Small Town Murder · · Transcript & summary by WhipScribe
It is a dizzying true-crime story where a woman's serial marriages, a fake baby and a stomach-contents clue all lead to a small-town killing.
Tap a chapter to open that moment in the transcript; the link to it is copied for you.
“We're comedians. Murder is certainly going to happen.” James Petrigallo · at 6:56 — open in the transcript →
Jill Coit's life, as the hosts tell it, is a tangle of overlapping marriages, adoptions and invented babies. Raised partly in Louisiana and Indiana, she moved through a string of husbands, some weddings that happened before earlier divorces were final, and a Haitian divorce American courts never recognized. Her history was pieced together from books, an Oxygen documentary and newspaper archives, and the hosts stress how hard the names and dates are to follow.
Her last husband in Colorado, Jerry Boggs, ran the family hardware store in Steamboat Springs. After they married in 1991, Jill claimed a pregnancy and a baby who had died, and his brother Doug hired a private investigator who uncovered multiple birth certificates and aliases. In October 1993 Boggs was found beaten, shot and marked with stun-gun prints in his home. Detectives built the case from small pieces: two disguised strangers seen nearby, a stun gun that matched his neck, and a stomach-contents test that placed his death in the afternoon.
Jill and Michael Backus were tried together in 1995 after a change of venue and convicted of first-degree murder, receiving life without parole. The hosts also link the case to Clark Coit's unsolved 1972 shooting in Houston and to Jill's 2026 clemency bid. They frame the episode as crude comedy about a real crime, and say the victims are never the butt of the jokes.
Seth Coit, Jill Coit's son, testified under immunity that his mother asked for help killing or hiding the body of Jerry Boggs. He said he told her to wear gloves, and that she called him afterward saying it was done and messy.
“if you do anything stupid, wear gloves.”Seth Coit · 2:42:04
Jerry Boggs told Jill Coit that if she had a baby and it was his, she had better bring it to him quickly. He later said he had spent nine months expecting a child only to learn there was no baby.
“if you have a baby and it's mine, you better get it here real fast.”Jerry Boggs · 2:58:41
Carl Steely, Jill Coit's husband before Jerry Boggs, was asked how a stable man ended up marrying her. He said that if you met her and talked with her, you would think she was the greatest person you ever met.
“you'd think she's just the greatest person you ever met.”Carl Steely · 1:42:41
Michael Backus asked his co-worker Troy Giffen, a fellow Vietnam veteran, whether he would kill Jerry Boggs, offering $3,500 and later $7,500. Giffen refused both offers.
“Hey, you think you can kill Jerry for me?”Michael Backus · 2:37:38
Jerry Boggs, a Steamboat Springs hardware store owner, was beaten, shot and stun-gunned in his home in October 1993. Jill Coit and Michael Backus were convicted of first-degree murder in 1995 and sentenced to life without parole.
The hosts count roughly ten marriages for Jill Coit, though the count shifts by source. They include a teenage marriage in Indiana in 1961, a marriage to Stephen Moore, a 1966 marriage in Texas to Clark Coit, and a marriage to Louis DeRosa, while a Haitian divorce from DeRosa was never recognized in the United States. Jerry Boggs, a Steamboat Springs hardware store owner, was husband number eight or nine depending on the source.
Jerry Boggs, a Steamboat Springs hardware store owner, was killed in the utility room off his kitchen at his home on West Hillside Court. Police found him shot three times with a .22 pistol, beaten in the head with a shovel and marked with paired stun-gun prints on his neck. The hosts say the attack most likely happened on the afternoon of October 21, 1993, and his brother Doug Boggs found the body the next day after he failed to open the store.
Forensic botanists examined Jerry Boggs's stomach and found potato and onion, which plant matter survives digestion far better than protein. Because his usual breakfast at the Shack included hash browns but no onions, investigators checked the kitchen and found a cook had flipped the potatoes with an onion spatula. That fixed the death in the afternoon of October 21, which left Jill Coit little time to be where her camping alibi placed her.
Jill Coit and Michael Backus were convicted of first-degree murder and conspiracy in a joint trial in early 1995 and sentenced to life without parole, plus 48 years on the conspiracy count and a $1 million fine each. The trial had been moved from Routt County to Grand County after a survey showed too many local residents already believed she was guilty.
Seth Coit testified under immunity that his mother asked him to help kill Jerry Boggs or dispose of the body, and that he told her to wear gloves. He said she called him on October 21 and said it was done and messy, and that he bleached a blood-stained hat, cut it up and buried it. The hosts note that his testimony was damaging to his own record but he gave it anyway.
No. Clark Coit, a pipeline engineer, was found shot four times with a .22 in his Houston home on March 29, 1972, in the middle of his divorce from Jill Coit. A cashier's check of about $6,000 he had withdrawn was never found, and the hosts say the case remains unsolved and open. Jill was questioned but never charged, and the prosecution kept the 1972 killing out of the 1995 trial.
In June 2026 Jill Coit filed an application for executive clemency with the governor of Colorado, asking him to commute her sentence. She wrote that she was now in her 80s and blind, no longer physically capable of the life she once lived, and posed no meaningful risk to public safety. A district attorney from Routt County called the request an egregious betrayal of justice.
Our own transcript of the public episode, with a timestamp about every 90 seconds. Tap a timestamp or the link button on a paragraph to copy a link that opens this page there.
0:01Hey, everybody, just going to take a quick break from the show and tell you the only way to keep your feet comfy this winter with Bombas. Oh, Bombas.com. We love Bombas. The cold weather's back for most of us here in the world, and I'm not dreading it, though. We got this because this year we've got Bombas, and they make socks, slippers, footwear, everything. They're going to keep us all feeling good and soft and cozy all winter long. Everything they make is great for gifting, too, so no need to stress about the holidays. You've got it covered with Bombas. Bombas make slippers for staying cozy inside, and now they make footwear for going out and about as well. You can feel just like you feel at home,
0:41fuzzy, like fuzzy Sunday slippers in the house. And then they have water-resistant suede booties that can handle the winter and feel just as good as the slippers. They're amazing. You're going to love it. You're going to love how cushy and supportive these Bombas slippers are. They're so good. Perfect for a nice Sunday cold day in the house, something like that. And you've got to wear the Bombas moccasins, the suede. They're so nice outside. They're so good. You're going to think you're wearing slippers. That's what you're going to think. Did I go out in my slippers? And then you go, no, no, I have shoes on like an adult. That's good. These are my Bombas. That's good. Bombas socks, too. Oh, my goodness.
1:14Winter, they got it covered. Merino wool and cashmere blend socks for warmth, fuzzy socks, and plush gripper socks for cozy home vibes. You're going to love that. And during winter, you got to get a whole uniform for coziness. That's the whole thing here. Socks, that's going to be the most important thing in the whole deal. I love the socks. And Bombas are non-negotiable if you want to be cozy in your own house here. And if you're looking for gifts this season, Bombas has something for everyone. Cozy socks and slippers, cushy footwear that can take on winter, sports socks for runners and skiers alike. You can find something for everyone on your list. And if I can get all my holiday shopping done in one place,
1:52that's a win, I think, right there. And at Bombas, I can find something for everybody. I can find something for my brother and his wife. Everybody on your holiday list. I can do it. And I know they're going to like it. I know they're going to love it, as a matter of fact. By the way, your first layer should be your comfiest layer. Bombas makes buttery and breathable underwear that feel like nothing is on under your clothes, plus t-shirts that feel so soft and fit just right. And the best part about all of this, about Bombas, is for every item you purchase, they donate an essential clothing item to someone facing housing insecurity. One purchased equals one donated with over 200 million donations and counting.
2:31You can join that list as well. Head over to Bombas.com slash smalltownmurder and use the code smalltownmurder for 20% off your first purchase. That's B-O-M-B-A-S dot com slash smalltownmurder. Code smalltownmurder at checkout. Now back to the show. 5 a.m. I'm up with a crisp Celsius energy drink. Running 12 miles today. Grab a green juice, quick change, and head to work. Meetings. Workshops. One more Celsius. No slowing down. Working late, but obviously still meeting the girls for a little dancing. Celsius. Live. Fit. Go. Grab a cold, refreshing Celsius at your local retailer or locate now at Celsius.com. This week in Steamboat Springs, Colorado, more than 10 marriages, affairs, and strange behavior culminates with multiple murders and a web of lies to untangle, including a person involving
3:25their own son in a vicious murder plot. Welcome to Small Town Murder. Hello, everybody, and welcome back to Small Town Murder. Yay! Yay, indeed. My name is James Petrigallo. I'm here with my co-host. I'm Jimmy Wissman. Thank you, folks, so much for joining us today on another insane, absolutely crazy story here. This is one that we've had on the docket for about eight years. We've had this one up there and it's one of those where it's so complicated. It's like, man, I'll get to that one of these days. We'll untangle that one of these days. And today is the day. It's a crazy, crazy story. Can't wait to get into it. Before we do that though, head over to shutupandgivememurder.com. Get your tickets for the last two live shows
4:26of the year. Actually, the last one, we'll say, because Tarrytown on November 13th looks like it's about sold out. So I don't know if you can get into that. You can check. Maybe something will become available. But the next night, November the 14th, Medford, Massachusetts, right outside Boston at the Chevalier Theater. Get your tickets right now. Last show of the year. We're going out with a bang, everybody. It's going to be fun. Can't wait to do that. And then very soon, next year's schedule will be announced in the next couple weeks, and then they'll go on sale in December, so you can get your 2027 tickets as holiday gifts or whatever you want to do. So do that. Shut up and give me murder.com.
5:04Also, get Patreon, everyone. Yes. Let's go. Patreon.com, P-A-T-R-E-O-N.com slash crimeinsports, just like the name of our other show that you should probably check out because it's really good. But that is where you get all the bonus material. And we are chock full of bonus material. Let me tell you guys. Anybody $5 a month or above, you get everything we put out. I'm talking about everything. As soon as you subscribe, you're going to get almost 400 back bonus episodes. You can binge on those. You get those as soon as you subscribe. Then you get new ones every other week. One crime and sports and one small town murder. And you get them all, everybody. Just take them. Wow. Take them, damn it.
5:44This week for crime and sports we're going to talk about a little bit of history of the harlem globetrotters which is one of those things if you grew up in a certain time it's uh just this weird legendary team they're not in a league they go around no beating the hell out of this same team all the time but like it's very interesting it's a they're iconic it's They're hanging out on Gilligan's Island. It's just a beautiful story, I think. It's really wild stuff. So we'll talk about that. Then for Small Town Murder, we are going to talk about how the Nazis, like actual World War II Nazis, led to the LSD craze of the 1960s. And how the Nazis helped create the hippie movement, let's just say. Not on purpose, but it happened.
6:26So we'll talk about all that. That is patreon.com slash crimeinsports is where you get all that and more. Because in addition to that, that would be enough. But we say, no, it's not. Damn it. You also get all the shows we put out. Crime and Sports, Your Stupid Opinions, and both Small Town Murders Every Week. All ad-free, too. Ad-free, Jimmy. Unbelievable. We're doing it. We're giving it away. Take it ad-free. And then on top of that, you get-free, too. Ad-free, Jimmy. Unbelievable. We're doing it. We're giving it away. Take it ad-free. And then on top of that, you get a shout-out at the end of the show, too. You bet. You can't beat it. There we go. That said, disclaimer time. This is a comedy show, everybody.
6:56We're comedians. Murder is certainly going to happen. It's the name of the show, and it's going on, and we're going to talk about it. And you might go, well, how does that work? How do you mix murder and comedy? Very carefully is how it goes. And it's not that complicated, actually. No. And as complicated as you think, as a matter of fact, we, you know, we make fun of a small town. Who cares? You know, we're all from somewhere that deserves to be made fun of. Let's have a sense of humor about ourselves. Who gives a shit? Who cares? We make fun of some police force that can't quite catch a murderer, even though there's evidence there, and then they go off and kill more people. We make fun of murderers.
7:30Yeah. What else can we do to them? What can we do to them otherwise? We can't take their honey buns away in jail, so all we can do is mock them from a safe distance, and that's what we're doing here. But what we don't do, what we never do, is we never make fun of the victims or the victims' families. Why, James? Because we're assholes. But? But we're not scumbags. See how that works? It's very simple there. So if that sounds good to you, you're going to hear one hell of a wild story. Come on. If you think true crime and comedy should never, ever, ever go together, you clicked on an odd podcast. Bizarre choice. Give it a chance and see what you think. But either way, no complaining later. Let's just say that.
8:09There's the answer. That's the thing there. There you go. So that said, I think it's time, everybody, to sit back. What do you say here? Clear the lungs here. Arms to the sky. Let's all shout. Shut up and give me murder. let's all shout shut up and give me murder let's do this everybody okay let's go on a trip shall we we'll go skipping through the woods where are we going going to Steamboat Springs, Colorado yeah Ricky the Dragon Steamboat Springs, Colorado it's beautiful nice looks like beautiful country up there ski country up there. Fucking A. Northwestern Colorado. About two hours and 50 minutes down to Denver. About three hours to Cheyenne, Wyoming. So it's in that area. Three hours and 20 minutes to our last Colorado episode,
9:01Whitewater, Colorado. Oh, wow. Which was episode 709, Like an Evil Onion, that was. So it was a crazy one. This is in, is it Routt County, Jimmy? You're a Colorado guy. R-O-U-T-T? Route, Routt County, one of those. I don't know the names of the counties, to be honest. There's a lot. It's rural up there, too, so who knows. But R-O-U-T-T, either way. It's probably Routt. Who knows? Area code 970. Nickname of this town. It is apt. SkiTown, USA. You bet. There it goes. That's what's going on here. A little bit of history. Trappers started coming to the area in the early 1800s. Those trappers were crazy people. They'd come from the east and just like half of them were just loners, too. They just go out in the mountains by themselves and come back with pelts like they were crazy
9:52people. And they go out into like the most just desolate areas where the where the most dangerous animals live. Yeah. And they're like, well, let's see if I can kill that. That'll be an expensive help. Yeah. If I can kill that dangerous thing, someone will want to wear that as a like, well, let's see if I can kill that. That'll be an expensive help. I'll kill it. Yeah. If I can kill that dangerous thing, someone will want to wear that as a jacket, probably, I think. Wow. So, James Harvey Crawford was the founder of Steamboat Springs, of the town. He arrived in 1874. He liked the region's mineral waters, so he built a cabin near Iron Spring, what is now Iron Spring, and a log shelter over the nearby Hot Springs.
10:27Spent a little bit of time here back and forth in Boulder and everything, and he was trying to get businessmen to join him in organizing the town site company. Basically, let's make some money here in 1884. So by 1885, they got five other families to settle in the area, including a newspaper guy who brought his printing press and started publishing the Steamboat Pilot, which went on. I don't know if it's still available, but I got a ton of quotes from the Steamboat Pilot that was going on during this murder. It is amazing how not that long ago this was established. Yeah, no, it's not that in the terms of history. It's really not that long ago this was established. Yeah, no, it's not that. In the terms of history, it's really not that long at all.
11:09Yeah. So it came slowly. The development came kind of slowly. They got a sawmill in 1883. Some people came. That's kind of how it worked there. The native Utes that were from here were forcibly removed from the area to a reservation in Utah by the U.S. Army starting in 1879. Sent them to Utah. Yes. Put the Utes in Utah. Yeah. So they had all this type of shit. Now, skiing is the big deal. Now, originally, skiing was literally necessity. There was no other way to get around up there. That's how you got A to up there that's how you got a to b that's how you got places during the winter was fucking skiing because horses and deep snow don't do well as we remember from the donner party right um thing that we in patreon we
11:55did yeah they they don't move very well and they just fall in the snow so they started doing it for that and then it became kind of a popular thing. And then in the 1910s, a guy named Carl Howelson, a Norwegian guy, got here, and he started showing people how to ski jump. And then it became a recreation. This is what we do. Yeah. We have fun with it a little bit. This is how we get place to place in Norway. Yeah. We got to jump over shit to get to other shit. So people got into that. And, you know, people that moved out west back then were kind of a chance-taking type. So they would jump off a thing on skis. Those are the people who would do it. Dangerous folks. Then tourists started coming because people were looking for good places to ski.
12:40By the 1960s, Storm Mountain is developed as a resort. And then it's really kicking into action here. Oh boy, it's about to boom, babe. And it booms hard. Reviews of this town, here is five stars. Okay. Steamboat is such a fun, happy town. That's nice. It's such a small town that the community is super tight-knit and everyone knows everyone. Yeah, you forget that people get to live here. Yeah. They stay there. It's one of those things all the tourists come, but then when they leave, there's still this group of people. It's smaller. Here's four stars. Steamboat Springs thrives on tourism with its worldwide known ski resort and champagne powder snow. What the hell is champagne powder snow i guess fancy good bubbly bubbly effervescent effervescent that's what we're talking about
13:32it's a great little town full of life from all the people and surrounded by national forest and all the animals that call it home right all right that's not bad. Here is two stars. We've been touring all over the United States, went to welcome center. She was not as helpful as we not helpful as we were new to the area. Not very welcoming at the welcome center. So I never imagined we go to a lot of places. Do we ever go, well, where's the welcome center? And have we ever gotten to look for a welcome center? I've been to gone and looked for a welcome center? I've been to one in my life, and it was because I knew there was a bathroom there and I had to piss. They will let a tourist piss in here.
14:12Yeah. Yeah, maybe in like Sedona or something you go to. That's where it was. Yeah, that's exactly, I think, where I've pissed, too. We've both pissed in the same one. I was like, I don't think I can make it to the village. I got to stop here. Got all those pamphlets outside. That's the one. Told many bike trails and restaurants along the riverside and things to do. Map was not helpful as we were new visiting. People in town were not friendly, even mean. Wow. Learn how to read a map. Oh, shit. We were going to stay a couple days, but left after so many mean people in town and restaurants looked awful. It's 2024. You don't even have to read a map. Christ, that's where the review is from. You got a phone, man.
14:52Right? Here is one star, finally. Okay. They hate it here. I hate it. This is the worst place ever. Because of the natural sulfur springs throughout the town, the place smells like an open sewer. That's nice. That is bad. I don't care how beautiful it is. If it smells like an egg fart, I'm not hanging out here. What are we talking about? Natural springs are not, like people think it's like an avion that pours out of water or pours out of rocks. Natural springs have lots of minerals in them. Tons of them, yep. And it all smells bad. God, it's so bad that it's so bad it is hard to eat at the few awful restaurants that exist. Is it that bad in town? Apparently. The town is also known for its lack of police.
15:35Is it known for that? That sounds awesome. Yeah, that's good. You should be happy about that. The few law enforcement officers who are somewhere in the town have been told by the mayor to leave the drunk tourists and locals alone. Okay. Great. Yeah, this is what we do here. We drink and party and leave them the fuck alone. It's like New Orleans, basically. Unless they piss in the street, let them do anything. Anything. I was in Vegas last weekend, James. You know how many cops I saw? Zero. Yeah. That's how it's supposed to be. Well, yeah. Well, also, too, because the casinos are all their own police forces. Oh, yeah. They probably got their own muscle in there. Insane security forces. Do they have jails underneath those?
16:14They probably do. I don't know. Is it like the Philly? Is it the veteran stadium of? Right. I'm not sure. This place is dangerous. This is a town not suited for families, especially with children. We locals call the place the dingy because it's so dull and boring. No culture or sights to see. Doesn't even look or feel like Colorado. More like Wyoming. I hope I have saved someone the time and money or worse, a wasted vacation. But what if you love to ski? Yeah, right. And everything up there from Boulder up to Wyoming is non-discernable. Yeah, it's all. It all looks the same. Yeah. All the way to Cheyenne. Absolutely. It's just mountains, babe. Enjoy it. Just look at the mountains. People in this town, 13,193.
17:06Not very big. That seems like a lot. More men than women. It's blown up a lot recently. 51% men, which normally it's the other way around. I don't know if that's the outdoor shit or that's probably part of it. Median age, 39.8, which is like a year older than the national average. And everything's kind of average. 50-50 unmar a year older than the national average and everything's kind of average 50 50 unmarried which is the national average all that's pretty average uh race in this town 87.8 percent white uh 1.1 percent black 1.2 percent asian 9.3 percent hispanic um religion here 29 religious it's usually 50 50 here it's 29%, and that's pretty low. And the highest one is Catholic, actually, as we wouldn't have known. Yeah, Catholic. Catholics are, as we
17:54know, the Baptists of the Rocky Mountain region, I guess. I don't know. Yeah. I mean, there are a lot of Catholic churches, now that I think about it, in the areas that I've been. I think of the places that you spend a lot of time in. Yeah. Anything that used to be Mexico or Mexico adjacent, too. There's a lot of Catholicism there. I guess that makes sense. Arizona, New Mexico, California. There's a lot of Catholicism there. I mean, I grew up when I was in Colorado in the Springs area. There was Catholic churches. I was born in a hospital called St. Francis, James. There you go. I think everybody was born in a St. Something. St. Some shit. They're not that anymore. Unemployment in this town is low, actually.
