The Briefing with Jen Psaki · · Transcript & summary by WhipScribe
A same-night breakdown of a nationwide flight shutdown, with a pilot and a former transportation official explaining why recovery takes days, plus the midterm flip in Colorado.
Tap a chapter to play it from that moment in the show's own player; the transcript opens there too.
“Our switches, our routers, actually got overloaded with data and they went down.” Sean Duffy · at 1:52 — ▶ hear it from here
“Frankly, I think I'm dumber at the end of it for having watched it.” Brendan Boyle · at 31:17 — ▶ hear it from here
On Friday night the FAA halted flights across the United States for nearly four and a half hours, lifting the ground stop at 8:15 p.m. Eastern. Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy blamed switches and routers overloaded with data, then used the outage to argue that Congress had left air traffic control modernization underfunded and to ask for $50 billion. Commentators on the show said the administration offered little timeline, and that the briefing felt more like a political statement than a plan for travelers.
The disruption did not end when the stop was lifted. Veteran pilot Keith Wolsinger explained that planes cannot unload at gates, that domestic crews are capped at about 14 duty hours and then need 10 to 12 hours of rest, and that airlines may need fresh crews or an extra night. FlightAware counted roughly 9,000 delays and more than 6,000 cancellations that day, with hundreds of flights for the next day already scrubbed. A reporter at Jacksonville International Airport described passengers boarding with no word from their airline and worrying about medication packed in checked bags.
Election night brought its own news. Ali Velshi reported that Democrats flipped Colorado's 4th District, held by Lauren Boebert, who had moved into the seat after narrowly winning reelection in 2022, and that retired Navy rear admiral Eileen Laubacher will defeat her. In Alaska, Mary Peltola led Republican Dan Sullivan by about 5,800 votes with 88 percent counted, and if she stays under 50 percent, ranked choice voting could decide the seat, though the count may take days.
Chief national reporter at MSNOW and host of State of Play. He was previously a White House correspondent and spent 14 years in the briefing room.
MSNOW senior transportation reporter who has covered the FAA and the air traffic control modernization effort.
Veteran pilot who explained crew duty limits, gate bottlenecks and why airline recovery takes days.
Congressman who is in line to become chair of the House Budget Committee next year.
MSNOW chief data reporter and host of The 11th Hour, who covered the Colorado and Alaska races.
Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy said the FAA's switches and routers were overloaded with data and began giving inconsistent information, so the agency shut the system down. He used the outage to argue that Congress had not funded the modernization and asked for $50 billion, up from the $30 billion the president had requested.
“Our switches, our routers, actually got overloaded with data and they went down.”Sean Duffy · 1:52
Peter Alexander said administration officials took about four and a half hours to come before cameras in the briefing room, and they did not clearly say early on that the ground stop had concluded and planes could take off. He called the first remarks a political statement and said the messaging was the opposite of what travelers needed.
“it took four and a half hours before administration officials came before cameras in the briefing room”Peter Alexander · 4:50
Veteran pilot Keith Wolsinger said domestic crews are limited to a duty day of about 14 hours. After that they must rest 10 to 12 hours, usually at a hotel, before flying again. Because of that rule, flights delayed for hours can lose their crews, and airlines sometimes have to hold planes an extra night.
“On the crew side, crews are limited for a duty day of around 14 hours on domestic flights”Keith Wolsinger · 24:21
Brendan Boyle said he watched the entire White House briefing with Sean Duffy and came away knowing less about what happened. He said the officials spent most of their time praising Donald Trump and blaming the Republican-controlled Congress, and he noted that Republicans had pushed a 29% cut to transportation and HUD budgets last year.
“Frankly, I think I'm dumber at the end of it for having watched it.”Brendan Boyle · 31:17
Ali Velshi said Lauren Boebert moved into Colorado's 4th District to run in what she thought was a safer seat, and lost it to Democrat Eileen Laubacher, a retired Navy rear admiral. He noted that Trump had won the seat by 18 points in 2024, and that Boebert ran behind him there.
“she wanted to keep being Lauren Boebert and thought that this was the safer district”Ali Velshi · 37:34
The FAA lifted a nationwide ground stop at 8:15 p.m. Eastern on Friday after about four and a half hours, but flights stayed delayed for hours afterward. The show's guests said the White House and Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy gave little clear information, and that the funding dispute and crew limits would keep recovery going into the next day.
Sean Duffy said the FAA's switches and routers were overloaded with data and began giving inconsistent information, so the agency shut the system down. He then argued that Congress had not funded air traffic control modernization and asked for $50 billion, after the president had requested $30 billion. Peter Alexander and others on the show said his explanation gave little clear timeline.
Peter Alexander said administration officials took about four and a half hours to come before cameras, and never clearly said early on that the ground stop had ended and planes could take off. He called the remarks a political statement rather than an update for travelers. He said officials should have said they could not rule out a cyber attack but had found no evidence of one.
Veteran pilot Keith Wolsinger said domestic crews are limited to a duty day of about 14 hours. After that they must rest 10 to 12 hours, usually at a hotel, before they can fly again. Planes also cannot unload passengers at gates, and airlines face fines from the Department of Transportation if passengers are not offered a chance to deplane after a set time on the ground. He said a national recovery would probably take at least a full day.
