podcasts / Still Counting / episode
Still Counting cover art
podcast
📅 2026-11-12 ⏱ 83 min episode · ~2 min read 📝 Transcript · 14,783 words

12: Where Do Republicans Go From Here?

Still Counting · · Transcript & summary by WhipScribe

Three election analysts sort through the midterm wreckage and then draft the 2028 Republican field, with real data behind the jokes.

Read the transcript Episode page ↗
In this episodeCook Political ReportSabato's Crystal BallJ.D. VanceMarco RubioRon DeSantisTucker CarlsonBobby KennedyBrian KempThomas MasseyStephen MillerDonald TrumpEzra Klein

▸Chapters

Tap a chapter to play it from that moment in the show's own player; the transcript opens there too.

Transcribe your links. Paste a YouTube, Google Drive or podcast link and WhipScribe gives you the transcript. Transcribe a link →

▸Notable quotes

“I can't be held accountable for anything I say on today's podcast.” Galen Druk · at 0:00 — ▶ hear it from here

▸What this episode covers

The hosts open by taking stock of the 2026 midterms, which were a bad result for Republicans. Galen Druk and Nate Silver point to the 53 House districts Trump carried that will now have Democratic representatives, to Democrats flipping 12 state legislative chambers, and to new trifectas in six swing states. They then examine the Mississippi Senate race, where a Democratic candidate's late surge exposed how national race-rating groups had written the state off, and they weigh whether those raters or the fundraising environment bear responsibility.

The second part turns to the direction of the Republican Party. The hosts describe its factions as a K-shaped structure, with establishment figures, highbrow conservatives, national populists and a Trump-aligned middle, and sketch three possible responses: more populism, a return to conservative principles, or better governance on the Florida model. They also weigh how Fox News and podcasts shape the message, and whether Donald Trump's lame-duck status opens room for rivals.

The show closes with a 2028 Republican primary draft played for laughs and for argument. Claire Malone opens with J.D. Vance, while Nate Silver favors Marco Rubio and Ron DeSantis, and later picks include Tucker Carlson, Bobby Kennedy, Brian Kemp and Chris Christie. The hosts check the picks against RealClearPolitics polling averages, where Vance leads, and end by declaring Nate the winner.

▸12: Where Do Republicans Go From Here? on Still Counting: the answers

What did Galen Druk say about Cook Political Report?

Galen Druk was skeptical that Cook Political Report cost Democrats races. He said that a race in a state Trump won by 23 points would have been nationalized to Republicans' benefit, which is why the Mississippi Senate race stayed under the radar.

“made Democrats lose races that they otherwise could have won because they would have spent more money there.”Galen Druk · 7:57

What did Nate Silver say about Patrick Rooney?

Nate Silver said Republicans do not have real factions because the party is unhealthy. He described Patrick Rooney, a friend of the show, as the source of the idea that the party is a K-shaped Republican Party, with an establishment lane, highbrow conservatives, national populists and Marco Rubio caught in between.

“So Patrick Rooney, friend of the show, calls it the K-shaped Republican Party.”Nate Silver · 24:49

What did Claire Malone say about J.D. Vance?

Claire Malone said her heart favored Marco Rubio for the 2028 Republican nomination, but her head told her J.D. Vance was the correct first pick. She said Vance looked less strong as a 2028 candidate because he is closely tied to the Iran war.

“Marco Rubio has my heart. J.D. Vance has my head.”Claire Malone · 39:32

What did Nate Silver say about Mississippi?

Nate Silver said the expert ratings agencies had the wrong picture of the race until far too late, in part because they assumed a presidential-style midterm environment. He argued that the good forecasting models all reached similar results by different routes, while the rating agencies did not.

“meanwhile, the expert ratings agencies really had the incorrect picture of the race until way too late, right?”Nate Silver · 5:52

What is Still Counting's main argument about the Republican Party after the 2026 midterms?

The hosts argue that Republicans took a crushing loss in the 2026 midterms, that the party is unhealthy and split into a K-shaped set of factions, and that the 2028 field is wide open. They also say Democrats are two-to-one favorites for 2028 in prediction markets, though Donald Trump's lame-duck status leaves room for Republicans to recover.

Mentioned in this episode

Episode facts

Released
November 12, 2026
Length
1 hour 23 minutes

▸Key takeaways

01Republicans lost badly in the 2026 midterms, and Democrats now hold full trifectas in six swing states including Arizona, Michigan and Pennsylvania.
02Expert race raters like Cook Political Report treated Mississippi as out of reach for Democrats, and the 2026 Senate race only looked close late in the cycle.
03After 2024 only 16 House seats split from the top of the ticket, but Democrats will represent at least 53 districts Trump won.
04A Mississippi Democrat blamed national race raters for weak fundraising, but Galen Druk said nationalizing a state Trump won by 23 points would help Republicans.
05Prediction markets make Democrats two-to-one favorites for 2028, and the hosts say Trump's lame-duck status leaves Republicans room to recover.

▸Questions this episode answers

Q1What did Nate Silver say about expert race ratings and the 2026 midterms?

Nate Silver argued that expert race-rating agencies had a bad 2026 midterm election because they assumed a presidential-style year despite Trump's approval rating and the usual midterm pattern. He said they were slow to correct their picture of races like Mississippi, where a Democratic candidate's late chances surprised them. Silver also said polls, fundamentals and prediction markets all move through a campaign, so election-day snapshots can mislead.

Q2What did Galen Druk say about Cook Political Report's Mississippi rating?

Galen Druk was skeptical that Cook Political Report cost Democrats races. He said a race in a state Trump won by 23 points would have been nationalized to Republicans' benefit, which is why the Mississippi race stayed under the radar. He noted Democrats were outfunded roughly three to one against the Republican incumbent until internal polling showed the race was closer.

Q3What did Galen Druk say about Democrats winning House seats Trump carried?

Galen Druk said that after 2024 only 16 House seats were held by a party different from the top-of-ticket winner, but in the new Congress Democrats will represent at least 53 districts Trump won. He argued those 53 lawmakers cannot simply vote with their party, and that the number shows the country is less stuck in the mud than people assume.

Q4What did Nate Silver say about the Republican Party's factions after the midterms?

Nate Silver said Republicans do not have real factions because the party is unhealthy. He described a K-shaped party, citing Patrick Rooney's framing: a center-right establishment including Nikki Haley and Glenn Youngkin, highbrow conservatives such as Ron DeSantis and Ted Cruz, and national populists like Josh Hawley and J.D. Vance, with Marco Rubio caught between lanes.

Q5Why did Claire Malone pick J.D. Vance first in the 2028 Republican draft?

Claire Malone picked J.D. Vance first because her head said he was the correct choice for a number one pick, even though her heart favored Marco Rubio. She said Vance is closely tied to the Iran war and looks less strong as a 2028 candidate, but he is clearly dedicated to running, which made him the safer pick.

Q6Who won the 2028 Republican draft on Still Counting?

The hosts declared Nate Silver the winner of the Still Counting 2028 Republican draft. Claire Malone's picks were J.D. Vance, Thomas Massey, Bobby Kennedy and Chris Christie. Silver's picks included Marco Rubio, Ron DeSantis, Tucker Carlson and Brian Kemp, and Vance led the RealClearPolitics average the hosts checked.

▸Transcript

Our own transcript of the public episode, with a timestamp about every 90 seconds. Tap a timestamp to play the episode from there in the show's own player; the link button on a paragraph copies a link that opens this page there.

0:00Guys, I can't be held accountable for anything I say on today's podcast. I'm fully strung out on Sudafed. So glad I'm sitting right in range of your spittle. Welcome to Still Counting. I'm Galen Druk. I'm Claire Malone. I'm Nate Silver. Yeah, you are. I remain. Estoy. Not estoy. You are permanently Nate Silver. Yeah. That's what I was trying to express. Are you at all bilingual? Galen's like trilingual. I tried to keep that on the deal. Quattrolingual. I tried to keep that on the deal. I can read menus really well because I like to eat and I know a lot about. That says taco. And here's where we're going to have Galen say something in Italian. Tell me how beautiful I look. Ma quanto sei bella, Claire?

0:47Tell me you like my aubergine sweater. Mi piaccio un sacco. No, I don't know how to say aubergine. On today's show, we're going to talk about what went wrong for Republicans in the midterms. How crushing the loss was. I mean, crushing. Yeah, crushing. That's our analysis. How leaders in the party have reacted over the past week and what might come next including our 2028 republican party oh shit I didn't do any prep presidential draft and Nate will be doing it from the seat of his pants which is basically like everything he does no offense that's not really true as Galen has said, Nate is the hardest working girl in showbiz. Don't let anyone forget that. He's just really bad at answering emails.

