PBS News Hour - Full Show · · Transcript & summary by WhipScribe
Summary, chapters and key takeaways for this episode are on their way; the transcript below is complete.
Our own transcript of the public episode, with a timestamp about every 90 seconds. Tap a timestamp or the link button on a paragraph to copy a link that opens this page there.
0:00Good evening. I'm Jeff Bennett. And I'm Amna Nawaz. On the NewsHour tonight, a series of outages from the FAA to the NSA spark concern about the stability of digital infrastructure. President Trump stops in the Philippines on his way to a summit in China where the AI race is taking center stage. And Joe Biden's newly released memoir recounts his perspective on his presidency and his decision to drop out of the 2024 campaign. We speak with his former counselor, Steve Ruschetti. He believed he was healthy and more prepared than anyone to take the next step and to lead the country for four more years. Welcome to the NewsHour. A string of major technology failures is raising new questions about the reliability and security
1:05of systems that millions of Americans depend on every day. The latest incident involved the NSA, or National Security Agency, which said its own internal systems were affected by an outage today. The NSA said it happened as part of routine maintenance and did not affect security operations. But several news reports said the outage involved a classified internal network. And this was the latest in a series of high-profile problems. In just the past week, a Microsoft outage last Thursday disrupted services around the world. On Friday, a nationwide ground stop by the FAA brought air travel to a halt. And yesterday, United Airlines experienced a separate outage while customers of several major banks, including Chase, Bank of America,
1:49and Wells Fargo reported problems accessing their accounts. The incidents are said to be unrelated, but their timing has fueled concerns about whether something more is at work. Homeland Security Secretary Mark Wayne Mullen, in an interview last night, dismissed suggestions of a coordinated cyber attack, instead blamed artificial intelligence. So I started talking to the tech industry, and one guy that's very smart with tech, he asked not to mention his name. No, it's not Elon, so let me just put that out. But I said, what could be causing all these separate outages? And he says, I believe that it's the SI. He said, because these programs aren't designed to work as fast as SI is. And so when they contribute or when they
2:31put in a program that's able to write codes and it goes in, it self-fixes itself. That's a ripple effect. And it causes these systems to be overrun that weren't designed to run as fast as the SI technology is today. But that is far from conclusive. For more on this wave of disruptions, we turn to Eric O'Neill, a former FBI counterintelligence operative who's now a cybersecurity executive specializing in cyber threats and national security. Thank you for being with us. It's great to be here. So we have seen a remarkable series of technology failures in just the past week, understanding that as we sit here and speak, there are more questions than answers. Still, what do we know about what's behind these disruptions?
3:15And is there any evidence that these are connected in any way? Right. So, so far, no evidence that they are connected other than there is a massive coincidence behind this. And I'll get into that as a second. And unfortunately, we don't know a lot because each of the different organizations and the government agencies that have been brought down by this are being very not forthcoming. So we start with Microsoft, who called it a technical glitch. And then, of course, we have the ATC system, the air traffic control communication system, where one of the 21 nodes suddenly has all of these issues and is communicating erratically, which causes the FAA to ground all flights, which was extraordinary, but probably because they, I would bet they thought it was a cyber attack. They did that under an abundance of caution. Then the banks, right after that,
4:08on the heels of that, banks start to fail and people can't log in. And then, of course, United comes back and says, we're having problems. I'm really glad I'm not flying this week. And then finally, the NSA has a problem with one of their classified systems. You put that all together in this string of events, and there are other companies that, by the way, in all of this have gone down, and it's too much of a coincidence to say that there might be some external factor causing all of these. That is what investigators are going to be looking at very diligently right now. We heard the Homeland Security Secretary, Mark Wayne Mullen, say there's no indication these incidents were caused by a cyber attack.
4:50How confident can investigators be in ruling that out at this stage? How long might it take to determine whether there was a sophisticated intrusion? They can't be confident at all. Right now, there are a number of different paths that investigators are going to look at. In fact, three things. They're going to be looking at whether this was just a coincidence of internal failures within companies that are using the cloud and are broadly used across the industry. They're part of critical infrastructure. Two, they're looking at whether there was an external attacker or force that came in and caused a flaw or a disruption based on some external threat. And three, and this might actually be the more likely one, they will be looking at whether there is a common application, networking
5:40tool, or technology that these companies in these similar industries use that broke down, went bad, or was attacked by an external threat actor. No matter how it happened, it still causes the same amount of chaos. So investigators are going to be looking down all three of those paths to see which it was. And I would bet within a week, by next week, by this time next week, we'll know a lot more data about what they learned. The secretary has also suggested that artificial intelligence is overwhelming older systems. Does that explanation hold up from a technical standpoint? I think, yes, it does. But I would suggest that the artificial intelligence that is overwhelming these systems is not coming from within the companies themselves,
6:25but actually, as we've seen, is coming from external attackers, whether they are foreign intelligence services or whether there are these cybercrime syndicates that are making trillions of money from us through these attacks, using AI agents who never sleep, never ask for a can of soda, just continue to launch probe attacks and find ways to attack, that might actually be one of the pressures that is happening on these companies because they have to defend against that 24-7 and they never stop. They're relentless. What would it take to make these systems more resilient? Is there a realistic way to avoid these types of widespread disruptions? Or is some degree of vulnerability just what we have to now live with?
