Bulwark Takes · · Transcript & summary by WhipScribe
Two Bulwark commentators piece together a fast-moving NVIDIA scandal and the Trump-circle fallout, with the Mississippi Senate race added on top.
Tap a chapter to play it from that moment in the show's own player; the transcript opens there too.
“whether U.S. politics under Donald Trump can sustain interest in a single scandal like this” Andrew Egger · at 19:10 — ▶ hear it from here
“He's an impressive person, it seems to me.” Bill Kristol · at 45:10 — ▶ hear it from here
The episode centers on NVIDIA's abrupt leadership change. Hosts Andrew Egger and Bill Kristol describe Jensen Huang's resignation as president and CEO, with CFO Colette Kress named interim CEO, after a New York Times report tied him to an affair with a woman linked to a suspected Chinese spy. They argue that a board would not push out a founder-CEO over affairs alone, so the company's compliance problems on export controls likely run deeper, and they describe reporting that Trump overruled national security staff to bring Huang on a May trip to China.
The discussion then widens to the administration. Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick faces scrutiny over reportedly stalled export-control work on the Megaspeed company, and Axios reported a tense Situation Room clash with the Treasury Secretary. Kristol compares the potential fallout to Iran-Contra, though he doubts a special counsel will be appointed, and both expect congressional document demands. They also treat the Justice Department's warnings to members of Congress as an escalation.
The last stretch covers Iran, where a Trump post called for a Vance-led corruption probe while signaling no deal, and the midterm results. Egger and Kristol say a Democratic House wave weakens Trump's leverage, and they praise Scott Colom's Mississippi Senate win as a sign that the state's count was handled professionally.
Bill Kristol said that in 2026 reporting, Donald Trump overruled what must have been a National Security Council recommendation to keep NVIDIA CEO Jensen Huang off the May trip to China. He called the degree of closeness between Trump and Huang remarkable, and said ignoring a memo like that would have been unthinkable for a president or vice president.
“Trump nonetheless overrules what must have been a National Security Council recommendation not to have Jensen Huang on the trip to China in May.”Bill Kristol · 3:03
Andrew Egger asked whether U.S. politics under Donald Trump can keep attention on a single scandal. He noted that over the past 18 to 20 months each new controversy has tended to crowd out the last, and said the NVIDIA affair could be different because Democrats have ways to keep it in the news.
“whether U.S. politics under Donald Trump can sustain interest in a single scandal like this”Andrew Egger · 19:10
Bill Kristol said he hardly believes Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick will survive the NVIDIA scandal much longer. He argued that Lutnick is not a random cabinet secretary, since he and Trump are old friends, so it is inconceivable that Lutnick acted on the export-control investigations without talking to Trump.
“I hardly believe Lutnick survives this for very much longer.”Bill Kristol · 13:33
Bill Kristol said Iran-Contra blew up largely because the Justice Department appointed a special counsel, which he thinks is unlikely to happen in the NVIDIA case. He said he expects congressional investigations instead, and that the White House Counsel's Office was very aggressive in shutting down talk among witnesses during Iran-Contra.
“one thing that really made Iran-Contra blow up was there was the Justice Department appointed a special counsel.”Bill Kristol · 15:14
Bill Kristol praised Scott Colom's Mississippi Senate campaign as a moving story and an excellent race against Cindy Hyde-Smith. He noted that Mississippi had not elected a Black statewide official since Reconstruction, and that Espy had won 44% of the vote in the state a couple of years earlier.
“He's an impressive person, it seems to me.”Bill Kristol · 45:10
Bill Kristol argues that Jensen Huang's exit from NVIDIA is a serious national security scandal, not just a personal one, because Trump overruled a national security memo and Commerce officials reportedly stalled export-control enforcement. He expects congressional investigations and document demands to reveal much more, and says the political balance has shifted against Trump.
Bill Kristol said the NVIDIA board would not have pushed out a founder who ran the company for about 30 years over one or two affairs, even with a subordinate. He suspects the board knows much more, including whether a customer company linked to Alice Wong was used as a route for getting chips to China. He expects more to come out about NVIDIA's compliance with export controls.
Bill Kristol said he doubts Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick will survive much longer. He cited Axios reporting that Treasury Secretary Scott Besant confronted Lutnick in a White House meeting over the failure to place NVIDIA client Megaspeed on a list of companies that pose national security concerns. Kristol argued Lutnick would not have done any of this without talking to Trump, since the two go back a long way.
Bill Kristol said Iran-Contra grew huge partly because the Justice Department appointed a special counsel, which he thinks is unlikely here. He expects congressional investigations instead, probably led by the intelligence committees, with Jim Himes in the House and Mark Warner in the Senate taking the lead once Democrats control those panels. He also expects document preservation letters demanding records of communications between the White House and NVIDIA, which has no executive privilege to invoke.
Andrew Egger and Bill Kristol said Trump has no clear Iran plan and appears to hope the issue fades from the news. They noted the Strait of Hormuz is more open than it was six months ago, though the economics are still worse than before the conflict. They read Trump's post on Vance as a passive-aggressive signal, since Vance had pushed for a negotiated settlement and had publicly argued the war should end.
Bill Kristol called Scott Colom's Mississippi Senate win a moving story and said he is an impressive politician who ran an excellent campaign. He noted that Mississippi had not elected a Black statewide official since Reconstruction, and that Colom won a state where Democrat Mike Espy had earned 44% of the vote a few years earlier. Kristol also praised Cindy Hyde-Smith for conceding gracefully and said the count was conducted professionally.
Our own transcript of the public episode, with a timestamp about every 90 seconds. Tap a timestamp to play the episode from there in the show's own player; the link button on a paragraph copies a link that opens this page there.
0:00Hello, everybody. Welcome to Morning Shots Live with me, Andrew Egger and Bill Kristol of The Bulwark. We write the Morning Shots newsletter. Usually we come to you on Tuesday. This week, it was decided by the powers that be that we ought to pull Ben Parker and Mark Hertling over on Tuesday because that was Hegseth impeachment day and he had a big press conference. So we had to let our foreign policy minds take a crack at it. We're all discombobulated now. It feels a little strange to go live on a Thursday. We'll see how it goes. It's a slightly different muscle memory. But good news is there's lots to talk about. We have real breaking news right out of the tech space and the White House. I mean, it's like every important story that's going on at once,
0:38the economy and AI and Donald Trump's proximity to billionaires. NVIDIA, still the most valuable company in the world, or was at one recent point the most valuable company in the world. Their stock's been going a little crazy recently. There has been a major scandal, major scandal, Jensen Wang of the CEO, longtime CEO, embroiled in this personal scandal with a woman, had an affair with a woman at an NVIDIA customer company who turns out, likely, possibly, reportedly, to have been some sort of Chinese spy. Bill, you have been following this story like crazy. And just this morning, we got the breaking news that Wang is out at NVIDIA. The longtime visionary. I mean, this is sort of like Apple.
