podcasts / James O'Brien - The Whole Show / episode
James O'Brien - The Whole Show cover art
podcast
📅 2026-11-16 ⏱ 143 min episode 📝 Transcript · 27,252 words

How the UK ended up leaving the EU

James O'Brien - The Whole Show · · Transcript & summary by WhipScribe

Read the transcript Episode page ↗
🔔 Get every new James O'Brien - The Whole Show transcript by emailOne email per new episode. Unsubscribe in every message.
One email per new episode, unsubscribe in every message. Not shared with the publisher.

Summary, chapters and key takeaways for this episode are on their way; the transcript below is complete.

▸Transcript

Our own transcript of the public episode, with a timestamp about every 90 seconds. Tap a timestamp to play the episode from there in the show's own player; the link button on a paragraph copies a link that opens this page there.

0:00Grainger knows if you're a procurement manager at an industrial manufacturing facility, you're balancing inventory and budget while sourcing critical supplies across the operation. Too much inventory? Cost climb. Too little? Production slows. Grainger's $2 billion in on-hand inventory helps you get what you need when you need it, so you can help keep budgets balanced and lines moving. Call 1-800-GRAER, click granger.com or just stop by. Granger, for the ones who get it done. This is a Global Player original podcast. Three minutes after 10 is the time. A very good morning indeed to you. It was a coincidence, really, that in the aftermath of the revelations regarding Davidid walliams we were scrambling scrapping around for the right question to ask that's probably the most important element

0:52of my job actually i suppose actually asking it's quite important as well but but getting the question right in the morning and and just completely uh by chance or completely organically rather not by chance because we were doing quite a lot of thinking. We zoned in immediately on that age gap angle, and now that dominates the entire discussion. So, we will return to that, I think, a little later today. I wonder whether it is quite as clean cut as some people contend. But we begin. I'll say it. You're listening to James O'Brien on Lbc and we're going to talk about brexit what happened then what happened does your heart sink does your heart sing do you do you find yourself feeling a little bit embarrassed because you know

1:38you got it wrong uh or are you feeling angry already because you think I'm going to rub your face in your own stupidity? I'm not, by the way. Or are you a little bit fatigued? Do you find yourself going, oh, lordy, I mean, it has to happen, obviously, but goodness me, it's always so febrile and so unpleasant. Well, then again, maybe James will get a call from one of those sort of three-pin plug or fish and chip paper people because they were always great fun. I don't know. What do you do? Should I examine myself at this point? I say, James O'Brien, LBC, Brexit. Whew, crikey. Crikey. That's my response, crikey. It's not the most articulate thought I've ever had in my life. Crikey, crikey. How are we going to do this? Because it's not the most articulate thought I've ever had in my life crikey, crikey, how are we going to do this?

2:26because it's happening and you know, again, you sort of wonder whether or not it does constitute rubbing people's faces in their own stupidity I remember not even that long ago people started, same kind of person who would say Trump derangement syndrome when other people were pointing out that Trump was an utterly depraved lunatic. And they'd go, oh, Trump derangement syndrome. And you go, no, mate, it's not Trump derangement syndrome. It is simply looking out the window, working out whether it's raining or not, and then telling people the truth. And the same kind of character who would say, oh, Trump derangement syndrome, would say, oh, I don't know why we're still talking about Brexit. And that was such a big moment, wasn't it? He said, I don't know why we're still talking about Brexit. And that was such a big moment, wasn't it?

3:06He said, I don't know why we're still talking about Brexit. You won, mate. You literally won. Why do you want people to stop talking about this glorious victory? Imagine if we got back from Wembley in 1966, and three months later, all the England fans were going, oh, yeah, we don't really want to talk about that. Don't really want to talk about that massive, glorious victory. Why are people still talking about that massive, glorious victory that we had in 1967? So, you know, they went quite quickly. It wasn't overnight, but they went quite quickly. From celebrating lapse of honour, canonisation for Boris Johnson and Nigel Farage. Oh, it's the best thing imaginable. And then they sort of went through a period of saying,

3:47well, no, this isn't the one we wanted. Never actually admitting that the one that they thought they wanted was never on the table in the first place. And then they started saying, well, let's stop talking about it now. Let's stop talking about it now. Absolutely magical moment, really, if we were to be remotely concerned by facts and common sense let's not stop that no no come on no let's not talk about it anymore why why aren't you why aren't you coming on air why aren't you writing articles every morning pointing out all the brilliant stuff that's happened let's be let's be fair right we left the european union immigration immediately plummeted cost of living suddenly got so much easier to deal

4:26with. We got rid of all those laws. Oh, you know, I can't remember them. I can't name any of them, but all of them, all of the laws that were really holding us back, we got rid of all of them. So we got rid of the laws. We got rid of the foreigners. We all got richer. NHS, flipping heck, who remembers the NHS before Brexit? What a mess. What an absolute mess it was. Thank God it's better now, eh? Waiting lists almost non-ex... I mean, crikey, everything. Just think of a promise that was made and ask yourself whether or not it was kept. And then, of course, you move into the second stage of Brexit, which is denial. So you go, oh, well, OK, clever clogs. That promise may not actually have been kept, but that's because of you. You, O'Brien. It's your fault. You and,

5:13let me, Lineker. You and Lineker scuppered Brexit. I mean, people make this argument. Admittedly, they're not people you'd necessarily trust with scissors, but they make this argument. You scuppered Brexit or the Labour Party ruined it. How? How? Boris Johnson betrayed Brexit. Boris Johnson betrayed Brexit? Okay. Okay. I mean, what on earth do you say to somebody making these sort of ludicrous claims? And then if you take a step back, you have to clock a very simple fact, a very singular, simple fact. It's the same conversation. People are still in a state of denial. If I told you that the front page of the Daily Telegraph today says, Johnson, Britain would back Brexit again, you could be forgiven for thinking

6:02that you'd woken up in the early scenes of a Bill Murray film. I mean, it is extraordinary. Daily Telegraph, Boris Johnson, Brexit, back on the front page. It was always going to happen, despite the best efforts of the fraudsters and ignoramuses who said, why are we still talking about Brexit? It was always going to happen. It had to happen. But I fear... Fear? Is that the right word? I don't know how can the conversation be different this time? Because all it takes is for someone who understands nothing to stand up and say, oh things could definitely be different things could be so much better, we just need to be tougher or less tough or more tough or as tough or tough tough or half tough or no tough or not tough

6:46at all we're just not oh come on we're just kind of always it's still there it's still there brilliant brexit it's usually communism isn't it that fits into that space true communism has never been tried they say and while it's technically true there's a reason for that human nature there's a reason why true brexit has never been tried it's because it doesn't exist how many different brexits were offered up to people how many different brexits were actually voted for how many other people bother to remember the promises made by the prominent brexitors that it would definitely definitely not be anything like what actually happened absolutely nobody is talking about leaving the single market.

7:25We could be like Norway. That's just Daniel Hannan and Nigel Farage, two Brexit extremists who were campaigning on the promise of a much milder Brexit than the one they actually got. And the reason why they got a much tougher Brexit than they were expecting is because that was all that was available. Once you decided to leave the single market, you had once you decided to leave the single market you had no choice but to leave the single market once you decided to abandon the freedom of movement of workers the freedom of movement of labor you had no choice but to leave the freedom of movement of goods and the freedom of movement of money you had no choice it was always true it was always true and yet here we are wondering whether anything will be different this time around so

8:13andy burnham has done what kirsten i think kirsten bottled it that would that would be the word that i use i i could be wrong that may be an unfair description but i think kirsten bottled it um andy burnham will today i think deliver a speech in which he will promise a revision if you like of the situation he is going to offer up a variety of options he's going to posit a variety of options and um and and and point out that we have lost more than we gained. First question I'd ask him at that point would be, what have we gained? He will make a case for a reset in Britain's relationship with Europe by claiming that the world has fundamentally changed since 2016, which is true. But even if it hadn't, it would still have been a terrible, a very silly thing to do, a very silly thing to do.

9:03And then he'll try something that's really interesting then he will try to argue that the um that the inevitable gravitational pull of closer relations with the european union is both irresistible and uncontroversial he will say the point is because the text of the speech has been released the point is that this is a win-win it illustrates our new approach not adversarial no longer burning bridges but being constructive and positive showing that we can come together to confront shared challenges um and and i find that fascinating because immediately the Daily Telegraph have got on the phone to Boris Johnson and said would you mind terribly being very adversarial please and Boris Johnson has said certainly I shall be

9:51as adversarial as you please my good man and so Andy Burnham releases the text of a speech in which he says we're going to be less adversarial Boris Johnson like Pavlov's dogs jumps up and starts being very adversarial and there will be plenty of people itching to get adversarial again here's johnson it is madness to escalate the brexit issue as your political priority he will impale himself and his party on this point and he needs to move off it because he won't win because the reality is that people are not fools says a man whose entire political career hinged upon treating people as if they were fools the idea of boris johnson riding to power on a tidal wave of informed and educated opinion

10:33is about as comical as the idea of boris johnson becoming prime minister in the first place spoiler alert he did so i mean do you know there's's the grown up in me wants to sort of ask you what it would look like. What would it look like a non adversarial friendly resurrection of the of the Brexit conversation? the list but i'm also thinking about the decade that has passed the decade that has passed you know i had something of a i wouldn't even say it was a sideline it was the main course of this program for longer than i care to remember when caller after caller after caller would tell me what they thought they were voting for what they thought they had voted for and i would often not very politely i'm not going to lie to you i think i'd probably be a

11:29little bit more polite now but then there was an awful lot to be angry about back then i would very carefully explain to them why the thing that they had voted for was never going to happen or i would explain to them why the, the reason that they had for voting in the way that they had voted was false. I mean, off the top of my head, a government of a country within the European Union could have had much more stringent rules on who was able to come here than this government chose to impose. How on earth can you prove that? Well, have a look, for example, at Belgium. The idea that we had loads of unconscionable and unbearable laws imposed upon us, more or less against our will, was best dealt with by asking people which laws it was

12:15that they most passionately objected to. That was mad, wasn't it? Do you remember when that first started happening? I mean, people would be so high on their own supply. They'd be so puffed up with this sense of righteousness that they would say to you with their full chest, we've got to get rid of these laws. We've got to get rid of these laws. And you would say, or I would say, and I can't remember the first time it happened. If only AI, would AI be able to find that? The very first time somebody said said because everyone was doing it this isn't a reflection on the people that would ring in making these points everyone was doing it oh we've got to get rid of these laws these laws are awful we've got to get rid of these laws and i would say oh i didn't know that much about this

13:02issue when we started coming off the back of the referendum. It felt like a daft thing to have done, but I hadn't dug as deeply as I probably should have done into the weeds of it. That happened retrospectively. So you'd say to someone, oh, which laws? You'd think, wouldn't you, if you'd made a decision based upon the belief that something was true, you'd think if you said to somebody, is that true they'd be able to say yes it is here's the proof here's here's the proof and they never ever could could never tell you which laws it was and of course listen if you want to go on google or whatever it is and find a law that fits into that category that proves nothing because the people who insisted

13:45that that's why they'd voted the way that they'd voted couldn't tell you what the law was and and you'd push them and push them and push them and eventually they'd say something about foreign workers or foreign non-workers which of course was not something that was made inevitable by subscription to freedom of movement of labor, with a small l. So, 10 years have passed, right? And I'm kind of thinking about a relatively well-informed 22-year-old. 12 years old at the time of the referendum. Not that I plugged into it. two-year-old. Twelve years old at the time of the referendum. Not that I plugged into it. You'd be too busy getting on with being twelve. And you look at it now and because the media

14:34that delivered Brexit is increasingly moribund, it's increasingly irrelevant, the Murdoch newspapers, the Viscount Rothermere newspapers, the increasingly irrelevant print media that pushed for it and pushed for it and pushed for it. And you just would look at it, wouldn't you? And how on earth did we become the first? You say to your dad, Dad, why did you vote to impose economic sanctions on yourself? And Dad would say, oh, I didn't. Oh, what's on the telly? Anyway, let's just anyone want to go out for a nice walk you just change the subject wouldn't you i i kind of think that the question i want you to answer today and you can do it positively or negatively i'm a big fan of empathy as you know you don't have to offer up reasons that paint people um as as ignorant or

15:22atavistic or xenophobic or any of those things. A bit naive, maybe. Gullible, certainly. But hey, we're all naive at times. We're all gullible at times. I think I just want you to tell me how it happened. 0345 6060 973. How on earth did people who've been proved wrong about pretty much everything manage to persuade quite a highly educated population to to vote for something that was impossible to deliver the the the mythical brexit that would please all of the people all of the time i don't really mind if some of your answers to this question are a bit obvious obviously i would prize the slightly less obvious ones. But I don't think we spend enough time. I don't think we have spent enough time

16:11digging a little bit deeper into it. Because we fall for the slogan, oh, I don't know why we're still talking about Brexit. Oh, Brexit means Brexit. Oh, they need us more than we need them. Oh, let's go WTO. These slogans that we can mock and deride actually damage us as well. The people who actually have a vague understanding of the issues get caught up in this sloganeering as well. Because instead of actually discussing things that matter, you are discussing things that don't, like meaningless slogans that just cover up ignorance. So that's the question I've got for you today. Andy Burnham is poised today to deliver a speech that will essentially resurrect, without any room for doubt, the UK's relationship with

16:57the European Union. It's at the Lord Mayor's banquet. It's a big flagship speech. He will, I mean, accuse is the word the telegraph uses i'd go with describe mr johnson as delivering a brexit that did none of the things he said it was going to do take back control of our borders improve our economic prosperity all of these things and and and asked whether he would he believed that britain would once again back Brexit at the ballot box, Boris Johnson replied, absolutely. So we're back, baby. It's back. I don't really want to have a conversation about whether or not we would be quite that stupid again as a population, because I have to believe we wouldn't be. But I do want you to tell me how it happened.