18:36It's a tourist town. If you want to work, there's work. I don't know if it's good jobs, but the median household income here is higher than the national average. It's $80,660 for the household, which isn't bad. And you fucking need it because let me tell you something. Cost of living here, wow. Outrageous. 100 is regular. Here it's 138, number one. Wow. But the real high thing is home cost. Holy shit. Median home cost here, $1,040,500. That is median. Median. They are out of their fucking minds. To live in Steamboat? To live in Steamboat Springs smelling egg farts the whole time. Not even Hooray. Not even Aspen. If we've convinced you that you want to smell egg farts all the time and pay a lot of money for it,
19:26we have for you the Steamboat Springs, Colorado real estate report. Two-bedroom rental here averaged $1,970, which is above the average. That might be the way to go. I think it is because wait till I tell you this. Just piss your money away on rent, because you can't afford it. House number one here is a two-story log cabin with a green metal roof on it. It's not the prettiest looking structure I've ever seen in my life. Real small Bass Pro. Looks like a mountain welcome center, is what it looks like. Exactly like that. Two-bedroom, two bath. Technically T-Bowl for each and every B-Hole. 1,136 square feet. It looks like the forest has exploded in your living room. Wood ceilings, wood walls, wood floors, wood everything.
20:15It's wood all. Floor to ceiling, wood. All wood. 7.39 acres. So that's nice. $899,000. That's the. 900 grand. That's the... 900 grand. That's the cheapest available property in Steamboat Springs. Oh my God. The cheapest. The next one has a picture of the house and in the foreground, there's a fucking giant elk in it. So watch out for those. Yeah, that's how they suck. This thing looks like... It's got like a silo on it. It looks like a rusted out, like what they would store like a coal in or something. It's the weirdest, ugliest looking house. Oh, in the silo? There's a silo that's got rust all over it, but it's connected to the house, which looks like it hasn't had occupants in it for 200 years.
20:59It's crazy looking. Three bedroom, three bath, T-bulb for each and every B-hole, 1,890 square feet on .65 acres. Just over half. It's on a mountain with a good view, $1,675,000. A million and a half for half an acre. An 1,800 square foot house that's hideous on no land. But you got elk. Then you got an elk. And then finally, seven bedrooms, nine baths, T-Bolt for each and every b-hole, 8,619 square feet, 144 acre lot. Yeah. 144 acre. You own a big pasture and a mountain and everything else. $24,499,990. But $25 million. Good news, $200,000 price cut just happened. So everybody, now it's going to move right off that market. Now it's going to move, baby. Is it 2%? What is that? Is that one? I don't know.
22:00That's not enough money. Not even. It's 0.01 or something. I don't even know. So it'd be 2%, I think. So things to do here. Ski, ski's not enough money. Not even. It's 0.01 or something. I don't even know. So, yeah, it'd be 2%, I think. So, things to do here. Ski, ski, ski, people. Yeah. Get your ski on. That's it. Also. Oh, yeah. The Steamboat Springs Music Fest is there as well. They've got to have great shit. We'll find out. 65 plus artists here. Oh. All sorts across all genres. I'm going to read off the bands. There's a lot of them. American Aquarium. They're great. Okay. Andy Hedges. No idea. Ashton Naylor. The Band of Heathens. They're great. B.J. Barnum. Brie Bagwell. That's the guy from American Aquarium.
22:45He's going to do some solo shit too. From America. B.J. Barnum, Brie Bagwell. That's the guy from American Aquarium. He's going to do some solo shit, too. Oh, when you said that, I forgot that that was a band, and I was thinking, I was like, what, some guy from an aquarium show? One of those aquarium shows that were on a few years ago. I was like, what the fuck is he doing here? I think that's his last name. Bruce Robison, Cameron Albright, Karen Mary, Colton Mortensen. Gee, I wonder what he plays. You know what every one of these people play. Courtney Patton, Cypress Valley Band, Dalton Domino, Fats is kid. Is it two different people? Dalton and Domino? No, it's the same one guy. David Lewis, DJ DU,
23:31Django Walker, Dos Barachos. Dos Barachos featuring Kevin Fowler and Roger Krieger, who sound very Spanish. Down Hazy, Hank Weaver, Hayden Wiginton, Hazy, Hank, Weaver, Hayden, Wiginton, Hudson, Westbrook, Jack Ingram, Jackson, Wendell, Jared Morris, Jason, Allen, Jason, Edie, Jordan, Nix, Josh Ward, Josh Weathers, Juliana Rankin, Kat, Hayden, It's all J's! Kurt Kaus, it is, the Crews Brothers, Logan, Ryan, are you getting the picture here? Oh, it's alphabetical. Yeah, yeah. The Midnight River Choir. The Ransom Brothers. The Smokin' Oaks. I'm just looking for a different one. Uncle Lucius will be there. Oh, yeah, he's very popular. Green Decade Club. And the Wilder Blue. There's a million others I didn't mention, but that's enough here.
24:23Crime Raid. American Aquarium's got to be headlining that. They're terrific. Who the fuck knows what they're – well, they were first based on alphabetical, so. Your headliner's got the A. That's good. Yeah, they say including American Aquarium, BJ Barnum, Pat Green, Reckless Kelly. Those are the ones that are really pushing. Pat Green's good. So crime rate in this town. Yeah. Property crime right at average. All right. By the way, you got to stop signing off on people you don't know about because then you end up with our fucking, you end up with certain people that we've fucking had issues with. Pat Green's a great writer, though. Doesn't matter. He's written a lot of very popular songs. He's going to write like a fucking pro-Hitler manifesto in three days and Jimmy's got to have to take it back.
25:04I'm pretty sure he's the guy that wrote that Little Red Rodeo song that we did from a long time ago. Yeah, yeah. That was a crime and sports episode, wasn't it? Oh, wow. I think it was. Was it? I think it was. Crime rate in this town, what we're interested in, property crime, right at average. Wow. Right at average. Violent crime, murder, rape, robbery, and of course assault, the Mount Rushmore of crime is about a quarter under the national average. So the property crime in a tourist town is usually average or a little higher because, you know, people do dumb shit. But you're on vacation, yeah. Yeah, what are you going to do? You're going to piss on something or, you know, punch a guy because you've had too many daiquiris or whatever you're drinking on vacation.
25:44Let's talk about some murder, everybody. What say all right we're gonna go back way back in time to start this bad boy out and it is gonna come right up to today so it's fun 1800s not that far no it's a guy with a coon skin hat killing a guy with a trapper a big fringy fucking buckskin jacket on there's a lot of them a lot of those. A lot of those, yeah. That's just the Denver airport. They're still wearing them, James. That's just the Denver airport, my friend. People in Denver dress crazy. It's fucking crazy. It's like, I like Brown, but I also... When they were dressed like assholes when they drove that Lamborghini, that's how they dress. That's how they dress. That's it. March 29th, 1972, we're going to start out.
26:29And let's talk about a guy here. And by the way, people have heard this story before that we're going to tell. If you're a true crime aficionado, you've probably heard this story. We're going to try to tell it as different and awesome as we possibly can. But it's been in a bunch of documentaries and news type things and all sorts of shit. So March 29th, 1972, William Clark Coit Jr. C-O-I-T is Coit. He goes by Clark. Okay. Clark Coit. He lives in Houston where he is found in a utility room just off his kitchen by his wife. So his wife, he's in his late 30s. His wife's in her mid-20s. She comes home and finds him shot three times in the back with a .22 caliber weapon. Yeah, rarely suicide like that.
27:23Hard to do. Very difficult. Yeah. There's no forced entry. It was clear that someone was already in the house when he came home and had to have done it that way probably and kind of attacked him and ambushed him. Now, like we said, his young wife, who is the mother of their two and actually three because she had a previous son that he just adopted. Oh. Mother of his kids and his wife is here and she's the one who finds him and calls the police. They have not been doing well and they're actually three weeks away from their final divorce from the divorce ending the marriage here and a couple weeks before this Clark had withdrawn a substantial sum of money from his accounts and told his friends that he did it to keep
28:10his wife from getting it, basically. Now, the money he pulled out of the bank was never found, either. They don't know where it is. It's gone. So... Forever? They never found it. To the annals of time. Who knows? It could be buried in the hills like Tra the annals of time. Who knows? Yeah, it could be buried in the hills like Trapper's Gold or something. Who knows? So Curly's looking for it. That's what's going on right now. Buried under the Astros field. Yeah, that's maybe where it is. So the investigation, they immediately look at the wife here because obviously they're headed toward a divorce. She's the one that found the body and it's kind of they're headed toward a divorce. She's the one
28:45that found the body and it's kind of an acrimonious divorce. And we got words from his friend saying he's taking out money to keep it from her. Yeah, so they're like, let's take a look at his wife. Now, his wife's name is Jill Coit at the time, C-O-I-T. She's born Jill Lonita, Lonita, Billiot, which sounds like a mix of hillbilly and idiot. You goddamn billiott. That really sounds like that, doesn't it? Hillbilly it. So Jill, she's born June 11th, and we'll find out why soon. Either 1943 or 1944. Oh. It's so crazy. The fucking like state and the federal government don't know what day it was. Between 43 and 44. Yeah, and she wasn't born like in a, you know, in an island somewhere while people were on vacation and they had no
29:41watches or clocks or anything. Home birth or some shit. None of that shit. She's born in a normal situation. We'll find out why. It's because she has washed herself over so many times that the records are kind of shaky. Really? She's born in Lafitte, which is a small town south of New Orleans. Yeah, Louisiana. When you say south of New Orleans, you're talking. How do you do that? Yep. Are you? Do you have gills? What the fuck? This is like Houma that we did. Houma, Louisiana was like that south of. I mean, those people are in the mud. Oh, they are. You can't even understand those people. Yeah. Boy, oh boy. Hey, everybody. Just going to take a quick break from the show and tell you a much better way to bank with Chime.
30:29Chime.com. Oh, you got to get that Chime card, everybody. I'm telling you. Let's talk about it. Can we talk about how this is the most expensive time of the year? The flights and presents and the groceries and people coming over. But with 5% cash back with a chime card, it'll be the most rewarding time of the year. You are going to love it. I'm telling you, because holidays are great, but it's expensive. It's tough. I'm telling you, look at everything. Let's talk about groceries, first of all, here. If you're putting off planning that big holiday dinner, just know that with a chime card, you can get 5% cash back on all those groceries. But be careful, though, because you might want to just impress your in-laws here because, you know,
31:10you're getting a little break here, especially when they find out the cash back is on a monthly category of your choice. You can do gas, you can do groceries, you can do whatever. It's really cool. 5% cash back on monthly selected category of your choice. Restaurants, travel, rides, bills, gas, groceries. You pick it. They do it. Plus, they help you build credit. It's awesome. That helps a lot. Fee-free banking. That is the main thing. Fee-free, everybody. You shouldn't have to pay fees. It's silly, honestly. It's very, very silly. That's right. That's what I'm talking about. You got to get this, the eligible purchases. You can get the 5% cash back. Fee-free. I mean, why not? What have you got to lose here except fees and old banking that you don't need?
31:53Yeah, your money is all you have to lose. That's why Chime is America's number one choice for banking. Head to Chime.com slash Small Town Murder. That is Chime.com slash Small Town Murder. Sign up now. It only takes a few minutes. Chime feels like progress. Now, back to the show. Hey, everybody. Just going to take a quick break from the show and tell you the only place you should be buying your clothes at Quince. Q-U-I-N-C-E dot com. Quince. Absolutely. Get those pieces that you count on. The best stuff in your closet. The ones you just, you know, you go to it time after time, whether you're heading to work, you're going out, or just keeping things casual. And this time of year, Quince makes finding something great for everyone else just as easy.
32:49This holiday season, it's where we're going to be shopping for both ourselves and everyone else on the list. Well, we'll start with everyone else and we'll end up buying ourselves a bunch of stuff. Because it's impossible to go on Quince's site and not find stuff that you're going to love. So it's awesome. Quince focuses on high quality staples made with premium materials like 100% Mongolian cashmere, 14 karat gold and Italian leather, all timeless, versatile pieces that feel special to unwrap. You know what I mean? And become everyday favorites long after the holidays. Their cashmere sweaters start at just $60 and the lineup doesn't stop there. Premium down jackets, wool outerwear and cashmere accessories. Everything you and your loved ones
33:30need to stay warm and look put together all season long. Everything at Quince is priced 50 to 80% less than similar brands. And you go, well, how does that work? Is it how is it junky stuff? No, it's insanely high quality stuff what they do is they work directly with ethical factories and they cut out the middleman that's where the markup is get rid of that so you get luxury quality pieces without that luxury price tag and that's what it's all about telling you all my stuff comes from quince now i love it oh their shirt selection unbelievable sweaters jackets it's incredible and we got this comforter from there is the softest I love it. Oh, their shirt selection, unbelievable. Sweaters, jackets.
34:06It's incredible. And we got this comforter from there. It is the softest, most amazing comforter. It's incredible. Everything they have is super high quality. And when it comes to gifting, Quince has a lot more than clothing. Think fine jewelry, leather bags, hotel quality bedding, chef-grade cookware, and five-star luggage. Basically, plenty of ways to find something special for everyone on your list. Give the gift of quality this season. Download the Quince app for app-exclusive offers, or go to quince.com. Get free shipping on your order and 365-day returns, now available in Canada and the UK, too. And when Quince asks you where you heard about them, let them know it was small town murder. It's the best way to support
34:48the show. Now back to the show. Her father, Henry Albert Billiott, was a New Orleans towboat captain. Oh. So he worked all the waterways and owned his own business, Billiott Tugboat. Yep. Yep. Her father traces his ancestry all the way back to the Homa Indians in this area. So he's been here a long time. Now, her upbringing wasn't anything crazy. See, this is the thing. Something had to have happened. Now, we don't know what it was because it was in the 40s and 50s. And in the 40s and 50s, if bad shit happened to a kid, they didn't like send them to a counselor and it was all written down. They just said, shut up and deal with it. At least at least the war's over. That's what you literally at least at least the war's over.
35:34Shut up. You think you got it hard. I grew up in the 20s. Yeah, I grew up through the Depression. And yeah, what do you want here? So we dropped a bomb on Japan for you. Shut up. You know, that's what they would say. So we don't know what happened. All we do know is that in school, she, her grades suck, but she's real popular. She's a popular girl with bad grades. Um, those usually go hand in hand for sometimes bad kid. That's the problem. And,'s very attractive, which obviously gets the attention of the boys, but apparently not the teachers here enough to give her anything. She's described in a book that we'll talk about all the books and everything we reference at the end of the show because there's a lot of sources here, just a ton of sources.
36:32In the book, she's described as a young woman with a beautiful peachy type of complexion and dark hair. And who would lean into saying that she was part Native American a lot, too. She loved saying that shit. There are so many people that can't wait to tell you they're 4% Cherokee. It's fucking insane. I don't know what it is. And it was more popular back then. Yeah. 50s, 60s, 70s. That was considered like exotic almost. But they're like, yeah, I'm 2% Cherokee. Okay, great. Congratulations. That's fine. But what do you care? It's weird. And all that does for most people is makes their skin tone fucking awesome. Look great. Yeah. Nice hair. They tan real good. Someone will say, you have nice hair.
37:12They'll go, I'm 3% fucking Chippewa. So, yeah, obviously, that's where my hair comes from. That's why I don't have hair on my shoulders like you, you fucking caveman. That's what it is. Jeez. I haven't got rid of that yet. So at some point, she, this is funny, she had, I guess, won a beauty contest. Oh. Which, and this is a crazy title. This is in Louisiana. They call her this. I could get if this was in like Alaska or something, but she wins the title of Miss Eskimo Pie. Okay. Which, that sounds very sexual, right? Or incredibly insensitive and sexual. Yeah. You're really making fun of a girl who's been nice to a lot of young men. That's what it sounds like. Miss Eskimo Pie sounds like if you squeezed her, jizz would shoot out of her ears.
38:04It sounds terrible. What was an Eskimo Pie? like if you squeezed her jizz would shoot out of her ears it sounds terrible what was an Eskimo pie it was was it an ice cream I think it was ice cream some sign of some kind of treat of some kind before our time I think though right yeah it's a 50s thing it's a exactly sock hops and it went the way of the way of the side. You got it, man. Yeah. Now, apparently, we don't know why she left. There's some people that say she had a fight with her brother or we don't know what happened, but she left home around 15 to go stay with her grandparents in Indiana. So we know from her sophomore year on, she's in Indiana for a bit here. She went to North Manchester High.
38:51And, I mean, she gets there and I'll read from another book here. Quote, and I'll give you the title of that and the vivaciousness, her southern accent, and the exotic locale of her former home that made the local teenage males sit up and pay attention. She was charming. Yeah. Interesting. And different is big, especially in a small town. You've known all these girls since the second grade. All of them. Which is very interesting because that's like the last thing you want to be as a teenager. New? Different. Everybody wants to just fit in and be, and you can see it today so much. It works for hot women though. Yeah. Like everything else it doesn't work for anybody with hot women. For a hot woman different is just because because they're looking boys don't care about anything else except your looks at 15. They really don't. They don't care what you're into. They don't care. They might pretend to listen to your poetry or whatever. They don't give a shit. tits. Exactly. And for them back then, I think the different factor comes from I haven't known this chick since kindergarten.
40:10Yeah. And so she's new. So it's like all of my friends haven't gone out with her already. Right. There's a different like an exoticness. She wasn't there that day. I was pantsed. Yeah. She didn't see that. She didn't see when they ran my underwear up the flagpole. That is totally off her radar and threw my fucking shoes over the fucking power lines. We didn't see any of that. They flushed my bomber jacket down the toilet. Started the, like the old Bill Cosby joke, started with the sleeve and fed it in there. God, that's funny from the 60s. So anyway, so yeah, all the guys like her. She's got a southern accent. She's different than the girls around here. And one of the, I guess her best friend
40:51in high school said all the boys were attracted to her like a magnet. And of course, most of the girls hated her for that reason. Yep. And also, she's kind of a bitch too, which is, as we'll get into. She's got an attitude. Yeah. She doesn't have a lot of women friends over time, which is an interesting factor. July 24th, 1961 here. Okay. She's not done with school yet. Yet she drops out and gets married. Okay. Which in 1961 was considered real romantic. real romantic and you know oh hope those kids do i hope those kids do well you know it's teenage wedding then the old folks wished them well type of shit you know that's what it is so she eloped with a guy named larry in him in him i h n e n in him in it that's a horrible name. Inen. She's like, I'd like to be Jill Inen.
41:48Inen. I want people to blink when they look at my name. What the fuck is your name again? Let's guess it's better than Hillbilly it. So she'll take it. But where's the rest of your letters, Jill? Where's the rest of you? That's what it is so um eventually she would say because someone asked her later like what the fuck why'd you get married so young why'd you do all that she said quote I was raised that women were to entertain to get married and have babies wow so that's what you want to do fine but that first word is real humiliating. She sounds like fucking Andrew Tate or something like what a weird horrible sentence. What a weird thing for a woman to say. So anyway, the kids, man, what a life you're living in Indiana.
42:38You're married to some kid who just, you know, is still in high school. And you move right into the trailer park on the outskirts of Manchester. Manchester, Indiana? Indiana. Where even is that? That's the point. It's crazy. Larry went to work laying bricks, which is hard work. You know, nothing wrong with that, but it's hard work, you know. It's building the outside of a building. Yeah, it's hard. I mean, it's a good skill to Masonry can do fine for you, but Jill got a job at the Heckman bindery. That sounds nice too. I guess that's what it is, but I guess a lot of people work there. You can go there and get a job. It's one of the places you can go. This does not last long here. No, absolutely not.
43:27It doesn't last a year, this marriage. It's a mess. Yeah, this sounds like someone who just wanted to get out of her grandparents' house and go wherever. So now Larry wanted a divorce citing cruel and inhumane treatment from Jill. From her, not from him. From her, yeah, that's what he said. So she got a restraining order against him. And he said, well, no, I want one against her because she's the one who's fucking nuts. So they went back and forth like that. And who knows who's right and who's wrong. It's two 18-year-olds married. In 1962. Yeah, they're coming. He's got like a fucking duck bill in his hair and his fucking cigarettes rolled up in his shirt sleeve and a leather jacket on trying to look like John Travolta in Grease.
44:10It's wild. It's a mess. So the divorce was granted in 1962. And I guess Larry was the one who initially put in for the divorce. So he is granted. When Jill left, she took all the money he had that he had saved up as a Mason's assistant, which was $280. Okay. She just took it all. That was his life savings. So he was very upset. But back then he was making like, you know, $1.80 an hour or something. So that's big money. I bet it was less than that. Maybe even less than that so that's big money. I bet it was less than that. Maybe even less than that. That's big money. So 1964, 1965. Okay. Jill heads back down south. We never hear from In-N-Again. It's over for him. In-N's gone. He's got to go make his 280 back.
45:00In-N-Out is what he is. Gone. So Jill goes back. In-N-Out. In-N- what he is. Gone. So Jill goes back. In and out. In and out, exactly. She goes to apparently complete, she wants to get her high school diploma. Okay. So she does that. In 1963, she signed up for a single course, British literature, during the fall term at Tulane University, which is down in Louisiana. Yeah. So that's where she goes. She earlier in the year, I guess she had went to enroll at Northwestern State University of Louisiana there. I guess she but she ended up at Tulane for some reason. But I'll give you the quote from the book here from one of the books. I'll tell you which one later. The confidently poised and charming beauty didn't go unnoticed by the male students when she strolled with the other coeds among the magnolia trees, lofty spires and gothic arches of the northwestern state campus.
