podcasts / Novara Live / episode
Novara Live cover art
podcast
📅 2026-11-12 ⏱ 60 min episode · ~2 min read 📝 Transcript · 11,319 words

Labour Review Says Cut Disability Benefits for Under-25s

Novara Live · · Transcript & summary by WhipScribe

A left-wing panel takes apart a welfare review that would hit young disabled people, and makes a concrete case for taxing extreme wealth instead.

In this episodeAlan MilburnAndy BurnhamKeir StarmerNick RobinsonDisability Rights UKPedro SánchezGadi EisenkotBenjamin NetanyahuNasser HospitalUniversal CreditPIPTenants' Union of Catalonia

▸Chapters

Tap a chapter to open that moment in the transcript; the link to it is copied for you.

Transcribe your links. Paste a YouTube, Google Drive or podcast link and WhipScribe gives you the transcript. Transcribe a link →

▸Notable quotes

“every survey of young people's attitudes shows that the overwhelming majority of young people want to work” Dahlia Gebril · at 17:57 — open in the transcript →

▸What this episode covers

The youth unemployment review led by Alan Milburn, due to be published next Tuesday, is reported to propose barring some under-25s from the health element of universal credit and from PIP, with a new youth allowance paid at the standard universal credit rate instead. The hosts, Helena and Dahlia Gebril, argue the changes are less radical than presented. PIP already scales support to the severity of a disability, so a new Additional Cost Allowance looks like the same thing under a new name. Disability campaigners warn the cuts would push young disabled people into poverty and out of jobs they have fought to keep.

On the causes of youth unemployment, Dahlia Gebril points to global austerity, a 60% cut to youth centres in Britain, and AI wiping out entry-level jobs, rather than young people's attitudes. She ties the problem to regional inequality in the de-industrialised north and says the welfare debate lets the Labour government avoid taxing extreme wealth. The alternative they put forward is a state-backed job guarantee and a 2% tax on asset wealth above £10 million, which they say could raise £24 billion a year.

The episode also covers a Conservative leader's welfare speech, which the hosts call misleading about what PIP does, and the Israeli military's account of a strike on Gaza's Nasser Hospital that killed at least six people. The show closes with Spain's general strike over housing, where a tenants' union spokesperson says the protests shifted the migration debate toward wages and rents.

▸Labour Review Says Cut Disability Benefits for Under-25s on Novara Live: the answers

What did Dahlia Gebril say about Alan Milburn's youth unemployment review?

Dahlia Gebril argued that blaming young people's attitudes for unemployment is the oldest story in the book. She said every survey shows most young people want to work, and that the focus on attitudes lets the Labour government avoid taxing extreme wealth.

“every survey of young people's attitudes shows that the overwhelming majority of young people want to work”Dahlia Gebril · 17:57

What did Pedro Sánchez say about Spain's general strike?

Pedro Sánchez posted on Monday that the eight-hour workday, pensions and public health care were collective achievements that would not be taken away. The post was read on the show as government backing for the strike, which drew more than three million workers over housing.

“They were collective achievements.”Pedro Sánchez · 49:49

What did Dahlia Gebril say about Berka?

Dahlia Gebril said she does not believe in the death penalty, so nothing is worthy of capital punishment, including stone-throwing. She argued the British government has little moral authority to criticise Israel's labelling of stone-throwing as terrorism, because the UK has been said to treat holding a sign as a terrorist act.

“I don't think anything is worthy of capital punishment”Dahlia Gebril · 40:55

What is Novara Live's main argument on Alan Milburn's youth welfare review?

The panel argues that the reported welfare changes in Alan Milburn's review are a way to avoid taxing extreme wealth, and that they would cost the government about £6 billion rather than save money. They say young people need a state-backed job guarantee and public investment instead of cuts to disability benefits.

Mentioned in this episode

Episode facts

Released
November 12, 2026
Length
1 hour 0 minutes

▸Key takeaways

01Alan Milburn's youth unemployment review, due next Tuesday, would bar some under-25s from universal credit's health element and from PIP.
02Under Alan Milburn's proposals, many PIP claimants would move to a new Additional Cost Allowance, a change the hosts say mirrors how PIP already works.
03Almost a million 16-24 year olds are classed as NEETs in Britain, while the hosts say about 20% of PIP claimants already work, so the welfare link is contested.
04Disability Rights UK warned that cutting benefits for young disabled people would push them into poverty, destitution and homelessness.
05Helena and Dahlia Gebril argue the answer is a state-backed job guarantee and a 2% tax on asset wealth above £10 million, which could raise £24 billion a year.

▸Questions this episode answers

Q1What did Alan Milburn propose for under-25s and disability benefits?

Alan Milburn's youth unemployment review was reported to propose barring some adults under 25 from the health element of universal credit and from personal independence payments (PIP). They would instead get a new youth allowance paid at the standard universal credit rate. Many PIP claimants would move to a new Additional Cost Allowance, and people who could never work would receive a separate new benefit, according to the Times report quoted on the show. The review was due to be published next Tuesday.

Q2Does PIP keep disabled people out of work, according to Dahlia Gebril?

The hosts argue that PIP does not keep people out of work. About 20% of PIP claimants are in work, and many use the payment to make reasonable adjustments that let them stay employed. Dahlia Gebril said PIP has no work requirement, so it is not an out-of-work benefit. She said the existing incapacity support in universal credit already covers people who cannot work, which makes the proposed cuts look inconsistent.

Q3What did Dahlia Gebril say about austerity and youth unemployment?

Dahlia Gebril said about 20% of young people were classed as NEET globally in 2023, and that the causes are austerity after the 2008 financial crisis, which cut education systems and third spaces. In Britain, she said youth centres were slashed by 60%. She added that AI now threatens to obliterate the entry-level job market that young people are trying to enter, so the problem is structural rather than about young people's attitudes.

Q4How much could a 2% tax on wealth over £10 million raise, according to Dahlia Gebril?

Dahlia Gebril said a 2% tax on asset wealth over £10 million would affect a tiny part of the population and could raise £24 billion a year. She argued this is the economically, politically and morally sound alternative to cutting welfare for young and disabled people. She also called for a job guarantee programme, which the Green Party supports, to give young people training and a route into work.

Q5What were the five demands of Spain's general strike over housing?

A Tenants' Union of Catalonia spokesperson set out five demands behind Spain's general strike. They were measures against speculation so homes are used to live in, a much bigger public housing stock funded through a wealth tax, open-ended tenancy contracts, lower housing, energy and food prices with higher wages and pensions, and legal protection for collective housing rights. The strike drew more than three million workers, with 600,000 people marching in Madrid and more than 400,000 in Barcelona.

Q6Did the Israeli military describe its Nasser Hospital strike in Gaza as targeted?

