The Rest Is Politics: Leading · · Transcript & summary by WhipScribe
A rare mix of economic theory and government practice, with Mazzucato explaining why Starmer's missions fell short and what she thinks Britain should do next.
Tap a chapter to play it from that moment in the show's own player; the transcript opens there too.
“I don't think economists are very good at listening or understanding how to work with communities.” Mariana Mazzucato · at 32:14 — ▶ hear it from here
Mariana Mazzucato, an economist at University College London who advised Keir Starmer's government, argues that Britain needs a hopeful, mission-led goal set, such as health, sustainable housing and transport, rather than technocratic talk about fiscal rules. She points to NASA's moon programme as a model, where procurement reform came first and private firms did the engineering. She says Starmer's missions stalled because they stayed inside one department and were rarely pursued across Whitehall, and that Germany's public bank tied loans to greener steel.
On the civil service, she blames decades of outside consultancies, which she says leave departments dependent rather than more capable, and cites conflicts of interest such as PwC working for both medical device firms and their regulators. Her own alternative is a research institute that works slowly with governments, from Brazil's rubber-tapper forest communities to a Camden citizens' assembly that turned food banks into green food co-ops.
Turning to economics, she argues governments must shape markets during booms, not only spend counter-cyclically in busts, and contrasts this with US growth under Donald Trump, which she says comes mainly from financial markets. Rory Stewart and Alistair Campbell pushed back: Stewart warned against confident academics promising simple fixes, and Campbell found the conversation scattered across too many unconnected projects.
Mariana Mazzucato is an Italian-American economist and professor at University College London. She has advised Keir Starmer's government and Andy Burnham's team, and wrote The Common Good Economy.
Mariana Mazzucato said a mission is meant to be a provocation that changes how government policy and public-private partnerships work, not a slogan. She said Keir Starmer's government adopted the idea but used it as a label, so the missions did not drive cross-departmental work.
“It's meant to be a provocation to fundamentally change how we not only do government policy”Mariana Mazzucato · 7:54
Mariana Mazzucato said Deloitte was paid $1.5 million a day to run test and trace during COVID. She used the example to argue that specialist knowledge is valuable, but that governments rely on consultants too much and should build their own capability.
“Deloitte was getting paid $1.5 million a day to do test and trace during COVID”Mariana Mazzucato · 23:35
Mariana Mazzucato said she was called in by a Brazilian minister to redesign the Bolsa Verde programme for the Amazon. She proposed making it a pre-distributive tool that funds forest people through their cooperatives for their knowledge, rather than handing out money because they are poor.
“I don't think economists are very good at listening or understanding how to work with communities.”Mariana Mazzucato · 32:14
Mariana Mazzucato said Donald Trump is not doing what she thinks governments should do, and that he is dismantling the entrepreneurial state. She argued that US growth under him comes mainly from financial markets rather than the real economy, with wages and investment lagging.
“he's not doing anything I think he should do.”Mariana Mazzucato · 46:56
Mariana Mazzucato argues that Britain should set bold, mission-based goals that require several departments and private firms to work together, backed by public investment. She says governments should build their own civil service capability rather than rely on consultants, and should shape markets rather than only fix them.
Mariana Mazzucato said a mission should be a bold, memorable goal, like the moon landing, that forces government departments to work together and draws in private firms. She argued that NASA first changed its procurement rules, and that Keir Starmer's missions faltered because they were treated as slogans rather than cross-departmental programmes.
Mariana Mazzucato said decades of reliance on outside consultancies has weakened the civil service, and she blamed governments more than the firms for failing to call out conflicts of interest. She cited PwC advising both medical device companies and their regulators in Australia, and said Deloitte was paid $1.5 million a day for COVID test and trace.
Mariana Mazzucato said Starmer's missions never reached the centre of the industrial strategy and were not organised across departments such as health and education. She said that after the 2024 election the early missions talk was quickly overshadowed by negative stories, with net zero the only mission that stayed positive.
Mariana Mazzucato argued that US growth under Donald Trump comes mainly from financial markets, with about $7 trillion used to boost stock prices and executive pay, rather than from the real economy. She said he is dismantling the entrepreneurial state, including funding for agencies such as DARPA and the National Institutes of Health.
Mariana Mazzucato said a Camden citizens' assembly, run through resident associations across 10 housing estates, found that residents felt humiliated by food banks. The project set up green food cooperatives that residents run themselves, which she said gave people agency and dignity instead of talking at them.
Mariana Mazzucato said Keynes would urge Keynesians to focus on the good life and the common good, building communities rather than only homes. She linked this to arts and culture spending, citing the Notting Hill Carnival as a year-long system of production, and quoted Celso Furtado's line that cultural policy is economic policy.
Rory Stewart said he found the conversation hard to get into, because Mazzucato sometimes sounded like a consultant with a ten-point plan, and he feared she was selling a simple set of remedies. Alistair Campbell called her extraordinarily clever and an important voice, but said the talk felt like a bundle of projects that never came together.
Our own transcript of the public episode, with a timestamp about every 90 seconds. Tap a timestamp to play the episode from there in the show's own player; the link button on a paragraph copies a link that opens this page there.
0:00Thanks for listening to The Rest Is Politics. Sign up to The Rest Is Politics Plus to enjoy ad-free listening, receive a weekly newsletter, join our members chat room and gain early access to live show tickets. Just go to therestispolitics.com. That's therestispolitics.com. This episode is sponsored by IG. The budget has landed, which means there's an awful lot more noise from speculators telling you what it means for your money. But what investors should actually be asking is this, do you actually know what you hold you what it means for your money. But what investors should actually be asking is this, do you actually know what you hold, what it's worth right now, or what you can actually act upon? Many investors won't know the answers because they will have their
0:33accounts spread across multiple different apps with multiple different institutions. And so you won't really know what is their position on American equities, European equities, bonds, or how it all sits together. So here's some good news for you. From investments to trades, IG brings your entire portfolio together in a single app with one unified wallet to fund across all your accounts. And with over 20,000 stocks and ETFs, you have the breadth to act no matter how the budget affects you. And it gets better. With no annual fees and zero commission on UK stocks, shares and ETFs, more of your money stays where it belongs. Invest it. Download the IG app to get started. IG. Trade. Invest. Progress. Capital at risk. Other fees may apply.
