podcasts / UK True Crime Podcast / episode
UK True Crime Podcast cover art
podcast
📅 2026-11-13 ⏱ 28 min episode · ~2 min read 📝 Transcript · 5,932 words

The House Of Blood : Episode 561

UK True Crime Podcast · · Transcript & summary by WhipScribe

A full account of a 2004 Glasgow triple killing, from the first call through the trial and sentencing, including the teenage defendants.

Read the transcript Episode page ↗
In this episodeIan MitchellTony CoyleDavid GillespieJamie GrayWillie JohnsonVioletDixon AvenueGlasgowEdithNicola Talent

▸Chapters

Tap a chapter to play it from that moment in the show's own player; the transcript opens there too.

Transcribe your links. Paste a YouTube, Google Drive or podcast link and WhipScribe gives you the transcript. Transcribe a link →

▸Notable quotes

“Thank you so much for joining me today for a story as violent and horrific as any as I've ever covered on this podcast.” Adam · at 2:28 — ▶ hear it from here
“As you hear this, I wonder if you are as angry as me by these sentences.” Adam · at 26:40 — ▶ hear it from here

▸What this episode covers

In October 2004, three men died inside a top-floor flat on Dixon Avenue on Glasgow's south side. Ian Mitchell, a retired joiner, lived there with his long-time lodger Tony Coyle, who did odd jobs for neighbours and never charged for his work. David Gillespie, 42, was the third victim. The blood spread across the walls and ceiling so thoroughly that neighbours and reporters began calling the flat the House of Blood.

The violence began after a row between David and Edith, who had left prison that same morning after nine months for an assault on a previous partner. Edith stabbed David in both legs, then phoned her teenage son John and his friend Jamie Gray, who arrived by taxi. Hours passed before anyone called an ambulance, and the lead detective believed David might have survived with basic first aid. Prosecutors said John and Jamie then attacked Ian and Tony, who had locked himself in his bedroom, and police first found the teenagers through a hostel resident who said John had boasted of stabbing a man.

All three accused first denied the murders at the High Court in Glasgow in May 2005, but by the end of the trial each admitted one killing, and the court accepted those pleas. John and Jamie were 17 and 16 when they stood trial, and each received life with a minimum of 12 years; Edith's minimum was 13. Violet, David's former partner, said the families' pain had not ended, while the host called the sentences ridiculous. John was released on parole in 2016 but was back in custody after a 2018 street incident involving his partner.

▸The House Of Blood : Episode 561 on UK True Crime Podcast: the answers

What did Adam say about House of Blood?

Adam, the host of the UK True Crime Podcast, opened by calling the House of Blood case as violent and horrific as any he has covered on the show. The story concerns three men killed in a Glasgow flat in October 2004.

“Thank you so much for joining me today for a story as violent and horrific as any as I've ever covered on this podcast.”Adam · 2:28

What did Willie Johnson say about Dixon Avenue?

Detective Superintendent Willie Johnson, who led the investigation, said the flat on Dixon Avenue was the most chilling crime scene he had ever visited. He said the violence there left even experienced detectives struggling to comprehend what had taken place.

“He described it as the most chilling crime scene he'd ever visited.”Willie Johnson · 30:03

What did Violet say about Edith?

Violet, David Gillespie's former partner, said after the pleas were accepted that Edith was a monster. She called for justice over the knives, axes, drills and kettles used on the three men.

“Justice should be done for the horrific things that they've done, knives and axes and drills and kettles.”Violet · 24:54

What did Adam say about Scottish law?

Adam explained that under Scottish law a person can be responsible for a murder committed by someone else if they took part in a shared criminal purpose that included the killing. The law calls this being guilty, art and part, and the agreement can form at the scene.

“The law describes this as being guilty, art and part.”Adam · 14:38

What happened in the House of Blood case in Glasgow in 2004?

Three men were killed in a Dixon Avenue flat in October 2004 after a night of drinking turned violent. Edith, David Gillespie's partner, admitted killing him, while her son John and his friend Jamie Gray pleaded guilty to killing Ian Mitchell and Tony Coyle, and all three received life sentences with minimum terms of 12 to 13 years.

