The Rest Is Money · · Transcript & summary by WhipScribe
A pensions minister admits the system has lost public trust, and the hosts push him on what would actually fix it.
Tap a chapter to play it from that moment in the show's own player; the transcript opens there too.
“They don't have trust in pensions.” Torsten Bell · at 4:09 — ▶ hear it from here
“Pensions are the biggest domestic pool of capital in Britain.” Torsten Bell · at 42:28 — ▶ hear it from here
Pensions Minister Torsten Bell argues the central problem is trust. He cites 45% of people who think they will have a worse retirement than their parents, and 30% who doubt the state pension will still be there in 30 years. The pensions commission estimates 15 million people are undersaving, mostly private-sector workers. The self-employed are the sharpest case, with pension saving falling from about half in the 1990s to a sliver today. Women on several low-paid jobs, below the £10,000 earnings threshold, save far less than men.
Automatic enrolment since 2012 is the clearest success, keeping roughly 90% of eligible workers saving with low opt-out rates. Counting the whole working-age population, though, 45% save nothing. The debate over raising the 8% minimum toward 12%, a figure from an earlier report, turns on employer costs and how changes are phased in. Bell says contributions will not rise this Parliament, and the commission reports in February.
Robert and Steph press on where the money goes. Bell stresses that investment returns, not contributions, do most of the work in a pot. Robert cites about 2% of pension assets held directly in UK shares. New rules for drawdown and a required default lifetime income are on the way, and Robert suggests an AI service could replace £5,000 adviser fees. The episode ends with a teaser for a later episode on alternative investments.
Torsten Bell is the Pensions Minister and was previously the boss of the Resolution Foundation think tank.
Torsten Bell said the government has set up an independent Pensions Commission that is working closely with employers and unions. He said its review is due in February, and he would not pre-empt what it recommends.
“we've set up an independent pensions commission”Torsten Bell · 15:56
Torsten Bell called automatic enrolment a real success, because it settled the question of whether workplace pensions would survive in the private sector. He said about 90% of eligible workers stay enrolled, and that opt-out rates were much lower than anyone expected.
“I think it's been a real success.”Torsten Bell · 11:38
Torsten Bell said pension schemes are the plumbing of British capitalism and the biggest domestic pool of capital in Britain. He argued that pensions policy has consequences for where that money is invested, including UK growth companies.
“Pensions are the biggest domestic pool of capital in Britain.”Torsten Bell · 42:28
Torsten Bell said Canadian pension schemes are about 10 years ahead of UK schemes. He said they have grown to scale, moved investment in-house and chosen what to buy directly rather than outsourcing to global trackers.
“they are about 10 years ahead of us in terms of the evolution of their pension schemes.”Torsten Bell · 46:44
Torsten Bell argues that Britain's pension system has lost public trust because private-sector workers cannot be sure of a comfortable retirement. He says the fix is a phased, long-term reform that brings people's savings up to a sustainable level, gives them a clearer guaranteed income at retirement, and invests more of the pension pot in UK growth companies.
Torsten Bell, the Pensions Minister, says the core problem is that people do not trust the pension system. He cited 45% of people who think they will have a worse retirement than their parents, and 30% who think the state pension will not be there in 30 years. He also said the trust gap is worse among older generations than younger ones.
Robert cited figures showing the share of self-employed people saving for a pension fell from about half in the 1990s to around 20% now, and to 4% among those who are only self-employed. Torsten Bell said the self-employed are a much bigger part of the undersaving problem, and that the number who save at all has fallen sharply over the last 20 years.
Torsten Bell says the gender pension gap for people in their 50s is about 48%, but he thinks it may have peaked. Automatic enrolment has brought many more women into pension saving, and the state pension is now almost equal for men and women, at about 99%. He says the remaining gap comes mainly from women moving to part-time work after maternity leave, which slows their pay growth.
Torsten Bell called automatic enrolment a public policy triumph, because about 90% of eligible workers stay enrolled. He accepted that the 8% minimum of qualifying earnings, made up of 5% from employees and 3% from employers, is too low to give people a decent retirement. He said the pensions commission will decide the right rate, and that no increase will come during this Parliament.
Torsten Bell says UK defined contribution pensions are mostly invested in public markets and hold very little in private assets such as infrastructure and growth companies. He says foreign pension schemes invest in fast-growing British firms that UK schemes overlook. He points to Canadian and Australian schemes as models, and says fewer, larger funds can build in-house expertise. He cites a rule that schemes must reach £25 billion in assets by 2030.
Torsten Bell says that for someone saving through their working life, investment returns make up more than half of the final pension pot. Adjusted for inflation, every pound put in over a working life becomes about four pounds at retirement, and about nine pounds for someone who starts saving in their 20s.
Our own transcript of the public episode, with a timestamp about every 90 seconds. Tap a timestamp to play the episode from there in the show's own player; the link button on a paragraph copies a link that opens this page there.
0:01We have a hidden pensions crisis in Britain. Millions and millions of people are not saving enough for their retirement and actually there are plenty who are not saving anything at all. But even so, there are billions and billions and billions in our pension fund industry. It is the biggest pool of savings in the country and these pension funds are not backing Britain. So there are two big challenges. How do we get people to save more and then use that pot of money to support more UK infrastructure, private markets and growing businesses? Well, with us is Torsten Bell, former boss of the Resolution Foundation, now the Pensions Minister. We're delighted to say that this year the rest is money is powered by Octopus Energy.
