podcasts / Novara Live / episode
Novara Live cover art
podcast
📅 2026-11-13 ⏱ 63 min episode · ~2 min read 📝 Transcript · 12,035 words 👁 1 views

Global Institutions Reeling After Microsoft Outage

Novara Live · · Transcript & summary by WhipScribe

The hosts connect one Microsoft outage to wider arguments about tech sovereignty, Iran and a Nvidia boss's sudden exit, with plenty of scepticism about the sourcing.

In this episodeMicrosoftOutlookCopilotNvidiaJensen HuangDonald TrumpBenjamin NetanyahuHoward LutnickJim BanksLuke PollardMegaspeed

▸Chapters

Tap a chapter to open that moment in the transcript; the link to it is copied for you.

Transcribe your links. Paste a YouTube, Google Drive or podcast link and WhipScribe gives you the transcript. Transcribe a link →

▸Notable quotes

“The war is unequivocally lost.” Barry Malone · at 29:45 — open in the transcript →
“For me, this reinforces the need for greater resilience.” Luke Pollard · at 7:26 — open in the transcript →

▸What this episode covers

Michael Walker and Barry Malone open with a Microsoft outage that began the previous evening and hit Outlook, Teams and Copilot for much of the next day. They argue it exposed how far UK public services depend on US-owned platforms, from courts and the NHS to Ministry of Defence email. Microsoft blamed failing servers rather than a cyber attack, and a Web3 Foundation executive interviewed on the show said single points of failure cause outages like this. The hosts doubt decentralised systems are easy to build, pointing to the NHS's costly database failure.

The show then turns to Iran, where the hosts ask whether Donald Trump will resume the war. Benjamin Netanyahu is reported to be pressing for new strikes, and Israel's Mossad director went to Washington to make the case. Barry Malone argues the United States has effectively lost the war and that Trump's talk of not needing a deal looks like a search for an exit. Michael Walker sees a renewed bombing campaign as a possible distraction from Trump's domestic troubles, though both expect the American public to oppose it.

The final section covers Jensen Huang's resignation as Nvidia chief executive after reports of an affair with a direct report. The hosts argue the New York Times report about a Chinese spy relied on thin, anonymous sourcing, and note a later CNN piece saying US intelligence was not sure. They link Huang's ouster to a defence bill that could tighten chip export controls by year's end, and to a public dispute between the Treasury and Commerce over Megaspeed, which puts Howard Lutnick under scrutiny. Senator Jim Banks now wants Huang and Lutnick to testify.

▸Global Institutions Reeling After Microsoft Outage on Novara Live: the answers

Who is Bill?

Bill

Bill is a Vice President of Technical Operations at the Web3 Foundation, an organisation campaigning for a more decentralised internet. He was interviewed on the show about the Microsoft outage and how decentralised networks work.

What did Barry Malone say about Iran?

Barry Malone argued that the United States has effectively lost its war with Iran and that Donald Trump is now looking for a way to accept it. He read Trump's recent Truth Social post, saying the US no longer needs a deal, as a sign of that shift. He also dismissed reports of a shouting match between Benjamin Netanyahu and Trump as overblown.

“The war is unequivocally lost.”Barry Malone · 29:45

What did Luke Pollard say about Microsoft?

Luke Pollard, the Minister for Defence Readiness and Industry, said the Microsoft outage admitted problems with relying on single tech giants. He argued it reinforces the need for greater resilience, including backup systems for government services and for the wider public.

“For me, this reinforces the need for greater resilience.”Luke Pollard · 7:26

What did Bill say about Bitcoin?

Bill, a Web3 Foundation executive, said Bitcoin is the clearest example of the resilience decentralised systems offer. He explained that if one computer running a Bitcoin node goes down, the wider Bitcoin network keeps running, and that the Foundation wants that resilience applied to other technologies.

“Bitcoin is a great example of Web3 technologies.”Bill · 12:26

What did Barry Malone say about Jensen Huang?

Barry Malone said the New York Times report that US intelligence believed Jensen Huang's associate was a Chinese spy relied on thin sourcing for such a large claim. He noted it cited only people briefed on the surveillance and did not say which agency was involved. He said he doubts the paper should have run the piece on that basis.

“So I honestly think there's a question mark over whether they should have run the piece.”Barry Malone · 46:30

What is Novara Live's main argument about the Microsoft outage?

The hosts argue that the outage, which disrupted UK courts, the NHS and Ministry of Defence email, shows how dependent public services are on US-owned tech firms. They conclude the problem is strategic autonomy as well as resilience, and that governments should build alternatives.

Mentioned in this episode

Episode facts

Released
November 13, 2026
Length
1 hour 3 minutes

▸Key takeaways

01A Microsoft outage that began around 6pm the previous evening left Outlook, Teams and Copilot largely down across the UK and worldwide.
02Microsoft blamed unavailable servers overloading the remaining ones, and said a cyber attack was unlikely to be the cause of the failure.
03According to Microsoft's own website, around 430 million people use its online tools, though the company has not said how many were affected.
04Jensen Huang resigned as Nvidia chief executive on Thursday after reports of an affair with a direct report, and the hosts think he jumped before being pushed.
05Barry Malone calls the New York Times spy story thinly sourced, saying it relies on people briefed on surveillance and was never independently verified.

▸Questions this episode answers

Q1What did Barry Malone say about the Iran war on Novara Live?

Barry Malone argued that the United States has effectively lost its war with Iran and that Donald Trump is now looking for a way to move on. He read Trump's Truth Social post saying the US no longer needs a deal as a sign of that, and said the American public firmly opposes renewed bombing. He also dismissed reports of a shouting match between Netanyahu and Trump as overblown.

Q2Why did Jensen Huang resign as Nvidia chief executive, according to Novara Live?

Jensen Huang resigned as president, chief executive and board member of Nvidia on Thursday, effective immediately, after reports that the board would oust him. The New York Times reported he had an affair with an Nvidia executive who reported directly to him, and Reuters cited sources on a third woman. The hosts think he likely jumped before being pushed, and treat the spy allegation behind the story as unproven.

Q3Was the New York Times report on Jensen Huang's alleged spy well sourced?

Barry Malone argued the New York Times piece relied on sourcing too thin for a claim this large, citing sources described only as people briefed on the surveillance. He noted it did not say which intelligence agency was involved or what prompted the monitoring. He also said a later CNN report, based on unnamed sources, said US intelligence had not proven the businesswoman was acting for Beijing.

Q4What did Novara Live say about tech sovereignty after the Microsoft outage?

The hosts argued the outage showed UK public services depend heavily on US-owned platforms, and that the problem is strategic autonomy as well as resilience. Barry Malone said the UK Competition and Markets Authority had recently moved to give Microsoft strategic market status. He pointed to the German state of Schleswig-Holstein, which in 2025 moved 40,000 mailboxes from Microsoft Exchange and Outlook to open source alternatives.

Q5What does the Web3 Foundation say a decentralised internet would fix?

A Web3 Foundation technical operations executive interviewed on the show called the Microsoft outage a classic single point of failure, where one bug or hardware fault snowballed across services. He argued decentralised networks such as Bitcoin keep running when a single computer goes down, and that the same resilience could extend to other technologies. The aim, he said, is to give users control over their own data and digital identity.

Q6Why is Howard Lutnick under scrutiny over Megaspeed and chip exports?

Senator Jim Banks, a Republican, called for Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick to testify before the Senate Banking Committee over loopholes that appear to have allowed some Nvidia chip sales to China. The hosts cite a New York Times report that Lutnick took a softer line on export controls, and note that a firm he previously ran, Cantor Fitzgerald, has financing ties to data centre companies that could be hit by tougher limits. The Treasury secretary said publicly that Commerce held the pen on blocking Megaspeed.