45:59She was always pert, bright and impeccably dressed. She was already perfecting her skills at dealing with men in business and on a more personal level. She didn't denigrate or overlook her own attributes and accomplishments, but she knew how to make a man feel like he was the most important person in the world. She's kind of made in the shade. Yeah, she knew how to hee-hee-hee-hee do that shit. Shake her little ass for the menfolk. Yeah, she's good at this. So Stephen Moore, a handsome student from downstate, was one of the most impressed by her and one of the most persistent of her suitors here. All right. They said casual campus dates soon developed into a love relationship and having a huge affair here.
46:42So on May 5th, 1964, they get married again. She's married again now. Make it official. Let's do it. Let's be 21 and married twice. Great. They first married in a civil ceremony in Mississippi, and then the following October, they had a religious ceremony in Abbeville, Louisiana, there in Vermillionion Parish. So that's what's going on. Now, March 28, 1965, Jill gives birth to a son. Oh, boy. Okay, now. Stevie Jr. Like everybody in this entire story, as we'll find out, he goes by his middle name. There's hardly a man. No, no, I'm talking about the son. There's hardly a man in this he goes by his middle name. There is not a, there's hardly a man. No, no, I'm talking about the son. There's hardly a man in this story
47:28who uses his first name. What is that? It's the weirdest shit in the world. Now, the son's name is Stephen Seth Moore. Goes by Seth. Yeah. Is he junior? I don't know about that. It doesn't say he's a junior. So I think he just gave him the first name. So Stephen Seth Moore Moore goes by Seth. And I guess that's if you name someone after the father, it's to avoid confusion. But everyone's James and my, I don't know, whatever. So anyway. Then name him Seth Steve Jr. Give him the middle name of Stephen. Yeah, that's what I don't understand. Why are you giving him the first name and calling him the middle name? It's a very strange thing to do. Now, this marriage falls apart very quickly, as you might imagine it would.
48:11It's based on nothing but, oh, she's got a hot ass. And, oh, I like the way he fucking, you know, I like his car or whatever the fuck 20-year-olds are in the early 60s are interested in here. So Jill takes the baby and moves to Texas. She's out. Now she's got a child. She's got a baby, baby Seth. Boy, that Seth, let me tell you something, that Seth is going to be a huge part of this story. We will call him the Seth of Damocles and leave it there. It's dangling from this point on. Now, you'll get that later. there's still a divorce pending with Stephen Moore. They're not officially divorced, but she takes the baby and moves to Texas. Where she is going to meet a guy named William Clark Coit Jr. Remember him from the named William Clark Coit Jr.
49:06Remember him from the beginning? Clark Coit. Okay. Now, in Texas, Jill worked a little bit. She had a fledgling modeling career. She was trying to, I don't know, do ads for Eskimo pies or whatever the fuck she was trying to do. Fucking rodeo grounds in Houston. Oh, man, there's got to be a car, a boat show that someone needs to go. Look at that. Something for a model to do. So she meets this guy. Now, Clark, another guy going by his middle name, by the way, he is an engineer with a company called Tenneco. OK, now they didn't meet in in in Texas, though, which is interesting here. I'll read this from the book. This is an interesting passage from the book that shows how they got together. It was a typical Saturday night in the French Quarter. The tiny nightclubs, bars, and eateries were moist, sultry, and overcrowded with neighborhood regulars moving or seated elbow to elbow in the twilight darkness with smattering of tourists.
50:06Okay. In New Orleans. They listen to the vagabond jazz riffs of a mellow sax or a modern-day descendant of Storyville's old whorehouse professors tickling the ivories. Jesus Christ. Say there's piano being played. Enjoying the atmosphere. No, we got to get the word whore out. We got to tell everyone this used to be a whore house. They need to know. Did we mention pussy used to be for sale? They need to know there's cum on the floor. They need to know that. Don't bring a black light in here. Okay. So ceiling fans droned overhead slapping listlessly at the tobacco smoke and stale air. We all got the scene. You get it. William Clark Coit Jr. was relaxing with a martini after another long day in the marshes when he got his first look at Jill.
50:57Okay. She was a stunningly beautiful woman with long legs, exquisitely, exquisitely swelling breasts that were shown off with a provocatively low-cut blouse. Are we supposed to be jerking off to this? I think we are. Just a slow stroke for now. I mean, don't really get into it for a while. And a tiny waist that complemented the smooth, feminine flair of her hips. Her long, dark hair was pulled back to accentuate the dramatic, planes of her oval face. I looked at Jimmy and started laughing. I had to say that looking away from Jimmy, because if I look at you like, Jesus, I got to laugh. Okay. I can't believe how horny this is. This is very horny for her. Jill knew how to use clothes and cosmetics to enhance her natural loveliness and make
51:44the most of her sensuous shape, smoldering brown eyes and fine high cheekbones. Her makeup was perfectly applied, with just enough accent to complement her dusky complexion, an inquisitive brightness of her big eyes, and the stark sensuality of her full lips. She knows, too. Oh, she knows exactly what she's doing. This is crazy. That's a hot chick. Yeah, a hot chick walks in. Okay, Clark was enchanted by the alluring temptress. Does she work here? what she's doing. This is crazy. That's a hot chick. Yeah, a hot chick walks in. Okay. Clark was enchanted by the alluring temptress. Does she work here? I don't think she's just hanging out there. I think she's just out for a night on the town. A lanky 35-year-old bachelor
52:20who had spent the last decade working his way up through the ranks with the Tennessee Gas Transmission Company and Tennessee Gas Pipeline Company, he was a rolling stone. This is about Clark. By the time he began loping through the French Quarter jazz joints and watering holes, he was already on the fast track at Tennessee Gas and was in charge of all the company's construction in southern Louisiana. That's why he's there. He's a Texas guy. He lives in Houston. Doing well. He was such a – it was such a massive responsibility that he had his own company assigned float plane and pilot so he can inspect and examine potential pipeline sites in the bountiful marshes and gummy shallows of the tidewater.
52:58I've never had a job that my company was like, take the plane. It's all yours. They give him a plane and a pilot that's just waiting for him to say, take her up. Like, that's awesome. I mean, it's one of those that lands on water and shit, but still, it's cool. Fuck. It's amazing. Yeah. The job he was working would eventually involve the laying of the intricate network of more than 300 miles of pipe through the swamps and across the Mississippi River. Awesome. bigwigs as well as the men in the field referred to this job as the muskrat line because of the proliferation of the little rodents in the marshes, a lot of muskrats. So after the pipelines were connected, natural gas was pumped through them across the country to customers as far away as
53:43New England and the Midwest. So this is to get a pipeline going. Now, Clark is not, as you say, he's an executive. And he said, Clark Coit sounds like a cowboy. And the book says Clark was not a ladies' man. Really? Not at all. And it was especially difficult for him to develop a serious relationship with a woman, the book goes on to say. After 15 years of moving around the country from job to job and living in temporary apartments, he was more experienced at casual, short-term, hit-and-run romance. He's been getting it in there. He's just not been sticking to anybody. More nighters and a little shorter. Yeah. In large part, it was the nature of the job. There was not much of an opportunity to lay down solid roots.
54:26But he's successful. He's stable. Yeah. down solid roots. But he's successful. He's stable. And it's also the 60s where a lot of guys would see a young woman that was married twice already and as a baby as not taking a chance on her. Don't need that. He didn't give a shit about that at all. Nowadays, nobody would care about that. But back then, that was a big deal. So the book goes on to say he was midway into his 30s. However, it was a time when even long time holdouts like Clark were beginning to consider finding a girl and settling down back then. It's what one of his friends goes. He was no spring chicken, you know, and it's like, he was like 35 back then. 35 was like, what's wrong with you?
55:03Jesus guys. Half dead. That's literally half dead at that point. He'll be dead in another 35 years, this man. We've got to get him married off. That was considered crazy. He's half a tank. Yes, look at him. He's dying over here. He's already, he's wilting to nothing. So they say that Jill was a young, dark, beautiful, charming, intelligent, and had a tiny waist, and would fit perfectly between his big, rough engineer's hands. She was everything that a man like Clark could wish for, or so it seemed. Right. And they said the attraction appeared to be mutual. Clark was tall and as raw-boned as a cowboy, the book says. He was also blonde, lonely, and had an excellent job with a high income and an even greater future earning potential.
55:49This is husband material, basically, for a guy like Jill. This guy's the limit. Perfect. So, and just what Jill was after. And so the book says, the morning after meeting Jill, Clark telephoned his pilot and asked if he minded taking him on a rare Sunday flight over the marshes. The pilot said, no problem. Clark was a popular man among his employees and people did things because they liked him. That was to take her up and show her around. Jill moved into Clark's apartment in the French Quarter. The lonely engineer thought he was the luckiest man in the world as he enmeshed himself further into the relationship. He plunged deeply and irretrievably in love. So there we go. Jill also enrolled at Tulane again, taking classes during the fall term of 65.
56:39She took classes in U.S. history, the history of public address, and astronomy. Pretty grab bag, just random shit she takes. Just to make it look like she gives a shit maybe it's a shit she's interested in all right that's all she's taken and she kept in touch with nancy her close friend from high school that's the woman who we quoted earlier saying that all the girl all the guys loved her and all the girls hated her in november 65 which is eight months after the birth of uh of her son from the last marriage right jill and her boyfriend flew from new orleans to cleveland where he showed her off to his family for the thanksgiving holiday oh hey cleveland this is my new girlfriend check this out you know and he's
57:25proud and he's his family's finally because it's the first time you finally brought somebody home for thanksgiving they're happy construction man from cleveland he's clark from cleveland good lord um yep jill was her usual charming self when the family gathered around the dinner table at the house in the comfortable upscale bedroom community of gates mills just outside the east edge of the city neither clark nor his girlfriend though mentioned that she was the mother of an infant son that they left in new orleans oh she's like don't tell don't tell the family you have a kid as far as they know you're just a nice young lady you know don't tell her you're shit about seth no don't tell her your damaged goods that's what it was back then so
58:04anyway january 29th 1966 they are married in Texas. By the way, her divorce is not final yet from Stephen Moore. So this is husband number three overlapping into husband number two. And we're going to count marriages and husbands over time. Oh, she's going to have more? Right now, she's three marriages, three husbands. Let's just keep it at that for now. Okay. One baby. So the wedding was a big surprise. They didn't have a big to-do, a big invite all the families. They just went and got married real quick. Apparently, this Clark called his brother and just said, we're married. Isn't that great? They were like, okay. Clark was 36. I didn't even have chicken or the fish. What the fuck? Yeah, what the hell? I didn't even get to choose. Clark was 36. I didn't even have chicken or the fish. Yeah, what the hell?
58:50I didn't even get to choose. Clark was 36. Jill was 22. His older brother said, quote, he was no spring chicken. I mean, he was beyond the age of the first juices running. What the fuck is that? What the fuck kind of Texas-ism is that? Actually, Cleveland-ism. It's Ohio. The first juices running? He was no kind of Texas-ism is that? Actually, Cleveland-ism. It's Ohio. The first juices running? He was no, I'm going to read that again. He was no spring chicken. Yeah. I mean, he was beyond the age of the first juices running. I wonder which juices running on the moon. I'm real confused there. I guess he's not just some horny young kid trying to, I guess that's what he's saying. I don't know. Hey, everybody.
59:32Just going to take a quick break from the show and tell you how to get your smile looking just how you want it with Smile Set. Smileset.com. Absolutely. You put it off. We put things off. You've been putting off your smile. You look, there's a little something you want to fix. You know there's an adjustment. Just do it later. But Smile Set is the way to do it. It's how there's a little something you want to fix. And you're like, I don't know. Just do it later. But Smile Set is the way to do it. It's how you're finally going to do something about it. These are doctor prescribed clear aligners. It's done from home and for 60% less than braces. Totally game changer, I'm telling you. Very affordable.
1:00:04Smile Set delivers doctor prescribed clear aligners for under $1,900. That's 60% less than traditional braces or in-office treatment. A licensed doctor reviews your case and builds your custom treatment plan. Start with an at-home, in-home impression kit, and your aligners, they just ship right to you. Your progress is monitored remotely through the SmileSet app, with doctor check-ins available whenever you want them. Smile Set has treatment options and payment plans that fit around your life. Nighttime only aligners mean you can straighten your teeth while you sleep and monthly payments start at just 89 bucks. To feel good about your smile, that is really, honestly, very low and minimal here.
1:00:48Over 2 million smiles treated with this technology already. 30-day money-back guarantee after starting treatment. This is a great, super easy thing. I got the aligners. They sent them to my house. It's super simple. And how happy are you with your smile? So great. Yeah. It's so happy. I love my smile. We love it. It helps so much. It's awesome. Get yourself feeling right, too. Listeners of our show get an additional 35% discount. 35% when they go to smileset.com slash smalltownmurder. With this discount, you can get the smile of your dreams for under $1,200. Go to smileset.com slash smalltownmurder to get started. Smileset.com slash smalltownmurder. Now back to the show. Hey, everybody, just going to take a quick break from
1:01:39the show to tell you a better way to quit and a better habit to get with fume. Tryfume.com. Absolutely. You've tried to quit vaping. You tried to quit smoking. What happens? You end up right back where you started. That's why you need to know about fume, and we're going to spread the word here. You've probably tried to quit more than once, and that's what happens. You're not the problem. It's how you're trying to quit. That's the issue. It has a hold on you, and you need to quit the right way. I'm telling you, you've tried it. It doesn't stick because you didn't have the right tools. It's not on you. See, these nicotine things, everything, pouches, patches, and gum, all that to try to quit,
1:02:16that only deals with the chemical side, and it keeps you tied to nicotine, too, especially if you're dealing with nicotine. And if you do cold turkey, you're going to be white-knuckling every craving, and that's horrible, too. That's tough. And vaping is never a nicotine problem. It's also a habit because people do it all over the place. Fume, though, is different. Fume is a flavored air device, just air. You just draw through. No vapor, nothing like that. Just tasty, tasty air that gives your hands and mouth and brain a better habit when cravings hit. And it's no nicotine, no vapor, no batteries. Fume is not a vape. It's a device designed to distract you from cravings when your willpower isn't enough.
1:02:57And they have great flavors, too. That's what's also really nice. Over 10 interchangeable flavors, like a classic peppermint crisp mint, a spearmint ice, maple pepper, and my favorite, peach blush, which tastes exactly like peach. It is so good. And I'm telling you, we use this thing. When you're sitting there at home and you're starting to get a craving and all that, you take this. It's like couch and watch a game. You can pick it up in your hand. The weight feels right. And just drawing through it and getting the flavored air, it really gets that initial thing out of your system. That's a huge deal, and it can quell that craving and get past it. You know what I mean? So that's all you need to do.
1:03:37You do that enough, and you won't be doing it anymore. So over a million people have already used Fume to quit differently. Join them today and grab a Journey Pack. Plus, get a free gift with purchase when using our code SMALLTOWNMURDER. Addiction is really good at saying later, don't let it. Head to tryfume.com. That's T-R-Y-F-U-M dot com and use the code SMALLTOWNMURDER for a free gift with your purchase. Thank you, Fume, for sponsoring this episode. Now back to the show. Hey, everybody. Just going to take a quick break from the show and tell you a better way to feed your cat with Smalls. Smalls.com. Oh, absolutely. We just got a new kitty. So now there's two kitties. Now we got Brandy and we got little Louie over here.
1:04:26And he's awesome. He runs around. He's so much fun. He's a lover. He purrs and he gets all up in your chest. And you's awesome. He runs around. He's so much fun. He's a lover. He purrs and he gets all up in your chest. And you know what else he loves? Smalls. Oh, my goodness. I don't know what they were feeding him from where we got him, but it wasn't Smalls, I'll tell you that, because he goes nuts. He does like a little spin when you give it to him. It's weird. He does like this happy little circle in there. They're so awesome. And I love my cat and I want to give him. It's weird. He does like this happy little circle in there. They're so awesome. And I love my cat and I want to give him the best stuff possible. And it is Smalls. I'll tell you
1:04:55that right now. Smalls Fresh Cat Food is protein packed recipes made with preservative free, 100% human grade ingredients that you'd find in your own fridge. It looks good too. Yeah. I want to sit down with him and eat it myself. It's delivered right to your door. Since switching to Smalls, I mean, you're going to notice so many improvements. You really are. And their fur is going to be shinier. Their poops are going to be better. There's going to be less fur balls and hair balls, all that stuff. Smalls is different. Their fresh recipes are made with at least 80% animal protein, and they're gently cooked to retain all their nutrients and flavor. It's because Small's fresh, gently cooked food is made without preservatives.
1:05:36That's why it's so good. It's a balanced diet that leads to less shedding, fewer hairballs, more silky shine. Cat's protein is their main energy source. So more protein means more fuel, more sustained energy, more cat running around playing, having a good time. That's what you want. More of the nutrients in Small's food are digestible. So there's less junk that's going to come out of the other end there. That means better poops, less stinky, less nasty. Small's cat food leads to high protein and it's improved hydration. That equals strong bones, toned muscles. And I'm telling you, if you love your cat like I do, get the cat. Get the cat some Smalls. The cat deserves it. They go crazy for these recipes.
1:06:20Forbes ranked Smalls the best overall cat food. And BuzzFeed said my cats went completely ballistic for this stuff. And they will. After switching to Smalls, 88% of cat owners reported overall health improvements. And hey, you don't like commitment? Who does? Well, you can try Smalls risk-free. They'll refund you if your cat won't eat their food. Unbelievable. Very simple. Your cat's health and longevity start with what they eat. For a limited time, because you're a small town murder listener, you get 60% off your first daughter plus free shipping and free treats for life. When you head to smalls.com slash STM, that's 60% off your first daughter plus free shipping and free treats for life. When you head to smalls.com slash STM. Now back to the show.
1:07:10How many juice runnings do you get? I think you get your first juices running and then around, what, age like 30, you get your second juices. And the third juices don't come until midway through your 50s. It's crazy. Got a whole lot of those second juices for a while. It's like your adult teeth. You gotta hang them. It's a disgusting way to catalog years. The word juices is never good. It's never good. It's always gross. Always grosses me out whenever anybody says that. So the book says Clark's behavior and shutting his family out was one of the most important events in his life and was out of character for him. That's not what he does usually. He doesn't just on a whim do wild shit. Well, especially get married because they go on to say his brother was an Episcopal priest
1:07:55and it wouldn't have been an odd thing for him to ask his brother to officiate his wedding because that's kind of what he does. But they said they didn't even know. In fact, they said the family couldn't even figure out exactly where the marriage took place. Oh, we don't even know where? Clark didn't tell him. He just said they said the family couldn't even figure out exactly where the marriage took place because they never, we don't even know where Clark didn't tell him. He just said we got married over the weekend. And that was that. Um, but they were like, I mean, be happy for him, I guess. Yay. Good for you. If you're happy, we're happy, but you know, whatever. And they said it was about time that Clark settled down and began to raise a family. God damn it. He's
1:08:26no spring chicken. You only got so many juices. You're on your second juicing and it's about to run out. Now Clark adopts Seth and raises him as his own. What a guy. Seth takes the name Seth Coit and that'll be his name forever. He'll keep that name. So he adopts Seth here, which is very nice, which is strange because he's not, I don't know if the father had any say in that, Stephen Moore. Right. But not only is she still married to him, but now the kids adopting out his kids. This is wild. This is wildly presumptuous, right? I'm not crazy. Any of this is legal. I don't think any of it is. That's the fun part. I don't think it is legal, especially the marriage part. Now, they're going to have two more children together.
1:09:13Oh, that's nice. Buckle up for their names, dude. Okay. William Andrew Coit. Guess what he goes by? Andrew. Andrew. But William, after his dad's first name, William Clark. That's in November 66. Then in March of 68, they have another son, William Clark Coit III. He named both his kids William. You can't have a bunch of Williams. They have two kids named fucking William. And guess what he goes by? Clark. Yeah. You know, so it's not confusing. This is crazy. Oh, my God. Oh, no. it's not confusing. This is crazy. Oh, my God. Oh, no. He's known as Billy. I'm sorry. The second one is not as Billy. I apologize. But William, again, two kids named fucking William. This is nuts. So he's Billy and the other one's Andrew.
1:10:04So and he names the third. The second kid is the one who's the third, not the first. Yeah. Which is odd also. Strange. He went with Andrew and then Billy. So he's naming them A and B. Kid A, kid B. It's fucking weird. So there you go. Yeah. And during this time, this is important. There is some problems. And apparently doctors have performed a partial hysterectomy after his birth on Jill. Okay. Jill had some issues in there that she needed to get scraped out. And, yeah, she's not going to be able to have any more kids. That's it for Jill and her kids. Well, the partial, I mean, you'd need all of it. Yeah. I mean, I guess you could have one ovary and it would work or whatever. But if they take out both of –
1:10:51A fallopian tube, yeah. Both of something, you're in deep shit, I think. Imagine if any partial and it either, A, doesn't work or it's, B, insane challenge to have children. Yeah, you might need – whatever. You might need in vitro or something like that. I'm not sure. Now, Clark is really into his old thunderbird the car he has a 57 thunderbird that he loves yeah loves it and it's a cool car but it's cool i mean it's not bad he's in a thunderbird club they love him the 237s You can see them trailing the Corvette Club By about three miles Picking up With more distance between them as time goes on It's not a fast club We're here to be seen We're here because we like the lines of the thing That's all it is.
