podcasts / The David Pakman Show / episode
The David Pakman Show cover art
podcast
📅 2026-11-11 ⏱ 78 min episode · ~2 min read 📝 Transcript · 13,532 words 🎙 Sarah Longwell

Sarah Longwell: David Pakman Show transcript and summary

The David Pakman Show · · Transcript & summary by WhipScribe

It explains why Democrats lost a Hegseth impeachment vote they could have won, and how a CBS edit of Trump's interview compares with the Kamala Harris lawsuit.

Read the transcript
In this episodePete HegsethThomas MassieNancy PelosiHakeem JeffriesRobert GarciaJim JordanMike JohnsonSteve ScaliseKamala HarrisCBS NewsThe BulwarkCaroline Sunshine

▸Chapters

Tap a chapter to play it from that moment in the show's own player; the transcript opens there too.

Transcribe your links. Paste a YouTube, Google Drive or podcast link and WhipScribe gives you the transcript. Transcribe a link →

▸Notable quotes

“We should not live in a banana republic patronage country.” Sarah Longwell · at 55:33 — ▶ hear it from here
“Funny how that works, isn't it?” David Pakman · at 1:11:51 — ▶ hear it from here

▸What this episode covers

The White House counsel's November 9 letter to Congressman Robert Garcia, the incoming House Oversight chair, warns that threatening investigations could amount to criminal conduct. The host argues that Congress has legitimate authority to investigate misconduct, waste and abuse of power, and that the administration is trying to shape oversight before the new House is sworn in on January 3. He notes that Republicans spent years investigating Joe Biden and his family.

Democrats also lost a procedural vote on Thomas Massie's articles of impeachment against Pete Hegseth. The motion to send them to committee passed 211 to 204 because 11 Democrats did not vote. Explanations ranged from traffic and a motorcade to a medical procedure, while Nancy Pelosi was in California for an award. The host calls it an organizational failure that Hakeem Jeffries should answer for. Separately, Texas Democrats filed bills to legalize adult recreational cannabis with home grows and a 20 percent retail tax, though the Republican-controlled state Senate remains an obstacle.

Jim Jordan won the House Republican leadership post over Steve Scalise after Mike Johnson stepped aside. The host points to an older clip in which Jordan said Americans can live with higher gas prices, and contrasts it with Republican attacks on gas prices under Biden. The show also argues that CBS heavily edited Trump's 60 Minutes interview by cutting his rigged-election claims, which is the same kind of edit Trump sued over in the Kamala Harris case. Guest Sarah Longwell describes focus groups of Trump voters who backed Democrats, and says corruption is the message that could move them.

▸Sarah Longwell on David Pakman Show: the answers

Who is Sarah Longwell?

Sarah Longwell

Sarah Longwell is a political strategist and publisher of The Bulwark, and the author of How to Eat an Elephant One Voter at a Time. She says she runs focus groups of Republican and Trump voters to understand why they are turning away from the party.

What did Sarah Longwell say about Donald Trump?

Sarah Longwell said the Trump voters she has spoken to since the election who switched to Democrats often feel they were promised lower prices and an end to wars. She said many of them are now saying they wanted a check on Trump, and that the economy has been bad enough that some are willing to give Democrats a chance.

“I was told he was going to lower prices.”Sarah Longwell · 40:23

What did Sarah Longwell say about Putin?

Sarah Longwell said she rejected Donald Trump from the start partly because he seemed to admire dictators. She argued that America should not side with dictators such as Xi, Putin and Kim Jong-un, and should clearly state its values even when it has to deal with them.

“We don't buddy up with dictators.”Sarah Longwell · 52:18

What did David Pakman say about 60 Minutes?

David Pakman said CBS's 60 Minutes heavily edited Donald Trump's interview, cutting about half of the recording, including claims that the 2020 election was rigged. He said Trump had sued CBS over editing Kamala Harris's answers, yet he did not object when the same kind of editing made his own answers look more coherent.

“Funny how that works, isn't it?”David Pakman · 1:11:51

What did David Pakman say about Pete Hegseth?

David Pakman said Democrats lost a House vote on impeaching Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth because 11 of them did not show up, and he argued that attendance failures would make it harder to hold Donald Trump accountable. He said the failed vote came just a week after Democrats' midterm victories.

“If you can't get your members to show up for a vote on Hegseth”David Pakman · 17:05

What is Sarah Longwell's main argument on The David Pakman Show?

Sarah Longwell argues that voters who backed Democrats in the midterms want a check on Trump, and that Democrats should root out corruption across both parties rather than make it look retributive. She also predicts the Republican Party will reconstitute into a more blood-and-soil nationalist movement, and that liberal democracy has to be rebuilt after Trump.

Mentioned in this episode

Episode facts

Released
November 11, 2026
Length
1 hour 18 minutes

▸Key takeaways

01The White House counsel's November 9 letter to Congressman Robert Garcia warned that threatening investigations of Trump officials could cross into criminality.
02A motion to send Thomas Massie's Hegseth impeachment articles to committee passed 211 to 204 after 11 Democrats did not vote on the House floor.
03The motion won by seven votes, with 11 Democrats absent and seven Republicans also missing, so the impeachment effort was shelved until January.
04Texas Democrats filed bills in early November to legalize adult recreational cannabis, but the Republican-controlled state Senate still stands in the way.
05CBS aired about 27 minutes of a roughly 52-minute Trump interview, cutting his rigged-election claims, after Trump sued CBS over editing Kamala Harris.

▸Questions this episode answers

Q1What did Sarah Longwell say about Trump voters and focus groups on The David Pakman Show?

Sarah Longwell said she has run focus groups with Republican and Trump voters who backed Democrats in the midterms. They cite prices, the Iran war and broken promises, and many say they wanted a check on Trump rather than a set of policies. She says she uses focus groups to learn the why behind voters' views, which polls do not capture.

Q2Why did Democrats lose the Hegseth impeachment procedural vote?

The House motion to send Thomas Massie's impeachment articles against Pete Hegseth to the Judiciary Committee passed 211 to 204 because 11 Democrats did not vote. Reasons given included traffic, a motorcade, a bus escorted by police, a medical procedure, and Nancy Pelosi's trip to California for an annual award. David Pakman called it an organizational failure for Hakeem Jeffries to answer for.

Q3Did CBS edit Trump's 60 Minutes interview the way it edited Kamala Harris's?

David Pakman said CBS aired about 27 minutes of a roughly 52-minute Trump interview conducted by a New York Times columnist, and that the broadcast cut Trump's claims that the 2020 election was rigged. He argues editing alone is normal, but notes Trump sued CBS over its October 2024 Harris edit and that Paramount settled for $16 million in July 2025.

Q4What does Jim Jordan's election as House Republican leader mean?

Jim Jordan defeated Steve Scalise 106 to 73 in a secret ballot to become House Republican minority leader when Democrats take control in January. David Pakman argued Jordan is picked for his record fighting Democratic oversight, and that the smaller Republican conference will lose its ability to set the legislative agenda.

Q5What did Jim Jordan say about higher gas prices during the Iran war?

In an earlier clip circulating after his leadership election, Jim Jordan said Americans can live with higher gas prices for a short time if that is what it takes to stop Iran from getting a nuclear weapon. David Pakman contrasted this with Jordan's 2022 and 2023 posts complaining about high gas prices under Joe Biden.

Q6Are Texas Democrats really moving to legalize recreational cannabis?

Texas Democratic state representatives filed nearly identical bills on the first filing day for the next session, which would allow adults 21 and over to possess two ounces, grow 12 plants at home, and buy from licensed businesses, with a 20 percent retail tax on top of sales tax. David Pakman said the bills face obstacles because Republicans still control the state Senate, and the session begins January 12.

▸Transcript

Our own transcript of the public episode, with a timestamp about every 90 seconds. Tap a timestamp to play the episode from there in the show's own player; the link button on a paragraph copies a link that opens this page there.

