Rugby Union Weekly · · Transcript & summary by WhipScribe
Two former Wales internationals and the BBC panel break down how Wales beat the All Blacks, from the defence to a halfback change, and what it means for Welsh rugby.
Tap a chapter to open that moment in the transcript; the link to it is copied for you.
“I've had a little taste for it now and it's a special playing here and I want to do it again.” Will Joseph · at 38:47 — open in the transcript →
Wales beat New Zealand 35-28 in Cardiff, and the panel debates whether it is the greatest win in Welsh rugby history. Odds of 200-1 had been on offer, and commentators say almost nobody expected Wales to win. Hosts James Hook and Alex Cuthbert describe a stadium where fans were still in tears long after full time, and they expect the result to lift ticket sales for Wales' Australia game.
The match turned on defence. New Zealand made 122 tackles to Wales' 310 and carried far less often, yet Wales held them out on their own line for close to half an hour. Commentators single out James Botham and Eddie James for their work, and they note Steve Tandy's halfback change with 15 minutes left in a one-score game. The hosts argue New Zealand, who changed many of their starters, lost their shape and tried to force things in the final stretch.
Attention then moves to what comes next. Panellists compare the upset to Japan's win over South Africa at the World Cup and say Wales must build on it in the Six Nations. The show also covers England's 78-15 win over Japan at Twickenham, where Will Joseph scored five tries and equalled an England record, and the panel asks why Japan have fallen since their 2019 World Cup quarter-final.
Will Joseph is an England winger who scored five tries against Japan at Twickenham, equalling an England record for a men's international. He was interviewed on the episode about his return to the squad after a long wait for his second cap.
Will Joseph said his family were there pitchside to watch him score five tries at Twickenham, and that he grew up watching his brother Jay play at the stadium. He called the day special because he could do it himself with his family supporting him.
“obviously i've grown up watching him a lot watching him play at this stadium and do special things”Will Joseph · 38:03
Will Joseph described the four and a half years since his first cap as a challenge, covering a change of club to Gloucester and an ear problem. He said the journey back to international rugby had been worth it and that the day felt like the payoff for the hard work he had put in.
“Yeah, like it's been a challenge of four years, but nonetheless, I've enjoyed the journey to getting back here”Will Joseph · 38:03
James Hook said the win over New Zealand was a huge shot in the arm for Welsh rugby after the low points of the last two to three years. He said it gave the players confidence in what they can do going into the autumn internationals, the Six Nations and beyond.
“it's a huge shot in the arm, it just gives these boys so much confidence to know what they can do now going forward”James Hook · 3:24
Wales beat New Zealand 35-28 at the Principality Stadium in Cardiff, their first win over the All Blacks since 1953. The panel said Wales' defence on their own line decided the match, and that Steve Tandy's late halfback change helped close it out.
Will Joseph said scoring five tries for England against Japan at Twickenham was a very special day he will probably never forget. He equalled an England record for tries in a men's international and was one try short of breaking it, but said he stayed focused on his job rather than hunting for a sixth. He said getting a try with his first touch eased him into the game.
Wales defended their own line for about half an hour against New Zealand, holding up several close-range balls and making dominant tackles. The panel singled out James Botham and Eddie James, with James Botham's physicality a surprise to the hosts. The defence stopped New Zealand's momentum, and the hosts said the crowd grew louder each time Wales held the ball up over the line.
The panel said New Zealand lost because they changed many of their starters, lost their shape and got caught up in the emotion of the match. Dave Rennie's side had 65% of possession and territory but still struggled to score in the final stretch. The hosts also pointed to their halfbacks, who were held up three times and sometimes indecisive in their own 22.
Steve Tandy made a late halfback change with about 15 minutes to go in a one-score game, bringing on Reuben Morgan-Williams and Dan Edwards to see out the win. The hosts called it a big call that could benefit Wales' halfbacks in the future. They said Dan Edwards held one ball up over the line in the closing stages.
The panel compared Wales beating New Zealand to Japan's win over South Africa at the World Cup and said it was as big an upset. They said no one in the rugby world expected it, with odds of 200-1, and that modern test rugby has few big upsets because teams are so powerful and well drilled. Wales' coaching turmoil and player uncertainty made the result even more remarkable in their view.
Our own transcript of the public episode, with a timestamp about every 90 seconds. Tap a timestamp or the link button on a paragraph to copy a link that opens this page there.
0:00This BBC podcast is supported't just about the grid. That same racing mindset, the obsession with engineering, the pursuit of perfection, lives in the Cadillac V-Series lineup, giving you the chance to experience the precision and performance of the grid on the open road. Cadillac V-Series, distinctive luxury performance, engineered to thrill. Discover the V-Series lineup at Cadillac.com. Host Thanksgiving with industry-leading quality standards from Whole Foods Market. There are no antibiotics in their meat department ever, so carve up turkey and spiral-cut ham with peace of mind. Shop organic sides like stuffing mix and cranberry sauce from 365 Brand. And guess what? All their delectable pies are made with no high fructose corn syrup.
1:06Gourmet Thanksgiving flavors with the quality you want. Only at Whole Foods Market. Five Lives Rugby Union Weekly. Welcome to Rugby Union Weekly. We are still in the Principality Stadium. Wales have still beaten New Zealand. 1905, 1935, 1953, 2026. 73 years of hurt. You will have been hearing that so many times by the moment that you listen to me say this. But what a Rugby Union Weekly we have coming to you right now and i have two very smiley welshmen with me alex cuspert and james hook you just beat new zealand that is unbelievable i've not seen the stadium cathy you'll be the same yeah like that bouncing for decades and decades and i think it was just because the way, nobody gave us a hope.
2:08Everyone was saying 30, 40 points, they're going to lose by 50 points, some people. And they just turned around and the way they performed. One to 200. Was that what it was? That's what it was. One to 200. So you have to put 200 quid to win a pound. And just, I don't think I've ever seen a defence display inside or on your own goal line like that ever again. And I don't think I've ever seen a defence display inside or on your own goal line like that ever again. James Botham has just rewritten how you defend on the line, hasn't he, Ricky? Three balls held up on the line. Plumtree, Botham, Dan Edwards. And we talk about Sean Edwards-era defence. Gareth Thomas as well. Gareth Thomas, yeah. There's four, isn't there?
