James O'Brien - The Whole Show · · Transcript & summary by WhipScribe
Summary, chapters and key takeaways for this episode are on their way; the transcript below is complete.
Our own transcript of the public episode, with a timestamp about every 90 seconds. Tap a timestamp to play the episode from there in the show's own player; the link button on a paragraph copies a link that opens this page there.
0:00Hey y'all, Kelly Clarkson here with Wayfair. You know my favorite compliment during the holidays? Your house feels so cozy. That's when I know everyone's comfortable enough to kick off their shoes, grab more dessert and stay a little longer. Wayfair makes it easy, with everything from dining furniture to festive guest room essentials, all in one place. So whether you're hosting for an afternoon or all weekend, everyone feels right at home. Get holiday guests ready at Wayfair.com or on the Wayfair app today. This is a Global Player original podcast. Good morning. It's three minutes after 10 and you are listening to James O'Brien on LBC. Disappointment for Paul, it's not bus routes. Did you like that little tease that I did a few moments ago?
0:47I never know what's going to come out of my gob until it opens. It's going to get me into huge amounts of trouble one day. But I just sort of listened to the thing rising in the background. Can you tell when I'm doing it? I bet you think I'm a professional, don't you? Or that I've got a script in front of me or something like that. So I'm just shooting the breeze with you. End of Nick's show. Suggesting or talking you through what's currently in my mind take alan milburn's speech take all the questions and answers afterwards possibly even though there's 45 minutes of them scheduled because a he's a good talker he's not a member of government so he has a lot more freedom than other politicians do or or serving politicians do um doesn't take the whip and
1:27secondly it's it's the single most important issue of our time in so many ways and i've been telling you that for years in fact if it wasn't such an important issue i'd probably activate um keith's mystic jim jingle because i told you years ago that this story was not going to go away. Speaking of mystic, Jim, I have got an opportunity to have a look at that a little later from the pages of the Daily Telegraph newspaper, no less. Finally coming around to recognising something I've been telling you for the best part of a decade. And there's a clue there as to what it might be linked to. So I was just shooting the breeze with you, minding my own business, giving you a little heads up on what was likely to occur. And I noticed that we were getting towards the end
2:09of that little introduction. I didn't have time to tell you what I was going to be talking about. So I said, I bet you can't guess what it is. And I bet you can't. I bet you didn't. Although the story was around yesterday. I mean, here's one of those things I can say, and you can clip it out of context and try to embarrass me. Ready? I have a very complicated relationship with cannabis. We talked about it a bit, I think, last week, didn't we? Because the difficulty of giving it up and the fact that the older generation, my generation, is much more likely to be consuming it daily than the younger generation. And it was a really interesting conversation. I hinted or I touched upon, sorry, I was completely honest with you,
2:48I touched upon the fact that I used to be a very enthusiastic advocate of cannabis use and a sworn enemy of criminalisation because it damages usually young lives potentially in such an unfair and unbalanced way. How does he know? know well because it damaged mine quite badly when um when we got busted at my boarding school and uh and and came to the attention of the humberside drug squad and it seemed at the time and it still seems now absolutely ridiculous at the full weight of the law they talked about oscar wilde i think being a butterfly broken on a wheel. I got a letter off one of my old English teachers quoting that when we were facing police interviews for our involvement in cannabis consumption
3:34at my boarding school. So that informed my opinion for a very long time. And now I've changed a bit. When I was 21, if I met someone who smoked a lot of cannabis, I'd think I'd met a kindred spirit. When I was 51, if I met someone who still smoked a lot of cannabis, I would think that he was a loser or she was a bit of a loser. And that's a terrible thing to say because some of my closest friends, dot, dot, dot. But it just strikes me as doing more harm than good as the years pass informing lethargy inactivity and absence of motivation and a fondness for quite ludicrous food combinations it also gives you the ability and this can actually be relevant to mental health although its impacts on mental health are at the
4:23very least complex it also gives the ability to to lose yourself for quite a long time and some people perhaps need to do that it's an amazing story yesterday i should dig it out for you or was it this morning about silence two hours if you can somehow access two hours of silence every day then um it has benefits that you i'm not going to speculate on this in case I get it wrong. I'll dig it out and share it with you before close of play today. The benefits of two hours of silence. When you think about it, it's probably true. I normally have my headphones on when I come to work. I didn't put them on today because it was raining. And if my headphones get wet, they go a bit glitchy. So I didn't put my headphones on today. It's not silence traveling into central London by public transport.
5:10But I certainly felt different when I came up the stairs at the tube station. I certainly felt different from how I usually do. Probably as a consequence, just a little bit more, oddly, I'd say a little bit more relaxed, even though I generally listen to relaxing music. But the news yesterday that you heard during the bulletins, but not on the programme proper, that Boots, of all places, Boots the Chemist, I say Boots the Chemist, here's an interesting game, let's play it for a moment. If I say Boots the Chemist, what do you think of? What do you, I mean, what do you think of? What was it? How did it arrive in your consciousness? If you grew up in Kidderminster, Boots the Chemist was one of the only places you could buy CDs,
5:56would you believe, back in the day. My 13th birthday, Dad took me to Boots the Chemist and told me I could choose two CDs for my 13th birthday present. Don't pity me. Don't get the violins out. I think my main present that year was going to see Kenneth Branagh in Henry V in Stratford. But I was allowed to pick two, not CDs, not two. What am I talking about? Cassettes. Two cassettes. Boots the Chemist. Two cassettes. And I picked The Collection by Ultravox because I loved a couple of the songs on it and it had lots of songs and I only owned four cassettes at that point in my life and I picked Give My Regards to Broad Street by Paul McCartney which I still think is an underrated album, albeit an
6:38execrable film no more on that, I promise but that's Boots the Chemist for me, first thing I think of, now I think of the three for twos on the moisturis but that that's boots the chemist for me first thing i think of now i think of the three for twos on the moisturizers that i always forget to use boots the chemist you will be able to buy medicinal cannabis there um very soon it's an online service you've got to be an adult aged 25 and over um and you will need to find a private prescription how many private prescriptions they doubled i'll give you a clue they doubled between 2023 and 2025 how many private prescriptions foricate because one of the conditions mentioned here is anxiety others include chronic pain insomnia you submit your case online it's
7:38reviewed by a specialist team and prescriptions are then issued or not issued before being examined a second time by an independent consultation in a video call with the patient before treatment starts you will then receive ongoing clinical support with an initial review after 28 days and reviews every three months where your quality of life your pain your anxiety your sleep and your mood will be assessed i i mean i find this fascinating i i find the uh it also suggests that um addiction is to to this particular substance is is not a thing which uh is is controversial i normally want to side with scientists but um it certainly seems to me to be fairly addictive in some cases and has been found to be so in um in in coroner's inquests
8:33for example um but including an inquest into the death of a young man for whom cannabis had been subscribed uh prescribed um that the brother of a of a young man called oliver robinson um has has indeed warned about this and the warning should be heeded but the reason i say i've got a complicated relationship with it is because i can't quite believe this you go back to 1990 and my personal life my life was turned absolutely upside down by this and fast forward to 2026 and you can buy it in boots i mean it's a slight exaggeration but i wonder if we're going to look back and think that the criminalization and the demonization of cannabis consigned millions of people to pain misery and anxiety that they might otherwise have been able to avoid and that's why today's phone in
9:33the first one at least is very straightforward um i mean given that last week we put the boot into to to the to the drug we put the boot into the drug. We put the boot into the substance quite heavily, or by the standards of this program, quite heavily, albeit with a big side order of it being illegal. It's increasingly ridiculous. Most people grow out of it. But the people who don't grow out of it, I think we maligned them a bit last week as needing it because, as I said to you 20 minutes ago, no, 10 they're losers they're not are they i mean it's a terrible thing that it's a terrible stigma a terrible demonization um i i'm sort of thinking of superannuated students or danny out of withnail and i and i'm not thinking about people who have discovered
10:22sometimes much to their own surprise that cannabis helps them deal with whatever it is that they've got. There was a writer on The Observer many years ago. I always remember this story. There was a writer on The Observer many years ago who had a chronic eye condition. She had rapidly deteriorating eyesight. And she went to a party and smoked a joint. And her eyesight improved in that moment. And it wasn't like hallucinatory. It was a response. Nobody expected it. I don't think anybody had marked it before, but it persisted. I don't think the improvement was as striking or as immediate every time she subsequently partook. But my goodness me, imagine something that helps a person who is almost blind
11:13see also being a crime, also being something that the very possession of can constitute criminal proceedings and even ultimately a prison sentence. So I just want to do that. I don't really want to have a row this morning. We did Brexit for two hours yesterday. I'm all rowed out for the week. I'm not, by the way, but still. I just want to know what difference it makes to you. And I mean, we need to be responsible. If you haven't got a prescription, then we need to remind you and everybody else listening that you're breaking the law. But if you have got a prescription, then in some ways, the floor is completely yours. What conditions does it help with? Can I sound a bit stupid as well? I used to sit here
12:00and I was by some distance the youngest person on LBC when I started working here. I'm not anymore. And I used to congratulate myself on actually knowing quite a lot about this subject. And I would listen to colleagues who shall remain nameless who knew absolutely nothing about it. And that didn't stop them having incredibly strong opinions and tub-thumping views and very daily male-flavored attitudes. And I used to... It's probably, do you know, thinking about it, it was probably my introduction to the art of the radiophone in, as presented by people who neither can nor understand about anything. And so if we paid more attention to cannabis phonemes, we probably could have predicted Brexit.
12:40And I would sit here thinking, well, I know quite a lot about this, and that's obviously not true. Why are you repeating that nonsense? Everybody knows that. And you sort of realized on that subject more than any other. There's no responsibility in the UK media to respect facts or indeed to be curious about them. You can pick an opinion and then shout it from the rooftops until your dying day without it having any relationship whatsoever to observable reality science or facts we're back to brexit again aren't we but i don't have that anymore i can't congratulate myself on knowing more about this than other people do because a i haven't smoked cannabis and i was always a smoker i'm too old really to have got into gummies or edibles for years.
13:26And B, I know absolutely nothing about medicinal cannabis. For example, and we'll deal with this question quite quickly, I think. For example, if you're taking medicinal cannabis, do you still get high? 0345 6060 973. And if so, how does that impact on the rest of your life if you're taking cannabis for anxiety do you still want to go to the petrol station at two o'clock in the morning to buy 400 jaffa cakes and a packet of monster munch it's a foolish question but it's a genuine one i'm curious because here we are having a conversation about cannabis and your favorite friendly neighborhood radio presenter who used to be a bit of an expert, to paraphrase Daddy Pig, I'm a bit of an expert, today knows nothing.
14:09I know nothing about this. How do you take it? You don't smoke it. Is it the same sort of stuff that you'd buy off a very, very good dealer? Or is it something completely different? So questions galore. And let's just fill our boots, shall we, collectively on this one and find out what is going on. I don't think it's a debate, really. I mean, there is a little bit of wiggle room on questions of whether or not we should still be on our toes about potential dangers and differences. That's why I'm keen to track the differences between what you might buy down at the dog and duck or indeed these days what you might buy down at the dog and duck or indeed these days what you might buy online and have delivered to your front door uh discovered last week when you told me um and and what you are
14:52likely to get from boots that's that's another area of curiosity for me what are the differences between what you're going to get from uh from your friendly neighborhood dealer and what you're going to get from Boots Online Doctor. But that's it. 0345 6060 973. How big a difference has it made to your life? And, I mean, if it's pain alleviation, then it could be helping with some truly hideous conditions. And final question, I mean, in my experience, it can make you more anxious experience it can make you more anxious it can make you more anxious and nervous so how does that bit of it work as well this is more of a fact finding mission than a heated debate 0345 6060 973 it's 10.18 it is 20 minutes after 10
15:42you're listening to James O'Brien on LBC where we are having what I think might be our first ever phone-in about the medicinal benefits of cannabis. Ideally prescribed, but of course self-medicating may be something that we will talk about as well. And I suppose in a way, at risk of sounding too choosy or selective, my dream caller would be someone who can't quite believe. So someone who, you know, 30 years ago would have been reading the Daily Mail and thinking that cannabis was a, you know, crack cocaine, basically. They're all the same, these drugs, and you best avoid them. Somebody who was absolutely of the view that it was the spawn of Satan, Satan's seeds. And 30 years later, the world has turned turned you've developed a condition somebody told you
16:26that cannabis would help and you find yourself later in life having been a kind of high court judge or the matron at an all-girls boarding school or some sort of highly respectable role where cannabis was absolutely frowned upon and now you are um you're up to your ears in it because it has such extraordinary impact upon your health, your medical condition. 21 minutes after 10 is the time. Richard is in Worthing to kick things off. Richard, what would you like to say? Morning, James. Interesting stuff today. I've had a private prescription for about six months now and it was basically, I mean, I'm the most straight guy ever i don't drink i don't smoke i'm just a dad getting through life and just an innocent man just a normal man just a
17:13normal innocent man and i was just a little down you know life was just getting a bit on top and also i'd had a long-term knee pain which i'd had for years and years and years and just a friend of mine said hey you know i'm taking um private medical cannabis why don't you try some of this right and so she gave me the name of the company um and i phoned them up and i have to say i was completely shocked surprised at just how easy this was. It was a sort of a perfunctory ten minute phone call with a doing rabbit ears doctor, who basically talked you through it, saying, oh, so you're feeling stressed? It was a doctor. Well, I presume it is a doctor. I thought you were using some technical term there.