1:21Are you looking for support in your weight management journey? ZepBound Terzepatide may be able to help. ZepBound is a prescription medicine used with a reduced calorie diet and increased physical activity to help adults with obesity or some adults with overweight who also have weight-related medical problems to lose excess body weight and keep the weight off. Zepbound is approved as a 2.5, 5, 7.5, 10, 12.5, or 15 milligram injection. Zepbound contains terzepatide and should not be used with other terzepatide-containing products or any GLP-1 receptor agonist medicines. It is not known if Zepbound is safe and effective for use in children. Don't share needles or pens or reuse needles. Don't take if allergic to it,
2:04or if you or someone in your family had't take if allergic to it or if you or someone in your family had medullary thyroid cancer or if you've had multiple endocrine neoplasia syndrome type 2. Tell your doctor if you get a lump or swelling in your neck. Stop, zip bound, and call your doctor if you have severe stomach pain or a serious allergic reaction. Severe side effects may include inflamed pancreas or gallbladder problems. Tell your doctor if you experience vision changes before scheduled procedures with anesthesia. If you're nursing, pregnant, plan to be, or taking birth control pills. Taking Zepbound with a sulfonylurea or insulin may cause low blood sugar. Side effects include nausea, diarrhea, and vomiting, which can cause dehydration and worsen kidney problems.
2:42Talk to your doctor. Call 1-800-545-5979 or visit zepbounce.lily.com. For adults with Crohn's disease or ulcerative colitis symptoms, every choice matters. Tramphya offers self-injection or intravenous infusion from the start. Tramphya is administered as injections under the skin or infusions through a vein every four weeks, followed by injections under the skin every four or eight weeks. If your doctor decides that you can self-inject Tramphya, proper training is required. Tramphya is a prescription medicine used to treat adults with moderately to severely active Crohn's disease and adults with moderately to severely active ulcerative colitis. Serious allergic reactions, increased risk of infections or
3:29lower ability to fight them, and liver problems may occur. Before treatment, get checked for infections and tuberculosis. Tell your doctor if you have an infection, flu-like symptoms, or need a vaccine. Explore what's possible. Ask your doctor about Tramfiaya today. Call 1-800-526-7736 to learn more or visit tramfayaradio.com. Welcome to The Rest is Politics Leading with me, Rory Stewart. And me, Alistair Campbell. And we are with Mariana Mazzucato. She's an Italian-American economist and academic who's become a very important voice in politics in the UK and beyond. She's a professor at University College London. She's advised a number of leading British politicians, including Keir Starmer, who adopted her mission-led government, but
4:24perhaps not in the way she hoped and intended. She worked with former First Minister of Scotland, Nicola Sturgeon, on their National Investment Bank and with Andy Burnham's team when he was Mayor of Greater Manchester. And I know from talking to her at Labour's conference in Liverpool and from reading her latest book, The Common Good Economy, that she has plenty to say about what the new Prime Minister and Chancellor should do to get the British economy going again. When Rory and I talked to Gordon Brown recently, he said the UK had to become an innovation nation, and innovation and investment are central to Marianna's views as she tries to get governments to take them more seriously and to do better. She's also passionate about
5:05the role of arts and culture. She's equally passionate about the damage done by the climate crisis. So lots to talk about. And thank you very much for being with us. Thanks for having me. Rory, where do you want to start? Yeah, Marianne, let's start by maybe you providing your vision for Britain. What would you be doing if you were Prime Minister, which is radically different from what Andy Burnham is doing now? Sure. Well, first, to actually provide some hope in terms of the actual economic goals. It seems like sometimes when we talk about the economy, it becomes very kind of technocratic, and we talk about fiscal rules. And then when we want to say something hopeful, it's about how to get, you know,
5:45homeless people off the street, how to have stronger care, but these two discussions are never joined up. So I would say use his current goals. I'm not here to tell, you know, Andy Burnham what the goals should be, but the actual kind of societal and hopeful goals, the whole conference was called Hope Again, use that to actually drive economic growth. And that means putting those goals at the center of government. It doesn't mean putting health in the Department of Health and maybe climate, if we ever talk properly about that again, far off in, you know, DEFRA or the Department of Energy. It means actually saying, what does it mean to catalyze a massive wave of public investment, which we've had way too little of in the UK for decades, had we invested
6:25even just the average of the G7 on the public side, we would have invested 500 billion more. And on the private side, we remain very low compared to the OECD. So we are, I think, 27th in the OECD for business investment. So the big goal is to catalyze public and private sector investment to actually drive solutions towards the goals that this government is setting itself. Again, health, sustainable transport, housing, but not just any housing, sustainable housing, good housing, close to people's jobs. And also with, you know, building communities as we used to do when we actually designed proper public housing. Mariana, I mentioned in the introduction that there was a point at which the missions were going to, meant to be forming the whole heart of the Starmer government.