Brendan Boyle said he watched the entire White House briefing and came away knowing less about what happened. He said the officials spent most of their time praising Donald Trump and blaming the Republican-controlled Congress. He also pointed out that last year Republicans had pushed a 29% cut to transportation, HUD and other agencies as part of the DOGE process.
Ali Velshi said Democrat Eileen Laubacher, a retired U.S. Navy rear admiral, will defeat Republican Lauren Boebert in Colorado's 4th District. Boebert had moved into the district to run in what she thought was a safer seat after narrowly winning reelection in 2022. Velshi noted that Trump had won the seat by 18 points in 2024, and that Boebert ran behind him there.
Ali Velshi said the Alaska Senate race was 88 percent counted, with Democrat Mary Peltola still below 50 percent and leading Republican incumbent Dan Sullivan by about 5,800 votes. If she stays under 50 percent once every vote is counted, ranked choice voting would begin, with the lowest candidate's ballots redistributed by second choice. He said that could be decided between Tuesday and Thursday, but that Alaska's slow mail counts make the timing uncertain.
Keith Wolsinger said he wanted to hear from the FAA administrator or the chief of the air traffic organization, and that a clear timeline would have helped pilots. He said air traffic control gave estimates of at least eight hours with no firm answer. That left planes that had already taxied out burning fuel, so some had to return to the gate to refuel and wait again.
Our own transcript of the public episode, with a timestamp about every 90 seconds. Tap a timestamp to play the episode from there in the show's own player; the link button on a paragraph copies a link that opens this page there.
0:00Every day someone sits in this chair convinced healthy strong hair has to come with a luxury price tag. But you know what really surprises them? How simple the solution can be. The secret isn't some long expensive salon treatment. It's actually Pantene. Pantene Daily Moisture Renewal Shampoo and Conditioner has a vitamin-rich lather that leaves hair looking vibrant and hydrated after every wash, with results lasting over 72 hours. And for an extra boost, use Pantene's Miracle Rescue 10-in-1 Multitasking Spray. Oh, here comes a new client. Time to share the secret. For salon-quality hair repair, it's actually panting. At Sutter, we promise to plan your knee replacement so you could be home the same day.
0:52To make scheduling a checkup as easy as booking a haircut. To open more urgent cares. Urgently. Caring for your health is a group effort. That's why there's a whole team on your team at Sutter Health. If you're joining our coverage just now, we've been following, of course, the FAA's ground stop of all flights nationwide. A press conference was just wrapped at the White House. We're going to get into details of that in a moment. As you know, this has been in place for nearly four and a half hours, but was just lifted. We have been getting very little official information from the administration. I can tell you from working in two, that is not normal in any way, shape or form. While the air space was actually shut down across the country. And when we finally did hear from the transportation secretary, he gave what I would consider pretty limited and confusing information on what exactly happened.
1:52And this is important because this is an opportunity to speak to everybody out there at airports, waiting to hear updates on their loved ones, wondering about their travel this week and in the weeks to come leading up to Thanksgiving, what exactly is happening. And this is how he explained what happened today, part of what he said. Our switches, our routers, actually got overloaded with data and they went down. And I shouldn't say they went down. They started to give us inconsistency in the data from those routers. And because of that, we shut the system down. If you have no idea what that word salad meant, I don't either. And we're going to talk to some experts about what that meant, what we should take away
2:35from it, what it means for the future. Secretary Duffy followed that with an attack on Congress. Ironically, I would note, a Congress that has been in Republican control for the last two years. He attacked them for not providing funding. So there's that. We'll talk about that, too. Now, as we head into tonight, Duffy warned that while the ground stop has been lifted, that does not mean everyone's stuck at airports all across the country right now. We'll see their flights ready to go right away. Here's what he said about that. At 8.15 tonight, Eastern Time, we've opened up the airspace. Now, does that mean every flight is going to fly right now? It's going to be slow, right? So if you're watching, you're at an airport, check with your airline. It depends on,
3:19do we have crews available? Do we have pilots and flight attendants available to fly your flight? We're going to try to move as many of those as we can tonight if we have the capacity with crews to move those flights. If not, we're going to start tomorrow morning with our airline partners moving those aircraft. But it's going to take us some time to unwind what's happened this afternoon. I should note we do have reporters out at a number of airports. We're going to be talking to them as well. Also, this is only the second time since 9-11 that the FAA has issued a nationwide ground stop like this. The last time was in 2023, when the FAA grounded planes across the country for 90 minutes. And that's important because despite only lasting
4:00an hour and a half, that nationwide ground stop in 2023 led to more than 10,000 flight delays and over 1,300 flight cancellations. We don't have the total number. I'm sure there's lots of reporting on that. We'll keep you updated on that. And as of this hour, I should note, today's ground stop has lasted nearly five hours. Now, as of now, for today, we're seeing around 9,000 flight delays and over 6,000 cancellations, according to the flight tracking website FlightAware.com. Hundreds of flights scheduled for tomorrow have already been canceled. So even though the ground stop has been lifted, we may not be out of the woods just yet. That is certainly part of the story, too. Joining me now to discuss all of this is MSNOW's chief national reporter and host of State of Play, Peter Alexander.
