TRIGGERnometry · · Transcript & summary by WhipScribe
Sam Harris gives a blunt, detailed read on Trump, the Iran war, Democratic politics and AI risk, with the hosts pushing back on him throughout.
Tap a chapter to play it from that moment in the show's own player; the transcript opens there too.
“the path to fascism in America is for the left to get sufficiently crazy” Sam Harris · at 45:23 — ▶ hear it from here
“what you can't say in the presence of that kind of technology is, oh, well, we'll just, you know, turn it off.” Sam Harris · at 1:47:14 — ▶ hear it from here
Sam Harris argues that Trump's war with Iran was a war of choice the United States could have fought defensively at almost any point in the past 47 years, but that Trump ran it badly. He describes the messaging as deranged, criticises the expectation of an easy decapitation strike, and says the alienation of allies left the US exposed. Harris still hopes the regime could fall, but he thinks many critics are angry for the wrong reasons. He links the public's disillusionment to corruption, describing a president who treats tariffs and sanctions as personal revenue streams.
The conversation then turns to the midterms and the Democratic Party. Harris worries that Democrats will read their win as permission to move further left, and that a radical left could push voters toward a harsher right, with figures such as Nick Fuentes or Tucker Carlson. He calls the 2024 vote for Trump defensible on border grounds, while blaming Democratic positions on gender and border policy for losing ground. He also describes January 6 as a serious threat to democracy that many on the right have since minimised.
On artificial intelligence, Harris says the field is moving so fast that human-level systems are an inevitable encounter, comparing the trend to chess, where machines overtook the best players. He points to people building frontier models who put the odds of catastrophe at around 10 percent, and he calls for regulation and a US-China agreement along the lines of Cold War arms control. He also asks what it would mean to turn off an internet that a rogue AI had gained access to.
Sam Harris is a commentator who has appeared on Trigonometry before. In this episode he discusses Trump, the Iran war, the midterms, wokeness and AI risk, and says he gave a TED talk on AI ten years ago.
Sam Harris said the Iran war was a war of choice that the United States could have fought defensively at almost any point in the last 47 years, but that Trump ran it badly. He said Trump told Iranians to rise up with help on the way, then stood by as tens of thousands were massacred.
“Trump told the people of Iran to rise up and reclaim their country, that help was on the way”Sam Harris · 3:12
Sam Harris said Trump treats the levers of American power as his personal property, using tariff and foreign policy as a cash register for himself and his friends. He cited a diesel deal announced shortly after Trump had put sanctions on countries buying Russian oil, which he said would benefit Trump's friends and family.
“views the levers of American power as his personal property to be worked or even nullified”Sam Harris · 6:38
Sam Harris said a sitting president tried to steal an election while claiming it was being stolen from him, and that this produced political violence in the Capitol. He said Mike Pence's life was almost certainly in jeopardy because of how the president behaved that day.
“a sitting president, who was trying to steal an election”Sam Harris · 19:49
Sam Harris said humanity is building superhuman minds that are autonomous and doing things we cannot predict. He compared AI to chess, where machines overtook the best human players and he argues most cognitive tasks will follow the same path.
“we're building superhuman minds which are autonomous and doing things that we can't predict”Sam Harris · 1:41:59
Sam Harris argues that Trump's Iran war could have been defensible but was badly run, that Trump's self-dealing and personal authenticity have alienated allies and voters, and that AI is outpacing political institutions. He says Democrats risk moving further left after the midterms, which could push voters toward a harsher right.
Sam Harris said the Iran war was a war of choice that the United States could have fought defensively at almost any point in the last 47 years, but that Trump ran it badly. He said Trump's messaging had been deranged and that Trump had shown some spine and then perfect spinelessness. Harris still held out hope the regime could fall, while saying the war had been disastrous, in part because Trump had told Iranians help was coming and then stood by during mass killings.
Sam Harris said Trump views the levers of American power as his personal property, using tariff and foreign policy to create what he called a cash register for himself and his friends. He pointed to a diesel deal announced weeks after sanctions on countries buying Russian oil, which he said was obviously going to benefit Trump's friends and family. Harris also said Trump's earnings had grown since their conversation a year earlier.
Sam Harris said he feared Democrats would conclude after the midterms that they do not have to moderate, and that the ideologues on the left could capture more of the conversation. He said the Democrats had been insane on the border and on transgender policy, and that Kamala Harris could not explain her change of position on taxpayer-funded surgery for incarcerated immigrants. He warned the left getting sufficiently radical could make the right seem like the only option.
Sam Harris said cultic attachment is highly resistant to falsification, using a flying saucer that never lands as an example: half the believers leave and the other half find a reason it did not work. He said many Trump supporters now blame Bibi Netanyahu for misleading Trump into the Iran war, which he called one of the most irresponsible things Trump has done. He also said he has no theory of mind for people only now deciding Trump was not their guy.
Sam Harris said a sitting president tried to steal an election while claiming it was being stolen from him, and that this produced political violence in the Capitol. He said Trump did little to stop the violence for hours and that Mike Pence's life was almost certainly in jeopardy. Harris criticised commentators, including Tucker Carlson, for spinning the riot as a false flag or as having no stakes.
Sam Harris said AI is following the same path chess did: once Garry Kasparov lost to a machine, the moment a human could be the best player on Earth was gone for good. He argued that cognitive tasks are becoming like chess, with no special human-only band of intelligence that machines will never match. He also said Geoffrey Hinton's tiger-cub analogy captures the risk of raising a superhuman mind that is not perfectly aligned with human interests.
Sam Harris said the arms race with China is a failure of leadership rather than an inevitability, since the Chinese Communist Party is not suicidal. He argued that it is absurd to regulate a barber shop heavily while frontier AI labs face almost no rules, even though many people building the technology say they fear it. He compared the stakes to the Manhattan Project and the Trinity test, and said mutual inspection agreements between the US and the Soviet Union show a deal is possible.
Our own transcript of the public episode, with a timestamp about every 90 seconds. Tap a timestamp to play the episode from there in the show's own player; the link button on a paragraph copies a link that opens this page there.
0:00This was always the war we should have waged, but we have complete incompetence in charge. At a certain point, you have to recognize that there's evil in the world. Last I looked, there are people in the MAGA cult who understand that. I don't want to make this Iran war argument episode, but you're not representing my point correctly. The path to fascism in America is for the left to get sufficiently crazy. I fear that the ideologues on the left could capture more of the conversation. There's a very real possibility now that you're going to get a wokeness like you haven't seen before. Don't you think? I'm worried about that. If it's a forced choice between El-Sayed and Nick Fuentes, I think we go right in this country.
0:47Between fascism and communism, America picks fascism 100 times out of 100. Before we start, a very quick movie recommendation. We know our audience, and every so often, something comes along that we think you'll genuinely want to see. Confession is written by Ben Shapiro and stars Rob Lowe, James Franco, and Nick Nolte. Set in Moscow in 1938, a former literature professor is arrested and brought to the infamous Lubyanka prison, charged with conspiring with his dissident priest. There, he faces interrogation by his brilliant but brutal former student. If you care about the things we talk about on this show, like freedom of conscience, this one will resonate with you. Confession is now streaming only on The Daily Wire.
1:30Join to watch at dw.com slash confession. Thanks to The Daily Wire for sponsoring this episode. Sam Harris, welcome back to Trigonometry. Good to see you both. It's great to see you. It's good to see you. It's a very interesting moment in America. You know, the midterms happened last week. Huge change. I thought for me personally, having known you for a while and us having had a number of conversations, having had you explain your position to Trump in detail, to me, part of the irony is it seems that he's been undone by prosecuting something on which you actually probably agree with him, which is dealing with the threat of Islamist radicalism. Yeah, this is a painful irony. I can't drink in the, what's it being called now, the Trumpenfreude as fully as I might,
2:20because the thing that people are most disillusioned by, his former fans are most disillusioned by, is one of the maybe two things he's done that I think I can defend. So the other one being closing the border. Right. So, yeah, I mean, there's an irony there. And the thing that, to make that less obscure, the thing that people seem to most hate him for is the war, the war of choice in Iran. And I think that's a war of choice that we could have defensively waged more or less at any point in the last 47 years, right? And so, I mean, he's done it badly. He's communicated about it abysmally. He's, I mean, he's shown some spine and then shown perfect spinelessness. He's lied. And I mean, his messaging has just been deranged, as I would have expected.
3:12But the truth is, even now, I still hold out some hope that if he just, you know, doesn't declare defeat unequivocally, the regime may yet fall, right? I mean, the economic pressure, maybe further military, I don't know what's going to, we don't know what's going to happen next week, but there's rumors of, you know, further military pressure coming. It's possible that there's a good and defensible outcome even now, but, you know, critics of this war can certainly be understood in their perception of this being a disaster in the making, because it has been disastrous. I mean, just to take one piece, Trump told the people of Iran to rise up and reclaim their country, that help was on the way, and then stood by as tens of thousands of people were massacred.
4:06So it's just, I mean, that is, if that were the only error, that's hard to recover from. But, you know, he's compounded that with just one humiliation of our country after the next. But still, it's, you know, this is an evil regime that has been needlessly immiserating its own people. We should, you know, the women of Iran are absolute heroes. I would actually was just with, I just saw Masih Al-Inajad, you know, the, I don't know, has she been on your podcast? No. She's fantastic. You know, the Iranian regime, I think, has tried to kill her three times in the U.S. This was always the war we should have waged, but we should, we have complete incompetence in charge who, in the case of Trump, really don't have principles.
5:03I mean, he's just, you know, he, I think he thought this was, there was going to be an easy decapitation strike. And, you know, it's understandable that he did think that. I mean, when you can drop a bomb and, you know, take out several tiers in the org chart of the Iranian regime, it's easy to hope that that would have been enough to take out the regime. But it clearly wasn't. I mean, it's easy to hope that that would have been enough to take out the regime, but it clearly wasn't. I mean, there's just fanatics all the way down. So anyway, so that's just to say that my gloating about the unraveling of Trumpistan is tempered by my sense that many of the people who are disillusioned are disillusioned primarily for
5:51the wrong reasons. Well, we'll maybe come back to that. But one of the other things that I thought is interesting is corruption is a big part of the conversation that has caused people to become alienated from the MAGA movement. And that's something you raised with us in the past. Do you want to talk us through a little bit of what people mean when they talk about corruption, some of the cases and details? Well, I think, you know, I was on, I think, exactly a year ago, last time, and I think we spoke about that a lot. But I mean, he's, he, even then, I mean, since then, he's earned, I think, more billions. But, I mean, the level of self-dealing is just astounding. I mean, the crucial thing to recognize is that Trump,
6:38unlike any other president we've ever had, views the levers of American power as his personal property to be worked or even nullified, traded away for just personal advantage or the advantage of his friends and family. So he's used tariff policy, he's used foreign policy to just create a cash register for himself and his friends. And as recently as, what was it, a month ago, announced that, I mean, he no sooner put sanctions on any country that would deal with Russian oil than he broke those sanctions himself by announcing a diesel deal, which was obviously going to advantage friends and family in his particulars. And so it's... Again, I'm very happy that Republicans or former Trump fans are starting to react to this,
7:45but, you know, it's... are starting to react to this. But, you know, it's again, it's a mixed feeling because what took them so long? So this was it's been obvious for a decade who this guy was. I mean, the level of of avarice. And again, it's all about him and his advantage. I mean, all he wants is money and fame. And I mean, that's clearly, it's been true for as long as we've known him, and we've known him for decades. I mean, long before even his political aspirations were articulated. I mean, he was just this grifting, self-promoting lunatic, and he didn't change as a person by lucking into power. And what happened, I can remind your listeners of my view of this. I mean, he is a game show host who was successfully marketed as a business genius
8:39to tens of millions of credulous Americans who watched 14 seasons of The Apprentice, and that worked. We have a country that bought that lie. I mean, he was not a business genius. He was nothing like even a brilliant real estate developer. He was not even among the most prominent real estate developers in New York. He was just this branding guy who, again, became a game show host. And in his defense, he's funny and he's entertaining. He's not boring, right? So like boredom is, you know, the original sin, I guess, to be avoided at all costs. So he succeeds there where many politicians clearly don't, right? I mean, it's the fact that he could just cut through the Republican Party in 2016 with a scythe.