The Israeli military said it struck Mohammed Abu Ismail, commander of Hamas's Khan Yunus Brigade, who was hiding inside Nasser Hospital, and described the strike as targeted with advance warnings and precision-guided munitions. Reports said the overnight strike killed at least six people and injured about 30, including medical workers and patients. The hosts said that even if the military's account were true, the deaths and injuries make it hard to call the strike targeted, and cited NBC interviews with two surgeons who said they heard no warning.

▸Transcript

Our own transcript of the public episode, with a timestamp about every 90 seconds. Tap a timestamp or the link button on a paragraph to copy a link that opens this page there.

0:00Welcome to Novara Live. Coming up tonight, proposals in the upcoming Melbourne review could see some under-25s barred from claiming PIP and universal credit health benefits, the IDF are bragging about a so-called precise strike on a Gaza hospital which has killed at least six people, and millions of people have joined the general strike in Spain. I'm Helena, aka NoJusticeMTG, and I'm always on Thursday joined by Dahlia Gebril. It's a pleasure to have you back. Oh, it's lovely to be here. I must say, you are looking fantastic today, Helena. I love that red on you. It's very, very spicy. I love it. It's very vibrant in the studio lights as well. Yeah, we need to inject a little colour and joy into people's lives.

0:40It's true. It's the one on the video thumbnail as well, I think. So it's recognisable for many at home. And you guys probably can't see at home, but she's also got like a gorgeous little pink eyeliner flick as well which i'm also a very big fan of i do have a pink eyeliner flick it's very true it's a very very true and as always if you'd like to support our work at home you can sign up at novara media.com forward slash support and you can also listen to the show on spotify and apple podcasts like this video as always make sure that you subscribe to the channel if you haven't done so already, and don't forget to let us know what you think in the comments section down below as well. Next Tuesday, the government is set to reveal the findings of the long-awaited Alan Milburn review into youth unemployment,

1:23and the man himself has teased some of the largest recommendations from that report to the media this morning. The review was specifically looking into the large number of young people not in education, employment or training, otherwise known as NEETs, and it drops amid a maelstrom of pressure on the UK government to cut welfare spending from their opposition. The review will recommend a fully funded suite of employment support, which should of course be welcomed. Investing in people is one of the best ways that public money can be spent, and the previous Conservative government's austerity agenda left people of all ages high and dry with a total lack of support. The issue is how they plan to find the money for

1:58it. Prime Minister Andy Burnham had previously ruled out the idea of implementing what he called crude cuts to welfare, but Lilburn is suggesting exactly that. Here's what ITV reported about the recommendations so far. The proposals could see some adults under 25 barred from claiming two main sickness and disability benefits. This would include the health element of universal credit and personal independence payments, PIP, the Times has reported. They would instead get a new youth allowance paid at the standard rate of universal credit. Milburn's review will recommend that many people receiving PIP should be moved on to a new benefit called the Additional Cost Allowance to help with costs relating to a

2:33disability. Meanwhile, those with disabilities who could never be expected to work would be given a new benefit, according to the Times. These changes are being promoted by Milburn as a radical shake-up of the welfare state for young people at a time where almost a million 16-24 year olds are classified as NEETs. Is it really that radical though? The biggest change is blocking young people from accessing LCWRA, that's the health element of universal credit, for people who are unable to work or in capacity benefit. This comes after last year's welfare bill cut this particular benefit in half and froze the rate at which it is paid. What's odd, though, is that the reporting suggests that young people who could never be expected to work will still be getting some new level of incapacity payment anyway,

3:14so it's difficult to ascertain what's actually changing here other than potentially making it harder for young people with temporary levels of incapacitation from accessing that level of state support. There's also more details needed over the replacement of PIP with this supposed additional cost allowance, because that's what PIP already is. For those who are unaware, PIP, or personal independence payment, is a non-means-tested income supplement for the disabled to help with their additional costs of their disability. It is paid to all disabled people who qualify, whether or not they are in in work and it appears the difference will be in the differences of eligibility between pip and this new allowance

3:49based upon the severity of the disability so all the hot air about creating some new payment that only the severely afflicted will qualify for makes no sense as that's basically how pip already works what also needs explaining is how any of this will help people get into work. 20% of PIP claimants are working, and those that do use it to make reasonable adjustments to keep them working too. And taking away incapacity support makes no sense when the clue is in the name. These people literally cannot work. These initial reports have seen immediate pushback from disability campaigners. Here's a response from Disability Rights UK. In what universe does Milburn think that taking away benefits from young disabled people

4:26which help them to survive will result in them getting jobs what his proposals will do is discriminate against disabled people based on age drive a worsening of mental and physical health and push young disabled people into poverty destitution and homelessness for young disabled people in low-paid insecure work the Milburn proposals could lead to them being forced out of hard-won employment opportunities, which can't be sustained without top-up payments from Universal Credit and personal independence payment, leading to yet more people out of education, employment and training. Green Party leader Zach Polanski was also asked to weigh in on the rise in welfare claimants by Nick Robinson on the Today programme.

5:02I don't think it'll help at all, and we will fight this tooth and nail. This is cruel and vicious, both on disabled people and young people. The idea that there's enough jobs for young people to go to, first of all, is a complete fiction. We've just been talking about the climate crisis, and we've been talking about the risks, but actually there's huge opportunities here in the green energy sector, in the green sector more generally. It's growing three times faster than any other sector of the economy. And what the government should be doing is putting public investment into the green economy to create those jobs for young people rather than demonising them. Do you believe that there are double the number of disabled people in this country than there were

5:38before COVID? Because that number on benefits has doubled. So is it the view of the Green Party leader? Yes yes something has happened in this country where twice as many people are disabled as used to be disabled well let's first of all look at the fact that since margaret thatcher and for decades inequality has risen and so mental health issues have got worse and so young people i think are struggling more this government have done things like rule out rent controls despite the fact that we know more and more people are incredibly stressed to the point of the question do you think it's doubly isn't it possible that something's gone wrong with the design of the benefit system, which is still perhaps not helping

6:10people enough in certain cases, you might argue, but is giving money to people when it should be helping them get into jobs, not incentivising them to stay at home? Well, this argument that we need to find the money, it's always difficult choices for young people or disabled people. When is it going to be difficult choices for multimillionaires and billionaires, what this Labour government should be doing is taxing the super wealthy. And what I'd say to Labour MPs is when Keir Starmer tried this, there was mass dissent. Any Labour MP listening to this with a conscience, this is a recommendation, yet it is not policy. But if Andy Burnham looks like he's going to take this up, I expect them to do the right thing and rebel.