▸Transcript

Our own transcript of the public episode, with a timestamp about every 90 seconds. Tap a timestamp or the link button on a paragraph to copy a link that opens this page there.

0:00Welcome to Navarra Live. Tonight, Microsoft is scrambling to rectify an outage that has exposed global reliance on US big tech once again. Also, Iran claims to have destroyed a radar belonging to the United States in Bahrain. And finally, Jensen Huang, one of the world's most powerful, important CEOs, resigned yesterday. Today we're going to ask, was he brought down by the deep state? I'm Michael Walker, and I'm joined tonight by Barry Malone. Barry, welcome to the show. Hello, my friend. It's been a while since it's been me and you. It has been a while, and it might be a while again after this, because Barry has a new job that you're going to go to. You're going to be leaving us. Next Tuesday is going to

0:44be your final show. It is. With Navarro Media. Well, hopefully not your final show, but your final show for now. But you're going to be announcing what you're doing next later on, right? Yes, yes. But yeah, going to miss you. I'm going to miss you too. It's been lovely. I've been on with you more than anyone else. I know. Many, many times more than anyone else. And our audience love you. Do they? I love you, but our audience love you. No, they I love you, but our audience love you. No, they really do. I mean, give some love to Barry in the emergency. And also, watch next Tuesday as well, which will be Barry's final show with Navarro. I'll sing a song or something. And I have to just say how disappointed we are

1:19that we are going to be losing you. But it is an exciting gig that you've got. So people should wait to find out what Barry will be doing next because it is very interesting. So congratulations. If you'd like to support our work, those of us staying here, you can sign up at navarramedia.com forward slash support. Of course, you can listen to the show on Spotify and Apple Podcasts. Like this video, subscribe to the channel if you haven't already. And don't forget to let us know what you think in the comments below. For anyone relying on Microsoft services, the past 24 hours have been challenging. And that's apparently a hell of a lot of people. So an ongoing global outage at the company has rocked firms and institutions worldwide.

2:00It's resulted in millions of people being rendered unable to do their jobs. I suppose for some people, that's a silver lining potentially. But it has meant that countless public and private services across the global economy have been severely disrupted. The outage began around 6pm last night. By this morning, the multi-trillion dollar company warned its millions of users that its attempted fix was not going as expected. Whoopsie. The outage continued through lunchtime today, by which time the failure at Microsoft was being referred to as possibly the most disruptive electronic communications crash of all time, with Microsoft applications such as Outlook, Teams, and AI software platform Copilot all not working,

2:42or at least not working as usual. So what's brought down the world's email accounts? Well, according to Microsoft, the disruption is unlikely to be a cyber attack. We've been talking a lot recently about how super powerful AI is going to be able to bring down the internet or bring down websites. Apparently, this is something more mundane. It's just, according to the company, that a number of servers became unexpectedly unavailable, which caused remaining servers to overload. So it sounds like a fairly old-fashioned problem, I suppose, to have at a tech company. Microsoft has not yet disclosed exactly how many users have been affected, but according to their own website, around 430 million people use its online tools. Not just use its online tools but rely on them to

3:26do their job microsoft's crash out has once again illustrated just how reliant our economy is on u.s owned tech firms as this caller to the bbc confirmed or emphasized today all of our systems run heavily on outlook and microsoft we're not even able to access an inbox or send an email um my friend alfie just next to me, he's tried to go on to some of the portals this morning and they also run on the Microsoft servers and they're all down. What do you do? We work for a brokerage, so we do sort of insurance and things like that. Yeah, how does it feel just not being able to do this stuff, having been so reliant on this stuff? I feel like it's very strange, but I feel like it's a sign of what's to come in the future.

4:06I mean, we rely so heavily on technology and these things these days. And I feel like now, this just goes to show that when these systems go down, we're all sort of a bit lost. We don't know what to do. It probably is a sign of things to come. And we'll be talking about that on the show. I imagine we could easily have, it feels like there's going to be a situation at some point in the near future where just the whole internet goes down for 24 hours and i would i mean that would just be i mean it would obviously be very bad for um those sort of essential services which are connected to the internet when maybe we're going to see a bunch of fridges heat up again i don't even want to think about what in a hospital is reliant on being connected to the internet hopefully not that much but i mean i i

4:45think a a digital detox an enforced digital detox for 24 hours in many ways wouldn't be such a bad thing and that's not an invitation to bring down the world's internet connections um in terms of the effects that this crash has had in the uk public sector westminster magistrate's court told the bbc there have been delays after their whole system was brought down and schools and police forces have been telling members of the public to call them rather than get in touch online. The NHS has also been affected and Rachel Harrison is public services head at the GMB. She said this today, those who work in 111 and 999 services are unable to refer patient details in the normal way which is creating a massive backlog and has the potential for chaos.

5:27Emergency and life-threatening call-outs appear to be unaffected, though. The disruption has even impacted the top of the UK government, so staff at the Department for Work and Pensions, the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government, and the Ministry of Defence were reportedly unable to send emails today. A senior Ministry of Defence official told the publication Civil Service World this. It's not great at our end. I have access to Teams, but nothing else. We need to question resiliency. I know Microsoft is the standard, but if most of us can't even send an email, then that's an issue. Again, this is the Ministry of Defence. So, you know, apparently national security-related operations are said to be unaffected.

6:05So there's no terrorists getting away with plotting an attack on everyone because someone hasn't been able to send an email. But ideally, you would want the Ministry of Defense not to be brought to a standstill when Microsoft has a momentary problem at its service. The impact has also been significant in the finance and banking sector, where people are questioning reliance on American tech giants. This is from the AFP. So they spoke to someone called Shira Forti, a risk manager at a mid-sized bank. She said that businesses needed to be better prepared for unexpected technology failures. I think we need to be a little bit more careful, she said. Anything can happen. You wake up and Outlook is not working

6:50and it's the main communication we use for our global team. So I don't know, she's probably not a small business owner. She's an employee there, but she's saying, you know, the whole thing is down for a day. Does it matter? Risk manager at a mid-sized bank? I'm sure we can go 24 hours without that. But no, all respect to Shira. I'm sure she's doing very important things. I don't want to just like randomly diss someone. I'm sure very hard working and probably does important work. I hope she had, you know, I hope she made the most of it, went to the pub, had a picnic, who knows. Minister for Defence Readiness and Industry, Luke Pollard, speaking to BBC Radio 4, admitted there are issues with our alliance on single tech giants.