0:45And that means we get to welcome back to the show, the founder and CEO of Octopus Energy, Greg Jackson. With all the talk of data centres and AI, how can the UK have the competitive advantage? Yeah, I mean, the reality is the UK has got electricity that's about four times more expensive than the US and China. And so the first thing we've got to do is get our electricity prices down. The second thing is, they talk about a queue to get an electricity connection. These numbers may sound confusing, but basically the UK has got a 700 gigawatt queue and our entire electricity systems, only 50 gigawatts. What we need is reform of the bureaucracy that manages the queue, so important projects get done quickly. Not just data centres, but houses, electricity generators, grid-scale
1:31batteries to store our renewables. And of course, we need to get our electricity costs down. Thank you very much, Greg. You'll be hearing more from Greg on The Rest is Money this year, but for now, let's get on with the episode. Hi, this is Garyllinker from Goal Hangers. The Rest Is Football. This episode is brought to you by Wise. It's only when you start moving money between currencies that you really think about the exchange rate, the fee and what might be hidden away in the small print. Whether you're living abroad, paying someone overseas or just trying to manage your money across borders, you want a fair exchange rate, an easy transfer and no surprises along the way. Wise keeps things simple. Wise is a smart way
2:11to move the currencies you need around the globe. It works in more than 160 countries and with over 40 currencies. Most transfers arrive instantly. Wise uses the mid-market exchange rate, like the one you see on Google, with no markups or hidden fees. So when money needs to move, you can see the rate, know the fee, and get on with it. Join millions saving billions on hidden fees by downloading the Wise app today. Be smart, get wise, T's and C's apply. No haggling, no hassle. No one called him boss. He's still on the couch. Astonishing. Sell your car today on Carvana.com. Pickup fees may apply. Tosin, it's lovely to have you back in a slightly different capacity now. Are you enjoying life as a politician again?
3:28The good thing about being a politician rather than running a think tank is, yes, the logistics of life are more complicated, but you can actually get stuff done. Well, we're talking pensions with you. And, you know, this is something that often comes up about the fact that there are lots of people not saving enough for retirement. And before we get into the solutions around that, I just want to talk about the problem. You know, it's something like 15 million people are undersaving according to this, you know, pension commission report. So how worried are you about people not saving enough, Torsten? Well, I think it's actually, it's almost bigger problem than that, which is if we step back, the problem is that people don't have trust in the pension system.
4:09They don't have trust in pensions. How do we know that? How do we know they don't have trust? I'll give you two facts on that. So 45% of people now think they'll have a worse retirement than their parents, 45%, which obviously historically shouldn't be possible to be true. 30 percent think that the state pension won't be there for them in 30 years' time. And that, by the way, is actually worse amongst older generations than younger generations, their faith. So those are my... I think if you want to say what's the one problem, I think it's trust in the system. And I think sitting beneath that are two problems. People believing that when politicians look them in the eye and tell them that the state pension will be there for them, that they can mean it, that you've got a
4:49sustainable state pension, that you won't force people to work into their 70s to get it. And then I think the second problem is the one that Steph's rightly started with, which is for private sector workers, can we confidently say to them that we've built a system that means they're on track for a comfortable retirement? And for too many, the answer is no. I think there's loads of different ways of thinking about that. So the pensions commission that we launched last year, they think 15 million people are undersaving for retirement. The overwhelming majority of those will be private sector workers. That's my focus in terms of where the challenge lies. I think it is worth saying, though, there's obviously a lot of differentiation within that. There's big groups within that. For example, the self-employed, you would definitely say we've got a kind of much bigger, if we think we've got a X percent problem when it comes to the self-employed people, of which only a million
5:46are saving anything for a pension? That's a number that sticks in my head. Is that right? It's those kind of proportions. I think it's a few less than that. We've seen a slight fall in the number of self-employed recently, but over the last 20 years, a big rise. What's going on is, as the big rise in the self-employment has happened over the course of this century, we've seen the proportion of people who have got any self-employment income and are saving for a pension go from 50% in the 1990s. So half of the self-employed were saving for a pension in the 90s. It's now fallen to 20%. So that's your one in five figure you just mentioned, Robert. I think it's actually worse than that. If you look at
6:19people who are just self-employed, so they're not self-employed and an employee at the same time, which lots of people are. If you look at people who are just self-employed, So they're not self-employed and an employee at the same time, which lots of people are. If you look at people just self-employed, we're now down to 4% of people saving for a pension, which rounds to zero. That's basically telling you the self-employed have opted out of pension saving entirely. And then there's a massive gender imbalance as well, isn't there? I mean, women on the whole saving far less for their pensions than men, and particularly women who do multiple jobs to keep the show on the road, because if you earn less than, I think it's 10,000,
6:54you're not involved in auto enrollment, an employer does not pay into a scheme for you. And if you're one of those women who, as I say, has a multiple number of jobs, but each of them earns less than 10,000. You're looking at a pretty brief retirement, aren't you? I would hope that we're at peak gender pension gap now. It's huge. The gender pension gap right now for people in their 50s is enormous, absolutely enormous, about 48%. What do you mean by 48%? If I just look at the level of pension wealth held by the average person over 50, over 55, I think it is, who's a gap and the rest. Now, let's do optimism, and then I'll come to why we definitely shouldn't be optimistic overall about that. So the optimism
7:51is we have seen a big change in the state pension. So the state pension used to be, on average, significantly higher for men than women because you had the state second pension, and that tended to go to higher earning men in particular. For the changes in the 2010s mean we're basically now going to be a system where men and women on average get exactly the same state pension. We're more or less already there. We're about 99% now. Then you've got the impact of automatic enrolment, where Robert was rightly there just highlighting one of the gender-based challenges with that, which is we see more women are working part-time hours. And so lots of those are coming in below the automatic enrolment threshold of £10,000. But the big increase in pension saving driven by
8:32automatic enrolment is much larger amongst women. I was just going to say, so why do you think it's peak now, that gap? So it's because automatic enrolment has brought lots of women into pension savings over the course of the last 14 years or so. So the big increase in pension saving has been amongst women in particular, and particularly low paid women, because the £10,000 threshold has become less significant over time because the minimum wage has risen quite significantly and the £10,000 threshold has stayed flat. It's because women are disproportionately likely to be working in the public sector, and they are disproportionately less likely to be self-employed than men. And it's because the long-term drive upward in... Remember, there have been more women going to
