PBS News Hour - Full Show · · Transcript & summary by WhipScribe
Summary, chapters and key takeaways for this episode are on their way; the transcript below is complete.
Our own transcript of the public episode, with a timestamp about every 90 seconds. Tap a timestamp or the link button on a paragraph to copy a link that opens this page there.
0:00Good evening. I'm Amna Nawaz. And I'm Jeff Bennett. On the NewsHour tonight, major questions remain about the nationwide grounding of flights and the travel chaos that followed, even as the Trump administration seeks to deflect responsibility. The Commerce Department works to close a loophole that made it easier for China to access AI chips. How pressure is building in the wake of the NVIDIA scandal and ahead of President Trump's meeting with his Chinese counterpart. And while some white South Africans are being welcomed to the U.S. as refugees, we report on what's drawing many of them back to their country they left years earlier. There's a sense of home here that I didn't have in the United States,
0:45that I didn't know I was missing when I was there. Welcome to the NewsHour. Three days after the federal government brought air travel nationwide to a standstill, attention is shifting to what it will take to fix the nation's air traffic control system. Investigators are still digging into what went wrong, and now a funding fight is brewing. The Trump administration is calling for tens of billions of dollars to pay for air traffic control improvements. Democrats are questioning that price tag, saying billions have already been approved for an FAA overhaul. Our White House correspondent Liz Landers begins our coverage. Planes are back in the skies tonight and air travel is slowly returning to normal.
1:37I'm the only one that's currently not delayed, fingers crossed, but I got here three hours early. After being ground to a halt nationwide for more than four hours last Friday, creating an entire weekend of travel headaches. We wound up with cancellation, rescheduled cancellation, tired, ready to go home and crawl into bed and sleep for a week. The Trump administration is now pointing the finger at a government contractor that was replacing aging copper wire communication lines to fiber at a single FAA facility in southern Arkansas. A network router there overloaded communication systems that air traffic controllers use to guide pilots with thousands of data pings every few seconds. That then may have led a network router in Texas to do the same.
2:25Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy. This was a remote facility in Arkansas, and we didn't anticipate that this could take down the system, which is why it was done during the day. Well, we're going to review our whole procedures on when we do this work, how we do this work so the system doesn't go down. Essentially, what you saw on Friday was very, very old equipment that had a heart attack. And there's more blame being placed on outdated equipment and the age of air traffic control systems altogether. I don't take any responsibility. They did a great job. Secretary Duffy, they acted incredibly. Everybody was safe. Nobody was hurt. No crashes, no nothing. And I mean, the only responsibility should be for 40 years they should have done this.
3:18This is a system that's probably on average 50 years old. Secretary Duffy is asking Congress for $50 billion to upgrade the FAA's air traffic systems. But Democrats are demanding answers about the billions already approved to do that job. My first question would be, well, what about that other 12.5 million that's sitting in your bank account right now? How about if you spend that before we put more money in that bank account? So actually, whoever's saying that, they have to actually read the bill that gave me the money. I have no money in that $12.5 billion that I can use for a new architecture for telecom. I can't build new software to manage our airplanes in the airspace because it dates back to the 1990s, but there's no money for that. Democrats on the House
3:57Transportation Committee say most of the $12.5 billion appropriated last year still hasn't been spent. Secretary Duffy said he planned to send a breakdown to lawmakers as soon as today, detailing what his $50 billion ask would pay for. For the PBS NewsHour, I'm Liz Landers. For more now, we turn to aviation correspondent Miles O'Brien and congressional correspondent Lisa Desjardins. So Miles, let's start with you. You've been reporting on this since Friday, speaking with your contacts. Help us understand more about what happened and what you make of the official explanations for what went wrong. Amna, the whole thing is kind of stunning, that one simple router could bring down the system in
4:38the way it did. But basically, a crew with the contractor L3 Harris was installing a new router, which was part of the overall effort to put in fiber optic cable in the system, part of the modernization effort. Evidently, that router was not configured properly. And so it sent out a broadcast messages, thousands of requests for information. They call them pings. Thousands every second. And it's like somebody yelling nonstop in a room and nobody else can be heard. And that's what caused the network to break down. 17 of 20 en route air traffic control centers were affected with static and potentially inaccurate information. And so when you don't know and when clarity means life and death situations, out of an abundance of caution, they issued that ground stop. But aviation, Amna,
5:33is built on redundancy. And the fact that this could happen, this one box in one place could cause this, really speaks to a much bigger systemic problem, a systems engineering problem, which needs to be addressed. Lisa, meanwhile, you've been looking into the funding piece of this. We've heard Secretary Duffy say repeatedly it's about a lack of funding. Is that what your reporting has shown you? I'm waiting for responses from the administration to my questions. But based on my research and speaking with my sources, no, this is not about congressional funding. It is true that our FAA and our system needs more funding for some things, but the modernization effort, President Trump has gotten what he's asked for. Let's look at these requests when I went back through them. In the past two
6:14years, President Trump's budgets have requested some $5.5 billion to modernize FAA facilities and engineering, including that copper wiring. Congress has funded far more than that, $14.4 billion in two different bills. And instead, in my research, it turns out in September, some of the holdup of this funding is from the president's own OMB, which has put a pause on $5 billion of modernization funding. It cannot be spent until next year. I did ask for comment and context on this, but it shows that there is money flowing. Something else that shows this is the map of these repairs. The FAA has this map on its website of all the modernization efforts going on. That certainly speaks to the fact that there is current
6:55funding flowing. So, Lisa, the fact that Secretary Duffy is now requesting another $30 to $50 billion more, what would that be for? Right. It's the right question. And one thing I wanted to find out is, has this program to exchange fiber optics in for the copper wire, is that fully funded? So I looked back at what the request has been. Here's what President Trump requested initially for this in his budget last year. He asked for $1 billion. That's it for this transfer from copper to fiber optics. So then the question is, Secretary Duffy, what is he talking about when he says $30 billion or $50 billion? There is a proposal in Congress for $30 billion for the FAA. That is called Modern Skies.