6:44Loads of different claims worth dissecting there from what Robinson said. So first of all, saying, well, do you think there's double the number of disabled people because the number of claims has doubled, doesn't necessarily suggest that the number of disabled people has increased. I think that it has done, but all it suggests is that the number of people who've actually managed to claim has gone up. That could be from an additional additional level of uptake more people being able to come out about their disability and claim what has always been known has been a very underclaimed benefit in lots of cases and normalizing the level of disability in terms of the remuneration from the state that they should be

7:18but also on top of this him going well do you think there's more disabled people, you know, between before the pandemic and now? Yeah, Nick, there was a pandemic, a mass disabling event where people got long COVID. Do you not think that might be somewhat relevant to the increased preponderance of people with disability in this country? Like, people just kind of forget that that's what happened then. We didn't just, like, pause the country. We let COVID rip through the population in a way that we shouldn't have done given that we're an island nation. And that caused the incidences of long COVID in this country to go up considerably. Which again, that seems very, very unfair and unreasonable to suggest

7:54that it's just people faking it, for example. Like essentially saying that there are loads of people getting it who don't deserve to get access to it. And even mentioned the idea that somehow they'd be better off in work. When of course, as I mentioned before, 20% of P of pip recipients are also in work the idea that we're talking about these disabling conditions automatically moving people out of work isn't true because pip isn't an out-of-work benefit now what zach also mentioned there is last year's welfare rebellion it's been narrativized by the mainstream media that it was the moment that broke Keir Starmer's premiership, such as here on Sky News this morning. I feel like you can trace,

8:29I guess, the beginning and the end of Keir Starmer's government to losing that big welfare vote. And look, I know that there are differences, but it's kind of the same thing, right? It's about trying to reform disability and sickness benefit. Do you think Andy Burnham's going to have the same issue? Well, it'll be interesting to see, won't it? I think, you know, the reason Alan Milburn was appointed really was after Sir Keir Starmer failed to get through those £5 billion in welfare cuts to kind of say, look, we are going to look at this in more detail. It's not about the crude cuts that Andy Burnham keeps talking about. So I think this is a real effort to say, no, we're not just trying to cut for the sake of it. We're trying to resolve the root of the problem. And at the moment, it's not actually going to save the government much money. It doesn't look like it. It looks like it's going to cost them some £6 billion. But ultimately, in the long run, they're hoping that it will do not wanting to say that we're going to cut the total benefits bill in monetary terms in the course of this parliament.

9:33It's almost like a nod to Labour MPs to be like, look, there's going to be this big controversial set of changes to welfare, but it's not an arbitrary cut. And it's just such an interesting dynamic that I think, because if it was involving cuts, the longer you wait, the less your political authority from taking over. Now, the narrative is there that Keir Starmer was ousted because he lacked the authority to cut welfare. But the reality is that, in fact, the vote failed because the MPs were protecting their constituents whilst also following public opinion. Polling from after that welfare vote showed the public thought it was right that backbenchers forced the government to withdraw large parts of the legislation which would have thrown the disabled into poverty. And this poll

10:13from More in Common showed that the public overwhelmingly did not trust the government to be fair in their assessment of who should or should not be able to access disability support. These latest announcements from Alan Milburn seem to follow the same trend. Either the plans will bring endless extra bureaucracy by just creating a parallel welfare system for the young that they then need to navigate again once they turn 25, or fully create a two-tier system where young disabled people are thrown into poverty as well as their support that keeps them in work or keeps them protected is taken away. Dahlia, I mean, I want to kind of discuss about lots of the framing as well as the potential impact of a lot of these plans here. But again,

10:49like it does seem to be the implication here that they somehow just don't believe that young people can be disabled in the same way as the older generations, right? Yeah, absolutely. And I think you're completely right to raise the question of long COVID. I think long COVID, I mean, as someone who knows many people who have suffered from long COVID, you know, that is a complete attack on your ability to work, to, you know, have predictable levels of energy, to be able to hold down a job. You know, it is an incredibly difficult condition. And also, and we don't have the exact numbers or breakdown for this, but I would also assume that a lot of this increase of young people going on disability or

11:31the DWP kind of disability budget increasing, going to increase carers allowance. You know, we have to remember as well that we have a crisis in social care, we have a crisis in the ability of our society to take care of disabled people, which then means that family members, often the children of people who are suffering or siblings of people who are suffering from disabilities, have to pick up that slack. And so there's also a kind of knock-on effect more broadly in the society. But when it comes to the question of needs, you know, I think it's just so unbelievably lazy for a former Labour politician and for a Labour government to once again beat this drum that this is a problem of young people's frame of mind.

12:23I mean, like, with, like, you know, the saying, like with friends like this, who needs enemies? I'm like with former Labour MPs like this, who needs the Tories? Like they're just doing the work of the Tories for them. And because when you look at the NEET question, the NEET problem is not just a British problem. The problem of NEETs is actually a global one. 20% of young people in 2023 were classified as NEET globally and that is because and it completely makes sense I mean in 2008 when meant you know a few years after many of these young people were born we suffer a global financial crisis globally countries across the board respond to that through austerity. They slash their education systems,

13:05they slash third spaces. In Britain, we had youth centres slashed by 60%. And then when those young people then get to the point where they are about to enter the job market, we invest in and promote a technology that basically, and obviously I'm talking about AI here, that essentially just obliterates the entry-level job market. So there's quite an obvious story as to why we have ended up in this situation. There's quite an obvious story as to why we've ended up in a situation where young people are unable to get into work and unable to get into training, and also why they are suffering increased levels of mental health problems. Because the story is there, but the focus on young people's attitudes,

13:50which, by the way, is the oldest story in the book. Every older generation says the problem with young people today is they don't want to work. No matter how far you go back, all the way to ancient Greece, you have the older generation saying the young people these days, they're lazy, they don't want to work. But the reason that the Labour Party are banging this drum is because it enables them to not do the thing that we all believe they should do, that is the rational thing to do in this moment, which is to tax extreme wealth. You know, we're talking about all of this money that can be squeezed out of disabled people and squeezed out of young people. We're focusing on that so that we are not focusing

14:33on the fact that if you tax asset wealth over 10 million pounds by just 2%, a tax increase that will affect such a tiny, tiny part of the population, you can raise £24 billion a year. So we're having all these conversations about disabled people are lying, young people are lying, they're shirking work in what is objectively a broken economy. Also, we cannot have to actually reckon with the fact that the logical thing to do here, the economically and politically and morally sound thing to do here is to tax extreme wealth, not to further punish young people and punish disabled people who have already suffered over a decade of cuts and are also facing a globally broken economy specifically for young people. We are essentially asking 16 to 25-year-olds here

15:27to overcome a global condition through sheer willpower alone. And it's boring, and it's lazy, and it's wasting very precious time and very precious political capital. I think what's interesting, what Zach pointed out there, was obviously the dawn of Thatcherism. I think there's a really interesting part of Thatcherism that kind of correlates with the data here which is that the places in this country where the young neat level is the highest all in the de-industrialized north and the periphery of the country and no one's reckoning with this fact like the regional inequality is a huge predictor of this and again it moves towards the kind of the problems in terms of the financialization of western economies where a lot of these problems are happening and we've seen what 0.7 percent

