Ukraine: The Latest · · Transcript & summary by WhipScribe
Two hosts unpack why the Abu Dhabi peace talks went nowhere and what the Starshield dispute could mean for Ukraine's front line.
Tap a chapter to play it from that moment in the show's own player; the transcript opens there too.
“Unfortunately, this is helping the Russians kill more Ukrainians and carry out more accurate strikes against Ukraine.” Zelensky · at 4:51 — ▶ hear it from here
“And in the end, we accepted the ceasefire. But we said it shall not be unilateral.” Oleksandr Bevz · at 17:20 — ▶ hear it from here
The Abu Dhabi talks ended without a breakthrough, and the hosts read Moscow's stance as proof it is not serious about peace. Russia's delegation head, Vladimir Medinsky, said Russia would take every inch of Ukrainian land one way or another, while US envoys were welcomed in Moscow by sanctioned Kremlin ally Kirill Dmitriev, whom the hosts describe as a business-first dealmaker. The one concrete result so far is a planned prisoner swap of up to 1,500 people. The hosts also argue Russia is pushing talks toward European security, a framing that hands Moscow a win.
On the battlefield, President Zelensky accused Elon Musk of slowing his Starshield satellite network to about 100 miles an hour along the front, which he said let Russia strike Ukraine more accurately. The hosts also list a bad stretch for Russia: two Ka-52 attack helicopters reported lost near St Petersburg with seven crew killed, a colonel killed by a suspected car bomb, and an eight-hour drone attack on the Omsk refinery. Ukraine, meanwhile, expects its first Swedish Gripen fighters in early 2027.
Oleksandr Bevz, a presidential adviser to Ukraine, told the hosts that Russia has agreed to no ceasefire since the first Istanbul talks in May 2025. Dom Nicholls called the process a zombie process, arguing Russia is short of people and oil refineries and is looking for a framework to save face. Adelaide Pojman-Ponte countered that NATO has in fact kept European security working since the Second World War, and that Russia's talk of a broken system is a seed of doubt aimed at Washington.
President Zelensky said Starshield, the military version of Starlink, had been slowed again to about 100 miles an hour along the front line and in occupied Ukraine. He accused Elon Musk of putting Ukrainian lives at risk and said interception systems could not reach the speeds needed to stop some strikes in time.
“Unfortunately, this is helping the Russians kill more Ukrainians and carry out more accurate strikes against Ukraine.”Zelensky · 4:51
Oleksandr Bevz, an adviser to Ukraine's presidential office who was on the negotiating team, said Ukraine accepted a full ceasefire on sea, land and air after long discussions with the US, but insisted it could not be unilateral. He was not optimistic, because Russia has never agreed to any ceasefire since the Istanbul talks in May 2025.
“And in the end, we accepted the ceasefire. But we said it shall not be unilateral.”Oleksandr Bevz · 17:20
Dom Nicholls argued that NATO has done a pretty good job of European security since the Second World War. He said that, unlike the Russian claim that the post-war system is sick, NATO has kept the peace in Europe, with no third world war and Finland and Sweden joining the alliance. He accepted that NATO reform can be debated.
“As in, we haven't had a third world war.”Dom Nicholls · 23:12
The hosts said Kirill Dmitriev, who is sanctioned by the United States, runs the Russian Direct Investment Fund, a sovereign wealth fund of at least $10 billion that they described as a slush fund for Putin's network. He greeted US envoys on the Moscow tarmac with handshakes and hugs, and has emphasised business deals between the two countries.
“they were welcomed on the tarmac by Kirill Dmitriev with handshakes and hugs.”Adelaide Pojman-Ponte · 10:32
The Abu Dhabi peace talks ended without a breakthrough, with Russia's delegation vowing to capture every inch of Ukrainian land. The only concrete result was an agreement on the next prisoner of war swap, with up to 1,500 prisoners possibly exchanged within two to three weeks.
President Zelensky said Starshield, the military version of Starlink, had been slowed again to about 100 miles an hour along the entire front line and in occupied Ukraine. He accused Elon Musk of putting Ukrainian lives at risk through what he called systematic speed restrictions, not random errors. He said interception systems could not reach the speeds needed to stop some strikes in time, and that the issue had gone on for several days. Neither Washington nor Musk had commented on the allegation at the time.
