podcasts / Rugby Union Weekly / episode
Rugby Union Weekly cover art
podcast
📅 2026-11-12 ⏱ 68 min episode · ~2 min read 📝 Transcript · 14,375 words 🎙 George Ford

Ford on selection, All Blacks aura & Eddie’s back: Rugby Union Weekly transcript

Rugby Union Weekly · · Transcript & summary by WhipScribe

A weekend-two Nations Championship preview that unpacks England's ten changes, George Ford's selection at fly-half and Eddie Jones on Japan and refereeing.

In this episodeGeorge FordSteve BorthwickEddie JonesMarcus SmithFinn SmithAntoine DupontStade de FranceTwickenhamNorthamptonBrendan Venter

▸Chapters

Tap a chapter to open that moment in the transcript; the link to it is copied for you.

Transcribe your links. Paste a YouTube, Google Drive or podcast link and WhipScribe gives you the transcript. Transcribe a link →

▸Notable quotes

“Well, just on the weekend, we've got two university students playing that haven't earned a penny.” Eddie Jones · at 55:51 — open in the transcript →
“Did you see it coming? No, not really to be honest.” George Ford · at 12:48 — open in the transcript →

▸What this episode covers

The episode previews weekend two of the Nations Championship, with the hosts calling France versus South Africa at the Stade de France on Friday the must-watch game. France rarely lose at home in Paris, but South Africa are missing several of their best fly-halves, and the hosts wonder how Antoine Dupont will be used at ten. They also expect Scotland's defensive problems to meet an Australia side that has looked porous, and they point to Australia's constant changes at number ten as a sign of a team still searching for an identity.

The England discussion centres on the ten changes for the Japan game. Max is back at twelve, Freddie Stewart is picked for form, and George Ford is named at ten after Finn Smith's calf problem. Ford says he only gets a vague idea from midweek training and that experience helps players stay ready whether they start or not. The hosts argue that the three fly-halves must stay competitive yet respectful, and that England's plan is about speed of ball and getting the back three into space rather than chasing a single new idea.

The last section widens out to Eddie Jones, who joins the show to talk about Japan's amateur university players, a crowd that is lighter in November, and referees who penalise attacking teams too often. Jones argues that rugby needs to favour attack to stay competitive with other sports. The hosts close by weighing the cost of long southern hemisphere travel and the finances of the sport, and by asking whether New Zealand still carry their old aura.

▸Ford on selection, All Blacks aura & Eddie’s back on Rugby Union Weekly: the answers

Who is George Ford?

George Ford

George Ford is an England fly-half with 109 caps who was picked at ten for the Japan game. He has played for Northampton and has been in the England squad for about 12 years.

What did George Ford say about Steve Borthwick?

George Ford said that when England head coach Steve Borthwick tells a player he is not in the side, he is very clear about the reasons. Ford said players may agree or disagree, but they leave the room knowing what they need to do to improve or push for selection in future.

“he's very very clear as to the reason why”George Ford · 14:00

What did George Ford say about Will Joseph?

George Ford said Will Joseph is the only new face in the England back line for the Japan game, starting on the wing. He called Joseph's form incredible and said the back line had trained together for two or three campaigns, so it feels cohesive.

“Will Joseph on the wing who's been incredible by the way”George Ford · 20:15

What did Eddie Jones say about Japan?

Eddie Jones said Japan are a unique case because they have no high-performance development pathway, so players go from high school to university competition, which is completely amateur. He pointed to two university students in the Japan squad who have not earned a penny, and said Japan's best ten, a 21-year-old, plays for his university rather than with the squad.

“Well, just on the weekend, we've got two university students playing that haven't earned a penny.”Eddie Jones · 55:51

What did Eddie Jones say about refereeing?

Eddie Jones said referees should favour attacking teams more, especially at the breakdown, because penalising attack too often causes teams to lose confidence in keeping the ball. He said the England v Australia game had some indifferent refereeing that even fans at Twickenham would struggle to follow.

“I saw a lot on the weekend some really indifferent refereeing in that game”Eddie Jones · 53:45

What is George Ford's main argument on Rugby Union Weekly?

George Ford argues that squad players must stay ready at all times, because a player outside the starting side can be called up at short notice. He also says England's three fly-halves compete hard but work as a unit, and that England's attack should use speed of ball to get the back three into space.

Mentioned in this episode

Episode facts

Released
November 12, 2026
Length
1 hour 8 minutes

▸Key takeaways

01France host South Africa at the Stade de France on Friday, the weekend-two Nations Championship game the hosts call unmissable.
02George Ford, capped 109 times, starts at fly-half for England after Finn Smith's calf concern led to a rest.
03England name ten changes for the Japan game, with eight Tests left before the World Cup.
04Australia have used six different players at number 10 in the past 16 months, according to the hosts, a sign of a side struggling for identity.
05Eddie Jones says Japan are massive underdogs, since England have won all 13 previous meetings between the two sides.

▸Questions this episode answers

Q1What did George Ford say about being picked at ten for England?

George Ford said he did not really see the selection coming, because the short turnaround meant he only had a vague idea from training during the week. He said official confirmation came late on the Tuesday night before the game. He added that experience helps players stay ready at all times, because squad members who are not starting still have to be prepared right up to kick-off.

Q2What did Eddie Jones say about Japan's amateur university players?

Eddie Jones said Japan's best ten, a 21-year-old who has played ten Tests in a row, was playing for his university rather than joining the squad. He said Japanese rugby has no high-performance pathway, so players move from high school to university competition, which is completely amateur. He argued the player was as good as any his age in the world, and that universities can decide whether to release players.

Q3What did Eddie Jones say about referees favouring attacking teams?

Eddie Jones argued that referees should favour attacking teams more, especially at the breakdown, because penalising attack too often makes teams lose confidence in keeping the ball. He said the England v Australia game had some indifferent refereeing, with unclear calls at the breakdown that even fans in the 80,000 crowd at Twickenham would struggle to follow. He said rugby needs to be more attacking than defending to compete with other professional sports.

Q4How many different fly-halves has Australia used recently?

The hosts said Australia have used six different players at number 10 in the past 16 months, a figure they called damning. They linked some of the changes to injuries and to players moving between rugby league and union, including Carter Gordon's injury. They said the constant change at ten is often a sign of a team struggling to find itself.

Q5Why does the episode say Marcus Smith is not starting at ten for England?

The hosts said Marcus Smith, a two-time British Lion with more than 50 England caps, is not in the starting ten conversation for now, with George Ford chosen ahead of him after Finn Smith's calf problem. They described Marcus Smith as a Swiss army knife who can cover nine, ten and 15, and said selection made the pecking order clearer than before. They said he will likely still go to the World Cup.

Q6Why did Steve Borthwick make ten changes for England's game against Japan?

The episode says Steve Borthwick made ten changes for England's game against Japan, including Max at twelve and Freddie Stewart on the wing. The hosts said he had only eight Test matches left before the World Cup, so he was building squad depth and giving more players a chance to force their way into the World Cup squad. The hosts also said changes in the front row were part of the shake-up.

▸Transcript

Our own transcript of the public episode, with a timestamp about every 90 seconds. Tap a timestamp or the link button on a paragraph to copy a link that opens this page there.

0:00This BBC podcast is supported't just about the grid. That same racing mindset, the obsession with engineering, the pursuit of perfection, lives in the Cadillac V-Series lineup, giving you the chance to experience the precision and performance of the grid on the open road. Cadillac V-Series, distinctive luxury performance, engineered to thrill. Discover the V-Series lineup at Cadillac.com. Host Thanksgiving with industry-leading quality standards from Whole Foods Market. There are no antibiotics in their meat department ever, so carve up turkey and spiral-cut ham with peace of mind. Shop organic sides like stuffing mix and cranberry sauce from 365 Brand. And guess what? All their delectable pies are made with no high fructose corn syrup.

1:06Gourmet Thanksgiving flavours with the quality you want. Only at Whole Foods Market. Right, Rugby Weekly, Thursday, weekend two of the Nations Championship on the way. Ugo's here. Hi. It's old school when it's just the two of us, Ugo. I know. Not just two, we've of the Nations Championship on the way. Ugo's here. Hi. It's always old school when it's just the two of us, Ugo. I know. Not just two, we've got some great guests, but you know what I mean. Yeah, it's a throwback to how it all started, which is nice, I guess. Yeah, 10 years ago in January. I know, remarkable. Have we survived this? Have we? Yeah, well, that's... This pod marriage. Yeah, you just head off air. Maybe there's a book coming out to lift the lid.