17:42How did it happen? Explain to a young person who's looking at the promises that were made and the reality that was delivered this is the crucial point the promises that were made increased prosperity reduction in immigration sovereignty laws all of those things nhs and what actually happened how i mean how did we fall for it how did how did it happen how how did it happen oh three four five six oh six oh nine seven three is the number that you need that's it that's the question it's 10 21 10 23 is the time the most consequential vote probably of our lifetimes unless we get another one which is a possibility now that andy burnham has grasped the brexit nettle and by a very very small margin the country got it hideously and obviously wrong how how explain to someone not not the mythical

18:37coma patient who's just woken up after being asleep for 11 years. Explain to someone who's 22 today but was 12 in 2016 how we, their parents, their grandparents, turned them into a country that became the first in history to vote to impose economic sanctions on itself. How did Brexit get over the line? Gary's in Cotham. Gary, what would you like to say? Hello, James. Be kind on me because I would never normally ring your show because we're so opposite um i would just like to point out that as much as i appreciate what you're saying about that they messed brexit up all i can no no i haven't said that yeah all i can no i haven't i haven't said that they messed brexit up yeah well i've just i've just pointed out that what has happened was always going to happen yeah but all i can say is as a working class man i voted to leave i didn't want to leave i voted

19:31to leave because i wanted some kind of reform and all i can see all i could just let me explain one thing all i can see is that i spent i spent five years watching the telly watching people in parliament battle argue and just rip this country apart. And what I wish they'd have done is respected the vote from day one, all pulled together across all parties and got the best deal they could. But what I witnessed... They did. No, they didn't. They got the best deal they could. No, because what I'm saying, you have a game of poker, yeah? You spend five years... It's not a game of poker. It's not a game of poker. It's not a game of poker. You can't... Let me explain. No, because you can't explain things that are based on falsehoods.

20:11You see, this is the problem with resurrecting the conversation. It's not a game of poker. Well, this is why I never ring your show because you'll not let anyone... No, I am. I'm just not letting you make a fool of yourself. It's not a game of poker because you know exactly what cards are in circulation, what's possible and what's not possible. It's only people like you who've been persuaded you can pretend that it's like a game of poker. So you can say to the EU, ha well I'm going all in on this but they know that you can't possibly have a full house in your hand. So I used to live in an area, we used to have an MP called Tom Brake, yeah? Yeah. He was a genuinely nice fellow. He lost his seat, right? Right. called tom break yeah yeah he lost he was a genuinely nice

20:45fellow he lost his seat right right and then about two years afterwards he was in my local high street helping the next candidate that was going to take his replacement run for the next election i pulled into one side i said tom i said do you think you would have kept your seat if you respected the vote he said what do you mean i said well if you had a respect what does that mean gary we're not not sitting there arguing against the people who voted to leave. But what were they arguing about, Gary? Like I say, if I sit an MP that was sitting for 10 years off the seat and agreed he got it wrong... But what were they arguing about, Gary? What were they arguing about? They were arguing about the fact

21:20that one thought they could do this, one thought they could do that, one didn't want to leave, one did want to leave. If we had a vote. They should have respected it. That's the point. Right, and was the vote for leaving the single market? Yes. Because Daniel Hannan said it wasn't. Yeah, but... Was the vote for being like Norway and still being in the customs union? All you're doing is regurgitating the argument. No, no, no. You're regurgitating the ignorance. I'm regurgitating the facts. Was the vote for being like Norway? Look, James, we're going to go round in circles. regurgitating the ignorance i'm regurgitating the facts was the vote for was the vote for being like norway look james we're going to go around in circles no we're not going around in

21:50circles gary i'm going in a straight line you're jumping up and down on the spot no we're not was the vote to leave the single market yes right lots and lots of brexit campaigners said it wasn't so how are you going to how are you going to settle that? How are you going to deliver the Brexit that was voted for when loads and loads of people voted for a Brexit that didn't involve leaving the single market? Like I say, we're all adults and we chose to vote. So I chose the bit I wanted to listen to. You began the conversation by saying you didn't want to leave at all. No, I wanted to reform. But you didn't want to leave. The first thing you said to me was that you voted to leave but you didn't actually want to leave no no no because even i know that we were

22:28better together like what i also i also it sounds like you're arguing with yourself now after spending five years complaining about parliamentarians arguing with each other no because i also knew that our didn't know anything mate went and what you thought and believed things that were simply not true you didn't know anything and i'll You thought and believed things that were simply not true. You didn't know anything, and I'll prove it to you now. What reform did you want? I wanted reform. Yeah, what, though? You've got to tell me something. You've got to give me something, Gary. You've got to give me something. We've got to put something on the barbecue. What reform did you want? I wanted lots of reform.

23:01Yeah, just name one. Yeah, more control of our NHS. More control of our NHS? Yeah. So you thought that the European Union exercised control over the NHS. Could you tell me how? Because we had less freedom of movement. So more control of the NHS because we had less freedom of movement? Yeah, because you've got less people pulling on it. Those words don't mean anything. Oh, I see. You wanted to get rid of the foreigners who were being treated in NHS hospitals. No, James, I'm not pretending I've got all the answers. You haven't got any answers, mate. You don't even know what the questions are. And I'm not pretending I'm more intelligent than you. I'm not saying that. All I'm saying to you is...

23:41You wanted reform, but you can't tell me what reforms they were. And our Prime Minister wanted reform, and that's why he went and asked for it. You can't... So if he wanted reform when he was voted in, we all wanted reform. So which Prime Minister are you talking about now? David Cameron. He went... David Cameron is a pie. Yeah. But that's your opinion, James. Everyone's got an opinion. No, You are not expressing opinions. You are saying things that are not true,. You are saying things that are not true. And I am saying things that are true. Admittedly, David Cameron being a pie, that is an opinion. That is not a matter of sort of biological fact. I'm happy to concede that to you. But when you talk about reforms...

24:18No, no, no, listen now. You talk about reforms that you wanted. It's a meaningless conversation if they were not achievable or if they were never going to be delivered by brexit do you still not understand that even now no i understand it doesn't matter what your opinions are if you voted for the moon to be made of cheese or for the earth to suddenly become flat or for you to become the best looking man in copthorne it doesn't matter how many times you voted for it, it would never happen. It would never happen. But yeah, like I say mate, I appreciate you taking my call anyway. But nothing's changed. No, but like I say James, because we're just doing what they did for five years. No, we're not. We're not.

25:00Alright, well try... But we can't, can we? Because you've got your opinion, I've got my opinion. No, I haven't said an opinion. I haven't expressed an opinion. James, you do, but we can't because you've got your opinion, I've got my opinion. I haven't said an opinion. I haven't expressed an opinion. James, you do, but you don't realise. What opinion have I expressed? That you clearly did never want to leave. No, what opinion have I expressed today about Brexit? That you didn't want to leave. No, the opinion I've expressed about what has happened since that vote. Your opinion is that we would have been better staying and we would have achieved more staying. Well, that's a matter of historical record.

25:30Yeah, exactly. And your opinion is what? My opinion is that I can't agree with you because I can't get out of my head that if they had come out of the traps fighting for the best deal instead of fighting against each other, it might be different. But now I ask you to tell me what was the deal that you thought was achievable, and you can't tell me. James, we can go on. Because whatever I say, you're going to rip apart. Why is that, do you think? Because you don't agree with me. No, it's not a question of agreement. Listen, I will now be silent for two whole minutes while you tell me what was achievable and better than what we got like i say more and i'm going to give you headlines and then you're going to rip them apart like i say

26:10we we want to send terrorists back that have used our system we couldn't because the human rights law and then you're going to come out of an argument and i'm not saying that i'm right i'm not saying that you're wrong maybe you are right but i can't get my head around the fact that it may be if they didn't spend five years fighting with each other and just respected the vote and tried to work together and get the best deal, that yes, it might never have happened. And then you might have been right. But then at least I would know you were right and I wouldn't be rigging your show. But I think the biggest problem was that they messed it up and I wish they didn't mess it up. And then you could say to me, Gary, they did what you wanted and it's still wrong so i'm right so there you go i appreciate your time

26:50what what did you want i just wanted i wanted what i prime minister wanted at the time reform and change there you go mind how you go 10 32 is the time. Dominic Ellis has the headlines and we're back. Everything from dining furniture to festive guest room essentials, all in one place. So whether you're hosting for an afternoon or all weekend, everyone feels right at home. Get holiday guests ready at Wayfair.com or on the Wayfair app today. There's a thing, isn't there? And it will sound a little odd to you, possibly even a little bit facetious. But, you know, you don't let me make my point. You don't let me do this. You don't let me do that. It's very ungrateful someone is literally making a fool of themselves and you're

27:48giving them everything they need to stop and they get cross with you for pointing out how how little they know what what did you vote for reform what reform anyway you're interrupting me you're talking i don't think we did it enough i think the debate was too polite i think the the BBC booking one economist out of the whole world who was prepared to say that Brexit was going to be a good idea, where every other economist on the planet was clear that it wouldn't be. It's a terrible, terrible mistake. The debate in many ways should never have been conducted in a yin and yang way. There should always have been numbers they're like a massive seesaw of evidence and understanding and even now somebody who voted for something 10 years ago

28:31that they simultaneously didn't want and wanted will eventually if pushed hard enough boil down to the um observation that they didn't want so many foreigners to be treated by the nhs to which the obvious response is what about all the people that work there you're getting rid of them as well you realise that don't interrupt me don't argue don't condescend don't be so arrogant it's taken me a while to realise what that is it's just another fig leaf isn't it don't point out how wrong I was don't point out how silly I am you arrogant condescending so-and-so. Let me speak uninterrupted bilge and then go away. Don't challenge what I'm saying. Don't point out how wrong I am. Don't patronise me with

29:16contempt for the con men, compassion for the con. Let me say things that are demonstrably untrue and treat me with respect and don't point out my falsehoods. That is, of course, what the BBC did, both before and after the referendum. It let people say things that were nonsensical. It let two positions be simultaneously held by the same team. You have two people on the same team. So I feel sorry for Gary. I doubt he welcomes my sympathy. But you've got two people on the same team. One of them saying we're definitely not going to leave the single market. One of them saying that we definitely are. And you voted for that team. So what were you voting for with regard for the single market? Were you voting for the team member who said we were going to leave it?

30:02Or were you voting for the team member who said that we weren't? Oh, I don't want to talk about that. I just want to talk about all the arguments that happened afterwards. Mate, you voted for a team that couldn't agree with each other about what game they were playing. And your cross arguments ensued? It's a brilliant call that. It's incredibly helpful. Not necessarily intentionally, but incredibly helpful. I'm very cross about all the arguments why didn't they just do what we voted for what did you vote for the thing that that member of your team said the thing that this member of your team said or the thing that that member of your team said so that's the first answer to the question of how did it happen

30:39is they made not just conflicting or different promises, they made fundamentally contradictory promises. So two people who voted for the same thing were voting for two things that could never both happen. You cannot be simultaneously inside and outside the single market. And yet here's a Brexiter who is adamant that he wanted to be inside it, and here's another one who is adamant that he wanted to be inside it. And here's another one who is adamant that he wanted to be outside it. And the bit that I missed and the reason why that was such a helpful call is that then you can persuade yourself that all the arguments that have ensued as a consequence of you voting for something that the team delivering it hadn't even agreed it would look like is somehow excusing you from your responsibility for voting for the impossible

31:27well it wouldn't have been impossible if the other people who we also voted for hadn't made entirely contradictory promises incredible that really helpful though um so one of the main reasons it happened is that you are always going to get more votes if you're promising ten different things that cannot simultaneously happen than you are if you're promising one thing that has already happened. What do you want to vote for, the status quo? Or ten contradictory mythical futures? Well, I'm going to vote for one of those mythical futures, I think, James. Thank you very much. Stick it on the side of a bus. Alan is impressed with it. Alan, how did it happen? Honestly, James, I thought the Remain campaign was awful.

32:10Yeah, I think I'd probably come more to that conclusion in the years that have passed since. You hear people like George Osborne on the radio, David Cameron being interviewed by Michelle Hussain the other day, and you think, how the hell did we do so well? Well, yeah, and i put a lot of that down to the then leader of the labour party yeah me too yeah um because i think he attended 16 functions the lies were never refuted i i can remember when i was working you know people people were coming up to me and saying they need us more than we need them you can have all the benefits when you leave the single market. The sunlit uplands of Brexit, and there were these arguments that I mean, their campaign was clever

32:52James, I thought. I mean, they had that red bus, red, what do you think of it? Red Labour. Oh, Labour. Labour are for leaving. Yeah, right, yeah. Nice one. I hadn't spotted that. Labour are for leaving. Oh, and we never had a figurehead to turn around and say, utter rubbish. Utter rubbish. We never had anyone charismatic. And I think I saw an interview with Alan Johnson saying, Alan Johnson was pleading then with the leadership of the Labour Party to do something. Do something. And, you know, at the end, theirs was a better campaign, full of lies, but they campaigned better than us. And, you know, it was led by two of the biggest rogues ever. Which one? Johnson and Farage. Just back up on the Remain campaign,

33:38because I think if I'm making a list of how did it happen, we've got point one from Gary, which is that everybody who voted for it voted for not only something different from the other fellow who voted for it, but also something that couldn't happen if the other fellow got what he wanted. So it was a contradictory promise, contradictory promises from the start, although it would appear that some people still haven't clocked that. Point number two, if I was to paraphrase your contribution, Alan, Jeremy Corbyn was a leaver yeah it was it was alexa tear and so were a lot of other trade union leaders who were supposed to be looking after their members interests and he wanted to leave he was a tony

34:17ben flavored 1970s revisionist leaver he didn't want to be in the european union and he couldn't really pretend otherwise yes but as a leader of the labour party he should have stuck to the labour party's mandate which was we believe we believe in remaining and he didn't he would argue technically that he did and that he attended and that he attended events and he never actually encouraged people to vote leave but he didn't really encourage anybody to vote remain either did he and he went the interview where did you give the eu seven out of ten i'll tell you what people don't well i'll tell you what happened with james the rich the original referendum in 1973 i said to my dad i was age 13 i said dad why you know what what you're voting for this thing and he said i'm voting to stay son

35:01i said why is that he said because i've said, no one is sticking a rifle on your shoulder and telling you to go over the hill and kill a foreigner. Because I've lived through World War II, I've seen enough of that. And the EU was the most brilliant peace project ever. That's certainly how it was envisioned and it's how it was delivered. I mean, I suppose in Corbyn's defence, you've got quite big trade unions who were against leaving as well. I remember watching Mick Lynch's Halo Wobble when he was in this studio, trying to retrospectively justify it. But that was based in large part on some misunderstandings of what legislation, European Union legislation, could and couldn't countenance, would and wouldn't allow.