7:26For me, this reinforces the need for greater resilience. You heard it in the interview played just before I spoke to you about how we need to make sure there's backup systems in place to provide that resilience. That's a work that government does for government services, but also that we need the wider population. Because I think my appetite for disruption when it comes to using my phone is virtually zero. I imagine that's the case for every one of your listeners, that people want it to work all the time, every time. And we're seeing more disruption from those tech companies. That's partly because we've become more dependent on technology. So the conversation that the government has been having with tech companies is not just

8:08how do we maximise these opportunities, the incredible opportunities that AI and new technologies can bring to us, but how do we make our systems more resilient? I was in a cockpit of a warship there. If you're a minister of defence, you always have to be standing in front of some kind of military equipment, or ideally inside it, I suppose. So what's been going on in the rest of the world? Well, in the US, staff at the House of Representatives told Politico their work had been halted by the outage. In Japan, some companies turned to fax machines to continue being able to communicate. And in Australia, the outage hit the country's spy agency. So maybe that's where you could get away with terrorism over the past 24 hours. The incident has also shone a light on how much even other big tech companies are relying on

8:49one another's infrastructure. It's all interlocked. Microsoft is linked to a vast range of other tech services. It's caused ripple effects with AI giants, OpenAI and Anthropic, reporting issues with their platforms. The EU has come out of this looking okay though. They've come out relatively unscathed from the outage reporting minimal disruption, although that's only for their institutions. It's not that no one in Europe has been affected. Of course, the EU has taken the issue of tech sovereignty a bit more seriously than we have. One example cited in that Politico article I just showed you is this. So this is an example of the Europeans taking tech sovereignty more seriously. They say the government of Germany's northernmost state of Schleswig-Holstein,

9:35which in 2025 moved 40,000 mailboxes from Microsoft Exchange and Outlook to open source alternatives to reduce their reliance on US tech. That sounds like a good idea. Maybe more of us should follow suit. And this outage will presumably give governments further motivation to move away from US big tech. Of course, this is not the last or the first shock we've had. Last year's outage at Amazon Web Services took down platforms such as Reddit and Snapchat. God, really no one would have missed those for 24 hours. That's completely fine. But it did lead some experts to conclude that internet users were at the mercy of too few providers. Microsoft shares, I mean, they haven't taken a tumble today.

10:13They've dipped by 0.2%. So people who trade on the stock market don't care if the product works. That's the conclusion from that. Your whole product hasn't worked for 24 hours. You've probably caused billions of dollars in damage and your share price goes down 0.2%. That's the incentive structure we're dealing with. The firm has, though, issued an apology for the disruption this afternoon. So what's happened? What's gone on? Earlier today, I spoke to Bill de Boon. He's Vice President of Technical Operations at Web Free Foundation, which is an organization campaigning for a more decentralized internet. I started by asking him to explain what went wrong at Microsoft. Essentially, what we have seen is what often happens when you have these single centralized

10:59points of failure. You have one system, one company, and one thing went wrong. There was a bug or hardware failure. Microsoft hasn't released the specific details. And essentially, it snowballed. And this failure in one part of the system caused failures in other parts of the system. And it's been quite a slow process to bring these systems back online. You can't just replace all of the systems immediately. It's actually a bit of a process to do that. So we are currently in the situation where they have replaced many of these, they've brought many of the systems back up and running, but still not out of the gates yet. So I get what you're saying in terms of there's a single point of failure in that loads and loads

11:39of companies are using this one company, Microsoft, loads of services, loads of institutions, and they rely on this. So if Microsoft goes down, then half the economy goes down or whatever. But Microsoft, I mean, it's a multi-trillion dollar company. Lots of people work for Microsoft. Presumably they haven't set up their systems to have a single point of failure, right? Presumably they should have built some slack into their own internal systems. If you are looking just to do things as quickly as possible or your focus is not on having a resilient system, but rather ease of use or other things, then they may have an internal single point of failure, maybe even a single server. And when these systems are so complicated, when you have a problem in one part of the system, it often can propagate out to other systems like this.

12:26So Microsoft may not have known that there was a single point of failure, but almost from the way, as a result of the way companies think about how to do these things, these single point of failures tend to crop up again and again. And so you're an organization that campaigns for a decentralized internet. Talk to me about what that means. What would that look like in practice? So basically the idea behind Web3, when you have decentralization, is we know that there will be failures. As I mentioned, we live in the real world, right? A rock hits the server somewhere there. This happens. However, when my computer, if I have a computer running a Bitcoin node, for instance, Bitcoin is a great example of Web3 technologies. If my computer goes down, the Bitcoin network

13:11continues. It's actually extremely difficult to stop the Bitcoin network from running, even if you were trying to do so. And so our goal at Web3 Foundation is to make sure that that resilience that is built into systems like Bitcoin will also be used for other technologies. Especially because of the presidency of Donald Trump and him using sort of all the leverage the Americans have in whatever sphere to try and achieve his own sometimes bizarre ends. There's been a big push, especially in the EU, to try and reduce reliance on American technology. Would this Web3 decentralized blockchain-style internet system, would that allow for a greater degree of tech sovereignty as well? Yes. And in fact, if you look at the

13:58motto of Web3 Foundation, we talk about once again, internet internet where people are in charge of their own data and destiny so that's really another way of saying sovereignty right that they have control over their own data and that it's not put in hands you know not just in the u.s government but any government or any other you know like large third party entity and what's the barrier i mean i suppose because you know there's all sorts of examples where people try and build an alternative system and then it doesn't like the nhs had a real they tried to make their own uh sort of database and it cost like 20 billion quid and then they gave up and it was a big embarrassment and i think now they've just gone back to um some of the more um american tech

14:38firms um but is there a way that you could do this and it would work and everyone would be happening it'd be just as easy to use as Microsoft? And I suppose then it is the only reason we don't have it because the big tech lobby thinks that it would undermine their power and their ability to make profits. The good news is really that I would say this is much less a political problem than a technical problem. And a lot of the technical hurdles have been solved over the last few years. Unfortunately, I think that often blockchain has a bad name, right? Or a bad reputation because some of the stuff that has been done with blockchain, but at an underlying level, like the technical abilities to handle the software just simply weren't there five or six years ago and are there now.

15:29So we are seeing some institutions, some companies, some projects that are working on making decentralized storage systems that are useful and cheaper than the major Web2 companies. We're seeing that for chat applications and messaging, for computation, actually. So like, you know, like storing things on the cloud and serving pages on the cloud, et cetera. So we're really starting to see a lot of different organizations and different ecosystems develop these now because we really figured out these technical hurdles that were holding us back in terms of scalability so jimmy marshall says what the fuck is this web free bullshit i can't watch this michael doesn't know what the fuck he's doing whoa i will admit that in the case of the internet and how it

16:24works i don't really have that much of a clue of what i'm talking about but um i did look up what Whoa. I will admit that in the case of the internet and how it works, I don't really have that much of a clue of what I'm talking about. But I did look up what Web 3 was today. Apparently, it was Web 4. Oh, what's Web 4? I just Googled it. It's like AI, AI agents. Oh, AI. Oh, AI, that makes sense. It's like the agentic web. You taught me the word agentic. Yeah, I know more about AI than I do about the internet. Web 1 was read early. So that was early static websites where users consumed information without interacting or creating content. So circa 1990 to 2004. So you went on it and you just read what was on the website.

16:54Web two, read and write. Interactive platforms, so social media apps. The user generates content, but it's largely controlled, hosted and monetized by centralized corporations like Google, Meta and Amazon. And web three, what my guest was in favor of, a decentralized model where users own their own data, digital identity, and assets directly through blockchains and smart contracts rather than renting space from corporate intermediaries. Sounds good? You're in favor of Web3? Yeah. I think I liked Web1. We should go back to that. That was better for civilization and society. Do you remember Badger, Badger, Badger, Badger, Mushroom, Mushroom? Like, those were the days. Those were great. You know.

17:34Yeah, Web3 has been an absolute... No, Web2 has been a disaster for all of us. Web2 started the rock. I suppose on a serious level, I do think it is quite plausible. There are all these single points of failures. That's what our guest was talking about, which is absolutely true. And we are going into new unknown technological frontiers, most significantly with AI, and especially when the open source AIs get released. If you've got Mythos, but it's open source because it's come from China. They're obviously trying to build up their defenses at the same time as sort of the attack infrastructure and ability gets built up. But it seems plausible to me that the internet could get sort of brought down,

18:14the whole internet get brought down for like 24 hours a week. And I want to know what would happen. I feel like in a way this is, you know, when the government are telling us to stock up on food yeah cans and bottles of water i'm really not worried about like russia invading us but i do think the internet could go down yeah yeah i i mean i do agree with that i think that yeah i'm not worried about russia invading us either but um uh yeah like it clearly is uh a big a big risk i mean okay look today might not have been a hacking thing but but it could have been, or, you know, hacking could have the same result. And we've seen how many sort of essential services rely on Microsoft, but also so many essential services, as you say, just rely on the internet.