1:31Okay. We're also going to talk about the emerging beef between one Democratic Senate candidate and the expert race-rating groups like Cook Political Report and Sabato's Crystal Ball. But first, a very important announcement. You should subscribe to our podcast. You should subscribe to our podcast. You should subscribe to it on YouTube, in your RSS feed. You should tell your college group chat about us because we think they would really like us. And it helps us when you subscribe and review and rate the show and share it. And you want to help us, don't you? Yeah. It's like post-election. Like sometimes there's a lull in these kinds of things. That's right. But we're relying on you to help us get through the three-week period between the midterms

2:11and when the 2028 primaries begin. So, yeah. I mean, even giving us a review, you know, like, you know, it's free to give a review. Go share the love. That's right. Yeah. And we're still going to be here making podcasts for i know some people were like oh are you gonna be done now that the midterms are over you mean are we gonna stop counting no it's in the name folks we're still counting okay all right so let's get to this is the state of mississippi and alaska look at that professional transition he goes silver is an audio professional call me mississippi because I'm still counting. Okay. As I teased in the intro, let's talk about Mississippi, where District Attorney Scott Palome is very likely on track to defeat incumbent Senator Cindy Hyde-Smith and win another seat

2:57for the Democrats. You may know Scott Palome for his viral ads like, pick another protein. Shit. I'd rather pick another senator instead. That's right. Which talked about, that was really good, Galen, which talked about the cost of beef. But this race largely did not get national attention until very late in the game when a Chuck Schumer aligned super PAC dropped some money and everyone realized that it was a lot closer than expected. And Scott Colombe has been telling a different story. He has been criticizing the media, Democrats and race raiders like Cook Political Report very specifically for writing Mississippi Democrats off in this cycle. And he called out Cook Political in a pretty viral tweet, I would say, and also mentioned

3:43other on-air prognosticators, as he called them, who, by rating his race and other Southern races as out of reach for Democrats, it made it, quote, much more difficult to fundraise and are part of the reason the South has been neglected for so long, close quote. He also expanded on this point with a hit on MS Now on Monday. Here's a clip. You know, and I'll tell you this, The thing about political report is there was one guy that I tried to explain to him the potential in Mississippi and why the rating was wrong. And he wouldn't even listen to me. He basically acted like he knew more about Mississippi politics than me. And I'm like, thinking in the back of my mind, he's being so condescending to me.

4:22I've been practicing Mississippi politics for 20 years, buddy. I've never even seen you in Mississippi. Okay. This was a spicy little entree into election Twitter. And I, for one, found it very interesting. Nate, what'd you make of it? Did you and Scott Colum talk before he tweeted this? We did not. And we should say Flipper, for all its success, doesn't really want to talk about Mississippi. I know. Y'all gave Democrats a 5% chance. 4 point something percent, I think. In the polls only version, it was like 9%. There weren't very many polls. So it's just saying, I don't know what. Ironically, the fake Wedgwood poll was in Mississippi that kind of was most suspicious. And then in our deluxe version, which layers in expert ratings, then it's four, but also based on the fundamentals of Mississippi, right?

5:11This race is a real surprise. Personally, it's a race where I'm happy. I think it's a really fun 4% to come in. You know what I mean? It does signify something unlikely that happened. I think that expert ratings agencies had a really bad election, right? One point I emphasize is, you can't just count where people are on election day, because strategies are planned throughout the campaign, people are viewing your page throughout the campaign, people are prediction markets, like trading throughout the campaign, right? And so like, there are all these debates over what about Flipper versus Kelshi versus whatever else on election day and it's all within – I mean there were some good models and some not so good models.

5:52All the good models and there were like four of them, right? Like all wound up in the same place but they got there in different ways. Like meanwhile, the expert ratings agencies really had the incorrect picture of the race until way too late, right? They, for some reason, thought we're going to be in a presidential type year environment despite all the signs like President Trump's approval rating, despite the long history of the midterms. It's just a really weird thing to anchor to. I think part of what happened is that like in 2024, 2020, those years, the House is pretty neutral, right? In 2022, you had a below average wave, I mean a red ripple against Biden, which was surprising in its own way, right?

6:35So they haven't gotten burned by this in a while. But I think they are supposed to be rating individual races and they're supposed to provide things that the polls or the fundamentals might miss. And let's talk about that. Like for people who don't know, and I have to confess, and I want to follow up on something you said there about the differences between race raters and maybe modelers and push a little bit. But before we do that, Galen, what do people like Cook, what are the inputs into their predictions? Like, what are the things that they're actually using? Because I was actually thinking about it. I haven't really thought that deeply about it. So what is Cook using to rate those races? Yeah, they're using some of the same

7:15tools as forecasters like Nate. They're using the publicly available polls. They're also talking to the candidates and assessing how good they are as candidates. They're looking at private polls. So there's not as much public polling done in a lot of House races in particular, for example. So they see some of that private polling in a place like Mississippi or South Carolina, where some of the private polling was never made public, even in Senate races. They look at some of that stuff. But, you know, I am thinking about Scott Clum's assessment, if he's saying that Cook Political Report was wrong on its assessment of Mississippi, point taken. But I do wonder if his point is, you know, people like Cook Political Report

7:57made Democrats lose races that they otherwise could have won because they would have spent more money there. I'm skeptical of that. Because if you look at South Carolina, Annie Andrews' campaign said, we had internal polling that showed us winning, and we kept it private. We didn't make it public because we didn't want this race nationalized, because we worried that if it became nationalized, that would be to our detriment. So if Cook Political Report had been out there saying, oh, you know, Mississippi is a toss up or something like that. This is a state that Trump won by 23 percentage points. A state like that that becomes nationalized, I don't think is to Democrats benefit. So having this kind of

8:38slip under the radar and Scott Colom is able to run, you know, this pretty good campaign on more populist issues where he talks about, you know, he pretty good campaign on more populist issues where he talks about, you know, he's a former Republican, his dad worked for Reagan, all this kind of stuff. You know, Republican turnout is not juiced there because it's not nationalized, but Democrats still get excited and they're already angry at Trump. And I'll just say also when it comes to funding, I mean, he said like, oh, races are going to be underfunded for Democrats in the South because of moves like this. They were outfunded, you know, three to one relative to Cindy Highsmith. And yes, a lot of those dollars came in later in the race once they had internal polling that showed that

9:13it was closer, they were up or whatever. But I think this is kind of how these things go. And actually, I think if it had the race been nationalized, yeah, it wouldn't have been to Scott Klum's benefit. It's kind of funny because, first of all, there was a decent amount of campaign activity in Mississippi. Pete Buttigieg campaigned there. Kamala Harris campaigned there, for example. I think Matt Iglesias said in our election night live stream that, like, Democrats thought this is when they might have a chance, right? So that was weird. Yeah, I spent video – actually, I spent time yesterday watching video of, like, all the emerging stars of 2026 for a piece I'm working on. And Column has an interesting, I mean, a lot of the more successful candidates have some means of code switching when they're talking to different audiences, right?

9:58And you see the ads and they're very funny and creating a permission structure to be like, well, just like you might get a different hamburger, right? Then why not pick a different sandwich? This one was kind of lame, right? And he's smiling and funny, right? You watch him on like, you know, shows for black audiences and it's more vernacular. You see him at local events and he comes across as very much a product of his state, right? Well, he does a lot of talking to Trump voters. I mean, one of his videos was him talking to Trump voters standing in line for a Trump rally where he's like, what are you worried about? And then he wrote, I mean, it's kind of like monotony. He can't have sharp elbows.

10:32Yeah, so finish the point. Are you saying that he was speaking to the fundraising class, like the MS Now class? There's obviously a bunch of Democratic Party insidery events coming up these next couple of weeks. No, I don't think he's doing that. I think he was speaking to Mississippians as compared to someone like Annie Andrews where Annie Andrews clearly wants to be a big star, right? He wanted to win his race and that worked too, but he wanted to win a race in Mississippi and I don't know that national attention. Also, I don't think it's a job of political raiders to care what impact it has on the parties. You know what I mean? It was interesting. I mean, I will say, you know, pulling back the curtain on my commute here,

11:17I was listening to Adam Jentleson on the Ezra Klein show. I have not listened to the full conversation because my train ride ended and I had to come record our podcast. But Jentleson's book basically talks about like how do Democrats build a supermajority over. They basically want to recreate like the FDR over a decade of super supermajority power for Democrats. And I sort of interpret maybe you're sort of saying the same thing. I sort of interpreted the the Scott Cologne thing as like come to play in Mississippi. Right. Like that we are that like recruit candidates like pay attention to us, that it was a little bit like that. It was kind of pay attention to the South, which which I think has become a strain of real argumentation in this post

12:08blue wave. Yeah, I think what Nate was saying that like on the stump during the 2026 race, Scott Cologne was speaking to a Mississippi audience. This kind of mini fight that he's picking with Cook Political Report, I think is in service of something else now, which is, yes, saying go spend money in the South. And look, at a certain point, not in this election or even the aftermath, Democrats are going to have to think about how slowly they do seem to be doing worse in the North and slowly they seem to be doing better and sometimes not so slowly, sometimes in one fell swoop, they seem to be doing better in the South. So is there a longer term realignment? You know, that's a dangerous word here. But is there a longer term realignment? You know,

12:49that's a dangerous word here. But if there is, then Republicans are going to have to get more comfortable campaigning in the North. And they have been leaving a whole bunch of races uncontested in a lot of places in the Northeast and so on. And Democrats are going to have to get more comfortable campaigning in the South in places where they have. Yeah, 2000 since 2008. Democrats have won a U.S. Senate race in 43 of the 50 states. They added, assuming these races are called, Mississippi this year, Alaska, Kansas, Texas, and Maine, where you actually hadn't had a capital D Democrat in a long time. I might be missing one there, potentially. Oh, South Carolina. Yeah. some races were really close. There wasn't a lot of polling in certain states like Mississippi, South Carolina, Tennessee, and that maybe some things could have pushed things over the edge.