1:19If Steve Jobs had gotten into some kind of scandal and they had kicked him to the curb, he is gone. He's been fired. I'll just read from the NVIDIA statement for a minute. Board of Directors announced today that Jensen Huang has resigned as president, chief executive officer, and a member of the board, effective immediately. Colette Kress, current executive vice president, chief financial officer of NVIDIA, has agreed to serve as interim CEO. They're doing a permanent chief executive officer search. They're going to consider internal and external candidates. The statement continues, Jensen's contributions to NVIDIA are profound. You can say that again. NVIDIA is one of the most consequential technology
1:53companies in the world. The board and the company thank Jensen for his immeasurable contributions to the company and the industry. I mean, this is a fall from grace. Like, when did we get the first piece of reporting about this? Like a week ago or something? I mean, this is a fall from grace. Like, when did we get the first piece of reporting about this? Like a week ago or something? I mean, this really has accelerated at extraordinary pace. So, Bill, can you kind of just talk us through what where we're at with this story? And then we'll turn to the obvious political implications here. Yeah, I mean, there's been scattered reporting about both his personal life and about problems with their compliance and noncompliance with export controls and the law,
2:26of course, the lobbying of Trump. It's been quite public and wanted to sell more stuff to China and all that stuff. There's a lot of stuff, but the Times sort of put it all together over the weekend. I think Saturday was when they put out their big story. And I will say that we report in Tuesday and Wednesday in Morning Shots. I wrote little items just saying, I've seen these scandals before. This feels to me like a very big one. It's got everything in it. It's got Trump clearly, Trump, I mean, think of, and the key thing in the Times reporting was the National Security Council memo, apparently signed by Rubio as National Security Advisor, warning that Jensen Huang had been, was having an affair basically with someone who had been,
3:03was a Chinese spy or had been recruited to be a Chinese spy or a Chinese asset, and therefore was deeply compromised. Trump knew about this. Trump nonetheless overrules what must have been a National Security Council recommendation not to have Jensen Huang on the trip to China in May. He has all these other tech guys, remember this, and it was reported, where's Jensen Huang? He's the CEO of NVIDIA, kind of a huge player in this field. And Trump overrules the staff, invites him on the trip, is in very close contact with him for the next bunch of months, gives him an award. He's part of the AI team that advises Trump on policy. And he's always been a big Trump. He gives 20 million, I think 25 million to the
3:39ballroom or NVIDIA does or Huang does, I don't know. I mean, the degree of closeness between Trump and Huang and Trump's ignoring a memo. I mean, I did this, I don't know. I mean, the degree of closeness between Trump and Huang, and Trump's ignoring a memo. I mean, I did this, I was used to vice president, chief of staff, so I wasn't in a kind of huge policymaking role there in the George H. W. Bush administration. The idea that you would get a memo like that, be briefed on a memo like that as president or vice president, for that matter, and treat it as if, okay, business as usual, I'm going ahead with this meeting and with this bringing him to China and all the, you know, blessing that confers, so to speak, as being part of the president's entourage and the signals and
4:12sends to Xi Jinping, among others. I mean, it's really, so I was mind boggled just by that time story. That's why I wrote about it Tuesday, Wednesday. And so it has everything, the scandal, though. I mean, it's got a little sex it's got national security which makes it a serious scandal not a kind you know this the a lot of the graft uh is scandalous obviously the corruption but it's you know people paying off people for good deals here in the u.s and so forth it's not this is pretty this is national security it's ai it's very important national security trump's allegedly anti-china here he is not just being kind of neutral but basically favoring a policy that clearly helps China, trying to go blind. I do it. And we've got this massive company that I guess was sort of competing to be the largest market cap in the world. I believe it's not anymore since it's probably opening down, you know, 15% was the founder, as you say, like Steve Jobs at Apple, and ran it personally for 30 years, I think.
5:08And so the idea, the board did not dump him because he had one or two affairs, even an affair with a subordinate, which is frowned upon in corporate America. I don't know, like, do we think the board of Elon Musk's board is going to fire him for his various misbehavior? I mean, these guys are pretty, if the board, he is NVIDIA. And for the board to do this means there's a lot more there. Yes, this is not a Me Too story, right? Not at all. And it's not even a sexual, yeah, there's no evidence that he abused anyone. He just had these affairs, just, but I mean, but there's the degree to which the Alice Wong's company was a cutout for getting stuff to China that China shouldn't have, kind of a cutout almost really for Chinese intelligence, you might say.
5:51The other stuff that's now coming out, and this you have to, I'm not an expert on it at all, but you read stuff online by reputable people. And the degree to which there are all these questions about NVIDIA's compliance and noncompliance with export controls or finding ways to evade them if they're not actually just flat out breaking the law. The Lutnick connection, Lutnick at Commerce, the Secretary of Commerce, a great buddy of Trump, involved in all these shady business deals with Trump, stopping investigations at Commerce into this. The export controls guys at Commerce who are serious career people are like, hey, you know, this is bad. We have to stop this. This is what we do for a living. We do these, enforce these export controls to try to
6:28prevent China and others from having things they shouldn't have. And it goes up to the highest political levels of Commerce and Lutnick and his, one of his top aides, stop these investigations. So there's that internal administration side of it. And Lutnick's very close to Trump. I mean, I just think the, I think the board knows much more. We will know much more about what NVIDIA has been up to. And it's going to be way more than Huang behaving inappropriately as a CEO and having relationships with customers and subordinates. We're going to learn a lot more about the White House and what happened. Who really wrote the Rubio memo? What does the intelligence community think about it? And people like Rubio, he is Secretary of State. He's going to have to testify before Congress. And
7:08finally, I'll just, I've gone on too long. I mean, there will be serious congressional investigations at this point. I don't know if it's quite Iran-Contra. I don't know if we quite get a special committee. I don't know if we get a joint committee of the House and the Senate. The intelligence committees will want to take the lead, and they probably should at first, I guess. Jim Himes in the House, Mark Warner in the Senate, when the Democrats take the lead and they probably should at first i guess jim heim is in the house mark warner in the senate when the democrats take control but i've noticed that even the republicans and you've been following this probably a little this much more closely than
7:33i some of the republicans including pretty trump supportive ones are saying yikes i mean this is something we really do need to look into so yeah i think it's just a it's i did have the sense god knows where these scandals go. They're always hugely unanticipated things that happen. Different shoes drop that you didn't expect. Some things that you did expect don't happen. But I think this is a very big one. Yeah, let me just back up just for a minute and kind of, because you mentioned that this scandal has brought to light, it's given us some new explanatory power for one of the strange sort of cross currents in the Trump administration's AI policy and its China policy, which is that it's been weirdly soft on this one specific thing, which is exports of these chips from this one specific company, from NVIDIA in particular, because really this is – they're not the only processor of these GPUs that are powering the global AI boom, but they are by far the leading company in this field.
