podcasts / What A Day / episode
What A Day cover art
podcast
📅 2026-11-17 ⏱ 29 min episode 📝 Transcript · 4,855 words

1728: Has America’s Tech Reached Its Breaking Point?

What A Day · · Transcript & summary by WhipScribe

Read the transcript Episode page ↗
🔔 Get every new What A Day transcript by emailOne email per new episode. Unsubscribe in every message.
One email per new episode, unsubscribe in every message. Not shared with the publisher.

Summary, chapters and key takeaways for this episode are on their way; the transcript below is complete.

▸Transcript

Our own transcript of the public episode, with a timestamp about every 90 seconds. Tap a timestamp to play the episode from there in the show's own player; the link button on a paragraph copies a link that opens this page there.

0:00I think both in public and in the media now when things happen, there is this kind of, you know, spidey sense like, ah, this is this it? Is it starting? Is the great, you know, grid power down happening, right? Do we need, you know, do we need to go and buy some Infowars survival gear or whatever. It's Tuesday, November 17th. I'm Jane Koston, and this is What A Day. President Donald Trump, a cool, normal guy, arrived in the Philippines today. He met with leaders from Australia, India, and Japan. But he could not escape all the controversy still swirling here at home with service outages involving the National Security Agency, Microsoft, the Federal Aviation Administration, and online banking with

0:58JPMorgan Chase. And his words do not inspire confidence. Are you concerned about all these outages? Microsoft, FAA, United, the Chiefs Bank? It's life when you're big and powerful and you have all the money. Things like that happen. It's fine. It's not fine. You might be fine, but it is not fine. I am not fine. Many people are not fine. Anyway, back to those deals. Trump signed a trade statement with Thailand and said that he was looking forward to, quote, finalizing the details of our formal agreement in the coming weeks. The Philippines is Trump's first stop on a three-day trip that will later take him to China for historic three-way nuclear talks with Chinese President Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin

1:43and, according to Trump, potentially for a meeting with North Korea's leader Kim Jong-un. Again, what a party. Acting Navy Secretary Hong Kao, normal guy, is seeking the permanent top civilian job. Senators from both major political parties pressed him in his confirmation hearing today about the impact of long-ship deployments on sailors and the eight suicide attempts on the USS Abraham Lincoln aircraft carrier during its record-breaking deployment. But Hung Kao, again, very normal guy, said we all need to stop being so negative because, quote, I see eight suicide mitigations. Yeah, it's like attempted murder isn't bad. It's a success because it was just an attempt. No one got murdered. It's fine.

2:35Remember, we're all fine. Well, I'm not fine. Lawmakers raised concerns about the lack of an aircraft carrier in the Asia-Pacific as the Trump administration has shifted resources to the Middle East. A third aircraft carrier arrived in the region yesterday. The U.S. has lost its measles-free status. Congratulations, RFK Jr. The Pan-American Health Organization says the highly contagious virus, once relegated to medical textbooks, has spread largely among the unvaccinated at the highest rate in more than 30 years. Mexico also lost its measles elimination status following a resurgence of the virus there that included a massive outbreak in Chihuahua State. Bolivia, too, lost its status. This may be seen as the beginning of an era in which diseases of the

3:25past become deadly problems for the modern world. Looking forward to the leprosy reemergence next. Great. Remember, we're fine. But I want to talk about AI, big tech, and why everyone is mad and Silicon Valley just doesn't get it. Joining me is Charlie Worzel, staff writer at The Atlantic. Charlie Worzel, welcome back to What A Day. Thank you for having me. So you've said that the backlash from voters on AI and tech, and the backlash seemed to come from pretty much everyone, it was bigger than data centers. So after the midterms, what was that backlash against? Let's put it this way. The data center backlash, I think, is actually like I've talked about data centers as this like national pain sponge, right?

4:13Like you can direct any ire that you have about the world, right? You could, it's like the environmental concerns, tech's physical incursion into your neighborhood, town, backyard, the circular potential bubble of the AI economy, just the fact that you dislike tech billionaires, obviously that you dislike artificial intelligence. If you have any of those feelings in any way, you can direct them at data centers. So in a way, it is about data centers, but it's also about more than that. And I think what you saw, especially in Texas with Elon Musk'sico did a great job of painting this election as the tech oligarchs are trying to buy it. They're trying to buy you. And frankly, we're not going to let that happen. And I think that that was a broad feeling across