35:44So it wasn't just Corbyn. But so, I mean, in a way, Cameron was rubbish. Whether or not he was a pie is open to debate. And Corbyn was rubbish. And there was very little left. No, the thing is, Cameron had that public school arrogance. I'm always like... Hang on a minute, mate. There's nothing wrong with a bit of public school arrogance. It pays the bills. It pays the bills, Alan. It pays the bills. It pays the bills, Alan. It pays the bills. But no, you're right. I'm going to go to the European Union and get some concessions instead of explaining to the people in this country that we had by far the best available deal to the resentment of other member states, especially France. Our rebates and our exemptions

36:24were boiling the blood of some of our fellow European Union members but Cameron either didn't have the wherewithal or didn't have the appetite to actually explain that to voters so I mean who was that who was the maypole that we were all supposed to dance around it ended up being people like Michael Heseltine and John Major coming out of retirement practically to make these arguments tony blair i think was probably a busted flush by then i'd like to have heard more from gordon brown but where would you have heard it right yeah so it's number two on the list absolutely abominable leadership from the remain campaign very hard to argue with liars if the thing that they're lying about doesn't actually get tested until weeks months years down the line all right well you can't prove

37:06that i'm lying you know what was it that jk reese mogg used to say cheap food for peasants well he didn't actually used to say that that was me paraphrasing some of his contributions to this debate cheap food for peasants he would say cheap shoes cheap shoes for peasants and i'd say that they're right there isn't going to be any cheap shoes but i couldn't prove it couldn't hop in a time machine and bowl into JD Sports and show you that the shoes were still costing the same as they were, if not more, actually, because, of course, supply chain issues would add to the costs. How on earth did something as bonkers as Brexit happen to a country that used to be sensible? 0345 6060 973. 1048. Granger knows. If you're a procurement manager at an industrial manufacturing facility, 0-345-6060-973. and on-hand inventory helps you get what you need when you need it, so you can help keep budgets balanced and lines moving.

38:07Call 1-800-GRANGER, clickgranger.com or just stop by. Granger, for the ones who get it done. It is the time and Brexit's back, baby. I won't add baby to that, I don't think, again. And if I do, please feel free to submit your complaints to all the usual places. But, I mean, crikey, think of all the Brexit predictions we made on this programme. Every single one of them has come true, up to and including the fact that, of course, it's going to return to the political fray. The only question is when. And I leant towards sooner rather than later until Keir Starmer became prime minister and essentially tried to kick it into the long grass for the duration of his entire lifetime. Up pops Andy Burnham

38:49with a very early determination to at least reopen the debate. There's a question to be had later this year about whether or not the debate is going to be less febrile, less ignorant than the ones we had before. The fact that Boris Johnson is on the front. Boris Johnson of course didn't make his mind up about which way to jump on this until he'd written an article in support of both positions and made his final decision based entirely upon the question of what would be more likely to open up his passage to No. 10 Downing Street. I don't think he thought they'd win. In fact, if you really want to have the photograph that summarises this question, how on earth did it happen? Go and have a look now. Look it up. Have a look at the photograph

39:30of Johnson and Gove the morning after they won. Have a look at the press conference. So Farage was dancing around the place as if he'd sort of just been given five million quid secretly by a foreign-based crypto billionaire. Farage wasn't interested in anything except Farage. He wasn't going to have to deliver this nonsense that he'd promoted. He wasn't going to have to actually explain why it was impossible. He wasn't actually have to go back to the people and say, ah, well, you know, when I said it was going to be like Norway and that chap over there on the same team as me said that we were going to be out of the single market, there's no earthly way that we can deliver both of those things. so at least 52 percent of at least half of

40:08you are going to be disappointed angry and betrayed at least half of the people who voted for me who voted for leave are going to be disappointed angry and betrayed by definition half of you voted thinking you'd stay in it because people like danielan told you that you would, or me, I told you that Norway was an option. And now you're on the same side as all the people who told you they were definitely not voting for that. So Farage didn't have to worry about that. For the first time in his life, Boris Johnson stared the consequences of his own actions in the face. Go and have a look at that picture. Go and have a look at that picture. Go and have a look at that picture. 10.51 is the time. Kieran's in West Norwood. Kieran,

40:48what would you like to say? To your question about why, there's a number of reasons, but I also wanted to address, I think, your first caller's point where he was saying that he wanted change, didn't really know what change he wanted, just wanted reform. It's a big deal, though. And I voted remain, but I feel like I understand the points that they were making a little bit more and probably hope to address his part as well. So fighting against something is a lot easier to say, oh, let's leave. It's a lot easier because it's like, okay, well, here's the change. We can offer this change even if it is fabricated and an illusion of, oh, you know, if we stay, you're going to have to join a European

41:35army and you're going to be constricted and your children are going to have to join a war. And I can't prove that that's not true until it happens. And then it doesn't happen, as it were. And you used to say a lot of the time, it's better to be on the side of the you know, be on the side of the army that, you know, will be in an army rather than be against it kind of thing. That still baffles me, mate. I'm still baffled by that, Keira. And since when were the army that we were in the one that we were supposed to be worried about? I know, but ask Farage, because I still don't know. Well, it is scary to think, you know, oh, I'm going to have to join an army that I didn't ask to join. You know, then about the law changes,

42:17there was, again, yes, we could set our own laws and everything like that. But, you know, when people are told, oh, our Luma are not supposed to be, you know, when people are told, oh, our lawmowers are not supposed to be as strong, you know, they could be stronger, but the Europeans are ruled on it to say that our lawmowers can't go above a certain noise, then it's like, oh, look at those silly rules. And then ignore any other rule. There's so many silly rules. And that's why I'm happy to vote to leave. And no one would say that to me. Even if I, you know, when I said, what law? No one could sit there and say, well, I'm happy to vote to leave and no one would say that to me even if i you know when i said what law no one could sit there and say well i'm voted to leave the european union

42:49because yeah exactly because it would be too embarrassing to say out loud although there was a woman on question time who i mean she giggled afterwards but it was very interesting that she had nothing else who talks about bananas that boris johnson. I don't even know what the claim was that the European Union had inflicted upon us, but that was all they had, bananas. There was more as well, though, in my mind, because then it was like, okay, the NHS, you know, oh, if we pay money to the European Union, look how much money we're paying to the European Union, oh, if we stop paying them, we can spend all this money on the NHS. You're bringing it all back. You're bringing it all back here, because that would be a bit like going to a car boot sale,

43:29making £1,000 every Saturday, and then voting to stop paying your subs to go to the car boot sale. So you weren't allowed to have a stall there anymore, but you were £100 a week better off because you were no longer paying for a pitch at the car boot sale. Oh, it's all coming back to me now. There you go. One of my strongest beliefs i remember um when i was in secondary school watch over now but i remember when i was in secondary school learning about the european union and it was only i think 15 countries at the time that i was learning about it um and obviously it continued growing it continued growing as more countries join obviously there's more freedom of movement, of labour and stuff like that, and then obviously

44:05more people are coming, more foreigners, more foreigners are coming, and obviously people are like, oh, if we leave, then we can stop foreigners coming in, and there we go, we're solving all our problems, and it's like if everybody just understood what it really meant, then no, we probably wouldn't, but again, it's easier to paint these quick pictures, and it'll be all solved with the flick of less leaves of course and if someone turns up at the door of a theater and shouts fire and there isn't a fire you cannot call the 52 of the audience who ran for the fire exit stupid because they thought there was a fire 48 sitting there going either i don't trust that guy he's been shouting fire every night since

44:45last january or i there's no fire there's no smoke i mean you're taking a risk when you sit so that yeah again responding to the scaremongering whether it was racist or not is is in some ways a rational response kieran i want to crack on so i can squeeze in at least one more call although do we fancy another hour of this i mean it's a bit like the good old days isn't it i mean it would be quite nice to hear some of the arguments or the attempts to argue the things that were promised back then and never came true now. But Gary might have covered all of those bases by simply saying, no, it could definitely have been better and it's all the fault of everyone who argued that it isn't. But I can't tell you what it would have looked like if it was.

45:22Full stop. Luke's in Marlow. Luke, what would you like to say? Hello, James. First time caller. I can't believe I'm actually calling you. Our opinions differed so much these years ago that I voted to leave. I wanted to come out of the European Union and it was an emotional vote, I would be honest and say. I think most of them were, probably. Yeah, and the key concept was having power over the vote. I wanted my vote to control a prime minister who'd run our country and not have to then sit in a European chamber and listen to a larger chamber controlling everything from charges to bananas, whatever you want to call it, was the reason I did that. I was converted. I've had a child. Maybe that's changed my opinion.

46:04I don't know but I'm prepared to come back into the European Union and I feel the key thing for me is I like Andy Burnham I think he's got the charisma and I think the things he talks about, re-nationalising services and stuff like that really does help the people and because of that I hope he hasn't over I don't know what the word I hope he hasn't over... I don't know what the word is, but hasn't overcommitted by going to the European Union as well and risk splitting the country. But I think we need to give him time. Yeah, I mean, I kind of agree with most of that. My worry would be that the conversation in this country is still exceptionalist and that the European... I mean, we have literally...

46:42And again, I'm going to say thanks to people like you, but I don't say it with any malice. we have put ourselves in the position of being rule takers rather than rule makers we were rule makers before so all the rules that you were unhappy about albeit that you could probably not name anything beyond bananas and vacuum cleaner legislation that we were part of that legislative process we were probably in many ways the biggest contributor to the process that made those rules so the great success was persuading people like you that they were somehow inflicted upon us against our will, which is just bonkers. I mean, the polar opposite of what is true. I mean, I'm sure there's part of the, you know, some laws we didn't want,

47:18and we didn't have the control over. We did. We had a veto. It was always a veto in place for most major legislation in Europe. But again, it's not your fault you don't know that, because I don't think Jacob Rees-Mogg did. Fair enough, fair enough. But I think the most important reason for calling, and the one that I wanted to make, and I think it's really important, if we have this vote and we decide to go back in, and I've still not 100% decided which way I will go, he has to negotiate the terms of Europe first. He cannot go, let's feel, should we go back in? Do we do that on a field vote and then try to negotiate the terms once he's had a mandate? That's where the lead really went wrong.

47:54And I hope that we get the terms of rejoining knocked down first and then we vote on that. The problem is that I don't think we can possibly get what we had that you voted to abandon so i mean would it be really rude of me to say you shouldn't be allowed to vote in if there is another referendum because you literally set fire to what we had before and that's now off the table well yeah no but we you know i can't think of many other areas in life there's not many other areas in life where the arsonists get to lay down the conditions for rebuilding the house they burnt down no but it's not the arsonists doing the conditions is it it's Andy and you You're the arsonist, and you're demanding a right to define what the rebuilt house looks like when you burnt down the last one.

48:42But the key thing is that Europe want us back as much as we want to join them. That's very true. Well, more possibly. No, but that's the problem, isn't it? Maybe more. So from a position of strength and negotiation, we give them the opportunity to set the terms, and they've got to convince those arsonists, as you want to call them, or misguided, a path to reconciliation. If you don't give them that opportunity, if you just go blind and leave or remain, then Europe can hold us over a barrel if we do get that. I wouldn't be worried about that, actually. And I think that's probably a legacy of where you were 10 years ago. There's no, I mean, it was people like Johnson who used phrases like punishment beatings and

49:19comparing European Union politicians to, I think, to concentration camp guards even. So that rhetoric was both hideous and horribly wrong. But you're right, it lingers emotionally, which is, as you said at the very outset, the basis of your vote was emotion. My problem is that I don't think many of your fellow Leave voters are as thoughtful as you. Maybe not, but if we get the facts right and work out what rejoining means first, then we have to hope that the whole population is wiser and will make the right decision this time. And like you say, I'm still not 100% convinced I would. I want to know what rejoining means. Yeah yeah and if it looked exactly like the thing that we left then you'd be all for it

50:04exactly that how dare you that's the thing and you're right you see that's where those of us who've been proved right about everything have to learn a little bit of humility and suck it up because you can't spend 10 years saying content for the con men, compassion for the con, and then say that the people you've got compassion for shouldn't be allowed to vote in the next referendum. It's 11 o'clock. I'm just looking at the photographs now in case I'd misremembered, but I don't think, even when he was presiding over the disastrous response to the COVID pandemic. I don't think Boris Johnson, I've never seen Boris Johnson looking as contrite as he does in these photographs of the press conference that him and Michael Gove held after winning the Brexit referendum.

50:50If that didn't sound any alarm bells, what would? You know, if you think about it, there's a natural progression from Johnson and Gove looking absolutely crestfallen after winning right through to client journalists saying things like, why are we still talking about Brexit? It's almost as if somewhere inside them, they had all they'd realized pretty much from the start this wasn't actually supposed to happen. You were only supposed to blow the bloody doors off. We just wanted to give David Cameron a bloody no so that Boris Johnson was in a stronger position to challenge George Osborne for the leadership when Cameron stepped down. We weren't supposed to win. But we can never admit that. It's like

51:32a Greek tragedy, isn't it? We can never admit that we didn't want to win. First caller, Gary. I voted for it but I didn't actually want it. How dare you? How dare you? Inflict as a consequence of your own ignorance and psychodrama. How dare you inflict something upon an entire population? I didn't want it. I just voted for it. And listen, in defense of voters as opposed to leaders of Vote Leave, austerity was huge. It's the third thing on the list. It's the third thing on the list. Austerity had made many, many people feel that they had less in 2016 than they had in 2010. Because they did. George Osborne took it away from them. And therefore, come 2016, you've got a chance to vote. You want to vote against the status quo.