7:33But here's what's in it. $10 billion of it for air traffic control. Most of that, actually, though, is not for this kind of fiber optic switch. There's another $10 billion for terminals at three airports, $10 billion more for control towers, more infrastructure. All in all, basically, this $30 billion right now is really not for this same modernization project. It's for other things that might be necessary, but Secretary Duffy at best is conflating things. So, Miles, there are some other new concerns being raised here, referencing back to a GAO report, a Government Accountability Office report in September that was warning these kinds of upgrades need to be paced properly. They need to be staffed properly. There was concern that the FAA plans weren't specific enough. Do we know
8:15more about that if those concerns were ignored or overlooked here? Not a pretty picture, Amna. And as Congress and all of us consider throwing more money at this problem, we should think about how it is currently being spent, including that box problem on Friday the 13th and how that happened. The GAO discovered a modernization campaign that has no real central strategy. There are, Amna, nearly 12,000 individual project schedules without it all being integrated together. Couple that with the fact that the FAA has had systems engineering expertise degraded steadily over the past decade or so, and then throw in the doge cuts. A couple of years ago, additional workforce cuts to the technical and engineering enterprises at the FAA.
9:08If you're really serious about modernizing, why would those things be cut? So the FAA really needs to rebuild its engineering ethos, its brain trust from the inside out. Lisa, meanwhile, you've been talking to your contacts on Capitol Hill. What's the reaction to last week's nationwide ground stop bid? Quite a lot happening. Secretary Duffy actually has been on the phone lines. I have confirmed that he spoke to Democratic House leader Hakeem Jeffries tonight. He is planning to speak to all Senate Republicans at their lunch tomorrow. I know they have a lot of questions for him, especially about not just why he is blaming Congress when they funded these projects, but why he's asking for more money. In general, there is sympathy for the FAA here from Congress.
9:50However, I think Secretary Duffy in this moment has undermined it because he is asking for other funds. Miles, before I let you go, I have to ask, I know you've been looking into how this all works in Canada. In a nutshell, what have you found and what kind of questions does that raise? In 1996, Amna, Canada moved its air traffic control operations separate from its regulatory safety body. They call it NAV Canada. The government still has oversight authority, still regulates aviation safety, but there is a nonprofit private public partnership which operates the air traffic system. And what that does is it enables them to issue bonds. It allows the steady stream of funding, and it allows that entity to charge a fee for aircraft using the
10:40system. It's a controversial subject. It's been discussed in Washington in the past. Private pilots hate it. The airlines generally like it. It'll be interesting to see if out of this, a healthy debate on this subject comes to the fore, because I think it should. Miles O'Brien, Lisa Desjardins, thank you both. Welcome. In the day's other headlines, President Trump left for Asia today, where he'll meet with regional leaders in the Philippines, followed by talks with Chinese President Xi Jinping and Russia's Vladimir Putin later this week. Speaking to reporters as he left the White House this morning, Mr. Trump said the three leaders would discuss the Iran war and denuclearization. They're due to meet in the southern city of Shenzhen on Thursday for what will be their
11:39first ever trilateral summit. President Trump says he'll also bring up Russia's war in Ukraine, telling reporters that he thinks Putin is softening his stance towards the war. I think he's backing down a little bit. I think he could be tougher. I think he could be a lot tougher, frankly. I think he's backing down. I think he'd like to, frankly, I think he'd like to see it finished. Mr. Trump also said that he may meet with North Korean leader Kim Jong-un during his time in China, though no further details have been provided. Meantime, Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky warned today that North Korea is providing Russia with ballistic missiles, and he called on Europe to boost its support in response.
12:23Ukraine also needs clear parity so that we can respond to the Russian threat on equal terms. During his evening address, Zelensky also said that Ukrainian officials spoke with U.S. envoys Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner again today on prospects for ending the war. Ukraine has scaled up its aerial attacks in recent months. Russia said today it intercepted more than 1,300 drones, making it Ukraine's biggest aerial assault of the war. The U.S. Supreme Court is declining to hear a challenge to Maryland's ban on guns in so-called sensitive places. The decision leaves in place a block on firearms in places like health care facilities, schools, and public transportation. And it comes as the justices prepare to hear a separate case on state laws banning AR-15s and other semi-automatic firearms.