13:50How do you think you go about navigating that nationalized race versus localized, tailor-made candidate for a state thing? That's a really actually kind of difficult balance to strike in a lot of ways. I mean, the way that a lot of Democrats did it in 2026 was by creating distance from their own party. Like, first and foremost, what you hear from somebody like Rob Sand or Adam Hamilton or Scott Colombe is either, well, from Scott Colombe, my dad worked for reagan yeah or from rob sand you know left wing right wing same same bird right is sort of saying this whole yeah two-party system it's bullshit anyway like i'm post-partisan or i'm anti-politics i mean we've seen this in other countries too

14:36that anti-politics is popular more like take a step back harder to do that when you're a sitting senator or sitting governor though of course yeah but like also you know you can always just fudge it make things up whatever you know that is true that like you saying politicians lie yes exactly the outsider position is like a tale as old as time in american politics reagan did it trump did it you know obama did it as a sitting senator to be clear uh and so i think that while in this very moment, there are plenty of partisans on the left who are very excited about what just happened and so on. Like, I still think that broadly, Americans don't really like politics. And one of the best ways to and especially like what's going on in politics now and one

15:19of the best ways to relate to people is by agreeing with them that the system is broken. It has become overly conflictual and unpleasant. And you kind of like put yourself, it's a populist way of putting yourself with the people when you kind of trash pop. Well, Sand is unusual in that he actually comes across as quite angry. Like his affect is not chill. Rob Sand. Yeah. Not chill like Adam Hamilton, right? He needs to smile more. He's got a great smile. Reverse sexism, we love it. Oh my god. But these candidates have a lot of interesting texture, right? They're all quite interesting, especially that like Sand, Andrews, Colm, he hosts a group. They all have different ways of creating distance with their parties.

16:09Because you have to show some anger. I mean, I don't want to steal a feature column. So we'll talk about this when the column comes out. But yeah. Anger in American politics. Interesting. I mean, in Rob Sand's case, it might just be his smoldering Zoolander face, right? Well, the House candidate in Montana, Sam Forstack, who was also an above-average-looking gentleman, one might say, also doesn't smile very much. Nate, I actually pitched the New York Times opinion section on a piece called Will Hot Politicians Fix What Ails Us? back in May, which they rejected. But I went and I did the research. I did the research and I found that across many different countries, different political systems, there's a benefit in electoral politics to being hot. research, I did the research, and I found that across many different countries, different

16:45political systems, there's a benefit in electoral politics to being hot. But that benefit decreases. Yes, but that benefit decreases significantly as partisanship goes up. And so in the same way that the penalty for scandals has been going down recently, the benefit for being hot has been going down recently as well, because people care more about the R or the D than they care about whether you're hot or scandal free. I actually really love that. One of the things that would fix American politics is if we got to a place where people were more persuaded by, on one hand, scandals and rejecting people who are sort of like scandalous and not fit to serve. And on the other hand, it would be a sign that our politics is

17:23maybe curing itself if we had hotter people in public office. Who do you think our ugliest president was? This pitch did not get accepted. This pitch was rejected. Although I think that November 3rd was, I don't know, a testament to the fact that it was a good idea. Any of those people who look like oil painting presidents, like it's hard. Unfortunately, guys, young Stalin. Hot. Hot. I know. Yeah. I yeah i know okay let's not get ourselves let's talk about republicans still counting is brought to you by zip recruiter we are in peak back to school post labor day everyone's so busy everyone's trying to save time i mean if i know a busy man it's it's nate how are you trying to save time? I hate to admit it. I've kind of become a open the laptop in the cab kind of guy, right?

18:11Red flag. Oh, red flag. Car sickness prevents me from doing that. But anyway, we all have our time saving hacks for everyday life. But if you're a business owner, how can you save time hiring? That's ZipRecruiter. ZipRecruiter has a new feature that quickly lets you see the most interested, qualified candidates first. So you save time by meeting the right people faster. And right now, you can try it for free at ZipRecruiter.com slash counting. ZipRecruiter's powerful matching technology finds qualified candidates quickly. Candidates tell you in their own words why they're interested in your job. No wonder ZipRecruiter is the number one rated hiring site based on G2. Save time and meet great candidates sooner. Maybe you can even stop working on your laptop in the cab, you know, if you save

18:58all that time from ZipRecruiter. With ZipRecruiter, four out of five employers who post on ZipRecruiter get a quality candidate within the first day. Try it for free at ZipRecruiter. Four out of five employers who post on ZipRecruiter get a quality candidate within the first day. Try it for free at ZipRecruiter.com slash counting. That's ZipRecruiter.com slash counting. Meet your match on ZipRecruiter. Still Counting is brought to you by Wild Alaskan Company. Galen, I hear tell that you are eating a lot of brain food, a.k.a. fish from Wild Alaskan lately. Yeah. Wild Alaskan, in a fortuitous way, accidentally sent me Nate's portion of the fish that we were going to try out as well. So I had two big boxes of Wild Alaskan Company fish hanging out in my freezer throughout election season.

19:42I kid you not, pretty much. it was like, it's one of those periods of time where like, you don't realize you're hungry until you're starving because you're working so much. You know, go to my freezer, take it out, pop it in the air fryer, 13 minutes, make a little rice meal, done, full. Like, I don't have to worry about food for another five hours. It's the beauty of fish. It cooks up quick. And Wild Alaskan Company offers the best way to get wild-caught, high-quality seafood delivered to your door on your schedule. Each Wild Alaskan box comes with individually portioned fillets, vacuum-sealed, easy to prep, and great for any meal, no matter how quick or how elevated. All the fish is quick-frozen, fresh from Alaskan waters,

20:21which helps lock in its freshness, texture, flavor, and other key nutrients like omega-3s. Fish you can trust with no GMOs, antibiotics, or other additives. And every order supports sustainable harvesting practices and Alaskan fishermen whose history is tied to the region and practice. Wild Alaskan is so confident that their fish is best that they offer a 100% satisfaction and money back guarantee. So you can try your first box risk-free. Go to wildalaskan.com slash count for $35 off your first order of premium wild caught seafood. That's wildalaskan.com slash count for $35 off your first order. Thanks to Wild Alaskan Company for sponsoring this episode. so poorly in the midterms, cost of living, the price of gas and diesel as a result of the Iraq War, Freudian slip as a result of the Iran War. Keep that in because it's just actually quite

21:33true. Just echoes of history. Corruption and their unwillingness to or inability for Republican candidates to distance themselves from Trump. But we wanted to talk about how Republicans have reacted in the past week or so and where the party goes from here. Galen, are there any stats or that really stand out to you in this week about what demonstrates the scale of those losses for Republicans? Yeah. I mean, I think one in particular dovetails off of what we were just talking about, which is having cross-partisan appeal. You know, after 2024, there were only 16 seats, congressional seats in the entire country that were represented by a representative from a different party than the person who won

22:25at the top of the ticket. 13 were Democrats representing Trump won seats. Three were Republicans representing Kamala Harris won seats. In this Congress, Democrats will be representing at least 53 House districts that Trump won. So that says something about sort of where Democrats were able to compete and break down partisan barriers and whatnot. I mean, it also tells you something about what the incentives are going to be of those 53 lawmakers who can't just sort of like hook, line and sinker agree with Democrats, probably. So that's that's one thing. I mean, that's just like a really large number, especially, you know, as we talk about our politics being so stuck in the mud, I think for people who have

23:15been paying attention for the past decade, a lot has happened underneath the top line that suggests we aren't as stuck in the mud as people like to think we are. But that's that's one stat. I mean, the other stat is that Democrats flipped 12 state legislative chambers. That's me, really. Yeah. And I think like Democrats have been playing catch up in some ways since 2010, when I think it was they lost over 500 state legislative seats in one fell swoop in that, you know, sort of Tea Party energized midterm. And they now have trifectas in Arizona, Michigan, Minnesota, Nevada, Pennsylvania, and Wisconsin. All of those basically being swing states. I mean, maybe minus Minnesota. You could make the argument. Who knows?

24:06But that says something dramatic about we've all been focusing on the Senate so much. I just want to sort of point out how severe some of these losses were in the House and in state legislative chambers. It's really true. Nate, I feel like one of your skills has always been kind of creating buzzy names for different tracks of, you know, you had the wine and beer voters. Maybe you didn't come up with that, but you used it a lot. I'm kind of curious how you've been metabolizing all the news about Republicans and where you see the biggest, you know, factions. Or how you would characterize the different factions of people, obviously, like Ron DeSantis and Vance, you know, were quick on the Twitter trigger finger.

24:49But like, how are you thinking through the past week of news from Republicans? I don't think you really have factions because you don't have a healthy party. So Patrick Rooney, friend of the show, calls it the K-shaped Republican Party. There is a little bit of a center right establishment, he claims. Nikki Haley, for example, Glenn Youngkin. Then you have conservatives. You have the kind of highbrow conservatives like Ron DeSantis, Ted Cruz, maybe Thomas Massey. People who literally went to Ivy League or MIT. Is that what it means? Highbrow populists? Yeah. You have the low ground, his terms, not mine, for the president of the United States, Donald Trump, who deserves our respect. But he can sometimes be a little bit vulgar.