8:28And so their most advanced chips have been at the center of all of these export controls. Just to talk a little bit about that, I mean, to put that in context, the reason for all of this is because of this AI race that we are in with China, which is a humongous policy priority of the Trump administration, by the way, to win that. I mean, I mean, they have basically said it's so important that we win this race with China, that we are that we remain, you know, head and shoulders above them in the terms of the capability of the models that we have and that our companies control versus the capabilities that they have and that their companies control for all sorts of reasons related to, especially to cybersecurity and,
9:05and, and, you know, national security that touches the internet and touches computing in any way, which is all of it right now. And so it's, I mean, it's just, it is a key core priority so much so that, that, you know, the White House has said that it is willing to risk all of these other AI risks, you know, of super ofintelligence developing too fast and becoming too capable and, you know, causing all these economic harms and maybe even getting to the point where, you know, it's computers making decisions about whether people keep on living, you know, these sort of catastrophic sci-fi type scenarios. The Trump administration has said, we can't worry about all that because we can't slow down because we can't lose to China. Meanwhile, this has been one of, if not the core
9:48policy levers in making sure that China remains behind us in this race is the fact that by luck and by ingenuity and by all of these things, it's these American companies, not just that are producing the most capable AI models, but also that these different American companies, not just that are producing the most capable AI models, but also that these different American companies, and particularly NVIDIA, has been making by far the most advanced chips that are, you know, has wanted to keep those chips out of Chinese hands. And as it has been obvious for a while that a lot of them are getting over there anyway, like you say, because I now want to turn to the Commerce Department and the Lutnik angle
10:35in all of this, it just has not seemed like that's been a real priority in terms of them following through on that supposed policy priority of actually cracking the whip and making sure the chips aren't getting over there. And so let's turn to that now, because you mentioned it. You mentioned how Howard Lutnick has, you know, he's kind of the guy inside the White House other than Donald Trump himself who's holding the bag here. And let's turn real quick to this Axios report that came out yesterday. Our old colleague Mark Caputo has been all over this story. Last week, last Thursday in the Situation Room, Treasury Secretary Scott Besant actually confronted Lutnick in a White House meeting, basically saying, well, look, isn't it the case that you guys are supposed to have been cracking
11:18down specifically on this company, Megaspeed, this NVIDIA client that this Alice Wong is connected to. She ran that company. And Lutnick didn't really have a response to it. It says, I'll just read again here, Treasury Secretary Scott Besant confronted Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick over a failure to place NVIDIA company Megaspeed on a list of companies that pose national security concerns. The Commerce Department oversees the export of sensitive U.S. technologies, and Lutnick's actions, or lack thereof, are increasingly under scrutiny following revelations that NVIDIA CEO Jensen Wang had an affair with Megaspeed employee and suspected Chinese spy Alice Wong. So Lutnick, it's not just outside the White House.
12:01I mean, he has guys like Bassan who have never, never really liked him very much inside there, but it's very much knives out for him, even inside the building right now as the scandal heats up. Yeah, this is very interesting in kind of a couple of ways. They were having a meeting Thursday in the Situation Room. It's a little unclear why, except I suspect the reason was they knew the New York Times was working on this blockbuster. Obviously, the Times called people to get comments on it and so forth. And they were sort of, this was very much remember they had the meeting in the Situation Room before the Epstein files broke. And, you know, because they knew the journal piece was coming. I think it was Wall Street Journal piece in that case.
12:33That's like the main thing the Situation Room is used for now. It's like, man, there's this big story. Isn't that kind of amazing? So the Secretary of Treasury, so A, that's sort of interesting timing. B, how did, I'd ask Mark Caputo this. It's great that he got this scoop. How did he get it, Besson, so A, that's sort of interesting timing. B, I haven't asked Mark Caputo this. It's great that he got this scoop. How did he get it? Someone told him, right? I mean, someone who was in or talked to someone who was in the Situation Room and was reliable, presumably, so a pretty senior person, I should think, at some agency, maybe Treasury, I'm just guessing, since Besson comes out well from this,
13:01told Mark or someone else at the White House who has it in for a lot, but also maybe some people who are genuinely appalled by what's been happening. So the leaking, which we saw in the Times story, how does the Times know that Marco Rubio wrote a memo to senior officials that Trump would have been briefed on? That's not something that's widely distributed. They didn't send a copy. It wasn't like the signal gate where Jeffrey Goldberg gets on the thing by accident. The Times didn't get a copy by accident. So the leaking is serious, which is also a sign that they know it's a big scandal. People are beginning to get out and say, I did my best to stop this, right? I mean, if you're a best, you sort of care,
13:33maybe your reputation on Wall Street and stuff. So I think that part is pretty interesting. No, I think Lutnick, I bet, I hardly believe Lutnick survives this for very much longer. But again, it's inconceivable to me that Lutnick does any of this without, he has his own financial interests probably with Xi, but it's inconceivable to me he does any of it without talking to Trump. He and Trump are buddies. I mean, they go way back. This is not like a random cabinet secretary who, maybe Kristi Noem, if you want an example, who, you know, Trump, she's a Trump supporter, but she never was close to Trump really as so far as one could tell. And Trump got annoyed at her. Lutnick is a different kind of thing.
14:06So maybe he quits. On the other hand, does he then talk? The degree to which there's the ability to kind of, there are documents, there are conversations. I would be amazed if the Congress, if we don't get letters from, I guess, Heimson, Warner or someone, you know, what do they call it, document preservation letters, I think they call it, you know, the lawyers talk about, you know, we want all, you know, now they'll say exact, you know, what do they call it? Document preservation letters, I think they call it. You know, the lawyers talk about, you know, we want all, you know, now they'll say, you know, we want everything that has gone on between you guys in the White House and in the administration
14:32and dealing with outside companies, including NVIDIA, over the last X number of days, weeks, months, and you cannot destroy any of these documents. Now, the White House will just say executive privilege, I suppose. A little harder for that to be invoked if it's, you know, Lutnick talking to Huang. NVIDIA has no executive privilege. NVIDIA is going to be asked by Senator Warner and Representative Himes or whoever runs some select committee on this, well, we might need a record of your communication. So I think, again, the degree to which, this is where I do think may just have seen this fairly, not really up close, but, you know, from a somewhat, not quite a ringside seat, but not quite the nosebleed seats either, seeing Iran-Contra, seeing some of these
15:14other scandals, the degree to which once you start pulling on these strings, and there are documents, and there are prosecutors, or there is a serious congressional effort to look into it, the degree to which stuff starts to come out, none of us has even thought of. I don't know, there's some memo we don't know about. I'm making this up, you know, between Besset and Lutnick from five months. You know, who knows what there is, right? But there will be a ton of stuff, I think, that will come out. And I think that will be, and that's, I think that really will be an important part. I would say one thing that really made Iran-Contra blow up was there was the Justice Department appointed a special counsel. I think say one thing that really made Iran-Contra blow up was there was the Justice Department appointed a special counsel.
15:46I think that's unlikely in this case, unless you think Todd Blanchard's gonna, but they should, incidentally. This is a classic, classic special counsel situation, right? These guys can't investigate themselves. They won't do that. The Justice Department, I'm just gonna stipulate, won't do that. The White House Counsel's Office, which was very aggressive in Iran-Contra, they shut, they told people they couldn't talk to eachulate we'll do that. The White House Counsel's Office, which was very aggressive in Iran-Contra. They shut, they told people they couldn't talk to each other about what had happened. They kind of, they told the Counsel's Office not to deal with the people, Ali North and Poindexter,
16:13all the people who were kind of in the middle of it, because it had to be treated more like a legal situation where you had to treat them as possible defendants and you couldn't, you know, none of that's going to happen in this White House. But Congress will play a role. And I do wonder if some state attorneys general could step in and do some stuff. If laws are being broken, there are probably some state laws that are being broken as well as federal ones, and do some of the kind of legal work here too. So it's not going to quite be like Iran-Contra where you had a Justice Department in the old days that felt it should investigate malfeasance in the executive branch, even if it got into the White House.