13:12In another decision today, the high court rejected the Trump administration's effort to cancel research funding at the University of California. The justices left in place a lower court ruling that the administration violated researchers' free speech rights by terminating grants over objections to diversity, equity, and inclusion initiatives. Lindsay Clancy will be tried for a second time in the killings of her three young children, with a judge in Massachusetts setting a trial date for late March. Her first murder trial ended in a mistrial in September after a loan holdout prevented the jury from reaching a unanimous decision. Clancy has been charged with three counts of first-degree murder. Her lawyers have argued she was suffering from severe
13:56postpartum psychosis when she carried out the killings in 2023 and cannot be held criminally responsible. Customers at some of the country's largest banks reported difficulty accessing their accounts online today. According to the website Down Detector, users reported problems at Bank of America, Chase, U.S. Bank, and Wells Fargo, among others. The Associated Press is reporting that a technical issue at JPMorgan Chase was initially to blame, and that then affected other banks. In a statement, Chase says the problem is not the result of a cyber attack. The disruption follows a major outage at Microsoft last week that affected services like Teams and Outlook. In entertainment news, Robert Pattinson is trading Batman's cape for James Bond's tuxedo.
14:55The 40-year-old British actor was named as the next 007 in a social media post, ending years of speculation over who would succeed Daniel Craig. Pattinson, who first rose to fame in the Twilight films, becomes the seventh actor to play Bond, adding another iconic franchise to her resume that already includes roles in Batman, Harry Potter and Doom. Filming on the next James Bond movie is expected to start next year. And British singer-songwriter Ray leads the field of 2027 Grammy nominations. Ray earned 11 nominations, including for Record, Song, and Album of the Year. That ties a record for female artists set by Beyonce, who now has a staggering 100 career Grammy nominations. The classically trained
15:46Spanish singer Rosalia earned nine nominations, while Miranda Lambert, Olivia Rodrigo, Phoebe Bridgers, and newcomer Ella Langley all tied with seven. The 2027 Grammys take place in February. On Wall Street today, stocks crumbled to start the week as NVIDIA led another sell-off in tech shares. The Dow Jones Industrial Average dropped more than 700 points. The Nasdaq plunged nearly two and a half percent. The S&P 500 fell for its third straight session. And the oldest known survivor of the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor has died. Freeman Johnson was just 21 years old, serving aboard the USS St. Louis when Japanese forces attacked on December 7, 1941. In an interview with the Associated Press earlier
16:32this year, Johnson recalled being below deck, unaware of the attack as it unfolded. He was among some 87,000 American military personnel stationed on Oahu that day. With his passing, fewer than a dozen known survivors of the attack remain. Freeman Johnson was 106 years old. Still to come on the NewsHour, Tamara Keith and Amy Walter break down the latest political headlines, a look at why many white South Africans are repatriating, and a new documentary chronicles the history of crime and punishment in the U.S. This is the PBS NewsHour from the David M. Rubenstein Studio at WETA in Washington, headquarters of PBS News. The Trump administration announced new rules today to further restrict China's access to advanced chips for the use of AI.
17:33It comes as questions are mounting about how the Commerce Department allowed loopholes for chip exports, including for the most advanced ones known as Blackwell. The rule puts new restrictions on overseas data centers so that China cannot access advanced computing power remotely. And it's designed to counter possible smuggling by putting new curbs on Singapore, Malaysia, Thailand, Indonesia and Brazil. Just before he left for his trip to China, President Trump told reporters he was not opposed to having former NVIDIA CEO Jensen Huang return to the company. And he was asked about the risks of their relationship. Jensen, as you know, wanted to sell to China, and the only thing he was able to sell to China were chips that were sort of obsolete,
18:11a little bit like our avionics, our aviation equipment. He wasn't allowed to sell the Blackwell or any of that, but no, it's a different approach, just a different approach. How do you imagine? You know, we're heading to China, And I don't think you want to insult China just before you get. To help us sort through all of this, I'm joined now by Liza Tobin. She's the former China director for the National Security Council in the first Trump and Biden administrations, and currently managing director at Garno Global. That's a geopolitical risk advisory firm. Liza, welcome back to the NewsHour. Thanks for being with us. Thanks for having me, Amna. So let's just look at that new rule that was issued this morning. What exactly
18:54is its practical impact? Does it close the loopholes that it's intended to? Yeah, this is a really important rule and it's a long time coming. So as you explained at the top, you know, the U.S. and China are in a race to lead in AI and the key variable there is compute or these advanced AI chips that are primarily designed by NVIDIA and made at TSMC in Taiwan. And so after the Biden administration back in 2022 and 2023 restricted the export of these chips to China directly. This sort of shadow trade developed where Chinese AI developers started accessing them remotely in places like Malaysia, Indonesia and Singapore. So that's essentially a gray area. It was technically legal. And there's been growing
19:45pressure from national security professionals and from the Congress to close this loophole. And the Commerce Department just this morning has put out a rule to do just that. How do you look at this, though? Is this a matter of an administration trying to save face or is this going to have a real effect? Yeah, so clearly President Trump is on his way to Beijing. He's been anticipating this meeting with Xi Jinping for a long time. And so he's not, you know, throwing Jensen Huang or his Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick under the bus or anything like that. But he has been clear for a number of months now that his policy is it's all right to sell China the so-called H200 chip, which is this more older generation, but still very good AI processor.
