Iran: The Latest · · Transcript & summary by WhipScribe
Summary, chapters and key takeaways for this episode are on their way; the transcript below is complete.
Our own transcript of the public episode, with a timestamp about every 90 seconds. Tap a timestamp to play the episode from there in the show's own player; the link button on a paragraph copies a link that opens this page there.
0:00The Telegraph From shipping supplies to PPE to hand tools, he counts on Grainger to keep products moving and trucks rolling so his operation runs smoothly no matter the shift. Call 1-800-GRAINGER, click Grainger.com, or just stop by. Grainger, for the ones who get it done. This message is brought to you by today's sponsor, Walden University. Set a course for change. Now is the time to make a real change in your life, career, and community. This message is brought to you by today's sponsor, Walden University. Set a course for change. Now is the time to make a real change in your life, career, and community. At Walden University, we give you the support and flexibility to get the W. Walden's online programs are designed for
0:56working professionals like you. You'll gain hands-on skills to take on real-world challenges and succeed. Your future is waiting, and Walden is here to help you achieve it. Take the first step to make your impact. Visit waldenu.edu. Walden University. Set a course for change. Certified to operate by Chev. I'm Roland Ollivant, and this is Iran The Latest. It's the 17th of November, 2026. Tuesday, the day of Ture, the bravest of the gods, the ninth month of the war between the US and Iran and four days from the end of Iran The Latest. So watch, enjoy, savour the following hour of scintillating conversation and geopolitical insight because you are going to miss it when it's gone, I promise you.
1:48On today's episode, how has the Iran war, and indeed all of the wars since October 7th, changed Israel? We'll be speaking to Henry Bodkin, our man in Jerusalem, and Paul Newky here in the studio. A short time ago, the United States military began major combat operations in Iran. Iran's Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei was killed in the attacks. Ayatollah Ali Khamenei! For the first time ever, the U.S. Navy used a surface sea drone in combat to strike Iranian targets. The Saratov almost completely closed again. Does anyone really think that someone can tell President Trump what to do? Come on. First of all, let's talk about the latest news from Iran, the Gulf and the war. Top of the list. CNN reported yesterday that US intelligence agencies
2:48or US intelligence indicates that Iran is developing plans to target senior Trump administration officials by detonating a dirty bomb or chemical weapon of some sort in Washington, D.C. CNN cited seven officials as the source for that claim. They said sources familiar with the latest intelligence characterised the Iranian planning as, for now, an effort to give itself options rather than an indicator of imminent attack. But they said the plotting picked up by the US has been very specific and includes locations and targets. Two of the sources, not all seven, said. Iran's foreign ministry, needless to say, has denied that flatly this morning saying the allegations are baseless in an ex-post in the gulf iran said it fired drones at a u.s military radar
3:34system in bahrain on tuesday despite talks between tehran and oman on safeguarding maritime corridors in the strait of hormuz the is Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps said the radar system that it attacked was at the Sheikh Issa base in Bahrain, the Gulf state that's home to the US Fifth Fleet. Bahrain said it had intercepted the attack after sending an air raid alert and telling citizens to take shelter. There were no reports of casualties or damage. This comes after Bahrain intercepted several Iranian aerialian aerial attacks on sunday during what iran said had been targeting a u.s radar system at the al-rifah helicopter base there is at the time of recording no statement yet about this from central command
4:19and some potentially dramatic events at sea worse worse things happen at sea, they say it because it's really true. The IRGC Navy claims that two vessels, in violation of its rules about navigating the Strait of Hormuz, were struck by a naval mine and suffered severe explosions and fires while receiving, this is their words, while receiving air support from a large number of American fighter jets and aircraft. They say one of the vessels was a supertanker carrying more than 2 million barrels of crude oil and the other a liquefied natural gas carrier. This claim is carried by ISNA, the Iranian Students' News Agency. We can't immediately verify it and there's nothing I've seen from US Central Command about this.
5:03However, UK Maritime Trade Operations has put out a couple of reports. The first one, yesterday they said they had received a report of an incident seven nautical miles north of Kasab Oman. A third party, they said, reported an attack involving a tanker transiting the Strait of Hormuz, disabling the vessel and resulting in an engine room fire. Now, in the initial report yesterday, UKMTO said the crew were reported safe, but this morning they issued an update in which they said the crew was unaccounted for and that the vessel had suffered a second strike, which caused a fire on board. Damage assessment unknown at present. Vessels advised to transit with caution and report any suspicious activity to uk mto that's their latest report there was a separate update saying that they
5:51had received a report of an incident in the straight of form as the company security officer of a tanker reporting that vessel had been struck by an unknown projectile while transiting outbound through the straight that resulted in a fire in the engine room. No casualties reported. All crew accounted for. So potentially dramatic activity in the strait. Of course, bear in mind what we consider our most reliable naval experts are very sceptical about the presence of naval mines in the strait, and we haven't yet had third-party confirmation of these Iranian claims of enormous fires there but we'll keep an eye on it and on the other side of the Arabian Peninsula in Yemen Saudi-backed forces are readying to thwart what they say could be a possible Houthi advance on
6:38Aden the Houthis have been trying to take the district of Tur al-Baha some 85 kilometers it's 52 miles from Aden which is the seat of Tur al-Baha, some 85 kilometres, that's 52 miles, from Aden, which is the seat of the country's internationally recognised government. Two Yemeni officials, speaking to Reuters, said that the Saudis have been putting up stiff resistance and have deployed more troops and equipment in and around Tur al-Baha, considered the first line of defence for Aden. One of the officials, who apparently is close to the Houthis, said the rebels have suffered significant casualties in their recent battles in and around the Bab al-Mandeb Strait and the Red Sea. We'll be keeping an eye on that well for the next few days
7:15while we're still on air anyway. Then you'll have to do it yourself. That more or less wraps up the news from the Middle East today. And I'm very pleased to say we're joined in the studio today by two of Telegraph's most illustrious journalists, Paul Nookie here, our global health security editor, Henry Bodkin in Jerusalem. And the meat, gentlemen, of today's episode is really an opportunity partly to look back as we're in the last furlong of this podcast. You've both been basically talking a lot to us about Israel over the past nine months or even longer on battle lines. And we've been reviewing different parts of the conflict. I'm really interested essentially in getting your takes on where we are right now.
