Small Town Murder · · Transcript & summary by WhipScribe
It traces how one family's trauma and a string of missed warnings ended in four killings in a single day in Vermont.
Tap a chapter to open that moment in the transcript; the link to it is copied for you.
“I can't take back that day. I wish I could, but I can't.” Jody Herring · at 1:18:07 — open in the transcript →
The roots of the case go back to November 1979, when David Herring, a father of 16 on a Vermont farm, was found shot in his front yard. The family ruled it a suicide, but his five-year-old daughter Jody never accepted that. Her childhood then fell apart, with seizures, a stepfather who beat the children, and being thrown out of the house as a young teen. Years of drug problems, misdemeanor charges, and two daughters taken into state custody followed.
By 2015 Jody Herring had lost her job and her home, and she lost custody of her youngest daughter after a third DUI. She moved in with Henry Premont, who later told police she had shown him a list of people she planned to kill. Two gun stores turned her away in March because of a 1998 court disqualification. On the morning of August 7, three relatives, Rhonda, Regina and Julianne, were shot dead at a farmhouse in Berlin. That afternoon Herring fired at DCF social worker Laura Sobel in a state office parking lot as Sobel lay on the ground.
Scott Williams, the county prosecutor, had once defended Herring, and he was in a gym near the lot when the shots rang out. He stayed with Sobel until she died. Herring was calm and even laughing after her arrest, and in July 2017 she pleaded guilty to four killings. At sentencing the judge imposed life without parole for Sobel's murder and 20 years to life on the other three counts, to run concurrently. Premont was separately convicted of misdemeanors after a two-hour standoff at a gas station.
At her sentencing, Jody Herring said she could not take back the day of the August 2015 shootings and wished she could. She also said she wished she had stayed in the hospital the full 90 days recommended after her suicide attempt, instead of leaving after five days.
“I can't take back that day. I wish I could, but I can't.”Jody Herring · 1:18:07
As part of her 2017 guilty plea to four killings, Jody Herring signed a written confession. In it she said she did not resist after being disarmed and that a life in jail would be worth it.
“if I have to go to jail for the rest of my life, it was worth it.”Jody Herring · 1:15:00
Desiree said the state child welfare agency, DCF, had been involved in her life for as long as she could remember. She said her mother reported her to the agency, and the state later took Desiree's baby.
“DCF has just been pretty much involved in her whole life.”Desiree · 33:15
In August 2015 Jody Herring killed three relatives at a farmhouse in Berlin, Vermont, then shot DCF social worker Laura Sobel in a parking lot. Herring pleaded guilty in 2017 and received life without parole for Sobel's murder, with 20 years to life on the other three counts to run concurrently.
At her sentencing, Jody Herring apologized to the families and said she could not take back that day. She said she wished she had stayed in the hospital the full 90 days recommended after her 2015 suicide attempt, rather than leaving after five days. She also said she had asked for help several times and did not get it. The judge described her as a caring mother, though not a good one, and imposed life without parole for Laura Sobel's murder.
Jody Herring tried to buy a .40 caliber Ruger in March 2015 at MidState Sports in Randolph, and the federal background check refused her. A judge named Edward Cashman had disqualified her from possessing a firearm in 1998 because of mental health issues. She tried a second gun store four days later and was denied again.
Laura Sobel was a Department for Children and Families social worker who had spent about 14 years as a family services worker and had handled the case of Jody Herring's youngest daughter. On August 7, 2015, around 4:45 p.m., she walked out of a state office building in Vermont at the end of her Friday shift while on the phone with her youngest daughter. Herring shot her, fired again at close range as she lay on the ground, and Sobel died on the sidewalk.
Henry Premont, who had lived with Jody Herring, was in a Shell station parking lot in August 2015 holding two beers when police confronted him. He threw one beer down, pulled a .380 handgun from his holster, and raised it. Officers took cover behind cruisers, and a two-hour standoff followed with no shots fired. He was placed on a 72-hour psychiatric hold and convicted of misdemeanors.
Scott Williams, the Washington County state's attorney who was prosecuting the case, said Henry Premont stood in front of the store's glass panels while provoking police and put everyone inside at risk. Williams had earlier defended Jody Herring on misdemeanor charges and was at the rehab gym near the parking lot when Laura Sobel was shot.
David Herring was found dead on November 17, 1979, in the front lawn of the family home with a pistol in his right hand, though his wife Janella said he was left-handed. Relatives also said the gun looked planted. Investigators closed the file as a suicide and never reopened it, but Jody Herring argued for decades that someone had killed her father.
Our own transcript of the public episode, with a timestamp about every 90 seconds. Tap a timestamp or the link button on a paragraph to copy a link that opens this page there.
0:00Spend this Thanksgiving with the Fockers. The beloved Meet the Parents franchise returns with a twist. Robert De Niro and Ben Stiller are back. Joined by Ariana Grande as the newest member of the family. Get ready for laughs, unexpected surprises, and a hilarious new chapter in the family saga. Focker-in-Law, rated PG-13. Only in theaters this Thanksgiving. You know you don't have to wait to shop Black Friday at Lowe's, right? Only in theaters this Thanksgiving. Shop Black Friday deals before the rush at Lowe's. Valid through 1118. $25 minimum and loyalty membership acquired. Order eligible items by 2 p.m. Subject to weight and size restrictions and availability. Terms at Lowes.com slash shipping terms. Hello, everybody, and welcome back to Small Town Murder Express.
1:13Yay and choo-choo. Yay indeed, Jimmy. Yay indeed. My name is James Petrigallo. I'm here with my co-host. I'm Jimmy Wissman. Thank you, folks, so much for joining us today on another absolutely really crazy edition of Small Town Murder Express. Last week, we squeezed a serial killer into here last week. So we'll stuff it in. And this week is just as crazy, honestly. Wow, this is a wild, wild, wild story. We'll get to that and more. Before we do, though, head over to ShutUpAndGiveMeMurder.com. Get your tickets for live shows now. If you're listening to this right when it comes out, we are currently performing in Tarrytown. So hello from stage. Right at this moment. So if you're listening right away, you can still get tickets for November the 14th in
1:59Medford, outside of Boston. That's the last show of the year. So come join us. This and the next couple weeks, we'll be announcing our 2027 tour, and those tickets will go on sale in early December, so get ready for that. Absolutely. So shut up and give me. Murder.com is where you get all that stuff and all the merchandise and everything else. Also, get yourself Patreon. Oh, boy. Do yourself a favor, everybody. It's a mere cup of coffee. Patreon.com slash Crime in Sports, which is the name of our other show that you should definitely check out because it's really funny. But Patreon.com slash Crime in Sports. All you have to be is $5 a month or above, and you get everything we put out. As soon as you subscribe, you're going to get almost 400 back bonus episodes you've never heard before.
2:45Then you get new ones every other week, one crime and sports, one small-town murder, and you get them all, everybody. And it's a good deal. This week, what you're going to get for crime and sports, we talked about the Harlem Globetrotters. Sure did. And the history of them, and it was a lot more interesting than we could have imagined. First of all, they're 100 years old, which was interesting. There was some crime involved there. There was all sorts of some interesting stuff. Then for small-town murder, really cool topic. We talked about how the Nazis' search for a truth serum ended up with the hippie movement and the LSD movement and all that kind of thing. And you go, how is that connected?
3:19It's weird, but we figured it out. And it's very, very, very strange, mainly just LSD. So check all that out and more patreon.com slash crime in sports is where you get all that and on top of all that you get everything we put out crime in sports your stupid opinions small town murder both episodes all ad free god damn that's amazing ad free with your patreon and you get a shout out at the end of the regular show so we're kind people there you go we appreciate you. That said, I think it's time, everybody. What do you say? Let's all sit back here. I think it's time to clear the lungs, arms to the sky, and let's all shout. Shut up and give me murder. Let's do this, everybody. Yes, let's go. Let's go on a trip, shall we?
4:09Yeah. Let's do it. We are going to Vermont this week. We were in Maine a while ago. Now we're in Vermont. Vermont, very syrupy skiing going on there. Very original is what they are. Lots of trees. We're going to Berlin, Vermont. Fuck. So we were in Belgrade, Montana, which is Serbia. Now. Lots of trees. We're going to Berlin, Vermont. Fuck. So we were in Belgrade, Montana, which is Serbia. Now we're in Berlin. All these European named places here. This is in north central Vermont. You loved it so much, why'd you leave? That's such a strange thing to... There's so many towns named like that. The weirdest ones, though, are when they move a state over and name the town the same thing from the town they just left.
4:46So you could have just stayed a state over. It's not like you had to cross an ocean. 40 minutes to Burlington, about two hours and 10 minutes to Montreal, the other direction, and then about an hour to St. Albans, Vermont, which was our last Vermont episode. It was a while ago, episode 692, so it's been 60 episodes since we did a Vermont. One deadly twist, that one was. I remember that was a weird one. When they're up in the forest like that, things get weird, man. This is in Washington County. Area code 802. Population here, it's a small town. 28, 84. Real small. So not even 3,000 people. Median household income here, a little bit above the national average. 80,789. Median household income here, a little bit above the national average, $80,789.