20:35But he said no Blackwells to China. Up until recently, Blackwells were NVIDIA's most advanced chips. So he's been clear about that. And so for months and months, there has been this gap between what he said the policy was and what China was able to do remotely by accessing these chips kind of through the back door in these other countries. So today, the Commerce Department closed that gap. And what's interesting is, of course, that there's kind of a disagreement playing out in public where most of the president's cabinet members, of course, that there's kind of a disagreement playing out in public where most of the president's cabinet members, Secretary Besson, the trade representative, Jameson Greer, you had the director of national intelligence, Clayton, and many others,
21:17who are all on one side, clearly advising the president, you have to put out a rule. And so that's what actually happened today. And the Secretary of Commerce, Howard Lutnick, was kind of the lone man left out who was wanting to keep this loophole open. Liza, can I just underscore something here in terms of what made its way to China? Because we heard the president say there that the chips that made it to China were largely obsolete, that they did not put national security at risk, essentially. Do we know that to be true? No, I think the president has probably gotten some bad briefings. We know that Jensen Fong for a long time had a lot of access to the president. He was essentially acting like the president's chief technology officer.
21:59And what he told the president last year essentially was that these H-200s were kind of not that great of a chip. And it's just not the case. They actually are really good chips. They're far superior to anything that the Chinese can fabricate themselves at Huawei, at SMIC, at their chip making facilities in China. So even though they're not NVIDIA's most cutting edge chips, they are good chips and they are advancing China's AI ambitions. Nonetheless, that's where the president drew the line. He said, H200s, okay, Blackwell chips, not okay. And we know that there's a lot of evidence that there have been these shell companies like Megaspeed, the company run by this woman, Alice Huang, has been facilitating the diversion of
22:47these chips, the smuggling of Blackwell's and other advanced chips into China directly or into these other countries. Alice Huang, of course, Hugh Jensen Huang had admitted to having an affair with. Liza, you mentioned Lutnick being on the other side of other administration officials on this. Help us understand exactly what he's being accused of here. There's been some reporting that he wanted to weaken the chip rules because it could impact data centers in Southeast Asia that were represented by his former firm. There's a lot we don't yet know, but what should we understand about this? What this looks like is a severe and massive case of regulatory capture where Howard Lutnick spent a lot of time with Judson Huang.
23:31And it really looks like NVIDIA had direct influence blocking different regulations, pressuring the Department of Commerce to drop investigations into things like chip smuggling. What we should remember is that commerce is an agency that promotes international trade, but it also has a very important function as a law enforcement agency. And it needs to enforce these laws that say where the chips can go and where they shouldn't go. And it's very clear that there were multiple occasions where information about chip smuggling and other illegal behavior was presented to the Secretary of Commerce, and he didn't take any steps. And that, you know, I think where Congress is really going to be drilling into is what is the link to Howard Lutnick's former firm, Cantor Fitzgerald, which was benefiting from this data center trade
24:25in Southeast Asia. Before I let you go briefly, do you see Jensen Huang coming back as NVIDIA CEO? Well, the NVIDIA board, I think, just put out a statement recently. They said, hey, that's not what we're focused on right now. They're focused on the investigation. So it's not just Congress that's going to be kind of forcing more information about what did Jensen Huang know when, what did he hide, what did he obscure? There's a lot more coming out and the board doesn't seem to be indicating that they want him back anytime soon. That is Liza Tobin of Garneau Global joining us tonight. Liza, thank you so much for your time. Thank you. President Trump kicked off his trip to Asia today ahead of a planned meeting with the leaders of China and Russia later this week. But what the summit might accomplish remains unclear.
25:26And that's where we start tonight with our Politics Monday duo. That's Amy Walter of the Cook Political Report with Amy Walter and Tamara Keith of NPR. It's great to see you both. Good to be here. So President Trump is on his way to Asia. He's seeking economic deals and nuclear talks with Russia and China. Tam, China says it's not going to participate in these denuclearization talks. And the war in Ukraine may not fully be on the agenda. So what's the president hoping to accomplish here? I mean, he likes meeting face to face with his fellow leaders. And he will get the image that he wants, which will be Trump and Xi and Putin all together, these three global powers, in some ways, that's all he wants.