The Abu Dhabi talks ended with no breakthrough, and the hosts describe the outcome as a collective shrug. Vladimir Medinsky, the head of Putin's delegation, said Russia would capture every inch of land one way or another, and the hosts read this as Moscow treating the talks as a win already in hand. The only concrete result was an agreement on the next prisoner of war swap, with up to 1,500 prisoners possibly exchanged in the following two to three weeks.
Oleksandr Bevz, an adviser to Ukraine's presidential office who sat on previous negotiating teams, said Ukraine accepted a full ceasefire across sea, land and air after long talks with the US, but insisted it not be unilateral. He said Russia has never agreed to any ceasefire since Ukraine first proposed one in Istanbul in May 2025. He was not optimistic, and said Russia is failing on the front line while trying to make life unlivable for Ukrainians.
Adelaide Pojman-Ponte argued that Russia's push to put European security architecture on the agenda is a Russian framing that sows doubt in the US about NATO's value. Dom Nicholls disagreed with the idea that Russia's critique has merit, saying NATO has done a pretty good job since the Second World War, with no third world war and Finland and Sweden joining the alliance. Both agreed NATO reform can be debated, but said the framing serves Moscow.
Kirill Dmitriev, who the US has sanctioned, welcomed US envoys with handshakes and hugs on the Moscow tarmac when they landed. He is a close Putin ally and the head of the Russian Direct Investment Fund, a sovereign wealth fund of at least $10 billion that the hosts describe as a slush fund. He led the US-Russia contacts after Trump's re-election and has emphasised business deals between the two countries.
President Zelensky said in Copenhagen that Ukraine expects its first Swedish-made Gripen fighters in early 2027. Sweden pledged in May this year to supply 16 new Saab JAS-39 Gripen C and D jets and to help Kyiv acquire up to 20 new Gripen E aircraft, backed by the EU's Ukraine support loan. The jets will join American F-16s and French Mirage 2000s in Ukraine's Western combat fleet.
Two Ka-52 attack helicopters were reported to have crashed near St Petersburg, killing their crews, after Ukraine's drone attack. The hosts say the reports were unconfirmed and that it is unknown if the losses were in the same incident. Russian channels reported seven aircrew killed, and one Russian telegram channel, Fighter Bomber, reported the deaths. Speculation in Russian channels points to a malfunction in an identification friend or foe system that led air defence to target Russia's own aircraft.
Our own transcript of the public episode, with a timestamp about every 90 seconds. Tap a timestamp to play the episode from there in the show's own player; the link button on a paragraph copies a link that opens this page there.
0:00The Telegraph And if nobody picks up, that call goes to your competitor. That's why over 90,000 companies choose Quo, the business phone built for busy teams. Smart call routing sends calls to the right person. Shared numbers let your team cover for each other. And an AI agent picks up when nobody can, capturing every lead. So nothing falls through the cracks. Money is on the line. Always say hello with Quo. Try Quo for free. Plus, get 20% off your first six months when you go to quo.com slash tech. That's Q-U-O dot com slash tech. This message is brought to you by today's sponsor, Walden University. Set a course for change. Now is the time to make a real change in your life, career, and community.
1:06At Walden University, we give you the support and flexibility to get the W. Walden's online programs are designed for working professionals like you. You'll gain hands-on skills to take on real-world challenges and succeed. Your future is waiting, and Walden is here to help you achieve it. Take the first step to make your impact. Visit waldenu.edu. Walden University. Set a course for change. Certified to operate by Chev. In 2010, newlyweds Debbie Cooper and Jamie Starbuck set off on a round-the-world honeymoon, but something wasn't right. We kind of started to scrutinize things a lot more. What exactly is going on here? Debbie was missing. We just looked at each other and said, so what's the next step?
1:49And it's like, police. He was a lovely little boy, but something happened to him to turn him into a monster. There's nothing off her, he just erased her. Missing Debbie, a new Bed of Lies podcast from The Telegraph. Out now. I'm Dom Nicholls and this is Ukraine The Latest. Today, after the peace talks in Abu Dhabi inevitably end without a breakthrough, with the head of Putin's delegation saying in the true spirit of a serious negotiator that Russia will capture every inch of land one way or another, Jared and Steve try to keep up the pretense of diplomatic momentum by heading to Moscow, with Mr Kushner saying, we see some openings and opportunities. Although whether he was talking about peace or future business deals,
2:35it's hard to tell. President Zelensky in Dublin for an EU gathering, let's hope he avoids the cartons of milk that were thrown at Joe Biden earlier this week, accuses Elon Musk of slowing down Starshield again and helping the Russians kill more Ukrainians. And Russia suffers a bad equipment day with the loss of helicopters, a frigate and a senior officer to another car bomb. Not all of that is equipment, just the colonel. Bravery takes you through the most unimaginable hardships to finally reward you with victory. The Russians is not one piece. First of all, we defend with our help for Ukraine also our freedom and our European values. If I'm president, I will have that war settled in one day, 24 hours.