7:59But I was wondering if first we might start with the latest news out of Israel today. There is an interesting story about UK sanctions and Jared Kushner. What's going on? So Ed Miliband has announced this morning sanctions on eight Israeli firms. They're all construction firms of one sort or another operating in the West Bank, so building settlements. So he's announced sanctions on those firms. It means their assets will be frozen. Their directors will not be allowed to travel to the UK. And one of those firms, a company called ZF Building, that company is financed, given mortgages by another Israeli company called Phoenix Financial. And Phoenix Financial is partly owned by Affinity Partners, which is Jad Kushner has talked the Saudis, the Emiratis, the Kuwaitis
9:09to invest. And that fund invests in Phoenix Financial, a big financial conglomerate in Israel, which is providing mortgages to at least one of these sanctioned companies. So in effect, Ed Miliband has in a roundabout way sanctioned Jod Kushner, President Trump's son-in-law, I believe, and a key player on the Board of Peace, the body that is supposed to be sorting out Gaza. Extraordinary. Is there some suggestion that's deliberate or is the suggestion that they didn't really know? No, I mean, these investments, you know, like a lot of modern day investments are, you know, pretty arm's length. You know, it's only a 7.4% stake affinity holds in Phoenix. But nevertheless, it shows the web of money
9:59that always comes with Donald Trump and his acolytes. It's interesting. And just one last thing on this, Paul. That's kind of the latest round of the UK-Israel kind of standoff, the Ed Miliband's, you know, kind of admonishing of Israel and its policies in the West Bank and elsewhere. How significant is it? I think it is significant. You know, we weren't expecting this today. We were expecting a whole package of sanctions to come from the UK next year. I think that's still likely to come and it may include some of the big banks. But it is significant. Miliband is basically drawing a line in the sand. He's saying that britain supports the two-state solution that the settlements are under light undermining a two-state solution and that is
10:51his red line that the the uk will sanction companies involved in the settlement projects henry can i bring can i bring you in here and do some i don't know if there's anything you can say about the the the before we move on to the next story, about how this, it's one of the narratives of the past several months has been this UK-Israel rift, at least for us. How's it going down there? Well, I mean, obviously when the sanctions were announced in September, Israel took against Britain, mainly, even though it was a joint package between Britain, France and Canada, it was, they chose to devote all their criticism to the UK very much kind of highlighting the fact that it was a Labour government policy, and that, you know,
11:39relations had deteriorated since Labour came to power. And then obviously we had the downgrading of the consulate to a mission and the expulsion of about 20 diplomats from the former consulate in Jerusalem. It's headline news here today that these sanctions have taken place, that they've actually been imposed, but I don't imagine it will lead the news agenda for very long given everything else that's happening. I mean, the obvious question is, will this reopen the row over the expulsion of diplomats? I think the foreign office's view would be well it needn't because we said we were going to do this and then you expelled quite a few of our diplomats so we're just doing what we said we were going to do to start with.
12:18The briefing from Whitehall has been that you know the threats to really, really clean out a lot of diplomats from the Israeli embassy in London. If Israel went any further, these expulsions hit home and therefore everything's settled on that front. I see on Ed Miliband's announcement today, really driving home this language of a reset in Israel, UK-Israel relations, pegging it to the two-state solution, pegging it to this E1 kind of monster development out to the east of East Jerusalem. And there's another stage in the planning process that's coming up soon, and they've pegged it to that. So, yeah, it's flared up again. Thanks for that. You were talking about front page news i'm assuming what's really dominating israeli papers
13:11is still the formation of this government following the uh following the election um a week or two ago could you please i mean to the best of your ability tell us where we are there um it can be quite difficult for those outside Israel and not kind of immersed in Knesset politics and alliance building and so on to keep up with this. Just a very quick recap. Benjamin Netanyahu lost his governing coalition majority. So the parties that made up the government of the last four years, it lost its majority in the Knesset at the election. Although Likud emerged as the largest party, nevertheless, the president invited Gaddy Eisenkot, who's the leader of the kind of de facto opposition leader, this was about
13:55nine days ago now, gave him the first opportunity as a kind of constitutional thing to try and form a government because enough of the other factions had indicated that they would support him trying to do that so we're in this formal process now where gaddy eisencott who's this relative newcomer to politics he's a former chief of staff of the idf career general is is trying to form a coalition uh and that will involve him breaking at least one of his campaign promises which is not to form a coalition with the Arab parties, who of course did very well at the election and hold 19 seats in the 120-seat Knesset. He also promised not to form a coalition with Benjamin Netanyahu, which is what Netanyahu is calling
14:36for him to do, citing national unity and all the security problems facing Israel. Eisenkot also said he wouldn't form a majority with the ultra-Orthodox parties if that meant continuing with this effective exemption of young men, young Haredi men as they're known, ultra-Orthodox men, from joining the army, which is a really, really sore point in Israeli society. It looks like that's the promise he's trying to break because he's got to break one of them in order to form a government. He doesn't have to break all, but he does have to break one of those three. one or two one or two on the arithmetic so he's he's in talks with at least one of the Haredi parties um united Torah Judaism or is it united Torah justice and cut out for the right one you know and and there's this maverick guy
15:22Avigdor Lieberman, who leads one of the smaller factions within the so-called change bloc. He's saying, don't go with the Arabs. I won't have it. I won't hear of it. Try and form a deal with the ultra-Orthodox. You've got the Arab party saying, look, we want you to become prime minister, that one of them, which is a little bit more, how do I put it, a little bit less nationalist in its views. Rahm is saying, look, invite us into a coalition. Formal coalition members are suggesting that they would formally denounce Hamas as a terrorist organization if they were invited in. They always denounce acts of terror, but they've never before said, we think Hamas is a terrorist organization. Then there's the other Arab party joint list who would probably support it from the outside.