26:09Often the president doesn't come into these meetings with a very clear agenda. He was asked repeatedly today about things. Will you bring this up? And he's, well, I may talk to Xi about NVIDIA or he wants to talk about Ukraine and Iran and denuclearization and economic issues. But it's not clear that there are any sort of deliverables or specific end goals, because so much of the way President Trump does foreign policy is about his gut and about his feeling for the leaders. And so whatever the goals of the people around the president going into these meetings, different outcomes may come out or there may be no notable outcomes at all. And in administrations past, if there are going to be no deliverables, you don't take the meeting,
26:57right? So for President Trump, what's the political value of a summit like this? I think the political value is exactly as Tam laid out, which is it's more about the optics than almost anything else. I mean, there is something about a lame duck president who has just lost midterm elections, not particularly popular at home, going abroad to show strength. Other presidents have done similar things. And so standing with these other leaders showing basically, hey, I'm still the president of the United States of America. I can still do things regardless of what the actual outcome is. Meantime, you've got President Trump. He's blaming the Biden administration for the problems plaguing the FAA. The transportation secretary, Sean Duffy, says the agency needs more money.
27:41Democrats have already they're pointing to money that was already appropriated that hasn't been spent. What's actually standing in the way of Democrats and Republicans working together to fix these issues, Tan? Democrats are not the only ones pointing out that there was a lot of money already appropriated to the FAA that isn't getting spent. Senator John Thune has also noted that. And so I think that this meeting that's going to happen, this lunch meeting with Republicans and Secretary Duffy, will be important in Duffy trying to resolve concerns and potentially move towards convincing Republicans that they should actually get on board with his request, which ballooned from $30 billion to $50 billion basically
28:22overnight. I don't know what it will take to get them to work together. Obviously, there are millions of inconvenienced travelers who are upset, who want solutions. I think that we're going to see hearings. We're going to, that there will be a lot more investigating of exactly what happened and why the money that's been appropriated hasn't been spent in a cohesive way. And I think that's the issue here, too. I mean, we've talked a lot over the course of these last two years about Congress sort of being sidelined and the empowered president and executive branch. And the breakdown has also been on appropriations, right? These pocket recisions basically saying, well, I know that Congress said we have to spend this money, but we really don't want to spend it. So there's no trust
29:09between even before we turn the page in 2027 to a Democratic controlled Congress, this breakdown between Congress and the president, it actually matters in terms of not just what gets what members of Congress want to spend, but then whether the administration actually spends it on the things they said it should go to. Well, as we turn the page to 2027, I can't believe it's almost upon us. I almost said 28. So be careful. That's where our heads are already. Well, we've got this battle over Senate Democratic leadership that is heating up. You've got Senator Chris Van Hollen. He's now challenging Chuck Schumer to lead Senate Democrats, who Schumer has done that for nearly a decade. Here's Van Hollen yesterday talking with our friend over at CNN, Dan Abash.
29:55This is not about one person or any one individual. This really is a response to the call of the voters who clearly rejected Donald Trump and his awful policies, but they haven't fully hired the Democrats. They've given us a chance. And I think we need to earn their trust. And I think that begins by not going back to business as usual, not going back to the status quo. So Van Hollen is presenting himself as the candidate of change. You have a number of progressive senators and new senators elect who are backing him. How compelling is his argument that he represents a break from business as usual? It's a challenge for a 67-year-old career politician who has been in leadership in the House. He ran the Democratic efforts to get senators elected in the Senate.
30:46Like he is someone who is pretty establishment. Now, in recent years, he has been more progressive in his policy, in his language, in particular towards funding for Israel. But he is not, you know, like a fresh young person coming in to lead the Democrats. He would just be a different person coming to lead the Democrats. And he has even in interviews not fully distinguished himself from Schumer on policy in a lot of areas, agrees with him that impeachment isn't the right path right now, various other items like that. So looking at the electorate, is there evidence that Democrats want a leader, whether it's Van Hollen or someone else, to move more to the left? Or do they want someone who's going to be aggressive about trying to hold President Trump and the administration
31:42accountable? Yeah, I think there's a split. I think that there are many Democrats, if you look at the exit polls, people who identified as Democrats really want to see more efforts basically to hold Trump accountable. And then if you look at the many new members who come in who had to win with independents and some Trump voters, those are the ones who say we want some actual deliverables. The most important thing, though, I think about this whole fight is that it really is a fight that for today is interesting, but it's not going to be consequential for very long because the real fight will be in 2027 and early 2028 for the Democratic nomination. That's who the leader of the Democratic Party will be. It's not who controls the Senate Democrats or the House
32:23Democrats. It's who the nominee will ultimately be who sets the course for Democrats. It's interesting you say that because right now there is no standard bearer. That's right. That's why there's so much focus on a Chuck Schumer and a Hakeem Jeffries. Exactly. Because they will be the spokespeople for the Democratic Party for now, for a relatively short period of time. And what Van Hollen is saying is that voters are demanding a better spokesperson. Tamara Keith, Amy Walter. Happy Monday, friends. Thank you. Good to see you. In South Africa, at least 17 people were killed in two separate shootings over the weekend, a grim reminder of the violence in a nation with one of the world's highest murder rates.