0:00Big news! Wayfair's Black Friday sale is here, early! Right now at Wayfair, get up to 70% off everything you need for the season ahead. Save on kitchen and dining, bedroom furniture and mattresses, holiday decor, and way more. Now is the time to score big, from seasonal finds to favorites you'll use all year long. Plus, with Wayfair, enjoy fast and easy shipping, with delivery in time for the holidays. Save up to 70% off early Black Friday deals. Shop now at Wayfair.com. Wayfair, every style, every home. Starting a business can seem like a daunting task unless you have a partner like Shopify. They have the tools you need to start and grow your business. From designing a website to marketing to selling and beyond,

0:42Shopify can help with everything you need. There's a reason millions of companies like Mattel, Heinz, and Allbirds continue to trust and use them. With Shopify on your side, turn your big business idea into... Sign up for your $1 per month trial at shopify.com slash special offer. When you spend enough time around great companies, you notice that the best ones treat trust as a growth strategy, not a box to check. Vanta helps companies build and prove trust from day one. Its agentic trust platform connects compliance, risk, and trust at enterprise scale. Vanta delivers a 526% return on investment over three years and pays for itself in just three months. Learn why over 16,000 of the fastest growing companies use Vanta at vanta.com. The Trump White House is now threatening Democrats

1:33with criminal investigations if they dare to investigate Trump and they actually put these threats in writing. We'll look at a letter that Robert Garcia received. Now, meanwhile, Democrats had an opportunity to keep Pete Hegseth's impeachment alive and somehow managed to blow it because 11 of them didn't show up to vote. Nancy Pelosi was off getting an award. We've also learned just how much 60 minutes cut out of Trump's latest interview, including some truly bizarre rambling. Remember, this is the same network that Trump sued for editing Kamala Harris, a 60 minutes interview to make her look better. Plus Republicans have selected Jim Jordan as their new leader. Texas Democrats are already pushing to legalize marijuana and Trump's search for another White

2:20House press secretary is getting increasingly strange. I will also be joined by the bulwark Sarah Longwell to talk about everything, really, including what is next for the Republican Party. We've got a show today. Let's do it. Donald Trump's White House is now threatening the Democrats who are looking at doing their jobs with possible criminal investigations. Wait a second. What? Why? Not because Democrats are planning to break any laws, not because Democrats are planning to abuse power. The Democratic plan to investigate Trump and his administration after Democrats won the midterm elections fair and square is what the Trump White House is now saying. You'd better be careful because that could be criminal.

3:17Now, if it were, you know, Benny Johnson or some random MAGA influencer making threats on social media. All right. But this is coming directly from the White House counsel. This is coming in a formal three page letter to the incoming Democratic chairman of the House Oversight Committee. And on November 9th, White House counsel William Scharf sent a letter to Congressman Robert Garcia. The letter was just released hours ago, warning him, listen, we know you're planning to investigate a whole bunch of different people. The investigations could cross the line into criminality. I want to read to you a couple elements from this letter. It says that, quote, threats to executive branch officials designed to deter them from public service or process designed

4:07merely to abuse or instill fear in the recipient may cross the line into blatant criminality. Whoa, that that sounds pretty scary. The letter continues, quote, and issuing unlawful subpoenas with the intention of depriving citizens of their constitutional rights and privileges may warrant further investigation. In other words, if you do investigations, we will investigate the investigations. Trump also going down this road on truth central where he posted, quote, The Democrats are going around threatening a lot of people, including the attorney general of the United States and others with impeachment and many other forms of people, including the attorney general of the United States and others

4:45with impeachment and many other forms of punishment, even though they admit they have no reason to do so. And there have been no impeachable acts committed or even thought of by the victims of this illegal process. This is extortion at the highest level and they should be held accountable for this. Also, they're threatening our donors, some of the most respected people anywhere in the world. Is that right? Trump donors are some of the most respected people with imprisonment and many other levels of punishment just because they happen to be Republicans or Republican supporters. This is weaponization and lawfare at another level. The senator from Michigan, at least Alyssa Slototkin is saying that she is going to go after all young people that believe in Republican values and that give even the slightest inclination

5:30to be a Republican. The imprisonment should be against these extortionists. Republicans should get smart fast. Threatening letters have been sent, blah, blah, blah. Investigate these people immediately. So think about what's happening here. Democrats win an election, by which I mean voters voted and said, we want to give Democrats power. One of the powers that Democrats get is to investigate the executive branch. This is part of their constitutional duty. And before the new Congress has even convened, which will happen January 3rd, the executive branch is warning them. Your investigations could be criminal. You might be investigated for investigating. And it is a blatant and pathetic attempt to intimidate Congress before they've even issued a single

6:17subpoena. They've done nothing yet and they're already getting threat getting threatened with. You might be committing crimes. Now, the letter contains a single, I would say, legitimate legal point, which is congressional investigations are supposed to serve a legislative purpose. Congress can't simply become criminal prosecutors. They can't issue subpoenas only to harass people. All true. Democrats have not suggested that that's what they're going to do. And that is not remotely the same thing as saying Congress can't investigate potentially criminal behavior by administration officials. That also has legislative relevance. Congress can look at government corruption and in doing so they might find criminality. Congress can

7:01investigate our laws being followed. Is there misconduct, waste, abuse of power? Do we need legislation to stop those things from happening again? All that stuff is legitimate. And in fact, there's a Supreme Court case from 2020, uh, Trump versus Mays ours. I hope I'm pronouncing that correctly. Where the court said, no, we, we reaffirm that congressional investigative authority has broad scope and there is something particularly absurd about the white house suddenly discovering, Oh, congressional investigations that are politically motivated are really dangerous. We just spent years watching Republicans investigate Joe Biden, Hunter Biden, members of the Biden administration. Anybody they thought thought might generate a politically useful hearing.

7:52Dr. Anthony Fauci. We've got the full list. And so now Democrats are rightly preparing to investigate the Trump administration. That's why we voted for them and set among passing legislation that's useful to people. But one of the reasons was do your jobs, do the oversight that you're supposed to do. And suddenly the White House wants to talk about the constitutional limits on subpoenas. The letter even cites statements from Democrats like Robert Garcia's response to Mike Johnson warning Democrats would investigate Trump and his family donors where Garcia responded. He's not wrong. And they are suggesting that that acknowledgment is somehow evidence of improper motives. Now the letter also cites Dems joking about handing out subpoenas like candy.

8:42These are political statements. These are not evidence that any specific subpoena doesn't have a valid legal basis or violates the law. And this is part of a broader effort. Trump directed the Justice Department to investigate Democrats whom he accused of criminal threats. And Todd Blanch, his attorney general, has already signaled we are going to resist these investigations. So we see the pattern before Democrats can investigate the administration. Trump wants his administration investigating Democrats. And the important thing here is Democrats should take the constitutional limits of their authority seriously. I'm a law and order guy, so they should do legitimate, well documented investigations

9:27with a clear oversight and legislative purpose. They should not allow, however, the administration that they're supposed to be doing oversight on to decide whether oversight will be allowed. If Trump can get away with intimidating Democrats in Congress into not doing investigations by threatening them, then once again, we have done away with congressional oversight. That's what Trump wants. And we have to make sure that that is not what Democrats decide to do. Speaking of Democrats, what the hell just happened in the House of Representatives, Democrats managed to lose a vote that they had enough votes to win related to the impeachment of Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth. And the reasons they lost are speculated to be traffic, potential health issues, a motorcade,

10:21Nancy Pelosi getting an award and a whole bunch of other stuff. I wish I were making this up now. Just as a reminder, this entire story is about Thomas Massie's impeachment articles, not the ones we are expecting. Once Democrats take control, we'll come back to that. But yesterday, the House voted on a procedural motion on those eight articles of impeachment that were introduced by the outgoing Republican Congressman Thomas Massie. Now, when I've been talking about Democrats impeaching Pete Hegseth, I've mostly been talking about what they can do once they're sworn in in January. That is when Democrats will have majorities to pursue these investigations, to do impeachment proceedings on their own terms.

11:06However, we had this unexpected earlier opportunity to do it before Democrats are even sworn in because Republican Congressman Thomas Massey introduced articles of impeachment while Republicans still control the House and the articles. Of course, we looked at the allegations. They're very serious, unauthorized war in Iran, unlawful military operations, civilian deaths, strikes on suspected drug smuggling boats that may be illegal, really serious stuff. Now, Republicans weren't going to allow the impeachment to proceed voluntarily, so they introduced a motion to send the articles to the House Judiciary Committee, where they would almost certainly go nowhere during the remainder of the Republican Congress.

11:44The final vote was two eleven to two oh four. committee, where they would almost certainly go nowhere during the remainder of the Republican Congress. The final vote was two eleven to two oh four. Republicans won by seven votes. But here is the problem. Eleven Democrats didn't vote. And if all eleven Democrats had shown up and voted against the motion, as their colleagues did, the result would have been two fifteen to 11 in the other direction, assuming that the Republicans who were absent remained absent. And instead, the motion passed and they have shelved the impeachment effort. So the question now is, where were the 11 Democrats start with Nancy Pelosi? She was at the Capitol earlier. She left to fly to California where she was getting an award.