3:23I will be steadfast in my support for Ukraine and stand up to threats wherever they come from. We cannot, as Europeans, let Russia win in Ukraine. Nobody is going to break us. We are strong. We are Ukrainians. It's Thursday, the 12th of November, four years and 261 days since the full-scale invasion began, and today I'm joined by my co-host Adelaide Pojman-Ponte. Now, as night follows day, just hours after the Abu Dhabi peace talks ended with a collective shrug, Russia launched Iskander-M and S-400 ballistic missiles, Zircon anti-ship missiles, and 123 long-range attack drones at ukraine last night in kiev one person was killed and others injured after a nine-story residential building in the
4:11western solomiansky district was hit elsewhere russia targeted power gridded to warehouses and agricultural facilities in dnipropetrovsk harkiv herzon helmanitsky and jitomir oblasts in total 10 people were killed and 40 injured across the country. Now, the only meaningful and serious outcome from the Abu Dhabi talk seems to be an agreement on the next prison of war swap. We're told numbers will be finalised today, but President Zelensky said yesterday that up to 1,500 prisoners of war may be exchanged, possibly in the next two to three weeks. President Zelensky also said Starshield, the military version of Starlink, had been slowed down again to 100 miles an hour, or 160-odd kilometres an hour,
4:51along the entire front line and in occupied Ukraine. He has accused Elon Musk of putting the lives of Ukrainians at risk, saying these are not random errors but systematic speed restrictions. Mr Zelensky wrote on X, Unfortunately, there have already been strikes that got through because our interception systems cannot reach sufficient speeds and are unable to intercept in time. Unfortunately, this is helping the Russians kill more Ukrainians and carry out more accurate strikes against Ukraine. He said the issue has been going on for several days and neither Washington nor Mr Musk have commented on the allegation, although President Zelensky said he was trying to establish all the circumstances
5:28with the American side. Now, I'm told by folks on the ground in Ukraine that Russia has taken full advantage of the Starshield issues recently to hit Zaporizhia with jet-powered drones, and I really don't want to think that the Russians have prepared in advance, knowing Starshield was about to go down. Next, and it's been a rough old 36 hours for Russia, in the northwest of the country in particular. First, after Ukraine effectively defeated Russia's Black Sea fleet, Kiev seems now to be expanding its campaign against Russian warships in the Baltic Sea. Overnight, Tuesday, Wednesday, Ukraine's SBU said it struck the narrow for misc that's a a bayan m-class corvette carrying caliber and onyx cruise missiles hit in the gulf of Finland
6:09then yesterday two ka-52 attack helicopters were said to have crashed killing the crews in the nearby St Petersburg area I've seen unconfirmed reports that the aircraft were attempting to shoot down Ukrainian drones at the time it's not known if the loss of the reported two helicopters was in the same incident. I've also seen reports that in fact three aircraft were lost, either two Ka-52s and an Mi-8 HIP helicopter or two Ka-52s and a MiG-31 jet. There is speculation in Russian channels of a malfunction in their identification friend or foe system, which caused air defence units to target their own aircraft during the Ukrainian drone attack. Either way, significant losses with seven aircrew reported killed.
6:56Ilya Tumanov, who's the author of the Russian telegram channel Fighter Bomber and someone considered a mad Russian propagandist but within the normal margins of error, reported the deaths but gave no further details. He said, Defending the skies over St Petersburg from a drone attack today came at a very high cost to us. A very, very, very high cost. May you fly forever, brothers. Fair enough. And still in St Petersburg, around 7am local time this morning, an explosion thought to have been a car bomb is reported to have killed another senior Russian officer. This one, a colonel, said to be the chief navigator of Russia's 6th Air Force and Air Defence Army. This is according to Russian media.