1:11:50We keep them shiny because we know people will see them. Yeah. And I guess their wives, Clark's got a friend and I guess this friend's wife and also Jill get into the club too and help out with shit as one does. One year, Jill serves as the club secretary and records the minutes of the meetings and takes care of the paperwork? I don't know what kind of paperwork a Thunderbird Club could have. What kind of paperwork do you have? What do you have to keep straight there? What meetings? The minutes? What are you talking about? Some other car show. It's just a bunch of coffee at a coffee shop parking lot. Where are we meeting? And look at our cars. What do we need fucking minutes for here? This isn't a meeting of the United Nations.
1:12:34What are we talking about? Treating this dead ass serious like it's a union meeting. Yeah. She also loved the T-Bird here. The club, which got a name eventually the Classic Thunderbirds of Houston, sponsored rallies and joined with other groups for shows, picnics, and parades. They were the ones all the way in the back, trailing by a bunch. Last place. Oh, yeah. If you stick around for 20 minutes when the parade concludes, you'll see the Thunderbird Club finally catch up. Here they come, everybody. You guys can take a bathroom break or whatever. In a few minutes, the Thunderbird Club will be here. So apparently there's another club in San Antonio, and every year, members from the Houston group
1:13:17drive there to appear in the St. Patrick's Day parade, and people come from Dallas and everywhere else. Another group of T-Bird owners from Arkansas and Louisiana would meet in Shreveport and invite the Houston club to come. Wow. These Thunderbird clubs get around to each other. Who knew? Now, with all this, this is a better lifestyle than Jill has had with the first two guys. I mean, the first guy was in a fucking trailer for a while. Right. The second guy is a college student or whatever not living you know an adult luxurious life whereas this is different there's a small age gap this guy's got some money together he's got so much expenditure uh extra cash he can he has a classic car and friends that have
1:14:02the same car he has disposable things cars and everything. We can go hang out. And she had money, and Jill spent money, and he didn't mind, and she loved spending money, and Clark would travel for work all the time. And while he's traveling for work, Jill gets lonely, let's just say. Oh, no. Jill's very lonely. Oh, this is nothing, Jimmy. This is the tip of the crazy iceberg here. Apparently, she took riding lessons to be a horses, horses. I'll read from the book. She was a natural equestrian. She had easily learned to ride and jump her mounts. Within weeks, however, the story being whispered around was that she was having a romance with a riding instructor. She's riding him, too. Lots of riding.
1:14:50Shortly after Clark was sent to Syracuse on another job, the rumor mill began buzzing again about a torrid liaison she was reputedly having with a doctor who treated one of the boys. Which, that can't be ethical. I don't think you're supposed to fuck your... I don't think pediatricians are supposed to fuck their patient's parents, are they? I don't think that's right. I don't think they're supposed to know anything about sex. Not at all. Unless they're telling you about your problem with it and how you can fix it. They said Jill and Clark were back in Houston when she began taking scuba diving lessons. She is bored. Bored? Nah. She is so busy. She's trying to find ways to not be bored. And a new round of stories started circulating.
1:15:32This time, she was said to be having an affair with her diving teacher. Because why not? School instructor. She was flaunting her infidelities and almost deliberately inviting attention as if she enjoyed being the center of the feast of spicy gossip. Yeah, I was just about to ask, how the fuck does everybody know about not one, not two, but three affairs? She's telling everyone. She does not hide it either. That's the other thing. She doesn't hide it. She doesn't care. So, one of his Thunderbird buddies, one of Clark's Thunderbird buddies, didn't really like this. They said none of the company gossip seemed to have any real evidence to back up the stories, but didn't really like this. They said none of the company gossips
1:16:09seemed to have any real evidence to back up the stories, but they were still stories you don't want to hear about your wife. And a Thunderbird man's a proud man. That's obviously a proud man. He's a member of the Thunderbird Club. He drives that car. Obviously here. They say there were so many of them, and how, he wondered, did they start? How did these rumors get started, this guy thought. Furthermore, if the nasty tales were untrue, they were grossly unfair and damaging to his friend and his friend's wife, too. And if they were true, Jill's behavior was fucking repulsive. That's fucked up. Repugnant. And he was mad because his friend Clark was deeply in love with his wife and very devoted to her and all that.
1:16:52Now, Jill, the book says it was Jill herself who crushed any doubts this man may have had about the stories that he had heard. Basically, Clark and Jill were hosting a Christmas party for some of their friends from Tenneco, the company. And this guy, the Thunderbird Club guy, was in the kitchen by himself mixing a drink when she opened the back door and slipped inside, according to his recollections. A bitter wind, which locals call a Canadian norther, was sweeping across the prairie. Despite the frigid weather outside, Jill didn't have a coat on. She had a reputation for wearing flashy, revealing outfits that showed a lot of skin, especially her legs and breasts. The cold clung to her body like an envelope as she moved up close to this other guy here.
1:17:41She said, has anybody missed me? Meaning like, is anybody looking for me? He said, well, I don't know. Where the hell have you been? He said he couldn't have asked a question she was more anxious to answer because she was super mad. It said she was steaming mad and she spit out more information than this guy wanted to hear. Quote, that son of a bitch I'm taking scuba lessons from. He knew I had to run this party tonight. She had called him a bit earlier from the telephone in the back bedroom and suspected from the way he talked to her that he wasn't alone, so she had left the party to drive over to his house to look for herself. She's jealous? How dare... She's jealous that the guy I'm cheating on my husband with...
1:18:24How dare he? ...might be fucking someone else. How dare he? That is narcissism at a different level right there. She wants all the dicks. Yep, for herself and no one else to have any. Why can't I have hair and money and he have nothing? Why can't I have all the dicks? Hair, money, and all the dicks. All the dicks and none of the other women have anything. So she said, quote, I went over there and caught him shacking up with somebody. That's sorry, son of a bitch. She's telling her husband's one of his best friends. This wow. The guy I'm fucking a man because he's fucking somebody else. So she has does not care at all. They said any image of a sweet southern bell Jill may have planned to maintain for her friend that night had exploded into a nasty torrent of jealousy and vitriol.
1:19:12Wow. So Jill spent a lot of time away from home on her own. They set a fledgling modeling career in public relations work. She was doing were taking up big chunks of her time. Her boys were being watched by professional babysitters or friends or whoever. After a while, she began taking overnights, weekends, then breaks of a week or two at a time to deal with her business affairs. Oh. Sometimes back to New Orleans. For modeling. Wow. Another Teneco company there were close friends with Clark and kept the boys a few times while Jill was on one of her trips. And they later told the other friend, the Thunderbird friend here, that one day they found ugly bruises on one of the boys where and asked where your bruises come from.
1:20:02And the boy told them that Jill had whipped him with a belt buckle. Mama hits me with the wrong end. Fucking A. That's brutal. When the boys were picked up, the woman who had been taking care of them had a little talk with Bill. Or with Jill, I'm sorry. She made it plain that if she ever saw evidence again of one of the boys that they had been beaten, Jill was going to be in big trouble. Yeah. That's it. Call the cops. I don't even know if you could call the cops in 72. They'd say, well, she's being a good parent. That's discipline. I don't even know if you could call the cops in 72. They'd say, well, that's just being a good parent. That's discipline. Especially in Texas. You can't call the cops in Texas and say someone's hitting their kid in 1972.
1:20:37They go, yeah, good. I don't know if the belt buckle has ever been picked up. Has it? I think in Texas, that's the weapon of choice probably. But that end? It's all belt buckles down there. That's what they got them for. They're kid beaters. No, I don't know. I don't have any idea. Yeah, when you win the rodeo, they say, your kid's really going to stay in line today. Yeah, when your dad wins the rodeo, all the kids cry. That's how it works. Oh, no. That's a big one. Jesus Christ. He got the biggest one. He got a dinner plate. God damn it. Oh, Jesus. Looks like the Intercontinental Championship. This is terrible. I hope he doesn't find out about that winning. See, I don't know back then if that was even a thing you could go to the cops with in Texas in the early 70s.
1:21:19I can only comment on the 80s, but I remember vividly in the 80s. I was hit with a belt all the time. But it was never the belt buckle. And I had friends at school that would tell us that their mom hit him. And all of us would be shocked. And we all were beaten. Beaten, but not early. Not with that hard part. Early 70s Texas beaten is probably a different kind of beaten. It might be different, too. It's all different. That's when you get hit and dust clouds come off of you. It's rough. So anyway, she and Clark then, Jill and Clark, began an off-again, on-again series of separations and reconciliations. Clark was embarrassed by his wife because she would fuck everybody in town and everybody knew it.
1:22:05He's like William Macy in Boogie Nights. He's like, look, I don't know. Jim Carrey, me, myself, and Irene. It's bad stuff. But he's not doing anything about it. No. Well, he's, he's working too. He's also, you know, fucking busy. She openly, this is from the book. She openly boasted about her lovemaking skills. Stunningly lovely. Oh yeah. Jill had a keen sense of the power of her beauty and femininity to go along with the convenient set of elastic morals she was a sassy sexy temptress and she had no difficulty or compunctions about attracting admirers and lovers so unbelievable yeah he's away on business she's banging everybody she can yeah this turns into a fight over who's going to get the kids now. That's what this turns into.
1:22:52March of 72, we're not sure who filed first, but we think it's Jill filed for divorce on March 8th 1972. Not sure. Either way, in March of 1972, they were active in divorce proceedings, and a couple weeks earlier he had taken money out that now can't be found after we know what happens. Because on March 29th, 1972, is when he's found shot to death in his home in Houston. Now, I have a newspaper article from the Houston Chronicle for March 30th, 1972 that I found. And it says, slain pipeline firm executive William Clark Coit Jr. was known to carry $500 to $600 in cash at all times. All the time. That's a lot of money back then to be carrying around, by the way. They also said he had a cashier's check
1:23:40for about $6,000 the night before he was killed. And fuck, so cash, that's cash, basically. Yeah. Officers reported finding no money in Quite's house at 6923 Sharp Crest. His recently acquired, I'm not a gun guy, but is there a .41 caliber? I've never heard of that. .41 Magnum pistol was also missing. Oh. Is that just a miss? Maybe he meant zero i i've never heard of a 41 caliber a 40 caliber 44 i've never heard of a 41 i'd never heard of before i saw that i was like that's news to me i'll have to ask jimmy because i never heard of that before okay never heard of 41 unless they made it at some point and stopped because that's stupid sounds dumb just doesn't sound good let Let's go with even numbers.
1:24:30Well, then, you know, five on the... Well, what about 38s then? Shut the fuck up, alright? Just don't even bring it up, okay? What about the .357? I don't care. Those are already being made. There's rifles in those. The .32? 40? 44. That's it. 45? Whatever. No .22s? We're going .25. Right up the line. We're retiring the .44, as a matter of fact, right up the line. We're retiring the 44 as a matter of fact. Nobody make another one. We'll sell the ammo. Nobody make another. No more. So, a friend of his ends up finding him because he didn't report to work or answer his phone, so they sent somebody over there. Now, he lived alone at this point. He was found lying in a hallway. It's actually, I think, a utility room
1:25:12off the kitchen is what we found out. He'd been shot four times with a .22 caliber weapon, twice in the back and in the head and shoulder as well. Okay, but all from behind. Well, it looks like all from behind. He was wearing his underwear and a television set was on in the bedroom. So somehow he got drawn out to go look for something. Obviously, he was in bed. Police found no new sign of forced entry. The front door had been forced open and the lock broken. But police said that he did that himself some time ago when he locked himself out of the house. They got there like, well, we know where the entry came. And they were like, no, no, no, that's him actually. He did that. He lost his keys one day and his mind at the same time.
1:25:56Just kicked this motherfucker open like a SWAT team member. He had $600 in his pocket and refused to wait for a lock. Nope, not happening. Kicking it open. He was last known to have talked with a friend on the telephone from his home 945 the night before. So this is interesting. And then Jill found the body. And then they find out that he had taken money out. They were in the middle of a divorce. Jill didn't live there anymore, but she came in to find him. Because they said a friend found him, but it jill that found him not a friend um so they the company had called jill and said do you know where clark is yeah and she said no i'll go check on him and that's what happened so um and he had told his friends that
1:26:42he took all the money out now they never found the money he took out which was a six thousand dollar cashier's check it's gone gone. Wow. In the wind. Don't know. So the investigation, they're naturally going to look at the younger wife who's in the middle of a divorce with him first. They don't know all. They don't know about scuba instructors and equestrian. They don't know all these different instructors she's banging. But so they want to talk to her. Jill, though, runs away. So they want to talk to her. Jill, though, runs away. Doesn't want to talk to them. No, she leaves Texas, goes to New Orleans, and hires a lawyer. Hmm. Okay. Now, her lawyer told her you should check yourself in with psychiatric hospital.
1:27:24That'll be good for you. Oh. This is what you do. This is not the murder, by the way, that we're talking about this week. There's nothing about Colorado. No. No. Exactly. I haven't even got there yet. So Houston police never gathered enough evidence to extradite her or charge her. They never really got to question her at all. They just got on the scene. They talked to her quick. Where were you? Did you just get here? All that kind of shit. But they never got to do an interrogation with her at all. They just got on the scene. They questioned, you know, talk to her quick. Where, where were you to just get here? All that kind of shit. But they never got to do an interrogation with her really. So,
1:27:54um, apparently she was admitted to the hospital claiming acute hysteria and emotional distress. She stayed there for weeks. Yeah. Weeks. Then she retrieved the three kids from Cal, uh, from relatives and collected whatever she could get from Clark's estate and moved to California. Really? Yep. That murder will never be solved, by the way. Is that right? We're pretty sure, but it's never officially off the books. It's still a cold case today. Still going now. So, in California, this is one of the strangest parts of the story, and that's saying a fucking lot because we're going to get into some weird shit. But in California in the early 70s, she meets a man named Bruce Johansson around 1973. He is people describe him as over 90 years old.
1:28:47She's going to add a Nicole Smith. This man, dude, 90 years old. She's going to Anna Nicole Smith this man, dude. 90 years old. Now, I don't know what the, she can't marry him because she's still married and all sorts of shit like that. So she talks this man into legally adopting her. Okay. She's like 28 years old with three kids and he adopts her i can't get married but what if you're my dad yeah a few months later he dies of natural causes because he's in his fucking 90s and she inherits a decent portion of his estate oh my god yeah that's why she said adopt. Let me adopt me. Okay. Oh, boy. So from there, she finds another guy still in 1973, Donald Charles Brody. He is husband number four.
1:29:42We don't count Johansson because he's a daughter. Yeah. She's a daughter. It's her dad. She's her dad. I can't remember where they are here. But this guy is a Marine Corps guy. He's a major in the marine corps probably california majors are pretty high up rankings pretty good yeah it's a major then corporal that or then a colonel then general i think yeah it's above lieutenant and all that bullshit right i think it's a third in command yeah i think that's what it is um so uh the uh the way this goes down here um he liked to control his money a lot and not let her do whatever she wanted you know like a like a fucking major would do yeah so they get married she's not thrilled about the fact that she's not
1:30:25allowed to take out whatever she wants money-wise. So this ends pretty quickly. And they separate. Now, here's what happens. She leaves, and she calls him up and says, I gave birth to your son. Oh, my God. Yeah. She said the baby's name is Thaddeus John Brody. This guy's name is Donald. Major Thaddeus John Brody. This guy's name is Donald Major Thaddeus John Brody. So this guy said, what are you talking about? I didn't even know you were pregnant. That sounds a little shady. So she said, well, here's his birth certificate. It's a, it's a boy. Congratulations. Yeah. Stuck a cigar in his mouth and said, yeah, pushups and shit. Oh yeah. So, um, now and said, hey. Those push-ups and shit. Oh, yeah.
1:31:16So now he said, well, where is this fucking baby then and all that sort of thing. So then she paid or convinced or did something, got one of her friends to let her borrow their infant so she could present the baby as this is your son. So she never had a child. She had a hysterectomy. Right. She can't have a baby. She just made this up to get child support from this man. Oh, my. One way or another, I'm getting something out of you. I have to squeeze it like a fucking lemon. You'll never see him. Here he is, though. Yeah. So that's what it was. And the child support was the point um we don't the baby definitely never existed we know that for a fact uh so she forged the birth certificate which she gets good at because she has a bunch of different identities as we go forward
1:32:01here oh boy um so then as this goes on you can only borrow a baby once in a while before he's like, I'd like to have my son for a weekend or I'd like to whatever. So she says at that point, well, he died. Oh, your son has passed. He's dead. And I buried him in our family crypt. So he's gone. Sorry. You don't have to pay anymore. Dead. Threw him in a hole. He's all dead now. Sorry. Our bad. Now, the crypt was open later. There's no child in there at all. There's no baby. No, it doesn't exist. So, obviously, there's that. Now, 1975, the Brody marriage ends in divorce here after about a year and change. Okay. So, that is that. Now, that was husband number what? Three? Four. change. Okay. So that is that. Now that was husband number what?
1:32:52Three, four, four. Okay. Next up is October 11th, 1976 in Mississippi. She's married again. She went back down to the South. Louis DeRosa is his name. D I R O S A. D I. Okay. D I, not even the D-E. That's why I spelled it. Now, he was a lawyer who later become a judge. Yeah. So this is good. He was one of the attorneys, apparently, who had represented her during the investigation into Clark Coit's murder. She is charming. It's charming and fucking like so good at this. Yeah. She's got, you know, when a toilet flushes, it's got like, that's what she is. She's like just people. Yeah. Centrifugal pull into the earth, like with her. It's wild. So it's crazy. Another source described him as a lawyer who helped her with her divorce. We don't know, though, which one it is. Either way, how the fuck does she keep reeling all these men in based on her history? Now, I'm sure she lies, number one. She doesn't say everything.
1:34:04She fucks good, too. And if somebody, sometimes that's enough to make you just believe anything they say. Especially if she knows which guy to look for. Yeah. Because there's a certain guy that if you fuck him right, he will be putty. You know what I mean? Guys who haven't been fucked right, those are generally. Food and pussy go a long way. It really does. We're not very complicated creatures, everybody. That's the thing. It's true. When I hear women talking about, well, I don't know about this, and God, what were they thinking and all that? Way too complicated. Bring it back about base level. Like, you know when you, those rolly bugs and you touch them and they roll up? That's what a man is.
1:34:44It's stimuli reaction. That's all we are. I'm not even kidding with women. Do that thing on the tip of the dick, and he hasn't had that in a while. He's going to fucking potty bait. That's how it works. I'll do whatever. There's very few factors. Whatever you want. Man. So here's a quote from the book here. Quote, Jill had this rare ability to spot vulnerabilities in a man. Dick hasn't been touched right. And she focused on their weaknesses like a hungry cheetah surveying a herd of wildebeest to pick out a prey animal that was too young or too old, lame or sick. Men were her prey. And when she was on a blood scent, she didn't deviate from her target. I've never heard those two words together.
1:35:30Blood scent? Yeah. Me neither. That's dangerous. That is crazy. She was a sultry temptress who could addle male minds with her sexual charisma, serve as a charming dinner companion, or chat knowledgeably about sports cars, guns, or business. And she knows cars. She knows cars. She knows diving. She knows. And she knows cars. She knows cars. She knows diving. She knows horses. She knows bucking. Everything. She knows thunderbirds. That's right out of the book, that quote. Now, this relationship is volatile with DeRosa. They're going to get married, like I said on that date, then get divorced, then get remarried, then get divorced again. Two marriages. In like a two and a half year period. They're going to get married and
1:36:16divorced twice, which is impressive. How old is she? 30? She's 30 at this point. What? She's born in 43 or 44. So she's starting to push in her mid-30s now. Okay. That's not so bad. No, no, it's fine. Now, the crazy part is that second divorce, not quite the divorce she's looking for. She gets a divorce in Haiti from him. Why? Which, hey, everyone, shocker, the Haitian legal system has zero jurisdiction over anything that happens in the United States of America. American marriages are not dissolved in Haiti. In case you were wondering, there's an option where you can go to. I know people back in the day used to go to Reno. If you establish residency for six weeks, you get a divorce. Haiti is not that.
1:37:03OK, it's not Reno. And as minuscule as their ability and jurisdiction is today, 70 was 50 years ago. So much less. So this was not recognized in the United States as a divorce. It just didn't work. So they remain married, and you'll be shocked to find out. I'll tell you when they're finally actually divorced. You'll be like, holy shit. Thrift. What the fuck? Okay. What was his name again? Louis DeRosa. That's husband, uh, five and six marriage, five and six. That's also husband, five and seven, five. Yeah. Husband five. So we'll, yeah, we'll keep it up. Just let's say marriage is equal. Husbands. We'll just say so. Okay. That's six. Now we're going to call it six. Okay. So, yeah, we'll keep it up. Just let's say marriage is equal husbands, we'll just say. So, okay, that's six now.
1:37:53We're going to call it six. Okay. Now, March 27th, 1978 in Ohio now. Why? She gets around, man. She meets another man. We'll call him number seven. Lucky number seven over here. Eldon Metzger is his name. This is in Lima, Ohio. She marries this guy. His name is Eldon Dwayne Metzger. He's an Indiana auctioneer and auction organizer. Oh, boy. Talks real fast. And gets shit done. Hey, come over here and put your hat on my dick. Right there. Take your pussy out. Spread them legs. Let's go. Dick on that. Down the balls your hat on my dick. Right there. Take out your pussy out. Take your pussy out. Spread them legs. Let's go. Dick on down. Down the balls. Dick on balls. That's right. Oh, and I'm going to come in.