4:50OK, I have been on the side of prepping cabinet officials to go out to the briefing room in those moments. You have been on the side of asking questions. I just gave some of my thoughts. What did you make of that? Well, I think I have a thought for you, first of which is it took four and a half hours before administration officials came before cameras in the briefing room to share what was in effect limited information. The good news was that the ground stop had concluded. To be clear, they never said that right out of the gates, which would have been the first most important thing to communicate to the American people. You're safe. There's nothing to worry about. The ground stop has been lifted. We are allowing planes to begin taking off. What struck me is that vacuum,
5:20the four and a half hours that passed from when this started, roughly 336, he said, but nationwide 345 roughly till about 815 when it was finally lifted. That to me was remarkable. Obviously, I think, as you would note, as a communications expert, that the first responsibility is to share information. I felt like this was largely a political rant. Rant may be a strong word. A political statement. I would call it a rant. Fine. You can call it a rant. Fine, you can call it a rant. From my perspective, I would say that they came out there and basically the first sentence that Mark Wayne Mullen said, one of them was, this is what the leadership of President Trump looks like. I think if you're talking about a four and a half nationwide
5:57ground stop and this is what the leadership of President Trump looks like, I don't think that's the messaging that they were desiring there. I'm sure they were trying to say that everybody got to their destination safely, but I don't think that's the messaging that they were desiring there. I'm sure they were trying to say that everybody got to their destination safely, but I don't think that's the way Americans are seeing it. Number two, and this is a point that you made, but I think it's a critical one, which is that they effectively use this opportunity not to detail the best information that they knew, the circumstances to the best of their understanding, a timeline about how elements came to be when everything occurred, why they made the decisions that they made.
6:26Instead, they focused heavily on blaming Congress for its failure to fund a modernization project as it relates to America's air traffic control infrastructure, the systems. As you noted, both the chambers of Congress, the House and the Senate have been controlled by Republicans for the last two years. One of those Republicans was the Department of Homeland Security Secretary Mark Wayne Mullen, then the senator from Oklahoma for much of that time before he replaced Christine Noem there. And while it would likely often take bipartisan support to get the 60 votes necessary in the Senate, there's also a product, and we're not going to get lost, in a language called reconciliation. It's where Republicans can do things of priority all on their own. It's the way they pursued that
7:09one big, beautiful bill, as it is called. But this was never, and I was in the White House during those times, this was never a priority, never something that they focused on, and certainly never in the terms with the urgency that they just communicated today. It was, while I was watching it, you never get as many questions as you want in the briefing room, no matter the White House, no matter who's president. Were there things you wish were asked during that press conference? There were a lot of things I think that I would have liked to have seen asked. I was just struck by the moment that they came out there. He said, hey, I know this, I mean, if I'm honest, as someone who's been in that briefing room
7:41for 14 years asking you questions, asking presidents questions, it struck me just the sort of loose nature that they addressed the situation. The moment Mark Wayne Mullen came out there, and there's going to be plenty of time for the blame and the like, but just in terms of fundamental communication skills and a responsibility of the American people, the first thing he said was, I know a lot of people have been talking about this, but let's be clear, there was no connection between what we just saw today and yesterday's Microsoft Outlook outage. It's like he'd been deep in the recesses of Twitter. That's what it struck me. And I will say, just to echo this, typically what you would do is you would have a cabinet member or two cabinet members
8:17who's ever briefing go out there with a prepared set of an update that is actually not political at all. Typically, it would be speaking broadly to the American people. That is the goal at that moment. Facts first. What do the American people who are watching this on a television in an airport want to know, need to know right now? What struck me on top of that was one of the, out of the gates, he said that this was not a cyber attack. And then someone followed up, can you rule out that it was a cyber attack? Well, I can't rule out that it was a cyber attack, but it does not appear to have been a cyber attack. The best communicators of information, we were working on opposite sides during this process,
8:54but I'm sure behind closed doors, when I was getting ready to pepper you with questions, you were having conversations to say, let's say everything we know and acknowledge what we don't know. And what they should have said is, we cannot rule out that this was a cyber attack, but we will say declaratively right now that we have found no evidence that it was. Just tell us what it is, as my mom would teach me. Keep it simple, stupid. Instead, there was a lot of information shared there that made it really convoluted. And I think a lot of people are left with as many questions right now as they are with answers. It created this is the goal. This is the opposite of the goal, I should say, created more questions and created more panic, right?
9:28What you're trying to do is you're trying to calm people in that moment. Here's what we can tell you we know. Here is the, this is the other thing they didn't really do. Give people transparency on the process and what the process looks like from here. Here's why we can't. We're gonna do a review over the course of the next 48 hours. We're gonna give you an update at the end of 48 hours or 72 hours or next week or whatever. And instead of doing that, it felt very haphazard and very loose to me as well. You're right. The only thing I'll add, and I know you have a lot of other guests with a lot of other expertise on this. One thing that struck me as I was anchoring some of our coverage earlier this evening
9:58is while this was all playing out, the first comments on camera were Mark Wayne Mullen walking to what we call the sticks, the microphones outside the White House. It was not a prepared statement in any way, and it left a lot more questions to be answered. And then number two, while this was playing out, Marco Rubio, not just the Secretary of State, but the National Security Advisor to the President, was giving an address at the Federalist Society about lawfare in this country instead of being present with the President either in the Oval Office or the Situation Room as necessary. Just some of the other things that struck me in terms of the way these things normally play out. It is certainly true. I'm glad you could be here. I know you've
10:34worked a very long day today. I was also the last thing I struck on. I'll bring some people in is that Mark Wayne Mullen oversees FEMA and he turned it over to Secretary Duffy, the Secretary of Transportation, to give a FEMA update. A small thing, but a little bit of an indication of the haphazard nature of it all. Can I just say lastly? Yes, go ahead. There's still no press secretary in the White House. And as you know well, having been a press secretary, it's that person's job to say to the president and to others, we need to be out in front of this. Our responsibility is to communicate and share a message. That's one of the challenges that exists in the vacuum that we're seeing at the White House these days.