9:15university than men now since the 1990s. So there's a long wind pushing through the labour market and the rest that is seeing change over time. So those are the reasons for optimism. We're seeing far more women saving into pensions at all. The relative amounts they're saving have also narrowed relative to men. The reason, to be totally honest, that we definitely haven't cracked this, apart from the fact that the problem is huge, is one, if I look at other parts of the system, so I look at what's happening to pensions in divorces, then there's far too little attention being paid to pensions when divorces are happening. Only about 11% of divorces include some kind of pension sharing order. That tends to be because
9:52the initial discussion is on the house, understandably, with the kids and the rest, but it definitely leads to challenges later in life. It's also because the patriarchy is there. If you look at what happens to people's earnings, if you have a period out of the labour market has still got, you know, the patriarchy is there. So, you know, if you look at what happens to people's earnings, if you have a period out of the labour market, usually to have a child, there's things we can do about the period in which somebody is on maternity leave. So, in the public sector, within the local government pension scheme, for example, we're continuing pension contributions at the normal level right through someone's maternity
10:23leave. We introduced that change last year. But does that not happen in the private sector? It's very variable. It depends on the scheme, but lots of places know it doesn't. And it wasn't happening to the local government pension scheme until last year. So is that on your reform agenda? You're making it compulsory when you're on maternity leave to continue receiving your pension contribution. There are rules. There already are some rules that constrain um that i'm i was making a bigger point which is it's not just about the contributions when you're on maternity leave the big thing that is going to continue driving a gender pension gap is the then divergence in work patterns and earnings that happen when you return to work after your maternity leave that's
11:02by far the bigger thing because if you move to part-time work, the chances of your earnings growing go through the floor because of the nature of the work you're likely to be accepting. It's not just the hours you're working, which definitely do. It's that you don't see the same kind of pay growth as someone who stays in full-time employment. That's what's driving the lasting part of the gender pension gap, and it's definitely something we all need to think about. But that isn't just about the pension system. That's about our labour market, our caring systems, and all the rest. So on the point on auto enrolment, obviously, this was brought in in 2012 and was kind of graduated, wasn't it, depending on the
11:38size of the companies. Has that been deemed a success then in terms of getting more people in? Yeah, I think it's been a real success. I think it's a good example when people say, you know, lots of people look at the last 20 years in Britain and say, everything's broken, policy can't make any difference. Let's just give up on the whole thing. I think you would include automatic enrolment in one of the counter examples. And you would say, if you were in the 2000s, you could easily have believed that as the collapse in the defined benefit pension schemes in the private sector gathered pace, remember it happened much quicker than people expected in the 2000s, we could easily have ended up in a world where workplace
12:14pension saving just disappeared entirely from the private sector. And automatic enrolment has settled that existential question. We are going to have a workplace pension system. It has got the vast majority of people saving. It's got the vast majority of employees saving, and it's had much lower opt-out rates than anybody expected. So we've got about 90% of those who are eligible for automatic enrolment can stay enrolled. That is definitely a public policy triumph. But there are issues with it, aren't there? For example, the minimum contribution rate of 8% of qualifying earnings is too low, isn't it? So this is 5% made up of employee and 3% made up of employer. That is not enough, is it, to give people a decent retirement?
13:02I think we should celebrate it, but you're absolutely right. We shouldn't be complacent about the system that we have built. It's not just, it is about the contribution rates. I'll come to that. It's also just about who is in the system at all. So let me give you a fact on that. 45% of working age adults are saving nothing. So 90% of people eligible for automatic enrolment are saving into a pension. That's much higher than we expected. But if we then extend that to the whole working age population, 45% are saving nothing, and half of those 45% are working. That's where the self-employed problem sits. It's where the low earner problem that Robert talked about sits, and it's where people who have opted out of the system sit. So we've got lots of people
13:45still saving nothing. And that is a big problem. Some people you might not worry about them saving, maybe they're not saving for a few years or they're being self-employed for a couple of years, but they've got a big employee pension somewhere else. So you might not worry about them. But if somebody is self-employed for 20 years and doesn't save into a pension, it's a very, very big deal for their retirement. So there's how many people are saving. And then you're right, Steph, we definitely need to think about how much people are saving. And we need to do that with two things always in our mind. One is, are people on track for the comfortable retirement that we want them to enjoy? Because for the Labour Party, one of the big wins of the 20th century
14:25is that ordinary workers, for the first time in human history, had the prospect of a significant period of leisure at the end of their life. Apart from the very, very richest 0.1%, the 20th century invented that idea, that you would have a significant period of your life where you had the option. Some workaholics, like some of us here, might want to be working forever, but lots of people don't. That was a huge win for ordinary workers, or you have the option. Some workaholics, like some of us here, might want to be working forever, but lots of people don't. And that was a huge win for ordinary workers, particularly private sector workers. The 20th century delivered that. We have now put that at risk. That's why the trust figures are low, because private sector
14:55workers are saying, well, I'm looking at this, and I don't know if I'll have a comfortable retirement, partly because I don't know if I'm saving enough, partly because the system's quite complicated. So I can't look at the system and think, I'll definitely get this income in retirement. So we do have to improve the system. And that's exactly by the Pension Commission. So let's break them down. Let's just start with what is a sensible savings rate. Now, I was struck that somebody who has exactly the same name as you, Torsten Bell, in 2023 published a report which said the sensible target for the amount that we should be saving is 12 percent split 50 50 six percent employees six percent employers um is that still your view that that
15:56would be where we should end up well my view is that we've set up an independent pensions commission who's working closely with employers with unions with you are the pensions minister i'm going to come to that but i do think it's important that review is coming in february so Pensions Commission, who's working closely with employers, with unions, with... But you are the Pensions Minister. You're entitled to have a view. I'm going to come to that. But I do think it's important. That review is coming in February. So I'm not going to preempt what they say, not least because I actually don't know, because they haven't... So weirdly, I asked Claude what you'd say about that. He came back with, I'm going to say, I'm not going to preempt what they say.