Mentioned in this episode

Episode facts

Released
November 13, 2026
Length
28 minutes

▸Key takeaways

01Three men died in Ian Mitchell's top-floor flat on Dixon Avenue, Glasgow, in the early hours of 17 October 2004.
02Edith stabbed David Gillespie in both legs, then no ambulance was called for about two hours after the stabbing.
03Jamie Gray was 16 and John 17 at the Glasgow High Court trial in May 2005, which ended in one guilty plea per defendant.
04Edith's minimum sentence of 13 years was cut by a year for her guilty plea, a reduction that drew widespread anger.
05John was released on parole in October 2016 and recalled to prison in 2018 after a Glasgow street incident involving his partner.

▸Questions this episode answers

Q1What happened in the House of Blood murders in Glasgow in 2004?

The House of Blood case was a triple killing in a top-floor flat on Dixon Avenue, Glasgow, in the early hours of 17 October 2004. Ian Mitchell, Tony Coyle and David Gillespie died after a night of drinking turned violent. Edith admitted killing David, her son John admitted killing Ian Mitchell, and Jamie Gray admitted killing Tony Coyle.

Q2Why did it take so long to call an ambulance in the Glasgow House of Blood case?

After stabbing David Gillespie, Edith called her teenage son John and his friend Jamie Gray rather than an ambulance, and about two hours passed before emergency services were called. The lead officer believed David might have survived with basic first aid. His view was that Edith had been too drunk to give it.

Q3What sentences did the House of Blood killers receive in June 2005?

In June 2005 the judge gave John and Jamie life sentences with minimum terms of 12 years each, and gave Edith a minimum of 13 years. The judge said the minimum would otherwise have been 14 years, but was reduced by one year because Edith's guilty plea shortened the trial. The sentences drew widespread anger and disbelief.

Q4What happened to John after his release from prison in the House of Blood case?

John was released on parole on 26 October 2016 after serving his 12-year minimum. In July 2018 he was involved in an incident on Elmbank Street in Glasgow city centre, where witnesses heard him shouting at his partner. He admitted a threatening and abusive charge in November 2018, and the parole board recalled him to prison for breaching his licence conditions.

Q5What did Detective Superintendent Willie Johnson say about the House of Blood flat?

Willie Johnson, the detective who led the investigation, said the flat was the most chilling crime scene he had ever visited. He said the violence and destruction there left even experienced detectives struggling to comprehend what had happened. In 2021, after retiring, he described Tony Coyle as a deeply religious man who was always willing to help others.

Q6What did the UK True Crime Podcast host say about the victims' families in the House of Blood case?

Adam, the host of the UK True Crime Podcast, said the end of the trial did not end the families' suffering. He pointed to Violet, David Gillespie's former partner, who said her children were crying at night after losing their father. He also questioned whether the sentences were fair to the victims.

▸Transcript

Our own transcript of the public episode, with a timestamp about every 90 seconds. Tap a timestamp to play the episode from there in the show's own player; the link button on a paragraph copies a link that opens this page there.

0:00Before we get into this episode, here are two more gripping cases from the Always True Crime Network that you need to get lined up to play next. In the Murder Mile episode, The Rotter, Mike takes you back to February 1954. Isabel Chesney, the owner of a West London care home, is found drowned in her bath. Her mother, Lady Mary Menzies, has also been killed. The murderer believed he had the perfect alibi hundreds of miles away, but his plan had more confidence than common sense. And on British murders, 50 years on from the night they vanished, Stuart Blues remembers Renée McRae and her 30-year-old son, Andrew. In November 1976, they disappeared near Inverness, sparking one of Scotland's longest-running murder investigations.

0:47Go to alwaystruecrime.com or search for Murder Mile and British Murders wherever you get your podcasts to get them in your queue. Good news for anyone who's bad at waiting. Black Friday deals at Lowe's are already on. Get up to three free select DeWalt, Craftsman, or Cobalt power tools with the purchase of a select battery kit. Three for free? You better believe it. Plus, select ladders are up to 50% off. So go ahead, get in there early. Shop Black Friday deals in-store or online now at Lowe's. Valid through 1118. While supplies last. Free tools vary based on battery kit purchased and location. This episode is sponsored by ZocDoc. Have you been putting off a doctor's appointment or need a dentist and you don't know

1:36where to start? We've definitely been there and that's why we use ZocDoc. Actually, over the holidays, Michael had a dental emergency and seemingly every office was closed, but we hopped onto ZocDoc, found an in-network dentist, had great reviews, saw real-time appointments available, which was key. It was on New Year's day and booked an appointment in just minutes. It took so much of the stress out of the already stressful situation. ZocDoc makes it easy to search and compare over 250,000 local in-network providers across more than 200 specialties. So you can find the right doctor or dentist and book instantly. Taking care of your health just got easier. Download the ZocDoc app today and book that appointment on your to-do list. That's Z-O-C-D-O-C, ZocDoc.

