Raging Moderates with Scott Galloway and Jessica Tarlov · · Transcript & summary by WhipScribe
Two hosts unpack the fallout from NVIDIA's CEO exit, weighing whether the chip industry's security stakes outweigh the scandal itself.
Tap a chapter to play it from that moment in the show's own player; the transcript opens there too.
“This will go down likely as the biggest national defense compromise breach, whatever you want to call it, in history.” Scott Galloway · at 15:41 — ▶ hear it from here
“there needs to be government intervention in these companies, but it should be through regulation.” Scott Galloway · at 48:09 — ▶ hear it from here
Scott Galloway and Jessica Tarlov open with Jensen Huang's resignation as NVIDIA's CEO after reports of relationships with two women, one a businesswoman that U.S. intelligence reportedly links to Beijing. The chief financial officer, Colette Kress, has become interim CEO. Galloway treats the stock fallout and the board's investigation as the main business story, and doubts the independent review will be independent. Tarlov focuses on the political side, arguing the Trump administration's 2025 China trip and a September state dinner put the exposure squarely in its orbit.
The conversation then turns to national security. Galloway lists what NVIDIA chips are used for, from modeling nuclear weapons to drone targeting and satellite analysis, and argues the case could become one of the largest defense breaches in history. Both reject a simple infidelity story. Galloway still expects NVIDIA's shares to finish the year higher, since they trade near an average S&P company's multiple despite faster growth. He also sees the Anthropic IPO as a clearer signal of AI demand. On government ownership, he favors tight regulation and security screening over a state takeover.
The second half covers other news: Secretary Hegseth's visit to the Tomb of the Unknown Soldier, a missed House impeachment vote, and a Mississippi Senate upset in which a Democratic district attorney won the first Democratic Senate seat there since 1982. The hosts tie that win to Black women's turnout and to the party's map for 2028. They close with data center ballot measures, which were largely defeated across 10 states, and a Democratic agenda built on health care and housing rather than investigations alone.
Scott Galloway argued that the reports about NVIDIA CEO Jensen Huang are a national security story rather than an infidelity story. He predicted the case could be the biggest national defense compromise in history, because NVIDIA chips are used for work such as simulating nuclear detonations and guiding autonomous weapons.
“This will go down likely as the biggest national defense compromise breach, whatever you want to call it, in history.”Scott Galloway · 15:41
Scott Galloway said the Anthropic IPO, expected the following week, would matter more to the AI market than the Jensen Huang story. He argued it would show whether frontier AI companies are growing fast enough to fund large purchases of NVIDIA chips.
“what's probably more important to the AI market is the Anthropic IPO that's coming up, because that'll give a signal on the demand side.”Scott Galloway · 14:46
Jessica Tarlov said it was insane that the Trump administration knew about Huang's affair with a woman tied to the Chinese Communist Party while that woman was inside their small delegation. She said the political ramifications for the administration are massive.
“That is insane that they knew that someone directly tied to the Chinese Communist Party in their group, their tiny group that could”Jessica Tarlov · 3:01
Scott Galloway said that naming Colette Kress, NVIDIA's CFO, as interim CEO was the board's way of signaling stability. He said a CFO is typically the person who keeps the company steady rather than the one driving its growth.
“So appointing the CFO is basically the board's way of saying, don't panic.”Scott Galloway · 11:47
Scott Galloway said the federal government should not nationalize NVIDIA. He said companies that matter for national security need regulation and strict security screening instead of a state takeover.
“there needs to be government intervention in these companies, but it should be through regulation.”Scott Galloway · 48:09
Jensen Huang resigned as NVIDIA CEO after reports of affairs with two women, and CFO Colette Kress became interim CEO. Scott Galloway and Jessica Tarlov framed the case mainly as a national security question, and Galloway predicted NVIDIA's stock would finish the year higher.
Scott Galloway said NVIDIA CEO Jensen Huang's resignation, after reports of affairs with two women including a businesswoman U.S. intelligence believes may have ties to Beijing, is first a national security story. He argued that NVIDIA chips support nuclear weapons modeling and drone targeting, and he predicted the case could become one of the largest defense breaches in history.
Jessica Tarlov said the Wall Street Journal and New York Times both reported that Trump and his team knew about Jensen Huang's affair while he traveled on Air Force One to China in 2025 and attended a White House state dinner in September. She called it insane that someone with possible ties to the Chinese Communist Party could be in that small delegation, and said the political ramifications for the administration are massive.
Scott Galloway said NVIDIA's stock was off about $400 billion after the news, a loss roughly equal to Oracle's market value. He predicted the stock will be up by the end of the year, because it trades at about the multiple of an average S&P company while growing much faster and having broader competitive moats than companies like Caterpillar or Procter & Gamble.
Colette Kress, NVIDIA's chief financial officer, was named interim CEO after Jensen Huang resigned. Scott Galloway said appointing the CFO is the board's way of saying not to panic, because a finance chief is the stabilizing source of truth rather than the figure driving growth. He argued the company can keep thriving without its founder-style leader.
Scott Galloway said he does not think the federal government should nationalize NVIDIA. He said companies that matter for national security need regulation and defense-level screening, but that taking away profit and innovation motives would produce failures like Air France or DeLorean. Jessica Tarlov said she would not be surprised if the Trump administration demanded a 10% stake, and she warned about installing allies inside the company.
On Raging Moderates, Jessica Tarlov and Scott Galloway celebrated a Democratic district attorney's upset win over Republican incumbent Cindy Hyde-Smith in Mississippi, a state Trump carried by nearly 23 points in 2024. The hosts credited Black women's turnout, which they said was double that of Black men, and argued the win shows that Democrats should invest in the South, where campaigning is cheaper.