18:02This always happens when I spend the introduction owning up to being ignorant. I then spend the rest of the hour going, oh, God, is that something else I don't know? What's a rabbit ears doctor? Is it some sort of AI? No, it's inverted commas. Yes, I get that now. Eleanor just mined it to me. So it is a doctor. Otherwise, they were breaking the law. So don't say rabbit ears. But I take your point. It was perfunctory. That's a great word. It was perfunctory. And they literally led me through, like, saying so are you feeling stressed oh did you think this would help you do you know and i was like yes yeah but you weren't telling you were also telling the truth to be clear but you're you're you're clearly expressing concern that you might have quite
18:38easily secured the prescription even if you hadn't been telling the truth yeah and at the end of the day you feel like that was a lot easier than i thought because they're getting a bit of money out of me obviously yes um and then uh you know then you get put through into their system where you get all sorts of choices of how do you want it do you want it in gummies do you want it in oil do you want it in a leaf you know whatever right and then it just arrives and every sort of months, you get a phone call from them saying, how are you? And, you know, how's it going? Man, do they say, how's it going, man? How's it going, man? It's cool, man. But your question about, do you get high? Yeah. I mean, obviously you're supposed to take
19:20a small amount of the small amount and it isn't supposed to get you high because it does have the thc in it and you're not supposed to be getting high but it's sitting there on a friday night you think well i'll just take double that tonight and yeah it does get you high it does really do the job so it obviously has the stuff in there but i was saying to um your producer that actually i i don't use it anymore because one of the questions i asked sort of the third or fourth appointment on the phone with them was what happens um you know if i'm in a car accident oh yes yeah and they were very sort of sheepish about it and said well yes if you've got thc in your blood then your insurance was probably negated so i thought well that's just not worth it then is it
20:05to be uh well we we probably need a little bit more guidance on that because you know i mean there's lots of things that if you're if it's in your blood your insurance would be negated so the most obviously i suppose alcohol but it worked while you used it it did what you wanted it to do used it definitely make you know it's definitely it's a stupid thing to say isn't it james but yeah definitely more chilled out definitely you know the pain went away in my legs for a bit and it definitely did it but to me and maybe it is because i am so straight it was it was just such a shock at like oh okay i'm getting that now am i fantastic that was really easy did you enjoy being um under the influence um well when you when you're sort of just taking it day to day you don't really
20:53think i know but you said on friday night sometimes you did did you enjoy that as someone who'd never really got off their nut before i well i mean in the 80s i did but that's a long time ago but but no but i mean um no it's scary isn't it it's like you're lying in bed and you're lying in bed and you're free flying you're flying round in your dreams and you're it's yeah some people love that some people love it it's a bit like roller coasters I think you can love it in your 20s and find it absolutely terrifying in your 50s exactly you love that but then i'm thinking well i've got to get up and walk the dog is this going to go away you know if you were in chronic pain again would you reconsider re re re prescribing i think so yeah i mean i think so i mean the worry i mean
21:35again being such a uh stick in the mud the worry for me don't sound like a stick in the mud you just sound like a responsible adult that's kind of my life my life would have been a lot better if you weren't on the radio every day between 10 and 1 because you just my my entire life stops be careful what you wish for richard i think i think i think i think you might find that it would it would be a cause of epic epic uh psychic harm were i not here to spend three hours a day with you um and the th I think, is recognized as having anti-inflammatory qualities. It relieves inflammatory pressure. That's why it's prescribed for endometriosis, among other things. And just for the avoidance of doubt, as you could tell, Richard tying himself
22:17in knots to establish his maturity and responsibility, once or twice being tempted to take more than the recommended dose is obviously not to be encouraged. The driving bit is a bit trickier. Emma, who knows a lot about this stuff, tells me that the medicine is legally prescribed, so the police would have to prove impairment, as with any other painkiller. Failure to provide a sample is likely to be the bigger problem. But again, guidance will be available and as it's often the case with the law it sometimes takes a little bit of time for behaviors and understanding to catch up with change and that's why i am still really surprised to learn that 1.7 million prescriptions were issued last year once i've admitted to ignorance by the way all bets are off
23:01so that is 1.7 million people is it or? Or is that just a much, much smaller number of people getting several prescriptions a year? The way the article is written, it looks like 1.7 million people. And the way Richard described the ease with which this prescription can be secured, not by any stretch of the imagination necessarily a bad thing, adds to the idea that it's 1.7 million people. Karen is in Margit, home of the abandoned Lido. Karen, what would you like to say? Oh, James, so lovely to talk to you. I listen to you every day. Thank you. You're my sanity, mate. You're my sanity. What a lovely thing to say. Oh, honestly, I'm made up. Anyway, I've got full body ataxia, which means I can't walk. I'm in a wheelchair.
23:48Gosh. It's very complex. I won't go into it. Well, you've given us the sort of key factors, I think. I've got a full... My husband's my full-time carer. I can't walk anywhere unaided without him holding my hands. And then I get full body spasticity, which means my body cramps and the pain is off the chart. Oh, you poor thing. Yeah. When did it start? About seven years ago. Oh, lordy. I'm so sorry. Oh, no, no, no. I am. You can't stop me. No, it's not my fault. you can't stop me no it's not my fault you can't stop me feeling sorry for you it's a horrible thing to happen thanks you're lovely anyway i went to see my pain consultants my gp just kept giving me morphine morphine morphine wow wasn't
24:38working wasn't i was on loads wasn't working um i went full rent and came off it yeah and uh that was pretty tough i saw a pain consultant at my local hospital qqm and he actually suggested to go on to medical cannabis what did you think when he said when he said that word well i was quite shocked yeah yeah and then i spoke to my GP, and he said the same thing. I think that's what you should do. Spoke to my husband, and then... It's not easy to get James. No. And that's a fallacy. Well, I mean, it might be for some people. Well, it wasn't for me. No, so what did you have to do? What did you have to do? Well, I went to a company, and I had to have a long Zoom consultation with a specialist that knows about the different strains of cannabis
25:35and the different terpenes. Right. Now, I'm prescribed Indica, which is a full body relaxation, no head high, no paranoia no munchies nothing like that wow you've learned the lingo haven't you oh yeah i am so it just it just it just relaxes you and then it has a measurable difference on light switch james a light switch, James. Oh, mate, that's wonderful. I mean, honestly, I can now watch TV. I don't smoke it during the day, really. And do you smoke it in a vape? How do you part... Yeah, yeah, yeah. You're not allowed to smoke it in a joint. No. That's illegal. Yeah. Oh, is it? Okay. That's interesting. If you combust medical cannabis in a joint,'re breaking the law oh you live and learn so
26:28so you heat it to the point where the active ingredients are released but the but the leaves are not burning and you just vape it i don't smoke so i didn't want any of that anyway and um i vape it and i can have an enjoyable evening, totally relaxed. It also cures, I've got complex PTSD from the medical stuff I've been through. I don't get the horror dreams that I was getting. How amazing. Every three months, I have another consultation with the company I use. They're all specialists, they're brilliant. And you get something called a cannabis block, which is where your body gets used to the strain you're on. And so they change the strain. Oh, how interesting. So, good lord. So it's quite sophisticated science then, what we're
27:23describing. Oh, very. And I'm also limited to a level of THC. So I'm only allowed 25% THC. That's what I'm allowed. Right. I cannot go over that. So when I go to order from the pharmacy that they use, I can only order 25% or less. A certain type of strain. Yeah. And is this on the NHS? No, no. Oh, you have to pay privately. But my GP, when I last saw him, he was fascinated by it and was asking me lots of questions. And he said to me, he's hoping that our surgery will start doing that. Well, that would be good good wouldn't it i i'm late for the news cam but i wanted to hear your whole story on on a scale of one to ten how much of your how much of a difference has it made to your life oh ten percent hundred percent really it's completely transformed your existence
28:19well i'm on no morphine that's's incredible, isn't it? And I am pain-free. Oh, what a wonderful story. I don't know if we could probably finish the phone in here, couldn't we? No, you've closed it down. I'll tell you what, James, you have made my day, mate. Honestly, you have made my day. What a great story. I think you are brilliant. I think you are brilliant. Thank you, Karen. And I listen to you every day laying on my sofa because obviously I can't walk and I don't know you just cheer me up immensely What a lovely thing to say you've cheered me up immensely what a wonderful story from a place where you sort of thought that there was no help available and then lo and behold it's that thing that until relatively recently
29:02we were being taught was terrible. Well, great story. Thank you, Karen. I still want more, though, because I'm greedy. And you can tell me your story after the headlines with Dominic Ellis. The plural of anecdote is not data. But if the testimony coming into this studio via phone calls but also via texts and messages is even close to reflective of a broader reality, then 1.7 million prescriptions for medicinal cannabis being issued last year is nowhere near enough. People who are self-medicating are reporting extraordinary differences between life with it and life without it. And I wonder how hard it is the first caller made it sound very very easy but it's going to be horses for courses isn't it and
29:51and knowing where to go and um i understand why some there will be quite rightly reluctance and resistance to the idea of it being too easy but how easy is it to be also you need money to get a private medicinal cannabis prescription i presume that it is much much harder to to get one on the nhs most things are i think i don't know whether it's appropriate or not but think about ozempic or moon jarro where privately relatively easy to access quite strong drugs you want to go down the NHS route, it's going to take you a heck of a lot longer and the threshold for qualification is going to be a heck of a lot higher. That at least is my experience at 10.38 is the time. What is your experience of medicinal
30:36cannabis? And remember, there's always room for negatives on this program as well. You can sound a voice of warning, a voice of caution, or indeed explain potential downsides, which is what the family of Oliver Robinson have done. Oliver was 34 years old when he took his own life after being prescribed the drug by a private clinic. I mean, you know, Samaritan's advice is always to resist any temptation to attribute an act of suicide to any single factor. So correlation is not causation. But his family have certainly warned today that that prescription of high-strength cannabis after a single video consultation was suboptimal, telling the Times today that the coroner warned that more people could die unless action was
31:26taken because the prescriptions in the words of Oliver's brother those prescriptions stood in the way of the psychiatric and addictions care he needed so I don't know that it's a rarefied case necessarily but it's not going to be the experience of everybody but it is a timely reminder that this is probably not a black and white issue 10 40 is the time charles is in southampton charles what made you pick up the phone uh hello yeah um i am a medical cannabis user and i also work for one of the largest medical cannabis providers in the uk do you get staff discount unfortunately no we're not outrageous unfortunately not outrageous go on tell me more um well i think well probably you've you've covered loads of
32:13things over the last couple of minutes it's kind of difficult to know where to start but i think starting with the suicides generally if it's uh if it's disclosed it's on a summary care record that would preclude you from treatment from most clinics in the country. You don't need to respond to the things that I've just said. I'm more interested in what prompted you to ring in in the first place. So when did it, I mean, were you using it non-medicinally before you started using it medicinally? Yeah, I started using it when I was 15. So I'm 36 now, so I've had quite a long time on it. Yeah, so I've got ADHD. Obviously ADHD obviously didn't know that when I was 16 and looking back I now realise
32:50that it was probably self-medicating that now that I'm on medication for ADHD like I've not smoked today and don't really need to so there's definitely a bit of a self-medication thing going on there what are you on? Are you on Amfexa? What are you on for the adhd yeah dexamphetamines yeah yeah yeah i think that's the generic name for it so that just i mean it has the opposite effect on you to the effect it has on people who are neurotypical in that it slows you down and and sort of calms you down rather than speeds you up so the other day i went um went out to do the big shots, and quite often I'll just get absolutely ripped before I go to the shop. You could go to the shop, and it's probably the most efficient that I am
33:31whenever I go to the supermarket. But it's also with the pain thing. So I technically get mine prescribed for back pain. And I think there's something weird with cannabis. When you're actually in profound pain it doesn't really give you the same psychoactive effect so okay i had um my appendix out three months ago and um when i was recovering from that i got through so much uh i think i was doing about 200 milligrams a day which is is a lot what's that in old money um 200 milligrams i can tell you it'll probably be over a gram a day something like that i was using the oil something okay and what how do you how do you take it how do you ingest it uh so the oil you just stick it under your tongue and the rest of it we've got vaporizers but where
34:16i had uh surgery on my abdomen i couldn't really take the vaporizer it made me cough it was like yeah a world of pain so i was making the oil but um i was taking so much if i took that now if i took that amount now i'd be capsulot so i wouldn't wouldn't be able to function but um but horses for courses and and your your your condition is understood well enough for you to know that right now this is going to help but if i was doing this when i don't need it then i'd be in all sorts of trouble so like any i mean you heard the last caller she was on morphine before she discovered it then karen yeah i i was listening to her and i was like she actually sounds like she's one of our patients and it's uh it's really
34:53nice hearing that from the other side because obviously in in our industry we do a lot about harm reduction and and sort of like the upper end of risk we don't really hear a lot about what goes on with patients at that sort of lower end where they have these really positive effects so yeah that was lovely to hear from me it sounded like it's been life-changing well clearly it has by our own account 100% life-changing but now you you compel me to ask you about the higher end of risk what what are the concerns there what are you what are you looking out for there yeah well so it's high use it's escalating use um typically uh clinicians are very good at identifying the risk and getting like a dependency so like you just like the way
35:31it makes you feel so you take it when you take it for reasons that are not the reasons you were prescribed it that's it yeah or it can become quite habitual there's still although you're not allowed to do it we obviously give loads of feedback around it there's still a lot of people that are smoking it with tobacco and that's obviously like a second addiction alongside anything habitual so yeah we're having a bit of an internal discussion at the moment about how we do harm reduction with high volume users and what we do around that yeah so I mean as with anything else I mean if you're not smoking it with tobacco the health disbenefits are presumably more behavioural than chemical are they it's more about being
36:13a bit zonked all the time as opposed to yeah well paranoia anxiety that still happens doesn't it yeah everything everybody reacts to things slightly differently so it's you know it's not So it's not a pharmaceutical drug, so we don't have like an LD50 test or something where we can say that this will work on 70% of the population. Ah, okay. That's interesting. We have to go through quite... It's like tritation, like you would with ADHD medicine. So you go through quite a long process of trying different strains and different terpenes have different effects with different people and stuff like that. That's the word of the day for me. I've not heard that word before, terpenes have different effects with different people and stuff like that. That's the word of the day for me. I've not heard that word before, terpenes,
36:46but it's obviously intrinsic to all of these conversations. The body work at the moment is looking at whether or not endocrine fever actually has any effect on the heart at the moment, and it seems to be showing that actually it's the terpenes that are having a much more significant impact on how you feel in response to medication. I'm fascinated by your age. You're sort of nearly 20 years younger than me and knowing what don't snigger like that it's not i'm 54 years old i'm still a human being man i still got rights i know you weren't i um i i got this growing sense that we've missed huge opportunities for decades that now you and your colleagues and other companies and other other scientists are exploring but that this is so self-evidently a good thing that it's it's a
37:31downright tragedy that it's taken so long to recognize that yeah i mean i think we would i think it should be done with caution of course it should be done with caution but no one is arguing about the fundamental baseline of an existing positive. I wouldn't want to see a world where you can go to your local off-licence and pick up an X from there. Because there's plenty of places where you can do that, including in the United States of America, as you know. Yeah, yeah, yeah. But you're still leaning towards the medicinal as opposed to the recreational. I think it should potentially be a bit easier. Yeah. I think there should be oversight and i kind of i mean i'm pretty anti-prohibition in most cases
38:10yeah i think that we should have a bit more of a wider conversation yeah and the more informed the more informed and wide the conversation is the more likely you are to experience the benefits that you and karen and others have and richard of course, a sort of dream case study in many ways, used it, it worked, and then stopped using it because, you know, he didn't need it anymore. And he was worried about some other factors as well. But, yeah, of course there's going to be concern that somebody who's introduced to it because of chronic pain six months later is, what was that word did you say cat yeah couch locked that's another thing i've added to my vocabulary today couch locked and terpene uh i might have experience of being couch locked but i didn't know there was a name for it
38:5610 47 is the time 10 50 is the time do you know one of the best stroke embarrassing things about this job is I can indulge a truly ridiculous urge, like an epic childish urge, which is if I crack what I consider to be a really good joke in very little company, as in only in front of one person, then because I have this radio show, I get to share it with you. I get to present the joke to a much bigger audience, even though it makes me seem slightly tragic. And I'll be doing that shortly. I'm also, I don't know, a few people have picked up on this and contacted me via Blue Sky, and I've had a couple of texts this morning as well. I think Andy Burnham's nicked another one of my lines. There's no way, and I know this sounds a bit self
39:42indulgent, but there's no way he randomly came up with the observation when talking about privatisation of water companies. There's no way and i know this sounds a bit self-indulgent but there's no way he randomly came up with the observation when talking about privatization of water companies there's no way he randomly came up with the observation that the only squares on the monopoly board you can't put hotels on are the utilities right and and if he had come up with it randomly or his speechwriter had come up with it randomly the fact that he came up with it randomly 10 days after I came up with it randomly is distinctly fishy, right? And now he's talking about the emperor's new clothes in the context of Brexit,
40:11which isn't just something I've said. It's practically one of my catchphrases, right? And I like it. I mean, you know, imitation is the sincerest form of flattery, but I'd be nice to get a bit of credit or even a royalty or a knighthood, actually. A knighthood would be nice, wouldn't it, Keith Keith I'll take you to the palace mate for the investiture be a lovely day out but anyway we'll try and find a little bit more evidence of that shortly speaking of evidence I'm going to play you a little clip of Donald Trump and I'm going to tell you that if you pay attention to this clip you should be able to work out from how Donald Trump attention to this clip you should be able to work out from how donald trump talks to
40:47this reporter something about the reporter have a listen to the way donald trump talks to this reporter um and see if you can without having any insights information information from me, or indeed pictures, see what you can work out regarding the NBC news reporter talking to Donald Trump here. If you listen to me, I know you don't see dirt, but if you take a look at the White House, you'd never notice broken windows, obviously, from where you come. I don't know. But we had 18 broken windows. I know you don't see dirt you wouldn't notice broken windows what does that tell you about the person who had posed the question i know you don't see dirt but if you take a look at the white house you'd never notice
41:38broken windows obviously from where you come from she was simply asking him whether or not he should have been paying a little bit more attention to the traffic control meltdown in the United States of America as opposed to his DIY projects at the White House. She's black. And that's racism. And that, once again, is the thing that they love, even though they can never tell you that. The people that want him to be prime minister of this country or the people who use phrases like Trump derangement syndrome. If it's not the sexual aggression and the misogyny that they love, it's the racism. Spoiler alert, it's usually both. And there is yet another example of it. So thin-skinned, so pathetic, and so racist.
