truth,
9:33and I just don't think this will rest. And I know I'm going to respect your comments about moving on, Jim, but it's very, very difficult with the acceptance of the consequences that we live day to day in our lives, and it's challenging. We come here and do our job, and I'm still getting called the architect, with the acceptance of the consequences that we live day to day in our lives. And it's challenging. We come here and do our job and I'm still getting called the architect, you know, the fixer and all this kind of stuff. And it really, really hurts. But it's also affected Australia, you know, and the Australian cricket team. So, you know, it's important for us to allow us, you know, time to heal it.
10:01But until the truth is accepted, it's going to be very, very difficult. I 100% agree with Lussmann. The Cape Town change room, there's two sides of the change room. There's only one in Port Elizabeth. I think that gets glossed over quite a bit and there's a lot more detail there that I think Uzi speaks about in his book that is very hard to grasp but people don't know. Do you intend to, whether it's via a book or a media conference like Pat, to tell your story or are you comfortable saying versions of events are differentiating between person to person and we can move on? Yeah, each person is going to have their differences, but I'm not going to accept them to the truce out there. So, Michael, where now? Because it is very much.
10:42No, we didn't. Yes, you did. No, we didn't. Yes, you did. It's like being in the playground again, isn't it? It is. I mean, where next? Honestly, I get a sense from listening to David Warner that he wants the full truth to be out. He wants more to come out and speak. From the way that he spoke today and the way that he 100% backed up Uzi Kowalja's claims, he thinks there's a lot more people that knew about the sandpaper. Now, I asked him the question on Fox today, did sandpaper happen before Cape Town? And clearly it did. It's been a situation where... Do we know that definitively? Well, it's in Usman's book and David Warner backed that up and it's been spoken about that it was used, I think, in Durban
11:26in that same Test Match series. I've read parts of Chris Wokes' book that suggests after the Ashes here in 2017-18, there was a conversation in the dressing room with David Warner. Well, this is interesting because Pat Cummins in that press conference said he couldn't 100% say that there wasn't something going on during the 17-18 ashes. Yeah, which is, you know, covering himself as well. That's, you know, it was a masterclass in PR. It was a masterclass in being open and honest to any journalist that could ask any question. You know, he didn't hold back from any of the questions. There were some really tough questions to answer. I thought he answered them as well as he possibly could. I still think it's a massive
12:07grey area because ball tampering or tampering with the ball to try and make the ball swing, it's been happening for generations. Now, Australia stepped over the mark by taking sandpaper onto the field. Now, is it possible that some people within that team didn't know? I think it is possible that someone have known about the sandpaper that Cameron Bancroft took onto the field in Cape Town. But if it's happened previously, you can't tell me that only those three people knew because there's no way that those three people catch it quite if it's worked one week and then the week after you do it once again. We've all been in team sport. We understand what happens in the dressing room. So how does this play play out from here on in um
12:50i i can't think there's going to be too many more press conferences um i i guess if three or four or five more players that played in 2018 came out so no actual fact we all spoke about it uh there could be trouble ahead because clearly someone's lying in this situation. And I get a sense over here that people are wanting to move on, but there's just that element of doubt. There's that element of doubt of people saying, wait a minute, what if the bowlers in particular wrote that letter in 2021, having seen what Cameron Bancroft said in an interview, to kind of put to bed that they knew anything about it. If it comes out in the next week or so that one or two did know about it and they've lied, well, we're in for another problem.
13:35I personally hope we can kind of move on from this situation and that doesn't happen because we've got some good cricket ahead. England are here and then obviously New Zealand arrive and England go to South Africa, there's so much cricket going on, I don't think we're ever going to get to the truth I don't think we're ever going to get to that moment where we absolutely 100% know because clearly some are going to say Nat didn't know anything and those on the other side are going to say yes she did so how do you get to that moment of truth because there's no cameras I don't think anything's been recorded. Usman Khawaja states that he stood up in front of the Green and said, come on, we've got to take it as a team.
