Best of the Spectator · · Transcript & summary by WhipScribe
Summary, chapters and key takeaways for this episode are on their way; the transcript below is complete.
Our own transcript of the public episode, with a timestamp about every 90 seconds. Tap a timestamp to play the episode from there in the show's own player; the link button on a paragraph copies a link that opens this page there.
0:00Hey y'all, Kelly Clarkson here with Wayfair. You know my favorite compliment during the holidays? Your house feels so cozy. That's when I know everyone's comfortable enough to kick off their shoes, grab more dessert, and stay a little longer. Wayfair makes it easy, with everything from dining furniture to festive guest room essentials, all in one place. So whether you're hosting for an afternoon or all weekend, everyone feels right at home. Get holiday guests ready at Wayfair.com or on the Wayfair app today. Wayfair, every style, every home. Hello and welcome to Quite Right, the Spectator podcast. And this week, I'm joined by Zia Youssef, Reform's Shadow Home Secretary, and one of the most powerful and articulate voices on the right.
0:53Zia is different from most people in politics in that his entire career before joining Reform was in business. And he's been explicit in the critique that he's mounted of those of us who've been involved in establishment politics over the last two decades, the missed opportunities, the mistakes, and the need for apology. Zia, wonderful to have you on this podcast. One of the things I first wanted to ask you about this week was Andy Burnham's proposed Brexit reset. Is the PM right to revisit the Brexit deal? Well, obviously not. But one of the things I want to zoom out on, specifically with regards to Burnham and Brexit, this is a man who just a few months ago told the good people of Makerfield
1:37that he wasn't going to reopen the debate about Brexit. That's a direct quote, would not reopen that debate. Almost within, immediately after winning the election, which of course it was to be the next parliamentarian for the constituency of Makerfield. In the end, it was clear this was to be the next prime minister. And when we think about why so many people in this country are utterly despondent with politicians, simply don't believe things that politicians say, this is a big reason why. Because people assume that politicians will say something instrumental to persuading a given group of people to give them their vote in order to achieve their own personal ambitions. Remember, this is a man who has wanted to be prime minister for decades.
2:20And so before we even get to the merits of, should we renegotiate the deal? Should we go back into Europe? Should we stay out? Before we do any of water would be an upgrade to Keir Starmer's politicians. That wasn't hard. But he's still way below what even Keir Starmer got in the last general election, and that was one of the lowest percentage vote shares to deliver a majority. So that would be the first point I'd make. In terms of the deal itself, I draw attention to viewers of this podcast to just how much the European Union has changed since these discussions were last had. And I had this discussion on Question Time too. So number one, there's three quarters of a million nationals of, let's call them the small boat nations, Afghanistan, Syria, Eritrea, Sudan, etc.
3:23The nations that top the league tables in terms of over-representation on those boats, three quarters of a million have been granted citizenship into the European Union. And so given that these predominantly men are risking their lives and paying thousands, about 8,000 pounds, to people smugglers to come to Britain, the idea that a large percentage of those are not going to immediately come here is nonsense. And actually, to illustrate that, they will no longer, if Burnham gets his way, they won't have to come across on a boat, putting their lives at risk. For what they're paying people smugglers, they can come first class in the Eurostar. So that's the first point we would make, because obviously the Brexit discussion and the Brexit campaign, clearly
4:08immigration was, I think, the number one. I mean, would you agree with that as someone who's in the group? It was the number one. Much more so than trade, certainly. So the number one, I'm not saying the only, I'm not saying exclusively, but key issue, right? And so if that's the case, people need to appreciate that. Number two, we need to be clear about what it is we want out of a relationship with Europe, and then also seek to benefit from the freedoms that were at least in theory availed to the British government as a result of Brexit. On immigration, you make the point about the Boris wave and the way in which following on from both the vote and our exit, migration went up, not down. That provokes the question,
4:47if you were Home Secretary, there are two elements. One, restricting access to the country, and then two, reviewing people who are already here, whom you and others might think have no right to be here. On the first, what would a reformed government do? And on the second, what's the scale effectively of removal? So it has to be both. And I think an enormous amount of damage has been wrought on the country post-Brexit. And that's why I go back to the point about why did people vote for Brexit? More people voted for Brexit. Again, as you know, no elections saw more people vote for a single thing in this country's history than Brexit. Why did they do that? Again, I'm not monomaniacal about this issue, but clearly immigration,
5:30I think, was the number one point. And that's why the slogan was take back control. Right. And what then happened was Boris Johnson used that control to throw open our borders. I think 4.7 million visas issued, just 17%, 1.7% of those came in on work visas. And most of these people were unskilled. The majority, or at least half, do not work and clearly will never work. Widespread abuse. We can go on enormous change across the country, concentrated in certain communities. Okay. So then you think about how do we go forward from here? Number one, yes, we've got to look at the country's immigration policy. So I'm clear that under a reformed government, if I'm the Home Secretary, not just the Prime Minister,
6:13we will have net negative immigration for a sustained period of time. That doesn't mean nobody can come here, but my God, the bar's going to be extraordinarily high, like extraordinary. If you're an entrepreneur- So the population will be smaller. Overall, more people will leave than will come. 100%. Absolutely. Absolutely. If you're a multinational chief executive and you're coming here to create an additional 5,000 jobs, cool, right? But there's going to be a lot more people leaving than coming. And by the way, that's also consistent with what we're saying on the mass deportation of everyone in the country here illegally. My view is immigration law is law. And if you don't believe that we should uphold immigration law,
6:48then I don't understand why you'd want to uphold any other law. We just haven't upheld immigration law now for, frankly, decades in this country. So nobody who came to this country illegally should be allowed to stay. Not only is it a baseline axiom through which we make policy and how I would execute my role as Home Secretary, I think it's also fair. And I think the polling actually, it's interesting when you poll this, British people who have an amazing sense of fairness, I think that's reasonable. If you broke into the country, look, Michael, if somebody broke into your house, God forbid, and went to your fridge and started eating your food, you would call the police and you would expect them to immediately come and remove them. You wouldn't say, well, no, actually,
7:24have you thought about their Article 8 right in the ECHR, Michael? Have you thought about what that would cost? So the moral principle there is pretty clear. In numbers terms, how many people do you think that would mean that a reformed government would be deporting from the UK every year? And of course, as well as people who are here illegally, there are people, as you point out, millions who've come here on visas, some of whom entertain an expectation that they'll secure the right of permanent residency, indefinite leave to remain, or even UK citizenship. Presumably, a number of those would be told at the expiry of their visa, thank you for your service, but I'm afraid you have to go. Correct. 100%. And to be fair, it's a very good question, and I understand why you're asking it.