18:59And that is scary because when we looked up at the, you know, the backups that people have gone to today, fax, where that gone to today, Fax, I actually think that's actually a really good idea. But when you look at some of the other backups, I guess some have worked to some extent, others have worked to a lesser extent, but it has certainly caused massive chaos. And I know we're going to see Bloomberg and the FT or whoever report lost productivity and how much kind of money has been lost through this. But that is, you know, the least scary thing about this when you again, you talked about hospitals today and police forces today. And I do think the US aspect is a big one, too. Like, I do think the fact that the world relies so much on US firms is a problem.

19:43Tell you a story. Story, Tom, I know you love my story. Story time. I love it. Yeah. One time years ago, I was in a newsroom. This was back when it was like pivot to video, right? I don't know if you remember this, when everybody was like sacking all their text correspondence and hiring people to do video for Facebook primarily. And everybody was getting millions and millions and millions of views. And so you had all these news organizations who thought, well, we've arrived, we've been discovered. Everybody thinks we're fantastic. We're getting millions of views. Now, this place I was working at, Facebook came to see us, right? And they sat down in a meeting room and they went, what do you guys want?

20:17We're like, they said, do you want people to come to your website? Do you want them to watch videos on Facebook? You just tell us what you want and we can make it happen. So they left and I said, that was a shakedown. I felt like I was talking to a mob boss there, you know? But the other point that I made at the time was that they were American, right? And depending on who you are, whether you're a government or a news organization or a business that's in competition with American businesses, and you rely on those companies, this switch can be turned off anytime. Now, that can happen through hacking, yes, but it can also happen through a change in geopolitical circumstances. Even far back as 2011, 2010,

20:56I think when the protests were happening in Egypt, Twitter, which was, I think this was the first time when Twitter was used to organize in a massive sort of protest revolutionary movement was 2011 in Egypt. Twitter was going to, now imagine this, Twitter was going to go down for a little while for maintenance. Wow, that would not happen these days. And they decided not to do it because they wanted to ensure that that platform was there for the Egyptian protesters. Now, you might agree with that. You know, I happen to believe that the Egyptian revolutionary movement was a good thing. But it's a political decision being made by an American company. And that decision favored the American foreign policy stance as well.

21:38And you have this revolving door between all these organizations, right? People are going from State Department to White House to Microsoft to Facebook to, you know, the head Facebook, sort of, I can't remember exactly what his title is, but the guy who decides kind of what political things get taken down and what get left up. And he's ex-CIA. This is just a fact. It's not a hidden thing. He's an ex-CIA guy. So, you know, I do think that this is not a question of resilience. I think it's a question of sovereignty. And I think that's really important. And I think countries need to be thinking about how to disentangle themselves from all these different services. Just going to finish on this.

22:13I found today that just last month, the Competition and Markets Authority in this country said that they wanted to give Microsoft strategic market status, which essentially means that's incredibly important to the functioning of businesses in the UK, to the functioning of the UK state, and that it was becoming a monopoly, that people needed alternatives to Microsoft business tools. And they, even the Competition and Markets Authority, which I think this is like slightly beyond their purview, but I looked in the reports, they use the term strategic autonomy, right? They said resilience, yes, but they also said strategic autonomy. And I think that's a huge, huge thing. You know, different countries need their own solutions. Otherwise,

23:00it's just an incredible vulnerability. Ever since last week's US midterms, when American voters roundly rejected US President Donald Trump's war on Iran, it's looked as though Washington would slowly wind down its illegal assault on the country. But today, Israel has sent its big guns to try and change Trump's mind. The Jerusalem Post has reported that Mossad Director Roman Goffman has arrived in Washington, where he'll try to persuade CIA Director John Ratcliffe and other officials to resume the war. Now, the context here is somewhat complicated. Israel's Prime Minister, Benjamin Netanyahu, is at risk of being ousted from power. His main rival, Gadi Eizenkot, is seeking to form a government and that was after

23:46neither Netanyahu nor Eizenkot's bloc won majorities in those recent Israeli election. Netanyahu's bloc actually won more seats but Eizenkot is being given the first go at forming a government after more members of the Knesset backed him. That's of course thanks to the help of Israel's Arab party, who Eizenkot is still refusing to work with. Anyway, that's all put Netanyahu in a tenuous position, with some arguing a war would help him out. On Thursday, though, The Independent reported on a call between Trump and Netanyahu, which they said collapsed into what a source described as a shouting match from hell. That was when Netanyahu pushed Trump to restart attacks on Iran. The Financial Times has also reported that Netanyahu has been calling Trump on a daily basis to make the case for war.

24:29According to reporting from Israel, Netanyahu hopes that a fresh wave of strikes on Iran will allow him to declare a state of emergency in Israel, in turn permitting him to form a unity government as current Prime Minister. And today, Netanyahu may have received some support for his point of view from an unexpected quarter. The International Atomic Energy Agency has announced that it's increasingly concerned about nuclear enrichment in Iran's Isfahan and with the country refusing to allow inspections. Now Iran for its part says it can't facilitate inspections while under attack from Israel and the United States but the IAEA's statement is likely to increase pressure on Trump from Washington hawks to

25:10restart hostilities. Obviously Trump has sort of been on the telly saying, we know they're not doing anything because we got these satellites, which means that they can't possibly be doing nuclear enrichment. And now the IAEA is saying, well, maybe they are. Let's look at a tweet from Donald Trump. The context here is that J.D. Vance, who's an Iran war skeptic, had been charged with negotiating a ceasefire with Iran. But that seems to be no more the case. Donald Trump posted this on Truth Social. I have asked Vice President Vance to focus his complete and total attention on the massive corruption and crime taking place in Democrat-run cities and states throughout the USA. The blue states such as Minnesota, California, Illinois, and many more are all poorly run, corrupt disasters.

25:54Billions of dollars is being stolen each and every month. Our budget could be quickly balanced with the correction of this large-scale criminal activity. Corruption is in the Democrat leadership's blood. And then this is, I suppose, the important bit. We don't need a deal with Iran. Those days have long since passed. We've got their money, hundreds of billions of dollars, and we've got their straight. Thank you for your attention to this matter. That's not very encouraging. The claim about not needing a deal appears to have been sort of followed up with some military action. So on Thursday night, Iran announced it had suffered what it called an enemy attack on Sirak, an area near the Strait of Hormuz. Then in the early hours of Friday morning,

26:34Iran announced it had targeted a US military radar installation in Bahrain in retaliation for a US strike on a communications tower in Sirak. If so, that would mark the first direct Iranian attack on a US military site in the region in months. U.S. Central Command, though, denied it happened. So they posted this. Today, Iran's Revolutionary Guard Corps said it attacked a U.S. early warning radar in Bahrain. Then they say, fact, the IRGC launched two one-way drones towards Bahrain and both were shot down by US forces. There were no injuries or damage. Responding to the US attack on Sirik, the Islamic Revolutionary Guard said, this is a serious warning to the aggressor enemy to end its aerial mischief and oil smuggling