42:211053 is the time. Back to the medicinal cannabis question tim is in wonderful wonderful copenhagen tim what would you like to say oh good morning james how are you very well tim good um i am i have ms i was diagnosed with ms in uh 2002 i think in the last five years now i've been a full-time wheelchair user. Okay. And one of the things about MS is something called neuropathic pain, which is essentially my nervous system is a bit messed up, so my brain interprets certain signals as pain. Right. Now, this can be an annoyance. My leg contract, the muscles in my legs contract a little bit, and, oh, that's a little bit annoying. Or it can be, Jesus Christ, somebody's just stabbed a red-hot poker in my calf muscle.
43:17Wow. And it can be anywhere. And it's all happening inside. It's without external stimulus or stimuli. Exactly, yeah. Oh, you poor thing. Well, no, it's just what it it's it's it's without external stimulus or stimuli exactly yeah it's because it's because well no it's just what it is i know it is but still you tell me something like that and i i kind of think oh god that sounds blooming awful and and when i say you poor thing i'm not patronizing you or condescending i'm just no no no no no of course authentically responding to something that sounds terrible but that you've obviously got used to. Yes, it is. Now, just to go back to the medicinal cannabis, I think over the last 15, 20 years, I've used things called tinzanidine.
43:58I've used pramiprexol. I've used sativex. I've used a couple of different baclofen all none of which work for me right how however and they do work for lots of people yeah so i'm not saying they don't work i'm just saying they don't work with me if i um experience neuropathic pain and my leg starts hurting If I smoke two or three lungfuls, within 25 seconds, it stops. Good Lord. And now again, that's my experience. I can't talk for everybody. So during the night, for example, I will have a joint. I choose to smoke it because I'm a smoker anyway. I keep it by the bed. So if my leg goes bananas in the middle of the night and wakes me up, which it often does, I lean over, pick up a joint, take two or three hits, put it back down.
45:00Within a minute, I'm asleep. Is this prescribed or is this just i do have a medical prescription but you can't get the leaf that you're or you can but i also i also it's very expensive let me put it that way so i also have a guy okay i understand and and i don't mean what is this legal situation in denmark is it is it the legal situation is that your doctor is perfectly allowed to prescribe medicinal cannabis but there are there are several doctors my last doctor for example had and i'm using air quotes again like your previous caller he had moral problems with prescribing it okay so so so so i mean i you could just, forgive me for being flippant, but you could just pop down to Christiania,
45:48I believe, in the city of Cologne. Is that right? Well, I could have done it until about 10 years ago. Yes. But the Danish government in their very, very high intelligence closed it down. Oh, I didn't know that. So now you have a guy. So you're forced into criminality, really, to manage your pain. you're forced into criminality really to manage your pain i'm forced into criminality because i can get five grams at the chemist and that will cost me 75 i'm translating money in my head so that'll cost me 70 quid um to go get five grams from the chemist right or i can ring my guy up and he'll be knocking on the door within an hour yeah and he'll sell me 50 grams for a tenth of the price good lord and
46:35you might have thought it would be the other way around really but i suppose you've got taxes and duties and and all sorts of other things going on so who can really blame you for well i mean obviously as you're aware you're breaking the law but the the priorities that you've described um don't necessarily mean that the law is going to be at the top of the list exactly but purely from a pragmatic point of view and i'm looking at this from a national economic status in denmark the the the earlier police chief has he he said that he believes the cannabis market is somewhere between 500 million and 1 billion danish crowns divide that by 10 to get the pound value yeah look at the amount of of economic um tax revenue that would come
47:29if you just legalized it and and you of course i mean you might not remove them completely but you take the the big respectable internet outwardly respectable international criminals off the board who sit at the top of these pyramids while it's kids on bikes generally getting arrested um you can tell by the rousing chorus in the background tim that you have taken me up to the end of this hour um i i'm not sure what we'll do next we've only got half an hour before alan milburn delivers his speech finally giving his um his neat report a subject that we have covered tirelessly on this programme. And it's probably another example of me being a bit too honest with you. Not always with great success.
48:10I found it quite a difficult nut to crack. Whether that changes or not, now that we will have clear government guidance and indeed potentially policy on how they're going to address this issue, only time will tell. But can we talk about James Bond, do you think? Just a bit. on how they're going to address this issue. Only time will tell. But would it, could I, is it, can we talk about James Bond, do you think? Just a bit. Three. Twas many nights before Christmas, and one woman knew she needed a Christmas tree, so to Wayfair she flew, finding just the right one, and for years it will last. Wayfair shipping was free, and remarkably fast. What's this? Garland? A wreath? Essentials to host? Good thing she celebrates way longer than most.
48:50As her cart filled with magic and decor from the heart, Merry Christmas to all. Get your Wayfair head start. For holiday decor you can count on year after year, Wayfair delivers. This is the story of the one. As a shipping manager, he's running the dock, stocking supplies, and making sure every order goes out on time. And Grainger helps him stay prepared. From shipping supplies to PPE to hand tools, he counts on Grainger to keep products moving and trucks rolling so his operation runs smoothly no matter the shift. Call 1-800-GRANGER, click granger.com or just stop by. Granger, for the ones who get it done. Minutes after 11, Donald Trump in Manila for a meeting with leaders of India, Japan and Australia, a summit looming as well where he'll
49:41sit down with Vladimir Putin and the chinese leader and discuss absolutely nothing substantive um at least of all vladimir putin's illegal invasion continuing war crimes in ukraine sometimes when you watch stuff with the sound off you you forrest gump was nice right everybody liked forrest gump he was he was an ingenue an innocent. He was wonderful. And that rhetorical device, that narrative device by which he just accidentally turned up at all the great moments in history was absolutely magnificent. Donald Trump is none of those things. But he's on that stage, and you just, when you haven't got the sound on, and he's standing there sort of swaying, and I'm not particularly well informed about the leaders
50:26of japan or australia the leader of india is a very controversial character but you know the idea that donald trump is the president of the united states of america it's probably the most delusional thing that's happened in my lifetime the idea that people thought he was going to be x or thought he was going to be y when he was obviously and completely zed absolutely hideous depraved i mean ridiculous just possessed of some diabolical energy that allowed him to persuade lots and lots of people to give him a chance and now here we are and of course some people still clinging to the carcass of the idea that he's anything other than a depraved imbecile. But of course, it is impossible to sustain that position if you're even vaguely honest or even vaguely unmoved by weapons grade racism and misogyny.
51:19But oddly, it's when the sound's off sometimes that you find yourself marveling at what is going on. So Alan Milburn here at half eleven, not here, here, but on this radio radio that you're currently listening all this device that you're currently listening to and we will take that speech in its entirety and I'll take the questions afterwards for as for as long as it remains interesting um which may be the entire duration which is going to take us up almost to Sheila Fogarty time be nice to squeeze in a little bit of Simon Marks before the end of the programme. Or indeed, if it doesn't take quite as long as is expected, start canvassing your reaction as well, although I'm sure Sheila will be doing that too.
51:53It's a hugely, hugely important issue that we have talked about many, many times together, but have not really got to the heart of. And that makes me particularly fascinated in what Alan Milburn is going to say. Because, you know, we're not bad at this business, you and me, finding something that's going on in our world and exploring it until we all feel we've got a much deeper and better understanding of it. And we do have a much better and deeper understanding of it than we had before we started talking about so-called needs. But it's nowhere near as deep or complete an understanding as I would want or as I would like. And I wonder whether it's even possible to achieve. But that is the challenge
52:32Alan Milburn has been set. And partly because he is not a member of government, I think that the Q&A will be worth listening to because it will not admit the possibility of journalists asking him about things that have absolutely nothing to do with the speech that he's just given i'm all for that by the way i'm not for a minute suggesting that journalists shouldn't ask politicians serving politicians especially government politicians questions about other things that they are involved with or responsible for i'm just saying that in alan milburn's case it would be very very odd if they if they were to do that the best questions I've heard recently I was asking that ridiculous man Chris Philp to account
53:08for the schoolboy the handbags that he had with that other ridiculous man Zia Youssef the other day on live television I mean again a bit like looking at Donald Trump with the sound off how has our politics ended up populated by such absolute... I don't think I should say that word. I think it's probably got connotations. But such minuscule figures, such tiny characters, not a physical reflection. I don't care how tall they are, but just the paucity of talent and principle. Chris Philp, shadow Home Secretary. It's like a punchline to a joke isn't it and then that use of character whose contribution to british politics has been a financial contribution to nigel farage's coffers i don't know if you saw the story by the way about the party the reform party
53:58paying his security um bills after he turned down the same provision that cammy badenock enjoys so he literally while claiming that it had been taken away from him he literally turned down i think a bodyguard a chauffeur in a car and you have to sort of wonder why he would do that and the answer is that they'd be well one possible answer is that they would be government employees wouldn't they or at least no they'd be civil service employees or or metropolitan police employees and and therefore their first loyalty wouldn't necessarily be to him it would be to um the united kingdom and i think we all know how nigel farage sometimes uh feels about that being a big fan of course of vladimir putin a sworn enemy of the united kingdom but we're not
54:43going to talk about any of that we We're going to talk about James Bond. I don't have strong views, and even if I did, I don't know if it would be a phone-in on who it should be. I really like Slow Horses, and the actor Jack Loudon in Slow Horses I think is brilliant. He's one of those actors who can do a lot by doing very, very little. But I've got recency bias. You know, I've only just recently finished the latest series of Slow Horses, so to be honest with you he's so prominent in my mind that he was my favourite to be Bond and then Gary Oldman sort of dropped a hint that he'd got the part. I don't have the same kind of framework that encompasses Callum Turner or one or two of the other actors that were in the frame
55:20I certainly will never be presenting a phone in along the lines of i should bond be black or anything like that because they're just invitations to indulge in really ludicrous pontifications aren't they um although i like robert pattinson i i think he's one of those actors you probably don't realize how much you've seen him in you probably didn't notice him in june for example because he had peroxide hair and a tube coming out of his nose. Someone said the other day, well, of course he was in Dune with Denis Villeneuve, who is going to be directing the new Bond film. And I sat there, I went, what did he do in Dune? Who was he in Dune? I like watching credits, but not when the film is 17 hours long.
55:58If the film itself, if the main feature is 17 hours long, I can give the credits a swerve. Unless it's one of those ones my kids like, where you have to watch the credits because there's going to be a secret scene at the end of them that will tell you about the next chapter in the Marvel universe. Is that right, Keith? Yeah. So, obviously, you'd stay in that, but I didn't, I don't even notice that Robert Pattinson was in that. And I know him, of course, as Cedric Diggory from the Harry Potter films, but some other brilliant parts that he's played. My youngest was watching the drama last night, which is a cracking little film. Twilight, of course. I was more of a Hunger Games person. They seemed to me to fit into the same sort of space.
56:34But Mickey 17, was it called Mickey 17? That was a brilliant film. That was quite subversive. He plays weird little guys, Robert Pattinson, and he plays them really well. He's one of those actors that... God, I didn't think I had anything to say about this. He's one of those actors that has one foot in the art house and one foot in the mainstream. It's really hard to do that. And it makes it a potentially fascinating... This is my audition for Film 26, by the way. It makes him potentially a fascinating casting. And it looked to insiders and outsiders alike as if they had gone the other way something happened last week something got sort of thrown up into the air it's not barbara broccoli anymore she sold the whole outfit the whole legacy to um amazon i think and so they
57:17would have the final say and and something happened last week people thought they'd got the job according to some reports and then patterson sort of came in out of nowhere. Or not out of nowhere, because Barbara Bocherly was talking about him being Bond in 2019. And now he is. Probably the most famous and accomplished actor ever to take on the role. Daniel Craig gives him a little bit of competition in that space, but Daniel Craig was a relative unknown when he got the part of uh of james bond robert patterson has has played batman robert patterson is currently batman so you know that is that is rare for someone of that caliber to shift into this franchise and i read this morning that he he has declined to commit to the four films that everybody else
58:04being considered was was required to commit to so four films that everybody else being considered was required to commit to. So he's given himself an element of suck it and see. What's the phone-in? It's not who was your favourite Bond. Because that's not a phone-in. That's a listicle. And besides, everyone knows it's Roger Moore. The phone-in that I want to have is about the character. There's nothing like it. There's absolutely nothing like it. There's not even a lot in the original books which I enjoy, and I really like the new iterations of the books. Charlie Higson has just written a brilliant one, and there's a new series underway. I think only the first one has been published. The name of the author escapes me, but it will come to be in a minute.