1:46Do a kind of Usman Khawaja daddy cares got form in his book isn't it of course yeah that sandpaper story is that's a that's a nut sporting story but how many years on it's still rumbling he said she said and they can't get a handle on it they just can't get no one get handle on it everyone knew they're like no we didn't no no but the moment they admit every the moment they admit everyone knew that it it calls everything into question oh those wickets you got seven years ago when it was wet how have you swung that ball if they admit it then pandora's box is opened if it wasn't open already anyway different sport different story but it's one of those where i'm sure our listeners have been um have been across uh yeah what is most tickling your fancy ahead of weekend two it's got to be france and africa has to be

2:33stad de france a sort of france stad de france a friday night under the lights the best team in the northern hemisphere they're the six nation champions against the World Champs. That just feels good and proper. And what a way to be able to kickstart this weekend of rugby, no? Because, yeah, I completely agree. The weekend one kickstarted with Ireland-Argentina. We hoped for a Puma performance, but I think deep down we all knew Ireland would win that with a bit to spare. I don't think it was the best way to bound into the new November leg of the championship. Yeah, we discussed this earlier. And often I feel when you're having to switch gears. So, for example, you've got the Premier League going into the Nations League this week.

3:16We went from the Gallagher Prem, URC, top 14 into the Nations Championship. I often feel some people just miss weekend one because it changes, it's a change of focus it's a brand new competition, you're going from domestic to international but everyone's on board by weekend two so I think had you started with France and Africa last week I reckon there would be some rugby audience that just would have missed it no one's missing it this Friday because we've had a load of fixtures, loads of tries storylines podcasts news articles all the rest of it to center and focus to let people know next championship on so placing it as the first game of the second weekend it now becomes unmissable yeah it's a

3:57huge game i think if you had said at any other part of the galtier regime but particularly the last few years, France are starting a game under-liked at home in Paris. As the underdogs, you would go, eh? Because they've lost four times at home under Gaultier. One was COVID, behind closed doors against Scotland. One was in Marseille. Crazy game. Crazy game that France kind of kept the ball alive, but, you know, great, great play from Scotland at the end. Own goal. Marseille, just after the World Cup, when Ireland did a number on them. But again, not in Paris. Not saying it should make a huge difference, but talking about Paris. And the other two times they've lost. World Cup 23. World Cup 23.

4:36Box. This time last year, box. So if there is a team that beats France at their home at the Stade, it is South Africa. Always low to bet against the French. They did it with 14 men last year. They did it with 14 men. So there's huge context to that win for South Africa. Always low to bet against the French at home. But they are the underdogs, not least because South Africa are South Africa, but also they've got Antoine Dupont at 10. Got low 10s. You've got no 10s. And they've got Antoine Dupont at 10. Got low 10s. And you've got no 10s. And they've got loads of injuries elsewhere. They've got loads of fans. They've got loads of... You've got 80,000 fans. And you've got an amazing ground. But they do have no 10s.

5:18I mean, their best three or four ruled out. So I personally thought Luku would play 10 and Dupont 9. How those two work won't be a kind of you go to that ruck, I'll go to this ruck. Surely it's got to be more structured than that. But yeah. It's funny because they're over a half with Anton Dupont at 9 and Luka at 10 last week. You're like, okay, cool. We've plugged and played that. That works. We're settled. Let's just do that again. And they've gone, no, no, we won't. We're actually going to flip reverse it and do the opposite of what you thought might um what you thought of the back of last week i don't i i don't understand it personally and by the way they're both really really good tens because they're both highly skilled but i just thought on the back of what

6:00we saw last week you would just roll that over stop the disruption maybe some of it comes down to how they play are they going to want to play a more slightly expansive game with Antoine Dupont surely he's the one with more of a threat in around the the ruck and the guard areas to bring on your big forward so he would play that so maybe they're not gonna use their forwards in the tight exchanges as much and they're gonna look to play slightly wider and Dupont definitely has more quality at trying to do that than Lukaku so I guess we'll have all those questions answered very very shortly but yeah it's a real fascinating one okay so Friday night that's the game that starts off we've got commentary

6:40on five live really looking forward to doing that one with with paul grayson um your top team top team top team scotland australia that for me is a fascinating one because i just don't see australia pitching up and playing as badly again and scotland have to deal with that sort of psychological deflation of missing out on trying on the all-black scalp yet again i don't think this got much deflation actually okay so because i think australia might win that game i can't see australia win that game because i i don't think scotland be disappointed they lost but it's not like the heartache of oh it's a mckenzie last minute oh but we were so close they got battered lost by 20 points like the game was gone entering into that last quarter yes that's gutting to

7:23almost if you're to look at it by the result of last year to this year, they've regressed. But sometimes like a last minute sucker punch, we thought we were in it. For 20 odd minutes, they weren't in it. So with that in mind, I just think they're in the same position as to where England were going into Australia. They cannot, they can, you can't afford to lose the game. You just can't, you can't, you can't, you can't, you can't. And I don't think they will. Because I think Scotland have an even greater ability to be able to move the ball into space. I really think they do. And Australia have looked porous. And I listened to the Nations pod with Gro and Tom English and Tom English and the damning

8:08stats of Scotland's defence it's not until you hear it just narrated to you back to back like conceding tries in quick succession than the volume of points and this Australia if they get their act together can I wonder will they? Because when Henry Pollock went onto the wing at the weekend, if I was a winger, I'd be going, hey, lads, they've got a back row out there. Can I have the ball? Henry didn't have to do any of the things which I think are challenging as a winger. Didn't have to contest kicks, didn't have to chase kicks, didn't have to manage backfield. The Australians just didn't test him. And I was like, where's your eyes gone? Where's your vision? Where's your rugby intellect gone?

8:49Hopefully they can learn off that and employ a lot more of it this weekend at minefield. I think again, we talked about England smarting before the game against Australia. The Australian, you know, there's pressure on this Australian team. You know, there's a World Cup coming up and Ashley was absolutely like to the point and kind of where they're at and rugby league reliance and how they're using Swally so I think there's a lot of a lot of heat on this Aussie team coming from back home I just have a feeling Australia are pitching up on Sunday not quite not quite sure why but I think they're pitching up which which makes the two most interesting games for me the games are most jeopardy yes the start and the end of the weekend france south africa and then scotland australia um we're going to be joined by george

9:28ford we've got eddie jones on the pod as well because the england team has dropped and we're at the england team hotel oogs that a million things we could talk about in this england lineup so just give us a couple uh max jomo's back he starts at 12 first of all before that headline is 10 changes and then within that max, Max Adjoma in at 12. I think there's been a clamour for him, the quality. I think people always, and I've reverted back to, well, the last time he played for England, he was the best player on the pitch. We get to see it again. Really excited about that. And then what we see in the back three, I'm personally thrilled for Freddie Stewart because I think he's having a top season.

10:02He's a different type of player, but he is a more proactive attacking player this year so I'm excited about that the changes in the front row this changes everywhere but I am excited I do think this is a team that is set up to run I just truly hope that's the stylistic version we get to see of this let's pick that up with George Ford just one on a Jomo and we speak so much to Steve Borthwick in this job and he often gives a real insight into what he wants from his players and he is effusive in his praise of Max Ajomo's talents He said he's one of the most gifted rugby players in the country and I agree Yeah, so there you've got a guy with who can do it all. The bit that Borthwick will want to see from a Jomo

10:44this weekend is maybe taking a little bit of Seb Atkinson's game, a little bit of Fraser Dingwall's game and having that consistency performance through the 80, not switching off, being relentless in what he does off the ball, because when he's on the ball, we just have to watch him over the past few seasons. He's got those little bits of magic. And, you know, from an England fans point of view, they'll be desperate to see the best of max ajomo this weekend i think i mean we chatted to steve earlier didn't we i think steve is desperate to see a relentless level of physicality because when he speaks about the 12s that have played most recently for him in seb atkinson and Van Rensburg he talks about their level of physicality he sees

11:2612 that 12 position in the role of they are they are the back back row he wants to see them so physical in attack and defense and I know Max can do it but we will often refer to Max's skill set his passing range all those other things he's got that for days, maybe better than anyone else. But your challenge is to be in this team, whether you agree with it or not, the role and what is clear from Steve, his identity of that role is he needs you to be really, really physical. So I hope we get to see that from Max. Yes, so many changes. The kind of selection that I thought Borthwick might do before the Fiji game and he didn't, he went for consistency through the summer and now with only what, eight test matches

12:10after this to go to the World Cup I don't think you could have blamed him if he'd looked for more consistency, he had to make four changes so maybe his hand's been forced well we know his hand's been forced in one way but yeah just very very interesting to see the number of changes he's made with a view to building that squad depth and maybe a few players getting the opportunity to force their way into into the world cup squad even though it's still quite a long way down the track right george ford is with us um george great to see you as ever cap number god what cap number is this george i had the the sheet here and i've just lost it. 109. 109. Yeah. Goodness me. It's George Ford everyone.