5:27Yeah, but? Median home cost is right around the national average. Is that right? A little bit lower, actually. $340,300 there. I would have never guessed it. Vermont is fairly affordable. This is the middle of nowhere. Okay. It's really. There's 3,000 people there, yeah. Yeah, and the county's like right landlocked, well, it's all landlocked, but locked right in the middle. It doesn't border anything. It's right there. A little bit of history of this town. It was chartered in 1763. Very early, yeah. Yeah, the name Berlin is obviously from Germany, and it was the only German town name in the entire state of Vermont. Wow. Which is interesting. Yeah. The grantees who received the 70 original rights to the township
6:12were all priests, merchants, and judges. So they didn't just give it out to people who were just looking to move. They had to be like important people or whatever. So that was, of course, issued by the royal governor of New Hampshire. And he stated that each proprietor, settler or inhabitant should pay one ear of Indian corn for each acre of land. An ear of corn per acre. That's what it costs here. But you also got to take that from natives. Well, I think this is assuming that you've run them off and taken their corn. There's probably that too. And after 10 years, one shilling for each 100 acres. So that's your tax. After 10 years, you get a shilling for every 100 acres you own, which is nothing. So
7:01not bad. Pretty cheap to live up there. Pretty good deal. Reviews of this town. It has 4.1 stars on niche. There's nothing below three stars on there. So people seem to like it. Here's five stars. I love Berlin, Vermont. Right away. Love it. It is a quiet town. It's the perfect place to raise a child. Perfect. Perfect. The neighborhood is safe that I can let my child play outside without worrying about anything. Very safe. If you never heard this show, this is what this show is about. People who go, it's the perfect, like I let my kid go outside and then they're murdered viciously. I don't worry about anything. Yeah, that's amazing. I worry about nothing at all. Nothing. Here's four stars. The area is very safe and has little crime.
7:45We have the four seasons. I don't know if they mean the group, the hotel, or the actual seasons. All four, yeah. Which I enjoy. I see this area staying the same as it is, somewhat expensive to live here. And most of the people I know want the excitement of the city. Well, they're in the wrong place. They're in the wrong state. There's nowhere in Vermont that offers the excitement of the city. It's just not the way that it works there. Perhaps when I settle down and have kids, I may come back. It's a good place. When I'm ready to be boring, this is the place I'll be boring in. When I'm ready to not worry about anything. Yeah. This is a wild one. Four stars. The housing here is very diverse. They don't mean people, by the way.
8:28What does that mean? And ranges in a variety of shapes, sizes, and colors. They have different color houses here, Jimmy. There's not all the same... Oh, boy. There's different house shapes here. And sizes. You don't have to live in a big house or a tiny house. There's all sorts of different sizes in between. Shapes, colors, and sizes of houses. And sizes. You don't have to live in a big house or a tiny house. There's all sorts of different sizes in between. Shapes, colors, and sizes of houses. Houses. Makes a diverse community. Very diverse. From new to old, everyone can have a home they love. Everywhere in the United States is what that is. And then finally, three stars. Vermont has very special seasons, which usually means longer winters and a, quote, special muddy season in between winter and spring.
9:11Yeah, it's called when everything melts. It's muddy. That's how it works there. And also spring. And spring. Things to do here. The bear or Barry, B-A-R-R-E, could be either one. Yeah. It's a tough one there. Isn't there a bar? Is it bar? It might be bar. Yeah, yoga? Bar Heritage Festival this is. The B-A-R-R-E Heritage Festival. Now, that's in the next town over, and some stuff in our case takes place there, so I wanted to include them, and that's why I put them in here too. It's a fun-filled annual event that brings our community together. Oh, yeah. Live music, delicious food, a festive parade, fireworks. You know, a festival. You know, a festival. Band after band after band, they promise.
9:58Oh, boy. The musical acts include the Jacob Green Band. No. Train wreck. Two words. Nope. Thunder Horse, which sounds like booze. Sounds like cheap booze. Let me get a quarter of that Thunder Horse, all right? It's not Thunderbird and it's not Crazy Horse. It's Thunder Horse. Native Tongue and the Messengers. And Betty B., whose voice locals will recognize from Froggy Vermont's Country Superstation, is the master of ceremonies. Oh, my God. Attendees can watch street performances such as the Red Trouser Show and Kate the Great. Also, the Cycling Murrays are going to be there. Yeah. They don't have a lot ofs are going to be there. Yeah. They don't have a lot of money in reserve to be paying an act.
10:48I don't think so. Yeah. They do have the red trouser show, though, so that's good. I don't know what that is. I have no goddamn earthly clue what the fuck that is. Not at all. Anything that's a trouser show. I assume a bunch of guys with red pants that slap each other and do like Three Stooges maneuvers in the street. That's all I can imagine. Trouser show sounds illegal. Like you're going to get arrested for some sort of sexual crime. It's a trouser show. Yeah. He's going to fucking open up a zipper and obviously let that go out too. No children allowed. And the Cycling Murrays, I assume, are a family whose parents have forced these kids into doing bicycle tricks against their will so they can make a living.
11:29That said, let's talk about some murder. Oh, boy, is this one deep for an express. Okay. August 7th, 2015. Let's start. 4.45 p.m. This is in Bar or Barry or Bear or wherever the goddamn you say it. OK, the parking lot at City Place. So this is the Bear City Bar City Place that sits on North Main Street in downtown Bar, a few hundred feet from the courthouse, actually, the county courthouse. OK. Now, there is a state held offices there, obviously, including a regional Department of Child and Family Services there, like the CPS, basically. That's on the first floor, or that's there. And then there's also a gym on the first floor called Rehab Gym as well. Right. There. Now, shortly, it's about 4.45. Workers are coming out for the weekend. It's a Friday. So there's workers leaving the government buildings and there is people working out at the gym that just came from work. They hear two shots go off in the parking. Oh, shit. So now people know, too, that it's up here. You know what you know what a deer rifle sounds like in Vermont because there's a shitload of deer hunting. And they recognize it all as like a deer rifle sound. Everybody does. Yeah. So people in the upstairs
12:51buildings rush to the windows and they're looking down. There's a guy next door in a tavern parking lot talking to friends named Thomas Knowles. He calls 911. And there's a guy in the gym right there named Scott Williams, who is the newly elected Washington County state's attorney. So he's a prosecutor and he's a former defense lawyer as well. That's a very interesting connection here. But he was working out at the rehab gym on the first floor when he heard the shots. He ran outside and saw a woman he he knows lying on the first floor when he heard the shots, he ran outside and saw a woman he knows lying on the ground bleeding. And it's a woman named Laura Sobel. She works for DCF and he's known her for years.
13:34They work in a small town, both in the government. So they know each other. So that's interesting. So he sees her on the ground and he sees a woman standing near her holding a rifle. Oh, who he recognizes. Case standing near her holding a rifle. Oh. Who he recognizes. Case solved. Because he's represented her before. Oh, shit. That's how he knows her. Yeah. So that's interesting. And like I said, Laura Sobel is a social worker who he knows, and this is the scene he's in. He dives down to try to help this Laura Sobel lady, and then we'll find that out later on. Unpack. Let's unpack a little bit here. Let's start with a completely unrelated person. Well, not completely unrelated, but... No, can be, completely. David
14:15Sean Herring, let's start with. And his experience is at Happy Valley Farm. Doesn't that sound nice? Oh, what's that? That sounds great, doesn't it? Sounds idyllic, ducks walking around, quacking. Pigs, but without even mud on them. Like Babe, just bright pink. It was Happy Valley, not Hidden Valley. I feel like they'd move more ranch. They'd move a lot more ranch over here. So he's born in 1948, one of 16 children. Oh. If you got a farm, make some kids to work on them. That's abuse, right? Anything more, you know my opinions, and people will say, oh, no, no, I have six kids and it's great and I grew up with seven. It seems crazy. You cannot pay attention to any more than two. No way. I'm sorry.
14:55If you have three kids, one of them you've already wrote off. Let's just be honest here. If you have five kids, you're hoping two of them turn out okay because it's just too many. You can't have that kind of energy. Sixteen is abusing at least ten children, right? Sixteen is crazy. There's no way they're getting any of the care they need. You should be arrested on ten counts of child abuse. I'm going to go with thirteen. So, his dad, the horniest farmer of all time here. And busiest. Francis Frank Herring here. Now, okay, they grew up on Happy Valley Farm, which is sprawled across roughly 1,000 acres along the Dog River. Wow. Yeah, it goes a long way. So Frank is his dad and his wife. They have 16 children.
15:49Now, Frank, according to all the sisters, abused the shit out of this boy, David. Oh, boy. He got it the worst, they said. He got it worse than anyone in the house. So out of 16, he picked, this is the one I'm taking it out on. I mean, he did other things that we'll talk about, but they said Frank threw pitchforks at him. And eventually you're going to hit him. And he did too. He's got scars all over him from his dad doing shit to him. Hit him a lot. Yeah. He's a bad guy, but that's only the tip of the abuse iceberg from Frank here. Two of the daughters, Sharon and Sandra, later would say in court what described what went on in the house. And the father beat all the kids, all 16, which takes energy.