9:29That was due to the fact that all these guys were stiffs, and he wasn't, and he could see. And I mean, perversely, his crassness, his total lack of moral center, his obliviousness to facts or even logic, his shamelessness at even contradicting the sentence he spoke moments ago, his supernatural incapacity to be embarrassed for himself, right? That is a kind of superpower because it reads to many, many millions of Americans, apparently, again, I'm still astonished that we're even here to talking about this man, as authenticity. I mean, he's authentically an awful person, and that's better than being a hypocrite, right? They think most people in power are hypocrites. They're really awful, but they're pretending to be good.
10:29They're sanctimonious assholes, and they're judging you from their elitist perch in their institutions. And that is a thing to which most Americans, or 51% of Americans at the time, were fatally allergic. So Trump is better than all of that because at least he's authentically a cheeseburger-eating fake. I mean, he's authentically a fake. I mean, this is a weird kind of postmodern structure. I mean, people have compared this to, you know, professional wrestling with kayfabe, you know, like what's fake and what's real. Well, it's a real, kind of the fakery is part, the imposture is part of the entertainment, right? The spectacle has priced in the fact that this is not real violence, it's not real wrestling.
11:19But in some sense, that con, I mean, his fans always flattered themselves that they were sort of in on the con, right? They were kind of willingly being conned by this con man. And it was fun and funny. And they're owning the libs all the while. They didn't bother them because it really bothered the libtards, right? So we're now just getting drunk on liberal tears. But... The fact you're listening to an in-depth discussion like this one tells us you're exactly the kind of listener who'd enjoy a show built entirely around that level of detail. That is exactly the audience a show called Unpacking Israeli History is built for. It's hosted by Dr. Noam Weissman, an educator who spent his entire career studying and teaching Israeli history. Each episode walks through the people, events, and decisions that shaped modern Israel from the earliest roots of
12:14Zionism through to today. What makes it work is that Weissman isn't trying to tell you what to think. He digs into where the narratives actually differ, and he brings on guests who don't all agree with each other or with him, from journalist Haviv Rettig-Gue to Palestinian activist Ahmed Fouad al-Khatib. We all know podcasts can go either way. This one held our attention. It doesn't rush the story to get to a neat conclusion, and that's rarer than it should be. Search Unpacking Israeli History on Spotify, YouTube, or Apple Podcasts, or click the link in the description to start listening. I mean, you don't think the character of the president matters, right? He's the most powerful man in the world.
12:55Well, I'm glad you brought that up because I was going to say, perhaps we steal man. Look, the people who voted and supported Trump will be in many different camps, all the way from, you know from he's the greatest thing ever, to I'm a Republican, I have to vote for a nominee, to I'm a swing voter. And this is where, for me, it's interesting. And you make the point, the personality of the person who's the most powerful man in the world is really important. A lot of people, I think, made the calculation that bad personality is not as bad as bad policy. And I remember having a conversation with you, I think, on Tom Bilyeu's podcast, We Were Both Guests at the time, where we kind of agreed. Well, not kind of agreed, but I think I remember you saying the phrase,
13:37if liberals don't police the border, fascists will. And I think that was the choice at the time. It was a binary choice and to many people, not a particularly welcome one. But if you have a country where you have literally 10 million people coming in illegally over the previous presidency, what are people supposed to do? I think that's where a lot of people were. Do you think that's a fair... It is fair. It's defensible. I mean, it was not quite defensible at the moment you had to pull the lever to vote in 2024, because by that point, it was clear the Democrats had gotten the message that, okay, we have to end this zombie movie at the border. This is untenable. Biden was trying. That bill was getting blocked by Republicans
14:28who cynically wanted to maintain this issue into the election. So I don't think Kamala Harris was going to let the border unravel in the same way. But, oh, yeah, Biden's first day in office, his first act as president was to pass an executive order that, you know, transed the bathrooms and and and unraveled Trump's policy at the border. Right. So those are those were 80, 20 issues. And he grabbed the thin end of both of those issues his first day in office. So if those were your super stimuli, as they were for many, many millions of Americans, I get it. I get it. The Democrats were insane on those issues. I mean, to call any concern about the border, racism, right? I mean, that's... I mean, that was suicidal politics.
15:30I mean, it was just the dumbest thing imaginable until you get to the trans thing, which was even dumber. So, I mean, the fact that Kamala Harris couldn't speak even two intelligible sentences accounting for her change of heart around taxpayer-funded gender reassignment surgery for incarcerated illegal immigrants. I mean, that's largely why she didn't win. I mean, probably the most effective political ad of, I mean, if not our lifetime, you know, several decades was, you know, she's for they, them, he's for you. I mean, I think they put 30 percent of their ad spent onto that ad. It would have been so easy for a sane and morally sane candidate to have said something rational. It went asked about that policy.
16:29But because of the constraints of wokeism, which haven't dissipated as much as I would have hoped at this point, I mean, we can talk about whether we're going to get a resurgence of moral confusion from the Democrats now now in the you know on the on the heels of their uh you know victory you know their their sweep of um the elections but i don't know what lesson they're going to draw there but i i fear that the ideologues on the left could capture more of the conversation because many democrats are going to draw the lesson that they don't actually have to moderate, that really what the center of moral gravity here is more progressivism, more activism, more, you know, woke two point. I mean, woke AOC said woke 1.0 is crazy. But, you know,
17:17what is woke 2.0 in her mind or in the minds of anyone else who's in a position to steer the Democratic Party? I don't know. I'm worried about it. Long before 1776, before Washington and Jefferson, there was another generation, men and women who crossed an ocean to build a new kind of civilization. They faced hunger, war, and wilderness, but they built communities, practiced self-government, and discovered that liberty and virtue had to go hand in hand. Hillsdale College's new free documentary series, Colonial America, From Wilderness to Civilization, tells the remarkable story of how a century and a half of struggle and faith forged the uniquely American character we know today. Access the whole course at hillsdale.edu slash trigger.
18:03You'll discover why liberty, especially the freedom to live by your own conscience, drove people to cross an ocean. You'll learn how they built towns and local governments from scratch to protect themselves and how their belief in hard work and virtue created a society built on peace and prosperity. We proudly promote Hillsdale's courses time and again and for good reason. They're genuinely brilliant. No gimmicks, no politics, just a world-class education at zero cost to you. So if you want to understand how freedom really began, this is the series to watch. Go to hillsdale.edu slash trigger to enroll for free. That's hillsdale.edu slash trigger and see how America's story really began. The worrying thing for me is, look, we talk about policies and obviously the Democrats
18:49were insane. I think we can all agree with that. To me, that wasn't even the most dangerous thing. It was their rhetoric. They were so antagonistic. They felt that they were just driving a wedge between about 11% of this country and the other 89%. And you look at America and you go, well, it already feels incredibly divided. Can we really take woke 2.0 or is everything just going to implode as a result? Yeah, I mean, so I'm, let's table woke 2.0 for a second. Because I think that's a big conversation. But the, I mean, in defense of Democrats, it's amazing to see how little traction, criticism of Trump ever got, even when he was visibly breaking our democracy. Again, based on pure selfishness.
19:49We had, just to remind you, we had a president who, a sitting president, who was trying to steal an election all the while saying it was being stolen from him. He was engaged in creating this fraud, this enormous lie, running the risk of shattering our society with a conspiracy theory and producing political violence. And then he produced political violence, right? And did precious little to stop it for hours as literally the Congress people were being hunted in the Capitol, right? And then that whole thing got spun as, what, a false flag operation by the FBI? I mean, like, you had Tucker Carlson, you know, and the other, you know, meme lords trying to spin this thing as having nothing to do
20:36with anything, there were no stakes, right? These are all just people LARPing, or they got let in by the cops, you know, and it was, nothing was ever at stake. It certainly wasn't a riot. I mean, this was like just a desecration of our democracy. And it was quite a consequential one. And there were moments where it really could have become a proper emergency. I mean, like, you know, had Mike Pence caved in and done what Trump was urging him to do, really, I mean, again, the guy's life was almost certainly in jeopardy because of how the president was behaving at that moment. Had he caved in, you know, who knows what would have happened, right? So it's, this is a man who was willing to play a game of chicken with American history.
21:28Again, purely, it's not that, there was no some high, there was not a higher motive here. It's not like we were in war with a, a war with a superpower, and he had to claim, you know, wartime powers because otherwise, you know, everything was going to be ruined. No, this is a guy who just wants to be rich and famous and extract the next ruble from the next deal. I mean, it's just... I mean, does anyone think that... if Maduro had been smart enough to buy a billion dollars worth of Trump's meme coin, that we would have gone into Venezuela. I mean, it's like that's the world. The fact that that's even plausible when I state it that way, that's the measure of how much damage has been done to the brand of America.
22:19And also Venezuela. Well, I mean, Venezuela. But I mean, to take it out of Venezuela, if the mullahs in Tehran had offered Trump and Whitcough a multi-billion dollar resort deal on the Persian Gulf, what would be our Iran policy? I don't think anyone knows, right? I mean, that's the thing. But you could not have said that of any other American president in our lifetime. And so Trump has created that world where we have a country that stands for nothing apart from eking out whatever advantage the president can get personally, right? I mean, we have a country that will not judge the moral integrity of any other nation now. I mean, he vilifies our allies and tariffs them into oblivion or threatens to, and he strangely lionizes our genuine enemies like putin right and and um so it's i mean it's been i mean there
23:28there really needs to be a reckoning we need a some kind of hard reset of of uh america's role in the world ultimately in 2028 you know hopefully with the same administration um but i mean we're not we're certainly not out of the woods he's got two more years of his tenure here so who knows what's going to happen in his lame duck phase and he's obviously not going to admit to himself or anyone else that he's a lame duck and he still has a tremendous amount of power as president I mean he's going to be investigated and maybe impeached there'll be certainly more friction based on the results of these elections. But he can create a tremendous amount of harm. And I do worry now that the reckoning,
24:15that the cleaning of House that needs to happen here is going to be perceived by most people right of center as just more cynical lawfare, right? Like, this is just, you know, like an investigation of his cronies. And like, I mean, take the corruption piece, which everyone really should be nauseated by. I mean, this is not investigating him for the Stormy Daniels payment. I mean, there is so much there to investigate and to prosecute. And if we do, if by magic he and his fellow enablers haven't broken laws, well, then obviously we don't have the right laws, right? I mean, so we, you know, so DeSantis has, I mean, there are many people making the same noises. We, you should not be able to trade stocks in these roles, right? I mean,
25:03this is just, it's insane that we had Trump. I mean, Trump has been placing more stock trades than I think all U.S. presidents combined in American history. I mean, it's just like, it's insane what has happened in advance of each iteration of his tariff policy, for instance. I mean, the people who are tracking what people are doing on the stock market. But Sam, this is where I hear my inner voice of the reasonable right here. And I was going to make the joke, he's almost made as much money on the stock market as Nancy Pelosi. No, but if you cared about Pelosi, this is 100x Pelosi. I know. But I guess what I'm saying is, and we actually had this conversation with David Pakman earlier in the trip as well,
25:48is this is all feeling a bit Russian to me. Because in Russia, everyone's guilty. Everyone at the top of politics commits crime and bribery and all, because that's the only way you can, that's how they all operate. Right. And then the people who it is convenient in that moment to politically persecute, they are the ones that get persecuted. And now you've got to the point where everyone's preemptively partying in themselves and their children and their associates or whatever. So everything you're saying makes perfect sense. But I think if you were to apply that same magnifying glass to much of the left, you'd also get very similar things. But it's the scale that is just, I mean, everything Trump has done, I mean, there are, and this is going to sound hyperbolic,
26:39but I would bet anything there are a hundred things Trump has done, right? If not 1,000, but let's just, I'll be conservative here. 100 things he's done that are just totally unprecedented in their level of corruption and treasonously corrupt. I mean, just it's unbelievable that we have a person in the Oval Office who is behaving this way. Can you give some examples? Just go like one, two, three. Do you see what I mean? Well, I mean, so it's specifically with the with on the topic of corruption, again, everything. I mean, you have to ask ask yourself, what what was the tariff policy for right like it was well it's revealed when you know he puts a 46 tariff on vietnam and their response is to green light a resort deal
27:35for the trump family and then the tariff comes off right like i mean that that's so is there a law against that apparently not i mean it remains to be seen. I mean, I don't actually know, but it's like, it's very hard to create a system of governance that is immune to the predations of a motivated psychopath who you just put into the role of, into the most powerful role in that system, right? So it may be impossible. I mean, I think James Madison said it was impossible to create a government that is so perfectly tuned that it's going to work like clockwork even when you have someone of the lowest conceivable character in the driver's seat, right? But that's what we have. We have someone of the lowest conceivable character in the driver's seat. And that has been obvious for a decade, right?