58:43Which extras... Oh, he hasn't been in Dune yet. He's in the new one. No wonder I hadn't bloody noticed him then. Thank you for that, Alan. He's in Dune 3, which hasn't been... I saw that picture in the paper... Sorry, you can tell A, that I'm live, and B, that I'm telling you the truth. So I saw that picture. Maybe I'd seen the trailer, but I still hadn't cropped... Someone said, he's in Dune. I said, what? He's not? I'd have noticed. Turns out I wouldn't have done because he's not in the Dunes that I've seen. Albeit that they were both 17 hours long. Thank you, Alan, in Poitiers, which is an appropriately cinematic location, of course. Anybody? Poitiers? No? All right. All right, here's another little bit
59:21of top quality cinema trivia for you. Why is Tom Courtney responsible for the James Bond franchise? Why is Tom Courtney... Do you need another clue? Do you know who Tom Courtney is? No, you don't know who Tom Courtney is. I work with ignoramuses. I work with philistines. Do you know that? Have you heard of Alan... You haven't heard of Alan Siletto have you either no he doesn't play for kidamist areas um why is alan silletto the author from the kitchen sink period of British cinema, theatre and literature, responsible for James Bond films? It's a brilliant question, that. And I may remember to tell you the answer if you're lucky. But here's what I want you to tell me. Why? Just why? Why is the James Bond character so uniquely enduring?
1:00:24It transcends generations. it transcends nationality it transcends era it transcends everything and and every time you think it's reached the end of its natural life they manage to reach so that's the easy bit to answer is it i mean it is a triumph of cinematic reinvention but the fundamental character at the heart of all the stories is the same he might have changed a lot with the times but it's still a spy fighting the enemies of the united kingdom and there are loads and loads and loads of stories like that none of the other characters have sustained in in the same way the frederick forsyth characters have not sustained in the same way even the john le caray characters have not sustained in the same way um the the military characters the jason
1:01:15statham type characters in films how on earth can one character have sustained a cinematic presence so uniquely and uniformly popular for so long what is it about james bond that explains the fact that we will be as excited about the new film as we were about the first film that roger moore made the first film that ge Moore made, the first film that George Lazenby made, the first film that Timothy Dalton made, the first film that Pierce Brosnan made, and the first film that Daniel Craig... How is it still, why is it still so extraordinarily popular? It's 11.16 and Alan Milburn is due to speak at 11.30, so two things occur to me. You better be quick on 034560609735 6-0-6-0-9-7-3. Otherwise, I've probably got another 20 minutes
1:02:08of material on Robert Pattinson's cinematic career and the role of James Bond in British espionage iconography. And none of us want to hear that. And the second thing that occurs to me is this would be a nice one. If you've sort of found the show relatively recently and you found yourself thinking, oh, I might ring in one day, but I don't want to ring in about that. I've never taken cannabis. I can't ring in about that one. This might be a nice one. You've got a view on it. Why? James Bond. Uniquely. There's no character like it. I sat here before I even came on air. I did some research on this one, which is a first. Trying to think of another character. So they're making Harry Potter into a television series.
1:02:41But it won't be reinvented. I mean, it won't be a complete kind of mean it will it will it won't be a complete kind of re-interpretation of it in the way that bond is there's no other character in any series saga franchise or whatever it may be that has survived for decades flashman hasn't survived for decades i'm a big fan of flashman master Master and Commander didn't work. It sold loads and loads of books. It didn't work in film form. There's no other character. James Bond is supremely unique. And I know because last month I was him. I played him for several hours on a game called First Light on the PlayStation 5. And I mean, frankly, I think I could have done a job for them over at Amazon if I was just 10 years younger. It's a brilliant,
1:03:25brilliant game. But it is the character. I've played loads of games where you go around shooting people and solving problems. That one absorbs you. It just gets you. It reaches parts. I'll tell you how big a deal James Bond is. Even the video game had a song by Lana Del Rey that was recorded specifically for the video game. A theme song for a video game. Which was written and produced in conjunction with my mate David Arnold, the brilliant, brilliant composer and musician who is often to be found listening to this programme at the moment. So if you are listening at the moment, David, I hope you just did that thing that people do when they hear their name. Whoa, whoa, whoa, what just happened?
1:04:11But why? What is it aboutames bond that is so extraordinarily what's the word i want for something that lasts for a long time so extraordinarily so extraordinarily so so what was resilient no we don't like that amazing Amazing, brilliant, fantastic. No, none of those words. What is it about James Bond that explains longevity? What explains his extraordinary longevity? It's 1118. Your thoughts after this. Grainger knows if you're a procurement manager at an industrial manufacturing facility, you're balancing inventory and budget while sourcing critical supplies across the operation. Too much inventory? Cost climb. Too little? Production slows. Grainger's $2 billion in on-hand inventory helps you get what you need when you need it. So you can help keep budgets balanced and lines moving.
1:04:57Call 1-800-GRAINGER, clickgrainger.com, or just stop by. Grainger. For the ones who get it done. Zobrien on LBC. Call 0345-6060-973. Can't say I'm surprised to See you running towards the sun Like I'm locked to a flame People try and stop you all the features will watch you time just to know whether you play your life like they're game I could listen to this all day and here's the magic right I can't believe we've only got 9 minutes and haven't taken a call yet here's the magic this song is different, man, I can't believe we've only got nine minutes and haven't taken a call yet. Here's the magic. This song is different because you know it's about James Bond. So it's not a bad song, right? And David Arnold is a genius.
1:05:53But because it's about James Bond, it somehow flicks switches inside you that it wouldn't flick if it wasn't about... It was exactly the same song, but it wasn't about James Bond. You might think, oh, that sounds like a David Arnold composition, but it's not about James Bond. You might think, oh, that sounds like a David Arnold composition, but it's not about James Bond. What is it? What is it? And the word I was looking for, you know, I've been sent it by about 200 different people. Eleanor and I just had a chat and said, who shall I credit with telling me what word it was I was searching for? But Sheila Fogarty just messaged me, actually, so she can have the prize. Enduring. Enduring. What is it that makes James Bond so enduring?
1:06:26Now, shut up, James O'Brien, and take a call. Dan's in Hannam. Good morning, Dan. The name's O'Brien. James O'Brien. What would you like to say? It is, yeah. Hi, James. So, he endures. There are other characters that endure, and I would counter that. So, Sherlock Holmes, of course, and the Doctor, of course. I mean, I don't want to go full geek and talk about why I think Bond deserves a category of his own, even when up against those two titans. But, you know, Holmes is very much set in his own era, and although they've updated it, it's not the same as a character moving effortlessly through the ages. And I don't think Doctor Who fits the same popular culture question for the very simple reason that it's only the same character technically.
1:07:19Well, they're an alien, but you know what I mean. In terms of endurance, though, they've all kind of gone on for more than you probably thought they might, and they've taken stories with them and done lots of different kinds of stories. Yeah, but I'm not going down the geek route. I'm asking what it is about Bond. What is it about Bond that makes him so enduring? What is it about Bond? Well, he's very, very... He carries himself beautifully. He walks with an energy that most men do not. Yeah, poor things. He talks in a way that most men do not. But you could say this about anyone. You could say this about Harry Palmer. You could say this about, you know. No. No? No, no, no, very different characters.
1:08:00George Smiley? No. No, they're both everymans, really. Yeah, you're right. Harry and George don't have the same energy. They're more cerebral than Bond, although Bond is a very clever man. They are not... You could quite easily see Harry Palmer make himself dinner in his room. Yeah. An omelette. And we rarely see, yeah, rarely see Bond do that. The only time we see Bond make any food is in A View to a Kill, where he makes a quiche, for God's sake. Or in Live and Let Die, where he makes Emma coffee. Blimey, I know your stuff. I do. I've got two of Anthony Horowitz's books right in front of me. They're very good. I enjoy those. The guys who do Doctor Who audio, his big finish, are about to release Charlie Higson's Young Bond as audio dramas.
1:08:52Oh, wow. So I'd recommend them. Did you read King Zero yet? I have read King Zero, yes. It's good, isn't it? I enjoyed that. Yes. Okay, King Bond. Do you know why Alan Sillito... Is this something to do with the diamond smugglers? Nope. I got you! You are the king of Bond trivia, and I know something that you don't know. Oh, I don't know the Tom Courtney one, although I can't recall it. It might not be Tom Courtney, actually. He was in The Loneliness of the Long Distance Runner, but it might be Albert Finney, in fact, who probably must have been in the frame to play Bond at some point. He was in The Loneliness of the Long Distance Runner, but it is... It might be Albert Finney, in fact, who probably must have been in the frame to play
1:09:28Bond at some point. He has been. He was in Skyfall, though. He played the gamekeeper. He was. But anyway, stay tuned. How can you not now? Because I'm going to reveal the role that Alan Sillitoe played in the James Bond film franchise. Hardly anybody knows this. As a kid, I'd go along when I first moved to London. I couldn anybody knows this. And I used to, as a kid, I'd go along when I first moved to London, I couldn't believe the things you could go to. So, you know, I loved those books when I was about 16 years old. Saturday night, Sunday morning, The Loneliness of the Long Distance Runner. And one day, I just saw that in Time Out magazine that Alan Sillitoe was doing a talk at the National Film Theatre.
1:10:03And I thought, flipping hell, the real part, this is what happens when you grow up in Kidderminster and then go to a very, very isolated boarding school, and then move to the best city in the world at the age of 19. And I thought, the actual writer is going to be sitting in a room, you'll be able to see him and talk to him. So I went along. It wasn't even full. That's how blasé Londoners are. And Alan Silito explained why he is personally responsible for the film, for the Bond film franchise. I'll tell you more in a moment. But first, Omar is in Brighton. Omar, what would you like to say? Oh, hi, James. Can I just say I'm a big fan? No, you can't say it. You're not allowed to, apparently. Keith gets very upset.
1:10:37This really is an all-time high for me. That's another Bond reference there, isn't that? Is that an Adele song, or is there not a song called All Time High? Oh, no. Come on, what film's that from? I don't know. Skyfall? I'm not a geek. You're a geek. Octopussy. Is it? Is it Octopussy? It's a Roger Moore. It's your Roger Moore. You're a Roger Moore. Okay, a little bit of trivia for you. Which LBC presenter is in the background of a scene in Octopussy? Oh, God. Nick Ferrari. Correct. There you go. That's proper trivia, isn't it? I hope I've got that right. I hope I've got that right. Thank you very much. Go on. Why is Bond so enduring? Well, I was just saying, I think the character's amazing,
1:11:19but it's more than just the character. It's the escapism. It's the food. It's the locations. A big part for me is the musiccapism it's the food it's the locations it's a big part for me it's the music music's amazing you know but you could pre you could i theoretically could emulate all of those things what's the thing it's got that nothing else has got well it's well i mean for me it's got um i'm the same pretty much the same age as you so i remember like on a sunday night before school going back to school you'd stay up and watch the bond film uh so it's the memory so i what i think with it's quite clever what they're doing with sticking pats in the role do you is is to try and get the the younger generation so i was saying to your producer that you know i'm i'm a kind of
1:12:03sad old bond fan dad yeah the first thing when my 12 year old daughter walked through the door when she got back from school was guess who the new james bond's going to be and she's a big twilight fan i was like it's robert patterson and she had a big smile on her face so this could be the next generation of bond fans who will have all the same stuff that we had when we grew up. Yeah, so they've done it again, haven't they? The cinema, the music, the action. Yeah, maybe it's magic. It's alchemy. Maybe we're not going to be able to pin down precisely what it is, but you're quite right to point out that the casting has got, you know, resurrection or next generation written all over it. Are we going to the news a bit early?
1:12:50Shall I not reveal the thing first before we go to the news a tiny bit early? Why Alan Silito is responsible for the James Bond? So Saturday night and Sunday morning, a seminal film from the kitchen sink drama era of British literature was turned into a film by Harry Saltzman. And it was such a successful film that Harry Saltzman made a ton of money. And with the money that Harry Saltzman made from Saturday night and Sunday morning, he funded Dr. No, which was the first James Bond film. Let's go to a little early to the news now and then return for Alan Milburn's speech. It is 11.29. Dominic Ellis has your headlines. Whether you're building a roster or a business, great talent can come from anywhere.
