The Daily Beast Podcast · · Transcript & summary by WhipScribe
An insider who worked closely with Pete Hegseth at the Pentagon describes the access, image and classified-information episodes firsthand.
Tap a chapter to play it from that moment in the show's own player; the transcript opens there too.
“I've never known a secretary of defense to install a makeup studio.” John Elliott · at 19:46 — ▶ hear it from here
“if you become a dead weight on him, a millstone around his neck” John Elliott · at 41:18 — ▶ hear it from here
John Elliott, a former Marine intelligence officer, was asked to set up Pete Hegseth's Pentagon communications operation when Hegseth became defense secretary. He describes a Senate confirmation process in which Hegseth met only Republican senators and brought his wife, Jennifer Hegseth, into closed-door sessions. Elliott also recalls that Jennifer grilled him for about 40 minutes before he was hired, and that Hegseth refused to meet Democrats on the committee, including Jack Reed.
The second thread is the press. Elliott says a close aide of Jennifer's asked for a makeup studio beside the briefing room, and he rejected the request three times, marking it disapproved on paper. After he left, the studio was installed anyway. He argues Hegseth has used that briefing room less than almost any secretary because he keeps reporters at a distance, and that credentialed reporters gave up their passes rather than sign a pledge against printing unapproved information.
The third thread is classified material and the Musk visit. Elliott says Hegseth, with little experience handling secrets, posted pre-strike details on Signal in a group that accidentally included Jeffrey Goldberg of The Atlantic. He also describes Hegseth bringing Elon Musk into the Pentagon's secure tank while the Joint Chiefs waited, which angered the president. Elliott's bottom line is that Hegseth should step down voluntarily, and that the president should never have appointed him.
John Elliott is a former Marine intelligence officer who was spokesman for the Senate Armed Services Committee. He later worked in the White House and at the Pentagon, and wrote the book The President Deserves Better.
John Elliott says Pete Hegseth brought his wife, Jennifer Hegseth, into closed-door meetings with Republican senators on the Armed Services Committee, which he says is never done. He also says Jennifer grilled him for about 35 to 40 minutes before he was hired to set up Hegseth's Pentagon press operation.
“she sat down and really grilled me for about 35, close to 40 minutes”John Elliott · 12:51
John Elliott says a close colleague of Jennifer Hegseth asked him to install a makeup studio beside the Pentagon briefing room, and he turned the request down three times. He says no earlier defense secretary had asked for one, and that the studio was installed after he left the department.
“I've never known a secretary of defense to install a makeup studio.”John Elliott · 19:46
John Elliott says Pete Hegseth had no experience handling classified information before becoming defense secretary, and that he posted pre-strike details of an operation against the Houthis on Signal. The details went into a group that accidentally included Jeffrey Goldberg of The Atlantic. Elliott says the inspector general found the material was secret and no-foreign.
“Here's 1545, F18s taken off over the tar HV”John Elliott · 34:25
John Elliott says Pete Hegseth brought Elon Musk, then head of DOGE, into the Pentagon's secure tank, where the Joint Chiefs make operational decisions. He says the Joint Chiefs waited in uniform for about 20 minutes before the meeting was called off, after President Trump reacted to a New York Times report of the visit.
“they brought Elon Musk up on that private elevator and reportedly kept the Joint Chiefs waiting for him to show up”John Elliott · 38:51
John Elliott says Pete Hegseth should step down voluntarily, and that the president should never have appointed him in the first place. He describes Hegseth as a performance art self-promoter whose image was built around being a warrior, despite having no clear strategy for implementing policy.
“He is, I would say, a performance art self-promoter.”John Elliott · 25:03
John Elliott argues that Pete Hegseth's time as defense secretary was driven by image rather than competence, and that Hegseth should step down voluntarily. He describes Hegseth's Senate confirmation meetings, the Pentagon makeup studio request, the Signal posts of pre-strike details and the Elon Musk visit to the Pentagon tank as evidence.
John Elliott says Pete Hegseth brought his wife, Jennifer Hegseth, into closed-door meetings with Republican senators on the Armed Services Committee, including Joni Ernst, which he says is never done. Elliott believes the presence made it harder for senators to ask pointed questions about reported infidelity and other allegations. He thinks Hegseth did not realise how bad it looked, and that Jennifer later stage-managed him closely, as she had at Fox News.
John Elliott says a close colleague of Jennifer Hegseth asked him to install a makeup studio beside the Pentagon briefing room, and he turned the request down three times. He says no earlier defense secretary had asked for one. After he left the department, the studio was installed. Elliott calls the idea contradictory to Hegseth's public message about lethality.