2:28Great meeting. Who took notes? Anyone? With Monday Notetaker, the meeting ends and the plan already exists. Action items, owners, deadlines. Go to monday. of the UK True Crime Podcast. I'm Adam. Thank you so much for joining me today for a story as violent and horrific as any as I've ever covered on this podcast. But before we start today, I just wanted to let you know that in a special episode on Sunday, I'm talking to journalist and the host of the Crime World podcast, Nicola Talent, about her new book all about the Kinnahans. Nicola has been covering this story for over 20 years, so you won't want to miss her insight on the rise and the fall of the Kinnahan cartel. But back to today, and before we get started,

3:24let's quickly set some context for the story with our Guest of Month and Year game. You ready? It was one for the technical music intellectuals in the UK, as Eric Pride was at number one with Call On Me. Goodness me, remember that? In the US, it was boys to men in the top spot with the awful sickly sweet I'll Make Love to You. And in Australia, number one in the album charts was American Idiot from Green Day. In the news this month, the very first park run, known at this time as Bushy Park Time Trail, took place in Bushy Park in London. The Scottish Parliament Building in Edinburgh opened. In British cinemas, Shark Tail and Saw were in the top box office spots. There was horror in Iraq as hostages Ken Bigley and Margaret Hassan were killed.

4:15Tony Blair announced he would seek a third term as Prime Minister. And in UK true crime news, this month saw 14-year-old Danielle Beckham fatally shot in a drive-by shooting in Nottingham as she walked home from a fun fair. The two thugs responsible were later sent to prison for a minimum of 32 years. So did you get the month and year? It was October 2004. On Saturday the 16th of October 2004, 67-year-old Ian Mitchell went out for a drink at a pub near his home in the south side of Glasgow. Ian was a retired joiner who lived in a top-floor flat on Dixon Avenue, a property that had been the family home for many years. Following his separation from his wife, he had remained there, sharing the flat with a good old friend, Anthony Coyle, known as Tony, who had rented a room from him

5:11for around 10 years. Originally from County Donegal in Ireland, Tony had worked as a labourer in the building trade before retiring about six months earlier. He was one of these guys who always liked to keep busy, and much of his spare time was spent helping elderly people in the neighbourhood with odd jobs, repairs, and doing stuff in their gardens. He was also a practising Catholic, and his parish priests would occasionally put him in touch with people who needed a hand around the house. Tony was more than happy to help, and never charged him for his work. Dixon Avenue sits between Govan Hill and Cross Hill. It's an area of Glasgow characterised by its mix of traditional sandstone tenements and larger period houses. Ian's flat was on the upper

6:00floor of one of the tenements, with another household living directly beneath him. Tony had his own room, and over the years the two men had developed a really deep friendship and camaraderie that went beyond simply sharing a home. They'd settled into a comfortable arrangement and were well known and liked in their neighbourhood. On that Saturday, Tony was out doing some of these odd jobs for churchgoers, while Ian had headed off to his local pub for a drink. On that Saturday, Tony was out doing some of these odd jobs for churchgoers, while Ian had headed off to his local pub for a drink. That evening, Ian was joined at the pub by two people he knew, David Gillespie and Edith McAlindon. David was 42 and had two children with

6:39his former partner Violet. The couple had been together for about 20 years before separating and now David was in a relationship with Edith who'd been described in the media as a convicted thief, sex worker and a homeless drifter. Whatever the truth about how the media described her it's certainly fair to say that she'd experienced a troubled and chaotic life. Edith had known Ian for some time and she was particularly fond of him, affectionately calling him Pops. She and David had visited Ian at Dixon Avenue on numerous previous occasions, so when he invited them back to the flat for another drink that evening, neither had any reason to hesitate. But there was something rather significant about