33:13President Trump has long alleged that the violence has targeted South Africa's white minority, and his administration has carved out an exception for white South Africans to a strict ban on all refugee admissions. Of the just over 16,000 refugees admitted through the end of September, all but five were from South Africa. However, as Fred de Samlazo reports, that migration is becoming a two-way trend. The next moment, the free guy stands there with pistols against my head. On June 1st, armed men broke into Nico Struyck's home, and when they forced him to take them to his brother Steve's house next door. And they opened this door. Yeah. And they shoot. He was laying on the floor. And this man just go on with shooting.
34:05Here you can see where the bullets go through. I get like a blank. He's still in shock at the loss and gets regular check-ins from neighbors who patrol a sprawling swath of farmland just outside South Africa's capital, Pretoria, trying to fill in for a scant police presence. They speak Afrikaans. Afrikaners are descendants of Dutch settlers who came in the 17th century and part of a white minority that ruled this country under strict racial segregation laws until 1994, when democratic elections brought majority rule. This is genocide. I mean, that's what that is. It's targeting a group of people. Right-wing media outlets, including this episode last year from the Tucker Carlson show, have for years called attention to attacks on white South African farms,
34:55a cause embraced by President Trump, most prominently in a tense exchange with South Africa's president at the White House earlier this year. These are all people that recently got killed. Amid a near-blanket ban on all refugee admissions, the president carved out an exception for Afrikaners. South Africa's government rejects the allegation, and even Nico Sturweg sees things differently. So black farmers have the same problem? Yeah, yeah, same problem. Then there's others that just go to get wealth, to get money, some weapons. Would you say that it's a white genocide? No. Ernst van Zyl is with AfriForum. So we do press conferences here. A right-leaning Africana civic group, primarily responsible for bringing Washington's attention to the farm attacks. At the same time, we also say that it is a serious, unique crime in South Africa.
35:50It's undeniable that many farm murders are motivated by a hatred, not just robbery. He blamed some of the violence on Julius Malema, a far-left politician who has led crowds in chanting, Kill the Boer, a term often used to describe Afrikaners. Whites also face discrimination in hiring, he adds, and the prospect of their land being seized without compensation. But AfroForum's critics say those claims are exaggerated. Whites make up about 7% of the population, but the government's last land audit found they owned nearly three-quarters of farmland owned by individuals. And white unemployment stands at about 9%, compared with 37% for black South Africans. These critics add that poverty and inequality help fuel South Africa's high rate of violent crime and that it affects everyone.
36:46People who suffer the most from this sort of thing tend to be poor and black. Nikki Falkoff is a professor of media studies at the University of Witwatersrand in Johannesburg. So framing violence perpetrated against white people as some sort of exceptional thing that happens to white people, is not only untrue, it's also incredibly self-serving. By Afroforum's count for 2025, there were 29 murders, a drop from 55 in 2021. By comparison, South Africa recorded 23,642 murders between January and December 2025, averaging 65 murders every day. Since July, Falkoff notes, the bodies of a dozen black women have been found in the Johannesburg area. Are we to say, you know, all black women have no option but to pack up and immigrate and move to a different country because of the violence they face?
37:43Van Zyl says his group does not advocate immigration. When it comes to the refugee program of President Trump, it's good that it exists, but AfriForum is going to stick to our mission of building a future here for those who choose to stay in South Africa. Not only are people choosing to stay, there's also a reverse migration story here. Many who left in the years after apartheid are returning. Natasha Robson Lovato was 12 when her family left in 1994, the year apartheid ended. Her engineer father, Howard Robson, got a job in America. It was a good career move, he says, but uncertainty here was a factor. The situation here in the couple of years prior to 1994 was fairly tumultuous in terms of there were protests
38:35and kids were going on school tours and you were worried about the bus being stopped along the road, things like that. And we wanted to give the kids the opportunities that we didn't think they might not get here. Three decades later, after Robson Lovato built a life and business in Seattle, she helped pull the family home, including her American husband, Jason. My history was here, and I needed to spend time on that land. And so that became a big draw for me. There's a sense of home here that I didn't have in the United States that I didn't know I was missing when I was there. They now farm pecans in a large family compound that encloses their home and those of her brother and her parents.
39:30For many South Africans returning, their decision has been informed by a combination of cost of living and quality of life considerations. Housing is much more affordable here, as is child care, household health, and health care. All this in a cultural comfort zone. We are fifth generation white South Africans. Drum magazine. For arts writer Petra Mason, who returned after two decades in New York and Miami, culture was part of the pull home. South Africa is the type of country that is so complex and so interesting. The draw to be part of the story is enormous. She took us to a jazz Sunday at a nearby sculpture park. We're surrounded by contemporary artworks by mostly South Africans. Welcome, please come in.