John Elliott says Pete Hegseth had no experience handling classified information before becoming secretary, and that he posted pre-strike details of an operation against the Houthis on Signal. The details were in a group that accidentally included Jeffrey Goldberg of The Atlantic. Elliott says the inspector general found the material was secret and no-foreign, and he notes the same administration is prosecuting John Bolton for emailing classified information.
John Elliott says Pete Hegseth brought Elon Musk, then head of DOGE, into the Pentagon's tank, the secure room where the Joint Chiefs make operational decisions. Elliott says the Joint Chiefs waited in uniform for about 20 minutes before the meeting was called off. He says Donald Trump was angry after Maggie Haberman of The New York Times reported the visit, and that Hegseth had to scramble to turn it off.
John Elliott says Pete Hegseth should step down voluntarily instead of waiting to be impeached, which he thinks Democrats would pursue after January 3rd. He argues the way out is for the president to ask for the resignation, framed as the secretary's own idea, as George W. Bush did after losing the midterms about 20 years ago. Elliott says the president is ultimately responsible for the appointment and should not have made it.
John Elliott wrote The President Deserves Better to describe his career in the Trump campaign, at the Veterans Affairs department, at the National Security Council and at the Pentagon. Two of the book's ten chapters concern Pete Hegseth. Elliott says the book passed clearance reviews at the NSC and Pentagon, which found no classified information, and that the title reflects his view that America as a whole deserves better.
Our own transcript of the public episode, with a timestamp about every 90 seconds. Tap a timestamp to play the episode from there in the show's own player; the link button on a paragraph copies a link that opens this page there.
0:00If a friend asked what's actually going on with AI, could you explain it? Machine Gods from NPR is the show to send them to. It's hosted by Kevin Roos and Casey Newton, two veteran tech journalists with front row seats to the industry. Casey and Kevin take an AI realism approach. They report on AI as it is. They don't cheerlead for it or panic about it. The show explores what AI means for work, for life, and for all our futures. Weekly episodes, mixed interviews, and industry news analysis, so you can be in the know from all the angles. You don't need to be an AI expert. It's made for smart, curious people, like those who listen to The Beast, who want to understand what's happening without the
0:45hype. Casey and Kevin are the real deal. In fact, I just had dinner with Casey in San Francisco last week, and the two of them have got 40 years combined experience as tech journalists. And Machine Gods helps me feel like I'm in the know about the latest on AI. It feels like hanging out with two smart friends who happen just to know a lot about AI. So listen now to Machine Gods in the NPR app or wherever else you get your podcasts. He is, I would say, a performance art self-promoter. I've never known a secretary of defense to install a makeup studio, and I just thought that was crazy. And ironically, Pete Hegseth has used that briefing room less than probably any secretary in history because he, in fact, he has a very
1:30adversarial approach with the press, kicked them out of the building. Literally, it's a farce. It's a charade. Mrs. Hegseth was clearly in terms of stage managing him. I'm sure that she talked with him and said, we need to get you a makeup studio. So I thought it was just, as you say, I think it's bonkers. And it's completely contradictory to his message of lethality. I'm Joanna Coles. This is the Daily Beast podcast. And we have an astonishing interview today with John Elliott, the author of this book, The President Deserves Better. He worked for Pete Hegseth. He was asked to set up Pete Hegseth's communications department when Hegseth first came in as defense secretary. And what he saw in those first three months are
2:22so disturbing. This account of Pete Hegseth's character is so disturbing. Not only was he calling for Pete Hegseth's impeachment, but he is demanding that the president fire Pete Hegseth. He says the president deserves better. We all deserve better. America, this country we love, deserves better. I cannot recommend this book more highly, specifically for chapters nine and 10, which detail the madness of Pete Hegseth's ego, his giddiness in showing off the Pentagon to Elon Musk, his determination to have his wife running operations and her determination to have him under her thumb. It's a riveting read. Before we get into our conversation, a reminder to please subscribe to this Daily Beast podcast
3:13wherever you get your podcasts, share it with a friend, share it with your neighbours. We love to have independent conversations because we are independent media and we love your support to underpin that independence. Okay, no time to waste. Let's get into it with John Elliott. Most people use Claude like it's a fancy version of Google. That's like owning a Ferrari and driving it at five miles an hour. They open it up, see the models, Haiku, Sonnet, Opus and Freeze, but never find out what Claude can actually do. Because Claude isn't a chatbot anymore, it's how people build apps, automate their entire week and ship work that used to take a whole team, often without writing a single line of code. If you use Claude Chat every day but freeze the
4:06second someone says Claude Code or Cowork, you're in the right place because I just found the Claude AI Mastery Workshop. It's a full deep dive into Claude, its real use cases, and 10 plus other AI tools happening this weekend, 10 till 7 EST. And they have been generous enough to make it free of cost for my audience. So go register through the link. In two days, you'll do deep research with Claude, create full presentations, get hands-on with Claude Code, build custom agents, and walk away able to put your whole week on autopilot. Sign up now and you also get three free bonuses, 50 secret clawed codes, a full AI prompt library and a personalised AI toolkit builder. What you'll learn in two days will change your next two years.