52:17You want to vote against the stuff that's going on the biggest opportunity you had after the general election of 2015 which they sort of somehow squeaked um was to vote for for brexit so austerity i think is probably the the mother of brexit actually i don't know if that point is made often enough i'm not claiming for a moment i'm the only one who makes it but i don't think that point is made often enough. I'm not claiming for a moment I'm the only one who makes it, but I don't think that point is made often enough. So what have we got? How did it happen is the question that I'm asking, and it's every bit as fascinating as I hoped. Answer number one, you had people on the same team, i.e. the vote-leave team, promising completely contradictory Brexits,

52:56Brexits that could never happen at the same time. If one person's Brexit was delivered, the other person promising Brexit could not be delivered. And that, of course, created the chaos, the political chaos that followed the result. I don't even know if Gove and Johnson were arguing for exactly the same Brexit, to be honest with you. That might be part of the reason why they look so absolutely crestfallen at the victory press conference. And then, of course, if you are desperately clinging to the carcass of not being stupid, you can pretend that all of the argument and the chaos that followed was all the fault of somebody else and not the people who voted for completely contradictory things.

53:35Number two, an epic failure of leadership. I think this is massively underpriced. A huge failure of leadership, both in politics, but also in the media. You know, I mean, it's all very well me getting on my high horse about this. I wasn't there in the run up to the referendum. I was doing some shifts at the BBC. So I was trying quite hard to be a little bit less outspoken than i have been subsequently but a big big big fail on my part looking back although i didn't realize that at the time i didn't realize that the bbc had been captured to be honest with you um by people including a bloke that went on to be theresa may's director of communications epic failure of leadership from cameron and corbin most obviously

54:16which is why leaders from the past had to step into the fray. Your Majors and your Hesseltines, your Blairs and your Browns, and then austerity. But these are all excuses, aren't they? Rather than explanations, these are all saying to people, oh, you voted for something stupid. Oh, well, look, never mind. You were lied to. How much responsibility should these people bear? How much compassion should we show to the con as we prepare to resurrect some of these arguments and some of them are still determined to be conned? All three of those things. Oh, I know you didn't really understand the European Union, but you were really unhappy about all the Sure Start centres being closed, so you voted to leave the European Union.

54:54Or you were let down by the leadership. Well, 48% of the country had exactly the same leadership and they managed to cast a vote which was not idiotic. Put media under that as well, media influence, perhaps. My mum and dad voted for it because they were reading the Daily Mail. A lot of people tell me, and that is actually both excuse and explanation, because they fell into the trap of thinking that they were being told truths. And then you've got all the contradictory ones. A little bit more sympathy for that position, perhaps. But you could have realized if one bloke says we're going to leave the European Union and it means that you get jammed tomorrow. And another bloke said we're going to leave the European Union.

55:31It means that you don't get jammed tomorrow. You should have realized that voting to leave the European Union did not did not settle the conversation about jam. Right. And here we are. Here we are. to leave the European Union did not settle the conversation about jam, right? And here we are. Here we are. And of course, number four, sorry, of course, I mean, I keep glossing over it, media. Incredibly biased, hideously, horrendously biased media that then captured the one place that is supposed to be impartial, the BBC. So that you end up with what Maitlis called the Minford paradigm. A producer would spend their lives trying to find an economist to come on programmes, radio, TV programmes, arguing that Brexit would be a good idea,

56:07when if you wanted an economist to come on and explain why it would be a really bad idea, all you had to do was leave the door open. There'd be 500 of them walking past any minute now. If you needed to find one who would say it would be a good idea, then, yeah, you'd have to get up very, very early and fight tooth and nail with every other broadcaster in the country to get your hands on the one or two people that were prepared to do it. So how did it happen? A million different promises, appalling leadership, austerity, media. What else? Is there anything that doesn't cast the Brexit voter in a negative light? Because I'd take that. 0345 6060973. But remember, the two leaders of it, Farage, of course, not charged with actually delivering anything.

56:48So he just swung off on a jolly on the shoulders of his supporters. But Johnson and Gove, who had at least the temporary grace to recognise what they'd done, look absolutely broken. The morning immediately afterwards. Listen, hangovers may account for some of it, but they can't possibly account for all of it. Hughes in Amsterdam. Hugh, what would you like to say? Very good morning to you, James. Likewise. Well, you're not going to believe this, but 20 years ago, so 10 years before Brexit, I actually wrote my thesis and it was titled The Future of the United Kingdom in the European Union. And yeah, pretty much everything we thought was going to happen happened. And it had so much to do. I won't give you an economical sort of explanation, but it had everything to do with the fact that we always kind of felt special and different.

57:44So it's a lot to do with the fact that, on the one hand, we're an island nation. So that's why we think, you know, we're not really Europeans. But, of course, then you've got the Irish who do. And on the other hand, we had this very big imperial background that the other countries didn't yeah well they did just not quite as recent as us yes yes i don't know actually belgium in the conga anyway it's all right sorry i'm being i'm being pedantic no but i mean you have that combination of the two which made it feel a bit special britannia britannia waves the rules. Absolutely. That is 100% what we've been teaching children for, let's say, the past 75, 80 years, more and more. And that is one of those things

58:27that really pushed the envelope in many different ways. And so what then happens is when you start saying you're special and post-World War II, you suddenly realize that, yeah, it's not the number one, two country in the world anymore, but just national progression, it's not as strong. It's still one of the strongest countries in the world, but not that strong. You get people a certain amount of resentment going. And what do you start to resent? Well, what can we lash out at? And it's different things. It could be, well for instance immigrants as we've as we've spoken about before could be the eu could be anything but it's not the things that make sense so we're putting exception exceptionalism has to go on the list i mean some of these individual

59:09items explain the success of the other items on the list rather than constitute reasons in and of themselves exceptionalism does a little bit of both you know that underlying earlier caller describing his vote as being essentially emotional that underlying sense that we don't need them we're we're you know it is a post-imperial fallacy that we are capable of we are somehow stronger alone than we are in company absolutely i mean i still remember very well the sentence that I wrote down about Maggie Thatcher when she was brought to this European conference and she said, I feel like I'm Genghis Khan invited to a peace convention. Although she was a much bigger fan of the European Union than most of her admirers like to admit these days.

59:56You're describing Farageism really, aren't you? Yeah. This kind of, I don't care, I don't care what happens to the ship as long as the crew is English. I'd rather sink to the bottom of the sea with a white English crew than have the finest vessel in the history of maritime adventure with a crew that's a bit like the one that Nelson had on the HMS Victory, i.e. multicultural and multicoloured. Yeah, and the big problem becomes the day after Brexit when, okay, we voted to leave. I mean, I didn't, but fine. But then is the actual question, okay, so what did you vote for? No ties whatsoever? Or as close a possible ties as humanly possible? Or somewhere in between? And then all the fighting starts.

1:00:41Is that the biggest? I mean, that's the biggest explainer of why it's all gone so badly, because it could never go well for everybody. One person's successful Brexit was another person's Brexit betrayal. And, of course, factor in the fact that there was never any such thing as a successful Brexit. But that doesn't explain. How big is that factor in getting it over the line so the fact that there were a million contradictory promises made is the biggest explainer of why it fell apart so fast and so completely but is it the biggest explainer of why so many people voted for it or is that more likely to be exceptionalism plus austerity well yeah i think exactly as you just said and it was the expectation that everybody had themselves of what brexit would entail without

1:01:27anybody of course having actually shown them well this is what we've negotiated because nothing had been negotiated so you've got those three bits coming together that really resulted in brexit yeah you're right you're right. You're right. Did you get anything wrong in your 20-year-old thesis? Well, I didn't get top marks, but I got pretty close to it. So most of it I got right. I did think that the UK would probably say, we've got to vote on this again within about five years. And that didn't happen. No, I wouldn't have backed that. Not five years. But of course, I'm like a weathervane on this again within about five years and that didn't happen no i i wouldn't have i wouldn't have backed that not five years but of course i'm like a weathervane on this one you get blown

1:02:03around by what the politicians are saying because they're the ones who get to decide when and indeed whether it out it ever happened so i'd go a little further i'd say exceptionalism plus fabulism plus the the mythical element of the debate the things that were being promised that were not just going to be undeliverable in the event of other things being promised, being delivered, but they were going to be undeliverable by human beings in the entire history of our solar system. So some of the stuff that was promised was just impossible. I love this. Thank you, Hugh. Do you know the other, the question earlier caller picked up on that I just still can't answer is is why we were supposed to be

1:02:41so frightened about a european army i didn't understand that at the time and i don't understand it now you listen to farage wanging on about how wonderful vladimir putin is or how awful nato is and then wanging on about how awful a european army have been. You can't help wondering whether there is a link between those two positions. Putin fanboy, enemy of European military unity. Why on earth would somebody hold both of those positions at the same time? Well, anyway, I mean, in the guy's defence, it's not as if one of his closest political allies is currently in jail for parroting Kremlin talking points in return for money, is it? What? Oh. It is 19 minutes after 11. I mean, so many questions, aren't there,

1:03:25that we haven't looked at for years. Who was most betrayed by Brexit? Was it fishermen and women? I mean, a tiny, tiny proportion of our economy. Video games is immeasurably bigger for example but somehow that partly because of what he was just talking about our island nation status somehow imbued them with a with a magic and the bloke who probably wang is 0.02 percent of the uk economy fishing and yet the bloke who was wanging on about fishing more than anybody else is the same bloke who didn't go to any meetings of the um fisheries committee when he was a serving european parliament member with a place on the fisheries committee um his name rhymes with barrage um and i guess we've got to be a bit better

1:04:12this time around you can't just sit here being a bit oh dear here we go you've got to you've got to bite the bullet grasp the nettle, do what Andy Burnham is doing, and just recognise that the people who led the Vote Leave campaign or the Leave EU campaign were, at best, horribly wrong, and at worst, horrible liars, horrible racist liars. It's just true. Either horribly wrong, so you don't have to be a horrible racist liar to have led these campaigns, but if you weren't horribly wrong, you were a horribly racist liar or both, of course. So how on earth did it happen? And so far, all of the answers cast Leave voters in a negative light. What can we do to put them? Well, Gary, our first caller, how did it happen? Because people wanted change. What change

1:04:56did they want? Don't ask me that. Stop bullying me. me um yeah okay so i don't know if that gets on the list does it it does get on the list people wanted unspecified change that they couldn't describe yeah right i'm gonna where's my pen gone sorry i'm gonna write i'm gonna have to write that then we'll call that gary's. So you've got contradictory promises, contradictory and undeliverable promises. You've got appalling leadership. You've got austerity, horribly biased media. The fact that you can't prove a lie preemptively. Exceptionalism plus fabulism. And then you've got unspecified change that the voter cannot describe and accuses james of being arrogant and condescending when he insists that they do is that the biggest one of all why did you vote for brexit ah change reform

1:05:54something different what's the biggest one of all should we take a text vote on it what's the biggest one of all i voted for something that text vote on it? What's the biggest one of all? I voted for something that I couldn't describe and anyone who asks me to describe it is an arrogant, condescending so-and-so. Snowflake. Remainer. Is that the biggest one? Is that actually going to be the biggest one of all? Because it encompasses all of them. There might be a bit of racism in there but you don't want to admit it so you just say oh I don't know. I don't know what it is. A bit of exceptionalism in there but that doesn't really make sense when you say it out loud uh can't prove a lie preemptively horribly biased media the media didn't influence my vote

1:06:28i did my own research austerity appalling leadership i don't know i don't know anyway on we go tim's in chelsea tim what do you reckon oh hi hi james hello first time caller you're very welcome it's a good old days tim welcome aboard yeah i've got lots and lots i'd like to rant about brexit i'm a i'm a true remainer despite uh despite coming from essex we don't do stereotypes we don't do stereotypes on this program yeah but picking up on your point um about who you know who did we let down i think the most the biggest biggest thing we let down is is the younger generation yes i mean they're the ones that got to live with the vote of um i would call the arrogant british older elite really which is which is um which is where which is where we are and i

1:07:16think they generally a lot of the youth didn't come out and vote and I think if they had done it, it would have been a different story and I generally think they didn't think the older generation would be daft enough to vote. I think that's exactly right. I mean, and in fact that picture of Johnson and Goh really sums up the fact that none of them thought that they were going to win and then suddenly they're like the dog that caught the car aren't they? Yeah, I mean, it was quite clear from all the interviews afterwards that nobody was expecting it to go the way it went, even the adamant Brexiteers. So why do you think it did then? I think it went through I said to your researcher so forgive me if it's a bit strong, but

1:07:57I said, I'll keep it clean. Thank you. I think it was a quote from one of the Guy Ritchie films, you can never underestimate the predictability of stupidity. Yeah. And I think that sort of sums it up. The leaders we had in Cameron, I put firmly front and centre for this. He's had a very elite, privileged upbringing, but he's also had a very sheltered one in terms of, unless you've had a job dealing with the general public in this country, you don't realise, you know, honestly, where they're coming from. And they just underestimate the stupidity of a lot of the people. I remember listening to this show it might have been your show it was lbc and someone came on about she'd actually issued notice to a landlord

1:08:45for a hairdresser because she was no longer going to be allowed to use the hairdryer that she's been using because of eu legislation wow somebody somebody came on and said no you've got it wrong it's just an advisory note but she's's already contacted her landlord. I mean, that's the level. That's extraordinary. I don't actually think that was one of mine. And of course... No, I think it was LBC. Oh, I'm sure it was. Yeah, but I mean, I just worry that she was on with a presenter who wouldn't have known enough to tell her that she was wrong. So tell me this. Why did we not have a weighted vote? So, you know, 16 to 24-year-olds, you had... They had, you know, a weighted vote of 70%. Because more of your life is going to be affected by it.

1:09:23Yeah, exactly. And the majority, I'd say, the majority of over 80s would have voted out. Yeah. A lot of them probably aren't here anymore. But why were they given a 100% vote? I mean, you know the answer is it would be far too complicated to introduce something like that i suppose and and also there's something quite fundamental to democracy of one man or one woman one vote but but i mean but but all of i think all of these ones they've got to live with a decision it's my my children your children have got to live with this for the next even from a purely business point of view i've run a business before and why would you kick your biggest customer into touch? These are the questions that I find extraordinary.