2:40I can't remember. I've lost count. Ridiculous. But Peter Murchie's got to take a huge amount of credit. Dan Lyddiott as well. Can I just say, these two, they're on either side of me here, and I think I could let you two go this whole pod without me interrupting. I'm a bit out of breath, I'm sorry. I don't blame you. If anyone, for any reason, didn't watch this fixture, where were you? What were you doing? Oh, my goodness. It finished Wales 35, New Zealand 28. And the last, basically, half an hour, we looked off to our right-hand side, where Wales defended for their lives, solidly, on their own line. The only time we looked left was in the last three minutes, when all of a sudden the ball went down the other end,
3:24and Wales held on to the ball for absolute dear life, for this incredible historic moment can you just both put into some kind of context what this victory actually means for the Welsh fans and for Welsh rugby James Hook it's so difficult to put into words because it means so much because I think you know myself and Cathy have been watching Wales now particularly the last five ten years and you know the the lows of Welsh rugby particularly the last 5-10 years and the lows of Welsh rugby, particularly the last 2-3 years, it's a huge shot in the arm, it just gives these boys so much confidence to know what they can do now going forward the rest of the Autumn Internationals, the Six Nations and
3:56beyond, it feels like just a new era is arising for these young players I think it goes even further, I just spoke then, I think how good it is for the boys the squad, rugby, but I think take goes even further. I just spoke then. I think, you know, how good it is for the boys, the squad, rugby. But I think take away rugby, what it is in Wales, hooky, you know, like to beat the All Blacks. Like the last time they beat, what was it, 1953. You know, how many great teams players have tried and not been able to do it. It's scary. And I include the teams that you guys have played for that. Yeah, Gareth Edwards sat there watching. Yeah, yeah. Do you know what I mean? I've never seen so many people in tears.
4:31And even where I went now, everyone's still crying. I don't think I've ever had that sort of emotion. And we've won Grand Slam championships like that. That was on another level, wasn't it? I've only just stopped shaking. It's about 30, 40 minutes post-match now. So imagine what the players are feeling. That last five minutes, when Blair Murray kicked that ball from the 22, relieved that pressure, the row, and then when Ruben Morgan-Williams kicked the ball out. Honestly, I got goosebumps now thinking about it. Incredible. We will talk about the celebrations on Westgate Street, which, by the way, have already started. And I think this might be one of the most profitable nights that Westgate Street has had in a long, long time.
5:07You've already told me, James, that you're going to delay leaving tonight, aren't you? I am. You ain't going home quickly. I am, no. I was touching Gorbals Steen or not, but I think it's just me with my mind up now. I'm supposed to fly home tomorrow morning. I've cancelled that flight and I'm flying on Monday. I've got the phone call now and my wife's saying, I'll see you in a couple of days. Right then. I think it's only right we hear from the captain today who again put an incredible performance here is the Welsh captain Dowie Lake speaking to Laura Jane Jones Dowie Lake not a dry eye in the house did you shed a little tear at the end then yeah I did um not too dissimilar from when we beat them in 20s although I'm not
5:41going to cry in the interview this time. Go on, do it. Look, the boys worked hard today. I said earlier in the week we had a lot to put right from last week, performance-wise. And it wasn't perfect at times today. It wasn't. But the trust we've got in this group, the care we have for each other, it goes a long way. Debo, you say it wasn't perfect, but let's deal with it in the two halves. First half, attacking rugby all the way. How do you come out of the blocks like that? We said all week we were going to fire a shot, we were going to attack them. I think it's the only way to play the All Blacks sometimes. We probably flipped it back to 12 months ago where in the first half we did attack them
6:27second half we didn't and that's ultimately where we fell there's big emphasis on it for us coming out imposing ourselves on the game and I think we did it today you certainly did Dowie Lake congratulations you're the first captain to beat New Zealand in a Wales jersey since 1953 Incredible words there by Dowie Lake. Even going as far to say it wasn't perfect, I can tell you every Welsh fan said, I don't care what that looked like. Who cares? The result is the result. But let's just talk about Dowie Lake and the performance he put in. He had to go for an HIA. He came back on. But just his steeliness and how he is leading this side now. So many people were thinking after Alan Wynne-Jones had gone,
7:12who was going to step up and lead this side? What a leader. You could see it in his eyes when he walked out the tunnel as well at the start of the game. He was well up for this game. And, you know, you mentioned in his interview as well, he beat the New Zealand under-20s at that level as well so you know they believed nobody else gave this Welsh team a hope it was just that 23 players and coaching staff nobody else in the stadium give him a hope and I think that's why he was so emotional and you know the atmosphere at the end was something I've never ever experienced yeah I think Derry Lake the way he is captain in this team in in obviously absolute turmoil whether it's his club, Ospreys before,
7:46or Wales when it was 18 straight losses. I think being in an environment where he was, I think you've got to give credit to other captains in the past, Alan Wynne-Jones, you know, being in that environment, the Ospreys, he's obviously picked up an awful lot, because not many people get chosen captain and rise to the occasion. We see it in cricket, don't we? You know, like you could go Joe Ro root was captain and his stats went down and you know that you know that the pressure is different pressure isn't a hooky yeah you know i was never captain because i would have probably just folded but a guy like derry lake seems to just rise to the occasion and and and that if you look at his last 10 15 games to wales they they are nearly man of the match. He's so on it every time.
8:26And then he's on it in the week in interviews. And I'm not sure, Zara, you probably interviewed him a few times, but he speaks really well. It's all about the team. Never about him, isn't it? He's an incredible figure. And so much has been talked about in the media already about the move he's made out of Wales into Gloucester, how he has led Gloucester in the Prem this season, how much experience he's getting, not just from being at Gloucester, how he has led Gloucester in the Prem this season, how much experience he's getting, not just from being at Gloucester and how well they're going, but from that leadership position, which suits him so well. And I just really hope, and the biggest thing in all of this
8:57is you just really want this to be the line in the sand that we now look upwards for Welsh rugby. And everyone gets behind this team. Our five live production staff, who were listening to the commentary, have already said they were monitoring ticket sales for the Australia game, and apparently they are ticking up very nicely all of a sudden, because let us not forget, when we started commentary, Alex Cuthbert, on Five Live, this is a 74-capacity stadium. The confirmed attendance was 55,152, and that is for an all blacks match against Wales they're not giving away but selling tickets for 20 pounds can you imagine if that's what you spent on that ticket to witness history today that's the best bargain
9:37you remember back in the day when we played New Zealand we were getting people knocked on the door have you got any spare tickets? you couldn't get a ticket now they're giving them away but yeah I think hopefully that will start to change. That's the effect this result will have, I think. Let's talk about the match itself. Just a few statistics to throw at you. Tackles made by New Zealand, 122. Tackles made by Wales, 310. Possession, 65% New Zealand. Territory, 65% New Zealand. Territory 63% New Zealand. Carries 258 New Zealand to Wales 119. I could go on. Let's talk about defence. Let's talk about James Botham in particular. He was the player of the match today. He did some wondrous things. He did, he did.