7:35Now, go east a little bit from St Petersburg, actually quite a lot, and you get to the Russian city of Omsk. That's about 2,500km from Ukraine. It's closer to Mongolia than Moscow. It's home to the largest oil refinery in Russia and overnight last night was subjected to an eight-hour drone attack. Local telegram channels reported that the region's airspace was closed and restrictions implemented on mobile internet. There are no details about any battle damage assessment. On to wider stories now, and the Financial Times are reporting that Romanian President Nicosua Dan has offered to pay Washington to retain American troops in Romania, countering potential US troop reductions across Europe. Presenting cost-sharing figures to US
8:16Defence Under-Secretary Elbridge Colby, President Dan proposed a financial arrangement mirroring Poland's September offer of US$15,000 annually per soldier for a planned permanent base. Romania currently hosts 1,172 US soldiers down from 1,700. They're primarily supporting the Dovesilu ballistic missile defence site and the strategic airbase Bucharest allowed Washington to use during its war against Iran. Now on the way to Ireland, President Zelensky stopped off in Denmark. He was speaking in Copenhagen and said that Ukraine expects to receive its first Swedish-made Gripen fighter jets in early 2027, expanding Kyiv's Western combat fleet alongside American F-16s and French Mirage 2000s. Sweden pledged in May this year to supply 16 new Saab JAS-39 Gripen C
9:03and D variant jets and assist Kyiv in acquiring up to 20 new Gripen E aircraft backed by the EU's Ukraine support loan and the Brits. Concurrently, Poland's deputy defence minister said Warsaw and Kiev signed an agreement establishing joint drone technology working groups while continuing talks on transferring two Polish MiG-29 fighters. Poland has previously supplied 14 MiG-29s in spring 2023. So, Adelie, as well as that comment at the start that I mentioned about taking every inch of Ukrainian territory, Vladimir Medinsky, Medinsky, he's the chap, Putin's chief negotiator in Abu Dhabi, he also parroted the line that Putin came out with last year, June last year saying, wherever a Russian soldier has
9:47set foot belongs to Russia. So clearly the person best placed to negotiate a peace treaty. They're nowhere near being serious about stopping the fighting and negotiating in good faith, are they? No matter how many air miles Steve and Jared rack up. Abu Dhabi was just about trying to influence the Americans about some fictional front line, an inevitable Russian victory, I think. Although interesting that President Zelensky said yesterday that U.S. negotiators had backed up Ukraine's assessment of the battlefield situation. They rejected Russia's false claim to control half of Ukrainian held Donbass. Don Bass. So before you do the rest of the diplomatic news, what do you think Steve and Jared are hoping they can get out of their Moscow and then Dublin trips, Dublin to see President Zelensky?
10:32Well, Dom, what are they going to do in Moscow? Well, I am no Sherlock Holmes, nor am I the trip organiser for Jared and Steve. They sound like the main characters of a really bad sitcom put like that. But they actually, we have one hint on what they might be doing in Moscow because they landed this morning and they were welcomed on the tarmac by Kirill Dmitriev with handshakes and hugs. So Kirill Dmitriev, for context, is sanctioned by the United States. He was also in the White House last week at the meeting with Melania Trump. So I'm not really sure how that works. Troubling his sanctions? Yep. He was actually born in Kiev, I found out this morning. I didn't know that. But he's also mostly a very close ally of Putin, as you know, and he is the CEO of the Russian Direct Investment Fund, which is a sovereign wealth fund of at least $10 billion,
11:27or also a slush fund in order to continue Putin's kleptocratic empire. So he was the lead negotiator sent to the US after Trump's re-election, and he has been emphasising business deals between the two countries. Sure, yes. So I am no Sherlock Holmes, as I said, but maybe that is a hint on what they were going to be discussing in Moscow. If you want to know more about their business dealings with Russia, I would point to the Wall Street Journal's excellent investigation from a year ago called Make Money Not War, Trump's Real Plan for Peace in Ukraine. I'll link that in the show notes. But later, the two envoys will be meeting with President Putin and Politico reports that they will ask for his blessing
12:09in order to allow European representatives to join future peace talks for Ukraine. So they who don't speak for Europe are asking Putin, who doesn't speak for Europe, to for Europe to allow Europe to get involved in discussions about European security architectures. Yep, absolutely. You've got that right. They just don't get it, do they? They just don't see it. I think they may see it. I think they may not care. I think they see other things. Dollar signs. Here's a quote from Jared Kushner at a press conference. He said, we need to have the Europeans at the table. We have relayed to President Putin directly several times and to his team that the only way to get this done is to have them by our side.