1:10:02Farage swanning around the place claiming that he understands business, having been a rubbish commodities trader for about 10 minutes before moving into politics. All he ever talked about was fish and BMWs, wasn't he? Do you remember? No, I do. They weren't going to be horrible to us because we bought all their BMWs. I mean, that's just ridiculous. Here is, right, absolutely frictionless and free trade with the biggest single market in the world. In the history of humankind, right? You're in it. What are you going to do as a businessman, as someone who understands business? You're going to kick it into touch. You're going to vote to leave it. Of course you are, you absolute wombats. It's incredible, isn't it?

1:10:35What's your biggest then? I'll run through a list. Contradictory promises, appalling leadership, austerity, biased media, fabulism and exceptionalism or, we haven't put Cambridge Analytica on the list yet. No, I'd say appalling leadership and the media and the right-wing media. I think that's the two big ones for me. And there's no reason why being right-wing should necessarily have been in favour of leave. And of course, it wasn't a Conservative Party was full of people who could see the idiocy of it. And then along came Dominic Cummings. And then there were none. Tim, lovely stuff. A sparkling debut. I look forward to your second call. We move now from Chelmsford to Milton Keynes. Paul is there. Paul, what happened?

1:11:16Well, good morning. I think in some respects it doesn't matter what Andy Burnham does because the principal reason for Brexit still exists. Whenever there was a debate about Brexit, especially on your show, it always ended up in immigration because I think that there's a lot of people who think that immigration has somehow polluted the idea of Britishness. So, here comes this idea that I don't need to necessarily join the far right to express my prejudiced views, but here's a legitimate position that I can do to express, I can get rid of all these foreigners. Here comes Brexit. Fantastic. It doesn't matter if it's going to be a disaster, but I can achieve my lifelong objective. I don't need to see brown people walking down the street.

1:12:04And that idea will always exist. So whether it's called Brexit or called something else, that feeling will still exist. And all it needs is someone else to come along with a slightly different view of it. Nudge, nudge, wink, wink different view of it nudge nudge wink wink and we're here again oh I don't mean you I just mean them over there the ones I'm reading about in the Daily Mail the ones with those funny clothing hijab thing or whatever those ones over there have got that thing on their head that was a vote I will never forget the fellow who was adamant that he was voted or he had voted to leave the European Union because there weren't enough white faces on the tills in Sainsbury's. I mean, it's not funny. I think I might have

1:12:47laughed then, but not gaily. A very wry laugh. But as you speak, I feel I have to point out that these people were voting jingoistically, xenophobically or in a racist way against largely white people. That's probably been the biggest post-Brexit change to our society is that anti-white supremacism has been unleashed as a consequence of giving people permission to vote against fellow white foreigners. But it was never a logical vote. It was always an emotional vote. are giving people permission to vote against fellow white foreigners. But it was never a logical vote. It was always an emotional vote. And whenever people make decisions based purely on emotion, nine times out of ten, it's a bad decision.

1:13:32And that's why no one, like the guy at the very top of your programme, was putting himself in knots. Because he was trying to wrap logic around something that has no logic and and it's you will never convince people that what their prejudice doesn't make sense until they have an epiphany and think hang on wait a minute that person who saved my life or who works in the nhs or looking after my granny and or or looking after my children and educating them that person is a different color from me but they're brilliant when that day happens then things may change but until that day we're always going to be in the same situation and that day may never dawn but you have to keep a fighting for it and be hoping that it does otherwise you might as well pack up and go

1:14:14home there was an advert i don't know if you saw it and and this again is one of the most massively underpriced elements of the whole conversation and it was very carefully targeted to um to facebook and and and cummings gave one speech when he was a little bit high on his own supply in the immediate aftermath and he gave one speech it wasn't very widely attended by the media, but it was filmed. And he talked about spending a ton of money right at the end. He called them engineers, using the word in the same way that Kemi Badenoch does. And it was just people who were flooding the Facebook feeds of susceptible voters with this image of the NHS just being utterly devoid of foreigners. It was like this hideously kind of,

1:15:04what would you even call it? This sort of rose-tinted, utterly unachievable, if you vote for Brexit, we'll get rid of all the foreigners in the NHS. It was like a kind of white supremacist utopia. And it didn't get picked up. I didn't see it until months after the vote. I didn't really dig into it until I was writing a book years after the vote. And that was huge as well. You look at the tininess of the margin, and you can poo-poo what I'm saying, but Cummings thought it was crucial, you see. Cummings thought that that very carefully the first place. And it only works if you are not clocking just the nature of reality, not just sort of the nature of the NHS, but the nature of a post-imperial country,

1:16:10inevitably having a population that draws upon all corners of the former empire. Ah, man, Paul, great stuff. Dominic Ellis is here now, not Dominic Cummings. Dominic Ellis is here now, not Dominic Cummings. Dominic Ellis is here now with your headlines. It is 11.36. You're listening to James O'Brien on LBC. And, of course, the reason we haven't got sovereignty on our list is that literally nobody ever mentioned it until after the Brexit vote had been counted and people had started realising they weren't going to get any of the things that they said that they'd voted for before the vote was counted. It's only afterwards. Oh, sovereignty. Sovereignty. And then, of course, if you were really paying attention to the issue

1:16:48because you cared so much about sovereignty, you'd know that the British Parliament was always sovereign. Never not sovereign. Unbelievable. So it's a longish list now. So. I mean, what is the biggest reason? We're asking how it happened. With the benefit of 10 years hindsight, cheerleaders are, for Brexit, utterly busted flushes, but that doesn't mean they won't be able to resurrect their lies and xenophobia. So what were the biggest reasons for it? A million contradictory promises, or even just two. Two people on the same team promising things that were entirely contradictory. They could not both happen, which means from the very start you got more votes than you'd get if you were committed to something plausible, feasible and

1:17:29deliverable, but you got twice as many votes by promising two things that were entirely at odds with each other. Most obviously, single market membership or Nigel Farage's claim that we could be exactly like Norway, while other Brexiters were insisting that we categorically couldn't. In two, everyone likes a little bit of a bullseye throwback, don't they? You've got appalling leadership on the Remain side. I mean, who was a hero of Remain? I don't think you can name one. Was it Stuart Rose from Marks & Spencers that was supposed... I hope I haven't just misremembered stewart rose was it from marks and spencers who was supposed to lead the remain camp i mean can you even would you recognize him if he walked in

1:18:10now how did that happen david cameron probably appointed him david cameron was awful when he wasn't absent george osborne didn't want a referendum in the first place. Even a stop clock is right twice a day, probably, because he had the wit to realise that the austerity he'd inflicted upon the population without any mandate to do so, it'd create an environment in which they'd vote for anything that constituted an opportunity to say, oh, we don't like the way things are going at the moment. So austerity in three. In three! So austerity in four i mean a horrendously hilariously biased media um which of course is still very much in place arguably it's even worse now because the people that were um funding brexit have now bought

1:18:53themselves television stations and magazines number five you this is a little bit more intellectual you can't preemptively prove a lie to be a lie so if you say to me that tomorrow you're going to win the lottery i can't prove you're lying until tomorrow until the numbers are out can i i can't actually prove hey you might be a little bit surprised that people are going to fall for the idea that they're going to win the lottery, but they did. And then they didn't win it and it was not their own fault. So you can't do that. Then you've got exceptionalism plus fabulism, this idea that something in our psyche, our national psyche, was susceptible to the idea that we were unique or special. Britannia rule Britannia, Britannia waves the rules.

1:19:42And that I definitely think is part of it, especially for older voters who were persuaded that the European Union was somehow a German conceit. I remember when I first started seeing messages saying things like EU SSR or Fourth Reich, and you'd just sort of think, good Lord, where on earth are you getting this stuff from? That was before social media was the sewer that it is today. Then you've got the people, then you've got Cambridge Analytica, which is still massively underpriced. Then you've got the people who voted for unspecified change that they categorically can't tell you about. They cannot describe. But if you ask them to, they will accuse you of being condescending and arrogant. That's a huge factor, you know.

1:20:22A little bit personal, obviously, given that I'm the patron saint of that particular process. But you tell me. Find someone in your life that voted for it. Ask them what they voted for. Point out that that was never possible. And then count how long it takes them to call you condescending, arrogant, or rude. And then you've got immigration racism and the ease with which people were persuaded that people who were persuaded that their problems were all the fault of foreigners john's in bristol john what would you like to say ah james o brexit thank you for taking my call let's get a t-shirt i don't even know where to begin. Well, tell me how it happened. Well, you've just stolen a lot of my thunder, actually, in the last couple of minutes.

1:21:04Oh, sorry. As you generally do. But how did it happen? Well, you've had a lot of callers on, and they've pointed out a lot of the reasons why. And I completely agree. we had a terrible remain campaign we had a labor party that sat on the fence and twiddled their thumbs all right absolutely ridiculous and then we had a a leave campaign that was basically all the architects were millionaires sponsored by billionaires most of them offshore i'm gonna stop you there no nigel farage was not a millionaire let me speak no i don't stop nigel farage was not a millionaire in 2016 because his income was dependent entirely on what he could actually earn a salary for i'm not just talking about about No, I know you're not, but he is a millionaire now

1:22:00because he's accepted a secret £5 million gift from a foreign-based billionaire, but back then... And I think, self-serving bunch of bar stewards, right, who, they saw the writing on the wall, the EU were bringing in all these industrial scale tax avoiders, and they're going to bring in a law where millionaires, billionaires have to pay the right amount of tax. And this is where it all comes from. It's not where it all comes from, but it's probably, again, it's underpriced. That and regulation, financial regulation. We can remove the guardrails that prevent bank collapses or Grenfell Tower tragedies. We can get rid of all of the health and safety legislation if we leave. That drove some of it.

1:22:47Exactamundo. Exactamundo, right? And what happened was that I've lost my train of thought. Hang on a minute, James. Welcome to my world. No, but basically all this all these lies and nonsense about all this stuff being imposed on us by brussels it's ridiculous the uk was a major co-author of all the laws and rules and regulations we were we had the best deal in europe we were germany plus plus. But what is this then? And now we're scrabbling around, scrabbling around to get a better deal that isn't even going to come close to what we had before. And that's what's going to happen next, you know. We've got a little flavour of it with an earlier caller. It's going to be like, well, you know, I wish I hadn't voted for Brexit,

1:23:35but I'm not voting to go back in because what they're offering is worse than what we had before. And that's why I use the line about the arsonists getting to decide whether or not we build a new house or not. But what are you filing your complaints under? Is it all of the above? Oh, it's all of the above. It is, isn't it? It's Cameron, David Cameron. Bad leadership, austerity. They all should be in prison for treason. I mean, for what they've... The damage they've done, not just economically, but culturally, socially, politically. Right? This country... Well, it's not a crime to be an idiot. Otherwise, we'd all have done a sentence, John, I think, at various points in the past. But then you had the outside influences,

1:24:15like Putin. You can't tell me that Putin didn't have an influence on the... I nearly swore there. No, well, you nearly swore before as well, although you swerved it in the nick of time. I don't know whether... Did you press the button? So be careful. Ofcom might have chalked that up to mispronunciation. But, yeah, I mean, Russian interference, which, of course, one of the first things Andy Burnham did when he became prime minister was establish that there had been Russian interference in the referendum. And the way the right wing media responded was extraordinary. You cannot ever prove that influence has worked. Right. I voted to leave the European Union because Dominic Cummings spent seven million pounds on carefully engineered Facebook adverts designed to appeal to elderly racists.

1:25:04No one's ever going to say that. They'll say, I voted for it for the NHS. Now, you're never going to admit that propaganda works. Victims of propaganda never admit that propaganda works. That's how propaganda works. Propaganda doesn't march into your sitting room, slap you around the face, and then frog march you to the polling booth and tell you what to do. Propaganda seeps into your consciousness, sways you, persuades you, poisons you, pollutes you, and then the next thing you know, you're in the polling booth doing what the propagandists wanted. So I don't personally know, and I don't think we ever will, how big a role Russia played in 2016. But if you were deriving most of your input from social media, then you were almost certainly prey to bot farms and carefully orchestrated campaigns designed to undermine stability in the West.

1:25:56And, of course, we all know what they moved on to next. Donald Trump. Thank you, John. I think the tax avoidance stuff is a bit of a red herring, but I don't want to fall out with you, so I'll leave it at that. Anne's in La Rochelle in France, and we'll talk to her after this. It's 11.49. We found a way back into it today, which we haven't always done in the past, and it suggests that Andy Burnham might be onto something. And do me a favour, if people still don't understand anything even if they're in this business, you know, even if they're writing columns or broadcasting, if they still don't understand the difference or the indivisibility of the four freedoms, then this time just give them a swerve. If they can't

1:26:34be bothered to do the research themselves the most basic reading, the most basic learning, you do this for a living you have the privilege of actually being able to invite people into your studio who can explain to you be bothered to do the research themselves, the most basic reading, the most basic learning. You do this for a living. You have the privilege of actually being able to invite people into your studio who can explain to you what's going on. And if that's too tricky, then just invite callers. I think I learned more from Kieran, who's a courier, who was crossing the channel into continental Europe on a daily, weekly, frequent basis. absolutely crystal clear about what was going to happen as a

1:27:00consequence of leaving the single market. I think I learned more from him than I've learned from any politician in all the years that I've been doing this job. So if we are going to return to this territory, do yourself a favor and don't pay any attention at all to people who can't be bothered, who don't respect you enough to do the most cursory research into, for example, the impossibility of having free trade with a single market if you're not in it. It's just extraordinary that 10 years later you can still have. It's not even performative, is it? I don't even understand ignorance like some of the ignorance you're going to hear in the coming days, like ignorance that you're going to see on the front page of the telegraph today it's quite spectacular

1:27:43and and now of course compounded by an inability to admit that you made a terrible mistake 10 years ago so now you've got the inability to make a to admit that you made a terrible mistake coupled with the unaddressed ignorance that caused you to make the mistake in the first place if you only had one vote that's fine but if you're in a position to persuade other people if you're in a position to influence other votes then right so it's a it's it's actually a disgrace in my rather sententious opinion um i think love island is a place that we should turn to more often on this program i i feel that love Island is often illustrative of a broader malaise and this is what happened on there in June of 2018.