16:32I got to be honest with you. I don't think I could beat 16 kids. It would just be too much. You'd be tired after six or seven of them. But you got to grow shit, sir. What are you in here for? Well, then he also sexually abused his daughters. Oh, for heaven's sake. So this guy has boundless energy. This Frank here. Why did he do this? He often did this at gunpoint. He would rape his own daughters at gunpoint. And this is like, you're not in a park at two in the morning. This is your father. That's disgusting. It's obviously disgusting. A thousand acres and you can't get away from him too no um and he would lock the children after he did this he would then lock them in a closet for a while afterwards for a
17:13cool down period um one of the aunts said frank once was actually arrested for raping his own daughter which is shocking in the 50s that they even took that seriously so apparently he was acquitted after she said this of the aunt after he paid relatives to lie for him on the stand i don't know if alibi paid them paid them to lie gross yeah now back to david the son yeah david gets out of this house marries a woman named janella Markham and has several children here. He's not abusive, apparently. No, which is surprising at best here. His favorite kid is his daughter Jody, Jody Herring, Jody with a Y. She's born September 11, 1974, and her dad's David, her mom's Janella, and she has several siblings,
18:09including sisters named Sheila and Amy and a brother named Dwayne, who will come up later as well. Now, David, in 1979, Jody's dad, he starts to, we don't know if he's paranoid, but he starts acting a little funny. He starts telling people that he's being threatened and followed and things of that nature, and he starts sleeping with little funny. He starts telling people that he's being threatened and followed and things of that nature. And he starts sleeping with a gun under his pillow. So he starts getting a little, yeah. Um, then November 17th, 1979, when Jody's only five years old and home, by the way, the kids are home. Everybody's home in the family. Um, dad apparently shot himself to death
18:46in the front lawn right outside the front hall right right in the front of the family home yeah yep and he's found with a pistol in his right hand yeah and he's 31 years old the death is ruled a suicide but the family never believes the suicide story as a lot of people a lot of people think that they don't they can't it, so they just imagine it. I'm sure it wasn't that. Yeah, so Jody especially never stops arguing with everybody about it. It's not a suicide. Somebody killed my father. And the main issue was the stepmother said he was left-handed, or the mother, I'm sorry, Janella. She said he was left-handed and the gun was in his right hand. That's the big. That's a good crux of an argument, to be honest.
19:34Yeah, and relatives said that the gun in his hand looked planted as well, which I don't know if they're crime scene homicide detectives to know. How many suicides they've seen. Yeah, show me the rigor of the finger like yeah cops know what it looks like when a gun looks planted they say it looks like you stuck a weapon in a gi joe's hand or something it doesn't fit right um so jody was only five years old and home that night and she quote vividly remembers playing in sawdust saturated with her father's blood. Which can't be good for you. Yeah. You know, they treated it like an eight-year-old threw up at camp and just put some sawdust over it. So you were not going to make sandcastles in it? Yeah.
20:17Like the pilot on the plane who said, put some coffee down over that shit. That time. It's the same thing. So Jody grew up believing her father was murdered and apparently was fixated on it, by the way. Now, the investigators weren't. They closed the file. Suicide in 1979. Never reopened it. Never cared. But the family is different. Now, Jody, this suicide, as to be expected, really changed her a lot as a person, as a kid. If you're five years old, everything's fine one day. Next day, your dad blows his brains out in the front yard. You're going to get a little weird, you know, when you're playing in a sawdust. You'll make you a hell of a soccer coach. You didn't see that. Jesus. That's a good joke, I suppose.
20:58No. So before this, relatives described her as a happy-go-lucky kid. One aunt said she was the sweetest little thing. After it, she became like basically the kid from The Shining. She would have seizures now out of nowhere. Seizures. That's not. Become more and more frequent. She would sit and stare into nothing for long stretches of time. Like, like Danny from the shining. I mean, it's fucking, I can see that, but seizures are like neuro shit, not firing too much, right? Yeah. Who knows, man? We don't know anything. We know nothing about the brain. We really, but I didn't know that. We know even less. Doctors don't know about the brain. We don't know anything about the brain. We don't know anything about the brain.
21:46I didn't know trauma can cause seizures, like emotional trauma. Who knows? Or maybe she just, her epilepsy, who knows what the deal is. But she started having seizures and staring off. And nobody took her to like a psychiatrist or a doctor to talk about this. She must be fine who knows think it's gonna work itself out yep her aunt said she stared into space like she wasn't aware of anything and her other aunt said she always had a dead look to her like she just wasn't happy anymore just a ruined a ruined kid that's just horrible um yeah, that's that's what it was. And everything went untreated. Nobody helped her. So then her mom remarried to a guy named Ken. Janella remarries to a guy named Ken who physically abused the children as well.
22:38So and she was dad's favorite, too. so that's fucked. That's the other thing, too, which is probably why I think the stepfather concentrated extra on beating the shit out of her also here. So that's all that goes on there after the remarrying. And apparently Jody and brother Dwayne were the most abused in the household. Somewhere between the ages of 10 and 14, because a bunch of people have different tellings here, she and Dwayne were thrown out of the house. Both kids under the age of 14 were not thrown out, not shipped to a grandparent's house or an aunt's. Just get out. Thrown into the yard. Lock the door behind them. Peace out. Just go. Figure it out. So they slept in cars and would show up on relatives' doorsteps and stay there for a couple of nights when they could.
23:28And like little urchin kids. This is just trying to figure it out. Yeah. Fucking some Dickinson shit here. This is crazy. At 17, she's kind of been on and off the street for years here. She's sexually assaulted, I assume raped, because she becomes pregnant with her first daughter. Wow. So it's going swimmingly for her so far. Everything's going great. Her first daughter's name is Felicia, who is taken away by the state weeks after her birth because Jodi is a mess, as you might imagine. So that's not good. So she's lost her daughter now, too. Oh, boy. Now, yeah, weeks, too. It only took a couple of weeks. Then things just go in a loop, just terrible things happening to her, bad relationships, substance abuse, legal problems, and just keeps going here.
24:26Throughout the 90s, she's going to have a bunch of misdemeanor convictions, over 10. And we'll talk more about them. A credit card fraud, larceny, heroin possession, DUIs, driving on suspended licenses, domestic assault charges, the full spectrum of trash crimes, basically, of white trash crimes. In 1998, you can't, I mean, honestly, I don't know how she would have turned out any other way from the way she was raised. She never had a chance. Right. And this all started from her dad committing suicide. It's so crazy how a whole entire family can just collapse with one event. Snowball. It can just snowball out of control from one thing. Everything could be fine one day. Now, 1998, a judge named Edward Cashman disqualifies her from possessing a firearm.
25:22She's not allowed to have a gun anymore because there's some mental issues there that they're aware of. Too many issues, to be honest. She's been adjudicated a non-gun owner here. She's going to have two more daughters as well because why not, I guess. Desiree, who's born around 1995. Desiree is taken away by the state at age six. Immediately. So she's two for two now on kids taken away. According to Desiree, her father went to prison for a long time and her mother did not respond well to this, to her father getting taken to prison. What? She said, quote, Desiree's a character. Desiree said, my dad went to prison for a long time and she just kind of went apeshit and started using drugs. She wasn't a fit parent.
26:12What is that? She's kind of went apeshit with the drugs, bro. This is a girl who, and we'll find out later, is banned from Dunkin' Donuts. Desiree is? Desiree is a girl. She's banned from Dunkin' Donuts. Like that's, she Desiree is a girl. She's banned from Dunkin' Donuts. Like, that's, she's a problem. And we'll talk about her, too. She's got her own shit going on. It's wild. How do you get banned from Dunks, for heaven's sake? Dude, people show up hammered at 3 o'clock in the morning and they're allowed back. So you gotta really fuck up good. Hey, everybody. Just gonna take a quick break from the show and tell you a much better way to bank with Chime. Chime.com. Oh, you got to get that Chime card, everybody.
26:50I'm telling you. Let's talk about it. Can we talk about how this is the most expensive time of the year? The flights and presents and the groceries and people coming over. But with 5% cash back with a Chime card, it'll be the most rewarding time of the year. You are going to love it. I'm telling you, because holidays are great, but it's expensive. It's tough. I'm telling you, look at everything. Let's talk about groceries, first of all, here. If you're putting off planning that big holiday dinner, just know that with a Chime card, you can get 5% cash back on all those groceries. But be careful, though, because you might want to just impress your in-laws here because, you know, you're getting a little break here.
27:28Especially when they find out the cash back is on a monthly category of your choice. You can do gas. You can do groceries. You can do whatever. It's really cool. 5% cash back on monthly selected category of your choice. Restaurants, travel, rides, bills, gas, groceries. You pick it. They do it. Plus, they help gas, groceries. You pick it. They do it. Plus, they help you build credit. It's awesome. That helps a lot. Fee-free banking. That is the main thing. Fee-free, everybody. You shouldn't have to pay fees. It's silly, honestly. It's very, very silly. That's right. That's what I'm talking about. You've got to get this, the eligible purchases. You can get the 5% cash back. Fee-free. I mean, why not?