7:10There will always be vulnerability, but the threat is worse than it's ever been. Right now, in this quarter of 2026, we have 53% more cyber attacks than this time last year. With this enormous increase in attacks, we need to be more resilient and we need to be better at defending ourselves, which means there has to be much more of an investment in cybersecurity. And the cybersecurity of the future is not what we've been seeing for the past decades. It's cybersecurity that uses AI to battle against the best AI for criminals and spies. That is what's being deployed and that's what's being built. And that is what's going to save us. Cybersecurity expert Eric O'Neill, his book is Spies, Lies, and Cybercrime Cybersecurity Tactics
7:55to Outsmart Hackers and Disarm Scammers. Thanks for your time this evening. Thank you so much for having me. President Trump began a 48-hour visit to Asia today, attending a summit of regional leaders in the Philippines. Tomorrow, he heads to China for meetings with Chinese President Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin. Among the major points of tension between Washington and Beijing is the race for dominance in artificial intelligence, with the U.S. restricting China's access to advanced American microchips. Our Nick Schifrin is in China, where he visited one of the country's largest technology companies. But his report begins in Manila with the president's visit. In his first trip abroad, since many midterm voters rejected his leadership,
8:54President Trump visited a region eager for more of his attention. America is deeply committed to the success, sovereignty and prosperity of our many friends and partners, many of whom are at this table right now. But the table of Southeast Asian leaders haven't always felt that way, since they were Trump tariff targets. And so the president announced progress on new economic deals with Thailand. DONALD TRUMP, President of the United States, Actually, it's a very big trade deal. NICK SCHIFRIN And a group of allies that are a counterweight to China. DONALD TRUMP Ensure that none of our nations is vulnerable to coercion by any single foreign supplier. NICK SCHIFRIN That's a barely veiled reference to Beijing, and U.S.-China tensions over technology
9:29loom over this summit and region. Tomorrow, President Trump joins the 20 other leaders of APEC here in Shenzhen, China. Just in the last few decades, this city has transformed from a fishing village into an economic hub, and its home to China's largest technology companies. NICK SCHIFRIN, Outside the city lies this 300-acre research and development campus for state technology champion Huawei. China proudly describes itself as the Middle Kingdom, as in the middle of global civilization. But this Huawei campus celebrates the middle of Europe. The tram leads to architecture designed to look exactly like Fribourg, Switzerland, buildings out of Verona, Italy, fair if only a decade old. The Heidelberg Germany Castle, one of 108 structures here filled with 30,000 employees,
10:17mostly researchers, and what looks like the Sorbonne University in Paris. The real Sorbonne's motto is creator of the future, a motto that Huawei also believes applies to them. The company is a telecommunications giant that has become China's chips and AI leader, developing indigenous AI capacity out of necessity. We don't want companies to be complicit in Huawei's human rights abuses. In 2019, the Trump administration blacklisted Huawei and in 2020 labeled it a national security threat. The Commerce Department is very focused on export controls. And the Biden administration blocked all Chinese companies from the most advanced chips in the world and high volume manufacturing and the most advanced
11:09manufacturing machines. So because Huawei's had no access to the best individual chips at the heart of the AI race, it's doubled down on designing its own chips. And this year began to stitch them together to make them faster and more efficient. This is Huawei's flagship store and Huawei's first phone that uses a new chip design that tries to pack in more computing power to get around those American restrictions. And this technology has helped Huawei and China become more self-reliant when it comes to AI. Huawei is the national champion for China for AI computing. I sat down today with Michael Frank, CEO of Radeon Intel, an AI research platform for geopolitical risk with long experience in Asia. Their business strategy is part and parcel of China's national AI development.
12:00And they are the biggest player by far. They are the most capable. And most importantly, they're the biggest player by far. They are the most capable. And most importantly, they're the most indigenized. So they are already more insulated from international technology shocks that we might have tried to use against them through policy in the past. After the U.S. restrictions, Huawei's revenue dropped 30 percent. Today, it's returned to 2020 levels. And along the way, it's received billions from Beijing. DAVID WU, Huawei Investment Adviser, Huawei Investment Adviser Group, They have a lot of resources at their disposal. They have functionally infinite capital. The Chinese government has plenty of money to throw at the problem.
12:37And they have a massive domestic market that they can use as a testbed. NICK SCHIFRIN, The company increasingly relies on that domestic market and new businesses. Ni hao. Hi. How are you? Like smart car technology. OK, so we're about to start our Tesla drive. Huawei arranged for a test drive for this autonomous car. Sorry, I'm not touching. It's my hand and my feet. It's unreleased. So it's driving itself. Yes. It's called Huawei Cockpit, and because the company is blocked from many foreign parts, it's increasingly made in China. So during the journey, we just asked the AI assistants to play some music. Okay, great. Can I speak to the AI agent in English, or it's only Mandarin right now? Currently, it only understands Chinese.