12:24OK, her spokesperson said this is an annual event. She goes every year. It's very important. Earlier, she left to fly to California where she was getting an award. Okay. Her spokesperson said this is an annual event. She goes every year. It's very important. She was being honored. Wonderful. All right. But we're talking about a vote on impeaching the guy overseeing the war that Democrats have been denouncing for months and she left to get an award. All right. Her spokesperson said she would have voted, would have voted against the motion and she wants Hegseth impeached. All right. But she didn't vote. Then we have traffic explanations. Democratic Congresswoman Melanie Stansbury says she couldn't get to the Capitol for the

12:56vote because of a traffic incident and a bus that was being escorted by the police. All right. Congressman Jonathan Jackson, Congresswoman Laura Gillen gave similar explanations. They got to the chamber just as the vote was closing. Congresswoman Marilyn Strickland's office says she was stuck behind a motorcade. She missed the vote by a minute. Now, AOC was asked about this by our friend Pablo reports. And here is what she had to say. Your reaction to the attendance issues that Democrats had tonight on this impeachment vote. Um, I mean, of course we need to be, I don't know why people were in here. So for sure, you know, someone may have a health issue. I don't know. But obviously having a vote like that on attendance is hard.

13:43That hurts. I'm curious. But again, I don't know if someone had a had a big issue or were you following that? To be fair, to be fair, there were legitimate personal circumstances for some of the members. Congressman Luke Correa couldn't travel because of a medical procedure. Congressman Stephen Horsford's office said personal emergency. So listen, I'm not here to go, oh, disregard medical advice, disregard medical emergencies. But 11 people absent on a vote that's this consequential is an organizational failure to some degree. And Democratic Congresswoman Sidney Campbell's or Dove was absolutely furious. Well, what happened out there with Hanks as with Democrats having intended decisions again?

14:24You know, I have to say this. Pathetic Pete should have been impeached a long time ago. This is a dude who is wholly unqualified and really undignified to be in this seat. The man don't got no aim. He's probably on some gender-affirming care, which I support, okay? This is obviously a gender- gender fluid brother right now. But he spent over $100 million basically to rebrand the Department of Defense to Department of War. And here's the thing. And then he lost the war and he spent a whole bunch of money. And I have to tell you this. We knew that this vote was coming. So people should have gotten their raggedy selves up the steps to vote. There is no reason why we should have lost this vote because of attendance issues.

15:09This is what the people have been talking about. You man, you know, this man should not be in this position. That's why. All right. So, of course, once Democrats take over, if Pete Hegseth hasn't been fired, this is going to come up again and they may well impeach him. But there is a question here about organization. If Pete Hegseth hasn't been fired, this is going to come up again and they may well impeach him. But there is a question here about organization and it's a question arguably for the Democratic leader, Hakeem Jeffries. Where's the coordination? Where was the vote count? Why wasn't there a plan to get every Democrat into the chamber? And Jeffrey says, listen, this is only the beginning.

15:38We're going to take control of Congress in January and we'll come back to this. And I think that that's completely legitimate. Defeating this procedural motion would not even have impeached Hegseth. It would have just kept the effort alive, maybe allowing the House to consider impeachment sometime over the next two months. I get that Republicans had seven members absent themselves. If all of those Republicans had shown up, the math could have changed again. I'm not naive to that, but none of it excuses excuses. Um, what happened here? And we've had months of Democrats telling voters how serious the Iran war is and how important it is to have accountability and how urgently the Trump administration needs

16:19to do, uh, needs to have oversight done on them. And they had an admittedly unexpected opportunity that came up to keep this impeachment effort going and enough of them didn't show up. That's what happened. And it came just a week basically after Democrats got these sweeping midterm victories. I don't think you can celebrate winning power and then fail to do the basic logistical work that is required to exercise that power. And again, they're not in power yet. I get it. It was an unexpected opportunity. But being there is a part of the job. And this is the sort of dysfunction that will drive Democratic voters crazy. They organize and they donate and they vote and they get a victory. And then they see a

17:05potentially winnable fight lost because people didn't make it to the Capitol. Again, this is the previous Congress. This is not the Congress that was just voted in. I get it. But we have to be ready as bigger opportunities are going to come in January. We don't want attendance to prevent the incoming Democratic Congress from doing this the next time. Democrats are about to get a lot more power and we need to make sure that Democrats are going to be capable of using it. If you can't get your members to show up for a vote on Hegseth, how are you going to hold Donald Trump accountable at the end of the day? Getting enough protein matters even if you're not a bodybuilder and on busy days, a shake can be an easy option. One of our sponsors is equip and it's prime protein powder can be a

17:55good way to add protein to your routine. Each serving provides 20 to 21 grams of protein. It is dairy free made with protein from grass fed beef and a short list of ingredients. No artificial flavors or fillers. Every batch is independently tested for contaminants. You can mix prime protein into a shake, add it to a smoothie or use it in overnight oats. There are familiar flavors like chocolate and vanilla plus options like cinnamon roll that gives you a few easy ways to work protein into whatever you're already eating. Go to equip foods.com slash Pacman or use the code Pacman at checkout to get 35% off your first subscription order. Paws or cancel your subscriptions at any time. Speaker 1 and Speaker 2.

18:58A lot of people carrying debt don't think to themselves, I'm in trouble. They're not necessarily behind on payments. They're working. They're kind of managing. But if you're carrying credit card balances, personal loans, collections, medical bills, the question is whether your current plan is getting you out fast enough or just kind of keeping you busy. That is what our sponsor, PDS debt can help you figure out. PDS debt gives you a free 30 second assessment. You can compare your current path with their customized debt relief options. They will look at your unsecured debt. They'll use financial data to personalize a solution that will work for you and show you what you might qualify for before you have to decide anything.

19:41The programs really are designed to just reduce what you owe, simplify multiple payments into one lower monthly payment and work towards being debt free. There's no minimum credit score. Savings start the day you complete the assessment. And PDS debt is top rated in the industry with thousands of five star reviews and an A plus rating by the Better Business Bureau. Lots of people in my audience use PDS debt. And we looked at the numbers for people coming just from my show. It turns out the average David Pakman show viewer who uses PDS debt saves an average of twenty four thousand nine hundred ninety four dollars. Get your free 30 second personalized assessment today at PDS debt dot com slash Pacman YT. The link is in the description.

20:36It's been a little over a week since Democrats pulled off this massive victory in Texas and Texas Democrats are already moving to legalize recreational cannabis. It would be this would not be a little expansion of medical marijuana. This would not be slightly reducing penalties for possession. We are talking about full recreational legalization with licensed dispensaries and home cultivation and a system for taxing cannabis sales. Now, if you went back a month and you told me, hey, on November 11th, Texas Democrats are going to be preparing to legalize cannabis. I would have said, yeah, I don't think no matter what the results are on November 3rd, I don't think that that's going to happen. But this is where we are.

21:27And on Monday, which is the first day that lawmakers were allowed to file legislation for twenty twenty seven, the Democratic state representatives Joe Moody and John Bucky introduced to almost identical bills. They're called the Texas Regulation of Cannabis Act. They are comprehensive. Number one, adults 21 plus would be allowed to have up to two ounces of cannabis, including up to 15 grams of concentrate. Got it. Individuals would be allowed to grow as many as 12 plants at home for personal use. The state would create a regulated commercial market with licensed businesses growing, processing, testing, transporting, selling cannabis. So basically, Texas under the proposal would go in the direction

22:10of the systems that already exist in states like Colorado and Massachusetts. Now, here's another interesting part. This legislation includes a 20 percent retail cannabis tax on top of regular sales taxes, plus a separate 15 percent tax on transfers from producers to dispensaries. Where would that money go? Half would go to schools. Texas schools are a disaster. They need money. Half of this tax would go to schools. Twenty five percent would go to a assistance fund, 15 percent to drug treatment programs, and 10 percent to local governments. Now, there are questions about how high should taxes be on cannabis. If you put excessive taxes on it, it can make it difficult for the legal businesses to

23:01compete with the illegal market, which is kind of the whole point when we say let's regulate this thing and create oversight on the manufacturer and clear labeling and lab testing, all of that stuff. The whole point is, let's make that a better option in all ways than illegal purchases from the black market. So if you tax the legal purchases too aggressively, that won't pull enough people out of the black market. But OK, the concept is very straightforward, which is instead of spending money arresting people for having cannabis, Texas could just regulate the industry and say we're going to collect revenue from it and we are going to use the revenue to fix areas of this state that aren't working so well.