8:09And this is the second part, the original question that you asked. So I answered the first part, right? Yes, it is true that we need to deport everybody who broke into the country illegally, clearly. And there's well north of a million, maybe two million in that category. Very hard to count. But it is also true, and I've articulated this time and again, just because you entered the country legally does not mean you get to stay forever. In the same way, if somebody came to my house for dinner and I invited them in, they don't get to pitch up and live there forever. And I have some personal experience of this because I got a visa to go to America when I was the founder, CEO of a company. And there were all of these conditions
8:44that I had to meet in order to A, get that visa and then sustain that visa. And it involved investment into America, involved hiring lots of people and sustaining that hiring, ensuring that I didn't commit crime, that I paid my tax, all of those things. Now, this is how a serious country operates. And by the way, the moment I no longer adhere to the terms of that visa, I would have been expected to leave. And I wouldn't have needed to be deported by an armed ICE agent, right? I would have just left. If you look at what's happened with indefinite leave to remain to these people who came legally. Now, I would position millions of people who came in under particularly the post-Boris Johnson era, you know, let's call it the Boris wave.
9:20While they may have come legally, in my view, they came illegitimately relative to consent from the British people. And that's a discrete point. Yes, they entered legally. Fair enough. I'm not claiming they broke in. It's not their fault. Well, unless they committed fraud, in which, again, a lot of fraud, as you know. But I understand the point you're making. But we've got to be honest. They did not come here with the permission of the British people. They came here expressly against the permission of the British people. They came here expressly against the wishes of the British people. And that's why we're saying, look, if you are contributing economically, you have not committed crime, you're speaking good English, fine.
9:51There are a lot of people who are not in that category. And those people will not have, so we're going to abolish indefinite leave to remain. That's our policy. We'll create a five-year renewable work visa. Yes, we will have a special visa available, aid to spouses. I want to be really clear about that. Spouses of British citizens. And we will also have a visa program for what we call national critical industries. But outside of that, yeah, Michael, we're going to have to be honest about this. And so in terms of the scale, you asked me how many people who came legally might end up having to, will not have their right to remain in this country renewed. I mean, if you just look at the numbers, assuming the general election is in 2029,
10:27that number is clearly well north of a million. It is in the millions for sure. There's obviously a logistical challenge there. And there's a challenge also in that the countries from which some people have arrived illegally are countries like Eritrea and Afghanistan. And the countries from which people have come here on indefinite leave to remain, or with the prospect in their minds that they will secure indefinite leave to remain, are countries where the governments wouldn't necessarily welcome what they would see as the premature return of individuals. What are you going to do if Eritrea says, we're not taking anyone back? What are you going to do if countries in the subcontinent or elsewhere in Asia say, look, I'm really sorry, but these people are now your problem?
11:11Well, look, so let's go through what leverage Britain does have. First of all, Britain is still giving foreign aid to every single country that you just mentioned, right? So before we even talk about taking, literally paying, people watching this, your taxes are currently going to countries like Pakistan, which has a massive stock of illegal migrants in this country. They don't come by boat, they come other ways. They don't really appear on the top 10 of nationalities on the boats. They come on student visas, they come on visitor visas, and they just overstay and claim asylum. I don't know what war is going on in Pakistan that would make that remotely appropriate. Bottom line is, it's clearly fraud, right?
11:44If you come here on a visitor visa and then claim asylum from Pakistan, you have come here expressly to the fault of the British taxpayer and the British citizen. And frankly, you should be treated as such. And so if we look at a country like Pakistan, hundreds of millions of pounds in aid in recent years, enormous numbers of visas, millions, I think, of visas issued over the last decade. So number one, we stopped the foreign aid. And by the way, where is that foreign aid spent? Given the over-representation of Pakistani nationals in the rape gangs, for example, I think people, it is a reasonable thing to point out the outrageousness of where that foreign aid is being spent on sex education
12:19and contraceptive programs in Pakistan. Now that to me is utterly insane. So number one, we'd stop the foreign aid. Number two, we'd stop the, if we have to be then, blanket visa ban on all Pakistani nationals, if they continue to refuse to take back their nationals. And then if you have to go further, Michael, then yes, if you go around some of the leafier, lovelier neighborhoods around central London, many of these properties are owned by Pakistani government officials. So we will look at sanctioning them and if necessary, we'll seize their assets. Look, we're going to put, we will go to the wall. Nigel Farage as prime minister will go to the wall on securing the interests of the British people.