5:17the United States in these elections where there was tech money. And so I think, you know, what we are seeing right now post-election is that both Silicon Valley and Donald Trump are extremely unpopular and they have, Silicon Valley has yoked themselves to Donald Trump, sort of compounding all of that. So I think something else that binds them is that both Silicon Valley and Donald Trump are very unpopular and neither Silicon Valley nor Donald Trump have any means of understanding how unpopular they are. So I repeat myself who are defending former NVIDIA CEO Jensen Wong, including making a weird AI version of him that replaces him as Trump in the photo after the Butler attempted assassination. or an actual normal person. And you see all of these tech people being like, this guy who at best had multiple affairs,

6:28including with at best a Chinese cutout for a company that does nothing and has no offices. And he resigned from that company because the company was like, seems bad. And you're like, this guy's too important. He's so awesome. He's so cool. Actually, his wife is bad. Actually, we have to too important. He's so awesome. He's so cool. Actually, his wife is bad. Actually, we have to defend him. Elon should hire him. Like, you're like, these people are weird. And there's new polling from CNBC that found that every AI leader, so Elon, Jensen Wong, Sam Altman, all these people are distrusted by at least 65% of young people. So how siloed is big tech right now? Well, they're siloed in a lot of ways.

7:08Twitter is the manifestation of that. Obviously, I really liked, I think it was Ezra Klein who has that idea that Twitter is like the monkey's paw, right? Whoever is sort of ascendant in terms of either being on Twitter as a culture or who owns it, you know, drives themselves crazy. And I think that there's a lot of truth to that, for sure. But there's also a insular and niche culture in the Bay Area in general, right, around artificial intelligence. There is this feeling that, you know, you can see the future first in San Francisco, that, you know, about 1500 people are determining the future of humanity forevermore, building these artificial intelligence models. You know, these people are also getting obscenely wealthy later this week, anthropical IPO, and there will be like a

7:58entire fleet of centimillionaires that, you know, yesterday were not. And so that is inflating egos and importance around these things. Right. And I also think it's directing what they're interested in, which is why it seems like every Silicon Valley conversation that I witness or overhear is about restaurant reservations. They are obsessed with restaurant reservations. And I'm like, guys, come on. They do seem to be trying to marshal, you know, the super intelligence that they feel that they've created towards, you know, getting a good table, which I think is, you know, if you really have created super, super intelligent, autonomous agent, there's got to be better uses for that. Right. But I think that there's this third bucket

8:42of, of people, which is these founders and these leaders and the think fluencers of the Bay Area who, you know, have kind of radicalized themselves in a lot of group chats and things like that. People like Mark Andreessen. And I think what you are seeing in response to the Jensen Wang stuff is actual fear. This is an existential thing for them, I think, because not only is Wang actually, in reality, a very load-bearing figure in the AI economy, because he is sort of, you know, NVIDIA personified. NVIDIA is this really influential company at the center of the AI boom for a lot of reasons we can talk about. But he's also seen as the visionary, right? He is the guy who made this huge bet on artificial intelligence, transformed his company, and then made all of this, you know, is a very scary thing for them because it means that the founder is replaceable.

9:50And I think that these guys have been walking through life thinking that if you do enough great stuff in your industry, you are above the law. And this would show that, you know, maybe that's not true. Yeah. I think it's also interesting because you get a window into a silo in which people are perceived only for the things they want to be perceived for. So you see there's this meme online of how people are like really defensive of Elon Musk to the point where I'm like, I'm pretty sure that you either work for Elon Musk or are a autonomous agent created by Elon Musk in some manner. Because you see people who are like, how could anyone not like this great man who all he's ever done is try to get us a space? And I'm like, he tries to just

10:36impregnate people and foment a race war. Like, come on, man. Like, it's fascinating to watch people unable to see how they are perceived by people who do not already like them. But to that point, something else that, you know, Trump, you mentioned Trump and Silicon Valley really shoved in all their chips on each other. And now Silicon Valley is like, oh, we kind of forgot that there might be a chance that at some point Donald Trump would lose the semblance of power. And the Trump administration is like, oh, we kind of forgot that there might be a chance that at some point Donald Trump would lose the semblance of power. And the Trump administration is like, oh, we kind of forgot that this is all weird stuff that we don't really understand.