16:09growth uh in the last quarter i believe was reported today and i'm like but it's all coming from the ai sector it's all your venture capital investing in this product which only therefore filters even more wealth upwards what does that growth mean for anyone that's not creating new jobs not being part of a growth in consumption amongst working age people in this country yeah it's not doing anything for the real economy that real people live in which is secondary now to what the largest economies in the world are doing which is you're trading financial products across borders or investing venture capital into ai companies for example exactly and so again the big problem is that if we really wanted to invest we could have

16:42a job guarantee program and the green Party support that policy at the moment. We could be looking at, you know, something moving towards full employment as a specific policy goal, rather than expecting that the only role of the government is to give people employment and training opportunities, for example, which is fine. I'm not saying that it's bad, right? The Melbourne Review said we want to give people some help.'m all about i'm all about that but rather than just thinking the government is there to facilitate the private sector have more public sector employment do more to make sure people have the skills and the training necessary from the state to get them ready for the world of work because what happens when you apply for a job right now you go well

17:21why should i employ you when unemployment is going up and i can find your 30 or 40 year olds who has more experience than you do regardless whether we pay them the same amount because we've got a lower minimum wage at the moment for young people and then that's not going to be solved unless you can give them a state-backed job guarantee policy that gives them the training and the resources and the start of a career to then present to an employer later on so look i've done the job i have the experience i'm not just fresh out of school anymore and the longer that you stay out of employment during that period longer you stay out of education during that period the less employable that you become long term this is

17:57again an existential crisis and just expecting that some employment support and then cuts to disability is going to solve this existential problem especially when people who are disabled find even more difficult to interact the job market too i think it's really really short-sighted and also like every you know we're making this about young people's attitudes every survey of young people's attitudes shows that the overwhelming majority of young people want to work yep they want to work they want to have a stake in society and so it's really that is really not the problem and i just imagine if we had a government that was like we there is a global structural problem where the younger generation across the world is being abandoned by our

18:38economy through a combination of different factors part of it is you know bad policy that we've been doing for 10-15 years some of it is you know know, bad policy that we've been doing for 10, 15 years. Some of it is, you know, things that might be a little bit more out of control of the national government. What if we had a government that was like, how are we going to hold those people through this time? How are we going to make sure that they get through this time with their mental health and their well-being and the social fabric intact. And instead, what we're doing is we're further pummeling young people's sense of, you know, having dignity and sense of being respected and sense of being seen. And like, how can the Labour

19:16Party in good conscience want the young people to vote for them when they are being told, when in this acute crisis, they are being told, well, it crisis they are being told well it's your fault it's your fault for having adhd or it's your fault for having autism it's your fault for being a carer do you know what i mean frustrating to us that the milburn review it points us out with the milburn review actually says right young people do genuinely have mental health problems they do genuinely i mean can you blame them and yet the conclusions from the report don't mesh with what he's acknowledged there by saying we need to cut people's access to certain kinds of welfare, especially disability welfare.

19:49I find it, again, it seems like the brief was just we can't spend any more money, you have to find a way of cutting to be able to fund this employment support. And so he's just gone, I guess we've got to cut disability from somewhere. glad as well that you brought up the question of the geographic distribution um of of needs because uh there was also a recent report that came out that made a lot of um that had a lot of fuss basically around it which said that you know white working class children are faring the worst in education and and are more likely um to become neat and the immediate response is, this is the problem of DEI. It's DEI. And I'm like, first of all, what support do you think that black and brown kids are getting in schools

20:32that white working class kids aren't getting? And, you know, they want to blame it on DEI and throw it into this culture. And it's like, the reason that white working class kids are more likely to fare worse in education and more likely to be neat it's because obviously you know working class black and brown people tend to live in major cities right and people white working class kids tend to live in these underdeveloped regions and so it's a geographic problem it's an it's a de-industrialization problem industrialization yeah but they're like we want to come up like we we look at the statistics and we look at a problem and instead of trying to get to the root of it we're like what culture war can we fit this into how can we find a way to blame this

21:16on disabled people or black and brown people like that is literally it feels like that is the brief of the Labour party government yeah well that would involve literally anybody from the mainstream media having to leave the like the m25 to then go outside to the north and see what it's like for people outside of their little uh little metropolitan bubble now in the wake of alan milburn's review into youth unemployment with the tim's review into disability welfare well on the way too, Tory leader Kemi Bejanok has made firmly clear which issue she thinks are the most pertinent in modern-day Britain. When she's not banging on about the Chagos Islands or getting into internet fights with David Tennant, she's spending all of her time and energy demonising those who

21:56claim welfare. This week it wasn't just any welfare claimant she was targeting though, in true nasty party fashion, she used a press conference to go all in on attacking the disabled. The question of whether we should cut welfare goes to the heart of what sort of country we want to be. It exposes a fundamental difference between Labour and the Conservatives. Labour MPs think cutting welfare is always cruel. They believe the kindest thing you can do for someone who is struggling is to tell them it's okay not to look after themselves, that there's nothing wrong with a life of dependency. We disagree. Of course, there are people who genuinely cannot work, people with serious illnesses or severe disabilities.

22:38We must have a safety net for those people. But the reality is that millions of people can work and do contribute to our economy, to their families, to their communities, even when they face serious challenges. Double amputees run marathons. People who are housebound do wonderful creative work from home. People with autism run some of the biggest tech companies in the world. If you tell a young person that their ADHD means they are defective and that they can't do anything, that is likely to be more damaging to their future than the condition itself. I'm sorry, Kemi, but no one is saying that those with ADHD are defective and they can't do anything. The reality is that most people with neurodivergence are desperate for fulfillment, and welfare such as PIP is invaluable in providing the support and

23:28the reasonable adjustments necessary for them to do so. What she's trying to do here is narrativize that PIP is being used to keep people out of work, when this is not how PIP functions. It has no work requirement. So many people who are in work can and do claim pip to do so implying that pip acts like an incapacity benefit for those who are unable to work is incredibly disingenuous when that already exists in the form of lcwra now she then moved on to directly going after the prime minister conservatives believe in a system that looks at people through the lens of what they can do not what they cannot labor think that if someone is struggling, the answer is always to give them more money. The Prime Minister even said that unless we give people benefits, they'll

24:11commit crime. This is a terrible view of human nature. In that interview, Andy Burnham criticised our £36 billion of savings. That is because he lacks the imagination, he lacks the will, and he lacks the support of his party to even try to cut welfare. Yeah, I mean, people can do things if they have support to be able to do so. That's the whole point of having disability welfare like PIP, it's an income supplement. That's literally what it's there for, to supplement people's income so they can deal with their disability better. Do you think people who run marathons while being double amputees, like someone who called out Kimmy Bailnock ironically after she made these statements, do you think they're more or less likely to run those marathons

24:52with PIP or without it? Like, it's not difficult to understand. And also, it's funny that she talks about like human nature and the understanding that, well, if you cut welfare, crime might go up is just a bad way to look at human nature. I'm sorry, that's just what the statistics and what the data says. There are so many peer-reviewed studies, you can find them yourself online, it was very easy to find, show that cuts to welfare and increases in poverty because of cuts to welfare correlate with increased crime rates. And the studies even show that it was specifically welfare cuts during the coalition government, the Tories and the Liberal Democrats in coalition, that was one of the biggest predictors of where the cuts into welfare were the heaviest

25:30and heaviest felt that's where crime increased the most during that time it was a very very strong correlation now Kimmy Badenock was also joined at her speech by shadow DWP minister Helen Waitley and if you thought Kimmy Badenock's comments were bad listen to how Waitley. And if you thought Kimmy Bade-Knox's comments were bad, listen to how Waitley responded to this question from the Independent's David Maddox. We also heard last week the story of Evie White, who was killed at self-age 13, again because of the failures of the SEND system. Won't your cuts, your £3 billion cuts, actually make this a lot worse? No. And it's a very serious question you ask about that. And we've thought a lot about what is the right thing to do.