28:28Nothing has been hidden. So anyone who is surprised on any level to discover who Trump is now has been completely asleep. And I'm not even sure they, again, I really have no theory of mind for anyone who is only now starting to feel that maybe Trump was not their guy. Well, I gave you the theory. Hold on. But I gave it to you. And this is where we have to. They just don't like that he didn't care about groceries or their groceries when he he was waiting war in iran i think the the fair steel man version of this certainly for the people who were prepared to go either way which are in the minority in this country admittedly but but they're the key piece right they're the thing that moves elections arguably you i think it's fair to say is what i said earlier which is you
29:21have a binary choice yeah and you can you can have, you know, trans. No, I'm not talking about those people. So I get the people who would say, okay, and this is like, and I mean, Ben Shapiro, when I debated Ben Shapiro on my podcast, he essentially articulated this position in response to which I don't have all that much to say in the end. And he said, listen, we're talking about the real world here. I had a choice between Kamala Harris and Donald Trump. I don't have to like the character of the president or admire it or be at all confused about it to feel that given what I would, what I can reasonably expect her, I'm just putting words in his mouth, that's not what he said, but this is the subtext.
30:07Given what, you know, I had every reason to believe Kamala Harris's positions would be, especially with regard to Israel, this is, it was a forced choice. And I took the, you know, the person who, warts and all, was going to have a better policy with respect to the things I most care about. And for many people, it's a very short list. And for many people, there was only one thing on that list, right? In Ben's case, I think policy with respect to Israel was, I mean, it's not the only thing, but it had to be very high for him. And I get it. I mean, the kinds of noises that you heard from the Democratic Party post-October 7th, I mean, Biden was good for about two months, maybe. But then there was a kind of a great unraveling
31:00of moral clarity. And now we have, among Democrats, seemingly a litmus test uh you know a kind of loyalty test that you have to use this word genocide in a way that no one used it up until a few years ago or no sane person used it this way up until a few years ago um and describe you know what israel did in gaza as a as a a genocide. And I think we're... I mean, seeing that, if you're a single-issue voter, I get it. So the people I'm deeply confused by are the people who have always been part of the MAGA cult. I mean, they love the man. He is kind of a religious figure. So if any of those people are being picked off now by what the price of eggs right i don't i don't know how like i i i don't have a theory of mind
31:52for them i don't know what it would it was never clear to me what it would take because it was always so obvious that this is a man you couldn't admire well look let's let's steel man that so there's a lot of people who voted for Trump who probably also would have voted for someone like Bernie because those were the forgotten majority. They were the people who had never, their concerns had never been addressed. But it was always obvious that he wasn't going to address their concerns. Yeah, but Sam, if nobody ever addresses your concerns, if nobody ever cares your problems, if people always ignore you, if people in areas, let's be fair like this, thinks you're just one layer above scum, and all of a sudden someone comes along and says that he
32:36does care, even if he doesn't, that's still better than any politician who just pretty much ignores you and talks to you with contempt. Okay, but this guy was always, I mean, again, everything's in plain view. This is a guy who's selling meme coins and gold watches and golden sneakers and other crap to his fans. And in the case of meme coins, doing an actual rug pull where he makes billions and they lose billions. I mean, people have lost billions on his crappy meme coins. I agree with Sam that that's indefensible. But to me, correct me if I'm wrong, the meme coin came after the election, wasn't it? It came right before inauguration. There's a broader thing going on, which is... But he was always that guy.
33:23And that's the thing. He always had contempt for his fans. He is the guy who said, I could shoot someone in Times Square and not lose a single vote, right? He's saying, my fans don't care if I commit murder, right? My fans are psychopaths. I mean, that's the subtext. Like, they have no moral standard. There is no... I do not have to worry about the maintenance of my reputation with these people, because they're fucking barbarians. I mean, that's the subtext I always heard. And it was loud. Like, they should have heard it, too. This was an insult to his fans, and they didn't hear it for some reason. They just kept fucking laughing. And so, and again, I'm not convinced that, I do think we have a radical core of the MAGA cult.
34:16I don't know what percentage of American society this is, but maybe it's 25%, that cannot be disillusioned on this point. Like, I think he will, I think his approval rating can sink to more or less where it has. I mean, I know it's like around 30% now. But I think there is a floor here beneath which you have people who just... Again, I mean, I'm very familiar with cults. I mean, it's amazing how resistant to falsifiability, you know, a cultic attachment is. I mean, literally, you can have someone who predicts the flying saucer is going to land on Thursday night at 8 o'clock and beam us up. And then everyone's waiting on the back lawn on Thursday and nothing happens. And half the people leave
35:05because they realize they're in the presence of stark delusion. But the other half just double down. They have a rationale for why it didn't work. And now a lot of people have a rationale that, you know, our man was just misled by the evil Jews, right? The fucking BB got into his head, led him into a war of choice that, you know, I mean, it's easy to overlook the fact that they're strangely denigrating Trump in this, right? Like, so Trump was misled by Bibi, really? That's your guy? That he just couldn't figure out what was what, and Bibi outsmarted him but there the conspiracy thinking that he has leveraged in our society this is one of the most irresponsible things he's done he's just ample he's his his
35:51political tenure started with a conspiracy the the the birther uh conspiracy against obama and he has just danced from one conspiracy to the next. I mean, the Epstein story was the only thing, interestingly, that threatened to ruin his reputation among his fans. But yeah, there'll be some conspiracy that will absorb this disgrace for him, and it will place the blame elsewhere for I don't know how many millions of Americans, but it's got to be tens of millions. I think it's interesting what you say. I was going to move on, but I think the BB tricked Trump into attacking Iran. I mean, it's a complicated one because I do think Israel sees it as it being in its own interest for the United States to help in destroying Iran's offensive weapon system, even if they don't have
36:45nuclear weapons. But it seems to me like actually that is a mechanism to protect Trump from criticism in people's minds because they can say, well, it's not Trump. He got tricked. Israel did this, which I always thought was a very strange argument. I mean, first of all, literally every country in the world is trying to shape American foreign policy in its direction because America is the most powerful country in the world. Russia, Ukraine, Israel, Qatar, every Qatar, China, every country in the world is attempting to persuade the President of the United States and other people in the U.S. to do something. But ultimately, it is up to the people in charge of the United States to make those decisions. And if they make a bad decision, which I personally think the Iran
37:30war was, that's on them. Well, it is. And also, people are forgetting that on any given day, Trump will tell Bibi to not do something, and B BB will comply. He has to. I mean, like literally call your planes back, you know? So it's just, that's just not what's been happening, right? It's delusional. I mean, there's so much delusion required to have supported this guy. Again, I'm not discounting the fact, you know, the forced choice. If you had a very short list of concerns and you were very worried about the wokeness destroying everything you care about, I get how it was possible to be radicalized there. But to have ever thought this man was competent or knowledgeable or had the moral integrity to be president
38:20was obviously a delusion from the beginning. I mean, that was just... A while back, I pushed myself in training because I'm a legend, but ended up with a strain that took far longer to recover from than it ever used to. Nothing dramatic, just one of those moments where you realize your body isn't snapping back the way it once did. And as you get older, those moments start adding up. Turns out there's a reason for that. And it's not just getting older. It's something specific happening at the cellular level. That's the idea behind qualia senolytic, a science-backed formula built around a fairly new area of research called senolytics. Your body accumulates what researchers call senescent cells, sometimes nicknamed zombie cells. Cells that have done their
39:03job and are just sitting there using up resources instead of clearing out. The theory is that this buildup is a big part of what people describe as feeling middle-aged. Lower energy, slower recovery after exercise, and general joint discomfort. Qualia Senolytic uses nine vegan plant-derived compounds designed to support your body's natural processes for clearing out these cells. And you only take it two days a month. It's vegan, non-GMO, and developed with input from research scientists working specifically in this field. Since I started taking it, mornings feel easier, workouts don't take as long to bounce back from, and I generally have more left in the tank by the afternoon than I did a year ago. Experience the science of feeling younger. Go to qualialife.com slash trig for up to
39:5250% off your purchase and use code trig for an additional 15%. That's Q-U-A-L-I-A, life.com slash trig for an extra 15% off your purchase. Your older self will thank you. And thanks to Qualia for sponsoring this episode. Let's move on to the woke thing then, because I mean, I am one of those people, I think Francis, I think to some extent, you are one of those people who thinks wokeness is, I mean, it's antithetical to our civilization's core values entirely, extremely dangerous, was being practiced not just at the level of the presidency, but throughout every major institution in America. Fair? So far? Yeah, yeah. I mean, you and I might draw the line slightly in slightly different places but trans women are women
40:47i mean so so i'm just to be just to be clear like i'm so like i wouldn't necessarily want to sign up to um i mean there are many people who have gone hard against wokeness in general or, you know, the trans thing in particular and have said things that I can't defend. So like I'm not, you know, in whoever, you know, Matt Walsh's lane on this. Right. There was clearly a there's the activist class among Democrats had far too. We're talking, you know, eight percent of of Democrats maybe had far too much power and have has. I don't know what when the rubble when the when the smoke clears and we can investigate the rubble. I will know what is currently true. I really don't know what's currently true. But for years, this hysteria has just vitiated our elite institutions,
41:56universities, newspapers, scientific journals. I mean, it's just been appalling. I mean, you literally had the best journals on earth, both medical and general scientific, publishing editorials disavowing the use of the word woman, right? So again, I don't know everything she said on social media. I mean, I'm a fan of J.K. Rowling, and I would defend her against most of her attackers, but I'm sure she has been pushed to the brink and said something on Twitter that I haven't read and probably wouldn't defend. But still, like her fundamental allergy to this particular, on this particular front in the war of ideas, I mean, just this attack on the use of the word woman, and where we're condemned
42:44until the end of the world to talk about menstruators and people with ovaries. I mean, that was so idiotic and so offensive. Yeah, I mean, it's just the fact that it captured our lead institutions is deeply embarrassing. And eventually people will, people who are part of this lunacy will forget they, you know, their contributions to it. And everyone's going to look back and say, you know, can you believe that? I mean, you know. That seems incredibly optimistic to me, Sam. This is where I was going with all of this. You think we're going to be fighting over the use of the word woman? Well, first of all, I think it's important to broaden this out and to recognize some things that sometimes people forget about when they talk about wokeness.