1:38:35Oh, and sold. And you're all wet. He just yells sold when he comes. That's how it works. Yeah. Take it out and suck my balls now. And suck my balls. And suck my balls around. There we go. And we're going to stroke the dick. Stroke the dick. There we go. Up there. Show me balls now. And suck my balls. And suck my balls around. There we go. And we're going to stroke the dick. There we go. Up there. Show me the pussy. Tits on my face. Right there. Tits on my face. Tits on my face right here. We got tits on my face for 200. 200 tits on my face. Dang it. So fun. That would be so fun. Yeah. I'd beat off to that porn. That'd be amazing. Auctioneer porn. Happens real fast. Oh, what's going on? Or slow, but he's saying it so fast it feels like it's happening fast.
1:39:18I feel like you've got to whack it really fast to that just to keep up. You've got to keep your pace going hard, I think. So now she married him him by the way, while she's still married. Cause the Haitian divorce doesn't take, um, this is a short marriage. Um, yeah, it ends very quickly, very, very quickly. And we don't really know the exacts, but we know that it ends quickly. And that's that. Um, okay. January 6th, 1983. So she's 40 or 39 now depending depending. She's in Indiana now. Back to there. Full circle. She meets Carl V. Steely. Carl V. Steely. He's the headmaster of an Indiana prep school that her two sons attended. How does she, she's doing fine. She's got kids in prep schools.
1:40:14That's right. Me. Well, yeah, who knows what's going on? So this will be husband number eight, Carl. Okay. Uh, still legally married to right. The Haitian divorce guy there, DeRosa, obviously. Um, now this relationship to Carl Steely is the most stable one of her life. Okay. So far. It's long. It's stable. They're going to be together for years. He treated her sons really well. Yeah. He loves to ski and would take the family on trips. Where, Jimmy? Steamboat Springs. That's right, goddammit. Steamboat Springs, Colorado. Man from Indiana. Loves it. It's like, it's too flat. I got to get out to some hills. So they dreamed of retiring to Steamboat Springs and growing old there. Now, on one of the trips, they decided to invest in a small property in Steamboat and use it as a B&B.
1:41:12Brilliant. We're going to have a little hotel, a little bed and breakfast. Early. Yeah. And this was smart. It's a tourist area. Yeah. Get into it. So Jill persuaded Carl Steele that she should handle the business end because he's a teacher and she's better with money. Listen. And I'll just stay here. Yeah teacher and she's better with money. Listen. And I'll just stay here. Yeah. You're not a business person. Yeah. You know, I've taken British literature once, so I should be able to do this. So the plan was for Jill to take the boys, move to Steamboat, buy and renovate the property in both of their names, and then Carl would join them during school breaks. You fuck off, and I'll just be here.
1:41:53That's right. So Carl arrives after Jill's been there a while, and Jill essentially just pushes him out. She's got her own life set up now. She doesn't need him anymore. I don't need you anymore, yeah. Yeah. His money had all gone into the business, and he finds that his name is not on it. She has not. She's taken his name off. She has done this all in her own name. Well, her and her son Seth is also part of it. Oh, Seth's on it too. Seth is on it too. So those two are the names on the ownership. So it's interesting. Later on he is asked, why would, how does a guy like you end up marrying someone like that? Like you're a stable guy, headmaster of a school, all this shit. He said, quote, if you were to meet her and talk to her,
1:42:41you'd think she's just the greatest person you ever met. Why would all these people marry her if she weren't that way? Yeah. That's the reason you go. She fucks incredibly. Yeah. And also, if she was that way, all those men wouldn't have divorced her. That's the other thing. So that's the problem. When you look at the marriages, yeah, but there's that many divorces. That's a. Well, she presents really well. And then. Yeah. Up front. It's so hard. She's in. To keep up what you present. Bullshit, it's called. Yeah. So my dad was married nine times. It's hard to keep that bullshit up. It's when scammers are, it's scammers, they can't keep it up forever. Eventually it falls apart. So that's what it is.
1:43:23So now Jill is in Steamboat Springs with her kids sometime around 1990, 1991 is where this starts. Okay. The property at the center here was a cluster of vintage tourist cottages at Oak and 7th Streets in downtown Steamboat. Awesome. Jill and the boys are renovating them into a bed and breakfast here and, you know, that's what's going on here. That's amazing. They've got a series of them. Yeah, the property is a bunch of like single huts, basically, I think is how it works here. So people who see Jill describe her as someone who does not blend in at all here. No? Not blending in. She blends in as well here as I do in fucking Alabama. It just doesn't work. The tits are out, and these people are dressed like dickheads.
1:44:15They have like Patagonia coats on and she's like, look at my tits. Yeah, it's a different type of deal. There's, by the way, an Oxygen documentary that we'll talk about at the end. I'll give the name and everything like that. But a lot of quotes are going to come from that documentary. One person said she was a glamorous divorcee looking for love, although she's married to two people currently. I'm a divorcee. I mean, she is technically. She's definitely a divorcee. If you ever were around her and saw her, there's nobody else in the room but her. She was a provocative dresser, but not something that would shock you, just something that would intrigue you. She knew not to go too far. Yeah. Because then you're pricing yourself out at that point.
1:44:59She's the neighbor from Grumpy Old Men. Yes. Yeah. She just goes out with her, which one? Sophia Loren or Ann-Margret? Ann-Margret, because that was the first one. Then Sophia Loren came in. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Really went up to her. She had a tits out. Show everybody what a real hot chick looks like in her 80s, 70s, whatever she was. Yeah, but look at like Ann-Margaret from like the 50s and 60s. Yeah, she's crazy. Oh, my God. She was ridiculously hot back then, yeah. Now, this is from a different book than we were doing here. This quote says, she would come on very strong with men. She dressed flamboyantly. She dressed provocatively. She talked a lot. She made quite a stir whenever she showed up in the room,
1:45:42which is basically the same thing in different words. So she told people she was here from Culver, Indiana, which was technically true. She speaks with a Southern accent, which not a lot of people in Steamboat Springs, Colorado do. She's cheerful, real sociable, interesting, and interested. But they're renovating this property, so where do they have to keep going when you're renovating somewhere? Home Depot. No Home Depot yet, so this is the hardware store. Yeah, Ace Hardware. Yeah, 1990 equivalent of a small town Home Depot type thing. Hey, everybody. Just going to take a quick break from the show and tell you how to stay safe and keep your house protected with Simply Safe. SimplySafe.com.
1:46:26S-I-M-P-L-I-Safe.com. You know it. The holidays are coming up. That's a lot of time out of the house. Maybe you're going away. You're going to be visiting family, running errands for a big dinner, maybe a trip out of town. But here's an empty house during the busiest travel season of the year. And that, unsurprisingly, is when break-ins spike up every year. That's why there's no better time to secure your home with SimpliSafe, especially with 70% off SimpliSafe's biggest savings of the year. This is a security system that we both use and trust, and we want you to enjoy the same peace of mind this holiday season. We both have it for our houses, for our studios. It's the only way to do it, I'm telling you, because we realized I had somebody break into
1:47:11a house that we had, and I said, this is no good. And then we got SimpliSafe as a sponsor. And I said, I'm never going to worry about this again. Never going to worry about it again because it's honestly incredible, incredible service. The equipment's great because unlike traditional security systems that only alert you after a break-in's already underway. Gee, thanks. That's not going to help anybody. SimpliSafe is built to stop it before it starts. That is what this is all about. I'm telling you, smart AI-powered cameras watch for potential threats and alert a live U.S.-based agent ready to intervene. They can yell at the people through the speaker. Hey, dummy, call in the cops. Get out. Is this your house?
1:47:50Didn't think so. You don't belong here. The agent intervenes in under 30 seconds, speaking through the camera to stop this intruder in their tracks, and they call 911 for urgent dispatch when it's needed most. We've partnered with SimpliSafe to offer our listeners their biggest savings of the year, 70% off your new system with professional monitoring when you visit SimpliSafe.com slash small. That's SimpliSfe.com slash small. That's simplisafe.com slash small. And when you order, write in smalltownmurder at checkout and tell them we sent you. And it really helps the show. SimpliSafe, ahead of crime in real time. Now back to the show. So for renovations, she's always going to this hardware store,
1:48:33and she becomes a regular at the Boggs Hardware on Lincoln Avenue. That's where she met the part owner of the store and the guy working behind the counter, Gerald William Boggs. Goes by Jerry. He was born May 27th, 1941. Spoiler alert, he'll be husband number nine. Yeah. His parents are William goes by Harold. It's William Harold goes by. So nobody goes by their fucking first name, except for this guy who goes by Jerry. But yeah, his dad goes by Harold. His mother's name is Edith Sylvia, and she goes by Sylvia. Sylvia. I don't get it. Okay. They give him the nice name as the middle name. Yeah. He's got a brother named Doug who will come up an awful lot in this story as we go on here. Now, he's been in Steamboat Springs pretty much his whole life.
1:49:25His family has had this hardware business since 1939, Boggs Hardware. They are the—I mean, they're like the— Hardware folks. That's it. They are the store in town you go to. He went through school in Steamboat Springs, graduated in 59, attended the University of Colorado until 64, graduated, was a political science major with a minor in Russian language. Wow. Not bad. Fall of 63, he enlisted in the U.S. Army and wanted to get into military intelligence. That's why he studied Russian. Right. So he could get in. It would be like in 2002 if you were studying Arabic to get into intelligence. It's the same thing. So after basic training, he went to military intelligence school as well. So he's getting into that. Fall of 65, Gerald was sent to Vietnam
1:50:16with the 1st Cavalry Division. And he said, hey, this isn't very intelligent. Why are we here? This is very dumb. I've looked it over and I don't see much intelligence in this plan. This is bad. Very little. Very little to gain, a whole lot to lose here. So he's with the 1st Cavalry Division, and they set up a base camp, and it's a helicopter division, this 1st Cavalry. In the fall of 66, he has a furlough. He comes home, and he volunteers for another year of duty in Vietnam. Really? Sounds awful. Fall of 67, he's discharged. He is awarded the Bronze Star for his service in Vietnam. Done two tours. Done, done, done two tours. My God. So he comes home and he works in the family store, Boggs Hardware. Also takes pilot training under a government program from his military service he can take.
1:51:11Before he finished his training, he was qualified to pilot multi-engine aircraft. Wow. So not just a propeller, you know, multi-engine deal. So he's a pilot. He runs the store, the Boggs Hardware Store, with his younger brother, Doug. And it's very simple. Doug is the front of house, works with customers. Jerry handles the paperwork and the supply orders. Make sure you get enough hammers. Front and back of house, works with customers. Jerry handles the paperwork and the supply orders. Make sure you get enough hammers. Front and back of house, that's it. He was also here. He is extremely regimented, Jerry. Like a military man would be. Like a military man, like you have to be if you're flying a plane.
1:51:49Everything has to be right and perfect, and that's what he does. He does the same things at the same exact times every day whoa he's that guy same place for the for breakfast every day where he has the exact same thing right like you know he's they see him getting out of his car and they're already saying fucking get this and that going like they know what he wants he was ready for jerry jerry's black coffee yeah gonna coffee. He went to lunch at the same time every day. One person said he was very rote in his existence and that was just the way he was. He was just very regimented. Why would she even be attracted to this? This failed for her once upon a time. That's, well, I mean... With Marine Man. But this is the type
1:52:32of person who wants to settle down yeah that's why because if you get some wild guy he won't settle down with you he'll be doing the same shit you're doing you got to find the opposite um so uh he ate every day he ate breakfast at a cafe called the shack and he ordered the same thing every day. Eggs, hash browns, toast, coffee. Good breakfast. Not bad. Real basic here. He's very beloved around here. He's known as kind of a modest guy, kind, not a jackass to anybody, not a loud guy, not a big guy like that. He volunteered in a couple political campaigns. A co-worker of his said that he was kind of, he's the, like, locals local. You know, he's lived here his whole life. Family owns the business.
1:53:27Mr. Steamboat. She said he just got along well with everybody. He talked to everybody. He listened to them. If you'd seen Boggs, you would have seen Steamboat. So he is Jerry the Dragon Steamboat is what he is. He's all up for it. He's got a friend named Thane Gilliland, and he described him very interesting. He said, he was the good old boy, and yet he could sit down and have a conversation with just about anybody. There aren't many people that could do that. He was a real person. There was no pretense about Jerry Boggs. So that's the guy. By 1990, he's around 50 years old, never married, living the bachelor life, has a house on West Hillside Court. He's got money. He's got a family business.
1:54:13Got his family nearby. He's got money. He's got a family business. Got his family nearby. He's a catch. He's a catch at this point if you're looking for to settle down. They said everybody called him. Basically, he was everybody's Uncle Jerry at this point. Oh, God. Because he's the 50-year-old bachelor. And that's great and all, but nobody fucks Uncle Jerry. Not usually. And Jerry's kind of lonely. And that's the thing. And then here comes old Jill Coit in the door looking for supplies with her tits popping. Oh, shit. Jerry asked her out. Yeah. Fuck it. He shot a shot. Why not? Yeah, most eligible motherfucker here. That's it. So he, and he fell hard. One of the people that knew him said, I think when Jill came along, she showed an attraction to him.
1:54:56And that was exciting to him. And he fell head over heels in love with this woman. Yeah. Because he's not used to a hot. First of all, there's not a lot of hot single women walking around that are in his age range. And then their names are alliteration. It's just beautiful. It's perfect. So they become together. They become an item. And they go to shit together. They go to the ski ball, which is a benefit for Steamboat Springs Winter Sports Club together. He starts helping her renovate the cottages as well because he knows how to do shit like that. Right. Then about seven months after they met, Jill tells Jerry she has got a big announcement to make jerry no pregnant how could she say it how could she say the words i'm pregnant chill not only that she's also you know
1:55:46pushing she's in her fucking 40s at this point the other thing she's like it's not gonna be good she's like her mid-40s so especially in 1990 that was considered real and you've been drinking sulfur water who knows if this is good for this no fucking idea man so it's interesting now april 4th 1991 he becomes marriage nine husband eight yeah that's it um so and it's so funny too, because if you look over this, it's so confusing. If you look at all the sources of this case, cause some people will say he's marriage, not he's husband nine. Some people say husband eight, but he's marriage nine, husband eight. If you, this is not easy to sort out. Let me put it that way. Um, so that's how it goes. Um,
1:56:32and this guy, same thing. People close to him found out after the fact. Same thing she did with Clark Coit. Didn't tell anybody. She doesn't want the guy to have an opportunity to have anyone talk him out of it, I feel like. So she doesn't tell anybody. We'll get married right now. Let's go do it right now. One person said, got a call on a Monday that he got married on Saturday. Jesus Christ. That's it. Jerry, by the way, does not know he is her eighth slash ninth husband. Has no idea. Nothing. Oh, fuck. She also doesn't know. He also doesn't know that he is, that she's still legally married also. By the way, the Haitian divorce didn't come through till 1985. So she was like married and divorced and all that from somebody else before that even happened.
1:57:18Wow. So. And he doesn't know that she's not fucking pregnant because she can't. That's the problem here. He remodels part of the house as a nursery. No. Oh, bought cribs and children's furniture. He's sitting there at night at the end of night, just reading how to be a parent books and fucking Dr. Spock and reading all that shit. Look, they have cups now. They're suctions. Yeah, he's reading what to expect when you're expecting over here. We can milk you in the living room. Isn't this amazing? We can make it fun. That's what he's doing. Wow. People are stopping him on the street to congratulate. Here's what he's doing. Wow. People are stopping him on the street to congratulate. Here, you're having a baby.
1:57:57Congratulations. Yeah. They said, you know. Oh, shit. And they said, and he would say, you know, or a friend of his would come up and say, congratulations, we're so happy you're married. Now you're going to be a father. This is great. Everything's wonderful. Some couple months go by and Jill's the same size. Yeah. And then another month or two goes by and Jill's the same size. Amazon doesn't exist to buy fake bellies, babe. Nope. This is just wild. Women in Jerry's social circle and family start to like go, what the fuck? Yeah. When you're pregnant, you start showing like after what the fuck when you're pregnant you start showing like after four months three four months she's like six months pregnant and she's
1:58:39pretty skinny so this is looking like that documentary with the do what that guy do what with Wade there so they would say you sure aren't showing any signs of pregnancy and she'd go yeah I carry small and I'm lucky I guess you know what I mean that's what she would say you sure aren't showing any signs of pregnancy and she'd go yeah I carry small and I'm lucky I guess you know what I mean that's what she would say then out of nowhere because now she has to figure something out you gotta have a baby you better start producing a stomach pretty soon or people are gonna start to freak out so she runs away she leaves takes off heads to Texas or to New Orleans and somewhere. We're not sure exactly where.
1:59:16Did she take the kids with her? I don't think so. I think she left the kids up there. Then she comes back and says, I had a girl. The baby was born. No, no, no. Her name's Lara, L-A-R-A, Lara. But she died. Oh, she's dead so i'm sorry yeah baby died i took off had the baby it died my bad that's it jerry said i don't believe you uh-huh i don't believe it um i just don't believe it here uh he said at the time i believed there was no child. And yet every time Jill came to steamboat, she would go around telling people that she had a child. And he was like, I don't think there's a baby. And everyone else is like, Hey, congratulations. Heard you had a daughter. And then it died. I'm going to need a birth or death certificate.
2:00:09I need something, a fucking picture of you holding a newborn would be a start. Let's get a start going. Just that. A very small wristlet that has her name on it. Yeah, maybe you in a hospital in a bed with a baby, some shit. So the family, Jerry's family, starts to get a little suspicious, the Bogses. Her brother, Doug, the most suspicious. Not only the pregnancy, Doug just noticed that he seemed like it seemed like jill was a little too interested in money and especially the finances of the family business a little too interested in that he thought so he thought she was a gold digger and didn't trust her he was disturbed enough to hire a private detective to look into her background which would be
2:00:51the greatest day in a private detective's life. Normally you look into shit. It's kind of boring. They'd be like, Oh my God, I found so much cool shit. This is crazy. Yeah. The most time it's just, is your spouse cheating? This is show me the marriages. Yeah. He would come back and go, all right, sit down. I'll tell you all about it. You got about three hours. can put it on netflix because it's gonna take a while this is gonna be the longest story you've ever heard it's a story so the investigator turns to this family or the doug hires an investigator who's a family friend yeah and this investigator said it just developed into such a story, I was shocked. Yeah. Because they said it was, you know,
2:01:35a routine background check would bring on, yeah, a string, you just pull it, it keeps coming and coming. So what comes back here is four different birth certificates she found. This is why we don't know what year she's born. She has four different birth certificates? Four. She figured out how to steal identities and shit. Yeah. She knew how to do that back then. So she has four different birth certificates? Four. She figured out how to steal identities and shit. Yeah. She knew how to do that back then. So she has four different birth certificates and you go, okay, but you can find birth certificates. Yeah. And like I saw in the Ghost in the Wires book I read, he went to a place in South Dakota
2:02:08where there's a small town and he stole a bunch of birth certificates and embossed them all with the state seal. And then he could just fill them in as babies died around when he wanted to be. This, though, not only did she have four birth certificates, she had three Social Security cards. That's unbelievable. That's the federal government issuing that. That's not some fucking dinky office in the middle of nowhere South Dakota. That's Washington D.C. is fucking putting those out. That's very hard to get. At least 15 aliases are found. Aliases? She's got 15 names that she goes by. 15 names, four birth certificates, three social security cards, and fucking eight husbands and seven husbands and eight marriages.
2:02:55That's what this guy finds. Crazier that she, with all of those identities, she still marries under her real name. Yeah, under her old husband's name there, the dead one. That's what's crazy. Then they find Clark Coit. They find out about, she's got a dead husband in Houston that died under very suspicious circumstances. Still open, matter of fact. Found the same articles in the newspaper I fucking found. Had to go to a library and look through microfiche, but still found it. Yeah, they're flicking with their finger. Yeah, found marriages in Indiana, Mississippi, Texas, Ohio, Indiana again, Colorado. He found out she's got a dead husband who, after he died, she went to a psychiatric hospital where she stayed for an extended period of time and was never questioned.
2:03:42She was adopted by a 90-something-year-old man. And she had a baby with a major in the Marines who the baby wasn't real, didn't exist. So this is the second time she's who the baby wasn't real, didn't exist, so this is the second time she's done the baby trick now. And that she has a Haitian divorce that wasn't actually a divorce. And she's still married. to this one and that one. So it's fucking wild. This investigator. The investigator said she is such a mess that literally I could not determine what year she was born with 100% certainty. I don't know what year she was born. It's the first thing they established. More to that, I don't know who she... She's definitely still married to somebody.
2:04:24I just don't know who. Yeah, for sure. She's married to a Haitian divorce guy. Well, she's got to... Is she still married to the first guy, too? No, she's... Yeah, she's the DeRosa guy. I think she's, oh, no, she's married to the Steely guy, I think, still. Yeah, no, Stephen Moore's the second guy. I think that eventually came through while she was married to the third one. The Haitian divorce came through in 85 when she was already married to Carl Steely, and then the Carl Steely, they haven't been divorced yet, I believe, when she's married Jerry. Yeah. So this is a fucking mess. It's very confusing. She does not clean up anything. Nope. And they said when she married Jerry in April 91, she was still married to Carl Steely.