23:41And so I don't know if this is going to pass. This is where election results are really important because what Democrats did in Texas is so James Tallarico won as senator. He'll be representing Texas in Washington, D.C., but Democrats also won the governorship with our friend Gina Hosa, who defeated the longtime Republican governor, Greg Abbott. They also defeated the Republican lieutenant governor, Dan Patrick, with Vicky Goodwin. They took control of the state house for the first time in more than two decades. And I think that the defeat of Dan Patrick in Texas is a huge deal because if you look at recent years, who was the most aggressive opponent of THC legal in Texas? It was Dan Patrick and he championed these efforts to ban all of it.

24:38He had major influence over what would move through the state Senate and his replacement, Vicky Goodwin, proposed let's use the revenue from legal cannabis to fund a state administered health insurance option. That's a great idea. And after the election, she said lawmakers should look at expanding medical marijuana or just legalize cannabis altogether. So this is like a 180 in the conversation happening in Texas. And also, by the way, Texans have been making it clear to pollsters they support legal recreational marijuana for adults. They support decriminalization at an even higher rate. They support expanding medical marijuana at an even higher rate. So it's not like, oh, you've got some Democrats on Sixth Street in Austin who want this.

25:27There is widespread support for this. Now there is going to be even more legislation coming. Democratic Senator Carol Alvarado has a separate legalization bill which would allow possession up to two and a half ounces. It has a different approach to how you would tax and regulate. You also have Representative Mahala Plessa, who has legislation to expand medical access. Now am I here to tell you Texas is about to get legal cannabis? No, not necessarily. There are obstacles. Republicans still have control of the state Senate. And even though Democrats won the lieutenant governorship and the governorship, you still have Republican senators that could block legalization or just try to try to limit it.

26:10So we have bills that have been filed. They haven't been passed. But what is super interesting is the timing here, because, again, much like with the Hegseth thing yesterday in the House, we've had an election. But these new Democratic officials haven't been sworn in yet. It doesn't. The next legislative session in Texas doesn't start until January 12 and you've got lawmakers putting proposals on the table that would have been much more difficult to advance under the previous leadership. Now the next question is, are Democrats going to turn these proposals into legislation that really can get through both chambers, including the still Republican controlled state Senate? Because the election changed who's going to be in charge of the governor's office, the

26:54lieutenant governor's office and the house. But they still have the state Senate. There are still obstacles. But I love that there it's like a nude. It's a new day. It's morning in Texas. And there is a debate now over whether cannabis should be treated primarily as a criminal justice issue or whether you regulate it as a legal adult product. And we are eight days after the election. And that debate is already happening, which I think is phenomenal news. Now, no matter what happens, it is very clear that this election has completely changed what people believe to be possible. And sometimes, you know, the voting is important. The campaigns are important. Filing bills, all of it is important, but also an attitudinal adjustment of we never used to think certain things were

27:46possible. Now we believe that these things are possible. That's not nothing that's important because it creates new activists. It inspires people. It generates passion and getting involved. And we shouldn't ignore that effect of the election results as well. Republicans are doing some wacky stuff, guys. They have selected their new leader in the House of Representatives. Remember that Mike Johnson is being fired as the Speaker of the House, and he said he also has no interest in being in leadership anymore. I quit. You can't fire me. I quit was Mike Johnson's message. One of the incredible things that is taking place is that Jim Jordan. Yes, Jim Jordan has been selected the new leader of Republicans. And one of the clips that started

28:35circulating is this one from a few months ago. This was earlier in the Iran war where he says, hey, you know what? Americans can live with higher gas prices. They can tolerate it. They're going to have to buck up and take it on the chin. They lost with this message. This was Trump's campaign message. It's peanuts. Gas prices are peanuts. I thought they'd go up even more. And the guy that they are appointing their leader after these brutal losses had that exact same talking point. Take a listen to what he previously said. American people have common sense and they understand to stop this regime that for 47 years has killed Americans, killed Israelis, killed others and killed a number of their own people. To stop them from getting a nuclear weapon is a

29:24worthwhile objective. And President Trump is committed to achieving that goal. And if that means prices go up for a short time, I think Americans understand we can live with that. Oh, yeah? Well, they voted you guys out. In the end, we want all that to happen, and we want it all to happen in as quick a time as it possibly can. So you say we should be willing to live with higher prices. Would you say to your constituents in Ohio that this is worth sending their sons and daughters to the Middle East, potentially to put their lives on the line to achieve what you just laid out? Do we want this regime and all they have done, the killing of American servicemen over the last 47 years, the killing of Israelis, the killing of others, the taking of thousands of lives of their own,

30:11do we want them to have a nuclear weapon? I mean, I think the Americans say that is something we need to stop. President Trump, you can go listen to what us. Stop with boots on the ground, with American boots on the ground in Iran to stop it? We need, again, no one's talking about that. What they're talking about is reaching the objective of making sure this regime doesn't get nuclear capability. I would say this. Right, but how far would you go to achieve that objective? How far would you go? President Trump makes decisions that are in the best interest of our country. President Trump does what he said he would do. He told the American people- If you're nauseated, I understand. He secured the border, he did. He told him he cut taxes, he did. He told him that he wouldn't start any new wars. And he told the American people he If you're nauseated, I understand. Secure the border. He did. He told him he cut taxes. He did. He told the American people

30:47he'd make sure this regime didn't get nuclear capability. And he's making sure that is going to happen, that they do not get that capability in any way, shape or form, because that would be, as Senator Graham said, what I think would be devastating for the price of oil and for all kinds of other reasons. That would be a bad outcome. So you talked a little bit there about what the president said. Speaker 3 All right. So listen, they just lost because Trump and Trump ism were rejected by voters and they put up as their new leader, one of the most aggressive defenders of everything Trump does and says. And they just lost after Americans came to believe these people don't really care about what this is costing us.

31:32And they put up a guy who said just months ago, I don't really care what this is costing Americans. They can tolerate higher gas prices. Boy, oh boy. Now, Jim Jordan defeated Steve Scalise in a secret ballot 106 to 73. He will be the House Republican minority leader when Democrats take control in January. Now remember, Jordan has sort of a history with trying to be in leadership. He tried to become the speaker back in 2023 when Kevin McCarthy was removed, couldn't get enough Republican support. They settled on Mike Johnson. Well, Johnson's leaving. Republicans have lost their majority. So Jordan finally gets his leadership leadership job. And where it gets interesting is that almost immediately after Republicans

32:15selected him, that clip I just played for you starts circulating from earlier this year on CNN. And he insists Americans simply can live with higher prices. Very reassuring, right? And that is the sort of context of this. Now, people can debate the foreign policy argument. Iran should never or will never have a nuclear weapon. All right. Talk about that. Iran does threaten countries. I don't want Iran to have a nuclear weapon. But was it in the best interest of the U.S. for Trump to launch this harebrained war, which, by the way, is in its ninth month and it was supposed to last two to three weeks? Now, what's interesting is the contrast between that message and everything Republicans spent

32:55years saying about the economy under Joe Biden. Because remember, under Biden, even though gas prices were mostly lower, there were complaints about gas prices. Biden did this. Biden did that. Look at what you're paying at the pump. Biden did this. Biden did that. Look at what you're paying at the pump. Look at groceries. And Jim Jordan himself was posting about gasoline costing more than five bucks a gallon back in 2022. In 2023, Jim Jordan was going gas prices are up 60 cents. Groceries are expensive. Housing is expensive. And he called it by dynamics. But it seems that when Biden was president, high gas prices were evidence of catastrophic leadership. When Trump is president, it's a patriotic and acceptable price to pay that Americans can very much live with. And now the guy

33:38who made that argument is the person Republicans have said we want him to lead us over the next couple of years. And it is particularly interesting because this was the issue in midterm elections. The reason they lost was frustration with the cost of living the Iran war and what it did to cost of living. And they lost dozens of House seats and they go, hey, you know what? Let's elect Jim Jordan instead of a change in direction, instead of somebody who's been distancing himself from Trump and Trump's decision. Let's put in the same Jim Jordan who has never found anything Trump did worthy of criticism. And let's see how that does for us now. To be fair, why? I try to be fair. Why? Why? But I try to be fair. Jordan does have a reason