7:24Edith's circumstances that day. She'd actually walked out of prison that very morning, having served nine months for a serious assault on a previous partner. Neither she nor David had a settled home at this time, and Ian's flat was somewhere familiar where they could spend some time together. Both of them had been drinking for much of the day before meeting Ian, but the evening had been a fun and a jovial one as they slowly returned to Ian's home. However, sometime after the three of them had returned to Dixon Avenue, David and Edith began arguing. The reason for this is unclear, but it was probably about something minor such as who was going to be buying some more drinks. But whatever the reason, the fun and friendly atmosphere the friends had enjoyed

8:10began to change rapidly. The argument between David and Edith quickly escalated into something far more serious and it became violent with Edith stabbing David in both his legs. The injuries were serious as the wounds to his thigh were deep and he began losing a considerable amount of blood. Edith made a phone call, but rather than phoning as you or I might for an ambulance, she called her teenage son, John, and he set off for Dixon Avenue with a friend, Jamie Gray, in a taxi. When they arrived, they didn't have enough money to pay the driver, so Edith asked Ian to cover the fare. Ian was concerned about David so willingly handed over the money, believing that the two young men had come to help David,

8:58who was still inside the flat, badly injured and bleeding heavily. Let's forward wind about two hours to the early hours of Sunday the 17th of October and a neighbour, James Sweeney, was woken by Edith at his door. She was in a state of some distress and she told him that something terrible had happened in Ian's flat and asked him to go upstairs and see for himself. With some trepidation, John went to the flat with Edith, who unlocked the door, and inside he could see three bodies. He said, what the hell happened here? Did you do this? But Edith didn't respond. He told Edith to wait for a minute while he went to a nearby pub to get her phone to call the emergency services. She said, Jim, what will I do? What

9:46will I do? When he got back, Edith was still there in floods of tears. By the time the emergency services arrived, they found Edith cradling David in her arms, crying and pleading with him to wake up. The paramedics moved her aside so they could examine him. Tragically, there was nothing they could do. David had already succumbed to his injuries. The scene inside the flat was horrifying. Ian and Tony were both lying on separate settees while David's body was on the floor between them, close to the fireplace. All three men were dead. The flat was in a terrible state. Broken pieces of furniture lay among the bottles scattered across the floor, while an extraordinary amount of blood had been spattered across the walls and even the ceiling. The neighbour, John Sweeney, he later spoke to

10:39local reporters about what he had found there, telling them that the walls and the floors of the flat were covered with blood, which quickly earned the triple-killing a nickname, the House of Blood. Forensic officers began their examination inside the flat, while other police officers searched the surrounding area. They checked bins, drains and bushes along Dixon Avenue. Green tarpaulin was erected around the entrance to the flat to shield the scene from public view while the investigation continued. The condition of the bodies and the damage inside the property led detectives to suspect that more than one person may have been involved. Edith was the only person found alive inside the flat and she had plenty of blood on her clothing.

11:25Police arrested her in connection with David's death. During questioning she initially refused to identify anyone else who may have been involved. At this stage detectives were describing all three deaths as suspicious. On Monday the 18th of October Edith appeared before Glasgow's Sheriff's Court where she was charged with David Gillespie's murder. She made no plea and was remanded in custody. Three men had lost their lives inside the flat and detectives were now faced with the task of establishing exactly what had happened during those final hours and they didn't have to wait long for their first significant lead. It came through a conversation at a homeless hostel when a resident contacted the police to say that another resident

12:11had spoken about taking part in the violence. That resident was John McAllenden, Edith's son. John had seemingly told the resident that he'd stabbed a man in both legs, he claimed that a man had tried to rape his mum, and he'd also spoken about someone else being involved in the violence, and detectives soon identified this person as the other man who arrived in the taxi, his mate Jamie Gray. Once again, here we see people psychologically unable to cope with their actions and feeling the need to tell others just what they had done. We see it all the time don't we and it's often such a significant lead for detectives and in this case it was particularly vital because it matched something that detectives already knew. David had been found in the sitting room with stab wounds to his legs,

13:11just as John had told the residents of the hostel. For the first time, detectives had a clear lead that appeared to connect someone, except for Edith, directly to the violence inside the flat. The police questioned John McAllendon and Jamie Gray, and as the investigation progressed, it began to uncover evidence connecting both teenagers to what had happened inside the flat. Forensic examinations provided links between the young men and the scene while the injuries found on David were consistent with John's admission that he'd stabbed a man in the legs. But there had of course also been further violence after the initial attack on David. The condition of the flat and the injuries suffered by all three men pointed to a prolonged and brutal assault.