13:22Because it's for the Chinese market and China's richest, the base model costs more than $100,000. Bills making their way through Congress would close the U.S. market to all Chinese EVs, a reminder that Washington still considers Huawei's success a threat. We're leading now China substantially in AI, and we're going to keep it that way. President Trump acknowledges the AI race defines the U.S.-China technology competition. Blackwell is an engineering marvel. NVIDIA is a primary source of U.S. success. Former CEO Jensen Wang departed following an affair with a woman whose Singapore-based company bought advanced NVIDIA chips. That's led this week to the U.S. further restricting chip exports for fear they were being accessed remotely by Chinese companies.
14:10Increasingly, the U.S.-China tech battle will become a competition between NVIDIA and Huawei. We have in Huawei the instrument of China's interest in dominating the AI stack globally. And conversely, NVIDIA is our best hope to win over as much of the global market as possible. If we lose the global market to Huawei, even if NVIDIA is today the cutting edge, you're going to have Huawei reaping the rewards. And what is the chance that Huawei can succeed in that way? You look at the experience of the last six years, it would be foolish to underestimate their capabilities. This is a zero-sum competition, and it's going to be these two players going head-to-head for the next few years. And today, Nvidia promised that it would increase oversight
15:02to try and make sure that China didn't smuggle or remotely access its most advanced chips. Jeff, that was a decision that President Trump called a good idea. It's a great company, Jeff. And, Nick, today, former CEO Jensen Wong broke his silence in stepping down under pressure last week. What did he say? He acknowledged that he didn't live up to his former company's standards. But, Jeff, then he noted an online campaign calling for his reinstatement. And he wrote on X, quote, if the board of directors decides that my return is in the best interest of our shareholders, our employees, the company, and America, I would be honored to answer these calls and return as CEO. There are no indications, Jeff, that the board is interested in that. And that announcement
15:44that I mentioned earlier about increasing oversight to try and make sure the most advanced chips aren't smuggled into China or remotely accessed by China, well, Jeff, that's a way that the board is trying to clean up the mess that Jensen Wong has left because of his relationship with that Singapore-based company that was accused of doing exactly that remote access and that smuggling. NICK SCHIFRIN, The Washington Post-Midnight Times- In the meantime, President Trump is set to meet with his Chinese and Russian counterparts on Thursday. What are we expecting? DAVID BROOKS, The Washington Post- President Trump says he wants to talk about arms control, but China has given no indication that it's interested in having a serious conversation
16:20about reducing its nuclear stockpile, which is the world's fastest-growing arsenal. President Trump does acknowledge that he will talk about Ukraine, which, of course, is one of Vladimir Putin's top priorities. Now, many Russian officials are raising the possibility that this is a kind of Yalta II. Yalta I was where Roosevelt, Stalin and Churchill divided up Europe and embraced spheres of influence, even if today's leaders do not have the same leverage and aren't even allies, at least when it comes to President Trump. As for China, Jeff, Chinese analysts are telling me that Xi Jinping's priority is the photo op to try and prove to the world that the world's two biggest nuclear superpowers, the U.S. and Russia,
17:00would come to him as he tries to portray himself as the source of global stability. Jeff. Nick Schifrin reporting tonight from Shenzhen, China. Nick, our thanks to you. Thank you. And a note on the future of NVIDIA. The company's board late this evening publicly confirmed what Nick was reporting. It has no intention of reinstating Jensen Wong as CEO. In the day's other headlines, international health officials say the United States is no longer considered a measles-free nation. In a virtual briefing today, the Pan American Health Organization said endemic measles outbreaks in nation. In a virtual briefing today, the Pan-American Health Organization said endemic measles outbreaks in the U.S., along with Mexico and Bolivia,
17:50signaled the re-emergence of a disease that was once seen as controlled. Measles is one of the most contagious diseases in the world. Measles elimination is not a trophy that is won once and placed on a shelf. It is an achievement that must be safeguarded every day by closing immunity gaps and ensuring we reach every community. The measles elimination status is largely symbolic. Still, the Pan American Health Organization said it expects the three nations to submit plans in the coming weeks on how they will try to stop transmission for at least a year. Measles has been spreading in the U.S. at the highest rate in more than 30 years, mostly among the unvaccinated. Today, CDC Director Dr. Erica
18:37Schwartz stressed the importance of vaccination. Cell phone bans in some U.S. schools are leading to, quote, modest improvements in academic growth among students. That's according to a new study led by Harvard University. The report says strict cell phone bans, like using lockable pouches, restore the equivalent of one to two weeks of learning each year. But that's only about half the annual decline in test scores we've seen over the past decade or so. The study is the first nationwide assessment of its kind, analyzing math and reading scores of more than 3 million students at some 4,600 schools. Turning now to the war in Iran, maritime monitors say a gas tanker went up in flames today in the Strait of Hormuz after it was hit by multiple projectiles.