34:26for wanting this job, which is that with Democrats planning, planning with Democrats going to control the House and planning investigations into Trump and the administration and all of it. Jim Jordan has chaired the Judiciary Committee and he promoted his experience fighting Democrats during oversight battles. He was like, pick me because I know how to fight Democrats when Democrats try to do oversight. So you you and I might look at it and go, they elected the guy who represents everything that lost this for them. Well, he also is a guy who at least claims experience beating back and beating off. Oh, boy. Investigations and oversight from Democrats. So that may be the explanation doesn't really explain the economic part of it,

35:17which is when Republicans criticized high gas prices under Biden, they were worried supposedly about what Americans were paying, except when a different guy controls the White House and voters have to pay more for everything. Now they go. Those are acceptable costs that Americans can tolerate. The fact that Trump is president shouldn't really change that. Now, just one other point sort of worth considering. Jim Jordan is going to inherit a much smaller Republican conference because Democrats will control the House. Republicans aren't going to have the ability to dictate the legislative agenda like they did before the election. So the next two years are going to give Americans a chance to see what does the Republican Party

36:02offer from the minority? What what do they what do they make available? And one of the comments already following their new leader around is Americans can live with higher gas prices. I don't think the people paying the higher gas prices agree, but we will see. Let me know what you think. Leave a comment or send me an email to info at David Pakman dot com. The midterms may be over, but the work of defending secular government is not. No matter who wins any one race, the same constitutional questions remain. Should public schools promote religion? Should taxpayer dollars support religious instruction? Should government officials use public power to privilege one set of beliefs over others? The answer is no. Religious freedom only works

36:52when government stays neutral. That protects believers, nonbelievers and everyone in between. Our sponsor, the Freedom From Religion Foundation, works year round to keep state and church separate and to defend the rights of free thinkers, atheists, agnostics, humanists, and nonreligious Americans. Elections matter, but movements matter to visit FFRF dot us slash David or text my name, David, to five eleven five eleven to learn more or join. Go to FFRF dot US slash David or text David to five eleven five eleven. Now, if you care about secular democracy, join FFRF today. Text my name, David, to five eleven five eleven today. Text fees may apply. Ever make coffee, get distracted by something and realize your coffee is cold. It would happen to my partner all the time.

37:55Sometimes I'd be in the middle of making my beautiful cappuccinos, one for each of us in the morning, and she would have to go and bring our older daughter to daycare. She gets home and it's lukewarm and she's got to microwave it. No more. We now have an Ember mug, one of our sponsors, Ember. Our Ember mug keeps her coffee at the exact temperature she wants. It's 140 degrees, by the way. Each sip stays beautifully hot. And with the new Ember 3, I can adjust the temperature on the mug or through the app. Also comes with a sipping lid, which will retain heat, extend battery life to over three hours, and it is all dishwasher safe. What I like the most about the Ember mug is if you get sidetracked doing something,

38:46you go back to your coffee and it is at the perfect temperature. No rushing through it. No reheating it. I highly recommend that I'm going to be giving these out as gifts because they are perfect. They've got great deals at Ember dot com slash Pacman. Let them know who sent you. The link is in the description. Today I'll be speaking with Sarah Longwell. Sarah Longwell is a political strategist and publisher of The Bulwark, also author of the book How to Eat an Elephant One Voter at a Time. Sarah, good to see you. Thanks for your time. Hey, man, it's great to be here. How are you? I'm I'm you know, I'm good. It's a very interesting time because we had these election results last week. It is not yet the period where the new Congress has been sworn in.

39:33We already had, you know, the Hegseth impeachment situation yesterday and a letter threatening Democrats that their oversight, if they go too far, may be criminal. I was reading about that today. What do you know? You've done focus groups. You've talked to voters and sort of attempted to understand their motivations. Can we really chalk up these election results to voters basically see these first two years of the second Trump term as a screw up and they've decided to punish Republicans for that. Like, is it is that the core of what we saw? Hundred percent. Yeah, they they blame Trump. And listen, I've been doing focus groups sort of like a maniac since the election, just and really talking to Republican voters, Trump voters who voted for Democrats in the midterms,

40:23because I want to know why. And look, I was obviously doing focus groups the whole time going into the election. So I heard people say over and over again how upset they were about prices, how upset they were about the war in Iran, how upset they were about Trump breaking his promises. There's a lot of that. There's a lot of I was told he was going to lower prices. I was told he was going to end the war, not start wars. I was told he was going to be transparent or at least the Epstein files. I was told he was going to drain the war, not start wars. I was told he was going to be transparent, or at least the Epstein files. I was told he was going to drain the swamp, and instead he's super corrupt. Like, the voters that I'm talking to now who voted for Democrats, basically a lot of them

40:53are saying, I wanted a check on this shit show. And that is a quote. Like, the shit show part is a quote. There's just a lot of people who are like, it has been awful. The economy's been terrible. I wanted a check. And many of them, especially since these are people who voted for Trump in the past, you know, they're skeptical that Democrats are going to do things that they like affirmatively. But right now they are happy with the idea that Democrats could slow Trump down because they see Congress is not doing that. And I also think, though, they're just like whoever can do something about prices meaningfully. You know, there's a lot of people I've never even voted for a Democrat before, but it's gotten so bad that I'm giving them a chance.

41:37They deserve a chance now. What is the value qualitatively of a focus group where you speak to a small number of people in a country of three hundred and forty million? One might reasonably think you need a proper poll with twelve hundred people adjusted for the sample to really glean anything big about what's going on rather than talking to 15 people qualitatively about their views. What is it about these focus groups that is valuable in terms of telling us what's happening in the country? Well, first of all, I'm not sure we need another poll. There's like there's other people can poll. There's plenty of pollsters and there's so many pollsters that now there's a whole, you know, a bunch of organizations that are forecasters

42:26that aggregate the polls. That stuff's taken care of. They will tell you the what. What is the number of Republicans who think Trump, who disapprove of Trump? Great. I want to answer the why. Why do they disapprove of Trump? When I do a focus ... also, first of all, just the scale at which I do focus groups is I think different than most people. You know, when you introduced me, you said consultant. And I guess for a long time, I was that. Now I will, now mostly I do podcast. I do the focus groups. I don't do them for clients. I do them because I believe that focus groups. I don't do them for clients. I do them because I believe that people should hear the voices of Americans and how they sound and what they care about.

43:13And so I started doing focus groups because I was thinking about a specific thing. I was thinking about how do we primary Trump in the early days of Trump being elected and me thinking about how do we save the Republican Party? I mean, the evolution over the 10 years was, number one, listening to voters and focus groups was how I learned that actually they did want Trump and that saving the Republican Party increasingly looked like something that couldn't be done because voters wanted they didn't want the Republican Party of Mitt Romney or John McCain. They just didn't. And then more to the point, after January 6th, I became very clear that this was not a party to salvage. There was like, this thing had to be burned to the ground.

43:58And then over time, perhaps something healthier can emerge from the ashes of that. But that's going to be like a generational project. But so the reason that I do focus groups is one, I found them so helpful to me to understand what was going on in the country. And I feel like the whole punditry sort of world sits around and debates with each other without listening to the people who are ultimately going to make those decisions. And it's not even that, like, I still hold Sarah Longwell's opinions and like policy preferences, but the majority of the time I'm actually thinking in terms of, man, it is so clear to me what voters want on this. Voters are being so, and so I do multiple focus groups a week and also like different kinds of voters when

44:45somebody says voters think this i'm always like well some voters do you can say some voters believe basically anything some voters believe that the earth is flat um but what are the majority of voters think and what are the through lines in their narratives what are the ways that human beings in america talk about things that lead you to understand what they might want in terms of policies. And that's why so many of the conversations we have, I'm always like, that's like a little bit true. Like when people say voters don't care about policy, I'll be like, well, kind of. It's that they don't maybe care about the actual bespoke policies. So take New York and Momdani. It's not that they're not like, oh, he didn't make all the grocery stores, you know, government run. Nobody cares that he didn't

45:31do that. But what they cared about, they did care that he was somebody who had a bunch of ideas that directionally were about affordability and being able to afford living in New York City. So they care about the policy of being able to afford to live in New York City and a bunch of the policies underlying that. But the individual like what would it actually happens? They're less invested in. You mentioned what Sarah Longwell thinks and policy preferences and this sort of thing. Where are you politically right now? Because, you know, I think in one sense I see the events you do and you know, it's you, Tim and JVL and Pete Buttigieg is there and clearly you're on the pro democracy side loosely, I would say.