25:34The office deserves our respect. And then various people in the middle. National populists, he calls Josh Hawley and J.D. Vance. And then he has Marco Rubio stuck in between that rotting establishment lane sitting on the couch staring blankly ahead yeah and usually to be somewhere in the middle is how you win you know to appeal to multiple lanes right um but like it's not as much dimensionality as you see in like the the democratic i don't know i think this is a little bit too complicated to be honest okay coming out of the results on Tuesday night, I see three different buckets of people, which is people You said that you were going to carry the mantle of the little guy, like all you do is hang out with the little guy. The ban on war room listeners.

26:29Yeah, exactly. So like it was you didn't do the populism that you said you were going to do, and that's how you lost. Then there's people like Mike Pence writing an op-ed in the Wall Street Journal that are saying, this is a sign that we need to return to our conservative principles. And you have Nikki Haley on CBS and whatnot, and other folks sort of saying that as well. So that's bucket one, more populism. Bucket two, go backwards in order to go forwards. And bucket three is sort of like, that's all beside the point, we need better governance, which is like Ron DeSantis' argument, like, look at the Florida, you know, free state of Florida. Like, we have been able to rebut the Democratic wave because we've had,

27:10yeah, we've taken care of your social issues, but we're also doing good on the economy and we're running the state well. And I see that, I see those as the kind of three buckets merging. It's interesting. I I think Nate is right that there is it isn't it is a unhealthy party that is going through a lot of stuff. The one thing I've been thinking is kind of putting my media reporter hat back on is in this two year period. I mean, less than right once people like really declare their candidacy. Which of these factions not only can coalesce around something, a message that really resonates, obviously, they're sort of the anti-war in Iran stuff is the strongest leg to stand on. But also kind of what catches fire with like Fox News, like it or not, that's a huge part of the Republican ecosystem. I mean, you definitely have the podcast ecosystem, but like Tucker, even though Tucker's like out there with his own political faction, he's nowhere near as visible as he was when he was on Fox. So I still feel like the Murdoch, you know, benediction of a

28:27message that, you know, if it it can it can really matter. I mean, there has there have been sort of revolts of the the Republican Party base to, you know, what they're hearing on Fox and that will sometimes cow Fox. But I just think it's like they have to figure out a message kind of quickly because these people are going to start declaring their candidacy relatively soon. And I mean, Marco Rubio, I think, is his own kind of interesting question. I don't want to like preview our Republican primary draft too much. But I just think that there's a real, I don't know, like it's really open season and you kind of have to hearken back to like the 2012 autopsy when they did kind of have this radical,

29:16from the top, they were like, we got to radically rethink this. And now it's kind of this bubbling up from the bottom where they radically have to rethink this. And they're in the same place they were 10 years ago. They spent the first week after the election learning that the CEO of NBA, Jensen Huang, had cheated with a Chinese spy. And he's been, I don't know if he's a Trump stan, probably not, but you know, but he's a friend of Trump, right? They call each other. The Secretary of Defense, Pete Hicksetheth was trying to fend off impeachment. Stephen Miller was elevated above one of the regarded as more competent, less F-word people in the White House. And Susie Wiles, right? You know, none of these things seem like good news. Meanwhile, you know, every little ballot dump that comes into Mississippi brings Democrats one state closer to winning Mississippi.

30:06You know, and on top of that, we had a hot inflation report. It looks like an interest rate spike is is plugged in at this point. So, yeah, I mean, this is you might call it Republicans in disarray. Well, but I mean, like, how do we think? Because it's it's true. Like the Stephen Miller appointment, you know, even though Trump went on 60 Minutes and was like, I love Jim Jordan. Well, that's what I say. So, like the Stephen Miller appointment coupled with Jim Jordan becoming the leader of the House Republicans does sort of say, like, all right, we're we're spitting angry and we're going to fight all the way down. But how did like I guess this is my it's a better way to frame my question is like,

30:50do the Fox News and other influencers buy that we're fighting as we go down or do they kind of do what they did on election night, which was say like, man, Trump really kind of screwed us and we've got to find other ways because he's on his way out. And I genuinely like this is why this is the one of the most interesting elections. It's the way I felt like curiosity wise coming out of 2016 is because I genuinely don't know how they're going to go. I feel like often in the Trump era, it's been like, well, they're probably going to keep with the momentum of like just like fight the Democrats no matter what. But I do feel like the Rand Pauls and the Thomas Massey faction does have like a decent amount of

31:34attention that could grow. I don't know. I think somewhat similar to the Democratic side, arguments over leadership right now are not necessarily going to transfer over to presidential primary fights in that like the people who remain in Congress right now, especially in the House, because all of the seats were up for election are more diehard because the frontline moderates or people who are cross pressured have all lost their races. And so in that sense, I guess Jim Jordan makes sense. For Donald Trump, it is weird because he's kind of saying he wants to out of one side of his mouth, he's saying he wants to work with Democrats. Out of the other side of his mouth, he's saying that he's elevating Stephen Miller, which those two things don't

32:11necessarily seem compatible. But he's a lame duck. He's never cared about how Republicans do if it's not him himself on the ballot. I mean, look, if I were, look, the fact is that prediction markets, Democrats are two to one favorites to win in 2028, which is a lot for an open seat election given how close the American presidency tends to be. Yeah, no, I mean, look, if I were trying to paint a optimistic case for Republicans, right, I'd say, well, Democrats might nominate somebody that either is crazy or we can peg as crazy, right? Probably some mean reversion on the economy. Maybe we'll start to see more tangible dividends from AI and we'll figure out something in Iran. And just removing Trump from the scene might help a little bit.

32:58And maybe Democrats are a little cocky after 2026, right? Like it's not crazy that story right i mean ultimately the in many ways democrats were used as a tool to punish republicans more than their worldview if you look at like all the there are a lot of ballot initiatives and in general conservatively tinged ballot initiatives did well and liberal ones failed the wealth tax failed in california by quite a bit which is the end of the day. Which is such a funny, the shoe is on the other foot situation because so often you'll hear progressives say like, okay, well, in places like Missouri or whatever, you see that they're raising the minimum wage while they're also electing a Republican senator

33:37or governor or what have you. And it's like in California and wherever else they are electing Democrats while saying we don't want a wealth tax, or they're taking the more conservative position on trans issues or things like that. And so in some ways, the shoe is on the other foot. I don't know what that ultimately portends. But I think that this is, we've talked so many times about the winners over interpreting their mandate. I don't know that this is, we're all about to find out because they didn't run on a platform of these are the 10 issues that we're going to pursue if we win power. We're ultimately going to find out and maybe that will be popular and maybe it won't be. But like now, I don't think that there's going to be as much an opportunity for a backlash to Democrats

34:18as there will continue to be a backlash to Trump because ultimately he's the president of the United States and he will suck up most of the oxygen as he has done for the past 10 years. But yeah, I think I think there obviously will be some openings, I imagine, for Republicans. Yeah. I mean, to that point, Nate, you got you got name checked on the the sub stack of the political reporter Rachel Bade. And I do love it when we cover your clips. She was she was talking about how you were on Ezra's podcast talking about how a GOP wipeout would make the president a, quote, super lame duck, which does sound like something you would say. And, you know, she also talks about how the AP was eulogizing the twilight of the Trump era.

34:55And she kind of had a different take, basically, where she said she said my take is if the Trump era is an eight book saga, we're maybe at the start of book seven. So book one is 2016 shocker. Book two, unified GOP control in the first term. Book three, Democrats flip the House impeachments. Book four, the wilderness years at Mar-a-Lago. Book five, the comeback. Book six, Trump 2.0. And then book seven is a clash between Trump and the Democratic Congress. And then book eight, Trump as kingmaker heading into the 2028 primary. What's your reaction? Are you familiar with the term denouement? Denouement? It depends, right? In a Shakespearean tragedy, then you'd have things go totally mad over the next two years, right?

35:47So there's that part of it, right? But like, and some fits, since I feel like this midterm was the climactic action that triggers the ending, right? Like, it's hard to imagine Trump returning to a place where he's substantially more popular. Maybe Dario is right and And Claude cares cancer tomorrow. Still Counting is brought to you by ZBiotics. The election is over, which means we can have fun again. We can go out. We can do like a weeknight drink with friends in the West Village. You know what I'm talking about? Like, I, you know, I've been keeping it, keeping it calm for covering the midterms. Like I got to, you know, it's a lot of work out there. And when I, when I get back out there, you know what I'm bringing with me?

36:35Zbiotics? Pre-alcohol by Zbiotics. Zbiotics pre-alcohol probiotic drink is the world's first genetically engineered probiotic it was engineered by phd microbiologists to break down acetaldehyde an unwanted byproduct of alcohol metabolism make pre-alcohol your first drink of the night drink responsibly and enjoy your next day activities zbiotic has sold more than 15 million bottles and earned the trust of thousands including us the holiday season is officially here and the post election season for all who celebrate. And if you're anything like me, your social calendar is filling up fast. That's what it says in the script. I'm just going to like embody the kind of social butterfly that Z Biotics thinks that I am. Sometimes I am, sometimes I'm not. But anyway,

37:17from Friendsgiving with friends to the turkey trot the next morning, these are the moments you don't want to miss. Make Z Biotics pre-alcohol part of your routine before drinking because the best part of the holidays is being present for all of it. Try ZBiotics pre-alcohol for yourself, and if you're not satisfied, they'll refund your entire order, no questions asked. Head to zbiotics.com slash counting and use code counting for 15% off your first order. Okay, it's time for our 2028 Republican draft. Our first one. Oh, no, actually, we did one at the Comedy Cellar. It was a dark night. People for the Comedy Cellar crowds, they would show the fuck up for the Democratic drafts. Republican drafts, you had to like, yeah.