12:54Then you can look at a country like Afghanistan, different sort of situation. I get it. Okay, well, would you return people to Afghanistan? Well, Germany is. Germany is returning Afghan nationals who entered Germany illegally to Afghanistan using Qatar as an intermediate. And when we first announced, when me and Nigel announced Operation Restoring Justice, that we would do this, there was a complete meltdown from Good Morning Britain and from the BBC. And then what happened within a few weeks, Keir Starmer said, even he, even Keir Starmer would be open to doing it. Look, we've got to be clear about who we're prioritizing. And you're a smart man. People watching this are smart people. They understand sometimes in government, you've got to make zero-sum decisions. And we want to be honest
13:33about where we will, the direction in which we will go when there are zero-sum decisions to be made. And we will be unapologetic in prioritizing the safety and the interests of British people. The last point I'll make about Afghanistan, because I've been very vocal about my disdain and contempt for the things that the former Tory defence minister, Ben Wallace, did when he was a defence minister. And again, this has nothing to do with his service to the country in uniform, different point. But I'm going to make the point because it's very important and it cuts to the heart of one of the reasons why I'm in politics and why I'll keep making these arguments. Tens of thousands of Afghans, most of the men have been imported into Britain,
14:13many of them without the permission, well, all of them actually without the permission, but many of them without the knowledge of the British people because of the super injunction that was taken out. We know that Afghan nationals are orders of magnitude more likely to commit sex offences in Britain than British nationals. And that's despite the relentless attempts from British governments to suppress that data. And even The Economist, I put out a video yesterday making the point, when The Economist two weeks ago, that famous far right rag, The Economist, said, yes, clearly Afghans are much more likely to commit sex offences. When they put the chart up, they had to use a log scale, Michael.
14:48They had to use a scale that is normally used for exponential growth in frontier AI models because the numbers were so ridiculously different. And this really matters because then that cuts at the heart again of who was Ben Wallace prioritizing as defense minister. He was prioritizing the safety and security of foreigners over the safety and security of British women and girls. And I will keep making that point. I'm going to get attacked by lots of people all over the establishment and in the media, but I'm going to keep making that point because that's a key differential, Michael, in terms of when I talk about zero-sum decisions. And by the way, some of those people that were imported were
15:20literal Taliban fighters, according to well-sourced articles in The Telegraph. Some of them had been kicked out of the Afghan army for sex offences. Now think about how depraved one would need to be to be kicked out of the Afghan army for sex offences. And these were people that were imported into Britain and a super injunction then taken out. So that is an example of where the interests of British people, the safety of British people, not only compromised, but I would argue the British people completely betrayed. Obviously, in Afghanistan, as you say, there are some people who will have come here who pose a risk. It will also be the case that there are some of those who came here from Afghanistan,
16:02who will have risked their lives to save British forces. And there will also be some women and girls who, if they were returned, could face torture at the hands of the Taliban. And also in the case of Eritrea, one could also argue Somalia, there are people who, if returned, would face death. Do you accept that in order to fulfill your policy to the letter, there would be some Afghan heroes, some Afghan women, and some African individuals who would face grotesque consequences? No, because let's talk about what our policy is to the latter. So if you take Afghanistan, you know, Ministry of Defense verified Afghans who serve valiantly alongside our troops, a few hundred, a few hundred, right? Certainly not 15,000 or 20,000, right?
16:57We know that the large-scale importation programs began after the data leak. We don't have time to go into it all now. But classic failure at every aspect of the British state. So those people actually served, actually served, and our Ministry of Defence can verify that they served alongside our troops, no problem. They're staying, right? I want to be clear about that, as long as they haven't committed crimes and things like that. But that's a few hundred people, Michael, right? And so, I mean, actually, again, I'm glad you asked the question, because if those few hundred get to stay, that means the other tens of thousands who will continue to be. By the way, these importations are still happening. I'm sorry they don't get to stay. And similarly, if we're talking about, look, as Home Secretary, I have no interest and I will not send people to a fate that is clearly going to mean that they are tortured or killed. But the standard we must hold for that is,
17:46is there intelligence that, and a compelling case to maybe this particular individual, is going to be at severe risk. That's a very different evidential threshold to the current one, which is somebody can stand outside a gay club. And again, this is real stuff that has happened. Stand outside a gay club and say i am a gay person and i'm afghan and by the way i'm married to this man and i'm going to send in my asylum claim and i'm going to get it approved by the home office even though home office whistleblowers have told reputable outlets like the telegraph that the same man is apparently married to hundreds if not thousands of people there's a large-scale fraud on these things, Michael. And this is the point that the British people, the loveliest, most generous, warmest
18:29people, I think in the world, but their goodwill has been taken advantage of. And that's what we've got to stop. So if your question is as Home Secretary, would I send people to their deaths? Absolutely not. But, and it is important that you retain consent from the public for the things that you are doing. And it's important that you act in a morally upstanding way. But that's a very different thing to just importing tens of thousands of Afghan nationals, many of whom are committing fraud in order to come here in the first place, and directly putting at risk British people. And the last point I'd make on that is that the priority for a reformed government led by Naito will be the interests of the British
19:08people. when I know everyone's comfortable enough to kick off their shoes, grab more dessert, and stay a little longer. Wayfair makes it easy, with everything from dining furniture to festive guest room essentials, all in one place. So whether you're hosting for an afternoon or all weekend, everyone feels right at home. Get holiday guests ready at Wayfair.com or on the Wayfair app today. Wayfair, every style, every home. How does your policy, very clearly explained, differ from both the Conservatives and Restore? So the difference between reform and, I would say, let's start with the Conservatives. Again, I judge, I'm someone who voted Conservative, right? I'm someone who supported Brexit. And I, you know, frankly, when Boris Johnsonson this is one of the reasons i feel so strongly about this level of