10:21Back to that, just shows you in sport, nothing is a foregone conclusion, no matter what people thought when they arrived here today, but yeah that defensive effort, I think both of them, it's difficult to pick one player out because I thought Eddie James had his best game in the Welsh jersey, both sides of the ball, defensively, that last half an hour, everyone was just scrambling to make tackles, cover tackles, holding the ball up over the line and New Zealand were coming, they coming you know Satiti, Lakai kept coming at Wales but they just didn't have any answers in the end and it was it's it's interesting to see obviously the Welsh players walking around the pitch getting applauded and then just watching the New Zealand
10:58players just in ones and twos just lost for words just can't quite believe it absolutely shell-shocked yeah they will be in that changing room thinking how on earth have we not won that game because in theory, if you looked at the stats you'd think, oh my god, it must be 50-60 points but the heart I thought every time they held the ball it just gave Wales so much energy the crowd, it was just building and building and building, and in the end I felt like New Zealand just lost their shape completely. They literally sucker-punched themselves. They went so hard in that first sort of between 45 and 55, and they just had nothing left, did they? I'm so glad you said that because under this Dave Rennie regime,
11:41it has all been about this beautiful flowing rugby, the expectation of what all New Zealand rugby fans want to see from their side. It was completely lacking today. And New Zealand will be waking up to this result. That their side have lost to Wales, ranked 10th in the world. But when they watch it back, they're going to be so disappointed. That is not a New Zealand performance to be proud of. No, it's not. They made a lot of changes. They changed it to the starting line-up, which has come back to bite them, really. They didn't give Wales any hope. Wales turned out a performance from the ages. But, yeah, from a New Zealand point of view, they just looked lost for options. I think Wales' defence pressured their skill set.
12:22And, you know, Barrett was trying to make things happen in the second half, but nothing was happening. There was knock knock-ons there was turnovers and we spoke about the tries that were held up and yeah for New Zealand you know that obviously that's their problem it's not Wales's problem if you look at on the other foot you know it's been how many years to Wales 1953 73 years they haven't won on you flip that who are the first team to lose to Wales and that they're gonna be that's what this group will be known for but they lost to who were the first team to lose to Wales and that's what this group would be known for but they lost to Wales for the first time in 73 years it's mind blowing there were some really good individual
12:54I thought it was TT he was unbelievable wasn't he I spoke to John Mitchell and he was like they needed to go back to a little bit of structure you know when there was a penalty kick to the corner maybe or go off a scrum they they ended up going against 15 Welsh front line rather than maybe get it back to a set piece and then they can work from there and I think they completely just lost their minds a little bit in that last 10 minutes yeah in the first half New Zealand played a lot from deep didn't they when Wales kicked off they played from their own 22 and had a bit of payout of it in the second half Wales obviously talked about that at half time and said New Zealand are playing a lot let and had a bit of pay out of it, in the second half Wales had obviously talked about that at half time and said
13:26New Zealand are playing a lot, let's put a bit of pressure on them, so Murray would kick long, Costello would kick long and there was one time I'd never seen Bowden Barrett just indecisive in his own 22 was he going to kick, was he going to run, he ended up running getting turned over and that was the story of the game. Yeah, Eddie James and Max Llewellyn, unbelievable defensively if you go back and watch that, how many times they forced New Zealand back inside or put a massive hit in, stopped it on the gain line, and then it just killed all momentum from New Zealand. And, you know, I still can't believe it, I'll be honest. Can I ask you both? When you look down that Wales 23 now, having seen this result,
14:03having seen the performance they put out on the field who are you now looking at differently as a result of that one performance that maybe you're a bit like oh they're in oh they're out who has stepped up and come of age today for me it's difficult to pick one but i think eddie james had mentioned him i thought he was he was outstanding both of them as well obviously he was was playing the match but i was watching eddie james every instance he had both sides of the ball some of his tacklers he was putting in. It wasn't just, you know, soak-up tacklers. They were dominant tacklers. In attack, he looked good as well. His ball carrying, he scored a try as well. But it's difficult to pick just one.
14:35I thought Blair Murray has stood up, not just this week, last week he was outstanding as well. I think if you look deeper, I thought Archie Griffin, I thought that scrum was solid. His carrying has come on a lot. James Botham, I think physicality-wise, wow, he's got it, hasn't he? That was probably something he wasn't really known for. That backfield, I still think that left wing is still up for grabs, isn't it? You've got Zamet and Blair Murray, that's an area. But I think this midfield of Costello, James and Llewellyn, that is going to be the mainstay of that back line for Wales for a long period of time, whether it's defence or attack. I've got to say, Thomas Williams had a terrific game as well.
15:12He got criticised a little bit last week, didn't he? But he had a hand in pretty much all the tries, his kicking stuff was good, he was a running threat. Yeah, but it goes back to the breakdown though, doesn't it? It does, yeah. How aggressive, how much more physical Wales were at the breakdown, which gave Thomas Williams to get out, defender one and and do his thing i was really surprised around 65 minutes where steve tandy did make the call to change the halfback pairing you're nodding away at me already james hook you i was thinking is he going okay this is the game i've got to get these boys on because the other two are tired and i need to give them the experience of being in this game.