26:15But we do have the situation where a huge number of children are being told that they are disabled and they have something wrong with them and set off in the direction of travel and life, which is you need cash because you have something wrong with you and then they'll go on onto pip as an adult and uh many of them will not ever get into work the the path from being on DLA to being neat is very clear as well there so it's not the right thing to do yes I'm going to answer this question about a 13 year old committing suicide we're talking about how much we need to cut these people's welfare away lest they become neat in the times when they grow up i genuinely couldn't believe when she was just so dismissive it was a serious question but i'm going to go back to talking about

26:59how our welfare cuts are going to be really good remember right during the coalition period of austerity and moving up to 2019 when the conservatives were in office on their own by the way studies also showed up to 330 000 excess deaths as the result of austerity including those welfare cuts it seems like they're coming back to finish the job honestly when you look at the scale of the cuts they're trying to do in this current kind of tranche of legislation that they're trialing in terms of the seeing what public opinion is like. And the problem is that when she says, well, there's this clear path from being on disability living allowance, which is what benefits is paid for the parents of children with disabilities, to being

27:32moving on to PIP, I'm like, yeah, those disabilities don't just disappear in lots of cases, right? The reason why there is such a correlation between going from DLA to PIP is because when you turn 18, Helen, you don't just magically have your disability cured in the same way that between 18 and 25, you have all of the same disabilities that you do after 25, which is why having a two-tier system of welfare, as proposed by Alan Milburn, I find so disagreeable. And of course, they find it difficult to get into work and they're more likely to become NEET because employers are less likely to employ them. Because, I mean, they keep talking about just getting disabled people into work through welfare cuts, through employment support, or

28:09whatever it is, whilst again the government's already reducing spending on access to work to be able to provide the reasonable adjustments. And they just assume that disabled people can just find a job when there's going to be, what, two people looking for work to every job at the moment? What makes you think an employer in rational self-interested capitalist britain are going to employ somebody who is disabled rather than someone who is not again the equality act makes it clear that you can't make these kind of discriminatory hiring practices but they still happen they still happen all the time and we see it in study after study when it comes to like racial disparities too and these disability disparities are no different

28:48are no different and they just expect the disabled people can just have their welfare cut and just waltz into a job with some employment support which i think uh is not necessarily going to be the case adalia what do you make of those clips there yeah i mean when when we hear the conservatives talking about how we still need to cut the welfare bill i i'm just like what is left to cut like what is left to cut i mean a study by the bmj found that from between um from 2012 there's been an excess of 300 000 deaths linked directly to austerity between 2011 and 2014 nearly two and a half thousand people died shortly after having their disability benefits cut so like what what's left and i and i want to kind of really specifically

29:32tackle the thing that um that was brought up there about how uh there's this message that you tell people that they are disabled and then you set them up for a life of sort of disappointment or not believing in themselves or whatever it is. And like, look, and we're coming back here to sort of, I guess, something a little technical, which is like the social model of disability, right? Which fights directly against this idea that if you are disabled, it is because there is something inherently deficient or wrong in you. What it argues is that the way that society is currently set up does not allow for the ways in which you might, you know, whether it's your physical or neurotypical, you know, set up in like a neuro, for neurotypical society or

30:21for particular kinds of physical ability and so really it is society that decides whether or not you are disabled or not in many ways and and particularly when it comes to questions of neurodivergence and so when you then create an economy in a society where the job market is so contracted and is so competitive that is going to also disable people from participating. Because I know people, young people, who are neurotypical, who are physically able, who went to private school, who went to a red brick university, who got a good degree, who did well in their degree, who still can't find a job in the entry-level job market. So if they can't find a job, how can someone who didn't go to private school, someone who isn't living in a major city and who is neurodivergent, how can they possibly

31:20catch a break in that kind of economy when the when people that the entire economy is actually set up for can't even catch a break um and i also think you're completely right helena to point out that in order to for disabled people to be able to who are basically rendered disabled because of the way our society is set up in order order for them to be able to get a job, to maintain a job, and to be able to participate fully in society, that takes resources. And they are doing the precise and exact opposite. Those resources are to enable the participation of disabled people in society and in the economy. I, for example, I mean, I'm neurodivergent, right? I am very, very lucky. I have a full-time job. I rely on in-work benefits to make me able to

32:12perform my job. So actually it costs more, it costs the government more to employ me than it would cost them to employ someone who is not neurodivergent, right? And so actually it costs more resources to employ and support disabled, to do the thing that Kemi Badenoch says she wants to do, which is to not write off disabled people from participating in society and the economy. That takes resources. So you can't claim that that is what you are fighting for when you are taking away the very infrastructure that makes that possible. There was an article I was reading on stream the other day by a Tory MP from the Isle of Wight who had just been diagnosed with ADHD and it was him talking to someone from the Times essentially saying I don't think people should be

32:55given welfare for ADHD if I can manage it then everyone else can manage it basically was the line that he went with and this guy was privately educated on the Isle of Wight right like from an incredibly privileged background. And someone in my chat was talking about attribution bias, which I've been researched. And it just immediately clicked just how much of this is kind of baked into right-wing mythos, that everything is due to the level of kind of personal application, right? And if people who are neurodivergent or have disability are not succeeding, it's because they haven't applied themselves correctly, rather than as a part of, or at least somewhat contributed to, by systemic factors, by environmental factors, by factors outside of

33:34someone's control. And the problem is, of course, is that if you're growing up with neurodivergence or disability, and again, exactly what we were talking about earlier on the stream, about the de-industrialised areas of the country where prevalence of being neat or prevalence of being on pip or whatever it is significantly higher. And that is the result of external factors outside of your control because you're from a significantly less privileged background than this MP was. And they can't understand this level to which that actually people have a worse spawn point, people who grew up in poverty, especially poverty inflicted upon them by austerity cuts by the coalition government and beyond you know where our children in this country