46:14But like I've spoken to Sarah Matthews about this as well. Like would your are you a Republican still in your in your preferences? Would you like the 2028 presidential election to result in a Republican that you like being the next president? I know you've talked about John Ossoff. Like, have your politics changed at this point? And I'll also add, you know, I've seen a couple of these articles that are kind of like the bulwark are wolves in sheep's clothing. And you got to remember that these are at the core Republicans at the, you know, I'm sure you've seen those articles as well. Like where are your politics right now? Yeah. I mean, first of all, I would describe myself as a liberal, meaning somebody who believes in liberal democracy. And so you want to call me a lib

46:57as everybody on the right now does. I mean, it is funny to be us sometimes because if you're on Twitter or you just like follow the discourse, Republicans think we are downright DSA socialists and the DSA socialists think we are conservative Republicans. And so at some point you're like, actually, guys, I'm kind of a normie lib. I I've almost become burnt out on ideological commit, like like being a super ideologue, in part because, look, I came up through the conservative world, and there's a lot of things that I still think are true that I believed before. I believe that the national debt is an existential threat to America and our ability to do big things and invest in our country. I think the amount of interest we're paying on the debt is a huge problem. That was like one of the things that

47:50animated me as a conservative to be to be sort of a budget and deficit hawk. I'm still that person. I think that an America at its best, which is not us at the moment, should play a role in the world, in making the world safer. That doesn't mean nation building, it doesn't have to mean, you know, for adventurism abroad in terms of wars, but the idea that we are stalwarts for democracy and want to see democracy thrive around the globe, don't want to see people invading each other, like want to be a good guy, not a cop, but a good guy on the world stage is still something that I believe. I believe in pluralism as, and I've always been, I'm a big believer in immigration. So it's actually, this is funny. I actually preach, the voters want a closed border. The voters,

48:44a hundred percent. And I don't just mean Republican voters. I mean, the voters want a closed border. The voters, 100%. And I don't just mean Republican voters. I mean independent voters. I mean a lot of center-left voters. I believe that as a practical matter. But I think we should, we are a country, our entire existence is based on people coming here because they want to be an American. I believe an American can be born anywhere. And if you have freedom in your heart and you want the American experience, there should be a way that is relatively easy for you to come here and build a life. Like I find blood and soil nationalism, which has overtaken the Republican Party, to be not just sort of like a virus, but also a complete and total misunderstanding of what the American experiment is all about.

49:26And so my politics, I think, has always been sort of norm. It was always normie center right and has moved to a kind of normie center left. If you had to put me on a policy scale, but I was always pro-choice, but in a safe, legal, and rare kind of way, not as a form of birth control. Like, I don't know. We could go through the issues. I grew up in central Pennsylvania, and so I'm very comfortable around hunting and guns. Yeah. At the same time, I think that these, like, high-capacity magazines and that, like, that you can just walk into a Walmart and get them is pretty insane. So, like, I actually think I embody a kind of people talk about corporate centrism. And I'm like, actually, what I think I am is a pretty close to the way a lot of average Americans think about politics,

50:16which is I think that people who need a hand up should be able to get it. At the same time, I don't think that the American government should be subsidizing everything for everybody. But I also believe in a really strong public education system because I think that's to the national good. I think that's one of the things that our government should be very focused on, providing all Americans at an exceptional level of quality. I think that we should have a social safety net around health care. But if we're going to offer a social safety net around health care, we also have to be we're going to have to be judicious about who comes into the country and gets access to that. And what like I don't know, I feel like I'm a pretty normie lip.

50:54Speaker 1 One of the things you didn't mention there, and I wonder whether it rates for you, but also for some of the people you talk to that seems to have moved the line for a lot of maybe center right voters is there was a long period of time where the Republican Party would clearly identify that these authoritarians, autocrats and dictators around the world are to be opposed. In other words, they are not our friends. And all of a sudden now and I actually spoke with President Biden about this recently. All of a sudden now you've got Trump kind of paying lip service to the authoritarians. He's impressed with Putin. He's impressed with she's 100 percent conviction rate on drug cases and all of this sort of stuff.

51:34And it seems that for folks maybe where you grew up on the political spectrum, that has had a role or played a role in shifting your view? Well, I mean, it's one of the reasons that I've rejected Trump from the jump. Like one of the reasons I wasn't on board with him like 2015, 2016. And I was like, we've got to fight this with everything we have is I was like, this guy both admires dictators and wants to be one himself. And that was very clear. So it's very clear to me he didn't love America. And I do think that our leaders should love America and want America to be a best version of itself. And that is not what he represented. But when I said, I think America should be a good guy in the world, this is what I mean.

52:18We don't buddy up with dictators. We don't take the side of Xi and Putin and Kim Jong-un. Like, we recognize maybe that sometimes that we have to deal with them as world leaders, but we treat them, I think, with the correct level of either, if not outright adversarial, at least with a healthy skepticism that is very clear about the fact that their values and our values are not the same and in fact are often in conflict which doesn't mean we have to be in a hot war with them but it does mean that we should be clearly articulating what our values are which trump does not do and at its core this is why when some people are like oh trump's just about mean tweets i'm like well you don't understand anything about what he has actually done to the values of this country

53:05that were the ones that I held most dear. And I'll just say one other thing on like the people who are like, oh, the bulwark, this or that, like the Republicans. It's sort of like, who cares? I see people who say things like, you don't get to be in this party or that party. I'm like, there's no party police, guys. Like, there's just microphones and people and audiences and communities, and we're all talking. And this has been America as long as America's been around. And there's no gatekeepers here. If people have an interest, and we do as Americans, of how we would like to see the country evolve. And we put ourselves on the stage to say, this is what I think should happen. Or even for me now, it's a lot of here's what I feel.

53:56Here's what I hear from voters about what they want to happen. And what are the ways in which American politics can evolve to sort of help people better because we are failing people. And it is leading us into flirting with and occasionally veering into a kind of populist authoritarianism. And so, like, I want to solve that by hearing what voters are saying so that we can improve their lives so that they don't feel like they have to reach for some of these things that are sort of really detrimental to who America is. What's your sense of the role that the anti-corruption story might play in this, especially looking to 2028? And I'll kind of couch it in this sense. There are a lot of folks arguing that an anti-corruption sort of platform would be more than anything else. The way that Democrats can get center right leaning independents and maybe even some Republicans

54:50to join them by making really clear, like, we're going to deal with the corruption. And then there's another view, which is, yeah, that might work if you can really tightly link the corruption to how people's lives day to day are being affected. But broadly and philosophically, corruption is still a little bit distant from the day to day concerns of voters. What's your sense of that? My sense is that the thing with voters is that they think both sides are corrupt. And Trump has done it at such a scale, though, that it's sort of shaken people out of their both sides ism. And to be like, this is horrible. It's also the contrast is really important for voters. Trump is making all of his friends rich while I get poorer. A lot of it's too about like, what is Trump focused on?

55:33What is he not focused on? Who is benefiting from Trump? Like, hey, you were supposed to help us. The promise of America first was you were going to have your eyes on the American people. You don't. It's your rich buddies. It's the tech bros. It's the data center guys who are like in our communities now. Like that's a big part of what is happening for voters. I do think we should do something about corruption because just doing something about corruption is good on its face. We should not live in a banana republic patronage country. That is, again, anathema to who we are as Americans. I do think one of the ways that Democrats can square the circle overall is to wins in the senate and the house

56:26mean that republicans are going to have to chip away at those majorities that you know now they are not just something that one cycle can likely correct and so uh and also you know there's a lot of fears on the republican side that donald trump will now be an albatross around any candidate's neck um going forward and the democrats have this new crop of exciting sort of young candidates. And so if Democrats are about to be ascendant, Republicans are like, ooh, now might be a good time for us to rein in corruption, executive overreach, executive power. And so Democrats have an opportunity by saying we're going to root out corruption across both parties. Like, it can't look retributive. It can't look like

57:05vengeance. It has to be, our country has gotten too corrupt. Some of Trump's messaging around that was correct. He just was using it as a way for him to be more corrupt. But like, we're going to address it sincerely and we're going to do span stock trading. Stock trading is funny, isn't actually like the most important thing, but it's one that's landed with voters. And so do that. Do the things that try to make our government less of a revolving door. Like, let's just do those things. Sarah, last thing I want to ask you about, you said Trump is done as kingmaker, especially as we think to 2028. Who has the possibility of becoming the next Republican kingmaker? Or is it not really a role that in an open primary like the one that is going

57:54to be coming up for both parties you necessarily need? So here's what's happening right now. Right now, J.D. Vance and Tucker Carlson and Don Jr. are trying to form a triumvirate of evil, in my opinion, and figure out how they can take their ill-gotten gains and their access to the presidency right now. They are starting to, including Don Jr. People, I think, think Don Jr. wouldn't do this. And then I would like to just remind you guys, this is like the Trump family. These are not people who are bound by love and loyalty. He's looking for a way to be a player in the future. And they're all together. And they do have sort of a vision, a like real America first has never been tried. We will have to throw old man Trump under the

58:42bus to do this. But they are trying to grab the mantle right now. And that is the both blood and soil nationalism wing of the party. It is the America alone on the world stage. But like that's why J.D. Vance is saying they want to cut off aid to Israel. They want to, you know, end the war in Iran because that that's the part of the base they are trying to consolidate. And they would like to make the party reflect that. So I think they want to be the future. And that America first wing, and that would include sort of a Marjorie Taylor Greene, too, is going to be in some battle with what I call the MAGA establishment, which is your Marco Rubio's, your Ron DeSantis, people who've basically, you know, they've made their peace with Trump.