15:45But ultimately, they came on and they saw it out, Reuben Morgan-Williams and Dan Edwards. Yeah, I was surprised because 15 minutes to go, the game is in the balance. And, you know, you look over the last sort of year or so, Thomas Williams hasn't really come off. He stayed on the whole game. And all of a sudden, you see them change the halfbacks. You think, you know, one score game, that's a big, see them change the halfbacks you think one score game that's a big big call but in credit to Steve Tandy it's a big call but it's a call that's going to benefit that four halfbacks the two nines the two tens going forward because I thought Thomas and Costello had a fine 65 minutes and then Ruben Morgan-Williams
16:19Dan Edwards come on closed it out as you say Dan Edwards held one ball up over the line it's going to benefit them massively. I think that's the earliest Thomas Williams, you'll have to have a look back, but I have a feeling that's the earliest he's come off the Wales in probably like two years, I think. And they were playing well, because you don't usually see that, do you? If you're 9 and 10 on the pitch and it's going well for you personally in the games and the balance, you're thinking, right, I'm staying on for the full 80, and all of a sudden, you know, they change it and it's worked. We don't often do this on Rugby Union Weekly, but I feel it's quite important because Welsh rugby hasn't had a night like this in a while.
16:53So plot me the route down Westgate Street. Where's everyone going? Where's the place to be? Where do the players end up? And where are you two going next? You first, Alex Cuff, but you know this route well. Well, I was going to go home because I had about a six o'clock flight tomorrow morning, but I'm not now. well I was going to go home because I had about a six o'clock flight tomorrow morning but I'm not now so I will probably go to the Arms Park there'll be a lot of ex-players go there Tom Shantling does an event and then it'll just yeah it'll kick on a little bit from there I reckon Sarah that's probably as much I can say on this OK OK I came up with my wife and three boys so they're in Cardiff
17:22and I planned on going back with them so I'm going to give it a ring and try and negotiate a few more hours now. But yeah, we'll enjoy tonight. That's for certain. I think after 73 years, the negotiations should go in your favour. I should tell you, there was another rugby match that happened today. There was a few that's happened over the weekend, but one in particular that happened today was between England, Japan. That was at Twickenham. Let's head over to Chris Jones. Thanks loads, Sarah, and to Hookie and Cuthie as well. And what a job they've done down in Cardiff. What a performance. What a moment for Welsh rugby, for Welsh sport. And that says a lot. Alex Cuthbert, Matt Dawson, changing his plans.
18:00No six there. But to the arms part, meet up with some old players, because that's a result for all of Welsh rugby, isn't it? It's a once in a lifetime. I suppose it has been a lifetime for all of those players and hopefully Wales will beat New Zealand again. But a vast majority of the people in that stadium weren't even born. You know what I mean? That is an enormous result. I was just after the game here popped into one of the you know the hospitality rooms it was headline news on on itv news yeah it was like oh my goodness me i mean that is the enormity outside of wales i don't think people quite understand the enormity of of that victory i think if you throw into the pot everything what's been going on
18:47with Welsh rugby, where they are, coaching turmoil, teams being pulled here, there and everywhere, some players don't know if they're going to have a job week to week. And if you throw all that into context too, it is wild. Nobody on this planet would have said that Wales are going to do that and do it in style. And the results they have had, this Wales team, have been Japan and Italy. And then they go and topple the All Blacks. And as you say, the context is huge. And those results just don't happen in Test Rugby, do they? There was no evidence to say it was going to happen. But also in Test Rugby these days, you you know you used to get back in the day kick and clap backs to the wall win a kind of
19:31scrappy game you could maybe do that in the way in football you can have a one nil get 10 players behind the ball but teams are so powerful and well drilled you just don't see big upsets anymore you really don't you you do not put any money on 200 to 1. On? Of course you don't, unless you're mad. Or you're very rich. Even then, you're putting it on your tenner for a bit of fun. That's an insane result. No one in the rugby world thought that that was going to happen today. And to see just to see how deep Wales dug in for a sustained period of time that wasn't like a five minutes and it's a one point ball game and it's five it was like half an hour they went to places I'm not sure well I'm not
20:22sure you could ever go again that was deep. New Zealand I saw 200-1 on meaning you've got to stake 200 quid to win a quid I mean they're going to kill some accumulators this week that is for sure even last week after the game they were like we're miles off it we just beat Japan who've just shipped 78 here after the game the pundits were saying no no we're miles off here I can't remember a game where no one is yeah it's not like a few people are going giving Wales a fight. Alice Cuthbert was on 5Loss Sport with Grayson and Chappers earlier today and he said the Welsh players would believe because you've got no other choice you guys have ex-pros and we asked the question Chappers and I of Cuthie as if to say,
21:05how do you go into a game knowing you're going to lose? Because that's where we thought it was going. And he said, no, they'll believe they can win. Or they'll, you know, maybe in 20 years time when they're writing their books, they'll go, oh, maybe we didn't believe. In the same way, the love ex-Scotland and players go. You're under no book deals, are you? Well, no, I'm just saying that, you know, if you speak to some Scotland players who never beat New Zealand, they would go we never really believed you kind of thought Wales were in that then they've gone and done it and that's what's so incredible don't joke about that no I know that is that's crazy that's a fairytale film right there there's a documentary
21:36there's a film there's a book for balance what are we saying about New Zealand well they were they had made changes, but you can't be off the timers. Beforehand, it's maybe just me saying this, I looked at the team and didn't see many weaknesses. No. It's a changed team. Instead of Anthony Brown at 12, almost 100 kappa, the great Bowden Barrett at 15, Richie Mwanga, who's a World Cup final, you know, fly half, one of the best in the world three years ago. I know he's been over in Japan. Scott Barrett's in the second row. Lakai and Tsutiti both start. And they've been revelations. The front row was switched, but still some quality in there. Fretchen Yule starts, Amuah Hooker. I don't know. I mean, I don't think we can turn around and go,
22:17oh, it was a change you've seen inside, but I don't think it was a bad one on paper by any stretch. Okay. But they played, they were. And okay on selection, fine. Okay. The, what I would talk about is a slightly bigger picture around New Zealand is how did they not work out how to play against that team with all the possession for 30 minutes, all the territory, all the pressure they got wrapped up in the emotion of the game and the build of momentum that that Wales had delivered in defense but they still had plenty of opportunities to score tries and to tie the game sometimes you just I think that's a bit course you do, but New Zealand don't. I'm saying there's a bigger chink there than Wales have exploited it.
23:12It falls on the halfbacks then, doesn't it? If they are not attacking the right way, if they're not executing. They got held up three times. True, but Ratema rather than Roy, I mean Roy Godd's as we know a world-class player of course Ratema has been around for a bit and he's excellent and then Mwanga there'll be a spotlight on Mwanga given he's not been playing test rugby for a while compared to when Mackenzie or Love has been at 10 so I think in that situation do probably that inquest will that inquest will start in New Zealand it'll be going on will they have woken up now probably morning time in New Zealand that inquest will be fierce short-lived if they turn up here though next week It'll be going on, will they have woken up now? Probably morning time in New Zealand.