16:04They wouldn't come in but it looks like at the moment Gadi Eizenkot is going is trying to stitch something up with the ultra-orthodox in preference to the Arabs possibly he thinks that if he can get a deal with them on this issue of the draft maybe keeping a proportion of their young men out of the army and in the yeshivas the bible schools then that will be a more stable government over the long term than doing it with the with the arab israelis but he's got you know that he could have another three weeks to keep negotiating and then a further two-week extension before we know whether he's succeeded or failed and after that if he hasn't succeeded benjamin netanyahu will presumably be given a go in In the meantime, Netanyahu is
16:46going absolutely bananas saying the election was stolen. I mean, it really is. It's almost a facsimile if you change the details of the kind of stop the steal stuff from Trump in 2020. But it's actually now rebounded on him because the police are reportedly probing the behavior of Likud aides to Benjamin Netanyahu saying look did you just feed us complete rubbish on the eve of the election to try and stir up this scare of vote stealing in the in Israel's Arab community so it's all being carried on both at quite an incremental pace but also in an incredibly bad tempered way you kind of preempted my question I was going going to ask, okay, so how close are we to an Eisencott government? It sounds still quite a long way.
17:30Well, look, it could, I mean, it could come any day. But there are signs that they're not close to an agreement. For example, it was suggested today that the UTJ, one of these Haredi parties, is not going to support Eisenkot's efforts to replace the Speaker of the House with someone that Eisenkot wants. And that was considered, maybe that would be a test case of whether the two parties could work together. I don't think that means that the talks are in a terminal phase or anything. It just maybe they're holding out for more. Look, I mean, there is a school of thought, which is that there are enough people out there, outside of the former Netanyahu coalition bloc, who just want Bibi out so much that they'll cobble something together
18:14just to get him out of the prime minister's residence, get his hand away from the, you know, metaphorical red button, not the nuclear red button, of course, but, you know, in terms of restarting wars with Iran, that kind of thing, launching operations in the West Bank in Gaza, that it would be worth cobbling something unstable together to get him out of the Prime Minister's residence, and then trying to build a more permanent coalition. But yeah, it could come soon, but it could equally not come very soon at all. I think the big question with Isingkot is, is he and his bloc pushing now as hard as they can to do a deal with the Heredi? Because that is what Lieberman, a key player in his bloc, wants to test. And the question is, is if that fails,
19:06will Lieberman back down and agree to a government with Arab support? I think that's the big test. I don't think the answer is at all clear. It may be that Lieberman really does believe that he's not going to do a government with Arab support no matter what, which is what he claims. Sounds like you don't necessarily believe him, Paul. No. Why is that? Is he just a character who changes his mind a lot, or is it just politics? Consummate Israeli politician, you know, a real operator, very, very hard to read, utterly inscrutable. So it's hard to know what his game is. If you're cynical, and some people are, they say, well, what he's going to do is he's going to really hold out. He's going to hold out long enough for Netanyahu to have a go at forming
19:58a government, for which he has not got the numbers. And then there's a very brief period a three-week period uh before it goes to another election where the kinesis itself uh can form a government and it may be that he's hanging out for that window uh where he'll jump in and say i'll tell you what i'll be the prime minister and and this is i'll be the national union unity candidate yeah so that that's the that's a long machiavellian game if that's what he's that's that's a long Machiavellian game, if that's what he's... That's a long Machiavellian game, if that's what he's up to. He also said, I mean, I think, where was I reading it? The Times of Israel or somewhere this morning. He said he's saying,
20:35don't you dare go into coalition with the Arabs. But he also seems to have said the same thing about Netanyahu. He was talking to Eisenkot, saying, remember what happened to Benny Gantz when he did that? Don't you dare. That's right. And, you know, he has, I believe, is this right, Henry? Lieberman has sat with Rahm before, I believe, in the Bennett government, right? I think so. I think so. And, I mean, of course, Lieberman was Likud, which he used to be Likud, which tells you two things. One is that he's probably not instinctively well disposed towards Arabs. And I mean, you know, that's coming across from his comments. But also Likud are the ultimate pragmatists. You know, ultimately they go with whoever will keep them in power.
21:18But I think he's probably, I think as a piece of objective advice to Eisenkot not to do a deal with Netanyahu has to be sensible because he'll just get, the moment he does that, his credibility will be completely destroyed. He'll be chewed up and he'll be political history, I think. I think that's absolutely right. I think that of all the positions that they are not going to abandon, it is a deal with Netanyahu. I mean, they've really had it with him. And my instinct, and it's no more than an instinct, is that if they're unable to do a deal with the Haredi, they will form a minority government with Arab backing. And actually, in Israel, a minority government is much more stable than you would imagine, because it takes 61 positive votes to cause a vote of no confidence in that government.
22:13And as long as the bloc holds together, they're going to see off any vote of no confidence. It would really take something quite big, I think think once the minority government is formed to bring it down maybe i should lay out before you both the kind of fork in the road where i am in this conversation one is to ask you about there's another big story that's been going on in the past week or so about about winter in gaza um about floods about about all of that and the other question which is a little bit more crystal baller gazing is what does this actually mean and how do things change let's take that first the practical thing henry have you been following gaza winter floods aid gaza has kind of three years ago it was all we were ever talking
22:57about um but it has kind of fallen off the the radar a little bit what can you tell us about the the latest state of play there in a sad way the last week has been a real trip down memory lane because we've had uh the issue where we there was torrential rain two weekends ago um people were killed because of flooding and the issue of the fact that there simply are not enough decent tents in gaza came up and the blame came because of that. And then last weekend, there was an IDF airstrike on NASA hospital. And that's the first time they've actually struck a main patient building in a hospital since the war. And obviously, I mean, that was the most controversial thing that used to happen during the war with these various strikes on it.