20:09betrayal because i was building my company you know and i saw him finally you know i thought okay brilliant boris johnson is going to finally be a properly conservative prime minister now he's got the personality he's got this walloping majority you've got this opportunity of brexit let's go and become one of the most prosperous and powerful countries in the world. I genuinely thought that was going to happen. Maybe you did too. Obviously, the opposite happened. Literally the opposite, Michael. Not underperformance relative to the goals, importing 4.7 million people in four years, almost all of whom came in on non-work visas and largely from non-EU countries, with a vastly different culture to Britain. Again, i'm happy to say that it's an obvious point
20:48so so that would be the key thing and look it's going to be for viewers of this and voters to make this assessment you know who do you believe is actually going to go to the wall on these issues who's actually going to do the thing in terms of the difference with restore you know i think that restore is a party that is the people who support Restore, the people I meet who support Restore, they are deeply patriotic people. They're very anti-establishment. They agree that we don't have really many more chances, maybe any more chances in the next general election. And they love the country and they want this country to be governed by people who will just ruthlessly and relentlessly make decisions
21:30through the lens of what's in the interest of the British people. And I have enormous respect for that. And so I'm in the camp of saying, you know, it is up to us at Reform to convince those people who would currently say that, who either do currently vote for Restore, who would support Restore, that we deserve their support. I feel very strongly about that. So with the Conservatives, and again, I just want to be clear here, your point is that in terms of policy detail, certainly on the basis of what the Conservatives have said so far. There's not a huge difference between the Conservative position and the reform position on migration, but there's a big trust deficit. And your argument is, well, the Conservatives may say that they're going to
22:22take a similar approach towards reform. But what I infer from what you say is, can you really trust them given what's happened in the past? And by the way, we laid this out in detail first, and they're playing catch up. So there's a credibility question there. Is that broadly correct? Or am I missing something? But there are significant differences still, Michael, between us and the Tories. So let's go through them. And again, we need to be very honest about these discussions. So let's take welfare for foreign nationals. Now, my view is that the amount of money the British taxpayers have been forced to spend on foreign nationals over the last two decades is insane. So let's take foreign aid. I said this in Wolverhampton. In foreign aid, Michael, a quarter of a trillion pounds is the amount of money British taxpayers have been forced to send abroad over the last two decades adjusted for inflation. A
23:07quarter of a trillion. That's enough to send every British household almost 10,000 pounds. And people go, well, what about the soft power we generated from that? Andy Burnham, this Labour government can't even deport the Rochdale monster, the guy who was a ringleader of one of the most ruthless and rapacious rape gangs in Rotherham. Pakistan's even refusing to take him back. So how powerful do people feel right now? So that would be point one. Number two, let's look at the difference between even the current stated policies, even if you were to take the Tories on face value. Our position is no foreign nationals will be eligible for welfare payments from the British taxpayer. The Tory position is no foreign nationals
23:50except EU citizens with settled status. Well, that might seem like a technicality. It's actually a huge point. Again, if you actually look at the numbers, which very few people will do, even in the media class, frankly, I know you do, but very few people do, is let's look at how much money the British government is spending on the taxpayers' money, 9 billion, I think, on universal credit, like vast amounts of money for foreign nationals last year. The majority of that is to EU settled status people. So if you are going to exclude, just like Shabana Mahmood did with the Boris wave, yeah, we're going to delay settlement for the Boris wave, except for the largest cohort and the most financially devastating one.
24:28These are the details that really matter in politics. So our position is, yeah, we're going to have to have a big row with the European Union about those people because it's simply not fair. And then people say, well, Zia, what about British people in Europe? Sure, there are some, very few. The British taxpayer is still paying for a lot of Brits in Spain for their pensions. That's still being paid for. And if you look at the ratio, which we also need to acknowledge what's happened since that settlement deal was struck, to the degree there is data, and it's hard to get it, but there's been a massive increase, a vastly disproportionate multiplicative increase in British taxpayers funding foreign nationals in our country, specifically EU settled states people relative to the other way around.
25:11So we've got to be honest about this. And when people say, well, the EU's not going to like that, of course, they're not going to like it because we're actually standing up for ourselves. And in the same way, you know, we said that we're going to send those boats back to France. We're not going to allow them to come here. It's about time we actually had a government and a prime minister who will stand up for the interests of the British people. And if we're not willing to have an almighty row with Germany or France and the Elysee Palace about these issues, then you'd have to explain to me, Michael, about what are we willing to have an almighty row with people on. You mentioned in the case of Restore and with
25:45respect to Restore's supporters, why has there been a growth in support for Restore and a consequent fall in support for reform over the course of broadly the last 12 to 15 months? Simple answer is that a lot of people who currently vote for Restore previously voted for Reform. I mean, I spoke to some of these people, even in Makerfield, for example. Why have they opted out of supporting Reform? Again, very good question. So it's kind of what I'm going back to is that they believe, I can go off the people I'm speaking to. Sure. Right. And, you know, when I was in Makerfield, I was with Rob Kenyon, our candidate, and people were coming up to me as we walked through the park and saying, oh, you know, when I was in Makerfield, I was with Rob Kenyon, our candidate, and people were coming up to me as we walked through the park and saying, oh, you know, Zip, thanks for what you do.