13:53Detectives believed that they were dealing with more than one attacker and that the actions of those involved would need to be examined individually. John McAlindon and Jamie Gray were arrested and charged with all three murders alongside Edith. The lead detective later recalled being struck by the contrast between the teenagers he first encountered and the sheer brutality of the crime that his officers were investigating. Neither of the young men he said had initially struck him as particularly capable of the sort of violence which had clearly occurred in Dixon Avenue, and it was only the forensic evidence, combined with the other information gathered during the investigation, that finally persuaded him that both had been involved.

14:38The case reached a high court in Glasgow in May 2005, with all three accused of murdering all three men, and each initially denying the charges. I should mention just how young the two men on trial were. John was just 17 at the time of the trial, while Jamie was even younger, he was 16. I didn't realise this, I'm not sure if you know, but under Scottish law, a person can be held responsible for a murder committed by someone else if they took part in a shared criminal purpose that encompassed the killing. The law describes this as being guilty, art and part. Such an agreement does not necessarily have to exist before the crime begins. It can also develop at the scene. And with three people in the dock, what each had done before and during the attacks too would be central to the prosecution's

15:32case. One of the first people to give evidence was Ian Mitchell's son, also called John. He was 38 and he knew Dixon Avenue well as it was the home where his family had lived. He told the court that his dad had taken Tony in as a lodger about 10 years before. On visits to see his dad, he said he'd come across Edith maybe three or four times. When asked about her, he said that he remembered seeing her there but he was unsure how well she and his dad knew each other. The jury also heard from Isha Das who lived below the flat where the violence had taken place and he'd heard something that night. He described the noise coming from the flat above as being like thunder telling the court that his ceiling had literally shaken from the disturbance.

16:22The jury was then shown a police video recording of the sitting room after the violence had taken place. They were warned beforehand to brace themselves for what they were about to see. The camera showed the bodies of Ian and Tony on the settees with David's body between them. It then moved slowly across the room where bottles and broken furniture lay among the objects police had recovered as possible weapons. Among the items visible in the recording were a hammer, a baseball bat and an electric drill. The camera moved in close on a golf club, with hair caught in the blood covering it, and on a knife with tissue still attached. Blood had spattered the furniture and curtains, as well as the floor, the walls, and the ceiling.

17:10It really was like something out of a horror film. Good news for anyone who's bad at waiting. Black Friday deals at Lowe's are already on. Get up to three free select DeWalt, Craftsman, or Cobalt power tools with the purchase of a select battery kit. Three for free? You better believe it. Plus, select ladders are up to 50% off. So go ahead, get in there early. Shop Black Friday deals in-store or online now at Lowe's. Valid through 1118. While supplies last. Free tools vary based on battery kit purchase and location. Great meeting. Who took notes? Anyone? With Monday Notetaker, the meeting ends and the plan already exists. Action items, owners, deadlines. Go to monday.com, the AI workspace platform.

18:00This ad is sponsored by ZocDoc. Hi, it's Danny Pellegrino from Everything Iconic. Have you been putting off that annual doctor's appointment because you don't want to make the call? Or maybe you've been meaning to find a new dentist, but you have no idea where to start. I find that's especially true when you move. It's hard to find your people. I've been there, which is why I use ZocDoc. Now, as a busy podcaster parent and someone who's always juggling a million things, I love anything that makes life easier. And ZocDoc lets you search and compare local in-network doctors with over 250,000 providers across more than 200 specialties. You can read reviews from real patients, find a provider who feels like the right fit, see actual appointment openings, and book instantly.