12:48George Ford. I'm so guilty of this. You've just done it but it's good. No, I would have said I would have introduced him properly but I was just spitballing because I'd lost the team sheet. Anyway, congrats on the selection. Did you see it coming? No, not really to be honest. Obviously, we had a great start last week against Australia and due to the nature of the short turnaround, these last couple of days since Sunday, like Monday, Tuesday, it's like full on, as you know. And then you have a good idea, the first training day of the week, maybe what direction Steve's going to go in. So you have a vague idea there, but it's not until, obviously obviously official confirmation you find out which was

13:25was late Tuesday night how does that conversation go about these days it varies from week to week it could be Steve's here can you come and meet me at this time in his office or it could be that's a horrible I hate that conversation can you meet me like it gives me anxiety we've had this conversation what is the best way to it could be a tap on the shoulder. That's a horrible, I hate that conversation, mate. Can you meet me? Like, it gives me anxiety. We've had this conversation. What is the best way to? I have not a clue. I don't need a heads up. I need, like, I don't want to be told, can you meet me at half six tonight? And it's three o'clock. Because, mate, I'm bragging out. Because I'm like,

14:00am I going home? Am I starting? Am I captain? I don't know. But the thing is, there is that and then if it's a tap on the shoulder when you least expect it everyone's a bit like oh that took me a bit by surprise so it's I'd imagine from a head coach's point of view there's no right or wrong way unless you're telling someone they're playing which is obviously quite a nice conversation I think the more difficult ones are when they're not but if Steve informs you that you're not but you look if Steve informs you that you're not he's very very clear as to the reason why and sometimes as players you you might agree or disagree but you come out of the room knowing potentially what you need to do to improve or or push your case for selection in the future so that's all you can ask for really

14:42um last week Finn was touch and go with his calf wasn't he? So did you have to spend a lot of that week trying to get into a mindset of I could be playing but I might not be playing? Talk us through that kind of dynamic. Yeah a little bit. Obviously because we had the alignment camp the week before and I don't think Finn trained in any of that and then obviously he's recovered really well and he did bits and bobs of training Monday or it would have been Tuesday, Wednesday last week but I think and maybe what a little bit of experience allows you to do is you've got to stay ready regardless really and I know Finn was carrying something but the amount of times you see lads drop out of training

15:25because of one reason or another and next minute someone's playing or starting. So if you're part of this, what I'm trying to say is the wider squad, the non-23, I think a big skill of being part of that group now is just being ready at all times, leading up to literally kick-off, because obviously we warm up in games and all them things. So I think experience allows you to do that a bit better. literally kick off because obviously we warm up in games and and all them things so um it is uh yeah i think the experience allows you to do that a bit better and you almost have to given your position being a game driver whether you're starting on the bench or not involved you've got to be across absolutely anything and everything what's a bit weird about this situation is because

16:03of the the three of you and Marcus being so versatile, you know, more versatile than you, if you take that in the right way, it means that you could either be starting or not in the 23. So that's, again, another thing to throw in, isn't it? Yeah, and look, I know a lot. It's been like this all my England career. A lot has been spoken about. Fly half in particular, new starts. And 12 years ago now, when I first came in, it was the same. It was the same throughout that period. Whoever it might have been along the way. Genuinely, the three of us, me, Finn and Marcus, our relationship, the respect we have for each other, but how competitive we are as well. It's probably the best I've experienced within the England team.

16:49We understand selection is very subjective and Steve will pick a team or a 23, pick a 15 to start and the 8 on the bench that he thinks is the best formula to win the game. We are in a stage, in a position now as 310s where we compete and we compete hard but we're very respectful that if two are involved in the 23 and one isn't that we're almost like a little unit there that are responsible for getting the team to win at weekend because you personally it's been a bit of a I mean I was going to say it's been a roller coaster you would probably push back and go look it's that's not that's how things are but if you think that um you know 2025 or late 2024 2025 it was marcus and then finn and marcus and then you came in back end of 2020 off the bench in cardiff

17:37then you got the shirt in the summer 25 then you keep the shirt in the in the autumn 25 then finn's got it through 26 and the summer 26 and you don't get a huge amount of game time in the summer and now you're back for a lot of people that could be quite difficult to sort of be in out in out kind of thing but that's where it's your point experience yeah keeps you keeps you level yeah genuinely because it's been it's been like that for however long i remember debuting 2014 it's probably been a bit like that for 12 years. One thing I would say is for the team to succeed, for the team to win, for the team to go and win the Nations Championship or to go and win a World Cup in 12 months' time, it's going to need three high-quality, brilliant tens

18:22who are great people as well because Finn has been amazing. The way he's played for Northampton, high quality, brilliant tens who were great people as well because, you know, like Finn has been amazing, the way he's played for Northampton, the way he's played for England, he's took it to a new level in his game. So Marcus has started the season like a house on fire when he comes back from his injury at Quinns and you know what versatility he's got and you know how he can influence the game. And hopefully I can add when I am playing when I'm not playing maybe in a different kind of way of like a bit more experienced and if I'm not playing like how I can help and influence and get the team ready how like you control the lads who

18:56are not playing and make training as competitive as possible so what I'm saying is like you get the one who's starting at the weekend you probably get get another one of us who's on the bench. But it's like a three-man job to get the team ready for every week. So if you think of it like that, you've got your hands full a little bit. And look, if you ask all three of us, do we want to play? Of course we do. I'm not saying we're accepting that. But what we're saying is we're very respectful of the situation. Six-day turnaround. You see England last weekend scored seven tries and they scored tries from the moor from face play from kick return everything really good you've then been given the opportunity

19:32of leading this team how do you go about getting the boys to a level where they're kicking on once again yeah well that's our main focus this week is a little bit how we can take another step in the right direction by that it's what a great start it was on Sunday. Some of the play was very, very good, wasn't it? The challenge for us is a little bit of, yeah, we've got one less day's preparation, maybe. There's quite a few changes in the team. But the way I look at it, I said to the boys I know we may have not like played many games together but that group especially the back line that's been selected this week has trained a hell of a lot together over the last two or three campaigns so it almost feels very cohesive

20:15actually going into this week because of how much we've we've probably got used to each other's combinations and stuff like Max and the only new one coming into it really is probably Will Joseph on the wing who's been incredible by the way so yeah hopefully we've seen some opportunities which we can expose the opposition with this week a lot of it which Lee Blackett always goes on about is you know like the same sort of messaging and what we want to try and achieve with the ball it's been the same now reckon, for the last seven to 10 test matches. And I think that's why you're seeing some really, because really good players, because we're not going after anything too different. We're just going after the same things,

20:54but just becoming better and better and better at them. And I think that's- What particularly are you going after? Well, just like our off the ball stuff, like is a massive area. So, you know, the way we get set in attack, the way we can, why we you know the way we get set in attack the way we can why we say that is if we get set we've got options to do what we want really we've got options to move the ball we've got options to carry we've got options to change direction if we need to so that's been a massive mainstay of our messaging is like what we do off the ball especially in the middle of the field JVP's try exactly I think is a brilliant example of that because it's turnover go to Pollock

21:26he goes wide the minute Finn's got the ball he's got forward runners he's got players out the back and then his combination of Furbank to get to the edge gorgeous little offload Freeman back inside that's your 10,000 hours of repetition to get to that point where you scratch right that's what it allows you to do that race to set allows you I was going to go on to the next point being a little bit of our edge attack stuff. So like if you get in the middle right, you're going to have opportunities on the edge. And then therefore you're seeing like some of the play with the wingers popping up, or Ferbs or Freddie Stewart this week. So it looked, if I'm going to say it in simple terms, like are off the ball to get set in the middle.