16:45They set up a special commission. This all happened before you were born, Andrew, so you'll forgive me for going on about it. But I was... If I already knew, I wouldn't want to hear it as much. I had come to Washington in 85. I'll just give you my 30 seconds. I came to Washington in 85. I became chief of staff at the education department very beginning, late, very end of 85, beginning of 86. We had nothing to do with anything. We were at the education department. I knew nothing more than I was reading in the newspapers, believe me, about any of this stuff. But, you know, I was chief of staff of a cabinet agency, very invested in the success of the Reagan administration. The degree to which this thing just took over everyone's life,
17:17not mine, really, but everyone important, the life of everyone important in the White House and a lot of important people in the foreign policy world and in Congress in 87, with Iran-Contra, the hearings. I mean, you can't overstate how much it's not just a distraction, but it really becomes just a huge story going on and on and on. Yeah. Didn't Reagan ultimately survived? And of course, Gorbachev, he handled the Cold War a lot better than Trump's handling anything. So Reagan ends up okay, as it were, after the whole thing's over. But I just saw that kind of happening in real time. I remember a conversation I had after, I can't remember which one. Someone was, Ollie North probably was fired or poindexed to quit as National Security Advisor.
17:57There's a big, huge story at the time. It would be as if Rubio quit or something like, you know, in two weeks or four weeks. And I remember saying to someone who'd been around for a lot longer than I had, I guess that's kind of it, right? I mean, okay, that's, you know, that was rough. But I mean, I've probably seen the worst of it. And he was like, you have no idea. You don't know what this is. This is one shoe out of, you know, 37 shoes that are going to drop. And so I think there will be a lot happening over the next days, weeks and months. Yeah. I am really interested to see, because on the one hand, I feel like as much as we have talked about this story, we've only hit like a couple of the angles from which this is enormous. And we talked about the national
18:33security. We've talked about the politics and the economics of this are going to be remarkable too. I mean, the entire US economy is so over leveraged on the AI build out right now. And this company, NVIDIA, is right at the core. And, you know, it remains to be seen, you know, when one of these tech companies, when they get decapitated like this, they lose a leader, it can take a while for them to, it can be a real momentum-changing event. And the whole industry is looking a little bit rickety. You know, they're making a lot of money, but they're spending a lot more. And they want to spend so much more to build out, you know, the billions and billions and billions of dollars in infrastructure, you know, that's leveraged against possible future revenue
19:10sometime beyond that. And it all needs to keep happening or the economy crashes, right? So like, it's all very interesting and fraught in that direction as well. But just to go back to the politics of it for one minute, because there are two elements of what you just said there that I'm really interested in. One of which is, I'm just interested to see whether U.S. politics under Donald Trump can sustain interest in a single scandal like this, even an eye-poppingly large scandal like this one. That would cut against what we have mostly seen for the last two years, last 18 months of this administration, 20 months or so, which has been the opposite. Like no matter how big and impactful a scandal is, it just gets crowded out by the next one because there's a new one. You have to talk about the new one. And that'll be interesting. I mean,
19:54I just remember, you know, the serial fights that have gone down and the constant questions about how, you know, what the political implications of like the world's longest, America's longest ever government shutdown would be, you know, things like this that have just completely faded. But like you say, Democrats are going to have a lot of levers to keep this one in the news because they will have these ongoing investigations or the ongoing disclosures and things like this. It may more resemble, you know, the Epstein files scandal or something like that in that respect. That'll be interesting to see. The other thing that I'm interested in is the question of, you know, a guy like Lutnick who, who under ordinary circumstances
20:30would just look completely dead to rights here. Um, he, he, you know, there are a lot of Republicans, even China Hawks who, who have cause to, to cut him loose, at least even if they're not going to go after Trump. But the, the personal psychology question of how Trump himself will will deal with all of this. Right. Because it's not just that he is like a longtime friend of Letnick's himself. He's his his own sons have longtime business entanglements with Letnick's family, just like with Steve Witkoff's family. And that's ongoing. You know, they're out there making money right now in that respect. So so that's going to be interesting to watch. I mean, I don't know. Do you think like there's there's a way in which Trump's hand gets forced here or what do you think in that respect?
21:08Yeah, I don't know. And Trump's, you know, he's capable of hanging out to people he would think he would dump and he's capable of dumping people quite quickly when he thinks they're becoming big problems. You know, Kristi Noem, et cetera, Toppan Bondi. There's an awful lot of talk that Trump doesn't like firing people. I don't know. He seems to get rid of like his attorney general and his DHS secretary within about a month of each other, you know? So two footnotes to what you're saying. And I think those are both excellent points. I mean, it is AI. AI is already, as a political issue, I take your economic point too, but on the sort of politics of it, there are a lot of, you know, Democratic members who want to be sort of pro-business,
21:43but want to sort of be, you know, also responsive to their constituents. There are a lot of, you know, Democratic members who want to be sort of pro-business, but want to sort of be, you know, also responsive to their constituents. There are a lot of Republican members like that on data centers, on AI fears. How much does this, you know, put a big thumb in the scale on the side of, I mean, you're supposed to be like, could someone, a member of Congress, you know what, these companies are fine. You know, yeah, they could have consulted with us a little more here in Loudoun County before they built 5,000 data centers. But they're really doing a lot of good for the world. I don't know. Doesn't this raise some questions?
22:10I think it changes the political balance of power conceivably on AI and data centers. And that's, as we've said many times, actually, and you and I were both, but you especially were early on this six, nine months ago, I would say, even on the politics of this. I think it changes that political balance. And on Trump, I would say Trump at 37 percent and having lost a massive wave election is very different from Trump at 50 or 45 percent and still riding the wave of having won a presidential victory at a majority, a plurality of the popular vote and the republican congress in november of 24 so i think in that i think you're right to raise the question of whether this one has will be like the earlier scandals but one reason the earlier scandals were more
22:52went away quickly is there was a republican congress they weren't going to investigate it obviously justice was going to investigate it and trump still had this sort of you know the mandate of heaven he still had the people people's mandate as it were. And I think now there's none of that. There's a Democratic Congress coming in with the big majorities, and Trump is a weakened lame duck. And I do think that, you know, on the merits, these things should be investigated totally, obviously, you know, on the law and on the national security implications, and they will be to a large degree. But in terms of the political balance of power, I feel it's very different today, don't you? I feel this everywhere. You wrote about this also in warning shots in a different context.
23:28This morning, something we should come back to in the future. But, you know, the political balance of power is so different. This is a real wake up reminder of how why these elections make a difference. It's not just an X number of Democratic senators and representatives are going to show up in place of Republicans, you know, in two months. It's a whole political balance of power changes. And I think we'll see this with this scandal as well. Yeah, and I am struck too, just how much this whole scandal seems to play into some narrative themes that have been so useful for Democrats in particular the last couple of months. A lot of that sort of not really policy-focused necessarily energy, but that really populist just kind of like incl, that has driven this real shift of the country away
24:09from MAGA where people are just, again, it's not so much about policy exactly, but they're just so sick of this world that we live in where it's like the, the weird little peccadilloes and like, like psychological weaknesses of like six uber powerful guys who like run everything. That it's just like, nobody likes to live in this world. Nobody likes to live in a world where like, even if this, this like AI fight against China is this really important aim that we should be chasing. Like, I don't think a lot of people actually buy that argument outside of professional circles. But like, even if that were really true, and maybe it is true, it's insane. It's insane that that policy that we've like put in place to undercut China and like keep ourselves in in pole position in this important fight.