23:47That inquest will be fierce. Short-lived if they turn up here though next week. And then they turn up here. And now they go to London. And what a week this is going to be with the New Zealand team that have been humbled. But let's get into England. Final word on Wales, because I saw Lloyd Williams, who here we are at Twickenham down that left touchline. He puts that kick in for Gareth Davis, talking about great Welsh rugby memories. That's another one here in 15. But in terms of an upset, I do think that was as big an upset as Japan, South Africa. Lloyd Williams said in the live text, I hope the Welsh players know how happy they've made this Welsh nation. And I'm sure they do. But that really sums it up.
24:22You've got to use that now. The amount of confidence they're going to take from that coaches players we have seen that there is going to come a turn at some point and when you look at the squad now you look at how many are in the prem and they're like the best players in the prem most weeks there was going to come a time where they get going nobody thought it would be today the result they had but now they've got man they've got to use this now everybody wants a good Wales as much as you want to joke about it we need a strong Wales hopefully this is the the point where they start going forward again England go to Wales in the Six Nations England play against Wales in the World Cup you know that narrative now is starting to build. Just what a weekend we've had already
25:06with the France game and now this. And yeah, just what about sport, hey? You can't beat it. That Donnachra Callaghan quote back in the day when he said the Welsh players were Clark Kent for their regions and Superman for Wales. And, you know, that's what Welsh players can do. They can get that Welsh jersey on and feel the nation and what this could do for Welsh rugby going forward sell out the stadium you know the Prem's got to have a pat on the back here for these players playing in the Prem they are the bulk of that Welsh squad now and they've been the best players in the Prem yeah they haven't been doing that in the UFC yeah I mean what's it five the starting 15 is it no there's more we have to have a look but there's more in the squad I think I don't what's it, five of the starting 15, is it? No, there's more.
25:45We'll have to have a look, but there's more in the squad. I don't think it's certainly helped some of them, but I you know, I wouldn't go and say that it could be down to too much. It's all down to English rugby basically. I know, I can feel Oh no, I said a pat on the back. How has Chris Ashton turned this into an English rugby thing? Anyway, we keep trying to move on, but we can't because it was such a special day and such a special win. 78 points to 15. I mean, it was on from the off, wasn't it? Like from the off. Will Joseph scores with his first touch. He gets five. He's coming up on the pod. But reflections, Dawson. I mean, magnificent for Will Joseph, particularly that first half. And they weren't just stroll-ins.
26:31I thought that he showed great finishing quality. England looked very sort of well-drilled, accurate, powerful. They stamped the authority on the game very early on. I have to say, Japan were really poor, really poor, so passive in their defence. They obviously had a rocket half-time from Eddie Jones. They came out and had a couple of moments. But it's a while, actually, since I've seen England completely destroy a side like that. Maybe in the World Cup you're playing against Chile and you just know the result is going to be like that. Whereas I might have expected England to win by 30, possibly. Yeah. Mid-30s. Today probably could have been 100, couldn't it? England to win by 30 possibly? Yeah. Mid 30s?
27:27Today probably could have been 100 couldn't it? If they've got their kicking shoes up. And the ratio they were scoring points should have been 100. What's happened to Japan? Just first of all I don't want to take anything away from England because they were great from the start off and I'm really happy they've got two from two but what has happened to Japan here? Why are they all of a sudden probably not all of a sudden it's happened over a year or two why are they so bad? I think quarter finals in the World Cup in 2019 yeah that is a while back and they've lost some generational players they still have some experience the guys like Jimeno the back rower who's a generational player he's kind of in the wider squad.
28:07Michael Leach as well, they might get him to the World Cup. I think Eddie Jones is trying to build some experience and adding in some more experienced players to the wider squad. Oh, no, no, no. But no, I mean, look, they set out a team here incredibly callow when you've got guys who, too, play for the university. Their best player is playing for university over in japan the wingers first game of pro rugby 15 so are we are we saying that that we should be as a game we should be funding this a bit better if the potentials is in japan is it a funding issue i feel i feel like no that was aimed at a World Cup. We can't let Japan just slide away. That would be an absolute travesty for them to slide away
28:51and then be not challenging for this tournament. They've beaten Italy in the summer and they've beaten Fiji recently. So I don't think they are necessarily on the slide. They're just not the team that we saw in 15 and 19 for sure I had a quick word with Eddie Jones downstairs they had to be in the game on 20 minutes but within 5 they've conceded and they've had a man sent off haven't they so just everything that could have gone wrong went wrong from the off and then you're playing against a well drilled England with the Twickenham crowd up and they were taken to the cleaners so in answer to your question where they're going and where they will be come next year I think is a good question but certainly that's Eddie
29:38Jones' challenge isn't it? They're a far cry from beating South Africa in the World Cup aren't they? Yeah and they were even better in 19 than 15. They were, yeah. Remember when they beat Scotland the day after the typhoon? I've never seen quick rugby like it. They were a different gear. But I think a lot of that crop, or all of that crop, has now moved on. So it's a new era. They're in transition. So let's see how they shape up over the next 12 months. We don't have the same culture, or like we are far from it, no, and they brought the winger, Kenki... Kenki Fukuoka, was he? Yeah, Fukuoka, yeah. He was like one of the best players of the World Cup in 2019. I played against him here, he was such a good winger.
30:22He just left. He went to work. He went to work. He went to be a doctor. Like, you can't... They're culturally so different to us. Sport is not their be-all and end-all. It's my job or my career is what I'm aiming for. Rugby's a side piece. And when that's in your culture, you're always kind of going to struggle to build a team that wants to yeah well i suppose and the rest of the unions and the rest of the players are i mean the the curve of development in professional rugby is pretty steep at the moment isn't it from year to year yeah the kids know in the in the prem clubs are globally yeah yeah big time you look at the development the skill development the power the pace the fitness the endurance
31:09of these Eddie said on Tuesday they didn't have a high performance programme do they in Japan they've got to go to their university they might go to their top league club but they don't have what you're talking about there that kind of academy type type environment so it looked as though they were getting going and they were keen to get involved. And no, it just looks like we've seen that bounce. And this might be just how they continue forward. But I can't see the game in Japan going more professional than what it is. The league is what it is. And maybe the international team is going to be... Maybe a slightly broader pod or conversation that we had there, but you've got to probably worry about the split in the tiers.