22:03Our execution on edge is like repping that, looking at that. And then the last thing he pushes all the ball to get set in the middle are at execution on edges like repping that looking at that and then the last thing he pushes all the time is just he's staying in the moment so as soon as we've got speed of ball and we've got and Jack runs or Archie runs this week he's like we're just going and you can see that in the way we're playing because speed of ball is everything isn't it because when you get the speed of ball you've got the nine looks great, the 10 looks great and things flow from there. So with that in mind, it's been a tough season at your club, hasn't it? So has it been for you personally

22:31quite hard to really get some form going given the club haven't been going hugely well? Yeah, obviously like every team you're playing is probably in a different position. So like, you know, say at the minute we've struggled in certain areas of the game, but I find the intrigue of trying to make it work and how do we get better? And you take a lot of good stuff from here and try and implement it back there, because one of our main things is trying to create speed of ball and stuff like that. I think the extra bit of detail and where we go to here is like what allows you to get it and a lot of it we've just spoken about now but it's probably the things that people see you know you sit in the stands or sit and watch tv at home and see a brilliant try we just dig in a little

23:17bit deeper now what allows us to go and do that and it will be like some unsung hero stuff which you wouldn't you know you wouldn't expect people to pick up so that takes time because it's like a habit thing to make to make the lads value it first and then to understand what it looks like time and time and time again it's probably something we're just on the very beginning of the process at sail with when i've seen previous matches england against japan um and we spoke about this a little bit earlier briefly, international rugby is about finding the weaknesses in the opposition and then repping that and just being relentless at that. I think for me, historically, they've always been obvious,

23:51set piece, kick, chase, physicality, territory, those things. I think the things that England have been shy of is speed of ball attack. Japan have always historically been brilliant catch passes, speed and get into wide channels where England haven't wanted to go toe to toe with them. Off the back of what I saw last weekend, I'm thinking, and I look at your team, which is built to run. Yes, go after them in the mall. Yes, go after them in the scrum. But can we, can we show that we can, not just Japan, but anyone, when we get it together, go after them and attack as well? Is that a bit of a mindset this weekend? Yeah, 100%. Why not? When you were speaking then, I was just Japan, but anyone, when we get it together, go after them and attack as well. Is that a bit of a mindset this weekend?

24:25Yeah, 100%. Why not? When you were speaking then, I was just thinking like that is, we haven't pigeonholed ourselves into one area of the game and said we are just going to do this and no matter what, what we want to do is we want to, I mean, a lot of our good stuff last week was good, two more was because our set piece was good or our scrums were good so we can launch off scrum. So it's always in them. That stuff's always important. We just feel like we're in a place where we're just developing that next bit, like you were saying, and layering on top. Like some of the best stuff I saw last week, what got us going was getting the ball to space and getting it in our most dangerous people's hands,

25:02which was when you think of it like that, you can, you can pick attack to pieces at times and say I want this running line and I want you to stand here and like essentially if you're getting the ball in Tommy Freeman's hands and Manny Fejewo's hands Caden's hands, Will George's hands in space on a massive field like Twickenham and it's 1-1, 2-1-2 that sort of gets your attack going so you can simplify it that way as well. I saw good attack against Fiji, if I was to go back to the summer Nations Championship. But for me, I mean, and that was fine. But in Argentina, it was like, minute one, get the ball in Mane's hands. Right, and guess what? It was the best player on the pitch. And then I saw Sunday's game,

25:43and it was exactly the same because I think England's most dangerous players are the back three. Flipping heck. So much class, so much quality. I hope that trend continues. It's so interesting you used the word trend because I'm just thinking over your 12 years and 109 tests, George, just top of my head, you know, 2020 was a kickfest, wasn't it? You know, it was. And England kicked the ball a huge amount. Eddie would talk a lot about that. Look at the World Cup 2023, that game against South Africa, massively weather dependent, I know, but you kicked like 90% of your ball. Now you're talking a lot and we saw it, Fiji, Argentina, and particularly against the Wallabies, of ball movement, something Steve Ball

26:20has spoken about, but the trend and the style has changed a lot over the course of the time. So talk us through that and to what extent do you go, yeah, the game is always changing, but right, these are a few things this England team needs to do well, even if suddenly come the next World Cup, there's a shift in law, a shift in trend. How do you get ahead of the trend rather than sort of be reacting to it? Well, I do think it is fascinating how the game goes in like trends and cycles and, you know, how it bias maybe one part of the game goes in trends and cycles. How it bias maybe one part of the game more than another because it could be a law change, it could be the way the referees are being asked or told to referee.

26:55So obviously at the minute, as what we're seeing in the World Game really, in terms of the ability to hold the ball and the speed of ball you can get and how you can move the ball to space and maybe hold the ball for longer. Whereas maybe a few years ago, I think we've spoken about this in the past, where like, it was literally, if you hold the ball past three, four phases, the referee would, by and large, give a jackal penalty. So it's like, if you've not gone anywhere or scored quickly, then go and try and create another one of them opportunities. It's a bit different now. That must take some getting used to. Yeah. But to go to your second part of the question, then go and try and create another one of them opportunities. It's a bit different now.

27:26That must take some getting used to. Yeah. But to go to your second part of the question, is how can you stay out of it? That's what the best teams do. And I think maybe by the time the World Cup comes again, it might have changed again, who knows. But the way the coaches work and the way the players try and like stay a step ahead is the conversations we're having and like what we're picking up it like we're having all these and i think you're seeing i think you are seeing some some of that coming to fruition at the weekend um and just to just to go back to to the point of the attacking side of the game is like how many how many i think is a nine 10, but how many times can I, can we get the ball and will Josie Sands this week?

28:09Like I want him to have double figure touches. I want him to, same with Caden, same with Max O'Dromo. Do you know what I mean? Like, because, uh, you haven't always thought like that as a team. Not that we haven't always thought about it, but, let's put less onus on it, maybe. Yeah, I sometimes think when you're analysing and you're thinking about where the game's at and you're picking it apart, you can not get lost down a rabbit hole to a certain extent, but if you just bring it back to simplest terms of these guys are unbelievable athletes with skill who can run, pass, kick, beat defenders. So what do they need? They need a bit of time and space. So then if you need time and space, how do you get the ball to them in time and space?

28:51It's not necessarily so much about, you know, we need this person here, that person. It's giving them the ball and just give it to them, let them go. Because off the back of it, that's when you can then play through teams and you create line breaks. And so it's sort of like yeah because of speed of ball you can give them probably time and space a little bit better a little bit easier now which then allows you to keep the ball longer speed of ball nine's running playing on top and you're seeing like a lot of you know really exciting tries because the best choice for me that i ever see uh yeah you get individual brilliance someone's going to try from 60 yards or whatever it is. But in terms of a team try, it's a walk-in for the winger. Because the amount of work you

29:30need to do to be able to create that overlap means that it's been brilliant attack. And then the winger's job is just run it over. I know Finn Smith was getting stuck into Pollock at the weekend. He had a couple of tappings. That's because a great attack. Absolute brilliant attack. They're the best ones. And the game is built around attack around attack on average nine tries a game at international level is bonkers i hope i see more at the weekend compared to where it was for sure um and just finally george um because you got to run the mindset going into this weekend is probably quite different to last weekend when you were kind of spoiling stuff had been written out to prove a point bit of pressure on team out you went and played really well you're expected to win and win well which again throws

30:08another challenge on you guys and the best teams are ones who kind of embrace every single different challenge don't they yeah yeah 100% and uh we've spoken a lot about this however each week's different each week's got its own context uh you know in relation to who you've just played who the opposition is next. There was a couple of things going on last week which added a little bit of fuel to us. But yeah, you've got to find, and we've got to find as a team, the right mentality, emotion, excitement actually. And I think we're freshening the team up and everyone, the way we've trained this week and everyone, you can feel the buzz. Hopefully we can obviously, off the back of last week, take another step

30:52forward with that. Do you mean to do a piece? I can do a piece in the Guardian, just like hammer the boys. Do you know what? I know a lot's been said about that, but I think it's probably unfair to say that, I think people are saying it had a bit more of a impact to the performance than what it actually had. You could feel like the performance brewing even before that even came out, like off the back of the two games in the summer where we were starting to see some really good stuff. We had a great two-day alignment camp the week before and the way we were speaking about the first game of the autumn against Australia and Australia have had 15 games together whatever they had before they played