4:59Sign up now before they sell out, scan the QR and join the WhatsApp community before seats close. John Elliott, welcome to the Daily Beast podcast. Thank you very much, Joanna. I have to say, I cannot recommend your book, The President Deserves Better More Highly. It is the most astonishing read. I am fascinated that you got permission to write this book. And what's most gripping about it, you are, of course, a senior advisor. You are a deputy assistant in the White House. You are head of communications for the National Security Council. You have an unbelievable track record. You were at Harvard, you were in the Marine Corps. You have written two chapters about our defense secretary that I am A, astonished got published, and B, are the most devastating
5:54character description slash assassination I think I have ever read. This book, I wanted to throw it across the room and storm down to the Pentagon myself and remove Pete Hegseth. How disappointed were you? Let me start with this question. How disappointed were you that Thomas Massey's impeachment efforts failed this week? And then I want to get into very specific stories that you tell about the craziness of working for Pete Hegseth. But just give me a couple of words on Thomas Massey's efforts. Yes. So thank you, Joanna, once again for having me. And I'm glad you're enjoying the book. We have a lot to talk about. To me, impeachment is beside the point. I mean, that's for Congress to decide. I do note that, I guess, 11 Democrats were not present. But then you could have thrown in other Republicans who
6:49might have been there. But I was surprised that it didn't pass. But that's up to the Congress. What I'm saying about Pete Hagseth Moore is that he should step down voluntarily and not be... Because he is going to get impeached. There's no question. If the Democrats want to, right after January 3rd, when they take over the Congress, it would just be a very easy impeachment. And that would be, he would become only the third cabinet secretary in history to be impeached. One was Mayorkas, which is most recent. And then there was one from back in the 1870s, I believe, but there had only been three in history. And so that's a pretty big stain on you, obviously. And so I don't know why he would want to go through that when the Iran war that he's led, other than the president, has been the
7:37biggest public face of that effort. That was everybody, including Vice President Vance, said that that was poorly handled. Then we can going to really hobble the president as he tries to get his work done. So return to the title. It says The President Deserves Better Than Hague Says. I thought you should rename the book. We all deserve better. This is about America. It's not just about the president. And you're more of a fan of the president than I am of his agenda. But this is a devastating insight into a man that you meet right at the beginning of his career as defense secretary. But you don't even meet him. You are asked to stand up his communications operation when he comes into the job from his role as a weekend co-host of Fox News.
8:48But you don't meet him first. You meet his wife first. Can you tell us about that first meeting with Jennifer Hegseth? But then I want you to tell us about that meeting and the impact that she has as he then has to go around and meet individual senators, some of whom are very concerned that he doesn't have the ability to do the most important job second only to the president. Absolutely. So really quickly, to take the first, the Senate confirmation and that process. And so I was, for four years, I was the spokesperson for the Senate Armed Services Committee. That's when Chairman John Warner of Virginia, John McCain, Lindsey Graham, Susan Collins, they were all strong leaders on that committee. And so I know the
9:38process very well, which is that if there's a nominee, for example, Robert Gates came in before our committee when Rumsfeld stepped down 20 years ago. And he went around just like Hegseth did with his not with his wife, but went around to these meetings, which are customary. And they're sort of pre hearing meetings where you get to know the senators. They get to ask their questions privately and or their their pointed questions privately. And then typically a nominee would go around not just to Republicans, but to Democrats as well on the committee. And it's just a courtesy call of sorts. And in this case, Hegseth only met with Republicans. He refused to sit down with Democrats on the committee,
10:18like Jack Reed, who was the committee ranking member from Rhode Island, Democrat, and no Democrats he met with. But even in the meetings with Republicans, he brought his wife to them, which is never done, to bring the wife into these closed-door meetings. So she was sitting there in the meeting. So, for example, he went in and talked with Joni Ernst, who is the senator from Iowa who's on the committee. She had very, very big questions after media reports about his he's on his third wife. He had allegations of of infidelity, even of sexual impropriety. One with some somebody in Carmel. These were reports, I should say, or I want to underscore. But to have Joni Ernst, to have him in a closed-door session with his wife,
11:13insisting on bringing his wife, very tough to ask pointed questions like that. So that's never done, even for others than Joni Ernst. She went with him for every... And I hadn't really paid attention to that because I was doing a bunch of other things on the transition down in West Palm Beach and figuring out what I was going to do in the administration. I wrote an op-ed actually in December when his nomination was on the rocks that basically had a tone of saying, hey, give this guy a chance because I didn't know him that well. But I said, look, don't count him out just because he's not a former general. And let's see, his background, I knew he was pretty bombastic, but I thought maybe if he came into office, then he would tone that down. But anyway, so I was not a very loud supporter,
11:59but I said, hey, give him a chance in this op-ed. And that's where I kind of got on his radar screen and the radar screen of his team. So fast forward. So I'm given the job or I'm asked to come in for two months as a temporary assignment, but to serve him as his stand up his press operation. And then and so I go in and his chief of staff or his head of transition told me, great, you're going to do this for two months, but you need to come and have a quick courtesy meeting with Secretary Hegseth, then Secretary of the Nominee Hegseth. And so I came in. He was preparing for his hearing. This was after he met with the senators, and they said, well, at the last minute, I got a call and said, well, actually, you're not going to meet with Hegseth,
12:51you're going to meet with his wife. And so I thought it was, hey, I'm going to just shake her hand and just have her talk about what her kids or something like that. And then she sat down and really grilled me for about 35, close to 40 minutes, where she essentially said, how are you going to deal with a hostile press? What's your background? All this stuff. And I mean, it was like a full-on kind of hostile or skeptical job interview of sorts. And then at the end of that, she smiled and she said, OK, well, you're, you know, she basically said, OK, well, here you go. You're going to go ahead and get this job. I thought it was very strange from the outset. If you like the support of a sports bra but hate wearing one all day, I know exactly what you mean.