38:01But we got a crowd, a packed audience in the West Village to cheer for Tucker Carlson. That was quite an accomplishment on our part. But this is our first still counting official draft. I think, you know, we have to have firsts for all our still counting stuff. Okay. So if you are new to this, this is a long playground elaborate rules draft thing. But here are the ground rules for the way we do drafts. To determine picking order, we draw names out of a hat. Then we'll reverse that order in round two. It's called the snake draft. Nate has problems with it, but we ignore him. And we will put the scoring system in our show notes. But you basically have big points for picking the eventual nominee, smaller points for picking candidates who will meet milestones along the way, like entering the race.

38:49That's one of the milestones. Okay. Galen, what's our hat today? We got the GD Politics hat, as ever. All right. Who's going first? Claire. All right. Pressure's on Claire. Saul, did you write these? I'm not sure this is a... Saul, again, has... Producer Saul has really good hair in writing. Nate. Wait, what does that mean? Claire picks Claire. And I guess Galen picks Galen. I understand. I got Galen. Oh, my God. So what's that mean? It means Claire goes first, Nate goes second, Galen goes third. Okay. Okay. Okay. Claire, are you ready? Okay. Ien goes third. Okay. Okay. Okay. Claire, are you ready? Okay. I actually didn't want to get the first pick. Do you want to know why? I'll just talk it out.

39:32Okay. Because the two obvious frontrunners are JD Vance and Marco Rubio. And Marco Rubio has been doing this whole thing where he's like, I don't want to talk about 2028. I think Marco's going through something personally where he like feels a lot of pressure being the viceroy of Venezuela. And like he said he was going to support Vance internally, but now Vance is sort of, you know, not look. I mean, I think Vance is not looking that great as a as a 2028 candidate. He's so closely tied to the Iran war, but obviously he's dedicated to running. And so my heart tells me that Marco Rubio would actually be a better candidate, but my brain tells me that JD Vance is the correct choice for a number one draft pick. So it's my head and my heart. Marco Rubio has my heart. J.D. Vance has my head.

40:30A conflicted woman. A conflicted woman. So I have to go J.D. Vance as my number one draft pick. As all conflicted women do. I'm not sure if it's a bad pick. I don't know what that means. Someone has to say bad pick. Let me ask you guys a question. Yes. say bad pick it's bad pick let me ask you guys a question yes when was the last time the vice president to an unpopular president later became president uh was bill clinton al gore yeah but he didn't he did not do well he did enter the race though obviously i mean is that joe biden no ob Obama was popular-ish. Well, no. Like, wasn't he? No, his approval rating was in the 40s. We will go to the silver bulletin approval rating historical averages, and I'll give you the numbers.

41:13Let me go. Now I feel bad about my pick. I should have gone with my heart. No, you know, you got to, you know. Listen to your heart. Approval ratings at the end of the term. Biden, 38. It's unpopular. Trump, 39.7. Unpopular. Obama, 57. Popular. George W. Bush, 32. Unpopular. Clinton, 66. Popular. Okay, so what's the answer to the question? Was Reagan unpopular by the end of his term? No, he was kind of popular. Just senile. Oh, so I don't know. There's no answer. Never? Basically never. Oh, okay. Technically, Gerald Ford became president because Nixon resigned, right? Nixon was very unpopular when he resigned, but did not win re-election. Yeah, you know, Walter Mondale didn't follow in the footsteps of Jimmy Carter.

42:04Famous flop. Dick Cheney didn't follow in the footsteps of Jimmy Carter. Dick Cheney didn't run. So are you saying it's a bad pick? I'm saying a lot of people were nominated and lost, including Kamala Harris. That's kind of how I feel. Well, but we're not choosing, to be clear, because this is an important caveat, we're not choosing the person that we think is best positioned to become president. We're choosing who we think the Republican Party will elevate to Republican nominee. when he named Miller, you know, it was like J.D. Vance was kind of like nowhere to be found in sort of these photo opportunities, whatever. Maybe I'm overreading it, but that feels like something. I don't know who's leaking all this stuff to The New York Times, but, you know, J.D. Vance and a

42:57mustache, as we like to say. DJ Vance. Yeah. I mean, I also think it was interesting that there was a story that heavily featured Marco Rubio, like waving a paper in front of Trump's face on the plane to China being like, Jensen Huang slept with a Chinese spy. I'm kind of like, whoa, who leaked that to the New York Times, which makes me feel like maybe Marco's kind of like in it to win it. So there's a lot of kind of weird jockeying when it comes to like um hey i tried to make tump not do that really really catastrophically dumb thing um and also be like but i love the guy and he's super smart and i think that that's like like jd jd vance i think has the inside track and also he's just so incredibly thirsty like never has there been a thirstier candidate i will also say that you

43:44should have chose rokhana first during our democratic primary draft if we're going based off that that's true i mean but i think the demerit points the reason why it's a bad pick are like all of my sort of like instincts about how he is actually like a this is a like nothing to do with his policy stuff he's just a bad campaigner like he's yeah he's pretty underwhelmed pretty bad i think he's a really stiff campaigner he also went ohio by six points when he ran he he but the the the um the kind of the idea of standing behind vivek ramaswamy i don't know if and the and the sort of really gross amy acton ad i don't know if that'll i think people will forget people forget about it but it's like it does actually speak to his political instincts a little bit though like i know he and vivek are

44:28like they're personally friends but it just felt like kind of dumb like that's when you distance yourself i just don't think he has great right like on the ground political instincts yeah i think voters voters don't love someone who's ideological to the point of being a zealot but voters also don't love somebody who seems to just be sticking their finger in the air and trying to figure out which way the winds are blowing. And that's his political career. Yeah. Okay, Nate. So, Claire, you picked J.D. Vance. Nate, who are you going with? I guess it's pretty obvious, right? I will take John Fetterman with my second pick. Okay, so you pick Marco Rubio. I pick Rubio. I think he's a better performing track record than Vance.

45:16I think he's more talented. I mean, the rumors that he'll probably leave at some point, it's easier to do for a secretary of state than for a vice president. Although it has happened, by the way. You have had, I think, Calhoun resign. John C. Calhoun is who we're talking about? You know, John Nance Garner actually ran against FDR. Did John C. Calhoun resign in order to start a separate republic? Okay, so Marco Rubio may well resign. Yeah, look, I think he's smarter and has like more of a resume and like in Patrick Graffini's chart, maybe bridges a little bit of a divide between the old school establishment and the new. I mean, he was considered like a tea partier by some people when he began running in 2010.

46:06I will warn you, I've overrated Marco Rubio before. He was the great hope. Yeah, you always thought you're like to avoid being wrong. I know everybody says in every poll that they prefer Donald Trump. But once the voting begins, they're all going to choose Marco Rubio. According to political science. OK, so Nate, you chose Marco Rubio. Anything else you want to say? Claire, good pick, bad pick? It's a good pick. I genuinely think Marco Rubio is like, if he decides to run, he'll be formidable. Okay. So I get to choose two people because of the nature of the snake draft. I'm actually pretty, I know which two I'm picking, but I'm pretty torn between which one to choose first. So I'm going to go first, Ron DeSantis.

46:47Yep. I think that I said that the party is trying to choose between like we need more populism and we need more conservatism. And Ron DeSantis is kind of neither of those two things or he can marry them together and do whatever he wants. And he can run on, I've been good at administering government in Florida. Like, I think things are getting tricky in this moment in Florida in terms of the cost of living and homeowners insurance and things like that. But he, fortunately for himself, gets to leave now, give that job to Byron Donalds and run on sort of the memories of the free state of Florida. He also has a good, you know, his speech after Republicans lost on Tuesday night was like, okay, we can't just run on the culture stuff, right?

47:31I already did all that culture stuff, the things that you wanted, I implemented, and now we really need to focus on people's pocketbooks, stuff like that. And he also, a lot of people who ultimately end up winning their party's nomination, try once before, don't succeed, and then have to come back for more later. He would sort of fit with that mold. And, you know, I think that because he ran in 2024, obviously he did quite poorly, but he has a pretty big donor list. He's got a lot of emails. He can fund, I mean, he fundraised once. I imagine he can fundraise a second time. And he will. Yeah. Like I think having run is a big benefit, actually. And you can just kind of see anyone from like Mike Pence

48:11to Megyn Kelly kind of getting behind him. I agree. He's an interesting pick because, you know, I would say the big knock against him was sort of what the J.D. Vance knock is, which is like not actually a great interpersonal campaigner, like a bit of a weirdo, weirdo, weird presence. We've already talked about his cowboy boots, just like a lot of people sort of personally hating on him. But I think he was kind of like a big winner, quote unquote, politically out of covid. Right. Like Florida, you know, a lot of times I think particularly in this current environment, governors a little bit like fall into this weird space of like we're not talking about them that much. Florida is the opposite though.