31:33in us. All them things were part of and then it just added a bit more to us. I don't think we need another one. I'm sorry. One weird answer but no, we don't. We would look no sorry one word did answer but no we're done we'll look forward to a column we go cheers good to have you on the server five lives rugby union weekly so look forward to your expose do you know obviously I meant it as complete banter and there was so much made of it last week like I've got a lot of time for Owens a lot I think he's a brilliant journo and I'm glad that Fordy said it didn't have the impact which some people were expecting because I thought in the build-up to England Australia if the sole purpose or sole attention or driving force is a journalist outside of camp

32:26yeah it shouldn't be a game changer in terms of perhaps should it and that's why it's good to hear ford say it wasn't sprinkled a bit of spice understandably i like that so um yeah i'm glad he he's put that one to rest as ever with george ford that he speaks so well that there's so much to pick up on the The bit for me, and it tied into your point you made about Manny Faye with Boso and how many times we've sat in commentary boxes with the likes of Ashi going, oh, he's not on the ball enough. And then suddenly it's almost a light bulb moment. Argentina first half away from home. He's on the ball. Australia only 32 minutes, but he's on the ball. And George Ford there, he's a real student of the game

33:03who no doubt through his career has spliced up games and and magnified them to the to the nth degree is saying it can't be a bit simpler than that can you get your strike runners your power athletes your x factor players on the ball as much as possible that's quite a refreshing thing to hear him say I think I think we're living in a generation now where there is so much access so much access to so much data insights that you can almost get paralysis through analysis and sometimes you just need to simplify I can think of a number of different top quality coaches who I think are just overthinking. I remember listening to Brendan Venter earlier on in the season, said him and his coaching staff

33:49had a five hour selection meeting. And I'm like, if you're in a meeting for five hours, I think you're overthinking it. I actually think you're just overthinking it. That could be the same as any meeting that our listeners have in any of their jobs. Absolutely. You start off with a plan and then you talk your way in out the plan around the back of the plan through the plan just like sorry where are we again sometimes that kind of right and that's why it's gonna be this is the thing i'll have my eye on as much as anything else on the weekend is how we're gonna go about it how george ford goes about it because we know he's played many different ways in his career but he probably has a reputation as he ages

34:26as more of a strategist. Will we see that on the front line, on the front foot, close to the defence, George Ford, that we know he can, the role we know he can play, getting the ball into the hands of a Jomo and to Murley and to guys like Will Joseph? I think he's going to be there to shift the ball. Max is absolutely brilliant on the ball at the game line and loves it, and loves it. His variety and variation of passing, if anyone watched him in the England A's, his no-look pass, oh my gosh, under the sticks, is so, so good. He's got that for days. He's also got, yeah, he's got the long ball as well. He has every pass and he is highly skilled, so let's see how he gets on. But honestly, I'm not saying, oh, I told you so,

35:09or we called it early. We have very different pressures to international players and coaches. We just talk about it. Whether it comes off or not, it actually doesn't matter. But we've spoken about it so many times and did a couple of weeks ago. Just when you look at this england backline where is the x factor for me it's obvious it is the back three and it's the same again this weekend so i do hope that they're exposed to so much more because there will be england fans who have already been messaging me since the team came out two hours ago going what does marcus smith have to do to play at number 10 given the form he's been in for harlequins given the way he burst on the scene given the fact he's not had a run at 10 for a long time but I would just say George Ford has a habit

35:49of reviving himself doesn't he just when people are thinking that George Ford is third in the pecking order or you know might be on the wane as a player he shows his class he did it at the back end of the 25 Six Nations then through the summer tour of Argentina then in that autumn series starring role in the win against the All Blacks this time last year. So I'm not surprised to see Steve Borthwick go with George Ford. Really? No, I'm not. Well, George Ford said he was surprised. No, in terms of once Finn Smith, once he decided not to play Finn Smith and part of that reason. No, his first question to him was, and I forgot exactly what your first question was but George Ford said he was surprised I'm saying once um Steve Borthwick has committed to make a change

36:29at 10 which you know and he's spoken we spoke to Steve Borthwick earlier talking about certain players Tommy Freeman Ben Curry Finn Baxter Finn Smith are kind of a loading issue particularly with Finn Smith's calf so once Steve Borthwick's decided to give Finn Smith a rest I'm not surprised George Ford's the 10 in the same way that if... Why? Because I said last week or two weeks ago, if Finn Smith doesn't make this game, George Ford will be the 10. Because he's the guy who's played more recently at number 10 for Steve Borthwick's England. And while Steve Borthwick might say Marcus Smith is very much in the 10 conversation, it's clear from selection, he's not as in the 10 conversation as he was two years ago.

37:04Well, it's clear now. It's clear now selection, he's not as in the 10 conversation as he was two years ago. Well, it's clear now. It's clear now, but like... So you're surprised. You thought that if Finn Smith is not playing... Who's been the second best fly half in the country this season? But that's where we're coming at it from a different place. I don't think Steve Borthwick is looking at club form like that. So I think if he does look at club form like that, he will feel he will change his team too much camp to camp. He will go instead on who has done stuff for him in that position in previous England blocks as opposed to who's been the better club 10. Yeah but previous England blocks you're not making a decision

37:37based on what someone did in the Six Nations block of this year because they lost four out of five. They were half decent in the summer. They beat Fiji and Argentina. So extrapolate that. Why was Henry Slade 13 against the Wallabies over Will Joseph? Because of Henry Slade's performances alongside Seb Ackerton in the summer. You cannot compare 50 cap of Marcus Smith and 100 cap of George Ford to Henry Slade of 70 plus caps to Will Joseph of one cap. So at least if you go Finn Smith who's a lion it's the same theme as club form it's the same theme it's not the same thing and me saying the club form is not as relevant as a lot of people might think it's not the same conversation because you're comparing a single capper to a

38:1950 capper so the conversation of having Henry Slade versus Will Joseph and it would have been a huge game i think will joseph in the outstanding 13 i think but that's a massive call to stick him in for his second cap in a must win against australia it's not it shouldn't be seen and i spoke to danny care about this shouldn't be seen as a bold call or a big call to play Marcus Smith who's a two-time British Lion and a 50 plus capper for England. Now we do have clarity in terms of the pecking order through Steve Borthwick's eyes. I wasn't so clear as to what the pecking order was. No, I always knew Finn Smith was number one, number two and number three. I actually thought it was the other way but now it's

39:03it couldn't be any more clear, could it? Because Marcus. You're saying he couldn't have done much more to get a start at 10? What more can you do? Yeah. Like at Quinns and I've not seen how Marcus has trained in the weeks, but Marcus is his joker in his back pocket that can cover nine, that can cover 10, that can cover 15. We can plug and play him anywhere. He's the Swiss army knife and that won't be absolutely satisfactory to marcus because everyone wants to start but i think it's very very clear now if it wasn't clear before that that seems to be the role he plays within this team because he's not now going to go and start against new ze it's hard to see where Marcus gets a start at 10 between now and the World Cup but the yeah but the perverse thing about it is he's a central member

39:52of the England team isn't he 100% so it's just one of those things where if you're if you're Marcus Smith it's it's it's hard to get your head around he wants to be the England number 10 which he has worn on many occasions including in places like Eden Park lest we forget he's played big high stakes games but for whatever reason and there are plenty of good ones no doubt the other two ahead of him but he will still 100% go to the World Cup and probably if there was a World Cup final tomorrow would be wearing number 23 yes so and one of Finn Smith and George Ford misses out completely so it's a funny one it's just as a player getting and he's had time to get used to it but this selection will be another example of him having to get used to that role he

40:30has but we get that in f1 uh i remember valtteri bottas was a brilliant number two to lewis hamilton um you could never you probably couldn't go with like lew Max Verstappen probably doesn't work as a one and a two. You need someone to accept their role and be subservient and be that great teammate. That's what brings the very best out of everyone. And speaking to Fordy there in terms of no one's losing their competitive edge. They all want to be the number one, but more so than anything, just want to do whatever they can do to ready the team at its very best. Only two are involved, but he says it's a three-man job and I totally get that and really respect it. Right, Oogsmore in England, Japan to come.