40:17Let's take a look here. Rory O'Hagan, a Johannesburg luxury real estate agent, says business has risen sharply from returning South Africans since 2023. Space for a double-door fridge. His colleague Meg Wilson recently returned from Panama and is apartment hunting herself. It's beautiful. It really is. At about $400,000, this airy three-bedroom model costs a fraction of what most returnees from Western countries are used to, she says. I looked recently at a flat in London. It was just over 400,000 pounds, and it was tiny. It was, you know, a tiny little studio. We've seen a lot of younger families. There's a cross-section of people that are coming into South Africa. We talk about the brain regain.
41:06There are no reliable government figures showing how many white South Africans are returning, but this Facebook group intended for returnees is one proxy. When I first joined this group, there were just under 2,000 members. And that was three years ago. The group now has 27,000 members. And that was three years ago. The group now has 27,000 members. For those who come back, South Africa's problems are real, but they don't see a country they need to flee. I worried more about her walking to Seattle by herself than I ever have a part going to Joe Bird. What I'm hearing a lot more about is that people are considering South Africa a safe place to be with all that's happening in the rest of the world.
41:56For the PBS NewsHour, I'm Fred de Sam Lazaro in Hoteng Province, South Africa. And Fred's reporting is a partnership with the Under-Told Stories Project at Santa Clara University. Well, global health authorities are expected to announce tomorrow that the U.S. has lost its status as a country where measles is eliminated, a public health milestone it achieved 26 years ago. This past year, the number of cases in the U.S. doubled, making it the worst year in three decades. That was the focus of our newest episode of Horizons with William Brangham. Here's part of that discussion. Dr. Scheffner, I'm curious if someone is hearing all of this, worried about perhaps this very big undercount of measles. If they get vaccinated, how much protection does
42:47that offer you? Is this a bulletproof, 100% protection? How much does it give you? It's close to bulletproof. It's among the best vaccines we have. If you take the two recommended doses, you will get somewhere between 97 and 98% likelihood of protection for the rest of your life. And even if you do happen to get a breakthrough infection, namely you're vaccinated, you're exposed, and you still get an infection, your illness will be milder. So this is a terrific vaccine in terms of effectiveness, and it's also terrifically safe. There are very few adverse events associated with this vaccine. It's been used in the literal billions of doses around the world for 50 years now. Jessica Malati-Rivera, the HHS Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. plays a complicated role here.
43:47At times, when asked about measles outbreaks, he has said, yes, go get vaccinated. It will protect you. But in his previous career and in his current role in the federal government, he has done an enormous amount to sow distrust about vaccines and say that they are dangerous, they are harming people, that the government is not being square with people about this. How much responsibility do you place at the leadership of the federal government right now? I think he and the federal government bear a huge amount of responsibility because I think that this movement or this unprecedented outbreak didn't necessarily start at the beginning of it. There were seeds that were planted years and years ago by RFK Jr. himself and by people from
44:31his organization, his former organization, Children's Health Defense, and many like both of those actors who were sowing seeds of doubt about the MMR vaccine safety, the MMR vaccine's effectiveness, even the MMR vaccine's utility. And I think he would even say today that the only way to prevent the virus, the infection, is through the MMR vaccine. But what he's also saying is that it's okay to get it, and it's okay to suffer for it because it's just a mild disease. And this is where I think that the normalization of disease has become so ubiquitous among people who are anti-MMR vaccine because they've been sold a lie. They've been sold a lie that it is something that can be treated with vitamin A and it cannot,
45:15that it's something that is typical for childhood when, you know, I'm grateful that I live in a time where my children don't have to experience a disease that was so prevalent back in the 80s. Even varicella is an example of that, that we have the tools to prevent them. Suffering can be avoided. It should not be the expectation simply because there are ways in which you could care for somebody. Now, it's also important to note there is no known specific treatment for measles. It's all supportive care. And some kids will get pneumonia. And pneumonia is the number one cause of measles-related death. Some kids may get enceph is the number one cause of measles related death some kids may get encephalitis that is a very dangerous swelling of the brain that can cause
45:49a lot of permanent damage including hearing loss and blindness and other impairments it can cause complications years after recovery and a rare encephalitis called sspe can cause immune amnesia these are not benign complications of a disease that is almost nearly entirely preventable through two doses of that vaccine. And RFK Jr. absolutely knows this. And it is the responsibility of the administration and our HHS secretary to make it extremely clear that kids do not have to be getting a very preventable disease. And you can watch that full episode of Horizons and more on our YouTube page or wherever you get your podcasts. A new PBS documentary, Crime and Punishment in America, that starts tonight,
46:32traces the evolution of policing, prisons, and the criminal justice system across four centuries of American history. Directed by acclaimed filmmaker Lynn Novick and executive produced by Ken Burns, the four-part series examines how Americans have defined crime, determined punishment, and wrestled with fundamental questions of justice and fairness. Thanks for being here. Thanks so much for having me. So your film traces the history of crime and punishment in America, but it also speaks directly to the debates that are happening right now. What does that history help us understand about the current moment? Well, one of the things that we learned in now. What does that history help us understand about
47:05the current moment? Well, one of the things that we learned in trying to trace this history back, how did we get here? How did America become the world's leading incarcerator? Is that you really have to go back to colonial times and understand that we inherited a system of punishment and laws from England. And over time, we've tinkered with it, but we've really pretty much always been focused on punishment as a way to address crime. Even though we kind of know that the root cause of crime is something we should be addressing, we tend to focus really on what happens after someone commits a crime. What do we do to them to make sure this isn't going to happen again? And I think our approach has been proven to be deeply flawed. Throughout the film, we hear from people who have been incarcerated alongside people who have worked within the justice system.