12:58And I think they are receptive to it on the face of it, at least. But I talked about that yesterday at length in the episode. Russia continues to refuse to meet with European officials about the European security architecture. That is until their conscience awakens and they stop supporting Ukraine militarily and selling weapons to Ukraine. Like Medinsky said earlier this week, we don't understand what status they have here. We don't understand where we can agree with them on anything. Zelensky, meanwhile, has arrived in Dublin for an informal meeting of European leaders and some bilateral talks with Ireland. More on that in a minute. So he told reporters at a news conference that it depends on the will of the American side to put pressure on Russia or
13:42not. But to your point, Dom, I completely agree with you that this was, again, Russia approaching these talks as if this were an obvious Russian win. But I would even go further than that and argue that the framing of the talks, rethinking Europe's security architecture as a whole, is in and of itself a Russian framing and to some extent is a Russian victory to be able to reframe talks with Ukraine about Ukraine as something that is wider and that is about Europe. Because that's one of the key points of Russian propaganda, isn't it? That there is something unfair in the current world order, that Russia needs to have a bigger stake in it, they need to be heard, they need to be listened to. This was very well conveyed in a thread on X from Lisa Forkt,
14:25a reporter with BBC Russian. Here's what she wrote. Putting the issue of European security architecture at the top of the agenda is something Russia has wanted to do for a long time, so it can be seen like a victory for Moscow. I've often heard from sources both in Russia and the West that the lack of discussions on this topic was partly why the Kremlin wasn't too keen to engage during previous rounds. So this framing allows Russia to pretend it shows interests in the talks when they refuse to meet with European officials once again, and they refuse to engage with any request or consideration of a potential ceasefire. It also distracts from actually talking about the future of the Donbass and the front line as if that were a side issue.
15:07And as you've mentioned, Dom, Russia's stance is very much that it wants to keep the territories that it currently occupies. And they've said time and time again that they wanted the 30 percent of the Donetsk oblast that they do not occupy. As Medinsky put it this week, the entire system of security in Europe after the Second World War is working really badly. Essentially, the whole body is sick, and Ukraine was just a cyst that burst. The whole body must be cured. A band-aid won't be enough. The concern for Europe is, of course, that Russia wants NATO to withdraw from the countries that it shares a border with. So that's the Baltics, Norway, Finland, one of the alliance's newest members. And it also continues to suggest to the U.S. that the alliance is weak, it's inefficient,
15:54that therefore it is maybe a bad alliance, or to put it in a language that Trump would understand, that it's a bad business deal. David Arrahamia, who led the talk for Ukraine, told reporters after the event that the Russians came with very, very strict instructions, and it was hard to soften the discussion. Yesterday, Dom, I spoke with Oleksandr Bevz. He is an advisor to the office of the president in Ukraine, who was part of the negotiating team on previous rounds in Geneva, Istanbul and previous Abu Dhabi talks. He gave me a bit of insight on what Ukraine was trying to achieve in these talks. First, he said the Ukrainian team had a very strict mandate from the president. It had just three items. First, a ceasefire. Second, humanitarian relief, which was achieved to some
16:37extent with the prisoner swap that you discussed earlier. And Aramia actually said they was worth holding the talks despite any lack of major progress, as long as the sides continue to do prisoner swaps. And third, organising a meeting between Zelensky and Putin, which, as Zelensky has said previously, is a prerequisite for any territorial conversation. Here's what he posted on X recently. The territorial issue is a red line that can only be discussed at the level of leaders. We're ready for discussions. If it is the territorial issue, then it must be discussed at the level of leaders. Other issues at the level of technical groups. Oleksandr Bevs yesterday also conveyed the extent to which Ukraine has been discussing
17:20the modalities of a ceasefire with the US over the last year. So the United States came to these talks and said, like, you need to agree to a ceasefire. And we also were ready to discuss ceasefire with different modalities and whatever. And they said, like, you need to agree to full unconditional ceasefire in all dimensions, sea, land, air. And we had a very long conversation on that. And in the end, we accepted the ceasefire. But we said it shall not be unilateral. Otherwise, like, it doesn't work like that. So now we have to convince the Russians. So it's all very clear that although it is good that the talks resumed, he was not very optimistic. And yet again, my biggest concern is that Russia still never agreed for any ceasefire