41:13We've got Eddie coming up. He was a guest on our Five Live show on Tuesday night. Eddie's done more media and corporate stuff this week. He's been busy, hasn't he? Mate, he was there on Saturday, right? Doing the corporate boxes at the Allianz Stadium I don't know I think he has more hours in the day than other people because actually after he'd been on and he gave us a load of his time I sent him an email back and I got a reply at 4.15am He's great I love it I just think for him days are 20 hours so he can coach teams and do loads of other stuff in a day, whereas other people can just do one or two of those things. I love his hustle. I love his hustle. Fair play to him. So we spoke about France-Africa at the top of the pod.

41:56Other games this weekend. Italy-Argentina, Wales-New Zealand, England-Japan, Ireland-Fiji, and then a fascinating one on Sunday, Scotland against Australia. So we won't have the Scotland and Australia team news until until Friday when this pod will be out but the Wales and New Zealand teams have both been released this Thursday let's start with Wales they've made a handful of changes but not changed the number 10 there's been a talking point whether Edwards would come in for for Costello um Basham's in for the first time in the back row for four years. A couple of other tweaks but yeah, 1953 All Blacks have scored 50 points on their three previous trips to Cardiff. What a big job for these Welsh players.

42:40I mean this is a huge challenge. It's a huge challenge for any team. You don't need Aaron Wain a huge challenge for any team you don't need Aaron Wainwright out do you if you've got a player like him in his form and when I looked at them last week I was thinking this is a team with some of the top performers in the Gallagher Prem you've got Dabby Lake you've got Jack Morgan you've got Aaron Wainwright you've got Lewis Rees-Sammer you've got Max Llewellyn you've got Thomas Williams I'm like oh my gosh you've got a team full of so many dynamic quality players experience of a Josh Adams like I mean they've got loads it's not going to be enough this weekend unfortunately the all-black sides there just seen Bowdoin Barrett

43:18149 test matches I think there's some positions where you're more likely to get it, to have that level of endurance and consistency. But as a 10 slash 15, you've still got to be fast. You've still got to be run. You've still got to run. And I watched him last week against Scotland and I thought, you're superhuman. They must be the most talented rugby family to have ever played rugby scott barrett geordie barrett geordie barrett's the best 12 on the planet i don't know it's it's something we speak about a lot about this new zealand sort of comeback after i mean they they i think scott robertson's win ratio was still like 80 and they still beat the springboks um at eden park and they had some big wins under robertson but just it's clear they've come on a lot in the last 12 months to the point that they can make 10 changes for this game and I still look

44:09at it and I'm trying to see oh where is the area they look notice noticeably weak okay they've changed a couple in the front row but still got Bauer, Amu and Newell, Josh Lord, Scott Barrett's good second row, Segner's obviously only winning a fifth cap but Peter Lackey and Wallace Titi have been two of their players of the season. Roy Gard's a different level but Cortez Ratam has now got 26 plus 27 caps come the weekend. Then they bring in Richie Mwanga. That's good. Which is a pretty handy player who's kind of been managed quite carefully on his return to the fold. Anton Leonard-Brown's got almost 100 caps alongside Quintipier. He's good. Then Fahey, going to struggle with this one, Finian Ganafo who could and turn to the fold. Antoinette Brown's got almost 100 caps alongside Quinta Pire. He's good. Then,

44:46Fahey, going to struggle with this one, Finian Ganafo, who could and should be at Newcastle, but he's in the mix now. I was wondering how they're going to score tries with Ward Jordan not being available. It's just quite old school all-blacks. They make changes and you still look at the team and go, that's a mad strong team. Is the aura fully back? Is the aura fully back? Well well i would say the only reason i'm hesitating is because of the spring box and the spring box have the aura is there is there a certain can two teams have aura at once in world rugby or is there a maximum amount of aura that gets distributed to the team so back in the all blacks pomp so there's a hundred bits of aura

45:21they've got like 90 of the bits who has the all blacks okay but now the spring box probably have the fair share of the aura allocation yeah so they've got i don't know like 80 percent of the aura and then i reckon france and paris still have a bit of aura but i don't know so i'm i'm not sure they they always have a bit of aura. Then the question last year was, has the aura gone? Is the aura back? I just don't know if they have as much aura as they had when they were the best in the world, while they are not the best in the world. That would just be my reservation. But it's a good question. Where are they on the aurometer? Next two weekends, we'll find out. We'll answer a few questions. From Welsh point of view,

46:03I'm pleased that he's gone for Costello again because I just don't know if the chop and change really helps. And there's shades of Australia in Wales at the moment and vice versa, which does then put, you know, puts a sort of fascination on that Wales-Australia game come next weekend. And Wallabies are probably better than Wales. They beat South Africa recently. But similar kind of conversations. We're looking at individuals over team, a fair bit with teams like Wales and Australia. I know Australia shouldn't be in that category, but the chop and change at 10 is often sort of symptomatic of a team that's just struggling a bit for finding themselves. Yeah, Australia at number 10. It's like, how often have we had this conversation?

46:42How often would it be a conversation that's so topical in a coaches meeting it's phenomenal Carter Gordon I saw him on Sunday at the Allianz Stadium I'd imagine if he's fit he might get a nod but you're bringing in someone off the back of an injury with a new combination it's nuts in fact I'm pretty certain how about this for a stat about you can do the Ben Darman one what's that? In fact, I'm pretty certain. How about this for a stat about... You can do the Ben Darman one. What's that? That in 100 tests, Australia have changed their fly half 50 times. No. So this one, I mean, it's just as damning, but Declan Meredith, he is one of six different players to wear the Wallabies number 10 jersey in the past 16 months.

47:24One of six. One of six jersey in the past 16 months. One of six. In the last 16 months. And that's... What? That's an injury thing. That's people coming and going from rugby league thing in Gordon's case. But it's also a... We don't really know. We also don't really know what we are kind of. And yeah, man. One of six. That's mad. It's crazy. In 16 months. Yeah. that's the old peep show five nines jeremy what is it four nines four nines jeremy adam's given us the four six fly halves jeremy um okay let's hear from eddie jones he was a guest on the five lab rugby show on tuesday night you get the whole thing on the uh bbc sounds app but he joined matt dawson rory lawson myself and sarah loads to come on the State of the Japan team,

48:06the State of the Game in general. We talk a bit about the importance of a regular figure at number 10. But first, this is what he made of that England performance against Australia last weekend. You know, there's been a lot of noise which is fairly common for England. They're fairly used to it, but they responded in the best way that England can. And that was a really physical, powerful performance. You spent seven years as the England head coach, but just give us a little bit of a taste, Eddie. What is it like when you come back here and you're in London? What is the reaction when you walk down the street? What do England fans say to you? Well, it's funny. I think a lot of good things. Maybe they're happy I'm gone.

48:48I'm sure that's not entirely. They're always very polite, very nice. Yeah, it's always good to come back and, you know, Twickenham is such a great experience for rugby, although I must admit being a spectator and being told when to make noise is a bit funny. Yeah, just for context, there was on the big screen during the second half, they kind of said, make some noise, make some... That's a really interesting point, Eddie, because did you find with the Twickenham crowd that they were very different depending on the opponents? England's record against Australia is pretty outstanding. You know, Eddie never lost to Australia. They lost once in 2022. They've lost once two years ago. But on the whole, it's nine of the last 11.

49:28So the Twickenham crowd maybe does expect a bit to beat Australia. I've noticed, though, when Scotland are in town, Ireland, France, New Zealand, South Africa, that's when the atmosphere can pick up. Did you notice that as head coach, Eddie, that the atmosphere did change from game to game depending on the opponent? Yeah, well, I think Six Nations is different. Six Nations, you feel the intensity of the rivalry, whereas the November tests, the crowd's always a bit lighter and maybe a little bit more corporate. Yeah. When it comes to the psychology of the England players, it was telling how they were speaking on Friday and we know that had a lot of external noise, a lot of pressure on the management, a lot of pressure on the team.

50:07Did you sometimes get that England players react better when they were in adversity somewhat? Yes and no. I think they sometimes enjoy to be underdogs and sometimes enjoy to prove people wrong, which I think any team does, so that's fairly natural. But I think sometimes the noise does get to the team, you know, and it can be pretty loud in England, you know, and you've got a lot of newspapers, a lot of media, probably more than any other country in the world. So I think sometimes that can weigh down on the players. And, you know, it's the job of the team to get the players thinking straight and the leadership of the team. I mean, that's teed out beautifully to know what noise Eddie's going to be making this week to stir it up, Eddie.