7:20And from what you've just said, I know from what you've just said, though, are you basically saying that they said the NHS was the mission as opposed to what we want to do with the nhs and what went wrong with the missions because peter hyman is a friend and former colleague of mine and he was absolutely passionate about the missions and i think he was driving them internally as you were sort of pushing them from outside and yet i think he got very disappointed actually kia sama didn't really get it didn't really understand what this meant so what do you mean by mission-led government? Sure. Well, first of all, Keir is not alone. Unfortunately, you know, lots of people use the concept as a slogan and it's not meant to be a
7:54slogan. It's meant to be a provocation to fundamentally change how we not only do government policy, but especially, and this is a bit people sometimes forget, proper public-private partnerships. So what missions are for me, and the reason I actually wrote a whole book about this, because I don't think it's easy, is how can we be as bold, as inspirational, but even memorable, so if you don't remember a mission, it ain't a mission, as when we went to the moon and back, but on Earth, right? So this whole concept of Earth shots, you know, people use the word, but what does it mean? So to go to the moon, it wasn't just aerospace. We had to solve so many different problems. You know, how would the astronauts literally go to the bathroom? That happened again, by the way,
8:32a couple months ago with the Artemis, the toilet is always the problem in space. So how would they go to the bathroom? What would they eat? What would they wear? How would they communicate back to mission control room? So the first thing that NASA did, and the head of procurement in NASA, his name was Ernest Brackett, he said, look, on the technology side, I think we'll get there. The paperwork is going to kill us. So the first thing we need to do is change literally how we currently do public sector procurement, so public purchasing. So the first thing they did was to say, we need an outcomes, a mission orientation to solve all these problems. By the way, with the private sector, people forget that 400,000 people in the private
9:12sector across many different sectors, nutrition, materials, aerospace, and software worked with NASA. NASA provided the clear direction, some early upfront investment, but the solutions actually came from the private sector. So where did Keir get it wrong? First of all, it never went to the center of the industrial strategy. I actually worked with Johnny Reynolds and Darren Jones before Starmer got into government to actually do some mission workshops. So it's like, hey, guys, listen, missions are really powerful, but only if we think of really bold missions, which require government to work interdepartmentally, you know, interministerially. Climate is, again, not just for energy. Health is
9:50not just for the Department of Health. So how do we work in a war room kind of way? I hate wars, but now that we're back with war, how do we work with Department of Health, Department of Education, Department of Finance on, for example, a mission to make sure that every child has access to healthy, tasty, sustainable lunch? How do you do it to catalyze private sector investment? I'll shut up in a second. Sorry, Rory, I saw you had your hand up. But this is key to stimulate bottom-up innovation in the private sector by actually transforming the tools. So procurement is not fit for purpose. Public loans through different types of public banks globally and definitely here are not fit for purpose. They tend to just give money out to any sector that
10:29screams for help. If you have a mission like they have had in Germany recently, that has meant, for example, that their own public bank, the KfW, decided to provide loans conditional that the sectors as boring as steel were mission aligned. So the only reason there's green steel in Germany is that the loan from the NWF, from the KFW said conditional that the steel sector lower the material content of production across the whole supply chain. How you do it, it's up to you. If we micromanage you, that'll stifle innovation and entrepreneurship. But if you're not interested in being part of the solution, go back to the end of the queue. Marina, can I come to the really interesting question for me, which is government and
11:09capacity in government? So you spent a lot of time, obviously, when the conservatives were in power tearing your hair out. And now suddenly you get a very, very sympathetic government under Stalmer and Burnham. So you must have felt, wow, okay, here we go. You know, I'm going to be able to achieve the kind of dreams I have. And tell me some of the things that surprised you when you actually were trying to implement these things in government that you hadn't necessarily anticipated when you were less closely connected to the machine. Sure. Well, actually, it might surprise you, I was more connected formally to the conservative government, because I actually ran a commission on mission oriented
11:51innovation and industrial strategy. In 2018, I co chaired it with David Willits. And we did it for Greg Clark, when he was a Secretary of State of Bays. So what we did then, which was actually quite incredible, because that happened quite quickly, right after I actually set up the Institute at UCL, which by the way, is all dedicated to the actual capabilities and capacity within government to think in this way, we transformed the current industrial strategy at the time, you might remember Vince Cable had those top sectors. So it was like aerospace, automobiles, finance, life sciences, and the creative sector, right? So those are just sectors. And we said, hold on, why don't you think of goals
12:30which require those sectors and other ones, for example, digital services to invest and innovate. So healthy agents, clean growth. Can I interrupt for a second? The risk is you're going to get on to all the wonderful things you wanted to do. Except that then Brexit got in the way. Most of the people we were working with were then kind of moved over to other areas. Currently, I think what surprised me was that, first of all, that Starmer's government had talked about the missions before going in. And it's such a hopeful, I mean, I think the reason missions in some countries have taken off is it also really provides a narrative and a framing that's about opportunities, right? You can confront challenges, we can all complain, but missions
13:10are about saying, here's a really bold objective, and we're going to go after it, and we're going to go after it through not an ideological nationalization or privatization, but a real joint public-private. So what surprised me was that they actually talked about that before, and as soon as they came in, A, it was all negative, right? We know the negative stuff, the winter fuel payments, the disability allowance, but the missions themselves, it was really only the net zero one. And this was positive, right? Under Ed Miliband, that sort of became a mission because it actually required, again, innovation, investment, training, but it was just about energy. A key thing about missions, as I said before,
13:45is it's about intersectoral, that's in the business sector, investment. So also what surprised me, I guess, was that even within Desnes, it was never about a sustainability mission that would require, you know, sustainable food, sustainable transport, obviously sustainable energy, because the three things are all interlinked. And so what I guess surprised me was the kind of lack of imagination at a moment where people were really hopeful. I mean, I was at the Labour Party conference that first year that Starmer got in, and it was full of hope. I think they began on the right foot in terms of saying that they were going to invest within government. You know, my previous book was called The Big Con, how we've infantilized governments by this overuse of consulting. But we never actually saw
14:31with Starman, I'm really hoping we see it now with Burnham, kind of a wave of really investing within the civil service in order to rewire the state. So we always have slogans like rewiring the state, but then it's not actually followed through, through a different way to think about the actual investments within the brain of government. When you talk about imagination, I'm moderately obsessed at the moment with James Graham's latest play, which is about Keynes and Hayek. You quoted something not long ago, I read something you wrote, and you quoted something that Keynes said in 1926. The important thing for government is not to do things which individuals are doing already and to do them a little better or a little worse, but to do those things which are present
15:14are not done at all. So that, in a way, is imagination. So two questions. First of all, what did you think of the play? And secondly, what should the government be doing right now that at present is not being done at all? Right. First of all, I love the play and I was especially honoured that I got the tickets from the director himself who had just read my book and said, you have to go see it. It'll inspire you. And I thought it was really good in the kind of nuance too. It was neither kind of too technocratic or too poetic. It somehow weaved through the kind of too technocratic or too poetic. It somehow weaved through the kind of poetic, the imagination, as well as some really important insights that Keynes
15:50had on the multiplier, for example. So what Keynes meant, and I really think he was misunderstood. So modern Keynesians, and I was, you know, properly trained in some of this stuff. Unfortunately, we no longer have economics departments globally that properly teach, you know, all the different theories of value and of economics, and then students should be patching things up in their own brains. We're taught one theory, by the way, even the play talked about, right? If everyone is pro-cyclical, that's why before Keynes came about, you had recessions continuously turn into depressions. People remember the 1929 depression. But if you look at the data, and you can download this data, you see depressions every 15 to 20 years. So what Keynes said is, hey, why is this? When you have recessions,