1:13:30Pebble helps companies hire and support employees across 185 plus countries. Pebble believes you don't build a winning team by limiting where you look for talent. That belief is at the heart of their new partnership with Bay FC and the way Pebble helps companies build their own teams every day. With Pebble, companies can hire in over 185 countries, bringing everything together in a single platform that integrates with the tools teams already use. The result is a global team that's actually set up to succeed with accurate pay, real benefits, and the support they need to thrive wherever they are. Bottom line, great teams can come from anywhere. Pebble helps companies build them. Special offer for podcast listeners. Pebble is normally $399 a month per employee. Already a
1:14:11no-brainer for what you get. But right now, there's a limited time offer on their site that makes it even easier to get started. Go to hellopebble.com slash sports before it's gone. That's hellopebble.com slash sports. Terms and conditions apply. cross immediately there i've just remembered another bit of absolutely top draw lbc james bond trivia this is much more impressive than the fact that nick ferrari can be seen in the background of a scene in octopussy um this is this is absolutely first class um it really is uh and i'll tell you in a moment because first i want at least one more answer to the question of why is bond so enduring tim's in lowest Tim, what would you like to say? He's enduring, I think, because
1:15:08he's quintessentially what we think of the best of British. No, no, no, no, he's not. I think you'll find he is. I think you'll find he is, and I saw it on GB News. The new James Bond has just been announced. It's Robert Pattinson announced as the new James Bond. Yes, the fellow from the vampire movies. He's not even British. Surely Bond should be a Brit. What do I know? Robert Pattinson there has been announced as the new James Bond. He's American, right, Chris? No, he's British. Is he? I'll take that back. Oh, sorry, Tim. You were right. Yes, I was right. He's... That was live on television. That was real. That's an actual television presenter responding to the news. Robert Pattinson, who put on an accent
1:15:56to play a part as an actor, isn't British. Oh, Lord above. So, anyway, there was an obvious flaw in my claim. Of course I wasn't watching GB News. Someone sent me the clip this morning. You have to remember the outrage in the client media when James Bond's car was a BMW. Yes, of course. One of Timothy Dalton's films. And awful it was that he did not have a British car. But why? I mean, there's hardly any left now, is there? I don't know who owns the Aston Martin. It'll be Aston Martins. It'll be a Rolls Royce, even though they may not be British anymore. That's not the point. I hear you. Why would being quintessentially British appeal to the rest of the world? Because James Bond, and the character has changed
1:16:36over the years. Yes, that's true. And he has he's appealed to be every guy that every guy wants to be. And he's every guy that every guy wants to be. And he's every guy that every woman wants every guy to be. Wasn't that on the posters? Was that on the posters? Men want to be him and women want to be with him. Or was that for something else? Yeah, now you say that, I think I have seen that in the poster. And he's actually quite... What I loved about the Daniel Craig years is that they kind of moved away from the sort of 1970s soft porn type thing, didn't they, into a much more complex characterisation. So it changes with the times. As society changes. Exactly. That's the point. We'd lost all of those, you know,
1:17:18those names with the sexualised names of the female characters that were in it. That's right. Which I won't mention because of Oscar. But, I mean mean we all know what they are. We do. Probably one or two we could say, but not the obvious one that we're all thinking of. Exactly. The one that people do forget. There'd be Ofcom complaints galore. There'd be Ofcom complaints galore if we did that, Tim, wouldn't there? I'm not going to mention the obvious one because we know that one, but there was a Van Coronatop, which most people forget about. There was. But maybe, I'm not even sure mention the obvious one because we know that one, but there was a Van Koronatop, which most people forget about.
1:17:45There was. But maybe, I'm not even sure you should have gone there, but anyway, it's too late now. So quintessentially British. Quintessentially British, and he's changed throughout the whole thing. I mean, if you read the books, I mean, he's a misogynistic, heavy drinking smoker. That's not who Daniel Craig played. It's not really who any of them played, is it? There was misogyny there, but not the rest of it. I think, if you think about it, Spy Who Loved Me was probably the last film I can think of where Bond was a womaniser. Yeah, as in several conquests per film. Yeah, as society changed, as our views changed, they changed the character. And that's genius. And it's going to be interesting to see whether Amazon can keep up with the Broccoli clan on that, isn't it?
1:18:33Because that was very much what she presided over latterly, and her father Barbara Broccoli, and her father Cubby before that, alongside Harry Saltzman. But I think that generational shift, that moving with the times, had an awful lot to do with her and amazon have now stepped up to the plate and the casting of pattinson would seem to suggest that they are they have got their eye on the ball i think so i think they have i mean i mean you could never have imagined even you know 15 years before the last you know before the last james bond film um that that would be a James Bond film. You will be very excited when it's out, won't you? You'll be there on the first day. Will you be there? Will you camp out overnight, if you can still do that?
1:19:15I don't think you still do that anymore, but the last time I did that was when the new Star Wars came out. Oh, wow. The Force Awakens came out. But again, a franchise that sustains, but without the same central character moving from film to film and generation to generation in the way that, I would say uniquely, Bond has managed to do. Thank you, Tim. 11.37 is the time. We are waiting for Alan Milburn to unveil his review into youth unemployment and his plan to help at least half a million young people back into education employment or training but there is still a little bit of um uh what would you call it housework going on and at the venue where that speech is due to be delivered um so i can come back to some top
1:19:57quality trivia for you the second ever actor the second ever actor to play james bond is a form was a former breakfast host on this radio station a lovely lovely man called bob holness who presented the breakfast show on lbc alongside dougie cameron for more years than i think I could even calculate. I mean, forever, part of the absolute furniture. Best known, perhaps, to my generation for going on to present blockbusters on the telly. But Bob grew up in South Africa, and when he was a young man, he played James Bond in a radio play in the 1950s, which made him the second actor ever to play James Bond because there'd been a kind of now-for tv adaptation of one of the books that had that had already been filmed so bob holness lbc presenter the second ever actor to play james
1:20:54bond um and that is your second bit of lbc related james bond trivia i don't think there's much else apart of course from me narrowly missing out on the part when they decided to give it to Daniel Craig instead. But, you know, I don't like to boast. Kay's in Redbridge. Kay, why so enduring? Oh, hi, James. Why is it so enduring? It's something for everyone. I remember watching it with my mum. I'm now watching it with my kids. Can't wait for the next one to come out. I mean, gosh, lots of people that you've spoken to have already mentioned some of the things so i won't go over those ones but when i think of the kind of glamour or the wealth or the clothing the baddies the gadgets the cars i mean and plus other
1:21:39things that people have mentioned the humor that's so important i mean um john cleese as q just used to just oh make me laugh ben wishaw probably my favorite actor in the world at the moment and he plays that part so powerfully these days but none of these are unique i mean it's just going to be the sum it's more than the sum of its parts isn't it that's the thing yeah you have to take them in its entirety and certainly you know if they're just in one location it's not enough they need to be in lots of location and i would say have different women in there not just the one and you know you've got to have the humor and it's and the the soundtrack is so important it. It is a combination of everything.
1:22:27And if you start moving things, I know the Daniel Craig one's got a bit serious. Yeah, but I quite enjoyed that. But you're right, you need a lightness of touch alongside the seriousness. I mean, the Roger Moore incarnation of James Bond would seem horribly out of place in the modern world. And the Daniel Craig one, one similarly would have been a very very different film and nowhere near as popular if it had come out in the early 80s but yeah I mean that's the miracle of the production process I suppose and the stable behind the films that have managed to stay relevant in so many different in so many different spaces. It is 20 to 12, Thank you, Kay. We were expecting the new youth opportunity test
1:23:08for government policy and other elements of Alan Milburn's report to begin about 10 minutes ago. But these things are always a little bit fluid. I can see a lady clapping on a stage, which suggests to me that Alan Milburn's arrival is imminent. And I do want to hear the speech from the very top. It may be a young apprentice. There's a little nod there for the Star Wars fans. It may be a young apprentice that is currently on the stage sharing the fruits of her experience as a way of introducing Alan Milburn to the assembled media. It will be mostly media there. I've gone full Dimbleby again, haven't I? And she's wearing a nice powder blue trouser suit with a white t-shirt and a little microphone conveniently pinned to her
1:23:52lapel. It is now time I believe for Alan Milburn to No, it's not Alan Milburn. It's somebody else. Two more young people. Hey, don't get me wrong. I love the young people. I believe that children are our future. Treat them well and let them show the way is my motto. But these two young people are also going to be sharing interesting information relevant to the speech that Alan Milburn is due to give and that we are poised, as you can tell by this extraordinary episode in audio space filling, that we are poised to take live at least 12 minutes ago. Any minute now, it will begin. And the reason why it's important, it shouldn't need explaining by me, but I will nonetheless, very simply, because the demographic change that this country is enduring
1:24:38and the way in which we are not really being shown the full picture of what is coming down the train tracks is going to be absolutely revolutionized in a bad way by the continuing plight of so-called needs. And if Alan Milburn has cracked the riddle or he has got a significant solution to this potential problem, then the benefits for the entire country for generations moving forward will be almost immeasurable. And he has been touring the studios this morning in quite a bullion mood. Some of the things that he suggested are quite radical. I have, for example, no problem with the idea of reducing some of the money that young people currently receive if it is replaced with something substantive. The best way to understand that, and I don't want to preempt the speech
1:25:29because I've got no more idea than you do about what's in it, is the distinction between capital and social capital. Something else that you taught me on this program many years ago. So social capital would be something to which you have access as a member of society, but it is yours. Albeit that you can't put it in your pocket and take it home, it is yours. Social capital. So most obviously social housing is social capital, albeit that we don't all live in social housing, but a library is social capital. The NHS is social capital. Things that we own and that we can access, but which we can't put in our pocket and take home capital much much easier to understand capital you can put in your pocket and take home
1:26:13so if he takes away some of the capital that is currently being given to young people not in education employment or training and replaces it with meaningful and substantive social capital, then that would be absolutely fine. That would be a good thing, in fact, because the current system is not working for those young people. The idea of some benefit payments becoming a kind of holding pattern and a sentence rather than a stepping stone to a different life, a stepping stone to employment, education or training, has really taken hold. But that is something to look out for. So lazy people on the left may respond unthinkingly to a reduction in some welfare payments, but it will not be an unthinking response
1:26:59if that reduction is not replaced by social capital, by, for example, actual spots in places, whether it's workplaces or educational institutions, for the young people to do instead of essentially being signed off and written off. Time is 11.45. If I took a break now, which obviously is what the schedule generally demands, I can absolutely guarantee that within 30 seconds of me taking that break, Alan Milburn will moonwalk onto the stage at the office block in central London where he is poised to give this speech. So, I mean, hey, Eleanor's just written on the screen. If you're totally out of things to say, we can take a break. Just excuse me for a moment. How many years have you worked with me?
1:27:45Seriously, I've forgotten. How many years have you worked with me? Seriously, I've forgotten. How many years is it now? I don't know either. Keith? Too long. Have I ever run out of things to say? No, exactly. So why on earth would it happen to that? On what possible planet is today going to be the day when I've got absolute, if in doubt, talk about yourself, James? That's what you normally do, even when you're not in doubt. So I've done all my James Bond-related LBC trivia. I've told you about why Alan Sillitoe, the doyen of kitchen sink drama in 1950s Britain, was ultimately responsible for the James Bond film franchise. I've shared with you my enthusiasm for the James Bond video game First Light, which is an
1:28:22absolute classic. Thank you, Keith. Albeit there's no point in me recommending video games to you at the moment because, of course, Grand Theft Auto will be out before the end of the week, and who's going to play anything else for the foreseeable? And I've also talked you through why Alan Milburn's imminent speech is both deeply significant and potentially epochal. It will, if it is half-decent, capture the zeitgeist and offer up a solution to some of the zeitgeist's most pressing problems. Keith, I don't think this music adds to the sense of seriousness that I'm seeking to convey on the programme. Mark's in Harkiv, because if you're talking about James Bond, you should talk to someone in Ukraine.
1:29:00Mark, what would you like to say? Well, you know, I've just been listening to that cornucopia of segways that you just put there. Cornucopia of segways. Michael Jackson. I know, it's extraordinary, isn't it? I thought my life here was confusing living in a war zone. You don't have drivers down. A myriad of paths. I had no choice, did I? What else am I going to do? What else am I going to do? You did well. What else am I going to do? Why is James Bond so enduring? Well, you know what? We went to the cinema here in Kharkiv, which is possibly the only front-line city in Ukraine. And we do it over winter. And this year, our choice, we do it once a week. And we go to the cinema and we're going to watch the whole collection of James Bond movies.
1:29:50So two movies a night. We sit there. We eat popcorn. You know, things here are quite normalized, strangely enough. So we eat popcorn. We have hot dogs. We have a laugh and a joke. So it's going to be two movies a night once a month and if you had to pick something most likely to please most of the people most of the time you'd struggle to do better than that yeah exactly so you know we had Blazing Saddles last winter and last winter was brutal you know down to minus 30 for about three or four days and we thought you know what, let's play Blazing Saddles. And Blazing Saddles, as you know, is a parody. It's not exactly... They're Mel Brooks. Some of our colleagues who are, let's say, not from the UK or the US
1:30:38just didn't get the movie and it got a little bit complicated. Having to explain that this is taking the mickey out of a genre with which they may not be fully familiar. Exactly, exactly. So we've settled this time. We're going to run the complete series end to end. Alan Milburn is approaching the stage. Alan Milburn is approaching the stage, Mark. So, I mean, I feel bad now. Are you all right? OK, we'll talk again. Let's cross live now to Alan Milburn. Really inspiring young people and not unfamiliar, actually, to me at least. As I've gone around the country, I hear such an echo, what I've heard today from Uwe and from Olivia and the conversations that I've had. It's a different story from the one that we often hear about young people,
1:31:27which is a story of a soft generation or a snowflake generation, and it's absolutely the reverse of that, it really is. It's a generation that is full of potential, it's full of aspiration, it should be full of hope. This report is about how we make sure that this next generation has the chance to fulfil that potential. So I want to begin by thanking you and your fellow youth panel members for sharing your insights and sometimes your challenges as we've gone along. I want to thank my expert advisory panel, some of whom are here today, and my brilliant review team led by Matt for doing the same. I also want to thank the government. I've just come from Cabinet. I'm not in it, by the way. It was very odd sitting around it 21 years later, believe me.
1:32:13But anyway, for asking me to lead the review, but also for backing it, and most importantly, for giving me the freedom to follow the evidence wherever it is led. I'd also like to thank so many people in the room who've opened their doors to me, the charities, the councils, the mayors who are with us today, the colleges, the schools, the public services and the businesses and to Google of course for hosting us today and for doing all that you're doing to create so many more opportunities for young people. But my biggest thanks is to young people themselves. During the course of the last 12 months, thousands have spoken to me and to my review team. Many told us things that were difficult and deeply personal, and they've trusted us with their experiences.
1:32:58I hope the report that we publish today repays some of that trust. It's the product of a year of many visits, both at home and abroad, much analysis, and on the odd occasion, quite a bit of argument. And I suspect that we might have a little bit more of that to come. But there is one simple and inescapable conclusion that I hope that we can all agree on. Britain is at risk of losing a generation of young people. Not because they lack talent, not because they lack ambition, not because they do not want to work. This is not a crisis of aspiration. It is a crisis of opportunity. Nearly one million young people now outside education, employment and training, one in eight and rising, six in ten have never had a job. Those numbers, you know, you live
1:33:52with them day to day, but truly they should shock us. Instead, I fear that on occasions the nations become used to them. Something to be managed, something to be explained, maybe even something to be expected. But today we set out how Britain can change that. A lost generation is not a fact of life. It's a choice. And I believe it's the wrong one. Not just because it's a fiscal crisis or an economic one, but because it's a moral crisis. We are failing as a nation to gift young people, the next generation, the opportunities they need to succeed. We forecast that within five years, neat numbers will be well above one million. Indeed, we'll be in excess of one and a quarter million. So the conclusion I've come to is that half measures will not do.