50:57What's going to be the narrative? Well, I think, yeah, the bottom line is England's probably thinking about New Zealand, mate, aren't they? You know, they're not thinking too much about us. So that opens up an opportunity for us. Can I ask you, Eddie, you obviously had Steve Borthwick as a coach under you at both Japan. And then when you were England coach, you brought him with you. What is your relationship now like with Steve Borthwick? Are you still in contact? Have messages been exchanged? What happens? Well, Steve's an outstanding coach and a very intelligent man and a really good coach. So I've got the highest respect for him. Yeah, we keep in contact. We saw each other at the coaches get together

51:39last Sunday and hopefully over the next couple of weeks we'll have a coffee. Not this week though. Yeah, for sure. Take us us into that room the coaches get together because a few of us went went to the referees meeting the next day at World Rugby and it was really interesting to see the referees interact and show clips and talk through decisions and they were they'd all been in with you guys all 24 of the leading head coaches all in one one room just give us a little bit of an insight on about who was who was saying what who were the loudest voices in one room. Just give us a little bit of an insight about who was saying what, who were the loudest voices in the room, what kind of conversations were being had

52:09by the head coaches in that big meeting? Well, it's something that used to happen pretty regularly, but over the last five years particularly, they've gone right out of fashion and the referees have just had meetings themselves and the coaches haven't been invited. But, you know, they dealt with a number of key issues. And generally, the one and two coaches in the world have the most say, which is fair enough. Okay, so when you've been flying high with, you know, roundabout 2019 World Cup, that's when you would have been more involved than you were now. Were you a bit more of a sort of observer then in your current role with Japan yeah no no you generally take more of a back seat and allow the the big dogs to have their say and and you know and that's how it should be was that um

53:00maybe a little bit frustration boiling over from the weekend when you sort of made that comment about how things have been officiated. Is that sort of come out of meetings like that where you just sometimes need to have a little bit of a say at that moment? Yeah, I just think the game's in a pretty good state. And if we start mucking around with penalising attacking teams and then we only give one penalty a game, because basically every ruck there's an infringement and there's a number of rucks where the attacking support player goes off his feet. And if we penalise one a game, then it doesn't put a good context on that area of the game and can have a significant effect on the game, which it did on Saturday.

53:45And I'm not saying that's a reason we lost, but I just think we've got to favour the attacking teams. And it's an obvious ceiling where a jackal is in place and then penalise them. But I saw a lot on the weekend some really indifferent refereeing in that game, and especially in the England-Australia game, I thought that area was a little bit difficult to understand. If it's hard to understand for people who are in the game, you imagine the 80,000 there that have had a few pints trying to understand what's going on. Remind me of this conversation, Chris. When we're doing the commentary at the weekend and the first penalty is for sealing off, can we have this conversation? Yeah, it's interesting though.

54:26So do you think if, because there's no doubt that attack is reigning in the game at the moment, whether that's because of the maul or because of the number of yellow cards that have been given or because of the way the breakdown is being officiated, but you're just looking for that consistency within a game so that if they're going to ref one way, it's just consistent from ruck to ruck. within a game so that if they're going to ref one way, it's just consistent from rock to rock? Well, yeah, the general trend of the game is we get a good attacking cycle and then people start complaining it's favouring the attack too much. And then we go and we penalise the attack at the breakdown and then teams lose confidence in wanting to keep the ball.

55:02We go to 90 kicks, everyone complains about too many kicks. So we then start favouring the attacking time. It's just constant cycles. And I reckon we've just got to settle on we favour attack a little bit in rugby. Rugby's a difficult game. And if you don't favour attack a bit, it's hard to get continuity. And we need for the game to be competitive against other professional sports and keep its place in the totem of sports. We need it to be a little bit more attacking than defending. Eddie, can we ask you a little bit about Japan? Because obviously this is your second stint with them now. Just how different is Japanese rugby compared to you going in before that 2019 World Cup and how did things change since they were hosts?

55:51Well, just on the weekend, we've got two university students playing that haven't earned a penny. They're completely amateur players. One player plays at a university where he doesn't have a coach and a strength and conditioning coach. He's got nothing to support him. So that's the uniqueness of Japanese rugby. And our best 10 who's played 10 tests in a row for us is exceptional talent, 21-year-old. I reckon he's as good as any player of that age in the world. He's playing back at his university. So that's the uniqueness of Japanese rugby. And then we've got a combination of Japanese players and some foreign players. So it's quite a unique combination. But I think we've got an important role to play in rugby in the world

56:34that we can play an attacking style of game and we can play a little bit different from everyone else and we need to play like Japan. Just explain, Eddie, why your best flight half is at university, not playing with you this weekend. Because his university wants him to play in the university finals, which we all love. It's just part of the unique nature of Japanese rugby that we don't have any high-performance development. So kids go from high schools to university and play in the university competition, which is completely amateur. And then they go to a club team and the universities can say whether they release the players or not. There's no Regulation 9 in Japan. You know, that's that's not there.

57:19I mean, you're obviously sort of playing the Japanese side down a little bit there and giving us some context. But what's the expectation from your side at the weekend? You still – you can't tell me that there's anything other than that you're going to go and win the game. No, no, no. Our job, look, we're massive underdogs. There's 13 games between Japan and England, and England won 13 of it. So we've got to go out there and find a way to disrupt England. And, you know, an England side that's looking at New Zealand next week can sometimes be a little bit distracted. So our opportunities to get in there cause some havoc, cause some chaos, put England off their game, get the crowd booing, get the crowd not being happy

58:05and then the sky starts to come in on Twickenham and you never know what can happen there. We've seen it happen with Italy. We've seen it happen with other countries. So that's our opportunity and we're preparing really well for it and we're looking forward to the challenge. Eddie, to what extent, obviously, the Nations Championship, a new competition, new format. Japan, to what extent have they really embraced this? They're coming up against the six Nations teams from the Northern Hemisphere. They obviously welcomed three of them to Japan in the July test and then come up to the Northern Hemisphere. How has that been welcomed in Japan? Because it is a shift, isn't it? Yeah, mate, it is absolutely fantastic.

58:49I think the whole concept of the Nations Championship has been good for rugby. I think giving these November tests some context and seeing all the best teams play up here. You know, you get a Friday night, Saturday, or rugby game on Sunday. I think it's been fantastic for rugby. And then to culminate in a finals weekend, which should be really special at Twickenham in a couple of weeks, I think it's great for rugby. And for us, you know, Japan and Fiji, we're the two countries outside the Big Ten. And, you know, it's just almost like a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to play so many good teams in a row. Is there anything that could be done, Eddie, in your mind about the July leg and the sort of logistical challenges of it?

59:33Because Fiji had to play their games in the UK. You played Ireland, didn't you, in Australia, because Ireland didn't want to sort of go New Zealand, then Japan, then Australia, or that kind of order. Is there anything that can be done about that or is it just the reality of so many southern hemisphere nations being so far apart geographically? Well, I think it's the reality of geography, mate. You can't do much about that. And they're hard tools for the northern hemisphere countries. It's a little bit easier for the southern hemisphere countries to come to the UK where travel's, you know, you're an hour and a half, two hours from everywhere. Whereas, you know, Australia, New Zealand, South Africa,

1:00:11you're looking at, you know, anywhere up to 13 hours. And I think that's the reality of it. And for the sake of rugby, I think, you know, something has to give. You know, if you look at rugby in totality at the moment, it's not in a good financial state and we need to make sure that we're promoting the game. Yeah, you think about this Nations Championship. They had a wonderful weekend, wonderful opportunity when they had all the coaches together to start promoting the Nations Championship. You know, getting shots, getting interviews, getting Russie there with Dave Rennie or Steve Borthwick. And they miss all those opportunities, rugby. And, you know, if you look at the financial state of most national units, it's not healthy.