14:10Which, if you look back, that would have been the Australian thing to do. That would have been what I would have expected from an Australian side to take it all on the chin. That's what the bag of green stands for. We're all all together. If he did that and he said he did um they were wrong not to do it that way but obviously Pat's come out and said that's not true so um Henry I've no idea who to believe just finally on this as a cricketer and somebody with vast experience in the game the one question that wasn't really asked to Pat Cummins is, wouldn't you have noticed the ball looked a bit different and had these big swirl marks on it that Uzmakuar just spoke about? Would a bowling group have noticed?
14:53I mean, because in our trade, we turn on our laptops and we'd probably notice that someone had changed a desktop background, say. Do you know what I mean? Or, you know, swapped the microphones around. Would you know? And would you spot something was funny about the ball? Yeah, I mean, I never bowled too much. You did bowl such in general. Yeah, but I would suggest that if something happened to my bat, my tool of trade, so there was a big chunk missing out the side of my bat, my Gunnar Moore purist, I would know that my Gunnar more purist had a problem. Something's not right. So we've played enough. I find it staggering that the bowlers wouldn't have known about a ball because they're bowling with it. They're looking at it. They're shining
15:35it. But they're in their right to say that they didn't know. And the story will go on until we get to that moment where someone categorically either shows us a piece of video has a a recording of a conversation or to that lens of uh investigation um i don't think we're ever going to get to the truth but one thing's for sure is that there's a huge amount of doubt about the australian cricket team that that kind of umbrella that's been around them for all the generations that i've watched and played and commentated here. There's just a small element of doubt that they're not telling the truth. Well, in a time where turbulence is the order of the day around cricket, it was reassuring to have a familiar
16:17pattern in some respects. England's struggling in Perth. We'll get into that in just a moment. Put all your money into a single investment. YOLO! YOLO! YOLO! He wants you to liquidate your emergency fund. YOLO! And buy a digital racehorse named Silicon Steve. YOLO! Stay vigilant. He's very persistent. YOLO! Guard against wild money moves with PNC Bank. Brilliantly boring since 1865. Host Thanksgiving with industry-leading quality standards from Whole Foods Market. There are no antibiotics in their meat department ever, so carve up turkey and spiral cut ham with peace of mind. Shop organic sides like stuffing mix and cranberry sauce from 365 brand. And guess what? All their delectable pies are made with no high fructose corn syrup. Gourmet Thanksgiving flavors with the quality you want.
17:27Only at Whole Foods Market. Big news! Wayfair's Black Friday sale is here. Early! Right now at Wayfair, get up to 70% off everything you need for the season ahead. Save on kitchen and dining, bedroom furniture and mattresses, holiday decor, and way more. Now is the time to score big. From seasonal finds to favorites you'll use all year long. Plus with Wayfair, enjoy fast and easy shipping with delivery in time for the holidays. Save up to 70% off early Black Friday deals. Shop now at Wayfair.com. Wayfair, every style, every home. Well, England lost the toss and we're asked to have a bat first by australia and were promptly and rather brutally reduced to 65 for 8 with marley beardman 21 years old taking 6 for 24
18:17on debut eventually england did scramble to 131 all out gus atkinson making an unbeaten 29. He then bowled and got Travis Head out first ball. But Australia always likely to win. They did so eventually. 23.3 overs when the winning runs were struck to take a 1-0 lead in the series. Let's hear from the England captain. I spoke to Harry Brooke at the close of play. We've been in this situation a couple of times now. In my captaincy, we've managed to bounce back very well so hopefully we can we can learn from these from today this experience bank it and move on quickly on to Adelaide. Preparation was good build-up time plentiful so what went wrong? Preparation was outstanding I thought the boys put in a hell of a shift over the last week and a half. We've trained exceptionally hard.
19:05We've managed to have a practice game at the WACA, so preparation wasn't the problem. I think we've prepared so well that we've never had that opportunity before as a white ball side, so we can't really look at that as a problem. I think just the execution, really, probably. The Australian ball and attack put the ball in the right place for 30 odd overs and made us answer questions. Yeah, they bowled really well. We didn't execute as well as we could have done. How frustrating is it to see what looked at times slightly timid strokes getting out as opposed to sort of the aggressive approach that maybe you've called for the positivity in this side? We knew it wasn't gonna be an easy pitch to bat on.
