podcasts / Best of the Spectator / episode
Best of the Spectator cover art
podcast
📅 2026-11-15 ⏱ 24 min episode 📝 Transcript · 3,822 words

Holy Smoke: Pope Leo's homecoming – the strange Catholicism of Peru

Best of the Spectator · · Transcript & summary by WhipScribe

Read the transcript Episode page ↗
🔔 Get every new Best of the Spectator transcript by emailOne email per new episode. Unsubscribe in every message.
One email per new episode, unsubscribe in every message. Not shared with the publisher.

Summary, chapters and key takeaways for this episode are on their way; the transcript below is complete.

▸Transcript

Our own transcript of the public episode, with a timestamp about every 90 seconds. Tap a timestamp to play the episode from there in the show's own player; the link button on a paragraph copies a link that opens this page there.

0:00Hey, we're Nick and Jack, hosts of The Best One Yet. Behind every episode, there's research, email, spreadsheets, and our shared Google Doc, the headline hammer. With Google Workspace with Gemini, Google's AI is built right into the premium versions of tools we already use, like Gmail, Docs, and Sheets. No new tools or extra logins, just personalized AI for the way we work. That means less time on the work, around the work, and more time finding the stories worth talking about. Get AI tools for work. Upgrade to Google Workspace with Gemini at goo.gle slash workspace with Gemini. That's goo.gle slash workspace with Gemini. Welcome to Holy Smoke, the Spectator's Religion podcast. I'm Damian Thompson.

0:50Pope Leo has begun his emotional homecoming to Peru, the final-born pontiff, known affectionately in Peru as Padre Robert, landed in Lima to a sea of flags and cheers. Estimates put the crowds at three million as he rode through the streets, declaring with visible emotion, and he's very given to visible emotion, I'm returning to my homeland. Now, earlier, of course, he'd been in Uruguay and then in Argentina, where millions packed the streets and plazas for outdoor masses, the biggest gatherings of his pontificate so far. But now he's back in the country that, to a remarkable extent, shaped him even more than you might think. I mean, one would expect a missionary and a bishop from another country to identify very

1:53strongly with his new country, but the bond is very powerful indeed. And it started me thinking about Peruvian Catholicism and what about it is so attractive to Pope Leo and what makes it so interesting. Because I've been out there and I've seen how strange Peruvian religion can be. Well, Thomas Munson has written a fascinating article in The Critic about religion in Peru, about Catholicism in Peru. And he makes the point that the adoption of Catholicism in Peru hasn't been as straightforward as it has been elsewhere. Traditions adapted from the Incas have proved to be incredibly resilient. And Peru is one of the places in Latin America where there are the most obvious examples of religious syncretism,

2:51the fusion of ostensibly competing religious beliefs. So, Thomas, thank you very much for joining us. Could you just give me a picture of Peruvian Catholicism and how it compares to Catholicism in other Latin American countries? Of course. I think where Peru is particularly unique in very large indigenous population or the descendants of indigenous population in Peru. And so therefore, the way that Catholicism has integrated within that society is notably different. So take in Argentina, for example, Argentinians almost identify as European, who just sort of happen to live in South America, whereas there's a distinct culture within Peru. And so how that sort of manifested itself is that you have the presence of Catholicism, of course,

4:01you know, if you've been to Cusco yourself, so you're in the square, you see the large cathedral there. But, you know, there are also a lot of people who practice sort of more traditional Incan sort of ceremonies and behaviours. Actually, one sort of striking example I saw, and you see this all over the place across Peru, is you'll have a cross, a sort of Christian cross. And then next to them, you'll have these sort of two ceramic bulls, which are sort of homage to the Pachamama and Mother Earth. And so you have Christ, the depiction of Christianity alongside these sort of more incurred traditions and beliefs. And you mentioned the Pachamama. Well, everybody who follows Catholic politics is now familiar with this fertility and earth-spiritual goddess

5:00in Andean indigenous traditions, especially by Quechua-speaking people in Peru and Bolivia and Ecuador. It became notorious. The figure of the Pachamama became notorious because in October 2019, during the Pontificate of Pope Francis, there was a synod of bishops for the Pan-Amazon region, and wooden carvings of a nude pregnant indigenous woman were carried around in ceremonies. There was a treaty planting and prayer event in the Vatican gardens, and Pope Francis and various people bowed in front of this figure who was described by some as Our Lady of the Andes or of the Amazon or something like that, but looked to everybody else very much like an image of the Pachamama, perhaps one that had been made for tourists and picked up triply.