13:35Most of them feel great for a workout. But after a few days, the straps dig in, the band gets uncomfortable, and you're about to, well, strangle yourself. The Honeylove Crossflex Activity Bra completely changed that for me. It's got the support of a sports bra, but it's actually designed to be comfortable all day. Honeylove doesn't just make bras and shapewear. They've built a full line of tanks, bodysuits and underwear with supportive structure, smoothing and frankly soothing fabrics and premium finishes. Honeylove recently launched their new crossover contour bra, which features their best-selling wireless crossover bra design, plus built-in molded light foam pads for extra support and a beautifully contoured shape. So treat yourself to the most advanced bras
14:26and shapewear on the market during Honeylove's Black Friday preview sale. For a limited time, get up to 40% off site-wide at honeylove.com slash dailybeast. That's honeylove.com slash dailybeast for up to 40% off site- wide. After you check out, they'll ask you where you heard about them. Please support our show and tell them we sent you. Experience the new standard in comfort and support with Honey Love. You make it very clear that Jennifer Hegseth becomes a huge character in Pete Hegseth's administration. You know, Hegseth had also come to a $50,000 settlement with a woman who'd accused him of sexual assault. Very, very difficult for any senator to ask that when the wife is in the room. So obviously, do you think it was deliberate that he was taking her round to fend
15:26off those questions? Or do you think he was taking her round because he was afraid of going on his own? Is that why he was taking her to the meetings? Or do you think he was deliberately trying to fend off accusations of his drunkenness, of his financial shenanigans when he was running veterans affairs organizations, and also the accusations that he'd sexually assaulted at least one woman that he'd paid off with $50,000. Yes, Joanna. I think that I don't know definitively. I mean, only he knows and I'm not in his head about exactly why he brought her around. But I think it's a combination of about three things. One, I think that, and this goes to a lot of his problems even now, but certainly in the first few months while I was, or first
16:15couple months that I was there, and then really in his first nine months, he's demonstrated that he has no idea about how things work. He's never been in government other than being an officer in the Minnesota National Guard. So he didn't know that it was improper to bring his wife around. Maybe those who are shepherding him around, they actually call them a Sherpa, who is a team that gets him ready for his nominations, accompanies him here, accompanies him around to the Senate. I don't know if they told him it was inappropriate, but he must have insisted because she was there. So I don't know. So I think he didn't realize how bad look that was, number one. Number two, I think it is, to your point, it does sort of push back on
17:01the sexual impropriety, the fact that he's been kind of running around with different women, reportedly. That was something that says, hey, I've got my wife here. She wouldn't be with me if she didn't have confidence and that I'm a different man, et cetera. And then the third is that she just takes a very hands-on approach with him because she, of course, was his producer at Fox News. And that's when he, I believe, reportedly impregnated her while his second wife was pregnant with a child of his. And then he ended up leaving his second wife for Jennifer Hegseth. So she's his third wife. But she apparently is very much compared to the other two wives that he's had. She's very involved because she was his producer in sort of stage managing him. And I saw that directly when I went into the Pentagon. And it's just gotten worse since then. I mean, the New York Times wrote a big piece about it a couple of months ago,
18:11Hugh Miller, and I think it's pretty clear now how crazy it's gotten over there. In fact, I have a quote in that piece where I just said it's bonkers, which it is. Bonkers is a very Daily Beast word. Well, the other thing that, I mean, you've got so much detail in here and it's very clear that you saw so much of it up close, not least the posters of Jennifer Hegseth, which start going up on the Pentagon walls. This is the wife of the Secretary of Defense. Her picture is all over the Pentagon. It's absolutely peculiar. But one of the first things you also have to deal with, and you just say absolutely not, is his demand for a makeup room right next to the briefing room. Just tell us a little bit about that. Well, absolutely. So this is part of the very,