19:51It wasn't necessarily a case of crash-bound wallop on that surface. It's a case of putting some shots away, trying to make the bowler bowl into your areas a little bit more. Obviously, that didn't happen today. The Aussie attack put the ball in the right areas for a long period of time. Now, Adil Rashid. What's the thinking there? Conditions-based. We knew it was going to be a Seymour-friendly pitch. We knew spin wasn't really going to play a part. I know Zampa bowled a couple of overs, managed to get it to spin a little bit. But, yeah, we thought Seymour was going to dominate that surface, and it did. Would you be happy not coming back to Perth any time soon? No, I'd love the opportunity to play here. It's another experience for me
20:28that I can try and bank on later on in my career and it's not an easy surface to bat on but every experience that each individual in that dressing room plays on here will remember it and learn from it. For you Harry, there's been a lot of distractions in Australian cricket this week. How hard was it to make sure your group focused on what you had to do today and, I guess, take on the Australians that are out there and the 11 that are picked for them and ignore all the other noise that's going on in Australian cricket at the moment? Yeah, we haven't got anything to do with that. We weren't in that dressing room, so we have no place to comment. We've come here to try and play against a strong Australian attack in their own... strong Australian side in their own back garden,
21:07and we're still in this series now. Like I said before, we've been in this position plenty of times before when we've gone 1-0 down and managed to scrape a series win. So that's our main aim. On to Adelaide. Just finding, how do you turn it around? There's not much of a gap, just two days, and travel day as well. It's about adaptability again, really. We know we've got to adapt quicker. We probably didn't adapt quick enough today for that surface. Adelaide presents a different challenge, probably a slightly better batting surface over there. We've got to go over there and try and gain as much confidence as we can from this game and play the way that everybody knows we can. Harry, thanks for your time. Really
21:48appreciate it. Thank you. Harry Brook chatting there after play. A question in there as well from Mitch Turner from the ABC. Michael, it's probably time we started that petition to make sure England never have to come to Perth again, isn't it? Well, I did say this on BBC 5 Live, the morning show. I've been coming to Perth a long time and England have had no rewards. And that goes back to when I played here. We were all here for the Ashes where it just lasted two days. We're very consistent here in Perth. We're about around 32 overs, whether it's test cricket or 50-over cricket. We don't seem to be able to learn the fact that this pitch has a bit of bouncing. The big drives don't necessarily always
22:30come off. Well, very rarely does it come off here in Perth. The cross-batted shots work, the cut shots, the pull shots, almost the rounds back over your head down to fine leg third are a good option. But there's something in Perth, lovely place, Rottnest, great. Go and see a few quokkas. Wonderful kind of ferry over there. There's a few nice beaches and bars that are well worth visiting. But I think it's now time that we don't play cricket in Perth. Visit England side. What went wrong? Because it's very easy to actually draw quite a few parallels between some of the dismissals that we saw in the Test match a year ago and those sort of indeterminate, slightly timid strokes, as I mentioned to Harry Brook.
23:08Yeah, I think it was a good toss to win. So I'm going to give them that. But to be 60 off for eight, I keep hearing the word adaptability. You know, the captain himself keeps talking about adapting and reading the situation. In a World Cup, you don't get it all your own way. You get to a quarterfinal or a semifinal, you lose a toss and it starts zipping around what you're going to do as a team. Well, England have got under a year now to try and train their brains to understand that it's not always going to be in their favour. It's not always going to be a flat wicket where you can just bat naturally and get 330, 350, the odd occasion over 400, which they did in Pakistan. They're going to have to play a different style of cricket
23:47for the different conditions. And this was the perfect example where a modern one-day team is all about boundaries, getting off to a fly, really dominating, putting the ball under pressure. This was like a situation where you thought, oh, could you just play one-day cricket like in the 90s? You know, just try and be 85 for two after 25, 27, and then maximise the last 20-odd hours because you've got wickets in hand. cricket like in the 90s. You know, just try and be 85 for two after 25, 27, and then maximise the last 20-odd overs because you've got wickets in hand. They're going down to their, you know, their fourth, fifth bowling options. Massive outfield here in Perth. Then you can get to a 260, 280 right in the game.