19:28The crew had to abandon ship after it was engulfed by an inferno off the coast of Oman. Separately, Bahrain says it intercepted a flurry of Iranian drones that were headed toward a U.S. radar facility. U.S. Central Command reported no damage or injuries. In the meantime, a third carrier group, the USS Theodore Roosevelt, is now in the region, even as concerns linger over long deployments. Appearing in front of the Senate Armed Services Committee today, President Trump's pick to lead the Navy, current Acting Secretary Hong Kao, addressed a prior deployment, the USS Lincoln, which saw a number of suicide attempts during its record-setting time at sea. I don't control the deployment lengths, but I did answer those inquiries right away, especially
20:15with the mental health issues. You see it as eight suicide attempts. I see it as eight suicide mitigations because of the chaplains we have on board, the deployment resiliency counselors, as well as mental health specialists. Cao also acknowledged the Iran war's strain on Navy resources, but insisted that joint operations with other U.S. military branches have sent a message to adversaries like China. In Ukraine, President Volodymyr Zelensky says his country's drones and missiles hit a bridge linking Russia with the occupied Crimean Peninsula, calling the attack unprecedented. The 12-mile Kerch Bridge is a vital artery for moving Russian military supplies to the front line. Video released by Ukraine's security service shows drones hitting the bridge.
21:01Military officials say part of its road link was severed, though a railway line remains intact. A Kremlin spokesperson says the bridge will be restored. In the meantime, Russia fired missiles and drones at Kiev, hitting two bridges there and killing at least two people. In corporate news, NVIDIA beat expectations in its first earnings report since CEO Jensen Huang stepped down. The AI giant reported revenues of nearly $116 billion in the last quarter, more than double what it made a year earlier. And the company's expecting even higher revenues in the current quarter. Those results came after the closing bell on Wall Street. Before that, stocks struggled once again, with the Dow Jones Industrial Average dropping by
21:45nearly 850 points. The Nasdaq fell by almost three quarters of a percent. The S&P 500 posted its lowest close since July. And on Australia's Christmas Island, tens of millions of red crabs have begun their annual migration in one of nature's most unique and stunning sites. Dubbed the ruby red rush hour, the crabs make their way from the forest to the ocean to breed. Local authorities say the exact timing and speed of the migration is determined by the phases of the moon. Officials clear roads and even build bridges to help ensure a smooth journey. Naturalist David Attenborough has described it as a, quote, great scarlet curtain moving down the cliffs and rocks towards the sea. Couldn't have said it better of ourselves. Still to come on the NewsHour, lawmakers in the lame
22:35duck Congress rush to pass legislation before power changes hands in January. New findings show just how much strain data centers are putting on the environment. And a North Dakota museum works to bring focus to Great Plains artists. This is the PBS NewsHour from the David M. Rubenstein Studio at WETA in Washington, headquarters of PBS News. The Trump administration is seeking $50 billion to modernize the nation's air traffic control system following last week's massive nationwide ground stop. But the proposal could face resistance in Congress, where lawmakers are raising questions about the cost and how that money would be spent. Our congressional correspondent Lisa Desjardins joins us now to break down the price tag and the political hurdles ahead. So Lisa,
23:29how did Secretary Duffy, how is he explaining this $50 billion he's seeking and his decision making over the weekend with this ground stop? He has been calling some congressional leaders and he had lunch today with Senate Republicans. He again reiterated that it was a faulty router made by Juniper Networks that was to blame. However, he and the FAA administrator told the press today they're not sure exactly why that router misfired. They have taken this report and they have gone forward and shut down all of the Juniper Network routers in the system so far. As to that ground stop, he defended that decision. He said it was critical for safety. I get it was hard for people, but I would I would rather have
24:12that story than the other story that we didn't do our job and we let risk into the system, but we kept flying because then all of you would say, why why didn't you shut it down? Why didn't you make that decision? Now he is trying to encourage Congress to make a different decision, which, as you say, is fund $50 billion. We were one of the first outlets to get a copy of that proposal for Congress. It's just two pages. Look at that. But $50 billion. Here's what the secretary wants. $20 billion, first of all, for new terminals and upgrades at some airports around the country. $10 billion for air traffic control towers and some airports around the country. Ten billion dollars for air traffic control towers and some computing needs. Some of that is needed for that fiber
24:50copper wire switch. Ten billion dollars for five air route traffic centers. Those are the centers that handle flights as they are overhead at high altitudes. This is a large ask. This is 50 billion dollars. And it is also a late ask because this Congress is getting ready to close down for its session. So what's been the response from lawmakers so far? Yeah. Talking to Republicans coming out of that luncheon, they all said universally that they actually do trust Secretary Duffy. I didn't sense that he has a threat from them. He still has their trust. However, they all have a lot of skepticism about this request. One senator told me he thought airlines should be paying for all of this. Another,