11:06They're not all powerful, but they can be useful. I will say that. There we go. Okay, joining me now, thank you, Peter, as always, for being here. Joining me now is Josh Eininger, MSNOW senior transportation reporter and Mark Santia, MSNOW investigative reporter, who I told you we would have people from airports. Mark is currently at the Jacksonville International Airport in Jacksonville, Florida. He has been there for a very long time, but providing updates on what is happening. Let me start with you, Josh. I just laid out, we've just been talking about the things that struck us from that press conference. You speak the language of this. You have heard many briefings. You've asked questions at many briefings. What struck you watching that press
11:41conference? I mean, Jen, I have to be honest. I'm a little confused by what we were just told. Same. Because on the one hand, right, on the one hand, you know, look, Secretary Duffy is pushing to expand the modernization. And let me just back up for a second, Jen. Look, modernizing air traffic control is not controversial. Basically, everyone who's serious agrees that this should have happened a long time ago and gives credit to the administration for pushing through the first $12.5 billion to get this thing moving. They said in the last few months, they wanted another $30 billion. Today, it became $50 billion, which is the first I had heard that. But Duffy turned this into an argument for why they need more funding to complete the modernization.
12:27Our old switches, he said, and I'm quoting here, got overloaded with data. But Secretary Mullen said something that was really very interesting. He said, quote, the new technology was overloading the older system. So the question really is, how do you modernize without breaking what was already there? I had this actual conversation with Secretary Duffy. I sat down with him back in February. We talked about this, you know, all these issues and the upcoming modernization. And that is a question of how the contractors that are involved in this project, a huge sweeping project, execute what many people agree needs to happen without leading to something like this. And that's a question that I wish was sussed out
13:18a little bit more in that briefing today that I really don't understand the accountability in terms of how this is being monitored if in fact Mullen is right and that's what happened. Yeah, there are a lot more questions, I think, to that point about how it happened, how it can be prevented. I mean, at one point it was even, I'm not sure, I can't tell you it isn't going to happen again. And that's fair, but I think people were still left with some confusion about what was being done to address. Let me ask you, Mark, you know, I think one of the things they couldn't answer, and to be fair, I'm not sure how they would have necessarily answered, although you usually hope the administration has more information than they just provided, was what travelers should know
13:57out there. What are you hearing on the ground? What are you hearing from your sources about what now that this ground stop has ended, what it means for travelers, what they should be expecting from airlines? What can you tell people? To hear some direction here at Jacksonville Airport. But you see behind me, this is Terminal C. It's empty on a Friday night. This would be bustling. You're starting to see some passengers come through TSA here because they're starting to get word and word starting to trickle out that flights are taking off. I want to show you the board real quick. There's still several delays, but flights are actually boarding and taking off. There's an Atlanta flight leaving in a couple minutes here, Denver flight, Denver flying out at 1020. So we're seeing delays,
14:40but a lot of people, Jen, there was just, there was no word. There was no information. So people had a plan B. Some people took off. They rented a car, started their drive. We caught up with a couple of folks who made the first flight out. It was an Atlanta flight. They boarded. They talked to us about, one had a loved one driving, who's two and a half hours from Atlanta to come pick them up. He had a caller and say, turn around, our flight is boarding right now. So they boarded, they took off, but there's still a lot of confusion because there's not a lot of direction. And I think that's what we're hearing from passengers here. It's not that this issue happened. It's how the issue was handled, how the communication sort of fell apart. They weren't,
15:20they had no idea what to do. So you saw passengers talking to airlines, airlines doing their best to help. But that information really lagged. So again, you're looking behind. There's still a handful of people who are hoping to get on a flight because, again, flights are moving. We're seeing flights leaving the gate and taxiing. So, you know, there is movement here. But the planes seem to be moving a bit quicker than even some of the information at this point, Jen, because we're just we're not hearing a lot of announcements. And that's because folks here at Jacksonville, there's not a lot of information to share. So passengers really leaning heavy on the airlines getting some direction. I know down in Terminal C, there's a flight that's boarding for Nashville to leave soon.
16:06And that's what it is. And there's a lot of frustration, Jen, at this point because people check their bags. Some passengers had medication in their bags. There was a lot of questions. And, Jen, just not a lot of answers. Back to you. Yeah. There is a trickle-down impact here when there isn't a lot of information from the top. It is hard to get that information out from airlines and to travelers. I want to bring in Josh and Mark. You've been with us all for so many hours. Thank you so much for being here with me. I'm sure we'll be talking to you more in the coming days, too, about all of this. So thank you. I want to bring in Polly Trattenberg, who's the former deputy transportation secretary under Pete Buttigieg.