The hosts said data center policies were on referendums more than 40 times across 10 states last week, and that all but one of those initiatives were voted down. They called it a bad week for AI, noting that tech stocks fell and that Democrats such as Gina Hinojosa in Texas, who opposed data center proponents including Governor Greg Abbott, won big.
Our own transcript of the public episode, with a timestamp about every 90 seconds. Tap a timestamp to play the episode from there in the show's own player; the link button on a paragraph copies a link that opens this page there.
0:00Support for the show comes from Alumni Ventures. Your financial advisor may be perfectly happy keeping you in public index funds and spending the afternoon golfing, hoping you don't call. But public markets are not the whole market anymore. Alumni Ventures has spent over a decade building a way for individual accredited investors to assemble their own blue-chip venture portfolio. Backed by professional diligence and co-investment alongside leading VC firms, Time and CB Insights both rank Alumni Ventures a top 20 U.S. venture firm. You can sign up for free, see the weekly deal flow, and decide for yourself. Or write one check into the Alumni Ventures Foundation fund for a diversified portfolio of about 25 private venture deals.
0:38Go to av.vc.gov. Not an offer to sell securities. Venture capital involves substantial risk, including loss of capital invested. See disclosures and fund offering materials for more information. Hi, I'm Guy Raz. On How I Built This, I sit down with the people behind some of the world's most recognizable brands, like NVIDIA and Starbucks and Raising Cane'ses to find out how they actually built them. Think of it as a free MBA told through deeply personal stories about taking risks, making mistakes and building something great. I'm Guy Raz. Listen to and follow How I Built This wherever you get your podcasts. Hey, everybody, it's Sue Bird. The WNBA season may officially be over, but there's still plenty of basketball
1:30to discuss. This week on Bird's Eye View we're launching a special series dedicated to 30 years of the league. To kick things off, I've got WNBA OG and Hall of Famer Rebecca Lobo. She talks about what drew her to the WNBA, playing in the league's inaugural game, her dream starting five, and the rise of the W's first dynasty. Check out this week's Bird's Eye View on YouTube and wherever you get your podcasts. Welcome to Raging Moderates. I'm Scott Galloway. And I'm Jessica Tarlev. Jess, what to talk about. But before we get started. Nothing's happening at all. Nothing. Slow news day. Make sure to subscribe to stay up to date and support the show. All right, let's get into it. A powerful man who is facing accountability, NVIDIA CEO Jensen Huang.
2:19NVIDIA CEO Jensen Huang has resigned following reports of affairs with two women, including a businesswoman U.S. intelligence believes may have ties to Beijing and a senior NVIDIA executive who he also appears to be having an affair with or with past tense. The board launched an investigation. Lawmakers demanded accountability and shareholders sued the company. The CFO, Colette Kress, will take over as interim CEO. So much to unpack here, Jess. I'll talk about the business end, but first you talk about the political end. What do you think this means? What kind of ramifications do you think this has on the Trump administration, defense, security department? Any thoughts here about how this impacts Washington?
3:01Well, my first thought is I can't believe how quickly this all happened. I mean, usually these things are slower burns. And I think the NVIDIA executive who ended up coming forward with the whole story and also had an affair with him knew that once she came forward with this, that it would be, you know, a matter of uh until something changed i the political ramifications are massive uh the wall street journal and new york times both reporting that when jensen was on air force one to go to china in 2025 and came to the white house state dinner with she back in september uh trump and his team knew about the affair with the Chinese honeypot. That is insane that they knew that someone directly tied to the Chinese Communist Party in their group, their tiny group that could
3:55go on Air Force One and be part of this delegation was being exposed in this way. Obviously, there's a craven money angle to this and the idea that our entire economy is being propped up by seven companies, which I want you to talk about more. But when you think about accountability and what investigations look like in the new term, once Hakeem Jeffries and Chuck Schumer are in charge, this is one of the things that springs to mind. Like, how is it possible that the Trump administration were comfortable with this? Or even if they were uncomfortable that they still made themselves or twisted themselves into a pretzel to allow something like this to happen. We will, I assume, never find out exactly what it is that the spy, I believe her name was Alice, right, was relaying back to the Chinese government. But you have to have the expectations and it is absolutely everything possible.