25:30Senator Kennedy of Louisiana, said he thinks that airports should not be something that the federal government is paying to improve. Meantime, this Congress is in its final weeks. It's a lame duck session. What remains on their to-do list? Oh boy, it's a pretty hefty lift. And as you and I speak, Congress is getting ready to leave this week and won't be back until December. Then we'll just have a few weeks left. Let's look at what's on that list. Some big time stuff, including, oh, keeping government funded. The deadline for that is December 10th. And I have to tell you, Jeff, there are some real red flags going up that we could be in a situation for a potential shutdown. So we'll be watching this very carefully. In addition to that, Congress needs to pass the
26:09next defense authorization bill that usually is done each year, usually bipartisan. We will see. Then after that, Republicans have a big wish list, another reconciliation bill where they will hopefully get some agenda items in before they're out of power. But I have to tell you, I just don't see the serious discussions happening yet for them to get all that done, especially that reconciliation bill in time. And Lisa, while we have you, what is the latest with the midterms? What races remain to be called at this hour? Such a fascinating election. Let's start with the House of Representatives. There was even a new race called today. And where Democrats stand right now, you can see 257 seats. They picked up a seat in North Carolina today. You see those seven yellow dots. Those are the
26:50races that remain to be called. Of those, three of them right now are looking like they will be Democratic flips. So we're talking 260 or above for Democrats. Let's go look at the Senate. And you have just one yellow dot there at the bottom. That, of course, is the state of Alaska, where our friends at Alaska Public Media have had one of the longest election seasons in a year. But, Jeff, that could end tomorrow. Mary Peltola has been picking up votes, and she is poised to end this election tomorrow with 50 percent. Tomorrow is the day Alaska will decide whether it needs to go to ranked choice voting, or if she has 50 percent, she'll be the winner. Lisa Desjardins, thanks as always. You're welcome.
27:39Almost two years after leaving office, President Joe Biden has penned a memoir about his time in the White House. It's called Promise Me America, and it's out today. But the former president isn't doing the typical run of media interviews. Earlier today, I spoke with his former counselor, Steve Ruscetti, and began by asking him why he was here on Biden's behalf. Well, he's had to limit what he's doing in terms of a book tour and things like that, because I think, as you know, and it's been widely reported, he has a stage four cancer diagnosis. He got that last May. And so he's working his way through the part of this where he still gets pretty heavy doses of medication to help manage the cancer. It's moved into his bones,
28:28so there's some pain and discomfort with it, and frankly, even affects his energy level. So he's not going out in the way that I think he would really like to with a kind of traditional book tour. And so a number of us who worked closely with him are going to try to share some of the load and do it. You've known him for so long. You know him so well. He writes in the book, too, about the span of his career. He says, I was elected to the Senate as a 29-year-old kid. I left the presidency as an 82-year-old man. I've seen the long sweep of history. You say he wants the book to speak for itself. So what is it he hopes to accomplish by putting it out at this time? He wanted to do this close enough to his presidency, his time in office, that he could speak, you know, and remember the events
29:17and talk through what he experienced because it was still fresh in his mind. He waited until after the midterms because I think he didn't want the book to be the subject of what the political dialogue was for the midterm elections. He wanted this to be, as it was, a referendum in many ways on President Trump's first two years in office. So it was time to follow the midterms, but to be close to his presidency enough that he could talk about it in the ways that he had very completely and thoroughly. I mean, it is very thorough. It's incredibly comprehensive reading through it. I was reminded of all these stories that we covered, the chaos he stepped into in the pandemic after the January 6th insurrection, all the legislative efforts I know you were deeply involved in from
30:05the American Rescue Plan to the Infrastructure Act, the CHIPS Act, rallying NATO after the Russian invasion of Ukraine. All of these are detailed in the book. And yet, as I'm sure you've seen, it is his decision to run again that's getting a lot of attention as people are making their way through the book. He writes about that in the book. He says, I believe I was the best person to do it, the only person who'd ever beaten Donald Trump. I felt I was the best person to do it again. I'm sure you've seen as folks read this, one journalist in particular called his reflection on this pugnacious, unrepentant and unreflective. What do you make of that? I just don't think that's a fair criticism of the book for the reasons that you just said.
30:45I do think it is now hard to remember. Maybe there's even some kind of psychological effect from what we went through during COVID, but that we forget that he really inherited as severe a set of challenges as any president in our lifetime. There really were three crises in our country. There was an international pandemic. Hundreds of thousands of people had died of COVID by January 20th of 2021. The economy was flat on its back. We were in an economic crisis. And again, what you just pointed out that people have forgotten, it was two weeks after the January 6th attack on the Capitol. And really the heart of our democracy was on the line, the institution of the presidency, respect for other branches of government.