16:47business cuts back, consumers cut back. If government also cuts back, you get that downturn turning into a proper depression that causes huge human misery. So that counter cyclical investment that Keynes advocated for, and basically governments sort of do, you know, austerity doesn't do that, but we more or less have counter cyclical governments globally. What that quote says, I think, is that's not enough. You know, what do you do in the boom? You just sit back. So if you want a green transition, if you want an IT revolution, if you want a population that is really invested in in terms of their holistic well-being, that requires more than just counter-cyclical spending, more than just digging up holes and filling them up again,
17:31which could even create a multiplier effect simply by creating some jobs. And that's why I wrote The Entrepreneurial State back in 2013. We wouldn't have had Silicon Valley and today AI without these kind of bold, unfortunately, military industrial complex government funded investments during boom periods. It was during the boom, it wasn't during the bust that got us the internet, GPS, touchscreen, Siri. How did we get those? Government was trying to solve the problem. Internet solved the problem of the satellites communicating, GPS, knowing where the ships were. So having a problem oriented government, I think is the first point. And Keynes' point of really doing what's not being done at all. That means not fixing a market failure, which is the standard narrative of
18:16what governments should do, but really shaping an economy, even shaping markets to deliver more inclusive growth, sustainable growth, innovation-driven growth, instead of what? Growth that it's kind of fueled by problematic investment that causes global warming, but also kind of quick trades in the financial markets. We need long-term investment, so you need tax policies that reward long-termism. That requires really thinking through what the objectives are. And that's, again, fast forward, why I wrote Mission Economy. And the Common Good book, which is my last one, is also sort of my disappointment along the way, coming back to what I saw also with Keir Starmer's government, is that what really matters is the relationships along the way. So if you think of Aristotle and political
18:59philosophy, and even modern day communitarians, they didn't just talk about the telos, the goal, but also the polis, not the police, but the community, right? And Sandel's critique of Rawls is you can't have a theory of justice unless we don't value each other. So what the common good says is that whole idea of missions, that whole idea of Keynes doing really important things, not just tinkering on the edges, if we get the capital labor relationship wrong, if we get the public-private relationship wrong, which is my obsession, because I think we have really problematic public-private relationships, if the state has a problematic relationship with citizens, in other words, doesn't even listen, doesn't use the lived experience to design better policies,
19:39then it's impossible to actually achieve the common good. Marianna, as you mentioned, you've been very critical of governments for the extent to which they rely on outside consultancies and these huge global firms, which have got their fingers into most of the big governments around the world. And governments, including our own, spend an absolute fortune on consultancy. Is that because they lack capacity or they lack confidence? Or is it, as you call it, just a big con? Or does it also speak to the idea that, why is this happening? Right? So the fact that it's happening, Theodore Agnew, a Tory lord in the UK also said, you know, this is an infantilization of our civil service. He saw how much was being spent during Brexit during COVID. And we said, why is this
20:40happening? We trace it back to about 50 years, you know, and also say, by the way, it's not party political. You know, the labor government, for example, under Tony Blair, well, actually with you, you know, massively opened the doors also to the consultants. So if you don't have what I think should be a public purpose driven state, and if you think that at best you should bring in kind of like efficiency and just talk about, you know, we got to skim the fat and so on. But you believe in the state, unlike, say, a Reaganite or a Thatcherite that would say, you know, state, get out of the way. When we believe in the state, but don't think about what does it actually mean to shape a market? What are the dynamic capabilities you need within the civil service to be, you know,
21:22actually working with others in this outcomes-oriented way, not de-risking, not facilitating, not enabling, not just fixing, administering, regulating, these incredibly boring words, but actually really steering the ship and going to the moon and back alongside those 400,000 people in the private sector. That requires huge amounts of not only capacity, which tends to mean more like fiscal space, but also capabilities, the agility, the flexibility, again, the way to work across government, right? So unless you, so that's the first thing, depending what your theory of the state is, market fixing versus market shaping, let's just keep it simple, that will determine the kinds of capabilities you have.
22:02Second, if you are so risk averse, because we end up romanticizing the risk taking and the venture capital sector amongst private entrepreneurs, but as soon as a civil servant makes a mistake, they're in the front page of the newspaper, or maybe even get sued, which often happens, then even when you have that capability, that first problem, you might have the second problem, which is more cultural, of fear and risk averseness. And third, when you have a consulting industry, when then pops in, because of both those two problems, either you haven't invested in those capabilities, or second, you have them and you're very fearful and prefer just to rubber stamp a document with, you know, Deloitte or McKinsey told me to do this,
22:45then you also have a problem. Because if that industry is actually not set up to make you smarter, but is built and requires the contracts, right, there's also very little incentive to make sure that at the end of the relationship, that government department or also private sector, because don't forget, consultants also work a lot with the private sector, are more capable and independent later. It'd be like being with a therapist your whole life. Maybe you should switch therapist. And I don't blame the consultants. I actually blame governments for being so over-reliant and also not really calling out the conflicts of interest, right? So we also looked at, for example, in I think it was Australia, PwC was working both for medical device companies and the regulators of the medical device companies, that should just be illegal. Same thing in South Africa,
23:35working for ESCOM, the big energy state on enterprise and the Treasury, which should be regulating ESCOM. So that, you know, some of these things are low hanging fruit, just make it illegal. But the real problem is that conflict of interest. And that doesn't mean government shouldn't have advisors. You know, if government's going to have a cancer strategy, of course, they should be talking to the top doctors, you know, oncologists in the world, and of course, they should pay them. But that's different. There's expertise there. What we also said was, what's interesting is there's so little expertise. For example, Deloitte was getting paid $1.5 million a day to do test and trace during COVID demonstrates, does it not, how valuable
24:25specialised knowledge is when it comes to analysing the political landscape. But that same expert level of guidance isn't just useful in politics. It's incredibly important for your personal finances too. I mean, take retirement. Retirement obviously isn't just one moment in time. It might be a condition going on for many decades, you'd hope. And during that time, your personal circumstances can change. There could be new rules around how you save, how you invest, how you pass on your wealth to the next generation. That's where planning and advice exclusively for Barclays Premier customers comes in. A wealth planner builds your personalised plan around your goals, while your wealth manager helps it evolve as your life and the world around you change.
25:03Search Barclays planning and advice to learn more. You need to be a UK resident with at least £150,000 available to invest. Other eligibility criteria apply. Money invested for over five years has historically delivered greater growth than cash savings, although investment values can rise and fall over time. Did you know that psoriatic arthritis may progress over time and could cause permanent joint damage if left untreated? Listen to what it sounds like to be a million miles away. Trimphia guselkumab, taken by injection, is a prescription medicine for adults with active psoriatic arthritis. Serious allergic reactions, increased risk of infections, or lower ability to fight them, and liver problems may occur.
25:58Before treatment, get checked for infections and tuberculosis. Tell your doctor if you have an infection, flu-like symptoms, or need a vaccine. Thank you. including important safety information. Sometimes, remembering where you started makes you think where you're going. What if there's another way? Another way to breathe. Another way to connect. Another way to create. What if there's another way to grow? Another way to fly. There's always another way. Paradigm. Eau de Parfum. And the new Parfum by Prada. Marianne, I mean, I think the anxiety I might have is that if I was going to be unfair, sometimes you can sound a bit like a consultant. You can sound a bit like, I've got all the ideas. I know exactly how to fix this.