18:54he's very image conscious. That's why he'll have those pocket squares. And where's this sort of light blue suit with the flag pocket squares. And he's very image, he's very built on his image. And that probably helped him move up the ranks or move from being a correspondent to then becoming a weekend show, morning show co-host, one of three co-hosts there. So I think that being very image conscious and putting out this persona, and that's very stage managed, I think he was already leaning in that direction. Then his wife is helping him with that. But when I was in there for, once again, just standing up as media operation, I was told by another staffer who was very close to Jen, was also a producer, a colleague of hers,
19:46that she brought in or Pete brought in with... I think this is Jennifer's best friend, right? Yeah, exactly. Yeah, it's Jennifer's best friend. Incidentally, she was one of the three or four people who were admonished along with Hegseth for loudly talking and laughing at the Arlington Cemetery Tomb of the Unknowns just a couple days ago. And there were three aides and she was one of them. But anyway, she's very close with Hegseth. She came to me and said, hey, we need to... Pete expects to have a makeup studio if he's going to be talking to the media. And I said, that was kind of weird. I've never known a secretary of defense to install a makeup studio. And I just thought that was crazy. And in fact,
20:31it goes against his entire, it's very strange. It's contradictory because he talks about how he's all about lethality and getting rid of wokeness. And then now he wants to install a makeup studio off the Pentagon. No defense secretary had ever done that, but that shows how image conscious he was. And so I turned that down three times. It came to me once. I said, that's a crazy idea. It came to me again. Well, here's the budget. And I said, no, absolutely not. And then they said, seriously, here is what we want to do. And I wrote on an email, I said, I said, disapproved in all capitals across the top. And obviously these are all foiable, but anyway, it was the back and forth of this crazy idea. Then when I left first, one of the first things
21:16they did was install this makeup studio. And ironically, Pete Higgseth has used that briefing room less than probably any secretary in history because he, in fact, he has a very adversarial approach with the press, kicked them out of the building. Literally, there's no press credentials because the credentialed press at the time were all asked to sign a release saying that they would not print any information that was not authorized by and approved by the department. And of course, I mean, the whole idea is getting scoops, getting things that aren't being disclosed officially. And so this was very Soviet-like restrictions on the press. And so to their credit, all of the credentialed reporters said,
22:02look, if we have to give in our credentials, let's do it. And they said, because we're not going to sign that. And so they're all working offsite now. And Hegseth brought in sort of the MyPillow guy, the Mike Lindell TV, and a few other, I think OAN is there, and a few other. They're all right wing, I mean, far-right outlets that are there that are either right or far-right outlets that signed this pledge. And they don't even spend any time at the Pentagon because they're small outlets. And so anyway, it's a farce, it's a charade. But Mrs. Hegseth was clearly, in terms of stage managing him, I'm sure that she talked with him and said, we need to get you a makeup studio. So I thought it was just, as you say, I think it's bonkers and it's completely contradictory to his message of lethality.
22:58He also brought his brother into the Pentagon too, correct? Correct. And that was odd because you're not supposed to, they have sort of, I forget what the regulations are, but you're not supposed to hire family members to work for you if you're an appointee in government. And so this is very odd because of those restrictions, his brother, Phil, who's probably about at least 10 years younger than he is. Very nice guy, actually, Phil. And actually, to take a step back, I worked well with Pete Hegseth. I didn't like what he was doing most of the time, but my job was not to approve or disapprove. My job was to be professional and implement and be this spokesman role and defend his policies or explain his policies. I wasn't defending them, but explain his policies when there were questions from the media. to get around these regulations about not hiring your family, he was actually hired as a political
24:07appointee at the Department of Homeland Security. But I don't know, he was working out of Pete Hegseth's office full time. So I don't know what that arrangement was. I was told that he was detailed over, quote, detailed over to the Pentagon and directly to Pete Hegseth's office by the Department of Homeland Security, I would guess, at the behest of Hegseth to get around those regulations. It was very odd, and I'm not sure what his portfolio was or is, but it was very odd to have your younger brother working directly in your office for you. Right. To have your younger brother working in your office, to have your wife running the show and to have your wife's best friend as a special advisor. I mean, one of the things you talk about is that you had certain agreements with Pete Hexeth on all sorts of policies within the armed service.