5:51I thought that was a funny detail. But the scandal it caused was enormous. And one of the things that surfaced recently is an old grainy photograph of Father Robert Prevost, I think as a missionary rather than as Bishop of Chiclayo, kneeling down at some gathering where there is one of these Pachamama stroke, you know, Virgin of the Andes figures. Do you have any insight on that? Because it's mentioned all the time, for example, on Catholic social media. Well, I mean, I think that's a great example of the this insincretism that we mentioned at the top of the top of the episode you know you have as I as I spell out in the article as well you know part of the success of Catholicism has been its

6:39ability to kind of mold itself and integrate itself with the sort of various cultures across the world where it where it's practiced you know and you might call that an enculturation but where it perhaps can go too far and then this would be a good sort of pachamama example is is the where it becomes syncretism so when you when you have somebody who claims to be Catholic, but also worshipping a separate deity, which, at least as an observation, seems to be something that's fairly commonplace. And I think where that's particularly interesting is that the Pope himself earlier this year was talking about the importance of enculturation, he was talking about the importance of Catholicism, kind of sort of almost taking on some of the aspects of other cultures where it's practiced.

7:29But that raises a more existential question for the church itself, for the Vatican itself, I think, because, you know, if you take that up to a certain point, if you go too far, then is it really still Catholicism anymore? I mean, part of another one of the strengths of Catholicism, of course, is how ancient it is and the fact that it's rooted in something and it takes hundreds of years sometimes to deliberate any kind of change at all. So it begs the question of, you know, is the fact that a Pope from Peru, where you have so much syncretism and it's obviously been such an influence on his religious life where he talks about enculturation is is it actually enculturation that point or has it gone too far in in peru and i think that's where it's

8:18particularly interesting to see how this visit goes it's a a good question. I mean, I've ploughed through quite a lengthy volume of the Pope's pre-pontifical speeches mostly to his fellow Augustinians. It's not a page-turner, I have to say. I didn't come across even a hint of sympathy for syncretism, but then, you know, perhaps in that context, the subject wouldn't have come up. The Pachamama incidents in the Vatican did cause terrific scandal, probably more even than we realized, because while various traditionalists were completely hysterical about these, I think, rather unpleasant and troubling scenes. Lots of bishops and cardinals throughout the world were very troubled but didn't particularly,

9:08in the sort of vengeful atmosphere of the Bergoglio pontificate, didn't want to say anything about it. But Leo seems to be different. I mean, my line in articles, and I do get attacked for this on Twitter all the time, but it's that Leo is essentially orthodox. I can't explain this grainy photograph of him kneeling in front of a Pachamama figure, but maybe if he understood it to be some sort of native image of the Virgin Mary, then it's understandable. Yeah, perhaps so. And, you know, I think it's also important to make the distinction between the cultural and the religious. And I think perhaps sometimes those two things can become conflated, where if you're in Peru, it's only natural that indigenous culture

9:57is going to be present, and that naturally affects the behaviours of the people who live there and their traditions and so on but that doesn't necessarily make it religious and in the same way that you know you could describe oneself as maybe being culturally culturally christian because you adopt christian practices and you have a sort of christian code, even if you don't explicitly actually consider yourself to be a practicing Christian. And so while you have these behaviors being exhibited, including by the indigenous people too, that doesn't necessarily make them a religious practice. I think that where Catholicism has been thrust upon many indigenous people, the practices that come with that have kind of become a way of life,

10:48even if they themselves haven't been baptized, they don't necessarily believe in an explicit God in that sense. I think it's worth making the point that among many developing peoples around the world, the sharp distinction that we make in our minds between religious and non-religious, religious and secular, religious and pagan behavior doesn't necessarily exist. I mean, syncretism is a feature of Latin American religion, maybe not so much in European Argentina, but elsewhere in the continent. There's a tremendous amount of syncretism in Brazil and certainly on the fringes of Brazilian Catholicism. Obviously, there's a lot of syncretism in the Caribbean. Some of it's borrowed from West Africa, where in turn,

11:36both Protestant and Catholic Christianity are heavily flavoured with syncretism. So it's almost like an anthropological, you know, obstacle to Christian evangelism wherever you encounter developing peoples. Yeah, no, I think that's certainly my observation from my time there. And it'll be interesting to see what the impact of the visit is afterwards. You know, the Pope's visiting Peru at a particularly interesting time in Peruvian politics. There's a lot of concern about gun violence and crime and the economy and so on. And, you know, I think that the Pope is considered vastly more credible than the elected officials of the day at the moment and so you know if he does something similar to what he did in argentina where he was actually quite critical of many of

12:31malay's policies on the economy and and so on it'll be interesting to see what kind of impression that makes not just amongst the sort of the religious community within Peru, but also within the political landscape of Peru. And then in terms of his governance, his papacy, as I should say, going forward with that strong Peruvian influence that obviously he's had because he first came to Peru in the 1980s. It'll be interesting to see if that influences the direction of the Vatican or the direction of the policies of the Vatican. I wonder how it might do that. I mean, it is interesting that Robert Priebus has been so profoundly inspired by the country of Peru to the extent that his Peruvian Spanish is almost perfect.