59:29And now but they they have a little bit of fusion with some of the old Republican Party values, although to me, frankly, it's not the ones that were the most. The most not the ones that drew me to the Republican Party. Yeah, I mean, look, the reason I wrote the book, just to end on that, is because I do think there is a generate, Donald Trump has so hollowed out the Republican Party. It is such a cult of personality that there's not an obvious person to take the mantle, which means that Democrats, I think now have an historic opportunity to do a root and branch operation on MAGA in which they like burn it to the ground and salt the earth with its ashes. And it is forced to reconstitute in some way.

1:00:15I'm not bullish, though, on its prospects for the thing that emerges being a healthy political party. I think it is going to be more of this blood and soil nationalism. I think it's going to take some of the worst elements of Trumpism and fuse it together with this populist. Well, it's going to be this populist authoritarianism, blood and soil nationalism stuff just without Trump's. I don't want to call it charisma, but like without. No, but it is a sort of charisma that appeals to some people. Yeah. So that's where I think it's all headed. But I think the Democrats look, I don't know about you, man, but I smell hope and opportunity. And I want America like for me. And this is again, I'm just going to go back to the question you asked about the bulwark and the the left I think our our political projects are are fundamentally different and I think it

1:01:11leads us to not being uh we are like overlapping allies at times um and but perhaps not but I'm not sure we have a shared political project. Like their shared political project is driven by their feelings on a lot of different kinds of policies. Mine are about can liberal democracy, can American liberal democracy survive and also have a renaissance and a reemergence after we watched our institutions and norms and values get tested and be found wanting in a lot of ways. Right. I don't want to go back to anything, but I think the question is, if Trump's going to burn it all down, what are we going to build? What does an America look like that is still committed to pluralism and the rule of law? Like, those are what I'm focused on. And

1:02:02so it just doesn't always leave us focused on the same things. Speaker 1 Well, we are going to be watching it together, that's for sure. And we've been speaking to Sarah Longwell, publisher of The Bulwark. The book is How to Eat an Elephant One Voter at a Time, a book that pushed my book down one slot on The New York Times list. I must say, very nasty. Speaker 1 Sorry, your book is great, man. Everybody should go get your book. Speaker 2 Thank you. I appreciate it. And your book is phenomenal. Also, really good to talk to you. I know you're busy. Really appreciate your time. Speaker 1 Oh, thanks, man. Great talking to you. Speaker 1 The David Pakman Show is an audience supported program, and the best, most direct

1:02:40way to support the show is by becoming a member at join Pacman dot com. You'll get the daily bonus show, the daily commercial free show and plenty of other great membership perks. Get the full experience by signing up at join Pacman dot com. All right. This you have to see. Look at how pathetic this is. Remember when Trump sued CBS News because 60 Minutes edited an interview with Kamala Harris and he claimed, you know, they edited her answers in a way to make her look better, which is a form of election interference. Therefore, you owe me billions of dollars and even suggested, oh, CBS should lose its broadcast license. Well, you're going to love this. 60 minutes just aired that Donald Trump interview Sunday night. We covered it on Monday and it turns out that now that we're

1:03:30able to compare what aired to the full recording CBS and 60 minutes heavily edited it. They removed a whole bunch of Trump's rambling Trump's claims that the election was rigged. They removed all of it and it makes Trump look a lot less crazy even though he still looked nuts in the interview. And now Donald Trump is not threatening to sue CBS. On Sunday, the interview was conducted by Ross doubt that I'm taking another stab at the pronunciation. He's the conservative New York Times columnist. He joined CBS under Barry Weiss. The segment on TV was about 27 minutes that included narration that included transitions. So in reality, there was even less than 27 minutes of Trump talking. The interview as recorded was about 52 minutes, so roughly half of it was removed. Now, before

1:04:24anybody says editing interviews is inherently dishonest. Of course it's not. There are shows that are edited and shows that are not everybody. You know, many shows edit interviews. TV shows have time constraints. You can remove repetition, tangent stuff that's not relevant. That's normal. And in fact, that's what CBS is defense was when Trump sued them over the Kamala Harris interview. They said, we edit interviews. That's what we do. And it's true. 60 minutes is a show that edits interviews. If you go on CNN and do a 10 minute interview, it's live and it's not cut. If it's a live interview, everybody knows 60 minutes is edited, but let's look at what CBS removed from Trump's interview. Now this is going to be, I'm going to try to explain what we're

1:05:02going to see here. This is a really good edit, uh, from Juliet Jeske, our friend over at decoding Fox news. This is going to be tough if you're only listening. So I'm going to explain what's going on. What Juliet did is she took the full interview and what you're going to see in color is what was part of the broadcast edit. And when the interview switches to black and white, that is the stuff that was removed. Now, I am aware of the fact that for those who are just listening today, it won't be obvious. So I'll kind of fill in some of the elements here. OK, so let's take a look at this. We are starting in full color with what was on the broadcast. And then you will see in black and white what was removed. You came into office promising to make peace in Ukraine. Yeah,

1:05:50there is still a war going on. What's the biggest obstacle to peace? It was the hatred between Zelensky and Putin. OK, so that was part of the broadcast. What was the obstacle? It was the hatred between Zelensky and Putin. You're now going to hear what was part of the recording and was not in the broadcast, which they later put up online. I believe that we're very close to making a deal. And I think it two things. If I were president, because as you know, well, you're not going to admit it. The it was rigged. So Trump said there the two things are and that was part of the broadcast. But then he switches into now it's black and white. This was cut. It was rigged. You're not going to admit it, but it was rigged.

1:06:36This is something that makes Trump look really stupid. The whole it was rigged. Most of the country doesn't believe that anymore. Republicans did for a while. They are making Trump look less unhinged and more coherent by removing that. All right, let's just look at it a little bit more. That's why I did it a third time, because it was rigged. That was my ultimate goal. If I had been president, that war would have never started, zero chance. But it did start, so I inherited that war. I believe we're very close to making it. Who do you trust more, President Putin or President Zelensky? Well, I'd rather not say, but I get along with both. And in fact, we have a meeting. OK, so this entire we have a meeting thing was removed from the broadcast. We have

1:07:15a meeting. This show will air and the meeting will have taken place. It's going to be on Saturday, but it's going to extend to Sunday and to Monday and to Tuesday. And there's a, so you'll be seeing it. Uh, there's a very important meeting taking place. I believe all of that was removed. The entire thing about this, another meeting was totally removed. Even that that war is going to end and it's going to end soon. And the only reason it's going to end is because of me. There's tremendous hatred between president. It's difficult because we have an audio audience, so I'm not going to keep doing this. But Juliet Jeske from Decoding Fox News has a great three minute clip where you can go back and forth and you can judge with the removed content.

1:07:54Does that help Trump or hurt Trump? I think it's obvious that Trump seems a lot more together with the stuff that they removed. I mean, after all, he was asked about Ukraine and he ends up talking about the rigged 2020 election. If you only watch the TV broadcast, you didn't hear Trump go off into a tangent about a rigged election because Trump removed it. They also shortened another exchange where Trump was talking about supplying Ukraine with weapons and he made wacky claims about Barack Obama and they removed that. What they broadcast on TV was this tight answer that makes it seem as though Trump is staying on topic when he isn't. And this happened throughout the interview. Now let's be precise here.