25:03You were a Marine. He'd been in the Minnesota National Guard. But you said that what became clear to you was that he was incredibly one dimensional and that actually it was all about appearance and it was all about Pete Hegseth as central casting and that there was no depth there, despite the fact he'd authored books on the military. In fact, he had no idea how to implement policy. He had no idea about creating an actual strategy. And he was really just about the attention for Pete Hegseth. That's exactly right. He is, I would say, a performance art self-promoter. And that's something that, once again, that helped him. And he has this image as, he's cultivated an image as a very, as some type of a warrior, warrior's warrior. And it's odd because people who are truly,
25:58let's say, a Navy SEAL or SEAL Team 6 or Medal of Honor, I've met a number of them in my career, very many of them in my career. And almost to a man, they are very low key about their accomplishments. And so to have somebody who was a, hey, look, we honor everybody's service, reserve, or active duty. But to have somebody write three books about lethality, you'd think that he would have gone in full-time like most of us in my class. We had 10 of us go into the Marine Corps, I think aid in the Navy. And in Princeton, when he, I think I write in the book, I looked it up, I think there are 25 people from Princeton, which is where his alma mater, who went into the military this past year, I just looked it up, in 2025. And zero went into part-time National Guard, which once again,
26:54we honor everybody's service. We had a National Guard person killed and wounded down here protecting the White House. And so everybody, we honor their service. But if you're going to write three books about it and be chest beating about beating your chest about lethality in the military, then I would have thought that like the other 25 from Princeton who just graduated this year, that he would have gone in full time rather than in his state's National Guard. Let's now talk about perhaps the first big scandal of his career, Signalgate. You were there for that. Can you explain to us how you gradually realized how grave this situation was? Yes, absolutely. What it was, Joanna, is that this is, once again, I don't think that anybody
27:48really, he had no experience in handling classified information before he was sworn in as secretary, other than his stint as an infantryman in the Minnesota National Guard. And in my experience, when you're an infantryman, for example, in the Marine Corps, I was an intelligence officer and a scout sniper platoon commander, four years on active duty with the Marine Corps. And as an intelligence officer there, the infantry guys did not, they had usually a secret clearance and they never really handled classified information the way an intelligence officer would, or whether we did at the NSC. And so here, suddenly he's put in this job, doesn't know how to handle classified information. And for him, it was once again, we saw that we were going to take this action
28:36and we're preparing for it against the Houthis. And no one knew about it. This was something that was just like you'd expect, that this is operational planning. And so before that operation, he said something like, okay, guys, I will keep Dan Caldwell. And I pulled him aside after that meeting where Hegseth said, hey, I'll keep you apprised on signal about what's going to happen with this operation. I pulled this guy aside, and he's a Marine as well, Dan Caldwell, an infantryman he was. But I said to him, hey, Dan, I don't have the relationship that you have with him, but somebody's got to tell him to be very careful what he shares over signal because he was talking about operational stuff with us.
29:30And when he was telling us that it was in what's called a skiff, sense of compartmental information. So you could discuss operational plans, but, um, but, uh, uh, I was worried that he would, uh, not just about this operation, but in general, if he wasn't, you're not even supposed to send just any official taskings or anything over Signal because there's supposed to be a paper record. For example, you can take your Gmail and send something to somebody over their Gmail that says, hey, take this action in government, let alone at the DOD because of records in government. Everything has to be FOIA-able, et cetera. So you have to use your own work email and Signal's not allowed at all for anything official. So here you have the new Secretary of Defense putting classified operational material on
30:20Signal and then including an editor of a magazine, Jeffrey Goldberg from The Atlantic. Correct. And so what happened there was that, once again, this is not allowed to have anything even unclassified that's official business of the government. But what he did was he set up a text chain, which was with I believe it was Stephen Miller, J.D. Vance, Marco Rubio, Mike Waltz, who was the actually who had there. And then that was a signal group so that they could all get together. And then somehow Waltz's aide who set up this group punched in Jeffrey Goldberg's number and put it in thinking that it was somebody else. I think maybe another Goldberg he wanted to add there. But Jeffrey Goldberg happened to be on this chain, but mistakenly. And so that's how all this came to light, because this never would have come to light if he hadn't been accidentally added to that chain. well we had seen everybody's they've published the actual text joey goldberg did but what they
31:45were is pete hegseth was the one who decided to share uh pre-strike information uh with that group and it was things like uh at 1545 uh f-18s leave the carrier uh at 1615 expected over target, and then just said things like high value target HVT was seen entering his place last night, OPSEC is clear, ready to go, things like that. And that was all the inspector general determined that that was established that that was secret no foreign, which means it's a classified secret, and then slash no foreign, which means do not disseminate to any foreigners, even if they have a clearance. So secret no foreign. So that's very, very highly classified. I mean, there's higher, you have TS and whatnot, higher than that,