23:40So in that sense, it's almost as if we're back in the conflict from October 23 to October 25. On the humanitarian stuff, I mean, it is absolutely ghastly. All the same people, the UN, foreign governments, international NGOs have been saying that the Israelis could do a lot more to allow in adequate shelter in particular, without increasing the risk of Hamas getting their hands on things that they could turn to weaponry. Israel says, actually, we're doing everything we can. We're doing more than should be expected of us as the country who was originally attacked. And we have this winter plan to get in more tents and so on. There's an added element to this, which is that we reported exclusively actually about 10 days ago,
24:30or no, about a week ago, it was that Hamas have been confiscating some of these new tents, some of these new fiberglass tents. They have been preventing people getting their hands on them and they've been stopping essentially Palestinian civil servants, people that are technically loyal to the PA, Fatah-controlled government in Ramallah, from going into these vast refugee camps and making them safer, making them safer from these kind of earth collapses that killed a few children two weekends ago and stuff. The Israelis say that shows what Hamas are really about, which is about utilising the humanitarian crisis to put international pressure on Israel. And certainly the international pressure has been mounting on Israel in the last two weeks.
25:10I've spoken to people in Gaza who say, in reality, maybe it's a little bit more about Hamas trying to tax the tents, trying to make some money out of them, and also basically wanting to keep fatter people out of the camps, trying to keep Hamas' political control over these camps. They don't want to let fatter people engender any loyalty back towards the Palestinian Authority in Ramallah. It's hard to know to what extent Hamas mucking around with these tents is contributing to the wider shortage. But certainly that's an element to it, as well as obviously the issue of what's allowed in, which is completely under the control of the Israelis. Just to remind us, is it still the case that foreign journalists struggle to get inside Gaza?
25:54Foreign journalists cannot go inside Gaza unless they're on one of these very short, embedded tours with the IDF, which of course now just go into the IDF-controlled bit of it. So yeah, I mean, foreign journalists have been prevented going independently into Gaza since October the 7th. We should say that, I mean, there's no doubt that conditions in Gaza are appalling. I talked this week to an NHS doctor, a woman who'd been there for the last, well, she got back a week ago. She'd been there for two weeks. We talked to another doctor, a British doctor at the NASA hospital. You know, they all report severe shortages of medicines, equipment for surgery, and the most appalling living conditions.
26:43There is no doubt, on the other hand, that there is operating in Gaza an enormous black market. Everything you buy is hugely inflated. Gangs grew up during a period of real extreme food shortages. When a famine was declared a year ago. At that point, gangs made themselves extraordinarily wealthy, trading in food and that wealth, you know, they continue to invest in new trades. It costs $30,000, for example, to buy a donkey now in Gaza, which we wrote about a few weeks ago. But it applies to everything. If you want electricity through a generator to your tent, if you want Wi-Fi, it's all got to be paid for, and it's paid for in an enormous black market. And there's no doubt at all that where Hamas is operating,
27:39it will be involved in that. Thanks for bringing us up to date both on Gaza. I suppose, kind of bringing it back to the politics, what, if anything, for the past three years, really. There's Gaza, there's the West Bank and settler violence, there's Lebanon, there's the buffer zone in Syria, there's what do we do about Iran, all of that. How much do you see the current trajectory is baked in and how far is an actual change of government likely to shift Israeli policy and, I suppose, shift the dynamic in the region? My take on it, there are two types of Zionism. Henry will recognize this because I've just been reading a book he recommended called The Netanyahu's, but it's a very good book. It's about the...
28:40He wrote that. Joshua Cohen. Joshua Cohen, and it's about Benjamin Netanyahu's father, also a Ben. But, you know, there are two schools of Zionism that have been for 100 years or more. Eisenkot represents the sort of Zionism that is laid out in the Declaration of Independence of Israel, which is a democracy, a light in the Middle East, where everyone is treated equally, which is liberal, a liberal democracy. You know, Netanyahu and Likud come from a tradition which is much more fire and brimstone. It's about God. It's about God's command that the land belong to Jews. It's always been a much more aggressive form of Zionism. It disparages Arabs, and it is embracing, much more embracing of conflict, right the way through from the early 1900s.