16:21Well, I'm going to say, I haven't finished yet. You haven't let me get to the second part of my AI-induced answer yet, Robert, which is, look, when we go back to what the pension commission, the first pension commission that set out the plan for automatic enrolment in the 2000s said, they said in simple terms, think about your pension system as a third of your pension income is going to come from the state pension. A third is going to come from, you know, semi-mandated automatic enrollment contributions that everyone is heavily encouraged to do. And a third will come from voluntary savings. Now, the first two of those have gone to plan. So the first two, the state pension has risen significantly. That's what the triple lock has done. Adair Turner said the target was for the
17:07state pension to be 31%, I think, of median earnings. We're very close to that, aren't we? Yeah, no, no, that's exactly what I'm saying, which is the state pension is basically doing exactly what Adair Turner, who chaired the first pension commission, said, which is it's a really solid baseline that provides that foundation on which private savings can build. But he then said that there had to be two parts of the private savings, the automatic enrolment doing another third, and then there would be a third of the third that came from voluntary additional savings. And what the last 20 years has taught us is that the automatic enrolment and the state pension parts are doing their job, but the voluntary additional savings on top of those automatic enrolment and the state pension parts are doing their job, but the voluntary additional savings on top of those automatic enrolment levels, the numbers that Steph mentioned
17:48earlier, is only really happening for higher earners. It's only really happening for people on like 70, 80 grand plus. So we have got to rethink the system. If we're just stepping back and saying, if somebody is saving the automatic enrolment minimum, can we promise them that they're on track for a good enough retirement? The answer is no. So that's me giving you, that's not the answer. That's the straight answer. We will as a country need to save more, but we have to do that in the right way. And the lesson from- What is the right way? Well, the lesson from UK history and from around the world is that we need to do that in a way that sets the clear long-term trajectory, phases change in over a considerable period of time,
18:25because that's how you make sure that the system can cope with it, and wrestles with what I said earlier, which is the same people who we are worried about their income in retirement, we're also worried about their cost of essentials today. In January, we're expecting energy bills to rise. And so that's why I've said we're having the pension commission, we're going to make the right long-term decisions about how much we need to save as a country. How long is the long term? Well, I've said that we won't be introducing changes during this parliament. So we're talking about what changes need to be made during the 2030s to make sure that when people are retiring in the middle of this century, we have set them on that sustainable path.
18:58So let's say the pension commission agree with you from a number of years ago and suggest that this should be 12% minimum contribution of qualifying earnings, that obviously would improve retirement security and put more money in the pot, but it would also reduce take-home pay and increase costs for employers, especially if you're going to split it equally. And I know that you're saying, we don't know what it's going to say yet, but it's still whatever, if it goes up, it's inevitably going to be more money from employers putting into this pot. And small businesses in particular have said this would be a big issue for them because obviously it would increase their costs. It could mean they have to put up prices.
19:40It could mean lower profits, fewer jobs. There's lots of ramifications. So what would persuade you that the economy can absorb an increase in minimum pension contributions? Well, as I say, that's exactly why the Pension Commission are talking to all kinds of businesses. And so they got a very similar system to ourselves. In fact, Australia does it so that all of the contribution that's mandatory is on the employer. That's not the system we've chosen to have. But they do have 12% in Australia. On the mandatory side, yes, that's the number they use. Again, there's some other differences in the system, but broadly, yes. The way they dealt with their contributions and the way that the Conservative and the Lib Dem government rolled out automatic enrolment in the 2010s was obviously very gradual
20:29changes set in over long periods of time, taking into account different kinds of sides of organisations. That's the right way to think about it from a kind of organisational lens. It's also the right way, by the way, to think about it from the economics of it. These are significant changes. They need to be phased in. Other things adjust across your labour market to make it possible. That's what we see. And remember- So you're talking about phasing in, as and when it happens, it'll be phased in. Yeah. No, look, I've paid very close attention to what's happened in other countries. I've talked closely to all the employer organisations about this. The one thing that there is a very strong consensus about is that we need to pay attention to those lessons. And remember, Steph, when those
21:09employer contributions and those employee contributions were phased in during the 2010s, employment levels rose. But there wasn't a lot of the pressures that are on businesses now around the cost of energy, around national insurance contributions going up substantially, minimum wages going up. It's coming from all angles. Well, I've been very clear we're not increasing pension contributions this Parliament. I've said that on the day we launched the Pensions Commission. And you do need to think about pressures on businesses in the round, and you do need to think about phasing for exactly those reasons. So look, it's not just about whether people are saving enough. It's also where the money goes. Is it backing Britain? And we'll talk about that after
21:47the break. This episode is brought to you by Indeed. You're ready to level up your business, but the pressure to find the right person to make that happen is intense. Indeed Sponsored Jobs can help carry the load. It boosts your job post to help it reach quality talent fast. Cut through the chaos with Indeed Sponsored Jobs. Get a $75 sponsored job credit at indeed.com slash podcast. Terms and conditions apply. Hiring now? Then this is a job for Indeed Sponsored Jobs. Give yourself the gift of savings with visible wireless. Stay connected to what matters most with unlimited 5G data, talk, and text. Share the joy anywhere you go with unlimited hotspot and no contract to tie you down. For a limited time, plans start at $19 a month
22:32for one year on the Visible plan with promo code HOLIDAYHACK. Unwrap a little peace of mind this holiday season with Visible to switch today. Terms apply. Standard rate applies at month 13. See visible.com for plan features and network management details. Now at McDonald's, the new frosted cranberry splash with Sprite. Because there's no better time of year for friends, family, Sprite, cold foam and sprinkles. Now at McDonald's. You talked initially about trust. One of the aspects of not being enough trust is the vast majority of people are frightened about putting their money into equities, the stock market shares. People ought to recognize that if they're saving this money, the very strong likelihood is it's going to grow into really quite a substantial sum of money.