24:53Like that is that's going to be completely undermined by the fact that this one CEO over here has like this this like these extramarital affairs with Chinese spies, and he's really good friends with the president who ignores all of his own memos from his own national security and his own intelligence teams about the dangers here because he likes to pal around with the richest people in the world, and he likes the way that they treat him like he's the boss, and because the president has all these business entanglements with his longtime golfing buddies who he's put in government around him and they themselves have exposure financially to these markets. And so that's like its own like the idea that this is the way that everything works now, that like the entire government and the entire economy is constituted around these these forms of corruption and these people who are, who are bad and like their, their personal
25:46weaknesses are, are, are the holes through which all the stuff is getting out. That has been a useful argument for Democrats. That is, you know, uh, an enormous part of, other than just like the obvious, uh, the obvious grotesqueries of the particular Epstein scandal. That's kind of like the underlying energy of why the Epstein files were such a big deal. Um, other than just the fact that like there were these particular women who were sex trafficked, um, and, and, and these things like people just are sick of that kind of thing. And I think that that is yet another reason why this is a fruitful, a fruitful vein for, for Democrats to go pretty hard on here. Um, so totally, totally agree with that. And just, and I would say, incidentally,
26:23uh, and this is something again, you've reported on and we'll both will be, especially you maybe, how many Republicans are going to go into this thing? It's not like there's no Republican market for a kind of populist assault on the tech pros running our lives. I mean, just from the right, but also from a kind of more mainstream Republican point. how effective Ukraine can be in fighting Russia. Jensen Huang gets to decide what our export control policies should be to China. It's insane. And so there's a kind of, as you say, an anti-oligarch, anti-tech pro, anti-crotism side of this that certainly the Democrats are going to embrace, easy for them to embrace, and they should. But a lot of Republicans can embrace this too,
27:01I think, going forward. Mm-hmm, mm-hmm, yeah. Let's put a button on NVIDIA for now. We have to talk a little bit about Trump and Iran and J.D. Vance and fraud. We're going to do all that in a minute. First, let's throw to a quick ad. This episode is sponsored by Comiteer. So my day cannot begin without a good cup of coffee. I had a couple this morning, maybe three. And there's nothing worse than sitting down for your first cup of the day and it's just bitter. Burnt grounds or watery, weak brew. Now, I never have to worry about that. I have a great cup of coffee every morning thanks to Cometeer. Cometeer sources coffee from the best roasters in the world. It brews it to perfection and then it flash freezes it to
27:41lock in peak flavor and freshness. Comes on dry ice right to your door in recyclable aluminum capsules. All you have to do is melt it to make hot coffee, or you could do iced coffee, or you could do espresso-style drinks like lattes, and it's just in seconds. No machine or plastic brew path is required. These capsules are loved by coffee fanatics everywhere. Even the former president of Nespresso invested in Cometeer after just one sip. We have Cometeer right here in the office over there. And there's nothing easier than popping open a capsule and pouring over hot water. And for the younger folks on our team who are always craving iced coffee, psychopaths, those same capsules are perfect and have become a hit in the office.
28:23So get $20 off at cometier.com slash bulwark takes or use code bulwark takes. That's cometeer.com slash bulwark takes for $20 off. It's funny. My brother-in-law is like a giant cometeer guy. He like never drunk coffee before. And he like discovered that this summer and he's become a huge convert. And he's a bulwark content watcher too. So anytime Sam does those commentator ads, I always get like a text like, yeah, you go commentator, that sort of thing. Okay. Let's turn to Iran. Donald Trump, there's been a lot of speculation, you know, what's going to go on with Iran after the midterms? Is he going to be gloves off? And is he going to go over there and start bombing again? Or is he going to cut some kind of deal
29:04and get out of there? Well, we don't know for sure. We still don't know for sure. But we got a very strange and interesting truth social post on the topic from the president this morning, and I'm just going to read it off here. Trump starts off not even talking about Iran, by the way. I have asked Vice President Vance to focus his complete and total attention on the massive corruption and crime taking place in Democrat-run cities and states throughout the U.S. The blue states, such as Minnesota, California, Illinois, and many more, are all poorly run corrupt disasters. Billions of dollars is being stolen each and every month. Our budget could be quickly balanced with the correction of this large-scale criminal activity. Corruption is in the Democrat leadership's blood. We don't
29:43need a deal with Iran. Those days have long since passed. We've got their money, hundreds of billions of dollars, and we've got their straight. Thank you when it comes to Iran from here on out? Is he just gonna just be cool with the status quo and we're just gonna leave it at that and things are just gonna be more expensive from now on? Or I mean, I don't even know what to prognosticate about this statement, really. So one thing about it, just before we get to Iran for a second, I mean, it's such a passive aggressive attack on Vance, I think. I mean, Vance, of course, criticized, made clear on Wednesday, the day after the election, that he was against basically the Iran war and thought, and then Trump has said, well, I don't disagree with some of what Vance is saying
30:33about that we've paid a price for it politically, but he should have said, should have added that it was the right thing to do. And Hegsteth went out of his way to say that, didn't he, at his press conference, sucking up to Trump on Tuesday. And so clearly there's a bit of a, JVL had a good thing on this yesterday too, there's a little bit of a Vance Trump thing going on. And I feel like this is a wonderfully kind of Trumpy, but not unclever in a way. Two totally unrelated things, as you say, not even like a transition. The first part is assigning Vance meaninglessly to look into corruption and crime in democratic systems. I mean, this is like the most stable, most routine Republican talking point.
31:05Everyone's looking into democratic crime. Everyone's going on about democratic crime and corruption and everywhere they can find some of it where there's a little bit sometimes and where there often isn't really. And the idea that this is going to be good for a real thing that Vance is going to make progress on, how? It's ridiculous. I mean, at the Justice Department, we could look into this. Todd Blanchard's not inattentive to it. Anyway, the whole thing's ridiculous. So I feel like it's ridiculous. I mean, at the Justice Department, we could look into this. Todd Blanchard's not inattentive to it. Anyway, the whole thing's ridiculous. So I feel like it's a passive-aggressive way of saying to Vance,
31:30go look into this stuff and go scream some more about what's happening in Minnesota. Meanwhile, Iran, wasn't Vance supposed to be like, he did actual negotiations with Iran, right? This was kind of his baby. Like he was going to find a negotiated settlement. And Trump's just saying, forget that. You're out of it on iran and then i think in terms of so that's interesting uh yeah the trump fans relationship i i is worse i suspect than we think anyway um on iran i just think yeah trump's is gonna do nothing hope it dies down hope someone privately can tell the iranians don't blow up any more too many more ships in the Strait. Let the stuff go through. People will bribe the Iranians. They'll bribe the Houthis.
32:09Oil will settle at some price that's higher than it was, but not wildly insane. Gas prices will come down a bit. And Trump hopes it just fades out of the news. I think that whether the Iranians let him do this, whether the world lets him do this, whether events don't happen, God knows. But I don't know. Don't you think that's kind of his view of what happens over the next six, nine months? I mean, just kind of fades away, you know? Yeah. I mean, that's been his hope, right? He's kind of, he's tried the one thing and he's tried the other thing and they've both kind of blown up in his face. He doesn't think that prosecuting the war more aggressively will play to his benefit. And he doesn't think that, that, you know, a real thinking a real deal will
32:44play to his benefit either. And so, yeah, I think he's just kind of crossing his fingers and hoping, hoping that, I mean, I guess the, the, the one, um, good thing for him is that it is true that the Strait of Hormuz is more open now than it was six months ago. You know, it's, uh, it's, it's operationally, you know, the United States controls it better. Uh, Iran is, is letting more traffic through, you know, kind of by necessity because they just they don't quite have the capacity to really lock it down the way that they used to. But that is still a horrible status quo, economically speaking, relative to, you know, the pre-existing one where traffic just went came and went through there, you know, reasonably
33:23and at will as an international waterway government, international law. Um, the, the thing you said about, about kicking Vance's approach to the curb, that seems, I had not thought of it in quite those terms, but actually, yes, that seems, that seems like one very, very important takeaway from this. Um, I was trying to find, uh, that, that manifesto that Vance posted, uh, on, on, on, uh, Twitter the day after the election and the Twitter search function has gotten so bad I couldn't pull it up just now. But that was basically what he said, right? I mean, Vance was basically saying we need now to bring a real end, like a genuine punctuation mark end to this war so that we can turn back to other things.