18:47I recently had a last-minute health issue pop up and needed to see someone fast, and instead of calling around or sitting on hold, I found a doctor on ZocDoc and booked an appointment in just a few minutes. It made the whole process so much less stressful. Now, taking care of your health just got easier. Download the ZocDoc app today. That's ZocDoc, Z-O-C-D-O-C, and book that appointment on your to-do list. Shag here. What's it like to buy a car from Carvana 100% online and get it delivered to your door? Let me tell you. Your car is here, Mr. Shaq. Thank you, Mr. Carvana guy. Can't wait to take it for a spin. Only the best for you, Mr. Shaq. Hey, have you always been so big, tall, and handsome?

19:21Not always. I was 6'10 once. Seven days to love it or return it, Mr. Shaq. Not that I would. You never do. No, I never do. So buy your car today on Carvana. Delivery fees may apply. See our seven-day return policy at carvana.com. This message is brought to you by today's sponsor, Walden University. Set a course for change. Now is the time to make a real change. In your life, career, and community. At Walden University, we give you the support and flexibility to get the W. Walden's online programs are designed for working professionals like you. You'll gain hands-on skills to take on real-world challenges and succeed. Your future is waiting and Walden is here to help you achieve it. Take the first step to make your impact. Visit waldenu.edu.

20:06Walden University. Set a course for change. Certified to operate by Chev. When the lead prosecutor began outlining the attacks that had taken place in the flat, he referred to weapons ranging from an axe to metal files and pieces of wood. He also explained that the extent of the bloodstaining was so extreme that it was impossible to establish the precise order of events. The prosecution then began to explain how each of the three men had died. David Gillespie had suffered stab wounds to his thighs and the resulting blood loss had killed him. It was established in court that Edith, rather than John, had inflicted those wounds. David was in a serious condition after the initial stabbing and by the time John and Jamie arrived at the flat,

20:58those present feared he was dying. The officer who led the investigation later said that he believed there had been an opportunity at this time to save David In his account, he explained that if Edith had given him basic first aid and called an ambulance immediately, David may well have survived But his view was that she'd just been too drunk to provide the help that he needed And as you will recall, Edith's first shout for help had brought her son and his friends to the flat. It was only later that anyone contacted the emergency services for medical assistance. That's a good two hours after the initial stabbing. But by the time the two teenagers arrived, David had already been badly wounded. Ian was also present and according to the prosecution

21:46had become a potential witness to what Edith had done. The explanation put forward for the attack on Ian was that he knew David, he knew Edith and had been there when the violence began so his death would remove someone who could potentially tell police what had happened. And Ian had suffered the most appalling attack and he must have been utterly terrified by what was unfolding in his flat. He suffered several stab wounds to the chest as well as severe head injuries consistent with being repeatedly kicked. John was implicated in the attack on Ian. The prosecution's case was that the two boys had set out to harm him deliberately when they had travelled to Dixon Avenue in the taxi. That had been their plan, not to help.

22:35Tony, meanwhile, had been away from the flat when the violence began. When he returned, he walked into the scene in the sitting room and immediately understood that he was in danger and retreated to his bedroom and locked the door. But Tony's attempt to protect himself was unsuccessful. The prosecution argued that the two young men now had another witness to deal with and their attention turned to getting through the bedroom door. With the flat high above the ground, escaping through the window for Tony wasn't a realistic option. There was an electric drill among Ian's tools and the prosecution said that this was used to get through the locks and Tony was eventually attacked in his own bedroom.

23:18The injuries that killed him were consistent with repeated blows to the head of a golf club. Jamie Gray was implicated in this attack and the prosecution also alleged that a cushion had been pressed against Tony's face at one point. That's bad enough right but I'm afraid that wasn't all and the violence described in court went beyond the use of knives and clubs. The jury heard that boiling water had been poured over two of the men apparently to see whether they were still alive. The Crown also alleged that David and Ian had been punched and stamped on and that a bottle had been used on them. It had been a night of prolonged and savage violence and by the time the emergency call was made, David

24:03and the two harmless men who had shared the flat and welcomed people inside their home were dead. Edith was the only person still alive inside. The trial had begun with all three defendants denying responsibility for the murders, but as the evidence continued to be presented, their positions changed. By the end of May, each had admitted responsibility for one of the deaths. Edith pleaded guilty to murdering David Gillespie. John admitted murdering Ian Mitchell, despite earlier telling the residents of the hostel that he'd actually stabbed David. While Jamie admitted murdering Tony Coyle. The Crown accepted one guilty plea from each of them. The three admissions brought the trial to an end before the jury could return verdicts on the original charges.