23:32But people don't have that idea. They're terrified they're going to lose it. And also, they are very fixated, obviously, on their immediate needs. How do we create more of a, I mean, I hate to say risk-taking culture, but just a culture where people recognize that putting your money into a fund that's properly managed will make them significantly better off? I think that's a really important thing. I think because I sometimes see the pension industry likes to put out these big numbers saying you need to save a pension pot of like X hundred thousand to have a comfortable retirement. And I always think, I know why they're doing that, but I think the danger is that what the public hears is they need to save
24:13X hundred thousand into a pot. And they think, well, that's not possible. And so I think here's just two facts to put that in perspective. For someone who is just saving through their life, even at the automatic enrollment levels, the vast majority of their pension pot at retirement comes from the investment returns, not from the contributions. If you just think about it as the money you save each month, that looks small, but then add the employer contribution, add the tax relief, and then most importantly, add the investment returns. The investment returns is more than half of the total pension pot at retirement. On average, for every pound somebody puts in over their working life, their pension is four pounds. And that's adjusting for inflation. If they do it in their 20s,
24:55it's nine pounds for every pound they put in. So this is not zero sum. That's the other thing to think about. It's not just, would you like to spend it when you are 70 rather than spend it today you're overall better off over your lifetime for pension savings one of the reasons why i'm very keen on pension savings and you are right that but young people definitely don't think or even remotely aware that for every quid they put in they're going to be getting nine i shall be at a school on thursday saying that robert and you go your school talks but i'm actually more positive than you i do a lot of stuff in my constituency with schools. Actually, I'm actually staggered by the, there has been a step change
25:30in young people's engagement with their personal finances, with investing. People ask me questions that I wouldn't have even known how to ask when I was like a 17, 18 year old. They get out, they show me, I've got Labour Party members investing left, right and centre and they're like 19 year olds and they're like you know they're pretty lefty so they i actually think young people are way more savvy and way more interested in investing but i agree with you because obviously i spend a lot of time talking to young people and they are way more interested in investing but not pensions they're interested in you know making money like day trading and crypto and all that. Yes. What has seen faster returns in the last year,
26:08average pension savings or crypto? But it's so far off. If you are 19, you do not care about your 60s. You are, you know, communication experts communicating to the young all over the country. So you need to remind them that look at the last year, crypto, if anything, has come down and pension savings have seen significant growth. Torsten, that's the same with cash savings versus stocks and shares. Historically, stocks and shares have always done better than cash, but it is really difficult to persuade people to take that risk and put it in stocks and shares. People don't just switch on the basis of us all going, that's what you should do, because then everyone has to follow with, but of course, terms and conditions mean that your
26:49savings could go down as well as up. The way you've just described it is particularly clear for individuals holding of savings, so ISAs. In ISAs, you can see very large amounts held in cash where people are holding from a long-term and would almost certainly deliver better returns over the long-term if they were investing those. Which is why you shouldn't have done the U-turn on reducing them. Well, let me finish the point before you start on the next attack. I'm just finishing Steph's attack, Robert, before you start. The point I'm making is that is not true in pensions. So in pensions, people are saving significant amounts. Those are almost all invested. If anything, the level of investment in public assets,
27:25so listed equities and the rest, is actually very high in our DC pension system. The issue is not that we haven't got enough listed equities being held. You might think we haven't got enough UK listed equities. It's not right that we are seeing a lot of investment with people's pension savings. People shouldn't be holding very much cash at all in those when they're young in particular, and that is what the pension industry is doing. So I think we should think separately about ISAs and how we think about pensions. You're right, but you've just brought two groups together because you've said you are talking to lots of young people now who are really interested in investing. What I am saying is, yes,
27:58that's what I'm seeing too, but not pensions. Well, I was at the first bus depot last week in Swansea with young people, young workers who have got on their app their pensions savings and are definitely more highly engaged than the average 44 year old, which is what I am in terms of their pension savings. So I think, again, even just on pensions, I think you're too pessimistic. We haven't really discussed what should be done to help those on lowest earnings save something. This is a really difficult problem because if you're on really low earnings, you need every penny now. So what can be done to help those individuals build up some kind of a savings pot? Well, the most important thing can be done,
28:45it's got nothing to do with pensions, and it's about making sure we've got a labour market that rewards everybody, not just those on higher incomes. And that's why I know some people don't like everything we're doing to change employment regulations, but I do think lower earners deserve to know when their shift is going to be. And if people change their shifts at short notice, they deserve to be compensated for that, just like we see in that bastion of capitalism, New York. For the first time in British history, low-paid workers had access to sick pay from last April. Opposed by everybody else, but we've known we needed to do this for years. Those are the things that matter more in terms of the financial resilience of low earners
29:26who are in particular... The low earners we should be most worried about are obviously the low earners in lower income households, which is partly the important question to wrestle with on the pension side. So when it comes to the labour market, we want a system that works for, yes, for employers, but also make sure that we are building that on a foundation of good work and good work for everybody. And that is what we're in the business of doing. But why are we basically saying there's one very important group in the economy whose only retirement income, you know, it's great that the state pension has gone up, but whose only retirement income will be the state pension? Why are we simply saying that is your destiny?
30:03I'm definitely not. I mean, I've been very clear. And I think partly what we owe private sector workers is more clarity about what is the system that they are getting. If they do X and Y, will they be on track for a comfortable retirement? And so I've never said to people, if you've just got the new state pension, that that's good enough. It's not. And that is what the vast, vast, vast majority of workers... But the bit you're avoiding is at the moment, employers do not have to make a contribution if your earnings are less than £10,000. Now, the Institute for Fiscal Studies has said they think that should go, that broadly employers, because at the moment, right, it is unfair. If you own a bit more than 10,000, your employer puts in 3%.
30:53And if you earn less, you get zilch from your employer into a pension pot. And that doesn't feel fair. No, people raise that. And lots of employers recognise that themselves, which is why they don't have that cliff edge in the system. If someone is, they are. They just let, they enrol everybody that wants to be into their, into their pension. But you're right, that is a, is a feature of the system. And that's balancing, I mean, you've, you've made both parts of the argument yourself now, Robert, which is that, that is the, that is how the coalition government tried to balance the, how are you making sure that you don't ask too much of people's living standards today, while also making sure that you're keeping people on track for a pension in retirement? My answer to that would be, this is hard. The reason it's hard is
31:28because some people that you see from the perspective of the work they are doing as low earners are people where they almost certainly should be saving into a pension. I'll give you an example. Somebody who is a second earner, married to someone who's earning a lot more, then the right thing to do for them financially would almost certainly to be saving into a pension. Whereas someone who is living on their own has got a significant pressure on their spending right now. They're bringing up a number of kids on their own, for example. It's much less clear cut. And that is the system you've got to wrestle with because we live in households. We don't just operate as individuals. So that is exactly the thinking the pension commission has got to work through.