29:44Do these two schools have their own names? Well, the revisionist Zionist school is the school that comes from the shtetls of Ukraine, where my grandmother came from. You know, that's the Benjamin Netanyahu school. And the liberal school, you know, you could ultimately trace back to Herzl, you know, Vienna, which is where my grandfather came from, you know, and that's a more political school of Zionism. And it originally didn't even have Israel at its heart. Israel was one option where you could build a Jewish state. Baja California was another, for example. So they're two different schools. And I see the difference between Netanyahu and Isincott. I may be completely wrong on this, but I mean, that's my instinct is that Isincott is much more allied to the
30:40school. This hersaly, liberally old-fashioned tradition. Yeah, and Netanyahu the other side. And there is some evidence for that. You know, Eisencott has laid out these four principles for parties that want to deal with him in government. And they really focus, the first two focus on the founding principles of Israel and the Declaration of Independence. And you never hear Netanyahu talk about that, because I think that his school of Zionism, and certainly the school of religious Zionism, modern religious Zionism, it disapproves of that construct. It wants a much more theocratic state. This is all fascinating and it's wonderful context but the question was how might an Eisenhower government actually change trajectories and policies? Well I think it will
31:33end up being it'll be much more pragmatic and it'll be much more friendly to the west and it once again to build this idea of Israel as a liberal democratic state in a difficult part of the world. You know, that is the idea that people really bought into in the West, following Israel's formation. And unfortunately, in my view, it's an ideal that the country itself appears to have abandoned and is responsible for the huge welling up of, you know, support for Palestinian causes and anti-Israel causes. Okay, Henry, there you are in Jerusalem, living all this, breathing it, touching it every day. My instinct is that whilst I recognise everything Paul said about the sort of fundamental type of Zionism that Eisenkot may cleave to in an ideal
32:31world, my instinct is that he will, if he becomes prime minister, he will wake up in the morning thinking like a general. He will wake up in the morning seeing everything as a security problem, because Israel does face real security problems. And in reality, I'm not sure he will react that much differently to Benjamin Netanyahu. I mean, this guy has spent his life in the IDF. And we've got to remember that actually, you know, it's ironic that Likud and Benjamin Netanyahu campaign on the slogan of peace through strength. It's actually a bit misleading. Peace through strength is the Israeli baseline. That was the military doctrine pioneered by the original leftists like Ben Gurion. I don't think personally that even people like Yair Golan, who's the kind of centre-left former IDF general
33:27who's head of the Democrats, would have done, certainly in the initial campaign, would have done that much differently in Gaza. I don't think he would have responded that much differently in Lebanon. I don't think Eisenkot would have done either. I think in Gaza, Benjamin Netanyahu prolonged the war for political purposes and maybe was ultra-aggressive at certain stages. But, you know, he is not a soft guy, Eisenkot. And he has been the one executing Benjamin Netanyahu's policies for years as a senior IDF general. And there is a problem from Hamas. It hasn't gone away. Depending on who you listen to, there might be an emerging problem of radicalization in the West Bank. Maybe that's a bit of a right wing diversion. We're not really sure. But obviously, we've got Lebanon in the
34:16north and Iran. And I just think that the Israeli military baseline is actually in terms of thinking is actually not that far from where Netanyahu is. What Netanyahu does is he kind of gives it this extra aggression, this extra political spin. So, you know, I think in the West Bank, I doubt Eisenkot would want to remove any settlements. I think he might be a little bit more proactive in dismantling some of these illegal outposts that spring up outside the settlements. I think he would be more proactive in enforcing law and order, clamping down on some of these violent settlers. But again, you know, it's really difficult. He will know, because he's not an idiot, that a lot of the soldiers under his command sympathize with them, sympathize with these settlers.
35:05And I think he'd be quite pragmatic on that. My feeling is with Iran, that he's certainly not against in principle further fighting with Iran. But I think he would very much see it as an opportunity to stitch his government in with the states, to be able to say to people, you know, I have just as good a working relationship with the administration in Washington as Bibi ever claimed to. I don't think he's particularly interested in wholesale regime change, given that that's already been tried once. But I don't think he would be against further strikes on nuclear sites as long as that was done in lockstep with Washington. I don't think you'd see from him the sort of, you know, trying to bounce Washington into things
35:49in the way that Netanyahu did in 2025, which obviously actually worked out quite well in the end. So personally, I think that Eisenkot would change the political tone in Israel hugely. And that would mean a lot to Israelis. But I think the fundamental stance of Israel towards the Palestinian people towards its enemies would not change hugely. I mean, you know, that is a strong argument. And part of the difficulty in understanding which way it will go is understanding how Eisenkot will perform as a politician because henry's absolutely right to say you know he he's been a soldier all his life perhaps he's going to turn out to be a rather clumsy politician it's a difficult transition to make it is on the other hand though on the other hand and i you know i
36:39was pretty skeptical at first but if you look at the few weeks we've had since the election, and indeed the three months ahead of the election when he formed the party and got himself to be the biggest party in the change bloc, I think he's performed exceptionally well. And his PR, his statements that are put out once or twice a day are pretty polished. And I do see that he is trying, through his rhetoric, to become a leader for the country, a leader who is absolutely Zionist and dedicated to Israel's flourishing, but in a way that brings the world along with it. You know, that is what he's pushing. And he has been effective in that communication. Do you think he can make friends with Ed Miliband?
37:34I think he probably could if he continues with the rhetoric and crucially with the policies that the West want to see. I mean, this is the thing. Rhetoric will not be enough. We've seen in America this huge tsunami of support for the Democrats, fueled in large part by opposition to Iran and opposition to Israel. We feel the same in the UK. I mean, that's what Miliband's all about, buying in to this wave of anti-Israel support on the streets. And, you know, all of that is very, very dangerous for Israel, particularly the switch of opinion in America, where most people in America now disapprove of Israeli policies. And Israel is going to have to answer to that. Netanyahu's answer is to give them a finger
38:28and we'll carry on like we've always done. We'll decide ourselves. We don't need your weapons, et cetera, et cetera. It's super Sparta, he calls it. I think that Eisenhower, if he manages to gain power, will have a very different strategy and it will come with policy that seeks to assuage the West. I mean, the most obvious thing I think probably Henry and I agree on is that if he took power, he would be very quick to crack down on what they call the Jewish terrorism in the West Bank. These marauding settler kids who are just causing all sorts of stealing farms and burning down olive groves and terrorizing people i mean it really is terrible uh and i i think that he would be very quick uh to crack down firmly on that you know like like a general might just to
39:19annotate paul's point actually i had i was actually chatting to the the president over the summer and herzog and then he he as you do described a phenomenon to me which i wasn't aware of which is um what's called i mean there's probably a just a brilliant hebrew word for it which i don't know it's called the camp um and this is i mean you could call it the deep state or the elite depending on on where you look at it but these are the former generals academics uh middle sort of mainstream diplomats international people business people they're not they're not too far to the right they're not too far to the left and he said that they had decided that eisencourt was their man months and months ago and they'd started building bridges for him in the states and that there are a
40:03lot of willing people willing to give him a including probably quite high up in the States and that there are a lot of willing people willing to give him including probably quite high up in the administration including inside the White House itself who are waiting to work with Eisencott and they quite like the idea of it in some way that there's a lot of behind the scenes support for him to really get stuck into America and do it in a different way to Netanyahu. Well it's definitely going to be a mountain to climb I mean we've covered in detail actually with with some American some of the sceptical American voices about about the collapse of that relationship. We're going to take a short break now when we come back is it really right to
40:40look at the past three years of conflict in the Middle East as the October 7th wars. career, and community. At Walden University, we give you the support and flexibility to get the W. Walden's online programs are designed for working professionals like you. You'll gain hands-on skills to take on real-world challenges and succeed. Your future is waiting, and Walden is here to help you achieve it. Take the first step to make your impact. Visit waldenu.edu. Walden University, set a course for change. Certified to operate by Chev. The holidays bring brand new gadgets, bigger spending, and even more on your to-do list. Good thing Verizon gives you more than just a great network. We give you a whole lineup of products and services.