31:52And Wales beat New Zealand. Wales are always going to be in the top 10 or 12, but they are... Everybody is accelerating at such a pace at the moment but that's what and there is obviously criticism about the Nations Championship potentially having the top 12 going off on their own playing the Nations Championship every two years and then the next 12 not in the playing Nations Cup not getting the same top level but that's where Japan are in they're at the top table aren't they now they've joined the Big Ten. So, they have got that exposure every other year in the Nations Championship. But, if we go to England, just, there's obviously World Cup squad places up for grabs here and it doesn't, the team that played today
32:40didn't necessarily scream. I think years gone by, I remember when DC, the famous bit with Eddie Jones and he never was seen again for a good two years after that and at that time I felt the squad was more I don't want to say selfish but it was more I want to play I want to be first choice if you know if I'm saying that right I want to play you need to to be first choice, if I'm saying that right. I want to play, you need to pick me because I'm the best player I need to play. Whereas now, I think the lads are a bit more understanding of the squad feel of it and understand you can all have a role and there's a chance for everybody to play a part. And I don't know, it just didn't scream selfish to me that today.
33:23It seems like everybody was just enjoying being part of the squad, wanted to do their bit for the team and stay part of the squad with a focus to hopefully being part of the World Cup. I think sport in general, that is coached and that is trained and you have to develop that from whether you're 12, watching my lads play rugby and football, they are genuinely never bothered about whether they're in the team. It's not even a conversation. Right. Whether they're in the team or they're on the bench. It's not. It's like, yeah, okay. Whereas... I'd have been annoyed. Yeah, me too. It's like, yeah, okay. Whereas... I'd have been annoyed. Yeah, me too. I want to be in the team. I don't want to be on the bench
34:09and I'd probably have a little bit of a cry if I was 14 and I wasn't playing in the team. But I think it's just now, I mean, it's a fair point. It's just that is part of the culture of sport that it is around the squad. You're right. I mean, there were some great performances from some of the bench today, particularly for Slough. I thought, you know, he just... Freddie Stewart as well. Yeah. He came and he played well today. Yeah, he did. Well, the outside of the boot kick was so good, I thought it was Henry Slade, didn't I? In commentary. He went through and I went Slade and then he put an outside of the boot kick set up for Will Joseph. Because his skill set is... I don't know if he missed it as well.
34:48Pardon? He threw the pass to Murley, the wide pass to Murley. For Murley's try. But Freddie Stewart's been... He did a pass for Ben Earl in the Wales game earlier this year. It was good a flat ball. If Burbank threw, we'd be raving about it. I think because he's so big, Freddie Stewart, he gets categorised as aerial and a carrier in traffic but he's a skilful lad but I don't think he was I'm not sure he's been the skills that we've seen recently I think there's a lot of development there and probably a little bit of realisation that he has to change his game if he wants to compete with Furbank and he's got some good coaches around him that are saying hopefully saying the same thing rather than
35:29you know back it will you know keep doing what you're doing you know bigger stronger facts like no you've got to develop if you want a challenge he's a good example of um he's got a certain skill set and he's not come out today he's like right i've got to i've got to play amazing well to play next week because i'm under pressure to play against furbank and this and that where the coach has actually gone freddie we're going to use you a bit differently we're going to use you to your strengths we're going to bring you into the outside center you're going to hit a short line you're going to chase kickoffs you're going to chase box kicks we're going to use your skill set to better suit how we're going to play today and not try and fit you into a square peg
36:05or try and play like George Furbank. We're going to... And that's good coaching, I think, to be able to do that and change the way we have attacked and use the lad's strength. Plenty of standout performers, but no doubt the headline grabber. Four and a half years since he won his solitary cap before today, off the bench on the tour of Australia as a 19 year old through a change of clubs and through health issues and everything Will Joseph back scoring with his first touch scoring five in all a record equaler here he is on the pod it's a very special day a day I'll probably never forget and I'm just yeah I'm very grateful to be part of this team and given another opportunity to represent my country and I'm very grateful for the team of this team and given another opportunity to represent my country.
36:46I'm very grateful for the team and how well we moved the ball today to get five tries as well. So, a very good day. I imagine when you're a winger, it's nervous at the start. You want to get your hands on the ball. But to get a touch straight away, to score with basically your first touch, to have a hat-trick within 20 20 minutes that must have just been incredible. Yeah I think as a winger like you're always trying to get your hands on the ball as soon as possible and to have that as a first touch it sort of eases your way into the game so again very grateful to Max to throw on that one across the face and making sure I could get my hands on the ball. Were you aware that you've equaled an English rugby record five tries in
37:23the men's international and did you know that you were one try away from breaking it with six? Yeah, I think with like 15 minutes to go, one of the physios said, try to get six, try to get six. But I think I was out of gas, so I couldn't get six. But yeah, happy to get five. I can't complain. No, you showed good discipline though to stay on your wing and not go hunting for it. Chris Ashton in commentary was like, just go looking for the ball get that sick uh yeah i was just focused focused on doing my job but i was happy with with scoring five so for sure um your brother was touchline the camera was on him quite a lot he got a couple of hat tricks for england in his his quality career but how good to to not just get a hat trip but to
38:03score a couple more uh yeah again like a very special day um and it was awesome having like all my family there having jay there pitch side obviously i've grown up watching him a lot watching him play at this stadium and do special things so it was a special day to do that for myself and have them all there supporting me good man and finally um given what you've been through over the past four and a half years, you spoke to us on the rugby weekly the other day about it, the change of club and having to move to Gloucester and then what happened with with your ear, that must make it even more satisfying, given you've had to work so hard to get this second cap and wait so long. Yeah, like it's been a challenge of four years, but nonetheless, I've enjoyed the journey to getting back here
38:47and I'm just happy that all that hard work I feel like I've put in has paid off for a special day like today. And the journey's not done. Hopefully there's more to give. I was going to say, now the desperation is to get that shirt on many more times. Yeah, absolutely. I've had a little taste for it now and it's a special playing here and I want to do it again. Great to speak to you. Thanks so much. So actually, no better man to talk to than you when it comes to chasing. Well, I never scored five tries. You must have got four for England, did you, against Italy? Yeah. In a game? Oh. Yeah, yeah. Even I scored five tries in a game. You must have scored five tries. Yeah, yeah. Just not... Even I scored five tries in a game. You must have scored five tries in a game.