31:39There was so much at stake in that first year of his presidency just to restore a sense of confidence and respect for the presidency itself and to, you know, reaffirm our reputation and role in the world. And yet since then, as you know, the party is still sort of reckoning with that decision of how his candidacy for reelection ended, what happened in the wake of that, President Trump's reelection. And I have to ask, because I didn't see it in the book, but in hindsight, as you know him and you speak to him, has there been any reflection on maybe I should not have run again? Maybe they should not have taken a disastrous debate or an intra-party feud. Has that ever been part of the conversation? Because it's not in the book. It's not because in April of 2023, when he made the decision to run again,
32:29it was a pretty straightforward equation in his mind. We believed we were making progress in the country. There was no question that we had, the country had endured real difficulty, real challenge. His leadership through that period of time in his mind and in my mind and in the mind of those around him, we just believed we were making progress. We knew there were still challenges ahead and work to be done, certainly more work to be done with respect to the economy and prices. And he believed he was healthy and more prepared than anyone to, you know, take the next step and to lead the country for four more years. When you talk about the memoir and the legacy that it starts to create, even today, he goes to Dublin to support his son as he's getting an award,
33:21and he's heckled by protesters outside who opposed his support for Israel and their war in Gaza. Where does that fit into the president's legacy, do you think? I think it's still being real attention, and at times even struggled with the decision-making that was occurring in Israel with Prime Minister Netanyahu with respect to the direction that he and his military were taking there, and made every effort with the power and the influence of the United States to try to direct that in a somewhat different way. You've worked in Democratic politics for a very long time. As you and I sit here, you've just seen your party win sweeping victories across these midterm elections, flipping seats, flipping states in some cases. What is it you want to see the Democratic Party
34:21do now with this opportunity they have? I think it was a seismic election. It really was for Democrats in particular. It was just so deep and wide in our, you know, the fact that we won races in states that people for many years didn't think could be competitive. And I think maybe this is a moment to pivot in American politics because to a person, they said, I'll work with anyone, Republican, Democrat or even President Trump to attack America's problems. We have an affordability crisis. People around a kitchen table are struggling to get by. They need help. And I'll work with anyone to produce results for them. And I think that is very, very healthy in our politics. And I think we should put a premium
35:14on people who are willing to reach across the aisle or do whatever it takes to help move things along, to make progress in the country, to achieve legislative results in a bipartisan way, even in the way that President Biden did in the several of the things that you mentioned and that he discusses in great detail in his book. Well, as we said, his new book, Promise Me America, is out now. I hope we have the chance to speak with him directly about it as well. In the meantime, Steve Ruscetti, we thank you so much. Thanks for inviting me. Being here today. Thank you so much. The 400 largest data centers in the United States emit more greenhouse gas emissions into the air in one year than the entire nation of Denmark. That's according to a new report from Harvard
36:11University. The study found that from May 2024 to April 2025, data centers accounted for nearly 2 percent of total U.S. energy consumption and produced more than 25 million metric tons of carbon dioxide, a level two or three times higher than an earlier estimate in 2018. I'm joined now by the lead author of that study, Gianluca Widi, a postdoctoral research fellow at Harvard focusing on AI and public health. Gianluca, welcome to the NewsHour. Thanks for joining us. Yeah, thank you for having me. Hello, everyone. So what was most surprising to you from this report? What really stood out to you in the way of the findings? Yeah, so think about it, right? So Denmark is an entire country and with millions of people, homes, hospitals and industries.
37:00And we're talking about like comparable annual carbon emissions from just 403 data centers. Those are just like 400 buildings. And that's an extraordinary scale. And those facilities are just only a fraction of the industry and how the industry looks like right now. You point out in the report too, you weren't even able to capture all of the information from many data centers. So what do we not yet know about the impact that they could be having? Yeah, that's a great question. The study dates back like it's almost a year old by now. And since then, there's been like an incredible build out. We have preliminary results of newer studies that tells us there are around 1,000 hyperscale data centers.
37:50So that's just more than the double of what we reported in our study. So many more data centers, meaning the numbers in here, in actuality now, the scope of emissions could be much higher than your report suggests. Is that correct? That is correct. Yeah, that is correct. And together with the emissions, you have the water consumption and potentially also public health consequences. So in a way, we have a technology that is actually moving faster than our ability to understand its consequences. Tell us more about that, the intersection of the build-out of these data centers and the impact on public health? What are you finding there? Yeah. In this specific study, we haven't addressed yet the public health, but what's happening basically is that once you have a power demand and a power
38:39that is produced at the power plant level, not only you're producing, we're producing carbon emissions, but we're also producing adsorbs or pollutants that travel and eventually somebody breathes them. And the effects for the health are pretty dangerous. And there's plenty and ton of scientific research about this. The power pull as well, when we talk about the power use of these data centers, there are states, you point out, like Virginia, Iowa, Oregon, and Ohio that account for half of the electricity use. Why is that? And what kind of downstream impacts does that have for residents in the area? Yeah, that's correct. So basically, the states offer the infrastructure, the land and electricity that large data centers need.