2:05:06So, yeah. One of the books said here was a woman with about 10, 12, 14 aliases. Here was a woman with about the same number of marriages. Here was a woman who probably had been involved in a number of insurance scams and financial scams, hence all the aliases and shit. This one thinks she's untouchable. She really had gotten away with a lot of criminal behavior. Well, she is untouchable unless Doug hears her talk about the family business. That's it. He gets his ears go up, prick right up. He's like, hold on now. So the investigator basically said that they said she was cut from the same cloth as the black widow is what the investigator said. Oh, and they found out here's another thing she got a
2:05:55fucking hysterectomy is another thing they found out yes jerry's like well that makes sense so doug takes all this and brings it to his brother and goes hi jerry am i right divorce right yeah so december 3rd 1991 the is annulment day Okay, the marriage lasted about seven or eight months, including a fake baby, a fake dead baby, and other things. Their marriage is annulled, her and Jerry's. Okay, December 23rd, 1991, 20 days later, her divorce from Carl comes through. So she's been married and had it annulled while she was still married to Carl. Wow. That's fucking crazy. By the way, Carl, after all this, and in his divorce filings and everything talked about, he came to suspect that Jill tried to poison him on several occasions and had tried to have him run over by a truck a couple of times.
2:06:50Oh, Jesus. Yeah. And she, his marriage, this is his summary of the marriage, quote, I'm thankful to be alive. You should be. Yeah. So, for the first time in a long time, she's single. Yeah. She's actually single, actually not married to anybody at this point. First time ever. That I can think of, yeah. So, February 2nd, 1992, she gets married again. What? Where where vegas of course why not she hasn't gotten married there yet so she's trying to get all the states uh this is roy carroll uh with one uh two l's two r's two l's roy happening, there's a civil fight going on between Jill and Jerry, which is wild. OK, this is from later on a court decision. She was embroiled in a bitter civil suit against her ex-husband, who was considered the victim in that case, the lawsuit arose over his claimed interest in a
2:07:54bed and breakfast in Steamboat Springs, Colorado, which Jill owned with a son by a previous marriage. Seth, apparently she apparently had not had given him a fraudulent deed of trust encumbering the property in order to avoid execution of a judgment obtained in a divorce proceeding by one of her former husbands. So she gave him the deed so that they couldn't take it away, but it wasn't a real deed. So he wants his portion of the property. Exactly. So she's trying to keep it from both husbands. Yeah. Which is wild. So, yeah, basically he won a money judgment against Jill Steele he did so to keep him from collecting that and going after the bed and breakfast he tries she gives it to him a deed of trust
2:08:41is a recorded lien it looks as though the property's already pledged to somebody else to secure a debt because that's what it was and the doc they say that the paperwork represented that Jerry had lent her a hundred thousand dollars and used this for collateral which isn't true. But that's the way that she can keep it from Carl. So that's how that goes. But he put a bunch of money into the property himself, though, anyway. After the annulment, she sues Jerry to get his name off of it. Okay. she sues Jerry to get his name off of it. They say after she filed the civil action against him seeking a release of the deed of trust, he counterclaimed for intentional infliction of emotional distress and
2:09:25outrageous conduct. If there's one thing she's guilty of, it is outrageous conduct. Right. I mean, even if it's no crimes, outrageousness is for sure. The counterclaim alleged among other things, that Jill had falsely asserted she had given birth to a child fathered by him. Holy shit. Now, Jerry wanted a jury. Jill just wanted a property ruling. Just that. Jerry said, no, no, no, I want to get in front of a jury and tell them about a fake pregnancy, a fake dead child. I want to tell them about everything. Bigamy, what my private investigator found. I want to know about everything. His friend Thane said he wanted to expose her for what she was and what she had done so it wouldn't happen to somebody else.
2:10:12Yeah. Okay, now now she is currently married to roy carroll remember that all right married there they live in roy carroll's home in houston um i guess i she and she left him before the end of 92 this is a short-lived marriage again okay they split up but guess what they don't do? Get divorced. Get divorced, yeah. That's fucking wild. That shit's expensive and time-consuming. Also, this allows her to use civilian living quarters of the military. Yeah. So they said because one of her ex-husbands had been in the military, she was allowed to use civilian living quarters located at Lowry. Lowry Air Force Base in Denver. So she moves on. She finds another guy, 1993, Michael O. Backus, B-A-C-K-U-S.
2:11:05He's born September 9th, 1945, about the same age as her. He's a Vietnam veteran again. She likes a vet. Well, it's that generation. A lot of that age. They all were. Most of them were, yeah. He worked as a telephone repairman based in your favorite place, Greeley, Colorado. Yeah. Which you call the center of all white trash universe. Absolute. It's the sun that white trash orbits. It's the area that everybody has that shitty place in every state. Yeah, that's it. That's the one. So he's just a blue-collar guy. Telephone repair man, normal guy, nothing crazy. Jill begins using his last name, although they don't actually get married, and she doesn't change her last name although they don't actually get married
2:11:54and she doesn't change her last name she starts calling herself Jill Backus anyway either way she's still married to Roy Carroll and she still uses the name of husband number three who was killed in his house okay she's still quite now there's a civil trial with Jerry this is all going to go to trial and everything is going to come out now. Jerry got his way. They're going to trial. Everyone's going to know everything about her. It's going to be public fucking knowledge. Yeah. You can just go down to the courthouse and get all of it. Court documents. So this is set for late October 1993, very end of October of 93. Why wouldn't she just settle? She doesn't have the money, I don't think, to settle.
2:12:37Oh. I don't think she wants to. It's crazy. So October 1993, Jill and Michael Backus tell everybody that they went camping at Kelly Flats in Poudre Canyon, P-O-U-D-R-E, Poudre, Poudre, how do you say that? I don't know. I don't you say that? I don't know. That's what I was thinking. Maybe powder? West of Fort Collins on the Front Range. Over there. Trash areas. That's the western slope, babe. That's over there by fucking rifle. So the campsite's more than 150 miles from Steamboat. Over the Continental Divide. Which, again, Donner Party. We've talked a lot about this which again, Donner Party, we've talked a lot about this area and that Donner Party shit. So now they believe, they definitely at some point go on this camping trip and are in this
2:13:22canyon because they're seen and known and they're there. Okay. Thursday, October 21st, 1993. Jerry, Jerry Boggs here. Okay. This is what he does. He eats breakfast at the shack, has eggs, hash brown, toast, and coffee, as he does every damn day. That old basic-ass breakfast. That's right. Midday here, he went home early from the store that day. Oh, changed his schedule. And I guess around noon he went home for whatever reason. Okay. Now, and we're not sure exactly why he went home for whatever reason. Okay. Now, and we're not sure exactly why he went home because that's weird for him. But in the afternoon in his neighborhood that day, West Hillside Court, a local woman, a neighbor, saw two people walking down the street that did not look right.
2:14:14They had their hands stuffed in their pockets. And he said, this is October. It's not that cold yet, but they had like bulky shit on and nobody else in Colorado bulks up until it's time to bulk up. Yeah. I know early December. Yeah. That's exactly the way it is. Like, and especially like in the spring, Holy Christ in New York, in the spring, you're like, what is it? 47 today. Everybody's got a t-shirt on like, ah like the sun's out don't worry about it it's warm as fuck today i washed these shorts back in fucking august i want to wear them again that's what it's about dude so apparently they they look like hunters they were dressed like hunters the weather was mild one was like a bigger guy and then mild. One was like a bigger guy. And then the other person
2:14:55was like a smaller person wearing a bulky jacket and a baseball cap and a mustache that quote, looked kind of funny, goofy ass mustache, goofy, which is interesting. And they said that the walk of this person and the physique made it look like it was a woman with a mustache with a big mustache really wobbling his ass. Either that or that is an ugly lady. I'm not sure. So the other one was a tall, slim man wearing a tan jacket and blue jeans. So I'll read from the book. They said there was no strange vans or trucks parked nearby. They weren't wearing uniforms to indicate they were there to deliver or repair appliances or anything like that. Considering their weird get-ups, it was also obvious they weren't door-to-door salesmen.
2:15:42They didn't look like the type of characters anyone would willingly open the door for. So they said that was one of the bothersome aspects of their disturbing, their disturbing appearance in the quiet small town neighborhood. They weren't recognizable as people who lived in any of the nearby homes and didn't appear to have any actual business in the area. They looked so menacing and alarming that the neighbor that saw her saw these people, this her that saw them was actually on her way to the spa and decided to turn around, go home and make sure all her doors were locked. Really? And not go out. She stayed home and locked the doors because she didn't trust these people. She thought her house was going to get robbed if she left.
2:16:22Very interesting. Yeah. Yeah. She didn't usually do that, but she did it here. She said one of the people had turned and glanced at her as she drove past them. And it was something about the look that she found disturbing. So, so she said it was a relief when they drove away down the street after a few minutes. But then about two o'clock in the afternoon, they were back again wearing the same stupid outfits and cruising slowly and aimlessly through the neighborhood. And they said, they're just weird. And, you know, it looked like they were like dressed up for Halloween, but Halloween's a week away. What's going on here? So anyway, that's Thursday, the 21st. That's the day. Then Friday, October 22nd, 1993, Jerry is the one who opens the hardware store, like 730.
2:17:16He did not open the hardware store. It stays closed. He just doesn't show up. Now, Doug knows his brother does not just not show up for work. So he heads right to the house in West Hillside Court. He calls. Nobody answers. So he drives to his house and finds the front door locked. So he goes around to the back door, which opens into the kitchen, opens the door, and stepped inside. And I will read from the book here. After parking in the drive and approaching the house, Doug found his brother curled up dead on the floor of a utility room just off the kitchen. They said blood is all over the place. It's splattered and spattered on the floor, smeared on the wall. Ah, shit. And on the kitchen door, which is behind Jerry's head.
2:18:03Absolute struggle. The kitchen door was unlocked, as it usually was, but it was blocked by Jerry's body, so he couldn't even get all the way in the kitchen. He was lying on his left side wearing a flannel shirt, blue jacket, pants, and heavy shoes. So either he just came in or he was about to go out. One of the two. They said the handle of a dust mop was balanced at a 45-degree angle on his right hip. They couldn't figure out what that was all about with the mop end on the floor. And he was already dead by then. Very dead. Doug called 911, but it was just no helping anybody. Once the police arrived, as soon as they got there, they didn't even talk to Doug yet. They pulled into the driveway,
2:18:52get out of the car, and Doug's yelling, that bitch killed my brother. That bitch killed my fucking, that fucking bitch killed my brother, goddammit. He's pissed right away. So they describe it as overkill, what happened to Jerry in there. He shot three times with a .22 caliber pistol. It's familiar, Which is interesting. Shots were to the chest, apparently. He'd also been beaten in the head with a shovel. Badly enough that one of the blows split his face wide open from the top of his head downward. Oh, Jesus. Like the edge of the shovel. The edge of the, something like that, whacked pretty hard. One of those ones the edge of the something like a whack pretty hard one of those ones that kind of comes to it
2:19:37more of a not flat not totally flat like a dirt shovel as opposed to like a snow shovel according to a couple of sources to there was evidence that someone tried to strangle him as well then they find something they can't figure out either um they can't figure out because they find a set of marks on the right side of his neck or cheek it's a set of marks that they can't figure out what the fuck made these marks they're not gunshot wounds they're not muzzle stamp of a contact gunshot. They're small paired marks. They couldn't identify what made the marks. They couldn't figure it out. They look around the scene. That doesn't help much. Very little evidence on the scene. No forced entry. Nothing stolen.
2:20:28No fingerprints that led to anybody else except for Jerry. The shovel, which had been used as a weapon, had no prints on it, and the only blood it had on it was from Jerry. And it's still there. It's still there, yeah. Now, they never find a gun. There's no gun around, no .22 that worked here. J.D. Hayes, who's the director of public safety for the police department here, he was a captain at the time of the murder, police captain. He was sitting in his office when his radio started going, reporting that there's a dead guy. And he said that it's out of the ordinary because we don't have this kind of serious crime often. There's just a sense of we need to pull together. We need to find the person who did this.
2:21:10Absolutely. And that's the deal. They said it's like somebody had perpetrated this crime in your family, and we all take it very seriously, especially a guy who's lived there his whole life. He's not like some tourist or somebody who just moved here last year. Everyone knows him in the whole damn town. So it makes sense. So they got to figure out what happened in there. And they said he was attacked inside the house, pretty obvious. And they said the shovel, the three shots he was hit with, somebody tried to strangle him and we don't know what those marks are. So they can't figure it out. But the medical examiner preliminarily is going to put the attack on at the afternoon of the day before.
2:21:56Like when he went home early. Okay. Nobody in the neighborhood reported hearing shots. Not even the nosy lady who was worried about people driving around. Really? No one heard shit. So they do talk to the woman on the street who said, I saw two fucking people walking and then driving, dressed for a hunting trip. One was wearing a mustache that didn't belong, look like it belonged with it. Mustachio ass wiggles, yeah. Weird. So people freak out locally. This is a big freak out moment for people. Certainly. There's a lot less people there than there is now too as well. So the J.D. Hayes guy said that, you know, this was a very open, friendly community, no murders. So it sent shockwaves through the town.
2:22:40A reporter for the steamboat pilot, Brad Balchunos or Balchunos, one of the two. He's got a bunch of quotes coming up, so I'll just give his name out now. He said he remembered how fast the shit went from, we had a you know someone's dead to holy fuck this is getting weird yeah he said it's one of those things where you don't realize the magnitude of it right away it all seemed pretty surreal to me it just kept getting bigger and bigger that's a pretty far-fetched movie plot certainly they started getting on they're like okay this is how many husbands what the fuck yeah so police immediately turned to Jill, the person who in less than a week's time they're going to go to a civil trial with.
2:23:20Right. And all this shit. So Doug is the one who told him. He said, that bitch killed my brother, so do that shit. And he said, by the way, in case you're wondering who she is, I got a big file that'll save you a whole lot of fucking time. Boy, do I have a pamphlet of him. Here it is. Yeah. Because otherwise then they have to look into her and figure it out. I already got someone who did the fucking footwork for you here. So they were like, man, they look at the file. They're like, holy shit, this is a lot. This is a bad person. Yeah. The civil trial's coming up in less than a week, and they're like, one of the detectives said initially we tried not to focus on one person. They wanted to take it as a global thing and figure it out from there.
2:24:03And they said, and things just kind of kept leading us back to Coit and Bacchus. She was the only one with a motive. Nobody disliked this guy. So they said each piece of evidence doesn't necessarily mean it's Jill that did it for sure, but they paint a picture where it kind of starts to build things. The detective said, I call it the pebbles of a case that kind of weigh in favor of a guilty verdict. He said, we gather all these little pebbles and we put them on the scale of justice and hopefully they tip the favor in favor of a guilty verdict. Yeah, you add up all the small things. You don't have the big smoking gun, you know, that sort of thing. He said he and the other detectives really threw themselves into this case.
2:24:47He said, you go to bed thinking about it. You wake up thinking about it. And all day long, you're thinking about it. It's the ultimate type of investigation because so much is at stake, you represent the dead victim. Yeah. Yeah, totally. So now where the fuck was Jill? That's question one. Where was Jill? Where? Where were you, Jill? She says, well, I was 150 miles away. We were camping. Oh. I said, we've been camping at Kelly Flats there. I don't know what you mean. And they were like, OK, that's fine. The thing is, though, the alibi works if the murder happened late in the day because they were there that night. The night, the Thursday night where they think he was killed Thursday afternoon.
2:25:29Right. But if it's earlier than that, then we got questions. Yes. They said if Jerry was killed in the evening, the drive back across the mountains would have made it hard for them to be in both places. But if he was killed in the afternoon, it makes it a lot easier for them to be able to get back in time, you know, through the darkness and all that. So all of this depends on the time of death, which is normally very hard to pin down as we talk about a lot. So they needed to answer, okay, the only way we can figure this out is, do we know when he had eaten and where he had eaten? Yeah. Or what and where? So they go to that. They say his routine is super reliable, so that's good. So they know certain things.
2:26:09He ate at the shack nearly every day. He ordered his eggs, his hash brown, his toast, and his coffee. And they said if his stomach contained breakfast. Any of that. We know when he ate it exactly. And we know that he died within a few hours of eating it before it could be digested. If it contained something else, if he had eaten a meal later, then the time of death is going to move later and more in favor of Jill's alibi. Sure. later and more in favor of Jill's alibi. So they sent these stomach contents to these two people that we'll talk about, these Bach and Norris. These are two like they do botany mixed with medicine. It's very interesting to figure this shit out. It's gross. Give them all the credit in the world. That's a gross thing to have to do that.
2:26:53Here's some stomach contents of a dead person. Gross. That's the stomach strength that I can't fathom because if I saw it, I'd throw up. I couldn't do that. And I sift through it. Yeah. They said at death, the pyloric valve in the stomach shuts down. So no more digesting. Yeah. No more bile. They said plant cells have tough walls that survive chewing and digestion far better than protein. That's why they look for plants more. Potatoes stick around. They said under a microscope, a potato looks like a potato even after it's eaten. And the same thing with an onion. It just looks like an onion. So they find potatoes. Oh. This is a good sign. Hash browns are potatoes. The eggs are protein. They would have went through and digested quicker.
2:27:42Same with the toast. They also find onions. Oh. Okay. Now, this is a problem because they go to the shack and they say, do your hash browns have onions in them? And they say they don't, which is fantastic. And I'd order your hash browns all the time. I hate onions and hash browns. I just don't like it. I'll pay you to put James's in mine. Yeah, you can have it. Here's why I don't like it. It's not even that I don't like the onions. I don't like that there's pieces that you can't tell are onion or potato in there and shit. And I'm like, oh, I don't like that. I want to know what I'm eating. Fair. Okay. So anyway, no onions in this. Okay. So they said if he'd eaten onions, he may have eaten somewhere else later in the day.
2:28:23And now this could fuck the whole time of death up. Sure. So they're like, shit. So they go to the shack. And this is an amazing thing. Imagine you're a short order cook. You work at the shack. You're making breakfast. You're a Denny's cook essentially here. Yeah, it's a shit diner in Steamboat Springs. Yeah, these investigators go to the shack and go in the kitchen and they go listen to the cook. Do us a favor. Pretend Jerry just ordered breakfast. We're going to watch you make it. Just make it that way you'd normally make it. So now these cops are standing there arms crossed watching a guy make fucking eggs and shit. Don't worry about the health conditions. Just make it. Just make it. Now here's what happens.
2:29:00This is why you get sick all the time when you eat out. Oh, I know exactly why. And you fucking love breakfast and you shouldn't love breakfast out. I love breakfast. Breakfast hates me. Yeah. Well, you love eating out for breakfast. Yeah. Stop. Wait till dinner when there's less eggs. So the cook made the hash browns on the same grill where he cooked onions for other orders. And he turned the potatoes with the same spatula he used for the onions. So the onions weren't supposed to be in there, but they come along with the spatula. Cross-contamination. You're going to get an onion or two in your hash browns, basically. So the sample they prepared when they tested it contains onion and potato, and that's exactly what's in his stomach.
2:29:49So they figure out, finally, the stray onions came from breakfast at the shack. Now they understand breakfast was the last meal. He was killed within a few hours of eating it, putting the murder in the early or middle part of the afternoon, October 21st. Plenty of time for Jill and Michael to get back on the road, get back to their campsite and look all fucking good here. So they said, by the way, this brought the attention of these plant people who look at shit in the stomach to the rest of the country. There was a lot of law enforcement that didn't know this was possible or didn't know anything about it. Yeah, one of the people said, as a result of this Black Widow case, information about what we could do and how we could use forensic botany to answer specific questions in homicide cases
2:30:29resulted in a lot of additional interest throughout law enforcement and the grapevine. So now they need to search. Now they have death fixed in the afternoon. They have enough to get a search warrant. Now they don't know where Jill is at the moment, but they do know where her car is. Where's that? Somewhere. They find her car, and in her car they find a map of Mexico Oh. Two wigs What? Matching the description of the people's hair that were walking that day and a stun gun. Oh no mustache? No mustache but they find a stun gun. Stun gun for the paired marks on old boy's neck. So they take the stun gun they get the same model, they apply the stun gun to a dead pig which is very similar to human skin.
2:31:16Makes the same shit. The marks are exactly what's on Jerry's neck and cheek. Exactly. They stun gunned him first. The wigs fit the description of the oddly pair on the street. And the map is where they think Jill might have taken off to, which is Mexico. Holy shit. So there's a separate search on December 2nd, 1993, a federal and state personnel searched the room Jill was using at Lowry Air Force Base along with a vehicle on the base under a state warrant and the base commander's authority to search and seize. That'll come up legally later, as you might understand. Now, why the fuck isn't Jill in cuffs? Where the fuck is she? Well, because she went to Mexico understand. Now, why the fuck isn't Jill in cuffs? Where the fuck is she?
2:31:55Well, because she went to Mexico City. That's why. She went down. Way down. Not to Baja. She went to fucking Mexico City. Yeah, all the way down. Yeah. So she apparently gets down there with help from the U.S. Vice Consulate down there with help from the U.S. Vice Consulate down there. She signs a power of attorney so her son, Seth, can do everything. Yeah. And she writes a letter to Seth telling him to sell everything. Sell it all. We're fucking done. Fire sale. Yeah. Fire sale because she's going broke down there. Yeah. So they need a break here, obviously. And what she did, not only did she give Seth the power of attorney, she also wrote to Seth telling him, like we said, sell everything.