41:39Like a protection plan for your family's home tech that covers everyday mishaps. A credit card that rewards holiday shopping with real savings. And a smart watch built specifically for keeping up with your kids. Take the stress out of the season. Pick what works for you at verizon.com slash extras. This is the story of the one. As a shipping manager, he's running the dock, stocking supplies, and making sure every order goes out on time. And Grainger helps him stay prepared. From shipping supplies to PPE to hand tools, he counts on Grainger to keep products moving and trucks rolling so his operation runs smoothly no matter the shift. Call 1-800-GRAINGER, click Grainger.com, or just stop by. Grainger, for the ones who get it done.
42:31Welcome back. You're listening to Iran The Latest with me, Roland Oliphant. I'm joined today by Jerusalem correspondent, Emily Bodkin, and global health security editor, Paul Newky. Over the course of this. Guys, I wanted to, if I can, kind of pull the lens outwards a bit and indulge in a bit of history and so on, because we're approaching the end of the podcast, which is a completely arbitrary kind of place to throw down an ending point in history. It is the end of history. It is indeed the end of history. Never say that. and that's what um you know that's what historians do don't they they kind of they kind of pick a date and they make an argument for it but look this this podcast as battle lines was its its birth was kind of
43:16induced prematurely by the october 7th attacks um it was it was it we have this plan for a for a geopolitical defense podcast um looking all over the world. Then that happened, changed everything. A dramatic, traumatic moment for everybody being rushed out there to cover it. And it was probably one of the one of the really horrific stories that I've actually covered in my time as a foreign correspondent. You know, there's no overstating that. I'm wondering then, in that trajectory, in that three years, there is a way of framing everything we've been talking about with the Iran war and so on as kind of the post-October 7th wars, in a way. Do you think that is the right way to look at everything that's happened in the Middle East over the past three years, culminating this enormous war with Iran?
44:05Or are we perhaps putting a bit too much emphasis on an event that was admittedly horrific, tragic, and in every possible way? Have we perhaps kind of discounted other factors? I think that October 7 was the spark, you know. I think that what was different and so shocking about October 7 was not that it was simply a surprise military attack, you know, like the Yom Kippur War of 50 years previously, but that it was a military attack that immediately spiraled into a bestial pogrom. You know, it was really vile what happened. I suspect much of it was not even planned by Sinwar himself. It was vile what happened. I suspect much of it was not even planned by Sinhwar himself. It was vile, what happened. Unarmed people slaughtered, kids slaughtered at a music festival,
45:13mothers and children killed in their homes on kibbutzes. A lot of the carnage created by civilians and not necessarily Hamas soldiers. It was a proper bestial program in which the very worst of humanity displayed itself. And that created this incredible reaction within Israel. I mean, Israel was traumatized. It's a tiny country. It thought itself militarily secure. And then this happened, and for a Jewish nation, it correctly brought back the horrors, not just of the Shoah during the Second World War, but, you know, the pogroms that had been going on for hundreds of years before to 1290 in the UK, for God's sake. So it brought all of that back in it, and it created, against the very firm and
46:15explicit advice of Biden, it created an appetite for revenge. And Netanyahu took that revenge. That's the way he took the country. And the revenge was equally violent and horrific, particularly in the months of sort of November, December that year, when the number of people dying in bombing in Gaza was at its peak. And 70 odd thousand people have been killed, many of them civilians and there are allegations of war crimes there are allegations of genocide and we have all the rest of it that is what has sparked the broader conflict you do put it in that context that is for you the starting point in the context. in turn caused the Iranians to hit Israel directly with missiles for the first time,
47:27rather than acting through their proxies. It's the context in which the war in Lebanon exploded with Hezbollah. You know, it's the context in which the Houthis have started striking both Israel and Saudi Arabia. So yeah, absolutely. I see that as the flashpoint. Were the tensions there anyway? Yes, there were. You know, I mean, Iran has been a problem for a long, long time. In Trump's first term, he, you know, assassinated one of its great warlords who had been terrorizing Israel and the US. So there were tensions there. But no, I mean, the Sinwa-inspired attack on October 7, I see as the flashpoint. And I'm sure history will record it as such. Henry, you've been reporting from Jerusalem for...