27:18in the Strait of Hormuz. In the event of repeated violations and aggression, the IRGC Aerospace Force is on full alert to confront the enemy without constraint. These events follow a streak of ship explosions in the Strait of Hormuz this week. On Thursday, Iran claimed that four tankers had struck coast of the UAE in the Gulf on Friday morning, with Iran saying a gas tanker had hit a mine after using, quote, an unauthorised route. Those are just the latest in an increasing number of such explosions in the Strait. According to Reuters, in October there were 37 similar incidents in the shipping lane, the highest number of ship attacks on record. November is shaping up to have a similarly high

28:12tally with almost one explosion per day in the channel so far this month. And yet tankers carrying oil and gas are exiting the Gulf at pretty high levels. So the International Energy Agency has announced that for the first time since the start of the war, the global oil supply has returned to a surplus, with suppliers outstripping demand by two million barrels a day, and that's since October. That suggests that while Iran is still able to assert some control of straight traffic, high oil prices have made exporters less risk-averse, with a supertanker of oil now earning around $40 million more than before the war. That's according to the Wall Street Journal. Barry, Netanyahu wants Donald Trump to restart the war on Iran. Do you think there is any risk that he will get his way?

29:00I'm sure he does. Yeah, I'm sure he does. It makes perfect sense that he would want it to start again, both for domestic reasons, primarily that he wants to stay in power, and also that it's a bloody lifelong ambition of his to overthrow the Islamic Republic. It's tough to know it, Trump, now. I was on the show with Aaron last week, and we were talking about this kind of Tucker Carlson tweet that said that, you know, Trump was liable to launch a nuke, you know, what they call a tactical nuke or a battlefield nuke after the midterm elections. I said at the time I thought that was a completely overcooked claim, but I am surprised that he seems to have climbed down a little bit on even renewing military action against Iran. The wording of that Truth Social post is so

29:45interesting because, look, they've lost. You know, my take is the U.S. has lost the war. The war is unequivocally lost. It's just a question of when Trump is ready to accept that and move on. Really, it's just that question. You know, Trump, I think what Trump wanted to do was to overthrow the government, what Western countries like to call regime change. He was persuaded that that would be really quick. He thought that he could do something like he did in Venezuela. You know, at that time, you know, Washington sort of eggheads were talking about the Venezuela model. I don't hear them talking about the Venezuela model anymore because it failed in Iran. And Netanyahu probably wanted to go even further

30:29than so-called regime change. He probably wanted to render Iran a failed state. So I think Trump was in some way recognizing that when he would say, we have a deal, we have a deal, because I think he was realizing that he couldn't win it militarily. Now to be saying, we don't even need a deal. I'm surprised. I don't know what he's angling at there. Is it that he's now realized that there's no way forward here? He's finally realized that it's massively unpopular with the American public. He knows he's going to be hampered by the fact that he's lost the House and Senate. And is he finally looking for a way out? By the way, I don't buy all that shouting match crap. You know, they've been, the media has been reporting

31:11that Netanyahu's been shouting at Trump, been shouting at Biden. He's always on the phone shouting with somebody. I remember in the Biden days, you know, it was being leaked all the time that Biden was furious with Netanyahu. And that was a way that the Biden administration used to distance themselves from the worst of what Israel is doing. So, look, I don't know whether I believe all of that, but if he is getting that head up, then it would suggest, and if Mossad, the head of Mossad has been sent over, then yeah, it would suggest that they might think that Trump is cooling on the war. And I think that would be a good thing because it would also be an acceptance of the reality that they've lost

31:48and that they've seen their military power or their, you know, greatly, their ability to project military power and the belief that with military power, the US can get outcomes that it wants has been undermined again and I think they've lost influence in the region I think that the middle east and the gulf are going to come out of this in a very different geopolitical place to the one that they were in so he just has to accept it and and I hope that this is a sign that he will yeah I mean it does seem at this point I suppose the issue with Donald Trump is he just listens to whoever he spoke to last to some degree right and it seems to me i talked to treat to pass you about this earlier in the week

32:30you know the main people around donald trump they you know rubio jd vance they want to run to be president in two years time like i think they don't want the iran war to start again because it's not good for the administration like the electorate don't like it but trump's notice out in two years and if the israelis are telling him you know everyone's haranguing you about uh you know jensen wang and how you allow chips to get into china i mean now there's going to be a bunch of investigations in the house and the senate and because they can now sort of call members of don Donald Trump's administration to try and get to the bottom of all these aspects of corruption. So Donald Trump is going to be

33:09feeling in a way quite vulnerable and when he's feeling vulnerable and when the Israelis are in his ear saying, you know what would really take attention off all of this is if we just bombed Iran again, you know, what could go wrong? I wouldn't give it a, you know, less than 10% chance. Maybe he's smart enough to realize that it's just, it's, that's just not going to work. It's just not going to work. You know, it's not going to work as a distraction technique, probably because this, unless he uses that bloody nuke, which I don't think that he will, but you know, because this thing's been gone on nine, 10 months now. So it's not gonna be novel to start bombing the crap out of Iran again. Um, And I think that, you know, no matter what happens,

33:48the American public is going to remain absolutely firmly against it. And maybe he doesn't want to. I think maybe I used to think that he wanted to save face and that that was why he might go back. But maybe he's realized that the American people actually think he's a loser for pursuing the war. Well, I mean, the save face. So I think he's saying we don't he thinks that a deal would be losing face uh you know this is the central assumption he thinks that a deal would be losing face going back to war would you know all hell would be let loose and so he's gonna what treaty party is suggesting is you know some sort of status quo strategy but where you let a bit more go in than is currently going in.

34:25Because he's saying that if you maintain a blockade as strict as it is now, the Iranians still see that as sort of an act of war. Maybe they'll just watch the project fade away. Yeah, so he's saying that just... Officially, everything stays the same and Iran is still sort of subject to this blockade. But in reality, everything can continue as if the war hadn't happened, which is probably, you know, the best case scenario we can hope for. Obviously, like a full peace deal would be great. And Iran can be reintegrated into the world economy and everyone can be happy. But, you know, that's probably not what's going to happen under Donald Trump. But hopefully also, we're not going to see him bomb Iran

35:02and hopefully not use a tactical nuke. I mean, that would obviously be the worst outcome. We've been talking all week about the relationship between NVIDIA founder and CEO, Jensen Huang, and Alice Huang, who US intelligence alleged was a Chinese spy. On Thursday, the drama came to a climax. And a Fox News alert with breaking news because Jensen Huang has resigned as president and chief executive officer and a member of the board of Nvidia, effective immediately. So Huang's resignation followed reports that the Nvidia board would oust him. So we can probably assume he jumped before he was pushed. This wasn't sort of him saying, I don't want to do the job anymore. It also came the day after the New York Times

35:50revealed that Huang had been having an affair with a second woman, Kimberly Powell, who was an NVIDIA executive. And this is significant, who reported directly to him. And so it's like a no-go in business to date someone who's sort of directly reports to you. Reuters reported late on Thursday that two sources had told them about a third woman, also an NVIDIA employee, that Huang was having an affair with. So the most powerful man in AI has been dethroned after these two or three affairs, depending on which accounts you go by. But was this just the case of a powerful CEO who crossed the bounds of acceptable behaviour and so got his comeuppance? Or were there darker forces at work? Perhaps most likely it was both.