39:26Yeah, yeah, just not a test match. Got to four. Five's different gravy. But interesting him saying there that, because we were talking in comms, does he know that he's equaled, you know... Did he? Lucy and Underwood and people. Yeah. Oh, no. We heard him there. The physio came on and told him, said, get a sixth if you can that bothered me a lot and he didn't come hunting he didn't come on to even more stupid tough one he doesn't want to go looking for it and that's not what the england management want to see is him going hunting individual accolades so he did give him the right to yeah they've gone on i just can't i just can't believe twice he had almost a run in, didn't he? One ball from Slade, who as we know is such a good passer of the ball and it just made him check. Yeah, but I'd have been everywhere. I know, but I'm saying that if Joseph does that, is that almost a black mark next to his name because he's gone hunting an individual accolade and the management are like, no, no, no, team, team, team. Not if the physio has gone on and said, get sick.
40:27He's got permission. So he's shown good restraint. He's got permission. I think, if anything, those centre scrums for me, that bothered me. If he knew, you'd be like, get out, stop crowding this area. And by the way, I'm up against a back rower. Just give me the ball. Just give me the ball just give me the ball in an acre of space you gotta plant seeds though that's the tactic you've got to lay seeds in other people's mind go on that's what he didn't do just whisper in the center's ear yeah yeah and the fly up so the physios come to will and said right you need to try he's then got to go baldy so you know that move that ends up with me out of the post? Can you get me another one, please? Or to the forwards,
41:06can we get five more and I'll get on the back of it? You've got to let people know. You've got to let people in on the action. Let's have a word about New Zealand in a second. There are so many pods on the way. We're going to pod on Monday, and then we're going to Nations pod. What a Nations pod. Gareth Rousseau calling the commentary home on TV. And so you can't wait to speak to him and I'll be out in the middle of the week. But there's a book, Ed Smith, he may have crossed paths with Smith, he read a book called Luck about how your sporting career can be impacted on as it says in the title, luck and kind of, you know, it makes an example if you say get your test debut as a batsman on a lovely batting wicket against a poor bowling attack,
41:48you make 100, you're away. And I always remember Michael Carberry getting his debut against Mitchell Johnson at the Gabba. You're like, cheers, I'd rather, he would rather any other attack in any other place. Just bad luck. If you're Archie McParland, you're coming on as a debut at Twickenham, 60 odd points on the board, load of touches, 30 minutes. No, I don't think that's the one. Is that not the one? They looked a bit... It was disjointed by then. Do you think? So do you think that's not the ideal debut? That's... I say, you know... Made a lot of changes. You could argue either way. By the way, can be luck. When you say, you know, it can create, it does. For you to have a successful career, you need luck.
42:32End of, period, done. You can't go through the whole of your career without the bounce of a ball or a decision or, you know, weather conditions or, yeah, it just doesn't happen. You know, I felt a little bit for archie today because it was a bit hair and scare him for when he came on and the nature of the type of player that he is he went looking and that and you could sort of see that yeah he did he would not have scored very well i don't think with ste with Steve Borwick because he went looking too much rather than just zip, zip, zip, zip, go on and get on those little cutting, cheating lines and then do, you know, let it come to him rather than he just forced it a little bit, probably because the opposition were,
43:20you know, weren't that good. There were a few gaps. And so it was, I thought it was a tricky one for him. So not what I laid out as being a dream scenario kind of thing. I just remember him warming up and thinking, if you're going to come on, I remember... Ten minutes earlier, I think's fine. Right. He left it a bit later. Caden Murley debuted against Ireland in Dublin. Barrage of kicks. Just how you start off your career can be I don't know there's that luck element he doesn't have to go through that feeling again I think it's a good way of him getting into it lots of touches but so many things we could pick up let's just look ahead to New Zealand and was there anything from today and I asked Steve
44:01Borthwick this and he said every game has an impact on selection but I also wonder the way he went about using his bench clearly told you, you know, the fact that George Martin goes 80, does that indicate that Martin's then going to be used as a banger off the bench against New Zealand? Possibly. Other selections that he made today, other performers, anything you think changes the selection picture ahead of New Zealand? I know that it'll be dependent on Chessham and Fairbank and Seb Atkinson and whether they're fit as is hoped and expected. For example, does Joseph come in as a Manny Febibosa-like replacement? Do they look at that and go, right, that's X-Factor they need against the All Blacks or do you think they
44:46tell me there's a gap on the wing because Fabo says out the issue is with today is he didn't really get challenged in defence at all he just didn't there was no real threat from them moving the ball or kicking the ball in the behind or finding space in the behind. And we shuffle things around when George Ford plays because he plays in the backfield a bit more. I don't know, I didn't see enough for me to say that that would... To watch your back three again. I mean, he's scored five tries. So, no, there isn't many options. So, if you're Steve, you're going off that you think he's ready because he didn't get tested in defence today. He just didn't. Is it relevant that he's playing right wing and Tommy Freeman plays right wing?
45:36Steve thinks so. He likes a left and a right winger, yeah. In which case? I would never play left, generally. No? Yeah, there you go. There is something in that, but it's individual and how they feel about it. I suppose if you're a 13-stroke wing, you probably spend a lot of time on both sides of the pitch. But yeah, it's going to be interesting to see what he does. Murley is a left winger. Murley's solid, isn't he? Solid. Does his job. He played in that France game where they probably could have nicked it at the end of the game. He was solid. So he's had, yeah, it's going to be funny to see how he does because Willard's so well today. Five tries. But he did it to Arundel, didn't he? Arundel scored five
46:20against a similar position they play. Yeah, but that was, I don't think Arundel was going to get in ahead of, you know, a Johnny May or someone with in play. Yeah, but that was, I don't think Aaron was going to get in ahead of, you know, a Johnny May or someone with that experience. Yeah, but it's just World Cup knockouts. You score five strikes. Yeah, and that's the thing, a lot of fans will go, if the team comes out on Thursday for the Saturday game and Joseph's not in it, a lot of our listeners go, hold on, you can't score that many more than five. But there's a bit more to it than that, isn't there? Yeah. I suppose the difference is than five. But there's a bit more to it than that, isn't there?