34:11are growing up two inches shorter than their peers in european countries because of the cuts inflicted upon them by the conservatives and their democrat accomplices and they can't they just can't be able to understand that in their own heads. Because if that's an external factor rather than personal application, then that undermines the mythos of themselves as being, you know, personally driven and personally successful rather than a beneficiary of, you know, circumstances that were beneficial for when they were growing up. Yeah, and, you know, I'm really glad for him that despite having ADHD, he was able to fulfil his dream of being a, what is he, a Tory MP? Yeah, to fulfill his dream of being a Tory MP. Like, great for him. I'm glad that, you

34:51know, you had the resources in your education system, that you had, you know, a family that had the time and the money and the attention to cultivate you into what you wanted to be. Unfortunately for you, well, unfortunately for others, 50% of the prison population in this country are neurodivergent. Because for people who are neurodivergent, who grow up working class, who grow up in places that have been institutionally abandoned, and particularly those who are black or brown, they're more likely to end up in prison than end up in the Houses of Parliament. But the thing with the, you know, it's that myth, again, that the wealthy and the already powerful, they, I mean, they have to maintain it. They have to maintain this idea. It's like the divine right of kings, right?

35:38They have to maintain this idea that they are in the position that they're in, and we're in the position that we're in, because they in the position that we're in because they're inherently better than us and they just world fallacy and they made the right decisions they had the work ethic they had this of course they're going to maintain it you know of course they're going to reproduce that and it's so funny to see you know cammy badenock and helen i've forgotten her surname helen waitley saying you know we've thought really really long and hard about this it's like we've thought really really long and hard and come to the exact same conclusion that we've always come to which is that poor people are lazy wow what a revelation coming

36:16well and again good job you don't get paid for thinking i know when it comes to kimmy badenock right like i think if i remember correctly when she was working at the spectator she didn't take maternity leave because her husband was wealthy and she doesn't need it right these are the privileged backgrounds again privately educated camey badenock as well and somehow you know i'm supposed to take these people's opinions on what it's like growing up on the never never as if it's as if they have relevant experience on this matter it's crazy again how as you say they always come to the same six people have been killed and about 30 injured in an israeli airstrike on nasa hospital in the southern gaza strip according to the director of the hospital two missiles hit surgical wards and

36:56intensive care units overnight tearing through the third floor of the building and exploding on the second patients medical workers and visitors were reported killed in the strikes, among them surgeon Dr. Riz Abu Sharia. At least one was a child and another of those was killed was disabled. The Nasser Hospital is one of the few functioning medical centres left in Gaza after Israel's relentless three-year genocide against Palestinians in the enclave and this is how the Israeli military reported the strike. Struck, Hamas Brigade commander hiding in a hospital who held numerous hostages captive. The commander of Hamas's Khan Yunus Brigade, Mohammed Abu Ismail, an additional terrorist tidying inside of the Nasser Hospital, was struck in a targeted IDF and ISA strike in southern Gaza.

37:37Abu Ismail was responsible for directing terrorist attacks against Israeli civilians and IDF troops and for holding numerous hostages captive throughout the war. Hamas turned the hospital complex into a headquarters to advance dozens of terrorist attacks and restore the brigade's terror capabilities. Additionally, dozens of hostages were held captive within the hospital. Prior to the strike, advance warnings were issued to the civilian population and precision-guided munitions and aerial surveillance assets were employed to minimize the risk of harm to civilians. Even if any of that is true, it's hardly a targeted strike when doctors and patients are killed and 30 people are injured. But there are good reasons to believe

38:14that it isn't true. First of all, the entire history of Israel's approach to killing civilians. But second, there's eyewitnesses. NBC spoke to two surgeons who were working at the hospital at the time of the strike and who had recently traveled to Gaza from the UK. Both said they had no knowledge of any warning from Israel ahead of the bombardment. The Nasser Hospital currently serves around one million people in and around Khan Yunis and an unthinkable number for a single medical center. This was its director, Dr. Ahmed Alfara, detailing the damage. They are receiving thousands of patients, thousands of operations are done inside Nasser Medical Complex. This is the seventh time, this is the seventh time that this

38:55has happened against Nasser Medical Complex and I think this will not stop. They will continue that targeting against Nasser Medical Complex. We have to mention that there was no alarming for anyone to talking about there is attack against Nasser Medical Complex. This is a fake and didn't happen inside Nasser Medical Complex. The strike comes at a time when Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu is facing being forced to step down from power. On Tuesday, Israel's new parliament was sworn in, with opposition leader Gadi Eisenkot given 28 days to try and form a government. Eisenkot's bloc of four parties won 48 seats in the election, while Netanyahu's won 53, leaving both short of the 61 seats required for a majority.

39:45But Eisenkot was given first dibs at forming a coalition government after more members of the Knesset voted for him to lead the Netanyahu, thanks to the support from the country's Arab parties. That 28 days could be extended by a further two weeks, meaning Netanyahu was under pressure to scupper Eisenkot's chances, and creating militarized security conditions has worked for Netanyahu in the past. Increasing military operations in Gaza, which have never actually stopped with over 100 Palestinians being killed by Israel every month since the so-called ceasefire a year ago, is one option. Another is attacking Iran. Netanyahu has called a meeting of the country's security council for this Sunday, with opposition figures fearing that he will launch an attack on Iran,

40:21triggering a state of emergency and calling for a unity government that would include him. While two right-wing Israeli politicians jostle for power elsewhere in Palestine, Palestinians continue to live or die at the whim of the Israeli military. On Monday, Israeli forces shot dead 14-year-old Moataz Daglas in Berka in the illegally occupied West Bank. His crime? Planning to throw stones. Not actually throwing stones as if that were worthy of the death penalty, but simply planning to. This is Not actually throwing stones as if that were worthy of the death penalty, but simply planning to. This is how the Israeli military trumpeted their killing of a child. Tonight, during a proactive operational activity by IDF forces to prevent stone throwing

40:55in terrorist incidents on the outskirts of the village of Berke in the Samaria Brigade area, the forces identified several terrorists who intended to throw stones at a highway used by Israeli vehicles. This was in an area where stones have recently been thrown at Israeli vehicles. The forces responded with gunfire to neutralise the threat. Hits were identified. A 17-year-old was also hit in the abdomen and pelvis, and a 19-year-old in the hand, according to the reports. The Israelis blocked ambulances from reaching Moataz and detained three Red Crescent paramedics. Dahlia, do you think that stone-throwing is worthy of capital punishment? I mean, I don't think anything is worthy of capital punishment

41:30because I don't believe in the death penalty. But I also think it's really important for us to realise that Britain, you know, the British government doesn't really have a lot of moral authority in this case because obviously the Israelis are saying that stone-throwing is a terrorist act moral authority in this case because obviously the Israelis are saying that stone throwing is a terrorist act but in this country people say apparently the government says that holding a sign is a terrorist act and this is why we talk about counter-terror legislation having this always having this potential, and some would argue always not having the potential, but actually having the capacity to be used in a fascistic way. You know, it is one of the best techniques