24:54After the evidence of what had happened inside the flat had been heard, the responsibility for the deaths of all three men had finally been acknowledged. David's ex-partner, Violet, spoke publicly after the pleas were accepted. As we heard, she was in a relationship with David for 20 years, and they'd been separated for about three years by the time he died. The details that had come out at the trial, particularly the use of the drill and the boiling water, were among the most shocking that she singled out when she spoke about what had been inflicted on the men. She said, I hope they rot in hell for what they've done to two old men and my ex-partner. Justice should be done for the horrific things that they've done, knives and axes and drills and kettles. They said they put boiling water over them to see if they were dead.

25:47Just how evil can people get? She added, Edith McAlindian in particular is a monster. A statement read out on behalf of the families of the other two victims said simply, Tony and Ian were the very best of friends and they didn't deserve to be murdered. In June 2005, the three murderers appeared in court once again for sentencing. The judge imposed life sentences with a minimum of 12 years for John McAlyndon and 12 for Jamie Gray. Edith McAlyndon would have to serve at least 13 years. The judge explained that the court had accepted Edith's plea to a single murder on substantially different terms from the original charges. She said that the minimum would have been 14 years but reduced it by one year because Edith's plea had shortened

26:40what would otherwise have been a much longer trial. As you hear this, I wonder if you are as angry as me by these sentences. You know, it's no wonder, is it, that so many people have lost all faith in the criminal justice system when you hear of such ridiculous sentences like this, don't you think? And the sentences, understandably, were met with widespread anger and disbelief. Violet was furious when they were announced. Afterwards she told reporters that she'd seen the defendants laughing as they were led away from court. But what she really wanted people to understand was the shit impact that David's death had had on the family that he left behind. His children were now growing up without their dad and the consequences of what had happened in that flat would stay with

27:31them long after the defendants had left the courtroom. Speaking to reporters outside the court Violet said, my children stay up crying all night because they've lost their dad. John McAlyndon was released from prison on the 26th of October 2016, having served the 12-year minimum punishment part of his sentence. He was still a relatively young man, not yet 30, with much of his life ahead of him, unlike those who'd been murdered in the flat. Their lives had been taken from them. His release was on parole, meaning he remained subject to licensed conditions and could be returned to prison if he breached them. But his time as a free man was short. In July 2018, he was walking with his partner through Glasgow city centre when an incident took place on Elmbank Street shortly before one o'clock in the morning.

28:27Witnesses heard him shouting and swearing at her, while others saw him knock a mobile phone from her hand. The police were called, and the matter eventually came before Glasgow Sheriff Court in November that year. McAlindon admitted behaving in a threatening and abusive manner. He denied a separate allegation that he'd struck and kicked his partner and the Crown accepted his not guilty plea to that charge. His solicitor told the court that his partner had been supported of him and had chosen not to participate in the prosecution. The Sheriff deferred sentence to allow reports to be prepared but by then McAlindan was already back behind bars. The parole board had recalled him after determining that he breached the conditions of his release.

29:13He was returned to custody under the original life sentence for murdering Ian Mitchell. And to conclude, unfortunately, as I record this in November 2026 I can't say for sure whether the three murderers are still behind bars or out living their lives. Ah and one more thing which I always wonder about I wonder if you do. The flat where the horror took place was refurbished and sold so someone is now living in that flat. I wonder, is this somewhere you would live? Or like me, would you avoid it at all costs? So would you make it what we've heard today? Except for the quite ridiculous, stupid sentences given to the murderers in our story today. What stays with me the most is the pointless murder

30:03of three harmless men who were all just gentle and well thought of. And why did Edith firstly stab David and then rather than call for the much needed medical assistance, called her son and his mate who inflicted so much awful violence? As we've heard, the name that became attached to the case was the House of Blood, which invokes the horror of the scene. And outside the court, Detective Superintendent Willie Johnson, who had led the investigation and was a very experienced detective, he spoke about the scene his officers had encountered inside the flat. He described it as the most chilling crime scene he'd ever visited. He said it was a place of such violence and destruction that even experienced detectives had struggled to comprehend what had taken place there. When he reflected again on the case, what, 15 years later in 2021, following his