34:00Trump's rhetoric, too, has relied on that, though, is the strange thing. I mean, Trump has been saying forever, you know, all the prices are going to come down like a rock the second this thing's over. And it's not over now. So like I it's just I don't know. Part of this is that that Trump's own thinking and we've seen this over and over again since the election is not six steps ahead. I mean, he's very muddled on a lot of these things. He's doing a lot of on the one hand, on the other hand, and just sort of getting stuck in the middle of these various things. And he is taking over more and more of the actual sort of policy decision making in the White House itself with the departure of Susie Wiles and the promotion of, you know, an even more sort of
34:40sycophantic yes man in Stephen Miller. So part of it might just be that Trump himself doesn't exactly know what he wants to do here. But I do think, you know, there's one sense in which this is just him kicking Vance out into the territories, out to the sticks. You know, he doesn't get to go to Pakistan and negotiate, you know, world shaping global deals anymore. He has to go to, I don't know, Omahabraska or las vegas or or uh i guess san antonio maybe now austin is a state now maybe they'll texas is a blue state now maybe there's a there's there's fraud to be found in austin um but but uh at the same time this certainly does signal at least a psychological turn from the president back into more attacking, right? More,
35:26more war on, on team blue. Whereas just a few days ago, he, he was at least singing an opposite tune talking about like, well, you know, maybe the Democrats will get in here and we'll strike some deals and it'll all be cool. And, and we'll have a lot of fun together. So, I mean, maybe at least psychologically, there is, there's a new turn from the president as far as the domestic agenda is concerned. Oh, I think very much so. And I would say whatever his psychology is, he's capable of signaling two or three things at once. The actual Justice Department stuff over the last few days has been pretty crazily prosecutorial and adversarial. And the attempt to now go after Warren members of Congress that are not allowed to issue oversight because they could be prosecuted.
36:02That insane DOJ memo and then the various couple of U.S. attorneys writing letters. That's a fantastic exchange between the U.S. attorney, I think, for Connecticut and Senator Blumenthal. Blumenthal has a very good response. I mean, assault on Congress's investigative powers, which I don't think even all Republicans are quite. And that's beyond what they said in the first two years. So anyway, just to back up, can you just lay out for people? Because people might have missed this story. And you're right. It is like a real escalation on the part of the Justice Department. Can you just kind of walk through what these letters entailed and why they're so extraordinary? Yeah, I don't. I mean, there's so much else going on. But no, basically warnings from very senior people of justice to on paper in letters to members of Congress to be careful when you do these investigations.
36:50Because, you know, there are criminal law statutes that could apply if you are going beyond what is a proper level, whatever that is. And I guess I don't know what imputing people's reputations. It's unclear what what criminal statutes would apply, but i guess they're always vague ones that you could invent they've they've they've indicted a lot of other people on vague statutes or on miss you know misused statutes to indict people the idea of threatening congress directly though for what is a core constitutional function of congress i'd say even conservative you know types lawyers and stuff online are like what is it what are they doing here uh and then there's this as i said not just not just sent justice, main justice,
37:27but also these U.S. attorneys were given a pep talk by, I think maybe the number two or three person at justice about, you got to be on the war footing. And the war turns out to be against Democrats everywhere, of course, but also Democrats in Congress, really. The job of the U.S. attorneys to be on a war footing against duly elected senators and representatives. I mean, so I think I do think and Miller being there, of course. So the Miller vote Blanche nexus. Is that probably the key? I guess we'd say maybe in domestic policy now. All, you know, super loyal to Trump, all super aggressive and fighting Democrats and calling them terrorists and so forth. I wouldn't be surprised to see a little more of that stuff coming up too.
38:05The, you know, this interest group is a terrorist group. This, this foundation, this, you know, this civil rights organization. So I think that, yes, I think that will be the direction they go. So whatever Trump says about working with Dems, and he could sign some legislation that, I don't know, increases the minimum wage. Where does Trump care about any of that stuff? You know, if it thinks it looks good politically. But I think that, yes, the Miller vote, Blanche Nexus will lead to an attempt to get back away from the Middle East, certainly, and maybe from the world to the attack on Democrats. And then maybe insofar as Trump's imperial ambitions need to be satisfied, obviously part of that is the arch
38:41and the ballroom and all that stuff, which Trump does seem to be interested in, incidentally, still very much so. But also, I don't know, Greenland, Cuba, God knows what they could do there in three or six months. So it's not I don't think it's going to be a kinder and gentler Trump. I do think in that respect, we're not going to it's going to but it's going to not be focused, I suspect. It's going to be focused on Democrats more than on Iran. Yeah. Yeah. Do you think I'm wrong? And this is the kind of thing that I sort of hesitate to say because it could look very stupid in a few months here. But like, I hear all that talk of the Justice Department gearing up to go after congressional Democrats in this way,
39:15you know, this just real open, swaggering mob boss sort of thing. And I feel differently about it than I would have felt about that kind of thing a year ago. I almost feel like, like bring it on, kind of. I mean, I just think like a year ago, they had so much more actual power. Like they just had power everywhere. They had the seeming mandate of heaven, like you said. I mean, they had just been elected, didn't win the popular or didn't get 50% of the popular vote, didn't get a majority, but did win the popular vote. And it just felt so dangerous. I mean, like they were going to transgress all these norms and maybe it would work. Maybe it would really cow people and cow the opposition. And the legal retribution stuff has been so toothless in the end. Like they've tried so
39:54hard and they've fallen on their faces so many times. And it's so openly corrupt and people hate it so much that it just seems like if this is the strategy that the president is determined to pursue and that guys that guys like why am I blanking Blanche Blanche at the DOJ are determined to go along of thing, he's just setting himself up for yet another gigantic humiliation in 2028, which could really lead to like a generational power shift when it comes to that second set of elections, you know, enshrining a second class of Democratic senators for a six-year term in a lot of crazy places. I'm not saying that's guaranteed or anything like that, but it just seems like it augers the kind of back half, back nine for Trump 2.0 that isn't learning
40:55any of the lessons and that isn't making any kind of electoral triangulations. And that could just as easily wind up back in this same situation as we just saw in the midterms last week. No, I think that's well said. And I think that's an important point. And I would just add that the private sector, which the intimidation worked pretty well with them, I would say. And part of the intimidation was we go after anyone. We don't, you know, big business, small business, politicians. We don't, you don't want to get on the wrong side of us. That did have a big effect in the first year, year and a half, obviously. And Mark Zuckerberg and a million first year, year and a half, obviously. And Mark Zuckerberg and a million other people,
41:29big and small, and throughout the administration, and everyone cut deals and all this. I feel like they're trying, Trump wants to maintain that. He wants to literally maintain it in the sense of keeping the money flowing. But he also wants to maintain it for terms of his overall political power. The private sector is not a trivial part of that. And I don't know, if they look at this and think it is work. If it seems to work out three, six months from now, the way you're saying, and I think it could well, looks ineffectual, looks like bluster. I think the recalculating that's going on among in corporate America, law firm America, all parts of civil society America, the recalculating about do we need to really continue to cater this to this guy or to this team or to this party so much?