32:36but that is important. That is very information that's determined that would be very damaging if that got out. That's why it gets that classification level. Anyway, so he cut and pasted that in. So he must have had that signal app on his computer or maybe somehow he took the exact strike sequencing, copied it into this signal chat on which Jeffrey Goldberg was there. And to me, it was exactly a window into his personality because A, it's inexperience knowing that that is not something ever that you would do. I mean, you would get literally, if you're a Lance Corporal in the Marine Corps working for me as a young Lieutenant Intel officer, and you take classified information, email it to somebody,
33:22then you face, if you look it up, you face up to 10 years in prison and up to $500,000 fine for doing exactly what Pete Hegseth did there by copying that over and instantly this same administration, the Trump administration, is prosecuting John Bolton, his former National Security Advisor, did the exact same thing for not texting in that case, but emailing classified information to his wife. So that's what he did. And so it's a window, he doesn't know what's right and what's wrong because he's inexperienced. And number two is that he has this ability, he has this idea about how you talk about a flex. So you flex your muscles, et cetera, and sort of show off to other people. And so for him, this was a flex. It was sort of like the chats that you can read. They're all published. But the chats up to that point that Pete sent that classified information were sort of like, hey, let's get—this is really good. Sounds like the planning's going very well. And this is—sh should we go in here or should we not? You know,
34:25that type of thing. And then out of nowhere, he said, he pasted in this text because it was sort of like, okay, you guys, whether it's Vance, Rubio, you guys can talk about all that, about going here, going there, whatever. Let me just show you how it's done. Boom. It's like a flex. Here's 1545, F18s taken off over the tar HV, and this is down to the detail, kind of like showing him, hey, I'm driving this big Ferrari called the Pentagon now. The badass I am, right? Yeah. Well, he also does a similar flex with Elon Musk, doesn't he? He invites Elon Musk into the tank, which is the sort of place where you can have, again, top secret conversations and briefings. Donald Trump then gets to hear about this and that Elon Musk is supposed to be having briefings about China and says,
35:18you can't do that. Even Donald Trump sort of realizes that this isn't okay. Can you then pick up the story of what happens? Because the press are waiting, the Joint Chiefs of Staff are waiting for Elon to arrive at the tank. And in fact, Pete Hegseth has smuggled Elon into the building to avoid all these people. Right. So this was exactly as you said, Joanna. A quick recap is that Hegseth apparently saw Elon, who was the head of Doge at the time, at the White House and said, hey, it was once again like the Ferrari, the flex. He said, hey, let me come over and I'll let you sit behind the, literally sit at a chair. But it's like, hey, jump in the driver's seat of my Ferrari and drive it around the block a little bit and see how fast it goes, et cetera. So the idea was bringing him into this very,
36:09very tightly controlled nerve center, which is called the tank, where the Joint Chiefs of Staff make operational decisions and direct and get the information out that the secretary can direct the commanders there. And so the Secretary of Defense has a seat there at the tank with the Joint Chiefs around. And he set up this thing by saying, and once again, he has no idea the impropriety of this stuff because he's a former National Guard major and with no experience in government. And so he just said, hey, come on over as if it's no big deal. And I'll let you be briefed about China and other things, including where Elon Musk happened to have business dealings. And so the look was terrible. And President Trump apparently didn't even know about it.
36:53But Maggie Haberman of The New York Times found out about that. And it's obvious how she found out about that, because there are probably about 60 people that staff the tank and need to prepare for meetings, et cetera. And so one of them clearly, the word, it was not a secret that they were bringing in musts that day, but it wasn't around the Pentagon, but at least 60 people knew, and you know somebody's going to leak that out. And so anyway, the president saw Maggie Haberman's piece, and according to Axios, and I have all this footnoted in the book, but according to Axios, the president was so angry and he was throwing F-bombs and saying, what the F is going on over there? And apparently, Red Pete, the riot act, called him up. The piece came out about 11,
37:411130. Apparently, he called him up right away and said, what is going on? Are you crazy? Are you bringing him over for a briefing in the tank? Even if it weren't classified, just the look, and I hope it wasn't going to be classified, but the look of having him in there and just sitting around and having him be briefed as a private citizen who's just the head of Doge, who has no need to know any of this information, is such a bad look. And the president understands that. And he basically said, what the hell are you doing? What the F are you doing? And so then Hegseth had to scramble, turn it off because it was on for the next morning. And when I arrived at work the next day, I was not going to be part of that meeting at all because I'm managing the press. And I was right on my way out. And meantime, they have a private elevator for the defense secretary that's in the garage underneath the river entrance to the Pentagon.