1:28:25What do you think about Brexit? What's that? Where we're leaving the European Union. I seriously don't have a clue. So it was to leave the EU so we wouldn't be part of Europe. Which would mean like welfare and things we trade with would be cut down so does that mean we won't have any trees trees trees oh no we have trees what you saw no we're just we're just not in the european union we're still classes like being in europe doesn't it mean it would be harder to like go to like Spain and stuff so it'd be harder to go on holidays yeah I think so I love my holidays yeah 11 52 is the time so I mean we can smile indulgently at stuff like that but people like Farage and Johnson they were, absolutely betting the house

1:29:20on them not getting better informed. You know, people still spouting, I mean, utter undiluted bilge about trade and clubs and not having any interest whatsoever in explaining the difference. That's the audience that they're speaking to. Holy moly. 11.52 is the time. Anne is in La Rochelle. Anne, bonjour. Yeah, bonjour, James. We've spoken before, but it was highly forgettable. Well, not for me, Anne. Not for me. I'm sorry to hear it was for you, but carry on. Yeah, anyway, right. I will do. I'm ploughing on. Yeah, well, what a hornet's nest, actually. So my point is that I live in France. i've lived in france quite a long time and um well why don't you ask me how i voted in the referendum well you can tell me i don't have to ask you okay how did you vote in the referendum

1:30:13well i wasn't allowed to ah it was a trick question. Yes. So, I mean, thereby hangs a tale. I mean, you're living in the European Union like a lot of Brits. OK, we chose to live in Europe for various reasons, etc. Who says that we're not going to go back to the UK, etc.? We were not even given the chance to vote. Which was, I think, appalling, actually, for the record. But how do you think it worked? With a sort of one foot in, one foot out perspective like yours, how do you think it got over the line? How did we end up becoming the first country in history to vote democratically to impose economic sanctions on ourselves? Well, yeah, well, one, by not giving some people who are absolutely, I would say, on the front line, the possibility to vote.

1:31:01But OK. The other thing is just appalling, appalling campaign led by the by the remainers. Yeah, I think that's emerging as quite a big deal. And I don't know how different it would be next time, but I'd rather have Andy Burnham in the chair than Jeremy Corbyn. Yeah, well, I was after British politics at the in in the chair than jeremy corbyn yeah yeah well i was after british politics at the time i didn't quite follow the corbyn thing uh yeah but when you think a couple of blind spots that were omitted or overlooked or i'm thinking notably of the northern ireland problem yeah the day after brexit everybody realised what a problem that was I mean metaphorically speaking Theresa May mentioned it quite early on

1:31:44in the referendum you know and then didn't mention it again and then of course she bunged a million quid to the DUP to try to help her get her nonsense over the line so you know she doesn't emerge with credit I was wanging on about Northern Ireland I mean both before and after i remember bumping into a chap in red trousers on the seafront in wells next to sea in norfolk and um i normally promise mrs o'brien that i won't get engaged in political discussions in public but on this occasion i decided i think she'd gone into the into the shop so i decided to make an exception and i asked him what do you think is going to happen in northern ireland then if um if we leave the european union and ireland is still

1:32:22in it what's going to happen to the border and i'd learned the phrase regulatory alignment and i think it just got it got squeezed out of the conversation didn't it by people who were just about informed enough to realize that they didn't have an answer to this question so let's ignore the question let's let's pretend's not happening. And then we won't need to embarrass ourselves by admitting that we haven't got an answer to this question. Well, swept under the carpet, I think. Swept under, well, even worse than that, I'd say. Sort of pushed into the long grass. It was a billion quid, of course, not a million quid. So even I can make mistakes when we're talking about Brexit. A billion pounds given to the DUP.

1:32:59Anne, thank you. James is staying with a little European flavour at the end of this conversation. We'll turn our attention next to the suggestions of a staggered age of consent for sexual activity, which I think I like as a proposal, but with a little side order of worry that when legislation is framed in the immediate aftermath of something shocking or scandalous, it doesn't always turn out to be fit for purpose. But that's coming up next. James is in Munich. James, what would you like to say? Yes, hi, James. Thanks very much. So I don't think that it is a fair representation or when a Brexit vote happened, I don't think it was a fair representation of the understanding of the country. Fully for democracy, fully for everybody gets one vote.

1:33:45But I think there was a lot of voting that happened because of a set of questions which is set out from either side that is used to then demonstrate somebody's understanding of either the leave or the campaign and then from that if you get understanding from both sides you have you know 0.1 per question you get a whole vote if you only understand one side you get 0.5 of a vote and if you don't understand anything, you get a multiplier of zero times your vote. If you don't understand anything, you get a show on LBC, mate, I think is your answer to that question. Even 10 years later, it doesn't matter. I'd love to see you introduce this. I'd love to see you explain to people why they have to sit a test before they're

1:34:34allowed to vote in a second referendum. But yes, I think it comes down to a bit of the understanding part that gets missed. You know, instead of Dave down the pub reckons I should vote like this, that vote now counts as well as somebody who really understands what the benefits would be to either side. But that's democracy, isn't it? I mean, in some ways. Yeah. And, you know, a vote that is cast in complete ignorance is a betrayal of democratic values, but also a signifier of them. You know, the vote of someone who understands nothing has to be worth the same as the vote of somebody who understands everything in a society where both voters are going to be affected equally by the consequences of that vote.

1:35:15I mean, it's an idealistic position that you describe. Has it ever happened at any other point in history? Sounds like something the Greeks might have tried, or the ancient Romans. It was a level of education, if not, but I don't. I suppose we tried it here, didn't we, with votes for the gentry before you could vote as a member of the working class, but no indication of intelligence. I like it on one level, and I think we both know it's entirely unworkable on another. And that is the end of the best Brexit conversation we've had in a very long time. I don't know why that is, whether it is because Andy Burnham is refreshing the parts that other politicians have failed to reach, or whether it is just because I got out of bed

1:35:56on the right side this morning, or whether it's because we're all somehow absorbing by a process of political osmosis, we're all sort of absorbing a change in the weather. I'm fairly confident we'll be returning to it again soon though or soonish and that the conversation is going to get bigger if not better and I say that because if it is dominated once again by precisely the sort of liars, charlatans and racists who were successful and victorious last time, then even if the conversation gets much bigger, there is no guarantee that it will get much better. At least I suppose the people on the right side of history and the right side of the knowledge that James Immunic was just referring to

1:36:37probably realise this time round that the stakes are rather higher than they did last time round. It's coming up to 12 noon. Up next, responses to Russell Brand involve calls for a staggered age of consent. It is three minutes after 12 and you are listening to James O'Brien on LBC. Somewhat remarkably, we can actually link the two conversations today that we are having together because the bridge between the conversation. about brexit and the conversation about mooted changes to the age of consent prompted by in large part the the conviction of russell brand on rape charges there is a bridge between these two stories and that bridge is nigel farage who has been subject to even more embarrassing revelations from the not too distant past including him um responding to the original

1:37:37documentary the dispatches documentary that prompted the investigations into russell bram prompted women to come forward with accusations after various allegations were made on that that program in i think in in september on his funny little tv station in ways that again you know hashtag protect our women hashtag protect our girls are breath absolutely breathtaking i thought he was really rather loud incredibly coarse rather rude probably very badly damaged by drugs. And as for his behaviour with women and other people, well, I don't know. It's not for me to judge. There's no evidence being produced. There are four people, maybe five now, that have come out of the woodwork. But if anyone gives me pause for thought, you see, I understand that through his YouTube channel and much else,

1:38:31he has upset some very powerful people he's upset big government he's upset big pharma he's upset bill gates and everybody but if you go out there and upset people big powerful people you've got to be pretty clear that there's nothing they can really hit you back with wow um i i know he's a bit i don't quite what word to use but i didn't realize he was buying him fully to those conspiracy theories until of course we heard him on that podcast um after the criminal allegations had been made after the uh um the story had moved on a heck of a lot which makes it incredibly ironic that he went on Australian television. I guess that's progress from when he was appearing on Russian Kremlin-funded television every ten minutes,

1:39:21but he went on Australian television last week to say this. What I am amused by is I've not heard anybody from the Labour Party who were cosying up to him, promoting him a decade ago. I've not heard a single the Labour Party who were cosying up to him, promoting him a decade ago, I've not heard a single apology from any one of them. Well, I have, but I haven't heard one from him yet, despite the fact that in July of 2024, months after the allegations of sexual assault were made public, he was charged, of course, in April of the following year. He didn't just defend Russell Brand, as you heard him doing in the first clip, or try to claim that politicians from other parties who had consorted with Russell Brand.

1:40:02In Ed Miliband's case, it's important to remember, Brand had given a call to arms to young voters telling them not to vote at all. And Ed Miliband wanted to argue with him about the importance of voting so you know 2020 hindsight is a wonderful thing but Miliband's motivation for that argument was pretty strong and he has apologized I haven't heard Nigel Farage apologize for well I'll let you I mean whose podcast do you think he went on in July 2024, months after these allegations were made? It's too serious a matter this to do a multiple choice. But what would be the worst imaginable podcast for not just any British politician, but a politician who pretends to care about women and girls? Sorry, that's not fair.

1:40:52A politician who professes to care about women and girls when they're being abused by men who aren't white. What would be the worst imaginable podcast for Nigel Farage to have gone on in July of 2024? So long before his comments in defense of Russell Brown signing up to some sort of weird conspiracy theory that he was being... Women were coming forward to accuse him of rape because he'd joined Donald Trump's fan club. And appearing on this podcast two years, two and a half years, before he appeared on Australian television attacking Labour politicians for consorting with Russell Brand before anybody had accused him of rape or sexual assault? What would be the worst imaginable place for Nigel

1:41:40Farage to pop up after those allegations of sexual assault had been made and just less than a year before the charges were actually made? Well, no prizes for guessing guessing i wonder what you feel on that that vastest of the most vast of stages the global one the ascent of trump and vance will mean for the most important of geopolitical issues war yeah russell it's lovely to see you without you It's really rather lovely. Well, hold on. We've just started. No, John. It's not time. Well, I'm just reading a book. I'll write this down. That's for Gino. Who will you protect, Dan? Run with your instincts. You're a job, brother. It was a long time ago. And it's water under the bridge. It really is.

1:42:24They sound so warm in each other. They sound so happy in each other's company, don't they? So happy in each other's company. So chummy. So chummy so chummy quite and the crucial distinction here is before and after allegations of sexual assault and rape were made and it's important to have rules in politics that everybody abides by you know it's the opposite of footballification it's the great tragedy of the last 10 years in British politics is that all the rules are off now. You can lie with impunity. You can consort with alleged rapists with impunity. You can, in Nigel Farage's case, describe alleged rapists as important voices for young men, while simultaneously convincing your marks and the mugs that support you that you care

1:43:09about women. You care about women who've been a victim of sexual assault. But we should all be able to agree that when somebody is facing serious and well-documented allegations of rape and sexual assault, then the rest of us should just, let's just say, steer clear for a while until the allegations have been properly investigated or until the cases have been properly investigated or until the cases have been concluded. Everybody should just steer clear. Why can't we just agree on that? Andrew Tate gets accused of rape and sex trafficking. Let's just not big him up anymore. Let's wait and see what transpires. Everyone can agree on that. If it's someone whose politics you like, I don't know what the politics of

1:43:52Andrew Tate are, to be honest with you, but someone that you like is accused of something awful, then just don't go there. It's not hard. I liked Russell Brand when I met him like pretty much everybody else in the British media. And yet when the allegations came forward, I found it incredibly easy to say to myself, maybe let's not get him on the show again, or certainly let's not go on his podcast. Let's wait and see how this plays out. Whether it's someone you like or whether it's someone you despise, certain allegations, certain accusations should be absolutely the end of association. Privately, you might think that loyalty demands that you keep lines of communication open. I'm not so sure. I'm in a very happy position that no one I consider a friend has

1:44:40ever been accused of anything like what Russell Brand was accused of. But if you're in public, if you're in public life, let alone politics itself, if you aspire to be Prime Minister, surely a really easy thing to do is to say, do you know what? I'm probably not going to go and have a bit of a giggle, a bit of a laugh, a bit of a backslap session with a bloke accused of quite hideous crimes against women. But that is not obviously the decision that Nigel Farage took. And can I play that clip again, the one where they are so chummy, where he is on Russell Brand's podcast? So the final clip that we heard, because I think it's really important. You could just about make a case for saying, well, I went on it because I wanted to challenge him,

1:45:28or I went on it because I wanted to make it clear that I found the allegations against him deeply disturbing. I decided to go on. I would advise against it personally, but I decided to go on that podcast because I thought it was really important for somebody to point out how unseemly it was for him to be joking and laughing with people like the late Charlie Kirk and someone called Dambongino after these allegations. Why has MAGA become a safe space for people accused of sex offences? That's quite an easy question to answer. Why was Nigel Farage cosying up to Russell Brand after these allegations were public? I think that's actually a much harder question to answer. And if you think cosying up

1:46:11is an exaggeration, well, then listen to this once more. I wonder what you feel on the most vast of stages, the global one, the ascent of Trump and Vance will mean for the most important of geopolitical issues, war. Yeah, Russell, it's lovely to see you. Thank you. Without you abusing me, it's really rather lovely. Well, hold on. Nigel. It's not time. Well, I don't know. That's for Gino. Who will you protect then? that you're abusing me it's really rather well hold on it was a long time ago and it's water under the bridge it really is yeah it was great yeah it's just water under the bridge jeez um 30 minutes after that's the left's dirty little secret there, Russell Brand hanging out with a bloke

1:46:54that Donald Trump made deputy director of the FBI, the founder of Turning Point USA, and your own, your very own, Nigel Farage. It's important, that, by the way, because if you do care about women being the victims of sexual assault and rape and crimes, you can't care more about the color of the perpetrator than you do about the fate of the victim. You just can't. That's racist. The element of the conversation that we're going to address next is this idea, and other countries have demonstrated that you can do it. Oddly, some of them are European countries. You can have a sort of staggered age of consent. And it means that in some countries, it can be as low as 14 if you are in a sexual relationship

1:47:42with somebody who is, say, 15 or 16. But it would not be the age of consent if you were in a relationship with someone who was 25. And I heard some callers earlier on nick's show who were making the case that we made last week about the perfectly plausible scenario in which a 17 year old girl falls madly in love with a 32 year old man who has fallen equally in love with her and and we would be criminalizing that relationship even though it it then spawned a very happy 30 year marriage um a very very happy 30 year marriage and i i i don't think that this kind of legislation is going to work unless you have... What's the word that I want? Unless you have a scorched earth approach to it. Do you see what I mean?