16:46Polly, I think I know you were watching the press conference. We were all watching it. I think for people who don't know the vernacular and the language that was used, can you just share with us what your takeaways were, what you learned from that press conference, and maybe what big questions you still have? And first of all, thanks, Jen. Obviously, my heart goes out to the passengers and the frontline folks tonight, the folks at the FAA, the air traffic controllers, the airlines, the ground crews. It's been a rough night for everybody. And good news, at least, that the ground stop has been lifted. Look, I have to agree with you. Technical details were a little vague, and I'm sure there'll be a lot more information to come. You know,
17:23obviously, Secretary Duffy making a passionate plea for more funding for the FAA. And I think that's something in the aviation community, there's broad agreement that more investment is needed. I think his description in a way of the sort of the failings of the system that there's some real validity there. But I think there has to be a lot more of a nexus between what exactly has happened, what kind of dollars may be needed to solve any immediate problems. And then, as one of your reporters pointed out, we jumped from what was needed from $30 billion to $50 billion just basically tonight, and obviously wanting to know the details of that. Let me ask you a question that I think so many people
18:00watching, maybe they're in airports, maybe they've got loved ones who are traveling, maybe they got a flight in a couple days. You can't make an exact prediction, but from your experience, now that this ground stop has stopped, what does it take to get things up and running again? Can you just level set or expectation set for people out there? Yeah. And, you know, Jen, you mentioned what happened back a few years ago when we had the NOTAM outage, and it took a couple of days to dig out from under that. And that was sort of had the NOTAM outage, and it took a couple days to dig out from under that, and that was sort of a 90-minute outage. Obviously, the way the aviation system works now, so many pieces are kind of operating just in time. I suspect it will
18:36take a couple days to untangle this, but I think it is good news, again, that at least flights are starting to take off tonight. Partially, I think we'll see throughout the night how much progress the airlines can make and whether folks stayed in airports or found other ways to travel. Polly, I'm so grateful you could be here with us. Let me ask you before I let you go. Is there any, like, what big questions do you still have right now about what happened, why this decision was made? As we said, there wasn't a lot of information. We're learning a lot in the next couple of days, but you've been in the ground. What big questions do you have? I mean, look, in a situation like this, you really need to, as your reporters were pointing out,
19:18to say the systems got overloaded with data, there's a lot more you would want to know about exactly what happened there. And what are the dangers of it happening again. Obviously, that's your first question. But again, the deeper questions are, if we want to invest more in this air traffic control system and in modernizing our equipment, what's the best way to do it? We need more money, but we also need to make sure we have the right technology. And frankly, we have the right leadership and the right expertise in place to execute. And so I think it's partially a cry for more funding, but I think also it is a sort of a deeper discussion we need to have. And I'm sure leaders in Congress will want to be a
19:55part of that. How do we, $50 billion is a lot of money. How do we make sure when we spend it, that we get the results we need, that we get the system modernized, that it happens in real time, and that we don't have to deal with incidents like the ones we saw tonight. Polly Trottenberg, I'm so grateful with your expertise. You know, I think in the moments like this, we're all kind of wondering what the words mean, what we should take away from them. So thank you so much for being here with me tonight. Thanks so much, Jen. Okay, we have to take a quick break, but we'll continue following this breaking news story. Veteran pilot Keith Wolsinger is standing by. We'll be right back. Let's go, girls. So this is the little pink pill everyone's been talking about.
20:38Yep, that's Addy. Good things do come in small packages. And Addy is definitely a good thing. Not just good. It's. Oh, yeah. do come in small packages and addy is definitely a good thing not just good it's meet addy the little pink pill addy is a prescription medicine for women under 65 with hypoactive low sexual desire disorder that's distressing to them addy is for low desire that happens in all situations and isn't caused by a medical condition relationship issues or medicines addy isn't for men or to enhance sexual performance. Addy can cause severe low blood pressure and fainting. Your risk is higher if you drink alcohol close to your dose. Don't take Addy if you have liver problems. Take certain medicines or are allergic to any of its ingredients.
21:14Before taking Addy, tell your doctor about all the medicines you take. If you have had any mental health conditions, are pregnant, planning pregnancy, or breastfeeding. Side effects may include dizziness, nausea, tiredness, trouble sleeping, and dry mouth. Learn more at Addy.com, including important warnings. Use coupon code SXM for a $10 telemed appointment at Addi.com. I feel like a woman. Holiday drinks are now at McDonald's. Like the new Red Bull Frosted Cranberry Energizer. It's Red Bull meets cranberry flavors, topped with cold foam and sprinkles, made to charge your holiday spirit. Now at McDonald's. Bob Evans creamy mac and cheese and buttery mashed potatoes are made for those holiday moments you just can't plan for.