39:27But there's a catch. So the benefits of this expansion aren't necessarily felt by the same communities that bear its environmental costs. So more electricity demands can mean more power plants and therefore, as we're saying, more pollution and more pressure on local infrastructure. So those consequences don't stop at the data center's fence. There are those who will argue, Gianluca, as I'm sure you've heard, that we need to build out these AI data centers, that the country has to do it to remain competitive, that it's necessary for our economy, for national security, and that the impact of that on the environment or for residents in the area is a necessary evil, in other words. Would you agree with that?
40:10Can that argument be made? Yeah, I see that. And there's a big backlash happening right now. I wouldn't call them like a necessary evil. I'm an AI researcher myself, and I have to say I'm really excited about this technology and what it can do. But there are better ways to build it. So they might cost more. They might take longer. The question is whether we're willing to prioritize doing it right over doing it first. The report, as you mentioned, is now several months old, almost a year old. There are a lot of things you don't address in it. For the average citizen to understand how this might impact their lives, what are the questions you think need to be answered next? Yeah, here's what concerns me the most.
40:56We're building this AI infrastructure faster than we can independently understand its consequences. So our study, as you were saying, was just published, like, but the data are already like over a year old. So scientific evidence shouldn't arrive after the infrastructure, and neither should, I believe, the public participation. And the main concerns would be the water consumption, the electricity, such that putting the power grid into like in strain and potentially therefore, as I was saying before, the public health consequences. That is Gianluca Widi of Harvard. He's a postdoctoral research fellow there focusing on AI and public health. Gianluca, thank you so much for your time. It's good to speak with you.
41:43Yeah, thank you so much for your time. It's good to speak with you. Yeah, thank you so much for having me. Have a good night. Bringing great art to the Great Plains and creating opportunities for artists in a region where gaining visibility and finding a market can be a challenge. That's the mission of the North Dakota Museum of Art in Grand Forks. Senior arts correspondent Jeffrey Brown visited for our arts and culture series, Canvas. A late afternoon walk through farmland in rural North Dakota. For artist Christine Kerouac, a chance to get away from the distractions of everyday life and do her work. It forces you to be alone, really alone, and alone with yourself and alone with your thoughts and alone with the corn and alone with the soybean.
42:34Alone with the corn. Alone with the corn. Because there's a lot of it. There's a lot of corn. Indeed, there is a lot of corn on the endless prairie in this area. But less known, there's also art making in an old house in McKenna set amid a tree-lined oasis. Kerouac was here to work as part of an artist residency program. What are the particular struggles for you in this region? KEROUAC KEROUAC, I think visibility is definitely one of them. But the representation of Manitoba or prairie artists can be lacking in terms of exposure. JEFFREY BROWN, The residency is run by the North Dakota Museum of Art, some 35 miles east in Grand Forks, on the campus of the University of North Dakota. Museum director Matthew Wallace. MATTHEW WALLACE, We're not MoMA. We're not LACMA. We're just a little museum in the
43:27eastern side of North Dakota just doing what we can do. But also, I think that gives us some freedom to do whatever we want to. You know, we don't have someone looking down our shoulders, and we just kind of roll with what we want to do. The building was a women's gymnasium, and we moved in here. What Wallace and his colleagues want to do is have a museum with an international reach, but that also very intentionally serves its region, which it defines broadly. A vast, sparsely populated area of the Dakotas, parts of Minnesota, Montana, and Manitoba, Canada. For Wallace, this is personal. He was raised on a ranch in rural North Dakota, feeling far from any art center. Growing up, knowing that I didn't have access to these kinds of opportunities,
44:12that it was something that I really wanted to jump on board with and make available to communities that were interested in participating. He first came to work at the museum on one of its signature programs, creating small art exhibitions and bringing them into near and far rural parts of the state. DR. JOHN B. You know, the conditions are not museum conditions. JEFFREY BROWN, Right. DR. JOHN B. So we could be... JEFFREY BROWN, Probably, to put it mildly. DR. JOHN B. Yeah, yeah. I mean, I have installed exhibitions in an empty tire store, a Masonic temple, a church, a community center. Once in a while, we would get an actual gallery. You know, there are those communities that have really worked hard and done that.