28:05What have you got to lose here? Except fees and old banking that you don't need. Yeah, your money is all you have to lose. That's why Chime is America's number one choice for banking. Head to Chime.com slash Small Town Murder. That is Chime.com slash Small Town Murder. Sign up now. It only takes a few minutes. Chime feels like progress. Chime is a fintech, not a bank. Banking services and Chime card provided by Chime's bank partners. Qualifying direct deposits required. Terms and limits apply. Go to QINCE.com slash disclosures for details. Now, back to the show. Hey, everybody. Just going to take a quick break from the show and tell you the only place you should be buying your clothes at Quince.
28:47Q-U-I-N-C-E dot com. Quince. Absolutely. Get those pieces that you count on. The best stuff in your closet. The ones you just, you know, you go to it time after time, whether you're heading to work, you're going out, or just keeping things casual. And this time of year, Quince makes finding something great for everyone else just as easy. This holiday season, it's where we're going to be shopping for both ourselves and everyone else on the list. Well, we'll start with everyone else and we'll end up buying ourselves a bunch of stuff because it's impossible to go on Quince's site and not find stuff that you're going to love. So it's awesome. Quince focuses on high-quality staples made with premium materials like 100% Mongolian cashmere, 14-karat gold, and Italian leather.
29:30All timeless, versatile pieces that feel special to unwrap. You know what I mean? And become everyday favorites long after the holidays. Their cashmere sweaters start at just $60, and the lineup doesn't stop there. Premium down jackets, wool outerwear and cashmere accessories, everything you and your loved ones need to stay warm and look put together all season long. Everything at Quince is priced 50 to 80% less than similar brands. And you go, well, how does that work? Is it how is it junky stuff? No, it's insanely high quality stuff. What they do is they work directly with ethical factories and they cut out the middleman. That's where the markup is. Get rid of that. So you get luxury quality pieces
30:10without that luxury price tag. And that's what it's all about. Telling you, all my stuff comes from Quince now. I love it. Oh, their shirt selection, unbelievable sweaters, jackets. It's incredible. And we got this comforter from there. It is the softest, most amazing comforter. It's incredible. Everything they have is super high quality. And when it comes to gifting, Quince has a lot more than clothing. Think fine jewelry, leather bags, hotel quality bedding, chef-grade cookware, and five-star luggage. Basically, plenty of ways to find something special for everyone on your list. Give the gift of quality this season. Download the Quince app for app-exclusive offers, or go to quince.com. Get free shipping
30:54on your order and 365 day returns, now available in Canada and the UK, too. And when Quince asks you where you heard about them, let them know it was small-town murder. It's the best way to support the show. Now back to the show. Felicia, the other daughter, the first daughter, later said that she had known her whole life that her mother felt guilty about what happened to all of us. She said, though, that her mother didn't have the easiest time growing up. So she kind of understood what went on with her mom. So it's a very mature way to look at it. So 2006, she has another daughter. It's been four years since the state took her baby, took her last four years. And she thinks she's on track now. Yep. And she said she told
31:36her mother that this state hasn't taken my baby. She said, this is a quote. If I ever get this girl taken, I'm going to fucking lose it. That's what she says. They're not taking this baby. Now you're going to fucking lose it? Go ape shit. I'm going ape shit. Lose what? So a little about her charges since before this baby and since this baby, basically from the first baby through the beginning of this baby. In October 91, she was arrested for fraudulent use of a credit card. She was arrested for driving with a suspended license in 96, 97, 98, and several times in 2001. In June 2001, she was charged with false pretenses and ended up with a misdemeanor larceny conviction. In January 2003, she was arrested for domestic assault and pled to disorderly conduct from that.
32:28In April of 2003, she was arrested for felony heroin possession and pled down to a misdemeanor version of that. And a shit ton of DUIs, as you can imagine. Just sprinkling, getting pulled over every once in a while in there. Yeah. So now Desiree had a son, by the way. imagine just sprinkling getting pulled over every once in a while in there yeah yeah so now desiree had a son by the way the daughter desiree who was taken away had a son who was also taken by the state desiree got a baby taken desiree got her baby taken too and and disbarred from dunks. And completely fucking shunned from dunks. Yeah. So, yeah, Jody's, that's, you can, this is just a big snowball, shitball running downhill here.
33:15It's so cyclical and nobody's breaking it. Yeah, and Desiree said that DCF, which is the department that took the baby, had been a part of her mother's life as long as she could remember. She said DCF has just been pretty much involved in her whole life. So I'm sure she's just had enough of them at this point. Desiree said her mother once reported her to the authorities. By the way, Jodi reported Desiree to DCF. That's how Desiree's baby got taken. When Jodi thinks you're a shit mom. Think about that. According to Desiree, she called up DCS and told them that Desiree was, quote, well, this is what Desiree said, she called and said that I was, quote, shooting my kid up with drugs. Which, we don't
34:00know the truth or falseness of that, but that was the accusation. I mean, that's easier to determine as an officer, isn't it? The simple blood test or urine will do that. Track marks on a three-year-old just really stand out. Generally, yeah. You got Jesus, kid. You had it rough so far, huh? Hey, has this kid got chicken pox or are you a monster? What the fuck is going on? So in 2010, Jody has a psychiatric evaluation and it noted likely bipolar disorder, anxiety, irritability, and mood instability. Okay. Now, by 2014, Jodi still has her youngest daughter. Yeah. So she's still got her. She's got it together. She's not losing it. This is as long as she's kept a child for. This kid's like eight now, literally.
34:43I made it to eight. Wow. as long as she's kept a child for. This kid's like eight now, literally. I made it to eight. October 2014, and she was reasonably stable at this point. She had a job. She had a place to live. She was taking care of her daughter. October 2014, she loses her job. Uh-oh. This is bad for Jody. Very, very bad. Jody needs a place to go and a place to have to be. Too much time on Jody's hands is bad for her. Too much free time. Too much. Jody, she and her youngest daughter now are homeless because of this. Oh, boy. So that's not good. Now, the girl kept going to school. She kept sending the kid to school so it wouldn't raise any red flags with DCF. But the staff at school noticed that when Jodi would come to pick her up, she was becoming less and less coherent.
35:34They were like, have you talked to this kid's mom? She's fucking – she's wacky. She'd be anxious and in conversations, she would spin off on tangents. What does that sound like to you? That's a drug addict, James. Sounds like drugs to me. Yeah, that's a bad thing. So January 2015, the principal contacted DCF out of concern for the young daughter. Child safety. Yeah. So now Jody blames the principal saying, well, why didn't you help me? You should have helped me. Why did you call DCF? And they're like, we're concerned about the child, not you. You're not helping you. That's why I called them. Well, that's the thing. We're not concerned. The thing is, we're not concerned about you. We're concerned about the child. You don't matter to the principal. Their responsibility is the
36:17child. Oftentimes help looks like not help. That too. Yeah. So, yeah, she said that the principal said, well, I have to report things. It's the law, number one. It's my job. And I saw the kid, or I saw Jody covered in bruises from being beaten up by an abusive partner and nobody, you know, all that kind of shit. So, he did exactly what he was supposed to do, the principal, or she did, I should say. So the case goes to Laura Sobel, who is a, yeah, remember her from the beginning? She works for DCF. Now, Jody is pissed. Jody is now broken the world into people who are helping her and people who are helping DCF. That's the world. You're either with us or you're against us. You're team DCF, you're team Jody, period.
37:11So the state of Jody, unemployed, recently homeless, living in South Bar Bear or whatever the hell it is, she was taking prescribed Ritalin and Klonopin. And her daughter said that she didn't want to talk to them because she believed they were undercover agents for the DEA. She's gone. She lost it on the drugs, dude. She's crazy. March 15th, amongst all this craziness, she finds a new boyfriend. Oh, that's terrific. Perfect time to start a new relationship. Yeah. Perfect. This is the, every psychiatrist would tell you, you know what? Perfect time. You're not ready yet. No. So this is Harry, or Henry, I'm sorry, Henry Premont. He's a 51-year-old guy who lives in a small town called Williamstown, south of Bear.
38:02He dated Jody for a while, and she moved in with him in March. Hey, everybody. We got to tell you about one of the most wonderful things that there is really in existence. I'm telling you. It's Audible, everybody. The Audible app. Download that app. Get that app. Or audible.com. Either way. It's amazing. It's so useful. We need it. For travel and everything, when we're on planes going to shows and doing that sort of thing, need the Audible app. I'm a terrible reader. It's terrific to be able to listen to an audio book. It's amazing. I can tell Jimmy, Jimmy, listen to this. And he will. It's amazing. Jimmy, read this book. No, but I'll get it on Audible. But I will listen to it on Audible. It's a must for travel, for everything, because you can download the, you know, you can download the books ahead of time, so you
38:46don't need to have the Wi-Fi and all that kind of thing. We just love it. I'm listening to a bunch of books right now. First of all, The Trial of Lizzie Borden was really good by Kara Robertson. That's an excellent one, too, because it gives you all the real details of everything. Also, for The Donner Party, we did a bonus episode based on this. A lot of our episodes are based on Audible books, especially the bonus episodes, The Indifferent Stars Above by Daniel James Brown. One, if you want to laugh, this is a hilarious book. Failure is an Option by H. John Benjamin. Great. He's the voice of Archer and Bob's Burgers, and it's just a hilarious book that he both reads and wrote, and it's really funny.