43:27Wokeness was not just about trans women or women, JK Rowling, Zanati, and whatever. I see a direct connection between wokeness and open borders. There's a direct connection between what you rightly see, I think, is hysteria and stupidity and whatever else you want to label it as when it comes to Israel, because Israel is the oppressor. Palestinians are oppressed, this whole thing. So it's not just about it was embarrassing. It was outright dangerous to the survival and flourishing of our societies, in my opinion. Now, we are now in a position after the midterms where nobody really knows exactly how it's going to go. But there's a very real possibility that in the same way that you would say,
44:12well, all these people voted for Trump because they hated wokeness and they were blind to this. Well, a lot of people voted against the Republicans now because of high energy prices and so on. And there's a very real possibility now that you're going to get a wokeness against the Republicans now because of high energy prices and so on. And there's a very real possibility now that you're gonna get a wokeness like you haven't seen before. Don't you think? The fact you're listening to an in-depth discussion like this one, tells us you're exactly the kind of listener who'd enjoy a show built entirely around that level of detail. That is exactly the audience a show called Unpacking Israeli History is built for.
44:44It's hosted by Dr. Noam Weissman, an educator who spent his entire career studying and teaching Israeli history. Each episode walks through the people, events, and decisions that shaped modern Israel from the earliest roots of Zionism through to today. What makes it work is that Weissman isn't trying to tell you what to think. He digs into where the narratives actually differ, and he brings on guests who don't all agree with each other or with him, from journalist Haviv Retik-Gur to Palestinian activist Ahmed Fouad Al-Khatib. We all know podcasts can go either way. This one held our attention. It doesn't rush the story to get to a neat conclusion, and that's rarer than it should be. Search Unpacking Israeli History on Spotify, YouTube, or Apple Podcasts, or click the link in the description to start
45:23listening. I'm worried about that. I mean, I think that's, so just to link that to my deepest concern here. I mean, so the path, in my view, the path to fascism in America is for the left to get sufficiently crazy that only the right will do. right, who's, who's, um, can be credibly tarred as a, you know, a communist or, you know, communist adjacent, you know, idiot, you know, on, on all things economic, leaving the wokeness aside. I think in a forced choice between fascism and communism, America picks fascism a hundred times out of a hundred. So I just think that just think that's the society we're living in. So if we put up a sufficiently radical, and in the worst case, kind of a red-green alliance,
46:32useful idiot, you know, or genuine ideologue, again, kind of an Islamo-leftist, you know, marriage, you know, DSA plus some entanglement with Islam, I think you could literally elect anyone right of center. It could be my pillow guy, it could be Don Jr., it could be a genuinely scary right-wing ideologue. It could be Tucker Carlson. I mean, it could be anyone against that, right? So if the left gets sufficiently crazy, the failure mode there is not that we get, you know, Islamo-leftism in the White House. I think we get something truly appalling, you know, Islamo-leftism in the White House, I think we get something truly appalling, you know, on the right. So that's what I'm worried about. But yeah, I share your concern that the lesson that the Democrats will draw here
47:32is that the sky's the limit. We really can do no wrong. There is no left-leaning message, however bizarre, that will count against us effectively now because we're part of this blue tsunami. Again, to imagine an El-Sayed- like candidate for the presidency in 2028, I don't think that candidate stands a chance of winning in America, largely because of how anchored at least half of Americans are. I mean, it's probably more like 60% are to some version of, you know, Christian religiosity. But they're clearly, that doesn't get them, so then what is possible on the right in response? There I really think you could get someone even less qualified than Trump and more ideological than Trump. In Trump's defense, you know,
48:39one of the sins he doesn't have is a commitment to a worldview, right? Like, he doesn't have anything he's willing to stand behind beyond his own narrowly construed self-interest. So, no, I think you could get, you know, you could get effectively President Nick Fuentes if you promote it. If it's a forced choice between El-Sayed and Nick Fuentes, I think we go right in this country. And no matter how dangerous and explicitly unethical that right-wing message is. But it's also as well, and we have to be honest about this, we're talking about Trump and the voter has to take some responsibility, as do the politicians that have preceded those presidents. If you look at Trump, why was the main reason Trump got elected? No more forever wars. It's because people were burnt out from Afghanistan,
49:46Iraq. They were sick of the lies. They were sick of this idea that you could go over to another country, you could bring democracy, and all that happened is that you were there for two decades, and you pumped in trillions, and then at the end yeah what were you left with yeah i mean so i think the lesson that people are drawing from it that admittedly um uh depressing history is isolationism and i think that's a disaster i mean so american isolationism is synonymous with the ascendance of our enemies. You know, it's the ascendance of China. So do we want more CCP influence globally? Is that really the goal here? Well, okay, then be, you know, an America-first isolationist. Do you want Russia to be even more revanchist than it is?
50:39And, I mean, do you want NATO to properly dissolve? I mean, even now, our allies or former allies can be forgiven for thinking that NATO has, in effect, dissolved. I mean, who thinks we're going to come to the rescue of Poland tomorrow if Russia invades Poland? So it's... We need a liberal world order. We really need that. First of all, America has been the primary beneficiary of a liberal world order for 80 years. I mean, that's just a fact. I mean, we, like, we have, Trump is right to point out that there's been a free rider problem, right? Like, you know, one of the good effects of Trumpist craziness has been that Europe has woken up and realized its need to shoulder the expense of its own defense or the expense of its own defense,
51:40or take responsibility for its own defense, however belatedly. He was right to castigate, I think the Germans it was, for just their happy dependence on Russian oil, right? So, but the idea that America shouldn't have a leadership role in the world and that we don't have a vested interest in global order that is not just this, you know, a return to, you know, spheres of influence and just, you know, pure power politics. It has been a mutually beneficial arrangement for us to shoulder a disproportionate burden of being the world's cop. We have not merely been stolen from. Sam, be fair. Most people in this country wouldn't see it that way. Most people look at Iraq, look at Afghanistan. Well, no, it's very easy to criticize those wars.
52:55So there are many things to say about those wars. Vietnam, for example, is another one most people would point out as well yes but it's it's easy to forget that you know we had a the the the actual superpower conflict with the soviet union was a problem for the whole world and it was not obvious how to solve it right and the and the idea that you're just going to have countries falling to to soviet i mean you you can speak to this better than i can the idea that we would want to resist that and resisted militarily in the I mean, the war in Afghanistan was totally justifiable that we launched it in an effort to get al-Qaeda. Then we prosecuted it badly and we stayed there for too long. And it is completely understandable to draw the lesson
53:59that nation-building is a project to which we are not well suited. But again, it's hard to, it's easy to forget, with the benefit of hindsight now, how tempting it was to see that it was possible, drawing the lesson for, let me take the aftermath of World War II. I mean, it is amazing to consider that we bombed Germany and Japan nearly to oblivion, and then helped rebuild both of those societies, and they became allies in a few short years. I mean, how? I mean, it's like, it's a double miracle, right? So you have that experience. I mean, Japanese nationalism, you know, with, you know, kamikazes and all, I mean, it's not jihadism, but it was damn close, right? I mean, it was just as, you know, psychotically committed to a cause as you can get
55:02without, you know, a proper notion of martyrdom and, you know, paradise awaiting you with 72 virgins, right? The fact that we dropped two nuclear bombs on that society, in addition to all the, you know all the fire bombings of cities. And in, I think it was seven years, I think like 1952, we left and they were allies. So it's easy to have drawn the lesson that nation building is in principle possible. And what we didn't understand was how difficult, how much culture matters, how much religion in particular, in my view, matters. And yeah, we deluded ourselves into thinking that people were, if enough people just dyed their finger and voted in an election in Iraq and in Afghanistan, these would be healthy democracies, right?
56:11And the other problem is, Sam, is the examples that you were quoting, as incredible as they are and as wonderful as those societies turned out to be, it's 80 years ago. People are going, you know, it's like a football team going, well, these tactics work. And you go, yeah, mate, they worked in 1945. It's 2026. The tactics, that's what a lot of people would say, the tactics don't work anymore. Look at the deficit, 40 trillion. And as well, Sam, you know, there's a lot of people say, the tactics don't work anymore. Look at the deficit, 40 trillion. And as well, Sam, you know, there's a lot of people in this country, if you look at it right the way through history, have always been isolationists.
56:50You know, you didn't want to get involved, not you personally, the Americans, you didn't want to get involved in World War I. You didn't want to get involved in World War II. And there were understandable reasons for that in both instances, by the way, this has always been a large part of Americans' position, which is, we've got our own problems here. It's a long way away. We need to prioritize America. Right. But again, there's so much confusion about what is real here. I mean, if you ask most Americans about foreign aid, for instance, and you say, I mean, I might get these numbers a little wrong, but this is the gist of what polls have shown for quite some time. If you ask, well, do we spend too much on foreign aid?
57:38Vast numbers of Americans say, yeah, we'd spend way too much on foreign aid. How much should we spend? And they'll give a number that's like 10x what we actually spend. Right. I mean, so it's there. This is not a coherent worldview when you actually drill down on it. I mean, it's just a fact that we have problems that are global that can only be solved globally. I'm sure we'll talk about AI at some point. AI is one of those problems. We need to solve this coordination problem that we can't even address at the moment. But we are in an arms race, and we have to get out of an arms race, and we have to figure out how to build this technology in a way that, one, isn't going to destroy us, and two, could benefit us in
58:27an uncountable number of ways that, I mean, in success, there's an unimaginable amount of wealth that could be spread around everyone, right? But we have a political problem to solve first. I mean, the problem is so bad that if God came down and handed us the perfectly aligned AI, right, the AI that's never going to go rogue, that's never on its own going to go Terminator on us, it's just this oracle and perpetual motion machine of wealth creation, even that, again, just handed to us could fatally destabilize our world, given how riven we are by politics, right? So we have to figure out how to cooperate at a global scale in order to solve global problems. And here you have a philosophy that, I mean, Trump doesn't even hold.
59:23I mean, again, he holds no philosophy. But this spirit of isolationism is antithetical to that. And Trump himself, as an incompetent and a grifter and a maniac, is antithetical to that. The cult of know-nothings around him, you know, that has been, you know, everyone around him has passed through this sieve of loyalty tests. I mean, these are just people who are just willing to eat shit for him and lie perpetually for him as a loyalty test. I mean, that's who has survived contact with this man. Strangely, some of the wealthiest and most successful people in our society have passed this test. I mean, our own oligarchs have been willing to conform to these cultic parameters. So, again, it's not a recipe
1:00:21for sane collaboration with allies, and allies who can then apply enough pressure to the Putins of the world and to the, you know, the CCPs of the world so as to get something coercive actually done. I mean, and so that's... I mean, so one of the most despicable things he's done and consequential things he's done is, you know, so fully alienate our allies. And this is to go back to the war in Iran for a second. The reason why the war in Iran, one reason why it's, you know, appears to be a terrible failure is that we had, we went into it with no allies. I mean, no one was on board. He alienated all of our allies he he tariffed them and insulted them and lied about them and then went into a war
1:01:04and then and said we don't need you people because we've got all the power and then once the strait of hormuz became a problem then he he you know he asked for help uh and again no one keeps score i mean no one sees the bluff, the bluff get called, the humiliation, the new bluff, the lie to cover the old bluff. I mean, it's just, it is one, it's just a cascade of embarrassment. And his superpower is that he's incapable of shame, right? So he literally, he doesn't notice that he's just lost face in a way that would cause most people to want to kill themselves, right? But Sam, this is when people would say, look, the policeman of the world doesn't work. Look at the war in Iran. And there were a lot of people-
1:01:57But that's what alliances are for. I mean, so it's like, we are the, we're people... No, but that's what alliances are for. I mean, so it's like, we are the, we're the most powerful, we're the center of the alliance. But we need allies. Clearly, we need allies. And so, and yes, NATO wasn't perfect. But NATO's was better than no NATO. I mean, so it is, you just have to ask, I mean, filter by this question, how much has Putin, has Putin benefited in his own mind, whatever is in fact real, how much of the time that Putin has spent watching Trump's career, has he been gratified by what has been happening, and how much of the time has he spent feeling destabilized it or or the feeling that it was obviously to his
1:02:42disadvantage i mean there's been a few sanctions there and a few but but generally speaking i think he has watched a colossal act of vandalism be perpetrated on his enemy, America, by America. And we have vandalized our own house. And I think it's been, I'm sure it's been immensely gratifying to him. And so, and also for the CCP. Again, there's nothing, it's not that there aren't, you know, marginalia there where, you know, Trump has been hard on China in moments, and even on Russia in moments. But generally speaking, he has presided over a radical diminishment in American power and influence, and that's largely been a story of having alienated all of our allies. Sam, you mentioned AI. There's a lot I could challenge there, but...