24:16You get to that number. I don't see that enough from this whiteboard team. And over the course of the last couple of years, it's been a common trend that when they bat first, they've no idea of what a number is. When it's all their own way and they get off to a fly and they get those big big scores that all comes so naturally to this cricket team what doesn't come naturally to this team is when it's not in their favor and they have to really think of how they're going to get that number that's going to give them a chance I'm not saying that this is a kind of pitch that um 180 was going to be enough. Of course not. You've still got to look to be busy and you've got to run between the wickets
24:49hard and you've got to hit the bad ball. And you have to know you're scoring options on a pitch like we have here at the Perth Stadium. And England looked to me like they were playing a game and playing shots like we saw in Pakistan, driving on up because the wicket's skiddy and it's kind of flat. You can't play those shots in Perth. Two or three of them got out playing those big drives. Once you start losing wickets here and there's a lot of pressure on it, we're going back to 12 months ago in the ashes, I was not surprised to see England get bowled out. This adaptability is a problem because you can't keep talking about it. You can't keep saying as a team, we've got to adapt to the situation. We've got to adapt to
25:25conditions because with every game that you don't adapt, we've got to adapt to the situation, we've got to adapt to conditions because with every game that you don't adapt, it's a game closer to the World Cup and how can we trust that they're suddenly going to turn it on in the World Cup? England have won, in terms of men's cricket, 150 over World Cup and that was in 2019 and in 17, 18, 19, they had a group of players that completely understood the way that they were going to play as a group. This team don't know how they're going to play as a group. Every now and again, they play great, but too consistently, they play like they have done today, which is not reading the situation, not adapting.
25:54And they've got to turn that around quicker. They've got all the talent. You know, I can't argue about the person. I'll argue that Adam Shee should be in the side, but it wasn't the bowling that let England down today. What's going on with that? I've no idea. I just don't understand the England's greatest white ball. You could argue player. You could put Adam in the category of being our greatest white ball player because, you know, would England have won a World Cup without the leg spinner? Probably not. Would they have won the T20 World Cup in Melbourne without Rashid? Probably not. So he's been, you know, the one, you could argue player that England could not have replaced around the time that they were being so successful.
26:28So I put him right up there with the best white ball player. I don't know what he's done. He had that moment in Pakistan, was a part of that group that went for plenty. We haven't seen a great deal of him since last week in the one warm-up game. He got four wickets against WA. Yeah, whether they're trying Dawson just to see what the combination's like with that group of seam bowlers, they're not good enough to trial. They're not good enough to just test combinations at this stage. They've only got a handful of games left before that World Cup and if I was him, unless he's injured, unless he's lost his zip, which I don't think he has, Adil Rashid should be in this whiteboard team. Michael, with Australian cricket somewhat on its knees,
27:10was this a big opportunity, Mr. England, to actually get a little bit of momentum at the start of this talk? Yeah, yeah, it was. But it just shows you that a lot of these Australian whiteboard players, they weren't involved eight years ago. It's nothing to do with them. They're just getting on with their cricket. A very difficult cricket team to beat in their. They're just getting on with their cricket. They're a very difficult cricket team to beat in their own backyard and particularly here in Perth. They've got a really good record. A lot of the Australian side have played a lot of cricket here in Perth, so they understand the conditions, they understand the bounce, they understand the lengths
27:37that you have to bowl as a bowler, they understand the shots that are available on a pitch like this. So, yeah, we kind of missed an opportunity because we were hoping that Australia would be completely flat and dismantled with what's gone on over the last few days. They're tough cookies over here. You know, things like we're reading. I think back home in the UK when we have these headlines, front and back pages, it affects a lot of us. And that's understandable. But here in Australia, they seem to be made of something that's quite tough. They just got on with the cricket. What about the consistency in coaching? Because it feels to me like it's a bit of a rolling cast at times. I mean, Kevin Peterson is here at the moment, but then flies home on Monday.