2:32:43Unload. And among some other things here, Billy and fucking Andrew, because they think that she killed Clark Coit. Our dad. So the two boys who that's their real dad are real pissed about it. And so is Seth, because that's his adopted father. Huh. He has his name and everything. Right. So Seth goes to the police what remember i called him the seth of damocles that shit's about to fall right now he has some questions or some things to say nope he goes to the investigators and says i have some shit to tell you and i go love to hear it and he says my mother asked me to help her kill Jerry. She asked me to help. Yep. Or help cover it up or help dispose of the body. All three, basically. Yeah. If you don't help me, then will you help me get rid of the body?
2:33:46Blah, Okay. He also told investigators that he had come to believe that his mother killed Clark Coit, the man who adopted him. Trevor Burrus In Houston, yeah. Peter Van Doren And William, and like we said, Billy and Andrew think the same thing. Apparently, William, Billy really was looking into it. He started looking into how his father died. He'd been too young to remember his dad. So he was just looking into his day. He wanted to remember his dad more. Trevor Burrus Who is my dad, yeah. Peter Van Doren And then he started getting into it. into how he died and started looking up shit and seeing newspapers and seeing things of how his dad was houston's only unsolved yeah and he watched home movies of himself as a little boy with his
2:34:24father so he could see him and remember him or try to remember him and he began asking where his mother you know whether his mother did my mother kill him what the fuck basically um and that's that so apparently seth tells the cops that his mother called him at four o'clock in the afternoon on october 21st thursday the day that he was killed we found out okay seth was at a bed and at the bed and breakfast and steamboat that they were that they own she says hey baby it's done and it's messy. That's what she told him over the phone. It was messy and it's done, meaning Jerry at 4 o'clock. So it's, yeah. And they said, did you know what she was talking about? And he said, yeah, she's talking about Jerry
2:35:14because she had been asking me to help her kill him or cover it up or something um he said this is all he said quote don't talk to me and hung up the phone ha prank caller prank caller is what he said i don't want to know about this shit he literally prank called her that's very funny don't know talk to me. Hung up the phone. On the night of October 21st here, Seth talked about the room where his mother stayed that night. And I'll give you a quote from the Oxygen documentary. Quote, he testified that the room she stayed in that night had blood spatters, had blood on towels. There was stuff all over the place. One spatters, had blood on towels. There was stuff all over the place. One of his hats had blood on it.
2:36:03He bleached the hat, cut it up into pieces and buried it. Huh. Get rid of it. He scoured the room and she was gone by the next morning. So she came in to clean up her murder shit in one of the bed and breakfast rooms. And left it all there for him. For him to cover it up because she had asked him to help. And so he cut all that. Wow. Then Michael Backus, they figure out, had been doing some weird shit too. He showed up for work that Friday. Oh. The next day. He showed up for work. His employer had not been expecting him to work that day because he had the day off because he took it off to go camping. But they did notice that he had a new pair of boots on now. Brand new boots. Now, here's some other guilty sounding shit from Jill here.
2:36:53She had, I guess, apparently she had been telling Michael Backus because other Backus had told other people and we'll get to that. She convinced him that Jerry was a bad guy and convinced him that he was dangerous and was going to get her and kill her. And the only way to get rid of him was to kill him and to kill the guy. Only way to stop him. Then she started trying to find hit men. Oh, oh, yeah. A few different people. Do it. Only way to stop him. Then she started trying to find hit men. Oh. Oh, yeah. A few different people. Fucking a co-worker of Michael's. We'll talk about it. All right. Troy Giffen. He worked with Michael Backus. He's also a Vietnam veteran. Michael Backus asked him about killing Jerry.
2:37:38Hey, you think you can kill Jerry for me? You ever kill anybody? I'm sure you have in the war. He offered him $3,500. Yeah. He said, I'll give you $3,500 if you'll kill this guy. And this guy said no. So he said, how about $7,500? Wow. That's a, you really. Not bad. You really realized how low you were going. Yeah. And the guy still said, no, thank you. Wow. That's a... Not bad. You really realized how low you were going. Yeah. And the guy still said, no, thank you. Yeah. Thank you, no. Then in summer of 1993, this is how long this was going on, summer of 1993, remember the Midwest was all flooded? Oh, yeah. St. Louis. The arches. Yeah. Everything was flooded. The arch. Well, Michael Backus
2:38:17is a telephone repairman, and he traveled. He was sent to Iowa to help repair phone lines. Jill went with him. She spent the summer in Iowa. This is going to blow your fucking mind, dude. She spent the summer in Iowa pretending to be a psychologist counseling flood victims. She has no training license, no anything in psychology. You heard what she took in college. You hear psychology in there anywhere? The fuck did she tell them? Get yourself a blow dryer? She literally counseled their emotional needs, not their physical needs, obviously. That's not what a counselor does. The fuck would she know? That's the point. She said, I'm a counselor does. The fuck would she know? That's the point. She said,
2:39:01I'm a counselor, and started taking clients. And they didn't ask to look for a license or anything. They just said, oh, alright, she must be a counselor. They probably needed a bunch of them, so they're probably just taking on anybody that says they'll do it. Absolutely. Whoever needs whatever. It's one of those things. Yeah, if you show up and you're given food, they'll just take it. I mean, it's one of those. So, one of these flood and you're given food, they'll just take it. I mean, it's one of those. So, one of these flood victims, an Iowa woman, said that Jill tried to persuade her to kill Jerry for her. Some woman she was counseling. That's the way, that's how you know your counselor's
2:39:29back. How'd you like to make $7,500? Actually, she didn't even offer her $7,500 bucks here. She told this woman that Jerry was a rapist and a sexual deviant and that asked the client for a gun during the session. Do you have any guns I could have to kill this man? And she said, no. She said, well, if you do it, I'll give you a thousand dollars. We're here to talk about my problems, not yours. I watched my house float away. Do you understand? The woman said, no, thank you. Okay. And she's looking for counseling. That's fucking horrifying. And she's like, what is this guy in Colorado? We're in Iowa. What are you talking about? Yeah. So, and by the way, the story of why she wanted him dead shifts with each person she talks to is the weird part.
2:40:23She told some of the people that she approached that Jerry had been molesting her daughter from a previous marriage. She didn't have, there's no daughter. She just does, there is no daughter. She does not have a female female no female has ever shot from her loins ever there was a fake one yeah my my dead fake daughter um which is fucking crazy um and apparently um he she told back as something different she told michael backus that jerry would make would force jill to have sex with other men while he watched. Oh. Even though she didn't want to. She had to. And another time she also said, I guess, Backus told the Troy Giffen guy from work that we gotta kill this guy. He harmed a young girl.
2:41:14Again, he's a rapist and all this shit. None of these stories are true, by the way. No. Mike's buying it or he's just spreading it? He goes, I don't know. And then she starts sucking his dick and he goes, well, he sounds like a terrible, terrible man. He's probably a rapist. I would assume so. So good. Gotta be. Somebody, another person from Ohio, a guy in Ohio named, I guess, identified as a under a false name. Also, she tried to hire to kill Jerry. Then there was Seth, the son here. According to everything here, Jill asked Seth for advice on how to kill Jerry. OK, like he's killed a bunch of people before. She asked him to kill or to help dispose of the body. He said no. And then he said something.
2:42:04The only thing he told her was, quote, if you do anything stupid, wear gloves. Okay. Don't leave fingerprints. This is my advice to you. This is my advice. And apparently, according to everything, the sons knew about two weeks before the murder that something was going to happen. Obviously, Seth knew because he was trying to get them to do that. But they didn't do anything. They talked to each other but didn't say anything to any outside people. I guess you probably just figure you're being crazy. Yeah, who knows? Maybe mom's a wacky. I mean, you'd think mom is wacky being crazy, but. Yeah. Who knows? Maybe mom's a whack. I mean, you think mom is wacky. Okay. First of all, if this is your mom, you know, she's wacky.
2:42:43You just know it. She's dragged you all over the fucking country. All these different guys. Every time she does anything, you roll your eyes. Oh, Christ. Here we go. So now Michael Backus goes back, went back at some point to talk to Troy Giffen, the guy from work. And he said that, you know, remember what I told you? Yeah. He said, I was hoping you would forget that. Just forget that. Remember what I said? You never heard it. He said, that's the only thing that could hang me now. And then he said, Vietnam buddies don't rat off their buddies. Is that what they don't do? Vietnam buddies don't rat off their buddies. Is that what they don't do? Vietnam people don't fuck with each other. I mean.
2:43:23We've both been to the sticks. We've been in the rice patties together. We don't talk. So, wow. Happens in the rice patties, stays in the rice patties. Fuck, yeah. Now, at some point, too, what happens in the hole stays in the hole. What happened during this, people find out that Jerry had recorded threats from Jill that she left on his answering machine. She didn't know. He had a bunch of messages of hers that she had left. After his death, one of the things that was missing from his house was the answering machine tape. She did know. Yeah, she knew she left messages on there and she yanked it just in case. Now, Seth gets immunity for this. They give Seth immunity to testify against his mother.
2:44:11Okay. You got to give him immunity. He didn't do anything. These two are the main issue. And he's testifying against his mother. That's, you got a kid that's willing to testify against his mother, you have are the main issue. And he's testifying against his mother. You've got a kid that's willing to testify against his mother. You have to give him immunity. Now, the problem is that he had been asked in advance to knock on to the police. He told his mother to wear gloves. So a defense attorney is going to have a blast with this shit on cross-examination. So one person said, this is from the Oxygen documentary, here's a woman who dragged him all over the country, gotten him involved with her schemes, gotten him involved with the pre-planning at least of a murder, had made him do things he didn't want to do, and he had to sort of suck it up, so to speak, to be able to go into the courtroom and testify against this woman.
2:45:01It's a lot. Jerry's friend Thane said that, you know, it wasn't Jerry's not an idiot. He said that because people say, well, how dumb is he to get married to this fucking lady? And he said he's not an idiot. He said people need to understand that it was not the education or the intelligence part that got him in trouble. It was the emotional part. It was the love that he felt. 50 years old and lonely is a strong thing, you know? 50 years old and holding out and then getting this, I mean not necessarily, holding out for whatever reason, and then this lady lands in your lap with great tits and she's blowing you always. Yeah, and she comes right in your store. People don't understand how... You didn't even have to go to the bar.
2:45:37She came to your store. She comes up with a bunch of drywall. I mean, it's fucking easy pickings, you know? The vast majority of people settle for mediocre sex when it's really great. Yeah. It's crazy what you'll do for that person. Well, especially if you've had none of it and no prospects of it. You've had none and now it's amazing. How is that? And you're 50 and you're going, I could be doing this forever until I die of a heart attack with a smile on my face mid-fucking coitus. I didn't even have terrible sex. I had no sex. Now it's amazing. Oh my God. So the cops said that, you know, that's all they were working on at this point, trying to figure it out. So late 1993, Jill is out of money.
2:46:21Uh-oh. So she comes back. Now, Michael Backus is working, and they've left him alone because they feel like if he's there, maybe she'll come to him. Come up, yeah. So that's what they're trying to do, use him as bait, basically. Yeah. So she goes, comes back to Greeley, Colorado, where he works, which is what they thought. So they arrest both of them once they have them for first degree murder. And Bond is set at, and this is a 1993, five million apiece. Five million. In other words, have a seat in that jail. You're going to be there a while, homie. Five million dollars. You're not leaving. Million dollars. Million dollars. Million dollars. Five million dollars. Five million dollars five million dollars you're not you're not leaving a million million
2:46:58million dollars five million dollars five million sorry you have to see twins and see danny devito freak out over five five million five it's very fun he thinks it's a thousand so anyway yeah this is what's going on now after the arrest yeah jill asked to talk to the detectives this is how fucking insanely overconfident she is cocky to fish at what they have to try to she thinks she can talk them out of it because she can talk men into anything apparently so the interview is taped and uh it's not good um later on she's going to try to say they forced her into it, but they find that she asked for the interview, no evidence of coercion. She interrupted them numerous times during the Miranda advisement,
2:47:48but was in the end fully advised of her rights and understood them and talked willingly to officers. During the interview, Jill said, I have nine alibi witnesses, nine. I'm gold here. She said that, listen, number one, it wasn't me. I have nine alibi witnesses. So let's just get me off the table right now. And then I'll try to help you figure out who actually did this. Sure. She said, the thing is that you guys don't know as Jerry is a closeted homosexual. Okay. That's what she said. His sex life is outrageous. All over the place. He fucks everybody but her. He's gay. He's in the closet. And he has a mysterious lover. And that's who did it. It's another on the down low guy. And he doesn't want Jerry to blow up his spot.
2:48:36So he killed him. It'll ruin everything. So there you go. Now, they never found nine alibi witnesses. As a matter of fact, they found zero alibi witnesses. And they said she flirted with the detectives the entire fucking interview. She flirts with them as well, which, by the way, it doesn't help. It never works. It does not work. It just shows how guilty you are. It's just on video for all of us to laugh at. That's it, and it's so much fun to watch when that happens. Now, mid-December 1993, the national press gets a hold of this. Because the Houston Chronicle publishes an in-depth story connecting this Colorado arrest with the 72 shooting of Clark Coy. So then that becomes picked up by everywhere around the country because that's a fucking
2:49:25interesting story, as you can see here. It's crazy. You could put it on Netflix, do a podcast about it. It's awesome. It's unbelievable. Hundreds of thousands of people will watch it. It's wild. So December 26, 1993, there's a story in the Los Angeles Times under the headline, After 10 Marriages, Woman is Jailed on Murder Charges, which is, that's a great headline. I mean, salacious as shit. A subheading read, Jill Coit and a Boyfriend are Being Held in the Death of Husband number nine. Number three also met an untimely end. Jesus Christ. Calls are coming into the Steamboat Pilot newsroom, which is a small paper, from all over the world. Wow. And this is 94, early 94. They don't have an email.
2:50:15They have no way to do things. So they're photocopying shit and mailing them to Japan and folders, Italy, everywhere. It's crazy. That Brad Bolchunos guy or Bolchunos guy from the pilot, that guy who writes for them said all of this was about this kind of small woman who maybe has this crafty look about her. That might've been the person you see walking down the street. There were bizarre things we started hearing about right away. And then they start hearing about the affairs and all the weird shit. And one other guy, a pilot columnist named Joanna Dotter, said that, yeah, yeah, Joanna, said that, quote, people in Steamboat will always have something that sets them apart from others who hear that case, this case, because it's local and it's a local guy.
2:51:02And so it sounds real salacious nationally. But here it's a real personal story. It's part of their life. Yeah. He said, we can't help but grieve for a good family that never deserved this. With the murder of Jerry Boggs, all of us lost another piece of this community's innocence. Now, throughout 94 and 95, she's going to be held in the Routt County Jail. And she's regarded by the staff as the worst inmate they've ever had. Ever. She's difficult? Really? This is an interviewee here. Quote from the jail staff. She was one of the worst inmates. She was the worst inmate in the history of the jail, the history of the county. The minute she got in there, she started trying to manipulate people, turning one against the other, exactly what she had done with the Boggs family.
2:51:53She just can't help it. What is she doing? Getting this one said this about you, getting people to fight, getting people to do things for her. She's manipulative. Manipulating. Puppet mastering. Manipulating the inmates to try to pull puppet strings to keep her happy and entertained and also in charge of shit. She tries to manipulate the guard so she can get things and all that kind of shit. Now, why did she marry so many times? Well, she said, quote, I sleep with them. So I marry them. OK, I could just sleep with them. You get like a normal person. Normal people don't marry everybody. They fuck. That's not normal. Holy fuck. There are people on Tinder that be on their 88th fucking marriage.
2:52:38It's insane yeah um wow she also said before this you could ask any of my husbands and they would tell you i was an excellent wife before this you know obviously for this murder part oh except for that third one you know he said that yeah so both of these people, Michael and Jill, have their both win a change of venue motion to get it out of the county. Jill's lawyers brought in an expert who had surveyed public opinion across the 14th Judicial District. And according to that expert, unfavorable responses above 40 percent meant a fair and impartial jury could not be seated easily. More than 40% of respondents believed she was guilty or probably guilty. Not only that they knew about the case,
2:53:26just knowing about the case isn't enough to get you off a jury. You have to have a hard opinion on it. That can't be changed by, I know him and she did it. Yeah, that's it. We know him and fuck her. That's what it was. So the survey was weighted by population which meant most of its residents came from Route County, the district's most populous county and the place where the murder happened. So the judge grants part of the motion. He moved the trial out of the county but not out of the judicial district. He sent it to Grand County which is neighboring and still in that district. Okay. Jill's lawyers appealed that and attached a new survey limited to Grand County. And in Grand County, the unfavorable responses came in under 40 percent.
2:54:08So the judge said, good enough. That's where we're going. So the trial is held. It is a joint trial between with her and Bacchus together, which is awesome, too. Hilarious. Hilarious. is a joint trial between with her and Bacchus together, which is awesome too. You don't want that, do you? Hilarious. It would be harder to convict him on anything but conspiracy without having her next to him. It's a six-week trial. It is fucking long. And it takes place in early 1995, which means it is nationally, no one says shit about it because there is only one court case going on in 1995. One trial that we give a fuck about. And that is on TV all day, every day, and it's O.J. And every character in this trial is better than the next.
2:54:53It's insane. So people missed this for O.J., which this is technically almost as interesting, I think, pretty much. I mean, apart from the national celebrity part of it, yeah. This is, I mean, as a case itself, this is pretty fucking interesting. If OJ is just a random L.A. black guy, this is so much more fascinating. Would Chris Rock say if he was Arnthal, the bus driver, murder? It wouldn't even be OJ. He'd be Arnthal the bus driving murderer if he was a bus driver. That's what it is. That's a great line. So Jill Coit gets a lawyer from Denver described as very, very competent. And Michael Backus gets Leonard Davies, who I've heard of this guy, described as very colorful. And they said Backus had a very colorful attorney named Leonard Davies,
2:55:41and Jill had a very, very competent attorney named Joseph St. Veltri. And the Routt County prosecutors were more than committed to, you know, seeing justice done and seeing Jill brought down in this case. The prosecution's case, pretty simple. She did this to keep evidence out of the civil courtroom. They said the evidence, which concerns such matters as the defendant's allegedly bigamous marriage, her false claims of pregnancies and other false and fraudulent fraudulent activities on her part, admittedly portrayed the defendant as an evil, conniving, and manipulative person. However, it's supported by the prosecution's theory that the defendant murdered the victim to prevent exposure of the evidence in the civil trial,
2:56:23thus established the motive for the killing. So they have to let in all of her crazy shit because that's what she was trying to avoid. The only thing they keep out is the Clark Coit thing. They don't put the possible murder of Clark in there because that would be prejudicial. They have a ton of fucking evidence, bigamous weddings, false pregnancies, false child support, all this crazy shit. Now, they also, they look through everything here. Backus's attorney's opening here. He does some crazy shit, and the judge stops him and warned Leonard Davies that if he causes a mistrial, he's going to fucking pay for it. Oh, you're going to pay the cost. You're going to pay the costs of it if you cause a mistrial here.
2:57:10So don't fucking do it on purpose because sometimes that's a thing, which is interesting. Now, one of the things they bring in is something we'd have known nothing about. The rest of it we all know about, all the different, the Troy Giffen, all the witnesses, the lady in Iowa that she asked to kill somebody, Ohio, all that shit. There's a tape, an audio tape played for the jury. Well, I'll read this. This is right from the newspaper. Jurors at Jill Coit's murder trial on Friday heard a conversation surreptitiously surreptitiously taped by her slain eighth husband in which the two argue over whether Coit really gave birth to his child. The prosecution played the recording during the second day of testimony in the trial of court and Michael Backus.
2:57:57They are charged with first degree murder, blah, blah, blah. OK. In trying to portray Coit as scheming and manipulative, prosecutors played the tape Friday to show how Coit tried to persuade Boggs to remarry her by convincing him she had Boggs' baby when she had not. She had had no children. Where the fuck did they find that tape? That's awesome. Yeah. Prosecutors said Boggs taped the conversation without Coit's knowledge upon the advice of his attorney. That's why he made it. Yeah. He said, Boggs has heard to say on the tape, I want you to get off that baby kick. There's no baby. And she said, her response is, I have a baby. You don't. Right. And she said, her response is, I have a baby, you don't.
2:58:41Right. Boggs said, so Jerry said, if you have a baby and it's mine, you better get it here real fast. You better fucking show it to me then. And later, he is heard to say, you took more from me than I can ever realize. And he added that he had spent nine months expecting her to have his baby only to find out there's no baby. He said he learned from Jill's parents that there was no child. Your fucking parents told me you didn't have a baby. You lying asshole. So yeah, there's that. Now, Jerry's attorney here, Jerry Boggs, his attorney testifies and testifies about all of the financial issues that basically Jill had given Boggs $100,000 lien on the bed and breakfast. It was drawn up jointly by Boggs and Coit to make the establishment less desirable to the other guy suing her for money. So they said Boggs wanted Jill to sign a non-disturbance agreement as a condition for his dissolving
2:59:43the deed of trust, but she refused. The proposed agreement would have prohibited Coit from using Boggs' name, from harassing him, and from making false claims about the purported child. She wouldn't sign that. They also bring up Carl Steely. Remember that guy? Yeah the one she was with when she met him um so they bring him in um and he said that he they bring him in for a very specific person a purpose that he says she bragged that her, quote, mercenary training, she had some kind of training somewhere, her mercenary training made her, quote, more conniving. Now she knows how to connive even more as if she could possibly use that. All right. Seth testifies. He's the star witness. Sure. Under immunity.