42:15and forms and architectures of legislation for an authoritarian or fascistic government, because it kind of makes people lose their minds, you know, when you can define anything as a terrorist act and then apply the most draconian, disgusting kinds of punishment to what are clearly not threatening acts, right? Whether it's holding a sign or whether it's planning to throw stones. So this kind of reliance on counter-terror legislation, the reliance on the language of terrorism, which many people, when counter-terror first started to be written into the kind of legal architecture, not just in here, but globally, many people said you know this is a gift to authoritarian regimes this is a gift to an authoritarian style of of government um this is this is where you know this is a kind

43:15of global phenomenon of applying counter-terror legislation um in this way but i think what's really important here what i think is is really interesting about just how open um the israeli state is being about about its war crimes because like the israeli government have committed war crimes like for decades like this is not new you know bombing hospitals uh putting children through military courts uh this is all very part and parcel of the way that Israel has been in the region. And also, you know, war crimes are part and parcel of the way its sponsor, the United States, has behaved. What is different now to, say, 15 years ago, is that before there was a real concerted attempt to cover up war crimes. You know, when you think about Abu Ghraib, for example,

44:04the whole scandal of Abu Ghraib was that this was something that was happening and the government was trying to cover it up. And they were punishing whistleblowers. They were trying to prevent people from blowing the lid on the fact that these war crimes and these forms of torture were taking place. 15 years on from that, we're in a very strange position where actually there's no need to crush whistleblowers or there's no need to try and cover up because it's actually part of the theatre of politics and it's part of the theatre to put the brutality on display. And so whilst the prevalence of war crimes might not have necessarily changed in a material sense you know this has been going on for a while I do think that it is a market shift in the

44:52political landscape for this to become a source of pride rather than something that governments attempted to cover up and that obviously creates a much wider birth for further war crimes and in in this case um genocidal policy i'm thinking it's always been the hallmark of right-wing politics to play on the fear of the population like fear of the other us and them you terrorists versus civilians that's always been a really great way of dividing people and making them scared so they have to vote for strong men and that you know that is goes all the way back as you say to the institution that was created with the terror legislation that came from you know the george bush era you're either with us or you're

45:31with the terrorists kind of rhetoric and of course that's been how israel has operated basically for the last 80 years when you're living in stolen land of course there's going to be reprisal and the way of course to be able to maintain that level of you know support for an ethno-nationalist cause it requires an in-group and an out-group and it's so easy therefore as well as dividing along racial lines but to divide along like civilian terrorist lines is an extra layer with which to be able to manufacture consent for the repressive policy yeah and also because when once you invoke terror people people's critical faculties shut down precisely because of that fear and because it is attached to things that were very traumatic you know things that were traumatic to

46:14obviously traumatic to experience but also traumatic to witness and so people's critical faculties shut down and so it becomes really difficult you know when when i do sort of broadcast media or whatever, the two things that are the most, the two things that you get the most backlash for that I have found in my experience, and I talk about a whole bunch of things that are, you know, unpopular or stigmatized, but the two things that I always find I get the most backlash from is any kind of critical thinking when it comes to counter-terror legislation and defending trans people. like those are the two things that i get the most vitriol in my inbox for and it's because like yeah it's just like because of that trauma because of that playing of that fear when it

46:55comes to the counter-terror stuff i think the trans stuff is is kind of different um it does it does involve this kind of this this willing abdication of any kind of guardrails on state power. And it's very, it's the oldest trick in the book. I mean, back in the empire, you know, during colonial times, people who resisted British colonialism were cracked down on and written off through the language of terrorism that was appropriate, that was, you know, devised at the time. And so it's a tale as old as time. And I just wish that we could kind of take a beat when these things are discussed and brought up and really think about what kind of power we are giving the state in times of acute emotional response.

47:46Oh, your thing is, there's only one thing worse than terrorists that's gender terrorists those scenes were from madrid last night where where Spanish police have been accused of using unwarranted violence against protesters taking part in the country's general strike on Wednesday. There was also a heavy police presence in Barcelona last night, where protesters threw fireworks towards police and set rubbish bins and other objects on fire in the streets. Amnesty International says it's documented excessive use of police force, including blows with batons on peaceful protesters and indiscriminate use of pepper spray on crowds. Earlier that day, more than three million Spanish workers took to the

48:33country's streets, with protests happening in major cities across the land. In the first general strike in 14 years, housing was the central issue. With Spain suffering a shortage of three-quarters of a million homes, a figure set to grow to a million by 2028. But in Barcelona, fascism was also a concern, with populist right-wing parties growing in support in recent years. Backed by Spain's two largest unions as well as multiple tenants' unions, during the strike tens of thousands braved the rain in Madrid to demand to defend what protesters called decent and affordable housing for everyone in a country where housing costs have risen by as much as 12% annually. In some parts of the country, however, protests were cancelled due to more powerful storms.

49:12Some protesters also shut down Gran Via Boulevard, one of the capital's main shopping streets, forcing international megastores like H&M and Primark to shut down for the day. The number of workers taking part in these strikes was enormous, with 90% of workers in the car industry, 85% in the meat industry, 82% in waste collection, and 75% of energy workers all taking part. Now, the last general strike in Spain took place in 2012, when millions downed tools and took to the streets over the imposition of harsh austerity measures following the financial crisis. This time around, however, the strikes had the backing of the government, with Socialist Prime Minister Pedro Sánchez posting this on Monday. Your eight-hour workday, your pension,

49:49your public health care, none of this fell from the sky. They were collective achievements. We won't let it take them away from us. We're going to keep moving forward. Maria Torreina Paredes, a primary teacher who marched in Madrid, explained why she was on strike. We are tired of many things. We need dignified housing, we need public and quality education, we need decent healthcare. They aren't investing what needs to be invested. And we are sick with how policies are being handled. We hope this will resonate. A day might be little, but we think this will plant a seed. The only way to get something is by fighting. So we came to the street to fight. We hope to motivate and inspire people to complain.

50:32Because we need to change the world. Many things are not okay. At home we cannot solve anything. We have to get to the street. Mari Carmen was the last straw. Because we were already angry about many things, but that was horrible. Now that was a reference to Mari Carmen Abascal. She was the 87-year-old pensioner who was forcibly evicted by Stretcher from her Madrid apartment of more than seven decades in September. Her block was bought by an investment firm in 2018, and they increased the rent from €500 to over €2,600 a month, more than double her monthly pension. The eviction drew huge crowds who attempted to block it, and when Mara Carmen died in hospital just two weeks later, there were vigils and protests across the country.