4:50And that while he slept, she was digging through his stuff, the kinds of things that he was telling her. And they've been photographed together going back years at this point. So enormous ramifications for the Trump administration right now, but also for the agenda of the Democrats as they're looking to what it looks like to actually have some power on Capitol Hill. Yeah, I would argue that this isn't a story about infidelity. This is quickly going to be a story about national security. And just to give people a sense of how serious this is and just the ramifications here. Here are some of the most sensitive applications of NVIDIA compute or chips that potentially could have been compromised or close the
5:37delta between America's leadership in technology and weapons and China's nuclear weapons. These chips simulate nuclear detonations, modeling weapons aging, validating stockpile reliability, autonomous weapons, AI-driven drones, target recognition, coordinated drone swarms, hypersonic missiles, simulating aerodynamics, extreme temperatures, flight behavior, intelligence and surveillance, satellite image analysis, facial recognition, tracking individuals and military movements, cyber warfare, AI-assisted vulnerability discovery, missile defense, processing radar and sensor data, biological and chemical threats, molecular modeling, and protein design, military command and control, combining satellite. I mean,
6:22this is just going to get, when you think about how many people, whether it's people in universities, whether it's people, the brightest scientists in the world at Lawrence Livermore Lab, whether it's our millions of servicemen and servicewomen, whether it's hundreds of thousands of people working to build the best aircraft carrier in the world, trying to keep Americans safe. And to think that, okay, Jensen Huang always had these two rules for staying CEO, you know, don't get fired and don't get bored. It ends up there was a third rule. And it ends up that I think this is going to be the greatest national security breach in history. And I mean, just imagine what might have happened here. So Jensen had been
7:04actively advocating for selling more chips into China. Everyone thought, okay, that's wrong, but he just wants to get the share price up. As far as we know, this played out. Jensen, my love, it's Alice. I've got such terrible news. Someone who claims to be from the CCP called me and said they're gonna unmask our affair in the most aggressive, uncomfortable, ugly way possible. But they said that maybe they won't if you continue selling chips into my company more than we need. The Commerce Department went down there and found unpacked boxes of GPUs, meaning they were likely going somewhere else. You could even see them buying it. I mean, I think the lawsuits here are going to be so extraordinary. What if Binance finds out that the North Korean hack of $6 billion
7:52was using AI, possibly powered by NVIDIA chips, possibly secured or given access to by China, who got these chips from Megaspeed, if anyone can connect anything to AI potentially fronted by Chinese LLMs, they are going to have a case against the negligence of Jensen Huang. And to give you a sense for the market's reaction here, after I was trading yesterday, the stock was off about $400 billion. Theoretically, Ms. Wong is worth more than Oracle. What do I mean by that? The company last night and after hours lost the value of Oracle. And I think you're going to see them connect this. I think Democrats, when they get the gavel, if you will, are going to try and connect this to a total abandonment or negligence or
8:47careless disregard for our national security when one CEO of one of the most valuable companies in the world is throttling back defense systems for Ukraine, potentially without the president's knowledge. The president's pointing fingers at him. He's pointing fingers at the president's knowledge, the president's pointing fingers at him, he's pointing pictures, fingers to the president, and that the president knew about this and didn't stop it. So this is the biggest story. This is the biggest business story of the year. And what happened between, I think, so I said a few days ago, there's no way he gets out of this. And the board appeared to be supporting him initially. We talked about this. The board members, it's a group of fairly middling boards. They've
9:29been there on average of like 12, 15 years. One of the board members, just as an example, the CMO of NFL, hasn't worked since 2018, but since being on the board has made $80 million. And the board announced a quote-unquote independent council. And I've, first off, independent council, independent's doing a lot of work there because typically an independent council always comes back with a recommendation based on one thing, who's paying for the independent council. And this council was going to come back saying mistakes were made, but there's nothing that gets in the way of Jensen leading this company. I would bet in the last 72 hours, some people from our security apparatus have sat these board members down and started asking them questions and outlining scenarios
10:12here that could have taken place. And then each of these board members called their own personal attorney. And the personal attorney of these board members said, unless you want to be charged with crimes or negligence against the state, you need to swiftly cauterize this. And then I think they did another meeting yesterday and they said, okay, he's out. But this is likely, I mean, if every, and I apologize for what's out here, but if every Fortune 1000 CEO had a Wonder Woman's golden lasso around them and had to fess up to any indiscretions romantically, 100 to 900 of them would be out the next day or would have to admit to it. This is not about infidelity. This is about national security. And this is just getting started, what might have
11:00gone on here and the vulnerabilities. I think this is a very big deal, and I think it's going to have a lot of ramifications for the protocols around how these companies acquit themselves. If all of a sudden it comes out that some anthropic executives were potentially in any way having relationships with potential spies, that could shelve the IPO that's supposed to happen next week. The tentacles of this are going to go everywhere. Any thoughts, Jess? Yeah, I'm curious what you know about Colette Kress, who's now the interim CEO, and what you think the future of NVIDIA looks like. Is this one of those companies that can survive and continue to thrive without, you know, their big figurehead and the
11:47intellectual juice behind the company? Or do you think they're going to struggle? So appointing the CFO is basically the board's way of saying, don't panic. A finance chief person is the person you hand the keys to when you want the car parked, not necessarily accelerating. The first thing I do on boards is I introduce myself to the CFO and say, is it okay if I call you after board meetings? And they always say yes, because the CFO is typically the source of truth. The CEO is someone who is really handy with adjectives and embellishment and can turn chicken shit into chicken salad in front of the board and say that our shitty earnings are actually signs of growth. You call the CFO for a source of truth,
12:25they're usually the stabilizing force. It's a really good idea. The key term around all of this is the idolatry of innovators. The fact that famous hedge fund managers and most of Silicon Valley is saying, oh, human's gonna be human, boys will be boys, we should get past this, he's only human. Oh my gosh, CEOs are fired for so much less than this. And again, it's the idolatry of the dollar. If you create trillions of dollars in shareholder value, according to Silicon Valley executives, you are no longer subject to the law, norms of national security, fidelity around your obligation to the country. And then the flip side of that idolatry around your obligation to the country. And then the flip side of that, idolatry of innovators, is the following.
13:16The ridiculous notion that all of AI, much less this company, is dependent upon one person who is clearly distracted and spending a lot of time in Southeast Asia. You cannot, greatness is in the agency of others. And a $5 trillion company is in the agency of a ton of incredibly competent people. There are probably a dozen outstanding potential CEOs walking the halls of NVIDIA. We always like to believe, we fall into this ridiculous notion that there are these Jesus-like figures that are singular. Oh, Steve Jobs. Apple is done when Steve Jobs is out. The creativity is gone. Oh, wait, Tim Cook has 15X'd the company. Oh, wait, Sergey Larian, Eric, the dream team. What will happen to Alphabet when they're gone? Oh, what's going to happen? It's going to quintuple its market cap.