3:00:35He said that he did tell her, if you do anything stupid, wear gloves, and that she did call him and said, hey, baby, it's done and it's messy. He talks about the bloody towels, the blood on his hat that he cut up and buried. So he's admitting to destroying evidence. He's admitting to multiple crimes. Helping a lot. But helping a lot. And it's one of those things where the jury might have disregarded his testimony if he wasn't her son. But the fact that you are testifying against your mother, you're not just doing that for immunity. You're doing that because it's true. To do the right thing. It's fucking true. Yeah. Then they also said this. Here's a quote from somebody who watched the trial.
3:01:19What was very interesting to note at the trial was when her three sons testified against their mother. This is something you don't see very often. This is a rarity. And when each son would take the witness stand, Jill would wave at them and smile and try to get their attention, but they would not make eye contact with her. They all ignored their mother. They all ignored her. They said, you can almost imagine what it must have been like to have been first dragged around the country with all those husbands and boyfriends. And now they're ultimately testifying against their own mother for first degree murder. I just saw it in the process. That's amazing. I just saw a documentary on a woman who was put up on murder charges and there was retrials. And then she was an idiot and acted
3:02:04as her own attorney and got locked up again when she should have gotten off. But her daughter testified against her and she sat there and smiled and said, and now I still love you at her daughter and started crying, like totally just screwed her up on the stand. Yeah, manipulated her. So the defense, their whole case is what the little things the prosecution doesn't have, not what they have. That's a lot. So there's no physical evidence putting her or Jerry or Michael Backus inside Jerry's house. There's no fingerprints. There's no DNA linking them to the scene. No gun had ever been found. Nobody had ever seen either one of them leaving the house. They said the neighbor's description of a disguised person, by definition, is not an identification.
3:02:55It was a disguised person. It's a disguise. I can't believe Jill put on a fake mustache for this. What a fucking idiot. It's for the audience. So... Well, she wiggled her ass down the road. Yeah, well, she still kept her... Yeah. The defense maintained the camping alibi. It attacked Seth as a witness with immunity, a motive to shift blame, and a remitted role in destroying evidence. Bacchus's lawyer argued that most of the evidence was about Jill, not Backus, and that trying the two together allowed Jill's history to contaminate the case against his client. Neither defendant testified. Now, Jill was thinking about it. The judge questioned Jill in detail about her right to testify and what cross-examination
3:03:37might cover, and the record reflects she went back and forth on the decision and then ultimately said, never mind, I'm good. And Backus said, fuck no, not happening. Not a chance. So during closing arguments, they said, you know, remember what she said. Jill said, you heard her on tape say she had nine alibi witnesses. You see one of them on the fucking stand today? Not a one. Jill's lawyers moved for a mistrial, arguing this was an improper comment on her decision not to testify. The judge said, what are you, out of your fucking mind? It's a proper comment on the failure to produce the alibi witnesses she herself had named. That's what it is. It's not what the lawyer said in the beginning. It's what she said on the failure to produce the alibi witnesses she herself had named. That's what it is.
3:04:18It's not what the lawyer said in the beginning. It's what she said on the goddamn tape. So the verdict comes in. The jury, by the way, in deliberations, asked to review the testimony of four witnesses. Transcripts had not been prepared yet, which is awful. That's terrible courting, everybody. The court reporter estimated it would take about 13 and a half hours to read back the testimony of the four witnesses they wanted. It's just like in shorthand steno at the moment? Well, even once it's been, once the transcript is produced, it'll take 13 and a half hours to read it back to them. The defense lawyers were, they were not in agreement on whether to do it. Jill's lawyers wanted it honored, while Backus's lawyers said, we don't need this read back. All right. Court's view is that you should rely upon your collective memories of the testimony that was given.
3:05:21And if you have further requests, the court would consider that. But it is the procedure that would be followed. Please return to your deliberation. I hate that answer. Well, it's just use your recollection. You don't need to have the whole trial read back to you. That's ridiculous. What if they were like, we need to look at this picture? And they're like, wow, you remember what it looked like. Six weeks is a long time. If somebody's testimony from week two, you might not remember. I get that. Oh, it was that long ago. Six weeks is the fucking trial. But they deliberate for five hours. Okay. And they come back and find Jill and Michael guilty of first degree murder and conspiracy to commit first degree murder.
3:06:00They go to sentencing. It's pretty easy here. You, sir and ma'am, may fuck off life without parole. Yep. Plus 48 years on the conspiracy count. On top of that, plus a $1 million fine for each defendant. That'll keep them from writing a book because anything you make comes right back to us. They didn't have the Slayer statute in there, but they did have you can pay the victims that shit or restitution or whatever the fuck it is. So, wow. Doug Boggs, Jerry's brother, said she picked the wrong town. She picked the wrong man. She picked the wrong man. She picked the wrong family. And then he spun his six-shooter around and put it back in his holster. Doug Boggs takes no shit. Doug Boggs ain't taking no shit.
3:06:49I love Doug. I think he's awesome. He's great. He's my favorite guy in this fucking case. Bitch killed my brother. That bitch killed my brother. Fuck her. You messed with the wrong family, bitch. I can't wait to talk at the end of her sentence. I can't wait. He's waiting for that shit. He did something else amazing that you're going to love, too. The steamboat pilot said, quote, we were more aware of that sort of pervading sadness about what had happened to Jerry Boggs. Oh, that man ran the hardware store. How sad that he thought he met a woman who beguiled him. And tragically, she did. Headline in the New York Times says, woman guilty of murdering husband number nine. That sounds like she killed all nine husbands.
3:07:35Yeah, she killed the first date, too. That's you'll open that fucking article when jill is finally transferred to state prison out of the route county jail this is fucking there was a party they had a party at the jail because she was gone this is uh here's a quote quote so when they finally got rid of her she was sentenced they took her away doug doug boggs bought a case of champagne for everybody in the jail they all got together and drank champagne because the monster had been brought down that's amazing doug's a bad motherfucker he showed up popping corks in this bitch man that's wild now the thing that we never find out is who pulled the trigger we don't know yeah um we we think basically it doesn't matter because they were both there so
3:08:27legally it doesn't matter but you know and just curiosity it fucking matters um detectives believed jill was the shooter i think so too i think he hit him with the shovel he had the physical thing she had the yeah she can't cut I think he hit him with the shovel. He had the physical thing. She can't. Yeah. She can't cut somebody's fucking face open with a shovel. That's, I mean, you need the height of the fucking gravity to help you with that. And the man swing. Yep. So they entered through the back door, waited for Jerry, hit him with the stun gun, beat him with the shovel, tried to strangle him. And then Jill said, fuck it and shot him three times. That's what they detectives think. We don't know though. October 3rd, 1995
3:09:02TV movie airs. Yeah. Six months later it's on Fox of course. Legacy of Sin. The William Coit story. Oh, the Coit story. The William Coit story. This is all told from the perspective of Billy. Oh. The second son. He is played by Neil Patrick Harris, by the way. There you go. Is he a doogie house? Yep. It's told from the point of him as he investigates the death of his father. And he was too young to remember. Bonnie Bedelia plays Jill. And Gary Graham plays Mike Backus. And Ernie Lively plays Jerry Boggs. The tagline was a mothered together in the end and said, we've got to bring this woman down. You know, she's created havoc all over the country. If a story like this has any good parts, you know, it's that these brothers came together to do the right thing because they were so critical.
3:10:15There was no physical evidence tying them to the crime. So anyway, 1997, Jill appeals. It doesn't go anywhere. It's based on the fact that they let in all of her past stuff, not the coit thing, but all of her marriages and bigamousness and all that. 1998, Jill tried to place a personal ad from prison. The Department of Corrections removes it. Wow. In the newspaper, she tried to do it. Then a later ad on a site called Cyber Inmates carried a headline. This is her pitch. Quote, want U.S. citizenship? Marry an inmate. That's what she's pushing. They took that ad down, too. She's using the most desperate line to get married. That's funny. Last resort. Here I am. 2002, she published an online editorial calling for an investigation into her treatment in custody.
3:11:16Oh, God. She said she'd been denied therapeutic braces for her back and hands, alleged sexual abuse, and said a guard had broken her finger. Oh. A bunch of appeals are denied. Michael Beck, it's appeals. She appeals again. She appeals in 2006 based on the federal property search there. They say, no, that was all good. She sues the Colorado Department of Corrections and several officers alleging sexual assault and denial of basic rights. A federal court says, get the fuck out of here. You have no evidence. Now at the end, June 2026, just happened. Jill files her application for executive clemency with the governor of Colorado, asking him to commute her sentence. This motherfucker. She said, quote, now in my 80s and blind, no longer physically capable of life I once lived, no meaningful risk to public safety.
3:12:15She can't get anyone to fuck her now, so it would be impossible. She wrote she accepted responsibility for what she did. Now she's admitting it. And that if released, she planned to live out her remaining years in Colorado Springs, which is a sentence in itself. Now it's great. Yeah. She a district attorney called it an egregious betrayal of justice and the people of Route County. And she can go fuck herself and say, no, thank you. There is no clemency. She did do an interview with Candace DeLong at one point, too. Really? Yeah. And I tie an episode called The Black Widow Bride, where she said, quote, all of a sudden I'm this bad person because I committed a murder. It's embarrassing and humiliating.
3:13:02Yeah. Yeah. She said that on camera into a camera. Michael Backus is serving his sentence in the Colorado Department of Corrections. Looks like he is in the Lyman Correctional Facility here. He has not applied for clemency and he's never implicated Jill, by the way. Never said – she has had a spell on this man. Never did anything. One of the people in the Oxygen documentary said, Bacchus wouldn't turn evidence on her. Never did. He should have. He should have said, hey, I used a stun gun on him, and I beat him, but I didn't shoot him. She shot him. She sucks at that good, man. Yeah, that's what I'm saying. At some point, Jill was transferred out of Colorado under an alias, according to this.
3:13:48She was placed in Nebraska, Oklahoma, Florida, all over the place. She was later returned to Colorado. Her inmate number is 86530. She's held at the Denver Women's Cor later returned to Colorado. Her inmate number is 86530. She's held at the Denver Women's Correctional Facility. And here are some quotes about her from the Oxygen documentary. One, it's very rare to find a woman who's a total and complete psychopath. It is. That's a guy thing. Jill saw marriage as a means to an end to get money for men. Jill saw men as a target of opportunity. And I think she looked for men that had trouble with relationships or even having a relationship. Yeah. I said, it would take a very strong man, a man experienced in life experience with women to be able to spot what Jill
3:14:29was all about. Most men couldn't. That's the fact. Um, so they said she's a cold blooded killer. And if we didn't catch her rest assured, she would have killed again. Society is protected from her. Absolutely. She's not going to find victims 13, 14, 15. There's not going to be three or four more dead guys for their money. She's blind. Now the books here, Stephen Singulars charmed to death. That was the book published in 1995. First, I believe that became the basis for the TV movie. Not bad. Then, where we got a lot of quotes from this week is Clifford Leyendecker's Poisoned Vows, and that's available on Kindle and whatever. This was written during the trial and weeks before sentencing covering the whole span of Joe's life.
3:15:18So he got all his stuff from court. Now, both were written knowing that their subject had been fined $1 million to keep her from writing this kind of book. So they knew they had the market cornered there. It's appeared on The New Detectives, Forensic Files, American Justice, Deadly Women, Oxygen's Black Widow Murders It's been on a bunch of shit Hopefully we I don't know if it's been on Snap I didn't see it on that one Shouldn't be Snapped She wasn't abused Also she didn't Snap This is pretty fucking planned out She may have Snapped at birth for Christ's sake No shit This bitch is dangerous So anyway There you go There is Steamboat Springs, Colorado in a fucking wild ass story. That is a crazy goddamn story.
3:16:01Hope you enjoyed it. If you did, tell everyone about it. Get on whatever app you're on. Give us five stars. It helps a ton. I don't know why, but it does. Netflix, double thumbs up us, please. Two of those. One for each of us. That would be good. I got two guns. I got two thumbs. One for each of you. So be good i got two guns one i got two thumbs one for each of you so there you go do that uh follow on social media at small town murder on instagram at small town pod on facebook definitely head over to shut up and give me murder.com get tickets for live shows last two of the year terrytown november 13th this week in two days it's over after this which is about sold out so i don't think you're going to get into that one.
3:16:40But Boston, Medford, right outside Boston, November 14th, Saturday night, come party, last show of the year. Then new dates for 2027 will come out this month. They'll be on sale in December. So do that. Shut up and give me murder.com. And we'll announce that, obviously, and do all that shit. Patreon. You want Patreon. Patreon.com, and we'll announce that, obviously, and do all that shit. Patreon. You want Patreon. Patreon.com slash CrimeInSports, just like the name of our other show. You should check out. Also listen to your stupid opinions. But Patreon.com slash CrimeInSports, all the bonus material. Anybody $5 a month or above, you get everything we put out. You get almost 400 back bonus episodes as soon as you subscribe.
3:17:18Binge on that. New ones every other week. One crime and sports, one small town murder. You get them all. Everything. This week, crime and sports, Harlem Globetrotters. Fantastic. Crazy awesome history and a lot of fun. And we'll talk about, you know, they helped Scooby-Doo solve crimes and almost got Gilligan off an island. You got to give them some credit for that. Close. Then for small town murder, we are going to talk about how Nazi scientists and Nazi drug policies influenced America and kind of made the 60s happen. It's very interesting. We'll talk all about that. It's from a book called Tripped, which is the next one of the book Blitz that we did at Patreon. How did math make Kate Ashbery happen? Dell SD, more likely.
3:18:00Anyway, check that out. Patreon.com slash crime in sports is where you get all of those and more and everything else. What else do you get? Well, you get all the shows we put out ad-free is what you get, which is a big deal. And then on top of that, you also get a shout-out at the end of the show, which is right now, Jimmy, do me a favor. Hit me with the names of the people who would never marry us plus nine other guys and then kill us. Jimmy, hit me with them right fucking now. This is Executive Producer Curtis in South Carolina. Curtis, thank you. Latasha Campbell. Big Daddy B Truckin'. He be doing that. Keep on truckin', Big Daddy. And Steve Schnell had to put down his cat, Jasper, the poor guy.
3:18:44That's so sad. Steve's the best. Yeah, we like him a lot. Good dude. He had a big, a Brendel cat that he lost. That's brutal, man. The cat was like 17. Fucking hell. Oh, that sucks. He really did it. At least he had a good run anyway. But still, that sucks. It's a long time. Other, that sucks. He really did it. At least he had a good run. Anyway, still, that sucks. We hate that. It's a long time. Other producers this week, Travis Sundahl, Peyton Meadows, Gary Howardson, Gansavort, New York. Do you know where that is? Never heard of it before, Gary. You are finding the corners, baby. Happy hours in Springfield, Illinois. None of these truckers can ever get a good place. No, no. Maybe it's just cheap to stay in these shitholes.
3:19:21And it's probably better. Good truck stop there, maybe. Yeah, saves them money because gas is outrageous for them. Who knows? Thomas Woodward, Janice Hill, Liz Vasquez, Morgan McAllister, Josh E. Danny would know last name. Lisa Scott, Conan Janis, Kanon, Gabriella with no last name, Angie with no last name, Michelle Perry, Catherine Heaton, Matthew Goodwiler, Sam with no last name, Cassandra Hampton, Jennifer Lastman, Mama Mason, Elizabeth Charles, Opal with no last name, RJV, Natalie Blaisdell, oh, Toneby? Is that Toneby? No, that's got to be Toneby. That's got to be an accident. Toneby, Toneby, Toneby. Toneby Zitko? It's got to be Toneby Zitko. Or maybe it's Tobi. Look, I don't know. Both letters are right next to each other.
3:20:11Oh, no. Toneby or Toneby could be either one. Cynthia Valky. Sarah Bear. John Brightman. Hama Samich. Sarah Bear. John Brightman. Hama Samich. Tonya. Tonya. Tonya Patterson. Patterson. Alicia with no last name. Sarah Sugars. Rana Anchato. Ben Bridges. Joey Bomar. Jeremy Clay. Dom and Blind. Wait, what? That's just Dom. We know that guy. Why and Blind? We know Dom. Yeah. Why are you making me say Wait, what? That's just Dom. We know that guy. Why and blind? We know Dom. Yeah. Why are you making me say that, Dom? Maybe it's, maybe it was because he can't type. You know what I mean? I'm sure there's some way he can type. Dom and blind. It's that guy. Word to text. Yeah. Dr. Felicia Hacker. Speak to text.
3:20:52Ashley Boom. We know you, Dom. Eddie would know last name. Lee would know last name. Lachelle Cross. Lisa Kramer. Kramer Lacey.. Lachelle Cross. Lisa Kramer. Kramer-Lapie. Oh. Kramer-Lape? Joey Ayers. Kramer-Lapie. Crazy Cat Lady. Whoops-a-Daisy. Ashley with no last name. Dream Spliff. Ashley Marsh. Tom Henley. Curtis Higginbottom. Ciara. Ciara with no last name. Paul English. Natasha Garrett. Rebecca Anderson. Matt Leachman. Ollie English. Natasha Garrett. Rebecca Anderson. Matt Leachman. Ollie Marshall Stern. Jody Layton. Antonio Ryan McFarlane. Maria with no last name. Clint Beshears. Shannon with no last name. Nikki and the dogs at Poop. Oh, Pampered Pooch. I tried to read that too quick.
3:21:34That was going to be Poopered Pamp. Poochered Pamp. All right. Simon with no last name. Sarah with going to be Pooperd Pamp. Pooterd Pamp. All right. Simon would know last name. Sarah would know last name. Liz Schaefer. Kevin Wilkin. Brenda Hauser. Bruce Barton. Crystal Wolf. Danica would know last name. Gary Bacon. Tara Gregorich. Rain would know last name. Jennifer Myers. Jeffrey Bailey. Robert Ferrand. Lula Bell. Brenna Jennings. Tammy Campouse. Baby Cakes. Beth would know the last name. Lauren Clymer. Bethany Zimple. Woody Torkelson. Is that? Yep. Nakia Bolden. Meredith Grant. Michael Jones. Sean M.C. Britt would know the last name. Bonnie Yurden. Kelsey Kennimore, Tyson Grimmett, Tucker with no last name, Mason with no last name, Ryan Mokes, Eric Hilton, Amy Waters, Courtney Brugman, and all of our patrons.
3:22:33You guys are the best. Thank you so much, everybody. God damn it, you guys are awesome. We just appreciate the shit out of all that you do for us. You're as consistent as we are. That's right. We keep putting them out, and you keep coming and getting them. So we're happy with that, and we'll keep doing that. Let's keep that whole system moving. So thank you for doing that. Check it out. If you want to follow either of us or find out anything else, shut up and give me murder.com is how you do that. Keep coming back week after week and seeing us. And until next week, everybody, it's been our pleasure. And you know what really agitates me? Watching you scratch up your truck bed with your mountain bike
3:23:29and mess up the inside of your truck with muddy hiking boots. It just makes me like grrr. So take better care of your truck with products from WeatherTech. From custom-fit impact liner and floor liners to no-drill mud flaps and side window deflectors, WeatherTech can keep your whole truck looking like new. And that makes me less agitated, which is better for everyone. Trust me. Outfit your truck today at WeatherTech.com. DeWalt nailers are now at Lowe's. For a limited time, save on everything you need for your next job. Like the new DeWalt 20-volt max 18-gauge nailer. Stop by Lowe's or visit Lowe's.com today. While supplies last, selection varies by store. Insurance may all seem the same on the surface,
3:24:12but having insurance isn't the same as having State Farm. It's like getting a granola bar with a candle in it when you wanted a three-layer birthday cake. You wouldn't settle for just any dessert on your birthday, so don't settle for just any insurance. When it comes to getting the help you need, State Farm is the real deal. Like a good neighbor, State Farm is there. Hey, everybody listening to Small Town Murder out there. Hi. Good to see you out there. I'm here with Jimmy, too. And this is an ad, but not an ad for a product. This is an ad for tour dates. Yes. Come see a live show. The 2026 tour. All the tickets are for sale right now, starting out with February 21st in Nashville, March 6th in Durham, March 7th in Atlanta.
3:24:55Phoenix is sold out. We do have tickets, though, to Your Stupid Opinions on the 21st of March. Salt Lake City sold out. Denver has tickets. Be there on May 2nd. May 29th, Buffalo sold out. Royal Oak, Michigan, May 30th. We have September 18th, Milwaukee. September 19th, Minneapolis. October the 3rd in Dallas. October 16th in San Jose. October 17th in Sacramento. November 13th in Tarrytown. November 14th in Boston. Come see us. The live shows are spectacular. Come join all of the other STM people. You're going to meet so many people. You're going to have fun. Make some new friends. Like crazy and make some new friends. Come out and see us. ShutUpAndGiveMeMurder.com is where you go for those tickets. Get them right now while they're hot.
3:25:36See you on the road.