18:11for the diplomatic process. And that from what we started in Istanbul, when we first met the Russians in May 2025, suggesting the ceasefire. And that never happened. A year and a half already passed. And therefore, when you think of the realistic expectations for that, you cannot avoid seeing what's going on in reality, where Russia is not successful on the front line, but Russia tries to make Ukraine unlivable for Ukrainians while pretending it negotiates. And what the US had proposed that the ceasefire would be, Ukraine stopped fighting in every domain. And then what? Let me see what happens. Well, I'm not sure he went that far, but he seemed to say that they had been having extensive conversations
18:55about what a ceasefire could look like and what they were willing to accept, but that obviously they would not be doing that on their own. So until Russia agreed to anything, there was no ceasefire possible, which kind of brings us back to square one or zero or minus one. Dom, I'm afraid I'm boring you is not interested in peace talks. This is performative cosplay. They want us to talk about this framework or that narrative or this initiative or what have you, as if there's something of substance underneath it all, when there's simply not. So do you think the framing that this is now primarily about European security architecture rather than Ukraine itself, and distracting the US from Ukraine into some sort
19:46of overhaul of the wider picture either isn't a win for Russia or isn't very pertinent? Well, I got really confused with old Mr. What's-his-chop's Medinsky going on about, I lost interest and got, I mean, it's about European security and that's a win for, I don't get that. I mean, this objectively is all about European security architecture because you've got a mad, tyrannical, corrupt, murderous state on the eastern border of Europe. So, you know, newsflash, European security is front and centre here. Ukraine is bearing the brunt of that at the moment. Or for this idea that maybe there's a win because something that Russia said is now being talked about. I just or for this idea that there may be there's a win
20:25because something that Russia said is now being talked about I just don't get it I mean there's a war on Russia is as desperate as Ukraine is for this war to end because they are losing record numbers of people their economy is tanking they're losing their oil refineries they're going nowhere on the front line all they're able to do is build ballistic missiles and kill civilians that has shown that it is not in any way about to crack the resolve of the ukrainian people so russia is desperate here putin realized even if he believes the lines that he's shown and he thinks he's a tiny little bit closer to kiev than he was yesterday he knows that he's nearly five years into this and still nowhere near achieving his aim so in the back of his mind on a
21:13cold soggy tuesday morning when he's on his own in the shower maybe he thinks oh i've kind of uh you know this isn't such a good idea maybe i've made a mess of it all. So he knows that this is all going south for him. He's desperate for it to end. He sees the only way of it ending is by the United States being framed through a narrative, being informed, being whatevered. The United States putting pressure on Ukraine. He sees that idea sort of galloping off into the distance as Donald Trump totally disengages in terms of interest with Ukraine because post midterms he's shoring up his legal position doesn't want to be impeached again etc etc he's only got two years left to make as much money as he can so he's not interested in
21:54putting any political clout into this and Putin can see that so it's not going well for Russia at the moment hence all they can do is try and claim that the line is somewhere it isn't kill as many people as they can to get us all going, oh, would you please just stop at any cost, which pretty much nobody is saying, and then keep on this charade of these peace talks, which even while the peace talks is going on, you're coming out with lines like we're going to take every inch of territory one way or the other. And the more we talk about it, I'm very conscious that I'm talking about it now, the more we talk about it, I think we're just giving'm talking about it now. The more we talk about, I think we're just giving oxygen to this zombie process. This is a nothing process. There are no
22:30serious negotiations. I completely agree with you on the zombie process. I think the point I was trying to drive at is also that in changing the conversation away from Ukraine and onto the European security architecture, which obviously this is about European security, I agree, but pointing to an architecture framework that is supposedly failing or is ill the way the Russians frame it. It's also continuing to try and convince the United States that NATO maybe isn't a good deal, that they should withdraw from it. Seeds of doubt. Of course they are. Seeds of doubt in the US about the pertinence and the efficiency of NATO. And that's crackling the architecture that does exist. And that, to some extent, has been working.