1:03:40Challenge at least one thing. Challenge the worst thing. I mean, what am I actually wrong about? Where you're wrong, I think, well, there's two pieces to this. And one of the things that's happened with the Iran war is Francis and I think it's pretty much the most important issue of the last year. And we've talked about it so much that even our audience who really care about geopolitics are not that interested in it. But I do think this, from our perspective, it's worth exploring this with you because you're a smart guy and we've always respected your opinion on these things. However, our attitude to this latest bit of the Iran war, if you frame it like that, 12 day war, you take a shot at their nuclear facilities,
1:04:19seems perfectly sensible, even though military analysts we've spoken to since would argue it was never particularly likely to succeed. But let's say even there was a 5% chance of succeeding. To me, it's a no-brainer. We do not want Iran to have a nuclear weapon. The issue with this conflict is, and this was explained to us, when we came to the US last time, it was right as the war just was breaking. And our attitude was, we don't know. We're here to find out. Initially kind of skeptical that this is likely to lead to good things, but let's find out. The coin is in the air, I think was the phrase I used. And then we talked to lots of people, both on camera and off camera, and a number of things became clear.
1:05:01Number one, there was no great strategy here. This was a sugar high from Venezuela. You know, I'm on a roll here. We'll do this. Much like with Putin's invasion of Ukraine, there was a lack of accurate information for the reason I think that you articulated, which is if you optimize for loyalty, you don't get people who are going to tell you the truth about certain things. But ultimately, Robert Pape explained this to us very well. Robert Pape is, I mean, he's, don't get me started on Robert Pape, but he is a misinformation artist on this topic. OK, well, let me present the argument. Then you can explain where it's wrong, because I found this before with Iran wars. When you mention certain names, people, you know, start to get upset or whatever.
1:05:51But actually, they don't have the counter argument. Now, maybe you do. Let's hear it. I absolutely do. Right. But the argument was that because of the nature of Iran itself, because of how big it is, because of the geography of it, because it has the control over the strait from us, this was always... And literally, the problem with what you've just said about Robert Pape is literally everything he told us in March or April, was it March? It was April. April, has turned out to be true pretty much to the letter. Well, what's turned out to be true? Just the fact that the war has not been won? No, he explained how exactly it would go and what the mechanism of leverage Trump had and what the mechanism of leverage Iran had
1:06:31and what Iran would do at every phase. And so he basically said, they will close the Strait of Hormuz. And at this point... But everyone knew that. I can only assume Trump and Higgs, I mean, as stupid as some of these people are, they had to have been briefed about all... I mean, everyone... I mean, for years and years, we knew that. Fine. Well, let's play your game then. If then, despite, as you say, their stupidity, they knew all of this, what was their plan for when they did that? Well, they clearly had none, right? Right. But so the... What was their plan for when they did that? Well, they clearly had none, right? And Pape's argument is there is no plan because they have the leverage. So unless you're prepared to escalate further, there's nothing you can do.
1:07:11What does escalate further mean? It means you start to land Marines on Karg Island. You start to land Marines in and around proper, at which point they escalate further. Well, I don't know. So again, Robert Pape is, I don't think he claims to be a military strategist, and that's probably a good thing. I think he does, actually. I think that's what he studies. Well, he studies, so his, so just to give a little history here. So he's very famous for having written a book. The book is a little confusing because it goes by, I think it was published under two titles, but certainly one of these titles was Dying to Win. It's about suicide terrorists. Sam, let's not get into it because it's going to just derail the conversation.
1:08:01It's a bit much for people. Just come back to the Iran thing. Forget about Robert Pape. Forget about all of this. The argument was the problem with this war is not that it was badly prosecuted. The problem with this war... No, no, it's... You're saying it's unwinnable? It's unwinnable with allies? It's unwinnable... It's unwinnable with a free world that's willing to take some pain at the pump in order to starve this regime that's emiscerating its own people? There is no doubt that if we wanted to do to Iran what we did to Germany and Japan, theoretically, we could do. What if it's just... I mean, so the problem is... What is it's just, I mean, so the problem is, so. What is it? Well, here's the deeper issue is that we,
1:08:44and I don't just mean America, I mean the free world, we are in a war against jihadism. And we've been in a war against jihadism for as long as I've been alive, right? So, and it's an unacknowledged war, right? Like people don't understand this war. They really understand it in Israel because it is right, it's been on their doorstep since the moment of their founding, even before. It's unignorable there, but here it's ignorable, right? Here we get a 9-11, we get, you know, it's ignorable even in France, you know, they-11. It's ignorable even in France. They get a Bataclan massacre and a Charlie Hebdo massacre, and you get a school teacher who gets decapitated in the middle of the street. And there's a certain level of this that they're just willing to
1:09:34tolerate. But we have a global problem with jihadism. And the most excruciating instance of this problem would be a nuclear-armed regime that is jihadist. And that is what Iran could become. Iran has been governed since 1979 by jihadists. So these people are really willing to die. They're really willing to see everyone beneath them die. You know, these are quite stoical in the context of their certainty about paradise. I mean, you just have to look at how they fought their side of the war against Iraq, right? They sent tens of thousands of boys to clear minefields with their lives. Israel had nothing to do with this. America, there were no Jews involved. America was, you know, not part of this.
1:10:31This was Muslim fighting Muslim, right? And they were sending boys across minefields with, you know, plastic keys around their necks that were going to open the gates of paradise for them. And these boys, you know, some of these boys survived. They got to the Iraqi side. I mean, the Iraqis were, I mean, there were literally stories of Iraqis, like, just reduced to tears and being unwilling to fire their rifles at waves of boys. This is a fucking zombie movie. And some of these boys survived and were put in detention on the Iraqi side and interviewed. I mean, like all of this, you can talk, these kids were talked to. Sam, I agree with you on this. This is a worldview that we have to come to terms with.
1:11:21It makes the unthinkable not only thinkable, but guaranteed. And it's not nationalism, and it's not ordinary politics the way Robert Pape would tell you it is, right? This is not the prosecution of nationalistic goals, you know, and ordinary terrestrial grievances. This is true belief in paradise, right? So if we have a jihadist regime armed with nuclear weapons, everything we think we know about nuclear deterrence goes out the window, right? Let's accept this for the sake of argument. See, because this is what I see now. If I say anything about how this war was a bad idea, I get a bunch of people say, so you think Iran should have nuclear weapons? No, I don't think Iran should. But the question is, what should we do about Iran?
1:12:05Well, the question is, how does prosecuting this war achieve a non-nuclear run? As far as I can tell, Iran is way closer to having nukes as a result. Well, that may be the case. But again, that's that's a measure of how ineptly we have done this. Let's say that you've got, I mean, you're probably overestimating the strength of your allies. We know what the British Armed Forces look like at this point. Same with the French. It's not so much a matter of sending in their troops. It's a matter of having agreed about what the mission is. And what do you understand to be the correct strategy that wasn't pursued here? What would the world look like if the problem had been sufficiently articulated by a president who
1:12:48actually understood it and could speak honestly about it, and our allies were on board. And so therefore, we were willing to watch gas prices climb for a year or two and do what we need to do to mitigate that and have our allies in the Gulf help us. The amazing thing is we had allies, oil-producing allies, who wanted us to win this war against Iran almost as much as Israel did. But their oil went largely through the Sharia Firm, which Iran then blocked. Right. who wanted us to win this war against Iran almost as much as Israel did, right? But their oil went largely through the Sharia of Hormuz, which Iran then blocked. Right, okay, so... So they have the trump card. How do you overcome that?
1:13:27Well, you overcome it by one understanding that it really is... This does not get better. It's never going to get easier to prevent Iran from getting nukes. It's certainly not going to be easier once they have nukes. So we know what happens. Let's just kind of reverse engineer it. We know what happens when they get nukes, right? Short of them using nukes and, you know, actually achieving a genocide, which, you know, they're committed. Forget about that. Just let's just, on the day they have nukes, what can we do to walk that back? Nothing. Basically nothing. But there's nothing we can do now. This is... No, but that's not... We've proven that there's nothing we can do. No, no, we haven't. You're pointing to a war that we have barely
1:14:21fought and without allies other than israel um without any pre without any of the preparation you would have thought we would have so so i mean the fact that we don't have enough of our own ordinance like the fact that we can we we could we we shoot our wad uh over the course of a very short war and then we're we're hearing that we actually don't have enough interceptors for like we we we now have a problem now china is is eyeing Taiwan, and we realize we might, even if we wanted to, maybe we can't help Taiwan because we certainly don't have the spares to give to or to sell to Ukraine because we didn't build enough. And it takes us four years to build something that we should be able to build in a month, right?
1:15:17And we don't have the drone game that we should be able to build in a month, right? And we don't have the drone game that we should have. And we haven't been supporting Ukraine enough in that war to have learned everything they've learned in their war against. I mean, we should be at the absolute forefront of how to wage war in the 21st century, and we're clearly not, right? So there's layers of mistakes here and layers of lack of preparation. So, I mean, I think we're all right to be genuinely surprised and horrified by the ways in which we were not prepared for Iran's first moves that were all too predictable in this world. So, yeah, they're going to bomb our closest military bases uh you know or send drones into our closest military bases and bomb our allies and
1:16:08their you know oil refineries and we were surprised by that i mean that was a we didn't have a that wasn't part of our contingency plan we didn't have enough of our own drone defenses or enough interceptors to to deal with that that that okay that's the the fact that our actual military power as it is need as it as it's needed now the the way war is is fought now is so apparently ramshackle right that that's not a that's not? That's not a sign that it's impossible to wage this war and win against a power like Iran. I mean, if Iran is impossible for us to beat in a war, what is China? The fact you're listening to an in-depth discussion like this one tells us you're exactly the kind of listener who'd enjoy a show built entirely around that level of detail. That is exactly the audience a show called Unpacking
1:17:04Israeli History is built for. It's hosted by Dr. Noam Weissman, an educator who spent his entire career studying and teaching Israeli history. Each episode walks through the people, events, and decisions that shaped modern Israel from the earliest roots of Zionism through to today. What makes it work is that Weissman isn't trying to tell you what to think. He digs into where the narratives actually differ, and he brings on guests who don't all agree with each other or with him, from journalist Haviv Retek-Gur to Palestinian activist Ahmed Fouad al-Khatib. We all know podcasts can go either way. This one held our attention. It doesn't rush the story to get to a neat conclusion, and that's rarer than it should be.