26:28We're a big fan of yours, big fan of Nigel's. Thanks for what you do. And I said, can we rely on your vote? And the vast majority said, yes, we can. But some people said, you know what, we might consider a stall this time. And I said, well, you know, why is that? I'm always interested to answer. And again, it was the same thing is that we are so focused on the fact that this could be the last chance we have as a country in terms of the next general election to turn the ship around, get the country back on its feet, because the consequences of what might come after. If we are betrayed again, that's it. It's the sense of we cannot afford to be betrayed again. We can't afford to vote for a political
27:03party, say they're going to do the thing that we believe needs to be done. And then not only not do it, but do the opposite. And what I said to them, and I'd like to think I convinced those people I was able to engage one to one, is that I came into politics to make Nigel Farage our prime minister for a reason. Again, I don't get paid to do this. I think it's objectively true that there's not many people that have a bigger opportunity cost to doing this than me. And that is because I believe in my heart that Nigel is the person who will do the things when it really matters, when it really matters, when you have to expend political capital as a prime minister to go to the wall on the issues that we're talking
27:40about for the future of this country and the interests of British people, he will do it. And I've worked with him every day now for two and a half years. Everything I have seen reaffirms that view. Now, voters are going to have to make their own choices on those things. But I will tell the people who are currently watching this who would currently put an X next to restore that, again, I deeply empathize and sympathize with your perspective, that you are patriotic people who understand we cannot afford again to be betrayed. But with Nigel Farage as Prime Minister and me as Home Secretary, you will get the things that you want. And we are absolutely focused on making this case to you and earning your trust.
28:25Why then are there some people who believed that a year ago or just over a year ago and who were prepared to trust exactly what you say who aren't now? What's happened in the last year and a half to make those people doubt? So firstly, Rupert Lowe is a, I mean, I've had personal issues with Rupert Lowe, clearly it's well documented, but he is a formidable person. He's a force of nature and he has been out there articulating a point very clearly and forthrightly. So that's the first thing and that's not to be sniffed at. What's interesting about probably what's happened over the last year is reform isn't in government. We are also under attack really from pretty much every segment of the media. And so,
29:19you know, you've got the left-wing press who obviously want to attack Nigel and attack reform. I think it's clear that, let's call it the so-called right-wing press who obviously want to attack Nigel and attack reform. I think it's clear that, let's call it the so-called right-wing press, are institutionally now, I mean, I just think, frankly, large segments of the right-wing press have been co-opted as Kemi Badenoch propaganda arms. And you can see that from the front pages and any negative story on Kemi just simply won't be run. Now, I don't say that to complain because I've always understood, as has Nigel, we're playing this game at max level difficulty. If you want to come in as an insurgent party and disrupt the two-party ecosystem that's
29:53been around for a century, that's not going to be easy. There's going to be a lot of people who don't want that to happen. So I don't think that's helped either. But if we look forward, we are still, I think, just on the morning of us recording this, we are back in second place in the average of the polls with Politico. Have we played every move correctly? No, that's obviously true. But equally, we played the vast majority of moves right. And again, if you put things into context, when I came into politics, the first speech I gave was just a few weeks, a couple of weeks before the general election. And reform ended up winning 14% of the vote and five MPs. We then dominated the local elections in 2025, dominated them in 2026. These are historic things. It was always going to be the case that we were going to have to reinforce and revivify
30:45our base support while also continuing to make the case to other people in Britain who may prioritize slightly different things, for example, to immigration. And reform has a lot of things to offer them too. So a lot of the things that have happened were perfectly predictable if you're actually being mature about this and looking at it. But what I will say is, number one, I would not be doing this, Michael, if I did not believe that Nigel was going to do the things that we did. And number two, there is the notion that we are going to get knocked out of the game by a series of hit pieces or establishment attacks. If people think that, they've got another thing coming. But there will be some people who will say, your policy on migration, again, crystal clear.