38:51And it has a private elevator that goes straight up to the back of his office. And so they brought Elon Musk up on that private elevator and reportedly kept the Joint Chiefs waiting for him to show up. And so they were all in their uniforms sitting around the table waiting for Elon Musk because they were told they probably knew how crazy this was, but they have to follow orders. And so they were sitting around and waiting for him and 20 minutes go by and then they were probably given a call and said, hey, the meeting's off. And meantime, Musk is up having a sit around up in the secretary's office with some of his aides and they were all laughing in photos that were there. It's a terrible story. So you
39:32repeatedly talk about how inexperienced Pete Hegseth was. Isn't the actual fault of really his appointment by the president? Yes. President, the buck stops here, you know, as Truman had on the Oval Office desk. It's absolutely right. I mean, the president is responsible for everything that happens in his administration, including and most importantly, or as important as anything else probably, is the appointment of his cabinet and his cabinet members. And so what I say in the book, and just to review, two of the 10 chapters are about, you have the full book, I know, Joanna, but two of the 10 chapters concern Hegseth. The others are my time on the Trump campaign very early on in 2016 at the VA, Veterans Affairs. At the NSC. Bottom line is that he did appoint Pete Hegseth.
40:28And I thought that was, once again, I thought it was maybe a breath of fresh air, possibly if the guy knew what he was doing. That's why I supported it in my op-ed, saying that, hey, give him a look, basically, is what I said. But we've had a look. What do you think he should do? Do you think he should just fire him? I do think that. And, you know, the way to do this, the way that Bush did it right after 20 years ago, after he lost the midterms, is they just said, hey, ask for his resignation, but don't, but say it's the idea of the secretary himself. So I think that's what he should do. I mean, to me, the president, but I don't think he should have been appointed in the first place. And Joanna, you probably read this already, but my analogy is that not only should you step down
41:18if you do things like, let's say, signal gate that really embarrassed the president, if you become a dead weight on him, a millstone around his neck, then if you're truly loyal to him, you owe it to him to resign. But before you're even appointed, if the president comes to you and says, hey, Joanna, I would like you to have X job, and you say, thank you, Mr. President, and you take the job. If they ask me, if the president said on the transition, you've been with me for close to 10 years, John, I want to make you deputy attorney general, let's say. And I would say, I'd think about it and I'd say, thank you very much, Mr. President. I would get a big car, a driver, a motorcade going around town. It'd be
41:55great. It'd make me feel great. But you may want to get a lawyer, someone with a law degree to do that. How has Pete Hegseth allowed this book to go out? It has to be reviewed by the Pentagon. There's no classified information in it, but the character that you describe is so disturbing, John. And you saw him up close and you worked with him up close and you worked with his wife up close and his brother. It's a devastating critique of this man, which is why I urge everybody watching or listening to really pick up this book, The President Deserves Better. Do you have any sense of how Pete Hegseth is responding to this book? Because his people must have read it. Well, I think they're buying it on Amazon. I'm sure it came out this week. So I doubt they had a
42:52preview of it. But you're right that if you write a book like this, it has to go through clearance, which I did both through the NSC and through the Pentagon. And so other than that, but I mean, they vet or review hundreds of books, probably. I mean, they have a whole team that does that. My guess is probably about two or three dozen people whose job it is to look through manuscripts and to say, okay, this is classified, this is not. And so it's a process that takes weeks at least. In my case, I think it was about five weeks from the Pentagon or maybe another five weeks from the NSC because I spent a lot more time at the NSC than the Pentagon. But they both determined no classified information.
43:38And they can't withhold a book if they don't like it and if it's negative about it. Look at Bill Barr, former Attorney General Bill Barr. He wrote a book and his was vetted as well. And even though the president may not have liked it, they couldn't stop it from being published. Well, John, look out for yourself is all I can say. But many congratulations on this book. I'm going to hold it up one more time. It's out this week, and it is a devastating portrayal of Pete Hegseth. John, many thanks for joining us. Thank you very much, Joanne. I really appreciate you having me on. That was a conversation that I found riveting because it was from someone who'd actually worked cheek by jowl with Pete
44:26Hegseth in the Pentagon. And the way he describes what happens to the media who are trying to cover him in the book is also really amazing and again, worth your time to really understand how fundamental the changes going on in the Pentagon are and how long I think it will take for them to be rectified. Anyway, write and tell us, A, what you think of Pete Hexerth, B, do you think he should be fired? And if you have been, a big thank you for joining us and a thanks to our production team, who I love working with. They make these conversations as seamless as possible. We're constantly trying to hook up all kinds of tech, wherever any of us are, they really go above and beyond to make it work. So big thanks to Ryan Murray, John Romero,
45:17Benji Wilson, Rachel Passer, Heather Passaro, and Neil Rosenhaus. So the good news is we have so many Beebeast tier members now. There are too many names to read out. And we really appreciate your support.