1:00:53So we need to do something about the game. And the Nations Championship is one way of bringing the game forward. Yeah, we'd have done a podcast with all of them together, wouldn't we, Sarah? Oh, definitely. We would have done really well. Oh, 24, pretty good. We were talking just off air before, wouldn't we, Sarah? Oh, definitely. We would have done really well. Well, 24, pretty much. We were talking just off air before, weren't we, guys, about the balance of power in the World Game. And I know New Zealand and South Africa often did their own thing, the rugby's greatest rivalry. And it feels like they've raised the bar. Are those two out on their own at the moment, do you think, Eddie? Well, I think, again, you've got to own at the moment you think eddie well i think again you got to look

1:01:25at the context of the games like argentina played uh ireland on the week on friday night they only got their team together on tuesday you know because that most of the players are playing in the french league so you know teams have either got an advantage or disadvantage at this stage of the season and once you get the world, everyone has the same number of weeks to prepare. So, you know, New Zealand and South Africa particularly are really match-hardened at the moment. They've had a number of significant tests. They look fit. They've got great competition for places. So they're doing well. But, you know, you'd expect France and England I think you know over the next couple of weeks to really challenge those two countries. So good tip from Eddie Jones

1:02:11oogs lots of of good insight from Eddie as ever I mean when when your best tends playing uni rugby you're dealing with a crazy different rugby culture to others aren't you? Yeah it's um I'm sure a challenge is probably not faced at any other nation. Imagine going to South Africa, but like, oh, actually, got schools for rugby this weekend. Universities, a huge game, quarterfinals. I did want to pick Finn Smith, but he's playing for Loughborough Uni this weekend. Just unthinkable. But culturally, they're very different. I love everything about Japan, but that, yeah, that one, I'm not quite sure in terms of sporting priorities. Yes, Riku Kitahara is at 10. I mean, we know all about Saito at number nine.

1:02:51He's been around for ages. But on the left wing, Riku Tokito. I'm informed it's his first ever game of pro 15-a-side rugby. He'll be fine. Yeah? He'll be fine. A seven specialist. And we saw some videos that have come out this week of some peculiar training methods that's Japan are going to have to do something a little bit different cliched as it sounds to sort of overcome a lot of this adversity to you know make it as good a game as some of the Japan-England games at Twickenham have been in recent memory. Yeah, that's the balance of a coach, but you kind of want to get to a point whereby, yes, you need to consider or manufacture different ways where you can find competitive edge, but you want to do it without spoiling the contest.

1:03:39And of course, the infamous right gate was one of those where an edge was found by Italy. But you don't want to see a repeat of that. I'm sure we won't. And Eddie said, we're going to do all we can. We'll be within the laws. And he's a student of the game and he will look for loopholes and everything. But if England, once again, are fully focused on themselves, especially when they're in possession, this shouldn't be too much of a contest this shouldn't be too much of a contest shouldn't be too much of a threat quick one on Ireland against Fiji um I haven't really spoken too much about Fiji's regime change Jake White at the helm yes yes you know a guy steeped in experience a world cup winner in 2007 but a South African pragmatist by trade yeah coaching Fiji that that feels like it could go

1:04:27in one of two directions either yeah just what Fiji need or oh is he going to get the best out of what we know is an insanely talented group of players particularly behind the scruff I listened to Jake White head of Fiji taken in France last week and I think people made that point ask the question does he need to bring a level of pragmatism? And that's only fair and natural, especially at international level. But Jake White did back back and said, you know, whenever you speak to anyone, the tough teams to play against and what makes playing against Fiji so difficult, it's Fijians playing the Fijian way, being loose, being expressive and being unpredictable. How you mirror the two, I think, is really tough

1:05:06and you have to get your messaging right. They were fairly competitive against France last week. They were physical and they moved the ball really well, but the tactical discipline just wasn't there for long enough, especially against the top side. They were up against the top side in Ireland last week who, in cruise control against Argentina and still with a level of honesty from Andy Farrell we're not at a position to win the World Cup yet and so he considers there to be so much group growth within this team and he will absolutely look for this team to take a step forward considering what's coming next week and that's the World Champions. It's getting good. Nick Timoney plays at eight, no more of a flank but still

1:05:50that back row, Baird, Van der Vleer, Timoney. I know they've got their problems at eight but that's still very good on paper isn't it? And then you look at the rest of the forward pack, Porter, Kelleher, Furlong, Ryan Bird. I mean that's pretty mighty. Gibson Park back to play at nine with Prender, Gasp, Bundyak. He's back in the team playing 12 to Jamie Osborne's 13. And then with Hanson, Balakun. It's a strong Ireland team on paper. Praying for no injuries. He's just plotting. You feel Andy Farrell's just plotting. He knows where Ireland are. They're nowhere near where they were four years ago, 2022 going into 2023. But he's just building his depth in kind of a quite understated way he's making

1:06:26big changes to his team but then it doesn't look like he's making big changes to his team I think what we want to see over the next few weeks is people make a run now can Ireland announce themselves as potential World Cup contenders by beating the Springboks can England do likewise by beating New Zealand can Wales show then go toe-to-toe with the All Blacks or the Wallabies can Scotland recover from New Zealand to put the Wallabies away which they should be doing in Edinburgh so I think a lot of our questions which we're still asking are going to be answered over the next few weeks all being well and setting up a finals weekend which we haven't spoken about much but we'll get an idea won't we after this weekend there's no point speculating after weekend

1:07:04one but after this one we'll get a real idea of who could be shaping up to face who come the end of the month yeah and we could get those repeated fixtures depending on the connotations of this weekend and South Africa play against France and South Africa have an unblemished record France have lost one that was New Zealand in the summer Ireland have lost they're lost against the All Blacks they're in a really good spot but they're still down the rankings beneath England England have scored more tries than them have got an extra bonus point so yeah depending on what happens with South Africa and New Zealand we could get to a point where England play New Zealand next week and then play them again

1:07:39in the finals I quite like that back to back there will have to be repeats there will have to be some repeats somewhere there will Ireland could play South Africa next weekend and then South Africa in the final again yeah I don't mind that Clive I quite like that. Back to back. There will have to be repeats. There will have to be some repeats somewhere. There will. Ireland could play South Africa next weekend and then South Africa in the final again. Yeah, I don't mind that, Clive. See, I just think with the final, you want it to feel different because it is different and you're playing for something. Like in any other competition or tournament, you're not going to go from World Cup semi-final,

1:08:02knock someone out and go, oh yeah, no, but we'll have someone out and go oh yeah I get that but if Ireland were to beat South Africa and finish number one because say France lose to New Zealand England lose to New Zealand whatever and South Africa still managed to be number one because New Zealand actually that wouldn't really work somewhere New Zealand would have lost but England could beat New Zealand next week yeah but Ireland could still finish above them yes there's probably no point of speculating now. I just quite like those back-to-backs if there's a bit of kind of narrative around revenge and this, that, and the other. But there's still loads of, I mean, talking about revenge, South Africa, France.

1:08:33France humbled last year in their own patch, but they don't lose very often. England beating New Zealand. New Zealanders have memories like elephants when it comes to defeats. So that's going to be massive ahead of next weekend. So it's all building up nicely. First weekend, what, six? Don't want to do the internet meme, but six, six, seven. I think it's going to start getting better and better. Let's hope. Loads on Five Live, loads on Sports Extra, loads on BBC Sounds, loads on the Rugby Weekly Podcast. You won't miss a thing with us and we'll see you soon. Cheers. Thanks for downloading Rugby Union Weekly. For more info, head to the BBC Sounds app. This is the story of The One. As a shipping manager, he's running the dock, stocking supplies,

1:09:27and making sure every order goes out on time. And Grainger helps him stay prepared. From shipping supplies to PPE to hand tools, he counts on Grainger to keep products moving and trucks rolling so his operation runs smoothly no matter the shift. Call 1-800-GRAINGER, click granger.com, or just stop by. Granger, for the ones who get it done. In a world full of distractions, presence is power. Meet the new Kindle Scribe, a digital notebook that feels like paper. No tabs, no notifications. Just focus. Plus, built-in AI to organize, summarize, and move your ideas forward faster. Because the most impressive person in the room is the one who's fully in it. What are you working on? The new Kindle Scribe.

▸More episode summaries

Rugby Union Weekly cover art
Rugby Union WeeklyThe greatest win in Welsh rugby history?2026-11-14 · 52 min
Rugby Union Weekly cover art
Rugby Union WeeklyHamer-Webb, Bok Blues & where are Ireland?2026-11-16 · 59 min
Transcribe your links. Paste a YouTube, Google Drive or podcast link and WhipScribe gives you the transcript. Transcribe a link →
New Rugby Union Weekly transcripts by email
One email per new episode, unsubscribe in every message. Not shared with the publisher.