31:31And your principal criticism of the conservatives is, don't listen to what they say, look at what they did. And those same people will say, there are now a number of senior ex-conservatives who were in the government when it went wrong. Now, any of them as individuals may be, you know, nice people and wish them no harm. But it's not just one individual. Robert Jenrick, Suella Braverman, Jake Berry, Nadim Zahawi, they were all on the bridge of the ship when Boris Johnson was prime minister. So I trust you, Zia. I can't trust a party that has accepted these people wholesale. That's what some people will think. Yep, yep. And people are making that point, right? So I understand why you're asking the question. And i'm going to be very direct in answering these things i think
32:29um i don't think the country has time for us to not be candid about these things so look the first point to make is none of the above so if you are in the category of being concerned about that none of the above are going to be involved in immigration policy or borders policy. There's a reason why Nigel's given me this brief and not that. So that's the first point. Number two, it is objectively true that if we were to look at the most prominent of those, Sowell and Robber, objectively true that they were either sacked or resigned over immigration policy or issues around culture these are objectively true statements so that is the second point that i would make and each of them does have people that support them uh and like them and so and the final point i make on this actually is you
33:20know when people go well say you know you got Tories, if that is coming from the direction of a former Tory minister who is supporting the Tories, I say, I promise, if you are holding that as a point of criticism for a reform, I promise you, there's a lot more former Tory ministers inside the Tory party, including and especially Kemi. And I know that a lot of people in the media who want to memory hold this stuff um don't want to cover this but kemi actively campaigned for even more immigration pretty much at the height of the boris wave right if you look at something like brexit an issue around regulation where i talked a lot of small i was a small business owner you know i know how hard it is when you're dealing with regulation and you're
34:02struggling to make payroll and your biggest bills are coming from your accountants and your lawyers. When Kemi had all of the laws that she could have removed from our statute book, she refused to remove any of them on the basis that, quote, I'm a conservative and not an arsonist, thus directly betraying the very premise. I'm not saying you remove all of them without thinking about it, but it was a very, very different approach that was taken with regards to the promise of Brexit relative to what people expected. So look, again, I understand why people make that argument. We go back to the point, look, I'm the person who will be in charge of, if we get a reformed government, Nigel's prime minister, it is me that will be primarily responsible for stopping the boats, the biggest mass deportation program this country has ever seen. And I want to be really
34:50honest about this and really clear. And I know some people, sometimes columnists freak out when I say this, but I get no joy in saying that we're going to have to embark on the biggest mass deportation program this country has ever seen. I get no pleasure from that. But it is a commensurate response. It's the only sensible response to the severity of the issues in this country. I think, again, that's a very important point that you make. Your analysis is this is necessary economically and in order to restore trust democratically. And it's not the case that you feel bad about the fact that Britain is attractive to other people. You're proud of that. Of course. Proud of the welcome that Britain offers.
35:33Proud, obviously, of the fact that different people from different ethnicities have come here and contributed in the past. I think that's an important point to appreciate and understand. And if I got that wrong, do correct me. On the point about the conservatives, ex-conservatives, again, one thing that's very clear is, in effect, you're saying, A, these people are insulated from the migration case. If they've been in the Conservative Party, on this central issue, we'll keep them away from it. There's a trust deficit. And secondly, in the case of two of the most prominent, clearly very able people, they've also acknowledged fault. If it were the case that were other conservatives, either before or after a general election,
36:32who were prepared to say to you and to Nigel, look, we accept that people are voting for reform because of your migration stance. And we accept also that we've made mistakes. But we believe that we can work together in the national interest. So they pass those two tests you've said. What's your response? Well, again, I pay far more attention to what people do than what they say. And that's why I was reasonably successful in business, served me pretty well. I think it serves people well in politics too. And I think the British public are very smart in this regard. I think generally parties get in some what they deserve because the British people are very smart, much smarter by the way than most people in politics
37:13think. And so I would look at it and go, well, is this person telling me this thing because it is just maximizing their own self-interest in sustaining their salary or power or control? Or are they saying it because they believe it? Now, one way of really assessing this stuff is what sacrifice is this person making to do the thing? Now, that's not to say that just because somebody's making a huge sacrifice, you do think that they're right. But look, I'm going to say something that's probably quite controversial to your viewers right now, that I don't think if Jeremy Corbyn had beaten Boris Johnson, he would have been able to import as many people from non-EU countries on low skills as Boris did.
37:52I genuinely don't think that would have been true. I think the country would have had fewer migrants. And again, not just migrants, but people who came here expressly to defraud or live off the British taxpayer than had Boris Johnson won, right? And one of my pieces of evidence for that is some of the campaign literature against Jeremy Corbyn from the Conservative Party, from the Boris campaign was expressly sort of, if Corbyn wins, this is the number, this is how many people will end up coming to the country. And that number was considerably lower than the people who ended up coming. So I've always had great respect for people who say the thing that they believe and were willing to articulate that point, even if I deeply disagree with them. And so that's the lens through
38:34which I would look at it through. I mean, I understand why a lot of people will be watching this and going, we need to unite the right. Why are you being irrational in attacking people who are saying the same thing as you? Because I am acutely aware that we had, as someone who voted conservative in several elections, voted Brexit, was genuinely excited when Boris became PM, only to see him not only not do the things he promised to do, but do the literal opposite, betray the country to such a degree that I'm sitting here now. I've come into politics to reverse a lot of the thingsings now, pocket extra profit later. This is so simple now, this is so awesome later. Or sell fast now and pop the champagne later.