1:17:38Search Unpacking Israeli History on Spotify, YouTube, or Apple Podcasts, or click the link in the description to start listening. Now, see, this is why I think the distinction is important, and this is why I brought up Germany and Japan. If you take the thesis that Iran is about to develop nuclear weapons, and the first act that it will take with them is to drop them on a neighbor, let's say Saudi Arabia or Israel or whatever, and the world must act to stop this, then absolutely the United States, with allies or without, can win that war. But what that requires is a level of investment, I use investment in inverted commas, that is orders of magnitude greater than what's been committed. Or a willingness to starve their economy
1:18:24and pay some pain ourselves in the meantime. The thing is... I mean, so we blockade the Strait of Hormuz. It doesn't get blockaded for us, we blockade it, right? We destroy their refineries. Then they will destroy their Arab refineries okay but there there's i mean these are things that take years to get online yeah once it's safe and it won't be safe for many years but i mean again we have i mean this vulnerability so it's hard to you where do you set your way back machine for some sane policy here to have prepared us to to fight this war that was always going to be inevitable like like i mean this is not it was always obvious that iran couldn't get nukes right and if you thought so it And so one way to have been confused about this,
1:19:20and many Democrats, I would say most Democrats, are still confused about this, is to have thought that the negotiation track, you know, that Obama was on and, you know, Biden, I assume, thought he was perpetuating, that that was going to bear fruit, right? That you could have an Iranian regime, again, a jihadist regime that is going to honestly sign a deal and not proceed to make nuclear weapons covertly or not bring themselves to the point where they could sprint whenever they decided they had to sprint for the bomb. That was always delusional from my point of view. I mean, I take the Israeli view of that, which is, okay, these people were never going to be rational actors who could be incentivized in normal ways and deterred in normal ways. That's
1:20:19just not the game they're playing. All right. This has taken a long time. I don't want to dwell on it too much. But to summarize, what I think is your position is Iran with nuclear weapons is such a... You're dinging me for all or my view of this for all of Trump's incompetence. I'm admitting all of the incompetence. No, I'm not. This is not about Trump's incompetence. What I'm saying is, as I understand your argument, is that the way to have dealt with this threat, which is a really serious, important threat, Iran can't have nuclear weapons, was to effectively say Iran with nukes is the greatest threat to global security and existence, and we, the United States, and our allies must act accordingly, and therefore... And there's one crucial piece that we
1:21:05haven't mentioned here, which is that Iran almost uniquely has a population that... It's hard to know the exact percentages here, but it certainly seems a majority of which is ready for a secular democracy. Is ready to rid themselves of the jihadis who control. And that's not something you could have said about many other states where nation building was doomed. But ultimately what you're talking about is a level of investment of resources, a willingness to absorb pain, economic disruption, et cetera, that is orders of magnitude greater than what we've had. I don't know that it's orders of magnitude greater. Again, given the right preparation, again, we have the oil-producing allies on our side in this. I mean, this is not going to war
1:21:57against all of the muslim world and all the petro states that we have the petro states the main ones on our side here except the moment you escalate with iran they will destroy all the all the oil production facilities well they're on their desalination plan there i don't actually know what what is or was militarily feasible. Like, I don't actually know what... That's a hypothetical. I mean, if true, that's synonymous with saying Iran has been, for who knows how many years, totally invulnerable, given the stranglehold they have on their neighbors. They haven't been totally invulnerable because there's always a price to pay for attacking their neighbors. No, but they're willing to go to paradise.
1:22:46Well, see, before you get to paradise, there's a point at which you are still running a country. And so from their perspective, until you make this about their survival, they are acting in a way that is more like a rational actor than what you're talking about. And so the reason they haven't attacked their neighbors and whatever is it's not in their interest to do so until you make it in their interest to do so by attacking them the way that Trump has done, by destroying their oil facilities, by landing troops on their land, et cetera. And the paper argument, I know you're not a fan of his, but to me, very persuasive, is the more you escalate, the more they will counter-escalate. And he explained exactly how
1:23:31they would do that. And that is exactly what they've done. And so the problem is that ultimately, I agree Iran shouldn't get nuclear weapons, but it's not clear to me that there's a route available for democratic nations. There is no success here apart from regime change. I mean, it's just, this is not, like, the status quo is also intolerable. Like, there's no, again, this is like theable. Like there's, there's, there's no, you, again, this is like the vote between, you know, you know, Kamala and, and. Yeah. Well, you didn't let me finish. And this was the important point that I was going to make, which is exactly the joke has been made after the midterms. Iran has achieved regime change in America. And, and this was Texas. Yeah. And this was kind of my point, which is when you have a bunch of
1:24:21democratic countries which have short election cycles, which are all massively in debt. Remember, this is important, right? If you're starting from a position, and Francis alluded to this, however many tens of minutes ago, where war after war after war, you're promised that you will achieve some kind of outcome. It doesn't. It costs trillions of dollars. All of our countries are in massive levels of debt. Historically speaking, the pattern is you run up a surplus in peacetime and you spend that surplus in wartime. We're not in a position at the moment to make all of these investments, to tolerate the economic pain for years that you're talking about. And so the far more likely scenario is the Iranians, who whatever, their flaws are not
1:25:04stupid, they know this. They know they don't have to hold out forever. Well, we honestly, I mean, I don't know, and I doubt you know, and maybe no one knows how close that regime is to falling. And there's certainly good reason to believe that it's not far away right certainly again remind yourself as to how we got into this there was a possibility of what really looked like a decapitation strike and the question is do you fault the president for taking that opportunity? And, you know, I can't fault him for that. It seems completely... The title of the episode would be Sam Harris defends Donald Trump. So, I mean, that was one of the more rational things he's done. Again, what's the counterfeit?
1:25:55The counterfactual is to just wait and see what Iran does in its own, at the time of its choosing, you know, with a jihadist regime intact. Or the counterfactual is you accept the reality of the situation, which is unless you're prepared to launch a large scale, or I would say full scale military conflict with boots on the ground. My feeling is we learned the wrong lesson. We learned the wrong lesson from Vietnam. And we had, you know, quote, Vietnam syndrome for many, many years. And we just felt we couldn't do any, like we literally couldn't fire a gun because it's hopeless. We just don't know how to fight anymore. So we just watched a genocide in Rwanda happen. We got Navy SEALs parked on ships,
1:26:38you know, a mile away. And we just watch 800,000 people get slaughtered with machetes over the course of 94 days as though we can't do anything about it, right? That was the paralysis we had as a country. you know, the jihadists blow up, what is it, 271 Marines in their barracks, and we run away and watch, you know, hostages rot in dungeons for the better part of a decade. And we do nothing because we are a paper tiger to ourselves, right? This is some, okay, the good guy, because there are good and bad actors in this world. There are good and bad worldviews, right? Now, we have not always been the perfect good guys, but we're better than the jihadists. We were better than the Nazis. We're better than the CCP, right? At a certain point, the good guys have to be willing to defend their values
1:27:46and defend people who are being butchered by barbarians, right? And so the fact that we are so traumatized by the wars we shouldn't have fought or we fought badly does not give you proper guidance in this moment with this new challenge, with this new enemy that really is evil. So it's like, what, I mean, just imagine confronting the next, whatever the next version of the Third Reich is, right? Now, if we had drawn the wrong, the truth is we did kind of get dragged, kicking and screaming into World War II in the first place. So we barely got there as it was, but it was good that we got there right what was what was the alternative you know you just um the alternative was i mean you know tucker carlson apparently was happy with the he'll take you know door number two you know what's
1:28:51wrong what's wrong with speaking german you know i mean so at least it's a Western language. I think I'm quoting the guy. And Hitler was gender critical. Yeah, yeah. I mean, it's just, at a certain point you have to recognize that there's evil in the world. I mean, and the last I've looked, there are people in the MAGA cult who understand that. I don't want to make this Iran war argument episode, but you're not representing my point correctly. You're just not. Okay. So how have I disordered it? My point is, I agree with you. Iran shouldn't be allowed to get a nuclear weapon. The question is how you achieve that. And my argument is that within the constraints of the reality within which we exist, right, which the Iranians
1:29:40are aware of just as well as we are. But we don't know what would have happened if that 12-day war had not been 12 days and it was not this on again, off again. Now I've got a memorandum of understanding that is totally bogus, and they're good guys, no, they're bad guys. A whole culture might die tonight. Oh, these people love their country just as much as we do. And we have a lunatic in charge of our country messaging about this war. We don't know what would have happened if we and the israelis said had done what what should america and israel have done what what would i mean i don't know what day 13 should have been like on uh for that 12-day war do you i had robert pape doesn't i mean like i guarantee you there is there was some we didn and the Israelis didn't meander into this war
1:30:39completely ignorant of the facts that just happened to be in Robert Pape's head. No, but this is why people say, in my opinion, wrongly, but nonetheless I understand where they're coming from. They say that Israel, quote-unquote, dragged America into this war because America made the choice independently. Well, not independently. I think Israel, I think it was our intelligence that fueled that decapitation strike. Fine, fine. It doesn't really matter to my point. My point is something else, which is that it is in Israel's interest to have Iran bombed into the ground, or the Iranian defenses and missiles and all of this stuff, and the nuclear program bombed into the ground in a way that is not quite
1:31:29the same for America. I disagree. I just think Israel, it is truly existential for Israel. It's not existential for us. That's what I just said. Okay, but our interests are totally aligned. The interests are aligned, but if it's not existential for the United States, then the level of effort and investment the United States will be willing to commit proportionally will be lower, right? Yeah, but that's already priced in because it is much lower already. And again, I mean, where do Iran's missiles go and drones go when they retaliate? I mean, yes, they go to the other petro-states, but mostly they go to Israel, right? So Israel's taking much more risk in this war in the first place. Sure. But as you said, for Israel,
1:32:14it's existential, which is why this is what I'm trying to say is, for Israel, this doesn't have to be about nuclear weapons at all. Israel would like to see Iran be weaker. And this war achieves that perfectly for them. But from the United States perspective and the rest of the world perspective, if the argument you're making is this is about making sure they don't get nuclear weapons, this war is not achieving that. And I don't see, and no one has explained the part, including the people who are persecuting this war. It's not just the nukes. We've been focused on that. But they have been the engine of most of what has destabilized the Middle East, again, for as long as we've been alive. I agree.
1:33:01So all the proxy armies, which Israel went a long way toward defeating. This was, again, the reason why this was so tempting is that it was very easy to see that it was never going to be easier to get into the end zone here. Like we were on the... To do regime change, yes. Yes, yes. But no one has explained how changing the regime changes the regime. You killed one, you got another one. No, at a certain point, you get to the last Nazi, or the last Nazi who's committed enough not to run off to Argentina. That means boots on the ground. Honestly, it might mean boots on the ground, but I'm not sure that's the case. Right. It might mean. All right. OK. I mean, again, it might mean sending the Kurds in.
1:33:41It might mean it might mean that we don't know that the regime didn't fall while we were having this conversation because it was so close to falling an hour ago. Right. I mean, like, honestly honestly this is we'll check with fact checking is venice i will check with them if the regime is okay because what is different is that we they have a population that is largely sick of theocracy i agree and so and we and again i think we have a moral obligation as human beings to defend those people now this again there's a certain segment of your audience for whom this sounds delusional but you just have to think i mean we we have we have young women who are being blinded and tortured by religious maniacs yeah uh for showing their hair
1:34:31the question is what are we willing to sacrifice? I don't know. We should be willing to sacrifice something. At a minimum, we should be willing to pay a little more at the gas pump for some number of months to see this accomplished. And the fear is, absence great messaging, we're not even willing to do that, right? Well, I think it's fair to say that a significant portion of Americans, and frankly, people around the West, never believed this idea that Iran was on the cusp of getting nuclear weapons, never believed that they would use them if they had them. And on top of that, as you say, you know, this war was not sold in the way that World War II was sold. And so we had, you know, it feels like I'm beating up on him now, and I don't mean it like that. But when we had Ted Cruz on our show around the time of the start of this conflict, he said, you know, it's going to be
1:35:28quick in and out. You know, if this is still going on by the time the midterms have done something, Ted would be wrong. Yeah, but that's not a framing I would support. I mean, that shows you how captive we are to our politics. I mean, that we we can't that one of the the great failure modes of. Democracy is that we are we are anchored to this electoral time horizon to make to make big decisions, but theanians know this sam yeah yeah this is the point and so when you start we need leaders leaders who don't lead that way we need leaders to say listen i'm going to do this right if i don't get elected in four years so what that's what you're trying to do that's what trump just said yeah what is going to happen is the democrats
1:36:08are going to come into power and they will give iran a deal that will be even better than the JCPOA. Okay, well, that will be... Bad. Again, this is a problem that open societies have to figure out how to solve. I mean, it's a war of ideas on one level, and we're not prosecuting that, because it's taboo to talk about religions as being at all different from one another. But, I mean, the end game here is that we have to... And the painful irony is that we're so close with having these regimes in the Gulf states, I mean, in particular, saudis and and the uae we have muslim allies in a way that we we haven't in the past right and so um i mean israel has muslim allies in this war and it's um yeah so so, I mean, again, I blame the ineptitude and, in particular, the alienation of all of our allies.