51:17That series of events led Sanchez to call a snap election, after the country's Congress refused to pass two housing reform bills submitted to parliament during the housing protests around abascal those elections will take place at the end of this month with sanchez making housing the major priority of his campaign but current polling puts pedro sanchez's spanish socialist workers party the psoe and other left-wing parties at around 36 that's compared to the 50 currently intending to vote for the parties in the right-wing bloc, though that gap has narrowed in recent days. Earlier today, I spoke to Carme Arcarazo, a spokesperson for the Tenants' Union of Catalonia, one of the many backing the general strike.

51:54I began by asking her to describe the situation on the grounds in Barcelona. Yesterday, Barcelona, Catalonia and Spain lived a very successful general strike. Millions of workers went on strike for housing and against the cost of living crisis we are suffering at the moment. The country stopped. And in the afternoon, we saw massive demonstration in all major cities. For instance, in Madrid, 600,000 people went out in the streets and in Barcelona, more than 400,000. Okay, so what are the primary demands of the unions and the tenants' unions that are taking part in this strike? There's five major demands. The first one is measures against speculation and to make sure that houses meet their primary purpose,

52:46that is the residential purpose, so that houses are to live in them. The second one would be to have a much bigger public housing stock funded through a wealth tax. The third is residential stability, namely open-ended contracts. Right now in Spain, when the contract ends, people can be evicted without any justification, without any cost. Our fourth demand is basically to lower prices, housing prices, energy prices, and food prices, and to increase wages and increase pensions. And finally, we want union rights, collective rights in the housing dimension. In Spain, trade unions have collective rights, such as the right to strike or the right of collective bargaining. But housing, although it is the primary worry of the

53:41population, and although there is really big tenant organizing, does not have any sort of legal protection. And we want to advance in that direction so that it is easier to advance in housing rights and the right to housing. There seems to be a housing crisis in basically every Western country, especially in Europe. It's kind of the epicenter of many of the housing crises that we're seeing. But obviously, we can understand that that seems to have really, really found popular concern in Spain, much more so than other places. What was kind of the tipping point for this particular general strike? Why is it in Spain that the housing crisis has boiled over to this degree? Well, we have been working on this strike for three years already,

54:27given that in the past decade, housing prices have increased by more than 80 percent, food prices have increased by more than 40 percent. And right now, the situation for working people is that they spend, we spend half of our wage in housing and what's left, we have to spend it in surviving, in food, in energy bills. And there's no room to save or to live a life that is actually like a little comfortable. But it was the eviction of an 87-year-old grandmother, Marie Carmen, a month ago, the one that sparked massive protests in the country. We've seen millions of people going in the streets over the past months. We've seen camps in the squares in many, many, many cities. And this is what ultimately facilitated the general strike to happen.

55:24And yeah, basically, right now people have said enough, enough. It is not normal to work 40 hours a week and barely make it to the end of the month. And it is not normal that the vast majority of us, we see how every year our conditions, our living conditions are worse, while the ones at the very top, every day accumulate more housing assets and more wealth. Yeah, especially when you're working incredibly hard to be able to support yourself and also support your landlord as well, living your paycheck to your paycheck, your landlord is. Actually, if you look at this, if we are spending half of our wage on rent on average, this means that out of the eight hours we work every day, we are working four hours exclusively for our landlords.

56:13So it is insane. Yeah, 100%. We have very similar problems here. And the parties of the left in the UK have been calling for rent controls as a specific way to try and bring down housing costs, as well as increasing, as you say, the supply of social housing in the UK have been calling for rent controls as a specific way to try and bring down housing costs, as well as increasing, as you say, the supply of social housing in the country. But of course, at the moment, we were previously to have a somewhat left-wing government up until very recently, until obviously the elections were called, because Pedro Sánchez did try to implement some housing reforms, but was blocked by the Spanish Congress, which is why we've got this

56:42snap general election. Where do the unions, obviously this movement more broadly with regards to the general strike and tenants unions, like what's their relationship like with Sanchez and the PSOE or indeed like the broader like previous governing coalition? So we have found Sanchez's government as being quite deceiving in terms of housing and the cost of living. Basically, while Sánchez does have progressive standings for international matters, for internal questions, we believe he has not been brave. Like, he has had very, very coward policies and has not dared to stand up against big interests. Basically, it was not until the last week of his mandate, after massive pressure from the streets,

57:31that he actually dared to pass a housing bill that was like a very like minimal housing bill, an emergency housing bill without almost any structural measure. He was basically forced to do that because of street pressure. So right now we are in a complicated position because we see how in the next elections, the right and the far right could take over. But we believe that if we have gotten to this point, it is as well because the progressive government that has been ruling Spain for the past eight years has not done enough has not done nearly enough to to basically solve the housing question to solve the cost of living crisis and to stand up against those who are everyday richer in the country. And in popular discourse in regards to the election, is housing the front and centre of people's campaigns

58:27or has this been kind of overshadowed by recent problems in terms of the narrative coming from the far right on migration, for example? Actually, this is interesting because we were bombarded the entire summer with Ceuta's crisis, the migration wave from Morocco to Ceuta, the Spanish enclave in North Africa. And basically, for months, the frame was like invasion, migration, insecurity, like like far right frames. And it was thanks to Mari Carmen, the protest, the tenants union, that this was actually turned upside down. And we've been speaking about housing, about living conditions, about the struggles that working people feel over the past month. So we feel that it's a very positive and well,

59:24it's positive news that basically we've managed to turn frames upside down. And that now what we are speaking about is why working people live worse. That is not because of working people as ourselves. It is not because of migrants, but it is because the ones at the top are basically stealing our wages. And we don't know if we will be able to maintain this frame up until the elections, but that's the idea, yeah. And if it does look like there might be like a coalition between the centre-right and the far-right in government after this election, what are the union's plans to deal with that situation? We've just done a general strike. Spain had not done a general strike in 15 years. And we know

1:00:09that if the right and the far right govern, what they will want to do is basically cancel any housing right that we've achieved over the past years, eliminate the current pension system, lower minimum wages, carry out a tax reform to basically make wealthy people pay even less. So we will need to move towards more general strikes for sure. That was Kame Akaratho speaking to me earlier today. Now, thank you everyone for joining us for tonight's Novara Live. Come back tomorrow for another live stream from 6pm. For now, you've been watching Novara Media. Good night. This broadcast is brought to you by Novara Live. Come back tomorrow for another live stream from 6pm. For now, you've been watching Novara Media.

1:00:45Good night. This broadcast is brought to you by Novara Media. Go to novaramedia.com slash support.

▸More episode summaries

Novara Live cover art
Novara LiveGlobal Institutions Reeling After Microsoft Outage2026-11-13 · 63 min
Novara Live cover art
Novara LiveHow Trump Lost The War In Iran, With Trita Parsi2026-11-11 · 68 min
Transcribe your links. Paste a YouTube, Google Drive or podcast link and WhipScribe gives you the transcript. Transcribe a link →
New Novara Live transcripts by email
One email per new episode, unsubscribe in every message. Not shared with the publisher.