39:33Cash now, more later. Now available nationwide. Start your offer at opendoor.com slash ACAST. Profits calculated after fees and costs, eligibility and offer price may vary. You criticize Boris. You have a criticism of Kemi. But Katie Lamb wasn't an MP when this happened. Nick Timothy wasn't an MP when this happened. Neil O'Brien resigned from government in order to campaign for a different migration policy. They're all honorable people. Surely you could see circumstances in which, for the good of the country, you could work with Katie Lamb, Nick Timothy, and Neil O'Brien in order to put things right. So one person you just mentioned there, Nick Timothy, for example, and I don't think I've ever met Nick, so I don't want to be rude personally, but let's just go through his record. Correct me if I'm wrong, wasn't he Theresa May's chief of staff? And that manifesto that was one of the most woke, probably the most woke manifestos that ever came out from a so-called right-wing party, he was chief of staff. He held the pen on that stuff and so sometimes when i see some of the thing arguments that are being made even if i'd agree with them again i look at it and go is this
40:49cynically saying the thing that they think needs to be said right now instrumentally to win a vote like andy burnham yep in makerfield or is this something that they really believe well i would argue i say this with my hand on my heart if i was holding the pen pen on that manifesto, I would not put this insane woke stuff in. And a lot of the problems that they are now pointing out, well, specifically him, because I don't know if this is the case for the other two. I'm sorry, that is actually a very relevant data point. Now, maybe if I'd met him, he could make a really compelling reason why that happened, fair enough, maybe. But I'm not going to apologize for holding people to apologize for holding
41:25people to care for what they did in terms of the others look clearly there is some talent and um inside the conservative party and by the way i have met formatory ministers who i actually think are not all of them some of them in the opposite but who i think are decent people um who believed in the right things but then we get into okay, they were thwarted by the civil service. But, I mean, you know this better than anyone because you do do some valuable things in education. That's a skills issue. And this goes back to the point, you know, how are we going to lift this country out of the rock it's in? How do we get it back on its feet? The arguments and the rhetoric and the charisma and, you know,
42:01the social media, fine, obviously important. It's a necessary precondition, but we also need the competence. And in my view, and this is again, something I feel very deeply, and you'll see this, you saw Angus unveiled recently, our new defense spokesman, a man with multi-decade experience inside the armed forces, not a former MP. In fact, he had to discharge himself from the armed forces to take up this role. I've always said, as much as we have taken some formatory ministers, the majority of Nigel's shadow cabinet, and ultimately the significant majority of his actual cabinet, if we win, will be people like Angus, like myself, people who are not MPs. Untainted by politics, successful outside.
42:42Well, I understand why he's untainted, but that still looks at it through the lens of marketing. I'm talking through the lens of, you know, he's been on the other side of the hollowing out. You know, this isn't just a piece of political rhetoric. When we unveil our health spokesperson, you will see this is not a former MP. This is somebody who's worked in the heart of the NHS, has seen what's gone wrong, what's gone right. And I think that's what we need. We need extremely competent people. I think we need that galaxy of talents to get this country back on its feet. That won't be easy. It's very difficult to do. It's why I've always taken the view that it's only through a new vehicle outside of the two old parties that we're going
43:19to be able to do that. That's, again, very clear. You're not indulging in any personal criticism of any individual Conservative, but you're saying you'll assess their record. Not in this interview, but obviously I have done. Exactly. No, no. And again, that's very fair. You prefer not to unite the right as it's currently conceived. Well, hold on. You prefer not to have a sort of deal between the parties. And this is precisely the point. What you'd really like, tell me if this is wrong, is for the Conservative Party either to be destroyed or to wither away and for the government of this country and the politics of this country to have as the right-wing choice reform. Okay, so firstly, let's define terms if we're going to have this discussion. So what does unite the right-wing choice, Ruffalo? Okay, so firstly, let's define terms
44:05if we're going to have this discussion. So what does unite the right mean? Now, I think I have a different understanding of the parameters of that to you, right? So if you're asking me, would you bite off your nose to spite your face? Are you willing to just, you know, egotistically attack people who otherwise, you know, who agree with you on a principle and would do the thing. Of course not. That's not my position. And again, that's borne out by the fact that I get paid nothing to do this. I take on a significant security penalty for me and my family because I love this country. And I really believe the next general election is the most consequential in our history. I'm on the record as saying that. And it's why I believe Nigel needs to be our prime minister.
44:46Now, when we talk about what uniting the right means, I would look at what the Tories did in their 14 years as being not remotely what people would think of the right. And we've had this discussion after the Piddington thing that happened. It's being recorded 48 hours after I'm in Piddington. I'm not going to stand next to someone who is actively presenting themselves as the antidote to the very thing that they afflicted on the country and just stay quiet about that. And people might say, not the time and the place. I think it's always the right time and the place to tell the truth. Now, if you're asking me, do I want everybody who believes in the things that we're talking about, which is the – I'm not saying everything.
45:28I'm not saying I'm monomaniacal, right? I'm not that ideological. I'm quite a practical person. Number one, do you believe that our immigration law needs to be upheld? Number two, are you willing to go to the wall even when it can be unpopular? Because look, I'm saying we're going to deport well north of a million people. The idea that there aren't going to be bumps in the road in that is for the birds, right? Some people think, well, Zia, you're... No, I'm fully aware of that, which is why we need to conduct it in a moral way, in a way that the British people are happy with and consent to, and not be cruel or mean about it but am i willing to go to the wall when it matters yes absolutely but it's also really important michael that we're clear about
46:11what we're going to do before we go out and do it now in terms of are there people i don't know maybe in the conservative party maybe in restore who believe in that fair enough maybe there are i still believe and i've said this from the beginning that the the highest probability way of delivering the outcome that i think this country can have which is getting it back on its feet and becoming one of the most powerful prosperous countries in the world again which is what i'm reasonably young in political terms i take i view this as a multi-decade project that's's what the outcome I think Britain can have. The highest probability way of us getting there is a majority of turquoise-blooded reform MPs who are going to vote through things, the primary legislation, and you know that's