42:05Maybe we need to really more visibly pivot back to being, we're neutral. We don't take positions on politics, at least to that level. Maybe quietly make sure we have good relations, hire a lot of Democratic lobbyists to talk to all these Democratic members of Congress and Democratic governors and Democratic attorneys general. I think that could also affect it. So yeah, I think that the extent to which Trump is not, let's put it this way, cutting his losses and trying to make sure that they have a reasonable shot in 28, but he's doubling down on a lot of stuff. And it could really, you could end up in a situation where an awful lot of stuff starts to tip against it. On the other hand, I don't know, they succeeded with,
42:41before we all thought stuff was going to blow up in their face. And so maybe they're not stupid to kind of just double down in this way. And maybe they'll back off after a few weeks. And well, ultimately we won't be talking about it in February or March, I don't know. Yeah, yeah. Well, obviously this is another thing we're going to keep an eye on. We have a couple more things, one more thing really to talk about, but I did want to circle back super fast on NVIDIA because we do have a statement from Donald Trump. Now that NVIDIA CEO, J have a statement from Donald Trump. Now that NVIDIA CEO Jensen Huang, who has done a fantastic job, has resigned, there's only one man to take his place. Tim Cook of Apple. Apple CEO who retired last year. A legend replaces a legend,
43:15President Donald J. Trump. This is kind of an amazing statement. Also kind of reminds me a little bit of Elon Musk yesterday. He said he'd be glad to hire Jensen Wong if he were outgoing at NVIDIA. He'd bring him on at X, bring him on Elon's properties. So yeah, it's kind of just like what I was saying before. It's like 11 billionaires, right? It's a big club and you're not in it, right? I mean, we're speed running all of that. But anything on the Trump statement? Just what you say. Perfect, yeah. Let's really increase the loathing of this oligarchic in-group even more by doing this kind of thing. Right. Yeah. Yeah. No, it really is amazing. It really is amazing. OK, we got to talk. The last thing we really do have to talk about is is the Mississippi Senate race, which was called yesterday at long last.
43:57Scott Colombe, the winner of that race. They counted up enough ballots. Cindy Hyde Smith, the incumbent Republican, has conceded in that race, brings the Democrats to 55, assuming Mary Peltola wins in Alaska. She's looking likely to be 56. But this is such an extraordinary. I mean, you are on this one, Bill. But like I'll be honest, I didn't know how to pronounce his name like two weeks before Election Day. I think I was saying Scott Column or something on this stream. And and he really has come out of nowhere in terms of the national media coverage, which he's talked about himself, by the way. I mean, he put up a post yesterday basically saying how he thinks race handicappers like the Cook Political Report and all these guys who had
44:35considered Mississippi, you know, likely Republican forever made it hard for him to run, made it hard for him to raise any money, made it hard for him to get any national media attention. I will say our colleague Lauren Egan, who covers the Democrats, had been had been down there. She profiled him months and months ago. But but but it really is one of the most extraordinary stories of the entire midterms here, Bill. No, it is. It's a moving story. And I wrote a little bit on Monday, but I just see the extent to which he's winning in a state that hasn't elected a black statewide since Reconstruction. And even then, I think it was the Mississippi House that selected pre-popular election senators,
45:10selected during reconstruction a black man to be senator. So, you know, and Mississippi with all of its history. And I mean, winning the country that was named after the founder of the, one of the founders of the KKK. It was his name, Nathan Bedford Forrest. The whole thing is just such a moving story. He's an impressive person, it seems to me. I like the fact that his father was kind of a Reagan guy, right? He was a Reagan appointee to something, as I recall. And so, you know, he's kind of a never-Trump Republican, you know, or at least comes from never-Trump Republican roots, you know. The kind of never-Trump Republican that's a Democrat now, yeah. Yeah, exactly. Very much so, yeah. But, you know, and chose to run. I mean, a lot of admiration.
45:48He was not someone who was recruited by Chuck Schumer. I don't think, to be fair, Schumer was against it, or anything like that, but didn't get any support from anyone until two or three weeks out. The quarter two of the Super PACs helped him earlier. I think Lauren was early on this. We were generally, I think, oh, just look at the polling. I didn't. Well, Mississippi looks like it could be in play. You know, Espy, former Clinton official, ran in Mississippi a couple years ago and got 44% of the vote. So it's not, people have overdone how, you know, we have such a big black population and some white Democrats. It's not like so, you can see, well, you can make it competitive. But everyone sort of thought, okay, I'll get 47. That'll be nice. But he's not like so inconceivable that you can make it competitive. But everyone sort of thought,
46:25okay, I'll get 47. That'll be nice, but he's not going to win. And he ran an excellent campaign at that killer ad against Sidney Smith. She wasn't a good candidate. I will say one other thing, though. She conceded. She conceded gracefully. You know, there's a little bit of monkeying around. The state Republican Party harrumped for a few days in a kind of a slightly annoying way, but basically they didn't count. I talked to people who were down there. It was conducted professionally and appropriately. There was no, really no interference with it. If any, that's sort of striking. I mean, it shows what a big, either shows that there's more Republican commitment to the rule of law and to democracy
46:58than maybe some of us thought, and or you get a wave this big, people don't want to be messing with it. And even in a state where it was very close, you know i mean so i think it's just uneven i mean on that particular question i just think it's we have this sort of marbling through the through the state and county parties everywhere now where you have some places that are that are genuinely now staffed up even at the state and local level uh and even in these sort of functionary roles with real lunatics um and then you have other places where it is still primarily run by people who have public interest at heart. And they're just trying to make the trains run on time. And they're just giving their time and their energy to make the elections run well.
47:36And I guess we're lucky in one sense that Mississippi seems to be the kind of place where it's mostly the latter. I do think it's primarily in a lot of these states that were formerly so controversial in 2020, like the way that the Arizona Republican Party went so insane in the aftermath of that election. Same with the Georgia Republican Party to a lesser extent. And that's why it's so important that in so many of those states, Democrats ended up taking all of those functional roles in the last week. But I do think, you know, it's hard to generalize too much when you're talking about, you know, what essentially amounts to a million different small-scale functionary roles, which is one of the good things about the election system,
48:14by the way, the way it's so decentralized in power in that way. No, you're right. And actually, weirdly, I think you're right. The reddest states, people would have said, Mississippi was one, because they didn't have these closely contested elections, didn't go as crazy. And also it was a state always that had a kind of traditional establishment, Trent Lott, Thad Cochran. It's not like, you know, Haley Barber. I mean, you know, it's a state that if you are a Republican functionary who's 50 years old, the Republican party you grew up in was not Trumpy. It was very right wing and it wasn't enlightened entirely on racial issues, God knows, and all that, but it was a little different from Trumpism. So anyway, so that's
48:49a good, so I think it's great that Cologne won. It's great for what it says about, I think, you know, race and so forth in this country, but also the way it ended peacefully in an orderly way is a good sign actually for the next while. Yeah. And Alaska, which is a very different state, obviously, got kind of a quirky state in its own right. Again, that count seems to be going normally. And, I mean, it takes longer because it's Alaska for various crazy reasons. There might be bad choice voting, might have to kick in. But, you know, no one seems to think there's massive fraud going on there. That is such a, not to immediately swerve into the Alaska thing, but that has been one of the strangest things at the post-midterms.