1:34:48The scale of the problem is just too big for that. We have reached a profound moment of choice for the country. It calls for a new approach to back the next generation, to make young people a top priority. This is not what we have been doing. We spend less on helping young people into work than the low-neat countries of Northern Europe. We spend less today than the Conservative government in the 1980s did on its YTES scheme, and less than the new Labour government did in the late 1990s on the New Deal for the young unemployed and over the last 20 years the gap between what we spend on an average older person compared to a younger person has more than doubled. Now this is not simply a cause for young people, it's a cause for the country. Demographic change makes
1:35:44getting young people into work a necessity. Britain's future relies on backing young people. They're the next generation of workers, taxpayers, parents, carers, entrepreneurs and public servants. Helping them succeed is in all of our interests. This report aims to change the life course of one million young people and the generations that follow them. It starts with setting a new national ambition. Within 10 years we should aim to get the NEET rate down to around five percent. That would put Britain among the best performing countries anywhere in Europe. They have done what we have failed to do. They do not have better young people. They've made better choices and they've created better systems to get their young people learning or earning. If
1:36:38they can do it, so can we. This report shows how full employment and education for the young can be achieved for our country, and in the process, how we can end long-term youth unemployment once and for all. Youth participation has to run through all aspects of public policy, like a stick of rock. Education, health, benefits, labour market policy, a new settlement that makes work, not welfare, the future for the next generation. That means transforming the current welfare state into a working state, one that is organised around maximising young people's opportunities to learn or earn. That will require not just new policies and new resources, but new laws and new institutions. If you think back over recent history, our country has had no shortage of
1:37:32schemes and programmes and initiatives, policies for young people. But none of them have been sustained. They've all been temporary. I've come to the conclusion that we can only eradicate the problem for good if we provide a permanent platform for change. So I know that much of the public debate about this issue centres on welfare reform. For some people, the only exam question they're trying to answer is how to cut the benefits bill. That is important, and it does need to be done. But the primary question for me is important, and it does need to be done. But the primary question for me is not about saving cash. It's about improving lives. Change should begin before a young person ever becomes neat.
1:38:18It's one of the tragedies in our country that you can predict with reasonable accuracy at the age of four or five who will be neat at the age of 4 or 5 who will be NEET at the age of 16 or 17. Poverty and disadvantage are the breeding ground, so parents need more support in the early years and there needs to be a bigger focus on prevention. I propose two long-term prevention ambitions. By 2036 at least 90% of children should be school ready at the age of five. By the same year, at least 90% should reach the expected standard in literacy and numeracy at the end of primary school. So schools need to change. They rightly focus on academic results, but not enough on readiness for work. We cannot future-proof every occupation
1:39:07or every job against AI and technological change, but we can future-proof young people. Technical education should sit alongside academic. We should create a new integrated curriculum so that young people are emerging, not just with qualifications, but with the skills and the aptitudes to navigate the future world of work. Schools should have a statutory duty to provide work experience for their students. They should also be subject to a new work readiness test, inspected by Ofsted, to ensure pupils are prepared for the workplace. Alongside that, a new outcome measure should be published to judge school performance on where students end up once they leave school. And the shame, by the way, should be true for colleges and for universities.
1:39:57The education system should be judged on attainment of courtesan, but also on preparation and on destination. The purpose is not to weaken academic standards, it is to broaden our definition of educational success. Next, the low NEET rate countries of Europe have invested far more in vocational education than we have. We should learn that lesson. Over the next decade, we should create more college places for an extra 150,000 young people, and apprenticeships need to be returned to their core purpose, to give young people a route into skilled work. I propose doubling the number of young people achieving apprenticeships over the next decade to 215,000. By then, apprenticeships over the next decade to 215,000. By then, apprenticeships should
1:40:47rival university as a mainstream destination for school leavers. Young people need more opportunities but they also need more support and nowhere is that clearer than health. Mental ill health has become one of the defining causes of youth economic inactivity. The health system is not solving the problem, it is exacerbating it. Rather than helping young people access help quickly, its diagnosed way to treat model leads to too many waiting, not working and ending up on welfare. And once people end up in welfare welfare they find it very hard to get out. Poor mental or indeed physical health should not become a one-way route out of education and work so we've got to stop assuming that just because a
1:41:35young person has anxiety or ADHD that they cannot work. Instead the health systems response should be about helping them to earn or learn. A different model is needed. Earlier support that is needs-led, not diagnosis-led. Young people who are NEAT should get guaranteed fast-track access to services like vocational rehabilitation, talking therapies, counselling. There should be a new legal requirement placed on local health services to work with mayors to increase youth participation and to sufficiently fund health-related services that can help young people into learning or earning. A similar change is needed in the welfare system. For most young people, welfare should be a route to work, not a destination. Too often, the present
1:42:27system does the opposite. It writes a cheque, but does not write a plan. It asks a young person what they cannot do before it asks them what they could, with support, manage. And once a young person enters the system, all too often, as I say, it becomes a springboard, it becomes a trap rather than a springboard. It keeps them in poverty with no real prospect of prosperity. Forecasts prepared for this report show the number of young people claiming disability benefits is expected to quadruple between 2012 and 2027. Like, quite simply, cannot be right. The growth in benefits far outweighs the actual change in ill health and disability in society amongst young people. That has two consequences
1:43:16and both are serious. Young people's life chances deteriorate, the benefit bill rises. We should tackle the first to deal with the second, not the other way around. The only way of getting the benefit down in a sustainable way is to help more people, especially the young, with conditions like anxiety or ADHD, into work. The answer is not crude cuts. It's more jobs. For the overwhelming majority of young people, work beats welfare. Where young people, work beats welfare. Where young people can work, they should work. The state should support them and help create the opportunities to do so. And where the minority cannot work, the state, of course, should provide better support and enhanced long-term financial security. The maxim at the centre of the new welfare system should be work
1:44:07for those who can, security for those who cannot. So I propose the creation of a new and different system for young people from the one that serves older adults. Young people are not the same as older workers. They're not returning to something after a temporary period of youth unemployment. They're reaching for something for the first time. The only entitlement that the state gives to most young people today is a single one. The entitlement to a benefit. That's what we prescribe. In my view, they need a different system, which gives them new entitlements to propel them into earning or learning. First, a new opportunity guarantee that provides young people for the first time, a statutory entitlement to a route into education or employment,
1:44:57and second, a new support guarantee, again enshrined in law for the first time, that provides them with the practical help they need to take it up. And a new backstop too, that after a year out of work a young person should be guaranteed a paid role for six months. Opportunity and support go together, but so does responsibility. As opportunities increase, so do obligations. They should be enshrined in a new duty to engage, which young people receiving benefits should agree as part of their personal participation plan. A young person who persistently refuses to engage could ultimately lose their benefits. Sanctions, of course, should be rare and reviewed regularly, but a deal without consequences is not a deal. The conclusion I've reached is that none of this will work, however,
1:45:45unless there's also a new benefit system that supports and rewards participation. The current system does not. From the get-go it separates young people into those who are defined as not being able to work and those who can. That denies too many young people the space and the time to get into education or employment. Instead, they get stuck on welfare. So I propose that the Work Capability Assessment, Universal Credit Health and PIP all go, and instead there is a basic youth allowance that everyone will get alongside a range of new services to support them into work. There will be more help in cash and in services for young people with health and disability needs to help them do the same, and for the
1:46:31small minority whose profound and long-term disabilities mean they will never be able to participate, there should be an enhanced long-term financial support. security. The longer this review has gone on, the more convinced I've become about one thing. The state should be doing more, not less, for disabled young people. Almost without exception, the disabled young people I've met want one thing. They want the chance to work. That's what they want. So alongside the opportunity and support guarantees, the government should adopt a new ambition to narrow the disability employment gap. That gap has barely moved in 10 years. It is a profound social injustice that, in my view, we should no longer tolerate.
1:47:22Larger employers should publish what they're doing to help to close it. Government should review longer tolerate. Larger employers should publish what they're doing to help to close it. Government should review the results. If progress is not substantial, it then should consult on introducing a mandatory disability employment quarter. That is what happens already in over 100 countries worldwide. Now, I do not pretend for a moment that any of these changes will be easy to make. The new system I'm proposing should apply both to young people who are already claiming benefits and those who do so in future. The support will need to be being put in place before the new benefit system kicks in. But some people could get less financial support at the beginning of their benefit claim than under the current system. But the approach I've taken is to try to define what would give
1:48:16young people the best chance of building a good life, not just over a year or two, but over the course of their lifetimes. There is nothing, in my view, remotely compassionate or indeed progressive about leaving a 19-year-old on a path towards a lifetime of economic inactivity. That is what the current system does, and that is what we have to change. Rather than simply writing a young person a short-term check, we have to build them a long-term future. The modelling carried out for this review shows that these reforms should help around 440,000 young people into sustained work by 2036. The net incomes of young people are expected to rise by over £2 billion, and relative poverty after housing costs is estimated to fall by 50,000. To spend less on benefits and
1:49:08more on getting young people into work so they can earn a wage. Today for every £25 the state spends on benefits for young people we spend just £1 helping them into education or employment. £25 paying for inactivity, £1 helping someone escape it. That, in my view, is the wrong way around. As a result of these changes, within the next 10 years, that ratio should be £2 to watch, amongst the very best in Europe. So I'm unapologetic about advocating that the state should spend more to set young people up for successful life earning or learning rather than spending decades with their sole income from benefits. That is the choice I believe is the right one for this and future generations of young people.
1:49:58One of the other central failures exposed by this review is not a lack of effort on the part of young people, it's a lack of a system to provide them with opportunity and support. These changes need a new delivery engine. Today, a young person gets lost in a maze. The council, the job centre, the college, the NHS, a charity, different assessments, different appointments, different people, different rules. No young person should have to become an expert in the machinery of the state simply to get help from it. Employers by the way face exactly the same confusion. So I propose a new youth opportunity service should be created in every part of England, a local front door through which all these
1:50:39services can be properly and more efficiently coordinated, one place to go for the young person and the employer for help with pastoral support, for a small business taking on a young worker, for arranging work experience, for getting careers advice, for sorting out benefits and for delivering the opportunity and support guarantees. For the young person, they will have one named advisor who actually knows them, one plan built around them and one system that stays with them until they're securely learning or earning. If you begin to struggle, somebody notices. If you need help, it arrives earlier. If you leave education, there is somewhere to go. If you need work, somebody helps open the door and if you fall out, somebody remains
1:51:21responsible for helping you back. In England, I propose that the local mayor or a group of local authorities, where there isn't one, will have responsibility for commissioning this new service in their area. Multi-year participation agreements between central government and mayors will bring together the devolved funding and authority needed to deliver the guarantees. They will also be the mechanism to hold mayors to account for delivery. If mayors succeed in getting their NEETs rates down and youth employment up, they will be able to share in the savings rather than all flowing back to the Treasury. That will give mayors skin in the game. Political devolution aligned to fiscal devolution. All of this will count for nothing, however,
1:52:07if there are no jobs for young people to go to. Talent is everywhere. First chances are not. We have to change that. And that means changing the deal with business. The biggest fallacy, in in my view in public policy over 50 years is that the youth employment problem could be solved purely by fixing the supply side. Make the young person more employable, raise the standards in the schools, improve their skills, toughen their benefits. The labour market, it was assumed, would then do all the heavy lifting and get young people into work. It hasn't. Employment has risen. Youth employment has fallen. Without a change in direction, rebuilding the first rung of that career ladder will not happen.
1:53:02Government needs to focus on the demand side as much as on the supply. A new bargain is needed with employers to create more first chances for young people. Government has to make it easier, cheaper and less risky for employers to create more jobs. It should begin immediately with a commitment not to increase the costs and employers of hiring young people still further. These costs have risen, not just over the last few years, but for very many. On the minimum wage, the government should continue to direct the Low Pay Commission to judge the pace of convergence against the critical goal of protecting youth employment in what is a very fragile labour market. I've looked carefully at what more government can do
1:53:50to make employing a young person financially worthwhile. Given the fiscal position, an immediate across-the-board national insurance cut, in my view, is not the best use of £5 billion worth of public money. Instead, I advocate that Government should create a five-year glide path to lower employer national insurance costs for workers aged 21 to 24, starting in the retail and hospitality sectors, because they employ over one in three young people. The best way of doing that is by doubling the point at which employer national insurance becomes payable for those young people, from the current £5,000 threshold to £10,000. Hiring incentives for employers should also be boosted, particularly for small and medium-sized
1:54:37companies. The employment incentive package would more than double government financial help for employers, the one we propose in this report, and it should help to create an additional 170,000 jobs and apprenticeship opportunities. It would be the biggest employment programme of its sort in nearly 15 years. And to ease the regulatory burden, employers, government should introduce a new statutory youth opportunity test, again enshrined in law, to assess the potential impact on youth participation of public policy changes. The explicit aim should be to prevent the youth labour market being flooded with more new regulation and to reduce existing regulatory burdens. You cannot call youth employment a national priority while making young people
1:55:25harder or more expensive to hire. As an employer, government must lead by example too. Today, only 6% of the civil service entry-level workforce is under 25. I propose getting that to at least 11% by 2032. Big public sector employers like the NHS and local councils should have a similar target. And we should use the enormous power of public procurement to create more chances for young people. When taxpayers are due to spend billions, I think it's 700 billion pounds in the next few years, on energy, defence and infrastructure, that money should build the next generation of workers, as well as delivering new assets or services. One of the things I've been most struck by in these last few months is how many employers have stepped up to the plate, committing to create more opportunities for young people.
1:56:20If government makes it easier to give young people a first chance, I ask more employers to take that chance. It is time we gave one to the next generation, a first chance. Of course, all of this will require investment. There's no point pretending otherwise. It is no good willing the ends without also willing the means. But the choice is not between spending money and spending nothing. We're already paying. One million young people who are NEET is costing the country around £125 billion a year. The fiscal cost alone is almost £22 billion, and it rises inexorably year after year after year. The choice is not whether we spend more money, but on what? By doing nothing? We're choosing as a country to spend more on keeping young people in activity
1:57:12and on benefits than helping them into work. My proposals are about doing the reverse. Spend less on benefits and more on enabling young people to participate, on education, on skills, on college places, apprenticeships, jobs, opportunity and support. Anyone who pretends that you can get hundreds of thousands of young people into education or employment simply by cutting their benefits is living in a fantasy land. It will require upfront investment. We have to put our money where our mouth is to kickstart the reform programme I'm calling on government to give an initial investment of at least half a billion pounds which should be available from April next year that can come from reprioritising existing spending
1:58:01it will then need to ramp up investment for these reforms should be a priority for the 2027 spending review. The majority, again, could come from a radical reprioritisation of government spending. And it is worth remembering that during the course of the next decade, there will be three spending reviews, not one, and they will need to determine how best to source, phase and allocate the additional multi-billion pound investment required for future years. As upfront investment takes effect, savings will start to flow, initially from reduced spending on benefits. Welfare savings can begin in this Parliament in 2029 to 30, providing government passes the legislation rapidly through the House to change the benefit system. And within a decade the
1:58:53proposed reforms that I've announced will lead to annual savings on the welfare bill of 3.6 billion pounds. The cost curve on young people's benefit spending will have been bent. In that year, welfare savings cumulatively will reach £13.7 billion. They will grow in the years that follow, as more young people move from economic inactivity into work and pay their taxes. The positive fiscal impact means there will be more savings than costs within the decade. Now, I know, for some people, this will appear too slow. For others, these reforms move too quickly. I've looked long and hard at whether more could be achieved earlier. It could, but only through crude benefit cuts, without the accompanying support.