27:13I've got a 10 point plan. And actually a bit like a consultant, you'll be like, I've done it in 50 countries around the world. I know all these people in Mexico and the States. But actually, the reason why often VCG or McKinsey or Deloitte doesn't succeed is because they are too inclined to think that there is a general model and what they did in Australia or Mexico is going to apply to Britain and that there's a six-point plan, which if only they were in charge, they'd be able to do. And of course, the reason, one of the main reasons they don't work is that cultural change is unbelievably difficult and very, very specific. And as a British minister, the reason, one of the main reasons they don't work is that cultural change is unbelievably difficult and very, very specific.
27:48And as a British minister, you know, I was, I guess I was in six different ministerial portfolios. Listening to you, I feel all the actual problems in practice that would occur if you tried to do a lot of these things. And I fear that you are selling to an audience an idea that there's a simple set of remedies, which if only people listen to Mariana, everything would be fine. And that's fine for a book, but it's not actually the way to achieve change in government. First of all, it's a completely fair critique. I think it's an unfair critique to anything I've just said, because first of all, the reason I actually set up the Institute was that I don't think it's possible to achieve change through a book, doing a book talk, just flying in, flying
28:27out of a country. So it was actually my dissatisfaction of how academics actually work with governments, where we think that we can just do the policy side at the end of a paper, whether it's a journal article or a book. Most of us actually write journal articles. We're actually told not to write books. The books I write are mainly also to create kind of a lay language so people don't feel so excluded from the economic discussion. But the journal articles often just say, here's my policy conclusions. Listen to me. I'm so smart. Whereas the reason I set up the Institute was from a different perspective because I didn't work in government, but I also had that same kind of cynicism that you have is you don't create change just by going
29:05around and telling people, do this, don't do that. Also, because then you leave and they're like, damn, you know, what do I actually have to do now? How does it work? And what if things don't go right? So we work, first of all, we're not consultants. It's a research institute. We get money from research councils and philanthropies that go to our public university, University College London that does their full economic costing. I have no idea where the money goes, but I hire researchers, postdocs, and so on. And we work slowly, not in and out with governments. For example, in Brazil, it took four years to work with the government with about 50 civil servants, both on the training side. So we
29:40call it applied learning. So we do learning on the side, kind of rethinking what the civil service is, what is a different theory of value that should underpin this idea of market shaping, not market fixing. At the same time that we take a sandbox, like school meals, like the sustainable transition done through a financial instrument like BNDES, their own public bank, what does it mean for different types of ways of thinking of the public bank? And it's very culturally specific. First of all, we lead it through them, the Brazilian civil service in particular, my experience is that they had huge amounts of expertise, but they weren't working, again, between departments to actually find those kind
30:20of much more concrete changes that government required to do in order to do what Lula wanted, which is to say no hunger, no poverty at the center. What does it mean for the concrete plans on the ground? Second, one of the reasons I wrote The Common Good is I don't think it's possible, and this is what I've learned from my work along the way, to do it in a cut and paste way, as though Brazil is the same as Mexico, as though it's the same as the US, the lived experience on the ground, for example, in Brazil, in the latest work we're doing, really, really matters to improve the policy. So I just came back from Belém, the capital of the Amazon, where we took a 10-hour boat ride into Curalinha, which is deep into the river,
31:01because there, there's a whole movement called Hay Personas en la Foresta. There's people in the forest. It comes from the Consejo Nacional de Siringueros, the rubber workers. Those people who live in the forest have so much knowledge on how to keep the forest alive, on how not to go down the monoculture route, which unfortunately, even in Brazil, is happening in the forest with superfoods like acai kind of taking over. They have thought a lot about how to maintain the social and biodiversity of the forest. And yet their own voices are nowhere to be seen at the center of how to design the Amazon fund, at the center of how to design the Bolsa Verde. And what I've done there is they, I'm lucky people read my books. I was called in by the
31:40minister and we said, well, let's make this a proper project and let's take a tool like the Bolsa Verde and actually rethink it. So instead of it being redistributive, which is like, oh, let's give money to some indigenous people because they're poor. That was actually one of the conditions, the level of income, but actually transform it into what I call in the book, a pre-distributive instrument and actually funding the people in the forest through the cooperatives and the associations because of the knowledge in the forest through the cooperatives and associations because of the knowledge, the innovation that they embody. So first of all, it brings a completely different vibe. This is dignity.
32:14This is you valuing someone for their knowledge, not condescendingly giving them money because you think they're poor or have been left behind. And that experience in Brazil, first of all, I have very little to say except to say I learned from it. I don't think economists are very good at listening or understanding how to work with communities. We work at communities. But those are the projects that I think are really critical. Let's turn that around to Britain. What have you learned from working with communities in Britain? What have you learned about British government? Imagine you replaced Brazil with Britain. Instead of telling us the journey about traveling 10? Emotionally replaced Brazil with Britain.
32:46Instead of telling us the journey about traveling 10 hours up the Amazon and meeting Indigenous people. It's funny, Rory, that that's all you hear, the 10 hours. What have you seen on the ground in Britain? I've been working in this country since 1998 and I've done my best. I've worked very, very locally, even in Camden where I live, for example, with Georgia Gould when she was leader of Camden Council. Again, she had read the missions book. And during COVID, we set up the Camden Renewal Commission. And what I learned was that the Camden residents were fed up with both their own leaders, their own government, but also maybe with advisors who come and go to tell them why it's really important to have a green transition and so on. So what we did in
33:25Camden, and actually it's good you asked that because it actually relates very much to what I learned, again, in different parts of the world. If you don't like the fact that we went on a 10 hour boat ride, that's not the point. That's the only way to get there. Anyway, was listening to the care. So for example, we said, let's not just do cut and paste missions. Let's think what does Camden actually need? So the first thing was to have a We Make Camden, just call it citizen assembly was actually through resident associations across 10 housing estates to listen to the people in the Camden estates on what they thought was most needed in their own neighborhood that could fit into some sort of climate slash
34:07sustainable slash ecological transition, if you want to use the Brazilian words. They said two things. They said, first of all, our food banks make us feel very humiliated. So if we're going to have a green transition, how about transforming it into a green food cooperative? So we have agency, coming back to this point about dignity, and actually valuing people instead of talking at them. So we set up green food cooperatives. And I can tell you that the same people whose facial expressions revealed, unfortunately, not being very happy when they walked into a food bank, completely transformed when they are actually running the show in a food bank that also was working with different types of actors who were really thinking about the whole kind of sustainable food chain that could be interacting with the food cooperative.