14:07How will Microsoft ever survive without Bill Gates? Oh, it's not only survived, it's thrived. So again, ridiculous excuses that we would, or a different set of standards for someone because they've created shareholder value versus every other citizen or every other executive in history. And then this notion that there are these Jesus-like figures that are singular. So in sum, this is only going to get worse in terms of national security, but I believe NVIDIA stock will likely be up at the end of the year because if you look at the stock right now, it's trading at where the average S&P company trades. And even if you take out 20% of the chips that supposedly potentially shouldn't have been sold
14:46to bad actors, this company is growing much faster, is much more profitable, and has got much broader moats than, say, a Caterpillar or a Ford or a Procter & Gamble. So this is going to be a very tumultuous 30, 60 days, but absolutely the company can continue to thrive. And what's probably more important to the AI market is the Anthropic IPO that's coming up, because that'll give a signal on the demand side. If Anthropic's IPO goes well, and these Frontier LLMs continue to show that they're growing fast enough to provide them with the cheap capital to buy NVIDIA chips, that's more important than whether he was sleeping with five people. The thing that's going to be unfurled here in a very weird way, in a very ugly way, is
15:41going to be all the scenarios around what potentially the nation or Jensen's recklessness has done in terms of diminishing, eroding, and really damaging national security. This will go down likely as the biggest national defense compromise breach, whatever you want to call it, in history. So you would buy the dip? Yeah, I look. To summarize. Let's get to it, Scott. I don't know if you should give out advice like that, but like, did you buy the dip? I haven't bought NVIDIA. I typically don't trade stocks during the middle of the year, but NVIDIA right now, and I don't like to make stock recommendations, but my prediction is the stock's up by the end of the year. The stock right now has had such an overhang on it that right now,
16:34like I said, it's trading at the same multiple of some pretty boring companies. And it's an incredible company. And again, I know these guys, or I know some of them. They're just like us. They're incredibly talented people. It's such an insult to the team at NVIDIA. It's like, you could have the most amazing quarterback ever. You could have, I don't know, whoever you think it is, Steve Young or Joe Montana or Joe Namath or Aaron Rod. Pick Tom Brady, pick the quarterback of the, if he doesn't have an amazing line and amazing receivers and a running back to take pressure off of him, he goes 0 for 18. And to believe you can build a company like this with this design, supply chain, corporate development, sales, financial management, I mean, it's just ridiculous.
17:22The overhang here, the thing that could screw it up is they might be subject to just a crazy amount of lawsuits. But the company itself, without Jensen, I mean, let me put it this way. He was clearly distracted. He was clearly, you know, he was clearly, you know, the most valuable company in the world got brought down by the, you know, kind of the, what I'll call the oldest, the oldest playbook in the world. So, yeah, I would argue that this company, again, my prediction is the stock is up from here. I don't think this has been such a cloud over the company. But again, I think the Anthropic IPO is going to say more about the AI market than what happens with Jensen. OK, I would if this were Raging Moderate's estrogen edition, I would then say I would
18:16like to talk about the actual affair. And now I've like dissected all these videos of Jensen and his wife like dancing at events and how she's looking at him and he's just surveilling the room and like looking for what other eye connections he can make and like what his glow up meant to all of it. But we should move on to politics. But the affair does matter to me and I continue to be stunned. I know I'm in the throes of like little kids and like I love my husband and we're too tired to have affairs anyway. But this stuff, it just grosses me out so much. And that they're just doing it all the time. And with multiple people. And to these women who built these companies with them, like when you were a dork in school and they
18:59were your lab partner up until these, you know, trillion dollars worth of companies. My estrogen is mad about this development. Well, another prediction here is it just goes to what I'll call estrogen. There's a pretty decent probability that a ton of philanthropies are about to get billions of dollars, tens of billions over the next 24 months, because this, like, this has got to put a strain on their family and their marriage. And what typically happens when people get divorced is the side of the divorce that has estrogen, the female, the Melinda Gates or the Mackenzie Scott, they go about giving away tens of billions of dollars. This is a sexist statement, but there's something about the female billionaire brain that just
19:39bluntly is more philanthropic. That's not to say there aren't a lot of philanthropic male billionaires, but it just seems like standard pattern recognition that the moment Melinda or Mackenzie get their 20, 30, 60 billion, they start giving it away. And also, look, fidelity, and then we'll get some pushback on this, fidelity is somewhat correlated to opportunity. Yeah. Rock stars and athletes have a tough time remaining monogamous because men for millions of years have been sort of taught that it's your job to spread your seed to the four corners of the earth, and women are taught to use a much finer screen to pick the strongest, smartest, and fastest seed, resulting in evolutionary progress.
20:23It's not pretty. That doesn't mean we can't have a modern society and people shouldn't reflect character to modulate their instincts. But where you see it really in spades in the tech community is that a lot of these CEOs didn't have a lot of game when they were young. They didn't have a chance to go to St. Bart's and party on a boat with women and have, I mean, all of us, not all of us, most of us want a period in our life where, quite frankly, we can have some, for lack of a better term, fun. And most of these guys never scratched that itch because they were captaining the math team. They stayed home from prom, and they'd been working nonstop. And Jensen met his wife in college, and I like this story.
21:14He was, you know, if you look at pictures of Jensen in college, he wasn't exactly George Clooney. And he met someone, and he said to her, I love this, he said, if you let me tutor you every Sunday, I promise you I'll get you straight A's. That's how they met. And this guy never had that chance. It doesn't excuse it. But what you find with these guys is they wake up one day and they put on a leather jacket and they're worth $180 billion. And all of a sudden, they're the sexiest man in the room. And they have a chance to behave the way they wanted to behave when they were 19 or 22 and never got the chance to. But this is a story as old as time, but it's a story that plays out in high decibel volume in the valley
21:59because these guys never had a chance to kind of sow some oats, if you will. I mean, the dynamics here are around chemistry and, you know, the male ego. But for this guy, I mean, people have been calling him a traitor. I don't think this is a question of treason. It's just a question of how could you be this fucking stupid? Yeah. And that is, do you realize commerce executives were going down to Megaspeed? When he met her, Megaspeed had $3 million on his balance sheet. Now it has $2 billion. Commerce executives got suspicious and went down to the company and found unpacked boxes of GPUs, meaning they were probably just in a way station there waiting to be shipped somewhere else. And he never thought he might be compromised.