46:58what's important. And if we succeed in doing that, Michael, then we can do the things that we need to do. And institutionally, if the Conservative Party just disappeared, would that make things easier? Well, we're in extreme hypotheticals. It would. But again, I want to be clear to people watching this that sometimes people will try to position me as just sort of, again, irrationally angry about certain things. I am angry about certain things. It's not irrational. And again, I'm a practical person, which is why I've done the things that I've done in my life. I firmly believe that there is a path to which we can get this country back on its feet. And I also see a failure mode. This is another way of putting it. One failure mode for the country of the next decade is we get
47:41another Labour government or Rainbow Coalition. I totally accept that, right? And no one is more acutely aware than I am of what that would mean for the country. I don't think there's a path back to a Britain that me, you or I, or people watching this would recognise as this country. There's another failure mode, which is we get another united right-wing government that ends up being dominated by the exact same people that got us into this mess in the first place and end up actually delivering a worse outcome than we would have got even under labor and that's why i go back to the point about what boris did with the boris wave being even more damaging than what i think because i don't think jeremy corbyn would
48:18have been competent enough to execute yeah you'd be been caught up in other things. And so I'm acutely aware of that failure mode. And that's why I'll go to the wall on these issues and stand up for it and make the argument to your viewers that that's why we need Nigel as our prime minister. I'm not saying there are not... I've met decent people who are former Tory ministers. Now, granted, they were defeated by the blob. Fair enough. Some of them, by the way, in the background are giving us data on that and trying to help us you know that indiana jones film where he goes through in the cave and i don't even remember that where his dad is sort of reading the book as the last crusade you know and there's the the big uh saber that comes out to
48:58behead him and stuff and all of these other people have made that journey to try to get to um the the holy grail they they end up being taken out by let's call it the blob um in this film and he ends up getting through it and that is how i look at how difficult this is i think one thing people are not necessarily aware of you are because you've been in it you've these people on, to do the things we are talking about here and might casually talk about in a video or whatever, you know, we're going to do all these things. The level of difficulty that it is going to take, it is going to take the most talented people in this country with the highest level of conviction, willing to go to the wall on things and put themselves and frankly, their own families,
49:42safety at risk to do it. And that is why I feel very strongly about it and why the personnel, somebody who built a company from scratch, sold it for quite a lot of money in the end, made some good hires, made some bad hires. I have some experience of this. The people is what it comes down to. And that's why I'll keep making these arguments. Very clear. Just three final questions. What's your favorite movie? What's your favorite book? And what's your favorite piece of music? of Cambridge but a film that I probably watched more than any other I love the back to the future films I love them because they gave me they remind me of my childhood and what that sense of hope that I had for what the future could look like and a lot of the acting is extremely I mean you've
50:35seen them yeah yeah but they were you know this idea of the end of every film there was always this message that your future was whatever you chose to make it, despite all the trials and tribulations on that. And it was all born around the credible power of human ingenuity. Again, kind of a ridiculous films and lots of things, but I watched those films a lot. And in fact, I watched them so much on VHS that eventually these VHS, they wore out. I couldn't watch them anymore. Um, so I, I really enjoyed those. And I continue to. There's actually a great line in one of them stuck in my mind, which is the car sort of goes up and he goes, oh, you're going to run out of road getting to 88 miles an hour.
51:14And Dr. Emmett Brown, you know, the wild outside, he goes, roads where we're going, we don't need roads. And that always stuck in my mind. So I've always, that created one of many films actually of the time that created a huge sense of enthusiasm about what the future could hold. And that's kind of core to my belief system. What were the other questions? A book. Okay, so book. So this one is going to sound certainly at risk of sounding like intellectual pontification. But Man's Search for Meaning was incredibly influential on me because one of the things that you always try to do as a human being when you're faced with challenging situations is try to place them into context. Maybe you can relate to that.
51:55And when you read that book about what he went through in those camps, and he describes some of those things that kind of seared into my consciousness, some of those passages about a head bouncing. I still remember a head. He heard the thud of the head bouncing down the stairs. And yet he came out of it and he was imbued by this sense of hope and responsibility to his loved ones that he kept core to his belief system throughout that and therefore whatever i might go through in politics whatever you might go through but whatever people watching this might go through what human beings are able to go through and not just go through but go through with their head held high and then not only come out of that but
52:42deliver this extraordinary piece of literary work that I don't think I'm the only person upon whom that it had enormous influence. So that would be, that was a book, I can't say I've read it repeatedly, but it has stuck in my mind. No, no, no, it's had a profound influence. A huge influence on me, yeah. And finally, favourite piece of music. My favourite pieces of music are very much driven by what was popular when I was in my late teenage years. I think I'm going to be honest. You know, I could tell you it was Brahms and Mozart. It wasn't. You know, I actually really like rap music. I remember driving in my car. I remember 50 Cent's first album or first major album i really liked that music i liked
53:29um edgier rap as well at that time as well i really liked that stuff um again it gave me i didn't come from much and it gave me a sense of it imbued as a sense of a willingness to go and try to do things in the world like like that you had sense of agency. Energy and possibility. Yes, exactly. And I think I read a study actually recently that actually that's the case for all of us. You can really predict who you think, you know, who your favorite musicians are and songs are, again, defined as which music you continue to listen to based on what was popular in your late teens. Sadly, I'm no different. Nope. Zia Youssef, thank you very much. Thank you. Thank you. We'll see you next time. Grab more dessert and stay a little longer. Wayfair makes it easy, with everything from dining furniture to festive guest room essentials, all in one place.
54:48So whether you're hosting for an afternoon or all weekend, everyone feels right at home. Get holiday guests ready at Wayfair.com or on the Wayfair app today. Wayfair, every style, every home. Subscribe to The Spectator and get 12 weeks of Britain's most incisive politics coverage, unrivaled books and arts reviews and so much more, all for just £12. Not only that, but we'll also send you a £20 Amazon gift card, absolutely free. Go to www.spectator.com forward slash voucher to claim this offer now.