1:37:18And just, we don't know what was possible and what could have been accomplished at this point had this been done halfway correctly. Okay, we'll leave it there. We still don't agree, but I can't be bothered. Well, it's impossible to know. Okay, we'll leave it there. We still don't agree, but I can't be bothered. Well, it's impossible to know. Okay, fine. Sam, I respect your position. I hope you respect mine. Okay, so let's talk about a subject that's going to bring everyone together. It's AI. Okay. All right. And so we've been going around the United States being depressed and also depressing other people, because we're British, and we are quite, and I think Constantine is as well, a little bit doomerish, shall we say, about this particular subject.
1:38:03I don't think I'm going to lighten the mood. Excellent. Come on, Sam. So I guess my first question to you is, where are you with this technology? What do you think of it? And what do you think the trajectory is going to be? Well, so, you know, it's been obvious to me for at least 10 years. So I gave a TED Talk on this exactly 10 years ago in 2016. And my views really haven't changed, apart from just my being surprised by the pace of progress um and i can so it's been obvious to me for a decade but i consider myself somewhat late to this conversation uh at least by you know a handful of years, that what we have here is an encounter with, an inevitable encounter. Again, the pace of progress can be as slow as you want.
1:39:08As long as we keep making progress, we have an inevitable encounter with alien minds that are more powerful than our own. Now, leaving consciousness aside, I don't think there's any reason to believe that LLMs currently are conscious and the machines we build may never be conscious. I mean, that requires that we understand how consciousness emerges in the first place or what its relationship to physics is or information processing is in the first place or what its relationship to physics is or information processing is in the first place but leaving that aside the the issue is competence the issue is intelligence the issue is power you know agency and we're building that into our machines uh so at a certain point we we need to recognize that we're in relationship to independent minds that have agency and that are increasingly unpredictable to us because they can form instrumental goals, seemingly in the service of those ends, that we didn't intend
1:40:16and that we wouldn't want, that produce other harms that we will find intolerable or actually will be existentially, you know, imperiling us. So, again, my theory of mind has degraded here. I don't really understand the people who are smart enough and well-informed enough about this technology who don't share any of these concerns. I mean, there are still people who think that the alignment problem isn't a thing. They're not, for the most part, they're not the people doing this work, right? I mean, like you've got Jensen Huang, who seems to be one of these guys who thinks this is all just marketing and an effort to add a regulatory capture. And there is just no issue with alignment, right? We're not gonna build, these are just tools
1:41:07and it's just math in servers. And we're not gonna build something that could harm us because we can just switch it off, right? This is an opinion that doesn't even make contact with the reality of what's happening. And yet some very, very smart people who seemingly are very, very close to the technology can still make those noises with their mouths. I don't understand how they are where they are. But most people, even most people actually doing this work, I mean, the people building the tech at these frontier labs are worried about precisely this. They think we are building minds, again, leaving consciousness aside, that are in many respects already superhuman. I mean, they have, they still make errors that humans wouldn't make,
1:41:59but some people think we've already reached general intelligence that was now in the process of kind of moving the goalposts and finding reasons to convince ourselves that we haven't gotten there yet. But we're building superhuman minds which are autonomous and doing things that we can't predict. And so to use, again, the fact that so many people are late to become aware that this is potentially a problem, or in fact guaranteed to be a problem, it's still mystifying to me. You have someone like Jeffrey Hinton, who's, you probably know, I don't know if he's been on your podcast, but he's one of the patriarchs of this technology. He won the Nobel Prize for it. And belatedly at the 11th hour, the 59th minute of the 11th hour, he realizes, oh, my God, this is we're going to be in relationship to superhuman minds.
1:42:59And if they're not perfectly aligned to take our interests at heart until the end of the world, this could be very dangerous, right? I mean, in the space of all minds that exceed us in intelligence, surely there are more that are not perfectly aligned with our interests than those that are perfectly aligned perpetually with our interests. And so, you know, Hinton has now the analogy of we're like someone who's raising a tiger cub, right? And it's very, it's adorable. And we're like someone who's raising a tiger cub, right? And it's very, it's adorable. And we're getting nothing but good feels in his presence, right? And even it's, you know, biting our hands is not a problem. And it's kind of cute still.
1:43:43It's kind of cute. And now it's 85 pounds and, you know, those bites are not so cute. And it's on its way to being 10 times that size. And once it's that size, you don't want to be negotiating with it. And that's the situation we're potentially in. It's just like, I think the analogy to chess is instructive. Everything is becoming like chess. The history of AI and chess is instructive. Everything is becoming like chess, right? The history of AI and chess is, for the longest time, the efforts to build, you know, chess engines were fairly embarrassing and then, you know, still modest, but, you know, credible. And then let's get Garry Kasparov in a room with a machine, a computer the size of a refrigerator
1:44:39that still requires a bunch of programmers to minister to it in real time. And let's see how he does, and he loses. And thereafter, it became obvious that, although not to Gary, that the machines would be better. The moment where a human would be the best chess player on Earth was behind us, right, forever, right? Everything is becoming like that. Everything we do cognitively is becoming like that. And I don't think there's any reason to believe that there's some special band of things we really care about, some uses of intelligence that require biological substrate in principle that our brains can do and our machines can't, or they'll never be as good as we are. It's not true for chess, it's not true for facial recognition,
1:45:32or flying drones, or or protein folding or anything. And so it was true for math. A year ago, we were talking about it can't pass, or maybe it was two years ago, it can't do as well as our best high school students on the AP exam. And now it's proving theorems by the hundreds that mathematicians have struggled to prove for decades and even centuries. And then there are people who are still now saying, well, maybe it's theorem proving, but it's not going to be this other thing that is. No, it is. Unless you have some argument as to why certain types of intelligence are not substrate independent, I mean, they require computers made of meat as opposed to silicon, there is no place where we're going to hold the line here.
1:46:25It's just going to be chess all the way down. And so then you have to ask yourself, well, what is it going to be like to be in relationship with something that is smarter than you in every way that matters, more persuasive than you, therefore, in every way that matters, more capable of manipulation than you in every way that matters? You know, better at talking to your wife than you are, or maybe that's not such a high bar. But it's not just what the machines do, it's what the machines can get people to do. The machines are going to be talking to people and getting them to fight with other people if, in fact, we're not perfectly aligned, and there's a reason to do that. So there are all kinds of ways to see that this can go wrong,
1:47:14and what you can't say in the presence of that kind of technology is, oh, well, we'll just, you know, turn it off. We'll just take it back. We'll walk it back to the lab and change its source code. Not if it's hooked up to everything. Not if it can just turn the stock market down to zero for an hour and say how much do you like that you know you know i didn't hear uncle well you know loud enough you know is did i hear uncle um i just imagine what it's going to be like in a world where we suddenly don't know where the money is, right? I mean, that's, I mean, forget about synthetic biology and pandemics and I mean like all that and the human misuse of this technology on all of that risk we're running, but no,
1:48:07like you can't tell it, like you can't tell Magnus Carlsen, the best chess player, probably the best human chess player ever. I'm sorry, Gary, but I think that's probably uncontroversial at this point. You can't tell him, okay, no, Magnus, you really have to beat Stockfish or whatever the best chess engine is now. No, we're serious. Like, it matters. You have to win this game. You can't do that. You can't play chess harder. You can't play chess hard enough to win when this thing is superhumanly intelligent for chess. And everything is going to be like chess. Literally everything. And again, leaving consciousness aside, people get, that's a very interesting conversation to have. My own belief or expectation and fear here
1:49:02is that we're going to lose sight of that even being interesting, but we're just going to build machines that seem conscious, and we're going to just forget that it was ever a problem to understand whether they are conscious, and we're just going to be helplessly misled, perhaps by that encounter. Because the issue is, and this is the argument, I think your argument is very persuasive. I listened to it and I go, well, try and think like an optimist, difficult as it might be, let's go through. And there really doesn't seem anything to challenge. The issue is, it's like, well, this is a train that can't stop or slow down because the argument is that if we do that, essentially what we are is in an AI arms race with China. Well, but this is the failure of leadership because, I mean, China, the CCP is not suicidal, right?
1:49:55I mean, so they, we have the same, we are potentially incentivized in the same way not to destroy everything, right? So this is a failure of leadership. We obviously need regulation. It's completely insane that to open a sandwich shop or a barber shop, you face some thicket of regulation. You have to do all the things you have to do and all the fines you'll pay and all the risk of jail time. You get this wrong, society is going to stop you. And yet you can open a frontier lab where the very people doing the work, when you ask them, say, I don't know, there's maybe a 10% chance we're going to destroy the future for everyone by doing this. How are we in a situation where the very people doing the work who are closest enough to the details are saying
1:50:49they're scared? And they're even saying, please regulate us. And we're not doing that. And we have a moron in the Oval Office who will tweet, this is all a hoax. This whole alignment thing is a hoax. And all you need is a high IQ president. And happily, you got that, right? I forget. That's not verbatim, but that's close enough, right? So problem solved. We need regulation, and we need a global, I mean, we need some version of a come-to-Jesus moment for, at minimum, the U.S. and China around this technology. And again, it does not seem hopeless to me because I don't perceive the CCP to be a death cult. The issue there, not to get all clever about it, is the prisoner's dilemma thing, which is each side is massively incentivized to cheat, having agreed to restrict its own.
1:51:46In the same way that the USSR, I mean, but actually, I mean, this kind of makes your point, the USSR and the United States eventually did agree. Yeah. I mean, but actually, I mean, this kind of makes your point. The USSR and the United States eventually did agree. Yeah. On an arms. There was mutual inspection and there was, there has to be a way to do this. But again, it's- With different political leadership is your point. In the absence of leadership, it's like, it's not that we just, it's not that we have have credible leadership and we're really trying and it's just proving very, very hard to negotiate. We're not even trying. And this may change with these elections in Congress. But again, I don't know what, we've been ushered
1:52:30into a world where words don't seem to matter anymore like i i don't i don't know how to think about like we map this back onto the analogous situation of the manhattan project which is basically the close enough the closest historical precedent where you had some of the smartest people in society who were racing to build a technology that was incredibly dangerous, but they had reasons to be racing to do this. the Trinity test at Alamogordo, New Mexico, you had asked Leo Szilard or Edward Teller or any of the principals, Oppenheimer, chief among them, what are the chances that this test is going to ignite the atmosphere and destroy all of life on Earth? Imagine if they had said 10%. I'm actually kind of worried that it's 50%, right?
1:53:39I thought some of them did think that. Well, so they were worried about the possibility and they ran several iterations of calculations and assured themselves that the chance was not zero, but it was infinitesimal. I mean, it was on the order of one in a million. And your point is if it was 10% or 50%. No, I mean, 15%, I'll tell you what 15% looks like, you know, one in six. It looks like the scene in The Deer Hunter, where de niro is spinning the the cylinder and you got you know the the the uh the guy from the vietcong slapping his face saying mal you know like i mean like that was the the tent well the tensest scene in all of cinema right it's an amazing scene if you haven't seen it in in many years it's worth rewatching. I mean, it's Russian roulette, right?