32:07How do we balance those? Both of those are important things. Those are both things we need to put weight on and we need to take those seriously as we develop those proposals. Is there anything that could be done, and I've talked about this before, where yes, you're paying into a pension, but you see some type of benefit as you go? I don't know what that looks like, but maybe it's vouchers every year or just something that feels like you're also achieving something in the short to medium term and not just waiting for this day, which for some people might never come where you get to retire and live this great life that you've been saving for. Is there not something? Because that I just think would incentivise people more if there was like,
32:49oh yeah, I'm paying into my pension, but I've also now got enough to get cinema tickets or whatever it is to make things just a bit more tangible in the short term. There's other Torsten Bell, who I remember, who was in favour of, I think you called it sidecar. Was it called sidecar pots, where basically when you were saving, you would also create a small pot of rainy day money so that if somebody ran into financial difficulties, they could dip into that savings pot at any point to tide them over. And that's broadly what Steph is talking about. And that does, you know, I remember at the time thinking, this is a very interesting, constructive idea. Is that something the Pension Commission is looking at at all?
33:33Yes, they've said they'll look at that. And there've been a few organisations proposing versions of that. Why are people talking about that? It's because some of the same people that we are worried about having a decent income in retirement also have too low savings in the here and now. So if the fridge breaks and the rest... So absolutely. The issue is certainly... You need to think that obviously that needs to be thought about through the context of a pension system that does have more requirements on people to lock their money away because it's so tax advantaged. It's worth saying this. We have a pension system. It's about £70-80 billion a year we spend on pension tax relief, rightly, because we really want to give people a strong incentive to save. But it is because
34:15it's a long way away for lots of people. And us human beings do focus on the here and now. And so that's why you have a system that does provide significant tax relief to encourage us to save in. But that does bring with it consequences about how the system has to work so it's not being open to abuse because people want us to protect taxpayers' money, rightly. But do you remember the Fairpack Hamper scandal where people were paying into hampers for Christmas and the company went bust and loads of people lost money? And I remember at the time, I was working on the Today program on Radio 4 and I was saying how much of a big thing this was where I lived. I had friends and neighbors who all bought it, put money away for essentially saving for Christmas. And it wasn't with interest.
34:58You weren't getting loads of interest on it. You were literally just putting your money away to know that at Christmas you were going to get this big hamper. And I remember saying to the program team, this is a thing, this company got a bust, we'll really upset people. And they were like, who pays into a system where you don't get interest? There's a snobbery around all of this as well, isn't there? So my point about the short term is, yeah, people want to save for their retirement, but I just think tangible things in the short term is what people are thinking about day to day. They're thinking, how am I going to afford a holiday this year? How am I going to be able to afford Christmas? As well as the bigger questions of life about when they're older and how they'll survive that.
35:39So I just think the pensions industry could do well from thinking about what little things can we do that will actually mean so much to people. Yeah, that's really well put, Steph. Something else that you yourself raised only a few days ago was changes to what happens to your pot as and when you reach retirement. And actually, this is quite a complicated area. And I don't know whether you're doing this partly because of your concerns about trust in the system. But right now, you've got this system where when you reach retirement, you've got your pot from your direct contributions, savings over a period of years. You can take 25% out tax-free. You can choose to take an income at that point if you want to, or you can go into what's called drawdown. And the value of the money
36:38can continue to accumulate, you can get bigger, and you can take chunks out if you need them, but you've got to pay income tax on the chunks you take out above 25%. What changes are you thinking about to that system and why? The reason why there's a lot of change being introduced to the pension system now is because we are letting down private sector workers. There are 28.5 million private sector workers. Only 500,000 of those are in defined benefit schemes. And those are bits of the private sector often that are closely associated with the public sector. And just to remind people what that means, that means they know what their final salary pension will be. They know. People in the defined benefit schemes know what the system is offering them. They have
37:22a guaranteed income and they know when they'll start getting it and they know it will usually, that it will rise in line with inflation. And as you say, it's the tiny minority of savers in this country. It's a tiny, in the private sector. And that is not okay. And we have a system where we've made some progress, the point Steph made earlier about the progress from automatic enrolment, where we've got people saving again. But what we, and we do that through a fairly automatic system where they don't have to do anything that is brought into savings via their employer. That has been a big success. We currently, though, have a system where we've spent so long clapping ourselves on the back for getting that
37:55bit of the system working again that we've done nothing about what happens when you want to actually use that pension. In fact, what we've done is to say, we've built a system where you don't have to be highly engaged when you're saving, but at the point at which you come to retirement, you've got to become some kind of combination of an actuary, an accountant, and a fortune teller, all at the same time. You've got to know how long you're going to live. You've got to work out how to balance the risks of dying young versus dying old. You've got to choose how to invest your savings. People find that very scary. Sorry invest your savings. And people find that very scary. Sorry, just on that though, under that system, you do have, I think, a right to get
38:32advice from your pension provider, don't you? And you're just saying the advice is not good enough? No, some pension providers can provide some tax support to enable pension providers to provide pension advice, but sometimes that can be very expensive. I'm not going to name them, but I was talking to a financial advisor yesterday who's a part of the market they try to service is probably people with pension pots a bit over a hundred thousand pounds. They're charging an average of 5,000 pounds for that advice. That's ridiculous. That's pretty normal. Now I won't go into like, you know, I'm sure some of what they're offering is really good advice, but I'm just saying it's significant. I'm not sure it's worth five grand.