1:59:43I do not believe that is defensible morally any more than I believe it will work fiscally. It would plunge more young people into destitutions and the costs would simply show up in another part of the state's balance sheet in increased spending on housing or health or crime. So I believe the approach I advocate is both radical and critically, it's doable. What is more, this is just the tip of a far bigger potential iceberg. My remit has been about the under 25s. It's worth remembering they account for just 13% of health and disability claimants. The majority are over 25. I say in my report that government should urgently decide whether the principles of reform I have set out here should also be applied to that older age group.
2:00:33The success of these reforms should also be judged on the impact they have on the lives of everyone across the UK by contributing to higher levels of economic growth. By 2036, if delivered in full, they could add approximately 0.4% of GDP per year. This, then, is a ten-year project. It's not a one-year sprint. But this report sets out a clear timetable for implementation, so that change can start immediately. I want to see real changes in the lives of young people in this Parliament. I know the scale of what I propose can appear daunting. I do not believe this ambition can be delivered by another programme simply layered on top of the old system. The task is to change the system itself. The welfare state was one of the great achievements of post-war Britain. Its promise of security, of course, must endure,
2:01:28but this generation needs another promise alongside it, of opportunity. The old welfare state needs to evolve into a new working state which is maximising youth participation at its core. Now, none of this, if we can, will be easy. Whitehall will have to give up control. Public services will have to work in new ways and to a new priority. Employers will have to do more. Local leaders will have to accept greater accountability alongside greater freedom. There will be difficult arguments about both resources and reforms. There should be. This is more than new policy. It's a new project for the nation. And there's a more personal reason why I believe we have to act. I've been incredibly lucky in my life. I grew up on a council estate and I had the fortune
2:02:18to end up serving in the cabinet. I'm part of a generation that has by and large done pretty well. We entered a labour market where the first rung of the career ladder was easier to reach. For many of us, housing was more affordable. We benefit from expanding educational opportunities like so many other people of my generation. I was the first in my family to go to university and we inherited a simple promise from our parents work hard and you build a better life that great British promise for this generation is being broken our job is to fix it the response to the interim report we published in May has convinced me there is a visceral mood for change in the country. Parents and grandparents feel it. Employers feel it. Politicians feel it too. They all know that the risk of
2:03:13a lost generation of young people is real. Being neat used to be something that happened to other people's children. Now, when a third of young people who are NEET have five good GCSEs, when 15% of them have a degree, parents are wondering whether it's going to happen to their son or their daughter in all parts of the country. And more importantly, they want to do something about it. It is this that has given me such grounds for optimism. It is at the top of the political agenda, but more than that, the country has begun to mobilise. Over 100 local authorities have established task forces to reduce local NEET rates. Mayors are poised and ready to go. Employers in hospitality, in retail, in tourism have come to us offering 250,000 more job opportunities for young people
2:04:05who are need. It's not just employers and it's not just politicians. Charities, community organisations have begun creating more opportunities for young people. This is the moment to harness that momentum and turn it into a national movement for change. So this is the choice before us. We can continue to manage this problem or we can decide to end it. We can continue spending billions after young people's lives have gone wrong, or invest earlier to help them go right. We can watch while the first rung of work disappears beneath their feet, or we can actively build it. We can keep a welfare system that asks first what somebody cannot do, or create a working state that starts by asking what they could become.
2:04:48The young people I have met are not asking for us to rescue them. They're not asking for an easier life. They're asking for a fair chance to build one. So let us make a new promise to the next generation. A promise that if you put in effort, there will be a reward. That we will be here for you. This is the gift that my generation has to give to the next generation. I think that is an opportunity. Most importantly, it's a responsibility. Thank you very much. There's quite a lengthy slot scheduled for questions and answers here, so we'll play it by ear, shall we, you and me? See how he gets on, see how engaging and important it is, and then start responding. We've got about 40 minutes, so if you wouldn't mind saying your name, where you're from. And then start responding. About 40 minutes, if you wouldn't mind
2:05:46saying your name, where you're from. 40 minutes, wow. Mic back to me after. So that's it, I've forgotten to watch. Thank you very much. Ryan Saby from The Sun. What is your message to the Prime Minister who is negotiating a youth mobility scheme with the European Union? Does offering youths from the EU the right to work or study here, does that undermine your work and your report? And just if I may, this is going to need someone in government to enforce this and to make sure these proposals actually happen. Have you been offered or would you accept a job to enforce this? I think the Prime Minister offers people jobs, right? So on that one, look, I think I've done my work, I've done my review.
2:06:30Let's see what happens next. But, you know, obviously I'm not going to walk away from this. You know, I care about it. I've cared about it for countless years. I was going to say decades, but it probably is decades. So let's see where that goes. On the first question, you know, I was at Cabinet with Andy and the Cabinet this morning, and I think they were discussing Europe as well as discussing this issue, so the two in some ways are related, of course. I mean, I think, look, my message to the country, not just to the politicians, but to employers is, you know, young people who are in those disadvantaged communities, they've got to come first. They should be the priority. And in some ways, you know, what has happened in the youth labour market over the last 15 or 20 years
2:07:09is that there has become an over-dependence on migrant labour. And you can see that. And migration has fallen now. And that creates an opportunity. It creates an opportunity for employers to reorientate back towards employing young people from their communities. And that's what they should do, in my view. And here, the public sector has got to give a lead. You know, it's got a special responsibility to do that. Take somewhere like the NHS. It's a huge employer. It's the biggest employer in the country. And we say in the report, guys, you know, you have a very diverse workforce. That's great. And you recruit from all over the world. And that's fantastic. But you need to be doing more to recruit from your local communities,
2:07:49particularly amongst the young. And if you look at the demographic bulge, particularly in the public sector, if you look at local government and the NHS, it's skews towards an older workforce. So there are going to be lots of retirees, and the question is, who gets the jobs as those spaces are created? And we say in this report the priority has got to be young people in those communities. Chris? I don't know everybody's name, but anyway, so I know Chris's name. Can I ask one on the supply side, one on the demand side? Sure. On the welfare proposal, you are saying the young people should go over and claim to him. Now, there are clearly work incentives when it comes to universal credit and the work people issue incentives.
2:08:28Are you saying that receipts of PIP give people a disincentive to work, or are you purely saying... A little bit hard to make out what question is being asked there. Hopefully it will become clear from the answer, but I think it's a question about whether or not benefits per se are a disincentive to encouraging people into work. Certainly some clarification needed at some point on the fact for example that pip payments are at least 25 percent of them go to people who are in work they're not a benefit they're a sort of assistance yeah okay both good questions on pip look pip is a it's in one sense it's a strange benefit because it's for people who are participating and people who are not, as you know.
2:09:09And for the people who are participating, you know, when you survey them, one of the biggest fears they have is that if they try to do more, they will lose more. And so, if you like, that does provide a disincentive to trying. And we want more young people to be trying, particularly those with a disability. And we shouldn't, I think, I think part of the problem in the benefit system is that it sort of applies a deficit model of disability. It assumes that if you've got a disability you can't, where we should be taking an active view about disability and saying you can, but you need support and you need help. So one of the reasons for changing PIP for the under 25s is precisely to do that. It's not that then everybody loses all entitlement
2:09:49because they don't, and you read the report and you know we propose an additional cost allowance for people with extra needs, and we propose a local flexible fund if you need it for an aid or an adaptation, or if you've got 24-hour care needs, for example, we propose this new insurance-based scheme. So, I think, you know, Stephen Timms' report quite rightly got right. You know, PIP is trying to cover one hell of a lot of ground in a lot of different cohorts of people with health and disability needs, and I guess our response to that is to say there's different cohorts with different needs, so we need different benefits for them. And he was right to say, I think, that PIP is no longer fit for purpose
2:10:30and that it needs to be changed. And what young people with a health or disability need is they need both cash and they need support. They need both at once. On the question of regulation, look, as I've gone around the country talking to big employers and small ones, sometimes this issue of regulation is pretty difficult to I've gone around the country talking to big employers and small ones, sometimes this issue of regulation is pretty difficult to get your hands around. What actually is it? What is it that employers are talking about that they're worried about? In the report, we try to address some specific things. So, for example, this question of sole traders who are, you know, we want more sole traders, we want more
2:11:06people self-employed, and we want them to be part of the army of employers providing opportunities for young people, and right now there's a very simple disincentive for them helping with young people, which is they've got to take out insurance to take a young person on work experience, and if you're an employer having to take about a special insurance scheme, that's a hassle, but it's also a cost. It costs you around 300 quid. And that's something that we think should be ended. More generally on regulation, which is why we suggest the introduction of this youth opportunity test in law, we say that, look, employers need a reassurance from government that before any change is introduced, then that can be a fiscal change, it can be a tax change, it can be a regulatory change, it can be
2:11:52a legislative change. It's got to go through the prism of what does that mean for the youth labour market. And so this is going to be, I think, quite a new tough test. And I hope it means that the regulatory burden on employers becomes less rather than more. And I hope it means that the regulatory burden on employers becomes less rather than more. So this is part of constructing the new bargain, if you like, with employers. But it's a deal. If we're making it easier, then employers are going to take up that. They've got to make sure that they are providing more opportunities for young people. If you wouldn't mind just waiting until we get your microphone just so everyone else in the room can hear.
2:12:24Go for it. Hi there. It's Richard Partington from The Guardian. Do you recognise that young people might be quite fearful of some of the changes that you're proposing on benefits, and particularly when it's about half of young people who are need to actually benefit claimants? This doesn't always apply. And then secondly, if I may, if when the government legislates on this next year, they expand the ambition to include outside of the under 25 cohort, is that not undermined by the fact that you're trying to focus on something specific here? Does expanding those principles more broadly, is that not problematic? Yeah, look, I mean, I think there's a conundrum at the heart of all of this, which is that
2:13:09we think young people are different because they've got a different set of needs. Because it's not that now, look, you know, when I was growing up in politics in the northeast of England, you know, when I was active in the trade union movement all those years ago, you know, we were living through 3 million people being unemployed it was people's march for jobs, it was all of that and it was terrible it was de-industrialisation and what was happening but the truth is, it was cyclical then the economy recovered and youth employment picked up this is no longer cyclical, it's structural it's young people not being in the labour market, they're detached from the labour market, they've never had the chance
2:13:50to be unemployed because they've never been employed. And the numbers are getting worse. Year by year, six in ten young people have never had a job. And so the reason that we've come to the conclusion that you need a different sort of welfare system for the young from the old is that they've got a different problem. So you're right to say that's what we propose. I guess all that we are saying is that, you know, since there's such a big focus on this question of the benefits bill and welfare, if you really do want to go at that, then look at the majority of where the claims are coming from, not the minority. The minority are coming from young people. It just happens to be the fastest growing element,
2:14:30which is what should worry us, of the Health and Disability Benefits Bill. It is rising most fast, but the quantum is in the older age group. Look, I don't make a recommendation on this. I just say, government, you need to look at it and decide. And so, I mean, I guess that's something they will do. I don't know what the response will be. On PIP and benefit changes, look, I absolutely understand that, that people may well be concerned. What I can say to young people today is that, you know, even with the best will in the world and, you know, a favourable wind on legislation, the likelihood is that changes in benefit will not be happening next year. It will be, you know, it'll be some time off, so there'll be a graduated process. If you're currently getting a benefit, then,
2:15:19you know, you will be protected and there will be a proper process to ease your transition into the new benefit system. And don't forget, what we're trying to do here is make sure that young people are not just getting cash, but they're getting support. And critically, that we are giving young people the opportunity that they want to have, which is to get a job. At the moment, today, if you claim a health and disability benefit as a young person, you stand a 50% chance of still being on that benefit in 15 years' time. You're still poor. You're still out of work. You've got no prospect of improving your life chances, and we do not think that is right. That has got to change. This is about making, I don't say any of it is easy,
2:16:02but I say it is the right thing to do, and this is the moment where we've really got to grasp the nettle of change around this, in my view, because otherwise this thing. Welfare is not the sole answer to the problem. It really isn't. You can pull the welfare lever, and it's an important lever to pull, but you've got to pull the education lever. You've got to pull the skills lever. You've got to pull the health lever. And critically, you've got to pull the labour market lever as well. And I understand why people are focused on welfare, of course, but it's not the sole thing that you've got to pull the labour market lever as well. And I understand why people are focused on welfare, of course,
2:16:27but it's not the sole thing that you've got to change. We've got to have a completely different approach. I was saying to Cabinet this morning that, look, what has been so brilliant about this whole process, and my team has been so brilliant at doing this, is that we haven't engaged with just one Department of Government. We might have sat inside the Department of Work and Pensions, but we spent as much time talking to the Treasury or the Business Department or to the Health Department or to the Education Department, because guess what? All of these have a bearing on young people's lives and opportunities, and that is how we've got to approach this as we move into implementation. We've got to get out of the vertical silos.