28:16And you're never quite sure who's going to show up in the England training gear. Yeah, I just don't see any other team doing this. You know, this is, you know, 11 months away from a World Cup. I wouldn't see, you know, a World Cup football squad having a coach or two just nipping in and out. I think Kevin will be very good for English cricket. I really do. I think he's got an incredible cricket brain. I think he's a wonderful spokesperson about batting. But it is a bit loose. It's a bit relaxed. You know, Tim Souther didn't do the Triangler Series in Pakistan. Our white ball bowling coach, he was commentating in New Zealand for the New Zealand India T20 Series. So these are the decisions that Rob Keyes made
29:00and Baz McCullum. They're making those decisions, I guess, in a year's time in the World Cup. They'll have their moment because this is the group that's time in the World Cup, they'll have their moment, because this is the group that's going to see us through. They'll have that moment where they'll say, look, look at that, we've won a World Cup. Or they'll have a moment where they get knocked out and we'll go, did you get it right across the whole of the year when you're planning for this World Cup? And I guess when they're making decisions like they are making, they'll be challenged by doing that in a few months' time when the World Cup starts. Just finally, a star is born. Marley Beerman, 21 years old, six wickets.
29:32And this little stat today really underlined quite how good a performance it was. Six for 24 he took, and that is the joint best ever figures with England's greatest ODI bowling performance, Rhys Topley. So on his debut, he's managed to equal that. I mean, it was a brilliant bowling display. Yeah, I've seen a lot of him in the Big Bash and he's just got a manner of confidence, not arrogance. He's just got a real nice body language about the way that he plays his cricket. You know, I think back home in the UK, I think we're all thinking, oh, Stark will go soon, Cummings will go soon, Hazelwood will go soon, Lyon's going to go soon and Australia are going to be knackered. I think that's what all oh Stark will go soon Cummings will go soon Hazelwood will go soon Lyon's going to go soon
30:05and Australia are going to be knackered I think that's what all the England fans are thinking I've been here long enough to see a bit of Beardman I've seen Callum Biddler Jack Edwards who you've seen he's a really consistent performer Liam Scott's in this side again a consistent performer that can't get in this Australian side they've got enough talent here that are going to make the Australian side after Stark Hazelwood Cum here that are going to make the Australian side, after Stark, Hazelwood, Cummins and Lyon, just move to the side. I think they're going to have enough to be competitive. Will they take them to the top of the world? I'm not too sure, but they're certainly going to have a group of bowlers
30:37that are going to be competitive, which really **** me off. Well, there we go. Thank you, Michael, and thank you for tuning in to the Test Match Special podcast. You will not miss an episode if you subscribe on BBC Sounds or wherever you get your pods from. Don't forget, every ball of this White Bull series is available for you to listen to. The next game, early hours of Sunday morning from Adelaide, will be on air at 3.05 and bring you all the action from Adelaide Oval. Thank you to Michael Vaughan. And we'll wait and see what happens next, both on the field and off it, after a dramatic few days here down there. For more than a decade, British boxing has been shaped by two men. A crushing lip hook from Tyson Fury. Oh, what a man-offer from Anthony Joshua. British boxing has been shaped by two men.
31:30Two completely different personalities, two extraordinary careers, and one fight that just won't go away. There's never been a fight like this in the history of British boxing. Never. This is the story of how we got here. And how the AJ Fury rivalry redefined boxing forever. This will split the country. Half Fury fans, half AJ fans. Five Live Boxing, Fury v. Joshua. Listen on BBC Sounds. This is the story of the one. As a shipping manager, he's running the dock, stocking supplies, and making sure every order goes out on time. And Grainger helps him stay prepared. From shipping supplies, to PPE, to hand tools, he counts on Grainger to keep products moving and trucks rolling. So his operation runs smoothly, no matter the shift.
32:25Call 1-800-GRAINGER, click granger.com, or just stop by. Granger, for the ones who get it done. For getting work done, you've had to choose the focus of writing in a notebook or the efficiency of a laptop. The new Kindle Scribe digital notebook changes that. The feel and focus of paper, plus built-in AI for productivity. Change the way you work with the new Kindle Scribe.