47:50What do those personal accounts yield that history and archives cannot? That's such a great question because I think when we're talking about justice, we're talking about these abstractions, these kind of faceless institutions, statistics. And it's really important to remember that, put all that aside, we're talking about human beings, men, women, and children who have been incarcerated, who have worked in these places, who have tried to make them better. It's all about people. So for us, it's always been about finding the individuals who have borne witness and who we can learn from. You know, what did this really mean if you were convicted of a crime in 1870 and sent to a chain gang, sent to a prison? What would that have been like for you?
48:29You mentioned that the U.S. has the highest incarceration rate in the world. At one point, as the film notes, the country held roughly 20 percent of the world's incarcerated population. How did we get to that point? Yeah, I wish I had an easy answer. And one of the things that's really challenging about this topic is that it's very diffuse. We have 50 states and the federal government. We have 3,000 counties. We have 18,000 plus police departments. And each of these entities kind of operates independently. And all of them contribute to the way that we do justice and what our prisons look like and how people end up there and what happens to them when they're there. And so what it means is that you can think about a big picture,
49:09but you have to take it in small pieces, if that makes sense. And we've made a lot of small decisions, as the law professor, legal scholar James Foreman tells us in the film. And there's no one reason that we got here. And so to change it, it's going to take a lot of small decisions to kind of undo the over-incarceration that we've been facing. so to change it, it's going to take a lot of small decisions to kind of undo the over-incarceration that we've been facing. But we are out of whack with every other peer nation by orders of magnitude. And it didn't happen overnight. It happened over about a 20, 25-year period. Yeah. What surprised you the most when producing this film? Is there something that
49:40really struck you or challenged what you believe to be true about the criminal justice system? Well, the first thing that surprised me and a lot of things did surprise me was that before the American Revolution, there were no prisons or penitentiaries as we think of them today. If you got accused of a crime, you would be put in jail until your case was settled and then you'd be taken out and you'd be punished. And punished can mean executed, branded, whipped, tortured, put in the stocks or pillory, and then you would go home if you were still alive. And so that was a pretty barbaric, horrendous, just brutal system of punishment. And around the time of the revolution, our founding fathers, many of them believed we should do something better. We're a
50:21new kind of government, we're a republic with citizens who deserve better treatment. And so they came up with the idea that we should build a place called a penitentiary, where people would go if they'd committed a crime and been found guilty to repent. And they would be there for a period of time, and they would be returning to society reformed. That idea that incarceration was both punishment and rehabilitation was a new idea and Americans invented it. And I think one of the most important things we need to do is to really ask ourselves the hardest questions. How would I feel if someone I loved was harmed or killed? A horrible crime had happened to our family. What would I want to have happen to the person who did that?
51:00And flip it around and say, how would I feel if someone I loved committed a horrible crime? What would I want to have happen to them? And if you can try to see it from every perspective, then we can get to the deeper question of, do we believe in redemption for everybody? Do we believe in second chances? Do we believe in hope? Do we believe in human dignity? Do we believe in the things that our founding fathers and our national creed tells us we believe in, equal justice? And if we do, then I think we have to really challenge ourselves to think about whether we're doing justice, criminal justice, in the right way. You've screened this film for the incarcerated. What has the response been? Yeah, it's been really, it's been a profound experience for all of us who worked on the film to take a highlight reel into prisons and jails around the country and share the film with them.
51:51We have a scene about correction officers. We have a scene about victims and what they experience and what they do and don't get from the system. We have scenes about incarceration and what that's been like over our history. And engaging in conversations with people who are, in fact, confined right now has been really deep. It's been like over our history. And engaging in conversations with people who are, in fact, confined right now has been really deep. It's been deep. We've heard people say it's hard to watch. It's painful. It's making them feel angry at a system that they feel hasn't treated them fairly. And also a lot of regret for mistakes they've made that got them into the situation that they're in. And also that
52:25they didn't know this history, as I didn't when I started working on this project. So I think knowledge is power. And knowing where we came from and how we got here is helpful to go forward. And that's been the same conversation we've been having with people inside our prisons and jails. PBS documentary, Crime and Punishment in America. And Novick, always good to speak with you. Thank you so much for having me. It was a pleasure. Crime and Punishment in America premieres tonight at 8 p.m. Eastern, 7 p.m. Central here on PBS. Check your local listings. And that is the NewsHour for tonight. I'm Amna Nawaz. And I'm Jeff Bennett. For all of us here at the NewsHour, thanks for spending part of your evening with us. you