39:24Also, this is good if you're true crime people like us, and I listened to this on our last road trip all the way there and all the way back across the country to California. Extreme Punishment, the chilling true story of acclaimed law professor Dan Markell's murder by Stephen B. Epstein. Amazing. That's the, oh my God, that's the whole family getting together. It is wild stuff. The Adelson's and all that. It's so wild and it's really deep and all the details you want, even more than the trial. And then for a real fun one, the last action heroes, the triumphs, flops, and feuds of Hollywood's kings and carnage by Nick D. Semelin. And this is one of the ones I told you to get. It's all about all the 80s action
40:04movies and Schwarzenegger and Stallone and all the crazy behind-the-scenes stuff. It's really, really fun. In addition to that, too, all the podcasts they have. They have all sorts of podcasts. You can listen to all of our podcasts on Audible. All of them. No problem. Also, check out Over My Dead Body, Operation Sideswipe. They have tons of stuff here. They have Audible's True Crime podcast. It has a new featured series about ghosts. You want to check out that. Everybody, Audible can be your companion wherever you're doing, working around the house, working out, hanging out, doing whatever. It is the best and it's so much, just great. It's so much fun and so informative and you're going to love it. I'm telling you, listen to
40:43us, listen to these books, listen to the Operation Sideswipe, listen to all of it, wherever you get your podcasts. Audible subscribers can binge episodes early and add free right now for the Operation Sideswipe. Join Audible in the Audible app or by subscribing on Apple Podcasts or Spotify. He took her target shooting a few times and called her a really good shot. Oh. Because you want to have people who are real spun out on drugs to also be skilled marksmen. Straight as an arrow. That helps. He owned a Remington Model 700 bolt-action rifle, and that's what they were shooting with here. In March 2015, Jody tried to get her own gun. Oh. She went to try to buy a Ruger 40, a 40 caliber Ruger at MidState Sports in Randolph.
41:35I've heard about her. They run a federal background check. Yeah. And they said, no, you ain't allowed to have one still from 1998. Four days later, she went to a second gun store. I don't know what maybe they haven't heard. Lady, they've all heard. It's the same background check. They're all going to run. So that's what happens. And they deny her again. So she's been denied twice. Now, here's an interesting thing. Henry claims that he only she only lived there for three weeks. But every other thing, including court documents, say she lived there till early August. So I don't know what the deal is. But he said that he didn't want her around because, quote, she drank a lot and was kind of unpredictable on her whereabouts.
42:23She'd just go off. Like an addict. Like a drug addict, just disappears for two days at a time. May 24th, 2015, Jody calls a relative and tells them, listen, you're going to have to explain to my daughter why she doesn't have a mother anymore. And the relative said, what are you talking about? And Jody just hung up on her. So the relative called the cops and had the cops go over there. And they find her in bed surrounded by empty pill bottles and photographs of her children, which is not a good combination. Oh, wow. Jodi is in bad shape, obviously. She's tried to kill herself here. She took them all? Yeah, she took a bunch of empty pill bottles and had pictures of her kids out. That's tried to kill herself here. She's taken... She took them all? Yeah, she took a bunch of pill,
43:05empty pill bottles and had pictures of her kids out. That's all around her, set up. She was taken on an emergency basis, obviously, and involuntarily admitted to the hospital here. A clinician found she's a danger to herself and others and recommended 90 days of inpatient treatment in a psychiatric hospital. She ends up leaving in five days. Yeah, because that doesn't help. That didn't work for her. Sober sucks. Five days of it will really get you going, too. The bummer is that she doesn't know it, but she's almost out of it. Yeah, I don't know. She's almost out of the real discomfort. You mean withdrawal-wise. Yeah, I don't know. She's almost out of like the real discomfort. And then, then you mean withdrawal wise. Yeah. I thought you meant her life. I'm like, her life is,
43:50I don't know where rock bottom is, but it's, she's got to start feeling it with a toe pretty soon. Right. I mean, she's got to go, Oh, there it is. There's rock bottom. She's 40 years old at this point right uh yeah there's not a there's not a lot of help that 90 days in can do to fix 35 years of trouble and all of this trauma but i mean it's better than five probably it's a start it's something yeah um okay june 2nd 2015 at the walmart in berlin vermont she purchases purchases $20.08 worth of ammunition. The rounds are .270 Winchester, which Jody does not have that gun, but Henry does. That's the gun, the ammo that goes into Henry's bolt action. June 23, 2015, Jody's pulled over while heading to Henry's house, and she gets another DUI.
44:46What? Another DUI. Yeah, on that day. July 15th, or July 2015, Jodi loses custody of her youngest daughter. Yeah, because you got another DUI. You're not fixing yourself. Now they take her away. Oh, and she gave us a warning. Yes. And the state, by the way, and she gave us a warning. Yes. And the state, by the way, is undergoing efforts to terminate her parental rights. Not allowed. Three times. I mean, fool me once, fool me twice. What happens with three times? Holy shit. Does that apply going forward? I think so, yeah. Luckily, she's aging out of having this problem again, but we can only hope. So the girl was nine, and she was placed with her father in Massachusetts, who I'm sure is a gem.
45:34I'm sure she just picked wonderful, wonderful guys. Laura Sobel is the DCF worker on this case. Now, Laura Sobel, by the way, is born February 26, 1967. She grew up in Oceanside, New York. She got a bachelor's degree and a master's in social work from the University of Vermont and interned at the DCF office in St. Albans. Our last Vermont episode was there and spent about 14 years as a family services worker at this point. She lived in East Montpelier with her husband and her two daughters. At this point, her oldest daughter recently was bat mitzvahed, so she must be 13. Now, Jody's two oldest daughters said this really broke Jody's brain. Desiree said, I think she really wanted a good life for the girl.
46:31She's really all she had, her daughter. Her aunt said after losing her daughter, she was just getting worse and worse. Who called DCF this time? That's the thing. Who called? Somebody called again on her. Her teacher last time. It was the principal last time well her family found out or later said we're not positive that it's a couple of relatives of hers named ronda and regina her cousins that ronda and regina are concerned ronda and regina let's talk about who they are uh julie ann falzana falzarino is there ronda and and Regina's mother and Jodi's aunt. She's like 73 years old. She's related to her father's side of the family. I think it's maybe her father's sister. She lived with her two grown daughters, Rhonda and Regina.
47:21She also has a son named Richard, so all ours names there has grandchildren she's a grandma she does likes to play cards and does word puzzles and shit people say that's what she's into ronda is her older cousin the oldest of her cousins she was born in 67 so she's 48 years old she has a 23 year old daughter named named Tiffany. Regina is born in 72. She's 43 years old. They both live with Julianne in the farmhouse here. The farmhouse is at 3168 Airport Road in Berlin. So now Desiree, the daughter, tells later the tale of Jody confronting Rhonda and Regina about it directly. Okay. Yeah. Now, they deny this according to an affidavit, but Desiree said this is what happened. Desiree said that the three women may have called DCS on her
48:16and that they had basically the aunt and the two cousins had concerns about her mothering. We still don't know if they're the ones who even made the call, but it doesn't matter because in Jody's mind, they made the fucking call. For sure they did. For sure. Sometime in the summer, Henry buys Jody a handgun. He goes and buys it for her. Henry? A family member, people later say it's Dwayne, her brother, found out and called Henry and said, don't give her a fucking gun. Are you out of your mind? Do you know anything about her past? You're going to give this lady a gun? You're not out of your mind. I hope you can recognize that she might be. So he took it away from her and gave it to a neighbor instead.
49:00All right. So her mental condition, her daughter said that the Ritalin and Klonopin changed her whole demeanor and made her a lot more paranoid and things of that nature. Made it worse. Desiree said her mother was, quote, thinking people are after her, thinking me and my sister are drug enforcement agents. And also saying that mom believed that her daughters were plotting against her. Oh, boy. Okay. Tuesday, August 4th, 2015. Jodi goes by her brother Dwayne's house. She steals a bottle of Kahlua from him. Nice. He realizes she swiped a bottle of Kahlua afterwards. She swiped a mixer, for Christ's sake. Good God. I know it's got booze in it, but who the fuck drinks that? Pound Kahlua? Must have been the easiest to steal.
49:50The next day, Wednesday, August 5th, 2015, this is the last day Jodi lives with Henry. Apparently she leaves after that. That's Wednesday. Now, Friday, August 7th, 2015, somewhere between 7.30 and 8 a.m., Tiffany Herring, who's 23, who is, I guess it would be Jody's niece, technically. It's, I think, Rhonda's daughter. She is 23. She's staying at the farmhouse with her grandmother and her mother there. That's a second cousin, I think. Which, what's that? That's a second cousin, I think. Is it your cousin's kid? I guess it would be. It is, yeah. Yeah, but I don't know. In families, you'd say that's your niece or nephew because it's a different generation, right? Is that just Italian families that does that?
50:40I think you just say cousin and move along. That way you don't have to explain how fucking far down the cousin tree it goes. We do aunt with that if it's old. My mom has an aunt that has a cousin that's 20 years older. She's Aunt Lillian always. It's just how it is. It's an age respect thing, and it's a different culture. Never mind. My cousin's kid calls me Uncle Jimmy. So, yeah, same thing. Yeah, that's just what it is. It's just too confusing. This morning, this young lady wakes up to an answering machine, wakes up to somebody's, like the phone had rung. She didn't wake up, but she woke up from the message being left on the answering machine. And it's Jody's voice screaming on the answering machine.