13:22And interestingly, he's made a point of switching his Spanish accent from Argentina to Peru, so that he's now speaking in the Peruvian Spanish accent with which he's most familiar. One rarely reads, if ever, that Robert Priebus was profoundly influenced by his American Catholic upbringing. It always seems to be Peru. I wonder what it is about, I wonder whether there's a sort of political, a political statement almost buried in his preference, as it were, for his adopted homeland over his original homeland, if it's fair to say that, which it sometimes seems to be. Yeah, I mean, Peru is, we have to admit that Peru which it sometimes seems to be. Yeah, I mean, Peru is, we have to admit, Peru is a pretty mystical place, you know,

14:09steeped in all sorts of ancient tradition and beautiful landscapes. And I can certainly see if you were drawn towards mysticism or you had any kind of inclination in that sort of direction, I could certainly see how one could get sucked in in a way that perhaps one wouldn't as a practicing Catholic in, say, Chicago, for example. Yeah. So I'm not surprised, having been there. And it'll be interesting to see what happens with the rest of his visit, of course, as well. I mean, in Argentina, he was extremely well received. Argentina, by the way, is a fairly secular country. I mean, even the cathedral in Buenos Aires is actually designed not to look like a cathedral at all. It actually looks, when you're in the centre, the town, the city centre,

14:57it actually looks like a city hall or like the sort of building that a mayor would live in or something like that. It was done intentionally not to upset the secular community within Argentina. So it's sort of, you know, and he's been very well received there for the reasons that I set out with Peru as well, where there's sort of, in the absence of confidence in government and elected officials, then the Pope sort of takes on a new role in these countries. I'm wondering how strong Catholicism is in Peru, because there are countries in Latin America where Catholicism is conspicuously weaker than it was just 20 years ago, and Brazil is a very obvious example. What's been the sort of trajectory of the Catholic Church in Peru

15:45since, I don't know, since the Second Vatican Council, let's say? Do you have any idea? I think a lot of the Catholicism across Latin America has been heavily influenced more recently by the nature of the immigration throughout the continent. And so countries, actually, again, to mention Argentina, countries like Argentina have seen a up an uptake in the amount of people going to mass where there are sort of increasing number of immigrants from countries like venezuela and so on peru hasn't had that to the same extent um i think because of the the economics of the country ch Chile has seen an uptake in Catholicism as well. Again, you have a lot of economic immigration throughout the continent,

16:32whereas Peru actually doesn't. It's not got that same appeal, largely because of the growing drug crime in the country. I understand that Peru has overtaken Colombia as a producer of cocaine, for example. And so they're not having large amounts of Catholic immigration into the country. Yeah, I can understand that. And it does feel like a more, it doesn't feel like necessarily a natural destination for immigrants. I had a very strange experience in Peru 25 years ago when I visited, I think, the ultimate demonstration of Peruvian syncretism, which was a group called the Israelites of the New Universal Covenant, who had been founded by a man called Ezequiel Atacuzi-Gamonal, who had been a Catholic, then a Seventh-day Adventist and now was presenting

17:28himself as a Hebrew prophet and the next Messiah. And his followers dressed as Old Testament Jews, and they founded colonies in the jungle, which are still thriving 25 years after the death and failed resurrection of the Messiah, Ezekiel. But I must say, I mean, just look at the photographs. It's an extraordinary demonstration, seeing these tiny Andean peasants dressed like extras from a Cecil B. DeMille film. Extraordinary demonstration of Peruvian syncretism. I've just checked, about 27% of Peruvian Catholics attend mass weekly. That's not an impressive total given Peru's history as a Catholic country. And by comparison, 57% of Protestants in Peru report weekly attendance. Is evangelicalism a significant presence in Peru?

18:45I mean, a very, very significant presence in Brazil, the headline hammer. With Google Workspace with Gemini, Google's AI is built right into the premium versions of tools we already use, like Gmail, Docs, and Sheets. No new tools or extra logins, just personalized AI for the way we work. That means less time on the work, around the work, and more time finding the stories worth talking about. Get AI tools for work. Upgrade to Google Workspace with Gemini at goo.gle slash workspace with Gemini. That's goo.gle slash workspace with Gemini. That's goo.gle slash workspace with Gemini. It's not something that just as an observer that I saw a tremendous amount of evidence of personally, but it's important as well when we talk about Peru as one entity, it's

19:20quite a divided country, both geographically and of course historically for the reasons we talked about before when one is in lima that feels much more spanish and much more catholic and virtually every taxi you get in is you've got a cross hanging from the dashboard and so on which isn't surprising when you've seen the standard of driving in Lima. You definitely want some sort of divine protection. And then when you go to places like Cusco and so on in the Andes, it's less visible, certainly. And then when you go to the, you know, so I've been to Iquitos, then you're in the Amazon, and that's like a third culture. I've been looking at the statistics as we speak. Peru is quite low down the list of Catholic countries in terms of mass attendance.