2:17:03We've got to treat it as a horizontal issue. Rachel. It's Rachel Sylvester from The Observer. I wanted to ask about education. You talk about an integrated framework within a decade for 14 to 19-year-olds in the report. What does that mean for A-levels, T-levels, GCSEs? Do you think there needs to be much more radical education reform and what does that look like? It's a really important question. I think it does need to be a more radical change than the government is currently contemplating on curriculum and on assessment, on both. I think they're moving absolutely. I think Lucy Powell has really moved this along and is moving in the right direction on all of this, and particularly this point about being able to get a vocational education alongside an academic one is a really
2:17:59important one. The watch out on all of that is we've just got to make sure that the technical route doesn't just become a route for working class kids. And the academic route remains a route for middle class kids. Because then we just pigeonhole people. So this has got to be, and this is where I agree with Michael Gove on this question of rigor and standards, which is rigor has to apply and standards have to apply both to the technical route and to the academic route. We've got to apply the lessons lessons to both but over time i think this has got to be much more integrated it's got to be much more modular we've got to be setting people up for a different 36 this is james you can tell by the accent and i'm just going to take you quickly to the house of
2:18:38commons where pack mcfadden is is already working pension Secretary is already responding to the Milburn report. That is why when the Cabinet met this morning to discuss the report, the Prime Minister and the whole Cabinet endorsed the need for a whole new system for young people, one that puts work and opportunity at its heart, with earlier intervention, stronger support, more devolution and clear expectations to take part. One that changes the question the state asks to a much deeper and more fundamental question and that is how do we help people live the fullest life. Today I want to set out what Alan Milburn has proposed and the next steps the government will take. His report is clear that this has
2:19:34been a long time coming. He says the NEAT issue is not new. The NEAT rate has hardly been below 10% in 25 years. It has become a fact of life and that is what we must change. In the future, we should judge the success of the welfare state not just by a snapshot of people's monthly incomes but by the story of people's lives, by their ability to achieve their full potential. And that is why we need a new settlement for young people. Just as we announced at our party conference a new settlement for older people with a reformed triple lock and a new national care service. And this new settlement must give people the best chance of higher living standards for the whole of their lives. It must change the equation that sees us spend £25 on the
2:20:35consequences of inactivity for every pound that we spend on opportunity. And that work has already begun. Our £2.5 billion youth guarantee, fully funded apprenticeships for the under-25s, more work experience places, hiring incentives for employers, youth hubs in every community and for the long-term unemployed, a guaranteed fully funded six-month job. But we must do more. Alan Milburn is right to argue for a new system that is more personalised, more devolved and focused on participation first. Instead of asking a young person to prove what they cannot do, the system should begin by asking what they need to build a future. So his first key recommendation is for a new opportunity and support guarantee backed by legislation
2:21:33so that every young person who is not earning or learning has a credible route into education, training, an apprenticeship, high quality work experience or a job. And we support this recommendation. His second recommendation is for a more personalised system which treats people as human beings, not as departmental clients. With employment, education, skills, health and wider support brought together around the person and crucially that this be delivered locally. The government also accepts this second recommendation. More local delivery with proper standards and accountability for outcomes. This is common in other countries with significantly lower rates of youth in activity because local leaders have the knowledge, the relationships and the networks
2:22:29to connect young people to the support and opportunities that make sense for them. Every eligible young person who falls out of education or work should have one place to turn, one trusted person responsible for helping them and one plan bringing together the support they need. And in this new system, opportunity must be matched by responsibility. So where someone can participate, they should be expected to take up the support available. The report recommends a youth allowance which people will receive whilst they receive help from the Youth Opportunity Service with extra support for care leavers and those outside the family home. It says young people whose disabilities or health conditions create significant enduring
2:23:20additional costs including those with conditions that fluctuate should continue to receive help with those costs and that support should not be put at risk if they start work. And because people should not always have to wait for a national assessment for short-term help, it proposes a dedicated locally held fund to help with one-off costs or temporary cash support. And for those with the most severe and lifelong conditions, where work is not a realistic prospect, Alan Milburn recommends a stronger safety net, providing dignity and security and an end to unnecessary reassessments. The report points out that in some cases, extra cash may not always be the right way to support a young person and that is because where participation is realistic the right priority should be
2:24:14earlier and more intensive support with their health, education and employment to help them build a better future. To help change the situation that we have right now where a 20 year old who signs on for long-term sickness benefits is more likely to mark their 30th birthday and still be on those benefits than to have had a steady job in any of the intervening 10 years. And as the Prime Minister said to the Cabinet this morning, delivering this new settlement will require a genuinely cross-government effort. And that is why the Government is committing today to the creation of a new Youth Opportunities Unit, which will report directly to the Prime Minister. We will also work with the devolved Governments
2:25:03to ensure that the benefits of local delivery and personalised support are available for young people throughout the United Kingdom. These are significant commitments to begin building this new settlement and there is a further step that we can take immediately for young people who have already spent too long out of work. The jobs guarantee that I launched earlier this year provides for a fully funded six-month job matched to a young person's skills. Alan Milburn recommends making this available after 12 months on universal credit rather than 18. I agree and we will do that. I am also hugely grateful to businesses in the retail, hospitality and tourism sectors for their recent announcements
2:25:53to hire a total of 250,000 young people not in education, employment or training over the next few years. In the weeks ahead the work of change will continue. I'm already working with colleagues from the Departments of Health, Education and across government to put in place a better support offer from now. We will have the TIMS review reporting soon. In the new year the government will publish a white paper and following that legislation and then the house will decide whether to continue with the current system the system we inherited from the party opposite which far too readily signs people off and writes them off or to bring in a new settlement for young people which puts opportunity participation and work at the heart of the
2:26:47welfare system and at the heart of the wider challenges that young people are facing. I put forward this response today not because it's a tough decision, but because it is the right decision. Carrying on as we are has too high a human cost, too many wasted lives and too much spent on failure rather than opportunity. And as the party of work, we believe that people from all backgrounds and all parts of the country should fulfil their full potential. That is what will change lives for the better. That is what will bring more hope. Because you're confused, Alan Milburn has delivered his speech. He's now still taking questions and indeed answering them. But substantively speaking, and as you know by
2:27:35now, substantive is one of my all-time favourite words, the events in the House of Commons are more important because that will clarify exactly what recommendations made by Milburn the government is going to enact. So I'm just going to go back now to the Alan Milburn thing in case he's broken into song. And they've learned something about the world of work before they enter it. So I think that's a very simple maxim. I think we'll take a little break. It is 12.48. Grainger knows if you're a procurement manager at an industrial manufacturing facility, you're balancing inventory and budget while sourcing critical supplies across the operation. Too much inventory? Cost climb. Too little? Production slows.
2:28:15Grainger's $2 billion in on-hand inventory helps you get what you need when you need it. So you can help keep budgets balanced and lines moving. Call 1-800-GRAINGER, clickgranger.com or just stop by. Granger, for the ones who get it done. You're listening to James O'Brien on LBC, where the speech by Alan Milburn continues, but the speech by Pat McFadden about the speech by Alan Milburn is now over. This is a bit like a Russian doll of radio coverage. The speech by the Work and Pension Secretary about the speech still being delivered by the bloke that has done the investigation has finished, but the speech by the bloke that has done the investigation has not finished. Either way, Sheila Fogarty will be responding
2:28:58to what we have learned and inviting your contributions. Largely positive here, although not exclusively. An awful lot of anger, not least about... I mean, it can't be a misreading of what pip is but there is a profound shortage of jobs employers are not currently hiring um and pip of course is already personalized so there will be plenty of room for critique um although you know i love it or loathe it the majority the rather large majority of communications coming into this studio are positive. I'll give you a little flavour of it. That was a terrific speech, grounded in common sense and a desire to make things better. I applaud it and a reminder of the void in politics to address this for far too long.
2:29:40However, I still can't quite believe that as health minister in Blair's government, he helped introduce PFI and outsourced operations to the private sector. You can't please all of the people all of the time, can you? Andy Hughes is here, LBC's crime correspondent, with an update on this. Well, two things, really. The fact that Russell Brand, the rapist, managed to issue a sort of call to his supporters, his followers, in which he denied the crimes he has been convicted of via his wife has caused extraordinary, well, I don't know if it is extraordinary or not, but really notable levels of unhappiness at the Ministry of Justice. And you have a story today, Andy Hughes, about a possible response to that.
2:30:21Indeed. So prison bosses want to ban him from communicating with his wife after they launched an urgent investigation into the statement that he released on his podcast on Sunday. Now, this is clearly a breach of prison rules. Inmates are not allowed to release statements to the media, whether that be social media or whatever, that causes distress to victims. And this clearly has, because we heard from some of the victims yesterday. And so, I mean, it was a human rights issue, I suppose, in terms of not being able to communicate with your own wife or your wife, a woman not convicted of any crimes, not being able to communicate with her rapist husband. But it is as a direct consequence of the breach of the rules that you described.
2:31:08It would be an interim banning while this investigation goes on. They need to get to the bottom of how this happened. Was this done in a phone call? Was this done in a visit? Was this pre-planned? So once they've got to the bottom of that, they will give him a punishment. I do know that prisoners are punished for speaking to the media. I've been involved in a case myself where I interviewed a prisoner. We deemed it was in the public interest to publish. And then he was then banned from speaking to his family for 12 months. So, I mean, I'm not saying it'll get to that. But it's certainly a serious matter that many senior people in the moj are very angry about um and and laura brand his wife of course was the one who read out the message she hasn't
2:31:55necessarily done anything wrong herself no no this all comes down to russell brand um and the planning of that communication um and there's also a lot of head-scratching going on, I must say, throughout my sources in the prison service as to why Russell Brand was downgraded to a Category C prison within a week. It is normal practice for a sex offender who's been given a sentence of more than 10 years to serve at least three years in a Category B before getting to category C. Category C allows them far more freedom, more time out the cell, more visits. It's a completely different kettle of fish. So that has left a lot of people upset as well. Is it not just because his fame makes him a target in a way that other prisoners would not? Well, in fact,
2:32:43it should be the opposite. He should therefore be in a more secure prison rather than one with more freedom. Everyone I've spoken to, all my sources in the prison service, they're astonished that he's been downgraded so fast. Gosh. And of course, the conspiracy theories, this isn't really your territory, Andy, but the conspiracy theories are gathering pace as we speak with regards to, I don't really know what the conspiracy is, but the idea that because Russell Brand told lies about vaccines and became close to some of the Donald Trump regime, the women must have, I don't know, come forward and decided to tell lies that then go through the entire justice system where rape convictions are notoriously difficult to secure. And he was somehow found guilty. But I guess if you subscribe to
2:33:31conspiracy theory, number one, then signing up for conspiracy theory, number two, isn't that difficult? I find this fascinating. I want to talk about it more. Why certain types of politics, most obviously people like RFK Jr. and in America and Nigel Farage in this country, appear to be so supremely comfortable with men who have been accused of hideous sexual offences against women. But now is not the moment. Not least because I want to end the programme on a slightly lighter note, Andy. I've got a job for you. You like an investigation. I do, I love one. So here's some evidence of something a little bit suspect that's been going on in the world of politics, Andy Hughes, all right? I want you to listen first to a
2:34:14little clip. You may recognize the voice of the person here making quite a perspicacious observation about utilities privatization and monopoly. It is not as daft as it sounds for me to point out that the six squares on the monopoly board that you can't build houses and hotels on are the railway stations, the electricity company and the water company. Oh, so that was in August, mate, right? And then in September, so mere days later, this happened. As someone said to me recently, there's a reason why you can't build all over the waterworks and the electric company on the monopoly board. Hang on a minute. Yeah I've got lots to say about this. It could be a coincidence but you're not in the business of coincidences.
2:35:02None of your contacts believe in coincidences do they? It's one of the first rules of policing, one of the first rules coincidences. None of your contacts believe in coincidences, do they? It's one of the first rules of policing, one of the first rules of investigation. And then yesterday, Andy, this happened. I know it would be much easier to say nothing about the EU. That's probably the conventional Westminster view. But if we are going to be serious about growth, then we are going to have to have this conversation. It's like the emperor's new clothes where no one is prepared to say the obvious truth. Well, I mean, the archive is absolutely chock-a-block with one person, at least, using the emperor's new clothes as a way in which to say the obvious truth. But here he is, reflecting upon that fact
2:35:49from, you know, years gone by, back in June of 2023. Those of us pointing at the float, pointing at the emperor's float, shouting, he's naked! He's naked! Maybe we were missing something. maybe there was a flesh colored body stocking but you can't now avoid the reality of the emperor's nudity it is 12 56 i just in case you think i'm exaggerating because i know you like to get all your ducks in a row before you before you mount a full investigation into these into these things, but I think I Would know we don't need any more than that because I've used a world well that right here I am using the same analogy in a completely different context Why is everybody why is Jacob Rees-Mogg telling me that it's a beautiful cashmere suit why is why is
2:36:47boris johnson telling me that it's the best dressed emperor there's ever been and off it goes and now everyone can see that it's naked and then along comes boris johnson and everybody's going look at those amazing robes look at his beautiful crown look at that feather boa it really suits him and we're sitting here for 10 years going, he's not got any clothes on. It's not a Venn diagram, it's a circle. Pro-Brexit, pro-Johnson, pro-Trump, it's all of them. It's all of them. And I apologise for conjuring up the image of Boris Johnson in a feather boa, but, you know, there's something a bit wrong going on here. Well, do you know what? I've got a lot on my plate, but I'm going to clear the decks for this one, James.
2:37:24I'll tell you that. I think we need answers, Andy. We need answers. You can't have the Prime Minister of the United Kingdom swanning around the place, nicking lines off gobs on sticks. My kids need shoes. I've got bills to pay. Andy Hughes, thank you very much, obviously, in the studio for a far more important story, which is developing because, I mean, it's a key part to all of the grifts on the far right that you get money. You hit up your followers, your supporters, your subscribers for money. And Brand was calling upon his supporters to support his wife. I don't think he wanted to go to jail. Some of the other far right grifters need to go to jail to keep the business model afloat. I think this is a widely uh misunderstood issue so you
2:38:06know if you're if you're in the business of being a racist provocateur you need prison in order to move the quotes fundraising end quotes efforts onto the onto the next level and you don't need me to mention any of the names that have proved to be pioneers in that um in that grift but but brand obviously a very different kettle of fish but singing perhaps some of the same tunes that's it from me for another day if you missed any of the show you can listen back on global player or the lbc app where you can also stay up to date with all the latest news videos and opinions and don't forget the subscription i haven't had time to tell you about it today because of alan milburn wanging on but um that's a new and exclusive bonus content
2:38:44from me every week and all the podcasts ad-free. Find out more about that at the LBC app or indeed at Global Player. Download it for free from your app store now. Coming up at four on LBC, it's Tom Swarbrick, but now it's time for Sheila Fogarty. This has been a Global Player original production. Hey, y'all. Kelly Clarkson here with Wayfair. You know my favourite compliment during the holidays? Your house feels so cozy. That's when I know everyone's comfortable enough to kick off their shoes, grab more dessert, and stay a little longer. Wayfair makes it easy, with everything from dining furniture to festive guest room essentials, all in one place. So whether you're hosting for an afternoon or all weekend,
2:39:22everyone feels right at home. Get holiday guests ready at Wayfair.com or on the Wayfair app today. This is the story of the one. As a shipping manager, he's running the dock, stocking supplies, and making sure every order goes out on time. And Grainger helps him stay prepared. From shipping supplies to PPE to hand tools, he counts on Grainger to keep products moving and trucks rolling so his operation runs smoothly no matter the shift. Call 1-800-GRAINGER, click grainger.com, or just stop by. Grainger, for the ones who get it done.