46:45Yeah. I suppose the difference is that there is, there's a gap. There's a space. There's a shirt. I'm not sure. I think that type of winger is a really nice balance with with Freeman to have that slight balance of yeah you know raw power speed finishing ability to then having that very much that jinky don't you know as much as defensively yeah the question could be asked but you're asking a lot of New Zealand as well New Zealand all of a sudden they're playing against Will Joseph they're like oh okay how are we going to defend him again the the slightly the more pressing question would be for me if Seb Atkinson's not playing what they do with that midfield um some nice touches from a Jomo today yeah he
47:44and probably got overlooked a little bit because of what the other backs were up to, but he seemed pretty solid. But again, you know, you can't compare playing against that Japanese back line. He's not going to be tested. But again, what are the options if Seb's not available? Yeah, well, there's Fraser Dingwall, who's beaten the All Blacks this time last year, but didn't play today and hasn't been seen yet this autumn. So you feel that Jomo's jumped ahead of him in the pecking order. But Geordie Barrett will be back in the New Zealand team. So for any of those 12s, but particularly Jomo and Seb Atkinson, who are right at the start of their test careers, what a challenge against one of the best to do it in Geordie Barrett.
48:24So, wow. And on top of that that and it's only a small point but today highlighted to me how far ahead Finn Smith is over George Ford you know I don't I wouldn't say George Ford necessarily did anything wrong but just the flow of the game and the way that the back line run with Finn opposed to George. George looked quite tense. Maybe that was reflective in his kicking as well, kicking at goal. But, yeah, I don't know. He seemed to be forcing it a little bit. Big, big week then. And we were going to set up the week by saying New Zealand are smarting because they lost here 12 months ago. And New Zealand rugby players have memories like elephants when it comes to defeats. But they've had an even more humbling one.
49:17So, wow, they'll obviously bring a fair few big guns back. But that is... Does that set the week up just to finish, guys? Does that set the game up better or worse that New Zealand have lost to Wales does it make them even do they get bodies back pardon do they get players back what's their injury situation uh don't know yet well there was there were lots of proactive changes from Dave Rennie but oh proactive yeah I mean he didn't he didn't make these changes because of so necessary Jordan's the one, isn't he? Because Will Jordan on the pitch today maybe gives them that bit of cutting edge in class. Not that they were short of it, but Jordan Barrett comes back in. I'm sure David McKenzie goes to 10.
49:57Cam Royguard comes back in. Will Jordan comes back in if he's fit. That's a big... That's out of a few players. Yeah. Holland comes back in if he's fit that's a big that's out of a few players yeah Holland comes back in the second row there's a fair Cody Taylor comes back a hooker doesn't he no that's changed the table too yeah Razzy was saying it was all over for them last night that door's now wide open again so that puts that back on the table where you can get to the final if they get a win here. Both teams, potentially, I know England a little bit less so because France being at the top of that leaderboard, but you can't think like that. When is the France game? Is that before or after England?
50:36France. France-Argentina? No, France are not a worry though, are they? They're a top, so they're going to walk to the final, you'd think sure. I'm just thinking of giving England something to go after So yeah England played before but bear in mind if France get their full five points against Argentina which looks very probable But if you're England you're not thinking like that No no no But I think given basically when England lost to Ellis Park they didn't get a bonus point when France lost to New Zealand, they got two bonus points, losing and try. Right, which is the difference right now. I know we're getting all excited here about who's finished in first and second. The England boys are not thinking about that.
51:16I think towards the end of this week, why would you not? They're just thinking about New Zealand, beating New Zealand. Yeah, but if you do that, you... No, I know, but we're breaking it down. Okay. But I can't see it affecting their preparation or... Even so, right, if you do ignore what I've just said there about getting to a final, when are England, the not, going to get two fixtures like this back-to-back against a New Zealand and South Africa, are they? Back-to-back? No. Well, they've got to get in the top two. And then Ireland will have something to say about that as well. Let's say France are the big favourites to win it because of their result last night. England could do what they do next Saturday.
51:52Oh, they've bumped that beefy, do that. And then Ireland have South Africa. So it's all... Come third. They could end up third and playing the Aussies again or the Argentinians, yeah. But the chances are that they're going to finish... England will finish second and play New Zealand. That would be, would that be where the... No, because Ireland are right close as well. Ireland are right there behind England. If England don't win and, yeah, Ireland gets second. Ireland beats South Africa. It's all to play for. We'll go through it, through the week. Plenty of pods. Top team. Plenty of pods. And we're here next Saturday. Got Grace with us, haven't we? Yeah. Bring it on. England-New Zealand, always very, very special.
52:28Matt Dawson, Chris Ashton, to Sarah and to James Hook and to Alex Cuthbert, a massive thanks. Hope they're enjoying all that Cardiff has to offer after such an historic sporting occasion. If you were a true Welsh fan, you'd get in a car and go down the M4, wouldn't you? Like genetically Welsh. Yeah. Be there in a heartbeat. You would get in there, wouldn't you? Like genetically Welsh? Yeah. You would get on in there. It's only two hours. You'd go. Do you know the one guy that sees straight through Jonesy? Steve. He knows he's Welsh. I'm strictly neutral as everyone knows. Or Tom Allen, should I say. Would you consider it? Getting in a car and going down? Could be one of the greatest days of your life.
53:06Did you get that? What's the time? Tom Allen, yeah. We cut that out of the pod before. It's 8 o'clock local time. Although Tiger Tiger's probably open till 2, isn't it? Oh, mate. No. Are you Welsh or not? They're behind me. Anyway, got a job to do. Thanks, everyone. Cheers. Cheers, guys's got a job to do. Thanks, everyone. Cheers. See you soon. Thanks for downloading Rugby Union Weekly. For more info, head to the BBC Sounds app. We'll be right back. Too little? Production slows. Grainger's $2 billion in on-hand inventory helps you get what you need when you need it. So you can help keep budgets balanced and lines moving. Call 1-800-GRAINGER, clickgrainger.com, or just stop by. Grainger. For the ones who get it done.
54:23Welcome to the Haunted Library. Join me, Colin Morgan, as I read Frankenstein by Mary Shelley. A story of science and ambition, loneliness and longing, and what it truly means to be human. Listen to The Haunted Library wherever you get your podcasts or find us on youtube