22:51For a brief second, I thought, wait, he's not this stupid. Our security apparatus gave him a heads up, and he's been feeding them the wrong information, just the way we turned spies during the Oppenheimer days and fed the Germans faulty information around how to get to splitting the atom. I thought maybe this is a giant security operation. He's been cooperating with our security apparatus. I think that is giving him and the Trump administration, as we learn more about this, too much credit. But again, I think the stuff around infidelity and his failings is not going to be the story here. The story is going to be just how serious this most sensitive information even after you knew it, or enabling the handover of the most sensitive information, or the confiscation or get out of the hearings, peace out. Now I'm thinking, oh, these hearings are coming. And they're not only going to be—they'll be about Jensen, but what they'll really be about is how this administration has shown no fidelity and no respect for the expertise, the commitment, the expense, and the sacrifice our Defense Department,
24:27our Army, Navy, Air Force, Marines, our security apparatus have made over the last 80 years to try and make us more lethal and more safe and to ensure that our weapon systems had an advantage over the Chinese and the CCP, they likely, I think what you're going to find is this was like maybe a decade of progress around our national security. We just gave up a decade potentially to the CCP. I think this is a, anyways, Jess, I think this is a big deal. I get that. And I agree. And I think this is another ding,. I get that. And I agree. And I think this is another ding, by the way, on Marco Rubio looking ahead to 2028 because he was the China hawk in all of this. And obviously he would have been aware of whatever the Trump administration writ large was aware of vis-a-vis the honeypot sitch. And it was already bad enough that they were, you know,
25:26defending selling these more advanced chips. But I think this is a big blight on all of them. But there will be more to come. Yeah, it's it's it's yeah, this is going to be C-SPAN porn. We're going to there's there's going to be a lot here. So my favorite kind of porn. There you go. Support for the show comes from Upside. Gas, groceries, eating out. Even on the tightest budget, there's no escaping them. But here's what you can control. Getting cash back every single time you fill up, hit the grocery store, or go out to eat with the Upside app. The free Upside app gets you cash back on gas, groceries, and dining. The three things draining your wallet right now. Here's how it works. Open the app. The free Upside app gets you cash back on gas, groceries, and dining. The three
26:05things draining your wallet right now. Here's how it works. Open the app, claim an offer, pay with your card like normal, and get paid. That's it. And yes, it's cash back, not points you'll never use, not credits that expire, money you transfer straight to your bank account. And independent studies confirm Upside users earn significantly more than traditional rewards programs. Over 100,000 participating locations means once you start checking the app, you realize how often there's an offer right where you're already going. Upside has given back $1 billion to its users. To find how much you could earn, download the free Upside app and use promo code MODERATES to get an extra 25 cents back for every gallon on your first tank of gas. That's an extra 25 cents back for every gallon on your first tank of gas.
26:45That's an extra 25 cents back for every gallon on your first tank of gas using promo code MODERATES. Support for the show comes from Pendulum Metabolic Daily. We've all been there. You've been eating healthy all day, hitting every macro. Then the afternoon cravings hit, coaxing you to veer way off track. Pendulum Metabolic Daily was designed to help solve that problem. Pendulum Metabolic Daily is a science-backed probiotic designed to help you feel fuller longer, experience fewer cravings, and make it easier to stay on track with your health goals. Its key ingredient is called acromensia. That's the gut bacterium that helps signal your body to produce more of its natural GLP-1 after eating.
27:25It supports healthy blood sugar and metabolic health, so your energy stays steadier throughout the day. Our producer Eric has tried Pendulum, and here's what he thought. Jess, taking Pendulum has been great. It gives me a boost of energy in the mornings, and it helps with cravings throughout the day. It's only one capsule a day. It's really easy to make part of the routine. And who doesn't want to feel better? Right now, podcast listeners can save up to 48% off their first order at PendulumLife.com slash moderates. That's PendulumLife.com slash moderates to save up to 48% off your first order. Again, that's PendulumLife.com slash moderates and get almost half off today. Support for the show comes from Granola. You know that sinking feeling you get when you
28:09sit down to a meeting, your team starts working their way through the agenda, and suddenly you realize that you dropped the ball on an important next step. And this is not an ad to call you out. I know, sorry, I should have given you the content warning. The thing is, we've all been there. And that's exactly the kind of forgotten follow-up that Granola was designed to solve. Granola is an AI-powered notepad that makes your meeting notes useful. It captures what happens in your meetings and turns it into clean, structured notes with decisions and action items pulled out and made easy to find. And the best part? Granola integrates seamlessly with how you already work. No setup, no configuration, no friction.
28:44Once you try it on a first meeting, it's hard to go without. You can try it totally free when you head to granola.ai slash moderates. That's granola.ai slash moderates to get your time back. You can go to granola.ai slash moderates and try it on your next call. A man who isn't facing enough accountability is Secretary Hegseth. After a narrowly escaping impeachment, he had another rough day in the spotlight. This time on Veterans Day, during a visit to the Tomb of the Unknown Soldier, Hegseth's entourage was caught laughing and chatting before an Army sentinel had to remind the group to show some respect. All visitors will maintain an atmosphere of silence and respect at all times. Not exactly a good look for the Pentagon chief.