36:39But let's explore the possibility of darker forces working here. On Wednesday's show, we looked into the idea that Alice Huang might not have actually been a spy and was instead more of a fixer for the wealthy, what's known in China as a white glove. And after days of headlines declaring Huang to be a Chinese spy, which was all on the basis of US intelligence reports, right? So the US intelligence believes her to be an intelligence asset, believes her to be a spy. That's where all the reporting came from. On Thursday, CNN reported that actually US intelligence weren't sure. So this is a headline from CNN. US intel isn't sure if businesswoman spied on NVIDIA for China. Doesn't mean she wasn't a risk, sources say. Well, now you tell us,

37:23right? So this article came out mere hours after Jensen Huang was ousted from his position. So I mean, you know, if you've got a conspiratorial mindset, it does seem a bit like intelligence agencies sort of put out this story. Jensen Huang is brought down. And then they think, well, actually, is it time for us to come clean that we didn't actually really have much on this woman? Seems likely, right? This is from the CNN report. The US intelligence community is still working to understand the relationship between a Chinese businesswoman who had an affair with Chen Shih-hung and the Chinese government, with multiple sources telling CNN that the intelligence collected on her to date does not prove that she was acting

38:02as a spy for Beijing. Why don't you believe everyone she was a spy for Beijing? Anyway, the article expands on that point. It says some officials at the office of the director of national intelligence, including those close to director Jay Clayton, have framed the characterization of Alice Wong as a Chinese spy as not entirely accurate and over-talked, sources said. And officials at the CIA also are not yet convinced that the intelligence collected on Huang to date, including intercepted communications, proved she was knowingly following information back from Beijing, a source told CNN. Again, this all gets released in the hours after Jensen Huang has resigned. So if you thought this was them trying to bring someone down

38:43by putting out a story that wasn't entirely watertight, this would definitely support that view. There was, in this article, a defence of the idea that Alice Wong was a spy, but it itself was very revealing. So this is from that CNN report again. Some Trump officials told CNN that it strains credulity to believe that she was not acting as an agent of the Chinese government simply by virtue of the fact that she is a successful Chinese businesswoman working with one of America's most powerful companies. Under Chinese national security law, Chinese citizens can be compelled to help gather intelligence on behalf of the Chinese Communist Party, even if she had not done so yet, given her access to Huang, and by extension to Trump,

39:25some officials believe she posed a clear counterintelligence risk. So by that definition, let's be clear, every Chinese citizen is a potential spy. And actually, the reporting wasn't saying she's a potential spy. They were saying she's believed to be a spy, right? If you have an affair with any one of 1.4 billion chinese people in the world and if you're relatively powerful that could be deemed as a national security risk so that gets to a point of success and power in the american establishment where if you date a chinese person essentially that becomes a national security risk again this is very far from all the reporting was saying she's assumed by US intelligence, believed by US intelligence to be an intelligence asset or a spy.

40:09And now they're saying, well, to be honest, I mean, she's a successful Chinese businesswoman, so she's probably a spy. That's what that amounts to. Again, if Huang was brought down by the deep state, it seems possible. There's lots of things going on. He definitely did wrong. Having an affair, actually, with your subordinate has led many CEOs in the past to lose their jobs. It's not unheard of at all. But if there was also a concerted campaign to bring him down, we should ask what interest they would serve. And on that front, it is pretty clear. So Jensen Huang was the most prominent advocate for a soft stance on selling advanced AI chips to China. Now that puts him at odds with China hawks,

40:50both in Washington and in Silicon Valley. He was also the most prominent advocate for open weight AI models, which put him at odds with companies like OpenAI and Anthropic who don't want to face cheap competition. They don't want to have to try and beat these open source outfits on price. They want to say, if you want good AI, you've got to come to OpenAI or Anthropic and pay us the monthly subscription. There's a third group who probably don't have quite as much power in Washington, but are quite noisy and quite interesting, right? And that's people who care about AI safety. So Huang was the strongest opponent of AI regulation. So he suggested any fears about AI were essentially made up. They were nonsense. So all of those groups benefit. And there's one person that is

41:39at the middle of all of those groups that represents all of those groups. He's a hawk on China. He's the CEO of Anthropic, and he's an effective altruist who thinks that AI might kill us all. It's Dario Amadei. Now, to get a concrete idea of the extent to which Jensen Huang disagrees with Dario Amadei, this is a clip from earlier this year, where the podcaster Dwarkesh Patel put the Dario view to Jensen. Dario had this quote where he said, it's like Boeing bragging that we're selling North Korean nukes, but the missile casings are made by Boeing. And that's somehow enabling the US technology stack. Like fundamentally, you're giving them this capability. Comparing AI to anything that you just mentioned is lunacy. But AI is similar

42:18to enriched uranium, right? And then it can have positive uses, it can have negative uses. We still don't want to send enriched uranium to other countries. Who's sending enriched? The analogy here is enriched uranium is like compute. Because it's a lousy analogy. It's an illogical analogy. But if that compute can run a model that can do zero-day exploits against all American software, how is that not a weapon? First of all, the way to solve that problem is to have dialogues with the researchers, the dialogues with China and dialogues with other countries to make sure that people don't use technology in that way. That's a dialogue that has to happen. Whenever I listen to Jensen Huang, there's sort of half of it I agree with, which is like, we need to be soft on China and communicate

43:01with them. But if you listen to his full interview, he's like, so against any kind of regulation for AI. It's like unbelievable. And it is all because he wants to increase his profit. So I don't mourn the loss of Jensen Huang as one of the most powerful people in America. Barry, though, let's talk about, you know, whether or not Alice Huang was a spy, and whether or not it looks like this story was a concerted attempt by the US deep state and people with interest in a tough line on China saying Jensen Wang is the strongest proponent in Washington of exporting chips to China. Let's bring him down. Yeah. Okay, so we're firmly in the realm of speculation with this conversation. Which we love. in the realm of speculation with this conversation.

43:45Which we love. I love speculation in this show. But you know, the whole world is now firmly in the realm of speculation with this story. And the story emanated from where? The New York Times, right? The New York Times has very good connections with the US government, very good connections with US intelligence agencies. We know that. I think there were six journalists bylined on the piece and they were, you know, the best and brightest of the New York Times. But we also know that the New York Times has often, over decades, carried water for the U.S. government, carried water for U.S. intelligence agencies, carried water for the CIA, and also been duped by them. So it has sometimes wittingly,

44:26sometimes unwittingly done the bidding of US intelligence agencies. And I just wanted to look at a paragraph in the New York Times piece just to see exactly how they said that they sourced the allegation, or for them, the fact that she was a spy. This account is based on interviews with people briefed on the surveillance. We spoke in the condition of anonymity because the findings are drawn from classified intelligence. Then there's, as well as other officials and industry executives and analysts, but the important people are the people briefed on the surveillance. Findings drawn from classified intelligence. That doesn't even go so far as to say that they're from the intelligence agencies. It just says that they're people briefed on the surveillance. And you will

45:08know, but the audience might not know, when you're like reporting a news story, you move from trying to get, you know, you want people to go on the record, right? So you want a name. And then if you don't want a name, you work backwards. If you can't get the name, you work backwards. So you work backwards and try and find a way of phrasing it in agreement with the source that is as close as it can possibly be to establishing their authority. So it could be, you know, an intelligence agency source, right? That could have been a possibility and they would have presumably wanted that if that was the case. Now, I'm not saying that doesn't mean it's not an intelligence agency source, but I'm saying that people briefed on the surveillance is an incredibly thin, an incredibly thin sourcing.