34:52But it was mainly the dignity. Second, the adult social care mission that we focused on as one of the sandboxes, because as I said, I think we can only learn through local examples. The idea was to put the carers, the people who had actually been providing care in Cam of really flesh out what it means to have, you know, a growth in every postcode. I think it means listening to people in every postcode and actually bringing the knowledge, the lived experience of the people who've been not just left behind, but also working in areas that have failed to the table to design those better policies. There's a great book by Jennifer Palka in the US where she says that the people who actually design digital platforms often have never used those digital
35:50platforms to access, for example, their welfare payments, their driver's licenses, and so on. And so that's already messed up. We should be designing things with users in mind and what's the best way to do it through groups of users, and especially if you have a progressive government that cares about things like health and housing, that's incredibly important to ask, where are these policies coming from? Is it from the consultants? Is it just a random academic like me that comes in and out? Or do we work with the community through a process of designing that outcomes orientation with their knowledge? A couple of things we've talked about about that actually you mentioning Georgia Gould, who I've known virtually since she was born, was an exceptional council leader. I think she was
36:33really, really good. And I think is now becoming a very, very good minister as well with some of the most difficult issues in education. But I wonder whether that speaks to something that I was thinking when you were talking before, that ultimately, leadership is the key to all of this. So when you say, for example, I mean, I've never worked with a government that doesn't complain about the inability for departments to work together, that doesn't complain about the damage that's done by people thinking, never thinking outside their own silos. So actually, is it not the case that unless you have the political leadership to drive this change, then your ideas are going to just sort of stay on the page on the book? You always need that
37:18political leadership. Or do you think actually there is systemic change that can be made simply by coming in with a good idea. No. Yeah. I think there's three different issues. One is, also going back to Rory's good question, are we all just consultants if we go around telling governments? What I focus on is what I've been studying for 25 years. So it's not like, oh, here's a little gimmick, let's go sell it and leave. So this stuff is hard. It's hard to do good industrial strategy. There's lots of bad industrial strategy. Bad industrial strategy for me is when you're just giving money out to sectors as opposed to goals that require different actors to work together in a different way. Missions, again,
37:55are intersectoral, not sector specific. And with Georgia, what I really admired in her is not only does she get it, but then we got our hands dirty with, again, procurement in Camden. And it was interesting that her first job with Starmer was actually in the cabinet office, really kind of on the public admin side. And she brought that experience from Camden around procurement, around rethinking, again, the kind of inter-departmental collaboration, something we also, by the way, did with Andy Burnham in 2018. The whole B network was part of that sustainable mobility strategy that was really about kind of aligning services instead of just thinking of it as transport. So leaders matter, and she really got it. She was also really
38:35good at speaking. I mean, I was always really proud to be at her side in some of the meetings, just hearing how she spoke genuinely to people. You know, I think this is where people kind of criticize Starmer. I don't like the personality critiques. That's just not my thing. But she had the personality that people loved speaking with, as opposed to just feeling like you're talking to a technocrat. But even when you have that leadership, and I've seen this, I won't name the countries, if you then don't invest and work well with your own ministers and especially civil servants, then it all fails. First of all, because once you're out, it all is gone, right? So that's also why I really believe in civil service training. That's
39:15why I'm proud to be an academic in a public university, why I set up the Institute for Innovation and Public Purpose, which is all about investing within the civil service. So we're less reliant on others and building those capabilities. If you don't do that, whatever policy you do, however successful it might be, once you have a new election, all that gets lost. So part of that is the training. But another thing is, I think if you don't trust, I mean, I saw this, maybe I will just name one, with Colombia, we were with Gustavo Petro, the president. You know, he was really good at talking to workers, really good at talking to indigenous communities, not very good at working with his ministers.
39:53In fact, he kept firing them. So it was incredible instability. And yet he was very inspirational. I mean, he gave some of the best speeches at Anga, even better than Lula's. So that's obviously not enough. Just like with an academic, it's not enough just giving a great talk if then you don't get your hands dirty to really learn what Roy was saying, the difficulties, if you don't admit the difficulties. But if you don't have a successor, that's also a failure. And so sometimes great leaders, you know, invest a lot of time in their own great work. And if you're not investing not only in the next generation, but that more distributed next generation, that's not just about the next person. I think that's what I've seen really not happen. And that's what worries me the most. And
40:32again, it's the only reason that currently running this institute, which is 60 people, we've just welcomed our next cohort of master's students. We have also a PhD program and we do the applied learning, which is more four weeks with the different governments we work with. That is hugely tiring. It's exhausting. It would be much easier just to write a book and go around and do my book talks. Have you ever thought about actually going into government, not as an advisor, not as a consultant, but actually either through the political route or through the civil service route, actually becoming part of a government machine? Because, you know, I wonder whether that would give you a different perspective. I mean, I've thought about it. I was actually asked in Italy at one point,
41:14they asked if I was interested in potentially actually becoming a minister of finance. And I said, Oh, my God. So currently, I am very happy. You know. We all have our calling. I love ideas. I love working with students. I love working with governments, not at governments. So I'm very happy doing that in the future, maybe, but that's currently not what I'm interested in. But I am very interested in upsetting, debunking the relationship that academics have with governments. So first of all, I think we have a lot to learn from governments. I mean, I repeat, even in Mexico, the current civil service, so the Minister of Finance, Edgar Amador, and the President, Claudia Scheinbaum, were both academics, extremely smart. But the main thing is,
42:01because there was an inspirational plan, they've been able to crowd in incredibly interesting young people who want to be part of this moment. Now, is that then followed up with that civil service that comes in full of hope? Are they then able to work on those tricky problems? Or do they get infantilized in the process, as Lord Agnew said? you know, that depends on how we build the government machinery. And I'm very interested in helping governments build the machinery. Mike Bracken, by the way, who's one of our professors, he set up GDS, you know, gov.uk. He's one of our professors of practice. He says often that the people working in government don't even understand the machinery. Are there any governments you would not work for ever?
42:46Yeah, of course. Any fascist government. So United States? My own country currently. I mean, I tend to work not with a government, but with a program in the government. In the UK, for example, we even worked with the BBC to rethink public value. But I have refused to work with governments. and one could call it hypocritical, because as you said, the US government is incredibly problematic, and I have worked with them, with governments that are explicitly abusing human rights, and that have programs that go against my values. Marianna, tell us about Giorgio Maloney, and what's happening in the Italian economy and how you reconcile Maloney's ideological position with Italy's economic performance and what we can learn from Maloney.