49:31I mean, you want to talk about the ways in which Donald Trump has really been reduced to a color commentator in a lot of this stuff. Trump is out there repeatedly just tweeting. I mean, every few days he says, I think that every vote for every candidate other than Mary Peltola should be immediately handed to Dan Sullivan, and he should be appointed the next senator. Thank you for your attention to this matter. And nobody is paying attention to that. Like, there's no one who seems to think, now, that's not to say that there couldn't be more legal action against Peltola later. I mean, that is one of the things that the Republicans were really seeming to be gearing up to do ahead of the midterms. And maybe that is a situation where, you know, the blue wave nationally
50:05has taken some of the fight out of them for that, because it did actually seem like some of them seemed to be gearing up to even refuse to see Peltola. So we'll see. Maybe we'll eat crow on that one and that Alaska will be the one place where we do see a genuine localized stop the effort. But I'm with you. I mean, I think it's a real silver lining that even in the couple places that have seemed very close and even very Republican areas, there just hasn't seemed like an appetite for that. Well, there are a million really close house races. Every day, we get two or three more called in, you know, 300 vote, 700 vote margins, North Carolina, some of them controlled by Democrats, some of them, many of them in red or reddish states,
50:43you know. And again, that seems mostly to be going appropriately. So yeah, there is some, the stop to steal stuff never got quite embedded. Also in a midterm, just practically speaking, Trump has no standing. As you say, he is a color commentator. The Justice Department tried to butt in in a million ways, was mostly rebuffed. A lot of good legal work on that side, a lot of good tort decisions, actually, I'd say, especially at the district court level. And so, you know, if Dan Sullivan, the real Dan Sullivan, personally is not going to fight this in a, you know, take no prisoners way, if Cindy Highsmith isn't going to fight it, Trump has no, he's not on the, I mean, he is not on the ballot, to use a phrase. It's different from presidential race, right? Where if the Trump campaign pivots
51:23into being a Trump election denying organization, you have a whole set of different challenges and court cases and so forth. But if actually the relevant senators and House members and candidates are just, OK, I guess I've lost and it was a fair recount or a fair count of the absentee ballots or whatever, they always have less leverage over the midterm. But it's a good – so they will have more leverage in 28 in a sense. It's a presidential, but it's a very good sign. I think it is a good sign going forward. I just keep re-encountering how magnificent of a fact that this thing that you're talking about is. Where like, I feel like two weeks ago, if someone had said, come to me and said, I can wave my magic wand right now
52:04and we'll get a little bit of blue energy. And, you know, maybe maybe they just barely Democrats barely retake the House and they barely retake the Senate. But here's the good news. Stop the steal as a political movement for Donald Trump is eviscerated and goes away never to recover. I would have taken that. I mean, that has been such an unbelievable pestilence on our politics for the last five or six years. The deep, deep election denial and nihilism about just the ability of the country to elect its own leaders that had infected from Trump on down so much of the entire Republican Party. And the nihilism that had allowed to spread about all of our politics among so many of his supporters, so many of his voters. And it just seems like it's gone.
52:49It just seems like it's vanished. And maybe it could come back later, but I don't really see a mechanism for how it would come back, at least on the scale and to the extent that we've seen it in past years. And that just is such a genuinely magnificent thing, in my view. And the wave really helps make that possible. Not, not, not the only, it's not, it's not, you know, it's not by itself. The other things happened too, but if, if, if the Senate were 49, 50, 49, and everything hinged on Mississippi, yes, we might be living in a different world, right? That's very good point. Luckily, once you, so, so no, but, so that's, yeah, the world, I'd say, yeah, we'd let people go, but the, the wave has consequences beyond the board's the most direct ones ones, right, of which this is one, right?
53:29I mean, it has a bigger effect when it's of this magnitude than just producing X number of senators and X number of members of Congress and X number of governors. Yeah, yeah. We've been going for like a really, really long time. But I do have one other question for you, Bill, because people aren't leaving. You know, the numbers are actually still taking up a little bit. So I will pose you one other question on the Scott Colom race. He seems he is such an impressive politician. I mean, he ran a great, great race. And it's the kind of thing that like, you know, a win like this, in theory, sets you up for like a long and very illustrious like national career. On the other hand, Mississippi is such a red state.
54:03Like it's so red that first of all, like the idea that he would run for president in two years seems preposterous. They're not gonna pull him out and lose the Senate seat over that. And then the fact that, you know, he ran this amazing campaign against this very beatable on the merits Republican nominee and that even that was only enough to just kind of barely pull him over the finish line. Do you think that he has a real shot, a real shot six years from now of maintaining, of retaining this incumbency? Or is this more of like a Doug Jones situation where it's just like a miracle that it could happen in this state at all? And it's like one nice term, one nice kind of bonus seat for one term for the Democrats. And that's probably the end of it. I don't know, but could
54:44is it conceivable that Mississippi does become more competitive generally because the black for one term for the Democrats, and that's probably the end of it. I don't know, but it could, as I can see, well, the Mississippi does become more competitive generally because the black turnout stays elevated. And also some white voters decide after a year or two of watching Scott Colon that he's fine, you know, he's not a threat to the Republican. Maybe I should be a little less of a knee-jerk Republican. That happened. It's, God knows, it's happened in Georgia. It's happening, maybe it'll happen in South Carolina with Annie Andrews. It's happening in, you know, right down the eastern seaboard, really. So and maybe it'll happen in
55:08Texas, incidentally. So I don't I think we may have to rethink our sort of whole understanding of the South in a sense and how much of it could really be competitive on the presidential. He's not going to run for president, I don't think. But incidentally, he doesn't have to give up his Senate seat if he runs for president or is selected as vice president. Vance did not give up his Senate seat until he won the vice presidency in 2024. He ran for vice president as a sitting vice president. So ran for vice president as a sitting senator. And of course, many other people have done that too. So I think Cologne, Ossoff too, are in good shape in that respect in terms of if they want to venture into national politics, they don't have to give up their Senate seat.
55:47So who knows? Yeah. Yeah. It's interesting that we're talking about Cologne. The biggest stories in the Senate now, surely, are Cologne, Tallarico winning as newcomers, and Ossoff, I suppose, right? Yeah. Massive re-election victory. All three from the Confederate, from big, big big, big southern, bigish southern states, you know, and southern states that one would have said five, 10 years ago are at the core of the Republican hegemony. So that's very interesting. And the core of republic or of democratic sort of demographic nightmares about the future of the party. Right. As more and more of the country moves south and these states actually increase in their own political power. I mean, we were under the previously constituted map.
56:29We were looking at real hard times for Democrats where potentially you could have, you know, a bigger and bigger and a worse and worse tip where you need to win more and more of the popular vote just to break even in Congress and just to break even in the presidency. It's a whole new world out there. So we're going to keep covering all of that. But we have held the good people for 56 minutes already. So we should let them go. Thanks, Bill. Thanks, Bill, for you for sticking around all this time. I mean, it's amazing. It's all this stuff is amazing. Thanks to you all out there for watching. We hope you will subscribe to the feed if you are not subscribed already. Bill and I do this every week.
57:00And The Bulwark has 900,000 other good commentators and great shows that are all coming up here all the time you know you can you you could you can stand under it with your mouth open like uh like a waterfall cascading down and uh and it's all good stuff so uh so we hope you will subscribe