45:49And then the other thing that a news organization might do if the sourcing is that thin is they will say how many, you know, how many people they spoke to. They haven't said anything like that in there. And then further down, they, you know, rightly say what they could not prove. It could not be determined which intelligence agency or agencies have been involved in monitoring Ms. Huang or what prompted them to start. It is also not clear under what circumstances Ms. Huang began gathering information for Beijing, what information she passed along, or its value to China, right? So those are gaping holes, right, in that piece. So like, honestly, when I read this piece, I wonder if I was involved in the editorial

46:30process here, would I think that's strong enough to run on such a massive claim? And I'm not sure that I would. They haven't independently verified any of it. Now, I know that's a hard thing to independently verify, but it doesn't mean that you don't try. And it certainly doesn't mean that you run the piece just because you can't, based on sourcing that thin. So I honestly think there's a question mark over whether they should have run the piece. And then when you look at the CNN piece that casts doubt on it, that's also incredibly thinly sourced. More thinly sourced than this, because the whole thing just says sources. So it's just ask source, sources, a source, a source, a source. Doesn't say anything about the nature of the sources again.

47:10So now we have these like two very thinly reported competing pieces. One saying she's a spy and one saying maybe she's not a spy. And so it just doesn't leave you with any clear picture. And, you know, in terms of this like quote unquote deep state thing, there is, I think there was one person described as close to Jensen Huang who, um, who said that he thought that that was what was happening, that he thought that the deep state was, you know, trying to take, well, yeah, a person close to him, you know, that's a better description than, you know, but then the other thing, just to, just to again, reiterate the New York times thing, like the New York times has had some massive incidents before where it's got things wrong based on intelligence sourcing. 1999 in the lead up to, no, sorry, in 2003, in the lead up to the 2003 invasion of Iraq,

48:06had this now notorious story that Iraq was importing aluminium tubes and that those were going to be used to develop nuclear weapons, that they were like a component part of a centrifuge or something. And then the US government, now she sourced intelligence agencies, but she also relied on Ahmed Chalabi, who was a massive opponent of Saddam Hussein. That report then became an absolute key pillar of the US making a public case to go to war with Iran. So that New York Times report was something that they then put forward. And it turned out to be utter nonsense. It turned out to be complete nonsense. And then if you want, and the New York Times, I think, apologized for it since. And then, you know, there's even a China example,

48:48a notorious China example. Now for that one, you have to go back to 1999, which was called the Los Alamos lab affair, where there was a Taiwanese American scientist called Wen Ho Lee, who was accused again in leaks to the New York Times of giving nuclear secrets to, guess who, China. And he was fired and yada yada. And I think then there was Bill Clinton even had to apologize to Wen Ho Lee. So these are just, I think I'm just casting doubt on the grand dame, the New York Times stating something and then it being taken as a fact. And this is now taken as a fact. That CNN sort of thing that cast doubt on it, that's not going to travel the world like the New York Times piece has. Jensen, Alice Huang is a spy.

49:39Now, most people in the world believe, even though it's a thinly sourced New York Times piece that within days, doubt has been cast on. I mean, I think they're reporting from October on Megaspeed. They actually had sent a reporter to the Megaspeed offices in Singapore, and they had found that there weren't really any people working there and it looked like a shell company. This is a great point you're making. Right. So they had, the whole story isn't just based on like anonymous briefings from the security services there was definitely something going on with mega speed but there is definitely something going on with alice wong where she has a you know an interesting backstory where it's not

50:15all above board that's why sort of china experts who aren't quite so hawkish as saying she was more of a fixer so she was a front woman who would use her networks to help people hide the ownership of various companies. And there does seem like quite a lot of circumstantial evidence that she was involved in trying to ship chips to China in a way that was illegal, according to American law. That's actually an excellent and really important point. Because you had asked me, did I think she was a spy? And, you know, I'm picking apart that. But the Megaspeed thing, there's a story there. There's an amazing story there. And, you know, when you read the piece that they put out in October 29th, it was mostly about her herself.

50:54But then there was some stuff in there about Megaspeed. It wasn't as detailed. It wasn't as sort of deeply reported. It wasn't the top framing of the story. A lot of it was down near the bottom. But that's a story. And also, that's a story that you can potentially like really land a plane on. You know, if they'd spent a couple of years digging into Megaspeed and looking through all of the supply chains, and if they'd managed to prove that Megaspeed was smuggling NVIDIA chips that, you know, the US government has banned from going to China into China. That's a hell of a story. That's Pulitzer Prize worthy. Why didn't they do that? Well, they did do that. No, not comprehensively. In October last year.

51:36Not comprehensively. And then it was only once you put in the spy word that it becomes sort of sexy enough to be front page everywhere. And I mean, I do believe that they were told by... I imagine they were told by people in US intelligence that this was a thing, right? I imagine there are people in US intelligence who are really pissed off about the incompetence of the Trump administration who are allowing chips to get into China, whether or not you agree with it. But why do you imagine that? Because there are a lot of China hawks in the US secret services, and what Donald Trump and L lutnick have been doing is allowing mega speed and other companies to just like openly flout american law and if you are worried about

52:13china getting chips which lots of these people genuinely are um then that would concern you and i think now they see we've got this opportunity we're going to have a democratic senate and this could be the moment to the political incentives are there like there's absolutely no doubt that political incentives from a lot of people to take him down are there that's fundamentally obvious yeah well absolutely but the question just with the new york times report if you're looking at the new york times report which is where this came from and again i'm not saying that i know either way right i'm not saying that she's not a spy or she's a spy i'm saying that the reporting is thin, so how can I know, really? But, you know,

52:48the point is, yes, if those sources familiar, or however they described it, were from the US intelligence agencies, which they may well be, then the two questions that you have to ask is whether they were telling the truth or whether they're right or wrong. Yeah. I think it was probably sexed up. A sexed up dossier. British term, an old British term. Let's look at some of the interests here. So one of the big winners from all of this is OpenAI. So Bloomberg reported on Thursday that they were joining calls for tougher legislation on chip exports to China. That legislation would have cross-party support, according to Bloomberg. And when they say this, Congress is weighing free proposals that would seek to put restrictions on future sales

53:29of high-end chips, reduce the diversion of NVIDIA's AI processes, and block China from accessing sophisticated machinery from ASML holding, NV. The measures would be attached to annual defense legislation that must pass before the end of the year. Two lobbyists familiar with negotiations around that defense bill said NVIDIA's allies in Washington, including trade groups this week, have mobilized against the provisions, arguing they would harm the ecosystem of companies that are tied to NVIDIA. But NVIDIA itself has remained relatively mum as the defense bill efforts gained steam. Huang's ouster as NVIDIA chief on Thursday removed a longtime foe of stricter US export controls and diminished the chipmaker's clout on Capitol Hill. So again, in terms of

54:09timing, I mean, this is really, really significant, right? The defense, because I had in my mind, why didn't they wait until the Democrats did have the Senate and the House? Well, it's in that article, right? The defense legislation, which China hawks want to attach export controls to, has to be passed by the end of the year. So this was their last chance to pass it. The strongest lobbying force against more controls was Jensen Huang. And now, oh, he's gone. So easy to see the role of OpenAI, Anthropic, whoever, is driven by cynicism here. Unfortunately, exactly the same can be said of the other side of this struggle, right? This is not good guys versus bad guys. Huang wanted to sell into China to try and maintain dominance in that market. Trump loved Jensen Huang because he was rich and

54:56powerful and was supportive of the president. Earlier this year, Nvidia provided a secret $25 million donation to help build Donald Trump's ballroom. These are the kind of interests we're talking about here. And the motives of Howard Lutnick, the Commerce Secretary, seem even more shady. The New York Times has reported that Lutnick took a much softer approach to export controls on chips to China. Again, that's not because he was a peace-loving dove who wants better relations with competitors. it's more likely because of this. This is from the MIT. There are also concerns about possible conflicts of interest given that the investment firm that Mr. Lutnick steered for decades, Cantor Fitzgerald, operates in a wide