43:33Maybe that, and then we'll maybe get on to Trump to look at your other two nationalities, but let's start with Italy. I haven't worked with Maloney. I actually worked with Conte I, so Giuseppe Conte had two governments. He was prime minister. I have refused to work with Meloni. I haven't had any kind of explicit request to, again, be minister or anything. But I think we are quite opposites in terms of our thinking of how to run the country. So there wasn't that kind of sympathy to start working with them. However, what I would say about them is, first of all, what people sometimes don't get about Italy is that it has actually been a very stable country for many, many years. Like pre-Berlusconi, we basically had the Christian Democrats in power forever, right? People changed,
44:16but there was stability. Berlusconi then kind of upset that. And then what then happened was that the so-called right in Italy had these four different dimensions. You had the Meloni side, which comes from the fascist party, literally, it traces back to Mussolini, right? So it's not an adjective, it's a fact. It comes from the traditional fascist party in a new form. There was the Lega, which started in the north, the Lega Nord, now it's just Lega, which basically is just very xenophobic. They began by being very against the south. That's why it was called Lega Nord, acting as though all the southerners were just a weight on the Italian economy, when actually a lot of the statistics show the opposite, that a lot of the northern industry like fiat has been a huge weight
44:59on the Italian economy for reasons I can talk about later. They're basically not very innovative, and they kind of get the government to absorb the wage bill when things are bad and then take on the profits when things are good. But that's been a huge cost to the Italian economy. Then there's the, we call them the commercialisti who just don't want to pay tax. And that kind of fits in with the Berlusconi side, which is that there wasn't really like a strong right-wing narrative, like a conservative narrative. It was just kind of less state, less tax, basically just making his own profits increase, kind of very Trumpish, right? So Mussolini preceded Hitler, Trump preceded Berlusconi, Italy always leads.
45:34So Meloni right now continues to be sort of part of this coalition, which is this right-wing coalition in Italy, which is actually, for the reasons I just said, not so united, right? They have, for example, very different views of the state itself. And what I think she's very good at, she presents herself very well. She's, I think, actually quite professional in the sense that she goes to Europe and has functional, you know, relationships with the head of the European Commission. She knows how to get on with different types of, you know, diplomats globally. So she presents herself as though, okay, this is a pretty normal government. You know, yeah, she comes from the Mussolini, you know, fascist party, but hey,
46:13she's kind of normal. But that hides a lot of problematic things underneath the surface. There's something slightly disturbing with both the US and Italy, which is those are obviously governments that you profoundly disagree with politically, you'll come from progressive politics, and you often talk about those governments in terms of their fascist echoes or fascist roots. I've never used the word fascist for the US. I use it in Italy, because it's a fact it comes from the fascist party. Literally, some people use the word fascist just as a quick adjective. I don't. I think fascism is serious. Okay, so you tell us what you think about Trump. And I guess where I'm trying to get to is these are, rather uncomfortably for us, the kind of more progressive social democratic
46:56standard bearers of Europe, the countries that traditionally 10, 15 years ago, we would have held up as great examples of generous state investment and good investment in industrial policy are lagging. And now we have a United States with a president who you don't think is fascist, but who is presiding over sustained economic growth, relatively good employment figures, impressive productivity. Is there anything in that, whichever makes you re-examine anything that you've thought, or do you just see that as being explained by the fact that actually Trump is secretly doing all the things that you think governments should do? No, he's not doing anything I think he should do. In fact, I wrote a whole article about this in
47:38Foreign Affairs because he was starting to take equity stakes out of Intel, and people said, isn't that the entrepreneurial state? And I said, no. Anyway, so first of all, just to backtrack a bit, I didn't say Trump is not a fascist. I said, I don't know where you would have heard me say that because if I talk about Trump, I talk about very specific things he's doing and why it's extremely problematic. I have used the word fascist in Italy because it literally comes from the fascist party. What Trump is doing, which is a continuation of what he did with Trump one, is organizing an economy where the growth that there is, as you said, there is some growth in the US is basically coming from the financial markets. It's not coming from the real economy. There's a complete mismatch
48:20in the US for many years between what's actually happening in industry. We can take AI separately for a second, and the financial market. So the fact $7 trillion in the US has been used to boost stock prices, stock options, and executive pay, and executives are basically paid with stock options. And there's a capital gains tax that actually is rewarding those short term, almost millisecond trades that can produce growth, but that's a financialized form of growth. This is something that both Keynes and Hyman Minsky talked about, money manager capitalism, that growth doesn't then spill over to the working class or even the middle class. Unions have been, you know, fighting for this for a long time. It's very interesting, actually,
49:01to see what happened two Decembers ago, where the United Auto Workers, for the first time in their history, actually struck, is that a word, struck against the three big auto companies together to make sure that also the battery workers would see their wages go up instead of have this kind of divide and conquer situation you have in the US, where the labor share, the labor share of income in the US is one of the lowest levels it's been in US history. The profit share is at a very high level, and yet investment has been falling. So the US economy is one that's almost like profits without production, and without investment. So when you have this financialized form of growth, not only, you know, forget the climate consequences and all that kind
49:41of stuff, just forget the green agenda, Just literally the real economy is not benefiting. And given Trump's work towards increasing the stock market, one could not criticize him. Like if that's what the goal is, he's doing really, really well. Is he doing well for the real economy and those people working in the real economy with real wages that have not increased and the labor share falling, so on and so forth. I mean, that's where Biden tried, tried to make changes. The first thing he said was, I'm a union man. The policies he did, like the CHIPS Act that I mentioned, putting working conditions and worker pay at the center of any public-private partnership, I think that was a good direction. And that's being dismantled. And just one other thing that I don't think people
50:29appreciate enough about Trump. He is the first US president ever, ever to dismantle what I call the entrepreneurial state. In the entrepreneurial state, I looked at the Reagan years. Reagan increased the funding for all those organizations like DARPA that, you know, basically, you know, invested in the internet, like the National Institutes of Health, which are publicly financed that put 40 billion a year into health innovation and that are behind most blockbuster drugs. So China is extremely happy. You know, he is dismantling what I personally think has been the source of competitiveness of the US. My critique of the US is, hey, if you can do it for the military industrial complex, why don't you do it for all these other areas?