11:11But do you think that the rightward turn in big tech where everybody just was like, finally, we can use ethnic slurs again and we love racism and it's all great and we can talk about becoming great men, something, something, something, disempower working women, something, something. Do you think that rightward turn was really ever about belief or was it about permits and power and chips? I think that these things can get intertwined. I think it was mostly a business decision decision i think that you know they realized very quickly that donald trump is someone who as long as they could show that number go up that there was something in it for him and the people he surrounds himself with that they were going the trump administration

12:01would let them rip if they were sufficiently deferential to him. So I think that the kissing of the ring and all that stuff, I think that that is strategic. I think that you can't untie that from the opportunity that they all saw with AI development and infrastructure and the money that they could stand to make and the power they could stand to consolidate. I also think, again, that it is, you know, convenient, too, that a number of these founders, especially during the pandemic, really did get radicalized by the culture wars on places like X, but also in group chats and by, you know, some of the worker movements inside their own organizations around politics, around COVID, around, you know, the George Floyd protests, things like that. This idea that, you know,

12:52your workplace should be political. And certain people, again, Mark Andreessen has said publicly that he saw this as almost an existential threat to the business, to some parts of the tech industry. There's also a negative polarization against the Biden administration because the Biden administration wasn't giving a rubber stamp to a lot of these tech companies. There's also Lena Kahn and the way that she went after some of these tech companies and the way that Gensler went after crypto and things like that. So there's a whole confluence of factors. I do think that, you know, the culture war, you have to factor that in. But the money that they could stand to make with all of this, if they had the right person in office, that was the big reason.

13:40We'll get back to my conversation with Charlie Warzel in just a moment. What a Day is brought to you by Aura Frames. Everyday life is actually awesome. I've got photos of my dog on his daily walk or my husband and I at coffee shops in our home. And these are the moments I want to remember. Aura Frames makes it easy to relive them all by giving you a place to see all the photos you take in one beautiful frame. Life is amazing. Remember that with Aura Frames. Aura is the number one digital frame loved by millions of families, and their Black Friday Cyber Monday deal is the best of the year. Starting November 19th, visit auraframes.com and get up to $50 off select frames, plus an additional $5 off your order with the promo code WAD.

14:23That's A-U-R-A frames.com promo code WAD. Support the show by mentioning us at checkout. Terms and conditions apply. What a Day is brought to you by Casper. There are a few things in life you should never cheap out on, and the thing you spend eight hours a night on is definitely one of them. This podcast is sponsored by Casper. Casper makes reliable, high-quality mattresses designed to deliver consistent, comfortable sleep night after night. That's why, out of 99 mattresses, Consumer Reports named Casper's The One Mattress their top-rated all-foam mattress of 2026. That's a big deal. And if you've been putting off replacing your mattress, consider this your sign. It's Casper's Black Friday and Cyber Monday sale.

15:04Head to Casper.com and save 30% on the mattress you deserve. Casper's mattresses are built to be durable and long-lasting, so you're not replacing your mattress every few years. Their products are designed to withstand the test of time, maintaining support and comfort over the long haul. And Casper has their 100-night risk-free trial, so you can give Casper's mattress a try risk-free. Although with 110,000 five-star reviews, I'm sure you're going to love it like I do. Because Casper is how I have a great night's sleep every night, which guarantees a good day every day. Remember, the day always ends well with Casper. Right now, save 30% on mattresses and up to 35% on everything else when you go to

15:42casper.com. And besides casper.com, you can find Casper at retail stores across the country. One last time, that's C-A-S-P-E-R.com and save up to 30% on the mattress you deserve. Let's get back to my conversation with Charlie Worzel. I feel like I've been burying the lead unintentionally because we're in the midst of all of these outages of various things, whether it's I don't work for the NSA. And if you're listening toAA ground stop last week, which got millions of people in massive amounts of trouble as they tried to get to or from their destinations. unhelpful because there's a Trump administration thing that they do where they will take an event, but they'll talk about it like they aren't in charge of determining what's going on.

16:50So, yeah, Trump does this where he's like, it's like he's watching it on television. And I'm like, but you're the president of the United States. You are the television we are watching. Don't look at me. Yeah. And so you had Mark Wynn Mullen saying today, you know, well, I'm like 99 percent sure it's not AI, but a very smart guy, not Elon, said, oh, it could all be AI. And it seems, one, does that seem plausible with everything that's taking place to you? But also, if even if it isn't, it seems like the American public is very wary of all of this. And AI has become just kind of a technical, a giant technological shift is happening. We don't understand it. And it seems big and scary. And people keep telling us it's going to take all of our jobs.