51:17Oh. Tiffany said that she said, quote, you guys need to stop calling DCF unless you guys are going to have it coming to you. Rhonda, Regina, you might want to stop calling DCS or I'm going to come shoot your brains out. That's a straight threat. Yeah. Yeah. Then at 2.56 p.m., she calls her brother Dwayne and leaves a message and says, Dwayne, if you think anything of your sister, you'll get a hold of me now or ASAP. All right. message and says, Dwayne, if you think anything of your sister, you'll get a hold of me now or ASAP. So at three o'clock, four minutes later, she leaves a second message for Dwayne. He describes it as she sounds hysterical and she says, watch the news and you'll wish you
51:57got a hold of me earlier. Oh, my God. OK. Then August 7th, same day, about 3.20 p.m., a cousin, Christopher Herring, sees Jody's silver Honda Accord parked in the driveway of her mother's home. OK, her mother, Janella, who is not there, by the way. Then about from 3.30 to 4 o'clock, another cousin sees Jody driving slowly through the parking lot at Bar City Place that we talked about. Just driving slowly through the parking lot and then leaving. Where DCF is at. Yes, this is about 3.30 and 4 p.m., about an hour before where we started. Then about 4 to 4.30, Jody pulls into the driveway of a home in Bear belonging to Lori Setian, who's a sister of a former boyfriend and the father of one of her daughters.
52:50Okay. Oh, boy. This person, Setien, says that Jodi was, quote, moving her arms as if she was manipulating an object. And Setien and another guy told the police that there was, quote, no other reason for Jodi to have traveled to their residence or parked in their driveway. No idea why she was there. She yelled, screamed, ranted, and raved, and then drove away. Alright. Then, August 7, 2015, same day, 4.36 p.m., a silver Honda, her car, pulls into the lot at the Bear City place. Surveillance video shows the car arrive. She waits for more than eight minutes. A woman headed to a maintenance job in the building parks next to her. When the woman gets out and bent to pick up a dropped phone, quote, as she stood up, she was face to face with the operator of the vehicle beside her who was screaming about something.
53:45So Jody's just yelling to anybody who'll listen strangers one witness saw no one else in the car and saw that Jody's hands were flailing and that there was something black on the passenger seat that many witness later believed to may have been the butt of butt end of a weapon okay but this person didn't call anyone. They just went to work. There's a crazy person with possibly a gun in the parking lot. Not my problem. I got to clock in. Shift is starting. What, do I want to start my day off talking to the cops? I'm not a cop. So about 4.45 p.m. just before that, Laura Sobel walks out of her building for the end of her Friday shift. She's on the phone with her youngest daughter, who's asking her when she'll be home.
54:30Jody then gets out of the car with a rifle and goes straight toward her. Oh, boy. A guy named Jacob Graves, who was walking toward the lot, hears Jody screaming before he sees anything. He hears her screaming, you know what you've done, you know what you've done, because this lady's like, whoa, what's going on? She says, you know what you've done. You know what you've done. Because this lady's like, why? Whoa, what's going on? She says, you know what you've done. She said that this person, the witness said they could just make out bits and pieces of what she was saying. The woman from the next car over walking past a pair of social workers heard what she called a loud blast, which made her ears ring. Oh boy. Then she turned and saw Laura Sobel on the ground.
55:07So Laura Sobel falls. Um, then there's another woman there who's a cleaner at city place, sees Jody charging through the parking lot toward her. Jody fires a second time at close range into Laura as she lies on the ground. Oh shit. While her youngest daughter is still on the phone. That's fucked up. Yeah. Hey, I'm all fucked up. Guess I'll do it to another little girl. Yeah. That's what that is. Does she know that she doesn't know that there's a kid on the other end? Either way, it wouldn't have mattered. It's so fucked up that she's doing exactly what happened to her. Exactly. So seconds later here, Jody doesn't run. She just jumps around the parking lot, literally like swinging the rifle around, yelling and screaming.
55:54Hey, everybody. Just going to take a quick break from the show and tell you how to stay safe and keep your house protected with Simply Safe. SimplySafe.com. S-I-M-P-L-I-Safe.com. You know it. The holidays are coming up. That's a lot of time out of the house. Maybe you're going away. You're going to be visiting family, running errands for a big dinner, maybe a trip out of town. But here's an empty house during the busiest travel season of the year. And that, unsurprisingly, is when break-ins spike up every year. That's why there's no better time to secure your home with SimpliSafe, especially with 70% off SimpliSafe's biggest savings of the year. This is a security system that we both use and trust,
56:35and we want you to enjoy the same peace of mind this holiday season. We both have it for our houses, for our studios. It's the only way to do it, I'm telling you. Because we realized I had somebody break into a house that we had. And I said, this is no good. And then we got SimpliSafe as a sponsor. And I said, I'm never going to worry about this again. Never going to worry about it again. Because it's honestly incredible, incredible service. The equipment's great. Because unlike traditional security systems that only alert you after a break-in is already underway, gee, thanks. You know, that's not going to help anybody. SimpliSafe is built to stop it before it starts. That is what this is all about.
57:14I'm telling you, smart AI-powered cameras watch for potential threats and alert a live U.S.-based agent ready to intervene. They can yell at the people through the speaker. Yeah. Hey, dummy, call in the cops. Get out. Is this your house? Didn't think so. You don't belong here. You don't belong here. The agent intervenes in under 30 seconds speaking through the camera to stop this intruder in their tracks. And they call 9-1-1 for urgent dispatch when it's needed most. We've partnered with SimpliSafe to offer our listeners their biggest savings of the year, 70 percent off your new system with professional monitoring when you visit simplisafe.com slash small. That's simplisafe.com slash small.
57:52And when you order, write in smalltownmurder at checkout and tell them we sent you. And it really helps the show. SimpliSafe, ahead of crime in real time. Now back to the show. This ad placement is paid for by Bath & Body Works. This holiday, they're bringing back the feeling that makes the season special. It's called the season of wonder, and it all starts with fragrance. If the holidays have felt a little ordinary lately, Bath & Body Works' beloved seasonal scents bring that nostalgic festive feeling back to your home and to you. Start with fan favorite Snowflakes and Cashmere, now available in an eau de parfum for the very first time with a higher concentration of fragrance oils. Or bring it home with a three-wick candle, up to 45 hours of room-filling
58:34fragrance. Go with Snowflakes and Cashmere if you love warm and woodsy. Or try the new vanilla cocoa flurries if you want sweet and cozy. It's all about the little moments that make the holidays feel magical. Snowflakes and cashmere is available in more forms than ever across home fragrance and body care with fragrances you love and formulas you can trust. Let it be a season of wonder. Shop now at Bath and Body Works dot com. Hot flashes, rage crying, forgetting words mid scent and yeah. Yeah, we know. Menopause is a lot. Midi Health gets it. That's why Midi offers virtual healthcare specially tailored to women's needs. Built for women, by women. Every symptom, every stage, every question. Visit joinmidi.com to get started today.
59:21That's joinmidi.com. Individual results and coverage varies. Check with your plan for coverage. A witness remembered her saying, they didn't listen to me. It was my nine-year-old daughter. They got what they deserved. She is not sorry at all. So this other witness who's there with her daughter, her daughter said, what's going on? And she said, quote, there's a crazy bitch. That's what she told her kid. There's just a crazy bitch. Don't worry about it. Close your eyes. OK. So then Jody drops the rifle and three men come at her and tackle her to the ground. One of them is a 66 year old who holds her by the wrists until police arrive. Scott Williams is the prosecutor. He runs over. He has defended Jody before on misdemeanor charges
1:00:11when he was a defense attorney, so he sees a woman he knows being held on the ground, a gun laying there, and someone he knows well, Laura, bleeding to death on the ground. He goes back to the gym, gets some towels. The EMT, there's people there who have some medical experience. He goes back to the gym, gets some towels. The EMT, there's people there who have some medical experience. They come try to help. People come. Either way, Scott Williams stays with Laura Sobel as she dies on the sidewalk. Fuck. Shot twice. Yeah. By this time, Jody is on the ground and very calm, being held down and calm as a fucking cucumber. Just cool as a cucumber cucumber just cool she thinks she fixed her problems remember on the wire when that fucking girl slashed the other girl and then
1:00:51just sat there and dookie put the fan on her that's what she is she lost it and now she's fucking she has brought it down to a simmer now um so yeah now william, it was the prosecutor who's crying, asked his wife to go to the Sobel home and tell them in person so they don't have to hear it from strangers basically. And he also recuses himself because he's a, in the middle of the case and he's already, and he's defended the defendant, the future defendant here. So they arrive, handcuff Jody, put her in a cruiser. From here, it's wild. The detective said, quote, it should be noted that while on scene, Jody Herring was laughing about the incident and very calm. During transportation, the female
1:01:40continued to laugh and talk about the victim. Prior to placing the female into the cell, she was still laughing and making small talk about the incident like it was no big deal. Holy. Wow. That is interesting. Too much. She did take the time to correct an officer who referred to the boots she was wearing as shoes. She said, they're not boots. They're not shoes. They're boots. Okay. During processing, she reaches for her belt and hands over a sleeve of 270 rounds. Have these. She says, quote, you might want these. I don't need them anymore. No, no shit. A bunch of ammo. Yeah. It's a lot. So it's crazy. Now, Jody's being put in this holding cell with a camera on it. The video's later released.