1:48:47I don't think that you can have this conversation if you allow these exceptions. I mean, it's bad news if your mom and dad had a 20-year age gap and they're still married 50 years later because that relationship would be unlawful in in the new world but listen i'm beating around the bush is it always dodgy when a man over the age of 25 has a relationship with a woman under the age of 20 or do you want to move those numbers tell me what you think a staggered age of consent would look like or indeed whether a staggered age of consent would work i'd love to know about your experiences with other countries. But, and don't remember, with all of these thresholds, this is what worries me slightly,

1:49:39with all of these thresholds, you're talking about minutes and hours. You know, if we say 25 versus 17, it could be, someone could be 16 years old in 364 days, and someone could have just turned 25 yesterday. And they're going to be a heck of a lot closer you see what i mean that's the problem with thresholds with imposed thresholds but do we need as a society and i think this is probably more a question for women than men but not exclusively do we need as a society to start looking askance at any relationship between a woman under the age of 20 and a man over the age of 25 that that's the threshold i'm going for those are the dates that i'm going for and you can tell me that that's not fair or that's not correct or that's not um

1:50:26in any way acceptable how old is taggy and rivals because that's being set up on british television right now in an incredibly popular program as a i mean no spoilers i've read the book but as a as a possible romantic relationship between a young woman i think she might be under 18 between a young woman and a much older man and yet if we are to introduce this sort of legislation, if we are to introduce a staggered age of consent, then that relationship would not only be inappropriate, it would be illegal. So I guess that's all contingent upon the question of whether or not... There's this thing by divide by two and add seven. So, you know, you're 30, divide by two, two and add seven um so you know you're 30 divide by 2 15 add 7 22

1:51:1620 divide by 2 10 add 7 17 it's actually works quite well in the lower reaches it doesn't matter when you get older of course but um that's that's the question really is is what do we as a society want to think and say about men over the age of 25 having relationships with women under the age of 20 what what why do they do it oh three four five six oh six oh nine seven three we'll do a little bit more i don't want to do a super long introduction because I played you the clips of Farage hanging out with Brand, cosying up to Brand long after the allegations had been made public. So we'll come back to this in a moment. But if you want to get in early, the question's pretty simple. Should we as a society be a lot more

1:52:06judgmental about men pursuing women who are considerably younger than them. And I'm going for the sake of argument with men over 25 and women under 20. And remember, we're saying that 16-year-olds can vote in this country. I heard a conservative politician try to sort of cast some doubt upon the idea of them being somehow old enough to vote, but not old enough to consent to have sex with a much older man. There might be some mileage in that, you know. I guess I just want you to tell me what you think about this story. 0345 6060 973 is the number that we need. If I'm to be completely honest with you, my gut instinct is it's always a bit dodgy. And if you do go on to have a long and fruitful marriage,

1:52:51then, I mean, well done. But I can't help wondering whether or not the girl, the young woman that you married when you were 32 and she was 17, has actually spent the last 30 years still being, in some sense, a victim of the gaslighting and grooming that you inflicted upon her from a very early age. And I'm more than happy to be called an idiot for making that point you know what to do if you want to call me an idiot you have to do a bit more than that you can't just ring in and say you're an idiot and then hang up oh three four five six oh six oh nine seven three if you were allowed to do that keith would be on the line every day 21 minutes after 12 so someone else picked up on this point a writer in the independent called olivia petter picked up on this point. A writer in The Independent called Olivia Petter

1:53:34picked up on this point in May when the second series of Rivals was underway. They then, very cleverly, to make sure that you don't cancel your subscription because you're only subscribing to Disney to watch one show, they then decided not to show the second half of the second series until last week. But the big will-they-won't-they story involves a man in his late 30s and a woman who according to this article is is 18 years old and olivia petter wrote at the time it's predatory perverted and downright wrong and this was long before all of the convictions of russell brand and and accusations revelationsations regarding David Walliams came to light. Why then, asks this writer, is it that so many of us diehard Rivals fans

1:54:21are rooting for Rupert Campbell Black and Tagi O'Hara, a couple with such a vast and glaring age gap? He works with her dad. She still calls her mother mummy. And then the article continues. And it highlights a problem with the conversation at the moment about staggered ages of consent. But I don't think it's the end of the world as we know it to say, oh well, that won't happen anymore. You know? I don't know if you subscribe to the idea of the one. There is one soul on this planet that you are destined to be with. I'm, I suppose, lucky in the context of this conversation because the gap between my wife and me is two years. But I don't know that you are destined for a life of loneliness and misery if you're not allowed to go out with or to go to bed with the 32 year old man that you

1:55:14think you're in love with when you're 16 do you see what i mean it's a conversation about consent it's a conversation about what is socially or societally acceptable but it's also a conversation about whether men over the age of 25 arbitrary figure chosen by me you might prefer 30 men over the age of 25, arbitrary figure chosen by me, you might prefer 30, men over the age of 30 pursuing women under the age of 20 are by definition dodgy. I think I probably believe that, albeit that when I read Rivals many years ago, Jilly Cooper's book, I was completely caught up in the relationship between Rupert Campbell Black and Taghi O'Hara. Completely caught up in it. So I suppose, I'm just asking what you think and why.

1:56:050345 6060 973 is the number that you need. What do you think about this? And crucially, perhaps, why? Maddy's in Manchester. Maddydie what made you pick up the phone um it's just something from personal experience um i know you're talking about a um a particular age demographic but i just made that up though you can talk to me about any age difference if you think it's significant to what you want to tell me. It absolutely is. So from personal experience, I was a 15-year-old in a relationship with a 22-year-old. And at that time, I didn't think it was appropriate. But as I've grown older, I realised that it was absolutely inappropriate. And this person was an adult in a relationship with a child

1:56:55and it should never have happened. And at that time, I didn't have the capacity to make the decisions that I needed to protect myself. Wow. I mean, that's almost perfectly articulated. Yes. What was the process that you you went through i mean how did you i hope this isn't a crass question but how did you arrive at that conclusion and when and when perhaps is interesting as well maddie um i think it was as i grew older so i um i had a baby as a result of that relationship when i was 16 um and um I I battled with it for a long time because I wanted to protect this other person but then I think because I've been through lots and lots of therapy um because you know being traumatized and what I went through being in a relationship with an adult male

1:57:50um essentially yes um I've just come to the conclusion through that therapy and, you know, connecting the dots that it was highly inappropriate and, yeah, it was just... Why was it highly inappropriate? I mean, I agree with you in case there's any doubt about that. But in your own words, I got a friend who started going out with a much older man when she was just 18 and she's very much like you she's like i can't believe it it's so obviously wrong but at the time i didn't think it was what what words do you use now when you say it's wrong i mean do you see what i mean it It's a power thing. There's a power imbalance. Did he groom you? Did he gaslight you? Why wasn't he going out with women of his own age? I mean, there's a lot going

1:58:40on there. But in your own words, why was it wrong? I think there was an element of grooming there and that was the conclusion that I came to in therapy that he should have been in a relationship with a person, you know, of a more appropriate age. And also, I don't think that I had the protective factors on my side, you know, people to look out for me and maybe make the decisions for me at that time, which is what I really needed. And I didn't have that, you know. There were people that knew i was in a relationship maybe teachers at school that saw things and didn't question things you know my own parents that kind of just went along with it and yeah it's sad really it is sad it is sad and i just wonder what you feel about the subject the idea that somebody else with the same age gap would not necessarily have been groomed or traumatised?

1:59:37It could happen in a more pleasant way, or not? Yeah. What do we think? It could, but I think that the law is there to protect vulnerable young girls. You know, maybe one 15-year-'t has more capacity than a different 15 year old yes exactly um but the law is there to look after the one who needs looking after yeah the one who doesn't and it seems a relatively small price to pay to protect her to say to the other one sorry you can't go out with that fella yeah absolutely yeah and there are many nuances to it i suppose but um of course there are but the law doesn't really do nuances i mean prosecutions might be more nuanced the authorities might look at individual cases and context and the rest of it but the law won't

2:00:23how are you getting on now i hope you don't mind me asking that question um i'm i how am i getting on now um okay i mean it popped it pops up every now and again. Especially last week, I imagine. Yeah, absolutely. Yeah, it does. It pops up every now and again, but then I have the benefit of dipping in and out of therapy when I need it, which is wonderful. Indeed it is, for a whole heap of reasons. Maddy, thank you. I mean, that idea of nuance is is key isn't it because you probably do know or you can find someone who had a relationship with a similar gap or even a bigger gap where it doesn't immediately or retrospectively ring alarm bells but society has to make a decision about what it feels about these sort of relationships

2:01:14and the society decides that they are not to be encouraged. They are to be outlawed. I can live with that. Maddie more than can live with it. She categorically wants it given her own experiences. Put into words, if you can, why it's so wrong. I know that sounds like a stupid question and I don't need any help feeling that it's wrong. But putting into words of why it's wrong. 03456060973. And just for pet pedants, apparently, well, she is, isn't she? Because her mum misses her 21st birthday. So she's 21 just in the TV show. I don't think she's got off with Rupert Campbell Black yet. They certainly haven't been to bed or anything. But I think she's younger in the TV show. I don't think she's got off with Rupert Campbell Black yet.

2:01:54They certainly haven't been to bed or anything. But I think she's younger in the book, if that matters. So you can portray these relationships as being quite romantic and exciting, and yet simultaneously we're describing them as pretty close to perverted. Can't both be true at the same time. Amelia Cox is here now with your headlines. 12.33 is the time. I mean, this isn't a question we can answer definitively, but it's a fascinating one. How much lifting does the phrase it was a different time do? Because I don't believe that you should be retrospectively prosecuted, for example, for things that have been recently criminalized. So, for example, if I don't know, if we were to criminalize alcohol tonight, then you shouldn't be in court next week because you had a pint last month.

2:02:45Do you see what I mean? moral questions are possibly slightly different but if something is not illegal when you do it then you should not ever be punished for doing it seems a fairly clear observation to make you know the phrase i always use is we sent kids up chimneys as in it was normal then incredibly normal for very young women girls children technically according to today's morals and mores to marry much older men you know virginity was very prized until very very recently i think king charles was 32 and diana was 19 when they started courting and he'd had to end a previous relationship with a woman because a man came forward to say that they'd had sexual relations i read that the other day it was an extraordinary

2:03:39interview the bloke didn't realize he was doing anything wrong he just gave an interview i mean by a general rule of life if a journalist rings you up to talk about your ex because she's going out with prince charles then put the phone down immediately but he didn't he sounded a little bit tim nice but, and he was going, oh, she's a great girl, she's a lovely girl, we lived together for six months, she'll make the king very happy. And of course, it became impossible to ignore the fact that she'd been to bed with this bloke, which put the kibosh on any prospect of her marrying Charles. Quite a poignant story in a way, but very much of its time, right? Very much a different age. It was acceptable then.

2:04:14It wasn't just acceptable then. It was downright normal then. Think of all the pop songs that celebrate relationships between much older men and much younger women. The Bible is full of relationships between much older men and much younger women, none of which means that we are duty-bound or required to accept it or encourage it today i think we are as a society in a place now where we can say if you are over 30 and she is under 20 and you want to go out with her then you're a wrong and yes here is an exception but that exception proves my rule. It proves my rule. Doesn't it? I mean, the monarchy, historically, has married children. I mean, proper children. Not like puberty, but children children,

2:05:05because it was all about making dynastic alignments that were going to ensure that the two houses were united moving forward. No one here, I don't think, although fair play to anyone who wants to do it as a phone-in, would be in favour of bringing back beheading for adultery, especially unproven. Oh, three, four, five, six, no, I'm joking. So, you know, loads of stuff went on. We still treat King Henry VIII like some sort of hero. He was a syphilitic psychopath who killed several of his own wives. Didn't do it with his own hands. And advisors. He killed anyone who got on his nerves. And we were taught in schools when I was a kid that he was some sort of legend. I think his first wife had been married to his own brother.