39:06Well, I'll leave you to make that point, Robert. But the point I'm making is that I want people to have a clearer sense of what the system is on their side. Now, that does mean, though, that people want flexibility and choice. So we do want people to be able to choose to do whatever they want with their pension pot once it's provided them with that income and retirement. So you're not taking away this flexibility? There is no, anything that people can do today with their pension pots, they will be able to do in the future under our plans. Human life is messy. People do need to be able to have different options. You can't understand exactly what different people's circumstances are and the rest. But we do have to have a system
39:42where pension schemes have to make sure that they are offering people saving through them all the way through their lives a decent pension option. Rather than being like, it's not our job, Gav, that's someone else's problem. Is that what some of them think now, that they don't have to provide to somebody who's given them all this money over all this time a credible proposal for a lifetime income? Well, everybody would say they're doing something. But yeah, no, lots of pension providers don't provide an option for anything that would provide them with a guaranteed income through their lives. They might just provide a drawdown product. Or in some cases, they might provide nothing at all because of the way our regulatory system works. So we are saying that every pension scheme
40:23will have to talk to the person that wants saying that every pension scheme will have to talk to the person that wants to draw their pension. We'll have to take information from them about their wider circumstances, what other pensions they have, the nature of their housing situation, are they married or not? And then we'll have to provide them with a tailored offer, a default pension that does give them protection against the uncertainty we all face about how long we live. And that is important. It does not mean the person has to take that. They can have a wide range of other options, but having the certainty that you've got one good offer, I think will help people engage with their pension savings. And just to be clear what that offer looks like in your head, we're not there yet in terms of a firm proposal, this would be an inflation-protected
41:06annual income? So the provider would have to say, this is your income today, and it will be guaranteed to rise at least in line with inflation. No, I think the... No, that's too prescriptive. I'm not setting out exactly what pension providers should put in place. The thing we have said is that it has to offer people protection. What does protection mean then? For how long they live. It cannot be an income that runs out when they hit 85. If the pension provider has the ability to reduce payments, that's no use to anybody. No, no. So in most cases, what people will... I appreciate this is a complicated area. So in most cases, people will have a range of options for what they do as providers. We are encouraging them to provide the inflation protector
41:50you're talking about. Yeah, that's what I'm saying. But I'm not mandating that. But I think they most will choose to do that. We are requiring them to provide the longevity protection, which is it has to be an income that lasts throughout their retirement. There are then lots of choices about how that's offered. Some people will want to offer more flexibility about how much of people's pension they use, for example, in the first 10 years of retirement, and then moving to a more guaranteed steady level of income for the rest of their retirement. That sounds even more complicated than the system we've got now. No, it's really not. It's going to be a much better system that gives people the guarantee of a decent option from their provider, but that gives them a solid base to make the decisions they want because people
42:28will want different things and they should be allowed to do that. All right, let's say all of this works, Torsten, and we do get people saving more. What's it going to take to get that money invested in the UK, in our infrastructure, in our companies, because we have a big problem with that, don't we? Currently, it's only about 2% of UK defined benefit and defined contribution assets, which are directly held in UK equities. So how do we change that? One of the things probably if we step back and look at the last 20 years that we forgot is that when people were thinking about pensions policy, they didn't pay enough attention to the fact that pension schemes are the plumbing of our capitalism. Pensions are the biggest domestic pool of capital in Britain. They do have consequences.
43:15I would say, I'll tell you a bit about what we're doing and what's the main focus, but then you guys will have, I'm sure, ideas as well. But if you look at the defined contribution pension sector, the thing that makes it stand out in Britain is the degree to which the investment pattern is through public markets. So it's listed equities, other kind of debt markets that are public, and it has a very small allocation to private assets, whether that is infrastructure, private debt, and in particular growth companies. So whether that's VC, wider private private debt, and in particular, growth companies. So whether that's VC, wider private equity questions. And in particular, on the latter, we have got a perverse situation where UK pension schemes are not investing in fast-growing British
43:55companies, but lots of other pension schemes from around the world are. And I regularly have foreign pension schemes coming into my office, setting up offices in London to reap the rewards of that and make sure their savers benefit from... I mean, I think there's a lot to be excited about in Britain at the moment in terms of fast-growing companies, whether it's in pharma, whether it's in fintech. We agree with this. I mean, one of the running themes of this podcast is we have this amazingly impressive thriving ecosystem of higher tech companies. some of them spun out of our universities, all over the country. I mean, the idea that this is all Oxford and Cambridge is rubbish. I mean, they're literally everywhere. And yet, the rewards are going mostly to foreign investors.
44:39Yeah. And I basically completely agree with that. If you look at the report the British Business Bank put out just in September, it's showing the difference in VC returns in the US, the EU and the UK. It is not true to say that the returns are materially higher in the US than in the UK. It's really not. The evidence is pretty clear. There is money to be made. British savers deserve to benefit from that. What we're seeing is the pension industry, as those defined contribution schemes go from being very small. Remember all the DB schemes were the big schemes, but the DC scheme is where all the new money is flowing into. Well, Nest, which is one of the organisations set up to get all this auto-owned, it's more than 60 billion,
45:19well over 60 billion pounds of savers' money in there. I know they've talked about taking more risk and taking more risk in the UK, but it's not happening fast enough. Well, I think two things are true. I think this is a good example. They've just recently announced £200 million going into UK VC. Yeah, I saw that. And that's very good news. If you look at, there's a number of schemes collaborating, I think, really well at the moment on what's called the UK Scale-Up Fund. That'll be over £1 pounds going into the UK VC. Five billion would be more like it. Maybe, but if I'm being kind, I think two things are true. Significant progress is now being made and we need to keep going. Those are both true. It takes time to build an ecosystem.