44:53But we don't want to put those limitations on them. It's more about them being able to experience it than the conditions in which it's shown. But this is also a museum that very much operates in and highlights a global art world. Its recent exhibition, Material Abstractions, featured works by artists using a wide variety of materials from South Africa, Los Angeles and points all over. Curator Ana Sigridor Arnar. I kind of like juxtaposing those different kind of think about, like, geographic diversity. And I do that a lot, because, you know, when I curate, I think about works entering into conversations with one another. JEFFREY BROWN, But here, too, Arnar says there is always an effort to highlight artists from
45:39the region, including those who have left to build careers in the larger art world, but still look back to their roots. In this show, a sculpture of deerskin and willow by Carol Hepper. A work by indigenous artist Terran Lasgun. And this by Susie J. Lee, who grew up in Grand Forks and now lives in Seattle. She returned to her home state in 2014 to teen to document the in the boom each column says arnar is a kind of drill core also with details around an individual worker she's very conscious about making these approximately the height of a human and weight my art installer can testify to that these were really heavy earlier this year arnar curated a show celebrating the 10th anniversary of another of the museum's initiatives for Northern Plains artists, its Art Maker Series,
46:32a program that offers a solo exhibition to artists who've received some attention but have never had a major show of their own. I think it can be a game changer. Having a solo exhibition in a museum is kind of the creme de la creme, and it will open doors. And I love being a part of that. For the past 15 or so years of being here in North Dakota... Micah Bloom, who teaches at Minot State University, was the first art maker to have an exhibition featuring work that captured losses in the 2011 catastrophic Minot flood, including books found in the most unlikely places. His 2015 show included large installations and other works that he says he would never otherwise have been able to make an exhibit.
47:16I mean, that is a delight for an artist to be able to imagine something and then be able to have it kind of come, like there's actually possible to do some of these things. So by getting that first opportunity through art makers, it kind of was leveraged or it kind of launched me into those other experiences. At the McKenna House residency, Winnipeg-based Christine Kerouac also felt the benefit of her new relationship with the museum, which had recently bought one of her large drawings. That financial sort of gain was something that I don't experience very often. Also developing a relationship, like a patronage with buyers that the museum has access to, you start to feel like you are part of the conversation that's going on at that museum,
48:06that you are part of it. That, of course, is the goal for all. For the PBS NewsHour, I'm Jeffrey Brown in Grand Forks, North Dakota. Finally tonight, what secrets might a 194-year-old tortoise have for humans when it comes to living longer? William Brangham examines the remarkable life of a much-loved tortoise. It's lunchtime for Jonathan. And he gets the freshest produce. Jonathan is perhaps the most famous resident of the remote South Atlantic island of St. Helena, where he's lived for most of his 194 years. JONATHAN LINCOLN, He was born before the telegraph was invented. He was born before the light bulb was invented. He was born before the telephone was invented. When Abraham Lincoln died, he was 33 years old.
49:04WILLIAM BRANGHAM Remarkably, after nearly two centuries, Jonathan remains in relatively good health, says neurologist and longevity expert Dr. Stephen Clark. Clark recently led an examination of the Earth's oldest living land animal. He is blind. He has cataracts in both eyes, but he's very mobile and still has a very good appetite and is very social still. So we expect he could live quite some more time for sure. How did you land on the idea that Jonathan would be a useful subject to study? Well, first of all, Jonathan's kind of accessible. So a lot of the long-lived species, like the bowhead whale and the Greenland shark, are kind of difficult to get to. And so knowing Jonathan was on an island was critical,
49:56and we could get access to him. And then we wanted to get a blood draw, but the island is very protective of Jonathan because he's very famous on the island. And so they wouldn't allow us to do a blood draw, but the island is very protective of Jonathan because he's very famous on the island. And so they wouldn't allow us to do a blood draw. So we had to do a buckle scrape inside of his mouth. So that's how we got the samples initially is we actually did a buckle scrape of his mouth. Giant tortoises can live 150 years or more on average, but few reliable historical or medical records about them exist, and many of them outlive the researchers studying them. And what is it, practically speaking, that you're hoping to glean
50:34from Jonathan that could be applicable to humans and longevity? Yeah, so what really Jonathan represented is the first time we were able to really look at a difference between two different individuals over 200 years. So we compared him to a five-year-old tortoise. The secret we've sort of identified with him is he seems to have somehow been able to keep his mitochondria very young. And the mitochondria are sort of like the powerhouses of the cell. They provide the energy for the cell. They also provide energy for all the repair that's done for the genome. And so by keeping his mitochondria young, we think it's allowed him to repair his genome over 190 years. And so that was really the kind of surprising finding that we found with Jonathan. Do you think that this
51:23research and all the other research that is ongoing in this field, do you think we are on the cusp of extending human life in a meaningful way? So, you know, there, there've been predictions about what the maximum lifespan is for humans. And those predictions have ranged from 115 years old to 122 years old. I'm a believer in the nonprofit that I work with is a believer that we can increase current lifespan, at least closer to that. Going beyond that, you know, I think it's going to require a lot more knowledge about the biology of aging. But I think the, you know, increasing average healthspan and lifespan to around 100, I think is very doable in the near future. In their study, published in Science This Fall, Clark and his colleagues wrote,
52:10quote, these investigations have deepened our understanding of gene markers that potentially slow aging and inhibit cancer in these species. In the meantime, one easy lesson from Jonathan. He does love his carrots. Slow down and enjoy a good meal in the sun. For the PBS NewsHour, I'm William Brangham. The secret to a long life, taking it slow. That's the NewsHour for tonight. I'm Jeff Bennett. I'm Amna Nawaz. On behalf of the entire NewsHour team, thank you for joining us.