48:54I mean it's kind of like it gets all the New York Post coverage because all the rich people from New York were moving to Miami and like Jeff Be and is moving to Miami. And so there's a bit of a like a cultural relevancy around Florida that's obviously helped by Mar-a-Lago. I mean, you know, again, DeSantis, like famously a bit like difficult, had a big falling out with Susie Wiles. But like having actually run does I do think makes a big difference. And the one thing I will say is he was really early in that 2024 campaign to kind of pick up on the fact that the Republican base was angry with Trump about COVID policies and about the way, like he picked up on that kind of like anti-vaccine fervor

49:39that was percolating. And I think that there's a, there's still a sort of hunger for that among. Aren't you worried that he seems too much like he's a member of like election Twitter and has like these very detailed opinions about like. But most people don't know election Twitter. I mean, remember that if you if we're going to go based off of polling, he was already at a point in 2022, 2023, where something like 45 percent of likely Republican primary voters supported him. Yeah, there was a period where he was even with Trump. Exactly. And then all the prosecutions started. I mean, that's a simplified. So people have familiarity with supporting him before. The COVID boost wore out, I think, is part of the story, too.

50:20But again, I also think he's not compelled. Like, I do think he's not he's not he's not compelled. Like he's I do think he's he's smart. Right. Like see, I think his like foray into election Twitter was obviously for like the the think, you know, the the big thinkers of the party and to be to be out in front of things. But he is not a like natural human presence. Yeah, but I think maybe you would say the person who's most natural on the stump of these folks so far is Marco Rubio. But I just think there's a great advantage to not having been a part of the administration. I mean, I just think about I just think about like John McCain after Bush, for example, who can come out being like, I'm my own person. I have my own record.

51:00Ron DeSantis is going to try to do that. I don't know to what effect. I think my next pick is actually going to be able to do a better job of it. I'm excited for the back half picks because I think they're marched. And it is Brian Kemp. It's who? Brian Kemp. Oh, bad pick. Oh, I think it's a fantastic pick. Bad pick. So Brian Kemp has better experience than pretty much anybody I think that we're going to talk about being sort of pursued by Trump in a negative fashion and still coming out on top. Brian Kemp is, and also what's the antidote to one popular politician from Georgia on the opponent's ballot? Your own popular politician from Georgia on your ballot. Brian Kemp is, you know, remained pretty popular as governor of Georgia throughout a tumultuous

51:42period of time for the Republican Party. Obviously, Trump endorsed against him. He still won. He was elected trafficking in the cultural politics of the base, but also governed in a way that felt competent to a broad swath of Georgia Republicans and even Georgia independents. Like Ron DeSantis, I don't think he falls into the like more populism or more conservatism category. He falls into the let's be competent Republicans category. And I think there's going to be a lot of anxiety around how Trump does or doesn't endorse. And he just has muscle memory of sidestepping all of that from the way that he campaigned the last time that Trump endorsed against him. Okay. Have I convinced you from bad pick?

52:32He's just so... First of all, he chickened out. He didn't run against Ossoff. He could have, right? We just sent a race this year. Well, that's smart political instincts. He wouldn't have won. It's just not the right timing. I mean, which is maybe a reason why a lot of people who want to be president, who want to be Republican presidents won't end up running in 2028 because it's going to feel like... Yeah, I mean, isn't like 2032 a more desirable nomination, right? Yeah, but we got to deal with the hand we've been dealt, which is we have to draft a 2028 Republican nominee. But that is important because it affects like, you know, Kemp might have a political future in a post-Trump world. I mean, the problem is like, I don't want some fucking clips that come out in on November

53:1211th, 2026 to be replayed when the GOP wins the presidency in 2028, which could easily happen, right? But like, but if you're making long-term plans and making this two-year commitment, even in the best case, we'll probably end in failure. Right. Like that has to be a governing kind of kind of thing. But remember, right, like no one wanted to run against George H.W. Bush because after Saddam Hussein invaded Kuwait and he won the Gulf War in like a matter of days and had an over 90 percent approval rating, everyone was every Democrat was like, well, I'm not going to, you know, waste my powder now. And some random governor from Arkansas said, OK, fine, I'll do it. And that ended up ended up you know, he no longer has a stranglehold in the Republican base, but like a chokehold.

54:10Is that metaphor? Which is why I think being able to maneuver around Trump and still be and like 95 percent of Georgia Republicans have a positive view of Brian Kemp. And that is after Donald Trump trashed him. So like he just has look, Georgia is not the country, but he has probably more than many people out there experience dealing with the precarity of running as a Republican in Trump's party. Yeah, I think I think he has no nationalized platform. And that's a huge problem, and that you kind of can't overcome that. Okay. Well. Okay. Back to Nate. So another obvious one. I wanted a Michiganders. Let's go with Haley Stevens as the – Sorry. He's just going to punk this entire thing. God, this is hard.

55:01I guess I'll take Tucker. Okay. I wanted to'll take Tucker. Okay. I wanted to say bad pick, but I can't. But I have thoughts against it. I mean, if you go to the prediction markets, then everyone after the first three. First of all, there's some person named John McEntee. I know. I actually had the thought. I was like, who is John McEntee paying on the prediction markets to get there? And that is like, I am genuinely serious investigate that shit he just works in like the office of personnel or works in the office of personnel it's so weird it's so like smacks of like some weird corruption stuff going on there absolutely not uh yeah it's uh i was gonna say dogecoin but it's like uh amc stock anyway look he has a big platform it's probably not quite as big as it

55:47once was um there is always a chance the republican party gets crazier he's not been afraid to criticize president trump over iran in particular um and i don't think anyone would like question his conservative bona fides yeah i, that's that's the case. It's a lack of lack of lack of options. The argument against it is that it's fun to be rich. Exactly. It's that it's like, why would Tucker Carlson run for president? We can he can just do his podcast, run his media company, drive around Florida over a wall, drive around Florida in his golf cart and like go to nice dinners. Like, why would he spend hundreds of hours on the phone fundraising people? Does he live in Maine? Does he live in Florida?

56:30I thought he lived in Maine. But he lives in both, but he lives in Florida. Because then you can make more money and become more famous and have nicer dinners. No. I actually think that Tucker Carlson is just not a politician in that sort of like uh in that way i think he's he knows he has the better job yes he knows what it's like to be president yes and he knows what it's like to have his job and he knows he has the better job yes i i think it i think it comes down purely to like um personal will but it's a good ish pick it is a good ish pick like i understand i understand the it's the we need it's the we need more populism pitch it's yeah it's and that's why it's why the back half of this draft is much more interesting to think about because it's because

57:16it's the kind of like oh the lights are off and it's about to get weird in here kind of like version of the of the primary. Lights out Republican primary draft 2028. Let's go. Claire, you get two picks. Okay. My first pick is in the let's get weird Republican Party part of the draft. It is Thomas Massey. Outgoing. Bad pick. Okay. Outgoing Congressman Thomas Massey. the draft it is thomas massey outgoing okay outgoing uh congressman thomas massey and my reason for this pick is um a few right like massey has first of all he has obvious will to run for something he has um like a personal beef with Trump that he has. I have seen him speak a lot in the last year. And it's like part of his stump speech, right, is like playing on the

58:16dissatisfaction with the Trump administration. He has this he's like he went to MIT. He's got this kind of like libertarian, I'm a farmer background. He has embraced the, you know, COVID skeptical, anti-vaccine maha side of things, both the food and vaccine side of that movement. He grew a beard. He got married. But he's but I think that he and he also has a national platform through the Epstein files, which I think he is the most plausible and polished of that weird faction that's formed in the Tucker MTG lane, which is like, fuck Trump, fuck Iran. This party needs to get back to its sort of almost like Tea Party principles. And I think he's actually he's got the will. He's kind of like he he's got more

59:27polish and more like, you know, human interest than Iran DeSantis. He's like a better campaigner. I don't think he's actually crazy. I think he I think he'd play well on national TV. He just lost a Republican primary. Yeah. Yeah. I mean, I think the tricky thing is. Donald Trump came to power by criticizing. And the Republicans just lost a massive midterms, right? Donald Trump came to power by criticizing this sort of entrenched Republican elite that he cast as corrupt. He was going to drain the swamp. He was the outsider. He was going to counterpunch, yada, yada, yada. And over the past 10 years, he has become that. He has become the entrenched Republican elite. Is the same sort of trick going to work has become corrupt himself. And listen to me, like I am going to actually drain the swamp when Trump

1:00:31didn't. Or is somebody going to come in and say, we need conservative principles? Like I think if Republicans are ready to hear the like drain the swamp 2.0 message, I understand Thomas Massey. But I do wonder if like like there needs to be some novelty everyone was just sold on the drain the swamp populism do they want to hear something about how like you know we need to have a more sort of serious look at the nation's uh balance sheet and we need to talk about debt and deficit and we need to reinvigorate like, you know, you hear even Megyn Kelly, who's more on the populist side of things, being like, we need somebody who has strong moral values as like the next person to guide the Republican

1:01:13Party. I wonder if there is. Who do you think Megyn Kelly means? I don't know who Megyn Kelly means, but I do wonder if they don't just want the like the Republican primary electorate doesn't just want to be fed the same pitch. It was just fed in 2016. And throughout the entire Trump era, which is why I do, which is why I picked, I think, you know, Brian Kemp and Ron DeSantis, who can maybe like play different sides of that. But I both in Tucker Carlson and in Thomas Massey, I'm a little skeptical if the like drainless swamp populism works twice. I think there's some chance of a total nobody winning maybe not our friend john mcinty uh but like somebody who like you know a lot of these democrats i don't think many people had heard of adam hamilton or james talarico at this point

1:01:59two years ago um i don't know you know people always always love the Ross Perot analogy if they're of a certain age in our business the sort of Tucker MTG faction. And I was like, who's that guy who resigned from like the national security stuff a while ago? And it's this guy named Joe Kent, who is, he basically resigned over the Iran war. And he strikes me as and he wrote a big open letter. He strikes me as someone who is looking to make a play. Like, keep your eye on Joe Kent, people. He's going to be a rando candidate someday. Still Counting is brought to you by GiveDirectly. GiveDirectly is a nonprofit that puts money directly into the hands of the world's poorest people, no strings attached.