21:54Like when the neighbors burnt their holiday meal and you invited them over. Or that time when everyone's flights home were canceled and they stayed an extra two days. So when there is no plan, say hello to Plan B.O.B. When you bring out the Bob, you can take comfort this holiday season, knowing you'll always have something delicious on the table, no matter what the holidays bring. When you need comfort, bring out the country. In the last hour, the FAA has announced that the ground stop has been officially lifted, and that is definitely good news. are still many, many, many questions about what took place and the confusion it caused. Confusion that was especially evident when news of the ground stop spread throughout air traffic control
22:50radio earlier today. Take a listen. Southwest 2179, just a heads up. We went into a national ground stop, all aircraft with update unknown. Are you saying national like Reagan National or national the whole country? Across all enroute facilities, they're having communication issues. Hey, I was just wondering if you guys have any update on ground effect? Sorry, ground stop. A lot of 283 victors, Charlie. We are aware it's going to be at least eight hours. From what I understand, nobody's going anywhere for a while. Last I heard, the update is not until hours out right now. Joining me now is veteran pilot Keith Wolsinger. Keith, I'm so grateful you could be here with me because I think so many people watching this,
23:35I've been saying at airports or at homes, people are thinking about traveling and the Thanksgiving holiday or their family members. Just take us kind of into the cockpit and into a plane in moments like this. What makes it harder for pilots? What ability do they have? What should people understand about that? Oh, thanks for having me, Jen. Well, don't have a lot of control over a situation like this. We relay what information we get from our airline, which is, as you can tell, rather limited anyway, and explain the situation to the passengers. Try to call them as much as possible. There's a few things involved with the whole situation, right? So planes are prevented from departing. So at all
24:21the airports, the gates are occupied by existing airplanes that are waiting to leave. At the same time, there's planes rule that states that passengers have to be offered the opportunity to get off airplanes after a certain amount of time on the ground. And if they don't, the airlines are subject to a fine by the Department of Transportation. So when you have planes not able to depart and planes that have landed not able to unload their passengers at a gate, that creates a huge, huge bottleneck. On the crew side, crews are limited for a duty day of around 14 hours on domestic flights, which means that if they've been sitting around an airport for six hours and have to fly for more hours after that and then fly maybe a second flight, when they run out of the 14 hours or whatever their
25:26duty limit is for that operation, they can't fly anymore. So they have to go and take a rest period of between 10 and 12 hours, usually at a hotel, before they're legal to fly again. So that's why when flights are delayed for an extended period of time, you see the crews getting off the airplanes and leaving. And sometimes the airlines are nimble enough that they can replace those crews with fresh crews that have plenty of duty time available, sometimes not. And that's a case where sometimes flights have to spend an extra night before they can depart again. This is so helpful because this helps explain to people why, yes, the ground stop has ended, but it doesn't mean that everything's going to run smoothly moving forward
26:09because there are limitations in terms of how long, of course there are, in terms of how long crews can be on the plane and be working, I should say, in terms of where planes all go. As you've been watching this all unfold today, what do you think is the timeline for when this could kind of, when it could feel normal again? Do you have any sense of that or estimate of that in your experience? Well, on a national scale, not for many, many years, but as we've seen, individual airlines have had computer outages and glitches that have grounded an entire airline for some period of time. And as we've seen in the past, it could take up to a couple of days to rebuild the schedule, get the airplanes and the crews in place to resume normal operations. On a national scale,
26:57it's going to take at least probably a full day because the airplanes are there, the crews are there, and it's just a matter of organizing the crews, the airplanes, and the passengers to get airplanes moving again. So the planes that are on the gate, say overnight, tonight, will leave in the morning. The planes that are on the ground somewhere else on the airport will have to be repositioned onto the gate so that they can be loaded and have fresh crews and have the passengers getting on their way. So the airlines are doing the best they can. The crews are doing the best they can. The pilot unions, the flight attendant unions, the mechanics unions, everybody's going to be working around the clock to get this back on track, so to speak. One other thing I would say, though,
27:41that I was hoping I would hear something tonight from a representative from the FAA, which we did. I would have liked to have heard from the FAA administrator, the chief of the air traffic organization at the FAA, which oversees air traffic control. But sadly, we didn't see anything from any of those representatives. That's really helpful to know. What information would have been helpful to pilots directly from the FAA? I mean, there's a lot of questions out there still, but what information would have been useful? Well, the timeline would have been useful. And as we heard in the air traffic control transcripts, they didn't know. They gave hours, eight hours, no definitive answer. And when you're – let's say we pushed off the gate and we're departing
28:26in line for takeoff, you've got fuel, you can only sit out there for too long before you've burned enough fuel in taxi that now you don't have enough fuel left to complete the flight. So then you have to return to the gate, get more fuel, get back in line for takeoff again. In this case, whatever length of time people spent out on the taxi waiting for takeoff again. In this case, whatever length of time people spent out on the taxi waiting for takeoff was futile, and they had to return to the gate or some other holding position on the airport waiting for the fuel that probably was not going to come because they're not going to be released to depart the airport. So that's the main concern. And then we've got hundreds of passengers, hundreds of crews
29:08that may need overnight accommodation. You know, we don't want people camping out in the airport overnight, although that's happened in the past. And we see that, you know, it's not uncommon. We don't usually see crews camping out in the airport. That may happen in this case. I really couldn't say. Keith, I'm so grateful you could be here with us. Thank you so much for joining us tonight. Of course. With Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy pointing fingers at Congress, the Republican Congress, for today's massive ground stop and demanding $50 billion, we're going gonna get a reaction from incoming House Budget Chairman Brendan Boyle. He joins me next. In just the last hour, we finally heard
30:00from the Transportation Secretary about the four-plus-hour nationwide ground stoppage that delayed and canceled flights across the country. And right from the transportation secretary about the four-plus-hour nationwide ground stoppage that delayed and canceled flights across the country. And right from the start, he made it clear that he wanted to blame Congress. I think America demands that the Congress give the rest of the resources. The president's asked for $30 billion. I want $50 billion. And by the way, if you look at how much money Congress spends, Peter, you've covered Congress. They waste a lot of money. What's more important than having an air traffic control system that actually works? And so the president said, you know what? Let's finish this job.