48:18How long have you actually been doing the Israel job now? About one and three-quarter years. I sound like a toddler, don't I? I'm not one and a half. I about one and three quarter years. I sound like a toddler, don't I? I'm not one and three quarters. It feels like that. It feels like every month is a victory. Yeah. So, um, early 2025. So I came out in the middle of that big ceasefire and hostage, hostage prisoner exchange when we thought maybe that that would be the end of the war. Uh, and every weekend or every other weekend we had those memorable uh prisoner hostage releases and and in very various degrees of um humiliation they were put through before they were able to walk free and then of course
48:56the war started again in early march and um and it took on a different character after that and it was in in many ways i think that was the worst period after that because you had the hunger, you had the aid issues and all of that. I mean, I think I agree with Paul that I think the attack of October 7th was the trigger point. But I think a lot of the energy that has characterized the last few years was building anyway and in various different spheres and and the war brought it fast forwarded all of that so i think you know there was a rising hatred of israel in many parts of the world there was a rising anti-semitism anyway and when the war started that it just immediately spilled forward to write tens of thousands of people on the streets,
49:45a lot of them carrying anti-Semitic slogans, a lot of them openly supporting Hamas, a lot of them also, by the way, calling for a ceasefire because they didn't want civilian casualties. But I mean, no question about the Israel hatred and the anti-Semitism that this has brought to the surface. That was growing, in my opinion. That was growing already. If you look at some of the things which have characterized the internal Israeli situation since October the 7th, they've been growing for decades. The rise of the religious right, in a sense, as personified in the settler movement, the backlash to what Yitzhak Rabin achieved in the 90s with the oslo accords with the with the the foundation stones of a real peace process with the palestinians the
50:33um which obviously started unraveling when he was assassinated he was assassinated by people by one person but who adhered to a philosophy which is now the philosophy of the interior minister, Itmar Ben-Gavir of Israel. That's been a systematic reaction, a planned reaction, to increase the influence of the religious right in Israeli life. And that was building anyway. And that's obviously been brought forward by, given bigger license by the war that started on October 7th. The ambitions of Turkey was building anyway, and they obviously took their chance in Syria with Jolani, with Ashura, with the instability that was to an extent triggered from the October 7th wars. It fed on, it was triggered by October the 7th. Everything was triggered by that. But you have to ask,
51:25October the 7th was a pogrom, no doubt about it. It was a horrendous and huge anti-Semitic pogrom, a slaughter of Jews. But it was also, and this comes from the Israelis, this comes from the Israeli system, it was also a classic act of terrorism in the sense that actually there was a political goal beyond the bloodshed, beyond the immediate slaughter on the day, which was to isolate Israel. And if you look three years on, Israel really, they've lost most of Europe. They've lost the Democrat Party and they've lost half the Republican Party. So is it legitimate to ask whether Sinwa won? You know, I have wondered about that question. Is that giving him too much credit? I i mean it reminds me of the the whole thing about you know some bin laden wanted to
52:09lure america into an unwinnable war in the middle east and most of the the scholarship actually says if you read bin laden's writings that he thought they would leave the middle east that was the point yes are we are we giving sinwa a bit too much credit here for i agree with you i think it is i think it is he's only one in the sense that bin laden won which is to say they didn't win if i'm optimistic when i'm optimistic about uh israel and and and the region you know last time i was there a couple of weeks ago i felt that the that the spell of trauma and anger had been broken. There was a celebration of democracy with huge numbers going out to vote. I also feel that on the Palestinian side,
52:52that the spell of the myth of violence resistance delivering good has also broken. And I mean, Henry and I talked to a mutual Palestinian acquaintance. It was much more pragmatic than you might have thought. I talked to a lot of Arab Israelis as part of my reporting there. Much more pragmatic than you'd think. And I think that people now are looking for political solutions, both in Israel and, you know, the much broader Palestinian community. Maybe I'm being naive, a silly white boy, as some Israelis call me. But I do think that if the politics can be stabilized and diplomacy given a chance, I think there is a chance to start at least rebuilding, if not building a proper peace process henry we interrupted you as you were about to no you know well annoyingly paul
53:52started saying things that i agree with but i'll just go back to i'll go i'll go back to the bit i disagree with in the sense that i'm not saying sin i'm not saying that sinwa has won by the way i think that israel is more durable and israel's um appeal to the western world will turn out to be more durable it's particularly you know things are bad at the moment because there's been a horribly bloody war but i i wouldn't i don't think you can compare hamas and al-qaeda too closely i mean hamas you know it's it's it's firmly rooted in the muslim brotherhood philosophy they do things for a reason. It's very, very twisted ideology, but they are rooted in a certain geographical location. They do things for a reason.
54:32I think al-Qaeda was much more sort of agents of chaos, just general holy war. But, you know, hey, look, who knows? But I agree partially with Paul that there is a feeling of optimism here. I agree with what he said about the Palestinian feeling. I think that there is, I mean, since Arafat really let them down so badly 20, 25 years ago, I think a new generation has grown up and they talk about resistance a lot less now. They just want human rights, self-determination, but there's much less feeling that they want to go forward living in this space without the Jews here. So that's positive, I think. You're talking about integration, right? Yeah, a lot of them do. A lot of them do. I wouldn't underestimate
55:19the degree of hatred that's still there for the Israelis among sections of Palestinian society for all sorts of reasons. But I think things are improving there. On the Israeli side, there is, I would say, a cautious feeling of optimism. But the country's moved to the right a lot. But I think Eisenkot could be a better prime minister than he might be a campaigner. And if he gets in and starts to govern normally for a bit then that that could be the start of um of israel's thawing with with with the west henry thank you so much um gentlemen we've already had the um piece of the producer in my ear at least once but i'm going to defy him just once we can only defy him once okay in terms of that and i
55:59wanted to finish off with questions about um look this has kind of been slightly the raison d'etre was it was a showcase for telegraph journalism to a degree and i'm wondering what the past three years have told you about are the practice of war reporting the practice of of international reporting um whether you're filled with gloom and doom about whether we can ever get the job done or whether it's the same as this ever has what's, can I start with you? Because you've been being a foreign correspondent out there, living and breathing this for the past couple of years. Any thoughts about the future of our trade? I think Israel shows, ironically, just how you have to be there. You really have to be there and to an extent immersed in the societies you're talking about. I mean,
56:50Israel, if you take the kind of the purest form of the stereotype of foreign reporting, which is that, you know, we've heard there's a war in deepest, darkest somewhere, would you go and check it out and report to us and tell us what's going on? Israel's kind of the complete opposite of that, because everyone already thinks they know what's going on, right? Everyone thinks they're completely on top of things before you get out here so you you come with a massive set of targets on your back um and a bunch of people who think they know it all already um because both sides are such effective communicators both israel and also i'm not drawing a moral i'm not i'm not drawing a moral equivalence but both israel and radical
57:25palestinians and their supporters i think actually the moderate palestinians are very bad communicators but actually you really you come here and you realize how much of that is wrong and how you just have to be here to um understand that and um so i would hope it's an argument for continuing to shove a bit of wonga towards the foreign desk for the foreseeable future. and the facts on the ground. I mean, it's just incredible. You know, on social media, which sort of dominates discourse or has been allowed to dominate discourse in this area, you know, you're either an extreme Zionist or an extreme Palestinian voice. You know, in Israel itself, there's this immense diversity of voices, the same in the West Bank.