45:59Pension schemes need to hire the people that can do this. I want people's money to be invested well. But I'd say change is definitely happening. If you look at what in the British Growth Partnership with the BBB, we're seeing another 200 million going into venture that way. So across the piece, you're seeing pension schemes changing how they invest. I think that is to be encouraged. But if you're saying, do we need to go further and faster? I 100% agree. And we are supporting the industry to do that. I always find it fascinating how much Canadian retired teachers own in the UK. Infrastructure, tech companies, they're in energy. They've got a finger in every one of our pies, pretty much. What is it the Canadians are seeing that we are not when it comes to
46:44our pension fund investments? Yeah, I mean, that's a great question. And the answer is that they are about 10 years ahead of us in terms of the evolution of their pension schemes. So if you look to the 2030s, you will see maybe 10 to 15 very significant, very large UK, DC pension schemes with hundreds of billions of pounds of assets under management, who will have, as you put it, Steph, will have fingers in lots of pies, and will have built the in-house capacity to do that. What you're seeing with the Canadian schemes and to a slightly lesser degree of some of the Australian schemes is that they've got to that scale, and then they've changed what they are as organizations. They're not outsourcing their investment to a load of global trackers. They
47:28are doing it in-house and deciding what they want to buy. There was recently a transaction for ABP, which owns lots of the ports around the UK, including in Swansea. It was a foreign pension scheme selling it and it was a consortium including IFM, which is owned by Australian pension schemes that bought it. So that is the world we are heading towards. It will take us a bit of time to get there, but I'm very confident that's what we need to be on the route to do it. And we need to do that, not just because it's better for our growth and for our capitalism, but because it's better for savers. Savers will get better returns in the long run from that more diverse range of assets. ecosystems, if we could use that awful word. If you look at the Netherlands, if you look at Australia,
48:26if you look at Canada, one of the conspicuous features of all of those countries is that there are fewer, much larger pension funds. And what that means is that they can hire experts. There are also economies of scale. We have hundreds and hundreds of different, particularly in the private sector, hundreds and hundreds of tiny schemes where the trustees, many of them, have no expertise whatsoever. There are very few economies of scale. And in the public sector still, even though there have been some mergers, arguably, again, we just don't have big enough funds. So, I mean, we've legislated for exactly this reason. That is happening. There have been too many pension schemes. We need bigger, better schemes that are able to invest in that wider
49:22range of assets. And take more risk. Yeah, exactly. They'll take different risks and they can bear different risks. And that in the end is better for savers. And it does deliver economies of scale. It also does something that's slightly harder to pin down. But once you get to that scale, it means you have more active ownership. When you're managing an asset, you actually own it and you take seriously your job as an owner. And that doesn't happen in a kind of... It's really important. Now, that is exactly what is happening. So we have legislated to say, you cannot be a pension scheme taking automatic enrolment contributions unless you are at significant scale by 2030. You need to be at £25 billion worth of assets under management as a minimum. Is that big enough? Well, that will
50:01drive, speed up what's already happening, which is the consolidation in the market. If you're a player in the market, I promise you they're saying to me, you're already doing quite enough. So that will drive a significant increase in scale. And those pension schemes will then grow very fast to get to the 100 billions of pounds that I was talking about a second ago. Within the government, within the public sector, the big funded schemes are the local government pension schemes. We have transformed that sector in the last 18 months. All of the assets are being moved up to six pools. This is across England and Wales. These are very, very big players in the future of our country. I was in Leeds just on Monday, talking to Borders of the Coast that's based in Leeds. They are a
50:40huge asset manager. They'll be by far the biggest asset manager in Leeds. And they are doing exactly what you're saying, which is they're growing fast, taking in those assets, and then they are building the in-house expertise to do exactly that. And we're seeing that right the way across the LGPS, which is the local government pension scheme. In Wales, the pool there will be the biggest pension scheme in Welsh history. That is what our legislation has created. And I know these are techie changes, but I think these are really important changes. One, to make sure that that ecosystem is delivering for savers, good returns. As I said to you earlier, the vast majority of your pension comes from the returns on your savings, not just your savings. So it matters that you get those
51:19economies of scale to drive up the returns. And it means that, for example, the Welsh pension pool will be able to invest in a wide range of assets within Wales. And that is what we need to see in the long run. And don't forget cinema tickets as well, tossed in and all of this when you go back and chat to the commission. Front of my mind. And I think the general point, which is that we need a big picture system that works for private sector workers, but we need people to value that to see how it's supporting a good life today, not just a good life tomorrow. I'm going to make my rather more, I'm afraid, boring recommendation via you to the pension commission. Don't self-categorise like that.
51:53You know, you're fun too. You see? It's this, okay, which is as and when you move to these new options, you know, as and when people get to retirement, what you need to set up, and it isn't very difficult, is actually an AI service where people just plug in what their income is, you know, what their expectations and needs are, and out will pop a recommendation for which route they should go down. You don't need to pay anybody these days £5,000 for that kind of advice. Actually, you know, Claude can do it for you now if you've got the confidence. But of course, millions of people, when they come up to retirement, don't have that confidence. So you ought to create, you know, essentially an AI service that does that.
52:43And other AI options are available as well as Clover. I wasn't going to say that, Steph, but Robert's obviously on a retainer for a particularly AI company. But the general point, which is the way in which we provide advice and support to people to access their pension has absolutely got to keep pace with technology. Lots of people, if we're honest, are already getting their financial advice from that kind of route. And we as an industry and as the government and the regulators do need to keep up with that. And so that's two big contributions to the pension commission for me to pass on. Now, before you go, we've talked a lot today about investing and this is something we're obsessed with on this show. So in the next episode, we're going to do something a little bit
53:18different. I want to spend some time looking at alternative investments. So this is me and some of the best in the business talking about whether you can make a million from alternative investments. So things like cryptocurrencies or gold, art and wine. It's not advice on whether to invest or an advert of any kind. Instead, it's an overview of how the market works. How did it start? Who typically invests in it? How do you store the assets? How liquid are they? What's the return like? And how easy is it to get rich? Our politicians and political leaders over-promise us, and then they under-tax us, and then they use the most pernicious and they use the most regressive form of taxation, which is inflation.
54:00So first up, it's cryptocurrencies with the mooch. Yep, Anthony Scaramucci is a crypto critic turned evangelist. So he's going to talk to us about how that market all works. That's going to be in the next episode of The Rest Is Money. But we've got loads more to come for you on that front. I mean, it's literally everything that you need to know when you are thinking about not only, you know, where to save for the next year or two, but for retirement. It's unmissable. That's it from us. Bye-bye. Holiday drinks are now at McDonald's. Like the new Red Bull Frosted Cranberry Energizer. It's Red Bull meets cranberry flavors topped with cold foam and sprinkles made to charge your holiday spirit. Now at McDonald's.
54:55Sam's Club is the club for every holiday club. Guess who's joining the club this season? Walmart Plus. Yep, Sam's Club Plus membership now comes with Walmart Plus at no extra cost. Two memberships, one great price. Just $120 a year can save you time and over $700. Want to get in on the membership duo of the century? Visit samsclub.com. Come join us. Sam's Club. Annual plan only, auto renews, T&C apply. Estimate based on average combined Walmart Plus and Sam's Club Plus savings among members of both for one plus year versus non-member or club member pricing slash fees. Excludes membership fees. See Walmart Plus terms and Sam's club terms for more info it's officially the holiday season and abercrombie's new collection has outfits for everything on your calendar it's
55:32the busiest time of year and between shopping and party invites i don't have time to plan every look but abercrombie's always got me covered their sweaters are the perfect easy layer for low-key plans and on a nice night out I'm reaching for their classic trousers. Fill your closet with the pieces you'll need all season long. Have a very Abercrombie holiday. Shop in the app, online, and in stores.