20:15I mean, Mexico is up at 41%, Colombia 40%, Brazil 36%, and then quite a big drop to Peru, 27%, and then, perhaps no surprise, Argentina 12%, and Chile, 8%. What on earth is going on there, I wonder? Wow. I mean, Chile has a history of not being a particularly religious country anyway. You know, a lot of people, of course, have been exiled from Chile over the years. I think a lot of the older population have stayed where they're exiled to. So you have a lot of Chileans living in Germany and in Sweden, for example. And so statistically speaking, those people are probably more likely to be Catholic rather than the younger population. And it's the younger population who are there in Santiago, across Chile now.

21:07So a lot of that, I think, is to do with the legacy of the Pinochet regime. So just talking about the Pope in Latin America, any Pope in Latin America, any Pope in any country, it seems, but especially this Pope. Hard to believe that he was having surgery for lung cancer just three or four weeks ago, whenever it was. The crowds are absolutely enormous. Will there be a legacy? Yeah, that's a good question. I think that there are many things, there are many factors that will lead to there being a legacy to this visit. I think it's come at a very important time in Latin American history, generally. If you look at the politics of the continent, there seems to be, you've had this period of time where many of these countries have moved gradually towards democracy and have sort of stabilized.

22:03And then in more recent years there's been some lurches towards autocracy again president cast in chile for example is almost like a sympathizer i mean he actually voted in the plebiscite for pinache to continue instead of the adoption of democracy and he's the first chilean to do that. And so because of the political environment and the political context of Latin America at the moment, I think it's natural that more people will turn towards an authority that isn't an elected one. The more people will turn towards the church as opposed to their elected leaders. In fact, this is something that's sort of beginning to happen in Cuba too I was reading recently that as the the government sort of

22:51beginning to unravel and the economic conditions are worsening and so on in Cuba that there's been a revival in Catholicism in Cuba where obviously that was essentially prohibited under Fidel Castro before. So it's definitely trending, I would say, in a Catholic direction. As to whether this visit itself ends up being a significant factor in that is another question. But in the case of Peru more specifically, I think to have somebody who so clearly loves that country, who has become a naturalized citizen of Peru, can only stand to increase the level of interest and enthusiasm for Catholicism in the church in Peru. And it is a personal triumph for Pope Leo. I mean, it's not just that he's recently undergone a serious operation.

23:43It's that people are immensely attracted by his charismatic yet self-effacing personality, if that makes sense. His readiness to show emotions, for example. He has a very dignified way of crying, but he does cry quite a lot. And I imagine that doesn't go down badly in Latin America, to be honest, or indeed anywhere else. So I think we can say at the very least that this tour, not just to Peru, has been a personal triumph for the Pope. Do you agree? Yeah, absolutely. And a huge testament to him as well. As you said, he recently had an operation on his lung. And now, you know, he's going to a high altitude environment that actually carries a significant level of risk and will no doubt be a drain on his health too.

24:28And yeah, you're right. I've been to Cusco. I know what it feels like. You do too, I'm sure. Well, I actually ended up in hospital with altitude sickness so I know exactly what it feels like. But yeah, he's done very well. You can see he's visibly moved by the reception that he's received. And as you say, he's done very well. You can see he's visibly moved by the reception that he's received. And as you say, he's got a dignified way of presenting as well. I mean, I personally don't really like public figures showing excessive levels of emotion, but he does seem to have a way of, as you said, doing it in a dignified way. He does. And it's very moving. Thomas Munson, so enjoyable talking to you.

25:08I hope that we will have another conversation again very soon. Thank you. Hey, I'm Farnoosh Tarabi, host of the So Money podcast. One thing I learned from talking to entrepreneurs, your time is one of your most valuable resources. With Google Workspace with Gemini, Google's AI is built right into the premium versions of tools like Gmail, Google Docs, and Sheets. No new tools or extra logins, just AI to help you work smarter. Because less time spent on busy work means more time building the business you believe in. Get AI tools for work. Upgrade to Google Workspace with Gemini at goo.gle slash workspace with Gemini. www.gpectator.com forward slash voucher to claim this offer now.

▸More episode summaries

Best of the Spectator cover art
Best of the SpectatorReality Check: is the AI boom a bubble – or the next big revolution?2026-11-16 · 32 min
Best of the Spectator cover art
Best of the SpectatorQuite right!: Zia Yusuf interview2026-11-18 · 52 min
Transcribe your links. Paste a YouTube, Google Drive or podcast link and WhipScribe gives you the transcript. Transcribe a link →
New Best of the Spectator transcripts by email
One email per new episode, unsubscribe in every message. Not shared with the publisher.