17:34And then you've got this added on. How is this landing with a public that is already wary? Okay. So I think a lot of things are happening in this outage moment. I'm glad that we're talking about this. So I think one thing that is happening is that, as you said, the public is extremely aware and concerned, and I think rightfully so, about the rise of AI agents and hacks and finding vulnerabilities in critical parts of our infrastructure everywhere. I think that's real. That's why people have been ringing the alarms about it. We've seen that. And so I think both in public and in the media now when things happen, there is this kind of spidey sense like, ah, is this it? Is it starting? Is the great grid power down happening?

18:20Do we need to go and buy some InfoWars survival gear or whatever? I think that's one thing. I think the second thing is that people are in the cybersecurity world and in a lot of these systems who manage these complex systems, they're responding to that. And so they're upgrading. If you talk to people in cybersecurity, they're saying it is a boom time right now. Everyone is trying to harden their defenses on all these things. They're trying to make sure that their systems are up to date. That's a really, really good thing. Like that is a system becoming resilient, responding to a threat in a way that we should all be happy about. Of course, when you upgrade systems like that, sometimes you screw up, you push an update that doesn't work bad, you switch out a copper wire or whatever. And, you know, because these things are all daisy

19:10chains, sometimes there's these big outages. So I think you have the response to a threat potentially maybe causing some of these things. I, right before I came on, I saw that report that the NSA outage was caused by a system update, right? Yeah. So that's a good thing. Like, we should be happy about the fact that people in critical parts of our infrastructure are trying to upgrade them. The third and final thing is the Trump administration, which, as you said, is the most unreliable narrator that you could possibly have at the helm of this. People who are just like speculating about stuff or blaming things or, you know, it sounds like in the case of Mullen there, he's basically like trying to talk about

19:53how he has a friend who's a, you know, a tech baron for clout. Very smart guy, but not Elon. Right. It's a little bit of, you know, we're all trying to find the guy who did this thing or who's in charge of this thing and it is them. And so I think that that adds this level of conspiratorial thinking that can that can result when you have people that you don't trust doing the messaging or, you know, are they all just lying to us? Is this is the cyber attack happening? But, you know, they're just But they're just feeding this out one by one by one. I don't think that that is happening necessarily, but it adds this cloud. So what you have is you have these three things all mashed together. And I think a lot of people

20:37both have their hackles up about it and freaked out. But my guess, if I had to guess what is actually the cause of a lot of this, I'd say that it's probably some small little hacks or bugs or things like that or vulnerabilities that have been found, but also a system that is responding to a threat in a way that should actually make you feel pretty good about the resiliency of it. I think it's worth reading this Mark Wayne Mullen quote in full because I want listeners and you, Charlie, to recognize this is the head of Homeland Security. Quote, I started talking to the tech industry, one guy that's very smart with tech. He asked not to mention his name. No, it's not Elon, so let me just put that out. I said, what could be causing all of these separate outages? And he says, I believe that it's the artificial intelligence. He said, SI, I'm not

21:28doing that. He said, because all of these programs aren't designed to work as fast as AI is. So when they put in a program that's able to write codes and it goes in, it self-fixes itself. As it starts self-fixing itself, it's like doing a change order on a house. When you change one thing in a house, everything else starts changing. That's a ripple effect. And it causes a system to be overrun that weren't designed to run as fast as the AI technology is today. I don't know what any series of those words meant. And I don't think Mark Wayne Mullen did. And I don't know if any of this actually happened. But to your point, my hackles are indeed up. So given everything that's happening right now,

22:07outages, just kind of a general national distrust of this industry and of tech, what is this industry's actual plan for the next two years of interacting with the public if they do have one? Because we've seen Alex Karp go with, I was a progressive the whole time, which I don't believe. I was telling Dasha Burns yesterday that I was like, I was alive. I was alive two years ago. I was there. I don't believe you. So Democrats want to have hearings. They've already said, you know, Judson Wong's already agreed to it. Democrats also, you know, they can hear what the public is saying. What is the industry's plan of how to interact with the public? And can anything short of regulation change how the public

22:51views this industry? Well, first off, I think you guys should have Karp put his money where his mouth is and ask him to host a progressive technology podcast on your guys' podcast network, right? Like make him do it. Make him do it. That would go over so well. Make him do it. It would go so great. I want these guys to commit. Like, Trump makes everyone commit, right? Like, kiss their rig. Like, okay, you want to say that you're a big-time progressive. Like, let's, you know, let's have you host a podcast with Naomi Klein or something. Anyway, okay, so... What is the tech industry going to do i think it's going to be really difficult for them i think they they face i mean you can see almost like no lessons learned