55:33range of industries, from cryptocurrency to data centers that rely on NVIDIA chips and could be affected by rules Mr. Lutnick is currently weighing. That business is now run by Mr. Lutnick's sons. Cantor Fitzgerald has served as a financing or placement agent for several companies that are involved in developing or operating data centers in Southeast Asia, like Guerrilla Technology Group and Bitdeer Technologies Group, which could be hurt by tougher US limits on chip sales to the region. So again, the sourcing here is quite clear. There's no one anonymous here because you can just look at what is Cantor Fitzgerald invested in and who was the owner of Cantorzgerald before he passed it on to his

56:07kids it was howard lutnick who is the commerce secretary who is the person who had responsibility for stopping um mega speed illegally smuggling chips to china if that's what they were doing and as i say there's circumstantial evidence that that was the case. There are now moves to force Howard Lutnick, as well as Jensen Huang, to give evidence to a Senate committee. And Lutnick won't just be getting heat from the Democrats. So Jim Banks is a Republican MAGA senator. This has huge national security implications. China targets the CEO of the most important chip manufacturer in the world. And like Winnie the Pooh, Jensen Wong gets his head stuck in a honey jar. Yeah, that's right. This news is as concerning as it gets. When you are

56:54in a war with another country, I served in a war, I served in Afghanistan. When you're in a war with another country, you don't give them your best technologies. And that's why lawmakers for the last two years have been pushing hard to stop our high-end computer chips from being exported to China. And that's why my AI Overwatch Act is more important than ever. Last year, I had the Gain AI Act, which would have blocked our chips from being sold to China if there were American customers who wanted to buy those chips first. NVIDIA opposed my legislation a year ago. They've opposed other export control laws. And now we know that the Department of Commerce, Secretary Lutnick, it appears, used loopholes to allow some of these chip sales to occur, even though

57:38President Trump has directed his administration and the Department of Commerce not to allow that to happen. So not only do I hope for Jensen Wong to come and testify, but I would like for Secretary Lutnick ASAP to come testify before the Senate Banking Committee, because we have a lot of bipartisan questions and concerns about what's happened over the last year that would allow some of these issues to continue. So that was a Republican senator speaking there. And in another sign that Howard Lutnick could be screwed, frankly, he was thrown under the bus by none other than the current Treasury Secretary, Scott Besson, this afternoon. There have been reports that there was some tension between you and Secretary Lutnick

58:20about why Megaspeed was not placed on the entity list. And I'm just wondering about the interagency coordination. Could Treasury have done that? Was it only, you know, Lutnick that could have, Commerce that could have done that? What about the coordination? Yes. Well, I can tell you there was coordination. Treasury, War, USTR, and State, they were in favor of putting Megaspeed on the entity list for months. But Commerce has the pen. Commerce BIS has the pen. And you will have to ask them about their internal processes. So, don't they have collective responsibility in the same way that we do in this country? Like, if you are a member of the government, you have to agree with the government line.

59:09Because he's a member of the cabinet, and he's saying publicly about another member of the cabinet that, yeah, I disagreed with him, but he overruled me. He's essentially saying, everyone in the Trump administration wanted to block companies like Megaspeed from getting NVIDIA chips, which could then be used by Chinese companies. But there was one guy that blocked it all, which is Howard Lutnick. And to hear that from a treasury secretary speaking about a commerce secretary, when they're both imposed, you know, you would think that one of them is not going to be in that post for much longer. And you would imagine it's Howard Lutnick that is going to go here, right? Well, it sounds like they're lining up against him, which is never a good sign in politics, is it? But if that was here, you know,

59:49what would have happened is they would have been WhatsAppping lobby correspondents, right? That's like our equivalent of that. It's just, you know, journalists on Twitter going, I got a WhatsApp from him. But yeah, I don't know. Look, the corruption, I think, that is going to become apparent at some point, whether it's years after Trump is out of power, whether it's, you know, imminent, is going to be mind blowing. I'm sure it's going to be incredible how, you know, there's already been reporting, inference, rumor, some media organizations getting close to it. But I don't think that they've even scratched the surface of what's going on with the Trump family and people like Lutnik. I think it's going to be a massive, massive scandal.

1:00:38I only hope it's not one of these things. And it probably will be that the can gets kicked down the road until they're all in nursing homes. And, you know, then we find out about it or, or you know declassified documents come out 50 years from now we find out about it but i think i think it's going to be um i think it's going to be massive yeah well i mean lots of it i imagine will come out in the next two years because lots of the corruption is literally like public knowledge and it's been reported but people have struggled to dramatize it. And because people have struggled, you know, Donald Trump would just say, oh, it was just money, whatever, blah, blah, blah. But if you're going to have now

1:01:09all these Senate hearings, now that Democrats control the House and the Senate and they can bring forward all of these officials, I think you're going to get a lot of like really cinematic moments where people are getting absolutely needled and that will sort of give a drama to the corruption that might have lacked up until this point. A lot of it is like circumstantial as well. You know, you have to go from, well, this person was involved in that company that then got this deal and that, and you kind of piece it together like a puzzle. There was something about, look, Nick, I can't remember what it was, but me and you were on a couple of months ago and there was like a New York Times piece

1:01:42we were looking at that did that. It pieced a few things together where you go, okay, that sounds, that sounds like it stinks. Actually, I remember I said it stinks and you said it more than stinks. So, you know, it was clear, but again, it's like, it's, it is a difficult thing to make a top headline when it involves that kind of circumstantial piecing together of who's involved in what company. But if, yeah, I think if they can get a massive smoking gun um and then it will all come out but but it will be reliant on the u.s media who are very cowed by trump frankly they're not there won't be anymore they were cowed when they thought that he was the rising man now he's like but that's what i'm saying the story's been on the table for years the story's been on the table for

1:02:24years so yeah maybe you're right that's that's a really'm saying. The story's been on the table for years. The story's been on the table for years. So yeah, maybe you're right. That's a really good point, actually. It needs to be dramatized. You know, everything is television. You need conflict. You can't just sort of say, oh, outrageous person does outrageous thing again. You need to see this person bodied this person. Bodied. And I think you're going to get a lot of that in the house. So when this happens, that's going to be the Novara thing. Yeah, yeah, yeah. I've already got it planned. Barry Malone. Michael Walker. It's been a pleasure working with you. I'm going to be the North Arizona. I've already got it planned. Barry Malone.

1:02:46Michael Walker. Pleasure working with you. I'm going to miss you. I'm going to miss you too. I can even give you a hug, but we're mic'd up. Oh, Michael. We'll make that work afterwards. Edit that, guys. Edit that out. I don't think that needs to go. Let's wrap up. Thank you guys for watching. Come back on Monday for another live stream from 6pm. Have a fantastic weekend. You've been watching Navarro Media. Good night. This broadcast is brought to you by Navarro Media. Go to navarromedia.com slash support.

▸More episode summaries

Novara Live cover art
Novara LiveLabour Review Says Cut Disability Benefits for Under-25s2026-11-12 · 60 min
Novara Live cover art
Novara LiveHow Trump Lost The War In Iran, With Trita Parsi2026-11-11 · 68 min
Transcribe your links. Paste a YouTube, Google Drive or podcast link and WhipScribe gives you the transcript. Transcribe a link →
New Novara Live transcripts by email
One email per new episode, unsubscribe in every message. Not shared with the publisher.