1:03:18GiveDirectly sends your donations to a family across rural Africa living in poverty to spend how they see fit. $100 means about 100 times more to them than it does to you. The price of a nice dinner out can be life-changing for someone in extreme poverty. It can buy livestock or a new roof, cover an urgent medical visit, or get a kid back in school. It can start a business or get someone their first mattress. Claire, I got to say, the holidays are coming earlier and earlier every year. Like, we didn't even wait till Thanksgiving this year. I see ads already about, you know, give this, give that. I mean, you know what? Give directly. It's a cost effective, like really like bang for your buck, truly.

1:03:52One reason GiveDirectly's model is so great is that it is one of the most effective means of charitable giving. With GiveDirectly, you can be confident your gift has proven impact. There have been hundreds of independent studies showing giving cash directly improves people's lives in many ways. Researchers have studied giving people cash, no strings attached, hundreds of times across hundreds of places. And study after study finds the same thing. Families earn more, eat better, and their kids do better in school and have better health. And these impacts last for years. Why does it work so well? GiveDirectly sends families about $1,000 at once, enough for them to make the big purchase that starts something.

1:04:29People buy livestock, tools, or stock for a shop. They fix a leaking roof. They pay off debt. Then they work more for themselves and own more. The money keeps earning after it's spent, just like it does for us when we invest in something. There you go. If you're just hearing about GiveDirectly, don't donate yet. Just go and read some of these research studies at GiveDirectly.org slash counting. That's GiveDirectly.org slash counting. My next pick is... Bobby Kennedy. Of course. Tell us about that book you're writing, Claire. Now, listeners, I am writing a book about the Maha movement and Bobby Kennedy. So I'm kind of in. Also, by the way, bad pick. OK, that's fine. I don't think it's a bad pick.

1:05:24That's fine. Here's my think it's a bad pick. That's fine. Here's my here's my reasoning for it. OK, Bobby Kennedy obviously ran as an independent in the 2024 election for a time before things obviously narrowed, was polling pretty high for an independent. I mean, not as high as like the, you know, the Ross Perot era of independent candidates, but high name recognition and has obviously entered the Trump administration is very controversial, but has made the interesting decision. If you if you are a person who pays attention to Maha, as I do, the past week has been popping off in Maha land because Stephen Miller and his wife, Katie Miller, are quite Maha, as they say. And Bobby Kennedy has you know, I think a lot of people thought he was going to leave the administration after the midterms.

1:06:19The Maha vote that he kind of promised didn't really appear. And, you know, I think I've always been skeptical about whether or not theory is actually, I think Maha is a cultural movement. I'm not sure it's an electoral movement. But I think that Bobby Kennedy has, still has an appeal that is certainly based on a lot of his Kennedy-ness. He is obviously a hugely controversial figure, but he also has this ability to kind of play the, yes, I've got a lot of conservative views, but also I have a lot of like, you know, I do have a lot of fans on the left. And in Maha land, Bobby has decided to throw in his lot with Stephen Miller and kind of remain in the administration for a while and try to get

1:07:01things done. But a very close ally, Callie Means, has very publicly and dramatically left the administration. I don't know, is he like a, is this kind of like a placeholder? He did a Joe Rogan interview. It's sort of like a, maybe this is like a placeholder presidential campaign formation and waiting. I just think there's a lot of interesting things in here. I also think that that Bobby Kennedy is the kind of person who would like to run for president again. And that is a personality type. And that is my pick. Why is it a bad pick? Nate says fine pick. You say bad pick. Hit me. It's not a good pick for a moment of generational change. He's pretty old. He reads as pretty old on the stump. And I think that he's got millennial vocal fry.

1:07:48He's, he's too enmeshed in the administration for like a sense that the Trump administration screwed the pooch and the party ought to go in a more either like competent direction, administratively or more conservative or more popist he doesn't really it's not clear I guess he goes in a more populist direction but he doesn't have any foreign policy experience so like what is he even going to be able to make a credible pitch about like what we should have done instead on the Iran war like yeah I mean the populism pitch that he can make is about health and boy does COVID feel over right like I'm sitting here sick right now, not even wearing a mask. And just spreading my germs all over the place. Boy, you're gonna

1:08:31love my book. I think the other part of his, the movement is about chronic disease. And I think that is actually sort of a compelling issue for a lot of Americans. Yeah, it's interesting. I mean, I think that is, it's a good point. And it's a good counter, especially perhaps for Republicans, counter to Democrats who are going to try to pursue expensive health insurance legislation, right, potentially Medicare for all or a public option or what have you. Since I've been observing politics, I think I've maybe twice ever seen somebody bring up this topic on a presidential debate stage, which is like, when you're addressing health insurance, you're addressing like a secondary problem in some ways, which is like Americans are really sick. If we could make

1:09:17Americans healthier, health care and health insurance would both be more affordable as well. Not to say that there aren't problems in those systems, for sure. But one of the most expensive problems is that just Americans are not healthy. And the two people I've heard make those arguments are Marianne Williamson and Mike Huckabee. Obviously, neither of them went very far with those pitches. But I think there is a certain sense that like there is definitely some sort of leverage that somebody could try to employ to say, OK, there's so much fighting going on about how do we take care of people once they're already sick? What about taking care of people so they never get sick in the first place? And I mean, you know, as I've mentioned many times, I was you're probably most likely to believe that message from somebody who seems like a paragon of health.

1:10:09And I don't think Bobby Kennedy is that Bobby Kennedy does a lot of chin ups. We're not talking about a healthy party, though, right? It's a Republican nomination. Wow. Way to extend the metaphor. But it's an opportunistic like if we're talking about land grabs, it's a it's an opportunistic moment to make a land grab on a space in the Republican Party. Anyway, I think he'll run. It's so hard to pick like Republican candidates. Byron Donalds is the one I'll pick because he's the one Republican who had a good performance on Tuesday night, last Tuesday, by winning the state of Florida by about a point, was it, over David Jolly. I think I picked him in our earlier draft of The Comedy Cellar a year or so ago.

1:10:52Interesting background. He's from Crown Heights, Brooklyn. You know, Florida is the largest state now with a Republican governor. It is kind of the unofficial seat of power for Republicans. No kidding. I've seen him and think he's an interesting dude. The thing is, usually you do not go and immediately run for president when you've just won your first major office, right? He was in Congress, I think, three times. So the track record of that's quite a negative, right? But that's somebody whose future I'll be looking to see how he'll position himself. And by the way, there are consequences to having a bad night in a midterm where just none of your swing state candidates win. You also deprive yourself of future recruits for the bottom and the top of the ticket. Do you see there being downside

1:11:46to taking the reins of Florida now in an environment where inflation is rising and there's all of the, like I was thinking of picking him when I picked Ron DeSantis, but I thought, you know, having been the governor of Florida is probably better than being the governor of Florida right now. Yeah, everything's going to be tough in 2028 for Republicans. I think Florida's been hit a little bit less hard by um by some of the energy costs right you don't have a lot of in the winter particularly don't have a lot of like heating expenses in florida for example okay yeah me two picks oh we are scraping the barrel here okay this is really hard it's really hard i here's what i'm looking for i'll tell you what

1:12:27i'm looking for if i can create a candidate in a lab let me be your personal shopper for republican primary candidates so everyone's running on cost of living issues and the way that they're trying to address them is like you know to suspend the gas tax or to increase the minimum wage or whatever, like things that if you take a macroeconomic class, which suggests don't actually tamp down inflation. How can you tamp down inflation? You can increase interest rates. You can also increase taxes. You can also cut federal spending. And, you know, I don't, those are obviously, those measures are very much, would be a zig at a moment when economic populism seems to be zagging, right? Like economic populism is the name of the game

1:13:22for the Democratic Party. It's the name of the game for the sort of like Steve Bannon, Tucker Carlson, Josh Hawley part of the Republican Party. But is there going to be an opportunity at some point over the next year or so where maybe inflation has is now up to four percent annualized? It's going back up, is there going to be a sense that, okay, actually an opening for somebody to say, actually, we need to use the levers that we know, decreased cost pressure upwards. And it would be like, you know, cutting and also we're going to we're quickly approaching the sort of end of the road for the Social Security Trust Fund. And we are getting to a place where deficit spending is 100% of GDP or more.