23:36here in the uh response to the nvidia jensen wong stuff right where they're just sort of like we're above the law like don't no no one should have to do anything even though you know again the logic is such a pretzel here right like this is a guy who had a potential dalliance with an asset of the industry's number one enemy and people are saying that we have to let this guy be excused and reinstate him back into his company in order that the AI boom continues so that we can beat our number one enemy, the guy who he may or may not have funneled information to. So they're not making a lot of sense. I think they're alienating people and pissing people off left and right. I think it's going to be really, really, really hard, especially as a

24:25Democratic Congress comes in and wants a lot of answers for lots of things, including potentially Doge and Elon Musk. Also, you have a younger Democratic Congress, so there should be fewer examples of senators asking random AI people to tell them how to turn off their phone or something. Right, right. You will have that. I think, though, that one of the things that people believe in Silicon Valley, and especially in the world of AI, which I think actually helps explain some of their behavior, is that they are building something that is so powerful that is going, that is, and there's some reason to believe that they're right about how powerful these things are, right? That they are building something that is going to be so powerful that is going to be able to improve itself, perhaps change the trajectory of science and technology and all kinds of academic fields, that they're in charge of something that is so self-evidently powerful that they don't actually have to, they won't need to do

25:26any explaining to anyone in the near future, right? I really think that they believe that. Like when you try to ask people, when I talk about the messaging to certain people in Silicon Valley, and I'm like, you're alienating everyone. Everyone thinks you guys are, to borrow your term, weird. They say, well, who cares? Like no one's going gonna have a job in five years like we may all be dead like we're taking up smoking because we don't care we're not saving for retirement because that doesn't make it better i i agree but i am also saying that is a little bit actually of the position that i think these people feel like either all of us are going to be dead or we're going to be so firmly instilled in the permanent upper class that it's not going to matter or that any demands that we have will be easily met once people realize how dangerous, powerful, you know, insert your adjective here.

26:21This artificial intelligence stuff really is. And so I just think that's some good context for everyone to have in some of these discussions it does make them seem even weirder and more alienating to the public but i think that they feel that they don't have to justify themselves to anyone all of these people not not one of them nose, not one of them, nose ball, not one of them, not a ball knower among them. Charlie Warzel, as always, thank you so much for joining me. Yeah, thanks for having me. That was my conversation with Charlie Warzel, staff writer at The Atlantic. Before we go, Democratic changemaker Stacey Abrams has a long track record of voting rights advocacy in the South. And after historic wins across Texas, Mississippi, and her home state of Georgia, she has a lot to say.

27:10On her show, Assembly Required, Stacey is having the deep dive conversations about how we got here and how to make these wins count. And fight back against right-wing authoritarianism with guests like Heather Cox Richardson, Jen Psaki, Susan Rice, and others. There's really no better person to hear from in a moment like this. New episodes of Assembly Required drop every Tuesday wherever you get your podcasts and on YouTube. That's all for today. If you like the show, make sure you subscribe, leave a review. J.D. Vance has zero juice. And tell your friends to listen. And if you aren't reading, and not just about J.D. Vance talking to Laura Ingraham about normal stuff last night. Laura, we could absolutely do this with Democrats

27:54in the new Congress if they set aside the ridiculous obsession with men and women's sports and did what they said they would do, which was focus on affordability and focus on rebuilding our infrastructure. Again, these Democrats, they ran on the Trump agenda of 2024. Let's work together and rebuild American infrastructure. I know the president wants to. I certainly do as well. Like me. What Today is also a nightly newsletter. Check it out and subscribe at Cricut.com slash subscribe. I'm Jane Koston, and the J. the JD Vance Talks Down to People Tour. It should end now. I'm tired of it and no longer want to hear from JD Vance. I never really wanted to hear from JD Vance, but also like it's over now.

28:38No, thank you. What a day is a production of Crooked Media. Our show is produced by Emily Fore, Erica Morrison, and Adrienne Hill. Our team includes Haley Jones, Greg Walters, Matt Berg, Adam Lippert, Johanna Case, and Desmond Taylor. Our music is by Kyle Murdoch and Jordan Cantor. We had help today from the Associated Press. Our production staff is proudly unionized with the Writers Guild of America East.

▸More episode summaries

What A Day cover art
What A Day1727: FAA Outage Not So Plane and Simple2026-11-16 · 29 min
Transcribe your links. Paste a YouTube, Google Drive or podcast link and WhipScribe gives you the transcript. Transcribe a link →
New What A Day transcripts by email
One email per new episode, unsubscribe in every message. Not shared with the publisher.