29:42No. And while Hegseth walked away from impeachment, 11 Democrats are facing backlash for missing the vote that could have changed the outcome. But the impeachment fight is just one of several headaches for Republican leadership. Representative Thomas Massie has continued his procedural maneuvers to force uncomfortable votes for Republicans on issues including the Iran war and the Epstein files. I tuned in yesterday to see what you and Aaron had to say. I was shocked. I felt in yesterday to see what you and Aaron had to say. I was shocked. I felt like everything was turning up blue. Like I just got spoiled by all the momentum we had. And I thought, okay, occasionally you have to take an L. I feel as if yesterday was the first L we took
30:16when I found out that we didn't have the votes, potentially because of some people who missed the vote. But I tuned in and I thought you and Aaron had an interesting take on the mechanics of what went down or specifically what did not go down yesterday. Can you summarize for us? Yeah, I mean, I will say before I get into the minutiae of like how many votes we had and how many votes the Republicans had and how Mike Johnson would have ensured that this never went through anyway, that this is embarrassing and bad and should not have happened. And that Democratic leadership has not had a good enough answer as to how this was allowed to happen. And if they did want to say, we just want to do this in January when we control the gavels and
30:58there's no way that you would actually get this to go anywhere because majority Republican Senate and the way that Trump is being is never going to vote to convict. I think that would have been acceptable to people to say, oh, our work starts, what is it going to be like January 4th? They get sworn in on the 3rd and then, you know, that is effectively the day one. But when you have Democratic social media accounts saying things like impeach Hegseth now and then your members or just some of them can't get back from a cocktail party, it is a bad look. Would it have changed things? No. Mike Johnson. So the Republicans were missing seven congresspeople. Mike Johnson has kept a vote open over 10 hours before.
31:44They would have just waited until everybody got back and it wouldn't have gone through. And there's a very strong argument, which I would have made and I am going to make because here I am, that the eight articles of impeachment that Massey brought were far too broad and that you should be doing this piece by piece. And that's essentially what's going to happen when the Democrats come in and control the committees. You will have the pieces showing up in different committees and they'll move forward on that basis. And Massey is going to pare back the articles of impeachment. Those are the quote unquote uncomfortable votes that he's going to force Republicans to take about the war in Iran, what happened in Venezuela, also what happened in the Caribbean seas where we
32:27are just taking out fishing boats that weren't narco-terrorists, no matter how many times Secretary Hegseth tells you that that's what happened. So that's, in general, my take. And I agree with you that it doesn't feel, after you have this blue tsunami and that big promises are made about action and also accountability that you flub something like this. You know, Nancy Pelosi being on the West Coast, it's one thing. There's a congressman, Correa, who's actually ill and couldn't make it. But I think, you know, the imagery of Pat Ryan and, you know, Pat Ryan has a very particular set of feelings about Secretary Hegseth. And obviously he served our country honorably as well. But if you have him checking
33:11himself out of the hospital after back surgery to make sure he can get there to vote, it's not an excuse that you couldn't run fast enough or make it the mile and a half back to the House. And I think it's just an enormous unforced error and you need better answers from leadership. Not just Hakeem Jeffries, but Catherine Clark, the whip. This is your job. It's like, it's the title for you. So I think that people should, you know, spread the love in terms of who you're pissed off about, pissed off at for what happened. So he was on the greenest of the green miles, and he's got like a 60-day stay of impeachment. But this is going to come back in January, don't you think? Yes, definitely. I think that it is, you know, on the list for sure.
33:57But yes, it's coming back. And in a historic breakthrough for Democrats in the South, Scott Colombe has defeated Republican incumbent Cindy Hyde-Smith to become Mississippi's first Black U.S. Senator since Reconstruction. Colombe, a district attorney, pulled off the upset in a state Trump carried by nearly 23 points in 2024. His victory marks the first time a Democrat has won a Senate race in Mississippi since 1982 and puts Democrats at 55 seats in the Senate. Let's watch a bit of the speech last night. All I did was have the courage to imagine a night like this. I had the courage to believe in Mississippi. I had the courage to understand that we can show the country that Mississippi matters.
34:46For me, this journey started with a prayer, y'all. In Mississippi, our prayers have often changed the course of history. I can't help but think about Medgar Evers on Veterans Day, a moment like this, where he served his country and came home to Mississippi when they wouldn't let him vote. But he had faith that Mississippi could make progress. He had faith that one day everybody would have the right to vote. He had faith that a day like this was possible. Yeah, just I mean, this has been going on for a few weeks now that I'm almost emotional every time I talk about Senator now Senator-elect Cologne, but his campaign, he is the encapsulation of what this election meant for the civil rights movement and that it has been ongoing for decades.
35:47The ad that he released walking through Medgar Evers' house, if you don't feel the gravity of the moment, looking at the bullet hole that came through the house, how there's no door on it, and listening to Scott Colombe talk about how Evers would tell his children what to do if they heard gunfire. Their father taught them that if they ever heard gunfire, they should crawl to the bathroom. This is where Medgar Evers died. He fought for this country and Normandy. He came home to Mississippi and they wouldn't let him vote. So he organized, helping other people register. Just after midnight on June 12, 1963, he pulled into here with an armful of T-shirts that said, Jim Crow must go. A man hiding across the street shot him in the back.
36:38He was killed for helping Mississippians vote. On Tuesday, use your vote and honor everyone who died for that right. You know, I don't know what's broken in you if that doesn't touch your soul. There's a mother, a Mississippi mom, a white Mississippi mom who was talking to MS Now about the impact of his election. And she said, we have great dreams for our kids. And for a lot of us, that means that your kids leave and find a better place to live than Mississippi. But that changes now. This place has been about hatred and animosity and lawmakers who try to convince you that if we make life better for some, we have to make it worse for others. And Scott will be the leader who changes that. He'll reverse the brain drain.