1:02:30It shows her clapping and screaming at the camera. It's nuts, dude. This is unhinged shit. Yeah. And she was acting out the crime. She literally acted like the victim and said, oh, no, and then, like, fell down. She was doing that. Like, she's nuts, dude. Why did you do that? Fucking lost it. Detectives enter. And they said at that point she became quite agitated and became increasingly so as we walked to the second floor interview room. quote, Herring was ranting about how the police never did anything for her, about how she had been beaten up by a former boyfriend and nothing was done, about the injustices she suffered at the hands of the DCF. Oh boy, that's not good. No. So they stick her back in her cell. Now the next
1:03:15day, Saturday morning, August 8th, the women from the farmhouse, her aunt and her cousins, they're not answering their phone. No one's answering the phone. Tiffany, the 23-year-old, couldn't reach her mother. No. So she drives back to the farmhouse there, pulls up, and the door is open. She walks in and finds her mother, Rhonda, in the living room dead. Slain. Slain. Slain. Then she finds her grandmother, Julianne, in a bed downstairs, also shot to death. She got all three of them? So she calls police. The officers go through the house. They find Regina upstairs as well. So all three in the house got murdered. About three feet from a spent shell casing behind a door with a hole punched in it.
1:04:06She fucking lost her mind. Yeah. About three feet from a spent shell casing behind a door with a hole punched in it. She lost it. Lost her mind. Yeah. They found spent casings in four spots, the kitchen near the entryway, the living room near Rhonda's body, a downstairs bedroom where Julianne was found in an upstairs bedroom about three feet from Regina with the hole punched in the door. All three women were shot in the torso and died within seconds. Regina was shot twice, Rhonda and Julianne once each. Rhonda showed signs that she tried to fight back. She might have got her ahead of time and saw it coming, basically, because she probably, I don't know, if she heard the first shot from shooting mom or what.
1:04:46So now police have to talk to Jody again. They go in there and say they call it an unrelated incident. She asks for a lawyer. So we like to talk about an unrelated incident to the thing that you're in here for. Three more murders. Doing a lot of heavy lifting. It's using, it's really, it's everything. It's the, if you want to talk about a balance or something, it's doing all of it. Three casualties. Incident. All right. She keeps talking anyway, and she says, quote, what about the other fucking three, she says. Yeah. The way I look at it, they fucking deserved it too. This is what she says to them. Does she? Okay. Yeah. The way I look at it, they fucking deserved it, too. This is what she says to them.
1:05:27Does she? Okay. So the police search her car. They find three boxes of ammo, her driver's license, cash, and a digital voice recorder. Another recorder is found in her purse after her arrest. We never know what's on that. We never find out what's on her voice recordings. But I bet it was just ideas for great businesses. Yeah. Good poems. A recipe or two that we could use. Yeah. So they put it all together and they figure out the day before, from late morning to early afternoon, Jody drove to the farmhouse with Henry's rifle. Nobody saw her arrive, apparently. There's no witnesses to that. And yeah, Rhonda's in the living room. Julianne is in her bed in a downstairs bedroom. Regina's upstairs.
1:06:14They said first Rhonda, then Julianne and Regina last, having to endure knowing what was coming. That's what the affidavit said. So then she walked out of the house, left the door open, didn't even close the fucking door. Just not even gotten her Honda Accord and took off. Off she went. Off she went. It's fucking crazy. So this all comes out and it's like holy shit, man. I mean this is crazy. The story about three guys coming over and fucking wrestling a rifle out of her hand and all this kind of shit. The rifle on the ground that she dropped was the Remington Model 700 bolt-action deer rifle. And it holds four rounds in an internal magazine. And that all matches. The ballistics, the casings all match.
1:07:06So she used that gun to do all this. So after hearing about this, Henry Premont said, oh, they got shot with a rifle. Let me check my apartment and finds that his rifle is missing. He tells police that Jody had lived with him and she knew how to get in and he didn't give her the gun. But he said, it's super easy to get in my house. You just have to know how to jiggle the handle, which she knows how to do because she lived there. Anybody can get in my house. So then he says, I have some other stuff I should probably tell you, though, about Jody. I bought her a gun. Well, he said, she showed me a piece of paper a couple months ago. And on it were a bunch of names of people she was going to kill.
1:07:47It was her hit list. Uh-huh. And on it were Rhonda, Regina, and not Julianne, but Judy's own mother, Janella, or Jody's own mother, Janella, is on the list. Really? Her two cousins and her mother. Also, her stepfather, Ken, and he believes that her brother, Jody's brother, Dwayne's on the list, too. Shit. Julianne, the aunt, the name was not on the version that he said that he saw, and neither was Laura Sobel. He said he didn't go to the police with it. He just mentioned it to a few people after the murders, which helps a lot. He did remember that Jody said about the list. He told police she often said people are going to pay and, quote, there's going to be an Armageddon. Well, she talked about wanting to shoot someone in the head to, quote, see brain matter.
1:08:43She is. What is happening? Wacky. Okay. Now, Jody's first court appearance here. She pleads not guilty. The lawyers are saying it's a mental thing she wants to. They want to have an insanity plea here. That day, Jody's daughters talk to the press. They show up outside. They talk to the press, the older ones. Okay. Felicia, Felicia and Desiree. Desiree said she would have liked to have talked inside the Dunkin' Donuts, except she was banned from the Dunkin' Donuts. I'm not allowed in there. She told the reporter that. Desiree said that the prescriptions changed her mother. She said ever since she's been getting those, she's lost her mind. And then Felicia jumped in and said, she's lost her fucking mind.
1:09:26Not just her mind, her fucking mind. And Desiree continued. I love that. Two sisters just tag teaming. It is so funny. Lost her fucking mind. You didn't say fucking enough, Desiree. Wow. So then Desiree said that her mother was, quote, thinking people are after her, thinking me and my sister are DEA agents. And Felicia said, like, plotting against her. And Desiree said, absolutely, 100%. Like the sclopper. Yeah, and they didn't even grow up together. They grew up in separate. So Desiree told another outlet she was shocked her mother even knew how to shoot. She said, you know, my family, they do hunting and stuff, but never my mother. Then, quote, this is from the article, Desiree then took a phone call, handed the reporter to her sister, and left in a green pickup truck going God knows where.
1:10:21Incredible. So she's charged with three counts of aggravated murder here uh right away now under vermont law killing more than one person in the same incident can qualify as aggravated murder which carries a mandatory life without parole like uh the cover-up or in the commission offshore okay wednesday august 12 2015 a few days later. Remember Henry? Henry Premont? He is losing his motherfucking mind. He's having a day today. Tell me. A relative of Henry's calls police at 1.20 p.m. that day, saying Henry was in her yard with a loaded gun, making, quote, incendiary remarks. What is that? He's pissed. He's out there all sorts of pissed off. According to the affidavit, he said, if law enforcement approaches me,
1:11:09quote, it's going to be Armageddon. Did she teach him that or did he teach her that? Armageddon's big around these parts. Big Bruce Willis fans. Wow. Huge. Ben Affleck with new teeth. They loved it. It's crazy. So the troopers, because they do call the cops, and by the time the cops get there, he's gone. But they find him at a Shell gas station attached to a Ricky's Indian restaurant on South Bear Road. That's where I get all my Indian food. It has to be attached to a gas station or I won't eat it. Indian food because of the spices. Precarious in the first place when somebody qualified is making this dish. We're going to eat this at a fucking shell where they sell premium. That's right. I am going to smell 93 octane while I eat this curry.
1:11:55While I eat my lamb vindaloo. It's going to happen. So they, he ends up walking out of the store holding two beers. So the cops confront him. He throws one of the beers down and with his free hand pulls out a .380 semi-automatic handgun from his holster and raises it in the air. So he's got a beer in one hand and a handgun in the other in the parking lot of a shell station with a bunch of cops. And a broke High Life exploded in the parking lot. Yeah, I'm thinking steel reserve for some reason. Close enough. Do they take him? The officers draw their weapons, take cover behind the cruisers, order him to drop it. Civilians move away. They block off the intersection around there and everything.
1:12:39Then they have a two-hour standoff. Henry shouts obscenities at them. And at several points, asks the officers to, quote, blast him. Come on and fucking shoot me, you pussies. Customers are stuck inside the store. They can't leave. Now, Scott Williams, remember the prosecutor, he will prosecute this case. He said Henry stood in front of the store's glass panels while provoking police and put everyone inside at risk. Becausery stood uh in front of the store's glass panels while provoking police and put everyone inside at risk because he's standing in front of the store going shoot me shoot me but if they miss they can hit some kid inside right he had one demand but he we would go quietly you know what that demand is it's just to talk to her i want to see jody, you're going to a different jail. Wow.