2:05:51Or certainly betrothed. Married? Betrothed? What's that game? Avoid. Married, betrothed, avoid. So, you know, we can't, can we, say that what is correct now is always and was always correct. We have to reflect changing times. Where does Emmanuel Macron's relationship with his wife fit into this equation? She was not only much older than him, but I think she was his pupil. He was her pupil at some point in their early encounters. But society makes rules that are never going to be perfect, but we must never let the perfect be the enemy of the good. So what should the rules be and why? Lorraine is in Sidcup. Lorraine, what would you like to say? Oh, hi. Hi. Hello, Lorraine. So I've just pulled over because this is probably the first phone

2:06:42I've been listening to that I felt quite passionately about. Oh, well, thanks a bunch, Lorraine. I sit here every day doing my best work and none of it is... Oh, no, I love listening. I know, I'm totally teasing you. Tell me why. So it's easy you tell me why um so um it's a fascinating debate my situation is at 16 i went on my very first girls holiday to a holiday camp and met a man who was 22 at the time and came back and pretty much started having a relationship with him yeah um a full-blown sort of physical relationship yeah um what did it how did it impact me well i didn't finish my education i was at a really good school and was setting up for doing a levels and going to university i thought i knew everything at 16 as i think a lot of my peers did

2:07:25i was introduced to having very intimate physical relationship at an age when i was way too young to fully understand and he was obviously much more mature in that respect yeah so over many years affected started to affect my further career prospects because I didn't finish the education I have caught up and I had a great career I'm in my 60s now it affected me building intimate relationships um for many many years and um yeah at the time it was just fantastic it was exciting he was in a relationship with somebody else who then wanted he then wanted to marry her and it lasted for nearly two years so and i pretty much i've had therapy like your previous caller um basically there was stuff in my life that made me more vulnerable to people to

2:08:10spot me and and give me love because that was what i felt as love having sex which of course we know it isn't when you understand that yeah but at 16 you won't be told will you no i definitely wasn't going to be told and uh and but and it had a massive effect and it took many years to realize and it's the job of society to protect 16 year old you really because no one else can yeah well you think your parents would and my parents were aware and again like your previous caller they thought they were doing the best by letting it carry on rather than me being pushed more towards this individual but it lasted 18 months and it was that was a very long time and i was pulled away from my friendship

2:08:48circle boys and friends my own age because he groomed you he groomed you and then sought to control you i mean i i suppose some 22 year olds would not be all bad even if they were going out with a 16 year old but that's you know that's the price we pay to protect girls like you is to tell other 16 i don't know if he groomed i wouldn't i don't know i couldn't even say if i had thought about this if he'd groomed me. I really don't know. And I'd have to sort of, I understand the term grooming and I'm aware of what that looks like and how we describe it. Maybe I've not yet had enough work done to realise that that's what's happening. No, no, no, no. Billie Piper talks about her relationship, her marriage to Chris Evans

2:09:28in incredibly warm and glowing terms and that age gap is bigger than the one that you're describing. But that's the point I'm making, is just because it might sometimes be, apparently might sometimes be absolutely fine, and there's no imbalance, and it's a beneficial relationship to both parties. Society's job is to legislate for the greater good, and the greater good would be to say that these kind of relationships should not be allowed yes they'll still happen of course but but we create an idea in society so it becomes a deterrent 16 year old girls know that there's something they're doing something that is absolutely yeah and 22 year old men know that they're doing something absolutely because there could be other 16 year olds that that would be absolutely fine with and it would

2:10:12be a part of their life and manage the rest of their lives but if i'd have been if there was a rule or a law or some awareness for me and my parents to say this is wrong then that could have stopped me going down that path i'm fortunate my life has been amazing i've pulled all that back years ago and got a great family and relationships but you know it took a long time to catch up on that lack of education and with my peers and and i think you've said it i think you're the kind of young woman you were if it had been illegal you wouldn't have done it i'd have had some support to help people get me out of it yes yeah and and you would have had a different relationship with the relationship if it had actually been something adjudged by the society in which we live yes if it had been adjudged something unacceptable or

2:10:59something yes and i'd have matured with a healthier more healthy respect to where physical relationship sits and a whole emotional strong good relationship which didn't happen for into my 40s so it's not healthy no i know and well you've clearly done the work because you speak so clearly and so um and so powerfully about the places you've been the journeys you've been on but but that's the point i mean that is the absolute mothership of this conversation which is if if society said it was wrong i would be less likely to do it. And maybe 22-year-old men, impressionable and foolish fellows might think, oh, Lord, that's not actually allowed. And it would change. So you're never going to get rid of it entirely. You're never going to change the fact that some people

2:11:44who've been in relationships with a similar age gap are both adamant that it was healthy, and they've got a 30-year wedding anniversary next week to prove it. But what society does is supposed to be based upon who needs society's protection. And at the moment, it seems we all think that 16-year-old girls in general need protecting from men considerably older, notably older men, who seek sexual relations with them. Thank you, Lorraine. 12.43 is the time. Jackie's in Stuttgart. Jackie, what would you like to say? Well, I was listening to... One, I think a staggered age of consent would just be unworkable. But when I was 17, my boyfriend was 26. That was my choice. Girls mature a lot quicker than boys and I wouldn't have been interested

2:12:36in boys my own age. I wasn't interested in boys my own age. And that was my choice and I know that's not a universal thing but I think rather than trying to change the law, we need to look at education and we need to teach kids girls and boys because 16, 17, 18 year old boys could be pursued by older women that they need to teach kids girls and boys because you know 16 17 18 year old boys could be pursued by older women that they need to be taught more on how to how to see if the relationship's manipulative or if that's what you mean yeah i mean i suppose we're working on change the law because if you change the law the relationships are still going to happen but they're going to hide it and i don't want my daughters hiding

2:13:13a relationship that's perhaps harming them because it's illegal this is the crux of it because as the last caller pointed out if it was illegal many young women simply wouldn't do it in the same way that they don't I disagree you can't disagree I can because I know what I was like when I was 16, 17 but I didn't disagree. I just said many. But I didn't say all. I said many. I don't even think it's many. I think if you criminalise it, what you're going to do is drive it underground. And then I, as a mum... That's the argument for everything that's illegal. That's the argument for having crack cocaine being illegal. You drive it underground. That's the argument for... crack cocaine being illegal. You drive it underground. That's the argument for, you know, you name it.

2:13:56The argue... Taking crack cocaine is not a biological imperative. And when you're in your teens... Nor is having a relationship with a much older man. Teens are going to have sex. I want to know that... And society should be encouraging them to have sex with each other. Well, they are. Well, no. As I say, at 16, 17, 18, an awful lot of girls are more mature than boys of the same age and they're looking for relationships with lads who are a bit older. And a bit older is fine. But eight years older would not be. Why? Because of the imbalance in power. And the likelihood, but not definite guarantee, of either grooming or coercive control, or inappropriate conduct. Yeah, and that's what I'm saying.

2:14:45I think we need to be a little bit less prudish in our sex education classes in school, and deal with these issues more robustly in school, so that kids are better able to spot a relationship. So you should have been taught not to go out with a 26 year old man rather than forbidden by law. That relationship, there was no coercion in that relationship. But what do you think you should have been taught in sex ed then? But I think that kids need to be taught more how to spot I was in a relationship with a boy who was three years older than me, and that really was coercive and toxic. But what do you think you should have been taught about the man who was eight years older than you? What do you think could have been... I don't think it's about

2:15:22teaching, oh, so-and-so is so many years older than you. I just think kids need to be made more aware of tactics that can be used that are manipulative and that are coercive. And that could be someone exactly the same age as them. Yes, so they can spot it generally. It's not over a massive age gap. It could be someone who's two weeks older or younger than you. Yeah, and this is... And being taught that, I think, is just better in the round for everybody. They have a well-tuned alarm system, as it were. Yes, because especially now, in this day and age of the internet and everything else, kids are missing out on the brownie emotion of banging into real people all the time. And don't spot when something is off.

2:16:03And this is, I mean, I don't know if you were listening, but right at the outset, I said, I am sometimes wary of legislation that comes on the back of scandal, you know, as if there's a sort of sense among politicians something must be done something must be done yeah it feels like a knee-jerk reaction that's just going to be unworkable and i think there are better ways to protect young kids teenagers from from older people from from predatory people and from whatever age they are whereas i would put you and that relationship you had when you were 18, I would be quite comfortable filing that under collateral damage so that that relationship becomes outlawed in order to protect. What did you think about the David Walliams story

2:16:46and the photograph of him with an 18 year old? He denies all wrongdoing. I make that categorically clear. I've got to be honest James, I haven't seen it. How old was he aties all wrongdoing. I make that categorically clear. I've got to be honest, James, I haven't seen it. How old was he at the time? 31. Yeah, I said to your producer, I think 18 and 25 is one thing. 18 and 32, 31, 32, that's pushing it. So you are in favour of a staggered... So you do support a staggered age of consent? No, I... You do. You just did. I've had attention from men who were that much older than me when I was in my teens, and I found it iffy. I was mature enough to... This is it. We're dealing in absolutes. It can't always be iffy.

2:17:24You know, I just think a better education would help... It can't do any harm, can it? ...themselves better against coercive relationships, whatever the age gap is. And whether it's the man that's older or the woman that's older, they all need to be protected from coercive manipulative relationships. And I don't think changing the age of consent is going to make a blind bit of difference to that. Although we did implicitly, and I don't want this to sound like a gotcha, but as soon as you said 32 and 18 is very different from 25 to 18, you were, even if it wasn't in law, it was just in social attitudes, you were recognising a staggered age of consent. Well, it's not about the age of consent. I mean, you look at Barbara Winter and her husband.

2:18:06What was the age gap there? They were old when they met. No one's bringing that into this conversation. No, I know, but as I say, I think it's not about the age gap. But you did, you did. You're turning me into that guy I don't want to be. You're making me go, yes it is. You literally just said 32 and 18 is very different from 25 and 18. So it is about the age gap. It might not necessarily be a terrible relationship. I'm just repeating your own words back to you. Yeah, it strikes me as being a little bit sort of, oh, really? Yeah, no, I hear you. Appropriate rather than being sort of, you know, it should be against the law. It's kind of, hmm. I know, I dwell on it about who needs protecting,

2:18:46isn't it? And you didn't, you know, and an awful lot of other 16-year-old girls did. And therefore, I'm glad you were listening though, Jackie, because I think we needed some sort of nuance bringing into the conversation. And it's a lot easier to speak in theory about somebody being collateral damage or, oh, it's all very sad, that's a shame, you would have had a wonderful relationship with that person, but you're not allowed to uh set that against the reality of it and it does you're quite right begin to sound a lot more sententious or prudish or both it is 10 to 1. 12 53 is the time i'll give you the short version of this because i want to get some more calls on um i thought jackie was a very very important contributor to this conversation um

2:19:28but before we get back to those calls let me just tell you quickly about james o'brien plus which is a subscription service we have launched it gives you exclusive bonus content every single week as well as all of my podcasts so that's the whole of the show and the edited highlights and the um full disclosure as well and the and the mystery hour um completely ad free every wednesday you'll get an episode of Ask James Anything. I don't need to tell you what that is. And every month at the moment, you'll get James Reacts, in which I look back at stuff and react to it, including some of the stories that we have indeed discussed today. And then every two weeks, you get my newsletter, written by me, Life O'Brien.

2:20:08I'm going to drop the definite article on that and just call it Life O'Brien. And it looks at politics, culture, anything that you want me to look at. If you want to join on Global Player or Apple Podcasts, then just go to my podcast pages. You'll see a new subscription option. Click on it and sign up. If you want to watch your podcast, if you prefer the visuals, then you can join on YouTube instead. Just go over to James O'Brien Plus on YouTube, head to the full disclosure YouTube page and press the join button which is right next to the subscribe button. It's £4.99 each per month or £49.99 for the whole year. So just pick your subscription and join James O'Brien Plus now. Chris is in Billingham.

2:20:48Chris, what made you pick up the phone? Well, I think it's an interesting conversation and I think you're hitting somewhere with the age gap element. But I think there's a wider conversation that needs to be had. I think there's certainly some risks with individuals under the age of 18. But it really always comes down to the toxic behavior of people and certain individuals within our culture. And I think because I'm in my 30s now i've heard a multitude of horror stories from women that i know and have dated and there seems to be a a a number of individuals men predominantly that feel like it's okay to manipulate coerce and it's just i think that's the main issue i think we're not easily able to see these behaviors i think this is what the drama

2:21:42adolescence addressed and well the toxic masculinity as a business model rather than just as a lifestyle choice well kind of but this this is the the issue we're finding and you'll you'll hear from other people you speak to it's not the stereotypical violence that you see it's very like slimy it's very hidden and you can't necessarily see it you can have manipulation through tears financial like there's multitude of ways to manipulate and coerce and i think this stereotypical violence is is just one of these things. But we're not noticing those other elements. You're the only person who's mentioned violence. I wasn't thinking about that during these conversations. I was thinking there was a great message that came in while Jackie was talking,

2:22:27which just said, of course, she didn't want to go out with boys her own age when she was 17. I think Jackie was actually 18 but the question is why would a 26 year old man want to go out with a 17 year old girl you flip that question on its head you're not talking about violence you are talking about at the very least some sort of manipulation aren't you yeah exactly and i think it's it's more of the fact that when i've mentioned violence it's more that it's a lot easier to see in society. If you notice someone that you love and care for and you notice that form of manipulation quite clearly. Yes. But it's the others that you can't see straight away. And I think more work needs to be done to help those be able to see it from a distance.

2:23:12See, here's the thing. And I maybe should have made this clearer sooner i don't think that this is going to be an easily inactable piece of legislation and and i mean you only need to look at the number of alleged rapes that end up in court let alone end up with convictions to recognize that it's going to be close to impossible to police but i think perhaps naively that a law sends a message to everybody in a society about certain behaviors either being acceptable or not acceptable so it might be wrong chris but it's not against the law therefore a certain type of bloke is going to do it and a certain and a certain type of young woman is not going to realize that he shouldn't be whereas if it is actually against the law then it works as a sort of deterrent a behavioral deterrent even if it doesn't deliver um

2:23:59many convictions or or legal prosecutions and i think this is what you'll likely find is many people have divided opinions of it but i think we need to go back to um the the policing of consult society i think we should hold each back to the policing of society. I think we should hold each other accountable and actually live with an element of honour. I think as a bloke, it certainly gives me a bad... It makes me feel like it gives men a bad name. And I think we need to go back to that living with honour and respect. And I think that the traffic has moved in the opposite direction in the last 10 years. I really do. Maybe more, maybe a little bit less. But the idea of Nigel Farage not only praising Andrew Tate, but then cozying up to Russell Brand after horrible allegations have been made against both of them while retaining a very prominent place in public discourse is, to me at least, profoundly troubling.

2:24:47Profoundly troubling. That's it for today. If you missed any of it, you can listen back on Global Player or the LBC app. They're both free. It's also where you can find James O'Brien Plus that I was just telling you about. So download the official LBC app for free from your app store now. Tom Swarbrick will be with you at four, but now it's time for Sheila Fogarty. This has been a Global Player original production. Granger knows if you're a procurement manager at an industrial manufacturing facility, you're balancing inventory and budget while sourcing critical supplies across the operation. Too much inventory? Cost climb. Too little? Production slows. Grainger's $2 billion in on-hand inventory helps you get what you need when you need it,

2:25:30so you can help keep budgets balanced and lines moving. Call 1-800-GRANGER, click granger.com, or just stop by. Granger, for the ones who get it done.

▸More episode summaries

James O'Brien - The Whole Show cover art
James O'Brien - The Whole ShowMy life was turned upside down by cannabis - now it's in Boots2026-11-17 · 155 min
Transcribe your links. Paste a YouTube, Google Drive or podcast link and WhipScribe gives you the transcript. Transcribe a link →
New James O'Brien - The Whole Show transcripts by email
One email per new episode, unsubscribe in every message. Not shared with the publisher.