37:26And I thought that was really important because we've kind of stopped talking about that at the beginning of the Trump administration when they were going after all of the universities. It was top of mind to everyone. You know, what's going to happen when all of these incredible academics stop setting up their labs here, right? Or we deport them back to, you know, adversarial countries. They're going back to China. They're going back to adversarial countries. They're going back to China. They're going back to Iran, et cetera. So I love that she highlighted that. And she said, make this a place where mamas can be thrilled that their babies come back to. So again, estrogen addition of raging moderates, that really spoke to me.
38:01And I hadn't heard that perspective necessarily, you know, what folks are actually raising their kids feel about the fact that they wish that their kids, you know, go off to great schools and then stay away from this place. And the fact that, you know, he won against Cindy Hyde-Smith, who went to a segregation academy, whose kid went to a segregation academy, who's worn Confederate gear, called it the best of Mississippi history. It speaks volumes about progress, about the civil rights movement, about the importance of investing in Black leadership, of what is possible. And he was talking about the map and that if we continue to only focus on the places that we won before, maybe you got 51, 52 senators.
38:49But to ignore the South and where it is also a lot less expensive to play, because that does matter in all of this, right? How much can you carpet the airwaves? You can have incredible return on investment. And that's how you get real progress. That's how you get Chuck Schumer had always been thinking about Mississippi and made the pitch. I think three times he met with Cologne trying to convince him to run this race. I'm overwhelmed. I think there are so many beautiful elements to this story, and I think he's going to be sensational. I think he's going to, you know, stir shit up and bring a different way of thinking to Washington, also adding to the millennial caucus. I mean, we got such an upgrade in the ages and the perspectives of these senators that are you know, I'm a hammer and everything I see is a nail. And I was saying, wow, young men really showed up, 38-point swing from red to blue. You want to talk about estrogen power? 20% of the Mississippi electorate, or 20% of the people who showed up, Black women. By the way, it was 10%. Black women showed up in double the proportion. Black women showed up in double the numbers to vote as Black men.
40:30And do you know what percentage of that 20% voted for Cologne? 100? 99. I bet that in this election, if you took all of Trump's staff and found out who they really voted for once they got behind a curtain, I bet it's not 99% for the Republican candidate. I mean, Black women are sending a senator from Mississippi for the first time. I mean, I don't think I've ever seen any cohort this large vote at 99%. And then they did the work also. They were the ones chasing all of the ballots, making sure, I mean, Mark Elias was down there with his legal team and a forever hat tip to him. And what an incredible elections lawyer he is to make sure that to make sure that everything is counted fairly. And remember that Mississippi doesn't have a recount function. They haven't done it before. There's no,
41:34you can't look it up. This is exactly how it's supposed to happen. So you really had to make sure that everything was being done above board. But not only did the Black women organize, turnout show up 99%, but then they didn't stop. And they've been working around the clock to ensure that every vote is counted and that Scott C lines at 7 a.m. I mean, this is, you just got to hope the same way the D in democracy has worked for old people, that it starts working for some, I mean, quite frankly, for Black female voters. J.D. Vance is the vice president because of Peter Thiel. Senator Colombe has the term senator now because of Black Thiel. Senator Colombe has the term senator now because of Black women in
42:25Mississippi. Are you tired of hearing about business, tech, and finance from the bros? We are the Tiger Sisters, a top business podcast with the Vox Media Podcast Network. Tiger Sisters releases every Monday, and we decode money, power, and love. And who doesn't love all those things? We are the internet's Wall Street and Silicon Valley big sisters. Tune in every Monday for late night sister talk meets boardroom strategy. Check out Tiger Sisters on YouTube, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts. Welcome to the Tiger Fam. The Republicans lost the midterms, the Iran war probably helped, but artificial intelligence was also a big old stinker on the ballot last week. Data centers and the policies surrounding them were on referendums over 40 times across 10 states.
43:15And all but one of those initiatives were voted down. Democrats like Gina Hinojosa in Texas, who opposed data center proponents like Governor Greg Abbott, won big. Tech stocks took a tumble. Then the world found out that Jensen Huang from Nvidia likely got honeypotted by a Chinese spy. Nvidia stocks took another tumble. Huang might be heading towards one of the most expensive divorces in history. What I'm trying to say is that it's been a bad week for AI. And all the fresh Democrats who've been promising to hold big tech accountable haven't even been sworn in yet. Enough is enough. We need to make sure that the pace of development isn't outpacing the pace of risk. On Today Explained from Vox, we're going to hear from the guy those Democrats
43:53call for counsel on AI policy, and we're going to hear from OpenAI. Weekday afternoons in your feeds. What's up, everybody? Steelers captain Cam Hayward here. One of the most respected coaches in NFL history, Super Bowl champion, and the man who led the Pittsburgh Steelers to 19 seasons, and my former head coach, the legendary Mike Tomlin, is joining me on Not Just Football. We're talking unforgettable moments, legendary players, behind the scenes stories, and his decision to step away from Pittsburgh. Don't miss this two-part conversation. Part one drops Tuesday, November 10th, and part two, Thursday, November 12th. Listen wherever you get your podcasts or watch on YouTube and Spotify. I think we should go on to our questions.