30:35Sir, do you know that Republicans have controlled Congress for the past two years? They still control Congress, but there's that. Now that's about to change, though. So what does the incoming Democratic chair of the Budget Committee have to say about all of this? Actually, the perfect guess right now. Joining me now is Congressman Brendan Boyle, the man currently in line to become the next chair of the House Budget Committee next year. Okay, we were going to talk about an entirely different story, and we've got to do that soon, too. But now here you are. Sean Duffy, the Secretary of Transportation, Congress that is controlled by Republicans currently for not funding the FFA, the FAA, sorry, long day. What was your reaction to that? What should people understand about this
31:17whole process and the budgetary issues here? Yeah, great to be with you, Jen. I watched that entire White House briefing. Frankly, I think I'm dumber at the end of it for having watched it. We learned precious little about just what exactly happened today. Neither cabinet secretary seemed very interested in talking about that. Really, they spent most of the time, probably more than 90% doing two things. First, kissing up to Donald Trump at every opportunity possible. And then the second is they kept blaming Congress, the Republican-controlled Congress, for not giving them the money they supposedly are requesting. I find that interesting because besides the fact that he never mentioned that it's actually
32:01Republicans who run Congress, they neglected that just last year, they were pushing a 29% cut to transportation, HUD, and other agencies as part of the entire DOGE process. That suddenly has been forgotten, as well as the FAA workers. They were looking to furlough or force into early retirement. So a lot of short memories, it seems, with both of these cabinet secretaries and no answers about what exactly happened today and how we can prevent it from happening tomorrow. Yeah, I was more confused listening to the words coming out of their mouth than less, right? And all the experts I've been talking to felt pretty much the same way you and I did. So there's that. So let me ask you this. I mean, clearly, you know, the system is outdated. It
32:50needs more funding. There shouldn't have been cuts a year or two ago. As there were, the Republicans are not going to be in control in January. You got a lot of things you want to focus on. But how would you approach this? Because this is on Americans' minds right now. They worry about things being outdated, cyber threats, all of that. What do you think about it? Yeah, look, this has to be the latest wake-up call. Keep in mind, just last month, we had a ground stoppage for hours in Philadelphia, New York, and other parts of the very busy Northeast Corridor. I was one of the folks who was impacted by that. It's pretty clear these things are happening with increasing frequency. The fact we have an FAA system
33:29that's built on using floppy disks and the latest technology of 1989, come on. I mean, we really do need to fix this. I certainly would be willing to vote for a major appropriation to do this overhaul. I'm glad that the crowd that was bragging about Doge a year ago and making all sorts of deep cuts now actually wants to spend the resources. Fine. I'm willing to work with them. I accept that. Let's actually get this problem fixed once and for all. Congressman Brendan Boyle, there's so much to talk to you about. I hope you'll come back many times in the new year and even before then and talk about your plans and oversight and all the things you want to do. But I'm so glad you could be here tonight because it was quite a bizarre part of that press conference.
34:13So thank you again. Thanks, Jo. Okay, we have to take a quick break. But when we come back, MSNOW Chief Data Reporter Ali Velshi joins me. He's been keeping an eye on midterm results. He's also a pilot, but we're going to talk to him about midterm results. And he's going to give us the latest on uncalled races. We'll be right back. At Sutter, we promise to plan your knee replacement so you could be home the same day. To make scheduling a checkup as easy as booking a haircut. To open more urgent cares urgently. Caring for your health is a group effort. That's why there's a whole team on your team at Sutter Health. No extra logins. Just one subscription that gives you personalized AI right inside your actual workflow.