1:14:08Like our current deficit spending is greater than France. We're leveraged. We're highly leveraged. Yeah, we're highly leveraged. And they're like tearing their cities down over this issue. Obviously, we control our own monetary policy in a way that France does not because it's part of the Eurozone. But I wonder if there's room for somebody to come in and say, and this is this, I'm kind of's room for somebody to come in and say, and this is, this, I'm kind of picking a side here between the more populism, more conservatism. I can see where you're heading. And try to be, versus the third bucket, which is like, try to be like, okay, I can administer government as a Republican. So I'm picking more conservatism.

1:14:39This is like, this is, and my bucket is like Mike Pence. It's like, I'm back. Nikki Haley. I'm back at the the country club put your tassel loafers up on the couch and tell me about it and find like right and like yeah let's do some welfare reform you know let's pass a crime bill let's do some welfare reform let's maybe do nafta no i'm kidding obviously nafta probably not what you want to pursue in this moment but like yes this is, this is going back to a 1990s consensus vibe. This is where my picks are heading too, by the way. And for me, I just feel like part of me thinks that Ted Cruz could try to pull it off and there's like obviously a history there of he did come in second place in 2016

1:15:20and second place winners. He's the most hated man in the United States Senate. Which is why I think which is why I'm going to go ahead and pick Mike Pence. Taylor, that's crazy. That's one of the worst picks in the history of our drafts. What about Ken Griffin? Is that a better pick? The investor? Yeah. That's interesting. No, there's no take backs. But I get two picks in a row. Okay. So I want to, like that argumentation. Businessman X Machina. Yes, I get it. So okay, I'll pick Mike Pence then I'll pick Ken Griffin. Okay. take back but i get two picks in a row okay so i want to i like that argumentation yes i get okay i'll pick mike pence then i'll pick ken griffin okay um and my rationale for both of those is

1:15:52the rationale i just gave i'll be sim i'll be more sympathetic than than nate was we're like mike pence is obviously you know he had he he could appeal to the like old school Republicans where he's like, I, you know, have now, you know, garnered Trump's ire by certifying the 2020 election, yada, yada, yada. Ken Griffin is an interesting one when you're going with like businessmen who will run. I can see it. There was a hang Mike Pence chance chance i know it's a hard republican okay but think about like if we're talking about the most out there yeah like activist people of the party like in 2020 in 2020 literally think john fetterman would be a better pick than mike pence all right let's's go to Nate's pick. Okay.

1:16:45Yeah. I mean, again, anything that I fuck up on this episode, I'm blaming on Sudafed. I am holding on by a thread. I'm halfway to hallucinating the final picks of this draft. Ted Cruz. Sorry, this thing isn't working right. Quiet voice. Ted Cruz. Did I just do all the argumentation for you, then you picked the person that I was arguing over? He was second last time. I mean... He grew a beard. I should have picked Ted Cruz. It's fine. I'm blaming it on the suit of head. Regret is like a key. Immediate regret is a key part of this game. It's key. You got to like stand over the cliff and be like, oh, fuck. His seat is not up in 2028. FYI, right? Because that has to be a little bit more of a concern, potentially.

1:17:35No, Ted, take Texas back Cruz, I think, is good value with 11 picks into this. Also, there's so many Republican donors in Texas who now the only Republican who's representing them statewide for them to donate to is Ted Cruz. By the way, can I just, let me just tell you guys, because we talk about prediction markets a lot. Although, again, what's the name of our guy that we want investigated? John McEntee. John McEntee. Maybe McEntee. I don't even know. McEntee. Just some goofy stuff over there. But I wanted to just like pull up the real clear politics, like who has actually been objectivelled? Objective data. Objective. Oh, I'm a data journalist. I don't really think I am anymore. Am I? Well, you know, read the polls and then, yes.

1:18:11Read the polls and then I am. If you can read polls, yes. Okay, but these are the people that have actually been polled. Just the real, this is the RealClearPolitics average. Vance, 38. Rubio, 26. DeSantis, 8. Kennedy, Jr., 5. Haley 5 hayley 5 cruise 2.8 carlson 1.7 scott again we don't know if that's rick or tim but it's but it's one holly one and yunkin 0.7 so just just like a little like i should have picked yunkin instead of mike pence's fine. It's like it's it's all like it's all play money down here. But it's just just to like just to temper some of the craziness on Cal sheet. It's J.D. Vance, 33, Marco Rubio, 17, Ron DeSantis, 16, absolutely bananas. John McEntee, 5.2, Tucker, 3.5. Glenn Youngkin, 2.9.

1:19:05Ted Cruz, 2.9. Brian Kemp, 2.3. Thomas Massey, 2. Trump, Donald Trump, not Jr. Donald Trump, 1.6. Trump Jr., 1.2. Haley, 1.1. So it's like- Where's Mike Pence? Ivanka, Josh Hawley, Byron, Donalds. We're not even- You're still not getting to Mike Pence? We're still not getting to Pete Hegsa, Chris Christie, Mike Pence. We're not even. Joe Kent. You're still not getting to Mike Pence. We're still not getting Pete Hegsa, Chris Christie, Mike Pence. Pete Hegsa. Mike Pence, 0.4%. Right above Tulsi Gabbard. I'm going to kill myself. Claire, we're back to you though, right? We're back to me. Nate chose Ted Cruz. This is the last pick, I think, right? Last pick of the podcast. I only have one pick?

1:19:42Yeah. Yeah. I'm going to rage bait you guys. But it's in the general, like, sphere of what Galen has been saying about, like, just return to, like, rewarmed grits. You know what I mean? Like, we've done this. Reheated nachos, I think is what the kids are saying. Reheated nachos. Are the kids saying that? Mm-hmm. That's funny. Kids are funny. Okay. It's Chris Christie. Oh, man. Bad. That's funny. Kids are funny. OK, it's it's Chris Christie. Oh, man. Now I feel better about Mike Pence. And you want to know why I just decided to do it? One, because it's like he's just like establishment. But it's it's this quote. It's this quote that he said in New Hampshire some point in the last year. So am I looking at it?

1:20:31Look, anybody who comes up here, anybody who comes and told you that they're not looking at it again is lying. And then he said, once you go through the thought process of convincing yourself that you can be president and then the next step that you should be president, that doesn't leave your brain. I mean, an amazing, honest insight into the naked ambition and delusion that it takes to run for president. And you know what you get with that kind of attitude? Donald Trump? No, Joe Biden. But listen, at this point... Great job, Joe. At this point in the draft... Who will not be doing interviews for his forthcoming book, in case you missed that tweet. Oh, really? Yeah. That actually, on a more somberber note that makes me wonder about his health oh i mean he couched it in like in terms of his health but if he's like yeah i'm of course

1:21:16he's been diagnosed with cancer which is very sad also saying oh if you've convinced yourself once that you should run for president forevermore the answer to should I run for president will be yes because if you convince yourself once you can keep convincing yourself that's how you get somebody running in the 1980s and becoming president in the 2020s the rules of our game are you get points for the person entering the race and if this guy is out here saying in New Hampshire this out loud then maybe he'll get into the race what if he runs just to destroy Rubio again like totally possible. I think Chris Christie is obviously He's our former colleague. Traffic problems on Fort Lee Petty. Right? Like, he's our former colleague.

1:21:53He's our former ABC colleague. And what that means is that he's as much a media personality at this point as he is a politician. He's good TV. And running for president increases name recognition and increases demand for the brand. You know, run for president, then renegotiate that ABC contract. Yes. I think it's not a crazy pick. That's my last pick. And it's rage bait. And I don't care. Okay. Should we go through and name everyone who's been picked here and let listeners absolutely roast us in the comments? That's right. We want to hear it. Claire, your first pick was J.D. Vance, then Thomas Massey, then RFK Jr., then Chris Christie. It's so funny to hear it out loud. Nate, your picks were Marco Rubio, Tucker Carlson, Byron Donalds, Ted Cruz. I actually think you won.

1:22:38Who? I was Ron DeSantis, Brian Kemp, Mike Pence, Ken Griffin. Yeah, I won. Yeah, I won. Yeah, Nate won. You don't even have to ask. Nate definitely won. That is very, very, very obvious. All right. With that, I'm going to stick my tail between my legs and saunter on home from this exercise. It teaches me not to... Don't do drugs on podcasts, guys. You will pick a horrible lineup for it. And listen, I'm totally sober and I picked a bad one. So that's it for today's episode of Still Counting. Listen wherever you get your podcasts and subscribe. We really mean it. or wherever you get your podcasts. We'll be back next Wednesday evening with another episode. Still Counting is a Crooked Media production.

1:23:23Executive produced by Galen Druk, Claire Malone, and Nate Silver.

▸More episode summaries

The Daily cover art
The DailyWhy Do Some Memories Survive Dementia?2026-07-26 · 29 min
The Daily cover art
The DailyThe Iranians Who Want More War2026-07-28 · 29 min
The Daily cover art
The DailyEurope Is Burning2026-07-30 · 29 min
The Daily cover art
The DailyThe World Cup Final Is Here2026-07-19 · 30 min
The Daily cover art
The DailyKarl-Anthony Towns Knows the Knicks' Win Was Bigger Than Basketball2026-07-25 · 39 min
The Daily cover art
The DailyIsrael, AIPAC and Difficult Questions for Democrats2026-07-29 · 39 min
Transcribe your links. Paste a YouTube, Google Drive or podcast link and WhipScribe gives you the transcript. Transcribe a link →
New Still Counting transcripts by email
One email per new episode, unsubscribe in every message. Not shared with the publisher.