23:12Well, the European security architecture since the Second World War has been NATO. And as far as I can assess, it's done a pretty good job. As in, we haven't had a third world war. In fact, the big adversary that NATO has set up to defend against has shown itself to be the adversary we always thought it was. Into attack, one of the only countries. Well, in Finland and Sweden. For decades, not wanting to be part of NATO, want to be part of NATO. They joined NATO. So European security architecture is NATO. Yeah, there's all sorts of issues we can have talks or the cows come home about the need for NATO reform, but it's kind of worked. Old Medinsky going on about it being a boil or what does he call it?
23:53A cyst. That bursts. A cyst that's burst and, oh, it's all broken and it's sick and, hmm, nope, looks like it's pretty much worked for me, old Vladimir Medinsky. I mean, you know, I don't think that's a very sensible assessment of post-second world war european security but again if you're saying it hasn't worked sowing the seeds of doubt in the us that but who's who's allowing these seeds to grow then eating the seeds and believing the seeds being one with the seed you can sow these seeds if you like, Mr. Medinsky, but I don't believe that the seed is going to grow into anything. I look at it and go, that's not a seed, it's a weed, and I pull it up. Right, I think we've reached the end of that metaphor.
24:36I think it has flowered. Shall I take you to Dublin for the rest of the updates, Dom? Yes, I like going to Dublin. Yeah, I wish we could go to a key like, but it's just for the updates. So Zyatlana Tsirhanovskaya, the leader of opposition in Belarus, who is, as you know, widely believed to have won the 2020 elections that are disputed. Well, yeah, she did. So she's at the EU leaders meeting where Zelensky is also at. And she said that Belarus should also be included in the negotiations now. That's yet another conversation about who should be at the table. She said without a free and democratic Belarus, there will be no security, neither for Ukraine nor for European countries. We have to demand withdrawal of Russian troops, not only from
25:20Ukraine, but also from Belarus. But meanwhile, Zelensky, who's also in Dublin for the same meeting, also met with the Taoiseach and he thanked him for Ireland's unwavering support in the war. That's his third visit to Ireland in just a year. Apparently, they discussed a memorandum for co-production of drones, which Ireland is very eager to develop with Ukraine in order to ensure its maritime security. There has been no news so far of any conversation about the Organish aluminium plant that's been making headlines for its exports to Russia. So you'll remember that there was a bit of an uproar in July. Zelensky urged the EU to impose sanctions on the plant. And the Irish government launched an investigation
26:05over the summer, which concluded in August, they had not identified sufficient evidence to establish that Illumina produced in Organish is being utilised by the Russian military. So I'll link to our episode on the subject in the show notes. And we'll keep on monitoring if there are any conversations ongoing about that. Zelensky also welcomed the upcoming sanctions from Brussels, where a preliminary agreement to add 145 individuals and entities to the bloc's sanctions list was expected mid-November. So that targets Russian banks, companies that support the shadow fleet, also companies that orchestrate hybrid warfare and cyber attacks. So you may remember that these sanctions are the ones that caused a bit of a
26:51ruckus earlier in the autumn when France and Slovakia wanted to delist two oligarchs. So these are the set of sanctions we're talking about. They're moving forward in the EU process. Europe should also wean itself from Russian LNG, liquefied natural gas, by the end of January 2027. That's been in the works for a very long time. Their imports has been falling 10% month after month recently. But Spain, which had phased out Russian imports in September, has actually started importing Russian LNG again in October. They imported 138,000 metric tons. Can you say why? Well, we'll hear more about Spain very, very soon because they have elections at the end of the month. So we will be talking a lot about Spain around that time. So
27:36I'm sure we can ask them what's going on. But finally, a final item for me on the energy and sanctions update. The Financial Times reported that U.S. efforts to reduce diesel prices have allowed Russia to double its diesel exports in October to 271,000 barrels a day. None of these exports, however, have reached American ports. And that's it for me, Dom, on the Abu Dhabi energy and sanctions update. There are two types of business owners, those who are busy and those who want to be busy. Toast is designed for both, with tools to keep you humming and help turn grind into growth. That's how you turn busy into business. Toast, built for busy. This message is brought to you by today's sponsor, Walden University.
28:38Set a course for change. Now is the time to make a real change in your life, career, and community. At Walden University, we give you the support and flexibility to get the W. Thank you. the first step to make your impact, visit waldenu.edu. Walden University, set a course for change. Certified to operate by Chev. In 2010, newlyweds Debbie Cooper and Jamie Starbuck set off on a round-the-world honeymoon, but something wasn't right. We kind of started to scrutinize things a lot more. What exactly is going on here? Debbie was missing. We just looked at each other and said, so what's the next step? And it's like, police. He was a lovely little boy, but something happened to him to turn him into a monster.