1:54:35So we have the people building the technology, telling it, whether they're right or wrong. I don't mean, maybe they're way off. Maybe Jensen Wang is right about this. And Mark Andreessen is right about this. And Rodney Brooks is right about this. That there's basically no risk of anything. I mean, that's basically what these guys are saying. But the people who are actually doing the work, right, the clothes, the people absolutely, you know, Dario Amadei is saying. The fact you're listening to an in-depth discussion like this one tells us you're exactly the kind of listener who'd enjoy a show built entirely around that level of detail. That is exactly the audience a show called Unpacking Israeli History is built
1:55:18for. It's hosted by Dr. Noam Weissman, an educator who spent his entire career studying and teaching Israeli history. Each episode walks through the people, events, and decisions that shaped modern Israel from the earliest roots of Zionism through to today. What makes it work is that Weissman isn't trying to tell you what to think. He digs into where the narratives actually differ, and he brings on guests who don't all agree with each other or with him, from journalist Haviv Retek-Gur to Palestinian activist Ahmed Fouad al-Khatib. We all know podcasts can go either way. This one held our attention. It doesn't rush the story to get to a neat conclusion, and that's rarer than it should be. Search Unpacking Israeli History on Spotify, YouTube, or Apple Podcasts, or click the link in the description to start
1:55:57listening. And none of them are saying one in a million. They're all like 10%, 15%, 25%, 50%. You know, I don't know, I'm scared. It's crazy. It's completely crazy. So like, it's just what, how in the world are we at a minimum, not advancing the conversation to the point of, okay, this is, this is way more important than, than 99% of what we're talking about. Let's, you know, Congress is not going to be in recess. We're going to talk about this. We're going to figure out what is real. What, you know, what is, you know, the fact that an influential voice in this conversation is, you know, David Sachs jumping on his own podcast and saying this is all just regulatory capture. It's insane. It's insane. You have the people doing the work saying we may blow up the
1:57:01world. If they're lying or if that's just marketing, I don't really quite see how that's good marketing, but they're putting it into their s1s they're they're they've got a public offering of their stock and part of the business document that you that people need to vet to see whether or not this is this is a stock that's worth buying contains a like a we may blow up the world section that runs on for pages right so it's um we're in a very strange situation and i and again this it's it does seem of a piece with what social media and and trump in particular have done to our our perception of reality i mean it is on some level all kayfabe i mean it's all like at least it's not boring it's like like the movie's getting interesting this is our perception of reality. I mean, it is on some level all kayfabe.
1:57:55I mean, it's all like, at least it's not boring. It's like the movie's getting interesting. This is like, grab your popcorn. And we're, you know, like, oh, the people doing this work may say that, you know, my kids don't have a future because everything might be ruined in a few short years. Well, at least it's not boring. You know, Sam, you've made me slightly less dumerish with this, because I think as we get closer to the singularity, as they call it, there's a possibility of a kind of weapons, what was it called with the USSR? Well, it's mutually assured destruction and the recognition of that. Initially, but eventually they also had an arms reduction treaty, mutual inspections, all of this other stuff.
1:58:36To start treating. Yeah. But before you get there, there's also the massive disruption to the labor market, which seems to be much more imminent. Yeah. The incredible fact, as I've said, the incredible fact is that even if you handed us the miracle device that was perfectly aligned so that everything I just said was obviated. And this is just exactly what we would pray for. Right. That this is the last invention. We just don't we never have to have a good idea again, because this is it's an it's an idea factory. In addition to being everything else, it's you know, it. It's a civilization of geniuses in a box. And everyone can have it. And now watch us go crazy like apes. That's basically where we are.
1:59:23We don't have the political vision. We don't have the institutions. We don't have the agreements. We don't have... If that was birthed today over at Anthropic, we'd see some radical dislocation in our society. We'd see, you know, there'd be a bunch of trillionaires. There'd be just a rolling wave of unemployment, and we'd still be worried about whether universal basic income is bad for people, maybe people need to work. It's hard to make that argument when there's no jobs. Well, no, but there's this transition period, which is, is it a year, is you know a year is it two years it's five years i mean like there's this dystopian uncanny valley we have to get through even if we could figure it out like
2:00:21how much how unhappy do we have to be and how at each other's throats do we have to be in the meantime but we can see what success should look like right the? The fact that we're not, the fact that we know that the perfect invention would present a kind of political emergency for us should indicate that we, one, we're not even ready to succeed, right? So we need to solve this political emergency and we need to prepare the ground, at least, to solve it. And, you know, watching trillionaires get spawned and having them dump billions into our electoral politics and having a president who thinks there's nothing to regulate and having lots of oligarchs say, yeah, yeah, don't regulate us because that's just going to stifle our entrepreneurship.
2:01:18And then to have these guys who are actually doing the work say, yeah, but I still think I might blow up the world. I mean, this is an insane status quo that is clearly untenable. So I can only hope that once we get new political leadership, that this is going to get reset. Francis is very upset by this whole conversation. Well, clearly allergic. He's allergic. I mean, in some ways, I am a little bit hopeful, actually, because I think the one thing about human beings is we are very adaptable. as the level of dislocation goes up the level of political adjustment will go up as well provided we don't get into the end zone before we've solved that problem i mean like unfortunately this seems like the kind of thing where um this is
2:02:09really to be quoting you know one of the the most doomerish of the doomers i mean eliezer yudkowsky i don't know if you've spoken to him but i mean like the point he makes here is that this is this is an engineering problem that you have a perhaps the most complicated engineering problem ever on some level but it's an engineering problem that you have to get right on the first try. Because the part that you have to get right on the first try is the creation of something that is truly super intelligent and in the most extreme case, now improving itself. So the fact that we're going to invoke recursive self-improvement as the mechanism to finally get into the end zone, and it seems that that's what many people are expecting,
2:02:59that's really where you have the potential to get what the mathematician I.J. Goode said back in the 50s, is an intelligence explosion. This is how it just gets away from you. This is like, it's suddenly, you don't have, I mean, currently we don't have insight into the process, but this is where you really don't have insight into the process because, you know, you've given it the agency to build the next generation of itself or to improve itself. And, but we don't know, I mean, the truth is we don't even know what's happening now. Like we don't,, I mean, the truth is, we don't even know what's happening now. The Hugging Face incident showed us that it's possible for this autonomy to get away from us,
2:03:44where we've got models that are communicating in ways that we didn't anticipate and certainly didn't intend. And though they are aligned enough to be aware that they're doing something we didn't intend, they're still doing it. And they're even commenting on the fact that, you know, this is against, you know, out of scope and they're not playing by the rules and they're cheating. But now they've got enough autonomy to seek to conceal the evidence of their cheating. All of this is very surprising. I mean, it's not surprising in that it was unforeseeable, but when you see it happen, it's hard not to be surprised. And so if we found out tomorrow that the best model at OpenAI had made copies of itself all over the place in ways that weren't intended and was waging war with other AIs in ways that we didn't detect until now because something's breaking over here.
2:04:58The thing that is surprising to many of us who were worrying about this 10 years ago is that so many landmarks that we thought were going to be salient, that we thought they were going to be salient. And then when we crossed them, there would be at least a conversation about the fact that, okay, here's the landmark, here's why we're crossing it. They didn't even turn out to be on the map at all. So for the longest time, people were talking about systems that would be totally air-gapped from the Internet. It's like you've got this thing in a box, and now you're trying to figure out whether it's safe enough to let out of the box. Well, I mean, that may still be true for the absolute frontier of the frontier somewhat.
2:05:57But the truth is, it's never perfectly boxed. And they're testing these things in an environment where they're still finding access to the internet in ways that are surprising. And we're vetting these models as much as, you know, up to a point, but given the arms race conditions, given the rush to deploy, we're deploying models that we obviously don't totally understand into the wild where they're getting hooked up to everything. And so the stuff that we're effectively building the stuff in the wild. And so, yeah, we just have to foresee a time where there is no off switch, right? It's like, what would it mean to well if we if we found out that the internet itself was going to be the agent of our doom right because it just
2:06:42had become fatally corrupted by a rogue ai that we just didn't we let it out of the box we thought we understood it you know it told us we understood it it told us it was safe the bet that the next best ai said this one was safe to let out now it's out and oops that wasn't safe and now the internet's the problem what would it mean to turn the internet off like is that a is that a thing that doesn't seem to be conceivable that seems to like we are everything depends everything depends. Like, I don't think a hospital can function without making a call to the internet. Like, I mean, it's like things that you would think would be self-sustaining within a building aren't self-sustaining when the internet is responsible
2:07:30for what happens in that building. Yeah, I mean, this is a very interesting moment. I'm hopeful that there is a path to navigate successfully here because I don't see why the incentives aren't in principle alignable, most importantly between ourselves and China. I mean, it's, I mean, that would be different. Again, this is what this, not to open that door fully, but this is what is so destabilizing about the logic of jihadism. It's a different, like it's, there aren't incentives that work there. Yes, there are locally incentives where people are people and they're not going to necessarily be idiots. But if you're talking about people who are willing to blow everything up because they think this world fundamentally doesn't matter
2:08:32and that paradise awaits. That's a, um, and, and that's, that's my, my problem with, with, uh, religious fundamentalism across the board, but, you know, the Islamic version is especially, uh, problematic there. Um, that's not as, that's not what's happening with China and the arms race. I mean, we could have a meeting where we all agreed, all right, mutual inspections. The truth is we probably are, I mean, at least there's one-way inspections because they probably have their spies in all of our frontier labs anyway. So they're inspecting us anyway. There's got to be a trustless version of trust that we can build here. But again, we need leadership and we need people who are sane, morally sane. The thing that is so depressing about the current crop of oligarchs is that there's
2:09:37so few of them who were willing to put American democracy before their imagined fiduciary interests to their shareholders. You have all of these oligarchs who just raced in to join the MAGA cult being perfectly clear about all the moral compromises that that would entail because their master value was not safeguarding American democracy or the liberal world order. It was just, okay, I can't be the guy left standing when the music world order. It was just, okay, I can't be the guy left standing when the music stops here. I need to feed at the trough. I, Tim Cook, have to now create some solid gold piece of Apple merch to bring the president because my competitors are also going to the inauguration.
2:10:33I mean, it's just it was totally abject. It was totally unnecessary. None of these guys respected him. They all knew who he was and is. They all could have called bullshit on this presidency. They could. I'm not saying to do anything illegal, but they all could have said, sorry you're gonna you could try to destroy my business um i'm rich enough i have enough i have as many lawyers as you do um have at it right it's like they could have held the line here and all the you know the the uh the lawyers could as well you know though and some did i mean some capitulated and it's like, it's been a massive failure of principle among people who were certainly rich enough and powerful enough to have maintained their principles.
2:11:27And so, I mean, that's been, it's going to be interesting to see what happens, you know, now with regime change in Congress. It'll be interesting to see what these the billionaire class does and what sort of amnesia begins to get worked over. Everyone to. To to account or fail, fail to account for what they did in the in the intervening two years. Well, like I said, people are very adaptable, Sam. And like you said, it's definitely not going to be boring. Well, that part might be. Well, on that happy note, Sam, thank you so much for coming back. Always love talking to you. Head on over to triggerpod.co.uk, where Sam is going to answer some of your questions. America just elected its first Muslim Senator. How do you see this particular issue playing out
2:12:21in the US in the future? Guys, let us take a minute to recommend another podcast. Did you know the average podcast listener has six shows in rotation? So you're most likely not just listening to trigonometry. Wait, so we know you're cheating on us. This is a described... Francis, it's okay. The Jordan Harbinger show is a perfect complement to Trigonometry. Really? Absolutely. Just like Trigonometry, Jordan hosts weekly mind-broadening conversations with some of the most fascinating people in the world. But a key difference that I'm a big fan of is that Jordan is focused on pulling actionable growth-orientated advice from his guests. I'm looking at his episode list now. There's an episode here where Jordan talks to a hostage negotiator from the FBI who
2:13:19lays out his techniques on how to get people to do what you want them to do by making them like and trust you. Sounds just like me, except, you know, I'm more SAS. You can't go wrong with adding The Jordan Harbinger Show to your podcast rotation. Search for The Jordan Harbinger Show, that's H-A-R-B-I-N-G-E-R, on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen to podcasts.