58:24People say stuff in Israel that they would be lynched for on social media. Have we failed our readers and listeners then since that, all of that narrative, all that social media stuff, are we just not cutting through? Well, I'm hoping that Telegraph readers, they're subscribing to our paper, and I'm hoping they're getting the right information. But for people who take their news from social media, I mean, they're living in another world, a completely different world. And this applies to people in Israel. I mean, there's hardly anyone in Israel who doesn't believe that London is about to fall to the Muslim hordes. I mean, really, there's hardly anyone. It's completely out of control. And that's because
59:06of this huge social media campaign. I've been at air bases in Israel, where the guards at the gate, while bombs are coming over from Iran, are saying, how do you survive in London? It's so dangerous. No, I know. I mean, it was like something out of a comedy, except it was so bleak. One of my enduring memories of this place whatever happens from between now and i when i leave will be i was on the outskirts of gaza just by the fence about to go in this was during the war with the idf for one of those one of those trips into into the the war zone and chatting to a couple of soldiers and behind them looking into gaza behind them was the devastation not a single building standing, not a single tree alive,
59:47all of that, as we all know too well. And they said, where are you from? And I said, London. And they looked at me, they're like, oh God, sorry about that. I was like, what? You know, because as Paul said, the propaganda is so bad. But I think we do cut but i think we do cut through and a lot a lot of the sort of more controversial pieces i've done i've looked down in the comments and we've had loyal readers of ours who are quite angry at certain times being like what no no that's not right that's not right i know what's happening here and you've got it wrong and then you'll have other readers saying well actually this is where you come to find out what's going on there and he's he's sourced it properly and
1:00:28he's quoted people who were there and stuff and so you know it's i think we do cut through but it's uh it's a hell of a shouting match paul and henry thank you so much for your for your sterling efforts on covering the israel beat um which you will continue to do even without this podcast well thanks for the amazing podcast it's brilliant it. It's been great. Fantastic. It's been an absolute pleasure working with you. To our listeners, I hope you enjoyed all that. Henry and Paul are still around. Telegraph Towers, you'll find them on the website. There will still be proper objective foreign reporting being put out there. With that, I'm going to say we will be back tomorrow for more Iran the Latest.
1:01:03Don't miss that one either. Until then, that was Iran the Latest. Goodbye. Iran the Latest is an original podcast from The Telegraph. It was previously Battle Lines, which was created by David Knowles. It's hosted by me, Roland Oliphant, Venetia Rainey and Sophia Yan. Every episode featuring us in the studio, plus maps, battlefield footage and pictures of events we discuss is now on YouTube. Head over to our channel and subscribe to our playlist. You can find a link in the show notes. If you appreciated this podcast, please consider following around the latest on your preferred podcast app and leave us a review. For more from our foreign correspondents on the ground, sign up to our daily newsletter,
1:01:44Cables, via our website or listen to our sister podcast, Ukraine, the latest. We're still on the same email address, battlelines at telegraph.co.uk, and we read every message you send. Or contact us on X, you can find our handles in the show notes. The producers are Peter Shevlin and Max Bauer. Research and socials by Anna Hindmarsh. The executive producer is Venetia Rainey. T'was many nights before Christmas, and one woman knew she needed a Christmas tree. So to Wayfair, she flew, finding just the right one. And for years, it will last. Wayfair shipping was free and remarkably fast. What's this? Garland, a wreath, essentials to host. Good thing she celebrates way longer than most. As her cart filled with magic and decor from the heart.
1:02:42Merry Christmas to all. Get your Wayfair head start. For holiday decor you can count on year. Get your Wayfair head start. For holiday decor you can count on year after year, Wayfair delivers. Acast powers the world's best podcasts. Here's a show we recommend. I'm Robert Mace. I'm Derek Klassen. I'm Dave Hellman. And this is The Athletic Football Show. Are you the sort of NFL fan who wants to dig deep into the X's and O's? Who has their team's depth chart memorized? Who wants to break down the salary cap implications of every signing and trade? Well, then the Athletic Football Show is for you. From training camp in the summer through the ups and downs of the regular season, all the way to the Super Bowl, we're on top of everything that happens on the field.
1:03:19When the games end, we keep things rolling with our in-depth coverage of the scouting combine, free agency, and the NFL draft. And hey, speaking of the draft, be sure to catch Building the Beast with myself and the athletics draft expert, Dane Brugler, right here on the Athletic Football Show every week. We follow the draft cycle year round, giving you the scout's edge long before any draft prospect enters a green room. We bring you upwards of 300 episodes per year and produce original video content debuting daily on our YouTube channel. So if you consider the phrase football sicko a term of endearment, you want to be right here with us on The Athletic Football Show. Find The Athletic Football Show on YouTube,
1:03:54social media, and wherever you listen to your podcasts. The Athletic Football Show, the podcast by football diehards for football diehards. Acast helps creators launch, grow, and monetize their podcasts everywhere. Acast.com.