29:31There's nothing off her, he just erased her. Missing Debbie, a new Bed of Lies podcast from The Telegraph. Out now. I have a final thought for you. Oh, yeah, go on. It's a very short one. This week is the fifth anniversary of the Kiev Independent, our friends in Kiev. So I will link to an article they've put out in the show notes about their history, how they set everything up, how difficult it was. They opened three months before the full scale invasion, how they've expanded their coverage during a war, how they have made a business model that works, which is no small feat in the world of journalism today. So happy birthday to the Kyiv Independent in Kyiv. We're very happy that we get to speak with you on this podcast very regularly.
30:28It's been essential to us and everyone. Thanks, guys. Great journalism. That's it, folks. Now, we had, as we mentioned once or twice, an event in London on Monday night. It was a Telegraph Defence event, an audience event. We invited a lot of people to be able to come along to that. There is a video from it, which will be available very soon for UTL Plus members, and then it will be released a little bit after that for everyone else. But there was a Q&A at the end of the evening. We had a question and answer session that is going to be available today to UTL Plus members. So in case you haven't taken up a UTL Plus membership, here's a little snippet. Tom, does Putin count our troops or just count our willingness to use them?
31:11Well, it's both, isn't it? I said earlier, capability and intent. And, you know, that correlation of forces is really important. I mean, NATO as a whole, the European elements of NATO as a whole have immense capability and that's growing all the time. But what intelligence professionals really look at, as well as the capability, is the intent and the strength of intent. Two very quick points. Firstly, there are a whole bunch of people in the government I served in and there are a bunch of people in the government that is in power government I served in, and there are a bunch of people in the government that is in power now who served in Iraq and Afghanistan and put their body in harm's way as a consequence of political decisions that were taken by the government of the day.
31:55And I think the idea that there is a sort of bloodlust sat around NATO national security councils or a gratuitous aggression against Russia is utterly, utterly nonsense. The consequence of what people are discussing is very, very, very well understood. But second point, recreating conventional deterrence. Nuclear deterrence exists exactly where it is. I think the Kremlin and London, Paris, Washington understand that dance well. But conventional deterrence in Europe has atrophied since the Cold War. And in order to restore conventional deterrence, you need to do two things. Firstly, you need to physically rearm. But secondly, you need to communicate your intent to be able to confront aggression when it comes.
32:41And therefore, we should make no apology for being not aggressive, but assertive in the way that we discuss challenges like this in fora like this one. What was your favourite question from the evening, Dom? Oh God, I can't think, you know. I thought you wrote them all. No, I didn't. No, the audience did. Real questions. Yeah. There you go, folks. Plenty more where that came from. Anyway, that's it for today. Thanks Adelaide, thank you for your company We'll be back again the same time, same place tomorrow You're in charge tomorrow I think? I'm in charge, yes Hold on to your hats, do hope you can join us folks From the Telegraph Newsroom here in London, I wish you all a very good afternoon Thank you. Ukraine the Latest. There's a link in the description. If you appreciate our work,
33:49please consider following Ukraine the Latest on your preferred podcast app. Leave us a review as it helps others find the show. And please also share it with those who may not be aware we exist. You can also get in touch directly and ask questions or give comments by emailing ukrainepod at telegraph.co.uk. We promise we continue to read every message, even if we can't reply to you all. You can also contact us on X. You'll find our handles in the description. As ever, we're especially interested to hear where you're listening from around the world. My name is David Knowles. Thank you all for listening. Goodbye. is. It's Los Angeles. We talk about beauty. And by beauty, we mean proven science, celebrity glam,
35:06debunking internet narratives, and whatever drama TikTok has cooked up before 9am. Plus the products you should actually use, not just the products going viral on your feed. We are two beauty journalists who've been in this industry long enough to know what's real, what's marketing, and what's basically a group hallucination. And we're obsessed with the why behind trends. Why And if you want the real insider experience, join Gloss Angeles Confidential, where you get to test products before they launch. It's like being a beauty editor without the inbox trauma. So if you want the truth, the tea, the science, the scandal, and the occasional emotional breakdown over sunscreen, welcome to Los Angeles.