30:57retirement, he spoke about the three men whose lives had ended on Dixon Avenue. He remembered Tony as a deeply religious man whose life revolved around his church. Tony being someone who was always willing to help others, including people he barely knew, without expecting anything in return. He remembered David as a working man from a good family and admitted that he never really understood how David and Edith had come to be together. Perhaps this is another of the difficult things about this case. Three men, each with their own lives, families and connections to the community, had found themselves caught up in that one night of extraordinary violence. None of them could have imagined what was going to happen when they went for a drink that night

31:45or even when they entered that flat and how their lives would end and like all the crimes we hear about on this podcast we must never forget that when the three defendants had been sentenced the criminal proceedings were over and the photographers the lawyers the journalists had moved on to new cases Their nightmare just doesn't end for the families involved. I think Violet made that point powerfully when she spoke outside the court. She wanted everyone to understand that while the trial might have ended, the consequences of that night had not. Her children were still waking in the night, crying because they'd lost their dad. Just how powerful an image is that, and compared with the lack of respect of the three defendants, laughing, laughing during the trial is just

32:34shocking. The house of blood, but behind that name three ordinary men, each with a life, a story, and a future snatched from them. And for David's children, Ian's family and everyone who had known Tony, the loss would remain long after the courtroom doors had closed. Thank you so much for joining me today for this episode of the UK True Crime Podcast and I'll be back as always on Tuesday and Friday with brand new stories. And if you cannot wait until then, I get it, you can immediately unlock 110 bonus episodes by joining me and almost 1500 others at patreon.com slash UK true crime. Why don't you go and take a look. As well as the bonus episodes, you will also get early access to every single episode and all the episodes on Patreon are totally advert free, so no more adverts ever.

33:33You can join me there today for under £3 a month and you can cancel any time with no long contracts. Just head to patreon.com slash UK true crime. You know it makes sense. Okay, so that's all for me for another episode. A huge thank you to everyone who messaged me this week and there were lots to let me know that the Kings of Leon were live on The One Show this week. Goodness me, what a combination. Bland meets bland, about right. No, by the way, I didn't watch it. Please do try and join me on Sunday for my chat with Nicola Talent all about the Kinehans. It's a fascinating conversation. And until we speak again soon, please do take it easy out there. And despite the others, and it's always the others,

34:20stay classy. Cheerio for now. Good news for anyone who's bad Stay classy. Cheerio for now. for free? You better believe it. Plus, select ladders are up to 50% off. So go ahead, get in there early. Shop Black Friday deals in-store or online now at Lowe's. Valid through 1118. While supplies last, free tools vary based on battery kit purchased and location. Black Friday is coming. Last year, businesses on Shopify made billions in sales. This holiday season, you could be one of them if you start now. Shopify helps you launch fast, so you can design your site and start selling before the biggest shopping days of the year. What are you waiting for? Tis the season to start selling. Start for free at Shopify.com.

35:21The midpoint of life, a time to celebrate. Take stock and ask, what's next? I'm Gabby Logan. And on Life at the Midpoint, I'm joined by famous faces who share how they're navigating this stage of life. Plus experts with advice on change, challenges and everything in between. And I'm tackling your dilemmas and questions as we figure it all out together. Listen every Tuesday and Thursday. Search for Life at the Midpoint. In 2011, a woman's body was found in a California vineyard. This is one of those types of murder investigations that you come across maybe once, maybe never. It appeared the killer tried to make the victim unidentifiable. Much more extreme than any other case I'd ever worked on. It haunted me. For over

36:06a decade, she was a Jane Doe. Then she finally had a name. But learning her identity is when the real mystery began. The killer knows who you are, but you don't know who the killer is. So be careful. Because that's not a one and done. I'm Olivia LaVoie and this is Ada. All episodes available now. Listen wherever you get your podcasts. more are part of the Always True Crime network. It's packed with box sets to binge and twisted

▸More episode summaries

UK True Crime Podcast cover art
UK True Crime PodcastInside the Kinahan Cartel - Interview with Top Crime Journalist Nicola Tallant2026-11-15 · 39 min
Transcribe your links. Paste a YouTube, Google Drive or podcast link and WhipScribe gives you the transcript. Transcribe a link →
New UK True Crime Podcast transcripts by email
One email per new episode, unsubscribe in every message. Not shared with the publisher.