1:13:26So they said, Prymont seemed more focused on talking to Jody Herring than anything. He told the negotiator that they brought in that was the only chance that he's getting is that. So he eventually set the pistol on the roof of a car and stepped away. No one's hurt. No shots are fired. He's placed on a 72 hour emergency psychiatric hold. He's charged with reckless endangerment and disorderly conduct. Um, and he's taken to the hospital. Um, now his attorney said he never pointed a gun at anyone, just raised it in the air. No one disputed that. So the judge found that, uh, basically he's gonna, he's convicted of misdemeanors and he has to abstain from alcohol, give up his firearms and all that.
1:14:09And stay away from that shell station also. So between him and Desiree, there's parts of this town they can't go to. So they try to say Jody's incompetent. But after about two years, they find her competent. July 6th, 2017, about a month before the trial dates, she agrees to plead guilty to all four killings. Really? Yeah. Guilty. I don't know if they have her medicated and kind of chilled out or what, but so for Laura, she pleads guilty to first-degree murder as originally charged. For Rhonda, Regina, and Julianne, the three aggravated murder charges were reduced to second-degree murder with the state free to seek concurrent sentences of 20 years to life as part of the deal, basically. Now, she could get life without parole here. We don't know.
1:15:00So her lawyer said, you know, maybe we could get some parole in the future and whatever. She has to sign a written confession as part of her plea. She said that, quote, no one disarmed me and I did not resist. I then dropped the rifle and said, if I have to go to the if I have to go to jail for the rest of my life, it was worth it. That's what she said. If I have to. Wow. That's in her confession. Worth it. Yeah. So the process during the sentencing, the prosecutor Williams, who helped with Laura Sobel, he ends up taking a medical leave of absence and then ends up resigning, citing post-traumatic stress from the whole thing. Multiple witnesses come up for mitigation, including her siblings who talk about the horrific environment
1:15:50she grew up in and the fact that she was kicked out of her house when she was 10. And I mean, they go through everything. Her mother comes up even and talks about the father being killed. Psychiatrists come in and say she has severe anxiety disorder that fueled her general suspicion of others in the months preceding the offenses. Her symptoms of suspiciousness and persecution that rose to the level of paranoid ideation and delusions. That's what they said. Never had a chance. Yeah, that's the thing. Now, another one testified that trauma that Jodi described can have a lasting effect for decades, meaning this shit with her dad. Jodi says, too, Jodi says that she wished she wouldn't have gotten out of the hospital so early.
1:16:40Oh, on that 90-day stint? Yeah. Because this would have never happened. If she'd stayed the full 90 days, she would have still been in the hospital on August 7th, she said. It's been less than 85 days. Yep. She then said, you know, I sat up all night wondering what I was going to say. I didn't write anything out. And it bothers me, you know. Hear what I said that night in lockup. I've never been a mean person my whole life. And Mr. Sobel is right. The loss of a child is so hard to endure. Meaning Laura's father said that. Then she took a roll call of her daughters to see who was there. Only one was there. Her youngest was in Massachusetts. Desiree, she told the court, was locked up in the same county jail as her.
1:17:23They're in jail together. Yep. Desiree's a problem. The same week of sentencing, Desiree was picked up by Vermont State Police at the Cumberland Farms in Montpelier on November 14th. She had multiple active warrants for being on escape status with the Department of Corrections. So she was transferred to this facility. This is not Desiree's first escape. In the summer of 2016, she went missing while on furlough after serving about four months on a stolen check case. Wow. Cumberland Farms is a gas station up there. Yes. She wasn't working. Not on the farm, no. Yeah. No, no. So then Jody said, it bothered me for everyone to get up there and listen to those impact statements. I know how it feels and I'm very sorry.
1:18:07I can't take back that day. I wish I could, but I can't. I handle my stress so differently than anyone else does. And I wish I could help myself. I really could. Uh, I asked for help several times and I didn't get it. And then it finishes with, I'm sorry. Wow. The judge says he does believe that Joey, that Jody is a caring mother, not a good mother necessarily, but a caring mother. Wow. They were well planned. They're lying in wait and they'd been thought out for some time. Jody's family was all alone in their home, was all in their home sometime in the afternoon of August 7th and they were just mowed down. That's the only way to put it. And then Laura, I'm not going to repeat the facts of what happened then.
1:18:55We know what happened. We know how devastating it was. We know it was essentially an assassination. What I'm unconvinced about is the last month because the last month, whatever the anxiety was, it seemed like the overriding emotion was rage. I did hear a lot of rageful comments, and clearly on August 7th, she was in a state of rage, and the comments thereafter are consistent with still being in that state of rage. And at least at that time, it's absolutely clear what she wanted to do and why she wanted to do it. I have a great deal of compassion and understanding for Jody Herring, but I also have an obligation to assure that this community is safe and that people can start to heal and that the enormity of these crimes are reflected in the sentence.
1:19:35You, wacky lady, may fuck off. Life in prison without parole for the murder of Laura Sobel. 20 years to life on each of the three second-degree murder counts with her family, all to run concurrent. The courtroom broke into applause, by the way, when she was sentenced. The judge killed. The judge killed it. So she appeals on several counts here, automatic appeals and basically that the judge had essentially held her trauma and anxiety against her, treating them as reasons she was dangerous rather than reasons she was less culpable and all of that basically. So the court found that the judge actually viewed her trauma with compassion, that his finding was that it was not anxiety but rather rage that primarily motivated the defendant.
1:20:29And also this sentence is not just to help society. It's to help her and keep her under supervision forever because she's a problem. She needs to be all snuggled up somewhere, I feel like, big time. So there's Berlin, Vermont. Wow. Bar or Bear, Vermont. Yeah. It's a crazy fucking story. What a family. Wiping everything out. It's a wild story. Yeah. If you like that story or any of our stories, get on whatever app you're on. Give us five stars. It helps a ton. Netflix, if you're watching there, double thumbs up is the way to do that. Felicia Ann does all right. One for each of you. So do that. Thank you so much for doing that. Definitely head over to shutupandgivememurder.com. Get your tickets.
1:21:12If you're listening when this first comes out, get your tickets for November 14th. It would be like tomorrow night or maybe today if it's that afternoon. Medford, outside of Boston, get your tickets for that. Last show of the year. In the next couple weeks, we'll be announcing our 2027 schedule. Those will go on sale in early December. So get ready to buy those. Shut up and give me murder.com is where you find all of that. You can follow us on social media at smalltownmurder on Instagram, smalltownpod on Facebook. Easy to do there. Get yourself Patreon. My God. P-A-T-R-E-O-N dot com slash crime in sports, just like the name of our other show that you should also check out. And that is the best deal
1:21:53you're going to get here, Patreon. Anybody $5 a month, a mere cup of coffee, people. Very affordable. $5 a month or above, you get everything that we put out, including as soon as you subscribe, you're going to get almost 400 back bonus episodes you've never heard before. New ones every other week. Tons of good stuff to binge on this week, which you're going to get because you're going to get new ones every other week. One crime and sports, one small town murder, and you get all of it. You bet. This week for crime and sports, we talked about the history of the Harlem Globetrotters and some of the fun stuff there. That was a good time. Then for Small Town Murder, the Nazi search for a truth serum in World War II, how that led to the psychedelic, hippie, lots of bright colors movement.
1:22:44It might sound odd, but there's a connection that goes right through a straight through line, and it's pretty weird stuff, and we talked about it. Patreon.com slash crimeinsports is where you get all of that. And on top of that, you also get every goddamn thing we put out, every show we put out, all ad free with your Patreon. We're angels. We're just too kind. That's we're angels we're doing this we're angels so yeah do that you also get everything we put out ad free and you get a shout out at the end of the regular show because we are angels and we're thinking of you so definitely do that keep coming back and seeing us week after week after week. And until next week, everybody, it's been our pleasure.
1:23:52Getting ready for clients takes work. With Base44, describe what your business needs in your own words and build the website and software behind it. Your build comes headache-free. Database, login, backend, and hosting are built in and already handled. With Base44, go to market faster and keep building as your business grows. Go to Base44.com. That's Base44.com. Day or night, VerboCare is here 24-7 to help make every part of your stay seamless. If anything comes up or you simply need a little guidance, support is ready whenever you reach out. From the moment you book to the moment you head home, we're here to help things run smoothly. Because a great trip starts with the right support. And hey, a good playlist doesn't hurt either.
1:24:49Welcome to the 50th Hunger Games. Witness the beginning of the revolution. Hey Mitch, you've been trying to take down these games from the start. Filmed for IMAX. Make them remember you. The Hunger Games, Sunrise on the Weeping, Friday, made at PG-13. This holiday, all plans, even unlimited, are just $15 a month. A holiday deal this good obviously deserves an enormously expensive holiday song like All I Want. Right. Okay, we can afford that. You know what? Forget the music budget. We're going to stick with whatever's in the public domain. Give it a try at mintmobile.com slash switch. Upfront payment of $45 for three months, $90 for six months, or $180 for a 12-month plan required. $15 per month equivalent.
1:25:28Taxes and fees extra. New customer offer for initial plan term only. Greater than 50 gigabytes. May slow when network is busy. See terms. Support is available 24-7 with VrboCare. We're here day or night. Ready whenever you need help. Because a great trip starts with the right support.