44:47How does that sound, Jess? Yeah, fab. Okay, so question number one, we have not seen these. How should the Dems focus on the real work ahead, rebuilding government departments that provide oversight? What do you think the Dems need to do here, Jess? Well, I think that there are going to be a lot of folks who have been fired or have left the government that they're going to be talking to about how to rebuild here. I mean, this is one of those moments where I'm curious to see what all of the Project 2029s look like that folks have been working on. I know there are a lot of lawyers also hard at work focused on this question of how you rebuild. But I think it's really important for people to remember that the concept of doge is actually
45:31very popular. And Mamdani, for instance, has been doing this in New York City and saved a tremendous amount of money. So it's not just about putting everything back together the way that it was, but doing a proper doge or a proper procedure for seeing where there is fat to cut, what is necessary, what will make us, you know, lean, mean, and effective. Yeah, look, there's, we need, and I think they're planning this, we need to essentially, even if these bills get vetoed, outline what the Democratic agenda is for 28. Propose some sort of universal health care or renewing the health care subsidies. Propose $25 an hour minimum wage. Propose an ethics, new ethics guidelines around stock trading,
46:18corruption. Propose something that does something that codifies women's rights around, I mean, basically outline the agenda and let him veto everything. Let him veto an ethics bill. Let him veto a stock trading bill. Let him veto raising minimum wage to $20 or $25 an hour federally. But basically signal, this is what we're going to do. And the way I call it is the Democrats need to ensure that the ratio of ideas to indignance is hugely positive. And that is, I'm all for the late night C-SPAN porn of dragging famous people's children in front of Congress and accountability. Absolutely. But for every ounce of that, there needs to be a pound of how are we going to get people, help them get a mortgage, a job, and form a family. And if we go on what I'll call a nostalgia revenge tour, and that's what people think of as what we're primarily focused on instead of
47:17healthcare, instead of housing, this is how we have a red wave in two years. All right, let's move on here. Question two, Tuscan Sal asks, do the national security issues raised here open up a conversation of the federal government potentially nationalizing the most sensitive and critical parts of NVIDIA? I'll go first here, Jess. I don't think so. Generally speaking, you always want to have a bias towards the private sector running an industry. Now, it goes too far. The healthcare industry being totally privatized, prisons being privatized has resulted in externalities where we want to become the most incarcerated nation in the world. Check that box. We want to let healthcare companies verticalize so they can extract more and more money from consumers such that people working in companies, those businesses are now paying
48:09$23,000 a year. We pay on average $13,000 per individual for healthcare versus $6,500. So there are absolutely, there needs to be government intervention in these companies, but it should be through regulation. What we need at a place like NVIDIA is defense and Department of Energy and CIA-level security and protocols and screening and scrutiny and not WeWork-level security. But to privatize NVIDIA and take away the profit motive and the innovation motive to a certain extent, you end up with Air France or DeLorean. It's just, no, it should be regulated. We should be more thoughtful about our defense considerations. But this is the kind of company you want to let cook in the private sector. Your thoughts, Jess?
48:56Well, we do have a socialist-y president, so I wouldn't be surprised if he came out and said, you know, for the good of everything, they're going to take a 10% stake or something like that. And maybe that'll be like the proverbial slap on the wrist. But I'm always on high alert for this administration to be doing something mega corrupt. So if the ideas are floated of people in their orbit that they could install within the company. That would not surprise me at all. And I hope that this does put to bed the conversation over whether these companies need some degree of regulation and oversight. I think everyone who was saying absolutely not, you know, let them cook with no guardrails has big egg on their face.
49:49Question number three. Hi, Scott and Jess, big fan of the show. What do you make of J.D. Vance getting sidelined from foreign policy issues? Has he been sidelined, Jess? A little bit. I mean, the back and forth over is he right or wrong about his criticisms about Iran? I mean, remember, he was the point person for Iran for a long time and was the one who negotiated the world's worst MOU. So I would say, yes, he's been sidelined more and more. They also thought that he was going to be an effective campaign surrogate. But basically everything that I've seen relating to J.D. Vance to me just indicates that this is not the guy and that they know that this is not the guy who's going to be able to carry the party forward. So maybe he should just be Mr. Mom.
50:32He's got four kids now, you know, go into the sunset. There you go. And then question four, Tom the Temp says, Tom the Temp, these names are great. I wonder if Jensen will retire his leather jacket. Let me put it, something I'm fairly certain of, and here's a prediction. Hands down, the most popular Halloween costume is going to be Jensen Huang with someone who says, with a date that says spy. I just got to think that sales of leather jackets at halloween stores are going to skyrocket yeah the the leather jackets are going to be flown at half mast that was one of my favorite memes from this that's that's that's your joke there i mean not mine yeah it's uh i don't know if they're going to retire the leather jacket. I think this is, God, I'm just, literally,
51:34my mind is absolutely blown here that, I mean, just for so many reasons, what's gone on here. And I'm in the midst of trying to do the analysis around the anthropic IPO, and I've been talking to analysts, and everyone, every piece of information that comes out has just befuddled everyone. And you start thinking about all the, you know, information that comes out has just befuddled everyone. And you start thinking about all the, you know, the nuclear detonation has happened, but it's what happens over, you know, the blast radius, what happens over the next few months. I just don't even think we can begin to imagine the unintended consequences here. It's going to be just fascinating on an economic, a markets, and a
52:05political level. Anyways, let's leave it there, Jess. Thanks to everyone on Substack for tuning in. And Jess, I will see you, when are we next together? What day is it? Where am I? Monday. Oh, no, you're not on Monday. Monday, I'm on with Maggie Haberman, which will be awesome. Oh, that'll be great. Yeah, I love Maggie. I think we are reunited on Tuesday. I will miss you. Well, I appreciate that. You could say it back. That's how relationships work. No, no, no. Sorry. I will miss you. I will miss you as well. It's okay. I don't want to beg for it. It's fine. I am sending you every microchip and GPU hopper I have. That's how you show affection. That's how I show it. That's my love language is semiconductors.
52:45AI driven semiconductors. Thanks everybody for tuning in. Have a great rest of the day. Bye guys.