1:08:36I don't know why CBS made every individual edit. Some of these edits may have been requested by the Trump team. We don't know what oversight the Trump team was given. They may have said, remove the thing about the weekend meeting because we're not being public about that or something, right? Like you'd have to look at each one of these things. 60 minutes shortens interviews. And to say that they were deliberately protecting Trump. Well, I don't know. But the effect of these edits is Trump doesn't seem like he's rambling as much. Trump doesn't seem like he's lying as much. Trump seems more like he's responding to the question rather than ranting in tangents. So that brings us back to the Kamala Harris interview from October of 2024.

1:09:26Back in October of 2024, CBS aired different portions of Kamala Harris's response to a question about Benjamin Netanyahu and the the questions that the questions were from a Face the Nation preview and then the subsequent 60 Minutes broadcast. And Trump lost it. And he said, CBS edited it deceptively to help her and hurt me. It's election interference. I'm suing for 10 billion dollars. Take away CBS broadcast license. And CBS said, listen, we edit for clarity and time. We do that for everybody. We use different portions of the same answer, which is something that is what they do. But Trump didn't accept it. And then in July of twenty twenty five, Paramount agreed to settle the lawsuit and they said, we'll give you 16 million dollars.

1:10:17And they allocated it towards Trump's presidential library into legal costs. They didn't admit any wrongdoing. They didn't make an apology. But the implications were, I mean, listen, Paramount at the time, remember, was looking for federal approval to merge with Skydance. And that merger eventually went through and David Ellison took control. And Barry Weiss was installed as the editor in chief of CBS News. And now we see a Trump interview where they did all of the same stuff, extensive editing, just like CBS edited Kamala Harris's interview. And there's kind of an irony here because as part of the settlement, Paramount agreed to release transcripts of future presidential candidate interviews, with some exceptions.

1:11:05And to CBS credit, they published the extended Trump interview on YouTube. It wasn't hidden. You could go on and you could compare what was the edited version and the non edited version. But we now see, damn, Trump really benefited from the edit. It makes him look less like a lunatic conspiracy theorist. It makes him look less like a lunatic conspiracy theorist. It makes them look more coherent. So if editing an interview is election interference, when CBS does it to Kamala Harris, what is it when they do it to Trump's interview? And if just removing parts of a lengthy answer is an acceptable reason for a multibillion dollar lawsuit, why isn't Trump furious now? Well, the objection wasn't ever really about editing. Trump never established CBS fabricated Kamala Harris's

1:11:51answers. He just didn't like the way they were presented. And now his own answers are being shortened and they're rearranged and they're being cleaned up and it is no longer scandalous. It's now acceptable. Funny how that works, isn't it? Well, I'm not very surprised. I want to show you three women. And I want you to tell me whether you notice anything they have in common. This is not typically what this show is about, but let's take a look. First, it's Caroline Leavitt, Donald Trump's former White House press secretary. Second, it's Katie Zachariah, who replaced Caroline Leavitt and lasted five days. And third, it is Caroline Sunshine who is now reportedly being considered to replace Katie Zachariah and be the next White House press secretary.

1:12:34Do you see a trend here? Listen, three blonde camera ready right wing women with similar hairstyles, similar TV appearances, and I guess the same kind of general idea of what a Trump White House press secretary is supposed to look like. Now, there's nothing wrong with that on its face, but you kind of start to wonder whether Trump is running presidential communications or kind of like casting a reality show. And the latest candidate, Caroline Sunshine, actually comes from the entertainment industry. She is a former Disney Channel actress who played Tinka Hesse and Heffer on the show Shake It Up, which aired in the early 2010s. She moved into Republican politics, worked in the first Trump administration, was deputy comms director for Trump's 2024 campaign. The story of how she might end up with

1:13:32the White House press secretary job is wacky. There are reports that Trump appointed housing official Bill Pulte brought up Caroline Sunshine during a dinner at Mar-a-Lago over the weekend. And Pulte reportedly said, hey, you know, she might be a good press secretary. And Trump's response, according to the report, was she does a really good job on TV, but sometimes she says bad things about me, although she's getting better lately. And Stephen Miller, Trump's new chief of staff, reportedly agrees that Sunshine has been doing really well on TV. So notice whether, uh, notice, notice what they're discussing. It's not the, she understand policy. Can she answer difficult questions? Is a, uh, she well positioned to communicate transparently with the American people.

1:14:20It's, is she good on TV? Has she been saying nice about Trump? Now there's another interesting part of this. Caroline Sunshine went on Fox News with Jesse Watters last week and she demanded that Susie Wiles resign after the Republican disaster. And then Wiles actually resigned and she was replaced ultimately by Stephen Miller, which is suggestive of the idea that maybe she is already having influence on Donald Trump. And that would be an extraordinary thing because Donald Trump loves taking direction from random people on TV. Sunshine also criticized the administration's messaging and its approach to the Iran war. So she's been sort of willing to criticize the White House at some points in time.

1:15:10But the real issue that is being brought up as a concern is during the 2024 campaign, she supposedly had emotional outbursts and would spend her periods of time kind of isolated or locked in her office. And, you know, these are anonymous allegations. They have not been addressed, but it would suggest maybe she is not the right, uh, doesn't have the right personality to do this job. Now remember how we got here. Caroline Leavitt was Trump's press secretary starting at the beginning of the second term, youngest person ever to hold the job. Briefings were basically defend Trump no matter what he said, no matter what he did. She left in August of twenty twenty six. Totally legit, says she wants

1:15:50to spend more time with her young children. She joined Fox News. Fine. Trump then picks Katie Zachariah, right wing TV commentator, briefly worked for Trump media, briefly worked for DHS. Her first briefing was 14 minutes long. She took questions from only three reporters, struggled to read. Reporters said, have you actually worked as a lawyer before? And it all got really, really weird. And ultimately she was gone within five days. And now we're hearing about Caroline Sunshine, another at the end of the day, blonde, conservative TV personality, this time with a Disney Channel acting background. Now, she hasn't gotten the job yet. Trump offered it to UFC executive Dana White and Dana White didn't want it.

1:16:31And, you know, the pattern here is fascinating because Trump built an administration where performance and appearance and loyalty are what matter. That's what really the hiring process has become. It's like a casting call. And apparently the most important question is, does Trump like what he sees on TV and nothing else really seems to matter? So we will see whether she gets the job. But boy, oh boy, does Trump have a type on today's bonus show. Nvidia and Jensen Huang are facing a lawsuit over the spy affair. Russell Brand sentenced to over 10 years in prison for rape and sexual assault. And a lot of his rightwing defenders don't buy it. And the Kennedy family is suing to block Trump's arch.

1:17:31What is the basis of the lawsuit? I will tell you on the bonus show. Sign up at joinpacman.com. I will see you then. Starting a business can seem like a daunting task, unless you have a partner like Shopify. They have the tools you need to start and grow your business. From designing a website, to marketing, to selling and beyond, Shopify can help with everything you need. There's a reason millions of companies like Mattel, Heinz and Allbirds continue to trust and use them. With Shopify on your side, turn your big business idea into... Sign up for your $1 per month trial at shopify.com slash special offer. Big news! Wayfair's Black Friday sale is here. Early! Right now at Wayfair, get up to 70% off everything you need for the season ahead.

1:18:17Save on kitchen and dining, bedroom furniture and mattresses, holiday decor, and way more. Now is the time to score big, from seasonal finds to favorites you'll use all year long. Plus, with Wayfair, enjoy fast and easy shipping, with delivery in time for the holidays. Save up to 70% off early Black Friday deals. Shop now at Wayfair.com. Wayfair, every style, every home. When you spend enough time around great companies, you notice that the best ones treat trust as a growth strategy, not a box to check. Vanta helps companies build and prove trust from day one. Its agentic trust platform connects compliance, risk, and trust at enterprise scale. Vanta delivers a 526% return on investment over three years and pays for itself in just three months.

1:19:04Learn why over 16,000 of the fastest growing companies use Vanta at vanta.com.

▸More episode summaries

The David Pakman Show cover art
The David Pakman ShowRepublicans turn on each other as Trump's promises are dead2026-11-13 · 65 min
The David Pakman Show cover art
The David Pakman ShowVeterans Day disaster for administration as Republicans lose another race2026-11-12 · 70 min
The David Pakman Show cover art
The David Pakman ShowTrump waddles away when asked about being a LOSER2026-11-14 · 23 min
Transcribe your links. Paste a YouTube, Google Drive or podcast link and WhipScribe gives you the transcript. Transcribe a link →
New The David Pakman Show transcripts by email
One email per new episode, unsubscribe in every message. Not shared with the publisher.