35:26Make work less work. Try Google Workspace with Gemini at goo.gle slash workspace with Gemini. Hi, I'm Cindy Lauper, Cosentix lead detective in the new mystery series, Unpredictable Symptom Squad. My team and I are on a curious case to gather clues about plaque psoriasis and psoriatic arthritis and learn how Cosentix treats both and can help stop further joint damage in psoriatic arthritis. Cosentix Secukinumab is prescribed for adults with moderate to severe plaque psoriasis and adults with active psoriatic arthritis. Don't use if allergic to Cosentix. Get checked for TB before starting. Increased risk of infections and lowered ability to fight them may occur, like TB or other serious bacterial,
36:09fungal, or viral infections. Some were fatal. Tell your doctor if you have an infection or symptoms like fevers, sweats, chills, muscle aches, or cough, had a vaccine or plan to, or if IBD symptoms develop or worsen. Serious allergic reactions and severe eczema-like skin reactions may occur. Learn more at 1-844-GOSENTIX or cosentix.com. Don't let mysterious symptoms go unsolved. Talk to your doctor about Cosentix. Election results are still coming in from key races across the country. We are, of course, still keeping a close eye on the last uncalled Senate race in Alaska. But meanwhile, over in the House, Democrats have flipped yet another seat to add to their majority. MSNOW can now project that the Democratic candidate in Colorado's 4th District, Eileen
36:55Laubacher, will defeat the Republican incumbent, Congresswoman Lauren Boebert. Colorado's 4th District is actually the second district Boebert has represented. After narrowly winning reelection in 2022, She moved there to run in a comfortable Republican seat. It wasn't so comfortable, it turned out. In 2024, Trump won this seat by 18 points. Now retired U.S. Navy Rear Admiral Eileen Laubacher has managed to flip it. Joining me now is MSNOW chief data reporter and host of the 11th Hour and pilot all the things, Ali Velshi. Help us understand. I mean, this is a big deal. We would not have thought this is the beginning of election night. It is it is races are still being called. What happened in Colorado for?
37:34Well, as you pointed out, this used to be Lauren Boebert's district, but she wanted to keep being Lauren Boebert and thought that this was the safer district for the reasons that you just expressed. So she goes into the fourth district. She gets challenged by Eileen Laubacher, who, by the way, 34 years, I think, in the military, she was a rear admiral when she retired, a Republican until 2025, by the way, served under the Biden administration, served on the Trump administration. So she runs in this race in a relatively conservative place. And to your point, take a look at how Lauren Boebert did in 2024, 53 to 42 over her opponent. And take a look at how Donald Trump did. She underperformed Donald Trump in this district in 2024 when she first moved there. And if you look one more election
38:16out, the 2022 House, Ken Buck outperformed both Donald Trump and Lauren Boebert, getting 61 percent to 36.6. So this is a remarkable story here that Lauren Boebert moved here. She physically moved her house and moved to this district because she thought it would be safer. And the irony is the person who replaced her in her old district, Jeff Hurd, was reelected in the third district of Colorado. So not a great strategic move on the part of Lauren Boebert. She will no longer be representing Colorado's fourth district. You know what they say about karma. Yeah. OK, let's talk about the Alaska Senate race, because this is still on. This could be the 56th seat for the Democrats. Where are things
38:54standing right now? 88 percent in. We sort of get an update every two days, and I think we're going to get one now sometime within the next couple of hours. So it jumped from 76 to 84 to 88. So hopefully we get a better number here. Mary Peltola is still below 50 percent. And that's tricky because once you get to 100 percent, if she's below 50, then this goes to ranked choice voting. The bottom person falls out. Their votes get redistributed based on who the second choices were. And then if that still doesn't get somebody to 50 percent, it happens a second time. The second and third choice in ranked choice voting are instantaneous, basically. So we think sometime between Tuesday and Thursday, if somebody doesn't get to 50 percent, we'll go to ranked choice voting.
39:33You do have to get to 100 percent of voting in order to go to ranked choice. So that's the thing that this this is slow. Alaska's got a lot of voters that are not on the road system. Mail takes a little longer than it does everywhere else. So this is slow. But at some point point we'll determine if Mary Peltola has not got 50% that it goes to ranked choice. But all the votes that are coming in, she's got a lead of 5,800 votes right now. They've generally been favoring her. So I would rather be Mary Peltola than Dan Sullivan, the Republican incumbent senator right now. So people who are waiting for that 56th Senate seat, perhaps, by Thanksgiving. What do we think? Could that happen? It could happen.
40:09Doesn't necessarily. One never can tell. This is a little tricky because there are votes missing all over Alaska. Not missing. That's the wrong word to use. There are votes yet to be counted all over Alaska. So it's a little hard to tell. But at the moment, everything favors Mary Peltola. But we'll see. Part of the problem with ranked choice voting is you don't actually know where the voters, where the two candidates, one or two candidates who have to pull out, where their second choice voters were placed. In ranked choice voting, by the way, you could have voted for all four candidates, but you don't necessarily have to vote for all four. So this becomes tricky. If she doesn't get 50 percent,
40:43we won't know until we know. Ali Velshi, love the vest today, the navy. We are matching. So I appreciate that as well. Thank you for taking the time and being with us as always tonight and giving us an update on everything. Thank you again. Okay. We'll be right back, everyone. Oh, beautiful for spacious skies There's more hope for tomorrow. This is what tomorrow seems like! More change within reach. Help! Help! Help! Moments like this remind us what's at stake. We will be counted. And how it feels to be part of something bigger. We're gonna rise and stand strong together. We're lucky in the United States to be able to vote. We just need change. Oh, wait, there it is. There's more of us. The crowd here is celebrating.
41:37More of us getting involved. There's immense emotion here. The vibes are strong. This is a seismic change in Washington. That's democracy in action. And now, there's more that connects us. Join us. That does it for me tonight. Real talent is defined by what people can do, not where they learn to do it. That does it for me tonight. story unfold and gain a competitive advantage because hiring managers who start with skills are 60% more likely to find a successful hire. Hire skills first. Learn why at tearthepaperceiling.org. Brought to you by Opportunity at Work and the Ad Council.