51:11In fact, they have used military type thinking also for the health sector, like BARDA and so on, but we won't go into those details. But the public-private relationship has been the key thing also that I've criticized, because we've socialized the risk, privatized the rewards, but Trump is dismantling US competitiveness. So, you know, the future of the US economy has a very, very bleak outlook. My final question, Marianna, is if I can take you back to the James Graham play about Keynes, what do you think Keynes would be, if Keynes was still alive, what would he say to Andy Burnham and John Healy about what they should do in the budget? Well, Burnham said something, but he didn't repeat it. He talked about living well. And Keynes' good life.
51:55And Keynes' good life. And again, you know, very much inspiring also why I ended up writing this Common Good Economy and why I'm also now working on this public value of arts and culture project where we're measuring the value of a carnival. You know, the Notting Hill Carnival is not just, you know, two days. It's a year-long system of production, just like in Brazil, the carnival is a year-long system of production, which brings so much joy, the bem vivid, but also social cohesion, mental health improvement. So I think Keynes, he would say what he said, which I don't think has been said enough by Keynesians themselves, which is double down on this idea of the good life, of the common good, and ask how then to approach these policies
52:36like housing, like growth in every postcode, also through that kind of good life side, which means you're not just building homes, you're building communities. You are investing in arts and culture, not just in elite institutions, but increasingly like the work we're doing both with the Whitechapel Gallery, V&A East, which is really interesting how they're working with communities. That shouldn't be seen as just like arts. That's investing in culture. Like Celso Furtado said in Brazil when he was Minister of Culture, he said, cultural policy is economic policy because of the opportunities it creates on the ground. And I think these are things that Keynes really thought hard about and unfortunately,
53:17kind of got siloed away from just the kind of hardcore Keynesian economics that lots of us also believe in, but that is not enough. Well, lovely to talk to you. I'm glad you enjoyed the play and see you soon. Thank you to both of you. That's Mariana Mazzucato. She is, of course, a huge hero for lots of people who see themselves more aggressive left. I first came across her from my mother-in-law, who's a huge fan, follows everything she does on social media. I guess you picked up a little bit of my frustration, which may be a version of my general anxiety around progressive economists. You're going to mock my person. I find it, and maybe this is just a sort of allergy from Afghanistan and Iraq, where there were
54:07lots of incredibly confident academics who would come and say, this is the way that you sort out Afghanistan, this is the way you sort out Iraq. I read a book on this, I met this guy in Ethiopia, etc. The president of Afghanistan, Ashraf Ghani, was't even say it's like i did this in ethiopia i did this in the fall i'm going to do this in afghanistan um so maybe maybe i was overreacting anyway what did you know i i look she's obviously she's a bundle of energy she's extraordinarily clever and i've read um two or three of her books and have enjoyed them i think she's got an important voice i found it sort of quite hard as a conversation. She's one of those speakers who there's very little gap. And you're sometimes quite good at
54:51just sort of piling in. But I sort of like people to finish their own thoughts. But you could be waiting for quite a long time. And it sometimes just felt like there was a sort of a bundle of different projects and different ideas. and what I was looking for with things that would would knit them together and I didn't really feel that so for example you might ask a question about you know what should Andy Burnham do in the budget and back would come stuff about you know Whitechapel Theatre and Georgia Gould did this and what have you and I found that quite frustrating I think in terms of the the the the this notion i think it's really interesting she saw the canes play the james graham play about canes the night before we
55:31did the interview and coming out of the back of the labour conference because i think that is kind of what she's saying that the purpose of economics is actually to try to improve the lives of so-called ordinary people and i'd kind of like to have heard a bit more about that and a bit less about, you know, I wrote this book and I wrote this paper and did this project. Exactly. I think that's right. I think what makes it a six is she has a genuine, and when she talks about missions, I think it's a way of saying that she wants to go and defines big progressive goals and organises everything around it. I mean, again, if there's economists listening to this, I think there's a couple of things they would
56:05probably want us to point out to the audience. One is that Mariana was often associated in the public mind with somebody who suggested that what we should be doing is setting up investment banks and borrowing much more money. And of course, that was a slight different argument 10, 15 years ago when interest rates were very low and when I think she was absolutely right. We've done enormous amount. More was set out in the British investment banks, finance and property because it was cheap to borrow. But now we are spending $113 billion a year more than we're spending on almost anything else in debt interest with interest rates of 6%. And so it's much more difficult for her to mobilise the money, but I guess, of course,
56:50watching the way that was the case in the future. And there's a second interesting question, which is that when these arguments were particularly popular in 2008, 2009, the European economy was about the same size as the US economy. And most measures, the US economy is now about 15% larger than the EU economy. And that's partly to do with a lot of specific things to do with the US, including the dollar. But the US, yes, it has a much industrial side, but it obviously is not the world's poster child for a progressive, high-tech,tech redistributive government investment-led economy in fact you know in many ways that's what i suppose i was trying to get to for the trump question one of the things that's uncomfortable about the west is it's growing much faster
57:38down in europe and trump is not doing any of the sort of things that one would have thought progressive economics would suggest she do now she's she's saying well that's because it's all Europe and Trump is not doing any of the sort of things that one would have thought progressive economics would suggest she do. Now she's saying well that's because it's all going to come out, it's all going to go wrong and it's not going to work out, it's just a short-term thing but it is a problem and it's a particular problem with Germany which was the real example that everybody looks for, look at that in the early 2010s. It's troubling so much. Anyway, there we are. I think she was fine about you pointing out that she was talking about like and so on.
58:10I think she bristled a little bit by you objecting to her 10-hour boat journey. And I actually think, to be fair, she is one of those people who gets out and about. She doesn't just sort of sit behind the laptop and sit behind the book. But I'll be fascinated to know what people think of it, because as you say, I'm sure a lot of our listeners and viewers really, really like what they think her to be. But I found it quite sort of hard to kind of get into a conversation there. I didn't find it a satisfying conversation, put it that way. But we'll see whether our listeners and viewers agree. Well, let's see what everybody thinks. And thank you again, Elst. Have a great day. See you soon. Take care.
58:59We just moved into our new house and I didn't realize just how close we were to the neighbors. That's when my friend told me about Blinds.com. Blinds.com isn't a medication, but it can improve how you feel about your home. Customers who shop at Blinds.com experience excellent customer service, from consultation to installation. Side effects include increased privacy and better sleep. Talk to your partner today and see if Blinds.com is right for you. Shop Black Friday all month long at Blinds.com. Don't miss huge deals dropping every week.





